Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Buckthorpe2019 PDF
Buckthorpe2019 PDF
MATTHEW BUCKTHORPE, PhD1 • FRANCESCO DELLA VILLA, MD1 • STEFANO DELLA VILLA, MD1 • GIULIO SERGIO ROI, MD1
I
Downloaded from www.jospt.org by La Trobe University on 07/20/19. For personal use only.
n part 1,6 we described 4 pillars underpinning high-quality tion during the transition back
on-field rehabilitation: (1) restoring movement quality, (2) to sport.
physical conditioning, (3) restoring sport-specific skills, SUPPLEMENTAL On-field rehabilitation repre-
VIDEO ONLINE sents the period when the player
and (4) progressively developing chronic training load. In
is transitioning from gym-based
part 2, we describe how these pillars contribute to a 5-stage rehabilitation to the competi-
on-field rehabilitation program to help injured players transition tive team environment.6,7,9 Overall, the
to team practice and match play. We explain this program using an transition process can be considered a
example case of a soccer player with ambi- stand (1) where on-field rehabilitation continuum (FIGURE 1) of on-field reha-
tions to return to sport (RTS) after anteri- fits within the overall recovery process, bilitation, safe resumption of full-team
or cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction. and (2) whether the player has sufficient training, and gradual reintroduction
fitness to RTS practice. A prospective to full competitive match play.7 Players
How Does On-field Rehabilitation study found that 4% of elite-level soccer on European Champions League teams
Fit With RTS? players with ACL reconstruction sus- returned to practice at 202 days after
When planning high-quality on-field tain a graft rupture prior to their first ACL reconstruction, on average. Play-
J Orthop Sports Phys Ther
rehabilitation, it is necessary to under- match,16 highlighting the need for cau- ers returned to competitive match play
at 225 days,16 leaving only 23 days be-
UUSYNOPSIS: This paper is part 2 of a 2-part The program moves through 5 field-based training tween finishing rehabilitation and play-
series aimed at discussing the key elements of stages: (1) linear movement, (2) multidirectional ing a match to prepare for high-level
on-field rehabilitation training. In part 1, we de- movement, (3) soccer-specific technical skills, (4) competition. Twenty-three days is un-
scribed 4 pillars underpinning high-quality on-field soccer-specific movement, and (5) practice simu- likely to be long enough to adequately
rehabilitation: (1) restoring movement quality, (2) lation. The staged program is research based and prepare a player physically, technically,
physical conditioning, (3) restoring sport-specific facilitates communication, planning, control, and
skills, and (4) progressively developing chronic tactically, and psychologically for com-
safety in return to sport following long-term injury.
training load. In part 2, we describe how the pillars petitive match play after 202 days away
J Orthop Sports Phys Ther 2019;49(8):570-575.
contribute to a 5-stage on-field rehabilitation
Epub xxx. doi:10.2519/jospt.2019.8952 from the soccer pitch. This might be one
program to help injured players transition to team of the reasons why 4% of players suffer
practice and match play. We use the example of UUKEY WORDS: criterion-based rehabilitation,
ACL graft rupture before the first match,
a soccer player with ambitions to return to sport on-field rehabilitation, performance rehabilitation,
after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. reconditioning, return to sport and 3% soon after the return-to-play pe-
riod (less than 3 months).16
1
Isokinetic Medical Group, Education and Research Department, FIFA Medical Centre of Excellence, Bologna, Italy. The authors certify that they have no affiliations with or
financial involvement in any organization or entity with a direct financial interest in the subject matter or materials discussed in the article. Address correspondence to Dr
Matthew Buckthorpe, Isokinetic Medical Group, 11 Harley Street, London W1G 9PF UK. E-mail: M.Buckthorpe@isokinetic.com t Copyright ©2019 Journal of Orthopaedic &
Sports Physical Therapy®
We suggest the player meet the follow- sessions in a period of time) of training,5 ing sport-specific demands.
ing criteria prior to commencing on-field based on the player’s capacities and needs.
rehabilitation following ACL reconstruc- We recommend the rehabilitation
tion: (1) no knee pain or swelling,9 (2) no clinician use a global positioning system
subjective knee instability,9 (3) negative (GPS), which can provide a valid mea-
knee laxity tests,3,9 (4) a minimum of 80% sure of external workload,8 to quantify
limb symmetry during isokinetic assess- on-field rehabilitation training load. For Rehabilitation Performance
ment of knee flexor and extensor strength soccer players, we monitor 7 metrics,
(100% limb symmetry before discharge which provide a relatively simple but
from on-field rehabilitation),9 (5) good complete and reliable picture of the
movement quality (ideally, assessed workload demands of soccer (TABLE 2):
qualitatively with video analysis) in ba- total distance walked/run in a session, Rehabilitation phases OFR RTT RTC RTP
sic foundation movement exercises,3 and peak running speed, high-speed running
FIGURE 1. A RTS process involving a gradual transition
(6) ability to run aerobically (ie, without distance (at speeds greater than 19.8
from rehabilitation to performance training and a
blood lactate accumulation) for greater km/h), sprint distance (at speeds great- continuum of OFR, RTT, RTC, and RTP. Abbreviations:
than 10 minutes at 8 km/h with suffi- er than 25 km/h), total acceleration dis- OFR, on-field rehabilitation; RTC, return to competitive
J Orthop Sports Phys Ther
ciently normalized running mechanics tance, total deceleration distance (with match play; RTP, return to performance; RTS, return to
(ideally, assessed qualitatively with video acceleration/deceleration greater than sport; RTT, return to training. Modified with permission
from Buckthorpe et al.7
analysis).9 ±3 m/s2), and time in the aerobic and
Gym-based (indoor) OFR OFR OFR OFR OFR Return to training with
rehabilitation stage 1 stage 2 stage 3 stage 4 stage 5 the team
FIGURE 2. Timeline following anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. On-field rehabilitation fits between indoor rehabilitation and return to training with the team and is
subdivided into 5 stages. During OFR, indoor training can continue. Pain greater than 2/10 on an NRS, an increase in swelling, and/or unsatisfactory progression should trigger
regression to the previous stage. Abbreviations: NRS, numeric rating scale; OFR, on-field rehabilitation.
Five Stages of On-field Rehabilitation, With the Overall Focus for Each
TABLE 1
Stage, the Type of Activity, and Specific Examples of Content
Movement • Linear running (forward • Increased speeds of move- • Maximum-speed • Continued preplanned • Soccer-specific movement
and lateral) ments from stage 1 preplanned linear and and reactive movement training: soccer-specific
• Foundation movement • Multidirectional multidirectional movement training: high-speed mul- plus speed and agility
tasks (eg, squatting, lung- preplanned coordination drills (change-of-direction tidirectional preplanned training in preplanned and
ing, athletic walks) drills (eg, cutting drills at drills, peak running speed and reactive movements, reactive tasks, with and
• Deceleration tasks in increasing angles, curved exposure, ladder drills) movement in soccer- without fatigue
preplanned situations of running drills, figure-of- • Reactive movement specific situations, closed
differing velocities eight drills, accelerations, retraining: high-speed mul- soccer-specific fitness
• Mobility drills decelerations) tidirectional preplanned drills (eg, stage 3 soccer
speed, acceleration, and movement drills for con-
deceleration training ditioning), repeated sprint
(closed tasks) and running
movement practice • Reactive movement train-
under external focus with ing with perturbations (eg,
technical-based drills ropes; Swiss ball; agility
circuit with ropes, Swiss
balls, player contact)
• Technical drills with pres-
sure, contact to force the
player off balance
Table continues on page 4.
tackling)
Loading (see • Introduction to outfield • Develop total running • Exposure to sprint running • Approach training intensity • Mimic the physical loading
TABLE 2) activity: exposure to run- distances thresholds demands of team training
ning volume (3-4 km) • Exposure to high-speed • Develop volume in all areas • Develop chronic loading
linear accelerations,
decelerations, and running
speeds
Abbreviations: AT, anaerobic threshold; LSI, limb symmetry index; ROM, range of motion.
ics or hesitation. Once the player can do tioning (linear running only), using ef- “reactive movements.” Technical training
this, he or she can commence soccer- fective work-to-rest ratios to specifically involves practice of preplanned soccer-
specific practice, with focus on move- target energy system development, is specific drills (eg, control the ball and
ment coaching/coordination training, also appropriate. Simple soccer drills pass to the player on your right), with
and progress to preplanned multidirec- can be practiced during controlled tasks no pressure from other players. Techni-
tional movements of increasing speed (eg, straight-line dribbling, controlled cal elements can be progressively added
and complexity.2,15,17 volleying, simple passing drills). Linear to linear and multidirectional movement
J Orthop Sports Phys Ther
Movements practiced in stage 1 can movement drills can be performed with tasks practiced in stage 2 to add speci-
be performed at higher speeds (eg, high- a task goal (eg, forward and backward ficity (eg, external focus of attention
speed linear running, accelerations, and running with a controlled volley/pass with greater neurocognitive demands).
decelerations). Then, the player can exercise) (TABLE 1, ONLINE VIDEO 2). Reactive-movement training involves
progress through increasingly more Transition to stage 3 is criterion based performing movements such as cutting
complex change-of-direction drills, (TABLE 2) to ensure the player is well-pre- while reacting to an external stimulus
gradually reducing task constraints and pared for soccer-specific training (eg, (eg, running forward and changing di-
progressively increasing the intensity technical training, soccer-specific move- rection at the cone, either right or left,
of accelerations and decelerations (eg, ment drills). depending on how the player reacts to
progress from 2 m/s2 to 3.5 m/s2). The Stage 3: Soccer-Specific Technical the cue presented immediately before
GPS can confirm when the player is able Skills The aim of stage 3 is to complete the required task).
to complete the metrics of these tasks the technical soccer program and train Reactive movements can challenge
at the desired movement intensity (eg, “agility” (movement with reactive deci- biomechanics and increase knee loads
achieve near peak decelerations and the sion making).13 more than planned movements.2 Thus,
planned volume of accelerations and de- The player commences more intense delaying reactive movement training
celerations in excess of ±2 m/s2). Linear soccer-specific practice. In stage 3, the until the player has achieved safe biome-
running speed can increase (eg, greater focus is on progression through a soccer- chanics in preplanned tasks and restor-
than 25 km/h); cardiovascular condi- specific technical program and training ing and confirming safe biomechanics
Abbreviations: ACL, anterior cruciate ligament; HR, heart rate; HSR, high-speed running; RTS, loading demands of the sport.
return to sport.
Stage 5 aims to bridge the gap be-
*Seven key metrics are adopted, with progression through stages based on achieving the desired inten-
sity and quality of work, alongside other rehabilitation criteria (eg, movement quality, psychological tween on-field rehabilitation and unre-
readiness, strength and power, no pain or swelling). stricted team practice. During this stage,
†
Defined as 20 to 25 km/h.
the player can participate in modified
‡
Defined as greater than 25 km/h.
§
Defined as greater than ±3 m/s2. team practice (eg, join in the warm-up
and technical skills sessions), where un-
injured players are enlisted to replicate
in reactive movements prior to RTS are practice intensity (eg, 85%-90%), includ- the soccer practice environment (eg, have
crucial aspects of this stage of the on-field ing 1-versus-1 drills under match-type an uninjured goalkeeper help with shoot-
rehabilitation process. scenarios (eg, a goal) and controlled con- ing practice; 1 or 2 players for possession
Physical therapists should train tech- tact practice (eg, light contact for confi- or drill activities, such as crossing and/
nical drills and reactive movements dence, perturbation training in 1-versus-1 or finishing). Emphasize group-based
separately, prior to progressing to skills situations). technical and tactical drills, including
training. Skills training involves perform- Training neuromuscular control in possession drills in 1-versus-1 and 2-ver-
ing soccer-specific drills, either under soccer-specific movements and during sus-2 situations.
J Orthop Sports Phys Ther
pressure from an opponent or during skill-based training sessions helps the Monitor load progression (intensity
open tasks (involving greater choices and player prepare for safe participation in and volume) using a GPS (or other load-
environmental stimuli), and typically re- soccer. To do this, a program of progres- monitoring system) to ensure the correct
quires reactive movements, quick deci- sive sport-specific movements must be stimulus for adaptation and develop-
sion making, and less control. created to support the transfer of move- ment of chronic training load (TABLE 2).12
In stage 3, physical therapists should ment patterns into sport-specific scenari- The player’s key load metrics must be
progressively increase training load and os. This includes a gradual progression to achieved during soccer-specific activ-
cardiovascular conditioning of the athlete more challenging tasks at higher speeds ity (eg, soccer fitness drills, possession
on the field to develop the player’s physi- and with more challenging visuomotor scenarios, skills practice) and not during
cal fitness, limit/avoid fatigue during requirements (eg, a greater number of supplementary activity (eg, end-of-ses-
complex movement tasks, and improve choices),15 so the player must progres- sion runs). The exception may be high-
performance and avoid poor biomechan- sively become able to safely execute high- intensity/sprint running, which may be
ics.4,6,10 Movements trained in stage 2 may speed multidirectional movement drills difficult to achieve in some types of soc-
now be performed at maximal speed to while fatigued. cer practice (eg, small-sided games) and
develop anaerobic performances (eg, Physical therapists should use soccer- may require additional high-intensity/
speed training) (TABLE 1, ONLINE VIDEO 3). specific fitness drills to train technique sprint sessions. The player must perform
Stage 4: Soccer-Specific Movements The development, with simultaneous car- at a minimum of 90% of the required
aim of stage 4 is to progress toward team diovascular conditioning. Soccer fitness practice intensity and complete at least
@
may help rehabilitation clinicians and Sports Med. 2013;43:1025-1042. https://doi.
org/10.1007/s40279-013-0069-2
MORE INFORMATION
players communicate, plan, and execute
WWW.JOSPT.ORG
a safe RTS. t 9. D
ella Villa S, Boldrini L, Ricci M, et al. Clinical