Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Nutritional Epidemiology
1
Nestlé Institute of Health Science, Nestlé Research, Lausanne, Switzerland; 2 RTI International, Research Triangle Park, NC; 3 School of
Medicine and Jean Mayer USDA Human Nutrition Research Center on Aging at Tufts University, Boston, MA; and 4 Department of
ABSTRACT
Background: Many updates to young child feeding recommendations have been published over the past decade, but
concurrent intake trends have not been assessed.
Objective: The aim of this study was to evaluate adequacy and trends in energy and nutrient intakes of US infants and
children aged 0–47.9 mo through use of Feeding Infants and Toddlers Study (FITS) data from 2002, 2008, and 2016.
Methods: FITS are cross-sectional surveys of parents/caregivers of infants and young children (FITS 2002, n = 2962;
FITS 2008, n = 3276; FITS 2016, n = 3235). Dietary intakes were assessed by telephone with trained interviewers using
the Nutrition Data System for Research. Mean ± SE nutrient intakes were calculated. Diet adequacy was assessed with
the nutrient adequacy ratio (NAR) for 17 nutrients and the corresponding mean adequacy ratio.
Results: Energy and macronutrient intakes were generally stable across surveys, but significant decreases for saturated
fat and total sugars and an increase in fiber were observed among 6–11.9-mo-olds and 12–23.9-mo-olds (P-trend <
0.0001). Mean sodium intakes exceeded Adequate Intakes (AI) for all ages, whereas fiber intakes were universally
below the AI. Nutrients with the lowest NAR values were vitamin D (range 0.41–0.67/1.00) and vitamin E (range 0.60–
0.79/1.00 for 2008 and 2016). For iron, infants aged 6–11.9 mo had the lowest NAR values at 0.77–0.88/1.00, compared
to 0.85–0.89/1.00 for 12–47.9-mo-olds. Potassium was low from 12 to 47.9 mo (NAR range 0.55–0.63/1.00 across survey
years). The nutrients with the greatest decline in mean intakes were iron and vitamins D and E among 6–11.9-mo-olds,
and vitamin D and potassium among 12–23.9-mo-olds in 2016 compared to 2002.
Conclusions: The diets of US infants and young children were generally adequate for most micronutrients and stable
over time, but sodium intakes were too high, and nutrient gaps still existed, especially for vitamins D, E, and fiber across
ages and for iron among infants. J Nutr 2019;149:1230–1237.
Keywords: nutrient intake, Feeding Infants and Toddlers Study, infants, young children, nutrient adequacy ratio,
pediatric nutrition
Introduction with growth and development of infants and young children (9,
10). The project is being used in the preparation of the 2020–
The transition from breast milk and/or infant formula to a more
2025 Dietary Guidelines for Americans that will include specific
diverse diet is needed to meet infants’ changing nutritional and
B-24 recommendations for the first time (9).
developmental requirements (1, 2). This period is important
Over the last decade, there have been several important
for developing food preferences and eating behaviors that may
updates to feeding recommendations for young children, and
have lasting impacts on dietary patterns and later body weight
more will likely emerge with the 2020–2025 Dietary Guidelines.
status (3–5). Early exposure to a variety of foods, flavors, and
The American Academy of Pediatrics has issued 2 editions to its
textures leads to greater acceptance of foods comprising a
Pediatric Nutrition Handbook, encouraging offering new foods
diverse diet (4, 6, 7). Current feeding guidelines focus on what
multiple times (about 10 exposures) to promote acceptance
is consumed, when different foods are introduced, and how to
of new foods in 2009, and in 2014, focusing on diet quality
feed infants and toddlers to help them develop food preferences
and variety, and encouraging responsive feeding (1, 11). The
and eating patterns that are consistent with long-term health
Food and Nutrition Board of the National Academy of Sciences
(2, 8, 9). In the United States, work is currently under way
released new dietary reference values for calcium and vitamin
in the Birth to 24 mo (B-24) Project to gather and evaluate
D in 2011 (12), and the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics
the evidence base for feeding practices and their associations
Copyright
C American Society for Nutrition 2019. All rights reserved. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons
Attribution Non-Commercial License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/), which permits non-commercial re-use, distribution, and reproduction in any
medium, provided the original work is properly cited. For commercial re-use, please contact journals.permissions@oup.com
Manuscript received November 22, 2018. Initial review completed January 10, 2019. Revision accepted March 4, 2019.
1230 First published online May 9, 2019; doi: https://doi.org/10.1093/jn/nxz054.
published Nutritional Guidance for Healthy Children Ages attainment. Further details of the sampling and methodology are
2 to 11 Years in 2014 (13), identifying high intakes of sugar and available in methods publications from each FITS (27–29).
sodium as problems for children of these ages. Implementation A total of 9473 infants and young children were included in these
of these guidelines into nutrition recommendations may have analyses, 3235 from FITS 2016, 3276 from FITS 2008, and 2962 from
FITS 2002 (Supplemental Table 1). Because of the timing of recruitment
contributed to changes in nutrient intakes for infants and young
questionnaires and the subsequent 24-h recalls, 59 children from 2002
children.
were older than 24 mo by the time they had their dietary interview. We
Monitoring the dietary intakes of infants and young excluded them from our analysis because there were too few children
children is necessary to determine whether they are meeting in this age group to draw any conclusions.
recommendations (12), and to identify changes in nutrient Structured telephone interviews were conducted with the mother or
intakes over time. In the United States, the 2 largest population- primary caregiver of the selected child (1 child per household). Age-
based national surveys evaluating nutrient intakes in infants specific recruitment and feeding practices questionnaires were devel-
and young children are the NHANES (14–20) and the Feeding oped to assess household demographics, characteristics of the child,
Infants and Toddlers Study (FITS) (21–26). Until now, only feeding practices, and eating behaviors, with separate questionnaires
2 studies from these surveys have examined trends in nutri- for infants and young children aged <24 mo and for children aged
≥24 mo. After completion of the recruitment and feeding practices
ent intakes over time. The NHANES compared intakes of
the group had intakes at or close to the RDA/AI. Similarly, the MAR to 10.0 g/d among 12–23.9-mo-olds and 10.3–11.9 g/d among
is a summary measure that expresses the mean of all the NARs for 24–47.9-mo-olds across survey years.
different nutrients measured to provide insight into the adequacy of the Nutrient adequacy was assessed with use of the NAR for
diet as a whole. For the MAR in this study, a NAR was calculated for individual nutrients and the MAR as a summary measure to
17 vitamins and minerals from food and beverage sources only; not
assess the adequacy of the entire diet based on those same
including nutrients from dietary supplements if they were consumed by
micronutrients (Tables 2–5). For the most part, NARs for
the infant. All NARs were truncated at 1.00, and then the MAR was
calculated by summing the NARs and dividing by 17. Statistical analyses individual nutrients were >0.85. Mean vitamin D intakes were
were conducted with use of regression models with each nutrient as lower than the RDA/AI for many individuals and therefore they
a dependent variable and year as the independent variable, stratified had the lowest NAR values across survey years and across all
by age. ages (birth–47.9 mo), ranging from 0.41 to 0.67, with lowest
To evaluate the food groups consumed, we first classified the values among 24–47.9-mo-olds. Vitamin E was also below the
MAR values into tertiles by age. We then calculated the intakes (g/d) standard for a relatively large number of individuals, with NAR
for the following food group categories: milk and milk products, values ranging from 0.60 to 0.79 in the last 2 cycles of FITS, a
fruit, meats, and protein foods, grains and grain products, mixed significant decline from 2002 among infants aged 0–5.9 mo and
dishes, sweets/sweetened beverages/desserts, and vegetables. Data for
aged 6–11.9 mo. Another nutrient of concern was potassium,
the food groups are presented in radar plots by MAR tertile to
but intakes were low compared to the AI only among toddlers
visualize the impact of consumption of different food groups on diet
adequacy. and young children (12–47.9 mo), with NAR values ranging
from 0.55 to 0.63. For iron, infants aged 6–11.9 mo had the
lowest NAR values compared to other age groups (ranging from
0.77–0.88 for 6–11.9-mo-olds to 0.85–0.89 for 12–23.9-mo-
olds and 0.91–0.93 for 24–47.9-mo-olds over the survey years).
Results Overall, MAR values ranged from 0.88 to 0.94 across all age
Reported energy and macronutrient intakes were generally categories for FITS 2002, 2008, and 2016 indicating that the
stable across the FITS survey years (Table 1). Energy intakes diets of US infants and young children were generally adequate
increased with increasing age, but within age groups, there for most micronutrients.
were no significant differences in energy intakes across the We observed significant declines in mean intakes across FITS
survey years. The sole exception was for toddlers aged 12– survey years for many micronutrients among infants aged 6–
23.9 mo in 2002 whose intakes were slightly higher in energy 11.9 mo (overall P-trend < 0.0001) (Table 3). The largest
compared to the later survey years (overall P-trend = 0.0002). differences were seen for iron, and vitamins D and E, but
Carbohydrate intakes were also slightly higher among the 12– significant declines were also observed for vitamin C, thiamin,
23.9-mo-olds in 2002 compared to later survey years (overall riboflavin, niacin, magnesium, and phosphorus. Calcium was
P-trend = 0.0006). As with energy and macronutrients, intake the only nutrient in this age group that showed an increase
in grams of saturated fat, total sugars, added sugars, and over time. Among 12–23.9-mo-olds, mean intakes of vitamin
sodium increased with age. Significant decreases across survey D, potassium, and vitamin C were lower in 2016 (overall
years (overall P-trend < 0.0001) were observed for saturated P-trend < 0.0001) (Table 4). The only significant trends in mean
fat and for total sugars among 6–11.9-mo-olds and 12–23.9- intakes among 24–47.9-mo-olds were for vitamin E and vitamin
mo-olds (Table 1). Mean sodium intakes exceeded AI for K, both of which were higher in 2016 (Table 5).
all age categories (AI = 370 mg/d for 6–12 mo, and 1000 Lastly, we examined the intake (mean, g/d) of different
mg/d for 1–3 y). Dietary fiber significantly increased among food categories by tertile of MAR to obtain information
6–11.9-mo-olds and 12–23.9-mo-olds across the 3 FITS (overall about the food groups that contributed the most to intakes
P-trend < 0.0001). Although AIs have not been determined for of key nutrients (Figure 1). If intake of the food group rose
fiber in children aged <1 y, the mean intakes we observed for dramatically with the MAR tertile, it was considered that the
those aged ≥12 mo were well below the AI of 19 g/d established food group must have contributed to the adequacy of the
for 1–3-y-olds in the United States, with mean intakes from 8.0 diet. From this perspective, it is clear that milk and milk
products is the primary food group consumed by infants, and milk products (P < 0.0001). Increasing dietary adequacy
toddlers, and young children. Across all of the age groups, was also associated with increased fruit, vegetable, and grain
increasing dietary adequacy, measured by increasing MAR intakes across age groups, although those differences were
tertile, was associated with increased consumption of milk smaller in magnitude than milk (P < 0.0001). Higher MAR
TABLE 3 Comparison of nutrient intakes and nutrient adequacy for infants 6–11.9 mo from the Feeding Infants and Toddlers Studies
2002, 2008, and 20161
tertiles were also significantly associated with meat/protein of sweets/sweetened beverages/desserts and savory snacks
intake among toddlers and young children and with mixed were unaffected by diet adequacy, showing no association
dishes intakes among infants aged 6–11.9 mo and toddlers with the MAR tertile and presumably with micronutrient
aged 12–23.9 mo (P < 0.0001). In fact, only the categories adequacy.
TABLE 5 Comparison of nutrient intakes and nutrient adequacy for young children 24–47.9 mo from the Feeding Infants and
Toddlers Studies 2002, 2008, and 20161