You are on page 1of 6

Patient Education and Counseling 68 (2007) 23–28

www.elsevier.com/locate/pateducou

Educating and counseling of parents of children with


attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder
Ahmad Ghanizadeh *
Division of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, Department of Psychiatry, Hafez Hospital, Shiraz University of Medical Sciences, Iran
Received 15 December 2006; received in revised form 15 March 2007; accepted 21 March 2007

Abstract
Objective: This study surveys the parents’ knowledge and attitude about attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), barriers to enrolment for
treatment, parents’ source of information, reason for delay in treatment, and the first person who suggests the diagnosis of ADHD.
Method: The subjects of the study were the 119 parents and their children with ADHD. The parents and their children were interviewed and the
mothers completed a self-reported questionnaire about ADHD.
Results: The knowledge about ADHD was relatively low. Half of them did not agree that ADHD is due to biological and genetic vulnerabilities
and causation. Fifty-two percent of all the parents considered ADHD to be the result of parental spoiling. Only 6.2% reported that ADHD relate
difficulties would persist for the whole life. About 40% of the respondents considered it as a sign of child independency. The main source of
knowledge about ADHD was radio and TV. There were about 1.5 years between the time that the parents were suspected to the ADHD and the time
they referred for the first time. The most common reason for the delay was lack of knowledge about where or whom they should refer to. Teachers
were the first one who suggested the diagnosis of ADHD in most of the cases.
Conclusion: Knowledge about ADHD is low and barriers of referral are not usually overcome.
Practice implications: Educating and counseling of the parents should be directed toward emphasizing it as a biological problem, with concerns
about its course. Also, targeting of the barriers in delaying the referral is an important issue. Medical personnel, especially GPs should be more
informed about ADHD and play more active role in the treatment process.
# 2007 Elsevier Ireland Ltd. All rights reserved.

Keywords: ADHD; Parent’s report; Knowledge; Attitude; Barriers; Information sources; Farsi version of K-SADS; Iran

1. Introduction attitudes toward ADHD are extremely limited [6,7]. The


previous study is based on presenting case vignettes of
ADHD is the most common child and adolescent psychiatric hyperactivity (not ADHD) to mothers and taking their views.
disorder. Its core symptoms are hyperactivity, inattention and As the authors mentioned, the mothers’ answers may not reflect
impulsiveness. Beliefs and attitudes of parents have some their actual behavior. In addition, they did not examine the
implications for their willingness to seek and respond to mental mothers’ views on management and course of the behavior
health services for ADHD children and it is a cultural value problems [6]. African–American parents are less likely than
orientation [1]. In addition, it can affect how they evaluate white parents to have heard of ADHD, feel knowledgeable
and report their child’s behavior [2]. Furthermore, the parents’ about ADHD, or receive information from their physician about
knowledge of ADHD plays a significant role in their ADHD [8]. Most of the parents of ADHD children are reluctant
participation in treatments [3]. Acculturation played a role in to consider their child’s difficulties as an illness [9]. Parent
Latino mothers’ perceptions of the hyperactivity aspects of management training of ADHD children has a positive effect on
ADHD [4]. The acceptable level of activity for children is set by the parents’ general mental health [10].
cultural expectations [5]. Studies of parents’ knowledge and If Iranian parents of ADHD children are aware of their
children’s problems that are less consistent with scientific
research, they may be less likely to accept proper mental health
* Tel.: +98 711 627 93 19; fax: +98 711 627 93 19. services. Therefore, ADHD children will be less likely to have
E-mail addresses: ghanizad@sina.tums.ac.ir, ghanizadeha@hotmail.com. been referred to mental health services by family, or the
0738-3991/$ – see front matter # 2007 Elsevier Ireland Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.pec.2007.03.021
24 A. Ghanizadeh / Patient Education and Counseling 68 (2007) 23–28

families may be less willing to enroll and follow up treatment. behavior. The second part of the questionnaire was regarding
In other words, to care for children with ADHD, their behavior knowledge, attitude and source of acquired information about
must be understood within the context of their parents’ beliefs ADHD. It has been used in a study in Iran and has sufficient
and its related perceptions. validity and reliability [13]. The reliability of the questionnaire
There was not found any study from Asia about the in this study was 0.90.
knowledge and attitude of parents with a child diagnosed as The patients and their parents were informed and their
ADHD about ADHD. If the Iranian parents identified the consents were obtained to participate in the study. It was
child’s behavior as problematic, would they discuss it with their stressed that the information collected would be confidential,
child’s primary health care provider? This study starts to survey and would be used for analysis in writing an article in order to
Iranian mothers’ views of ADHD. improve the life of children with ADHD and their families by
increasing the knowledge of family. The study was conducted
2. Method according to the Good Clinical Practice Guidelines, in
accordance with the Declaration of Helsinki, 1975, as revised
2.1. Study design in 2000 and approved by the University. The data were analyzed
by using SPSS-10 for Windows statistical package.
This was a cross-sectional study of parents of 119 children
with ADHD. 3. Results

2.2. Subjects and setting The subjects of the study were 119 child and adolescents
with ADHD and 119 parents of them. The number of boys was
The study population was 119 ADHD children, consecutive 100 (84%). More than 73% of the parents were mothers. The
outpatients of the only Child and Adolescent Psychiatry Clinic age range of the children was 5–15 years old (mean = 8.4,
affiliated to Shiraz University of Medical Sciences at Shiraz, S.D. = 2.5). The mean of mothers’ age was 32.6 (S.D. = 6.3).
one of the largest cities in Iran. The individuals were drawn About 85% of the mothers were housekeeper. Mothers’
from general referrals to the outpatient setting dealing with education level range was 5–18 and the mean was 11.4
child and adolescent psychiatric and psychological problems. educational years. The fathers’ education level range was 4–18
The children and their parents were interviewed. In addition, and the mean was 11.3 educational years. The mean of the
the parents of children diagnosed with ADHD were asked to fathers’ age was 38.8 (S.D. = 5.8). 58.8% of the children were
complete a self-administered survey. the first child of family and 22.7% were the second child. About
The interviews were performed during the first visits of the 40% of the children were the only child of the family.
patients to the clinic. The inclusive criteria were child age Less than half of the parents reported that ADHD was due
range of 5–15 years old and having a diagnosis of ADHD. The to biological and genetic vulnerabilities. About 40% of them
exclusive criteria were child full-scale estimated IQ score less think that ADHD symptoms were sings of curiosity or high
than 80, suffering from a chronic medical condition, and the intelligence (Table 1). However, near two thirds of the
parents’ illiteracy. Only three of the eligible subjects refused mothers agreed that it was a serious problem and nearly all of
to take part in the study because it was time consuming and them believed that it would not improve spontaneously and
three other parents did not take part because they were emphasized the necessity for treatment of their children. In
illiterate. addition, a minority of them believed that it was a life long
Diagnostic assessment was the K-SADS Farsi version by condition. The parents reported that the mean age that
face-to-face interview with children and adolescents and their children with ADHD should improve is 16.5 years (range of
parents (over 90% of the parents were mothers). The K-SADS 12–21).
Farsi version is a reliable, respondent-based instrument About half of them said that poor parenting practices and
that provides diagnostic data on psychiatric disorders. It is parental spoiling is the cause of ADHD. A minority of them
the only diagnostic instrument based on the standard believed that sugar was a reason for this problem.
psychiatric diagnosis that has been translated into Farsi. The About one-third believed that it increased the risk of truancy
Farsi version of K-SADS used in the current study has been and about half them believed the children were at a higher risk
shown to have good validity and reliability. The test-rest of delinquency. The minority of the mothers reported that the
reliability for ADHD is 0.84. In addition, it has a good same discipline and rules used for all children should be applied
sensitivity and specifity for ADHD diagnosis [11,12]. to ADHD children. More than 90% believed that these children
require psychological support but only 40% said that they need
2.3. The knowledge and attitude questionnaire specially trained educators at school.
14.4% of the mothers reported that ADHD childrens’ IQ was
In addition to demographic characteristics (educational lower than that of non-ADHD children. 45.9% reported that
level of parents and children, type of parents’ occupation, their IQ is similar to peers and 39.6% believed that the
fathers’ age, mothers’ age, and income), the self-administered childrens’ IQ is more than that of their peers. Half of the
questionnaire asked parents to privately record their child’s age, mothers thought that educational achievements of these
gender, age when they first became concerned with their child’s children would be less than that of non-ADHD peers.
A. Ghanizadeh / Patient Education and Counseling 68 (2007) 23–28 25

Table 1
Knowledge and attitude of the parents of children with ADHD about ADHD
Statements % Answer code
ADHD is due to biological and genetic vulnerabilities 47.7 True
ADHD is a singe of child independency 10.4 True
ADHD is a singe of curiosity 40.9 True
ADHD is a singe of a bright intelligence 38.4 true
ADHD is a serious problem 73.3 True
ADHD will be improved spontaneously 2.6 True
ADHD can be caused by poor parenting practices and parental spoiling 52.2 False
They are at a higher risk of truancy and escaping 35.3 True
ADHD related difficulties persist for whole life 6.1 True
ADHD children should receive a special education setting and this would be more favorable than mainstream 78.4 True
ADHD children have a high risk for becoming delinquent as teenagers 54.4 True
ADHD children’ IQ is more than that of non-ADHD children 39.6 –
ADHD children need psychological support 93.2 True
Specially trained educators should teach these ADHD children 40 True
The same discipline and rules used for all children should be applied to ADHD children 18.3 True
Educators should be aware from ADHD and ADHD children in the class 92.3 True
ADHD children experience more difficulties in their relations with their classmates 67.3 True
Educational achievement of ADHD children will be less than that of non-ADHD peers 50.5 True
ADHD children experience more difficulties in their relations with their family members 60 True
ADHD students should receive less homework than others should 20.9 True
ADHD students should be examined orally 22.9 True
ADHD can be treated and managed with proper medication 60.4 True
ADHD can often be caused by sugar or food additives 11.3 True

About 77.3% of the mothers have already heard about referred for assessment 1.6 years later than when they were
ADHD and about 70% self-rated their information about suspected. The most common reason for this delay was
ADHD as very low or unknown. The most common sources of that they did not know where or whom they should refer to
the mothers’ information are depicted in Fig. 1. Fig. 2.
The mean age of the child that the parents were suspected Family members, friends and school psychologist were the
for the first time that their child have behavioral difficulty or three most common sources of advice for refries to Child and
ADHD was 5.3 (S.D. = 2.09) years old. However, the first Adolescent Psychiatry Clinic (Table 2). In one-third of the
time they referred for assessing their child was 6.96 cases, the teachers were the first individual who suggests the
(S.D. = 2.3) years old. In other words, the children were diagnosis (Fig. 3).

Fig. 1. Mothers’ source of information about ADHD.


26 A. Ghanizadeh / Patient Education and Counseling 68 (2007) 23–28

Fig. 2. The reasons reported by mothers for their delay in referring for assessment of the child.

Table 2 4. Discussion and conclusion


The source of advice for refries to child and adolescent psychiatry clinic for
assessment of the child’s behavior
4.1. Discussion
Adviser of the parents for assessment of the child n %
Teacher 9 8.9 The most striking finding of this study is that most of the
Family members 29 28.7 parents have not sufficient information about ADHD. Although
Pediatrician 9 8.9 most of the parents have already heard of ADHD, they feel that
Relatives 14 13.9
they are unaware about it. These might show high rates of
School psychologist 17 16.8
Friends 18 17.8 unmet ADHD treatment needs among the children even in those
Speech therapist 1 1.0 who already referred by their parents.
Psychiatrist 4 4.0 Most of them do not believe that there is a biological and
genetic vulnerability. It means that they did not take on a

Fig. 3. Who first suggests the diagnosis of ADHD?.


A. Ghanizadeh / Patient Education and Counseling 68 (2007) 23–28 27

biomedical meaning. Most of them thought that ADHD could be lower than that of the teachers. In a prior study, the teachers
caused by poor parenting practices and parental spoiling. It might were most likely to be first to suggest the diagnosis of ADHD
make parents feel extremely guilty for their behavior. When they (46.4%), followed by parents (30.2%) [20]. This result might
finally learn about ADHD, they might not feel guilty [7]. show that GPs should be more informed about ADHD. In
About only two-third of them believe that ADHD can be addition, it shows the teachers’ recommendations play a very
treated and managed with proper medication. It shows that important role in the diagnosis or treatment of ADHD.
many of them do not believe that it is an illness. Another Meanwhile, the previous study showed that the knowledge of
interesting finding was that only about 6% of the parents believe teachers in Iran about ADHD was found to be very low [13].
that ADHD symptoms would persist for the whole life.
Meanwhile, many studies demonstrate that in about 40–70% of 4.2. Limitations
children the ADHD symptom persists into adulthood [14]. It
seems that the parents maintain a sense of optimism. The responding mothers were those who referred to the
One-third of the parents do not think that ADHD children clinic and probably less likely to consider attention-deficit
experience more difficulties in their relations with their hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) behavior as a normal (or
classmates. On the other hand, the relationship with peers is expected) compared to general population mothers. In addition,
an important factor in the prognosis of ADHD and social the mothers had probably greater interest in discussing the
disabilities are negative markers in the outcome [15,16]. boys’ behaviors with their physician than those who had not
Meanwhile, it is estimated that 95% of ADHD students referred. In addition, it is possible that those who have the most
experience academic under-achievement [17]. Only half of the severe degree of ADHD were referring to the clinic. Knowledge
current study parents reported that educational achievement of and attitude of other parents in different phases of treatment
ADHD children will be less than that of non-ADHD peers. process could vary considerably with those who are in the
One of the most interesting findings is that near half of the stages of identification, diagnosis, and management. It is
parents were not aware about where and whom they should possible that in view of the mothers in community, ADHD is
refer to for treatment. This barrier is considered as one of the considered normal and the mothers would not seek physician’s
most common reasons expressed by the parents for delay in advice about the behavior. Of course, the focus of the current
assessment. On the other hand, the radio and TV were the most study is studying the parents who already referred to the clinic.
common sources of their information about ADHD. It might be Studies of parents’ view of ADHD children about ADHD are
concluded that providing information about ADHD is not very limited and this study can be a beginning point for this
sufficient and the references for assessing and treating of theses matter. Finally, it did not survey if the primary health provider
children should be announced in mass media. Most of the did not encourage further referral.
patents have information about ADHD from TVand radio, even Community sample studies are necessary for a better
more than that of the medical personnel or other resources. A understanding of cultural variation for the criteria for ADHD.
prior study showed that 39.4% of the parents of ADHD received In addition, more studies are necessary to understand why other
explanation/information from professionals [18]. It might show mothers do not seek treatment for a child with ADHD.
that the main source of information for the parents in Iran is
very different from those of others, or it is possible that other 4.3. Conclusion
sources such as medical personnel have very low information
about ADHD. This indicates that these personnel should take a There is an emergency need to improve the insight of the
more active role in the education of the community. parents of ADHD children, parents’ conception of the problem,
Economical factors and fear from stigmatization did not play its cause, its effect on behavior and education, its impact on social
any major role in delay for treatment. Of course, it can be relationships and its outcomes. Comprehensive training in
explained by the method of sampling which included clinical ADHD is very necessary for the parents. It is the starting point for
cases. To assess the role of these two factors, a community- better diagnosis, management, and treatment of these children.
based study is necessary.
There was found a delay between the time of suspicion about
4.4. Practice implication
ADHD by parents and their referral. It is very important
because a delay in the diagnosis of ADHD can be the cause of
Providing information about ADHD is not sufficient and the
the development of serious social problems [19]. The mean age
references for assessing and treating of these children should be
of the child when the parents were suspected for the first time
announced in mass media. Medical personnel should take a
about their child’s ADHD was 5.3. This mean age is very
more active role in the education of people; especially GPs
similar to another study which reported that the first age of
should be more informed about ADHD.
presenting symptoms was 5.2 years [18]. It is interesting that
the first time that they referred for assessing of their child was
References
about 1.5 years later.
The most common individuals who first suggested diagnosis [1] Chavira V, Lopez SR, Blacher J, Shapiro J. Latina mothers’ attributions,
of ADHD were the teachers and the family members. The emotions, and reactions to the problem behaviors of their children with
percentage for psychologist or GPs or pediatricians was much developmental disabilities. J Child Psychol Psyc 2000;41:245–52.
28 A. Ghanizadeh / Patient Education and Counseling 68 (2007) 23–28

[2] Livingston R. Cultural issues in diagnosis and treatment of ADHD. J Am children-present and lifetime version (K-SADS-PL): initial reliability and
Acad Child Adol Psych 1999;38:1591–4. validity data. J Am Acad Child Adol Psych 1997;36:980–8.
[3] Corkum P, Rimer P, Schachar R. Parental knowledge of attention-deficit [12] Ghanizadeh A, Mohammadi MR, Yazdanshenas A. Psychometric proper-
hyperactivity disorder and opinions of treatment options: impact on ties of the Farsi translation of the Kiddie Schedule for Affective Disorders
enrollment and adherence to a 12-month treatment trial. Can J Psychiat and Schizophrenia-Present and Lifetime Version. BMC Psychiatr
1999;44:1043–8. 2006;6:10.
[4] Schmitz M, Velez M. Latino cultural differences in maternal assessments [13] Ghanizadeh A, Bahredar MJ, Moeini SR. Knowledge and attitudes
of attention deficit/hyperactivity symptoms in children. Hispanic J Behav towards attention deficit hyperactivity disorder among elementary school
Sci 2003;25:110–22. teachers. Patient Educ Couns 2006;63:84–8.
[5] Pachter LM, Dworkin PH. Maternal expectations about normal child [14] Mannuzza S, Klein RG, Moulton 3rd JL. Persistence of attention-deficit/
development in 4 cultural groups. Arch Pediat Adol Med 1997;151: hyperactivity disorder into adulthood: what have we learned from the
1144–50. prospective follow-up studies? J Atten Disord 2003;7:93–100.
[6] Gidwani PP, Opitz GM, Perrin JM. Mothers’ views on hyperactivity: a [15] Bagwell CL, Molina BS, Pelham Jr WE, Hoza B. ADHD and problems in
cross-cultural perspective. J Dev Behav Pediatr 2006;27:121–6. peers relations: predictors from childhood to adolescence. J Am Acad
[7] Perry CE, Hatton D, Kendall J. Latino parents’ accounts of attention Child Adoc Psych 2001;40:1285–92.
deficit hyperactivity disorder. J Transcult Nurs 2005;16:312–21. [16] Greene RW, Biederman J, Faraone SV, Ouellette CA, Penn C, Griffin SM.
[8] Bussing R, Schoenberg NE, Perwien AR. Knowledge and information Toward a new psychometric definition of social disability in children with
about ADHD: evidence of cultural differences among African–American ADHD. J Am Acad Child Psych 1996;35:571–8.
and white parents. Soc Sci Med 1998;46:919–28. [17] Barkley RA. Attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder: a handbook for
[9] Wilcox CE, Washburn R, Patel V. Seeking help for attention deficit diagnosis and treatment.. New York: Guilford Press; 1990.
hyperactivity disorder in developing countries: A study of parental expla- [18] Brook U, Boaz M. Attention deficit and hyperactivity disorder/learning
natory models in Goa, India. Soc Sci Med 2007 [Epub ahead of print]. disabilities (ADHD/LD): parental characterization and perception. Patient
[10] Ghanizadeh A, Shahrivar FZ. The Effect of Parent Management Training Educ Couns 2005;57:96–100.
on children with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder. J Child Adoles [19] Tsai CH, Gau SF. Long-term outcome studies of hyperactive children:
Ment Health 2005;17:31–4. literature review. Kaohsiung J Med Sci 1999;15:307–14.
[11] Kaufman J, Birmaher B, Brent D, Rao U, Flynn C, Moreci P, Williamson D, [20] Sax L, Kautz KJ. Who first suggests the diagnosis of attention-deficit/
Ryan N. Schedule for affective disorders and schizophrenia for school-age hyperactivity disorder? Ann Fam Med 2003;1:171–4.

You might also like