Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Next: 3.2 Generalized Representation of Up: 3. The First Law Previous: 3. The
First Law Contents Index
Three examples of the first process are given in Figure 3.1. The first is the
pulling of a block on a rough horizontal surface by a force which moves through
some distance. Friction resists the pulling. After the force has moved through
the distance, it is removed. The block then has no kinetic energy and the same
potential energy it had when the force started to act. If we measured the
temperature of the block and the surface we would find that it was higher than
when we started. (High temperatures can be reached if the velocities of pulling
are high; this is the basis of inertia welding.) The work done to move the block
has been converted totally to heat.
The second example concerns the stirring of a viscous liquid. There is work
associated with the torque exerted on the shaft turning through an angle. When
the stirring stops, the fluid comes to rest and there is (again) no change in
kinetic or potential energy from the initial state. The fluid and the paddle wheels
will be found to be hotter than when we started, however.
All the examples in Figure 3.1 have 100% conversion of work into heat. This
100% conversion could go on without limit as long as work were supplied. Is
this true for the conversion of heat into work?
To answer the last question, we need to have some basis for judging whether
work is done in a given process. One way to do this is to ask whether we can
construct a way that the process could result in the raising of a weight in a
gravitational field. If so, we can say ``Work has been done.'' It may sometimes
be difficult to make the link between a complicated thermodynamic process and
the simple raising of a weight, but this is a rigorous test for the existence of
work.
during the expansion, heat must be supplied. Because the first law
takes the form . This is a process that has 100% conversion of heat
into work.
where 1 and 2 denote the two states at the beginning and end of the process.
The equation of state for an ideal gas is
with the number of moles of the gas contained in the chamber. Using the
equation of state, the expression for work can be written as
(3..1
)
(3..2)
The lowest pressure to which we can expand and still receive work from the
system is atmospheric pressure. Below this, we would have to do work on the
system to pull the piston out further. There is thus a bound on the amount of
work that can be obtained in the isothermal expansion; we cannot continue
indefinitely. For a power or propulsion system, however, we would like a source
of continuous power, in other words a device that would give power or
propulsion as long as fuel was added to it. To do this, we need a series of
processes where the system does not progress through a one-way transition
from an initial state to a different final state, but rather cycles back to the initial
state. What is looked for is in fact a thermodynamic cycle for the system.
The cycle returns to its initial state, so the overall energy change, , is zero.
The net work done by the system is related to the magnitudes of the heat
absorbed and the heat rejected by
The thermal efficiency of the cycle is the ratio of the work done to the heat
absorbed. (Efficiencies are often usefully portrayed as ``What you get'' versus
``What you pay for.'' Here what we get is work and what we pay for is heat, or
rather the fuel that generates the heat.) In terms of the heat absorbed and
rejected, the thermal efficiency is
(3..3)
The thermal efficiency can only be 100% (complete conversion of heat into
Next: 3.2 Generalized Representation of Up: 3. The First Law Previous: 3. The
First Law Contents Index
UnifiedTP
Thermodynamics and Propulsion
Next: 3.4 Refrigerators and Heat Up: 3. The First Law Previous: 3.2
Generalized Representation of Contents Index
Figure 3.4: Carnot cycle -- thermodynamic diagram on left and schematic of the
different stages in the cycle for a system composed of an ideal gas on the right
absorbed .
2. At state , the system is thermally insulated (removed from contact with
the heat reservoir) and then let expand to . During this expansion the
temperature decreases to . The heat exchanged during this part of
the cycle, )
3. At state the system is brought in contact with a heat reservoir at
(3..4)
The efficiency can now be written in terms of the volumes at the different states
as
(3..5)
The path from states to and from to are both adiabatic and reversible.
For a reversible adiabatic process we know that . Using the
ideal gas equation of state, we have . Along curve - ,
therefore, . Along the curve - , .
Thus,
Comparing the expression for thermal efficiency Eq. (3.4) with Eq. (3.5) shows
two consequences. First, the heats received and rejected are related to the
temperatures of the isothermal parts of the cycle by
(3..6)
(3..7)
The efficiency can be 100% only if the temperature at which the heat is rejected
is zero. The heat and work transfers to and from the system are shown
schematically in Figure 3.5.
Figure 3.5: Work and heat transfers in a Carnot cycle between two heat reservoirs
Muddy Points
apart the , isotherms are, the greater efficiency? And that if they were
very close, it would be very inefficient? (MP 3.2)
In the Carnot cycle, why are we only dealing with volume changes and not
pressure changes on the adiabats and isotherms? (MP 3.3)
Is there a physical application for the Carnot cycle? Can we design a Carnot
engine for a propulsion device? (MP 3.4)
How do we know which cycles to use as models for real processes? (MP 3.5)
Next: 3.4 Refrigerators and Heat Up: 3. The First Law Previous: 3.2
Generalized Representation of Contents Index
UnifiedTP
Thermodynamics and Propulsion
Next: 3.5 The Internal combustion Up: 3. The First Law Previous: 3.3 The Carnot
Cycle Contents Index
Subsections
o 3.4.0.1 Refrigerator Hardware
For a Carnot cycle we know the ratios of heat in to heat out when the cycle is
run forward and, since the cycle is reversible, these ratios are the same when
the cycle is run in reverse. The coefficient of performance is thus given in terms
of the absolute temperatures as
The Carnot cycles that have been drawn are based on ideal gas behavior. For
different working media, however, they will look different. We will see an
example when we discuss two-phase situations. What is the same whatever the
medium is the efficiency for all Carnot cycles operating between the same two
temperatures.
Starting in the upper right hand corner of the diagram, we describe the process
in more detail. First the refrigerant passes through a small turbine or through an
expansion valve. In these devices, work is done by the refrigerant so its internal
energy is lowered to a point where the temperature of the refrigerant is lower
than that of the air in the refrigerator. A heat exchanger is used to transfer
energy from the inside of the refrigerator to the cold refrigerant. This lowers the
internal energy of the inside and raises the internal energy of the refrigerant.
Then a pump or compressor is used to do work on the refrigerant, adding
additional energy to it and thus further raising its internal energy. Electrical
energy is used to drive the pump or compressor. The internal energy of the
refrigerant is raised to a point where its temperature is hotter than the
temperature of the surroundings. The refrigerant is then passed through a heat
exchanger (often coils at the back of the refrigerator) so that energy is
transferred from the refrigerant to the surroundings. As a result, the internal
energy of the refrigerant is reduced and the internal energy of the surroundings
is increased. It is at this point where the internal energy of the contents of the
refrigerator and the energy used to drive the compressor or pump are
transferred to the surroundings. The refrigerant then continues on to the turbine
or expansion valve, repeating the cycle.
Next: 3.5 The Internal combustion Up: 3. The First Law Previous: 3.3 The Carnot
Cycle Contents Index
UnifiedTP
Thermodynamics and Propulsion
Next: 3.6 Diesel Cycle Up: 3. The First Law Previous: 3.4 Refrigerators and
Heat Contents Index
Subsections
The Otto cycle is a set of processes used by spark ignition internal combustion
engines (2-stroke or 4-stroke cycles). These engines a) ingest a mixture of fuel
and air, b) compress it, c) cause it to react, thus effectively adding heat through
converting chemical energy into thermal energy, d) expand the combustion
products, and then e) eject the combustion products and replace them with a
new charge of fuel and air. The different processes are shown in Figure 3.8:
temperatures to .
7. Exhaust stroke, piston pushes remaining combustion products out of chamber
( ).
The actual cycle does not have the sharp transitions between the different
processes that the ideal cycle has, and might be as sketched in Figure 3.9.
The convention, as previously, is that heat exchange is positive if heat is flowing into
Substituting the expressions for the heat absorbed and rejected in the expression for
thermal efficiency yields
We can simplify the above expression using the fact that the processes from 1 to 2 and
from 3 to 4 are isentropic:
The ideal Otto cycle efficiency is shown as a function of the compression ratio
There is often a desire to increase this quantity, because it means a smaller engine for
the same power. The heat input is given by
where
is the heat of reaction, i.e. the chemical energy liberated per unit mass
of fuel,
so
Muddy Points
Next: 3.6 Diesel Cycle Up: 3. The First Law Previous: 3.4 Refrigerators and
Heat Contents Index
UnifiedTP
Thermodynamics and Propulsion
Next: 3.7 Brayton Cycle Up: 3. The First Law Previous: 3.5 The Internal
combustion Contents Index
sprayed into the cylinder at (high pressure) when the compression is complete,
and there is ignition without a spark. An idealized Diesel engine cycle is shown in
Figure 3.12.
Muddy Points
Explanation of the above comparison between Diesel and Otto. (MP 3.9)
Next: 3.7 Brayton Cycle Up: 3. The First Law Previous: 3.5 The Internal
combustion Contents Index
UnifiedTP
Thermodynamics and Propulsion
Next: 3.8 Muddiest points on Up: 3. The First Law Previous: 3.6 Diesel
Cycle Contents Index
Subsections
The Brayton cycle (or Joule cycle) represents the operation of a gas turbine
engine. The cycle consists of four processes, as shown in
Figure 3.13 alongside a sketch of an engine:
The components of a Brayton cycle device for jet propulsion are shown in
Figure 3.14. We will typically represent these components schematically, as in
Figure 3.15. In practice, real Brayton cycles take one of two forms.
Figure 3.16(a) shows an ``open'' cycle, where the working fluid enters and then
exits the device. This is the way a jet propulsion cycle works.
Figure 3.16(b)shows the alternative, a closed cycle, which recirculates the
working fluid. Closed cycles are used, for example, in space power generation.
Figure 3.14: Schematics of typical military gas turbine engines. Top: turbojet with
afterburning, bottom: GE F404 low bypass ratio turbofan with afterburning (Hill and Peterson,
1992).
Figure 3.15: Thermodynamic model of gas turbine engine cycle for power generation
operation]
Figure 3.16: Options for operating Brayton cycle gas turbine engines
Muddy Points
Would it be practical to run a Brayton cycle in reverse and use it as refrigerator?
(MP 3.10)
The objective now is to find the work done, the heat absorbed, and the thermal
efficiency of the cycle. Tracing the path shown around the cycle from - - -
and back to , the first law gives (writing the equation in terms of a unit
mass),
Here is zero because is a function of state, and any cycle returns the system to
its starting state3.2. The net work done is therefore
For a constant pressure, quasi-static process the heat exchange per unit mass
is
We can see this by writing the first law in terms of enthalpy (see Section 2.3.4)
(3..8
)
(3..9)
Figure 3.17 shows pressures and temperatures through a gas turbine engine
(the PW4000, which powers the 747 and the 767).
Figure 3.18: Gas turbine engine pressure ratio trends (Jane’s Aeroengines, 1998)
Figure 3.19: Trend of Brayton cycle thermal efficiency with compressor pressure ratio
Equation (3.10) says that for a high cycle efficiency, the pressure ratio of the
cycle should be increased. This trend is plotted in Figure 3.19.
Figure 3.18 shows the history of aircraft engine pressure ratio versus entry into
service, and it can be seen that there has been a large increase in cycle
pressure ratio. The thermodynamic concepts apply to the behavior of real
aerospace devices!
Muddy Points
When flow is accelerated in a nozzle, doesn't that reduce the internal energy of
the flow and therefore the enthalpy? (MP 3.11)
Why is the Brayton cycle less efficient than the Carnot cycle? (MP 3.13)
If the gas undergoes constant pressure cooling in the exhaust outside the
engine, is that still within the system boundary? (MP 3.14)
Does it matter what labels we put on the corners of the cycle or not? (MP 3.15)
Is the work done in the compressor always equal to the work done in the turbine
plus work out (for a Brayton cyle)? (MP 3.16)
The turbine entry temperature, , is fixed by materials technology and cost. (If the
temperature is too high, the blades fail.) Figures 3.20 and 3.21 show the progression of
the turbine entry temperatures in aeroengines. Figure 3.20 is from Rolls Royce and
Figure 3.21 is from Pratt & Whitney. Note the relation between the gas temperature
coming into the turbine blades and the blade melting temperature.
Figure 3.20: Rolls-Royce high temperature technology
For a given level of turbine technology (in other words given maximum
temperature) a design question is what should the compressor be? What
criterion should be used to decide this? Maximum thermal efficiency? Maximum
work? We examine this issue below.
Figure 3.22: Efficiency and work of two Brayton cycle engines
The problem is posed in Figure 3.22, which shows two Brayton cycles. For
maximum efficiency we would like as high as possible. This means that the
compressor exit temperature approaches the turbine entry temperature. The net
work will be less than the heat received; as the heat received
approaches zero and so does the net work.
approach zero as .
The conclusion from either of these arguments is that a cycle designed for
maximum thermal efficiency is not very useful in that the work (power) we get
out of it is zero.
A more useful criterion is that of maximum work per unit mass (maximum power
per unit mass flow). This leads to compact propulsion devices. The work per
unit mass is given by:
The first and the fourth terms on the right hand side of the above equation are
both zero (the turbine entry temperature is fixed, as is the atmospheric
temperature). The maximum work occurs where the derivative of work with
respect to is zero:
(3..11)
Hence,
Plugging this expression for the derivative into Eq. (3.11) gives the compressor
To find the power the engine can produce, we need to multiply the work per unit
mass by the mass flow rate:
(3..12
)
The trend of work output vs. compressor pressure ratio, for different
ratios
[Gas turbine engine core] [Core power vs. turbine
entry temperature]
Figure 3.24 shows the expression for power of an ideal cycle compared with
data from actual jet engines. Figure 3.24(a) shows the gas turbine engine layout
including the core (compressor, burner, and turbine). Figure 3.24(b) shows the
core power for a number of different engines as a function of the turbine rotor
entry temperature. The equation in the figure for horsepower (HP) is the same
as that which we just derived, except for the conversion factors. The analysis
not only shows the qualitative trend very well but captures much of the
quantitative behavior too.
A final comment (for this section) on Brayton cycles concerns the value of the
thermal efficiency. The Brayton cycle thermal efficiency contains the ratio of the
compressor exit temperature to atmospheric temperature, so that the ratio is not
based on the highest temperature in the cycle, as the Carnot efficiency is. For a
given maximum cycle temperature, the Brayton cycle is therefore less efficient
than a Carnot cycle.
Muddy Points
You said that for a gas turbine engine modeled as a Brayton cycle the work
Figure 3.25: Ideal ramjet [J. L. Kerrebrock, Aircraft Engines and Gas Turbines]
In the ramjet there are ``no moving parts.'' The processes that occur in this
propulsion device are:
in Mach number, .
: Constant pressure combustion.
: Isentropic expansion through the nozzle.
and
so
Muddy Points
Why don't we like the numbers 1 and 2 for the stations? Why do we go 0-3?
(MP 3.20)
Next: 3.8 Muddiest points on Up: 3. The First Law Previous: 3.6 Diesel
Cycle Contents Index
UnifiedTP