Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Foreword ................................................................................................................................................................. 5
Introduction ............................................................................................................................................................. 6
Data Analysis ......................................................................................................................................................... 7
3. Age of Victims ........................................................................................................................................... 8
Graph.2 ............................................................................................................................................................... 8
2. Gender Comparison..................................................................................................................................... 9
3. Crime Categories .......................................................................................................................................... 9
Graph.3 ............................................................................................................................................................. 10
3.1. Rape and sodomy .................................................................................................................................... 10
3.3. Abduction and CSA ................................................................................................................................ 10
3.4. Murder after CSA: ............................................................................................................................. 10
4. Abuser Category ..................................................................................................................................... 11
5. Places of Abuse ........................................................................................................................................ 12
6.1 CSA in Closed Places (Within boundaries): ...................................................................................... 12
6.2 CSA in Open Places (Without boundaries) ......................................................................................... 13
6. Geographical Area of Crime .................................................................................................................. 13
7. Rural and Urban Divide ......................................................................................................................... 14
8. Case Status: .............................................................................................................................................. 14
Cases registered with the police fluctuate every year, as can be seen through the years 2007-2011. ... 14
9. Criteria for Child Friendly Newspaper Award ................................................................................... 14
10.1 Complete information ............................................................................................................................ 14
10.2 Total number of reported cases .............................................................................................................. 14
10.3 Reporting Ethics: .................................................................................................................................. 15
10. Cases reported by other organizations to Sahil ............................................................................... 15
11. Court Convictions ............................................................................................................................... 16
11.1 Court Conviction of CSA Cases by Sahil .............................................................................................. 16
11.2 Court Conviction of CSA Cases Reported in news papers .................................................................... 19
12. Conclusion ........................................................................................................................................... 21
13. Recommendations ............................................................................................................................... 21
References ........................................................................................................................................................ 22
Acknowledgement
We would like to extend our sincere thanks to all those who have contributed to make the
completion of this report possible.
Very special thanks to Sahil’s dedicated volunteers from Sindh, Punjab, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa
and Balochistan;, Mr. Meher Shaukat, Mr. Iqbal Sajid, Mr.Zaheer Abbas, Mr. Muhammad
Syed, Mr. Muhammad Syed Khan, Mr. Zaffar Ali Shah, Mr. Irfan Hussain Joya, Mr.Syed
Muhammad Ali Shah Bukhari, Mr. Amjad Ali Shah, Mr. Shahzad Khan Sabari, Mr. Assadullah
Shiekh and Mr. Manzoor Hussain Abco, for data collection of reported cases of CSA from
newspapers in their respective provinces during 2007-2011.
We are grateful to Rozan, LHRLA, WAR and FIA for sharing CSA cases directly reported to
them.
Foreword
s exual abuse has for long been neglected by various segments of our society where social
norms and cultural anecdotes have played an active role in suppressing these issues. These
practices have affected the response of law enforcing agencies towards these issues of
violence. There are many victimized segments in the society. However one segment that stands
helpless due to its dependence on elders, and has less or no access to resources, is children.
Child Sexual Abuse (CSA) is prevalent worldwide and is one of the menaces that are persistent in all
classes. In Pakistan, children less than 18 years of age are falling prey to CSA at the ratio of 6 children
per day. Sexual abuse is perceived as shameful and not to be discussed and hence hundreds of innocent
lives live with the shadow, memories and trauma of the assault. Several children surrender their lives
in the name of honor or absorb the pain for fear of losing a loving one, if the secret is revealed.
In the past, cases related to child sexual abuse were published in newspapers using humiliating words
that could create more harm than good to the victim. However, in recent years various advancements
in media and the steps taken by Social Organizations, National Commission for Child Welfare and
Development, and Press Council of Pakistan have succeeded in sensitizing the reporters on following a
code of ethics set for reporting a sexual abuse case.
Sahil working on child protection with a special focus on sexual abuse, has been publishing Cruel
Number reports for the last 15 years, which is based on data collected through monitoring online and
printed newspapers, direct calls received at Sahil for free counseling services, free legal aid and cases
shared by other organizations working on CSA.
The report has been helpful in identifying the target groups for awareness raising. Moreover it has also
been of a great help for other organizations to steer advocacy campaigns.
The current publication is a five year trend analysis of the reported CSA cases from 2007 to 2011. We
hope this report will benefit our stakeholders in particular and society in general.
Introduction
Sahil working against Child Sexual Abuse (CSA) was established in 1996. Today Sahil’s vision
is ‘Har Bacha Mehfooz – safe, secure and protected”.
In 2006, Sahil started its interventions nationwide through the extension of its services to the
four provinces of Pakistan. These interventions deal with the consequences of CSA, and work
for its prevention.
Sahil provides awareness through mass media, teacher training, research and publications.
The two services provided are free legal aid and free counseling for victims of CSA.
Over the 5 years Sahil has provided free legal aid through its legal aid officers and referral
lawyers to 463 victims of CSA and free counseling services to 344 survivors of CSA through in
person, telephonic and email counseling.
This report is a situational analysis of the trend of CSA cases reported in newspapers from
2007 to 2011.
Sahil has monitored on average 60 newspapers through the years 2007 -2011.
The purpose of this report is to bring forward the facts and figures regarding child sexual
abuse.
Although CSA cases are largely hidden, this is a reliable fact sheet to mobilize policy makers to
take measures for the prevention of CSA in Pakistan.
According to UNICIEF South Africa statistics from the South African Police Service more than 54,000 cases of crimes
against children were reported between 31 March 2011 and 1 April 2012 where Sexual offences make up about half the
reported figure and around 30 per cent of these victims are under 10 years old. Research has shown that in most abuse
cases, the offenders are known to the children (UNICEF, 2012).
In the United States of America 1 in four girls and 1 in 6 boys are sexually abused before the age of 18 and nearly 70%
of all reported cases (including assaults) are on children ages 17 and under (NCA, 2008)
According to humanitarian news and analysis which is a service of the UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian
Affairs in Sri Lanka it takes as long as six years to prosecute criminals who abuse children, and as many as 4,000 child
abuse cases are before the country’s 34 high courts (Wn.com, 2012)
Data Analysis
Reports of physical and sexual abuse of children are increasing. This reporting
reflects an increase in social awareness of the problem, the promulgation of
laws for the protection of children, and punishment of violence, and the
implementation of more accessible and efficient mechanisms for handling
complaints (ODNA, 2005).
3. Age of Victims
Graph.2
The trend clearly shows
that among all the age
groups, the number of
victims (2617) between the
age bracket of 11-15 years
are most vulnerable to
CSA.
Children belonging to the
age bracket of 6-10 years
are second on the list. A
90% increase can be seen
in the 1 -5 year category
over the 5 years.
Newspaper reports often
do not mention the age of
the victims. Missing age of
victims is 42% of the total of reported cases.
Girls are at a much higher risk of CSA as Graph.3
compared to boys in all age brackets.
3. Crime Categories
Table.1. Crime categories
Attempt of rape /sodomy were
recorded in the category of cases Crime Year Year Year Year Year Total
of molestation during 2007-2008. Categories 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
Molestation 289 194 0 0 0 483
This was then merged with the
crime category of attempt of AttemptRape
of 0 0 118 155 112 385
Graph.3
3.4. Murder after CSA: Crime Year Year Year Year Year Total
Categories 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
Although no case of sodomy Sodomy 38 0 33 29 61 161
/rape and murder was reported in Murder
2008, both categories have the Rape Murder 24 0 38 22 59 143
highest number of cases in the Gang Sodomy 20 20 28 21 10 99
other 4 years. Murder
Gang Rape 28 12 20 18 14 92
Gang rape/sodomy murder cases Murder
were the second highest in this Molestation 12 39 0 0 0 51
category. Murder
Attempt of 0 5 1 9 2 17
Sodomy
There can be many reasons for the Murder
child’s death after sexual abuse; Attempt of 0 0 4 3 3 10
some of them can be suffocation Rape Murder
.
and/or bleeding, Abusers may kill the
child to block disclosure of the crime
or to express their sexual frustration.
Table 4 Abuser Category
According to the findings of a research by UNICEF (2009), child sexual abuse among other
abuses is the least reported one, especially when committed by parents or close family
members. In the same study it is also stated that parents who have suffered violence in their
childhood, is the most relevant factor which leads to an intergenerational transmission of
violence.
Total 72
Cases directly reported to Sahil 34
Cases reported by WAR 272
2010
Total 343
Cases reported to Sahil 31
Cases Reported by Rozan 27
2011
In 2009, 2010 and 2011 CSA cases directly reported to organizations were recorded with the
name of the relevant organization.
Table 9 Cases reported directly to organizations in 2007 and 2008
During 2007 and 2008 cases directly reported to Male Female Total
organizations were recorded as total cases with gender 2007 21 19 40
divide. In the 5 years, a total of 1139 cases were reported
directly to organizations, 80 cases were directly reported 2008 19 21 40
to Sahil. Total 40 40 80
11. Court Convictions
Court
Crime Convictio
Category Total Gende Total Gende Total Gende Total Gende Tota Gende ns of
No. r of No. r of No. r of No. r of l r of Abusers
of Victim of Victim of Victim of Victim No. Victim
Case s Case s Case s Case s of s Minimum Fine
s s s s Cas to
es maximum
imprison
ment of
abusers
Abduction _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ 5 Years of Rs
& Sodomy Imprisonm 10,00
ent 0
Abduction _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ Life Rs
& Rape imprisonm 60,00
Murder ent – 0–
Sentence Rs
d to Death 150,0
00
Attempt of _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ Sentence Rs
Rape d to Death 150,0
Murder 00
Gang _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ 7 Years of Rs
Sodomy Imprisonm 40,00
Murder ent 0
Attempt of
Gang _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ 1 Male
Sodomy
11.2 Court Conviction of CSA Cases Reported in news papers
Table 10. Court conviction of CSA cases reported in newspapers with minimum to maximum sentence
Court Convictions of
Crime Abusers
Category Total Gender Total Gender Total Gender Total Gender Total Gender
No. of No. of No. of No. of No. of Minimum to Fine
of Victims of Victims of Victims of Victims of Victims maximum
Cases Cases Cases Cases Cases imprisonme
nt of
abusers
Gang _ _ _ _ 1 _ _ _ _ _ 7 Years of Rs
Sodomy Imprisonment 40,000
Murder
Attempt of
Gang _ _ 1 Male
Sodomy
The records of court convictions of CSA cases by Sahil and those reported in news papers
during 2007 to 2011, were dispensed more speedily as compared to the records of court
convictions mentioned in Cruel Number Analysis (2001-2006).
12. Conclusion
The issue of CSA is complicated due to social norms which perpetuate practices
Child sexual abuse occurs in all classes of the society
In a prominent number of cases, the abuser is an acquaintance and has the trust of
children and their families and they have access to the children in their homes
Children are sexually abused both in open and closed spaces
Children need to know strategies for self -protection
13. Recommendations
The following recommendations are proposed to make greater efforts against the incidence of this
heinous crime:
Policy makers should prepare policies to protect every child from sexual abuse
Laws and child protection bill must be passed to protect children from exploitation.
Media should increase reporting of these cases
Government should ensure the implementation of code of ethics regarding CSA case reporting
The police department should facilitate the process of registering the First Investigation Report (FIR)
for the victims of CSA
A course must be included in the curriculum, to equip the child with the knowledge of body safety.
Professionals at the frontline of working with the children, such as teachers, medical professionals,
school counselors, police personnel should be sensitized and trained to prevent, detect, and respond
to child sexual abuse.
There should be effective strategies to bring awareness to the general public about CSA
Communities should have awareness on CSA to be able to recognize the warning signs of sexual
abuse
There is a need to address the communication gaps between the masses and the stakeholders.
Rural and remote areas should be made more safe and secure by being provided civic amenities.
Enable children and young people to talk about abuse so that they have someone to turn to.
Support systems should be established for intervention and rehabilitation Establish local child
protection centers.
Youth should be encouraged to work against CSA
There is a dire need to focus on child protection in the areas of disaster emergencies
References
1. http://www.nationalchildrensalliance.org/index.php?s=17
2..http://article.wn.com/view/2012/09/25/SRI_LANKA_Child_abuse_cases_stalled
3. http://www.unicef.org/infobycountry/southafrica_62328.html http://www.unicef.org/lac/Boletin-
Desafios9-CEPAL-UNICEF_eng.pdf 2009
4. Pinheiro, Paulo Sérgio (2006), World Report on Violence Against Children, Geneva, United
Nations Study on Violence Against Children.
5. http://www.unicef.org/lac/Boletin-Desafios9-CEPAL-UNICEF_eng.pdf 2009
6. United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF2006), La violencia contra niños, niñas
yadolescentes. Informe de América Latina en el marco del Estudiomundial de las
7. NacionesUnidas, Regional Office for Latin America and the Caribbean,
8. Observatory for the Rights of Children and Adolescents (ODNA, 2006), Estado de los
derechos de la niñez y la adolescencia en el Ecuador 2005 (EDNA 2005), Quito
9. http://www.apa.org/pi/families/resources/child-sexual-abuse.aspx