Professional Documents
Culture Documents
02 Reviewer Commercial Law Aquino PDF
02 Reviewer Commercial Law Aquino PDF
INTRODUCTION
1. GENERAL CONCEPTS.
1.01. Commercial law has been defined as that branch of
private law which regulates the juridical relations
arising from commercial acts and according to which
the questions or controversies which may arise
therefrom are resolved (Vivante’s Institutiones, p. 3;
Espejo de Hinojasa, p. 61 cited in Tolentino, Commentaries
and Jurisprudence on the Commercial Laws of the
Philippines, 6th Ed., Vol. 1, p. 1).
a) Traditionally, Commercial laws in the Philip-
pines include laws governing the following: (1)
commercial documents such as negotiable in-
struments, warehouse receipts, letters of credit
and the like, (2) business organizations like cor-
porations, single proprietorship and joint ac-
counts, (3) commercial contracts like insurance
or mortgage, (4) banking regulations, (5) insol-
vency, (6) securities, (7) intellectual properties,
(8) public utilities and other activities or transac-
tions involving commerce.
1.02. Commerce is the mass of acts of human life, which
tend to the satisfaction of necessities by means of
exchange or of the rendition of services, effected with
a purpose of gain and falling within the domain of
mercantile laws (ibid.).
2. APPLICABLE LAWS.
2.01. Code of Commerce — This law was extended to the
Philippines by Royal Decree of August 6, 1888. It
1
2 REVIEWER ON COMMERCIAL LAW
3. COMMERCIAL CONTRACTS.
3.01. Concept and Formalities. Contracts that are governed
by the Code of Commerce are called commercial
contracts.
a) In the absence of any requirement under the
Code of Commerce or Special Law that certain
formalities are required, commercial contracts
are valid in whatever form they appear (Arts. 51
and 52, CC). Example: Joint Accounts.
b) Contracts that are expressly required to be in
writing under the Code of Commerce are: (1)
Letters of Credit (Art. 267, CC), (2) Loans on Bot-
tomry and Respondentia (Art. 720, CC), and (3)
Charter Parties (Art. 652, CC).
3.02. Perfection.
The general rule under the New Civil Code is
that contracts are perfected upon the meeting of minds
with respect to the object and the consideration.
a) In perfection by correspondence, the applicable rule
is the Cognition Theory under which the contract is
perfected the moment the offeror learns about the
acceptance of his offer by the offeree (Art. 1409, NCC).
Thus, Cognition Theory should apply to all consensual
contracts that are governed by Commercial laws.
To my wife Felicitas, my children Macaria, Jocelyn, Jose, Jr.,
and Renato and their families
Jose R. Sundiang
Timoteo B. Aquino
iii
iv
PREFACE TO THE FIFTH EDITION
The last revision of this work was made when the Fourth
Edition was reprinted in March 2010. While less than a year
is normally too short to release a new edition, the passage
of the Financial Rehabilitation and Insolvency Act of 2010
necessitated the revision of the present work. As a consequence
of the same law, discussions on rehabilitation of corporations
which were previously included in Part III are now included
in the discussions on rehabilitation, insolvency and liquidation
of all business organizations in Part V on Credit Transactions.
The authors likewise took the opportunity to include new and
important cases on other subjects as well as new rules like those
pertaining to business names.
This edition adheres to the basic aim of the previous
editions — to present the core subjects of Commercial Law in
a simplified but comprehensive manner. The structure of the
book was purposely designed to help students review for the
Bar Examinations.
The authors extend their heartfelt gratitude to all those
who used this book in the past ten years. The authors hope that
this new edition will continue to be of help to students and Bar
Reviewees.
THE AUTHORS
v
vi
PREFACE
vii
caution given by Professor Henry Ballentine who declared that
students should not wait for the writing on the wall — “Thou art
to be weighed in the balance by bar examiners, Woe unto thee if thou
art found wanting.”
THE AUTHORS
viii
CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION
1. General Concepts....................................................................... 1
1.01. Commercial Law Defined. .............................................. 1
1.02. Commerce Defined. ......................................................... 1
2. Applicable Laws ........................................................................ 1
2.01. Code of Commerce ........................................................ 1
2.02. New Civil Code ............................................................. 2
2.03. Special Laws ................................................................... 2
3. Commercial Contract ................................................................ 3
3.01. Concept and Formalities .............................................. 3
3.02. Perfection of Contracts.................................................. 3
PART I
NEGOTIABLE INSTRUMENTS LAW
1. Definition of Negotiable Instrument ...................................... 5
2. Requisites of Negotiability ..................................................... 5
2.01. Negotiation Defined ...................................................... 6
2.02. How Negotiability is Determined .............................. 6
3. Governing Law .......................................................................... 6
4. Functions of Negotiable Instruments ..................................... 7
4.01. Enumeration of Functions ............................................ 7
4.02. What is Legal Tender .................................................... 7
4.03. Coins as Legal Tender ................................................... 8
5. Distinctive Features of Negotiable Instruments ................... 8
6. Kinds of Negotiable Instruments ............................................ 8
6.01. Bill of Exchange ............................................................. 8
6.02. Promissory Note ............................................................ 8
6.03. Kinds of Bill of Exchange ............................................. 9
6.04. Kinds of Promissory Note ............................................ 9
6.05. Bill of Exchange treated as Promissory Note ............ 10
6.06. Distinctions ..................................................................... 10
ix
6.07. Negotiability of Certain Documents ........................... 11
7. Persons/Parties Involved ......................................................... 12
8. Distinctions ................................................................................. 13
8.01. Negotiable and Non-Negotiable Instruments ........... 13
8.02. Negotiability and Assignability .................................. 13
9. Requisites of Negotiability ....................................................... 14
9.01. In Writing signed by Maker or Drawer. ..................... 14
9.02. Unconditional Promise or Order ................................ 15
9.03. Sum Certain in Money .................................................. 18
9.04. When Payable ............................................................... 19
9.05. Payable to Order or Bearer ........................................... 21
9.06. Identification of Drawee ............................................... 24
10. Omissions and Additional Provisions .................................. 24
11. Transfer and Negotiation.......................................................... 27
12. Holders ....................................................................................... 32
13. Real and Personal Defenses ..................................................... 39
13.01. Distinctions .................................................................... 40
13.02. Forgery ............................................................................ 40
13.03. Complete and Incomplete Instruments...................... 45
13.04. Insertion of Wrong Date ............................................... 48
13.05. Material Alteration ........................................................ 49
13.06. Fraud .............................................................................. 49
13.07. Failure of, Absence of, or Illicit
Consideration.......................................................... 50
13.08. Minority or Incapacity ................................................. 51
13.09. Prescription .................................................................... 52
14. Secondary and Primary Liability ............................................ 53
14.01. Liability of Maker, Drawer, and Acceptor ................. 53
14.02. Warranties of Qualified and General Indorser .......... 54
14.03. Accommodation Party .................................................. 55
15. How to Enforce Liability .......................................................... 57
15.01. Enforcement of Primary Liability................................ 57
15.02. Enforcement of Secondary Liability ........................... 57
15.03. Presentment for Payment ............................................. 59
15.04. Presentment for Acceptance......................................... 61
15.05. Acceptance ..................................................................... 62
15.06. Notice of Dishonor ........................................................ 64
15.07. Protest ............................................................................. 67
15.08. Acceptance for Honor ................................................... 68
15.09. Payment for Honor........................................................ 69
16. Bills-in-Set ................................................................................... 70
17. Discharge .................................................................................... 71
18. Checks ......................................................................................... 72
x
PART II
INSURANCE CODE
1. Definitions .............................................................................. 75
2. Characteristics of Insurance Contract.................................... 76
3. Elements of Insurance .............................................................. 78
4. Perfection of Insurance Contract ............................................. 81
4.01. Cover Notes ................................................................ 83
4.02. The Policy (Contents, Cancellation,
Kinds, Rider) ...................................................... 84
5. Types of Insurance Contracts ................................................... 87
6. Parties ......................................................................................... 88
6.01. Insurer .............................................................................. 88
6.02. Insured ............................................................................. 89
6.03. Beneficiary ........................................................................ 90
7. Insurable Interest ...................................................................... 92
7.01. Basic Concepts ............................................................... 92
7.02. Property and Life Insurance Distinguished .............. 97
7.03. Mortgagor and Mortgagee .......................................... 99
7.04. Insurable Interest Retained by Mortgagor ................ 102
7.05. Assignor and Beneficiary ............................................ 104
7.06. Expectancy ...................................................................... 105
7.07. Effect of Change of Interest. ........................................ 105
8. Risks Insured Against ............................................................... 106
9. Premium ..................................................................................... 107
10. Transfer of Policy ....................................................................... 109
11. Devices for Ascertaining and Controlling
the Risk and Loss ............................................................. 110
11.01. Primary Concerns ......................................................... 110
11.02. Devices Defined ............................................................ 110
11.03. Concealment ............................................................... 111
11.04. Representation................................................................ 116
11.05. Warranty.......................................................................... 116
11.06. Warranty and Representation Distinguished ............ 117
11.07. Other Insurance Clause .............................................. 118
12. Incontestability Clause ............................................................. 120
13. Double Insurance and Reinsurance ........................................ 122
14. Loss and Claims Settlement ..................................................... 126
15. Prescription ................................................................................ 130
16. Right of Subrogation ................................................................. 131
17. Marine Insurance ..................................................................... 132
18. Fire Insurance ........................................................................... 144
19. Casualty Insurance .................................................................... 146
xi
20. Compulsory Motor Vehicle Liability Insurance .................... 148
21. Suretyship ................................................................................... 154
22. Life Insurance ............................................................................. 154
23. Variable Contract ...................................................................... 155
24. Powers of the Insurance Commisioner .................................. 155
PART III
BUSINESS ORGANIZATIONS
A. BASIC TYPES OF BUSINESS ORGANIZATIONS ............... 159
1. Individuals and Sole Proprietorship ............................. 159
1.01. Business Name Law ............................................. 159
1.02. Merchants under Code of Commerce ............... 161
2. Partnerships ...................................................................... 165
3. Joint-Accounts (Cuentas en Participacion) ...................... 165
4. Business Trust .................................................................. 166
5. Joint Venture ..................................................................... 166
6. Cooperatives ..................................................................... 167
B. CORPORATION CODE OF THE PHILIPPINES ...................... 167
1. Corporation Defined ....................................................... 167
1.01. Enumeration of Attributes .................................. 167
2. Discussion of Attributes ................................................. 168
2.01. Artificial Being/Separate Personality ............... 168
2.02. Created by Operation of Law ............................ 178
2.03. Right of Succession .............................................. 180
2.04. Powers, Attributes and Properties .................... 180
3. Classifications and Distinctions ..................................... 180
4. Advantages and Disadvantages of Corporate Form .. 186
5. Components of a Corporation ....................................... 187
6. Formation .......................................................................... 191
6.01. Articles of Incorporation ..................................... 191
6.02. Amendment of Articles of Incorporation ......... 195
6.03. Suspension and Cancellation of Certificate .... 196
7. By-Laws ............................................................................ 196
8. Powers of a Corporation ................................................. 198
8.01. Kinds ..................................................................... 198
8.02. Express Powers .................................................... 199
8.03. Ultra Vires Acts .................................................... 200
8.04. Exercise of Powers by Board, Officers
and Stockholders ........................................ 202
8.05. Acquisition of its own Shares ............................ 207
8.06. Dividends ............................................................. 207
xii
8.07. Sale of All or Substantially All Properties ........ 213
8.08. Increase or Decrease of Authorized
Capital ........................................................... 215
9. Directors and Officers .................................................... 215
10. Trust Fund Doctrine ....................................................... 224
11. Stockholders and Shares ................................................ 228
11.01. Subscription Contracts ....................................... 228
11.02. Shares of Stocks ................................................... 230
12. Certificate of Stock .......................................................... 236
13. Transfer of Shares ............................................................ 236
14. Rights and Obligations of Stockholders ...................... 239
14.01. Enumeration ......................................................... 239
14.02. Suits by Stockholders/Members ....................... 241
14.03. Pre-emptive Right ................................................ 242
14.04. Right to Vote ......................................................... 242
14.05. Appraisal Right .................................................... 244
15. Collection of Unpaid Subscription ................................ 245
16. Books of the Corporation ................................................ 248
17. Merger vs. Consolidation .............................................. 249
18. Non-Use of Corporate Charter ..................................... 252
19. Dissolution ........................................................................ 253
20. Liquidation ....................................................................... 256
21. Foreign Corporations ...................................................... 256
22. Close Corporations .......................................................... 260
23. Non-Stock Corporations ................................................. 262
24. Religious Corporations ................................................... 265
C. SECURITIES REGULATIONS CODE (SRC) ............................. 267
1. Powers and Function of SEC .......................................... 267
1.01 Transferred Jurisdiction to RTC ........................ 269
2. Securities Defined ........................................................... 270
3. Definition of Terms ......................................................... 270
4. How Public is Protected ................................................. 273
5. Rules on Registration of Securities ................................ 274
6. Exempt Securities............................................................. 275
7. Exempt Transactions........................................................ 276
8. Grounds for Revocation of Registration ....................... 279
9. Manipulation of Security Prices..................................... 280
10. Put, Call and Straddle ..................................................... 282
11. Unlawful Sale and Purchase of Securities .................... 282
12. Insider ................................................................................ 283
13. Tender Offer ...................................................................... 285
14. Margin Trading ................................................................ 288
15. Violations of SRC ............................................................. 289
xiii
PART IV
BANKING LAWS
xiv
PART V
CREDIT TRANSACTIONS
xv
5. Suspension of Payment ................................................... 392
6. Liquidation of Individual Debtor .................................. 396
7. Liquidation Process ......................................................... 398
8. Distribution of Assets (Concurrence and Preference
of Credits) ................................................................ 400
9. Cross-Boarder Insolvency ............................................... 405
PART VI
TRANSPORTATION AND PUBLIC UTILITIES
xvi
17.02. Captains and Masters .......................................... 437
17.03. Officers and Crew ................................................ 438
17.04. Supercargoes ........................................................ 439
17.05. Desertion .............................................................. 439
18. General and Particular Average .................................... 439
19. Charter Party .................................................................... 444
20. Bill of Lading ................................................................... 444
21. Loans on Bottomry and Respondentia ......................... 445
22. Procedure and Prescriptive Period for Claims ........... 446
23. Ship Mortgage Decree .................................................... 448
23.01. Who may Constitute Mortgage ......................... 448
23.02. Formal Requirements .......................................... 449
23.03. Arrest and Foreclosure ........................................ 450
23.04. Concurrence and Preference of Credits ............ 450
23.05. Maritime Lien ....................................................... 451
24. Salvage Law ...................................................................... 452
24.01. Definition of Salvage .......................................... 452
24.02. Requirements for Compensation ....................... 452
24.03. Amount of Reward or Compensation .............. 452
24.04. Persons Entitled to Reward ................................ 453
C. WARSAW CONVENTION AND CIVIL
AVIATION LAWS ............................................................ 453
25. Warsaw Convention ........................................................ 453
25.01. Transportation by Air Defined ........................... 454
25.02. Damage or Injury for Which Carrier
is Liable .......................................................... 454
25.03. Limit of Liability of Carrier ................................ 454
25.04. Tort Liability ......................................................... 455
25.05. Jurisdiction/Venue .............................................. 456
26. Civil Aviation ................................................................... 456
26.01. Definitions ............................................................. 457
26.02. Inspection of Aircraft ........................................... 458
26.03. Nationality and Ownership of Aircraft ............ 460
D. PUBLIC SERVICE ACT............................................................. 461
27. Public Service Act ............................................................ 461
27.01. Agencies that Replaced the Public
Service Commission ..................................... 461
27.02. Conditions for Issuance of Certificate
of Public Convenience
and Necessity (CPCN) ................................. 462
27.03. Certificate of Public Convenience (CPC)
as Property .................................................... 462
xvii
27.04. CPC and CPCN Distinguished .......................... 462
27.05. Prior Operator Rule ............................................. 462
27.06. Grounds for Revocation of Certificate .............. 463
27.07. Notice and Hearing ............................................. 463
27.08. Franchise Defined ................................................ 464
27.09. Public Utility Defined.......................................... 465
27.10. Rate Regulation .................................................... 466
27.11. Foreign Equity ...................................................... 468
27.12 Non-Exclusivity of Franchise .............................. 469
PART VII
INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY CODE
xviii
6.08. Infringement ......................................................... 493
6.09. Protection of Tradename ..................................... 499
6.10. Unfair Competition.............................................. 499
6.11. Inter-Partes Cases................................................. 500
7. Patents ............................................................................... 504
7.01. Definitions, Requisites and Purposes ............... 504
7.02. Classes of Patentable Inventions ....................... 506
7.03. Non-Patentable Inventions ................................. 506
7.04. Person Entitled to Right ...................................... 507
7.05. Limitations of Patent Rights ............................... 507
7.06. Prejudicial Disclosure .......................................... 509
7.07. Non-Prejudicial Disclosure ................................. 509
7.08. Term of a Patent ................................................... 509
7.09. Infringement ......................................................... 509
7.10. Compulsory Licensing ........................................ 511
7.11. Concept of Divisional Applications .................. 513
8. Trade Secrets ..................................................................... 515
8.01. Applicable Laws................................................... 516
8.02. Factors.......................................................................... 516
xix