You are on page 1of 9

TOPICS OF INTEREST

The History and Development of the Dental


Surveyor: Part II
Robert L. Engelmeier, DMD, MS

Part II of this series on the history and development of the dental surveyor reviews ways in which
the basic dental surveyor has been modified to improve its accuracy and versatility.
J Prosthodont 2002;11:122-130. Copyright © 2002 by The American College of Prosthodontists.

INDEX WORDS: surveyor, dental surveyor, paralleling instrument, clasp surveying instrument,
block-out instrument

P ART I of this article described the development


of modern dental surveyors. It presented illus-
trations of basic surveying instruments from the
Broken-Arm Surveyors
Of all the modifications that have been made to the
basic dental surveyor, perhaps the most significant
time of the first surveyor through the end of the
was the addition of a “broken,” or hinged, horizon-
20th century,1,2 along with paralleling instruments
tal arm. The broken arm not only facilitated sur-
that predated conventional dental surveyors and
veying, but also allowed the surveyor to function as
were used in early precision attachment tech-
a milling machine through the adaptation of a
niques. These early paralleling instruments dem-
straight handpiece to the surveying arm (Figs
onstrate the fundamental importance of paral-
2- 5).6,9-19
lelism in the fabrication of passive dental
restorations.3 In addition, Part I defined the basic
features of a dental surveyor and described its
common uses.4-6 Blockout Instruments
Part II reviews the ways in which the basic dental The dental surveyor has proven indispensable dur-
surveyor was redesigned and accessorized to im- ing the laboratory task of blocking out undercuts on
prove its accuracy and versatility. Improvements a master cast before fabrication of a removable
to the basic dental surveyor included the addition partial denture framework. Using a pendulum sur-
of a small light to better illuminate the cast and veyor was a novel approach to this process.9 This
surveying tools and multiple surveying arms to device had a surveying arm at least 3 feet long that
save time when changing surveying tools. Also could pivot at some predetermined point well above
added were easy-to-read dial undercut gauges, the cast holder (Fig 6).20 Hence the operator could
handpieces for accurately preparing guiding planes, move the surveying arm laterally, heat the attached
and electrical components to heat the blockout waxing instrument in an open flame, and then
waxing tools.7,8 Highly modified surveyors are illus- return the apparatus to the master cast. At this
trated in Figure 1. stage, the heated waxing instrument could be used
to shape and trim the blockout wax. Because the
angle of the blockout was inversely proportional to
From the Department of Prosthodontics, The University of Texas- the length of the surveying arm, the degree of
Houston Health Science Center Dental Branch, Houston, TX.
Accepted November 7, 2001. blockout could be controlled by adjusting the arm
Correspondence to: Robert L. Engelmeier, DMD, MS, Director, Grad- length. Some surveyors of this type allowed the
uate Prosthodontic Program, Department of Prosthodontics, The University arms to reach from the laboratory bench to the
of Texas-Houston Health Science Center Dental Branch, 6516 M.D. ceiling.9
Anderson Boulevard, PO Box 20068, Houston, TX 77225. E-mail: Electrically heated blockout instruments have
rengelme@mail.db.uth.tmc.edu.
Copyright © 2002 by The American College of Prosthodontists been in widespread use for more than 40 years.7,21
1059-941X/02/1102-0010$35.00/0 Examples of such dental surveyors are shown in
doi:10.1053/jpro.2002.124355 Figure 7.

122 Journal of Prosthodontics, Vol 11, No 2 ( June), 2002: pp 122-130


June 2002, Volume 11, Number 2 123

Figure 1. (A) The Retentoscope, a nicely made surveying instrument produced by the Saddle-Lock Company. A
rotating head supports 3 horizontal arms, 1 of which was a conventional surveying arm. A second arm supports a
handpiece for milling, and the third supports a dial undercut gauge. A work light is attached to the vertical arm. The
table, rather than the surveying arm, can be raised and lowered during surveying. (Reprinted with permission.7) (B) The
Stressograph, produced by the Ticonium Company, features 2 horizontal arm assemblies. The first arm is designed to
be a conventional surveying arm, and the second arm supports a dial gauge to measure undercuts. (Reprinted with
permission.8)

Figure 2. (A) This attachment to the original Ney surveyor essentially converts it into a broken-arm surveyor.
(Reprinted with permission.9) (B) Note the adjustable cast holder in this early broken-arm surveyor from England
(unknown manufacturer). (C) The Torit broken-arm dental surveyor.
Figure 3. (A) The Harvey surveyor, manufactured by the MD Chemical Company, Gardena, CA. (Courtesy of Dr.
Gene Stevenson.) (B) The Lentz broken-arm dental surveyor. (C) The Hagman Balancer surveyor, a broken-arm
attachment that cleverly converts the Hagman Balancer articulator (both the junior and senior models) into a dental
surveyor. (D) The Victor Stoll dental surveyor and coordinator (U.S. Patent 23,498), another dental articulator with a
surveying arm attachment. This ingenious and versatile instrument was designed in 1947.
Figure 4. (A) The Williams Gold Refining Company broken-arm surveyor, featuring the gimbal stage table, adjustable
to any tilt in any direction. The instrument has a spring-loaded surveying arm. A straight handpiece could easily be
clamped to the surveying arm. (Reprinted from McGivney et al.6) (B) The U.S. Patent Office drawing for a dental
surveyor designed by Ringle, Hiatt, and Smith in 1945. This was the first generation of surveyors marketed by the
Williams Gold Refining Company. The adjustable surveying stage is particularly interesting. (C) The Nesor broken-arm
dental surveyor. (Reprinted from Dates.17)

Figure 5. (A) The Ticonium Company currently offers this broken-arm dental surveyor with a spring-loaded surveying
arm. They previously offered the same surveyor with a one-piece horizontal arm. (Reprinted with permission.18) (B) The
Bego Paraflex surveyor has a solid horizontal arm and a “parameter” dial undercut depth gauge. (Reprinted with
permission.19)
Figure 6. (A) Austenal currently offers this blockout surveyor with a 42-inch-long surveying arm. (Reprinted with
permission.20) (B) The Austenal Surveyor includes an electrically heated waxing tool. (Reprinted with permission.20)

Figure 7. (A) The Austenal Micro Analyzer measures


undercuts electronically. A dial indicator shows the desired
amount of undercut, and a flashing light signals when the
exact undercut is reached. The Austenal Flexseal pre-
formed clasp patterns are used as a standard of measure-
ment. (Reprinted with permission.7) (B) The Paratherm
surveying and blockout waxing instrument heats its waxing
tools electrically. The surveying arms move in 3 axes.
Paratherm also offers the Paraline, a nonelectrical sur-
veyor based on the Paratherm design. (Reprinted with
permission.21)
June 2002, Volume 11, Number 2 127

Figure 8. (A) The Chayes milling machine, an early example of this class of instruments. (B) The Austenal precision
milling machine. (Reprinted with permission.20) (C) The Galloni Isoparallelometer with a cross-table, a finely made
precision milling machine. (Reprinted with permission.22) (D) The Kavo precision dental milling machine. (Courtesy of
Edgar N. Starcke, DDS.)
Figure 9. Some European precision dental milling instruments. (Reprinted with permission.22) (A) The Frey milling
and paralleling drilling machine from Seitz and Haag with a magnetic table. (B) The Bachman parallelometer
swingable/movable magnetic table. (C) The Fäh parallelometer with cross-table. (D) The Albrecht Linear Motor Milling
Machine with built-in motor and cross-table.
June 2002, Volume 11, Number 2 129

Figure 10. (A) A prototype surveyor made by Intra-Tek, Dallas, TX. A beam of laser light projects vertically downward
from the distal end of the horizontal arm to serve as the surveying arm. Although this instrument does not produce a
visible “survey line” at the height of contour of the teeth, it does dramatically expose undercut areas. (Courtesy of Dr.
Mark Connelly.) (B) The laser light is visible only above the height of the contour, whereas the undercut below the
height of the contour is cast in a dark shadow.

Milling Machines References


Other dental surveyors have been developed to 1. Nichols IG: Prosthetic Dentistry—An Encyclopedia of Full
function as milling machines or drill presses.9,10,22 and Partial Denture Prosthesis. St. Louis, MO, Mosby, 1930,
Developed for precision attachment applica- pp 587-590
tions, these instruments ensure the parallelism 2. Kennedy E: Partial Denture Construction. New York, NY,
Dental Items of Interest, 1928, p 232
of guiding planes milled into castings (Figs 8
3. Chayes HES: Movable–Removable Bridgework. New York,
and 9). NY, Chayes System Laboratories, 1922, pp 39-48
4. Van Blarcom CW (ed): The Glossary of Prosthodontic
Terms (ed 7). J Prosthet Dent 1999;81:39-110
Recent Innovations 5. Stuart KL, Rudd KD, Kuebker WA: Clinical Removable
Partial Prosthodontics (ed 2). St. Louis, MO, Ishiyaku
A recently designed surveyor dramatically exposes EuroAmerica, pp 164-167, 221-226
undercut areas by projecting a beam of laser light 6. McGivney GP, Castleberry DJ: McCracken’s Removable
(Fig 10). Partial Prosthodontics (ed 9). St. Louis, MO, Mosby, 1995,
pp 189-212
7. McCracken WL: Partial Denture Construction—Principles
Discussion and Technique. St. Louis, MO, Mosby, 1960, pp 76-78
8. Applegate OC: Essentials of Removable Partial Denture
A relatively recent development in dental instru- Prosthesis (ed 3) Philadelphia, PA, Saunders, 1965, pp 98-
mentation, dental surveyors have rapidly evolved 111
into user-friendly and accurate instruments. Some 9. Osborne J, Lammie GA: Partial Dentures (ed 2). Oxford,
UK, Blackwell Scientific, 1959, p 130
surveyors are relatively simple, while others are
10. Shaw FG, Scott DC: Practical Exercises in Dental Mechan-
highly sophisticated laboratory tools with very spe- ics. London, UK, Henry Kimpton, 1968, p 156
cific uses. 11. Rebossia AD: Protesis Pareial Removible. Buenos
Although the evolution of the dental surveyor Aires, Argentina, Impreso en la Argentina, 1955, pp
has slowed in recent years, clearly its place in 407-415
dentistry is assured. The basic process of surveying 12. McCall JO, Hugel IM: Movable-Removable Bridge-
the dental cast is by far the fastest and most accu- work. New York, NY, Dental Items of Interest, 1950, pp
203-214
rate method for identifying hard and soft tissue
13. Schwartz JR: Modern Methods of Tooth Replacement. New
undercuts and ensuring the parallelism of the axial York, NY, Dental Items of Interest, 1948, pp 637-649
surfaces of abutment teeth to be used as guiding 14. Hagman HC: Dental Origins. Minneapolis, MN, Harry C.
planes. Hagman, 1973, pp 114-115
130 History and Development of the Dental Surveyor—Part II ● Engelmeier

15. Stoll V: Dental Surveyor and Coordinator. U.S. Patent No. 19. Bego Product Catalog. Bego, Bremen, Germany, 1998,
23,498, May 20, 1952 p5
16. Ringle C.J, Hiatt GN, Smith RW: Dental Surveying Instru- 20. Austenal Product Catalog. Austenal, Inc, Chicago, IL, 1997,
ment. U.S. Patent No. 2,376,384, May 22, 1945 pp 44-46
17. Dates JF: Removable Partial Denture Construction (ed 2). 21. Dentarum Product Catalog, Dentarum, Inc, Newton, MA,
Bristol, UK, John Wright and Sons, 1978, pp 14-15 2000, pp 78-79
18. Ticonium Product Catalog, Ticonium, Division of CMP In- 22. Gaerny AA: Removable Closure of the Interdental Space
dustries, Charlotte, NC 1988. (CIS). Chicago, IL, Quintessence, 1972, pp 70-71

You might also like