Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Milestone – I Report
Submitted to Submitted by
March 2017
Milestone-1 Report
1.1 INTRODUCTION
The life and functionality of any product depend greatly on the quality of the surface
produced. Surface finishing is the last and essential stage of a production system. This
stage requires almost 15% of the overall production cost and is uncontrollable in nature.
In the present era of nanotechnology, the focus of manufacturing industries is on
producing precision parts that require finish at micro and nano scale. Products like silicon
in IC industries, micro-channels in micro-fluidics, optics and free-form surfaces in
medical science, and moving assembly such as piston cylinder and bearings in
automobile require highest level of surface finish in order to increase their life and
functionality [1]. Also, the fact that the fatigue failure generally nucleates at the surfaces
of engineering components, makes the surface conditions to be one of the important
factors influencing the fatigue strength. Thus, the surfaces with higher roughness values
in general possess lower fatigue life. To ensure reliable performance and prolonged
service life of modern machinery, its components require to be manufactured not only
with high dimensional and geometrical accuracy but also with high surface finish.
Surface finish has a significant influence on vital functional properties such as wear
resistance, fatigue strength and power loss due to friction on most of the engineering
components. Thus, smaller roughness values are required to improve [2].
Wear resistance,
Optical properties,
Aesthetic appearance.
Unfortunately, normal machining methods like turning, milling etc. cannot meet this
stringent requirement. Therefore, a final finishing operation is required to make most of
the machined components capable to perform their desired functions efficiently.
Xnom=X
Shape and size
constraints
Advanced finishing processes use a flexible finishing tool that itself can take the contour
of the surface being polished. Such abrasive based finishing processes with flexible
polishing tool can be classified into two categories (Fig1.2.) that is with and without
magnetic field assistance. The former includes magnetic abrasive finishing, magneto
rheological finishing, and allied processes, and the latter includes abrasive flow finishing,
chemo mechanical polishing, elastic emission machining, and elastic abrasive finishing.
These second category of processes can control the finishing forces in real time, and thus
are the most suitable processes for finishing different materials to a nano level surface
finish [3].
All these processes use magneto rheological fluid as flexible polishing tool whose
rheological properties are responsible in transferring abrading forces to the abrasive
particles. Thus, by controlling external magnetic field the rheological properties having
control over abrading forces can be controlled. Magneto rheological fluid (MR fluid) is
a smart fluid that undergoes a change in its mechanical properties in the presence of
magnetic field. MR fluid consists of magnetic particles (CIP or ferromagnetic particles)
and nonmagnetic abrasive particles dispersed in a carrier fluid like water or oil with some
additives. By applying magnetic field, MR fluid experiences a transition from a weak
Newtonian fluid like structure to strong Bingham like fluid structure. This is because as
magnetic field is applied the magnetic particles in the MR fluid acquire magnetic dipole
moment and pile up into interconnected chain like structure along magnetic field, holding
abrasive particles in between them[4] & [5].
The quality of the final finished surface depends on the appropriate selection of
process while the process selection depends on the size and shape of the workpiece. MAF
is preferred when the workpiece is large and flat, MRF is preferred for finishing external
and freeform surfaces usually flat and cylindrical workpieces, MRAFF is capable of
finishing external and internal surfaces of cylindrical and complex shaped surfaces and
MFP is the only process for finishing spherical surfaces more precisely. In the present
work, the surfaces to be finished are flat and freeform disc, thus MRF process is selected
for finishing.
1.3.1 Magnetorheological Finishing (MRF) Process
MRF was invented at the Luikov Institute of Heat and Mass Transfer in Minsk, Belarus
in the late 1980s by a team led by William Kordonski. MRF is a magnetic field-assisted
precision finishing process developed and commercialized by QED Technologies, Inc.
[6]. MRF has gained broad acceptance by most of the world’s leading optics industries;
by transforming the way optics is being made. MRF is a fluid based deterministic
finishing process for finishing flat, curved and freeform surfaces. The MRP fluid forms
a conformal polishing tool and therefore it can polish a variety of shapes, including flat,
convex, and concave. With an appropriate combination of MRP fluid and other finishing
parameters, it has successfully polished a variety of materials to sub-nanometer surface
roughness value [7]. MRP fluid acts as a Newtonian fluid (viscosity 0.1–1 Pa s) in the
absence of magnetic field and viscoplastic fluid (viscosity 10–20 Pa s) in the presence of
magnetic field [8]. More details about the MR fluid are discussed in chapter 2. By
changing the magnetic field strength, the stiffness of the MRP fluid can be controlled in
real time. This exceptional characteristic facilitates rapid control (in milliseconds) of the
yield stress, and thus the pressure applied to the work piece surface being polished.
The conventional MRF machine developed by William Kordonski initially used a trough
to carry the MR fluid and was replaced by a vertical wheel in 1995 [6]. The components
of the machine are carrier wheel/vertical wheel, delivery and suction pumps,
conditioning and storage system and magnetic field.
Fig. 0.3 (a) Schematic diagram of forces acting on the workpiece. (b) Cross-sectional view (A-A) of
interaction of MR fluid with workpiece surface. (c) Magnified view of finishing region. [3]
As the wheel rotates, MR fluid gets squeezed in to the working gap between the wheel
and the work piece which is placed below the rotating carrier wheel as shown in Fig.1.3.
Under the action of applied magnetic field MR fluid stiffens and forms a ribbon like
polishing tool. The stiffness of the MR fluid depends on many parameters such as size
and concentration of CIPs, abrasive particles, magnetic flux density etc. This stiffened
MR fluid ribbon forms a finishing spot at the ribbon-workpiece interface during
finishing. When the magnetically stiffened MRP fluid flows over the surface, abrasive
particles being nonmagnetic, they are pushed away from the magnet due to magnetic
levitation force. Magnetic levitation force is the force exerted by magnetic fluid on a
nonmagnetic body. These abrasive particles that are pushed away from magnet (towards
workpiece surface) interact with the asperities of the surface and result in the material
removal. Material removal takes place due to normal 𝐹𝑛 and tangential 𝐹𝑡 forces
(Fig.1.3.) produced as the MR fluid ribbon is dragged into the converging gap by the
rotating carrier wheel. Normal force is responsible for the penetration of abrasive
particles into the workpiece and Tangential/Shear force is responsible for shearing off
the peaks [9] [5] [10]. The setup of the process and the magnified view of finishing zone
are shown in Fig.1.4.
Fig. 0.4 (a) Schematic of MR fluid-based finishing process and (b) magnified view of finishing zone [3]
Delivery pump is used to eject the MR fluid on to the rotating wheel, where it gets
stiffened under the applied magnetic field. Significant forces are created by the
interaction among the wheel, MR fluid, and work surface because the MR fluid ribbon
flows through a converging gap. Rotation of the wheel continues to drag the MR fluid
from delivery pump and is removed from the wheel by the suction pump. The MR fluid
is pumped back to the fluid conditioning storage system where it is cooled to a set
temperature and any evaporative losses are replaced. Removal rates obtained with the
standard MR fluid vary from approximately 2 mm/min for a hard silica glass to more
than 9 mm/min for a soft laser glass [5].
tool gets influenced by different parameters, such as magnetic field strength and
wheel speed. Thus, a variety of different polishing tools can be obtained from one
machine set-up.
Flexible polishing tool: The sufficient conformity of the polishing provides high
flexibility, and thus different surface shapes can be polished by the same
polishing tool.
variations in the immersion depth of the workpiece into the fluid of up to ±25 μm,
[11]
The standard MR fluid composition is effective for finishing optical glasses, glass ceramics,
plastics and some non-magnetic metals.
The computer controlled MRF process is able to produce surface accuracy of the
computer control, such that the dwell time determines the amount of material
removal.
1.5 MOTIVATION
Nano-finishing has a wide scope in the field of manufacturing science due to its demand
in current biomedical, optical, MEMS industries. Conventional polishing has proved to
have many challenges. It is a highly artisan-based skill and non-repeatable. These
limitations and their non-converging capabilities emerged the need to explore new
technologies. Using advanced abrasive based finishing process, it is possible to achieve
a surface to pristine form, figure, and finish, regardless of symmetry, geometry, or slope
variation. MRF systems offers many advantages that eliminate the inherent problems of
classical polishing. Today, MRF systems are in operation worldwide, helping businesses
achieve faster cycle times, predictable schedules, and reduced manufacturing costs. In
the end, one can expand capabilities, improve profitability, and satisfy customers like
never before. Flexible and fast, reliable and accurate — MRF does it all. The introduction
of CNC polishing addressed some of the challenges and has many improvements over
conventional polishing. The process is more repeatable. Researchers have explored MRF
process to find its application in various fields. But industries are still sceptical of this
process due to lack of optimization. The model developed in this process, can be used to
predict the final outcome.
In the current study, Titanium alloy Ti-6Al-4V has been used as workpiece material.
Some of the properties and applications of Ti-6Al-4V are discussed in the following
section. A titanium alloy (Ti-6Al-4V) disc with flat and tapered surfaces is finished by
the developed MRF tool. Ti-6Al-4V (6% aluminium and 4% vanadium) is an alpha-beta
titanium alloys feature both alpha and beta phases and contains both alpha (aluminium)
and beta (vanadium) stabilizers. These alpha-beta alloys are easily formable and exhibit
moderate high-temperature strength. The mechanical properties of these alloys can be
altered through heat treatment. Alpha beta alloys have higher tensile strengths than the
alpha alloys and are moderately difficult to cut. From the past many years, titanium alloys
are playing an important role in the field of aerospace. Commercially pure titanium and
titanium alloy (Ti-6Al-4V) are mainly used for the airframe and the engine parts
respectively. Titanium alloy is a commonly used material for aircraft engines because of
its excellent mechanical properties and corrosion resistance. It is high strength, low
weight ratio and outstanding corrosion resistance inherent to titanium and its alloys that
led their way to a wide and diversified range of successful applications in surgery and
medicine as well as in aerospace, automotive, chemical plant, power generation, oil and
gas extraction, sports, and other major industries. Use of Titanium alloys in many
engineering applications has resulted in reliable, economic and more durable systems
and components, which in many situations have substantially exceeded performance and
service life expectations. Of the various available grades of Ti alloy, Ti6Al4V alloy is
the most widely used titanium alloy with good machinability and excellent mechanical
properties. In aerospace, automotive and marine equipment, Ti6Al4V alloy offers the
best all-round performance for a variety of weight reduction applications. Being excellent
biocompatible, Ti6Al4V has numerous applications in the medical industries.
Characteristics of Ti-6Al-4V alloy like strength, ductility, fracture toughness, high
temperature strength, creep characteristics, weldability, workability, and thermal
processing (higher strength is easily obtained by heat treatment) made Ti-6Al-4V alloy
different from other materials being used in many airframe and engine parts. In
airframes, it is used for general structural, bolts, and seat rail. In engines; the alloy is used
for fan blades, fan case and similar other parts in the intake section where temperatures
are relatively low.
References
finishing for finishing flat and Tapered surfaces, which can be controlled by CNC
interface.
To conduct experiments on the developed experimental setup and to study the effect of
experiments.
Analyser.