Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Sofija E. Zagarins, PhD,1 Nancy A. Allen, PhD, ANP,2 Sandra S. Skinner, RN, MA,3
Andrew J. Kemper, MD,4 and Garry Welch, PhD1
Background: Although regular exercise is a significant predictor of weight loss and weight loss maintenance,
bariatric surgery patients are mostly sedentary/ low active presurgery, and up to 44% of these patients do not
Bariatric Nursing and Surgical Patient Care 2011.6:85-90.
engage in regular exercise at 1 year postsurgery. Furthermore, of all postsurgical behavioral recommendations,
exercise is the most likely area of nonadherence. The goal of this study was to evaluate adherence to a structured,
postsurgical exercise program and to explore the preliminary efficacy of this program on trends in exercise
frequency, duration, and intensity.
Methods: Data on exercise behaviors during group exercise sessions and at home were collected from all 46
patients participating in a 12-week, structured, postsurgical exercise program. Linear regression was used to
determine whether exercise behaviors changed over time.
Results: The frequency and duration of at-home exercise increased from 3.3 (1.9) times per week for 37.4 (18.3)
min/session at week 1 to 4.3 (1.7) times per week for 50.8 (23.3) min/session at week 12 ( p < 0.01 for increase in
both frequency and duration). The level of exercise intensity during the weekly group exercise classes increased
from 3.5 (0.9) METs (metabolic equivalents; equivalent to a moderate walking pace) at week 1 to 6.3 (2.9) METs
(equivalent to a very brisk walking/slow jogging pace) at week 12 ( p < 0.01).
Conclusions: The significant improvements in exercise behaviors observed during this group exercise program
suggest that such programs are feasible, and may be effective in helping bariatric surgery patients meet the
postsurgical exercise recommendations associated with improved weight loss and overall health.
1
Department of Behavioral Medicine Research, Baystate Medical Center, Springfield, Massachusetts.
2
Boston College, William F. Connell School of Nursing, Chestnut Hill, Massachusetts.
3
Department of Wellness and Integrative Medicine, North Shore Medical Center, Salem, Massachusetts.
4
North Cardiovascular Associates, North Shore Medical Center, Salem, Massachusetts.
85
86 ZAGARINS ET AL.
excellent target group to apply medically safe exercise strat- baseline exercise levels, and is used as a starting point for the
egies for weight loss and maintenance. first group exercise session. EPs then encourage patients to
Although research on physical activity and exercise in increase their exercise intensity, frequency, and duration over
bariatric surgery patients is limited, several recent studies the course of the 12-week program, as appropriate. The EPs
based on patient self-report suggest that weight loss is im- have found this to be a safe postsurgical strategy for these
proved at higher levels of physical activity.1,10–12 While pa- bariatric patients.
tients are typically advised by the surgical team at scheduled In addition to the weekly group exercise sessions, all pa-
Downloaded from online.liebertpub.com by Ucsf Library University of California San Francisco on 12/31/14. For personal use only.
follow-up visits to increase physical activity to improve tients are also encouraged to participate in regular exercise
postsurgical recovery and weight loss, a structured exercise outside of the program. Patients are encouraged to apply
program is not standard practice in weight loss surgery clinics what they learn about appropriate exercise type, intensity,
in the United States.13 To date, no research has been published and duration in the group classes to their at-home exercise
to determine whether such programs would be feasible or if program. This at-home program is largely focused on regular
they would be effective in increasing exercise behaviors in walking sessions, and patients are encouraged to use a pe-
postsurgical bariatric patients. dometer to track their progress.
program on trends in exercise frequency, duration, and in- bariatric surgery (i.e., laparoscopic adjustable gastric banding
tensity in both group exercise sessions and exercise completed [LAGB] or gastric bypass surgery [GBS]) between October 1,
at home (i.e., outside of the group sessions) over the course of 2009, and February 28, 2010. Patients began the CSWLP at
the 12-week program. different times. For the purposes of this analysis, patient data
were sorted by week in program rather than by calendar date;
Study setting and population therefore week 1 data represent each patient’s first day in the
program.
North Shore Medical Center (NSMC) in Salem, MA, pro-
Data collected at group exercise sessions included demo-
vides the only structured exercise program for bariatric sur-
graphic information, clinical information, and exercise-related
gery patients that we are aware of nationally. NSMC has
information. Data on exercise completed during the group
operated this unique postsurgical program since 1999, and
exercise sessions were collected by the EPs, and data on ex-
has an annual pool of approximately 200 patients referred by
ercise completed outside of the group sessions were self-
three bariatric surgeons. The exercise program is part of the
reported by patients in weekly exercise logs provided by the
Comprehensive Surgical Weight Loss Program (CSWLP),
EPs. Data collected during the group sessions included type of
which also includes nutrition and stress management com-
exercise, duration of each type of exercise, metabolic equiva-
ponents, and is run by a team comprised of bariatric surgeons,
lent (MET) level during exercise, and perceived exertion level
exercise physiologists (EP), dieticians, bariatric nurses, and
during exercise assessed using the Borg Scale. The Borg Scale
administrative staff. All bariatric surgery patients at NSMC
ranges from 6, representing no exertion at all, to 20, rep-
are required to sign up for the CSWLP. Program costs not
resenting maximal exertion.14 Self-reported data collected on
covered by insurance are paid by the patient.
exercise completed outside of the group sessions included
Patients begin attending CSWLP group exercise sessions at
number of exercise sessions per week, duration of exercise,
approximately 1–2 months postsurgery and participate in
type of exercise, and average Borg level during exercise. Data
these weekly 2-h sessions for 12 weeks, such that sessions
on exercise frequency, duration, METs, and Borg levels were
include both newly enrolled and ‘‘ongoing’’ participants. Ex-
summarized using means and standard deviations (SD).
ercise sessions begin with a group warm-up, followed by in-
Linear regression was used to determine whether these ex-
dividually tailored programs using cardio equipment (e.g.,
ercise variables changed over time.
treadmills, recumbent exercise bicycles, elliptical machines)
Pedometer use data were collected from patient exercise
during which patients are given an appropriate exercise goal
logs for the period from February 9, 2010, through March 23,
by the EPs (e.g., use the treadmill for 15 min at 3.5 mph on
2010. Among those using pedometers each week, means and
setting 5, then move to the recumbent bike for 20 min at set-
SDs were calculated for days per week of pedometer use and
ting 4). The cardio session is followed by a group weight-
pedometer steps per day. Linear regression was used to de-
lifting session led by an EP, which focuses on teaching
termine whether pedometer use changed over time.
patients about appropriate exercises for all the major muscle
groups. The session ends with stretching.
Results
All patients complete an exercise treadmill test (ETT) prior
to surgery, which the EPs use in tailoring a safe baseline ex- For the period from October 1, 2009, through February 28,
ercise prescription for each patient. This exercise prescription 2010, 59 patients had bariatric surgery at NSMC. Of these, 46
is based on the resting and maximal vital signs of pulse and (LAGB: n ¼ 15; GBS: n ¼ 31) attended at least one weekly
blood pressure, determined in the ETT, and includes a target CSWLP group exercise session by March 23, 2010. For the 46
heart rate and a target exertion level for each patient to patients included in this analysis, mean (SD) age at surgery
achieve at their first group exercise session. This exercise was 43.2 (12.2) years and 80.4% were female (Table 1). Mean
prescription is designed to educate patients about appropriate preoperative body mass index (BMI) was 44.7 (6.3) kg/m2,
BARIATRIC EXERCISE PROGRAM 87
Table 1. Selected Characteristics of Study All 46 patients also reported the frequency and duration of
Participants at Baseline (n ¼ 46) exercise completed outside of the group exercise sessions. At
week 1, patients exercised an average of 3.3 (1.9) times per
Mean (SD) Range
week for 37.4 (18.3) min/session, and this increased to 4.3 (1.7)
Age at surgery (years) 43.2 (12.2) 22.8–62.5 times per week for 50.8 (23.3) min/session at week 12
Preoperative BMI 44.7 (6.3) 33.6–59.1 ( p < 0.01 for increase in both frequency and duration; Fig. 2a).
Percent excess weight 49.0 (7.0) 33.0–61.3 Perceived level of exertion also increased steadily, from a Borg
Downloaded from online.liebertpub.com by Ucsf Library University of California San Francisco on 12/31/14. For personal use only.
prior to surgery level of 11.9 (1.4) at week 1 to 15.2 (1.7) by week 12 (r2 ¼ 0.21,
Female (n, %) 37 (80.4%) — p < 0.01; Fig. 2b). Mean pedometer steps per day increased
Type 2 diabetes at baseline (n, %) 11 (23.9%) — significantly across the 12-week program, from a low of 7,600
Hypertension at baseline (n, %) 20 (43.5%) — steps/day at week 3 to a high of 12,750 steps/day at week 11
Hyperlipidemia at baseline (n, %) 23 (50.0%) — (r2 ¼ 0.14, p < 0.01; Fig. 2c).
Type of surgery
Gastric bypass surgery (n, %) 31 (67.5%) — Discussion
Laparoscopic adjustable gastric 15 (32.5%) —
banding (n, %) This analysis of a structured, postoperative exercise pro-
gram for bariatric surgery patients showed that exercise be-
SD, standard deviation; BMI, body mass index. haviors improved significantly over the course of the 12-week
CSWLP. Specifically, the frequency, duration, and intensity of
which corresponded to a percent excess weight of 49.0% exercise increased, as did perceived exertion during exercise
(7.0%). Percent excess weight loss (%EWL) from surgery to the and pedometer steps per day. Enrollment among patients
Bariatric Nursing and Surgical Patient Care 2011.6:85-90.
first group session was 19.7% (8.3%). eligible for the CSWLP was high (78%) and the dropout rate
Of the 46 who began the program, six (13%) dropped out during our data collection period among patients who began
(defined as continued absence from group exercise sessions the program was low (13%), indicating good adherence to the
for 4 weeks), 13 completed the 12-week program, and 27 program. These results highlight the feasibility of a structured
were still enrolled in the program as of March 23, 2010 (Table exercise program following bariatric surgery.
2). For the 13 patients who completed the 12-week program, Although nonstructured physical activity has been shown
%EWL increased to 38.8% (12.0%) by the final group session. to improve postsurgical weight loss in bariatric surgery pa-
GBS patients (n ¼ 10) had a larger %EWL at 12 weeks com- tients,1,10–12 the CSWLP at NSMC is the only structured,
pared to LAGB patients (n ¼ 3), 43.0% and 24.9% respectively. postsurgical exercise program of its kind that we are aware of
Using the Kruskal–Wallis test, this difference was found to be nationally. While there was no comparison group for this
statistically significant ( p ¼ 0.03). analysis, the significant improvements in exercise behaviors
At the weekly group exercise class sessions, the average observed over the course of this program suggest that such
duration of exercise increased from 33.7 (8.8) min to 42.9 (7.4) programs may be effective in helping patients meet the ex-
min (r2 ¼ 0.08, p < 0.01; Fig. 1a). Level of exercise intensity ercise goals set forward in weight loss guidelines. The U.S.
increased from 3.5 (0.9) METs (equivalent to a moderate Department of Health and Human Services recommends 150
walking pace) at week 1 to 6.3 (2.9) METs (equivalent to a to 300 min of moderate, medically appropriate exercise per
very brisk walking/slow jogging pace) at week 12 (r2 ¼ 0.20, week for adults,15 a level achieved by all patients in the
p < 0.01; Fig. 1b), and perceived level of exertion measured present analysis. By comparison, our previous 2-year follow-
using the Borg Scale increased from level 12.0 (1.4) (defined up study of bariatric surgery patients found only that 51.4% of
as ‘‘fairly light’’ to ‘‘somewhat hard’’) at week 1 to level 14.3 patients self-reported exercising to this guideline.1
(1.7) (defined as ‘‘hard’’) at week 12 (r2 ¼ 0.14, p < 0.01; While we were unable to compare directly weight loss in
Fig. 1c). CSWLP participants to a control group, %EWL in CSWLP
Number of Type of surgery ¼ gastric Mean (SD) age Mean (SD) percent excess Mean (SD) percent excess
patients enrolled bypass (n, %) at surgery weight prior to surgery weight lost since surgery
a 55
30
25
20
0 2 4 6 8 10 12
Week in Program
b 10
Exercise Intensity (METs)
8
2
r = 0.20
6 p ≥ 0.01
4
Bariatric Nursing and Surgical Patient Care 2011.6:85-90.
0
0 2 4 6 8 10 12
Week in Program
c 17
Perceived Level of Exertion
16
2
r = 0.14
15 p ≥0.01
(Borg)
14
13
12
11
10
0 2 4 6 8 10 12
Week in Program
FIG. 1. Trends for exercise completed during group exercise sessions: (a) mean (SD) duration in minutes; (b) mean (SD) intensity,
calculated in metabolic equivalents; (c) mean (SD) perceived level of exertion, based on self-report using the Borg Scale (range from 6
[no exertion at all] to 20 [maximal exertion]). Based on 46 participants contributing week 1 data, of whom 6 dropped out and 13
completed the program before the end of the data collection period (November 1, 2009–March 23, 2010). SD, standard deviation.
participants was high relative to national averages. Nation- nario seems more likely given that improved exercise be-
ally, GBS patients lose an average of 25% to 40% of their excess haviors may encourage good nutritional choices and vice
weight by 3 to 6 months,16 while GBS patients in the CSWLP versa.17
lost an average of 43% of their excess weight by the end of the Data on exercise completed outside of the group sessions
program, which corresponds to 4 to 5 months postsurgery. were self-reported by patients, and as such may be less ac-
curate than data collected by the EPs during the group ses-
sions. However, patients were given weekly exercise
Limitations
logbooks to use for tracking their at-home exercise, and were
The current analysis is based on a comprehensive post- shown how to complete the logbooks by the EPs. In addition,
surgical program, which includes nutrition and stress man- trends in self-reported at-home exercise intensity and dura-
agement components. Thus it is possible that other aspects of tion were similar to those measured by the EPs during the
the program, and not just the exercise component, contributed group sessions, suggesting that patients were reporting the
to our positive results. Conversely, it is also possible that these information accurately.
nonexercise components of the CSWLP contributed to patient Despite the small sample size at week 12 (n ¼ 13), we were
dropout and/or reduced compliance. Of these, the first sce- able to observe significant trends in exercise behaviors over
BARIATRIC EXERCISE PROGRAM 89
6
r2 = 0.04
2
1
0
0 2 4 6 8 10 12
Week in Program
b 17
Perceived Level of Exertion
16 r2 = 0.21
p ≥ 0.01
15
(Borg)
14
Bariatric Nursing and Surgical Patient Care 2011.6:85-90.
13
12
11
10
0 2 4 6 8 10 12
Week in Program
c 17000
15000
r2 = 0.14
Steps per Day
13000 p ≥ 0.01
11000
9000
7000
5000
3000
0 2 4 6 8 10 12
Week in Program
FIG. 2. Trends for exercise completed during at-home exercise sessions: (a) mean (SD) frequency of at-home exercise
sessions per week; (b) mean (SD) perceived level of exertion, based on self-report using the Borg Scale (range from 6 [no
exertion at all] to 20 [maximal exertion]); (c) mean (SD) steps per day among patients using pedometers. Based on 46
participants contributing week 1 data, of whom 6 dropped out and 13 completed the program before the end of the data
collection period (November 1, 2009–March 23, 2010).
the 12-week period. However, it is possible that the 13 pa- exercise at one year post-surgery, and of all behavioral rec-
tients who completed the program during our data collection ommendations exercise is the most likely area of non-
period differed from general CSWLP patient population, and adherence.1,9 A recent study by Bond et al. of patients
that a larger sample would reveal a more accurate picture of successfully maintaining weight loss found that patients who
exercise trends. Repeating this analysis in a larger population lost weight via surgical methods reported less exercise and
would be useful in determining the extent to which the ob- dietary restraint than those who lost weight using non-surgical
served results will generalize to other populations. methods.18 This Bond et al. study supports our current findings
that morbidly obese patients can successfully improve exercise
behaviors, but also suggests that bariatric surgery patients may
Conclusion
focus on the surgical control of hunger and food intake to
Changing lifelong sedentary behavioral patterns is difficult achieve weight loss and may not be realizing their weight loss
and it is unknown whether the short-term exercise improve- potential due to their lack of behavioral changes. Thus, a
ments shown in this study will be maintained over time. Up to structured exercise program may be of great benefit in helping
44% of bariatric surgery patients do not engage in regular post-surgical patients achieve greater weight loss.
90 ZAGARINS ET AL.
There are many theories and models of behavior change, 7. King WC, Belle SH, Eid GM, et al. Physical activity levels of
such as Social Cognitive theory and Prochaska’s Trans- patients undergoing bariatric surgery in the longitudinal
theoretical Model,19,20 that have improved our understanding assessment of bariatric surgery study. Surg Obes Relat Dis
of how individuals change behaviors. However, we currently 2008;4:721–728.
lack behavioral, theory-based exercise interventions for bar- 8. Bond DS, Unick JL, Jakicic JM, et al. Objective assessment of
iatric surgery patients. In obese patients, effective behavioral time spent being sedentary in bariatric surgery candidates.
interventions have included self-monitoring, reducing eating Obes Surg 2010. [Epub ahead of print]; DOI: 10.1007/
Downloaded from online.liebertpub.com by Ucsf Library University of California San Francisco on 12/31/14. For personal use only.