You are on page 1of 5

Research Paper E-ISSN NO : 2455-295X | VOLUME : 4 | ISSUE : 8 | AUGUST 2018

TO STUDY THE EFFECTIVENESS OF PNEUMATIC COMPRESSION


THERAPY ON UPPER LIMB EDEMA, SHOULDER FUNCTION IN POST
RADICAL MASTECTOMY INDIVIDUALS.

DR. C.PRASAD 1 | DR. K.MADHAVI 2 | DR. ASHAJOTHI 3


1 MPT (CT) PG STUDENT, COLLEGE OF PHYSIOTHERAPY, SVIMS, COLLEGE OF PHYSIOTHERAPY, SRI VENKATESWARA
INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES (SVIMS) UNIVERSITY, TIRUPATI – 517 507 (AP), INDIA.
2 MPT (CARDIO THORACIC), PH.D., FIAP, PROFESSOR, HOD, PRINCIPAL, COLLEGE OF PHYSIOTHERAPY, SVIMS, COLLEGE OF

PHYSIOTHERAPY, SRI VENKATESWARA INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES (SVIMS) UNIVERSITY, TIRUPATI – 517 507 (AP),
INDIA.
3 MPT (CT), CLINICAL STAFF, COLLEGE OF PHYSIOTHERAPY, SVIMS, COLLEGE OF PHYSIOTHERAPY, SRI VENKATESWARA

INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES (SVIMS) UNIVERSITY, TIRUPATI – 517 507 (AP), INDIA.
ABSTRACT
Introduction
Breast cancer has been the most common form of cancer in women, but its incidence has decreased with increasing diagnosis and treatment options
in the last few years However, illness-induced functional impairment still constitutes a problem. Patients with breast cancer undergo surgical
treatment (mastectomy) accompanied by axillary node dissection, radiotherapy, and chemotherapy. These treatments impair lymphatic drainage of
the affected upper limb, and place patients at risk for secondary upper limb edema, which has been reported at rates ranging from 10.0% to 49.0%.
Breast cancer patients develop some complications because of both the nature of the cancer itself and the treatment of the cancer, including
cosmetic, psychological, and physical problems, such as dysfunction of the shoulder and upper limb edema. Post-operative breast cancer are
commonly referred to physiotherapy for treatment of reduced shoulder complex function . There is a growing evidence that strengthening or
resistive exercises, enhances strength, improves quality of life and reduces incidence of upper limb edema. Exercises is an important component of
the cancer rehabilitation continuum. Manual lymphatic drainage is a massage technique that is performed from distal to proximal directions .
Pneumatic compression therapy, which involves gradual pressure gradients on the lymph vessels, helps to drain the lymph flow. Apart from
strengthening exercises, lymphatic techniques as are essential to soothe the total motion.
AIM OF THE STUDY
To study the effectiveness of pneumatic compression therapy on upper limb edema shoulder function in post radical mastectomy individuals.
NEED OF THE STUDY
Many of the studies have done on Faradism under pressure and manual lymphatic drainage on upper limb edema but there is dearth of the studies
on efficacy of pneumatic compression therapy on upper limb edema, shoulder function in post radical mastectomy individual.
OBJECTIVES
 To find out the effectiveness of pneumatic compression therapy on upper limb edema through Pneumatic compression unit in units, in post
radical mastectomy individuals.
 To find out the effectiveness of pneumatic compression therapy on shoulder function through DASH scale in units, in post radical
mastectomy individuals.
METHODOLOGY
Patients who had a history of unilateral upper limb edema for at least 1year. Upper limb edema more than 2 inches compared to normal limb, were
taken up to the study.
All the patients who are eligible for this study were included in the study. 25individuals were taken up for the study they received a pneumatic
compression therapy for 60mm of Hg pressure for 30 minutes. Manual lymphatic drainage for 10minutes, upper limb stretching’s for 10 minutes,
shoulder mobility exercises for 10 minutes, under therapist supervision. Patients were treated 5times per week for 3weeks a total of 15 sessions.
After the therapy the patients were instructed to continue the exercises. Pre and post therapeutic values of upper limb oedema and DASH were
measured.
RESULTS
The pre and post experimental mean value, t-test and p-value of all the outcomes that is upper limb edema, DASH are significant at (0.05) in the
group.
CONCLUSION
The study concluded that pneumatic compression therapy, manual lymphatic drainage, stretching‘s, shoulder mobility exercises showed a significant
improvement in alleviating upper limb edema, DASH.

KEYWORDS: Breast Cancer, Pneumatic Compression Therapy, Manual Lymphatic Drainage, Disability Of Arm Shoulder Hand.
this signals resulting uncontrolled growth and
INTRODUCTION
proliferation2.
Cancer is a disease in which a group of abnormal cell grow
Breast cancer has ranked number one cancer among
uncontrollably by disregarding the normal rules of cell
Indian females with age adjusted rate as high as 25.8 per
division .Cancer cells develop a degree of autonomy, from
100,000 women and mortality 12.7 per 100,000 women.

INTERNATIONAL EDUCATIONAL SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH JOURNAL 60


Research Paper E-ISSN NO : 2455-295X | VOLUME : 4 | ISSUE : 8 | AUGUST 2018
Data reports from various latest national cancer registries advanced instrument which is available to alleviate
were compared for incidence, mortality rates. The age edema. Very few studies were done on the effectiveness of
adjusted incidence rate of carcinoma of the breast was pneumatic compression therapy on upper limb edema in
found as high as 41 per 100,000 women for Delhi, followed post radical mastectomy individuals. Hence the aim of the
by Chennai (37.9), Bangalore (34.4) and study is to find out the effectiveness of pneumatic
Thiruvananthapuram District (33.7). A statistically compression therapy on post-radical mastectomy
significant increase in age adjusted rate over time individual.
(1982–2014) in all the PBCRs namely Bangalore (annual
MATERIALS AND METHODOLOGY
percentage change: 2.84%), Barshi (1.87%), Bhopal
(2.00%), Chennai (2.44%), Delhi (1.44%) and Mumbai The said study was ethically approved by college of
(1.42%) was observed. Mortality-to-incidence ratio was physiotherapy ,SVIMS University, Tirupati. Study was
found to be as high as 66 in rural registries whereas as low averse events are collected at each visit or voluntary
as 8 in urban registries. Besides this young age has been reported by contacting the investigator. (code:16080146).
found as a major risk factor for breast cancer in Indian Materials used were pneumatic compression therapy
women. Breast cancer projection for India during time used to treat the upper limb lymph edema in post surgical
periods 2020 suggests the number to go as high as radical mastectomy individuals, inch tape to measure the
1797900. Better health awareness and availability of edema by recording the circumference of the upper limb at
breast cancer screening programmes and treatment the level of mid arm, elbow and forearm in inches.
facilities would cause a favorable and positive clinical STUDY DESIGN: The study is Quasi experimental study.
picture in the country.1
STUDY PERIOD: October, 2017 – February, 2018
Breast cancer is a family of diseases where cell in the
breast tissue grow and divide without normal control .This STUDY CENTER
growth of cells forms a mass or lump called a tumor The study was conducted in oncology ward, SVIMS
Tumors are either benign or malignant. Breast cancers are university,-Tirupati , Andhra Pradesh.
mainly two types that is invasive and non-invasive breast
cancer. Getting older, a history of breast cancer, Estrogen INDIVIDUALS
exposure, Obesity, Height, Alcohol consumption, Radiation One year duration of post surgical radical mastectomy
exposure, Hormone replacement therapy are some patients were referred by oncologist to physiotherapy
risk factors that can impact woman’s likelihood of department were taken up from the study.
developing breast cancer2.
SAMPLING METHOD: Purposive sampling method was
Patients with breast cancer will have a lump or thickening used.
in or near the breast or in the underarm area, change in
the size or shape of the breast, dimpling or puckering in SAMPLE SIZE: Only 25 samples were collected.
the skin of the breast, new nipple retraction, discharge INCLUSION CRITERIA
(fluid) from the nipple, possibly bloody, Scaly, red or
swollen skin on the breast, nipple or areola (the dark area  Gender – female
of skin at the center of the breast), skin that may have  Age- 40 to 60 years
ridges or pitting so that it looks like the skin of an orange.
 Upper limb lymph edema more than 2 inches
Breast cancer is usually diagnosed by breast examination,
compared to normal limb
breast ultrasound, biopsy of nodule detection by
mammogram or by palpation2.  Unilateral mastectomy with axillary lymph node
Management of breast cancer is mainly surgical procedure dissection(ALND)
that is, lumpectomy (removal of the lump only), or  Minimum 1 year after surgery
mastectomy( surgical removal of the entire breast) is
 DM, HTN without any co-morbidities
performed followed by radiation therapy involves using
high-energy X-rays or gamma rays that target a tumor or EXCLUSIVE CRITERIA
post surgery tumor site is used. Chemotherapy is the use of
 Bilateral mastectomy
anti-cancer drugs to treat cancerous cells2.
Post operatively breast cancer patients present with more  PA shoulder
complications like infection, fat necrosis, and severe  Cervical spondylitis
musculoskeletal problems such as soft tissue necrosis and
 Previous rib , shoulder fractures
mild to moderate musculoskeletal pain, restricted
shoulder movements swollen arm are more common13.  Age below 40 years
Faradism under pressure is the option to treat lymphatic  Any cardiac problems
edema in post-radical mastectomy individuals, along with
 Any kidney problems
manual lymphatic drainage, shoulder mobility, and
stretching exercises. Pneumatic compression therapy is an OUTCOME MEASURES

INTERNATIONAL EDUCATIONAL SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH JOURNAL 61


Research Paper E-ISSN NO : 2455-295X | VOLUME : 4 | ISSUE : 8 | AUGUST 2018
 Edema measured with inch tape in inches edema, DASH were analyzed using the paired t-test.
 Shoulder functions were assessed using DASH HYPOTHESIS
scale in units
Alternative hypothesis:
METHODOLOGY Pneumatic compression therapy may have impact on
Twenty five individuals with upper limb edema followed upper limb edema, DASH in post surgical mastectomy
by total radical mastectomy, who me inclusive criteria individuals.
were taken and the study was performed at SVIMS
Null hypothesis:
surgical oncology ward. All the participants were informed
about the study and their written informed consent was Pneumatic compression therapy may neither have
obtained. impact on upper limb edema, DASH in post surgical
mastectomy individual.
Demographic Data of the individuals gender, age, type of
surgery, side, date of surgery, upper limb edema (Inch Table 1: Mean, SD, t-test values of upper limb
tape) shoulder function (DASH score), were recorded. All edema, DASH score of post-radical
the individuals received pneumatic compression
Parameters N Mean SD Df t-value p-value
therapy with 60mmHg pressure for 30 minutes, manual MID ARM PRE13.3± 1.43
lymphatic drainage were given for 10 minutes, upper limb 25 84 10.69139 0.05
Lymphedema POST9.98± 1.24
stretching’s for 10 minutes, shoulder mobility exercises for
10 minutes for one hour per day, five days a week for three ELBOW PRE11.86 ±1.03
25 76.5 10.69139 0.05
weeks for total fifteen sessions. Under the supervision. Lymphedema POST8.8 ± 1.13
After the therapy the patient were instructed to continue FORE ARM PRE12.24 ±1.41
the shoulder mobility exercises at home .Handouts of 25 88.5 9.578068 0.05
Lymphedema POST8.7± 1.27
shoulder mobility exercises were given to patient and
PRE53.72 ±4.44
explained the pattern of doing the exercises. Assess the DASH% 25 504 24.40695 0.05
individuals initially and 15 day after the completing the POST33.56±4.09
therapy.
The result shows that the pre and post mean values of
pain, shoulder ROM, upper limb edema , DASH and are
significant at p=0.05.
Graph: Cumulation of pre and post mean values of
upper limb edema of arm, elbow, forearm, DASH of
post radical mastectomy individuals.

STATISTICAL ANALYSIS AND RESULT DISCUSSION


Pre and post mean valve of lymph edema using the inch
Statistical analysis has been carried out to analysis the
tape in inches is mid arm 13.3 ± 1.43 to 98± 1.24, elbow
significant impact of the PCT ,MLD, ROM, stretching’s
11.86 ± 1.03 to 8.8 ±1.13 ,forearm 12.24± 1.41 to 8.7 ±
issued to the subject by using 16.oversion for that the data
1.27 with significant at p –value 0.05. The above results
has got entered into microsoft excel sheet and tabulated
are because of the use of IPC and MLD, which works on the
then it has subjected to statistical analysis.
principle of motion and sequential compression method.
The total sample are 25 taken for the study, quasi The circumferential compression of the upper extremity
experimental study was done. All the individuals by IPC also transmits pressure to the subcutaneous tissues
underwent PCT, MLD, ROM, Stretching’s for fifteen and the muscle groups. Compression increases the
sessions without any interruption. interstitial pressure in the extracellular space. When the
The pre and post therapeutic parameters of upper limb interstitial pressure is greater than the hydrostatic

INTERNATIONAL EDUCATIONAL SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH JOURNAL 62


Research Paper E-ISSN NO : 2455-295X | VOLUME : 4 | ISSUE : 8 | AUGUST 2018
pressure within the vessels, third spaced fluids are forced CONCLUSION:
back into circulation. This phenomenon effectively
The present study accepts alternate hypothesis and rejects
decreases the cross-sectional area of the lower extremity
null hypothesis. Hence, the study conclude that pneumatic
and decreases the tensile stretch on the cutaneous tissues;
compression therapy, manual lymphatic drainage,
especially in patients with an edematous upper extremity.
stretching‘s, shoulder mobility exercises has a significant
The decreased surface tension may provide improved
improvement in alleviating upper limb edema , shoulder
transcutaneous oxygenation and clearance of metabolic
activities.
toxins.12
Many of the studies have supported that MLD. IPC helps to LIMITATIONS & RECOMMENDATIONS:
drain the lymphatic flow which enhances shoulder Scope:
mobility9,8,7,3,4.
The study may have lot of scope to continue the
Pre and post mean valve of shoulder function using DASH experiment for further observation and evaluation to find
scale in units 53.72 ±4.44 to 33.56±4.09 with significant at the other ways to encounter the problems of post Radical
p –value 0.05. The above said shoulder exercises can help mastectomy individuals to improve their quality of life.
to improve ADL activities and decreases the DASH score.
Limitations:
It is supported by Sahar Zamani et al 2017 which
concludes that shoulder dysfunction following surgery in  Small sample size (N=25).
patients with breast cancer is common. Physiotherapy  Duration of treatment 15session only.
treatment in these patients is almost different from
common cases. It should be taken into account that in  Needs to do comparative study
patients suffering from lymph edema, recovering the Recommendations:
shoulder movements and early return to normal function
is very effective in improving lymph flow and reducing  The further study is recommended to get large
edema. Therefore,, restoring shoulder movement in these sample size.
patients improves lymph flow in addition to reducing  The further study is recommended to study
shoulder pain and increasing its performance.14 the other outcomes also.
This is explained by effects of mobilization on joint  The further study is recommended to study
mobility which break the adhesions , realignment of other protocols also.
collagen, or fiber gliding increase by specific movements
that stress the capsular tissue. The induced rheological
changes in synovial fluid, increased exchange of fluid REFERENCES
between tissues and the cartilage matrix and enhanced
synovial fluid turnover are found to be affected by joints 1. Shreshtha MALVIA,1 Sarangadhara Appalaraju
mobilization. BAGADI,1 Uma S. DUBEY2
It is supported by few studies proved that that and Sunita SAXENA1: Epidemiology of breast cancer
multifactorial physical therapy (i.e. stretching and in Indian women. Asia-Pacific Journal of
exercises) and active exercises were effective to treat Clinical Oncology 2017; 13: 289–295 doi:
postoperative minimizes the adhesion formation following 10.1111/ajco.12661
treatment for post radical mastectomy musculoskeletal
complications when done regularly during first 180 days. 2. Ganesh N. Sharma,various types and management
This confirms the benefit of early initiation of the of Breast cancer; an overview.
functional rehabilitation and with continuous monitoring 3. Comparing two treatment methods for post
for at least three months after surgery10, 11, 6,12,5.
mastectomy lymphedema;complex decongestive
The most common physiotherapy intervention used in the therapy alone an in combination with intermittent
management of post-operative breast cancer patient were pneumatic compression.2010 25-33.
shoulder stretches, glenohumeral joint range of motion
exercises, general arm care advice, and postural education 4. Christina gummesson, isam atroshi and charlotte
(risk factors),which improves shoulder function and ekdahl. The disabilities of the arm, shoulder and hand
quality of life following axillary dissection in breast cancer. DASH outcome questionnaire; longitudinal construct
SUMMARY: validity and measuring self-rated health chang after
surgery.16 june 2003,
In the summary the present study supports that pneumatic
compression therapy, manual lymphatic drainage, 5. J l Feldman, N. L. stout. A wanchai. B R Setwart. J
stretching‘s, shoulder mobility exercise interventions for N cormier. J. marmr. Intermittent Pneumatic
the individuals with post radical mastectomy has shown Compression therapy a systematic review
significant results. Lymphology 45 (2012) 13-25.

INTERNATIONAL EDUCATIONAL SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH JOURNAL 63


Research Paper E-ISSN NO : 2455-295X | VOLUME : 4 | ISSUE : 8 | AUGUST 2018
6. Lale Akbulut Aktekin • Filiz Eser • Bedriye Score the DASH. 1999 Western States Chiroprac-tic
Mermerci Bas¸kan • Filiz Sivas • Simten Malhan College.
ErgunO¨ ksu¨z • Hatice Bodur. Disability of Arm 16. Jenny M. Nordqvist, MSc a, Kajsa M. Johansson,
Shoulder and Hand Questionnaire in rheumatoid PhD a, Theresa M. Holmgren, PhD b, Lars E.
arthritis patients: relationship with disease activity, Adolfsson, PhD b, Birgitta E. Oberg, PhD a,* A short
HAQ, SF-36. Rheumatol Int (2011) 31:823–826 DOI activity-related scale for measuring shoulder function
10.1007/s00296-010-1568-1. in patients with subacromial pain: the DASH 7.
7. A A AY,MD; S Kutun,md A Cetin md. Lymphedema (2017) 113–118, www.elsevier.com/locate/jses.
after mastectomy for breast cancer ; importance of 17. David P. Goldstein, MD,1* Jolie Ringash, MD,2
supportive care.june 2014 vol.52 . Jonathan C. Irish, MD,1 Ralph Gilbert, MD,1 Patrick
8. Crien HG Beurskens Caro JT van upon. the efficacy Gullane, MD,1 Dale Brown, MD,1 Assessment of the
of physiotherapy upon shoulder function following Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder, and Hand (DASH)
axillary dissection in breast cancer, a randomized questionnaire for use in patients after neck dissection
controlled study.30 august 2007. for head and neck cancer. 26 September 2014 , DOI
Dio;10.1186/1471-2407-7-166. 10.1002/hed.23593.
9. M Moattari1*, B Jaafari1, A Talei2, S Piroozi3, S 18. iram bokhari, zahid mehmood, mehvish nazeer,
Tahmasebi2, Z Zakeri4. The Effect of Combined asadullah khan. early complications of mastectomy
Decongestive Therapy and Pneumatic Compression with axillary clearance in patients with stage ii and iii
Pump on Lymphedema Indicators in Patients with carcinoma breast. october - december 2010.
Breast Cancer Related Lymphedema January 29, 19. A.H. chen, S.G.frangos, S.kilaru and B. E. sumpio
2012. 2001,intermittent pneumatic compression devices
10. Martin Müller1 • Karsten Klingberg1 • Maria M. physiological mechanisems of action.
Wertli2 • Helena Carreira3. Manual lymphatic 20. Sahar zamani, shahpar hagigat.Physical therapy
drainage and quality of life in patients with approach in shoulder impairment along with
lymphoedema and mixed oedema: a systematic lymphedema after breast surgery; a case study
review of randomised controlled trials. 23 January 2017;2(3):144-151 .
2018..https://doi.org/10.1007/s11136-018-1796-5.
11. V Bayrakci Tunay,†,* T Akbayrak,† Y Bakar,‡ H
Kayihan,† N Ergun†. Effects ofmechanical massage,
manual lymphatic drainage and connective
tissuemanipulation techniques on fat mass inwomen
with celluliteDOI:
10.1111/j.1468-3083.2009.03355.x.
12. Mette Cathrine Lauridsen, Peer Christiansen & Ib
Hessov. The effect of physiotherapy on shoulder
function in patients surgically treated for breast
cancer: A randomized study. 08 Jul 2009.
http://www.tandfonline.com/loi/ionc20.
13. Oliveira MMF1, Gurgel MSC1, Miranda MS2,
Okubo MA2, Feijó LFA3, Souza GA1 Efficacy of
shoulder exercises on locoregional complications in
women undergoing radiotherapy for breast cancer:
clinical trial. 24/11/2008.
14. Alison Hammond1* , Yeliz Prior1 and Sarah
Tyson2. Linguistic validation, validity and reliability
of the British English versions of the Disabilities of
the Arm, Shoulder and Hand (DASH) questionnaire
and Quick DASH in people with rheumatoid arthritis.
https://doi.org/10.1186/s12891-018-2032-8.
15. Owen T. Lynch, DC. Questionnaire: How to

INTERNATIONAL EDUCATIONAL SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH JOURNAL 64

You might also like