Professional Documents
Culture Documents
PHD. THESIS
THE INVESTMENT IN HUMAN CAPITAL AND ECONOMIC
GROWTH IN THE CONTEXT OF MARKETS GLOBALIZATION
Scientific coordinator:
PhD. Student:
Bucharest
2015
1
Summary of PhD thesis
CONTENTS:
Introduction .........................................................................................................................................................p. 1
2
5.4.1 Socio-demographic profile of graduates and the correlation between it and the
degree of integration in the labor market analysis …………………………………………….p. 164
5.4.2 Graduates satisfaction on work …………………………………………….....………………..p. 166
5.4.3 Analysis propensity to change jobs / city or country …………………………………p. 168
5.4.4 Analysis of correlation between income and the graduated education level p. 169
5.4.5 Analysis of correspondence between the studies completed and job
characteristics (Public Administration vs. Business Administration) ………….………p. 171
5.5 Conlcusions and recommendations ..............................................................................................p. 172
Final conclusions and recommendations .....................................................................................p. 175
References .......................................................................................................................................................p. 183
Appendices
Appendix 1. The evolution of the school population in secondary education ....................p. 194
Appendix 2. The questionnaire used in research on „The usage of the human capital of
graduates of economics and administrative sciences acquired in higher educational
system”................................................................................................................................................................p. 195
Appendix 3. List of Graphics ......................................................................................................................p. 208
Appendix 4. List of Tables ..........................................................................................................................p. 209
SUMMARY:
The human capital represents the mirror of a nation, and the more that society
invests in education and health, the closer it will be to prosperity and development. The
richness found in human resource can be effectively used as long as there are polices to
support the revaluation of this type of capital. In their absence, part of one nation human
capital is lost, due to phenomena such as unemployment, immigration or miss-usage.
Therefore, along with the development of the new economy and the transition from the
industrial-based economy to the knowledge-based economy, the educational component is
being assigned a significant role in ensuring the economic progress and development.
People are no longer ordinary workers, but are the one adding value to the products and
services, while their knowledge and skills represent key elements of the competitiveness in
a globalized and independent economy. In this context, the technological factors raised the
knowledge to a new level, allowing its transfer to a global level, and creating relational and
economic interdependences.
The globalization of the economic markets led to an unprecedented development of
the sectors based on advance technologies and use of highly qualified human resources.
Therefore, we are witnessing, today, not only a reconfiguration of the power poles, as a
result of increased competitiveness and wealth of certain nations, based on innovation and
technology, but also a restructuration of the labour market, characterized by a demand for
very well trained human resources, with high level of skills, and a greater ability to adapt
more easily to dynamic organizational environments, competing to introduce new
technologies and to enter as many markets as possible. In such context, it is necessary to
3
balance the investments and to support the development of human resources, all needed to
increase the economic competitiveness.
Current debates in business and academic environments are merging to the usage of
new educational contents to ensure a lifelong learning, so as the individuals to be able to
continually acquire new skills and competences, more adapted to the innovative processes
and technologies.
In Europe, during the economic integration process, there can be observed obvious
concerns for human resources, in general, and human capital, in particular, after the 80s,
when the European Union, as well as the member states have proposed to obtain a higher
level of employment percentage, of productivity and social cohesion. Even now, in a
European Union affected by global changes, investments in education and vocational
training are of a particular interest. Investing in human capital is a priority to create the
most competitive and dynamic knowledge-based economy in the world.
In Romania, the concerns on the human capital component were marked by a series
of reforms initiated in the system of education, usually either inadequate or improperly
implemented following the last two decades period. The effects of this period of searching
and positioning of Romania in its relation to the merger to capitalism and then to its
alignment to the European Union standards led to an uncertain economic, political and
social environment, an environment in which the development of appropriate use of the
human capital have suffered. During all these transformations, the human capital was in a
very sensitive position, requiring strategies and actions leading to a higher allocation of
resources for recovering the quantitative and qualitative discrepancy in between Romania
and other European countries and worldwide countries, mode developed.
After becoming a member of the European Union, the situation has improved, as a result of
European investments and of the know-how of the European best practices, but we are still
at the beginning of this „battle”, as Romania may not decelerate the process of economic
growth for ensuring its highest level of competitiveness. The content and the quality of the
education represent the main factor of progress of Romania, in general, and of the business
environment, in particular, given that it is the only way to sustain the changes and
transformations predicted on the labour market for the following decade. From this point
of view, the improvement of the quality of the human resources available in our country
through the investments in education and health systems, as well as elaboration of a
national strategy including precise actions to improve the efficiency of the usage of human
capital represent major pillars of our future development and progress.
Therefore, this paper work aims to provide a broad framework for the analysis of
the investment in the human capital, with a special view on the context and situation in
Romania, compared to the other states members of the European Union. The comparative
analysis finds its justification in the fact the European Union is one of the most advances
forms of economic integration. In theory, this paper work approaches the human capital
from the perspective of the theory opened by the Chicago school (in its economic version:
Mincer, Schultz, Becker, Kicker), the human capital being understand as education (formal
and informal) and health. Due to scientific and economic reasons, this paper work
4
considered only the component of the educational capital acquired during the initial
education and during the further continuous vocational training.
The choice of such subject if justified by the importance attributed to the education
during the recent decades, due to its influence on the economic growth and increase of the
competitiveness of the countries investing in the human capital. The Organization for
Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) is stating that the level of the
international competitiveness varies depending on the level of education of the population,
thus explaining much of the differences in productivity among OECD countries. The level of
education contributes not only to the increase of the productivity through the competences
and skills, but also contributes to the improvement of life quality (reducing the mortality,
maintaining an optimal level of health of the population), as well as to the increase of the
flexibility and adaptability of the individuals, which are vitals in the context of economical
structural changes. However, the choice of this subject was also based in considerations
identified during the stage of pre-analysis, considerations which revealed a poor
development of this topic in the specialised Romanian literature, as well as a low interest in
elaboration of more specific studies and researches, at national level, on the investment in
human capital, as well as a comparative analysis with other countries members of the
European Union.
In order to reach the proposed objective, that of achieving an accurate X-ray image
on the investment in human capital and economic growth in the context of markets
globalization, the paper work aimed to obtain an analysis developed over five chapters.
The first chapter, „Human capital in the economic theory and practice” has the
role to provide the theoretical framework of the development of the concept of human
capital in the economic theory. The concept was presented and approached in terms of
focusing on added value and on the limitations of the theory of human capital theory, in
close correlation with the evolution of school of thought. We can say that the human capital
theory could be considered as the promoter of the empirical analysis and explanation of
some phenomena the base for the development of other models. The primary model of the
human capital developed by the initiators of this theory seemed to provide most of the
answers at the time, by building a model of the demand for education. However, their
assumptions were contradicted by researches stating that the inequalities of the demand
have, in general, other causes than those related to individuals’ preferences, while the offer
of education is not unitary and has influences in the development of schooling. Further
developments of the models and the theories elaborated in recent decades on the human
capital can be found in this chapter. Some of the most recent theories converge to a number
of tendencies which characterize the newest economical realities, such as: increase of the
consumption of new developed technologies, increase of the interdependencies, increase of
the labour consumption, characterized by high qualifications and replacement of less
qualified human resources.
The researches have revealed the increasing tendency in the global GDI since the late
eighteenth century, when the Industrial Revolution begun, leading to an impressive growth
of the GDI per capita. This evolution determined even greater increases in the more
developed economies, or in the emerging ones. The periods of growth coincided with the
biggest jumps in the evolution of the process of globalization.
The intensification of the process of globalization, mainly in the second half of the last
century, led to increases of the commercial, investment, technological and information
flows, greatly increasing the role of the direct foreign investments. This aspect led us to
believe that the ISD transactions represented a primordial instrument for the globalization,
contributing to the economical growth of those regions, as well as becoming a catalyst for
other factors of production and for the domestic capital as part of the world economies.
Neither the second pillar of the education, the vocational training, with an important
role in developing the individual skills and competences in order to develop the human
capital, with an impact on the increase of the quality of the work and economy as a whole
has not benefited from better conditions in Romania after the 90s. There is an
improvement, in the recent past years, through the development of a legislative framework
meant to stimulate the level of participation in vocational training programs, but this is not
enough. There are evolutions in what concerns the level of participation in vocational
training programs, but the increases are registered in the sectors with a tradition of
investing in the continuous vocational trainings, such as financial intermediation and
insurances, electricity, thermal, gas production and supply, information and
communications. However, there is a high proportion of companies & enterprises choosing
to find less expensive solutions, mostly implemented only to meet the legal requirements
on employees training, solutions which are not designed to aim the quality of the human
resources training, but the lowest cost. Nationally, the share of the direct and indirect
expenses of the overall cost of vocational training is around 0.2% of GDI.
The fourth chapter, “The relation between the human capital and economic
growth” aimed to achieve a presentation of the main models of economic growth
developed over the time, with particular reference to the relation between these models
and human capital. In the specialised literature, there are a variety of theories on the
factors generating the economic growth. The first school of thought rooted in Becker
theory according to which the increase if being determined by the accumulation of human
capital. According to this theory, the differences in the growth rates of the income per
capita in between economies are mainly determined by the rates at which the economies
are accumulating human capital. The second approach sustain the assumption according to
which the quantity of the human capital has influences on the economy, on its capacity to
innovate or to obtain performances similar to the more advanced economies, thus
determining the economic growth. According to this approach, the size of the human
capital is considered as an indirect factor which determines the average economic growth
per capita. For instance, in Lucas` s view, the significant differences in between states are
explained by the technological differences and by the differences in knowledge of their
inhabitants, as the human capital. Therefore, it should be noted that the fact that there is an
interdependence of the factors involved in the production, but only some of them have a
superior role in the economic growth process.
In the fourth chapter we have conducted an analysis of the investment in the human
capital, at the level of the initial education, approached from the perspective of its recovery
or by contribution to the balancing of the budgets, and the imbalances generated by
8
migration. The analysis also includes an evaluation of the labour productivity given its
importance for the economy. The growth of the labour productivity is translated into
higher wage and economical prosperity.
For the pre-university educational system, for calculating the standard cost, we used
as term of reference a standard pupil attending the gymnasium, in urban environment,
having a coefficient of one (1). For emphasizing the main effects of the export of labour
force through migration, we analysed the main losses registered by Romania, as provider,
compared to the financial benefits of the host country. For such a comparison, we had
chosen Spain, the second European country in terms of number of migrating Romanians,
representing the largest community of emigrants. The official figure used for the persons
who have chosen Spain was of 796 608, while for the total of Romanian emigrants in 2014,
the used figure was of 3 000 000, estimated data.
The results of the analysis indicated an average cost for pre-university and
university educational system. In addition, we also estimated the expenses of a family for a
pupil/student, which are emphasizing a tendency not having an absolute representation.
Therefore, for the pre-university educational system, the Romanian state is investing, in
one single pupil, who started the first grade in 2002 and graduated high school in 2013, an
average of 6816.44 euro. In the event when, due to various reasons, this pupil is only
graduating only the primary educational system, the invested amount is being reduced at
4563.64 euro. For primary educational system, the expenses of a family are of 289.65
euro/year. In the event when the pupil is also graduating from high school, the average
expenses of his family will be of 3475.8 euro. In the end, the public and familial expenses
will reach a total of 10 292.24 euro for the education of a high school graduated pupil.
In terms of college/university education, the costs are higher than those above
mentioned, requiring an average public funding for a student graduating the three years
period college program, of 5 347,91 euro. For a student graduating from a four years period
college program, the costs are even higher, of 6 493,91 euro. The investment was calculated
for a student starting the studies in 2008 and graduating in 2011 (for three years college
program), respectively in 2012, for a four years college program. In the event of additional
expenses paid by the family, the average personal or familial cost is of 3 692, 66 euro, (for
three years college program), respectively of 4 923, 68 euro, for a four years college
program. In this case, the investment in the education of one student from public and
familial sources may reach a level of 9 040, 57 euro, (for three years college program), and
of 11 417, 59 euro, for a four years college program.
But, taking into account that approximately 13% of Romania`s total population
chose to live in another country, the level of invested and uncollected amounts are
burdening the Romania` s public budget. For example, analysing the losses registered by
Romania due to the migration of 769 608 persons in Spain, resulted a level of losses
incurred in those persons education of 5 409 372 358, 34 euro, while the loss of potential
contributions to the public budget from wage taxes and fees are of 6 421 508 333, 34 euro.
We have also identified losses from the diminution of labour productivity, by analysing the
social productivity of labour, the labour productivity per employee and the according to the
salary costs.
The more detailed results of the analysis of the contributions for balancing the
budgets and of the imbalances caused by migration are presented in the second part of this
chapter, emphasizing, therefore, an unfavourable situation for Romania, as a provider of
labour force, compared to the countries that are hosting the people who have migrated.
The fifth chapter is providing a case study on “The usage of the human capital
of graduates of economics and administrative sciences acquired in higher
educational system”. The innovation of this research, reported in other socio-economic
studies completed in Romania, is the provision of a comparative analysis of these two
majors, belonging to two different areas of studies, in order to emphasize the extent to
which the differences occurs in the hope of employment of the graduates, of income labour
and human capital development after graduation.
The usefulness of this research includes two dimensions: theoretical and practical.
The theoretical theory is to widen the knowledge on the use of the human capital of the
graduates of Economics and administrative science. The practical dimension is translated
into practical benefits that the interested entities may earn (graduates, the higher
educational institutions, employers, public authorities).
The study was based on the fulfilment of the central goal of the research that of
obtaining an X-ray image on the integration of graduates and their positioning on the
labour market, from the perspective of the use of the human capital acquired during higher
education. From the methodological point of view, we investigated the persons who
obtained a bachelor` s degree in the Faculty of Business and Administration (University of
Bucharest), included into the 2007/2008, 2009, 20011 promotions, Public Administration
and Business Administration specializations.
After analyzing the answers given by the respondents, we could outline the
following guidelines of the research, outlines which could be use for developing complex
researches on the integration of the graduates on the labour market, in order to widen the
10
scope of knowledge in these specializations, as well as to improve the politics and
strategies concerning the graduates of economics and administrative science.
The main results indicate a higher rate of continuing the studies, at postgraduate
level, thus contributing to a higher development of the human capital. Most graduated or
will graduate post-university studies offered by the state university, having a good
reputation on the labour market. In terms of attending the vocational training programs,
the situation is not as good, given that the interviewees had a much lower rate of
graduating a vocational training program, compared to attending a postgraduate program.
A very good situation stands out in terms of degree of insertion, which is high, 91% of the
interviewed graduates occupying a job, as employee. Among these, the graduates of the
economics have found, in a much greater extent, (69%), a job corresponding to the
investment they have made in the undergraduate studies, while only 34% of the Public
Administration graduates (coursework in Administrative Sciences) declared the same.
Also, another major difference between these two coursework is the earned salary. The
graduates of Business Administration had higher earnings than the graduates of Public
Administration. This aspect is also reflected in the answers given on the perception on their
lives quality: the Business Administration` s graduates declared to be more satisfied by
their style of living, compared to the Public Administration graduates.
The analysis revealed a very low share of graduates developing their own starts-up.
This low percentage is rather worrying, if we consider especially the Business
Administration graduates for whom, among the specific competences of the curricula, the
entrepreneurship is included.
A cause for this low rate is the unfavourable global economic context and the social-
political uncertainties at the moment of graduation, and so forth. Another reason could be
the lack of specific and practical skills that the graduated college failed to provide to the
graduates. This reason is a constant criticism of Romanian educational system in the last 20
years – creating general skills, theoretical skills and the ignorance of the real needs of the
labour market, due to the lack of an efficient communication in between the market
entities, namely the representatives of the educational institutions and the representatives
of the business environment and even the state institutions.
11
The results of the research will be presented to the board members of the faculty
and the teachers, to be used in order to better adapt the curricula, so as all these
shortcomings identified in the skills of their graduates to be improved, and for the
educational content to become more competitive in the current requirements found both
on the labour market, as well as in the academic community. At the same time, the results
shall be made available to the business environment in order to outline a profile of
graduates of these two coursework, a profile which may be used during the selection and
recruitment processes, as well as on the development of the motivation strategies and
vocational training of the employees coming from the analysed specializations, and more.
The public authorities, both in the education area, as well as in the labour market area, in
particular, represent another entity for which the results of this research will be made
available, so as to be used in order to develop more complex researches on the insertion of
the graduation on the labour market, in order to widen the knowledge of these two
specialization, as well as to improve the legislative framework.
From the perspective of the responsibility of the legislators and public authorities,
there is the need to elaborate and implement policies to facilitate the protection and the
development of the skills of the individuals, by stimulating their participation in lifelong
learning activities. At the same time, it is necessary to improve the medical services, both in
terms of the access to services, as well as in terms of the quality of the medical care, so that
12
the population to have a good health. And last, but not least, identifying some efficient
measures to boost the business environment in creating new jobs and to increase the
quality of the human capital in the organization by participation in continuous vocational
training programs.
13