You are on page 1of 7

Geotech Geol Eng (2016) 34:411–417

DOI 10.1007/s10706-015-9953-x

TECHNICAL NOTE

Strength Behavior of Clayey Soil Reinforced with Human


Hair as a Natural Fibre
Wajid Ali Butt . B. A. Mir . J. N. Jha

Received: 21 April 2015 / Accepted: 16 November 2015 / Published online: 19 November 2015
Ó Springer International Publishing Switzerland 2015

Abstract There are various ground improvement comparing the results with the non-reinforced soil.
techniques available, soil reinforcement technique has Fibres of average length 25 mm and average diameter
been successfully used in recent times to improve the of 50 lm were used. The test result revealed that the
shear parameters of the marginal/weak soils. Among strength significantly improves with the inclusion of
various reinforcing materials, human hair fiber (HHF) HHF and also prevents the sample from cracking.
can be used as a natural fiber to enhance the shear
strength and bearing capacity of a clayey soil for Keywords Waste material  Hair fibre 
sustainable use of waste material and sustainable Environmental pollution  Sustainable materials 
development of infrastructures in a rapid urbanization. Sustainable development
Human hair fiber is a natural non-degradable waste
material, which creates health and environmental
problem if not disposed-off in scientific manner. This
is available in abundance at a very low cost and can be 1 Introduction
easily used as a reinforcing material not only to
improve poor/unsuitable construction sites for sus- The geotechnical engineer has the challenge of
tainable construction but also to avoid its disposal construction of foundation at the sites which are
problems. Therefore, this paper presents some studies previously considered unsuitable and unacceptable.
on strength properties of clayey soil reinforced with Since the advent of the fibre reinforcing of concrete in
HHF. The HHF randomly distributed in clayey soil the 1940s a great deal of testing has been conducted on
samples were tested for its engineering properties by the various fibrous materials to determine the actual
performing CBR and tri-axial test on a number of characteristics and advantages for each product.
samples by using the different percentage of fibres and Among various reinforcing materials, human hair
fibre (HHF) can be used as a natural Fiber to enhance
the shear strength and bearing capacity of a clayey soil
W. A. Butt (&)  J. N. Jha for sustainable use of waste material and sustainable
Department of Civil Engineering, GNDEC Ludhiana,
Ludhiana, Punjab, India
development of infrastructures in a rapid urbanization.
e-mail: wajid2643@gmail.com; Many types of fibres were used and tested (asbestos,
wajid2643@yahoo.com steel, glass, synthetics etc.) for stabilization of
marginal soils. As natural fibres, horse hairs were
B. A. Mir
Department of Civil Engineering, National Institute of
used in motor and straw for mud bricks and many plant
Technology, Srinagar, J&K 190 006, India types like sisal, coir, bamboo, jute, rice husk, elephant

123
412 Geotech Geol Eng (2016) 34:411–417

gross etc., were also used. During current times, fiber on mechanical properties of fly ash based
human hair fibre is considered a waste material in most hollow block for masonry structures. Pillai and
parts of the world and its accumulation in waste Ramanathan (2012) describes the index properties
streams causes many environmental problems; how- of soil using human hairs. The biggest advantage
ever, it has many known uses in the form of randomly particularly with human hair fiber (HHF) is that it is
reinforced fibre in the present state of art and non-degradable, even though it may be categorized
technology. The exceptional properties of human hair as natural fiber. Most of the study reported till date
such as its unique chemical composition, slow degra- with natural fiber are either coconut/jute fiber, which
dation rate, high tensile strength, thermal insulation, are biodegradable in nature. From the literature is
elastic recovery, scaly surface, and unique interactions quite evident that very few study with HHFs has
with water and oils, has led to many diverse uses. been reported in the stabilization of soils as rein-
Recently soil reinforcement with short, discrete, forcement. Therefore, in the present study an attempt
randomly oriented fibres is getting more attention has been made to use HHF as reinforcement for the
from many researchers around the world. Extensive improvement of clayey soil. The objective of this
studies were carried out on the stabilization of soft research is to understand and investigate the varia-
clays and expansive clays using various additives tion of the strength of the cohesive soil randomly
such as lime, cement, synthetic and natural fibres. mixed with HHFs. The present study investigates the
Ranjan et al. (1994) conducted a series of triaxial suitability of solid waste material such as HHFs
tests to study the behavior of plastic fibre reinforced which has the potential to replace conventional
sand. Maher & Ho (1994) investigated the mechan- commercial fiber which are quite costly. Application
ical properties of a kaolinite/fibre composite in of HHF in stabilizing cohesive soil, if found effective
unconfined compression tests. Kaniraj and Gayathri may become an environmental friendly solution
(2003) conducted an experimental study to investi- for HHF which other wise is dumped near the place
gate the influence of randomly oriented fibre inclu- of generation and creates lot of clogging for water
sions on the geotechnical behavior of two Indian fly flow.
ashes. Maliakal and Thiyyakkandi (2012) studied the
influence of randomly distributed coir fibres on the
shear strength of clay. They concluded that shear 2 Materials Used and Experimental Program
strength improves significantly. Naeini and Sajadi
(2008) reported that waste polymer materials has 2.1 Soil
been chosen as reinforcement material and it was
randomly included into the clayey soils with differ- The soil used the present study is clayey in nature. All
ent plasticity indexes at five different percentages of the requisite physical and mechanical properties were
fibre content (0, 1, 2, 3, 4 %) by weight of raw soil determined as per relevant Standard tests (IS: 2720).
to enhance its engineering properties. The physical properties are given in Table 1.
Pradhan et al. (2012) examined the effect of
random inclusion of polypropylene fibers on strength 2.2 Human Hair Fibre
characteristics of a clayey soil of intermediate
plasticity. Estabragh et al. (2011) investigated the The HHF was gathered from local sources. The hair
effects of fibre on the consolidation and shear thread is a natural fibre formed by keratin, a protein
strength behavior of a clay soil reinforced with with a high grade of sulfur. The main physical
nylon fibres. The effective use of natural fibres as properties of the hair depend mostly on its geometry;
reinforcement was proved by several researches. Jha the physical and mechanical properties of hair involve
et al. (2014) studied the behavior of plastic waste characteristics to improve elasticity, smoothness,
fiber-reinforced industrial wastes in pavement appli- volume, shine and softness due to both the significant
cations. Akthar et al. (2008) studied the influence of adherence of the cuticle scales and the movement
Fly ash mixed with lime having varying percentage control as well as the easiness of combing, since they
of HHFs in California Bearing Ratio (CBR) values. reduce the fibres static electricity. The average com-
Akhtar and Ahmad (2009) studied the effect of hair position of normal hair is composed of 45.68 %

123
Geotech Geol Eng (2016) 34:411–417 413

Table 1 Properties of materials used


Properties of clayey soil Properties of human hair fibre

Clay content (%) 63 Cross-section Circular


Specific gravity 2.67 Diameter 50 lm
Liquid limit (%) 53.7 Length 25 mm
Plastic limit (%) 27.5 Linear density (gm/cc) 1.25–1.40
Plasticity Index (%) 26.2 Elongation 1.5 times its dry weight
Shrinkage limit (%) 12.7 Tensile strength About 400 Mpa
Classification CH Flexural strength (Mpa) 25–30
Maximum dry density (gm/cc) 1.72 Chemical reaction Depends on Hair surface porosity. About 80 % of human
hair is formed by a protein known as keratin
Optimum moisture content (%) 23.7
Compression Index, Cc 0.30 Absorption Depends on physical process of surface tension
CBR at OMC (%) 4.70 Friction Depends on the cuticle geometry and on the
physical–chemical status of the hair

carbon, 27.9 % oxygen, 6.6 % hydrogen, 15.72 % the samples were prepared at the OMC and 0.95 cmax
nitrogen and 5.03 % sulphur (Choudhry and Pandey (MDD) as per IS: 2720 (Part VII, 1980). For triaxial test
2012). After collecting HHF from local sources, fiber cylindrical specimen of size 38.1 mm in diameter and
of approximate same length was segregated manually 76.2 mm in lengths were used. For CBR, mould has
and the average length and diameter was kept as inner diameter 150 mm and height 175 mm for placing
25 mm and 50 lm, thus keeping aspect ratio (l/d) CBR test specimen. Fibres were mixed to the oven
constant having the value equal to 500. After cutting dried soil and extra care was taken during mixing of the
HHF into desired form (Fig. 1) it was mixed randomly soil sample so as to get uniform distribution of
with oven dried soil. Figure 2 illustrates the scanning HHF.CBR and UU triaxial tests were conducted on
electron microscopy images (Weia et al. 2004). The compacted HHF reinforced clayey samples having a
properties of these fibres are given in Table 1. curing period of 7 days, Strain rate of 1.25 mm per
minute was applied during the CBR. Undrained triaxial
2.3 Preparation of Samples and Laboratory Tests tests were conducted under different confining pres-
sures ranging from 0.5 kg/cm2 (50 kPa) to 2.0 kg/cm2
In this study, human hair fibres were used as an additive (200 kPa). For all percentages of HHF three samples
to the high compressibility clayey soil by weight (0.5, were tested to ensure the repeatability of the test results
1.0, 1.5, 2.0 and 2.5 %) to evaluate the effect of human and the results reported were the average value
hair fibre on the mechanical behavior of clayey soil. All obtained from three samples.

Fig. 1 Illustration of human hair fibre

123
414 Geotech Geol Eng (2016) 34:411–417

Fig. 2 Scanning electron microscopic images of human hair samples

3 Results and Discussion Resistance to penetration of a rigid plunger is


measured and the loads at penetrations of 2.5 and
3.1 Effect Human Hair Fibre on CBR 5.0 mm were expressed as percentage of two standard
and Undrained Shear Strength of Clayey Soil loads (1370 and 2055 kg). The higher percentage was
taken as the CBR value (which was 2.5 mm penetra-
Of all the available methods of design, the CBR tion). In the present study, an attempt was made to
method has been found the most practical means of conduct CBR tests on clayey soil reinforced with HHF.
evaluating the strength of the sub-grade (bearing Figure 3 show results of CBR tests for clayey soil
capacity of the soil) for estimating the required reinforced with human hair fibre. As seen from Fig. 4
thickness of pavement to satisfy a given loading.
10
400
HHF: 0% CBR variation @ 2.5mm
penetration
HHF: 0.5%
8
300 HHF: 1.0%
HHF: 1.5%
Load (Kg)

HHF: 2.0% 6
CBR (%)

200 HHF: 2.5%

100

0
0 5 10 15 0
Penetration (mm) 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5
Human hair fibre content (%)
Fig. 3 Penetration curves for CBR tests for clayey soil
reinforced with human hair fibre Fig. 4 Variation of CBR with addition of human hair fibre

123
Geotech Geol Eng (2016) 34:411–417 415

with HHF 0 % the CBR value was 4.70 % which was reinforced with HHF. As can be seen, the slope (M) of
increased to 7.75 % after addition of 2 % HHF. the critical state line (CSL) for composite specimens
Therefore it is quite evident of mixing HHF in the varies drastically with an average value of 1.28. The
marginal soil for construction of road pavements. As corresponding shearing strength parameter (/0 ) at

seen, about 2.0 % HHF is the optimum quantity to critical state corresponding to qf pf 0 of 1.28 is equal to
enhance the maximum CBR value at 2.5 mm pene- 32° and was calculated using the Eq. (1):
tration. When compared with other studies the results
3M
shows similar trends like other natural fibers. Sin /0 ¼ ð1Þ
The increase in CBR values due to addition of HFF 6þM
to clayey soil may be attributed due to improved Variation of stress ratio (M = q/p) with mean
interfacial adhesion between the soil particles and the stress and confining pressure for reinforced clayey
fibre, which allows a more efficient transfer of stress specimens is shown in Fig. 6. As can be seen, in
along the fibre matrix interface. However, the decrease Fig. 6 stress ratio shows more scatter in data with
in CBR values beyond optimum fibre content may be mean stress resulting in higher rate of loss of strength
due to the increase in fibre–fibre interaction. The fibre compared to confining pressure. Hence, under higher
may not be perfectly aligned with soil matrix leading mean stress, composite samples exhibit lower brit-
to poor dispersion of fibre in the soil matrix thus tleness compared to untreated clayey soil sample. It
resulted in a lower efficiency of load transfer with shows that soil is lightly to heavily over consolidated
increase in fibre content. Hence, up to some optimum resulting in medium stiff to stiff consistency. The
content, natural fibres, as a potential reinforcement undrained shear strength of clays or clayey soil is
ingredient offers many advantages such as good taken equal to qmax
2 . It is well known that the undrained
strength properties, low cost, high toughness, shear strength (Su) of normally consolidated (NC)
biodegradability. However, the overall performance clays normalised with respect to the current effective
of any fibre depends to a large extent upon the fibre– vertical stress is unique, and for over consolidated
matrix interface which in turn is governed by the (OC) clays, the following relationship adequately
surface topography of the fibre and by the chemical represents the normalised undrained shear strength
composition of fibre surface and resin properties. through (Eq. 2):
Figure 5 shows the variation of deviator stress (q)  
Su
with mean stress {p = (r1 ? 2r3)/3} for the ¼ a ðOCRÞm ð2Þ
undrained triaxial compression tests of clayey soil p0o OC

Fig. 5 Stress-path
behaviour of human hair
fibre reinforced clayey
specimens for undrained
conditions

123
416 Geotech Geol Eng (2016) 34:411–417

Fig. 6 Variation of stress


ratio (M = q/p) with mean
stress and confining pressure
for clayey specimens
reinforced with human hair
fibre (HHF)

where OCR is the overconsolidation ratio defined as under lower confining pressure up to 1 % HHF and
the ratio between the maximum past effective vertical beyond this value there is a marginal increase.
r0 However, higher confining pressures show steady
stress and the current effective vertical stress (¼ r0p ),
 vo
state improvement with maximum strength at 2 %
m is an empirical exponent equal to 1  jk , j, k are HHF. This indicated that compared to higher confining
soil model parameters obtained from laboratory test- pressures, lower confining pressure could not initiate
ing, and ‘‘a’’ is the normalised undrained shear interfacial adhesion between the soil particles and the
 
strength of NC clay = Spu0 for OCR = 1. fibre so effectively. When the confining pressure is
o NC
Figure 7 shows variation of undrained shear lower (50 kPa) the interfacial adhesion between the
strength (Su) with HHF at different confining pressures soil and the fiber is not so effective that the shear
for clayey specimens reinforced with human hair fibre strength is not improved significantly. With increase in
(HHF). As seen, there is no improvement in strength confining pressure the interfacial adhesion becomes

Fig. 7 Variation of
undrained shear strength
(Su) with confining pressure
for clayey specimens
reinforced with human hair
fibre (HHF)

123
Geotech Geol Eng (2016) 34:411–417 417

effective that leads to increase of shear strength Choudhry S, Pandey B (2012) Mechanical behaviour of
significantly. The strength and CBR both reduce when polypropylene and human hair fibres and polypropylene
reinforced polymeric composites. Int J Mech Ind Eng
HHF content is more then 2 % this may be because of (IJMIE) 2(1):121
too many fibers in soil matrix could lead to reduction Estabragh AR, Bordbar AT, Javadi AA (2011) Mechanical
of the interfacial adhesion between soil particles and behavior of a clay soil reinforced with nylon fibres. Geo-
fibers which may reduce strength and CBR value for tech Geol Eng 29:899–908
IS: 1498-(1970) Classification and identification of soils for
the reinforced soil. From the test results it reveals that general engineering purposes. Bureau of Indian Standards,
2 % is the optimum fiber content. New Delhi
IS: 2720-part 3(1) (1980) Method of test for soils: determination
of specific gravity of fine grained soils. Bureau of Indian
Standards, New Delhi
4 Conclusions IS: 2720-part 4 (1985) Method of test for soils: determination of
grain size distribution. Bureau of Indian Standards, New
Based on test results, it may be concluded that human Delhi
hair can be used as a natural reinforcing medium for IS: 2720-part 5 (1985) Determination of Atterberg limits.
Bureau of Indian Standards, New Delhi
stabilization of marginal soft clayey soils. HHF exhibits IS: 2720-part 7 (1980) Method of test for soils: determination of
many advantages such as good strength properties, low water content-dry density relation using light compaction.
cost and high toughness to biodegradability. However by Bureau of Indian Standards, New Delhi
increasing the HHF content, it marginally affects the dry IS: 2720-part 16 (1979) Method of test for soils: laboratory
determination of CBR. Bureau of Indian Standards, New
density-moisture content relationships of composite spec- Delhi
imens. MDD initially reduces lightly due to addition of IS: 2720-part 11 (1971). Method of test for soils: determination
light weight hair fiber and then practically remains same. of shear strength parameter by unconsolidated undrained
OMC increases marginally due to moisture absorption of triaxial compression without the measurement of pore
water pressure. Bureau of Indian Standards, New Delhi
hair fibres. It has been seen that about 2 % fibre content is Jha JN, Choudhary AK, Gill KS, Shukla SK (2014) Behaviour of
the optimum quantity to enhance CBR and undrained plastic waste fiber-reinforced industrial waste in pavement
shear strength of clayey soil. applications. Int J Geotech Eng 8(2014):277–286
Hence, using HHF as a reinforcing agent has a Kaniraj SR, Gayathri V (2003) Geotechnical behavior of fly ash
mixed with randomly oriented fibre inclusions. Geotext
twofold advantage. First, to avoid the tremendous Geomembr 21:123–149
environmental problems caused by dumping of human Maher MH, Ho YC (1994) Mechanical properties of kaolin-
hair waste in open fields and second, to help in ite/fibre soil composite. J Geotech Eng ASCE 120(8):
sustainable development of the various infrastructures 1381–1393
Maliakal T, Thiyyakkandi S (2012) Influence of randomly dis-
on marginal soils reinforced with HHF. This rein- tributed coir fibers on the shear strength of clay. Geotech
forcement may also be used in the field for embank- Geol Eng 31:425–433
ments especially for approach roads which connect the Naeini SA, Sadjadi SM (2008) Effect of waste polymer mate-
bridges to the road. It is also beneficial for the stability rials on shear strength of unsaturated clays. Electron J
Geotech Eng, vol 13, Bund. K
of slopes. If this reinforcement is used in the flexible Pillai RR, Ramanathan A (2012) An innovative technique of
pavements the sub-grade thickness decreases. improving the soil using human hair fibers. In: Third
international conference on construction in developing
countries, 4–6 July 2012, Bangkok, Thailand
Pradhan P, Karand K, Naik A (2012) Effect of randomly
References inclusion of polypropylene fibers on strength of cohesive
soil. Geotech Geol Eng 30:15–25
Akhtar JN, Ahmad S (2009) The effect of randomly oriented Ranjan G, Vasan RM, Charan HD (1994) Behaviour of plastic-
hair fiber on mechanical properties of fly ash based hollow fibre-reinforced sand. Geotext Geomembr 13:555–565
blocks for low height masonry structures. Asian J Civil Eng Weia G, Bhushana B, Torgersonb PM (2004) Nanomechanical
10(2):221–228 characterization of human hair using nanoindentation and
Akthar JN, Alam J, Ahmad S (2008) The influence of randomly SEM. Ultramicroscopy 105:248–266
oriented hair fibre and lime on the CBR value of Dadri fly
ash. Asian J of Civil Eng (Build Hous) 9(5):505–512

123

You might also like