a.Communicative Properties 10 Visual impact, emotional reaction, mood, etc. b.Creativity 20 Imagination, expression, creative approach c.Technical Qualities 5 Editing, cropping d.Color/Value 10 Excellent range of color tones; colors work well together based on color scheme e.Over-all Production 5 B.Symbolical Reflection a.Connection to Experience: Makes clear the connection(s) between the graphics and the 5 dimension being discussed (article) b. Accuracy: Symbols are accurate and supported with evidence based from the chosen article 5 c. Clarity: Consistently expands on and expresses ideas in alternative way through illustrations. 5 d. Relevance: Symbols are relevant to the articulated learning statement category and keeps the 5 discussion specific to the learning being articulated." e. Depth: Symbols addresses the complexity of the problem; answers important questions/ issues 10 that are raised from the article. f. Breadth: Symbolical Reflections gives meaningful consideration to alternative points of view 5 and interpretations." g. Logic: Symbolical Reflection demonstrates a line of reasoning that is logical, with conclusions 5 or goals that follow clearly from it." h. Significance: Symbols draws conclusions, sets goals that address a (the) major issue(s) raised 10 by the experience." i.Originality 20 C. Conclusion a. The conclusion captures the focus of the research paper. 10 b. The conclusion summarizes the writer’s main points (aspects) of the research paper by 10 paraphrasing the thesis statement. c. The conclusion provides a recommendation. 10 d. The conclusion includes an ending comment that inspires the reader to continue thinking about 20 your topic. TOTAL 170