You are on page 1of 45

COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION

DIVINE WORD COLLEGE OF VIGAN


Vigan City, Ilocos Sur 1

CHAPTER I

THE PROBLEM

Rationale

Language is one of the most important variable affecting education. Indeed,

learner’s will not achieve quality Education unless children are provided with the

opportunity to learn in their mother tongue. The MTB-MLE path to school success is

based on providing children with equitable opportunity to access learning. The use of

the mother tongue, or home languages, is key to increasing access to school and

facilitating learning, including learning of second language. This is because the use of

child’s home language is one of the most important factors in helping children learn to

read and write, learning academic content (such as mathematics and history), and also

learning other languages. Primary education programs that begin in children’s mother

tongue help students gain early reading skills to a second language.

(www.mlenetwork.org.the case for MTB-MLE)

The case for mother tongue-based and multilingual education is therefore simple

and powerful. Children learn best in a language that is familiar to them. Although

children can learn a language other than their mother tongue, they learn best- especially

in the early years- in an environment in which the language used to teach is also one

they speak in their home, with their parents, siblings, and friends. This is especially

true in environments where children have little or no exposure to a second or foreign

language. (www.mlenetwork.org.the case for MTB-MLE)


COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION
DIVINE WORD COLLEGE OF VIGAN
Vigan City, Ilocos Sur 2

Moreover, since the school is a new social environment to children starting their

education, learning in mother tongue language also helps to ease this transition,

providing a bridge from the “know” to the “unknown”.(www.mlenetwork.org.the case

for MTB-MLE)

The use of mother tongue enables the young learners to immediately construct

and explain without fear of making mistakes, articulate their thoughts and add new

concepts to that which they already knew. In turn, teachers can more accurately assess

what has been learned and identify the areas where they need help (Nolasco, 2010)

Further, Mother tongue-based education has a positive impact on educational

and learning outcomes. The child’s home language can effectively be used as a

language of instruction in the early years of schooling as a bridge to learning.

Appropriate language in education enables the teachers to instruct on the language a

child speaks most at home and understands well enough to learn academic content

through mother tongue.

Mother tongue instruction promotes inclusion in education and improves the

quality of education by building on the knowledge and experience of both learners and

teachers. UNESCO believes and supports findings of studies showing evidence that

mother tongue instruction is a key factor for literacy and learning. (UNESCO, 2006).
COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION
DIVINE WORD COLLEGE OF VIGAN
Vigan City, Ilocos Sur 3

Consequently, in the Philippines, the department of education mandated that

starting the school year 2012-2013 the mother tongue based multilingual education

will be implemented in all public school. The pupils’ home language will be used to

teach all the learning areas for literacy and as a medium of instruction inside the

classroom.(DepEd order No.16 s. 2012)

With the implementation of the MTB-MLE a lot of changes were made and every

educator has to face a lot of challenges. It is with this context that the researchers

became interested to conduct a study pertaining to the status of MTB-MLE in the private

primary schools in Vigan City. The study is intended to assess the program. The

researcher also believed that the result of the study will be the basis of the school

administrators and teachers in evaluating and fortifying the MTB-MLE program and be

able to formulate strategies and activities for the improvement of the program. Lastly,

the result of the study will also help the researchers understand better the nature and

essence of their chosen profession and as future implementer or teacher of MTB-MLE.

Theoretical Framework of the Study

This study anchored on the following concepts on language and education, and

on the mother tongue based-multilingual education in the Philippines.

One of the changes in Basic Education Curriculum brought about by the new K-

12 program is the introduction of Mother Tongue- Based Multilingual Education

(MTB-MLE) specifically in Kindergarten, Grades 1, 2 and 3 to support the goal of

“Every Child-A- Reader and A-Writer” by Grade 1.


COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION
DIVINE WORD COLLEGE OF VIGAN 4
Vigan City, Ilocos Sur

MTB-MLE refers to “first-language-first” education that is, schooling which

begins in the mother tongue and transitions to additional languages particularly Filipino

and English. It is meant to address the high functional literacy of Filipinos where

language plays a significant factor. Since the child’s own language enables her/him to

express him/himself easily, then, there is no fear of making mistakes. It encourages

active participation by children in the learning process because they understand what is

being discussed and what is being asked of them. They can immediately use their mother

tongue to construct and explain their world, articulate their thoughts and add new

concepts to what they already know.

Currently, there are twelve (12) major languages or lingua franca that shall be the

language of instruction. The major languages are a) Tagalog b) Kapampangan c)

Pangasinense d) Iloko e) Bikol f) Cebuano g) Hiligaynon h) Waray i) Tausug j)

Maguindanaoan k) Maranao l) Chabacano. (www.cu.edu.ph/mother tongue based

multilingual education)

As a subject, mother-tongue education focuses on the development of speaking,

reading and writing from Grades 1 to 3 in the mother tongue. As a medium of

instruction, the mother tongue is used in all learning areas from Kindergarten to Grade

3, except in the teaching of Filipino and English subjects. Filipino is introduced in the

second quarter of Grade 1 for oral fluency (speaking). For reading and writing

purposes, it will be taught beginning in the third quarter of Grade 1. The four other

macro skill—listening, speaking, reading and writing in Filipino—will continuously be

developed from Grade 2 to Grade 6.


COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION
DIVINE WORD COLLEGE OF VIGAN
Vigan City, Ilocos Sur 5

The purpose of a multilingual education program is to develop appropriate

cognitive and reasoning skills enabling children to operate equally in different

languages—starting in the mother tongue, which is the first language of the

child.(https://businessmirror.com.ph/deped-implements-mother-tongue-based-

learning-to-make-lessons-more-interactive-easier-for-pupils/)

Mother tongue-based education has a positive impact on educational and learning

outcomes in most of the developing countries. A child‘s home language can effectively

be used as a language of instruction in the early years of their schooling as a bridge to

learning. The positive reinforcement decreases rates of repetition, failure and dropouts,

and provides long-term benefits like higher self-esteem, greater self-confidence and

higher aspirations for schooling and life. (UNESCO, 2006).

Mother tongue-based multilingual education program have been established in

many minority language communities around the world. Most teachers, principals and

parents of children in that program have found that students who begin learning in their

home language: (a) Have more confidence in themselves as learners; (b) Participate

more actively in classroom discussions; (c) Ask more questions; (d) Demonstrate a

deeper understanding of the subjects; (e) Learn to read more easily and understand what

they read; (f) Learn to write more easily and express themselves better in written form;

and (g) Learn the school language-oral and written- more easily and with greater

comprehension.
COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION
DIVINE WORD COLLEGE OF VIGAN
Vigan City, Ilocos Sur 6

Through a familiar language, the child is able to access the power of education,

develop self-esteem and pride in his potentials. Likewise, children who read and write

in the mother tongue before learning another language are not only successful second

language learners but also excel more quickly than their peers who did not become

literate in their first language (UNESCO, 2003).


COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION
DIVINE WORD COLLEGE OF VIGAN
Vigan City, Ilocos Sur 7

Conceptual Framework of the Study

In the conduct of this study, the researchers were guided by the model below.

Independent Variables Dependent Variables

Profile of Administrator/ Teacher


 Age
 Sex
 Civil status
 Highest educational Status of Mother Tongue
attainment Based- Multilingual
 Training attended related to Education
MTB-MLE
 Instructional Materials
 Years of experience in
 Teachers’
implementing MTB-MLE
preparedness
 Pupils’ preparedness

School Profile
 Enrollment
 Numbers of teachers
 Sources of MTB-MLE
 Instructional materials

Figure 1- The Research Paradigm

The Paradigm shows that there is a relationship between the profile of the
administrator/teachers and school with the status of the Mother Tongue Based-
Multilingual Education (MTB-MLE) in the Private Primary Schools in Vigan City.
COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION
DIVINE WORD COLLEGE OF VIGAN
Vigan City, Ilocos Sur 8

Statement of the Problem

This study aimed to determined the status of Mother Tongue Based-

Multilingual Education (MTB-MLE) in the private primary schools in Vigan City for

S.Y 2017-2018.

Specifically, this study sought to answer the following questions:

1. What is the profile of the school administrators and teachers in terms of:

a. age,

b.sex,

c.civil status,

d.highest educational attainment,

e.training attended related to MTB-MLE,

f.years of experience in implementing MTB-MLE?

2. What is the profile of the schools in terms of the following factors;

a. enrollment,

b. number of teachers,

c. sources of MTB-MLE instructional materials?

3. What is the status of Mother tongue Based-Multilingual Education in terms of :

a. instructional materials,

b. teachers’ preparedness,

c. pupils’ preparedness?
COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION
DIVINE WORD COLLEGE OF VIGAN
Vigan City, Ilocos Sur 9

4. Is there a significant relationship between the profile of the administrators/teachers,

the school profile and the status of mother tongue based multilingual education?

Assumption of the Study

The researchers considered the following assumptions:

1. The instruments used in gathering the data are valid and reliable.

2. The data gathered are the respondents’ honest assessments on the status of the MTB-

MLE.

Hypothesis

With the concepts and studies presented, this study is guided with the hypothesis

that there is a significant relationship between the administrators/teachers profile, the

school profile and the status of MTB-MLE.

Scope and Delimitation of the Study

This study was delimited to determine the status of MTB- MLE in the private

primary school in Vigan City for the school year 2017-2018. The respondents were the

administrators and teachers from private primary schools in Vigan City Ilocos Sur S.Y

2017-2018 such as Divine Word College of Vigan, St. Thomas Aquinas, Vigan

Nanchong School, Inc., UCCP Christian Learning and Development Center, Inc.

The personal profile of the respondents were measured in terms of age, sex, civil status,

position, highest educational attainment, training attended related to MTB-MLE, years

of experience in implementing MTB-MLE. The school profile was measured in terms


COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION 10
DIVINE WORD COLLEGE OF VIGAN
Vigan City, Ilocos Sur

of enrollment, number of teachers, sources of MTB-MLE and instructional materials.

While the Status of Mother Tongue Based Multilingual Education were measured in

terms of instructional materials, teachers’ preparedness and pupil’s preparedness.

This study made use of questionnaires as the primary tool in gathering data. The

questionnaire were adopted from the work of Rosales (2016). This study made use of

the descriptive – survey method research. The respondents were the administrators and

teachers who are teaching MTB-MLE in the private primary school in Vigan City with

the total of seventeen (17). The data gathered in the study were analyzed through the

use of frequency count, percentage, mean and simple-correlation analysis.

Importance of the Study


This study entitled status of the MTB-MLE of the private primary school in Vigan

City showed the significant aspects of how this study influences the educational field.

These research maybe important to the following:

School Community. This study will make the school community understand and

appreciate the MTB-MLE.

Administrator. This would motivate the administrators of the private primary

schools to support and strengthen the mother tongue based multilingual education. This

study could be used as instrument in assessing the MTB-MLE program and in

measuring children’s performance and materials.

Teachers. Since the teacher is the primary instrument for instruction, it is a big

help for them become more strategic in teaching MTB-MLE.


COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION
DIVINE WORD COLLEGE OF VIGAN 11
Vigan City, Ilocos Sur

Researcher. Through this study the researchers will be fully aware of the

importance of the MTB-MLE in facilitating learning in the classroom.

Operational Definition of Terms

The terms used in this study were operationally defined for clarity and

understanding.

Profile of the School Administrators and Teachers. This includes both

personal and professional attributes of the school administrators and teachers who are

included as respondents in this study. These attributes can serve as points of reference

as regards their capability to lead in the active implementation of the MTB- MLE.

Age. This refers to the length of time a person lived. In this study it is categorized

as 21-30 years old, 31-40 years old, 41-50 years old, 51-60 years old, 61 and above.

Sex. This refers to the two main categories whether male or female.

Civil Status. This refers to the status of the respondents whether single, married,

widow/er or separated.

Highest Educational Attainment. This means the highest level of education

attained by the respondents. In this study it is categorized as: Doctorate degree,

Master’s Degree with doctorate units, Master’s Degree, Bachelor’s Degree with

master’s units, and Bachelor’s Degree.

Training Attended Related to MTB-MLE. This refers to the number of

training/seminars in relation to MTB-MLE conducted by the government or private


COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION
DIVINE WORD COLLEGE OF VIGAN
Vigan City, Ilocos Sur 12

institution which are participated in by the administrators and teachers. In this study it

is categorized as international, national, regional, division, district, school-based.

Years of Experience in Implementing MTB-MLE. This refers to the number

of years the administrators implemented and teacher have been teaching using the

MTB-MLE. In this study is categorized as 1 year, 2 years, 3 years and above.

Profile of the School. This refers to the important aspects of the school, such as

the size of its enrolment, the number of its teachers and the availability of instructional

materials and supplies used as determinant factors in the assessment of the school to

implement MTB-MLE.

Enrollment. This refers to the number of enrollees in the school. It is categorized

as 500 or more, 400-499, 300-399, 200-299, 100-99, less than 99.

Number of teachers. This refers to the number of teachers teaching in the

different grade levels. It is categorized as 50 or more, 40-49, 30-39, 20-29, 10-19, less

than 10.

Sources of MTB-MLE Instructional Materials. It refers to the various sources

of MTB-MLE instructional materials such as DepEd, Teachers, NGO’s and Private

Sectors. (Rosales, 2016)

Mother Tongue Based- Multilingual Education. This refers to the program by

the Department of Education that focuses on the use of the Mother Tongue to improved

learning and attain a higher degree of learning outcomes. (Rosales, 2016). In this study
COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION
DIVINE WORD COLLEGE OF VIGAN
Vigan City, Ilocos Sur 13

it is measured in terms of instructional materials, teachers’ preparedness and pupils’

preparedness.

Instructional Materials. This refers to the availability of instructional materials

used in the implementation of the Mother Tongue Based- Multilingual Education

(MTB-MLE). These are educational resources used to improved pupils’ knowledge,

abilities, and skills to monitor their assimilation of information, and to contribute their

overall development and upbringing. (Rosales, 2016)

Teachers’ Preparedness. This refers to the level of preparedness of teachers in

the implementation of the Mother Tongue Based- Multilingual Education. (Rosales,

2016)

Pupils’ Preparedness. This pertains to the pupils’ preparedness in the

implementation of the Mother Tongue Based- Multilingual Education (Rosales,2016)


COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION
DIVINE WORD COLLEGE OF VIGAN
Vigan City, Ilocos Sur 14

CHAPTER II

REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURES AND STUDIES

This chapter summarizes the related literature and studies which have direct and

indirect bearing on the study.

Related Literature

On Mother tongue as Medium of Instruction

Mother language or First Language (L1) refers to the language or languages first

learned by a child, which he/she identifies with, is identified as a native language user

of by other, which he/she knows best, or uses most. This includes Filipino sign

language used by individuals with pertinent disabilities. The regional or native

language refers to the traditional speech variety or variety of Filipino sign language

existing in a region, area of place. (DepEd, 2012).

Furthermore, mother language is the medium of one’s inner thoughts and

reflections. The mother tongue being the primary tool for thought processing and

knowledge acquisition is considered as the best medium of instruction. As source of

creativity and which for social expressions, the mother language along with linguistic diversity

matter for the identity of individuals and vital for the health of societies. It opens opportunities

for dialogue necessary for understanding and cooperation. (Manila Bulletin, 2012).
COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION
DIVINE WORD COLLEGE OF VIGAN
Vigan City, Ilocos Sur 15

Moreover, Nolasco, (2010) wrote that one’s own language enables a child to

express himself easily, as there is no fear of making mistakes. MLE encourages lecture

participation by children in the learning process because they understand what is being

discussed and what is being ask of them. They can immediately use the mother tongue

to construct and explain their world, articulate their thoughts and add new concepts to

what they already know.

By using the child’s language for basic education, we start from what they already

know and build on this. Since the child is already familiar with language used, learning

to read and write becomes the focus and not learning the medium instruction. The child

can immediately use this language to add new concepts to what he/she has already

learned. (Nolasco, 2010)

On Instructional Materials

Instructional materials refer to the human and non- human materials and

facilities that can be used to ease, encourage, improve and promote teaching and

learning activities. They are whatever materials used in the process of instruction. They

are a broad range of resource which can be used to facilitate effective instruction. They

indicate a systematic way of designing, carrying out and employing human and non-

human resources to bring out more meaningful and effective instruction. They are

human and non- human material that a teacher uses to pass information.

(http://www.igi-global.com>dictionary)
COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION
DIVINE WORD COLLEGE OF VIGAN
Vigan City, Ilocos Sur 16
Likewise, instructional materials as educational resource are used to improve

student knowledge, abilities, and skills to monitor their assimilation of information and

to contribute to their overall development and upbringing. There are three basic types

of instructional materials: (1) concrete objects, including objects from the world of

nature; (2) representations of concrete objects and phenomena and (3) descriptions of

such object and phenomena by means of the signs, words and sentences of natural and

artificial languages.(http://encyclopedia2.the free dictionary.com)

The importance of instructional materials allows the instructor to engage

learners by supporting concept through the use of multimedia, including sound clips,

video, images, hands- on experience and interactive games. Materials offer learners the

opportunity to practice concepts and develop a product that demonstrates their level of

understanding. Consequently, those products are then used to evaluate learner’s

knowledge. Instructional materials allow the instructor to support learners with varying

levels of ability and foundational skills by providing additional support.

Nolasco (2012), on the other hand suggested that material preparation for MTB-

MLE requires a minimum of one year should be develop with the community not just

with DepEd teachers. If materials are insufficient, the program will not be implemented

well and will not achieve the desired outcomes.


COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION
DIVINE WORD COLLEGE OF VIGAN
Vigan City, Ilocos Sur 17

On Teachers’ Preparedness

Teaching is a complex endeavour, involving classroom management, lesson

preparation and organization of teaching and learning activities. Evaluation and

feedback on student success in the classroom is largely based on effective classroom

instruction and adequate preparation by teachers.

Nolasco(2012), related that in one of the bridging languages workshops that he

facilitated he was deluged with request from the participating teachers for a more

rigorous Mother Tongue Based-Multilingual Education (MTB-MLE) training regimen.

The teachers were particularly concerned with practical issues like how to produced

home grown teaching and reading materials, and how to actually develop greater

fluency in their own languages. His apprehension grew from the fact that teaching in

mother tongue based program requires a vastly different set of skills, many of which

apparently do not have at the moment. Since the Department of Education decided to

implement nationwide its own version of mother tongue based education in

kindergarten and first grade, teaching education institutions have their work cut out for

them in revising curricula to be congruent with the new policy. It will required more

than three years before teachers could be equip with necessary competencies in the

required languages and in academic content. For teachers who are new in the service,

at least one year training program is needed to provide them with the pedagogical

knowledge and skills required as well the theories, principles and practical skills that

they will need in MTB-MLE. Likewise, intensive workshops


COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION
DIVINE WORD COLLEGE OF VIGAN
Vigan City, Ilocos Sur 18

for experienced teachers for MTB-MLE must be provided to help them gain

additional theoretical and practical knowledge and skills needed to be effective in

MTB-MLE. (m.inquirer.net. starting from where the teachers are)

On Pupils’ Preparedness

Learners should begin their education in the language they understand best their

mother tongue- and need to develop a strong foundation in their mother language before

effectively learning additional languages.(www.deped.gov.ph)

The purpose of multilingual education is to develop appropriate cognitive and

reasoning skills, enabling children to operate equally in different languages starting the

first language of the child. (www.deped.gov.ph)

Furthermore, students will learn and develop holistically. When learners are first

instructed in the language they know best, they are able to build a good “bridge” toward

learning another language. Multilingual also enjoy benefits that go beyond linguistic

knowledge. They are also able to learn with more flexibility. (www.deped.gov.ph)

19

Related Studies
COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION
DIVINE WORD COLLEGE OF VIGAN
Vigan City, Ilocos Sur

The Lubuagan Experience cited by Nolasco (2010) has shown that using the

Mother Tongue contributes to the performance of Pupils. The over-all results of the

tests showed that the experimental class scored nearly 80 percent mastery of the

curriculum, while the control class scored just over 50 percent mastery. The results

provide crucial evidence that mother tongue instruction strengthens the learning of

English and Filipino and does not hinder the learning of content, contrary to the fears

and concerns of many parents and educators.

In the study of Alonzo (2015) “Preparedness of Elementary teachers in using

the Mother Tongue Based-Multilingual Education” she found out that MTB-MLE

materials are provided by the DepEd and the teachers themselves. Administrators and

teachers have attended various level of seminars related to MTB-MLE and mostly

regional training which leads to having a “high level” of preparedness among the

administrators and “average level “of preparedness for the teacher respondent.

Although teachers and administrators are prepared in teaching the MTB-MLE, still,

huge support from the community are sought for the full implementation of the

program. The researcher also found out that the lack of support/involvement by all

internal and external stakeholder was identified to be the biggest problem of the

teachers and administrators.

20

CHAPTER III
COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION
DIVINE WORD COLLEGE OF VIGAN
Vigan City, Ilocos Sur

RESEARCH METHODOLOGY

This section discussed the research design the population and sample, the research

instrument, the data gathering procedure and the statistical treatment of data.

Research Design

This study used the descriptive correlation research designs. The descriptive

correlation research is a design used to collect and analyze the data.

In this study, the independent variables was described in terms of

administrator/teacher profile and the school profile. The dependent variable was

described along the status of mother tongue based multilingual education.

On the other hand, the simple correlation analysis were used to determine the

relationship between the administrators/teachers-profile, school-profile and the status

of the Mother Tongue Based-Multilingual Education.

Sources of Data

Population

This study was conducted in the private primary schools in Vigan city who

implemented MTB-MLE. There were four private primary schools considered in the

study namely, Divine Word College, St. Thomas Aquinas, Vigan Nan Chong School,

Inc., UCCP.
21

The respondents of this study were the total of 17 administrators and teachers

who implemented MTB-MLE.


COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION
DIVINE WORD COLLEGE OF VIGAN
Vigan City, Ilocos Sur

Table 1.

Distribution of the Respondents

Private Schools No. of Grade 1-3 Total


Administrators Teachers

Divine Word College of Vigan 1 3 4

St. Thomas Aquinas 1 3 4

Vigan Nanchong School, Inc. 1 3 4

UCCP Christian Learning and 1 4 5


Development Center,Inc.

Total 4 13 17

Locale of the Study

This study was conducted from the different private primary schools in Vigan

City who implemented MTB-MLE.

Data Gathering Instrument

This study made use of questionnaires as the primary tool for gathering data. The

questionnaires were adopted from the work of Rosales (2016). There are two parts of

the questionnaires that were use. Part I used to gather data on the profile of the

administrators/teachers, and the profile of the school in the private primary schools in

Vigan city. Part II was used to gather data on the status of MTB-MLE along:

instructional materials, teachers’ preparedness, pupils’ preparedness.


COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION
DIVINE WORD COLLEGE OF VIGAN
Vigan City, Ilocos Sur

The data gathered were interpreted using the following scale:

Statistical Limit Descriptive Rating Overall Descriptive Rating

4.21-5.00 Completely True (CT) Very High (VH)

3.41-4.20 Mostly True (MT) High (H)

2.61-3.40 Generally True (GT) Average (A)

1.81-2.60 Slightly True (ST) Low (L)

1.00-1.80 Not At All True (NT) Very Low (VL)

Data Gathering Procedure

This study involves the gathering of data through questionnaires in assessing the

status of MTB-MLE in the Private Primary Schools in Vigan City.

The researchers wrote a letter to the administrators of the different primary school

in Vigan City to allow the researchers to float their questionnaires. After which, the

researchers, floated and retrieved the said data.

23

Statistical Treatment of Data

The following statistical tools were used to analyze the data gathered in this study.
COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION
DIVINE WORD COLLEGE OF VIGAN
Vigan City, Ilocos Sur

1. Frequency Count and Percentage to determine the profile of the respondents in terms

of personal and professional factors.

2. Mean to determine the level of adequacy of school facilities and resources, and the

status of Mother Tongue Based –Multilingual Education.

3. Simple correlation Analysis to determine the relationship between the profile of the

administrators/teachers, the school profile and the status of Mother Tongue Based –

Multilingual Education.

24

CHAPTER IV

PRESENTATION, ANALYSIS AND INTERPRETATION OF DATA


COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION
DIVINE WORD COLLEGE OF VIGAN
Vigan City, Ilocos Sur

This chapter presents, analyze and interpret the data gathered relevant to the

problem raised in the study.

The following are the findings pertinent to each of the problems and hypothesis.

Problem1. What is the personal profile of the administrator and teacher of the Private

Primary school in Vigan City in terms of:

a. age,

b. sex,

c. civil status,

d. highest educational attainment,

e. training attended related to MTB-MLE,

f. years of experience in implementing MTB-MLE ?

25

Table 2a. Presents the personal and professional profile of the administrators in the

private primary schools in Vigan City.

Table 2a
COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION
DIVINE WORD COLLEGE OF VIGAN
Vigan City, Ilocos Sur

Profile of Administrators in Terms of Personal and Professional Factors

Profile F %
Age
61 and above 1 25.00
51-60 years old 1 25.00
41-50 years old 1 25.00
21-30 years old 1 25.00
TOTAL 4 100.00
Sex
Male 1 25.00
Female 3 75.00
TOTAL 4 100.00
Civil Status
Married 4 100.00
TOTAL 4 100.00
Highest Educational Attainment

Master’s Degree 2 50.00


Bachelor’s Degree with Master’s Units 1 25.00
Bachelor’s Degree 1 25.00
TOTAL 4 100.00
Training Attended Related to MTB-MLE
Regional 1 25.00
Division 2 50.00
School-Based 1 25.00
TOTAL 4 100.00
Years of Experience in Implementing MTB-MLE
3 years and above 4 100.00
TOTAL 4 100.00

On Age
The tables showed that each one (1 or 25 %) of the administrators in the private

primary schools in Vigan City is within the age bracket of 61 and above, 50-60 years old,

41-50 years old, and 21-30 years old.


26

On Sex
As shown in the table, majority of the administrator are female (3 or 75%), while

1 or 25% is male.
COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION
DIVINE WORD COLLEGE OF VIGAN
Vigan City, Ilocos Sur

On Civil Status
The table reveals that all of the private primary administrators in Vigan City are

married (4 or 100%).

On Highest Educational Attainment


As shown in the table most (2 or 50%) of the administrators are Master’s Degree

holder, while 1 or 25% is Bachelor’s Degree with Masters units, and 1 or 25% is

Bachelor’s Degree holder.

On Training attended related to MTB-MLE


The table revealed that most (2 or 50%) of the administrators in the private

primary schools in Vigan city attended training at the division level while 1 or 25%

attended training in regional level and 1or 25% attended school-based training.

On Years of implementing MTB-MLE


As shown in the table all (4 or 100%) administrators in the private primary school

in Vigan City have 3 years’ experience in implementing MTB-MLE.

Table 2b. Presents the personal and professional profile of the private primary school

teachers in Vigan City.

27
Table 2b.

Profile F %
Age
COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION
DIVINE WORD COLLEGE OF VIGAN
Vigan City, Ilocos Sur

51-60 years old 1 7.69


41-50 years old 2 15.38
31-40 years old 1 7.69
21-30 years old 9 69.23
TOTAL 13 100.00
Sex
Male 1 7.69
Female 12 92.31
TOTAL 13 100.00
Civil Status
Single 8 61.54
Married 5 38.46
TOTAL 13 100.00
Highest Educational Attainment
Bachelor’s Degree with Master’s Units 5 38.46
Bachelor Degree 8 61.54
TOTAL 13 100.00
Training Attended Related to MTB-MLE
Regional 3 23.08
District 1 7.69
School-Based 9 69.23
TOTAL 13 100.00
Years of Experience in Implementing MTB-MLE
3 years and above 2 15.38
2 years 4 30.77
1 year 7 53.85
TOTAL 13 100.00
Profile of Teachers in Terms of Personal and Professional Factors

On Age
The table showed that most (9 or 69.23%) of the teacher are within the age bracket

of 21-30 years old, 2 or 15.38% are within 41-50 years old, 1 or 7.69%) are within 31-

40 and also 1 or 7.69% is within 51-60 years old.

28

On Sex
COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION
DIVINE WORD COLLEGE OF VIGAN
Vigan City, Ilocos Sur

The table revealed that most (12 or 92.31%) of the private primary school teachers

in Vigan City are female and 1 or 7.69% is male.

On Civil Status
Based on the figures shown in the table, majority (8 or 61.54%) of the teacher-

respondents are single while 5 or 38.46% are married.

On Highest Educational Attainment


It can be gleaned from the table that majority (8 or 61.54%) of the teachers are

Bachelor’s Degree holder while 5 or 38.46% are Bachelor’s Degree with Master’s

Unit.

On Training Attended Related to MTB-MLE


The table manifest that most (9 or 69.23%) of the private primary school teacher

attended school-based training in MTB-MLE, 3 or 23.08% attended in the regional level

and 1 or 7.69% attended training in the district level.

On Years of Experience in Implementing MTB-MLE


It can be drawn from the table that most (7 or 53.85%) of the teachers have 1-

year experience in implementing MTB-MLE while 4 or 30.77% have 2 years

experience and 2 or 15.38% have 3 years experience in implementing MTB-MLE.

.
29

Problem 2. What is the profile of the school in terms of the following factor:
COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION
DIVINE WORD COLLEGE OF VIGAN
Vigan City, Ilocos Sur

a. Enrollment

b. Number of teachers

c. Source of MTB-MLE instructional materials?

Table 3. Presents the profile of the school in terms of the number of enrollment,

number of teachers and sources of MTB-MLE instructional materials.

Table 3

Profile of the School in terms of enrollment, number of teachers and sources of MTB-
MLE instructional materials

School Profile F %
Enrolment
400-499 1 25.00
200-299 1 25.00
Less than 99 2 50.00
TOTAL 4 100.00
Number of Teachers
20-29 1 25.00
10-19 2 50.00
Less than 10 1 25.00
TOTAL 4 100.00
Sources of MTB-MLE
Provided by DepEd 1 25.00
Provided by Teachers 2 50.00
Provided by Private Sectors 1 25.00
TOTAL 4 100.00

On Enrollment

Based on the table, most (2 or 50%) of the private primary school in Vigan City

have less than 99 enrollment, 1 or 25% have 100-199 enrollment and 1 or 25% have

400-499 enrollment.
30

On Number of Teachers
COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION
DIVINE WORD COLLEGE OF VIGAN
Vigan City, Ilocos Sur

As shown in the table most (2 or 50%) of the private primary schools have 10-19

teachers, 1 or 25% have 20-29 teachers and 1 or 25% have less than 10 teachers.

On Sources of MTB-MLE instructional materials

As shown in the table administrators revealed that most (2 or 50%) of the

Instructional Materials in MTB-MLE were provided by teachers, 1 or 25% mentioned

that materials were provided by DepEd and 1 or 25% also stated that materials were

provided by private sectors.

Problem 3. What is the status of mother tongue Based –Multilingual Education in terms

of:

a. instructional materials

b. teachers’ preparedness

c. pupils’ preparedness

The table 4 presents the data gathered on the Status of Mother Tongue Based-

Multilingual Education in Private Primary School in Vigan City along instructional

materials.

31

Table 4
COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION
DIVINE WORD COLLEGE OF VIGAN
Vigan City, Ilocos Sur

Mean Rating Showing the Status of Mother Tongue Based- Multilingual


Education in the Private Primary School in Vigan City in terms of Instructional
Materials.

Indicators Teachers Administrat As a whole


or

X DR X DR X DR

1. There are adequate supplies for making teaching- 3.54 MT 3.33 GT 3.50 MT
learning ideas.

2. There are adequate supplies of pictures, charts, 3.15 GT 3.33 GT 3.19 GT


posters, models, and other visual aids.

3. Taped stories, songs, poems, and rhymes are 2.85 GT 3.33 GT 2.94 GT
available.

4. There are adequate supplies of up-to date MTB- 3.77 MT 3.00 GT 3.63 MT
MLE books for teaching and learning activities.

5. Adequate supplies of workbooks in MTB-MLE in 4.08 MT 3.67 MT 4.00 MT


every subject are available for use.

6. Adequate teaching guides and manuals are 3.46 MT 4.00 MT 3.56 MT


available.

7. There are adequate standard evaluation devices. 3.69 MT 3.33 GT 3.63 MT

8. Adequate evaluation forms are also available. 3.54 MT 3.33 GT 3.50 MT

9. Translated MTB-MLE books are available. 3.54 MT 2.33 GT 3.31 GT

10. Adequate module, teaching aids/devices and 3.23 GT 3.33 GT 3.25 GT


facilities.

As a whole 3.48 H 3.30 A 3.45 H

Legend:3.41-4.20 Mostly True (MT) 3.41- 4.20 High (H)

2.61- 3.40 Generally True (GT) 2.61- 3.40 Average (A)

It can be gleaned from the table that the overall rating along instructional

materials is “high” (x= 3.45). This implies that both administrators and teachers

believed that instructional materials are important to facilitate learning. However, it is

also noticeable that the two groups have different perceptions along this area.

Administrators believe that MTB-MLE materials were only utilize at an “average”


COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION 32
DIVINE WORD COLLEGE OF VIGAN
Vigan City, Ilocos Sur

level (x=3.30) while teachers believe that instructional materials are enough and were

highly utilized (x= 3.48, high).

Moreover, the table revealed that item #5, “Adequate supplies of workbook in

MTB-MLE in every subject are available for use” was rated highest (x=4.00, MT). On

the other hand, item # 3 “Taped stories, songs, poems and rhymes are available” was

rated the lowest (x= 2.49, GT). This implies that administrators and teachers recognize

that visual and audio materials are limited and have somehow felt the need to produce

such kind of materials.

Table 5 presents the data gathered on the status of MTB-MLE in the Primary

Schools in Vigan City along Teachers’ Preparedness.

33
COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION
DIVINE WORD COLLEGE OF VIGAN
Vigan City, Ilocos Sur

Table 5

Mean Rating Showing the Status of Mother Tongue Based- Multilingual


Education in Private Primary School in Vigan City in terms of Teachers’
Preparedness.
Indicators Teacher Administrator As a Whole

X DR X DR X DR

1. Teachers undergo continuing and advance 3.23 GT 3.00 GT 3.19 GT


professional.
2. Teachers are regularly trained in new and 2.92 GT 2.67 GT 2.88 GT
effective teaching and learning strategies on
3. Teachers have enough technical skills in
MTB-MLE. 3.62 MT 3.67 MT 3.63 MT
MTB-MLE.
4. Teachers have enough manuals and teachers’ 3.38 GT 3.67 MT 3.44 MT
guide for teaching MTB-MLE.
5. Teachers read enough reading materials and 3.69 MT 3.67 MT 3.69 MT
magazines written in Iloko.
6. The school heads/administrators regularly 3.62 MT 3.67 MT 3.63 MT
monitor teachers’ performance and provide
7. Teachersassistance
technical support their co-teachers
in the by sharing
implementation of 4.15 MT 4.00 MT 4.14 MT
teaching
MTB-MLE. techniques and experiences on MTB-
8. Teachers are able to translate stories/selections
MLE. 4.00 MT 4.33 CT 4.06 MT
from books to Ilocano.
9. Teachers have mastery on subject matter 4.31 CT 4.33 CT 4.31 CT
(MTB-MLE) taught.
10. Teachers have sense of belongingness on 4.46 CT 4.00 MT 4.38 CT
language spoken at home and taken the
As a whole of preservation of the language.
responsibility 3.74 H 3.70 H 3.73 H

Legend: 4.21- 5.00 Completely True (CT) 3.41-4.20 Mostly True (MT)

2.61- 3.40 Generally True (GT) 4.21-5.00 Very High (VH)

It is figured from the table that the overall status of MTB-MLE in the private

primary schools in Vigan City along teachers’ preparedness is “High” with the overall

mean rating of 3.73. This means that both the administrators (x= 3.70, High) and

teachers (x=3.74, High) claimed that they are prepared to implement and teach MTB-

MLE. The data further showed that the administrator and teacher are equipped with the

skills and knowledge necessary in the full implementation of the MTB-MLE.


34

Moreover, item #10 “Teachers have sense of belongingness on language spoken

at home and taken the responsibility of the preservation of the language” was rated
COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION
DIVINE WORD COLLEGE OF VIGAN
Vigan City, Ilocos Sur

highest which yielded a mean score of 4.38 described as “Completely true”. This

implies that teachers take pride and confident to teach the mother tongue not because

they are familiar with it since it is the language spoken at home but because they feel

that the language is part of their being and they had the responsibility to preserve and

transmit it.

However, item #2 “teachers regularly trained in new and effective teaching and

learning strategies on MTB-MLE” was rated the lowest with the mean score of 2.88

and described as “Generally true”. This means that though teachers were sent for MTB-

MLE seminars and trainings they still need continuous and advanced trainings for them

to learn new techniques and methods.

The table 6 presents the data gathered on the Status of Mother Tongue Based-

Multilingual Education in private primary school in Vigan City along pupils’

preparedness.

35

Table 6
COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION
DIVINE WORD COLLEGE OF VIGAN
Vigan City, Ilocos Sur

Mean Rating Showing the Status of Mother Tongue Based- Multilingual


Education in Private Primary School in Vigan City in Terms of Pupils’
Preparedness.
Indicators Teacher Administrator As a whole

X DR X DR X DR

1. Pupils are able to use Iloco in 4.54 CT 3.67 MT 4.38 CT


communication.

2. Pupils are able to do their daily works 4.23 CT 4.67 CT 4.31 CT


accurately on MTB-MLE.

3. Pupils are able to explore new 4.00 MT 4.33 CT 4.06 MT


knowledge on MTB-MLE.

4. Pupils are able to use MTB-MLE for 4.38 CT 4.67 CT 4.44 CT


daily living.

5. Pupils show interest in MTB-MLE. 4.23 CT 3.67 MT 4.13 MT

6. Pupils can easily understand 4.23 CT 3.67 MT 4.13 MT


instructions in MTB-MLE.

7. Pupils can easily comprehend MTB- 4.15 MT 3.67 MT 4.06 MT


MLE instructions.

8. Pupils show constant progress based 4.00 MT 4.00 MT 4.00 MT


on standard evaluation devices on MTB-
MLE.

9. Pupils can read Ilocano words 4.00 MT 3.00 GT 3.81 MT


correctly

10. Pupils can recite poems and rhymes 4.08 MT 3.67 MT 4.00 MT
in iloco properly

As a whole 4.18 H 3.90 H 4.13 H

Legend: 4.21-5.00 Completely True (CT) 3.41- 4.20 High (H)

3.41- 4.20 Mostly True (MT) 2.61-3.40 Average (A)

36

It is figured from the table that the overall status of MTB-MLE in Private Primary

Schools in Vigan City along pupil’s preparedness is “High” as reflected by the overall

mean rating of 4.13. It is a noticeable that teachers (x=4.18, High) have higher
COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION
DIVINE WORD COLLEGE OF VIGAN
Vigan City, Ilocos Sur

evaluation with regards to pupil’s preparedness than administrators (x=3.90, High). The

high perception of teachers could be attributed to their day to day encounter with the

pupils. Teachers know their learners better than others involved in the curricular

process. Nevertheless, both group revealed that pupils are prepare for the

implementation of MTB-MLE.

The item “Pupils are able to use MTB-MLE for daily living” #4 was rated highest

which yielded a mean score of 4.44 which is describe as “Completely True”. This

implies that the pupils use the mother tongue most of the time. On the other hand, item

(#9) “Pupils can read Ilokano words correctly” was the lowest rated item with the mean

the score of 3.81, described as “Mostly True”. This means that although pupils fluently

speak the native language. They have experienced some difficulty in reading Ilocano

language or words.

37

Table 7 summarizes the data gathered on the Status of Mother Tongue Based-

Multilingual Education in private primary school in Vigan City along instructional

materials, teacher’s preparedness and pupil’s preparedness.


COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION
DIVINE WORD COLLEGE OF VIGAN
Vigan City, Ilocos Sur

Table 7

Summary of the Mean Rating of the Status of Mother Tongue Based- Multilingual
Education in Private Primary School in Vigan City

MTB-MLE Indicators X DR

1.Instructional Materials 3.45 H

2.Teachers’ Preparedness 3.73 H

3.Pupils’ Preparedness 4.13 H

Total 3.77 H

The table revealed that as a whole the status of the MTB-MLE in Private Primary

School in Vigan City is “high” (x=3.77). This generally implies that the MTB-MLE

program in the private primary school in Vigan city were highly implemented.

Moreover, pupils’ preparedness was the highest rated item (x=4.13, High). On

the other hand, among the three indicators instructional materials is lowest rated item

(x=345, High).

Problem 4. Is there a significant relationship between the personal profile and the

status of MTB-MLE:

38

The table 8 indicates the computed correlation of the profile of the respondents

and the status of mother tongue based- multilingual education.

Table 8
COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION
DIVINE WORD COLLEGE OF VIGAN
Vigan City, Ilocos Sur

Correlation Coefficient Showing the Relationship between the Profile of the


Respondents, the School Profile and the Status of MTB-MLE of the Private
Primary School in Vigan City

Variables Instructional Teachers Pupils


Preparedness Preparedness
Materials

School -.261 -.237 -.028


Age -.328 -.300 .049
Sex .048 -.016 .048
Civil Status -.159 -.200 .128
Position .265 .767 .773
Highest Educational Attainment .152 .308 .433
Training Attended Related to MTB-MLE -.671 -.816* .296
Years of Experiences in implementing -.330 -.547 .077
MTB-MLE

*.Correlation is significant at the 0.05 level (2-tailed). **.Correlation is significant at the 0.01 level (2-tailed). c. Cannot be

computed because at least one of the variables is constant.

It is observed from the table that there is no significant relationship between the

profile of the respondents, the school profile and the status of Mother Tongue Based-

Multilingual Education. This means that when these factors were taken together give

no significant relationship on the status of MTB-MLE.

However, when taken singly, there is a significant relationship between teachers’

preparedness with training attended related to MTB-MLE as evidenced by the

correlation coefficient of -.816 which was found significant at 0.05 levels. This implies

that administrators and teacher felt the need for continuous and more advance trainings

and seminars particularly in MTB-MLE for them to be fully equipped with knowledge,

skills and competencies.


39

CHAPTER V

SUMMARY OF FINDINGS,CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS


COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION
DIVINE WORD COLLEGE OF VIGAN
Vigan City, Ilocos Sur

This chapter summarizes the study with its findings, conclusions and

recommendations.

SUMMARY

This study primarily aimed to determine the status of Mother Tongue Based-

Multilingual Education (MTB-MLE) of the private primary school in Vigan City for

school year 2017-2018. The personal profile of the respondents were measured in terms

of age, sex, civil status, position, highest educational attainment, training attended

related to MTB-MLE, years of experience in implementing MTB-MLE. The school

profile was measured in terms of enrollment, number of teachers, sources of MTB-

MLE and instructional materials, while the Status of Mother Tongue Based

Multilingual Education were measured in terms of instructional materials, teachers’

preparedness and pupil’s preparedness.

The study employed the descriptive type of research. The researchers gathered

information through questionnaires. The data gathered were interpreted using the

following statistical tools. Frequency Count and Percentage were use to determine the

profile of the respondents in terms of personal and professional factors; Mean to

determine the status of Mother Tongue Based –Multilingual Education; Simple

Correlation Analysis to determine the relationship between the


40

profile of the administrators/teachers, school- profile and the status of Mother Tongue

Based –Multilingual Education. The study was conducted in the private primary schools

in Vigan City. There were four (4) administrators and thirteen (13) teachers of MTB-
COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION
DIVINE WORD COLLEGE OF VIGAN
Vigan City, Ilocos Sur

MLE in the private primary school in Vigan city who served as respondents of the

study.

Findings

From the data gathered, the following were the significant findings of the study.

1a. Profiles of School administrators and teachers

On Age. Each one (1 or 25 %) of the administrator in the private primary schools

in Vigan City is within the age bracket of 61 and above, 50-60 years old, 41-50

years old, and 21-30 years old, while, most (9 or 69.23%) of the teacher-

respondents are within the age bracket of 21-30 years old.

On Sex. Majority (3 or 75%) of the private primary school administrator are

female while most all the teachers (12 or 92.31%) are female.

On Civil Status. All (4 or 100%) the school administrators in the private primary

school in Vigan City are married, while majority (8 or 61.54%) of the teachers

are single.

On Highest Educational Attainment. Majority (2 or 50%) of the administrators

are Master’s Degree holder, while most (8 or 61.54%) of the teachers are

Bachelor’s Degree holder.


41
On Training Attended Related MTB-MLE. Most (2 or 50%) of the

administrators in the private primary school attended training in the division level,

while, majority (9 or 69.23%) of the teachers have attended school-based training.


COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION
DIVINE WORD COLLEGE OF VIGAN
Vigan City, Ilocos Sur

On Years of Implementing MTB-MLE. Majority (4 or 100%) of the private

primary school administrators have 3 years’ experience in implementing MTB-

MLE, while, majority (7 or 53.85%) of the teacher-respondents have only 1-year

experience in implementing MTB-MLE.

1b. Profile of the Private Primary School in Vigan City.

On Enrollment. Most (2 or 50%) of the private primary school in Vigan city

have less than 99 enrollment.

On Number of Teachers. Most (2 or 50%) of the private primary school in Vigan

City have 10-19 teachers.

On Sources of MTB-MLE Instructional Materials. Most (2 or 50%) of the

MTB-MLE instructional materials are provided by teachers.

2. Status of the Mother Tongue Based Multi-lingual Education (MTB-MLE).

On Instructional Materials. Overall, the status of MTB-MLE along

instructional materials is “High”, (x=3.45).

On Teachers’ Preparedness. Overall, the status of MTB-MLE along teachers’

preparedness is “High”, (x=3.73).

On Pupils’ Preparedness. Overall, the status of MTB-MLE along pupils’

preparedness is “High”, (x=4.13). 42

On the overall status of MTB-MLE. The status of the MTB-MLE in the private

primary school in Vigan City is “High” (x=3.77)

3. On the significant relationship between the profile of the respondents and the

status of the MTB-MLE.


COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION
DIVINE WORD COLLEGE OF VIGAN
Vigan City, Ilocos Sur

There is no significant relationship between the status of MTB-MLE, the profile

of the respondents, and the school profile. However, when taken singly only the

trainings attended by teachers were found to have a significant relationship with

teachers’ preparedness.

Conclusion

Based on the findings, the following conclusions were formulated:

Each one of the administrator in the private primary schools in Vigan City is

within the age bracket of 61 and above, 50-60 years old, 41-50 year old, and 21-30

years old. Majority are female, married, master’s degree holder, attended MTB-MLE

trainings in the division level and have three years’ experience in implementing the

program. On the other hand, most of the teachers are within the age bracket of 21-30

years old, female, single, bachelor’s degree holder, attended MTB-MLE school-based

training and have only 1-year experience in implementing MTB-MLE program. Most

of the private primary school in Vigan City have less than 99 enrollees; have less than

10 teachers and most of the MTB-MLE materials are provided by teachers.

The status of the MTB-MLE in the private primary school in Vigan City is

“High” (x=3.77). 43

Overall, there is no significant relationship between the status of MTB-MLE

and the profile of the respondents, but taken singly only training attended were found

to have significant relationship with teachers’ preparedness.

Recommendations
COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION
DIVINE WORD COLLEGE OF VIGAN
Vigan City, Ilocos Sur

In view of the gathered findings and conclusions, the following are strongly

recommended: 1. Administrators in the different private primary schools in Vigan city

must keep abreast with new trends and innovations with regards to the MTB-MLE

program to maintain its high status. 2. Since most of MTB-MLE materials were greatly

produced by teachers, intensive training for the production and development of

instructional materials should be given to teachers at least once a year to provide them

with enough knowledge and skills and to ensure that there will be enough learning

materials in the classrooms. 3. Since pupils have difficulty reading the mother tongue

teachers must provide activities that will help the pupils read the mother tongue

fluently. Among these activities are word puzzle formation, analogues, singing of Iloco

songs and hymns and poem recitation . 4. Since teachers’ training were significantly

related to teachers’ preparedness in teaching MTB-MLE they should be given

continuous trainings and seminars in the local, district and regional level for them also

to acquire deeper awareness and understanding of the program.

44
COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION
DIVINE WORD COLLEGE OF VIGAN
Vigan City, Ilocos Sur

BIBLIOGRAPHY

45

A. Unpublished Thesis
Alonzo, Jannice V. (2015). “Preparedness of Elementary teachers using the
Mother Tongue Based-Multilingual Education”. University of Northern
Philippines.
COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION
DIVINE WORD COLLEGE OF VIGAN
Vigan City, Ilocos Sur

Rosales Joannalyn V. (2016), “Status of Mother Tongue Based-Multilingual


Education in public elementary schools in the Division of Ilocos for the school
year 2014-2015”. University of Northern Philippines.

B. Internet
DepEd(2011).MotherTongue-BasedMultilingual
Education.www.depedro.7.com:ph/uploadediles/file/newsletter/72811/Mother
Tongue.pdf. Date Retrieve, October 5, 2017

DepEd (2012). Guidelines on the Implementation of Mother Tongue Based


Multilingual Education (MTB-MLE). DepEdOrder No. 16. S. 2012, Manila,
Philippines.www.deped.gov.ph.Date Retrieval, October 7,2017
DepEd (2009). Institutional of the Mother Tongue-Based Multilingual Education as
a Fundamental Educational Policy and Program in the Department
DepEdOrder No. 74 s.2009.
Manila,Philippines.http:mlephil.wordpress.com/2009/07/18 deped: order-no-
74-5-2009.Date Retrieval, October 5,2017.
m.inquirer.net. starting from where the teachers are.

Nolasco, Ma. Ricardo et.al (2010) Starting Where the Children Are: A collection of
Essays on Mother Tongue Based Multilingual Education and language Issues
on the Philippines.Mothertongue-based.blogspot.com/2009/01/mle-
primer.html.Date Retrieved, October 3,2017.
Nolasco, Ma. Ricardo(2012), Stating Where the Teachers Are. Philippine Daily
Inquirer.m. inquirer. net. Date Retrieved October 3, 2017
Nolasco, Ma. Ricardo (2012) K+12 and the MTB-MLE: Make Haste, Lay Waste,
Philippine Daily Inquirer. https://mlephil-wordpress.com. Date Retrieved, Oct.
5, 2017
www.cu-educ.ph/mother tongue based multilingual education
www.mlnetwork.org.the case for MTB-MLE
UNESCO,2003. Education in a Multilingual World. Education Position
Paper.wwwathttp://unesdoc.unesco.org/images/0012/001297/129728e.pdf.Da
te Retrieval, October 5,2017.

46

You might also like