You are on page 1of 9

Earth-Science Reviews 59 (2002) 287 – 295

www.elsevier.com/locate/earscirev

Earth Reflections
The complexity of simple geology
A.J. van Loon
Geocom B.V., P.O. Box 336, 6860 AH Oosterbeek, Netherlands

Abstract

Geology becomes, like all natural sciences, increasingly dependent on sophisticated, complex technologies. This is not
generally acknowledged, because many geological ‘products’ seem so simple that it is, for both the general public and decision
makers, often difficult to understand how complex the activities are that are needed for making these apparently very simple raw
materials available. A good example is aggregate, probably the simplest geological product. The understanding of aggregate
characteristics (required to determine whether the material is suited for a specific purpose) requires a profound knowledge of the
rock properties and of the variation of these properties. This is not enough, however, since the users must also be convinced that
‘stones’ are not always interchangeable, but that the efficacy of their application depends on their characteristics. Particularly
decision makers and customers in the fields of housing, civil engineering and environmental planning should be convinced that
they need the expertise of earth-science specialists, and that they should have themselves at least a basic knowledge of applied
geology, including the possible use of, and the problems related with, aggregate.
D 2002 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.

Keywords: Aggregate; Engineering geology; Applied geology; Environmental geology; Quarry rehabilitation

1. Introduction have, in one way or another, to do with earth science.


Examples are numerous; a well-known recent project
Much earth-scientific knowledge has disappeared that suffered from insufficient earth-scientific inves-
since most people lost immediate and continuous tigations is the foundation of the Traneberg bridge in
contact with nature. Stone-age people were well Stockholm, for which work the rock surface had been
aware that not all types of rock are suitable for all mapped, but for which no testing of rock properties
purposes, and they selected specific rock types for had been undertaken. When considerable vertical
tools that had a particular purpose. Arrow points, for movements of the arches occurred, the work had to
instance, were made of flint preferably, but the pre- be interrupted; boreholes were made, characteristics
historic hunters knew very well that not all flint was were measured and deformation moduli, compressive
equally suitable, and they were highly selective in strengths and bearing capacities were estimated. Five
gaining the right material, by mining or trade. It potential causal mechanisms for the foundation move-
seems that such practical knowledge has gone lost ments were found, and stabilization was required
on a large-scale, considering the many unjustified (Röshoff et al., 2002). The result was a significant
decisions taken by politicians and customers that delay in construction, which would have been
avoided if only it had been realized beforehand that
even apparently simple geological aspects may be
E-mail address: geocom@wxs.nl (A.J. van Loon). fairly complex. Even though it is, fortunately, in most

0921-8181/02/$ - see front matter D 2002 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
PII: S 0 9 2 1 - 8 1 8 1 ( 0 2 ) 0 0 1 6 4 - 9
288 A.J. van Loon / Earth-Science Reviews 59 (2002) 287–295

cases realized that large infrastructural projects such stone (production of 1 ton of dimension stone yields,
as bridges require careful engineering – geological on the average, 5 tons of aggregate: Smith, 1999;
analyses, it is less well known that much simpler Selonen et al., 2001). Nowadays, uncrushed materials
geological products such as aggregates also require a (scree, gravel, sand: Fig. 1) are sometimes also
good insight into their properties if problems are to be included, because rounded particles are for many
avoided. purposes more suitable than angular fragments. Some-
It seems, however, that particularly aggregate is times, indeed, but not always: this makes it difficult to
considered by non-geologists (but possibly also by compare figures from different sources with one
part of the professional earth-science community) as a another. The lack of strict terminology seems typical
product that hardly needs any expertise. However for the geological discipline that is most involved in
simple this geological product may be, it needs just aggregate research and application: engineering geol-
as much attention, for almost each application, as ogy. This discipline, at the crossroads of geology and
arrow heads needed in prehistoric time. Bill Langer engineering, is aimed at practice rather than at science
(USGS) stated in this respect at the Aggregate 2001 with its need of unambiguous definitions. However
conference (Helsinki): ‘‘nothing is as simple as it practical this approach may seem, such a practice-
seems, and certainly not aggregates’’. It seems there- oriented attitude has certain disadvantages: the lack of
fore justified to mention here, as an example of how clear definitions (although classification systems do
complex even seemingly simple geology can be, some exist; see, among others, Barton et al., 1974) gives
aspects of aggregates. frequently rise to misunderstandings and, conse-
quently, to products that lack optimum properties,
and thus may lead to hazardous situations.
2. Aggregate One may wonder what can go wrong with the
application of aggregate. This depends, obviously, on
The term ‘aggregate’ (Primel and Tourenq, 2000) the combination of aggregate type and intended appli-
was originally used exclusively for crushed rock, cation. The product is used for a wide variety of
sometimes produced as a by-product of dimension purposes, such as filling for concrete and road-con-

Fig. 1. Storage area (with heaps of different grain sizes) near the exploitation site of aggregate in the form of alluvial blocks, boulders, cobbles,
pebbles and sand of varying roundness. Just north of Kaikoura (New Zealand).
A.J. van Loon / Earth-Science Reviews 59 (2002) 287–295 289

struction material (e.g., asphalt), railway ballast, water domestic waste, or coal ashes: Chun et al., 2001),
defence (Fig. 2), and pipeline bedding. These applica- which could have the advantage of a product with
tions seem simple, and not requiring many specific exactly the properties needed for a specific purpose.
characteristics of the aggregate, but the opposite is true: Thus far, however, such a replacement is only rarely
aggregate with properties that do not meet strict speci- economically feasible and, moreover, there is still a
fications may fail to fulfill their tasks. It is of utmost lack of knowledge concerning the optimum aggregate
importance to recognise this, because aggregates are properties for specific applications, as detailed by
produced and ‘consumed’ in huge quantities: only in Prof. Raimo Matikainen (director of the Geological
Europe, the yearly production is 2  109 tons/year, and Survey of Finland) during his opening speech at
in Great Britain, it is even the largest industry if measured ‘Aggregate 2001’.
by product weight (Hawkins, personal communication,
2001). This is one of the main reasons why the Interna-
tional Association of Engineering Geologists (IAEG) 3. Economic and social importance
started some years ago with (mostly bi-annual) confer-
ences about aggregate. The ‘Aggregate 2001’ Confer- Aggregate is used in huge quantities. In Finland,
ence held in Helsinki (Kuula-Väisänen and Uusinoka, for instance, the ‘consumption’ amounts to 11 ton per
2001) was a successful example. capita per year (Tuomo Laitinen, in a keynote address
New research results on aggregate (economical, at ‘Aggregate 2001’). Crushed rock makes up 19
technical, environmental, political) can be exchanged million tons, gravel some 37 million tons. The aggre-
at the IAEG meetings, and good and bad results gate is used for road pavements (40%), construction
obtained in practice can be discussed. Other important of houses (25%), concrete (12%), asphalt (10%) and a
aspects dealt with at these meetings are the develop- number of other purposes (13%). The value of the
ment of new production sites, and the rehabilitation of yearly production is some o 200 million; including
abandoned sites (Rintala et al., 2001). Much attention transport, it is 50% more.
is also paid to the application of new research techni- Finland is a country with relatively few inhabitants.
ques, including the replacement of aggregate by If the production of aggregate is so high there, it
artificial materials (such as treated ashes of burnt should be much larger in a country such as the US. It

Fig. 2. Application of crushed rock of decimeter size as surface layer of the dam of a reservoir lake near Cooma (Australia).
290 A.J. van Loon / Earth-Science Reviews 59 (2002) 287–295

is: recent figures are not available, but the value of the be realized that golf courses, situated on sites where
aggregate produced in 1990 amounted already to US$ previous aggregate mines have been filled up with
9.1 billion. Also, the demand is still growing: it has waste, may pose problems in the future (in some
quadrupled since 1950 (Bichler and Bobrowski, 2001) lowland countries such as The Netherlands, new golf
and will continue to grow (Persson, 2001). The courses are commonly constructed on sites where
consequence of such a huge demand is that almost domestic - and sometimes even chemical - waste has
innumerable sites must be found for the mining of been piled up, and this has already resulted in serious
aggregate, and that many of these sites have large problems, but an even less understandable situation
dimensions. It is estimated (Bichler and Bobrowski, was created in the community of Golden - near
2001) that a million acres were used in the US for Denver, Colorado - where a new golf course was
aggregate production since 1950. Only some 30% of scheduled to be constructed around a site with famous
this area has been reclaimed afterwards, which implies traces of ceratopsid dinosaurs, which were to be
that some 700,000 acres have been left behind without protected against golf balls by covering the rock walls
any measures having been taken for reclamation, with these traces with domestic waste: Dalton, 2001).
following the ‘time heals all’ approach that is adhered An interesting approach was followed in Czechia,
to in a large number of countries. This has led to where in Tata, some 70 km NW of Budapest, an area
hardly acceptable situations, such as waste dumping with several abandoned quarries has been transformed
(either legally or illegally) in abandoned pits, which into a ‘geological garden’ of some 7.5 acres, managed
reduces the chances of later re-use of the area, but by the Eötvös Loránd University. The park, which is
which may also immediately pollute the groundwater. open for the public from April to October, is annually
It is true that this ‘time heals all’ approach is not visited by some 6000– 7000 people, who are informed
followed everywhere, nor always. In the US, for about the local geology, the natural resources of the
instance, much effort is put in feasible solutions, area, the prehistoric occupation, and the earlier quar-
which range from the reshaping of abandoned sites rying activities (Haas and Hámor, 2001).
into parks, golf courses, and water recreation areas, or It may be true that other countries also try to reduce
playing areas for children. In this framework, it should the negative effect of aggregate mining, but the cost

Fig. 3. Huge volumes of aggregate are available in mountain ranges (such as here in the Ötz valley, Austrian Alps), but such ‘reserves’ are
commonly too far away from places with a demand for aggregate to allow economically feasible large-scale exploitation.
A.J. van Loon / Earth-Science Reviews 59 (2002) 287–295 291

involved is sometimes prohibitive for less-industrial- removed - always by manpower, commonly by a


ized countries. This holds, for instance, for China. group of villagers. Showers also caused gullies by
Beijing, as a representative example, is situated on the superficial runnoff, and these gullies had to be filled
margin of a hilly area, where much sand and gravel is up. This latter job was easy: the man took some
locally being exploited by citizens, for an important crumbled shale with a spade from the abundant
part in small, illegal pits. Since the local people have nearby exposures (Van Loon, 1972), filled up the
no money for rehabilitation, these pits tend to be filled gullies, and thus made the road more or less smooth
up illegally with domestic waste, with groundwater again. This was simple and, because there was hardly
pollution as a result (Prof. Wang Sijing, President of any traffic, usually sufficient to keep the road in order
the IAEG, during his opening address at ‘Aggregate until the next heavy rain. Then the whole procedure
2001’). The only feasible solution for this unfortunate started again.
situation in Beijing might be making aggregate avail- Such a simple use of aggregate is, obviously, not
able to the local population at a low cost (or for free), efficient for road construction and maintenance if
so that illegal exploitation of aggregate pits will stop. there is much traffic: the top layer of highways should
An entirely different but not less important prob- not be destroyed by a simple shower, and wearing by
lem is commonly met in densely populated areas, traffic should take as long as possible. These require-
where insufficient aggregate may be available. This is ments imply that the top layer of concrete or asphalt
one of the unfortunate characteristics of nature: aggre- roads should contain aggregate with specific charac-
gate is available in immense volumes in mountain teristics. This is not always sufficiently well under-
ranges (Fig. 3), but these areas need, particularly stood, particularly in regions where knowledge of
because of the generally low population density, hard rock is restricted. This was one of the reasons
relatively small amounts of aggregate. Coastal low- why a highway in The Netherlands, near Almere, had
lands, where aggregate is scarce, house commonly to be provided with a new top layer already before it
huge numbers of inhabitants that require giant vol- had been opened for the public (Verhoef, personal
umes of aggregate. The Netherlands, for instance, has communication, 2001). The authorities had decided
to import the great majority of the aggregate needed that the top layer should consist of so-called ‘very
from Germany. Where sand and gravel from river open asphalt concrete’, which has an average pore
courses or from alluvial plains are exploited in The volume of some 20%, and which is applied nowadays
Netherlands, the landscape is destroyed for many for the top layer of some 55% of highways in The
years (cf. Kondolf, 1998); since ‘green areas’ are Netherlands. The advantage of this porous material is
scarce in The Netherlands, plans for the exploitation that it diminishes the noise caused by the traffic, but
of sand and gravel from alluvial plains meet always also - and even more important - that rain water is
much social resistance and have sometimes to be largely drained through the pores, and not over the
given up. surface, thus making driving much more safe (less
aquaplaning). These advantages are accompanied,
however, by some disadvantages, among others a
4. The unknown properties of aggregate much more slippery surface than occurs on other
roads if icy, and a 200% higher volume of salt for
During my student time, I carried out fieldwork in keeping the road snowfree when it snows.
the Cantabrian Mountains (Spain), in an area were the The constructor of the road had, following a fairly
only throughroad was unpaved. This dust road was normal procedure, opted for aggregate (as filling
maintained by a man who every now and then walked material) that had been imported from Germany. It
along the road with a broom, wiping away the small turned out, however, that the asphalt showed
stones that had fallen on the road from the walls extremely rapidly ravelling (the loss of aggregate
alongside. After the scarce showers that took place, he particles from the surface, which thus loses its smooth
had to change his activities, because large stones and character; in addition, ravelling leads to the quick
even blocks might have fallen on the road; the stones destruction of the road’s top layer if traffic affects the
and particularly the blocks had, obviously, to be irregular surface). The reason for the quick ravelling
292 A.J. van Loon / Earth-Science Reviews 59 (2002) 287–295

was found immediately: the aggregate particles were devote much attention to them. This seems insuffi-
extremely soft. It appeared that the aggregate con- cient, however, to convince all those involved of the
sisted of a Devonian greywacke. The quarry where the complexity of this simple geological product.
aggregate came from, was examined and it was found
that exceptional weathering had affected the rock. The
unusual degree of weathering was due to a locally 5. The difficult aggregate characteristics
extremely high content of clay (60%), in combination
with an uncommonly frequent occurrence of joints. One might question why costly mistakes such as in
Although the aggregate filling of road asphalt should the above case history are so frequently made. The
be relatively easily wearable (in order to maintain answer to this question is almost as complex as
sufficient road roughness), the material chosen for the aggregate is.
Almere project had been too soft. The consequence A first reason is that exploitation of aggregates, in
was a considerable delay in the opening of the road, the form of both crushed rock and gravel or sand,
and a great financial loss. This illustrates well how always involves large volumes, and that the properties
important the right choice of an aggregate can be, with of aggregate are consequently not constant: crushed
properties between fairly narrow limits. However, it is rock from one side or one level in a quarry may be
not only the composition of the aggregate that plays a highly suitable for a specific purpose, whereas rocks
role: choosing the right grain-size distribution is from another place may not. This is one of the reasons
equally important. This is why sites, where rocks why igneous rocks are often preferred: their properties
are crushed or where sand/gravel mixtures are may remain fairly constant over relatively large dis-
exploited, are characterised by the presence of sorting tances; such rocks are, however, not available at most
equipment (Fig. 4). places.
The ‘Almere story’ is just one example of the many A second reason is that there is still little known
that could be given concerning projects that do not about the physical and chemical properties of aggre-
develop according to the time schedule and the gate, and about the influence of these parameters on
financial planning, as a result of insufficient insight the suitability of specific aggregate types for particular
into aggregate characteristics. In each country, indus- applications. During the past few years, much atten-
trialized or not, such projects abound, and newspapers tion has been paid to the relationships between proper-

Fig. 4. Equipment for grain-size sorting in the Jansen quarry near Uelsen (Germany).
A.J. van Loon / Earth-Science Reviews 59 (2002) 287–295 293

ties and quality, but it became obvious during the scheduled application needed salt-free aggregate.
‘Aggregate 2000’ conference, from both presentations Consequences were infrastructural works that had to
and discussions, that the experts do not (yet) agree. be repaired or even replaced soon because of insuffi-
Whereas Brian Hawkins defended ‘traditional’ tests cient quality.
for the characterisation of aggregate, others pointed
out that these tests are not always useful, and rarely
reliable. In a discussion at the ‘Aggregate 2001’ 6. Much is being done, much more is to be done
conference, one of the conclusions about test results,
their statistical significance and the underlying quan- The great importance of aggregate for economy
titative data was that such results are, in the aggregate and society is increasingly recognised, and the neces-
industry, interesting for lawyers rather than engineers. sity of choosing the right type of aggregate therefore
This is because some properties may be easily defined gets ever more attention. This is reflected in the
for specific rock types on the basis of experiments research and experiments being carried out with
(e.g., the abrasion rate of mica-containing granite: respect to long-term durability (see, among others,
Tolppanen and Ebeling, 2001; or shape analysis: Khachadoorian, 2001; Lashkaripour, 2001) and envi-
Wang and Fernlund, 1994), but one should bear in ronmental impact (Dryden and Beer, 1999; Amaral,
mind that aggregate usually consists of a mixture of 2001; Bichler and Bobrowski, 2001; Langer and
rock types; in addition, the test results depend on the Kolm, 2001a,b).
sampling techniques, the laboratory equipment, the It seems that the impact on the environment, both
conditions during sampling (climate, temperature, during exploitation and after abandonment of quarries,
wind) and during the laboratory analysis (separation), gets relatively much attention. The result is that the
and even on the day of analysis (experiments show final impact may be small if thorough procedures are
that the personnel involved in the analysis signifi- followed (Box, 1998; Arbogast et al., 2001). This
cantly influences the test results: Klingberg, 2001). development is, beyond doubt, partly due to political
Even if test results would be reliable, this would not and social pressure. One can only enjoy this interest
automatically imply that it is clear what the results from third parties, because it shows that society
mean in practice, although some progress is reached becomes gradually more aware of the activities of
(Åkesson et al., in press). Bill Langer quoted Albert the aggregate industry. Such increasing interest can,
Einstein: ‘‘Not everything that can be counted counts, on the long term, only lead to a better understanding of
and not everything that counts can be counted’’. the problems that the industry is faced with. It is
The third important reason for costly problems is therefore to be expected that future policies will take
the ignorance of authorities. It happens that authorities the need for large aggregate volumes in account in a
prescribe that material from one specific location must more structural way than happened in the past decades.
be used for a specific project somewhere else. Such Much less positive seems the development of
prescriptions are commonly based on either low cost methods aimed at a more effective use of aggregate,
(for instance, because one project—such as the low- for instance, by avoiding unnecessarily early repairs
ering of an alluvial plane in order to increase the river due to the wrong choice of aggregate. It has to be
discharge during flood phases—yields large volumes admitted that testing of aggregate properties has
of sand), or environmental considerations (e.g., be- become routine in many countries, but it must also
cause a pressure group opposes against a previously be stressed that the value of these tests is questioned
scheduled site for gravel extraction). In densely popu- by many experts, and that the interpretation of the test
lated areas, it may also be extremely difficult to results is often subjective, and that it is still difficult to
appoint suitable places for aggregate exploitation. predict the behaviour of the tested aggregate under
One of the consequences is that it has happened practice conditions. This is remarkable, considering
numerous times that politicians in coastal areas stated the fact that such high costs are involved in failing
that sufficient aggregate for large infrastructural works infrastructural (and other) works. It seems likely that
was available, viz. in the form of gravel and/or sand the pressure exerted on the aggregate industry by
from shallow-sea bottoms, even in cases where the politicians, customers and public is not (yet) strong
294 A.J. van Loon / Earth-Science Reviews 59 (2002) 287–295

Fig. 5. Characteristic small-scale aggregate quarry (near Christchurch, New Zealand).

enough to result in optimum efforts to get a better Technology) for their hospitality and their help during
insight into the relationship between aggregate phys- the conference.
ical and chemical properties on one hand and func-
tionality in practice on the other hand. Obviously, References
owners of small quarries (Fig. 5) will not be able to
spend money on high-tech research, but large aggre- Åkesson, U., Lundqvist, J.E., Göransson, M., Stigh, J. (2002). Re-
gate-producing companies could - and should - do lationship between texture and mechanical properties of gran-
more than wait for universities and geological surveys ites, central Sweden, by use of image-analysing technique.
to carry out such research. Could it be that the lack of Bulletin of Engineering Geology and the Environment, 60,
277 – 284.
pressure from the side of authorities is partly due to Amaral, C., 2001. The influence of aggregate production and aban-
the - unjustified - idea that all rocks are equal? In this doned quarries on landslide distribution in Rio de Janeiro. In:
case, it seems worthwhile for the aggregate industry - Kuula-Väisänen, P., Uusinoka, R. (Eds.), Proceedings of Aggre-
however paradoxically this may sound considering the gate 2001—Environment and Economy (Helsinki, 2001). Tam-
pere University of Technology, Laboratory of Engineering
cost of research involved - to convince the authorities
Geology Publ. 50, vol. 2, pp. 359 – 369.
and customers that some rocks are more equal than Arbogast, B., Knepper Jr., D.H., Melick, R.A., 2001. Reading, re-
others. This was already generally recognised by our membering, and reshaping the past: clear Creek, Colorado. In:
prehistoric ancestors, who had so much less sophisti- Kuula-Väisänen, P., Uusinoka, R. (Eds.), Proceedings of Aggre-
cated equipment, but who were so well aware of the gate 2001—Environment and Economy (Helsinki, 2001). Tam-
variability found in nature. pere University of Technology, Laboratory of Engineering Geol-
ogy Publ. 50, vol. 2, pp. 371 – 376.
Barton, N., Lien, R., Lunde, J., 1974. Engineering classification of
rock masses for the design of tunnel support. Rock Mechanics 6,
Acknowledgements 189 – 236.
Bichler, A.J., Bobrowski, P.T., 2001. Sand, gravel and their com-
I want to thank the organisers of the ‘Aggregate munity: a look at North American reclamation practices. In:
Kuula-Väisänen, P., Uusinoka, R. (Eds.), Proceedings of Aggre-
2001’ conference, particularly Prof. Raimo Uusinoka gate 2001—Environment and Economy (Helsinki, 2001). Tam-
and Ms. Pirjo Kuula-Väisänen (both of the Laboratory pere University of Technology, Laboratory of Engineering Geol-
of Engineering Geology of Tampere University of ogy Publ. 50, vol. 2, pp. 341 – 358.
A.J. van Loon / Earth-Science Reviews 59 (2002) 287–295 295

Box, J., 1998. Setting and monitoring for ecological restoration and Lashkaripour, G.R., 2001. Shale as a construction material and its
habitat creation. In: Fox, R.H., Moore, H.M., McIntosh, A.D. durability problems. In: Kuula-Väisänen, P., Uusinoka, R.
(Eds.), Land Reclamation: Achieving Sustainable Benefits. Bal- (Eds.), Proceedings of Aggregate 2001—Environment and Econ-
kema, Rotterdam, pp. 7 – 20. omy (Helsinki, 2001). Tampere University of Technology, Labo-
Chun, B.-S., Ko, K.-S., Jung, H.-C., 2001. A study on the recycling of ratory of Engineering Geology Publ. 50, vol. 1, pp. 291 – 295.
coal ash as fill materials. In: Kuula-Väisänen, P., Uusinoka, R. Persson, L., 2001. The geology of aggregates. Prospecting and lo-
(Eds.), Proceedings of Aggregate 2001—Environment and Econ- calization of raw materials for aggregate production. In: Kuula-
omy (Helsinki, 2001). Tampere University of Technology, Labo- Väisänen, P., Uusinoka, R. (Eds.), Proceedings of Aggregate
ratory of Engineering Geology Publ. 50, vol. 2, pp. 471 – 477. 2001—Environment and Economy (Helsinki, 2001). Tampere
Dalton, R., 2001. Golf course threatens to leave hole in fossil re- University of Technology, Laboratory of Engineering Geology
cords. Nature 412, 572. Publ. 50, vol. 1, pp. 143 – 153.
Dryden, P., Beer, T., 1999. Environmental risk management. Envi- Primel, L., Tourenq, C. (Eds.), 2000. Aggregates. Balkema, Rotter-
ronment Australia. Dept. Environment and Heritage, Canberra, dam, 590 pp.
78 pp. Rintala, J., Rönkä, E., Britshgi, R., Nieminen, P., Niskanen, P.,
Haas, J., Hámor, G., 2001. Geological garden in the neighborhood 2001. Rehabilitation of extracted gravel sites—the role of top-
of Budapest, Hungary. Episodes 24, 257 – 261. soil material. In: Kuula-Väisänen, P., Uusinoka, R. (Eds.), Pro-
Khachadoorian, B., 2001. Some experimental results from using ceedings of Aggregate 2001—Environment and Economy
minerals in mortar. In: Kuula-Väisänen, P., Uusinoka, R. (Eds.), (Helsinki, 2001). Tampere University of Technology, Labora-
Proceedings of Aggregate 2001—Environment and Economy tory of Engineering Geology Publ. 50, vol. 2, pp. 429 – 434.
(Helsinki, 2001). Tampere University of Technology, Labora- Röshoff, K., Ekdahl, U., Hudson, J.A., Cosgrove, J.W., 2002. Rock
tory of Engineering Geology Publ. 50, vol. 1, pp. 287 – 290. property estimation and stabilization measures for the western
Klingberg, A., 2001. The variations of the characteristics in the foundation of the Traneberg Bridge, Stockholm, Sweden. Pro-
aggregate production industry. In: Kuula-Väisänen, P., Uusino- ceedings NARMS-Tac Conference (Toronto, July 2002) (in
ka, R. (Eds.), Proceedings of Aggregate 2001—Environment press).
and Economy (Helsinki, 2001). Tampere University of Tech- Selonen, O., Ramsay, A., Tolvanen, P., 2001. Use of by-product of
nology, Laboratory of Engineering Geology Publ. 50, vol. 1, dimension stone quarries. In: Kuula-Väisänen, P., Uusinoka, R.
pp. 181 – 188. (Eds.), Proceedings of Aggregate 2001—Environment and Econ-
Kondolf, M.G., 1998. Environmental effects of aggregate extraction omy (Helsinki, 2001). Tampere University of Technology, Labo-
from river channels. In: Bobrowski, P.T. (Ed.), Aggregate Resour- ratory of Engineering Geology Publ. 50, vol. 1, pp. 231 – 235.
ces: A Global Perspective. Balkema, Rotterdam, pp. 113 – 130. Smith, M.R. (Ed.), 1999. Stone: Building Stone, Rock Fill and
Kuula-Väisänen, P., Uusinoka, R. (Eds.), 2001. Proceedings of Ag- Armourstone in Construction. Geological Society London En-
gregate 2001—Environment and Economy (Helsinki, 2001). gineering Geology Special Publication, vol. 16, 478 pp.
Tampere University of Technology, Laboratory of Engineering Tolppanen, P., Ebeling, P., 2001. Analytical characterization of ag-
Geology Publ. 50, vol. 3. gregate degradation. In: Kuula-Väisänen, P., Uusinoka, R. (Eds.),
Langer, W., Kolm, K.E., 2001a. A systems approach to characterize Proceedings of Aggregate 2001—Environment and Economy
and evaluate environmental impacts from aggregate mining. In: (Helsinki, 2001). Tampere University of Technology, Laboratory
Kuula-Väisänen, P., Uusinoka, R. (Eds.), Proceedings of Aggre- of Engineering Geology Publ. 50, vol. 1, pp. 237 – 244.
gate 2001—Environment and Economy (Helsinki, 2001). Tam- Van Loon, A.J., 1972. A prograding deltaic complex in the Upper
pere University of Technology, Laboratory of Engineering Carboniferous of the Cantabrian Mountains (Spain): the Prioro-
Geology Publ. 50, vol. 2, pp. 401 – 405. Tejerina Basin. Leidse Geologische Mededelingen 48, 1 – 48.
Langer, W., Kolm, K.E., 2001b. Hierarchical systems analysis of Wang, W.X., Fernlund, J., 1994. Shape analysis for aggregates.
potential environmental impacts from aggregate mining activ- Division of Engineering Geology, Royal Institute of Technology
ities. Proceedings Annual Meeting Society of Mining, Metal- (Stockholm) KHT Ballast Report 2.
lurgy and Exploration (Denver, 2001), 1 – 103, SMME,
Littleton, CO, 10 pp.

You might also like