Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/244975173
CITATIONS READS
13 1,203
4 authors, including:
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Felix Guillermo Reyes Reyes on 24 August 2017.
* Correspondence to: F. G. R. Reyes, Department of Food Science, State University of Campinas±UNICAMP, C.P. 6121, CEP 13081-
970, Campinas-SP, Brazil
Copyright 1999 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. CCC 0894±3214/99/010029±08 $17.50
M. T. DE A. FRIEIRE ET AL.
Copyright O 1999 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. 30 Packag. Technol. Sci. 12, 29±36 (1999)
THERMAL STABILITY OF PET: OLIGOMERS AND VOLATILES
®lter. The same mobile phase and LC conditions immersion in a hot oil bath at 150, 260 and 270°C
used in the previous item, were also employed for for 5, 30 and 60 minutes.
this analysis.
Oligomer analysis. The oligomer content of the
Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) analysis. The samples was determined by dissolution in HFIP/
NMR equipment was a Brucker spectrometer AC dichloromethane (3 7 v/v) and precipitation of
250 set to 250 MHz. the high polymer using acetone.3 Identi®cation of
oligomers was carried out by LC/MS for the PET
Infra red spectrometer (IR) analysis. The IR samples heated at 270°C. Quanti®cation of oligo-
equipment was a Perkin Elmer 2050 calibrated mers was carried out by LC with UV detector at
with a ®lm of polystyrene. 254 nm.
Gas chromatography (GC) analysis. The unit Volatile analysis of heated PET samples. For the
used was composed of a GC 8000 coupled to an analysis of volatiles evolved by the heated PET
MD 800 quadrupole detector (Fisons Instruments, samples, a diffusion trapping method using Tenax
Crawley, UK); analytical column of 60m was employed.14 PET ®lm (1g) was placed in a
0.25 mm ID coated with polydimethylsiloxane headspace vial (24 ml capacity) and Tenax TA
(0.25 mm) (Restek RTX-1). Helium was used as (30 mg, contained in a open 2 ml vial) was placed
the carrier gas at 1ml/min; injection port was in the headspace vial alongside the ®lm sample. A
maintained at 250°C; column was programmed mixture of internal standards was added (6 ml of a
from 40°C (held 5 minutes), raised at 30°C/min to solution containing 1mg/ml of toluene, 1,4 di-
150°C and 20°C/min to 250°C (held 10 minutes); chlorobenzene, cyclohexylbenzene, benzophenone
injections of 1 ml made in split mode (20:1). and phenyl decane). The vial was sealed with a
Ionization for mass spectrometry was by electron special septum intended for high temperature use
impact (70 eV) at mass range between 50 and 500 and heated in the oil bath at 260°C and 270°C for 60
atomic mass units. minutes. The sample was then placed in an oven at
100°C for 2 days (to allow diffusion trapping on
Extraction of PET cyclic trimer. A standard of the Tenax to occur) and then removed to a freezer
cyclic trimer of PET was obtained by extracting overnight prior to further work-up. The Tenax was
PET pellets (10 g) with dichloromethane (200 ml) placed in a small glass column and trapped
for 48 hours with shaking at room temperature. substances were eluted with 0.5 ml diethyl ether.
The solvent was removed and the residue dis-
solved in a minimum of 1,1,1,3,3,3-hexa¯uoroiso- Migration Tests. Overall migration was carried
propanol (HFIP). The cyclic trimer was out according to EC directive 90/128/EEC under
precipitated by the addition of acetone (10 ml), conditions of 1 hour at 95°C (distilled water and
®ltered and dried. It was con®rmed as the cyclic 3% w/v acetic acid).15 Exposure was by total
trimer by LC-MS (liquid chromatograph-mass immersion.16,17 For the speci®c migration tests,
spectrometry) and 1HNMR (proton nuclear mag- ®lms were exposed as above, and simulants were
netic resonance spectrometry of a cyclic trimer analysed for the migration of terephthalic acid
solution at 10 mg/ml in deuterochloroform con- (TPA), monoethylene glycol (MEG) and diethylene
taining 0.03% tetramethyl silane). LC analysis glycol (DEG) according to European prestandard
indicated a purity of around 92%. methods.18,19
Copyright O 1999 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. 31 Packag. Technol. Sci. 12, 29±36 (1999)
M. T. DE A. FRIEIRE ET AL.
(®lms and pellets) as PET with good library match monomer was less than 0.8 mg/l, well below the
with authentic PET spectra. migration limit of 7.5 mg/kg of food or food
simulant established by the European Community
Migration tests and MERCOSUL.22 Similarly, migration of mono-
ethylene glycol and diethylene glycol was less than
Low migration levels were found for the two PET 3 mg/kg. The combined migration limit on these
®lms (Table 1). All overall migrations, were well two glycols is 30 mg/kg in food or food simu-
below the restriction limits established by Direc- lants.16,23
tive 90/128/EEC of 10 mg/dm2 (60 mg/kg), and
by Directive 56/92 MERCOSUL, of 8 mg/dm2, the Analysis for oligomers
highest value seen was just 1.4 mg/dm2 with the
acetic acid simulant.15,20 These results agree with The pro®le of oligomers extracted from PET did
the ®ndings of Ashby who found low overall not change markedly with heating until conditions
migration values under all conditions of use of of 260°C for 60 minutes were applied. Typical
PET.21 The speci®c migration of terephthalic acid chromatograms of the oligomer distribution before
Figure 1. Typical chromatograms obtained for F1010 PET samples. (A) not
heated, (B) heated PET. (1) Second series alicyclic dimer, (2) second series
alicyclic trimer, (3) second series cyclic dimer, (4) second series alicyclic
tetramer, (5) second series cyclic trimer, (6) cyclic trimer, (7) second series
cyclic tetramer, (8) cyclic tetramer, (9) cyclic pentamer, (10) cyclic
hexamer.
Copyright O 1999 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. 32 Packag. Technol. Sci. 12, 29±36 (1999)
THERMAL STABILITY OF PET: OLIGOMERS AND VOLATILES
Figure 2. High temperature effect on the ®rst series oligomers from F1010
PET ®lm. (a) Not heated, (b) 150°C for 30 minutes, (c) 150°C for 60
minutes, (d) 260°C for 5 minutes, (e) 260°C for 30 minutes, (f) 260°C for
60 minutes, (g) 270°C for 30 minutes, (h) 270°C for 60 minutes.
and after heating ®lm F1010 are shown in Figures oligomers tentatively identi®ed as TPA2MEG1-
1(A) and 1(B) respectively. The analytical recovery DEG1, TPA3MEG2DEG1 and TPA4MEG3DEG1
of oligomer extraction, using the cyclic trimer as a showed a marked increase in abundance on
reference spiked at 15 or 25 mg/kg, averaged heating (Figure 3). These oligomers containing
105%. one DEG unit generally eluted on the leading edge
The peaks in Figure 1 were identi®ed by LC-MS of `all-MEG' oligomers and quanti®cation was
with an APcI (atmospheric pressure chemical dif®cult. Nevertheless it was clear that the alicyclic
ionization mode) interface. As is typical for oligomers were the main products of PET degra-
chemical ionization, the spectra were character- dation with 5- up to 20-fold increases in concen-
ized by intense pseudo-molecular ions with few tration. Heating time was an important factor and
fragment ions of signi®cant magnitude. This the alicyclic trimer in F1010 ®lm increased 5-fold
analysis revealed two series of oligomers, the ®rst on heating at 260°C for 5 minutes, 9-fold after 30
with MEG TPA (TPAnMEGn) and the second minutes and 16-fold after 60 minutes. At 270°C for
series with one MEG monomer replaced by a DEG 30 minutes and 60 minutes the increase was 9- and
unit (TPAnMEGn-1).24 17-fold respectively (Figure 3). Taking into account
that the concentration of cyclic trimer, tetramer,
Change in oligomer distribution pentamer and hexamer remained stable at 260°C
and 270°C, the pro®les observed suggest that
Figures 2 and 3 show the change in oligomer formation of the alicyclic oligomers comes from
pro®le brought about by heating the PET samples. breakdown of the main polymer chains and that
From Figure 2, it can be seen that the pro®le of degradation can start at temperatures close to
cyclic oligomers TPAnMEGn in ®lm F1010 was 260°C.
rather constant even after heating up to 260°C. This
temperature corresponds to the melting point for Formation of volatiles
the samples (data provided by the manufacturer).
Almost identical pro®les were seen for ®lm F1021 Figure 4 shows a representative chromatogram of
(data not shown). In contrast, the non-cyclic the volatiles released when the PET ®lms were
Copyright O 1999 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. 33 Packag. Technol. Sci. 12, 29±36 (1999)
M. T. DE A. FRIEIRE ET AL.
heated at 260°C for 60 minutes. Among the suggested that degradation occurs primarily via
compounds identi®ed were p-xylene, benzalde- scission of the main chain in a random manner to
hyde, butylbenzoate, 2,4-dimethylpropyllbenzo- yield carboxyl end groups and a vinyl product
ate, diethylterephthalate and methylvinyltere- which can combine to form an ethylidine product
phthalate. which decomposes further. Acetaldehyde was
According to Peters and Still, during the detected by those authors at 288°C and the other
degradation process of PET there is a change in substances at 310°C and above.
functional group concentration with an increase in Kinoshita et al. used thermogravimetric analysis
carboxyl groups and a decrease in hydroxyl coupled to infra-red techniques to identify possible
groups.25 When all the hydroxyl end groups are pyrolisis compounds of PET obtained at tempera-
removed, anhydride formation occurs. It has been tures between 350°C and 600°C.13 Benzoic acid and
proposed by those authors that benzoic acid and carbon dioxide were the main compounds identi-
vinyl benzoate could be produced from a simple ®ed, followed by carbon monoxide and benzoic
repeat segment. In addition, vinyl benzoate may acid derivatives. The authors suggested that ether
decompose further to yield benzoic acid and and ethylene linkages are cleaved during thermal
acetophenone. Other substances could also be degradation of PET. Data obtained at 400°C and
produced as terephthalic acids, acetaldehyde, acid 500°C showed the presence of dimethyl phthalate,
anhydrides, benzene, ethylene dibenzoate, acety- diethyl terephthalate and alkyl vinyl esters.
lene, and carbon monoxide and dioxide through Acetaldehyde and benzene were not detected in
decomposition of the repeat unit in the chain (2- the present work. Some of the other substances
benzoylloxyethyl terephthalate). Those authors reported by Peters and Still, and Kinoshita et al.
Copyright O 1999 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. 34 Packag. Technol. Sci. 12, 29±36 (1999)
THERMAL STABILITY OF PET: OLIGOMERS AND VOLATILES
REFERENCES
1. Wallis, G. Perspectivas do mercado de embalagens
no Brasil. In: IAPRI 8th World Conference on Packaging,
20±23 June, SaÄo Paulo, Brasil, pp. 48±77 (1993).
2. Woods, K. D. Food and Packaging Interactions II, vol.
473 of Risch, S. J. and Hotchkiss, J. H. (Eds), ACS
Symposium Series, American Chemical Society,
Washington, DC, pp. 111±117 (1991).
3. Begley, T. H. and Holli®eld, H. Journal of Assoc. Off.
Anal. Chem., 72, 468±470 (1989).
4. Begley, T. H., Denninson, J. L. and Holli®eld, H. C.
Food Additives and Contaminants, 7, 797±803 (1990).
5. Begley, T. H. and Holli®eld, H. C. Journal of
Agricultural and Food Chemistry, 38, 145±148 (1990).
Figure 4. Chromatogram obtained by GC/MS for the PET ®lm 6. Jickells, S. M., Gancedo, P., Nerin, C., Castle, L. and
F1021 heated at 260°C. Column: 100% polydimethylsilox- Gilbert, J. Food Additives and Contaminants, 10, 567±
ane (0.25 df, 60 m 0.25 ID). (1) p-xylene, (2) 573 (1993).
benzaldehyde, (3) butyl benzoate, (4) 2,4 dimethyl propyl 7. Gramshaw, J. W. and Vandenburg, H. J. Food
Additives and Contaminants, 12, 223±234 (1995).
benzoate, (5) methyl vinyl terephthalate, (6) diethyl 8. Jickells, S. M., Crews, C., Castle, L. and Gilbert, J.
terephthalate. Internal standards: (A) toluene, (B) 1,4 Food Additives and Contaminants, 7, 197±205 (1990).
dichlorobenzene, (C) ciclohexylbenzene, (D) benzophenone, 9. Holli®eld, H. C. Food and Packaging Interactions II, vol.
(E) phenyl decane. 473 of Risch, S. J. and Hotchkiss, J. H. (Eds), ACS
Symposium Series, American Chemical Society,
Washington, DC, pp. 22±36 (1991).
10. Risch, S. J., Heikkila, K. and Williams, R. Food and
were identi®ed in the present work, even though Packaging Interactions II, vol. 473 of Risch, S. J. and
lower temperatures were employed, in relation to Hotchkiss, J. H. ACS Symposium Series, American
those used by the quoted authors.25,13 Chemical Society, Washington, DC, pp. 2±10 (1991).
11. Gramshaw, J. W., Vandenburg, H. J. and Lakin, R. A.
Food Additives and Contaminants, 12, 211±222 (1995).
12. Campanelli, J. R., Kamal, M. R. and Cooper, D. G.
Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 48, 443±451 (1993).
CONCLUSIONS 13. Kinoshita, R., Teramoto, Y., Nakano, T. and Yoshida,
H. Journal of Thermal Analysis, 38, 1891±1900 (1992).
14. Booker, J. L. and Friese, M. A. Food Technology, 43,
The obtained results suggest that some degrada- 110±118 (1989).
tion of PET can start at temperatures close to the 15. EEC., Commission Directive 90/128/EEC of 23
melting point of the plastic (260°C), with release of February 1990 relating to plastic materials and
volatile substances and an increase in low mole- articles intended to come into contact with food-
cular weight oligomers concentration. Heating to stuffs, Of®cial Journal of the European Communities,
L349, 26±47 (1990).
the melting point represents a self-limiting abuse 16. EEC., Council Directive 82/711/EEC laying down
situation and the data suggest that PET has good the basic rules necessary for testing migration of the
thermal stability and is well suited for high constituents of plastic materials and articles in-
temperature applications in contact with food. tended to come into contact with foodstuffs, Of®cial
Journal of the European Communities, L297, 26±30
(1982).
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS 17. EEC., Council Directive 85/572/EEC of 19 Decem-
ber 1985 laying down the list of simulants to be used
The authors acknowledge Rhodia±RhoÃne Poulenc for testing migration of constituents of plastic
Group for supplying PET samples. Maria Teresa de A. materials and articles intended to come into contact
Copyright O 1999 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. 35 Packag. Technol. Sci. 12, 29±36 (1999)
M. T. DE A. FRIEIRE ET AL.
with foodstuffs, Of®cial Journal of the European 21. Ashby, R. Food Additives and Contaminants, 5, 485±492
Communities, L372, 14±21 (1985). (1988).
18. CEN, European Commitee for Standardisation. 22. MERCOSUL. DeterminacËaÄo da migracËaÄo especõ®ca
Methods of test for plastic materials and articles in aÂcido tereftaÂlico em embalagens e equipamentos de
contact with foodstuffs Ð methods of test for the polietileno tereftalato destinados a entrar em contato
determination of terephthalic acid in food simulants, com alimentos, ResolucËaÄo 94/94 do Grupo Mercado
Draft European Prestandard (1994). Comum, MontevideÂo (1994).
19. CEN, European Commitee for Standardisation. 23. MERCOSUL. DeterminacËaÄo da migracËaÄo especõ®ca
etileno glicol (EG) e dietilenoglicol (DEG) em
CEN/TC194/SC1/WG2/N98. Materials and arti- embalagens e equipamentos de polietileno terefta-
cles in contact with foodstuffs. Part 7. Determination lato destinados a entrar em contato com alimentos,
of monoethylene glycol and diethylene glycol in ResolucËaÄo 11/95 do Grupo Mercado Comum,
food simulants. Last version: ENV XXX-7 (1996). MontvideÂo (1995).
20. MERCOSUL. DisposicËoÄes gerais para embalagens e 24. Barnes, K. A., Damant, A. P., Startin, J. R. and Castle,
equipamentos plaÂsticos em contacto com alimentos, L. Journal of Chromatography, A, 712, 191±199 (1995).
ResolucËaÄo 56/92 do Grupo Mercado Comum, 25. Peters, R. H. and Still, R. H. Applied Fibre Science, 2,
MontevideÂo (1992). 355±373 (1979).
Copyright O 1999 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. 36 Packag. Technol. Sci. 12, 29±36 (1999)