Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Editorial Board
M. Avellaneda
G. Barone-Adesi
M. Broadie
M.H.A. Davis
E. Derman
C. Klüppelberg
E. Kopp
W. Schachermayer
Springer Finance
Ammann M., Credit Risk Valuation: Methods, Models, and Application (2001)
Back K., A Course in Derivative Securities: Introduction to Theory and Computation
(2005)
Barucci E., Financial Markets Theory. Equilibrium, Efficiency and Information (2003)
Bielecki T.R. and Rutkowski M., Credit Risk: Modeling, Valuation and Hedging (2002)
Bingham N.H. and Kiesel R., Risk-Neutral Valuation: Pricing and Hedging of Financial
Derivatives (1998, 2nd ed. 2004)
Brigo D. and Mercurio F., Interest Rate Models: Theory and Practice
(2001, 2nd ed. 2006)
Buff R., Uncertain Volatility Models-Theory and Application (2002)
Carmona R.A. and Tehranchi M.R., Interest Rate Models: an Infinite Dimensional
Stochastic Analysis Perspective (2006)
Dana R.A. and Jeanblanc M., Financial Markets in Continuous Time (2002)
Deboeck G. and Kohonen T. (Editors), Visual Explorations in Finance with
Self-Organizing Maps (1998)
Delbaen F. and Schachermayer W., The Mathematics of Arbitrage (2005)
Elliott R.J. and Kopp P.E., Mathematics of Financial Markets (1999, 2nd ed. 2005)
Fengler M.R., Semiparametric Modeling of Implied Volatility (2005)
Geman H., Madan D., Pliska S.R. and Vorst T. (Editors), Mathematical
Finance–Bachelier Congress 2000 (2001)
Gundlach M., Lehrbass F. (Editors), CreditRisk+ in the Banking Industry (2004)
Kellerhals B.P., Asset Pricing (2004)
Külpmann M., Irrational Exuberance Reconsidered (2004)
Kwok Y.-K., Mathematical Models of Financial Derivatives (1998)
Malliavin P. and Thalmaier A., Stochastic Calculus of Variations in Mathematical
Finance (2005)
Meucci A., Risk and Asset Allocation (2005)
Pelsser A., Efficient Methods for Valuing Interest Rate Derivatives (2000)
Prigent J.-L., Weak Convergence of Financial Markets (2003)
Schmid B., Credit Risk Pricing Models (2004)
Shreve S.E., Stochastic Calculus for Finance I (2004)
Shreve S.E., Stochastic Calculus for Finance II (2004)
Yor M., Exponential Functionals of Brownian Motion and Related Processes (2001)
Zagst R., Interest-Rate Management (2002)
Zhu Y.-L., Wu X., Chern I.-L., Derivative Securities and Difference Methods (2004)
Ziegler A., Incomplete Information and Heterogeneous Beliefs in Continuous-time
Finance (2003)
Ziegler A., A Game Theory Analysis of Options (2004)
Eric Jondeau, Ser-Huang Poon
and Michael Rockinger
Michael Rockinger
University of Lausanne and Swiss
Finance Institute
HEC-Department of Finance and
Insurance
CH-1015 Lausanne-Dorigny
Switzerland
Apart from any fair dealing for the purposes of research or private study, or criticism or review, as
permitted under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, this publication may only be
reproduced, stored or transmitted, in any form or by any means, with the prior permission in writing
of the publishers, or in the case of reprographic reproduction in accordance with the terms of licences
issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency. Enquiries concerning reproduction outside those terms
should be sent to the publishers.
The use of registered names, trademarks, etc. in this publication does not imply, even in the absence
of a specific statement, that such names are exempt from the relevant laws and regulations and
therefore free for general use.
The publisher makes no representation, express or implied, with regard to the accuracy of the
information contained in this book and cannot accept any legal responsibility or liability for any errors
or omissions that may be made.
9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
(< .B?.
@LIG )C=B;?F .I=ECHA?L
";./*,.
;H> BOA?FS GCMJLC=?> >?LCP;NCP? JLI>O=NM *IH#;OMMC;H >CMNLC<ONCIHM ;L? NB?
E?S NB?G? I@ NBCM <IIE
QBC=B ;>>L?MM?M NB? =;OM?M ;H> NB? =IHM?KO?H=?M I@
HIHHILG;FCNS I@ ;MM?N L?NOLHM
+NB?L <IIEM CH NBCM W?F> CH=FO>? ;GJ<?FF
(I
;H> );=ECHF;S
;H> !G<L?=BNM
'FkJJ?F<?LA
;H> )CEIM=B %H L?F;N?> W?F>M
IH? G;S
;FMI =CN? #IOLCfLIOR ;H> &;MC;E
0M;S
;H> 0;SFIL +H
IJNCIH JLC=CHA
Q? B;P? NB? <IIE I@ /=BION?HM
;H> I@ IHN ;H> 0;HEIP
FF NB?M? <IIEM ;L? =IGJF?G?HN;LS NI NBCM IH? ;H> ;L? OM?@OF @IL
OH>?LMN;H>CHA MIG? ;MJ?=NM I@ NB? GI>?FCHA I@ ;MM?N L?NOLHM IL IJNCIH JLC=?M
%H NBCM <IIE
Q? =IP?L ; QC>? L;HA? I@ CMMO?M NB;N ;L? L?MOFNCHA @LIG HIH
HILG;FCNS ;H> NCG? >?J?H>?H=S I@ <INB ;MM?N L?NOLHM ;H> IJNCIH JLC=?M
0B? <IIE CM QLCNN?H @IL HIHG;NB?G;NC=C;HM QBI Q;HN NI GI>?F WH;H
=C;F G;LE?N JLC=?M %NM ?GJB;MCM CM IH JL;=NC=? 3? QILE?> B;L> NI G;E? NB?
G;N?LC;FM ;==?MMC<F? NI HIHG;NB?G;NC=C;HM <ON ;N NB? M;G? NCG? HIN NI M;=
LCW=? NB? G;NB?G;NC=;F LCAIL ;H> NB? =IGJF?RCNS I@ NB? ILCACH;F GI>?FM 0BCM
<IIE N;LA?NM JL;=NCNCIH?LM CH NB? WH;H=? CH>OMNLS ;H> ?MJ?=C;FFS NBIM? QBI
=;FF NB?GM?FP?M %B.;A ;H> B;P? NB? L?MJIHMC<CFCNS I@ G;H;ACHA JILN@IFCIM ;H>
GIHCNILCHA WH;H=C;F LCME 3? ;FMI BIJ? NB? ;<A@<%B.;A J?IJF? QCFF WH> NBCM
<IIE OM?@OF CH OH>?LMN;H>CHA NB? GSNB I@ ?<082A @062;A6@A@J CHPIFP?G?HN CH
KO;HNCN;NCP? WH;H=? 0BCM <IIE CM MOCN;<F? @IL OM? ;M ; =IL? N?RN @IL MJ?=C;FCMN
)/= ;H> ,B MNO>?HNM CH !GJCLC=;F "CH;H=?
"CH;H=C;F !=IHIG?NLC=M ;H>
2%%% ,L?@;=?
+H? I@ IOL G;CH ;CGM CM NI <LC>A? NB? A;J <?NQ??H NB? NB?IL?NC=;F >?P?FIJ
G?HNM ;H> NB? JL;=NC=;F CGJF?G?HN;NCIHM I@ QB;N G;HS OM?LM ;H> L?M?;L=B?LM
J?L=?CP?> ;M [MIJBCMNC=;N?>\ GI>?FM IL <F;=E <IR?M 3? I_?L G;HS ?GJCLC=;F
CFFOMNL;NCIHM I@ NB? GI>?FM >?M=LC<?> CH NBCM <IIE
;H> ?MJ?=C;FFS NBIM? >?P?F
IJ?> CH ,;LNM %% ;H> %%% FNBIOAB Q? OM? IHFS ; MG;FF =IFF?=NCIH I@ MNI=E
G;LE?N >;N; CH NB?M? ?R;GJF?M >O? NI NB? MJ;=? =IHMNL;CHN
G;HS I@ NB? N?=B
HCKO?M ;H> GI>?FM >?M=LC<?> B?L? =IOF> ?KO;FFS <? ;JJFC?> NI INB?L WH;H=C;F
NCG? M?LC?M
MO=B ;M ?R=B;HA? ;H> CHN?L?MN L;N?M ON CN CM CGJILN;HN NI L?G?G
<?L NB;N GI>?FM ;L? G?;HN NI =;JNOL? MNSFCT?> @;=NM C_?L?HN NSJ?M I@ WH;H=C;F
;MM?NM G;S B;P? MFCABNFS IL P?LS >C_?L?HN =B;L;=N?LCMNC=M HINB?L >CM=F;CG?L
CM I@ CGJILN;H=? FNBIOAB Q? ;LAO? ;H> JLIPC>? ?PC>?H=? NB;N NB?L? CM ; H??>
NI CH=ILJIL;N? HIHHILG;FCNS ;H> NCG? >?J?H>?H=S CH NB? GI>?FCHA I@ ;MM?N
L?NOLHM
Q? >I HIN MOAA?MN NB;N NBCM MBIOF> ;FQ;SM <? NB? =;M? )IL?IP?L
Q?
QIOF> HIN <? B?F> L?MJIHMC<F? @IL ;HS JLI<F?G NB? L?;>?L G;S ?H=IOHN?L CH
NB? CGJF?G?HN;NCIH I@ NB?M? N?=BHCKO?M
"CH;FFS
;FF NB? WAOL?M ;H> ?MNCG;NCIHM L?JILN?> CH NBCM <IIE B;P? <??H
JLI>O=?> OMCHA )0( 0BCM MI@NQ;L? JLIPC>?M ; P?LS ?^=C?HN IJNCGCT;
NCIH LIONCH?
;H> Q? B;P? G;>? ;P;CF;<F? IH IOL Q?< MCN?M G;HS )0(
=I>?M NB;N ;L? OM?> CH NBCM <IIE
!LC= &IH>?;O ;H> )C=B;?F .I=ECHA?L <INB Q;HN NI NB;HE NB? !=IF? >?M
$! I@ NB? 1HCP?LMCNS I@ (;OM;HH?
NB? %HN?LH;NCIH;F ?HN?L @IL "CH;H=C;F
MM?N );H;A?G?HN ;H> !HACH??LCHA ")!
;H> NB? /QCMM "CH;H=? %HMNCNON?
/"% @IL NB?CL =IHMN;HN MOJJILN 0B?S NB;HE G;HS A?H?L;NCIHM I@ )/= ;H>
,B MNO>?HNM @IL NB? G;HS >CM=OMMCIHM
=IGG?HNM ;H> KO?MNCIHM /?L$O;HA
,IIH Q;HNM NI NB;HE NB? );H=B?MN?L OMCH?MM /=BIIF
;H> NB? );H=B?MN?L
==IOHNCHA ;H> "CH;H=? #LIOJ CH J;LNC=OF;L
@IL JLIPC>CHA GO=B MOJJILN
;CFS >;N; OM?> CH NBCM <IIE =IG?M @LIG ;N;MNL?;G
;H> CHNL;>;CFS >;N; =IG?M
@LIG NB? !OLIH?RN ,;LCM >;N;M?N
)0( = CM ; L?ACMN?L?> NL;>?G;LE I@ 0B? );NB3ILEM
%H= "IL )0
( JLI>O=N CH@ILG;NCIH
JF?;M? =IHN;=N 0B? );NB3ILEM
%H= JJF?
$CFF LCP?
*;NC=E
)
1/ !G;CF CH@IG;NBQILEM=IG 3?<
QQQG;NBQILEM=IG
,L?@;=? %4
/B? Q;HNM NI NB;HE ;FMI B?L MNO>?HNM @IL G;HS MNCGOF;NCHA >CM=OMMCIHM ;H>
ALCFFCHA L?;>CHA =F;MM?M FF NBL?? ;ONBILM ?RJL?MM NB?CL AL;NCNO>? NI (;OL;
.I=ECHA?L @IL L?;>CHA NB? ?HNCL? G;HOM=LCJN ;H> =ILL?=NCHA G;HS GCMN;E?M
3? ?RJL?MM IOL NB;HEM NI G;HS INB?L J?IJF?
=IFF?;AO?M
@LC?H>M
;H> @;GCFS
NI QBIG Q? ;L? GIMN AL;N?@OF @IL NB?CL MOJJILN 0B?S ;L? NII G;HS NI H;G?
B?L?
!LC= &IH>?;O
/?L$O;HA ,IIH
;H> )C=B;?F .I=ECHA?L
OAOMN
98>/8>=
8><9.?->398
"CH;H=C;F G;LE?NM ;H> WH;H=C;F NCG? M?LC?M
!=IHIG?NLC= GI>?FCHA I@ ;MM?N L?NOLHM
JJFC=;NCIHM I@ HIH#;OMMC;H ?=IHIG?NLC=M
+JNCIH JLC=CHA QCNB HIH#;OMMC;H >CMNLC<ONCIHM
9./6381 )96+>363>C
2IF;NCFCNS ;N FIQ?L @L?KO?H=C?M
.$ GI>?F
"IL?=;MNCHA
'OLNIMCM I@ ;H .$ GI>?F
0?MNCHA @IL .$ ?_?=NM
.$CHG?;H GI>?F
%FFOMNL;NCIH
#.$ GI>?F
"IL?=;MNCHA
%HN?AL;N?> #.$ GI>?F
!MNCG;NCIH
0?MNCHA @IL #.$ ?_?=NM
/I@NQ;L? NI ?MNCG;N? .$ ;H> #.$ GI>?FM
%FFOMNL;NCIH
MSGG?NLC= #.$ GI>?FM
!#.$ GI>?F
0#.$ GI>?F
IHN?HNM 4%%%
#&. GI>?F
IRIR NL;HM@ILG
*?QM CGJ;=N =OLP?
,;LNC;FFS HIHJ;L;G?NLC= ?MNCG;NCIH
0?MNCHA @IL ;MSGG?NLC= ?_?=NM
%FFOMNL;NCIH
#.$ GI>?F QCNB DOGJM
GI>?F QCNB NCG?P;LSCHA DOGJ CHN?HMCNS
H ?GJCLC=;F CFFOMNL;NCIH
AAL?A;NCIH I@ #.$ JLI=?MM?M
0?GJIL;F ;AAL?A;NCIH
LIMMM?=NCIH;F ;AAL?A;NCIH
!MNCG;NCIH I@ NB? Q?;E #.$ JLI=?MM
/NI=B;MNC= PIF;NCFCNS
"LIG #.$ GI>?FM NI MNI=B;MNC= PIF;NCFCNS GI>?FM
!MNCG;NCIH I@ NB? >CM=L?N? NCG? /2 GI>?F
.?;FCT?> PIF;NCFCNS
0B? >C^=OFNS NI >CM?HN;HAF? DOGJM
-O;>L;NC= P;LC;NCIH
,IQ?L P;LC;NCIH
CJIQ?L P;LC;NCIH
!MNCG;NCIH IP?L WHCN? NCG? CHN?LP;FM
.?;FCT?> =IP;LC;H=?
"OLNB?L L?F;N?> L?MOFNM
&><?->?<+6 ":>398 #<3-381
/NI=B;MNC= PIF;NCFCNS GI>?F
0B? MKO;L? LIIN JLI=?MM
/IFPCHA NB? , ! <;M?> IH =B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH
H?Q J;LNC;F >C_?L?HNC;F ?KO;NCIH
+JNCIH JLC=CHA QCNB MNI=B;MNC= PIF;NCFCNS
$OFF ;H> 3BCN?
$?MNIH
B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH I@ NB? /2 GI>?F
"OLNB?L CHMCABNM
)I>?FM QCNB DOGJM
/NI=B;MNC= JLI=?MM QCNB DOGJM
C_OMCIH QCNB >IO<F? ?RJIH?HNC;F DOGJM
IG<CHCHA MNI=B;MNC= PIF;NCFCNS QCNB DOGJM
&OGJS ;^H? GI>?FM
)I>?FM QCNB ?P?H QCF>?L DOGJM (fPS IJNCIH JLC=CHA
IHN?HNM 42%%
%/0/</8-/=
8./B
"*;=
0BCM <IIE CM ;<ION NB? GI>?FCHA I@ ;MM?N L?NOLHM QB?H NB? HILG;FCNS ;MMOGJ
NCIH >I?M HIN ;JJFS %N JLIPC>?M ;H OJNI>;N? ;H> MN?J<SMN?J >?M=LCJNCIH
I@ NB? NIIFM NB;N ;L? OM?@OF @IL NB? GI>?FCHA I@ HIH#;OMMC;H ;MM?N L?NOLH
>CMNLC<ONCIHM ;H> @IL IJNCIH JLC=CHA CH NB? HIH#;OMMC;H =IHN?RN
;<MIFON? L?NOLHM
;H> ;FF G?;MOL?M ;H> JLIRC?M I@ PIF;NCFCNS ?RBC<CN MNLIHA
M?LC;F =ILL?F;NCIH 0BCM CM HIQ EHIQH ;M PIF;NCFCNS =FOMN?LCHA IL =IH>CNCIH;F
B?N?LIME?>;MNC=CNS !HAF?
"CH;H=C;F GI>?FCHA CM ;FF ;<ION =;JNOLCHA ;H> ?RJFICNCHA J;NN?LHM CH NB?
>;N; CH=FO>CHA NB? NQI JB?HIG?H; G?HNCIH?> ;<IP? B;JN?L >CM=OMM?M NB?
OHCKO? MN;NCMNC=;F JLIJ?LNC?M I@ WH;H=C;F G;LE?N >;N; ;H> M?P?L;F MI=;FF?>
MNSFCT?> @;=NM 0B?M? MNSFCT?> @;=NM QCFF <? NB? <;MCM @IL ,;LN %% QB?L? ?;=B
=B;JN?L QCFF N;=EF? MIG? MJ?=CW= @?;NOL?M I@ WH;H=C;F G;LE?N L?NOLHM
B;JN?L >?M=LC<?M NB? ;=NO;F @OH=NCIHCHA ;H> NB? GC=LIMNLO=NOL? I@ W
H;H=C;F G;LE?NM $?L?
Q? JL?M?HN MIG? NB?IL?NC=;F GI>?FM NB;N G;S B?FJ
?RJF;CHCHA QBS ;MM?N L?NOLHM ;L? HIHHILG;F ;H> NCG? >?J?H>?HN 0B? @IOH>;
NCIH CM <OCFN IH F;LE QBI JIMNOF;N?M NB;N HIHHILG;FCNS ;H> PIF;NCFCNS
=FOMN?LCHA =IOF> <? >O? NI CHN?LGCNN?HN CH@ILG;NCIH ;LLCP;FM
%HNLI>O=NCIH
,8786.=;2, 68-.5270 8/ *<<.= ;.=>;7<
,;LN %% CM =IH=?LH?> QCNB NB? NCG? M?LC?M ;MJ?=NM I@ ;MM?N L?NOLHM B;JN?LM
;H> =IP?L GI>?FM @IL NB? M?=IH>
NBCL>
;H> @IOLNB GIG?HNM ;H> NB?
N;CFM I@ L?NOLH >CMNLC<ONCIHM 0B?M? BCAB?L GIG?HNM ;H> N;CF G?;MOL?M ;L? NB?
B;FFG;LEM I@ HIH#;OMMC;H >CMNLC<ONCIHM B;JN?L >?;FM QCNB NB? >?J?H>?H=?
MNLO=NOL? QB?H NB? BCAB?L GIG?HNM >CMJF;S MCAHCW=;HN >?J;LNOL? @LIG HILG;F
CNS ;H> L?NOLHM ;JJ?;L NI <? NCG? >?J?H>?HN 0B? >?J?H>?H=? ;GIHA NB? N;CF
I<M?LP;NCIHM
>?M=LC<?> CH B;JN?L
CM P?LS >C_?L?HN @LIG NB? >?J?H>?H=?
>?M=LC<?> CH B;JN?L
I@ NB? =?HNL;F ;H> G;CH J;LN I@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIHM
Q? ;FMI H??> GI>?FM @IL ME?QH?MM ;H> EOLNIMCM B;JN?L >I?M ?R;=NFS NB;N
<S WNNCHA NCG?P;LSCHA BCAB?LGIG?HN =IH>CNCIH;F GI>?FM NI L?NOLHM %N ;FMI
>?M=LC<?M N?MNM @IL NB? ;>?KO;=S I@ NB?M? =IH>CNCIH;F BCAB GIG?HN GI>?FM
B;JN?LM ;H> ;L? =IH=?LH?> QCNB OHCP;LC;N? NCG? M?LC?M =B;L;=N?LCM
NC=M B;JN?L MBC@NM NB? @I=OM NI NB? L?F;NCIHMBCJM <?NQ??H ;H> ;GIHA NB?
;MM?N L?NOLH M?LC?M 0BCM CHPIFP?M NQI G;CH N;MEM "CLMN
Q? B;P? NI ?RN?H> NB?
#.$ @;GCFS NI ; JIMMC<FS F;LA? HOG<?L I@ ;MM?NM CH IL>?L NI L?JLI>O=?
NB? DICHN >SH;GC= I@ PIF;NCFCNS /?=IH>
Q? B;P? NI =;JNOL? CH NBCM GOFNCP;LC;N?
@L;G?QILE NB? HIHHILG;FCNS I@ L?NOLHM $?L?
Q? GIP? @LIG ; GOFNCP;LC;N?
#.$ GI>?F QCNB HILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH NI IH? QCNB ME?Q?> /NO>?HN [ >CM
NLC<ONCIH NB;N CM >?MCAH?> NI =;JNOL? <INB @;NN;CF?>H?MM ;H> ;MSGG?NLS 3?
;FMI ?R;GCH? ;H ;FN?LH;NCP? ;JJLI;=B NB;N =CL=OGP?HNM MIG? >C^=OFNC?M CH >?
MCAHCHA ; GOFNCP;LC;N? >CMNLC<ONCIH 0B? MI=;FF?> =IJOF; ;JJLI;=B CM ; NIIF
NB;N CM ;<F? NI DICH ;HS NSJ? I@ G;LACH;F >CMNLC<ONCIH %N B;M G;HS NB?IL?NC=;F
;JJ?;FM ON CH G;HS WH;H=? ;JJFC=;NCIHM CH JL;=NC=?
CHN?AL;NCIH I@ NB? DICHN
>CMNLC<ONCIH CM H??>?> 0BCM =;HHIN <? >IH? ;H;FSNC=;FFS CH NB? =IJOF; ;J
JLI;=B ;H> QCFF <?=IG? GIL? ;H> GIL? =OG<?LMIG? ;M NB? HOG<?L I@ ;MM?NM
IL NB? >CG?HMCIH I@ NB? JLI<F?G CH=L?;M?M
B;JN?L JL?M?HNM ;H ;JJLI;=B NB;N CM P?LS >C_?L?HN @LIG ;FF NB? INB?L
=B;JN?LM CH NBCM J;LN %N >?;FM QCNB GI>?FM @IL IHFS NB? N;CFM I@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH
3? >?M=LC<? CH NBCM =B;JN?L P;LCIOM ;JJLI;=B?M @IL =B;L;=N?LCTCHA NB? <?B;PCIL
+JNCIH JLC=CHA QCNB HIH#;OMMC;H >CMNLC<ONCIHM
,;LN %2 >?;FM QCNB >?LCP;NCP? ;MM?NM ;H> =IHMC>?LM IJNCIH JLC=CHA QB?H NB?
OH>?LFSCHA ;MM?N L?NOLH B;M ; HIH#;OMMC;H >CMNLC<ONCIH 0B? M?GCH;F =IHNLC
<ONCIHM <S F;=E ;H> /=BIF?M ;H> )?LNIH F;C> NB? @IOH>;NCIH I@
JLC=CHA <S HI;L<CNL;A? ;H>
F;N?L
JLC=CHA <S ?KOCP;F?HN G;LNCHA;F? G?;MOL?
0BCM GI>?F
QBC=B ?MM?HNC;FFS ;MMOG?M HILG;FCNS ;H> NCG? CH>?J?H>?H=? I@
JLC=? =B;HA?M
B;M <??H MBIQH @IL ; FIHA NCG? NI <? OH;<F? NI L?JLI>O=? MIG?
Q?FFEHIQH MNSFCT?> @;=NM MO=B ;M NB? PIF;NCFCNS MGCF? IL NB? N?LG MNLO=NOL? I@
PIF;NCFCNC?M M @IL NB? GI>?FCHA I@ ;MM?N L?NOLHM
IJNCIH JLC=CHA GI>?FM B;P?
NI CH=ILJIL;N? NB? PIF;NCFCNS =FOMN?LCHA ;H> NB? HIHHILG;FCNS I@ NB? =IH>C
NCIH;F >CMNLC<ONCIH GIHA NB?M? GI>?FM
NB? GIMN Q?FFEHIQH CM NB? MNI=B;M
NC= PIF;NCFCNS GI>?F ;H> NB? GI>?FM QCNB DOGJM O? NI NB? G;NB?G;NC=;F
+HFS NB? G?;H ;H> P;LC;H=? N?LGM ;L? L?F?P;HN QB?H ;MM?N JLC=CHA CM <;M?> IH ;
KO;>L;NC= ONCFCNS @OH=NCIH
%HNLI>O=NCIH
%H NBCM =B;JN?L
Q? >?M=LC<? NB? ?GJCLC=;F =B;L;=N?LCMNC=M I@ MIG? MN;NCMNC=;F
G?;MOL?M I@ ;MM?N L?NOLHM )IL? MJ?=CW=;FFS
CH /?=NCIH
Q? JLIPC>? MIG?
>?WHCNCIHM NB;N ;L? OM?@OF @IL NB? L?MN I@ NB? <IIE FNBIOAB GIMN I@ NB? MN;
NCMNC=;F G?;MOL?M OM?> ;L? Q?FFEHIQH
?GJB;MCM CM JF;=?> IH =LCNC=;F CMMO?M
=IH=?LHCHA NB? ?MNCG;NCIH ;H> NB? ;JJFC=;NCIHM I@ NB?M? MN;NCMNC=;F G?;MOL?M
0B?H
Q? =IHMC>?L NB? P;LCIOM ;MJ?=NM I@ NB? L?NOLH >CMNLC<ONCIH %H /?=NCIH
Q? MBIQ NB;N NB? MN;H>;L> ;MMOGJNCIH I@ HILG;FCNS CM L?D?=N?> @IL MNI=E
G;LE?N L?NOLHM G;CHFS <?=;OM? I@ ;MSGG?NLS ;H> N;CF NBC=EH?MM I@ NB? L?NOLH
>CMNLC<ONCIH %H /?=NCIH
Q? >CM=OMM NCG? >?J?H>?H=? ;H> >?GIHMNL;N? NB?
MNLIHA PIF;NCFCNS =FOMN?LCHA CH WH;H=C;F G;LE?NM /?=NCIH >CM=OMM?M =ILL?
F;NCIH ;=LIMM ;MM?N L?NOLHM
CNM NCG?P;LSCHA H;NOL?
;H> NB? CGJFC=;NCIH I@
=B;HACHA >?J?H>?H=? IH ;MM?N ;FFI=;NCIH $IQ?P?L
=ILL?F;NCIH CM HIN ; P;FC>
G?;MOL? @IL >?J?H>?H=? QB?H L?NOLHM ;L? HIHHILG;F +NB?L G?;MOL?M @IL
>?J?H>?H=? ;L? JLIPC>?> CH B;JN?L "CH;FFS
QB?H NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH ;JJ?;LM
HIHHILG;F
CN CM P?LS OM?@OF ;H> L?F?P;HN NI =IHMC>?L GOFNCP;LC;N? GIG?HNM
MO=B ;M =IME?QH?MM ;H> =IEOLNIMCM 0BCM CM =IP?L?> CH /?=NCIH
"CH;H=C;F GI>?FCHA >?;FM QCNB =;JNOLCHA NB? G;CH =B;L;=N?LCMNC=M I@ L?NOLH
>CMNLC<ONCIHM 0B? MN;NCMNC=;F JLIJ?LNC?M I@ WH;H=C;F G;LE?N >;N; C>?HNCW?> CH
NBCM =B;JN?L QCFF M?LP? ;M NB? <;=E<IH? @IL NB? F;N?L =B;JN?LM "IL CHMN;H=?
.D72=287< 8/ ;.=>;7<
FNBIOAB JLC=?M ;L? QB;N Q? I<M?LP? CH WH;H=C;F G;LE?NM
GIMN ?GJCLC=;F MNO>
C?M @I=OM IH L?NOLHM 0B? L?;MIH CM NB;N
CH A?H?L;F
JLC=?M ;L? HIHMN;NCIH;LS
QB?L?;M L?NOLHM ;L? MN;NCIH;LS 0B?L? ;L? M?P?L;F L?NOLH >?WHCNCIHM
?;=B I@
QBC=B JLI>O=?M ; >C_?L?HN M?N I@ JLIJ?LNC?M @IL L?NOLHM 3? GIL? MJ?=CW=;FFS
@I=OM IH MCGJF? L?NOLHM ;H> FIAL?NOLHM
/N;NCMNC=;F ,LIJ?LNC?M I@ "CH;H=C;F );LE?N ;N;
%2695. ;.=>;7<
%H MIG? =;M?M
C@ L?NOLHM ;L? MG;FF
Q? G;S OM? NB? ;JJLIRCG;NCIH
F
,
>N R >NE (
E
80;.=>;7<
H
%@ ; <;HE J;SM ;H ;HHO;F CHN?L?MN I@ >N
T NCG?M ; S?;L
NB? CHN?L?MN L;N?
H
@IL ?;=B OHCN I@ CHP?MNG?HN CM <S >?WHCNCIH
>N *T
;H> ;@N?L IH? S?;L NB?
H
H
NIN;F P;FO? I@ NB? >?JIMCN CM
H >N %H NB? FCGCNCHA =;M? QB?L? NB?
CHN?L?MN CM =OGOF;N?> =IHNCHOIOMFS T
Q? B;P?
H
H
&%'
>N LL* '
H T
?WHCNCIHM I@ L?NOLHM
3? >?>O=? NB;N YN
NB? =IHNCHOIOMFS =IGJIOH>?> L?NOLH IL FIAL?NOLH
CM
YN &)# <N
&)# <N
WN WN (
*IQ
NB? FIAL?NOLH I@ ; JILN@IFCI >I?M HIN B;P? NB? M;G? =IHP?HC?HN JLIJ?LNS
;M NB? =;M? QCNB MCGJF? L?NOLH %H>??>
NB? JILN@IFCI FIAL?NOLH YJN CM
. .
, ,
YJN &)# " D LL * " D YDN '
D D
%=B52C.- /*,=<
N WLMN MCABN
NB?L? CM HI L?;MIH QBS =IGGI>CNS JLC=?
MNI=E JLC=?
IL ?R=B;HA?
L;N? MBIOF> <?B;P? CH ; J;LNC=OF;L @;MBCIH $IQ?P?L
G;HS ?GJCLC=;F MNO>C?M
B;P? C>?HNCW?> ; M?N I@ =IGGIH @?;NOL?M ;GIHA WH;H=C;F >;N; NB;N ;L? EHIQH
;M @AF96G21 3.0A@ IHN
CH J;LNC=OF;L
JLIPC>?M ; =IGJL?B?HMCP? MOLP?S
I@ NB?M? MNSFCT?> @;=NM
QBC=B CH=FO>?
.A A.69@ 0B? OH=IH>CNCIH;F >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ L?NOLHM B;M @;NN?L N;CFM NB;H
NB;N ?RJ?=N?> @LIG ; HILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH 0BCM G?;HM NB;N
C@ Q? OM? NB?
HILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH NI GI>?F WH;H=C;F L?NOLHM
Q? QCFF OH>?L?MNCG;N? NB?
HOG<?L ;H> G;AHCNO>? I@ =L;MB?M ;H> <IIGM
@F::2A?F 0B? OH=IH>CNCIH;F >CMNLC<ONCIH CM H?A;NCP?FS ME?Q?>
MOAA?MN
CHA NB;N ?RNL?G? H?A;NCP? L?NOLHM ;L? GIL? @L?KO?HN NB;H ?RNL?G? JIMCNCP?
L?NOLHM 0B? ;MSGG?NLS ;H> @;NN;CF JB?HIG?H; J?LMCMN ?P?H ;@N?L ;>DOMN
CHA @IL =IH>CNCIH;F B?N?LIME?>;MNC=CNS IL =B;HACHA PIF;NCFCNS
G?;HCHA
NB;N NB? =IH>CNCIH;F >CMNLC<ONCIH CM ;FMI HIHHILG;F
44?24.A21 ;<?:.96AF M NB? @L?KO?H=S I@ NB? L?NOLHM F?HANB?HM
NB? L?
NOLH >CMNLC<ONCIH A?NM =FIM?L NI NB? HILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH
/@2;02 <3 @2?6.9 0<??29.A6<; .?NOLHM A?H?L;FFS >I HIN >CMJF;S MCAHCW=;HN
M?LC;F =ILL?F;NCIH
?R=?JN ;N BCAB @L?KO?H=S
/??
@IL ?R;GJF?
IFF?LMF?P
BIO
;H> 'LIH?L
,;A;H
/B?JB;L>
;GJ<?FF
(I
;H> );='CHF;S
IHN
;H> #IOLCfLIOR ;H>
&;MC;E ;
/N;NCMNC=;F ,LIJ?LNC?M I@ "CH;H=C;F );LE?N ;N;
2<=;2+>=287 8/ ;.=>;7<
"CAOL? >CMJF;SM NB? FIAL?NOLHM IH @IOL MNI=E G;LE?N CH>C=?M !RNL?G?
H?A;NCP? L?NOLHM ;JJ?;L NI <? GIL? JLIHIOH=?> NB;H ?RNL?G? JIMCNCP? L?NOLHM
"CAOL? >CMJF;SM NB? BCMNIAL;G I@ NB? FIAL?NOLHM
QBC=B MBIQ NB? ?GJCLC=;F
>CMNLC<ONCIHM ;M ;MSGG?NLC= ;H> B;P? N;CFM NB;N >I HIN P;HCMB ;M @;MN ;M NBIM?
I@ NB? HILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH 0BCM CM =IHWLG?> <S NB? GCHCGOG ;H> G;RCGOG
L?NOLHM L?JILN?> CH 0;<F?
&*+5.
!6:6:B: .;1 :.E6:B: <3 1.69F 9<4?2AB?;@
/, 4 "0/! *CEE?C
)CHCGOG
);RCGOG
86.7=< 8/ * ;*7-86 ?*;2*+5.
%H NBCM <IIE
Q? QCFF NSJC=;FFS OM? HIH#;OMMC;H >CMNLC<ONCIHM
QBC=B ;L? =B;L
;=N?LCT?> <S GIG?HNM NB;N ;L? BCAB?L NB;H NB? M?=IH> IL>?L IHMC>?L ;
=IHNCHOIOM L;H>IG P;LC;<F? D M;S NB? FIAL?NOLH M?LC?M QCNB 0B:B9.A6C2 16@
A?6/BA6<; 3B;0A6<; 013
%H NBCM <IIE
Q? OM? NB? QIL>M .B@@6.; ;H> ;<?:.9 CHN?L=B;HA?;<FS 0B? HILG;F
>CMNLC<ONCIH Q;M MNO>C?> ;M ?;LFS ;M <S >? )ICPL? (;N?L IH
(;JF;=? ;H>
#;OMM OM?> CN NI GI>?F F?;MNMKO;L? ?LLILM $?H=?
NB? #;OMMC;H >CMNLC<ONCIH CM
MIG?NCG?M L?@?LL?> NI ;M NB? #;OMM(;JF;=? >CMNLC<ONCIH
CMNLC<ONCIH I@ L?NOLHM
SP500 DAX
10 10
5
0
0
-10
-5
-20
-10
-30 -15
1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005
FT-SE Nikkei
10 20
10
0
0
-10
-10
-20 -20
1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005
20
C<9BA6<; <3 1.69F 9<4?2AB?;@
SP500 DAX
2500 1500
2000
1000
1500
1000
500
500
0 0
-30 -20 -10 0 10 -20 -10 0 10
FT-SE Nikkei
2000 3000
1500
2000
1000
1000
500
0 0
-20 -10 0 10 -20 -10 0 10 20
20
6@A<4?.: <3 1.69F 9<4?2AB?;@
/N;NCMNC=;F ,LIJ?LNC?M I@ "CH;H=C;F );LE?N ;N;
. R
28 _
+ D
_ M8 \
K\(
S =IHMNLO=NCIH
0B? M?=IH> =?HN?L?> GIG?HN CM NB? P;LC;H=? I@ D
B D T T 0B? NBCL> ;H> @IOLNB =?HN?L?> GIG?HNM
;H>
;L?
L?MJ?=NCP?FS
NB? HIHMN;H>;L>CT?> ME?QH?MM ;H> EOLNIMCM 0B? MN;H
>;L>CT?> ME?QH?MM ;H> EOLNIMCM
IL MCGJFS ME?QH?MM ;H> EOLNIMCM
;L? >?WH?>
;M
D
Z ?R D 1
(
D
7\ D 1 '
'82D;2@@
?RD
>?JC=NM NB? ;MSGG?NLS I@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH 3B?H CN CM H?A
;NCP?
F;LA? H?A;NCP? L?;FCT;NCIHM I@ D ;L? GIL? FCE?FS NI ;JJ?;L NB;H F;LA?
JIMCNCP? L?;FCT;NCIHM B?A<@6@
7\D
=;JNOL?M NB? N;CF NBC=EH?MM I@ NB? >CM
NLC<ONCIH F;LA? EOLNIMCM G?;HM NB;N F;LA? L?;FCT;NCIHM ?CNB?L JIMCNCP? IL
H?A;NCP? ;L? GIL? FCE?FS NI <? I<N;CH?> NB;H ?RJ?=N?> @LIG ; HILG;F >CMNLC
<ONCIH
"CAOL?M ;H> CFFOMNL;N? BIQ CHNLI>O=CHA ;MSGG?NLS IL @;N N;CFM QIOF>
;_?=N NB? MB;J? I@ ; >CMNLC<ONCIH PCMbPCM NB? HILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH %H "CAOL?
NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH QCNB H?A;NCP? ME?QH?MM F?;HM NI NB? LCABN
MCH=? NB? FIHA
H?A;NCP? N;CF IH NB? F?@N B;M NI <? =IGJ?HM;N?> <S ; AL?;N?L JLI<;<CFCNS G;MM
IH NB? MBILN?L N;CF IH NB? LCABN *IN? ;FMI NB;N >CMNLC<ONCIHM QCNB NBC=E?L N;CFM
B;P? ; NBCHH?L ;H> BCAB?L J?;E CH NB? =?HN?L QB?H =IGJ;L?> QCNB NB? HILG;F
>CMNLC<ONCIH
%H "CAOL?
NB? ;MSGG?NLC= >CMNLC<ONCIHM ;L? I<N;CH?> @LIG NB? MI=;FF?> ME?Q?>
/NO>?HN I >CMNLC<ONCIH QCNB
>?AL??M I@ @L??>IG ;H> ME?QH?MM J;L;G?N?LM
;H>
L?MJ?=NCP?FS
@IL NB? FIHA>;MB FCH? ;H> NB? MIFC> <IF> FCH? M?? /?=NCIH
%H "CAOL?
NB? @;NN;CF?> >CMNLC<ONCIHM ;L? /NO>?HN I >CMNLC<ONCIHM QCNB
;H> >?AL??M I@ @L??>IG
L?MJ?=NCP?FS
@IL NB? FIHA>;MB FCH? ;H> NB? MIFC> <IF>
FCH?
CMNLC<ONCIH I@ L?NOLHM
0.6
Norm al
Neg. s kewnes s
Pos . s kewnes s
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
-8 -6 -4 -2 0 2 4 6 8
20
E.:=92@ <3 .@F::2A?60 16@A?6/BA6<;@
0.4
Norm al
t(5)
0.35
t(2)
0.3
0.25
0.2
0.15
0.1
0.05
0
-8 -6 -4 -2 0 2 4 6 8
20
E.:=92@ <3 16@A?6/BA6<;@ D6A5 3.A A.69@
/N;NCMNC=;F ,LIJ?LNC?M I@ "CH;H=C;F );LE?N ;N;
0B? HILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH B;M ME?QH?MM ;FQ;SM ?KO;F NI T?LI ;H> EOLNIMCM
;FQ;SM ?KO;F NI FF @OLNB?L GIG?HNM ;L? ?CNB?L I>> GIG?HNM IL @OH=NCIHM
I@ ;H> ?P?H GIG?HNM $?H=?
; HILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH CM @OFFS C>?HNCW?>
<S CNM G?;H ;H> P;LC;H=? FMI
;M >CMNLC<ONCIHM ;L? I@N?H =IGJ;L?> QCNB
NB? HILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH
NB? 2E02@@ 8B?A<@6@ C?
CM I@N?H L?JILN?>
CHMN?;> I@ NB? EOLNIMCM CNM?F@ )IMN WH;H=C;F ;MM?N L?NOLHM B;P? EOLNIMCM P;FO?M
AL?;N?L NB;H
;H> MNI=E G;LE?N L?NOLH
CH J;LNC=OF;L
CM MNLIHAFS @?;NOL?> <S
; H?A;NCP? ME?QH?MM +NB?L WH;H=C;F M?LC?M
MO=B ;M CHN?L?MN L;N?M
L?NOLHM IH
=IGGI>CNC?M IL IH B?>A? @OH>M
G;S B;P? JIMCNCP? ME?QH?MM "CH;FFS
@IL?CAH
?R=B;HA? L;N?M G;S B;P? JIMCNCP? ;M Q?FF ;M H?A;NCP? ME?QH?MM
>?J?H>CHA IH
NB? Q;S NB?S ;L? =IGJON?>
692;2,*5 686.7=<
.*<>;.< 8/ 58,*=287
4
*IQ
=IHMC>?L ; NCG? M?LC?M I@ L?;FCT?> L?NOLHM 'YN (N 0B? GIMN =IGGIHFS
OM?> G?;MOL?M I@ FI=;NCIH ;L? @.:=92 :2.; Y ;H> :216.; T 0B? M;GJF? G?;H
CM =;F=OF;N?> ;M
4
,
Y
YN '
@ N
4
%@ 'YN (N B;M ; MSGG?NLC= >CMNLC<ONCIH
NB?H Y CM NB? IJNCG;F G?;MOL? I@
FI=;NCIH )?>C;H CM >?WH?> ;M NB? NB J?L=?HNCF? I@ NB? M;GJF? %H INB?L
QIL>M
I@ NB? M;GJF? B;M ; P;FO? FIQ?L NB;H T TLKY
C?
+ YN
T + YN T '
)?;H
;M ; G?;MOL? @IL FI=;NCIH
CM M?HMCNCP? NI IONFC?LM +H? ?LLIH?IOMFS
L?=IL>?> P;FO? =IOF> JIN?HNC;FFS GIP? NB? G?;H ;Q;S @LIG NB? =?HNL;F J;LN
I@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH %H =IHNL;MN
NB? G?>C;H CM GIL? LI<OMN ;A;CHMN IONFC?LM
<?=;OM? CN >I?M HIN L?FS IH NB? JL?=CM? P;FO? I@ NB? L?;FCT;NCIHM INB?L NB;H NB?
G?>C;H CNM?F@
.*<>;.< 8/ -2<9.;<287
%H NBCM <IIE
Q? >?HIN? ?MNCG;N?M QCNB ; B;N 9
*IN? NB;N CM HIN NB? );RCGOG(CE?FCBII> )( ?MNCG;NIL I@ NB? P;LC;H=?
OH>?L HILG;FCNS
"IL ; HILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH
NB? )( ?MNCG;NIL @IL P;LC;H=? CM
& & G& G
CMNLC<ONCIH I@ L?NOLHM
4
,
YN Y
'
@
N
%H WH;H=?
NB? MN;H>;L> >?PC;NCIH
NB? MKO;L? LIIN I@ P;LC;H=?
CM I@N?H OM?>
NI G?;H PIF;NCFCNS /CH=? NB? MN;NCMNC=;F JLIJ?LNC?M I@ M;GJF? G?;H G;E? CN ;
P?LS CH;==OL;N? ?MNCG;N? I@ NB? NLO? G?;H
?MJ?=C;FFS @IL MG;FF M;GJF?M
N;E
CHA >?PC;NCIHM ;LIOH> T?LI CHMN?;> I@ NB? M;GJF? G?;H ;M CH NSJC=;FFS
CH=L?;M?M PIF;NCFCNS @IL?=;MN ;==OL;=S 0B?L? ;L? G?NBI>M @IL ?MNCG;NCHA PIF;NCF
CNS NB;N ;L? >?MCAH?> NI ?RJFICN IL L?>O=? NB? CHXO?H=? I@ ?RNL?G?M M?? ;FF
;H> 0ILIOM
,;LECHMIH
IL #;LG;H ;H> 'F;MM
ON NB?M?
G?NBI>M A?H?L;FFS L?FS IH NB? ;MMOGJNCIH I@ HILG;FCNS I@ L?NOLHM
QBC=B CM
HIN FCE?FS CH NB? =;M? I@ WH;H=C;F G;LE?N M?LC?M
HINB?L CHN?L?MNCHA G?;MOL? I@ >CMJ?LMCIH CM NB? :2.; ./@<9BA2 12C6.A6<;
9 -0 %N CM =IGJON?> ;M
4
,
9 -0 )YN Y) '
@ N
201.; 686.7=<
;M
4
, YN Y
Z (
@ N
;H>
4
, YN Y
'
@ N
1H>?L NB? ;MMOGJNCIH I@ HILG;FCNS
Q? B;P? NB? @IFFIQCHA ;MSGJNINC= >CMNLC
<ONCIHM M?? '?H>;FF ;H> /NO;LN
+ +
@
(
@ ( (
+ +
@ Z (
@
(
(
3BCF? CH ?KO;NCIH CM ;H OH<C;M?> ?MNCG;N? I@
NB? MKO;L? LIIN I@
CM ;
<C;M?> ?MNCG;N? I@ >O? NI &?HM?H CH?KO;FCNS IR ;H> .O<CHMN?CH ?RJF;CH
BIQ NBCM <C;M =;H <? =ILL?=N?> ;MMOGCHA ; HILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH @IL G& $IQ?P?L
CH GIMN =;M?M
NB? CGJ;=N I@ NBCM ;>DOMNG?HN CM MG;FF
/N;NCMNC=;F ,LIJ?LNC?M I@ "CH;H=C;F );LE?N ;N;
&.<=270 /8; 78;6*52=B
%N B;M <??H HIN?> @IL ; FIHA NCG? NB;N GIMN WH;H=C;F ;MM?N L?NOLHM ;L? HIH
HILG;F );H>?F<LIN
;H> ";G;
0BCM HIHHILG;FCNS CM MNLIHAFS
@?;NOL?> CH NQI MN;NCMNC=;F JB?HIG?H; C !RNL?G? ?P?HNM I==OL GIL? I@N?H
NB;H JL?>C=N?> <S ; HILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH );H>?F<LIN
";G;
F;N
N<?LA ;H> #IH?>?M
'IH
;H> CC =L;MB?M I==OL GIL? I@N?H NB;H
<IIGM ";G;
L>CNNC
/CGEIQCNT ;H> ??>F?M
/CHAF?NIH
;H> 3CHA?H>?L
,B?HIG?HIH C =ILL?MJIH>M NI ?R=?MM EOLNIMCM IL 3.A
A.69@
QB?L?;M JB?HIG?HIH CC CM ;MMI=C;N?> QCNB H?A;NCP? ME?QH?MM IL .@F:
:2A?F
"IFFIQCHA );H>?F<LIN
NQI L?F;N?> CMMO?M B;P? <??H ;>>L?MM?> CH
NB? WH;H=? FCN?L;NOL? >I?M NB? HILG;FCNS ;MMOGJNCIH BIF> @IL ;MM?N L?NOLHM
%@ HIN
NI QB;N ?RN?HN ;L? L?NOLHM HIHHILG;F %H NBCM =B;JN?L
Q? @I=OM IH
OH=IH>CNCIH;F HILG;FCNS 0B;N CM
@IL NB? GIG?HN Q? ;MMOG? NB;N L?NOLHM
>CMNLC<ONCIH >I?M HIN =B;HA? NBLIOAB NCG? %H B;JN?L
Q? QCFF L?F;R NBCM
;MMOGJNCIH ;H> ;FFIQ >CMNLC<ONCIH NI P;LS =IH>CNCIH;FFS NI MIG? >CMNLC<ONCIH;F
P;LC;<F? 2;LCIOM N?MNM @IL HILG;FCNS B;P? <??H >?P?FIJ?> <;M?> IH NB? GI
G?HNM IL IH NB? >?HMCNS @OH=NCIH I@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH
IL JLIJ?LNC?M I@ NB? L;HE?>
M?LC?M 3? QCFF >?M=LC<? B?L? N?MNM NB;N ;L? <;M?> IH JLIJ?LNC?M I@ NB? ILCACH;F
>CMNLC<ONCIH
0B? GIMN QC>?FS OM?> N?MN CH NBCM =;N?AILS CM >O? NI &;LKO? ;H> ?L;
;H> ?L; ;H> &;LKO? QBI L?FS IH NB? @;=N NB;N ME?QH?MM ;H> ?R=?MM
EOLNIMCM ;L? <INB ?KO;F NI T?LI @IL NB? HILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH &;LKO? ;H> ?L;
CMNLC<ONCIH I@ L?NOLHM
&*+5.
'B::.?F @A.A6@A60@ <3 9<4?2AB?;@
/, 4 "0/! *CEE?C
;CFS @L?KO?H=S
I<M?LP;NCIHM
)?;H
)?>C;H
/N> >?PC;NCIH
)
%-.
HH G?;H
HH MN> >?P
/E?QH?MM
'OLNIMCM
3??EFS @L?KO?H=S
I<M?LP;NCIHM
)?;H
)?>C;H
/N> >?PC;NCIH
)
%-.
HH G?;H
HH MN> >?P
/E?QH?MM
'OLNIMCM
)IHNBFS @L?KO?H=S I<M?LP;NCIHM
)?;H
)?>C;H
/N> >?PC;NCIH
)
%-.
HH G?;H
HH MN> >?P
/E?QH?MM
'OLNIMCM
HHO;F @L?KO?H=S I<M?LP;NCIHM
)?;H
)?>C;H
/N> >?PC;NCIH
)
%-.
/E?QH?MM
'OLNIMCM
/N;NCMNC=;F ,LIJ?LNC?M I@ "CH;H=C;F );LE?N ;N;
MBIQ
@IL 661 ;H> HILG;FFS >CMNLC<ON?> L;H>IG P;LC;<F?M
NB;N NB? MN;H
>;L>CT?> ME?QH?MM ;H> ?R=?MM EOLNIMCM ;L? ;MSGJNINC=;FFS CH>?J?H>?HN ;H>
B;P? NB? @IFFIQCHA ;MSGJNINC= >CMNLC<ONCIHM
Z
8 (
;H> 8 (
'
*@ ( *@ (
?L; ;H> &;LKO?ZM C>?; @IL N?MNCHA HILG;FCNS CM NI OM? NB? 6. N?MN MN;NCMNC=
>?WH?> ;M
Z
6. @ (
+
a
(
;
"
@
@
N Z (
@
8
"
I
(
I
Z (
I I
Z (
H ;JJLIRCG;NCIH I@ WHCN? M;GJF? >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ ME?QH?MM =;H ;FMI <? @IOH> CH
ZAIMNCHI
CMNLC<ONCIH I@ L?NOLHM
@ @ @
@
I (
@
@
@
@
@
@
@
@
@
I (
@
@
@
@ @
I (
@
@
@
@ @
I
(
@
@
@
@
LN YN Y(
L N YN Y
(
L
N YN Y
*
Z(
LN YN Y
* '
QB?L?
3 '
1H>?L NB? HOFF BSJINB?MCM I@ HILG;FCNS
C CM >CMNLC<ON?> ;M ;
'
"IL NB? =;M? I@ Q?;EFS >?J?H>?HN >;N;
;C ;H> *A JLIPC>? NB?
M;GJFCHA >CMNLC<ONCIHM I@ NB? ME?QH?MM ;H> EOLNIMCM ?MNCG;NILM ;H> JLIJIM? ;
DICHN N?MN @IL HILG;FCNS NB;N N;E?M NBCM M;GJFCHA >CMNLC<ONCIH CHNI ;==IOHN
.C=B;L>MIH ;H> /GCNB ?MNCG;N? ;FF @IOL GIG?HNM ;H> N?MN QB?NB?L ME?Q
H?MM ;H> ?R=?MM EOLNIMCM ;L? DICHNFS T?LI +H NB? INB?L B;H>
$;LP?S J?L
@ILGM NB? ?MNCG;NCIH OH>?L NB? HOFF ;H> OM?M NB? F;MN NQI ILNBIAIH;FCNS =IH>CNCIHM
;M IP?LC>?HNC@SCHA =IH>CNCIHM
/N;NCMNC=;F ,LIJ?LNC?M I@ "CH;H=C;F );LE?N ;N;
0B? E?S N?MN B?L? CM NB? 'IFGIAILIP/GCLHIP '/ N?MN NB;N =IGJ;L?M NB?
?GJCLC=;F 013 2L '
I@ NB? L?NOLHM QCNB NB? 013 I@ NB? HILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH IL
;HS INB?L ;MMOG?> >CMNLC<ONCIH 2 '
QCNB J;L;G?N?L P?=NIL /CH=? NB? NLO?
>CMNLC<ONCIH 2L '
CM OHEHIQH
CN CM ;JJLIRCG;N?> <S NB? ?GJCLC=;F 013 3 '
>?WH?> ;M
4
,
3 _
L* R '
@ N
7? ,.* )2 _
3 _
) '
R
%H JL;=NC=?
NBCM N?MN CM P?LS ?;MS NI CGJF?G?HN
/ILN NB? M;GJF? >;N; <S CH=L?;MCHA IL>?L ;H> >?HIN? NB? H?Q M;GJF?
4
'0
YN (N
QCNB Y0
Y04 0B?H
<S =IHMNLO=NCIH
NB? ?GJCLC=;F 013 CM
ACP?H <S 3 0 YN
[*@
4
!P;FO;N? NB? ;MMOG?> 013 2 0 YN
@IL ;FF P;FO?M '0YN (N %H NB? =;M? I@
NB? HILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH
Q? ;MMOG?> NB;N NB? G?;H ;H> NB? P;LC;H=?
;L? EHIQH
IGJON? NB? 7? N?MN MN;NCMNC=
[
7? ,.* 2 0 YN
'
N @
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
-25 -20 -15 -10 -5 0 5 10
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1
20
<:=.?6@<; <3 A52 2:=6?60.9 16@A?6/BA6<; <3 A52 '$
+
7?, ' #CP?H NB;N NB? =LCNC=;F P;FO? CM '* '
NB? HOFF
BSJINB?MCM I@ HILG;FCNS CM MNLIHAFS L?D?=N?>
0;<F? JL?M?HNM P;LCIOM MN;NCMNC=M NI N?MN HILG;FCNS ;M >?M=LC<?> ;<IP?
0B? >C;AHIMCM IH HILG;FCNS I@ L?NOLHM CM KOCN? =F?;L=ON "LIG >;CFS NI GIHNBFS
@L?KO?H=C?M
NB? >C_?L?HN N?MNM MSMN?G;NC=;FFS L?D?=N NB? HOFF BSJINB?MCM I@ HIL
G;FCNS 0B? L?D?=NCIH CM >O? NI <INB ;MSGG?NLS ;H> N;CF NBC=EH?MM I@ NB? >CM
NLC<ONCIH %H NB? =;M? I@ ;HHO;F L?NOLHM
HILG;FCNS CM HIN L?D?=N?> ON CH NBCM
CHMN;H=?
CN CM JIMMC<F? NB;N NB? M;GJF? MCT? CM MI MG;FF NB;N NB? N?MNM F;=E JIQ?L
;H> ;L? MCGJFS OHL?FC;<F?
&26. -.9.7-.7,B
0CG? >?J?H>?H=S CH ;MM?N L?NOLHM =;H I==OL ;N M?P?L;F F?P?FM 3? QCFF >CM=OMM
>?J?H>?H=S CH L?NOLHM
PIF;NCFCNS
;H> BCAB?L GIG?HNM CH NOLHM CH NB? @IFFIQ
CHA MO<M?=NCIHM 0CG? >?J?H>?H=S CM ; =LO=C;F CMMO? @IL M?P?L;F L?;MIHM "CLMN
&*+5.
"<?:.96AF A2@A@ 3<? 9<4?2AB?;@
/, 4 "0/! *CEE?C
;CFS @L?KO?H=S
I<M?LP;NCIHM
/E?QH?MM
IH
'OLNIMCM
I
+$
JP;FO?
,1
LCNC=;F P;FO?
3??EFS @L?KO?H=S
I<M?LP;NCIHM
/E?QH?MM
IH
'OLNIMCM
I
+$
JP;FO?
,1
LCNC=;F P;FO?
)IHNBFS @L?KO?H=S I<M?LP;NCIHM
/E?QH?MM
IH
'OLNIMCM
I
+$
JP;FO?
,1
LCNC=;F P;FO?
HHO;F @L?KO?H=S I<M?LP;NCIHM
/E?QH?MM
IH
'OLNIMCM
I
+$
JP;FO?
,1
LCNC=;F P;FO?
G?HN CM I<PCIOMFS P?LS CGJILN;HN @IL G;HS WH;H=? ;JJFC=;NCIHM MO=B ;M LCME
G;H;A?G?HN ;H> ;MM?N ;FFI=;NCIH
$?L?
NB? HOFF BSJINB?MCM CM NB;N NB? WLMN W M?LC;F =ILL?F;NCIHM I@ L?NOLHM ;L?
?KO;F NI
4 J
QB?L? NB? =ILL?F;NCIH I@ IL>?L Q CM
?MNCG;N?> <S
0CG? >?J?H>?H=S
,4
YN Y
YNE Y
NE
E ,4 @IL
Q ) @
'
YN Y
N
%.;2*5 ,8;;.5*=287 27 ?85*=252=B
YN #N ( QCNB # N N aN (
1 # N )N N 1 aN )N N
<?=;OM? aN CM >CMNLC<ON?> ;M
0B?L?@IL?
# N =;H <? PC?Q?> ;M ; JLIRS
@IL NB? PIF;NCFCNS
;N NCG? [ FN?LH;NCP?FS
IGCNNCHA @IL NB? GIG?HN
Q? B;P?
YN ( N ;H>
8
1 )YN ) N *'
8
IHM?KO?HNFS
)YN ) * * CM ; JLIRS @IL N %N MBIOF> <? HIN?> BIQ?P?L NB;N
NB?M? NQI G?;MOL?M ;L? HICMS ?MNCG;N?M I@ =IH>CNCIH;F PIF;NCFCNS /?? B;JN?L
@IL GIL? >?N;CF ;H> GIL? MIJBCMNC=;N?> G?;MOL?M I@ =IH>CNCIH;F PIF;NCFCNS
#CP?H NB?M? =LO>? G?;MOL?M I@ PIF;NCFCNS
NB? N?MN @IL M?LC;F >?J?H>?H=? CH
PIF;NCFCNS =;H <? ?R?=ON?> CH NB? M;G? G;HH?L ;M NB? N?MN @IL L?NOLHM CH NB?
JL?PCIOM MO<M?=NCIH OMCHA (DOHAIR - MN;NCMNC= *IHT?LI M?LC;F =ILL?F;NCIH
CH MKO;L?> IL ;<MIFON? L?NOLHM CM ?PC>?H=? I@ PIF;NCFCNS NCG? >?J?H>?H=? 0;<F?
L?JILNM NB? (DOHAIR MN;NCMNC= @IL L?NOLHM
MKO;L?> L?NOLHM
;H> ;<MIFON?
L?NOLHM @IL W
;H> W CH NB? =;M? I@ ;HHO;F >;N; 0B? =ILL?MJIH>CHA
=LCNC=;F P;FO?M ;L?
' @IL W
;H>
'
@IL W 0B? L?MOFNM
CH>C=;N? NB;N L?NOLHM ;L? M?LC;FFS =ILL?F;N?> QB?H NB?S ;L? M;GJF?> ;N NB?
>;CFS @L?KO?H=S <ON HIN ;N INB?L @L?KO?H=C?M /KO;L?> ;H> ;<MIFON? L?NOLHM
;L? GIL? MNLIHAFS =ILL?F;N?>
;N F?;MN ;N NB? >;CFS ;H> Q??EFS @L?KO?H=C?M
/N;NCMNC=;F ,LIJ?LNC?M I@ "CH;H=C;F );LE?N ;N;
&*+5.
7B;4<E A2@A @A.A6@A60@ <3 9<4?2AB?;@ @>B.?21 ?2AB?;@ .;1 ./@<9BA2
?2AB?;@
"L?KO?H=S /, 4 "0/! *CEE?C
.?NOLHM
;CFS
3??EFS
)IHNBFS
HHO;F
/KO;L?> L?NOLHM
;CFS
3??EFS
)IHNBFS
HHO;F
<MIFON? L?NOLHM
;CFS
3??EFS
)IHNBFS
HHO;F
N & N #N (
NB? CMMO? =IH=?LHM QB?NB?L IL HIN & CM CH>CMNCHAOCMB;<F? @LIG )O=B I@ NB?M?
>CM=OMMCIHM NIIE JF;=? <?@IL? NB? H?Q =IH=?JN I@ L?;FCT?> PIF;NCFCNS >?P?FIJ?>
%@ Q? ;JJFS OHCN LIIN N?MN NI NB? PIF;NCFCNS M?LC?M =IGJON?> OMCHA CHNL;>;S
>;N;
Q? =;N?AILC=;FFS L?D?=N NB? HOFF BSJINB?MCM I@ ; OHCN LIIN ?P?H ;N NB?
F?P?F M?? /?=NCIH
0B? =IHW>?H=? CHN?LP;F L?JILN?> CH NB? WAOL? CM =IGJON?> ;MMOGCHA NB;N
NB? ?MNCG;NIL CM ;MSGJNINC=;FFS HILG;F / 4 QCNB 4 ?MNCG;N?> <S 4
0CG? >?J?H>?H=S
SP500 DAX
0.2 0.3
0.15
0.2
0.1
0.1
0.05
0
0
-0.05 -0.1
0 50 100 0 50 100
FT-SE Nikkei
0.6 0.3
0.4 0.2
0.2 0.1
0 0
-0.2 -0.1
0 50 100 0 50 100
20
BA<0<??29<4?.: 3<? 1.69F @>B.?21 ?2AB?;@
(85*=252=B *<B66.=;B
&*+5.
$.?.:2A2? 2@A6:.A2@ <3 C<9.A9696AF .@F::2A?F ?24?2@@6<;@ .;1
/, 4 "0/! *CEE?C
/KO;L?> L?NOLHM
<MIFON? L?NOLHM
T im e - va r yi n g m e a n T im e - va r yi n g vo la til ity
0 .4 3
0 .2
2
1
- 0 .2
- 0 .4 0
1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005
T im e - va r yi n g s k e w n e s s T im e - va r yi n g k u r to s is
5 80
60
0
40
-5
20
-1 0 0
1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005
20
(6:2C.?F6;4 :<:2;A@ 3<? A52 1.69F '$
) N
9 (
4 )4
N _N _
N `N `
&.<= /8; .:>*52=B 8/ =@8 ,8;;.5*=287 ,8.J,2.7=<
0B?L? B;P? <??H ; FIN I@ >CM=OMMCIHM CH NB? FCN?L;NOL? IH BIQ NB? =ILL?F;NCIH
=B;HA?M QB?H NB? WH;H=C;F G;LE?NM ;L? [;ACN;N?>\ 0BCM CM ;H CGJILN;HN CMMO?
CH JILN@IFCI >CP?LMCW=;NCIH %@ =ILL?F;NCIH CH=L?;M?M >OLCHA NOL<OF?HN J?LCI>M
;H> MNI=E G;LE?N =L;MB?M
NB?H NB? <?H?WNM I@ >CP?LMCW=;NCIH >CM;JJ?;L QB?H
NB?S ;L? GIMN H??>?> ,L?PCIOM MNO>C?M IH =B;HACHA =ILL?F;NCIH ?MNCG;N?> CN
&*+5.
<??29.A6<; :.A?6E <3 9<4?2AB?;@
/, 4 "0/! *CEE?C
;CFS @L?KO?H=S
/,
4
"0/!
*CEE?C
3??EFS @L?KO?H=S
/,
4
"0/!
*CEE?C
)IHNBFS @L?KO?H=S
/,
4
"0/!
*CEE?C
HHO;F @L?KO?H=S
/,
4
"0/!
*CEE?C
0.5 0.5
0 0
-0.5 -0.5
1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005
0.5 0.5
0 0
-0.5 -0.5
1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005
20
(6:2C.?F6;4 0<??29.A6<;@ /2AD22; 1.69F @A<08 :.?82A ?2AB?; 0<:=BA21
B@6;4 . ?<996;4 D6;1<D <3 :<;A5@
?CNB?L @LIG >C_?L?HN M;GJF? J?LCI>M IL =IH>CNCIH;F IH IH? I@ NB? L?NOLH M?LC?M
?R=??>CHA ; NBL?MBIF> 0B? WLMN NSJ? I@ MNO>C?M CH=FO>?M ';JF;HCM ;H>
.;NH?L QBI WH> NB? =ILL?F;NCIH G;NLCR NI L?G;CH =IHMN;HN <?@IL? ;H>
;@N?L NB? MNI=E G;LE?N =L;MB +H NB? =IHNL;LS
'I=B ;H> 'I=B
WH> NB;N =ILL?F;NCIH CH=L?;M?M NBLIOAB NCG?
<ON 'CHA
/?HN;H;
;H> 3;>
BQ;HC ;LAO? NB;N NB? MNI=E G;LE?N =L;MB CM NB? G;CH =;OM? I@ NB?
CH=L?;M? CH =ILL?F;NCIH $IQ?P?L
IS?L
#C<MIH
;H> (IL?N;H
(IL?N;H
;H> !HAFCMB
;H> "IL<?M ;H> .CAI<IH MBIQ NB;N NB? =ILL?F;NCIH
=I?^=C?HN <?NQ??H NQI M?LC?M CM <C;M?>
QB?H CN CM =IGJON?> =IH>CNCIH;FFS IH
IH? I@ NB? M?LC?M ?R=??>CHA ; NBL?MBIF> 0B?L?@IL?
?P?H QB?H NB? <L?;ECHA
>;N? CM ;MMOG?> NI <? EHIQH =ILL?MJIH>CHA NI ; Q?FF?MN;<FCMB?> =L;MB
@IL
CHMN;H=?
OH=IH>CNCIH;F =ILL?F;NCIH ?MNCG;N?M B;P? NI <? =ILL?=N?> <?@IL? ;HS
N?MNCHA JLI=?>OL? M ; =IHM?KO?H=?
; BCAB?L =ILL?F;NCIH =I?^=C?HN =IOF>
<? ; MJOLCIOM ION=IG? =;OM?> <S BCAB?L PIF;NCFCNS 0I N?MN @IL ; =B;HA? CH
NB? =ILL?F;NCIH L?F;NCIHMBCJ
CN CM H?=?MM;LS C NI C>?HNC@S ; >;N; A?H?L;NCHA
JLI=?MM NB;N ;FFIQM @IL NB? JIMMC<CFCNS I@ MNLO=NOL;F =B;HA?M
CC NI ?MNCG;N?
NB? GI>?F J;L;G?N?LM
;H> CCC NI N?MN @IL =B;HACHA =ILL?F;NCIHM ;H> JIMMC<FS
INB?L MNLO=NOL;F <L?;EM
0B? ;<IP? >CM=OMMCIHM BCABFCABN NB? =IGJF?RCNC?M CHPIFP?> CH ?MNCG;NCHA
;H> N?MNCHA =ILL?F;NCIH =I?^=C?HNM
NB? =IH>CNCIH;F H;NOL? I@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH;F
P;LC;<F?M
;H> NB? =IGJFC=;NCIHM =;OM?> <S MNLO=NOL;F <L?;EM 3? QCFF ;>>L?MM
/N;NCMNC=;F ,LIJ?LNC?M I@ "CH;H=C;F );LE?N ;N;
a
&)# '
1H>?L NB? ;MMOGJNCIH NB;N NQI M;GJF?M ;L? >L;QH @LIG NQI CH>?J?H>?HN <C
P;LC;N? HILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIHM QCNB NB? M;G? =ILL?F;NCIH =I?^=C?HN
NB? >C_?L
?H=? <?NQ??H NB? ?MNCG;N?> a
@IL NB? NQI M;GJF?M =IHP?LA?M NI NB? HILG;F
>CMNLC<ONCIH (
* @
* @
NL F >C;A F
? >C;A F
(
DE
QB?L? ? DE DE QCNB
C@ P Q(
DE
INB?LQCM?
>C;A -
>?HIN?M NB? >C;AIH;F I@ NB? MKO;L? G;NLCR - CH ; =IFOGH @ILG ;H>
NL .
>?HIN?M NB? NL;=? I@ . 0B? &?HHLC=B N?MN MN;NCMNC= B;M ;H ;MSGJNINC=
=BCMKO;L? >CMNLC<ONCIH QCNB W W
* >?AL??M I@ @L??>IG
QB?L? W CM NB?
HOG<?L I@ P;LC;<F?M IL NB? >CG?HMCIH I@ NB? =ILL?F;NCIH G;NLCR
)OFNCP;LC;N? BCAB?L GIG?HNM
Q? QCFF >?M=LC<? BIQ NB? GIG?HNM I@ ; JILN@IFCI L?NOLH =;H <? ?RJL?MM?> CH ;
P?LS =IHP?HC?HN Q;S
9
Z Z Z
Z Z Z
Z
Z
Z
Z
Z
Z
Z
Z
Z
Z
?EF ? EF ?
EF (
A;CH
QCNB NB? U ?R;GJF?
NB? (
=IEOLNIMCM G;NLCR CM
9 7FG 7 FG 7
FG 7
FG 7
FG 7
FG (
<ON IHFS U U
*
8 8 9 9
89
8
8 9
9
%@ # ;H> $
NB?H # $
: : ; ; %H A?H?L;F
C@ # B;M
:;
:
: ;
;
>CG?HMCIH B C ;H> $ B;M >CG?HMCIH E F
#$ B;M >CG?HMCIH BE CF
/N;NCMNC=;F ,LIJ?LNC?M I@ "CH;H=C;F );LE?N ;N;
NB?
=IME?QH?MM ;H> =IEOLNIMCM
G;NLC=?M B;P? >CG?HMCIHM U( U ;H> U( U
<ON IHFS CHPIFP?
L?MJ?=NCP?FS
U U
U
* ;H> U U
U
U
* >C_?L?HN ?F?G?HNM
869>=270 686.7=< 8/ 98;=/8528 ;.=>;7<
*IQ
OMCHA NB?M? HIN;NCIHM @LIG NB? JL?PCIOM MO<M?=NCIH
GIG?HNM I@ NB?
JILN@IFCI L?NOLH =;H <? =IGJON?> CH ; P?LS NL;=N;<F? Q;S "IL ; ACP?H JILN@IFCI
Q?CABN P?=NIL
GIG?HNM I@ NB? JILN@IFCI L?NOLH ;L?
J
J
9
ZJ
9
J
9
'
0B? M?=IH> NI @IOLNBIL>?L GIG?HNM I@ NB? JILN@IFCI L?NOLH =;H ;FMI <? QLCN
N?H CH ; MFCABNFS >C_?L?HN @ILG
I
,
J 1
D YD D
YJ J
J (
D
I
,
ZJ 1
D YD D
YJ J
?J (
D
I
,
J 1
D YD D
YJ J
7J (
D
QB?L?
J 1 YD D
YJ J 9
(
4 5
?J 1 YD D
YJ J 9
(
4
5
7J 1 YD D
YJ J 9
(
;L?
L?MJ?=NCP?FS
NB? U(
P?=NILM I@ =IP;LC;H=?M
=IME?QH?MM
;H> =IEOLNIMCM
<?NQ??H NB? ;MM?N L?NOLHM ;H> NB? JILN@IFCI L?NOLH
"IL C
Q? B;P? NI =IGJON? ION I@ ?F?G?HNM @IL NB? =IP;LC;H=? G;NLCR
ION I@ ?F?G?HNM @IL NB? =IME?QH?MM G;NLCR
;H> ION I@ ?F?G?HNM @IL NB?
=IEOLNIMCM G;NLCR
0B?L? ;L? INB?L Q;SM I@ =;F=OF;NCHA =IGIG?HNM %H J;LNC=OF;L
CN G;S <? JIMMC<F?
NI CGJLIP? NB? ?^=C?H=S I@ =IGIG?HN G?;MOL?M <S MJ?=C@SCHA NB? DICHN >CMNLC<O
NCIH "IL CHMN;H=?
/CG;;H ;MMOG?M ;FF L?NOLHM >?J?H> IH ; L;H>IG @;=NIL
QCNB ; HIHMJB?LC=;F >CMNLC<ONCIH 3B?H HI MJ?=CW= MNLO=NOL? @IL NB? =IH>CNCIH;F
DICHN >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ L?NOLHM CM ;MMOG?>
NB? G?;MOL?M I@ =IGIG?HN G;S MO_?L
@LIG CH?^=C?H=S /?? ;FMI B;JN?L
MQ;JM
;H> ;FGIMN ;M G;HS NL;>CHA MSMN?GM ;L? ;P;CF;<F? 0B?L? ;L? G;HS
MG;FF >?N;CFM NB;N QCFF >CMNCHAOCMB IH? G;LE?N @ILG ;HINB?L $?L?
Q? >I HIN
=IHMC>?L NB? MG;FF >?N;CFM <ON JLIPC>? IHFS MIG? AFI<;F @?;NOL?M =B;L;=N?LCTCHA
G;LE?NM
3? G;S >CMNCHAOCMB
;N ; WLMN F?P?F
KOIN?>LCP?H G;LE?NM @LIG IL>?L>LCP?H
G;LE?NM %H ; >B<A21?6C2; :.?82A
;H CH>CPC>O;F I@ MIG? WH;H=C;F CHMNCNONCIH
=;FF?> ; >?;F?L
QCFF JIMN
?CNB?L <S PIC=?
OJIH L?KO?MN
IL J?LG;H?HNFS
PC;
MIG? ?F?=NLIHC= CH@ILG;NCIH MSMN?G
; JLC=? ;N QBC=B MB? CM QCFFCHA NI <OS NB?
<C> JLC=? IL ;N QBC=B MB? CM QCFFCHA NI M?FF NB? ;ME JLC=? ; ACP?H KO;HNCNS I@
NB? ;MM?N %@ ;H CH>CPC>O;F
C?
; JO<FC= CHP?MNIL
QCMB?M NI JOL=B;M? IL NI M?FF
"OH=NCIHCHA I@ WH;H=C;F G;LE?NM
NB? ;MM?N
MB? QCFF B;P? NI =;FF ;H ;A?HN
=;FF?> ; <LIE?L
QBI QCFF CH NOLH =;FF
; >?;F?L QBI QCFF ?P?HNO;FFS ?R?=ON? ; NL;>?
0B? KOIN?M NB;N NB? >?;F?L JIMNM G;S <? ?CNB?L WLG IL CH>C=;NCP? %H NB?
=;M? I@ ; WLG IL>?L
;HINB?L >?;F?L G;S NL;>? ;N NB? JIMN?> JLC=? OJ NI =?LN;CH
KO;HNCNC?M /BIOF> NB? KO;HNCNC?M ?R=??> ; ACP?H NBL?MBIF>
NB? >?;F?LM QIOF>
=IGGOHC=;N? >CL?=NFS ;H> ;AL?? IH JLC=?M ;==IL>CHA NI NB? KO;HNCNS JLIJIM?>
%@ NB? KOIN?M ;L? IHFS CH>C=;NCP?
; >?;F?L QCFF =;FF @IL =IHWLG;NCIH 0SJC=;FFS
0BCM CGJFC?M NB;N NB? ;=NO;F G;LE?N JLC=? CM NB? MOG I@ NB? JLC=? CH>C=;N?> CH NB?
WAOL? ;H> I@ MIG? @OH>;G?HN;F P;FO? I@ NB? MNI=E 0BCM NSJ? I@ L?JL?M?HN;NCIH CM
=IHP?HC?HN NI GI>?F NB? IL>?L <IIE ;M MBIQH <S #I?NNF?L
,;LFIOL
;H> .;D;H
"OH=NCIHCHA I@ "CH;H=C;F );LE?NM ;H> 0B?IL?NC=;F )I>?FM @IL .?NOLHM
-1
-2
-3
-4
-5
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90
NL;>?LM JF;=?> NB?CL IL>?LM <?NQ??H NB? NCG?M QB?H NB? NL;>?L L?JL?M?HN?> <S
JF;=?> B?L IL>?LM
F?;LFS
;N ;HS JICHN I@ NCG?
IH? I@ NB? FCGCN IL>?LM G;S <? =;H=?FF?>
FMI
; <CA IL>?L G;S A?N MJFCN CHNI MG;FF IL>?LM
NB?L?<S ;FFIQCHA ; F;LA?
NL;>?L NI BC>? B?L CHN?HNCIHM ?LN;CH G;LE?NM ;FMI ;FFIQ @IL BC>>?H IL>?LM
0B? H;NOL? I@ FCGCN IL>?LM =;H ;FMI <? L;NB?L =IGJF?R CH NB;N FCGCN IL>?LM G;S
<? =IH>CNCIH;F IH MIG? ?P?HNM /IG? FCGCN IL>?LM ;L? P;FC> @IL IH? >;S
;H>
INB?LM OJ NCFF NB? ?H> I@ ; GIHNB +L>?LM NB;N ;L? HIN NL;>?> CGG?>C;N?FS ;L?
=;FF?> /<<821 IL>?LM 0B?M? IL>?LM ;L? ;FMI H;G?> <BA@A.;16;4 <?12?@
.IOABFS MJ?;ECHA
IL>?LM =;H <? JON CHNI NQI =;N?AILC?M 0BIM? NB;N MBIOF>
<? ?R?=ON?> ;N IH=? ;H> NBIM? NB;N MBIOF> <? ?R?=ON?> ;N MIG? >;N? CH NB?
@ONOL?
QB?H MIG? MJ?=C;F =IH>CNCIH I==OLM (?N OM NOLH NI NB? WLMN =;N?AILS I@
IL>?LM NBIM? NB;N MBIOF> <? ?R?=ON?> CGG?>C;N?FS 0B? GIMN A?H?L;F IL>?L CH
NBCM =;N?AILS CM NB? :.?82A <?12?
QBC=B CM ;H IL>?L NI <OS IL M?FF CGG?>C;N?FS
MIG? MNI=E ;N NB? <?MN =OLL?HN JLC=? %@ NB? HOG<?L I@ MB;L?M NI <? <IOABN
IL MIF> CM F;LA?L NB;H NB? HOG<?L I@ MB;L?M ;N NB? <?MN ;P;CF;<F? JLC=?
NB?H
NB? IL>?L QCFF ?B; A52 <?12? /<<8 0B? MI=;FF?> .99<?;<;2 <?12? CM CHMN?;>
;H IL>?L NB;N GOMN <? WFF?> =IGJF?N?FS IL NB? NL;>? QCFF HIN N;E? JF;=? %H
NB? M?=IH> =;N?AILS
Q? WH> NL;>?M NB;N ;L? =IH>CNCIH;F "IL CHMN;H=?
; 96:6A
<?12? .A :.?82A =?602 CM ;H IL>?L QB?L? IHFS PIFOG? KOIN?> ;N NB? <?MN G;LE?N
PCMCN NI P;LCIOM MNI=E ?R=B;HA?M MO=B ;M !OLIH?RN IL 0ILIHNI /NI=E !R=B;HA?
L?P?;FM NB;N NB?L? ?RCMN G;HS NSJ?M I@ IL>?LM
"OH=NCIHCHA I@ WH;H=C;F G;LE?NM
JLC=? QCFF A?N ?R?=ON?> %@ <S =B;H=? NB? ?HNCL? IL>?L A?NM ?R?=ON?> G?;HCHA
NB;N NB? PIFOG? NL;>?> CM MG;FF?L NB;H NB? NIN;F PIFOG? ;N NB? <?MN JLC=?
NB?
IL>?L L?JL?M?HNM ; =IGJF?N? WFF +NB?LQCM? CN L?JL?M?HNM ; J;LNC;F WFF H99 <?
8699 # IL>?L CM ;H IL>?L QB?L? ;M <CA ; PIFOG? ;M JIMMC<F? QCFF <? NL;>?>
;N ; ACP?H JLC=?
<ON NB? J;LNC;F WFF QCFF CGG?>C;N?FS <? =;H=?FF?> +NB?L FCGCN
IL>?LM ;L? 1.F <?12?@
C?
IL>?LM NB;N ;L? P;FC> IHFS @IL NB? >;S QB?H NB?S
;L? ?HN?L?> N NB? ?H> I@ NB? >;S
MO=B IL>?LM QCFF <? ?FCGCH;N?> @LIG NB?
IL>?L <IIE +NB?L FCGCN IL>?LM MO=B ;M NB? 4<<1A6990.;029921 <?12?@ IL NB?
4<<1A6991.A2 <?12?@ MJ?=C@S ; JLC=?
PIFOG?
;H> CGJFC=CNFS ; NCG? BILCTIH %H
; AII>NCFF=;H=?FF?> IL>?L
NB? NCG? BILCTIH I@ NB? IL>?L CM ?CNB?L NB? NCG? I@
NB? ?R?=ONCIH
NB? NCG? I@ =;H=?FF;NCIH <S NB? NL;>?L
IL ; JL?MJ?=CW?> BILCTIH
M?N <S NB? ?R=B;HA? "IL CHMN;H=?
@IL NB? 0ILIHNI /NI=E !R=B;HA?
NB? NCG?
BILCTIH CM IH? S?;L 0B? AII>NCFF>;N? IL>?L CM P;FC> OHNCF ?R?=ONCIH
IL OHNCF
; MJ?=CW?> >;N?
A*695.< 8/ 8;-.;<
%@
BIQ?P?L
NB? NL;>?L QCMB?M NI JOL=B;M? OHCNM ;N G;LE?N JLC=?
MB?
QCFF IHFS A?N 0B? L?G;CHCHA OHCNM ;L? NB?H L?ACMN?L?> ;N NB? <C> MC>?
0BCM G?;HM NB;N NB? NL;>?L CH>C=;N?M B?L QCFFCHAH?MM NI JOL=B;M? OHCNM ;N
0B? IL>?L <IIE <?=IG?M
"OH=NCIHCHA I@ "CH;H=C;F );LE?NM ;H> 0B?IL?NC=;F )I>?FM @IL .?NOLHM
' ''
%H NBCM =;M?
;@N?L NB? NL;>?
NB? IL>?L <IIE <?=IG?M
*7-.5+;8= *7- =1. <=*+5. -2<=;2+>=287
N NBCM MN;A?
Q? B;P? JLIPC>?> NB? L?;>?L QCNB MIG? CH>C=;NCIHM IH BIQ W
H;H=C;F G;LE?NM QILE ?@IL? >?M=LC<CHA GI>?FM NB;N ;L? <;M?> IH CH@ILG;NCIH
"OH=NCIHCHA I@ "CH;H=C;F );LE?NM ;H> 0B?IL?NC=;F )I>?FM @IL .?NOLHM
;LLCP;F
Q? G;E? ; BCMNILC=;F J;L?HNB?MCM ;H> >CM=OMM );H>?F<LINZM GI>?F I@
;MM?N JLC=?M
9>CC5270 ;.<>5=
; =F;MM I@ >CMNLC<ONCIH >?M=LC<?> CHCNC;FFS <S ,;OF (fPS +H? =ILIFF;LS I@ NB?
MN;<F? >CMNLC<ONCIH CM NB;N HI WHCN? M?=IH> GIG?HNM ?RCMN %H INB?L QIL>M
;==IL>CHA NI );H>?F<LIN
Q? MBIOF> GI>?F L?NOLHM OMCHA ; >CMNLC<ONCIH QB?L?
NB? P;LC;H=? HI FIHA?L ?RCMNM F?;LFS
NBCM >CL?=NCIH CM >;LCHA
<?=;OM? CN CG
JFC?M NB;N NB? G?;HP;LC;H=? J;L;>CAG >I?M HIN BIF> ;HS FIHA?L $IQ?P?L
);HS P?LMCIHM I@ NB? =?HNL;F FCGCN NB?IL?G ?RCMN /?? @IL CHMN;H=? CFFCHAMF?S
IL #H?>?HEI ;H> 'IFGIAILIP 0B?M? P?LMCIHM MJ?=C@S BIQ >?J?H
>?HN L?;FCT;NCIHM G;S <? ;H> BIQ >CMMCGCF;L
CH N?LGM I@ >CMNLC<ONCIH
NB?S G;S
<? MI NB;N NB? =?HNL;F FCGCN NB?IL?G MCFF BIF>M
);H>?F<LIN ;H> NB? MN;<F? >CMNLC<ONCIH
AICHA NBCM Q;S B;M N;E?H L?M?;L=B CHNI ; H?Q >CL?=NCIH <S ;NNL;=NCHA NB? ;N
N?HNCIH I@ L?M?;L=B?LM IH NB? =IHNLC<ONCIHM I@ (fPS
;H CMMO? >CM=OMM?> CH F;N?L
=B;JN?LM
HINB?L >CL?=NCIH NB;N B;M <??H MOAA?MN?> <S F;LE CM NB;N NB?
;LLCP;F L;N? I@ CH@ILG;NCIH CM NCG? P;LSCHA 0BCM H?Q ;MMOGJNCIH B;M F?> NI
NB? MI=;FF?> GCRNOL? I@ >CMNLC<ONCIHM BSJINB?MCM ) $
; GI>?F NB;N B;M
<??H L?F;NCP?FS QC>?FS N?MN?>
;N F?;MN CH ; OHCP;LC;N? M?NNCHA
%H NBCM M?=IH> M?=NCIH I@ NB? =B;JN?L
Q? ;>>L?MM M?P?L;F CMMO?M CH NB?
NB?IL?NC=;F GI>?FCHA I@ ;MM?N L?NOLHM %H NB? L?G;CH>?L I@ NBCM M?=NCIH
Q?
>CM=OMM );H>?F<LINZM =IHNLC<ONCIH ;H> CNM FCGCN;NCIHM 0B?H
CH /?=NCIH
Q?
JL?M?HN NB? CHCNC;F P?LMCIH I@ NB? ) $ ;M >?M=LC<?> <S F;LE %H /?=NCIH
Q? NOLH NI NB? <CP;LC;N? ?RN?HMCIH I@ NBCM GI>?F
>?P?FIJ?> <S 0;O=B?H
;H> ,CNNM 3? >CM=OMM NB? N?MNM I@ NB? ) $
JLIJIM?> <S $;LLCM
;H> .C=B;L>MIH ;H> /GCNB "CH;FFS
/?=NCIH >?M=LC<?M NB? GI>?F I@
!;MF?S
'C?@?L
;H> +Z$;L; NB;N ;FMI JLIPC>?M ; DICHN GI>?F @IL ;MM?N
L?NOLHM ;H> NL;>CHA PIFOG?
<ON CH NB? =IHN?RN I@ ; KOIN? >LCP?H G;LE?N
%=*+5. -2<=;2+>=287
);H>?F<LIN E?JN NB? ;MMOGJNCIH NB;N JLC=? CH=L?G?HNM ;L? CH>?J?H>?HN
;H> C>?HNC=;FFS >CMNLC<ON?> S >LIJJCHA NB? ;MMOGJNCIH NB;N P;LC;H=? CM WHCN?
J D J D ( J
(
QCNB J J J '
QB?L? NB? N?LG CH P\ =ILL?MJIH>M NI CHNLI>O=CHA ; G?;H I@ ' 3? HINC=? NB;N
@IL NBCM >?WHCNCIH
J J
J '
%N CM Q?FFEHIQH NB;N NB? ;O=BS >CMNLC<ONCIH B;M @;NN?L N;CFM NB;H NB? HILG;F
0BCM L?MOFN MBIQM NB;N NB? J;L;G?N?L
CM ;MMI=C;N?> QCNB NB? N;CF I@ NB?
>CMNLC<ONCIH #CP?H NB;N \* )\) CH NB? ?RJL?MMCIH I@ NB? =B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH CM
HINBCHA ?FM? <ON NB? @OH=NCIH L?NOLHCHA NB? MCAH I@ \
J;L;G?N?L CM ;MMI=C;N?>
QCNB NB? L?F;NCP? CGJILN;H=? I@ NB? NQI MC>?M I@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH %H INB?L
QIL>M
CN =B;L;=N?LCT?M NB? ME?QH?MM I@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH
"CAOL? L?JL?M?HNM ?R;GJF?M I@ NB? MN;<F? >CMNLC<ONCIH 0B?M? =OLP?M ;L?
I<N;CH?> <S CHN?AL;NCIH QCNB NB? /CGJMIH @ILGOF; @IL NB? CHP?LM? NL;HM@ILG
%HMJ?=NCIH I@ NB? =OLP?M L?P?;FM NB;N ;FF NB? >?HMCNC?M B;P? N;CFM NB;N ;L? @;NN?L
NB;H NB? IH?M I@ NB? HILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH I<N;CH?> B?L? QCNB NB? P;FO?
'
/?=NCIH >CM=OMM?M BIQ NI I<N;CH ; >?HMCNS @LIG ; =B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH %N
NOLHM ION NB;N NB? =B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH N;E?M ; QC>? L;HA? ;M <?=IG?M MG;FF?L
;H> MG;FF?L 0B? CHN?AL;NCIH OM?M ;M L;HA? @IL J @IL ;FF CHN?AL;NCIHM
QB?L? ! "IL NB? =;M? Q? B;P? OM?> ;M L;HA?
!P?H
QCNB NBCM L;HA? NB?L? L?G;CH MIG? IM=CFF;NCIHM CH NB? >?HMCNS
==IL>CHA NI NB? /CGJMIH LOF?
NI ?P;FO;N? NB? CHN?AL;F = *;* Q? =IHMNLO=N
* @IL @ / QCNB * - ;H> * 3 0B? L?MOFNCHA MJ;=CHA <?NQ??H
;>D;=?HN * CM >?HIN?> <S FMI >?HIN? = = * 0B? CHN?AL;F G;S NB?H <?
;JJLIRCG;N?> QCNB
= *;* =
= = = = =
= =
);H>?F<LIN ;H> NB? MN;<F? >CMNLC<ONCIH
4
α=0.5
α=1
3.5
α=1.5
α=2
3
2.5
1.5
0.5
0
-4 -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 4
20
$13 <3 A52 @A./92 16@A?6/BA6<; 3<? C.?6<B@ C.9B2@ <3
0B? CHP?LMCIH @ILGOF; <?=IG?M GIL? >C^=OFN NI CGJF?G?HN @IL MG;FF P;FO?M
I@
( CGJFSCHA NB;N AL?;N =;L? H??>M NI <? N;E?H CH ;=NO;F CGJF?G?HN;NCIHM
I@ NB? >?HMCNS %H>??>
F;LA?
CGJFS ; @;MN >?=L?;M? I@ & ;M \ GIP?M ;Q;S
@LIG
QB?L?;M ; MG;FF
CGJFC?M ; F;LA? >IG;CH @IL &
;H> NBOM GIL? QILE
NI M?F?=N =ILL?=N OJJ?L ;H> FIQ?L <IOH>M @IL NB? CHN?AL;NCIH CHPIFP?> CH NB?
CHP?LM? "IOLC?L NL;HM@ILG H??>M NI <? JLIPC>?>
%H "CAOL?
Q? E??J NB? J;L;G?N?L
M?N NI ;H> J?L@ILG =B;HA?M @IL
NB? J;L;G?N?LM ;H> M NBCM WAOL? MBIQM
NB? =B;HA? CH NB? J;L;G?N?L
=ILL?MJIH>M NI ; =B;HA? I@ NB? ME?QH?MM I@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH JIMCNCP? CM
;MMI=C;N?> QCNB ; JIMCNCP? ME?QH?MM 0B? J;L;G?N?L =ILL?MJIH>M NI ; M=;FCHA
I@ NB? =OLP?M
!P?H NBIOAB );H>?F<LINZM JLIJIM;F JLIPC>?> ;H ?RJF;H;NCIH I@ NB? HIH
HILG;FCNS I@ L?NOLHM
CN Q;M G?N QCNB ; =?LN;CH M=?JNC=CMG "CLMN
;M ;FL?;>S
G?HNCIH?>
NBCM >CMNLC<ONCIH
HIN ;FFIQCHA @IL NB? ?RCMN?H=? I@ NB? P;LC;H=?
?H
N;CF?> NB;N ; AL?;N J;LN I@ GI>?LH WH;H=? MBIOF> <? ;<;H>IH?> "IL CHMN;H=?
IL 'IONLIOP?FCM
JLIJIM?M GOFNCMN?J ;FAILCNBGM NI A?N ; ALCJ IH
NB? J;L;G?N?LM F?;LFS
OMCHA GI>?LH =IGJONCHA JIQ?L
CN QIOF> <? JIMMC<F?
NI HOG?LC=;FFS CHP?LN NB? =B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH ;H> NI ?MNCG;N? CNM J;L;G?
"OH=NCIHCHA I@ "CH;H=C;F );LE?NM ;H> 0B?IL?NC=;F )I>?FM @IL .?NOLHM
2
α=1.5,β=0,γ=1
1.8 α=1.5,β=1,γ=1
α=1.5,β=0,γ=2
1.6
1.4
1.2
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
-4 -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 4
20 $13 <3 A52 @A./92 16@A?6/BA6<; 3<? C.?6<B@ C.9B2@ <3
#CP?H NB? NB?IL?NC=;F >C^=OFNC?M ;MMI=C;N?> QCNB NB? NB?ILS I@ MN;<F? >CMNLC<
ONCIHM MO=B ;M NB? HIH?RCMN?H=? I@ NB? M?=IH> ;H> BCAB?L GIG?HNM ;H> CNM
@;CFOL? NI L?MCMN ?GJCLC=;F N?MNM
;H ;FN?LH;NCP? ?RJF;H;NCIH NI );H>?F<LINZM
B;> NI <? >?P?FIJ?> ;N MIG? JICHN +H? ;FN?LH;NCP? ?RJF;H;NCIH AI?M <;=E NI
NB? QILE I@ F;LE IH=?LHCHA NB? ;LLCP;F L;N? I@ ?P?HNM
F;LE MOAA?MNM
NB;N NB? =FI=E >I?M HIN ;FQ;SM NC=E ;N ; =IHMN;HN MJ??> $? ;MMOG?M NB;N NB?L?
;L? >;SM IH QBC=B GIL? H?QM CM L?F?;M?> NB;H IH INB?LM ;SM QCNB GIL? H?QM
;L? NB?H ?RJ?=N?> NI >CMJF;S AL?;N?L PIF;NCFCNS
"ILG;FFS
F?N WN &)# <N
<? NB? FIAJLC=? JLI=?MM $?L?
Q? ;MMOG? NB;N
NCG? CM N;ECHA =IHNCHOIOM P;FO?M
[ 0B? CH>?R [ L?JL?M?HNM NB? .0AB.9
F;LEZM MO<IL>CH;NCIH GI>?F
A6:2
;FMI =;FF?> 0.92;1.? A6:2 F;LE ;MMOG?M NB;N NB?L? ?RCMNM ; MNI=B;MNC=
JLI=?MM QLCNN?H @ [
NB;N G;JM CHNI ' 0BCM JLI=?MM CM ;MMOG?> NI <?
CH=L?;MCHA CH NB;N C@ [ ) Z CN GOMN <? NB;N @ [
@ Z
0BCM G;J CHNOCNCP?FS
N;E?M =;F?H>;L NCG? CHNI QB;N =IOF> <? =;FF?> 2C2;A A6:2 0B? ;MMOGJNCIH
NB;N GIL? CH@ILG;NCIH <?=IG?M ;P;CF;<F? ;M NCG? AI?M <S NL;HMF;N?M CHNI NB?
@;=N NB;N @ [
GOMN <? ;H CH=L?;MCHA @OH=NCIH I@ =;F?H>;L NCG? F;LE NB?H
MOJJIM?M NB;N NB? FIAJLC=? JLI=?MM CM ACP?H <S
WN @ [
C4 N (
QB?L? CN MN;H>M @IL ; LIQHC;H GINCIH
0B? JLI=?MM WN CM M;C> NI <? @B/<?16;.A21 NI CN ' 0B? JLI=?MM @ [
CM =;FF?>
; 16?20A6;4 =?<02@@ 3? G;S JL?M?HNFS ;ME BIQ NBCM H?Q GI>?F MIFP?M NB? CMMO?
I@ HIHHILG;FCNS I@ >;CFS L?NOLHM 3? NBOM =IHMC>?L FIAJLC=? CH=L?G?HNM IP?L
; ACP?H NCG? MJ;H I@ F?HANB NB;N =IOF> =ILL?MJIH> NI ; >;S 0B?H Q? B;P?
YN WN WN @ [
@ [
C4 N C4 N
'
#CP?H NB;N CH=L?G?HNM I@ LIQHC;H GINCIHM ;L? HILG;FFS >CMNLC<ON?>
Q? I<
N;CH ;@N?L CHNLI>O=CHA NB? HIN;NCIH 5N @ [
@ [
NB;N
YN 5N ( 5N
'
0BCM ?RJL?MMCIH G?;HM NB;N NB? L?NOLH G?;MOL?> IP?L NB? ACP?H NCG? MJ;H
>?J?H>M IH NB? ;GIOHN I@ ;=NCPCNS
G?;MOL?> <S 5N
NB;N I==OLL?> IP?L NB;N
CHN?LP;F %N ;FMI CGJFC?M NB;N =IH>CNCIH;F IH NB? CH@ILG;NCIH ;LLCP;F
L?NOLHM
;L? >CMNLC<ON?> ;M ; HILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH
#CP?H NB;N ?;=B L?NOLH CM >L;QH @LIG ; >C_?L?HN >CMNLC<ONCIH
Q? G;S PC?Q
NB? L?NOLHM ;M <?CHA A?H?L;N?> <S ; GCRNOL? I@ >CMNLC<ONCIHM "IL NBCM L?;MIH
=B;HA?M IP?L NCG? 0B;N NSJ? I@ GI>?F <?FIHAM NI NB? =F;MM I@ MNI=B;MNC= PIF;NCF
CNS GI>?FM
M?? @IL CHMN;H=? ;LH>IL_*C?FM?H ;H> /B?JB;L> /NCFF
;
@OLNB?L =IGJFC=;NCIH =IG?M @LIG NB? ?GJCLC=;F I<M?LP;NCIH NB;N ;@N?L ; F;LA?
>LIJ CH L?NOLHM
G;LE?NM N?H> NI <? GIL? ;ACN;N?>
;H I<M?LP;NCIH =;FF?> F?P?L
;A? ?_?=N
; @?;NOL? NB;N H??>M NI <? GI>?F?>
HINB?L JIMMC<CFCNS CM NI ;MMOG? NB;N NB? CH@ILG;NCIH ;LLCP;F L;N? =IHMNC
NON?M ; F;N?HN
NBOM OHI<M?LP;<F? P;LC;<F?
;<ION QBC=B Q? QCMB NI G;E? MIG?
CH@?L?H=? 0BCM F;N?HN P;LC;<F? G;S ;FMI ;_?=N INB?L I<M?LP;<F? P;LC;<F?M MO=B
;M PIFOG? IL NB? NL;>CHA ;=NCPCNS IP?L ; ACP?H NCG? BILCTIH A;CH NBCM IJ?HM
P;LCIOM >CL?=NCIHM WLMN >CL?=NCIH
@IFFIQ?> @IL CHMN;H=? <S 0;O=B?H ;H> ,CNNM
CM NI CHNLI>O=? PIFOG? ;H> NI ;MMOG? NB;N <INB L?NOLHM ;H> PIFOG?
;L? >LCP?H <S MIG? =IGGIH MIOL=? I@ CH@ILG;NCIH M?=IH> >CL?=NCIH
N;E?H
@IL CHMN;H=? <S &IH?M
';OF
;H> (CJMIH
CM NI WH> P;LC;<F?M NB;N =IOF>
JLIRS NB? CH@ILG;NCIH ;LLCP;F L;N? ;H>C>;N?M NB;N =IOF> JLIRS NBCM ;LLCP;F
L;N? ;L? MB;L? PIFOG?
PIFOG? CH GIH?N;LS N?LGM
HOG<?L I@ NL;HM;=NCIHM J?L
OHCN I@ NCG?
NB? ;P?L;A? NL;>? MCT?
?N= >CM=OMMCIH I@ JLIRC?M @IL ;LLCP;F
L;N? G;S <? @IOH> CH (I ;H> 3;HA
3? HIQ >CM=OMM
CH NB? @IFFIQCHA
NB?M? NQI ;FN?LH;NCP? ;JJLI;=B?M 3? <?
ACH CH /?=NCIH
QCNB NB? =IHM?KO?H=?M I@ ;MMOGCHA ; FIAHILG;F >CMNLC<O
NCIH @IL NB? >CL?=NCHA JLI=?MM 0B?H
CH /?=NCIH
Q? >CM=OMM NB? GC=LIMNLO=
NOL? GI>?F >?P?FIJ?> <S 0;O=B?H ;H> ,CNNM
CH QBC=B NB? CH@ILG;NCIH
;LLCP;F JF;SM NB? LIF? I@ >CL?=NCHA JLI=?MM @IL <INB ;MM?N L?NOLHM ;H> NL;>CHA
PIFOG?
&1. -.7<2=B 8/ ;.=>;7< >7-.; <>+8;-27*=287
1MCHA NB? JLIJ?LNC?M I@ =IH>CNCIH;F JLI<;<CFCNC?M ;H> ;MMOGCHA NB;N NB? >CM
NLC<ONCIH I@ CH=L?G?HNM I@ NB? >CL?=NCHA JLI=?MM 5N @IFFIQM ; >CMNLC<ONCIH QCNB
>?HMCNS N 5N
Q? I<N;CH NB;N
.
M YN
M YN )5N
N 5N
K5N '
)*
Q? I<N;CH NB;N
.
YN L 5N
M YN
8 "/*
)* L 5N L 5N
&)# 5N
+ "/* K5N '
T 5N T
0I CFFOMNL;N? NB? NSJ?M I@ MB;J?M I@ NB? >?HMCNS NB;N L?MOFNM @LIG NB? MO<IL>C
H;NCIH
Q? =IHMNLO=N HOG?LC=;FFS NB? >?HMCNS ;==IL>CHA NI 0B? HOG?LC=;F
CHN?AL;NCIH =;H <? J?L@ILG?> <S ;JJLIRCG;NCHA NB? CHN?AL;F CHPIFPCHA 5N QCNB
F;LEZM MO<IL>CH;NCIH GI>?F
NB? /CGJMIH LOF? >C^=OFNS CM NB? =BIC=? I@ FIQ?L ;H> OJJ?L <IOH>M @IL NB?
CHN?AL;F FMI NB? =BIC=? I@ MN?J F?HANB <?NQ??H ;>D;=?HN JICHNM IP?L QBC=B NI
?P;FO;N? NB? >?HMCNS G;S <? CGJILN;HN #CP?H NB;N NB? CHN?AL;H> CHPIFP?M ;
>?HMCNS
Q? G;S <? AOC>?> <S NB? 013 I@ 5N 3? G;S =BIIM? ;M ;H OJJ?L <IOH>
; P;FO? MO=B NB;N I@ NB? JLI<;<CFCNS G;MM CM N;E?H CHNI =IHMC>?L;NCIH
3? =IHMC>?L >C_?L?HN GI>?FM NB;N >C_?L <S NB?CL J;L;G?N?LM ;M >?M=LC<?> CH
0;<F?
%H NB? @IFFIQCHA
Q? M?N NB? FIQ?L <IOH> I@ NB? CHN?AL;NCIH 8 '
A
;H> '
' 3? I<N;CH "CAOL? L?JL?M?HNCHA NB? P;LCIOM >?HMCNC?M
0B? <?H=BG;LE GI>?F
)I>?F
CM NL;=?> QCNB ; =IHNCHOIOM NBCH FCH? M
Q? CH=L?;M? NB? P;LC;H=? I@ L?NOLHM
NB? >?HMCNS <?=IG?M QC>?L ;M NB? =OLP?
QCNB NB? NBC=E =IHNCHOIOM FCH? N?MNCW?M 0BCM =ILL?MJIH>M NI )I>?F 0B? H?RN
?R?L=CM? =IHMCMNM CH CH=L?;MCHA NB? ;P?L;A? F?P?F I@ H?QM @LIG NI 0BCM
SC?F>M )I>?F L?JL?M?HN?> QCNB NB? >INN?> FCH? 3? HINC=? NB;N NB? G?;H CM
MBC@N?> NI NB? LCABN ;H> NB? <I>S I@ NB? >?HMCNS <?=IG?M QC>?L %H NBCM GI>?F
H?QM ;_?=N <INB NB? >LC@N ;H> NB? P;LC;H=? 3? GCABN PC?Q NB? @?;NOL? NB;N ;H
CH=L?;M? CH H?QM MBC@NM NB? >?HMCNS NI NB? LCABN ;M ;H CH=IHP?HC?HN I@ NBCM GI>?F
0BCM CH=IHP?HC?HN CM ?;MS NI =CL=OGP?HN <S ;MMOGCHA NB;N 5N >I?M HIN ;_?=N
NB? G?;H I@ L?NOLHM 0B? F;MN GI>?F OH>?L =IHMC>?L;NCIH
L?JL?M?HN?> QCNB NB?
>;MB?M
)I>?F
=ILL?MJIH>M NI ;H CH=L?;M? CH NB? P;LC;H=? I@ NB? CH@ILG;NCIH
;LLCP;F L;N? 3? HINC=? NB;N NBCM A?H?L;N?M >?HMCNC?M QCNB J;LNC=OF;LFS NBC=E
N;CFM 0BCM CM ; @?;NOL? NB;N Q? ?RJ?=N @IL ;=NO;F L?NOLH >;N;
);HS >CMNLC<ONCIH;F ;MMOGJNCIHM =;H <? G;>? =IH=?LHCHA NB? CH@ILG;
NCIH ;LLCP;F F;LE ;MMOG?M ; FIAHILG;F ;LLCP;F L;N? /I >I 0;O=B?H
;H> ,CNNM ;H> "IMN?L ;H> 2CMQ;H;NB;H .C=B;L>MIH ;H> /GCNB
=IHMC>?L CH ;>>CNCIH ; OHC@ILG ;LLCP;F L;N?
; ,ICMMIH >CMNLC<ONCIH
;H>
NB? CHP?LN?> A;GG; >CMNLC<ONCIH 0BCM F;NN?L GI>?F CM J;LNC=OF;LFS ;JJ?;FCHA
<?=;OM? CN B;M <??H MBIQH <S F;NN<?LA ;H> #IH?>?M NB;N C@ L?NOLHM
;L? =IH>CNCIH;FFS HILG;F QCNB ; P;LC;H=? NB;N @IFFIQM NB? CHP?LM? A;GG; >CM
NLC<ONCIH
NB?H NB? L?MOFNCHA >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ L?NOLHM QCFF <? NB? /NO>?HN [ >CM
NLC<ONCIH M Q? QCFF M?? CH B;JN?L
NB? /NO>?HN [ >CMNLC<ONCIH B;M G;HS
@?;NOL?M NB;N ;FFIQ @IL ; AII> GI>?FCHA I@ ;MM?N L?NOLHM )IL? L?=?HNFS
);>;H
;H> /?H?N; JLIJIM?> NB? OM? I@ NB? A;GG; >CMNLC<ONCIH 1M? I@ NBCM
>CMNLC<ONCIH SC?F>M NB? MI=;FF?> P;LC;H=?A;GG; GI>?F 0B? C>?; I@ =B;HACHA
NCG? G;S ;FMI <? @IOH> CH NB? FCN?L;NOL? IH (fPS JLI=?MM?M
;M Q? QCFF >CM=OMM
CH /?=NCIH
&*+5. *.9B2@ <3 A52 =.?.:2A2?@ 3<? A52 C.?6<B@ :<129@ 0<;@612?21
)I>?F HOG<?L $ $ B
"OH=NCIHCHA I@ "CH;H=C;F );LE?NM ;H> 0B?IL?NC=;F )I>?FM @IL .?NOLHM
0.25
Model 1
Model 2
Model 3
0.2 Model 4
0.15
0.1
0.05
0
-5 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35
20 $13 <3 C.?6<B@ 12;@6A62@ <3 ?2AB?;@ B;12? 9<4;<?:.9 @B/<?16;.A6<;
*IQ
Q? AI IH? MN?J @OLNB?L ;H> CHP?MNCA;N? BIQ NB? CH@ILG;NCIH ;LLCP;F G;S
;_?=N HIN IHFS NB? ;MM?N L?NOLH <ON ;FMI NB? NL;>CHA PIFOG? 0B? GI>?F >?
P?FIJ?> <S 0;O=B?H ;H> ,CNNM CM L;NB?L MCGJF?
S?N P?LS LC=B
;H> CN
B;M <??H ?RN?H>?> CHNI P;LCIOM >CL?=NCIHM WLMN =IHNLC<ONCIH I@ NBCM QILE
CM NB;N CN JLIPC>?M ; <?NN?L OH>?LMN;H>CHA I@ NB? Q;S PIF;NCFCNS MBIOF> <?B;P?
C 0B?L? ;L? 6 NL;>?LM 0BCM HOG<?L CM ACP?H ?RIA?HIOMFS %H INB?L QIL>M
/?? @IL CHMN;H=? (C?M?H@?F>
<CP;LC;N? GCRNOL?I@>CMNLC<ONCIH GI>?F @IL L?NOLH ;H> PIFOG?
NI NB? @ONOL?M G;LE?N NB;H NI ;H ?KOCNS G;LE?N +H? L?;MIH QBS NBCM ;M
MOGJNCIH H??>M NI <? G;>? CM NB;N NBLIOAB NCG?
NB? HOG<?L I@ =IGJ;HC?M
FCMN?> CH=L?;M?M 0I NL;=E NB? HOG<?L I@ FCMN?> MB;L?M CGJFC?M ;>>CNCIH;F
>C^=OFNC?M
CCC %N CM ;MMOG?> NB;N ;N ?;=B >;S
NB?L? ;L? 5 NL;>?M 0B? CH>?R P
( ( 5
%H ?KOCFC<LCOG
NB? I<M?LP?> JLC=? CM NB? ;P?L;A? L?M?LP;NCIH P;FO? ;GIHA ;FF
NL;>?LM
3B;N CM NB? PIFOG? NL;>?> <?NQ??H NQI NCG? J?LCI>M 0I OH>?LMN;H> BIQ
NI =IGJON? NB? ?KOCFC<LCOG PIFOG?
=IHMC>?L NB? @IFFIQCHA HOG?LC=;F ?R;GJF?
,IMCNCIHD ,IMCNCIHD OS
*M?FF
Q
=D
Q =D
Q =D
0B? M?=IH> ;H> NBCL> =IFOGHM L?JL?M?HN NB? JIMCNCIHM
CH OHCNM I@ MIG? ;MM?N
I@ NBL?? NL;>?LM
Q
( ( @IL NQI >C_?L?HN CHMN;HNM
P
;H> P 0B? F;MN
=IFOGH CH>C=;N?M NB? =B;HA?M L?KOCL?> NI ;=BC?P? NB? H?Q JIMCNCIH
"OH=NCIHCHA I@ "CH;H=C;F );LE?NM ;H> 0B?IL?NC=;F )I>?FM @IL .?NOLHM
%H NBCM ?R;GJF?
NL;>?L IH? Q
B;> OHCNM ;N NCG? P
;H> MB?
>CGCHCMB?M B?L JIMCNCIH >IQH NI OHCN ;N NCG? P' 0B? H?N PIFOG? NL;>?> CM
%N L?JL?M?HNM B;F@ I@ NB? NIN;F ;<MIFON? P;FO? I@ NB? NL;>?> ;MM?NM 0BCM
L?;MIHCHA ;FMI BIF>M @IL NB? INB?L NL;>?LM M ; =IHM?KO?H=?
NB? ;AAL?A;N?
PIFOG? ;N NL;>? P CM
* *
, ,
]D )=DE =DE ) WDE WD '
E E
3? HINC=? NB;N NB? PIFOG? CM >O? NI =B;HA?M CH L?M?LP;NCIH P;FO?M QCNB L?MJ?=N
NI NB?CL ;P?L;A?M M ; =IHM?KO?H=?
C@ NL;>?LM B;P? P?LS MCGCF;L IJCHCIH HI
B?N?LIA?H?CNS I@ <?FC?@M
NB?L? H??>M NI <? HI PIFOG? 5?N
NB?L? G;S <? F;LA?
DOGJM CH JLC=?M 0BCM NSJ? I@ JLC=? <?B;PCIL B;M ;FMI <??H >CM=OMM?> CH ;H
?;LFS =IHNLC<ONCIH <S ';LJI_
0I AI @OLNB?L
?MJ?=C;FFS NI G;E? NB? GI>?F N?MN;<F?
0;O=B?H ;H> ,CNNM
;MMOG? NB;N =B;HA?M CH L?M?LP;NCIH P;FO?M ;L? >O? NI AFI<;F CH@ILG;NCIH
;H> NL;>?LMJ?=CW= CH@ILG;NCIH
WDE D ! DE '
0B? WLMN ?RJL?MMCIH MBIQM NB;N =IGGIH IJCHCIH ;H> ;P?L;A? CH@ILG;NCIH
G;NN?LM %@ =IGGIH CH@ILG;NCIH BCHNM ;N AII> H?QM
NB? ;MM?N JLC=? CM NI
CH=L?;M? %@ NB? JLCP;N? CH@ILG;NCIH I@ IH? I@ NB? NL;>?LM CM NB;N NB? JLC=? MBIOF>
<? BCAB?L
NB?H NB? ;MM?N JLC=? QCFF CH=L?;M? 0BCM CH=L?;M? QCFF
BIQ?P?L
<?
;P?L;A?> ION <S NB? G;MM I@ NL;>?LM
0B? M?=IH> ?RJL?MMCIH MBIQM NB;N B?N?LIA?H?CNS I@ CH@ILG;NCIH CM L?MJIH
MC<F? @IL PIFOG? 0I AI @OLNB?L
NB? ;ONBILM ;MMOG? HILG;FCNS I@ ;FF CH>CPC>O;F
<CP;LC;N? GCRNOL?I@>CMNLC<ONCIH GI>?F @IL L?NOLH ;H> PIFOG?
=IGJIH?HNM
3?
L?=;FF NB? @IFFIQCHA
8 ;H;FSNC=;F L?MOFN
OM?@OF @IL F;N?L IH C@
D ( ( NB?H 1 )D) * 0B? =IGJON;NCIH I@ NB? WLMN ;H>
M?=IH> GIG?HNM ;MMI=C;N?> QCNB ?KO;NCIHM ;H> SC?F>M
TL 1 YD (
L B YD (
6 :
6
TP 1 ]D 6 1 ! DE ! D B ! DE ! D
:
:
6
6 6
(
6 6
P B ]D B ! DE ! D '
N NBCM MN;A?
NB? GI>?F OH@IF>M CNM CHA?HOCNS "IL CHMN;H=?
Q? HINC=? NB;N
;M NB? HOG<?L I@ NL;>?LM 6 CH=L?;M?M
NB? ?RJ?=N?> PIFOG?
P
G;S CH=L?;M?
QBCF? ;N NB? M;G? NCG? JLC=? =B;HA? P;LC;<CFCNS A?NM MG;FF?L 0B?M? ;JJ?;L
NI <? =B;L;=N?LCMNC=M NB;N Q? ;FMI I<M?LP? CH WH;H=C;F G;LE?NM 0B? F;MN NQI
?KO;NCIHM ;FMI MBIQ NB;N F;LA?L B?N?LIA?H?CNS I@ <?FC?@M AI?M B;H> CH B;H>
QCNB GIL? PIFOG? ;H> F;LA?L P;LC;<CFCNS NB?L?I@ 3? M?? NB;N NBCM GI>?F =;H
NB?L?@IL?
<? OM?> NI CHP?MNCA;N? NB? CGJ;=N I@ ; =B;HA? CH NB? HOG<?L I@
NL;>?LM IP?L NCG? 0B? GI>?F ;FMI B;M CHN?L?MNCHA JLIJ?LNC?M C@ Q? @I=OM IHFS IH
; ACP?H GIG?HN I@ NCG?
M;S ; >;S
QB?H NB? HOG<?L I@ NL;>?LM =;H <? ?RJ?=N?>
NI <? =IHMN;HN +P?L ; >;S
Q? I<M?LP? 5 =?602 2>B696/?6. 0B? ?RJL?MMCIH =?602
2>B696/?6. CM I@ =IOLM? OM?> CH ; L;NB?L FIIM? M?HM?
<?=;OM? QCNB ?KOCFC<LCOG
CN CM G?;HN B?L? NB;N ; NL;>? I==OLL?> %H ?GJCLC=;F QILE
Q? =IOF> JLIRS NB?
HOG<?L I@ JLC=? ?KOCFC<LC; QCNB NB? HOG<?L I@ NL;>?M IP?L ; ACP?H NCG? BILCTIH
H ;FN?LH;NCP? CHN?LJL?N;NCIH CM NB;N NB?L? ;L? JLC=? ?KOCFC<LC; ;H> NB?H @IL
MIG? I@ NB?G NB?L? ;L? NL;>?M %H NBCM F;N?L CHN?LJL?N;NCIH
Q? I<M?LP? NB?
NL;>? JLI=?MM ;H> B;P? ;M ; F;N?HN JLI=?MM NB? HOG<?L I@ ?KOCFC<LC;
%@ Q? OM? NB? CHCNC;F C>?;
NB?H Q? =;H N;E? NB? >;CFS HOG<?L I@ NL;>?M ;M
; JLIRS @IL NB? HOG<?L I@ >;CFS ?KOCFC<LC; 3? NB?H I<N;CH NB;N
)
, )
,
Y YD ;H> ] ]D (
D D
%@ Q? B;> ( NB?H <S N;ECHA NB? L;NCI G K Q? IOABN NI I<N;CH ; HILG;FFS
>CMNLC<ON?> L;H>IG P;LC;<F? !GJCLC=;FFS
NBCM CM HIN NB? =;M?
<CP;LC;N? GCRNOL?I@>CMNLC<ONCIH GI>?F @IL L?NOLH ;H> PIFOG?
6952,*=287< 8/ =1. 62A=>;. 8/ -2<=;2+>=287< 1B98=1.<2<
;H> PIFOG?
]N
I@ ; ACP?H >;S
;L? =IH>CNCIH;FFS HILG;F FMI
=IH>CNCIH;FFS
IH NB? CH@ILG;NCIH ;LLCP;F
5N ( NB? =IP;LC;H=? <?NQ??H L?NOLHM ;H> PIFOG? CM
?KO;F NI T?LI
"ILG;FFS
Q? G;S QLCN? NB? GI>?F I@ $;LLCM ;M
YN TL 5N ( L 5N
(
]N TP 5N ( P 5N
(
/V] YN ( ]N )5N '
;FL?;>S I<N;CH?> <S 0;O=B?H ;H> ,CNNM .C=B;L>MIH ;H> /GCNB
@OLNB?L <OCFN IH NB?M? =IH>CNCIH;F ;H> OH=IH>CNCIH;F GIG?HNM NI =IHMNLO=N ;
@ILG;F N?MN I@ NB? GCRNOL? I@ >CMNLC<ONCIH BSJINB?MCM <;M?> IH NB? G?NBI>
I@ GIG?HNM OLL?HNFS
Q? @IFFIQ $;LLCM
;H> JL?M?HN M?F?=N?>
GIG?HNM ;H> =IGIG?HNM I@ NBCM GI>?F 0B?M? NB?IL?NC=;F GIG?HNM G;S <?
NB?H OM?> NI ?MNCG;N? NB? J;L;G?N?LM I@ NB? GI>?F CH ; #?H?L;FCT?> )?NBI>
I@ )IG?HNM #)) M?NNCHA
MMOG? NB;N NB? CH@ILG;NCIH ;LLCP;F P;LC;<F? 5 B;M G?;H T) ;H> NB;N
=?HNL;F GIG?HNM I@ 5 ;L? >?HIN?> <S F 1 5 T)
F FMI ;MMOG? NB;N
=IH>CNCIH;FFS IH 5
NB? >;CFS JLC=? CH=L?G?HN M;NCMW?M
1Y)5 TL 5(
B Y)5 1 Y TL 5
)5 L 5'
0B?H
OMCHA NB? F;Q I@ CN?L;N?> ?RJ?=N;NCIHM
Q? B;P? NB? @IFFIQCHA OH=IH
>CNCIH;F GIG?HNM I@ Y M?? NB? JJ?H>CR I@ $;LLCM
@IL =IGJON;NCIH;F
>?N;CFM
(C?M?H@?F>
JLIPC>?M >CL?=N N?MNM I@ NB? 0;O=B?H ;H> ,CNNM
GI>?F
"IL CHMN;H=?
NB? >?LCP;NCIH I@ ?KO;NCIH CM I<PCIOM
"OH=NCIHCHA I@ "CH;H=C;F );LE?NM ;H> 0B?IL?NC=;F )I>?FM @IL .?NOLHM
1Y TL T) (
1 Y TL T)
B Y L T) T L (
1 Y TL T)
L L T
L
(
1 Y TL T)
L T ) L T L L
T L L T) TL '
FMI
C@ TL
NB?H
1Y L T) (
1 Y L T)
TP L T ) '
?RY 1 (
B Y L T) T L
Y 1Y
7\Y 1
B Y
L T L L
TL TL
(
L T) T L
0B?L?@IL?
C@ TL
NB?H L?NOLHM QCFF HIN <? ME?Q?> ?P?H C@ NB?L? CM MO<IL
>CH;NCIH !KO;NCIH MBIQM NB;N C@ TL
EOLNIMCM <?=IG?M
7\Y (
T )
;H>
NBOM
;M $;LLCM JICHNM ION
EOLNIMCM QCFF <? F;LA?L NB;H NB? IH?
I<N;CH?> @IL ; HILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH "IL NB? A?H?L;F =;M?
QB?L? TL
NB?
AL?;N?L NB? ME?QH?MM ;H> EOLNIMCM I@ NB? H?QM ;LLCP;F L;N?
NB? AL?;N?L NB?
EOLNIMCM I@ NB? L?NOLHM 0BCM L?MOFN G;S ;FMI <? @IOH> CH F;LE 'OLNIMCM
CH ?R=?MM IP?L CM ; Q?FF>I=OG?HN?> @?;NOL? I@ ;MM?N L?NOLHM ;M ;FL?;>S MBIQH
CH B;JN?L
D T8 5( 8 5
( T8 ( 8 + (
E T9 5( 9 5
( T9 ( 9 + (
QCNB
/V] D( E )5
(
NB?H NB? @IFFIQCHA L?MOFNM BIF>
/V] D( 5 T8 (
/V] D ( 5 8 T 8
T)
(
/V] D( E T8 T9 (
/V] D ( E 8 T9 T9 T 8
T)
'
$;LLCM ;FMI >?LCP?M NB? ?RJL?MMCIH @IL NB? =ILL?F;NCIH <?NQ??H ;
L?NOLH ;H> NB? CH@ILG;NCIH P;LC;<F? IL <?NQ??H NB? NQI L?NOLHM 3? I<N;CH
NB;N
T8
/VYY D( 5 '
8 T) T 8
M Q? =IOF> ?RJ?=N
C@ NB? P;LC;H=? I@ NB? >;CFS CH@ILG;NCIH L;N? N?H>M
NI T?LI
MI >I?M NB? =ILL?F;NCIH <?NQ??H D ;H> 5 FMI
C@ NB? >LC@N I@ NB? JLC=?M
T8 CM T?LI
NB?L? QCFF <? HI =ILL?F;NCIH <?NQ??H L?NOLHM ;H> NB? CH@ILG;NCIH
XIQ 0B? MCAH I@ NB? =ILL?F;NCIH CM >?N?LGCH?> <S NB? MCAH I@ T8 3? ;FMI
I<N;CH
0B?M? L?MOFNM ;L? I<N;CH?> CH ; MNL;CABN@ILQ;L> G;HH?L "IL CHMN;H=?
Q? B;P?
0B? M?=IH> ?KO;FCNS @IFFIQM @LIG NB? @;=N NB;N CH NB? WLMN FCH?
&6 ;H> &6*
;L? <INB EHIQH IH=? * CM EHIQH "OLNB?L
;FF NB? N?LGM CHPIFPCHA 6 &6*
=;H=?F
"OH=NCIHCHA I@ "CH;H=C;F );LE?NM ;H> 0B?IL?NC=;F )I>?FM @IL .?NOLHM
T8 T9
/VYY D( E '
8 T) T8
9 T)
T 9
%@ T8
NB?H
/VYY D ( 5 T )
(
9
/VYY D ( E T) T) '
T 9
YN TL 5N ( L 5N
( TL
;H> L + '
0B?H
Q? >?>O=? NB? @IFFIQCHA ?RJL?MMCIH @IL NB? ;ONI=IP;LC;H=? I@ L?NOLHM
IH=?LHCHA PIF;NCFCNS
$;LLCM MBIQM NB;N C@ TL NB?H
/V] YN ( YN
1YN YN
1YN
11YN YN
)5N ( 5N L T )
1 L 5N L 5N L T )
L '
15N 5N 1 5N T) T)
5N T) T)
T ) '
T L *
/VYY YN ( YN '
L T) T L ( H
H(
<CP;LC;N? GCRNOL?I@>CMNLC<ONCIH GI>?F @IL L?NOLH ;H> PIFOG?
6 Volume
x 10
3
2.5
1.5
0.5
0
0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 7000 8000 9000 10000
Filtered Volum e
10
0
0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 7000 8000 9000 10000
20 C<9BA6<; <3 A52 1.69F A?.16;4 C<9B:2 <3 A52 '$
MIG? P;FO?
M;S
NB?S ?MNCG;N? P;LCIOM @ILGM I@ NB? GCRNOL? I@ >CMNLC<ONCIH
BSJINB?MCM QCNB #)) 0B? GIG?HNA?H?L;NCHA =IH>CNCIHM ;L? ACP?H <S
4
,
N4
9N
(
@ N
QB?L?
YN TL
]N TP
YN TL
L T L
] T
T
N P P P
Y T
] T
T T
N L N P L P
Y T
N L L
T L L
TL
9N
'
]N TP
P
T P P
TP
YN TL
]N TP
L P
P TL L T P
T L T P
YN TL
]N TP
TL TP L
T
L TP
YN TL
]N TP
TL TP P
TL T
P
0B? #)) ?MNCG;NCIH B;M <??H >?P?FIJ?> <S $;HM?H /?? $;GCFNIH
@IL ; Q?FFQLCNN?H ?RJIMCNCIH I@ NB;N ?MNCG;NCIH ;H> N?MNCHA N?=BHCKO?
<CP;LC;N? GCRNOL?I@>CMNLC<ONCIH GI>?F @IL L?NOLH ;H> PIFOG?
&*+5.
$.?.:2A2? 2@A6:.A2@ <3 A52 :6EAB?2<316@A?6/BA6<;@ :<129
,;L;G?N?L !MNCG;N? /N> ?LLIL
B$
$
B(
(
=IHP?LA?M NI 19N
( QBC=B MBIOF> <? ?R;=NFS ?KO;F NI T?LI C@ NB? GCRNOL?
I@ >CMNLC<ONCIHM BSJINB?MCM BIF>M /CH=? NB? HOG<?L I@ GIG?HN =IH>CNCIHM ?R
=??>M NB? HOG<?L I@ OHEHIQH J;L;G?N?LM
NB? ?GJCLC=;F GIG?HN =IH>CNCIHM
=;HHIN <? ?R;=NFS ?KO;F NI T?LI $IQ?P?L
CH NBCM =;M?
CN =;H <? N?MN?> QB?NB?L
NB? GI>?F =ILL?=NFS ;>DOMNM NI NB? >;N;
OMCHA NB?M? MI=;FF?> IP?LC>?HNC@SCHA
L?MNLC=NCIHM 0BCM CM NB? <;MCM @IL NB? $;HM?HZM & N?MN %N =;H ;FMI <?
N?MN?> C@ NB? J;L;G?N?LM M;NCM@S =?LN;CH L?F;NCIHM
0B? #)) ?MNCG;NIL I@ CM I<N;CH?> <S GCHCGCTCHA NB? ?RJL?MMCIH
N4
? N4
(
'
@ N
0B?L? ;L? ;FMI P?LMCIHM I@ NB? GI>?F NB;N =ILL?=N @IL JIMMC<F? ;ONI=ILL?F;
NCIH ;H> B?N?LIME?>;MNC=CNS CH NB? >;N; "IL NB? GI>?F ;N B;H>
NB?L? ;L?
GIG?HN =IH>CNCIHM ;H> OHEHIQH J;L;G?N?LM 1MCHA NB? M;G? >;N; ;M JL?PC
IOMFS
CHPIFPCHA
I<M?LP;NCIHM
L;HACHA @LIG &;HO;LS
NI &;HO;LS
;N NB? ;AAL?A;N? F?P?F
Q? I<N;CH J;L;G?N?L ?MNCG;N?M MOGG;LCT?>
CH 0;<F?
%HMJ?=NCIH I@ NB? P;LCIOM J;L;G?N?LM CH>C=;N?M NB;N NB? CH@ILG;NCIH XIQ
P;LC;<F? B;M ; P?LS MG;FF P;LC;H=? %H>??>
NB? J;L;G?N?L N;E?M ; P;FO?
I@ ' 0BCM L?G;LE B;M ;FMI <??H G;>? <S .C=B;L>MIH ;H> /GCNB
/CGCF;LFS NI NB?CL WH>CHAM
NB? CH@ILG;NCIH XIQ P;LC;<F? CM BCABFS JIMCNCP?FS
ME?Q?> /O=B ; >CMNLC<ONCIH CM =IGJ;NC<F? QCNB NB? ;MMOGJNCIH NB;N NB? ;LLCP;F
L;N? N?H>M NI <? =IHMN;HN GIMN I@ NB? NCG? CHN?LLOJN?> <S J?LCI>M QB?H NB?L?
CM ; BOA? CH=L?;M? CH NB? CH@ILG;NCIH ;LLCP;F XIQ 0B?M? CH=L?;M?M =IOF> <?
?RJF;CH?> <S CH@ILG;NCIH L?F?;M?M ;N ; WLG MJ?=CW= F?P?F IL ;N ; G;=LI?=IHIGC=
F?P?F
/?? $;GCFNIH
"OH=NCIHCHA I@ "CH;H=C;F );LE?NM ;H> 0B?IL?NC=;F )I>?FM @IL .?NOLHM
= (
QB?L? NB? P;LC;<F?M QCNB ; B;N L?JL?M?HN NB? P;LC;<F?M ?MNCG;N?> <S #))
3? ;FMI =IHMC>?L NB? G;NLCR I@ AL;>C?HNM I@ NB? NQI GIG?HN =IH>CNCIHM CH
?RJL?MMCIH
3 (
*
;H> =IGJON? NB? MN;NCMNC=M =
3B 3
=( QB?L? B CM NB? =IP;LC;H=? G;NLCR I@
NB? J;L;G?N?L ?MNCG;N?M =IHN;CH?> CH NB? P?=NIL ' 0BCM MN;NCMNC=M CM >CMNLC<ON?>
;M ;
OH>?L NB? HOFF BSJINB?MCM
FN?LH;NCP?FS
Q? G;S N?MN C@ NB? CH@ILG;NCIH ;LLCP;F JLI=?MM =IOF> <? A?H
?L;N?> <S ;H CHP?LM? A;GG; >CMNLC<ONCIH "IL MO=B ; >CMNLC<ONCIH
.C=B;L>MIH
;H> /GCNB >?LCP? NB? GIG?HN L?MNLC=NCIH
4
'
0B?S MBIQ @OLNB?LGIL? NB;N C@ NB? CH@ILG;NCIH ;LLCP;F L;N? @IFFIQM ; ,ICMMIH
>CMNLC<ONCIH
NB?H NB? HOFF BSJINB?MCM <?=IG?M
<CP;LC;N? GCRNOL?I@>CMNLC<ONCIH GI>?F @IL L?NOLH ;H> PIFOG?
&*+5. (2@A <3 .12>B.A6<; <3 . 46C2; 16@A?6/BA6<; <3 A52 1.A.
)I>?F MN;NCMNC= JP;FO?
1HC@ILG
%HP?LM? A;GG;
,ICMMIH
(IAHILG;F
(
4
'
(;MN
NB?S =IHMC>?L NB? =;M? I@ ; FIAHILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH ACP?H <S
(
4
'
A=.7<287<
/I @;L
Q? B;P? =IHMC>?L?> ; GI>?F NB;N =IOF> ?RJF;CH MIG? I@ NB? MNSFCT?>
@;=NM I@ ;MM?N L?NOLHM 3? G;S ;ME HIQ C@ CN CM JIMMC<F? NI G?;MOL? >CL?=NFS
NB? CH@ILG;NCIH XIQ CH G;LE?NM %H BCM M?GCH;F =IHNLC<ONCIH
F;LE
=IHD?=NOL?M NB;N PIFOG? GCABN JLIRS NB? CH@ILG;NCIH XIQ $IQ?P?L
B? L?D?=NM
NB;N C>?; IH ?GJCLC=;F ALIOH>M HINB?L C>?;
JLIJIM?> <S (;GIOL?OR ;H>
(;MNL;J?M
CM NI CHP?MNCA;N? QB?NB?L PIFOG? =IOF> =;JNOL? MIG?
I@ NB? CH@ILG;NCIH =IHN;CH?> CH NB? P;LC;H=? I@ ;MM?N L?NOLHM 0BCM C>?; CM <;M?>
IH
QBC=B MBIQM NB;N NB? P;LC;H=? CM =IH>CNCIH?> IH NB? CH@ILG;NCIH
XIQ 0B?S OM? ; MI=;FF?> #.$ GI>?F
JL?M?HN?> CH >?N;CF CH B;JN?L
;H> MBIQ NB;N PIFOG? CM ; <?NN?L JL?>C=NIL I@ NB? >;CFS P;LC;<CFCNS NB;H ;
J;L;G?NLC= GI>?F
%H NBCM MJCLCN
;HINB?L CMMO? CM QB?NB?L NB?L? ?RCMNM ; P;LC;<F? NB;N GCABN
<? GIL? ;>?KO;N? NI =;JNOL? NB? CH@ILG;NCIH XIQ NB;H PIFOG? 0BCM CM NB?
"OH=NCIHCHA I@ "CH;H=C;F );LE?NM ;H> 0B?IL?NC=;F )I>?FM @IL .?NOLHM
;FMI A?;L?> ;N GI>?FCHA NBCM NSJ? I@ <?B;PCIL ;H> GCABN JLIPC>? CHN?L?MNCHA
;FN?LH;NCP?M NI MO=B ; GI>?F
3? HIQ =IHMC>?L ;H ?=IHIGC= GI>?F NB;N ?RJF;CHM NB? KOIN? ;LLCP;F JLI=?MM
;H> NB? JLC=? JLI=?MM !;MF?S
'C?@?L
;H> +Z$;L; !'+ NB?L?;@N?L
JLIPC>? ; >?M=LCJNCIH I@ NB? N?GJIL;F ?PIFONCIH I@ NB? <?MN <C> ;H> ;ME JLC=?M
;M Q?FF ;M ; >?M=LCJNCIH I@ NB? JLC=? XIQ 0BCM J;J?L ;FMI ;FFIQM @IL ;H ?=IHI
G?NLC= ?MNCG;NCIH I@ NB? J;L;G?N?LM CHPIFP?> CH NB? GI>?F !P?H NBIOAB NBCM
=IHNLC<ONCIH B?FJM NI OH>?LMN;H> NB? N?GJIL;F ?PIFONCIH I@ NB? <?MN <C> ;H>
;ME
NB?L? L?G;CHM NB? CMMO? I@ I<N;CHCHA ; M;NCM@;=NILS GI>?F I@ NB? FCGCN IL>?L
;LLCP;F ;N NB? F?P?F I@ NB? ?HNCL? IL>?L <IIE /O=B ; GI>?F QIOF>
I<PCIOMFS
;H> NB?S QCFF <OS QCNB NB? M;G? JLI<;<CFCNS I@ #* %N CM ;FMI JIMMC<F? NB;N
HI OHCH@ILG?> NL;>?L NL;>?M 0BCM ?P?HN QCFF N;E? JF;=? QCNB ; JLI<;<CFCNS I@
#
1HC@ILG?> NL;>?L M?FFM
#
1HC@ILG?> NL;>?L >I?M HIN NL;>?
1HC@ILG?> NL;>?L <OSM
MCGOF;N?> >;CFS NL;>?M %N CM ;MMOG?> NB;N NB?L? ;L? NL;>?M J?L >;S
;H>
NB;N Q? =IHMC>?L >;SM !;=B I@ NB? LIQM CH NB? WAOL? L?JL?M?HNM
NB?L?@IL?
%H@ILG?> NL;>?L M?FFM
(IQ MCAH;F
#
$CAB MCAH;F
%H@ILG?> NL;>?L <OSM
%H@ILG;NCIH L?F?;M?
#
*I CH@ILG;NCIH L?F?;M?
#
NB? NL;>?XIQ ;M CN I==OLM >OLCHA IH? >;S 0B? J;L;G?N?LM =BIM?H ;L? '
'
'
;H> # ' 0B? MSG<IF L?JL?M?HNM ; <OS IL>?L ;H> NB?
MSG<IF L?JL?M?HNM ; M?FF IL>?L >IN CH>C=;N?M NB;N HI NL;>? I==OLL?> >OLCHA
; ACP?H NCG? J?LCI>
S MCGJFS CHMJ?=NCHA NB? M?KO?H=? I@ NL;>?M NB;N NIIE JF;=? IH ACP?H >;SM
Q? =;H CH@?L NB? MCAH;F NB;N I==OLL?> IH ; ACP?H >;S "IL CHMN;H=?
NB? WLMN
>;S
=ILL?MJIH>CHA NI NB? FIQ?MN LIQ I@ MSG<IFM
CM =B;L;=N?LCT?> <S G;HS
NL;>?M
;FGIMN ;FF I@ NB?G <?CHA <OS IL>?LM 0BCM G?;HM NB;N IH NBCM >;S
;
AII> MCAH;F AIN L?P?;F?> /CH=? NB? CH@ILG?> NL;>?LM <?=;G? CH@ILG?> ;<ION
NB? MCAH;F <?CHA ; AII> IH?
NB?S <IOABN MNI=E ;FF >;S FIHA +HFS I==;MCIH;FFS
>C> ; M?FF IL>?L I==OL 0BCM CM QB?H ;H OHCH@ILG?> NL;>?L AIN NB? =B;H=? I@
NL;>CHA %@ Q? =IHMC>?L NB? NL;>?M NB;N NIIE JF;=? IH >;S
Q? HINC=? NB;N
?CNB?L NB?L? CM HI NL;>? IL NB;N NB? J;NN?LH I@ <OSM ;H> M?FFM CM L;H>IG 0BCM
MOAA?MNM NB;N IH NBCM >;S HI CH@ILG;NCIH AIN L?P?;F?> +HFS HICM? NL;>?LM AIN
NI NL;>?
;H> QB?H NB?S >C>
NB?S NL;>?> ;N L;H>IG
GI>?F I@ JLC=?M ;H> KOIN?M CH ; KOIN?>LCP?H G;LE?N
11
10
0
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
20 '6:B9.A6<; <3 1.69F A?.12@ B@6;4 A52 # :<129
+NB?L M?NM I@ J;L;G?N?LM G;S <? OM?> "IL NB? M?N I@ J;L;G?N?LM '
'
'
;H> # '
Q? I<N;CH "CAOL? %HMJ?=NCIH I@ NBCM WAOL?
L?P?;FM NB;N
JL?M?HNFS
NB?L? ;L? >;SM QCNB ?MM?HNC;FFS HI NL;>?
@IL CHMN;H=?
>;SM ;H> 0B?M? Q?L? >;SM QB?H HI CH@ILG;NCIH AIN L?P?;F?> ,L?M?HNFS
11
10
0
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
20 '6:B9.A6<; <3 1.69F A?.12@ B@6;4 A52 # :<129
,L?M?HNFS
Q? QCFF ;A;CH @IFFIQ !'+ ;H> MBIQ BIQ NB? J;L;G?N?LM OH>?LFSCHA
NB? NL;>? XIQ =IOF> <? ?MNCG;N?> QCNB ?=IHIG?NLC= G?NBI>M 0B?H Q? QCFF
MBIQ BIQ LCME H?ONL;F G;LE?N G;E?LM KOIN? JLC=?M CH NBCM M?NNCHA
<=26*=270 =1. 9*;*6.=.;<
0B? CH@ILG?> NL;>?L QCFF J?L@?=NFS EHIQ NB? MCAH;F ;H> QCFF NB?H NL;>? QCNB ;
ACP?H JLI<;<CFCNS $?L NL;>?M QCFF <? =IHMCMN?HN QCNB NB? MCAH;F
C?
<OS QB?H
H?QM CM AII> 0B? OHCH@ILG?> NL;>?L QCFF <OS IL M?FF L;H>IGFS !;=B >;S CM
MO<>CPC>?> CHNI CHN?LP;FM I@ ?KO;F F?HANB OLCHA ?;=B CHN?LP;F
IHFS IH? NL;>?L
G;S NL;>? 0BCM G?;HM NB;N NL;>?M N;E? JF;=? M?KO?HNC;FFS
3? >?HIN? <S .( ?( ;H> : NB? HOG<?L I@ <OS
M?FF
;H> HI NL;>? J?LCI>M
IP?L ; ACP?H J?LCI> I@ NCG? F?;LFS
C@ NB? NL;>CHA >;S B;M <??H MO<>CPC>?>
CHNI 9 NL;>CHA CHN?LP;FM
NB?H . ? : 9 3? L?ALIOJ ;FF NB? J;L;G?N?LM
CHNI ; MCHAF? P?=NIL
( ( ( #
' M !'+
Q? >?HIN? <S NB? MCAH;F NB;N
AIN L?P?;F?> HI MCAH;F
( BCAB P;FO? I@ ;MM?N
4
IL FIQ P;FO? I@ ;MM?N
8
0B? OH=IH>CNCIH;F JLI<;<CFCNS I@ B;PCHA . <OS J?LCI>M
? M?FF J?LCI>M
;H> :
HI NL;>? J?LCI>M CH NB? M;GJF?
C?
NB? NLCJF?N '.( ?( : (( CM
F?;LFS
CHMJ?=NCIH I@ NB? NL??M L?P?;FM NB;N
+ 4
(
+ 8
(
+
'
"OLNB?LGIL?
<S =IHMC>?LCHA <INB NB? NL?? ;H> NB? MO<NL??
;H> =IOHNCHA NB?
JIMMC<CFCNC?M I@ NB? P;LCIOM ?P?HNM
Q? I<N;CH
# # # 3 .
+ .( ?( : ) 4
#
(
# # # 3 .
+ .( ?( : ) 8
#
(
# # # 3 # #3
. .
+ .( ?( : )
#
#
'
%@ Q? B;P? I<M?LP;NCIHM I@ NL;>?M @IL P;LCIOM >;SM
M;S [
( ( @( CN CM ?;MS
C?
NB? HOG<?L I@ <OS
M?FF
;H> HI
NL;>? J?LCI>M
NI I<N;CH ;H ?MNCG;N? @IL <S G;RCGCTCHA
4
,
0
+# ' / &)# +.N ( ?N ( :N )
'
N
1MCHA NB? MCGOF;NCIH M?NNCHA NB;N ;FMI SC?F>?> NB? P;LCIOM NL;>? XIQM
Q?
?MNCG;N? NB? J;L;G?N?LM I@ NB? GI>?F QCNB ; MCGJF? );RCGOG(CE?FCBII>
JLI=?>OL? 0;<F? MOGG;LCT?M NB? L?MOFNM I@ NB?M? ?MNCG;NCIHM 0B? WLMN
;H> M?=IH> =IFOGHM CH>C=;N? NB? J;L;G?N?LM =BIM?H @IL NB? MCGOF;NCIH 0B?
NBCL> ;H> @IOLNB =IFOGHM >CMJF;S NB? J;L;G?N?L ?MNCG;N?M ;H> MN;H>;L> ?LLILM
OMCHA M;GJF?M I@ MCT?
;H> NB? F;MN NQI =IFOGHM MBIQ NB? ?MNCG;N?M @IL
M;GJF?M I@ MCT? @
' %HMJ?=NCIH I@ NB? MN;H>;L> ?LLILM MBIQM NB;N NB?
KO;FCNS I@ NB? J;L;G?N?LM
;H> CM HIN ;M AII> ;M NBIM? =IH=?LHCHA # ;H>
0BCM CM FIAC=;F <?=;OM?
;H> ;L? MJ?=CW= NI ACP?H >;SM ;H> NBOM G;HS
>;SM ;L? L?KOCL?> NI A?N AII> ?MNCG;N?M @IL NB? J;L;G?N?LM +H NB? INB?L
B;H>
# ;H> ;L? >;S MJ?=CW=
NBOM CN CM JIMMC<F? NI I<N;CH AII> ?MNCG;N?M
L;NB?L ?;MCFS
<?=;OM? Q? =;H OM? ;FF NB? ;P;CF;<F? CHNL;>;S CH@ILG;NCIH M
NB? M;GJF? MCT? CH=L?;M?M
NB? KO;FCNS I@ NB? ?MNCG;N?M CH=L?;M?M ;M Q? QIOF>
?RJ?=N IGJ;LCMIH I@ NB? NLO? J;L;G?N?LM QCNB NB? ?MNCG;N?M MBIQM NB;N NB?
KO;FCNS I@ NB? ?MNCG;NCIH CM L;NB?L CGJL?MMCP?
M !'+ MBIQ
CN CM ;FMI JIMMC<F? NI N;E? NB? GI>?F NI ;=NO;F >;N;
<ON C@
NBCM CM >IH?
M?P?L;F JLI<F?GM G;S ;LCM?
%H ;FF NBIM? ?MNCG;NCIHM
NB? J;L;G?N?LM Q?L? =IHMNL;CH?> NI <?FIHA NI NB? M?N
7
8 "OLNB?LGIL?
NB? CHCNC;F P;FO?M ;L? 8
3? L?JILN MN;H>;L> ?LLILM NB;N ;L? =IGJON?> QCNB NB? OMO;F $?MMC;H .I<OMN
MN;H>;L> ?LLILM Q?L? P?LS =FIM? NI NB? IH?M L?JILN?>
"OH=NCIHCHA I@ "CH;H=C;F );LE?NM ;H> 0B?IL?NC=;F )I>?FM @IL .?NOLHM
&*+5. $.?.:2A2? 2@A6:.A2@ <3 A52 # :<129 12=2;16;4 <; A52 @.:=92 @6G2
0LO? 2 2
P;FO? !MNCG;N? /N> ?LL !MNCG;N? /N> ?LL
NB?CL ;==OL;=S QCFF <? FIQ %@ ; F;LA? HOG<?L I@ >;SM ;L? OM?>
NB? J;L;G?N?LM
G;S B;P? =B;HA?> >O? NI MNLO=NOL;F =B;HA?M
0B?M? =;P?;NM <?CHA G;>?
!'+ >?N?LGCH?
OMCHA ; P?LS =IGGIH MNI=E
NB;N ;L? HICM? NL;>?M #II> ;H> <;> H?QM ;JJ?;L NI <? ?KO;FFS FCE?FS
0B? JLI<;<CFCNS I@ ;H OHCH@ILG?> NL;>?L NI J;LNC=CJ;N? CH NB? G;LE?N CM @IOH>
NI <? ;<ION FF NB?M? J;L;G?N?LM ;JJ?;L NI <? L;NB?L JF;OMC<F?
%N CM OM?@OF NI L?G?G<?L NB? LOF?M I@ =IH>CNCIH;F JLI<;<CFCNC?M (?N # ;H> $ <?
NQI ?P?HNM
NB?H
"# "#
"
;H> "
GI>?F I@ JLC=?M ;H> KOIN?M CH ; KOIN?>LCP?H G;LE?N
*IQ
C@ G?;HM NB;N NB?L? CM HI MCAH;F
Q? B;P?
+ B B )? + B B ( ( 4( 8( ? * + ?
+ B B ) ( ? + )?
+ B B ) 4( ? + 4)?
+ B B ) 8( ? + 8)?
+ )?
+ 8)? '
$?L?
NB? WLMN FCH? @IFFIQM @LIG NB? @;=N NB;N =;H IHFS N;E? NBL?? P;FO?M
4
;H> 8 0BOM
NB?M? P;FO?M =ILL?MJIH> NI ;FF JIMMC<F? ION=IG?M @IL NBCM
L;H>IG P;LC;<F? 0B? M?=IH> FCH? @IFFIQM @LIG NB? @;=N NB;N =;H IHFS N;E?
IH? P;FO? ;N ; NCG? 0B? F;MN FCH?
CH NOLH
>?LCP?M @LIG NB? @;=N NB;N C@ NB?L?
CM HI MCAH;F
CH>?J?H>?HNFS I@ NB? IL>?L
CN ;>>M HI P;FO? C@ NB? MCAH;F CM EHIQH
B?L? NI <?
NB?H NB? JLI<;<CFCNS I@ NB? ;MM?N B;PCHA FIQ P;FO? CM FMI
Q? B;P? + 4
( + 8
( ;H> +
' FMI
!P?HNO;FFS
Q? I<N;CH
#*
+ )?
+?
#*
+ 8)? (
+?
#*
+ 4)? (
+?
QCNB
+?
#*'
.?ALIOJCHA NB? P;LCIOM N?LGM ;H> OMCHA
Q? I<N;CH NB? G;LE?N G;E?LZM
<C> KOIN? ;H> ;ME KOIN?
B
_
B _
I 1B ) ? (
_
B _
B
_
H 1B ) . (
_
QB?L? _
#*' OLCHA NB? >;S
NB? G;LE?N G;E?L QCFF ;>DOMN B?L
<?FC?@M OMCHA ;FF NB? CH@ILG;NCIH NB;N I==OLL?> OJ NI ; ACP?H NCG? I@ NB? >;S
OLCHA NL;>CHA CHN?LP;F P( ?CNB?L :
HI NL;>? I==OLM
IL ?
; M;F? I==OLM
IL
.
; <OS IL>?L I==OLM "IFFIQCHA !'+
CN CM =IHP?HC?HN NI J?L@ILG ; MFCABN
;<OM? I@ HIN;NCIH ;H> >?HIN? <S ?( :( ;H> . NB? HOG<?L I@ M;F?M
HI NL;>?M
;@N?L NB? NL;>CHA M?KO?H=? .( ?( ;H> :( >?J?H>CHA IH QB?NB?L NB? H?RN IL>?L
CM ; M?FF IL ; <OS IL>?L IH>CNCIH;F IH NB?M? ?P?HNM
NB? G;LE?N G;E?L M?NM
NB? <C> ;H> ;ME KOIN?M ;M
QB?L?
+ B B ).( ?
( : + ).( ?
( :
+ 8).( ?
( : (
;L? OHCH@ILG?> NL;>?LM L?;FFS ;M OHCH@ILG?> ;M NB?S ;L? GI>?F?> B?L? FMI
G;S MIG? F?;LHCHA I==OL @IL ;FF ;A?HNM ;M NB? >;S ?PIFP?M (;MN
NB? GI>?F
IHFS @I=OM?M IH NB? <?MN <C> ;H> <?MN ;ME QBC=B CM ; FCGCN;NCIH
<?=;OM? CH
JL;=NC=? NB? ?HNCL? IL>?L <IIE CM I<M?LP;<F?
"OH=NCIHCHA I@ "CH;H=C;F );LE?NM ;H> 0B?IL?NC=;F )I>?FM @IL .?NOLHM
130
120
110
100
90
80
70
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
20 '6:B9.A6<; <3 /61 .;1 .@8 >B<A2@ B@6;4 A52 # :<129 3<? 1.F
130
125
120
115
110
105
100
95
90
85
80
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
20 '6:B9.A6<; <3 /61 .;1 .@8 >B<A2@ B@6;4 A52 # :<129 3<? 1.F
GI>?F I@ JLC=?M ;H> KOIN?M CH ; KOIN?>LCP?H G;LE?N
0B? !'+ GI>?F NB;N Q? DOMN >?M=LC<?> JLIPC>?M ; M?NNCHA NB;N ACP?M ;
>?M=LCJNCIH @IL NB? <?MN <C> ;H> ;ME JLC=? ;M Q?FF ;M @IL ; JLC=? JLI=?MM 3?
QCFF M?? CH NB? H?RN M?=NCIH NB;N NB?L? ?RCMN GI>?FM NB;N =IHMC>?L NB? IJNCG;F
M;F?
IL <OS
MNL;N?AS
CH=FO>CHA @L;=NCIHCHA ;H IL>?L IP?L NCG?
C@ NL;>?LM B;P?
; G;LE?N CGJ;=N 0I P;FC>;N? MO=B GI>?FM
CN ;JJ?;LM OM?@OF NI B;P? ; L?;FCM
NC= >?M=LCJNCIH I@ NB? ?HNCL? IL>?L <IIE "IL CHMN;H=?
IL>?L ;LLCP;FM G;S <?
GI>?F?> OMCHA ; ,ICMMIH JLI=?MM /O=B ; MNL;N?AS B;M <??H MBIQH NI SC?F> ;H
?R=?FF?HN ?=IHIG?NLC= WN <S (I
);='CHF;S
;H> 6B;HA
BIQ?P?L
NB?
IONI@M;GJF? J?L@ILG;H=? CM L;NB?L Q?;E 0BCM L?P?;FM NB? CGJILN;H=? NB;N
MNLO=NOL;F GI>?FM I@ NB? IL>?L <IIE =IOF> B;P? ,LI<;<FS GIL? ?_ILN QCFF <?
>?PIN?> NI MO=B MNLO=NOL;F GI>?FM IP?L NB? =IGCHA S?;LM
Q? JL?M?HN ; MCGJF? >CM=L?N? NCG? P?LMCIH I@ NB? FGAL?H ;H> BLCMM
GI>?F 0B? ;MMOGJNCIH I@ IOL MCGJFCW?> GI>?F CM NB;N NB?L? ;L? >;N?M
C?
&)# ?F
&)# ?F
#F '
0B? >CMNCH=NCIH <?NQ??H N?GJIL;LS ;H> J?LG;H?HN JLC=? CGJ;=N AI?M <;=E NI
'L;OM ;H> /NIFF ;M Q?FF ;M $IFNB;OM?H
(?@NQC=B
;H> );S?LM
;H> B;H ;H> (;EIHCMBIE
"OH=NCIHCHA I@ "CH;H=C;F );LE?NM ;H> 0B?IL?NC=;F )I>?FM @IL .?NOLHM
?F ?F HUF #F
H + '
"IL MCGJFC=CNS
CN B;M <??H ;MMOG?> B?L? NB;N NB? JLC=? CGJ;=N CM FCH?;L A;CH
=?LN;CH ?RN?HMCIHM =IOF> <? G;>? NI CH=ILJIL;N? HIHFCH?;LCNC?M CH NB? JLC=?
CGJ;=N 0B? J;L;G?N?L H NB?L?@IL? CH>C=;N?M <S BIQ GO=B JLC=?M A?N J?LG;
H?HNFS >?JL?MM?> CH ; M;F? I@ UF MB;L?M
M NB? NL;>?L M?FFM B?L MB;L?M
MB? QCFF ;FMI @;=? ; ACP?H >?G;H> M=B?>OF?
F?;LFS
;M MB? M?FFM B?L MB;L?M
;==IL>CHA NI NB? MB;J? I@ NB? FCGCN IL>?L <IIE
MB? QCFF B;P? ;H CGJ;=N IH NB? G;LE?N 3? G;S GI>?F NBCM N?GJIL;LS CGJ;=N
<S ;MMOGCHA NB;N NB? ;P?L;A? JLC=? ;N QBC=B NB? NL;>? ?P?HNO;FFS N;E?M JF;=?
CM
?F
?F IUF '
$?L?
I CM ; M=;F;L NB;N CH>C=;N?M NB? N?GJIL;LS JLC=? CGJ;=N 0B? F;LA?L I
NB? MN??J?L NB? MFIJ? I@ NB? IL>?L <IIE ;H> NB? F;LA?L NB? CGJ;=N IH NB? JLC=?
#CP?H NB;N NB? NL;>?L IHFS >CMJIM?M I@ NQI J?LCI>M >OLCHA QBC=B MB? =;H M?FF
B?L MNI=EM
CN GOMN <? NB;N
D U U '
+<PCIOMFS
Q? B;P?
? ? HU #
? ? H U U
# # '
3? M?? NB;N
;N NCG?
NB? JLC=?M ;L? ;_?=N?> <S NB? ;GIOHN I@ MB;L?M NL;>?>
D
;M Q?FF ;M <S NB? L;H>IG JLC=? =B;HA?M #CP?H NB? FCH?;LCNS I@ NB? J?LG;
H?HN JLC=? =B;HA?M
CN >I?M HIN G;NN?L QB?H NB? MB;L?M ;L? ;=NO;FFS NL;>?>
MMOGCHA ; T?LI CHN?L?MN L;N?
NB? NIN;F L?P?HO? @LIG NB? M;F? CM
> U ?
U ?
U ? IU
U ? HU # IU
1> U ? IU
U ? HU IU
(
B > U '
FGAL?H ;H> BLCMM ;MMOG? NB;N NB? NL;>?L G;RCGCT?M ; G?;HP;LC;H=?
ONCFCNS @OH=NCIH MO=B ;M
A 1> B >(
GI>?F I@ JLC=?M ;H> KOIN?M CH ; KOIN?>LCP?H G;LE?N
D U
'
0B? HOG<?L I@ MB;L?M U NB;N G;RCGCT?M ONCFCNS CM ?;MCFS @IOH> NI <?
I H
U D'
I H
"LIG NB?L?
CN @IFFIQM NB;N
I H
U D U D'
I H
0I J?L@ILG ; =IGJ;L;NCP? MN;NC= ;H;FSMCM
Q? ;FMI =IGJON? NB? >?LCP;NCP?M
,U D
(
, I H
0
,U I H
(
, 0
,U I H
(
,
0
QB?L? 0 IH
' F?;LFS
C@ I CH=L?;M?M
MBIQM NB;N NB? HOG<?L
I@ MB;L?M MIF> >OLCHA NB? WLMN J?LCI> MBIOF> >?=L?;M? %@ NB? N?GJIL;LS JLC=?
CGJ;=N CH=L?;M?M
NB? HOG<?L I@ MB;L?M MIF> MBIOF> >?=L?;M? %@ NB? J?LG;H?HN
JLC=? CGJ;=N
ACP?H <S H
CM BCAB?L
NB? @ONOL? JLC=?M A?N >?JL?MM?> ;H> B?H=?
%H NBCM =B;JN?L
Q? MN;LN?> <S >?GIHMNL;NCHA NB;N HIHHILG;FCNS I@ ;MM?N
L?NOLHM CM FCE?FS NI <? >?N?LGCH?> <S CH@ILG;NCIH L?F?;M? %@ Q? MNO>S NB? LIF?
I@ CH@ILG;NCIH L?F?;M?
Q? ;L? H;NOL;FFS F?> NI NB? GC=LIMNLO=NOL? FCN?L;NOL?
#.$ GI>?FM B;P? <??H >?P?FIJ?> NI ;==IOHN @IL ?GJCLC=;F @?;NOL?M CH NB?
PIF;NCFCNS I@ WH;H=C;F L?NOLHM M >?M=LC<?> CH B;JN?L
L?NOLH >;N; ;JJ?;L
MN;NCIH;LS ;H> <;L?FS ;ONI=ILL?F;N?> $IQ?P?L
MKO;L?> L?NOLHM ;JJ?;L NI <?
M?LC;FFS =ILL?F;N?> )IL? MJ?=CW=;FFS
NB? PIF;NCFCNS I@ L?NOLHM ;JJ?;LM NI =FOM
N?L
MI NB;N F;LA? P;LC;NCIHM I@ JLC=? JIMCNCP? IL H?A;NCP? ;L? ?RJ?=N?> ;@N?L
; F;LA? P;LC;NCIH I@ JLC=? I@ ?CNB?L MCAH 0B?IL?NC=;F GI>?FM DOMNC@SCHA NBCM
PIF;NCFCNS =FOMN?LCHA B;P? <??H >CM=OMM?> CH B;JN?L 0BCM M?LC;F =ILL?F;
NCIH CH MKO;L?> L?NOLHM B;M <??H CHCNC;FFS GI>?F?> <S !HAF? QCNB NB?
.$ ONI.?AL?MMCP? IH>CNCIH;F $?N?LIME?>;MNC=CNS GI>?F ;H> <S IFF?L
MF?P QCNB NB? #?H?L;FCT?> .$ #.$ GI>?F /?P?L;F ?RN?HMCIHM
B;P? <??H <OCFN IH NB?M? ?;LFS GI>?FM NI =;JNOL? ;>>CNCIH;F ?GJCLC=;F @?;NOL?M
I@ ;MM?N L?NOLHM /?=NCIH JL?M?HNM NB? =F;MM I@ .$ GI>?FM
;H> /?=NCIH
CM >?PIN?> NI #.$ GI>?FM %H /?=NCIH
Q? ;>>L?MM NB? CMMO?M I@ CHNLI
>O=CHA ;MSGG?NLS CH #.$ GI>?FM "CH;FFS
/?=NCIH >?M=LC<?M #.$
GI>?FM QCNB DOGJM /IG? ;MJ?=NM I@ NB?M? GI>?FM ;L? GIL? J;LNC=OF;LFS >?
M=LC<?> BIQ NI @IL?=;MN PIF;NCFCNS OMCHA NB?M? GI>?FM BIQ NI ?MNCG;N?
#.$ GI>?F ?^=C?HNFS BIQ NI N?MN NB? JL?M?H=? I@ #.$ ?_?=NM
AAL?A;NCIH CMMO?M ;L? >CM=OMM?> CH /?=NCIH 0B? GOFNCP;LC;N? ?RN?HMCIH CM
>?M=LC<?> CH B;JN?L
HINB?L M?N I@ GI>?FM
NB? MI=;FF?> MNI=B;MNC= PIF;NCFCNS GI>?FM
B;M <??H
CHNLI>O=?> <S 0;SFIL
0B?M? GI>?FM
>CM=OMM?> CH /?=NCIH
)N '
%H
Q? >?=IGJIM? NB? L?NOLH _N CHNI ; =IH>CNCIH;F G?;H N
;H> ;
L?MC>O;F N?LG #N 0B? >SH;GC=M I@ NB? =IH>CNCIH;F G?;H N
G;S <? ;H
.) W( X
JLI=?MM IL =IOF> =IHMCMN I@ M?;MIH;FCNS @?;NOL?M N CM NB? CH@IL
G;NCIH M?N ;P;CF;<F? ;N NCG? [ %N G;S CH=FO>? =OLL?HN ;H> J;MN L?NOLHM
=OLL?HN
;H> J;MN L?MC>O;FM
IL ;HS INB?L P;LC;<F? EHIQH ;N NCG? [ ==IL>CHA NI
$ 68-.5
0B? .$ W
GI>?F
ILCACH;FFS CHNLI>O=?> <S !HAF?
;MMOG?M NB;N NB?
=IH>CNCIH;F P;LC;H=? CM ; FCH?;L @OH=NCIH I@ NB? J;MN W MKO;L?> CHHIP;NCIHM
J
,
N
"
# N
J # NJ "
D # ND
D
==IL>CHA NI
NB? =IH>CNCIH;F PIF;NCFCNS CM ;MMOG?> NI <? ; GIPCHA ;P?L;A?
I@ MKO;L?> CHHIP;NCIHM "IL NBCM GI>?F NI <? Q?FF >?WH?> ;H> NB? =IH>CNCIH;F
P;LC;H=? NI <? JIMCNCP?
NB? J;L;G?N?LM GOMN M;NCM@S NB? @IFFIQCHA =IHMNL;CHNM
" +
;H>
D
P
( ( W
0B? OH=IH>CNCIH;F P;LC;H=? I@ CHHIP;NCIH
>?HIN?>
CM NB? OH=IH>CNCIH;F
?RJ?=N;NCIH I@ N 1 #N 1 1N #N 1 N %H) NB? =;M? I@ ;H
J
.$ W
JLI=?MM
CN CM ?;MS NI =IGJON? NB;N "*
D
D
0BCM
MBIQM NB;N NB? JLI=?MM #N CM =IP;LC;H=? MN;NCIH;LS )C@J ;H> IHFS C@ NB? MOG I@ NB?
;ONIL?AL?MMCP? J;L;G?N?LM CM F?MM NB;H IH?
C?
D
D )
/?? /?=NCIH
<?FIQ @IL GIL? >?N;CFM IH MN;NCIH;LCNS =IH>CNCIHM
FNBIOAB NB? CHHIP;NCIH #N CM M?LC;FFS OH=ILL?F;N?>
NB?S ;L? HIN NCG? CH
>?J?H>?HN
<?=;OM?
>?WHCHA ]N # N N
Q? =;H L?QLCN? ;M
J
,
# N "
D # ND ]N
D
8;.,*<=270
"IL?=;MNM I@ NB? .$ GI>?F ;L? I<N;CH?> L?=OLMCP?FS %H NB? @IFFIQCHA
J;
L;G?N?LM QCNB ; B;N =ILL?MJIH> NI ?MNCG;N?M (?N [ <? NB? MN;LNCHA >;N? @IL
@IL?=;MNCHA 0B?H
NB? MN?J ;B?;> @IL?=;MN @IL N CM
J
,
N
" # N
J # NJ "
D # ND
D
QB?L? #N CM NB? ?MNCG;N?> L?MC>O;F "IL NB? MN?J ;B?;> @IL?=;MN @IL N
Q?
H??> ; @IL?=;MN I@ # N ' %N CM ACP?H <S N
' 3? NB?L?@IL? I<N;CH
N
" # N
N
J # N J
0B? MN?J ;B?;> @IL?=;MN @IL N CM
J
,
N
" N
J N W
"
D N P
D
QCNB N P
# ND C@ P
)I>?FCHA 2IF;NCFCNS
>;=8<2< 8/ *7 $ 68-.5
* N
N
"
# N (
"
T '
&.<=270 /8; $ .K.,=<
QC>?FSOM?> N?MN @IL .$ ?_?=NM CM NB? (;AL;HA?)OFNCJFC?L () N?MN
JLIJIM?> <S !HAF? >?WHCN? ;>P;HN;A? I@ NBCM N?MN CM NB;N CN CM P?LS
?;MS NI J?L@ILG 1H>?L NB? HOFF BSJINB?MCM
NB? ?LLIL
N?LG #N CM ;MMOG?> NI <?
; HILG;F QBCN? HICM? JLI=?MM #N )N ( 0B? ;FN?LH;NCP? BSJINB?MCM
CM NB;N NB? ?LLIL N?LG CM >LCP?H <S ;H .$ W
GI>?F
MI NB;N
"IL
# N N aN (
, J
N "
D # ND '
D
$276.*7 68-.5
QB?L?;M & N
N B;M <??H ;MMI=C;N?> QCNB NB? GI>?F I@ ;MM?N >?G;H>
"CH;FFS
& N
&)# N
B;M <??H ?MNCG;N?> @IL CHMN;H=? <S !HAF?
(CFC?H
1 '
,,
IHM?KO?HNFS
NB? ?MNCG;NCIH I@ NB? =IH>CNCIH;F G?;H ;H> NB? =IH>CNCIH;F
P;LC;H=? J;LNM I@ NB? GI>?F B;M NI <? J?L@ILG?> DICHNFS
)I>?FCHA 2IF;NCFCNS
55><=;*=287
_N #N (
# N N aN (
,
N "
D # ND (
D
$ 68-.5
O? NI NB? F;LA? J?LMCMN?H=? CH PIF;NCFCNS
NB? .$ GI>?F I@N?H L?KOCL?M ;
F;LA? W NI WN NB? >;N; %H MO=B =;M?M
CN CM GIL? J;LMCGIHCIOM NI OM? NB? #.$
#?H?L;FCT?> .$ GI>?F JLIJIM?> <S IFF?LMF?P 0B? =IH>CNCIH;F
P;LC;H=? I@ ; #.$ W( X
CM
J
, K
,
N "
D # ND E NE
D E
"IL NBCM GI>?F NI <? Q?FF >?WH?> ;H> NB? =IH>CNCIH;F P;LC;H=? NI <? JIMCNCP?
FIAFCE
0
1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005
20 '$
0
1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005
20
, C<9.A696AF 2@A6:.A21 B@6;4 .; & :<129
#.$ GI>?F
0
1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005
0
1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005
0B?H
@IL NBCM ?RJL?MMCIH NI =IHP?LA? NIQ;L> ; WHCN? FCGCN
MI NB;N NB? JLI=?MM
#N CM MNLC=NFS MN;NCIH;LS
Q? H??>
1 &)#
aN ) '
3? M?? NB;N
>O? NI NB? &?HM?HZM CH?KO;FCNS
1 &)#
aN
&)# 1
aN &)#
(
MI NB;N
?P?H QB?H
NB? JLI=?MM CM MNCFF MNLC=NFS MN;NCIH;LS
8;.,*<=270
N
"
# N
N
/CH=? # N N aN
NB? #.$
(
GI>?F =;H <? L?QLCNN?H ;M
N "
# N N "
N
N aN
(
MI NB;N
;N NCG? [
Q? B;P?
N "
N
N aN
(
QCNB 1 aN
)N ' 3? >?>O=? NB? @IFFIQCHA MN?J ;B?;> @IL?=;MN
@IL N
N
"
N
#?H?L;FFS MJ?;ECHA
NB? MN?J ;B?;> @IL?=;MN @IL N CM
N
"
@IL +
'
N
FN?LH;NCP?FS
NBCM F;MN ?KO;NCIH =;H <? ?RJL?MM?> ;M
N
@IL +
(
N
QB?L? " *
' 0BCM ?RJL?MMCIH MBIQM NB;N
;M
N
'
%H ?GJCLC=;F ?MNCG;NCIHM
NB? J;L;G?N?LM
;H> N?H> NI MOG NI ; P;FO?
NB;N CM P?LS =FIM? NI %N G;E?M NB?L?@IL? M?HM? NI MNO>S NB? FCGCN =;M?
=;FF?> ;H
CHN?AL;N?> #.$ GI>?F
QB?L? NB? MOG I@ NB?M? J;L;G?N?LM ?KO;FM JL?=CM?FS
IH?
"IL NB? .$
GI>?F
NB? =IH>CNCIH @IL MNLC=N MN;NCIH;LS <?=IG?M
& O&
IHM?KO?HNFS
?P?H QB?H
7=.0;*=.- $ 68-.5
)J )K
3B?H D
D E E
NB? OH=IH>CNCIH;F P;LC;H=? CM HIN >?WHCN?
;HSGIL? 0B? JLI=?MM _N CM HIN =IP;LC;H=? MN;NCIH;LS ;HSGIL? $IQ?P?L
CN
L?G;CHM MNLC=NFS MN;NCIH;LS
<?=;OM? NB? OH=IH>CNCIH;F >?HMCNS I@ #N >I?M HIN
=B;HA? IP?L NCG? /O=B ; =;M? =ILL?MJIH>M NI NB? %HN?AL;N?> #.$ IL
%#.$ >?M=LC<?> <S !HAF? ;H> IFF?LMF?P
0B? %#.$
(
GI>?F =;H <? QLCNN?H ;M
N "
# N N (
/I
NB? MN?J ;B?;> @IL?=;MN @IL N CM
N
"
N
( @IL
'
?MNCG;NIL I@ "(
;L? ;MSGJNINC=;FFS HILG;F
<=26*=287
M # ( ( #4 )
M #4 )4
M #4 )4
M #H )H
M # ( ( #H )
-4
#
8 "/* N M # ( ( #H )
(
NH N N
#CP?H NB;N L?AL?MMCIH J;L;G?N?LM CHPIFPCHA CHN?AL;N?> NCG? M?LC?M B;P? HIH
HILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIHM
QBC=B N?H> NI <? >C^=OFN NI =B;L;=N?LCT? ?RJFC=CNFS
NBCM
CM L;NB?L Q?F=IG? H?QM
)I>?FCHA 2IF;NCFCNS
4
-
#
M #H ( ( #4 )( # ( ( #H
8 "/* N '
NH N N
QB?L?
#
GN
&)#
&)# N N
N
CM NB? FIAFCE?FCBII> I@ NB? I<M?LP;NCIH [
QCNB #N _N N
?LCP;NCHA NB? FIAFCE?FCBII> @OH=NCIH SC?F>M NB? 4?.162;A
,GN
, # ,
, N # N
N N N
(
, N , N , N , N
QCNB
, N
(
,"
, N
# ND ( @IL P
( ( W(
,
D
, N
NE @IL Q
( ( X'
, E
MI NB;N
, GN
NN
1 1 '
,,
N
0B? =IP;LC;H=? G;NLCR I@ NB? )( ?MNCG;NIL CM ACP?H <S NB? CHP?LM? I@ NB?
CH@ILG;NCIH G;NLCR
QBC=B CM >?WH?> ;M GCHOM NB? ?RJ?=N?> $?MMC;H
#.$ GI>?F
, GN
NN
5
1
1 '
,, N
0BCM ?RJL?MMCIH =;H <? ?MNCG;N?> <S
4
, N N
5
'
N
@ N
M MBIQH <S 3?CMM
JLIPC>?> MN;H>;L>CT?> CHHIP;NCIHM B;P? WHCN?
@IOLNB GIG?HNM
NB? )( ?MNCG;NIL CM =IHMCMN?HN ;H> B;M NB? @IFFIQCHA ;M
SGJNINC= >CMNLC<ONCIH
+
@ ( 5
'
1 '
,,
IHM?KO?HNFS
NB? CH@ILG;NCIH G;NLCR CM <FI=E>C;AIH;F ;H> NB? NQI M?NM I@
J;L;G?N?LM =;H <? ?MNCG;N?> M?J;L;N?FS
%H JL;=NC=?
NB? ?MNCG;NCIH I@ ; #.$ GI>?F MBIOF> <? J?L@ILG?> ;M
@IFFIQM
!MNCG;N? NB? G?;H ?KO;NCIH _N N #N ?>O=? #N _N N ;H>
)4
4 N # N '
/?F?=N CHCNC;F P;FO?M @IL
M;S " (
( (
J ( ( ( K ;H> M?N
# # H
H
( QCNB T) ' / W( X
' )
J K
IGJON? NB? =IH>CNCIH;F P;LC;H=? N " D
D # ND E E NE
@IL [ T
( ( @' )4
IGJON? NB? FIAFCE?FCBII> 84 NH GN ( QB?L?
#
GN &)#
&)#
N N '
N
B;HA? I@ J;L;G?N?LM
M;S
MI NB;N NB? FIAFCE?FCBII> CH=L?;M?M
NB? P;FO?
84 + 84 '
%N?L;N? MN?JM ;H> OHNCF =IHP?LA?H=? I@ NB? FIAFCE?FCBII> NI ; WR?>
P;FO?
)I>?FCHA 2IF;NCFCNS
MMOG? Q? Q;HN NI N?MN NB? HOFF BSJINB?MCM NB;N NB? JLI=?MM CM BIGIME?>;MNC=
;A;CHMN NB? ;FN?LH;NCP? NB;N NB? P;LC;H=? @IFFIQM ; #.$
(
JLI=?MM 0B?H
NB? HOFF CM 4
;A;CHMN 4<
( QCNB ;N F?;MN IH?
MNLC=N CH?KO;FCNS
>C^=OFNS CH =IHMNLO=NCHA ; MN;NCMNC= @IL NBCM N?MN CM NB;N
OH>?L NB? HOFF
BSJINB?MCM
NB? GI>?F CM HIN C>?HNCW?> %H>??>
@IL ; #.$
(
JLI=?MM
N "
# N N
Q? B;P? QB?H
" "
N " N N $ N $ '
0B?L?@IL?
C@ Q? M?N
;N >;N? [
$
NB?H N $ @IL ;FF [ 0B?H
);HS J;=E;A?M ?RCMN NB;N ?MNCG;N? NB? J;L;G?N?LM I@ .$ ;H> #.$
GI>?FM 3CNBION JL?N?H>CHA NI <? =IGJF?N?
Q? QCMB NI >L?MM ; FCMN @IL NB?
L?;>?L QBI CM CHN?L?MN?> CH NB? ;=NO;F ?MNCG;NCIH I@ NB? GI>?FM >CM=OMM?> CH
NBCM <IIE "CLMN
NB?L? ?RCMN MI@NQ;L? JLIAL;GM NB;N ;L? MJ?=CW= NI ?=IHIG?NLC=
NCG? M?LC?M ;H;FSMCM ;H> NB;N ;FFIQ NB? ?MNCG;NCIH I@ ; QC>? L;HA? I@ .$
;H> #.$ GI>?FM 3? G;S G?HNCIH CH NBCM FCMN NB? JLIAL;GM !PC?QM ;H>
.;NM 0B?L? CM ;FMI ; FCMN I@ MN;NCMNC=M JLIAL;GM NB;N ?CNB?L B;P? GI>OF?M IL
J;=E;A?M NB;N ?MNCG;N? MO=B GI>?FM %H NBCM =F;MM
Q? B;P? /00
/,FOM M??
;FMI 6CPIN ;H> 3;HA
. 0BCM F;NN?L CM ;H IJ?H MIOL=? JLIAL;G <;M?>
IH NB? / F;HAO;A?
0B?H NB?L? CM ; FCMN I@ JLIAL;GGCHA F;HAO;A?M NB;N OM? G;NLCR F;HAO;A?
/?? BNNJ
QQQE?PCHMB?JJ;L>=IG
L?M?;L=B
O=M>:A;L=B
O=M>:A;L=B;MJR
/IG? #.$ =I>?M G;S ;FMI <? @IOH> OH>?L BNNJ
QQQB?=OHCF=B
GLI=ECHA?L
/?? BNNJ
@;=OFNSQ;MBCHANIH?>O
LIHM
#.$ GI>?F
55><=;*=287
&*+5.
@A6:.A6<; <3 . &
:<129 3<? 1.69F 9<4?2AB?;@
/, 4 "0/! *CEE?C
FIAFCE
/O=B ;M /*+,0 IL *,/+(
>?P?FIJ?> <S #CFF
)OLL;S
;H> /;OH>?LM
IL $?HNM=B?F
$ 68-.5
0B? !RJIH?HNC;F #.$ !#.$ GI>?F B;M <??H CHNLI>O=?> <S *?FMIH
NI CGJLIP? NQI ;HHISCHA ;MJ?=NM I@ NB? MN;H>;L> #.$ GI>?F
NB? J;L;G?N?LM
;H> B;P? NI <? =IHMNL;CH?> >OLCHA NB? =IOLM? I@ NB? ?MNC
G;NCIH NI ?HMOL? JIMCNCPCNS I@ NB? P;LC;H=? JLI=?MM ;M ;FL?;>S G?HNCIH?>
QCNB
;H> N aN
)aN ) 1 )aN )
!aN %H NBCM MJ?=CW=;NCIH
J;L;
G?N?LM ;L? HIN L?MNLC=N?> NI <? HIHH?A;NCP?
<?=;OM? NB? =IH>CNCIH;F PIF;NCFCNS
CM )
;FQ;SM JIMCNCP? 0B? JLI=?MM CM MNLC=NFS
8 ;H> =IP;LC;H=? MN;NCIH;LS C@ ;H> IHFS
K
C@ E E )
*INC=? NB;N 1 )aN ) * OH>?L HILG;FCNS
0BCM MJ?=CW=;NCIH CHNLI>O=?M NB? >?MCL?> ;MSGG?NLS CH NB? @IFFIQCHA Q;S
+P?L NB? L;HA? ) aN )
N aN
CM FCH?;L CH aN QCNB MFIJ? !
QB?L?;M
IP?L NB? L;HA? ) aN
N aN
CM FCH?;L CH aN QCNB MFIJ? !
"IL O& >CMNLC<ON?> ;M ; MN;H>;L>CT?> /NO>?HN I >CMNLC<ONCIH QCNB >?AL??M I@
@L??>IG
Q? B;P?
& O&
MSGG?NLC= #.$ GI>?FM
&$ 68-.5
$ 68-.5
D D ;H> E
@IL P
(
) J ( W ;H> Q
( )
( X 0B? JLI=?MM CM =I
K
P;LC;H=? MN;NCIH;LS C@ ;H> IHFS C@ D
D D *
E E )
$?HNM=B?F
8A8A =;*7</8;6
$?HNM=B?F B;M JON @ILQ;L> NB;N G;HS G?G<?LM I@ NB? #.$ @;GCFS
=;H <? ?G<?>>?> CH ; IRIR NL;HM@ILG I@ NB? @ILG CH NB? =;M? W X
N
"
N M aN
N (
QB?L? M aN
)aN I) J aN I
CM NB? H?QM CGJ;=N =OLP? CHNLI>O=?> <S
,;A;H ;H> /=BQ?LN ;H> !HAF? ;H> *A 0B? #.$ GI>?F CM
I<N;CH?> @LIG
I J 0B? !#.$ GI>?F ;LCM?M ;M ; FCGCN
=;M? QB?H
;H> I 0B? 0#.$ GI>?F =ILL?MJIH>M NI
I
;H> )J)
0B? #&. GI>?F CM I<N;CH?> @LIG
;H> I
"IL ; A?H?L;FCT?> ?LLIL >CMNLC<ONCIH #! QCNB @;NN;CF?>H?MM J;L;G?N?L
;H;
FST?> <S *?FMIH
Q? B;P?
& O&
!
QB?L?
)I>?FCHA 2IF;NCFCNS
0B?H
NB? JC?=?QCM? FCH?;L MJ?=CW=;NCIH I@ NB? B?N?LIME?>;MNC=CNS @OH=NCIH CM
MSGG?NLC= #.$ GI>?FM
1.5
GARCH
GJR
1
Conditional variance
0.5
0
-3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3
Lagged innovation
H
, H
,
N " N D <DN #N D
D :DN #N D
'
D D
0B? @OH=NCIH;F @ILG CM ; FCH?;L MJFCH? QCNB EHINM ;N NB? D M ?NQ??H ;H>
NB? MFIJ? CM
<?NQ??H ;H> CN CM
;H> MI @ILNB ?NQ??H ;H>
NB? MFIJ? CM
<?NQ??H ;H> CN CM
;H> MI @ILNB MCGJF?
;JJLI;=B NI M?F?=N NB? D M CM NI OM? ?KO;FFS MJ;=?> <CHM QCNB <L?;E JICHNM ;N
P @IL P (
( (
QB?L? CM NB? OH=IH>CNCIH;F MN;H>;L> >?PC;NCIH
I@ #N %H MO=B =;M?
Q? B;P?
H
, H
,
N " N D <DN #N P
D :DN #N P
'
D D
0?MNM @IL ;MSGG?NLS CH NB? =IH>CNCIH;F P;LC;H=? B;P? <??H JLIJIM?> <S !HAF?
;H> *A 0B?M? N?MNM ?R;GCH? QB?NB?L Q? =;H JL?>C=N NB? MKO;L?> MN;H
>;L>CT?> L?MC>O;FM <S MIG? J;MN P;LC;<F?M NB;N ;L? HIN CH=FO>?> CH NB? BSJI
NB?NCT?> PIF;NCFCNS GI>?F ;H> G;S L?X?=N ;H ;MSGG?NLC= L?MJIHM? I@ PIF;NCFCNS
NI MBI=EM
MMOG? NB;N NB? BSJINB?NCT?> PIF;NCFCNS GI>?F CM ; MN;H>;L> #.$
(
*IQ
>?WH? aN #N * N NB? MN;H>;L>CT?> L?MC>O;F I<N;CH?> OH>?L NB?
BSJINB?NCT?> #.$ GI>?F
;H> =IHMC>?L NB? ;ORCFC;LS L?AL?MMCIH
aN N <N < LN (
QCNB
, N
N (
N ,
, N N <N
<N (
N ,< N
;H> LN NB? ?LLIL N?LG
0B?H
Q? =IHMNLO=N ; (;AL;HA?)OFNCJFC?L N?MN MN;NCMNC= @IL NB? HOFF BS
JINB?MCM 4 < CH NB? ;ORCFC;LS L?AL?MMCIH ;<IP? 0B?L?@IL?
;FF P;LC;<F?M
CH N ;H> <N ;L? ?P;FO;N?> ;N )( ?MNCG;NIL I@ ;H> < ( MI NB;N Q?
WH;FFS B;P?
N
N (
N
<N <N (
%H ;>>CNCIH
OH>?L NB? HOFF
NB? F?@NB;H> MC>? P;LC;<F? aN CM NB?IL?NC=;FFS IL
NBIAIH;F NI NB? NQI LCABNB;H> MC>? M?NM I@ P;LC;<F?M 0B?L?@IL?
NB? () N?MN
MN;NCMNC= =;H <? =IGJON?> ;M NB? @ > ;MMI=C;N?> QCNB NB? L?AL?MMCIH 1H>?L
NB? HOFF
NB? N?MN MN;NCMNC= CM ;MSGJNINC=;FFS >CMNLC<ON?> ;M ; QCNB ; >?AL??
I@ @L??>IG ?KO;F NI NB? HOG<?L I@ L?MNLC=NCIHM
%H JL;=NC=?
P;LC;<F?M CH <N B;P? NI <? =BIM?H CH IL>?L NI N?MN NB? JL?M?H=?
I@ ;MSGG?NLC= ?_?=NM !HAF? ;H> *A JLIJIM? ; M?LC?M I@ =IGJF?G?HN;LS
N?MNM <;M?> IH NB? @IFFIQCHA L?AL?MMCIHM
aN H IN N LN (
aN H IN #N N LN (
aN H
IN #N N LN (
aN H I N
I N
#N I
N #N N LN (
"IL CHMN;H=?
NB? GCMMCHA P;LC;<F?M G;S B;P? NB? @ILG I@ ;H !#.$
GI>?F
0B? P;LC;<F?M CHPIFP?> CH NBCM GI>?F QIOF> NB?H <?
& & "
&
&
&
&
;H> NB? J;L;G?N?L M?N QIOF> <?
&
&
&
QCNB &
&
#.$ GI>?F QCNB DOGJM
QB?L? N
* ;H> N
N 0B? WLMN N?MN
NB? '64; /6.@
A2@A
?R;GCH?M NB? CGJ;=N I@ JIMCNCP? ;H> H?A;NCP? MBI=EM IH NB? =IH>CNCIH;F
P;LC;H=? HIN JL?>C=N?> <S NB? GI>?F OH>?L =IHMC>?L;NCIH 0BCM CM >IH? <S N?MN
CHA QB?NB?L NB? P;LC;<F? N B;M ; JL?>C=NCP? JIQ?L IH MKO;L?> MN;H>;L>CT?>
L?MC>O;FM aN ?KO;NCIH 0B? N?MN MN;NCMNC= CM NB? NL;NCI I@ J;L;G?N?L I
0B? "24.A6C2 @6G2 /6.@ A2@A ?R;GCH?M QB?NB?L NB? ACP?H GI>?F =;H ?RJF;CH
NB? >C_?L?HN ?_?=NM NB;N F;LA? ;H> MG;FF H?A;NCP? MBI=EM B;P? IH NB? =IH>C
NCIH;F P;LC;H=? 0B? P;LC;<F? OM?> @IL NBCM N?MN CM N #N ?KO;NCIH
0B? $<@6A6C2 @6G2 /6.@ A2@A ?R;GCH?M QB?NB?L NB? FCH?;L GI>?F =;H ?RJF;CH NB?
>C_?L?HN ?_?=NM NB;N F;LA? ;H> MG;FF JIMCNCP? MBI=EM B;P? IH NB? =IH>CNCIH;F
P;LC;H=? 0B? P;LC;<F? OM?> @IL NBCM N?MN CM N #N ?KO;NCIH 0B?
F;MN N?MN =IHMC>?LM NB? NBL?? JL?PCIOM BSJINB?M?M MCGOFN;H?IOMFS 1H>?L NB?
HOFF BSJINB?MCM I I I
;H>
NB? N?MN MN;NCMNC= CM NB? @ >
;MMI=C;N?> QCNB %N CM >CMNLC<ON?> ;M ;
*INC=? NB;N
C@ N CM HIN
CH=FO>?> CH NB? L?AL?MMCIH
NB? N?MN QCFF <? =IHM?LP;NCP?
55><=;*=287
#&.
;H> 0#.$ GI>?FM (IIM?FS MJ?;ECHA
NB? NBL?? GI>?FM JLIPC>?
L;NB?L MCGCF;L ?PC>?H=? CH ;FGIMN ;FF =;M?M
NB? ?MNCG;N?M MOAA?MN
;M ?RJ?=N?>
NB;N [<;> H?QM\ B;M ; MNLIHA?L ?_?=N IH PIF;NCFCNS NB;H [AII> H?QM\
%@ Q? NOLH NI NB? FIAFCE?FCBII> ?MNCG;N?M
Q? I<M?LP? NB;N HI GI>?F MSM
N?G;NC=;FFS >IGCH;N?M NB? INB?LM "IL CHMN;H=?
NB? !#.$ GI>?F J?L@ILGM
P?LS Q?FF @IL NB? *CEE?C <ON P?LS <;>FS @IL NB? "0/! %H =IHNL;MN
NB? #&.
GI>?F =;JNOL?M NB? >SH;GC= I@ NB? 4 PIF;NCFCNS <?MN
M M??H CH B;JN?L
NB? L?F?;M? I@ H?QM CM FCE?FS NI A?H?L;N? PIF;NCFCNS /I @;L
CH NBCM =B;JN?L
Q? B;P? ;>>L?MM?> NB? CMMO? I@ GI>?FCHA PIF;NCFCNS OH>?L NB?
;MMOGJNCIH NB;N H?QM ;LLCP?M
CH ; Q;S NB;N G;S <? GI>?F?> QCNB ; #.$
GI>?F H ;FN?LH;NCP? CM NI ;MMOG? NB;N NB?L? CM ; MO>>?H CH@ILG;NCIH L?F?;M?
@IFFIQ?> <S ; J?LCI> QB?L? NBCM H?QM A?NM AL;>O;FFS CH=ILJIL;N?> CHNI NB?
G;LE?N 0BCM MOAA?MNM NB;N CH ;>>CNCIH NI NB? #.$ JB?HIG?HIH
CN CM
JIMMC<F? NB;N L?NOLHM MO>>?HFS DOGJ /O=B ; GI>?F G;S <? L?;MIH;<F? <?=;OM?
NB? L?MC>O;FM I@ ; #.$ GI>?F ;L? CH A?H?L;F HIN >CMNLC<ON?> ;==IL>CHA
NI ; #;OMMC;H >CMNLC<ONCIH M?? B;JN?L 0BCM I<M?LP;NCIH MOAA?MNM NB;N
*INC=? NB;N ; H?A;NCP? ;MSGG?NLS NL;HMF;N?M CHNI ; H?A;NCP? J;L;G?N?L @IL NB?
!#.$ GI>?F <ON ; JIMCNCP?
@IL NB? #&. ;H> 0#.$ GI>?FM 0B? IHFS
?R=?JNCIH CM NB?L?@IL? NB? ?MNCG;N? I@ NB? !#.$ GI>?F @IL NB? "0/!
)I>?FCHA 2IF;NCFCNS
FIAFCE
!#.$
FIAFCE
#&.
;>>CNCIH;F JB?HIG?H; N;E? JF;=? NB;N ;L? HIN =;JNOL?> <S NB? MCGJF? #.$
GI>?F %H NBCM M?=NCIH
Q? >CM=OMM MIG? =IHNLC<ONCIHM NB;N =IG<CH? >CM=L?N?
#.$ GI>?FM QCNB DOGJ GI>?FM NB;N G;S =;JNOL? NBCM MO>>?H L?F?;M? I@
CH@ILG;NCIH
H ?;LFS =IHNLC<ONCIH CH NBCM W?F> CM ,L?MM QBI =IHMC>?LM NB? JIMMC
<CFCNS NB;N L?NOLHM ;L? A?H?L;N?> <S ; MOJ?LJIMCNCIH I@ ; #;OMMC;H >CMNLC<ONCIH
;H> ; DOGJ =IGJIH?HN "IL ?MNCG;NCHA NBCM GI>?F
,L?MM JLIJIM?M OMCHA
NB? G?NBI> I@ GIG?HNM 0B? H?RN GCF?MNIH? CM &ILCIH QBI ;MMOG?M
NB;N L?NOLHM ;L? A?H?L;N?> <S ;H .$ GI>?F NB;N CH=ILJIL;N?M DOGJM $?
WH>M NB;N ?R=B;HA? L;N?M ;L? DOGJC?L NB;H MNI=E G;LE?N L?NOLHM 0BCM GI>?F
B;M <??H ?RN?H>?> <S 2F;;L ;H> ,;FG
NI #.$ GI>?FM M ; GIL?
L?=?HN =IHNLC<ONCIH
Q? G;S G?HNCIH B;H ;H> );B?O ;H> );B?O ;H>
)=OL>S /CH=? NB?CL =IHNLC<ONCIH H?MNM NB? ?;LFC?L =IHNLC<ONCIHM NB;N
;JJ?;L?> CH NB? FCN?L;NOL?
Q? @I=OM B?L? IH NB?CL GI>?F
_N #N (
#N #N # N (
#N N aN (
aN (
(
N " N ( N
# N N (
N (
N
"/*
* 1UN )N
*
.
.* 1UN )N '
!KO;NCIH ;FFIQM @IL ; A?H?L;F H?QM CGJ;=N =OLP? H?MNCHA NB? #&.
;H> 0BL?MBIF> #.$ GI>?FM M CH A?H?L;F @IL =IH>CNCIH;F GI>?FM
NB?
MJ?=CW=;NCIHM >?J?H> IH MIG? CH@ILG;NCIH M?N N ' 0BCM =;H <? J;MN L?NOLH
P;LC;<F?M IL INB?L I<M?LP;<F? P;LC;<F?M 0B? IHFS L?KOCL?G?HN
CH IL>?L @IL
MIG? P;LC;<F? NI <?FIHA NI NB;N CH@ILG;NCIH M?N
CM NB;N NB? P;LC;<F? CM EHIQH
;N NCG? [ %H WAOL?M ;H CH>C=;NIL P;LC;<F?
N;ECHA NB? P;FO? I@
C@ # )
;H> NB? P;FO?
INB?LQCM? 0B? =BIM?H MJ?=CW=;NCIH ;FFIQM @IL NB?
CHNLI>O=NCIH I@ ; >C_?L?HNC;F CGJ;=N C@ J;MN H?QM ;L? >??G?> AII> IL <;> %@
J;MN H?QM ;L? [<OMCH?MM ;M OMO;F\
CH NB? M?HM? NB;N HI DOGJ I==OLL?>
;H> ;L?
JIMCNCP?
NB?H NB? CGJ;=N IH =OLL?HN PIF;NCFCNS QCFF <? "/*
# N ' %@ HI DOGJ
NIIE JF;=? <ON H?QM CM <;>
NB? PIF;NCFCNS CGJ;=N <?=IG?M "/*
.
# N ' %@
; DOGJ NIIE JF;=?
QCNB AII> H?QM
NB? CGJ;=N CM "/*
*
# N ( ;H> F;MN
3CNBION NBCM =IH>CNCIH
NB? ?RJ?=N?> L?NOLH QIOF> <? &M&
& ;H> CN
QIOF> HIN <? JIMMC<F? NI >CMNCHAOCMB NB? @LIG NB?
S MO<NL;=NCHA &
Q?
I<N;CH ; MI=;FF?> =IGJ?HM;N?> ,ICMMIH JLI=?MM %NM ?RJ?=N?> P;FO? CM T?LI
#.$ GI>?F QCNB DOGJM
0BCM ?RJL?MMCIH =IOF> <? ?MNCG;N?> C@ +UN Q)N Q?L? EHIQH' M MBIQH
<S );B?O ;H> )=OL>S
NBCM ?RJL?MMCIH G;S <? CH@?LL?> OMCHA ;S?MZ
@ILGOF; 3? B;P?
+UN Q( _N ( N
+ UN Q)N +UN Q)_N ( N
+_N ( N
+_N )UN Q( N +UN Q)N +N
+_N )N +N
+_N )UN Q( N +UN Q)N
+_N )N
M _N )UN Q( N
+UN Q)N
'
M _N )N
0B? WLMN ?KO;NCIH CH>C=;N?M NB;N NB? @OH>;G?HN;F CH@ILG;NCIH ;P;CF;<F?
;N NCG? [ CM N ( QBC=B =IHN;CHM NB? H?Q CH@ILG;NCIH IH _N ;H> NB? IH? I@ NB?
JL?PCIOM L?NOLHM =;JNOL?> CH N 0B? H?RN NQI ?KO;NCIHM OM? NB? @ILGOF;
I@ =IH>CNCIH;F JLI<;<CFCNC?M 0B? MN?J @LIG NI CM DOMN HIN;NCIH
"LIG NB?L? IH
CN CM JIMMC<F? NI ?P;FO;N?
MCH=? NB? P;LCIOM =IGJIH?HNM
I@ ;L? EHIQH %H>??>
=IH>CNCIH;F IH EHIQCHA N
N
;H> NB? HOG<?L
I@ DOGJM NB;N NIIE JF;=? IP?L ; NCG? CHN?LP;F
UN Q
NB? >?HMCNS I@ _N CM
,
M _N )N
M _N )UN Q( N
+UN Q)N (
E
QCNB
_N TN
M _N )UN Q( N
9 "/* (
N Q
N Q
?@IL? JLI=??>CHA
Q? H??> NI JLIPC>? =IH>CNCIHM ?HMOLCHA NB;N ;FF NB?
>SH;GC=M ;L? Q?FF >?WH?> %H ;H ?GJCLC=;F CFFOMNL;NCIH
Q? OM? ; #.$
>SH;GC=M MO=B ;M >CM=OMM?> ?;LFC?L ?KO;NCIH @IL QBC=B JIMCNCPCNS ;H>
MN;NCIH;LCNS =IH>CNCIHM ;L? ?;MS NI CGJIM? IH=?LHCHA
B;H ;H> );
B?O
;H> );B?O ;H> )=OL>S HINC=? NB;N NBCM ?KO;NCIH G;S
<? L?QLCNN?H ;M
N
N 1UN )N '
%H JL;=NC=?
NLOH=;NCIH NI NB? WLMN IL N?LGM I@ NB? MOG ;JJ?;LM NI <? F;LA?FS
MO^=C?HN NI I<N;CH MN;<F? ?MNCG;N?M &ILCIH
OMCHA ?R=B;HA? L;N? >;N; ;H>
;MM?N L?NOLHM
NLOH=;N?M ;@N?L N?LGM );B?O ;H> )=OL>S JLIJIM?
@IL
MNI=E G;LE?N >;N;
NLOH=;NCIH ;@N?L N?LGM %H JL;=NC=?
CN CM ; AII> C>?; NI
J?L@ILG NB? ?MNCG;NCIH @IL ; M?N I@ CH=L?;MCHA N?LGM
;H> NI P?LC@S
NB? MN;<CFCNS I@ NB? ?MNCG;NCIHM %N CM ;FMI JIMMC<F? NI CHMJ?=N NB? JLI<;<CFCN?M I@
GOFNCJF? DOGJM
CHN?LP?HCHA CH NB? FCE?FCBII> 0BCM JLI<;<CFCNS QCFF <? @IOH> NI
<? P?LS MG;FF CH JL;=NC=;F CGJF?G?HN;NCIHM
#.$ GI>?F QCNB DOGJM
1_N )N (
B _N )N N
N (
N
?R_N )N (
N N N
N
7\_N )N (
N N N
QB?L? ?R_N )N ;H> 7\_N )N >?HIN? NB? =IH>CNCIH;F ME?QH?MM ;H> EOL
NIMCM
L?MJ?=NCP?FS 3? HINC=? NB;N NB? MCAH I@ NB? DOGJM
( QCFF >?N?LGCH? NB?
MCAH I@ NB? ME?QH?MM
@OLNB?L OM?@OF L?MOFN =IH=?LHM NB? =IH>CNCIH;F JLI<;<CFCNS I@ I<M?LPCHA
M?P?L;F DOGJM 0BCM JLI<;<CFCNS G;S <? =IGJON?> ;M
0BCM F;NN?L N?LG CM ;FL?;>S =IGJON?> >OLCHA NB? ?MNCG;NCIH I@ NB? GI>?F
7 .692;2,*5 255><=;*=287
;H> NB? >SH;GC=M @IL NB? CHN?HMCNS J;L;G?N?L ACP?H <S 3? ;FMI ?MNC
G;N? NB? J;L;G?N?LM I@ NB? GI>?F QB?H NB? PIF;NCFCNS >SH;GC=M ;H> NB? DOGJ
CHN?HMCNS =IHMN;HN IP?L NCG?
N ( [( ;H> N ( ['
0;<F? >CMJF;SM NB? J;L;G?N?L ?MNCG;N?M @IL NB? L?MNLC=N?> ;H> NB? A?H
?L;F GI>?F 0B? DOGJ MCT?
( CM ;FQ;SM H?A;NCP? =ILLI<IL;NCHA NB? MNSFCT?>
@;=N NB;N L?NOLHM ;L? H?A;NCP?FS ME?Q?> 3? HINC=? NB;N CM F;LA?L QB?H NB?
#.$ ?_?=N CM CHNLI>O=?> "IL CHMN;H=?
@IL NB? /,
NB? DOGJ MCT? ?PIFP?M
@LIG '
I<N;CH?> @IL NB? GI>?F QCNBION #.$ HIL NCG? P;LC;NCIH
CH NB? DOGJ CHN?HMCNS
NI ' @IL NB? A?H?L;F GI>?F +OL CHN?LJL?N;
NCIH CM NB;N QCNBION NB? #.$ >SH;GC=M
NB? DOGJ =IGJIH?HN CM @IL=?> NI
=;JNOL? G;HS I@ NB? P;LC;NCIHM >O? NI NB? NCG?P;LSCHA PIF;NCFCNS ;H> NB?L?
@IL? >I?M HIN H?=?MM;LS =ILL?MJIH> NI ;=NO;F DOGJM F?;LFS
;M NB? DOGJ MCT?
<?=IG?M F;LA?L
NB? CHN?HMCNS I@ NB? DOGJM >CGCHCMB?M 3? HINC=? @IL CHMN;H=?
@IL NB? /, NB;N ' @IL NB? MCGJF? GI>?F ;H> 1N '
@IL NB?
A?H?L;F GI>?F 0BCM G?;HM NB;N
@IL NB? A?H?L;F GI>?F
; DOGJ N;E?M JF;=?
;<ION ?P?LS W@NB >;S
3B?H Q? @I=OM IH NB? >SH;GC=M I@ NB? DOGJ CHN?HMCNS
Q? HINC=? <S CHMJ?=N
CHA NB? J;L;G?N?L NB;N NB?L? CM CGJILN;HN J?LMCMN?H=? CH NB? J;L;G?N?L
CGJFSCHA ; L;NB?L MGIINB ?PIFONCIH I@ NBCM J;L;G?N?L NBLIOAB NCG? %@ Q?
=IHMC>?L NB? FIAFCE?FCBII>M I@ NB? L?MNLC=N?> ;H> A?H?L;F GI>?FM
Q? HINC=?
)I>?FCHA 2IF;NCFCNS
&*+5. $.?.:2A2?@ 3<? . & :<129 0<:/6;21 D6A5 . 7B:= =?<02@@ D6A5
A6:2C.?F6;4 6;A2;@6AF .;1 . ?2@A?60A21 :<129 D6A5<BA A6:2C.?F6;4 C<9.A696AF ;<?
A6:2C.?F6;4 7B:= 6;A2;@6AF
/, 4 /, 4
L
FIAFCE
&&
3? =IOF> B;P? =BIM?H ; GO=B F;LA?L QCH>IQ
BIQ?P?L
NB? JC=NOL? <?=IG?M P?LS
?LL;NC= C@ Q? =IHMC>?L NII G;HS I<M?LP;NCIHM
#.$ GI>?F QCNB DOGJM
0.9
0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
1999 1999.5 2000 2000.5 2001 2001.5 2002 2002.5 2003
-0.2
-0.4
-0.6
-0.8
-1
1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005
Conditional kurtos is
8
3
1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005
20 C<9BA6<; <3 A52 0<;16A6<;.9 @82D;2@@ .;1 8B?A<@6@ 3<? A52 '$
)I>?FCHA 2IF;NCFCNS
/I @;L
Q? B;P? M??H NB;N NB? >?M=LCJNCIH I@ NB? N?GJIL;F ?PIFONCIH I@ L?NOLH
M?LC?M
;H> CH J;LNC=OF;L CNM NCG?P;LSCHA PIF;NCFCNS
G;S <? L?F;NCP?FS Q?FF =;J
NOL?> <S #.$ JLI=?MM?M N NBCM MN;A?
H?Q KO?MNCIHM ;LCM? 0B? WLMN IH?
=IH=?LHM NB? ?PIFONCIH I@ NB? J;L;G?N?LM I@ #.$ JLI=?MM?M
;M Q? OM? >C@
@?L?HN NCG? @L?KO?H=C?M @IL NB? ?MNCG;NCIH "IL CHMN;H=?
Q? G;S <? N?GJN?> NI
OM? >;CFS >;N; NI ?MNCG;N? ; JLI=?MM NB;N MBIOF>
BIQ?P?L
<? M=;F?> NI MIG?
INB?L @L?KO?H=S
M;S ; GIHNBFS IH? 0B? ;HMQ?L CM NB;N NB? #.$ JLI=?MM
MNO>C?> MI @;L
>I?M HIN ;AAL?A;N?
; L?MOFN MBIQH CH ;H CGJILN;HN J;J?L <S
LIMN ;H> *CDG;H 0B?M? ;ONBILM CHNLI>O=? ; H?Q =F;MM I@ JLI=?MM?M
&1.8;.=2,*5 *<9.,=<
.D72=287
'2:6@A?<;4 & (52 @2?62@ #N ( D6A5 [ 6@ . @2:6
@A?<;4 & =?<02@@ 63 "
( .;1 :.F /2 05<@2; @< A5.A
?WH? HIQ NB? FCH?;L JLID?=NCIH IJ?L;NIL , ;M NB? <?MN FCH?;L JL?>C=NIL
I@ MIG? L;H>IG P;LC;<F? ACP?H NB? CH@ILG;NCIH MNLO=NOL? "ILG;FFS
Q? >?WH?
,_N )#N ( #N ( NB? <?MN FCH?;L JL?>C=NIL I@ _N CH N?LGM I@
( #N ( #N (
# N
# N (
N NBCM MN;A?
LIMN ;H> *CDG;H ;MMOG? NB;N NB?S I<M?LP? ; M;GJF?
4
'#N (N I@ MIG? ;MM?N L?NOLHM %@ <N >?HIN?M NB? P;FO? I@ ; ACP?H ;MM?N
NB?H NB?
=IHNCHOIOMFS =IGJIOH>?> L?NOLH ;N NCG? [ CM >?WH?> ;M #N &)# <N *<N
0BCM L?NOLH CM ;MMOG?> NI <? M;GJF?> ;N
M;S
NB? >;CFS @L?KO?H=S 0B? KO?M
NCIH CM QB;N J;L;G?N?LM G;S <? I<N;CH?> C@ Q? B;> M;GJF?> ;N ; >C_?L?HN
FN?LH;NCP?FS
Q? G;S M;S NB;N NB? =F;MM I@ #.$ JLI=?MM?M CM HIN =FIM?> OH>?L
;AAL?A;NCIH QB?L? NB? HINCIH I@ =FIM?>H?MM CM N;E?H CH NB? G;NB?G;NC=;F M?HM?
)I>?FCHA 2IF;NCFCNS
0BOM
#HN L?JL?M?HNM NB? L?NOLH IP?L ; FIHA?L J?LCI> NB;H NB? CHCNC;F L?NOLHM
M?LC?M 0B? G;CH L?MOFN I@ NB?CL J;J?L CM ACP?H <S NB? @IFFIQCHA JLIJIMCNCIH
";898<2=287 ?<@A .;1 "67:.;
3 A52 @2>B2;02 #N ( [ ( 6@ .
D2.8
&
(
=?<02@@ D6A5 @F::2A?60 :.?46;.9 16@A?6/BA6<;@ N "
# N
N ( .;1 B;0<;16A6<;.9 8B?A<@6@ A52; #HNH ( [ ( 6@ . @F::2A?60 D2.8
&
(
=?<02@@ D6A5
H
^H T" (
H
H H (
H
*T
T
T
H
(
T
H -
H .
(
H -'
H ( .
D52?2
- T
T T
T
T
H
(
.;1
H
.
'
LIMN ;H> *CDG;H CHNLI>O=? ; >CMNCH=NCIH <?NQ??H XIQ ;H> MNI=E P;LC;<F?M
"IL WH;H=? ;JJFC=;NCIHM
CHPIFPCHA ;MM?N L?NOLHM
NB? ;AAL?A;NCIH I@ XIQM CM I@
L?F?P;H=?
AAL?A;NCIH I@ #.$ JLI=?MM?M
#CP?H NB;N NBCM JLIJIMCNCIH L?KOCL?M NB? EOLNIMCM I@ NB? ILCACH;F ?LLIL
(
@IL ?GJCLC=;F ;JJFC=;NCIHM NB? @IFFIQCHA L?GCH>?L <S LIMN ;H> *CDG;H
G;S <? OM?@OF
T (
T
QB?L? aN >?HIN?M NB? MN;H>;L>CT?> CHHIP;NCIH 0BOM
C@ Q? ?MNCG;N? NB? EOLNIMCM
I@ NB? CHHIP;NCIHM aN ( ;@N?L B;PCHA WNN?> NB? #.$ GI>?F
Q? G;S CH@?L
IH=?
;H> B;P? <??H ?MNCG;N?> %HMJ?=NCIH I@ NB? @ILGOF; @IL EOLNIMCM
L?P?;FM NB;N ;M NB? ;AAL?A;NCIH MN?J T CH=L?;M?M
H =IHP?LA?M NI 0BOM
N?GJIL;F ;AAL?A;NCIH QCFF L?H>?L NB? >;N; GIL? HILG;F 3? G;S CHNOCNCP?FS
PC?Q NBCM L?MOFN ;M L?MOFNCHA @LIG NB? MGIINBCHA I@ I<M?LP;NCIHM ;M Q? MOG
NB? CHHIP;NCIHM $?N?LIME?>;MNC=CNS QCFF A?N MGIINB?> 0BCM L?MOFN B;M <??H
HINC=?> ;FL?;>S <S C?<IF> ;H> B;M <??H P?LCW?> CH B;JN?L
7 .692;2,*5 255><=;*=287
CH JL;=NC=;F ;JJFC=;NCIHM
C@ NB? EOLNIMCM CM HIN EHIQH
CN CM HIN JIMMC<F? NI
=ILL?=NFS CH@?L BIQ NB? J;L;G?N?LM QCFF ;AAL?A;N?
3? G;S ;FMI ;ME BIQ ;AAL?A;N?> J;L;G?N?LM =IGJ;L? QCNB NBIM? I<N;CH?>
@IL ; #.$ GI>?F ?MNCG;N?> IH ;AAL?A;N?> >;N; 0I ;HMQ?L NBCM KO?MNCIH
0.16
0.14
0.12
0.1
0.08
α
α=0.1,β=0.85
0.06
α=0.05,β=0.94
0.04
0.02
0
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1
β
20 C<9BA6<; <3 A52 =.?.:2A2?@ <3 . D2.8 & :<129 B;12? A2:=<?.9
.44?24.A6<; (52 @F:/<9@ 0<??2@=<;1 3?<: ?645A A< 923A A< @.:=96;4 2C2?F
</@2?C.A6<;@ B?C2@ D6A5 @>B.?2@ 0<??2@=<;1 A< .B@@6.; 6;;<C.A6<;@
.;1 /B992A@ A< 'AB12;A I 16@A?6/BA21 6;;<C.A6<;@
0.2
0.16
m =5
0.14 Param eters under agregation
α
0.12
0.1
0.08
0.06
0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1
β
20 C<9BA6<; <3 A52 =.?.:2A2?@ <3 . D2.8 & :<129 B;12? A2:=<?.9
.44?24.A6<;
>CMN;H=? <?NQ??H NB? ;=NO;F J;L;G?N?LM ;H> NBIM? J;L;G?N?LM NB;N MBIOF>
BIF> OH>?L ;AAL?A;NCIH 0BCM <LCHAM ;<ION NB? KO?MNCIH I@ NB? =ILL?=NH?MM I@
NB? GI>?F
%H ;H CHN?L?MNCHA =IHNLC<ONCIH
LIMN ;H> 3?LE?L =IHMC>?L ; =IHNCHO
IOM NCG? GI>?F QCNB DOGJM NB;N NB?S >CM=L?NCT? MI ;M NI I<N;CH ; Q?;E #.$
L?JL?M?HN;NCIH !MNCG;NCIH I@ NBCM GI>?F ;FFIQM NB?M? ;ONBILM NI JLIPC>? MIG?
CH@?L?H=? ;<ION NB? @L?KO?H=S I@ DOGJM CH NB? >;N; %@ Q? =IHN?GJF;N? NB?
GI>?F OM?> MI @;L
Q? L?;FCT? NB;N M?P?L;F @?;NOL?M NB;N ;L? JL?M?HN CH NB? >;N;
B;P? HIN <??H NL?;N?> MI @;L 3? G;S G?HNCIH NB? H?=?MMCNS NB;N NB? @IOLNB
GIG?HN <? WHCN? ;H> ;M Q? QCFF M?? CH B;JN?L
NBCM CM HIN H?=?MM;LCFS
NB? =;M? 0B? H?RN CMMO? CM NB;N NB? L?MOFNM ;L? I<N;CH?> @IL MI=;FF?> Q?;E
#.$ GI>?FM 0B?M? GI>?FM ;L?
BIQ?P?L
HIN =IHMCMN?HNFS ?MNCG;N?> ;M
>?GIHMNL;N?> CH ; MCGOF;NCIH ?R?L=CM? <S )?>>;BC ;H> .?H;OFN FMI
NB?M? GI>?FM >I HIN ;FFIQ @IL F?P?L;A? ?_?=N )?>>;BC ;H> .?H;OFN
=CL=OGP?HN NB?M? >C^=OFNC?M <S <OCF>CHA IH ; GI>?F CH NB? MJCLCN I@ MNI=B;MNC=
PIF;NCFCNS
;8<<<.,=287*5 *00;.0*=287
%H NBCM M?=NCIH
Q? =IHMC>?L NB? CGJILN;HN CMMO? I@ BIQ #.$ JLI=?MM?M
;AAL?A;N? ;=LIMM ;MM?NM
;H CMMO? CHCNC;FFS ;>>L?MM?> <S *CDG;H ;H> /?HN;H;
)I>?FCHA 2IF;NCFCNS
0B?H *CDG;H ;H> /?HN;H; @IFFIQ IFF?LMF?P ;H> CHNLI>O=? NB?
@IL?=;MN PIF;NCFCNS ?LLIL DN # DN DN # DN 1# DN )N ( QB?L? N
L?JL?M?HNM NB? J;MN CH@ILG;NCIH
NI I<N;CH ;H .)
(
L?JL?M?HN;NCIH @IL
# DN ( MO=B ;M
# DN D
D D
8
D 8 DN
QB?L? 8 CM NB? F;A IJ?L;NIL
>?WH?> <S 8 DN DN
;H> QB?L? D 1# DN
" D *
D D
' 0;ECHA NB? MOG I@ NB? NQI JLI=?MM?M SC?F>M
#N # N
8
8 N
8
8 N #N # N '
F?;LFS
NB? J;L;G?NLC= MJ?=CW=;NCIHM I@ ; MNLIHA ;H> ; Q?;E #.$ JLI=?MM
;L? HIN NB? M;G? 0BCM L;CM?M ;M WLMN KO?MNCIH QB;N QIOF> <? NB? ?LLIL C@
Q? ?MNCG;N?> ; MNLIHA #.$ JLI=?MM ;H> Q? >CL?=NFS OM?> NB? L?MOFNCHA
J;L;G?N?LM CH ; Q?;E #.$ JLI=?MM LIMN ;H> *CDG;H L?JILN NB;N
NB?S J?L@ILG?> MCGOF;NCIHM QB?L? NB? NLO? >;N; A?H?L;NCHA JLI=?MM Q;M ;
MNLIHA #.$ JLI=?MM ;H> QB?L? NB?S ?MNCG;N? NB? J;L;G?N?LM OMCHA ; -)(
?MNCG;NCIH "IL J;L;G?N?LM MCGCF;L NI NB? >SH;GC= I@ ?R=B;HA? L;N?M
NB?S
L?JILN NB;N NB? L?MOFNM I<N;CH?> CH NB? -)( ?MNCG;NCIH ;L? =FIM? NI NB? NLO?
J;L;G?N?LM
+H NB? INB?L B;H>
*CDG;H ;H> /?HN;H; =IHMNLO=N Q?;E #.$
JLI=?MM?M ;M NB? MOG I@ MNLIHA #.$ JLI=?MM?M ;H> <S J?L@ILGCHA -)(
/NI=B;MNC= PIF;NCFCNS
%=8,1*<=2, ?85*=252=B
;86 $ 68-.5< =8 <=8,1*<=2, ?85*=252=B 68-.5<
/I @;L Q? B;P? >CM=OMM?> G;HS GI>?FM CH NB? MJCLCN I@ #.$ GI>?FM 0SJ
C=;FFS
@IL ; MCGJF? GI>?F CH NBCM =F;MM
NB? =?HNL?> L?NOLHM G;S <? QLCNN?H
# N N aN (
N "
# N N '
%HMJ?=NCIH I@ NB?M? ?KO;NCIHM L?P?;FM NB;N NB?L? CM IHFS IH? MIOL=? I@ OH=?L
N;CHNS
aN ( QCNB 1aN
;H> B aN
0BCM Q;S I@ GI>?FCHA L?NOLHM CM
NB?L?@IL? P?LS MCGJF?
QBC=B G;S ?RJF;CH
;N F?;MN J;LNC;FFS
CNM NL?G?H>IOM
MO==?MM 0B? >L;Q<;=E CM NB;N NBCM GI>?F >I?M HIN ;FFIQ @IL ; MJ?=CW= ?LLIL CH
NB? >SH;GC=M I@ PIF;NCFCNS "IL ACP?H J;L;G?N?LM
C@ Q? CG;ACH? ; F;LA? L?NOLH
CH ;<MIFON? P;FO?
NB?H NB? PIF;NCFCNS ?KO;NCIH QCFF CGJFS ; MO<M?KO?HN
F;LA? PIF;NCFCNS %H A?H?L;F
NBCM CM =?LN;CHFS ; >?MCL;<F? @?;NOL? $IQ?P?L
NB?
CGJ;=N I@ ; ACP?H F;LA? L?NOLH QCFF HIN <? NB? M;G? ;FF NB? NCG? 0BCM CGJFC?M
NB;N NB? N NB;N NBCM GI>?F JL?>C=NM
CH =IGJ;LCMIH QCNB NB? NLO? OHEHIQH
PIF;NCFCNS
QCFF MIG?NCG?M <? NII F;LA? ;H> INB?L NCG?M NII MG;FF
0BCM I<M?LP;NCIH B;M F?> 0;SFIL
NI =IHMC>?L NB? WLMN >CM=L?N?
NCG? MNI=B;MNC= PIF;NCFCNS /2 GI>?F CH QBC=B PIF;NCFCNS B;M ; MJ?=CW= MIOL=?
I@ L;H>IGH?MM 0BCM GI>?F G;S <? ?RJL?MM?> ;M @IFFIQM
)I>?FCHA 2IF;NCFCNS
#N N aN aN "/* ON (
ON " ON ]N (
QB?L? ]N CM ;H 661 ( P JLI=?MM 0B? NQI JLI=?MM?M aN ;H> ]N ;L? OMO
;FFS ;MMOG?> NI <? CH>?J?H>?HN >>CHA ;H ?LLIL N?LG ]N CH NB? >SH;GC=M
I@ PIF;NCFCNS CHNLI>O=?M ;HINB?L MIOL=? I@ L;H>IGH?MM CH NB? GI>?F NB;N G;S
CGJLIP? NB? >?M=LCJNCIH I@ NB? ;=NO;F PIF;NCFCNS +<PCIOMFS
NB? NLO? PIF;NCFCNS
CM H?P?L I<M?LP?> ;H>
NBOM
ON CM ; F;N?HN JLI=?MM NB;N H??>M NI A?N ?MNCG;N?>
0B? JLI<;<F? CGJLIP?G?HN CH N?LGM I@ PIF;NCFCNS =IG?M ;N NB? JLC=? I@ BCAB?L
=IGJF?RCNS ;N NB? ?MNCG;NCIH F?P?F
/CH=? L?JL?M?HNM ;H .
JLI=?MM
MN;NCIH;LCNS =IH>CNCIHM ;H> GI
G?HNM ;L? Q?FFEHIQH %H>??>
MN;NCIH;LCNS I@ NB? ON JLI=?MM CGJIM?M )) )
0B?H
Q? B;P?
" P
1 ON C ( ;H> B ON C '
0B?L?@IL?
MCH=? aN CM ;MMOG?> NI <? 661 (
;H> OH=ILL?F;N?> QCNB N ( Q?
=;H =IGJON? NB? GIG?HNM I@ #N aN "/* ON M?? ;FMI 0;SFIL
B;JN?L
1 #N 1 aN 1 "/* ON (
C
1 #N 1 aN 1 "/* ON
"/* C (
1 #N (
1 #N 1 aN 1 "/* ON
"/* C C '
0BCM ?RJL?MMCIH CH>C=;N?M NB;N NB? EOLNIMCM =;H <?=IG? ;L<CNL;LCFS F;LA?
%H ;>>CNCIH
N;ECHA NB? MKO;L? ;H> NB? FIA;LCNBG I@ ;H> OMCHA
SC?F>M
&)# # N &)# N &)# aN ON &)# aN '
/CH=? NB? WLMN =IGJIH?HN
ON CM ;H .
JLI=?MM ;H> &)# aN
CM ; QBCN? HICM?
.OCT
;H> /B?JB;L> CH>C=;N?
?RN?HMCIHM I@ NB? >SH;GC=M I@ ON NI ;H
3? L?GCH> NB;N C@ ; L;H>IG P;LC;<F? 6 CM >CMNLC<ON?> ;M ; NB?H Q? B;P?
NB? GNB GIG?HN &< $ &<$ <$ $
/NI=B;MNC= PIF;NCFCNS
<=26*=287 8/ =1. -2<,;.=. =26. %( 68-.5
$IQ?P?L
;FNBIOAB NB? ?LLIL N?LG ]N G;E?M NB? /2 GI>?F GO=B GIL? X?RC<F?
CN ;FMI CGJFC?M NB;N NB? /2 GI>?F =;HHIN <? ?MNCG;N?> >CL?=NFS <S )( %H>??>
M # ( ( #4 )
M #4 )4
M #4 )4
M # )
(
. . .
84 )#4 M #4 ) M #4 ) 4 M 4 ) K K K 4 '
/CH=? NBCM ?RJL?MMCIH >I?M HIN L?KOCL? NB;N PIF;NCFCNS CM I<M?LP;<F? ;HSGIL?
CN
QIOF> <? JIMMC<F? CH JLCH=CJF? NI ?P;FO;N? ;H> NB?L?@IL? G;RCGCT? NB? FCE?FC
BII> @OH=NCIH 84 $IQ?P?L
?P;FO;NCHA 84 OMCHA NBCM ?RJL?MMCIH QIOF> L?KOCL?
NB? HOG?LC=;F CHN?AL;NCIH I@ ; @ >CG?HMCIH;F CHN?AL;F
QBC=B CM CGJIMMC<F? CH
JL;=NC=? /?P?L;F ;FN?LH;NCP? ?MNCG;NCIH JLI=?>OL?M B;P? NB?L?@IL? <??H JLI
JIM?> NI MCGJFC@S NBCM JLI<F?G
KO;MCG;RCGOG FCE?FCBII> ?MNCG;NCIH -)(! B;M <??H JLIJIM?> <S
$;LP?S
.OCT
;H> /B?JB;L> "CLMN
@LIG <L;GIQCNT ;H> /N?AOH
J
CN CM EHIQH NB;N 1&)# aN
' ;H> B &)# aN ''
%HNLI>O=CHA NB? HIN;NCIH N &)# aN
'
QBC=B SC?F>M ; G?;H T?LI CH
HIP;NCIH
;H> MKO;LCHA NB? L?NOLHM
Q? =;H L?QLCN? NB? MSMN?G ]
;M
)I>?FCHA 2IF;NCFCNS
&)# # N
' ON N (
ON " ON N '
%N CM JIMMC<F? NI ;JJFS NB? ';FG;H WFN?L NI NBCM MSMN?G #CP?H NB;N NB? ';FG;H
WFN?L ;MMOG?M #;OMMC;H CHHIP;NCIHM
QBC=B CM =F?;LFS HIN NB? =;M? @IL N ( CN CM
HIN JIMMC<F? NI I<N;CH ;H ?R;=N FCE?FCBII> NBCM Q;S .OCT J?L@ILGM
?RJ?LCG?HNM NB;N MBIQ NB;N NB? ?MNCG;N?M I<N;CH?> PC; NB? ';FG;H WFN?L B;P?
NI <? JL?@?LL?> IP?L G?NBI>I@GIG?HNM ?MNCG;N?M
HOG?LC=;F >C^=OFNS CM NI >?;F QCNB T?LI L?NOLHM
C?
QB?H #N IL
=;M?M QB?L? L?NOLHM ;L? =FIM? NI T?LI L?C>N ;H> ;LLCKOCLS MOAA?MN
NB? OM? I@ NB? NL;HM@ILG;NCIH
J
&)# # N &)# # N J * # N J
(
QB?L? MN;H>M @IL NB? M;GJF? P;LC;H=? I@ NB? #N ;H> J CM ; MG;FF HOG<?L MO=B
;M 0B? CGJ;=N I@ NBIM? I<M?LP;NCIHM ?KO;F IL =FIM? NI T?LI QCFF NB?L?@IL?
<? >CGCHCMB?> #BSM?FM
$;LP?S
;H> .?H;OFN MOAA?MN NB? OM? I@ MIG?
=IH>CNCIH;F PIF;NCFCNS ?MNCG;N? CHMN?;> I@ NB? =IHMN;HN '
FN?LH;NCP? ?MNCG;NCIH JLI=?>OL?M
<;M?> IH MCGOF;NCIH G?NBI>M B;P? <??H
JLIJIM?> 0B? WLMN IH? CM 6;16?20A 6;32?2;02 #IOLCfLIOR
)IH@ILN
;H> .?
H;OFN
0B? M?=IH> IH? CM NB? !.?8<C 5.6; !<;A2 .?9< &;=KOC?L
,IFMIH
;H> .IMMC
M?? ;FMI 'CG
/B?JB;L>
;H> BC<
IL !L
;E?L
&IB;HH?M
;H> ,IFMIH
INB G?NBI>M ;L? P?LS =IGJON;NCIH;FFS
CHN?HMCP? ?P?H CH ; OHCP;LC;N? M?NNCHA +NB?L ?MNCG;NCIH G?NBI>M ;L? <;M?> IH
@6:B9.A21 :2A5<1 <3 :<:2;A@ O^? ;H> /CHAF?NIH
2N062;A :2A5<1
<3 :<:2;A@ #;FF;HN ;H> 0;O=B?H
IL @6:B9.A21 :.E6:B: 9682965<<1
L;H>N ;H> /;HN;F;L;
OLB;G ;H> #;FF;HN
.?=?HNFS
NB?L?
B;M <??H ;H CHN?L?MN CH 2:=6?60.9 05.?.0A2?6@A60 3B;0A6<; :2A5<1@ /CHAF?NIH
?HTIHC
;H> (OH> =IGJ;L? MIG? I@ NB?M? ?MNCG;NCIH N?=BHCKO?M )OF
NCP;LC;N? ?RN?HMCIHM ;JJ?;L NI <? P?LS >C^=OFN NI ?MNCG;N? 0B? MNI=B;MNC=
PIF;NCFCNS GI>?F CM NB?L?@IL? ; P?LS CGJILN;HN <OCF>CHA <FI=E @IL ?GJCLC=;F
WH;H=? $IQ?P?L
<?=;OM? I@ NB? >C^=OFNS I@ ?MNCG;NCIH
CN G;S HIN B;P?
;NNL;=N?> ;M GO=B ;NN?HNCIH ;M CN >?M?LP?M
$.*52C.- ?85*=252=B
+P?L NB? L?=?HN S?;LM
CN B;M <?=IG? JIMMC<F? NI OM? >;N; ;N ; NC=E<SNC=E F?P?F
/O=B >;N; CM ;FMI =;FF?> 56453?2>B2;0F 1.A. %H J;L;FF?F QCNB NB? ;P;CF;<CFCNS
I@ NBCM >;N;
; H?Q L?M?;L=B MNL;H> ?G?LA?> 0BCM MNL;H> <OCF>M IH L?MOFNM I@
MNI=B;MNC= CHN?AL;NCIH 0B? @IFFIQCHA CM G;CHFS <;M?> IH ;LH>IL_*C?FM?H
;H> /B?JB;L> <
NB?L?;@N?L *
/
M?N I@ QILNBQCF? L?;>CHAM CH NB? MNI=B;MNC= CHN?AL;NCIH ;L?; CM ?FF;=B?LC? ;H>
)?S?L
&;=I> ;H> /BCLS;?P
,LINN?L
.IA?LM ;H> 3CFFC;GM
.?;FCT?> PIF;NCFCNS
10
-5
-10
-15
-20
-25
1970 1976 1983 1990 1997 2004
30
20
10
-10
-20
-30
-40
1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2004
/I @;L
JLI<;<CFCNS NB?ILS N?FFM OM NB;N CH NB? =IHNCHOIOM NCG? M?NNCHA
; L?;MIH
;<F? GI>?F @IL ;MM?N JLC=?M CM NB? M?GCG;LNCHA;F? %H ;=NO;F ?GJCLC=;F QILE
Q? I<M?LP?
BIQ?P?L
IHFS >CM=L?N?FS M;GJF?> >;N; 0BCM CMMO? <LCHAM OJ NB?
JLI<F?G I@ >CMNCHAOCMBCHA <?NQ??H NB? MNI=B;MNC=
S?N =IHNCHOIOM
J;LN ;H> NB?
DOGJM L?=?HN =IHNLC<ONCIH <S hN/;B;FC; MBIQM NB;N
CHNOCNCP?FS
>;N; M;GJF?> ;N ; BCAB?L ;H> BCAB?L @L?KO?H=S MBIOF> CH>??> JLIPC>? CH@IL
G;NCIH IH NB? ;=NO;F =IGJIH?HNM 0B?L? ;L? M?P?L;F >C^=OFNC?M QCNB >CM=L?N?
M;GJFCHA NB;N L?H>?L NB? >?N?=NCIH I@ DOGJM >C^=OFN
"CAOL? >CMJF;SM L?;FCT;NCIHM I@ NB? /, ;N >C_?L?HN @L?KO?H=C?M M
NBCM WAOL? CFFOMNL;N?M
NB? MBC@N @LIG NB? >;CFS NI ; S?;LFS @L?KO?H=S L?H>?LM
NB? >?N?=NCIH I@ NB? DOGJ CGJIMMC<F? 0B? =L;MB I@ >CM;JJ?;LM NIN;FFS ;N
NB? S?;LFS @L?KO?H=S 0I NB? IJJIMCN?
S?;LM QCNBION ; =L;MB
MO=B ;M ;H>
M;Q ; GO=B F;LA?L >LIJ CH L?NOLHM NB;H
3? G;S
NB?L?@IL?
L?;MIH;<FS ;ME @LIG QB;N NCG?M=;F? IH >I?M CN <?=IG?
JIMMC<F? NI PCMO;FCT? DOGJM CH NB? >;N; A;CH
hN/;B;FC; JLIPC>?M
MIG? ?F?G?HNM $? =IHMC>?LM ; MCGJF? GI>?F QCNBION N?GJIL;F >?J?H>?H=S I@
PIF;NCFCNS CH =IHNCHOIOM NCG? =IGJIM?> <S ; =IHNCHOIOM J;LN
JLIPC>?> <S ;
IL NB? ?R=?FF?HN L?=?HN <IIE <S IHN ;H> 0;HEIP /IG? I@ NB?
@IFFIQCHA >?WHCNCIHM G;S ;FMI <? @IOH> CH H>?LM?H ?N ;F
hN/;B;FC; JL?M?HNM ; MCGCF;L JFIN QCNB NB? IQ &IH?M %H>OMNLC;F %H>?R
@IL QBC=B NB? =L;MB CM ?P?H GIL? JLIHIOH=?>
)I>?FCHA 2IF;NCFCNS
LIQHC;H GINCIH
;H> >CM=L?N? WHCN? F;LA? DOGJM (?NNCHA <N >?HIN? NB? JLC=?
;N NCG? [
NB? GI>?F NB;N B? =IHMC>?LM ;MMOG?M NB;N NB? L?NOLH IP?L ; ACP?H
NCG? CHN?LP;F [( [ <?B;P?M ;M @IFFIQM
N
,
+
YNN
&)# <N *<N
#N 6M :M (
MN
QB?L? #N CM ; HILG;F (
L?;FCT;NCIH
:N CM ; ,ICMMIH JLI=?MM
CH=L?;MCHA
<S QB?H?P?L ; DOGJ N;E?M JF;=? 3B?H ; DOGJ N;E?M JF;=?
CN >I?M MI IP?L
; NCG? CHN?LP;F I@ F?HANB QCNB ;H CHN?HMCNS I@ 0B? >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ NB?
DOGJ MCT? 6 CM (
FF MIOL=?M I@ OH=?LN;CHNS
#N
:N
;H> 6N
;L? ;MMOG?>
CH>?J?H>?HN 0B? JLI<;<CFCNS I@ B;PCHA U DOGJM <?NQ??H [ ;H> [ CM
I
+:N :N U "/*
'
U
%H NBCM GI>?F
L?NOLHM B;P?
NB?L?@IL?
QB?L?
, I
Y
+ YNN + Y L
'
I
U U
;H> I<PCIOMFS
NB? JLI<;<CFCNS NB;N HI DOGJ I==OLM CM NB? =IGJF?G?HN I@ NBCM
JLI<;<CFCNS 1MCHA MCGCF;L =IGJON;NCIHM
Q? G;S MBIQ NB;N NB? JLI<;<CFCNS
NB;N NQI DOGJM I==OL CH NB? NCG? CHN?LP;F [( [ CM
L
L
+:N :N )YNN + Y '
+ YNN + Y
hN/;B;FC; =;FC<L;N?M NB? GI>?F QCNB NB? P;FO?M ( '( '(
'(
*
0B?M? J;L;G?N?LM =ILL?MJIH> NI >;N; NB;N CM =;FC<L;N?>
;HHO;FFS
<ON @IL QBC=B Q? =IHMC>?L IH? MCHAF? GIHNB ;M ; NCG? @L;G? %H
.?;FCT?> PIF;NCFCNS
1
No jump
0.9 1 jump
2 jumps
0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
0 2 4 6 8 10
r
0.9
0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
1 hour 1 day 1 w eek
20
$?</./696AF A5.A . 7B:= <00B??21 63 D2 </@2?C2 . ?2AB?; <3
12=2;16;4
<; A52 A6:2 5<?6G<;
.?;FCT?> PIF;NCFCNS
#>*-;*=2, ?*;2*=287
D52?2 %_& 12;<A2@ A52 3B;0A6<; ?2AB?;6;4 A52 9.?42@A 6;A242? 92@@ A5.; <? 2>B.9
A< _
0B? L?MOFNCHA JLI=?MM CM MIG?NCG?M =;FF?> NB? /?.082A =?<02@@ 0BCM ?RJL?M
MCIH >?WH?M NB? KO;>L;NC= P;LC;NCIH JLI=?MM ;M NB? FCGCN =;M? I@ ; =OGOF;NCP?
MOG I@ MKO;L?> L?NOLHM QB?H NB? M;GJFCHA M?KO?H=? <?=IG?M CHWHCN?FS WH?
0B? KO?MNCIH NB;N ?G?LA?M CM
QB;N NBCM JLI=?MM ;=NO;FFS L?JL?M?HNM
NI QBC=B
?HNCNS >I?M NBCM KO;HNCNS =IHP?LA? E?S L?MOFN I@ JLI<;<CFCNS NB?ILS MN;N?M
NB;N NB? KO;>L;NC= P;LC;NCIH =;JNOL?M NB? KO;>L;NC= P;LC;NCIH I@ NB? FI=;F =IH
NCHOIOM G;LNCHA;F?
;M Q?FF ;M NB? G?;MOL? I@ MKO;L?> DOGJM NB;N ;L? I@ WHCN?
MCT? 3? G;S NB?L?@IL? QLCN?
,
WN W$ N WM
(
MN
QB?L? <S >?WHCNCIH WM &%' WM WO ( ;H> QB?L? W$ N =;JNOL?M NB?
O MOM
KO;>L;NC=
) P;LC;NCIH I@ NB? =IHNCHOIOM J;LN I@ NB? JLI=?MM 0BOM
NB? HIN;NCIH
;<IP? MN WM
>?MCAH;N?M NB? MKO;L?> MOG I@ DOGJM NB;N I==OL CH NB?
JLC=? JLI=?MM F?;LFS
?P?H C@ NB? KO;>L;NC= P;LC;NCIH Q;M EHIQH
C?
<S
?MNCG;NCHA CN @LIG NB? ;=NO;F >;N;
CN MNCFF QIOF> HIN ;FFIQ @IL >CM?HN;HAFCHA
NB? =IHNCHOIOM ;H> NB? DOGJ J;LNM
=NO;FFS
CH GIMN I@ NB? @IFFIQCHA
Q? QCFF =IHMC>?L FCGCN =;M?M QB?L? QCFF
=IHP?LA? NI T?LI 0BCM G?;HM NB;N NB? CHN?LP;F I QCFF <? >CPC>?> CHNI MIG? /
CHN?LP;FM
QCNB / <?=IGCHA P?LS F;LA? 3? ;MMOG? NB;N NB? >C_?L?H=? <?NQ??H
/ ;H> I CM H?AFCAC<F?
%@ Q? OM? ?RJFC=CN GI>?FM MO=B ;M #.$ GI>?FM =IG<CH?> QCNB DOGJ =IGJI
H?HNM
NB?H CN CM JIMMC<F? NI >CM?HN;HAF? NB? =IHNCHOIOM ;H> DOGJ J;LNM 0B? CMMO?
QB?H >ICHA NBCM CM NB;N MNLIHA ;MMOGJNCIHM IH NB? MNI=B;MNC= PIF;NCFCNS GI>?F ;H>
NB? NSJ? I@ DOGJM ;L? G;>?
)I>?FCHA 2IF;NCFCNS
N NBCM MN;A?
Q? B;P? >?N?LGCH?> NB;N NB? KO;>L;NC= P;LC;NCIH I@ NB? JLI=?MM
=IHN;CHM NB? KO;>L;NC= P;LC;NCIH I@ NB? =IHNCHOIOM J;LN JFOM NB? G?;MOL? I@
NB? DOGJM CH NB? JLC=? JLI=?MM MCGCF;L L?MOFN =;H <? I<N;CH?> <S OMCHA NB?
=IH=?JN I@ JIQ?L P;LC;NCIH
NI QBC=B Q? NOLH HIQ
*
/ L?G;LE NB;N NB? M=;FCHA @;=NIL CM =LO=C;F NI A?N L?MOFNM NB;N ;L?
=IGJ;L;<F? ;=LIMM M?LC?M 0B? J;L;G?N?L Y CM =;FF?> NB? JIQ?L QCNB QBC=B NB?
P;LC;NCIH CM G?;MOL?> "IL Y
JIQ?L P;LC;NCIH CM NB? M;G? ;M KO;>L;NC=
P;LC;NCIH +<PCIOMFS
CH NB;N =;M?
NB? M=;FCHA @;=NIL >CM;JJ?;LM "IL Y (
'9 N 9 [ (
6@ . :.?A6;4.92
0B? MSG<IFM ;H> MN;H> @IL NB? MOJL?GOG ;H> NB? CHWGOG IJ?L;NILM
QB?L?
CH NBCM ?RJL?MMCIH
L L Y
*
*INC=? NB;N L =ILL?
MJIH>M NI NB? YNB GIG?HN I@ ; T?LI G?;H
OHCN P;LC;H=? HILG;F JLI=?MM
C?
L 1)\)L
C@ \ (
' 0B? @IFFIQCHA L?MOFN >?GIHMNL;N?M NB? CGJIL
N;H=? I@ JIQ?L P;LC;NCIH %N MBIQM NB;N DOGJM QCFF P;HCMB C@ Q? =IGJON? JIQ?L
P;LC;NCIHM
.@ 9<;4 .@ Y (
'
0BCM L?MOFN G?;HM NB;N C@ ; JLI=?MM B;M ; !"!$ =IGJIH?HN ;H> >CM=L?N?
DOGJ =IGJIH?HNM
NB? JIQ?L P;LC;NCIH QCFF ?FCGCH;N? NB? DOGJ J;LNM ;H> IHFS
=;JNOL? NB? =IHNCHOIOM CHWHCN? P;LC;NCIH P;LC;H=? %HNOCNCP?FS
NBCM L?MOFN MN?GM
@LIG NB? @;=N NB;N NB? CH=L?G?HN )WE WE )L G?;MOL?M CH=L?G?HNM I@ NB?
NSJ? )WE WE )L ;H> I@ NB? NSJ? )6)L QB?L? 6 MN;H>M @IL DOGJ 0B? M=;FCHA
<S L SC?F>M @IL NB? W J;LN
=IHP?LA?H=? NI ; Q?FF <?B;P?> CHN?AL;F
<ON
@IL NB? DOGJ J;LN
=IHP?LA?H=? NI
%@ Q? =IHMC>?L
@LIG B?L? IH
; MG;FF NCG? CH=L?G?HN [( [ K[ NB?H
IP?L
NBCM MG;FF NCG? CHN?LP;F
@IL Y ) ( CN GOMN BIF> NB;N
L L
L
L L WN?N WN
WN?N WN L LN K[ N '
L K[
N
LM () ,
'W(N =96: )WE WE )L )WE WE )M ( Y( Z '
E
L L
'W(N ,
WN WM
'
L L
MN
/I @;L
NB? L?MOFNM BIF> @IL ; NCG? J?LCI> ( [' "IL ?GJCLC=;F JOLJIM?M
CN G;S
<? CHN?L?MNCHA NI =IHMC>?L NB?M? G?;MOL?M @IL WHCN? NCG? CHN?LP;FM "IL CHMN;H=?
CH ?GJCLC=;F L?M?;L=B
Q? G;S QCMB NI =IGJON? NB? CGJILN;H=? I@ DOGJM ;H> I@
NB? =IHNCHOIOM J;LN
@IL ; ACP?H >;S >;JNCHA NB? P;LCIOM =IH=?JNM
CHNLI>O=?>
;<IP?
NI WHCN? NCG? CHN?LP;FM CM L?F;NCP?FS ?;MS .;NB?L NB;H MN;LNCHA ;N
Q?
G;S MN;LN ;N >CM=L?N? JICHNM I@ NCG? +P?L WHCN? NCG? CHN?LP;FM
Q? G;S N;FE I@
)I>?FCHA 2IF;NCFCNS
%H NBCM M?=NCIH
Q? CH>C=;N? BIQ NI NL;HMF;N? NB?M? P;LCIOM =IH=?JNM CHNI ?M
NCG;<F? ?HNCNC?M 3? ;FMI CFFOMNL;N? NB? NSJ? I@ L?MOFNM Q? G;S ?RJ?=N 0I >I
MI
Q? OM? ; >;N;<;M? =IHMCMNCHA I@ BCAB@L?KO?H=S >;N; I@ NB? "L?H=B MNI=E
G;LE?N 3? @I=OM IH NBL?? =IGJ;HC?M
4
;H CHMOL;H=? =IGJ;HS
(2)$
;
FOROLS @;MBCIH JLI>O=?L
;M Q?FF ;M /I=CfNf #fHfL;F?
; F;LA? <;HE 0B? NBL??
=IGJ;HC?M OH>?L =IHMC>?L;NCIH MN?G @LIG P;LCIOM M?=NILM "IL ?;=B I@ NB?M?
=IGJ;HC?M
Q? ?RNL;=N >;N; =IP?LCHA NB? M?=IH> B;F@ I@ ;H> NB? ?HNCL?
S?;L 0B? L;Q >;N; CM L?F;NCP?FS F;LA?
@IL CHMN;H=?
IH ; NSJC=;F >;S
BIOLM
>;S
/N;H>;L> >?PC;NCIH
GCHON?M
BIOL
BIOLM
>;S
/E?QH?MM
GCHON?M
BIOL
BIOLM
>;S
'OLNIMCM
GCHON?M
BIOL
BIOLM
>;S
ONI=ILL?F;NCIH
GCHON?M
BIOL
BIOLM
>;S
$.*52C.- 6.*<>;.<
%H IL>?L NI CGJF?G?HN ?MNCG;NCIH I@ NB? =IH=?JNM M??H ;<IP?
MO=B ;M NB?
L?;FCT?> P;LC;H=?
Q? H??> NI JLIPC>? MIG? HIN;NCIHM MMOG? NB;N ?;=B >;S
B;M <??H =ON CHNI 9 CHN?LP;FM NB;N Q? MOJJIM? NI <? I@ =IHMN;HN MN?J MCT?
MI
NB;N NB? CHMN;HNM QB?L? JLC=?M ;L? G?;MOL?> ;L? ACP?H <S Q QB?L? CM NB?
MN?J MCT? ;H> Q ( ( 9 "IL CHMN;H=?
=IOF> =ILL?MJIH> NI GCHON?M ;H>
9
@IL ; >;S QCNB BIOLM ;H> GCHON?M 3? CH>?R <S P NB? PNB >;S
0B? @IFFIQCHA ?RJL?MMCIH >?WH?M NB? >;S P L?;FCT?> P;LC;H=?
-
,
1
WD- WD-
E WD-
E '
E
*INC=? NB;N NB? >;S WAOL?M ;M ;H CH>?R NI NB? <L;=E?NM ;H> MI >I?M NB? M;G
JFCHA @L?KO?H=S 0B? L?;FCT?> PIF;NCFCNS I@ >;S P CM I<N;CH?> ;M NB? MKO;L? LIIN
I@ NB? L?;FCT?> P;LC;H=? :
1
W
D-
0B? >CM=L?N? G?;MOL?M @IL NB? L?;FCT?> YNB JIQ?L P;LC;NCIH ;H> NB? L?;FCT?>
<CJIQ?L P;LC;NCIH ;L? L?MJ?=NCP?FS
-
,
L
1
W (
)WD-
E WD-
E )L (
D-
E
-
,
LM
2
'W( ()
)WD-
E WD-
E )L
D-
E
)WD-
E WD-
E )M '
F?;LFS
CH N?LGM I@ =IHP?LA?H=?
;MMI=C;NCHA ; AFI<;F NCG? CH>?R [ NI NB?
P;LCIOM >;SM
Q? I<N;CH
. N ,
1
W W
W
O K\ WM
(
D- N N
- N NMN
QB?L?
) [ P9 ( P9
;H> [
P
9 ( P
9
( ;H> QB?L?
NMN WM
MN;H>M @IL NB? DOGJM NB;N I==OLL?> <?NQ??H [
;H> [' FMI
@IL Y Z ) ( Q? B;P?
. N
L
1
W W
L
W
L
LO K\(
D- N N L
- N
. N
LM
2
'W(
LM
'W(N
LM
'W(N L M LM
D- O K\'
- N
NB?L? ;L? G;HS L?F;NCP?FS MG;FF H?A;NCP? L?NOLHM NB;N =OGOF;N? CHNI MIG?NBCHA
F;LA?L ;N NB? >;CFS F?P?F +H NB? M?=IH> >;S
NB? M?=IH> BIOL WHCMB?M QCNB ;
F;LA? H?A;NCP? L?NOLH I@ ;<ION
0I CHP?MNCA;N? QB?NB?L NBCM CM ; DOGJ IL DOMN MIG? =IHNCHOIOM P;LC;NCIH
Q?
@OLNB?L @I=OM IH >;N; QB?L? NB? M;GJFCHA N;E?M JF;=? ;N ; GCHON? @L?KO?H=S
0BCM >;N; CM >CMJF;S?> CH "CAOL? 0B?M? L?NOLHM L?P?;F NB;N NB? WLMN @?Q
BIOLM I@ NB? M?=IH> >;S ;L? KOCN? ;ACN;N?> 0I CHP?MNCA;N? C@ NB? L?F;NCP?FS F;LA?
>LIJ I@ MN?GM @LIG ; MCHAF? ?P?HN IL ; MO==?MMCIH I@ ?P?HNM
Q? =IHMC>?L
;FMI NB? L;Q JLC=? JLI=?MM >CMJF;S?> CH NB? H?RN WAOL?
"CAOL? L?JL?M?HNM JLC=? CH=L?G?HNM ;N ; GCHON? CHN?LP;F 3? HINC=?
NB;N NB? JLC=?M >LIJJ?> CH ; L;NB?L MN?;>S G;HH?L >OLCHA NB? M?=IH> BIOL
MOAA?MNCHA NB;N NB? L?NOLH CM FCE?FS >O? NI MIG? =IHNCHOIOM ?P?HN L;NB?L
NB;H NI ; DOGJ 0I CHP?MNCA;N? NBCM =IHD?=NOL? GIL? @ILG;FFS
Q? NOLH NI
-1
-2
-3
-4
-5
50 100 150 200 250 300
-1
-2
-3
-4
0 50 100 150 200 250 300
-1
-2
-3
-4
0 50 100 150 200 250 300
39
38
37
36
35
34
33
0 50 100 150 200 250 300
NB? =IH=?JNM I@ L?;FCT?> P;LC;H=? ;H> <CJIQ?L P;LC;NCIH NB;N MBIOF> ;FFIQ NB?
>?N?=NCIH I@ DOGJM
"CAOL? L?JL?M?HNM NB? L?MOFNM I@ NB? =IGJON;NCIH I@ P;LCIOM MN;NCM
NC=M "IL =IGJ;LCMIH JOLJIM?M
Q? MFCABNFS CH=L?;M?> NB? HOG<?L I@ >;SM 0B?
F;LA?MN JLC=? P;LC;NCIH IH JLCF
CM HIQ IH >;S 0B? OJJ?L J;H?F
I@ NB? WAOL? L?JL?M?HNM NB? >;CFS ?MNCG;N? I@ KO;>L;NC= P;LC;NCIH
QBC=B CM L?
;FCT?> P;LC;H=? 0BCM WAOL? ;FMI =IHN;CHM NB? JIQ?L P;LC;NCIH I<N;CH?> QCNB
Y
IP?L NB? P;LCIOM >;SM M NBCM WAOL? MBIQM
NB? NQI G?;MOL?M ;L? L?F;
NCP?FS =FIM? +<PCIOMFS
ACP?H NB;N KO;>L;NC= P;LC;NCIH =;JNOL?M NB? CHN?AL;N?>
P;LC;H=? ;H> JIQ?L P;LC;H=?
@IL NB? ACP?H JIQ?L
=;JNOL?M NB? YNB JIQ?L I@
NB? ;<MIFON? P;FO? I@ MN;H>;L> >?PC;NCIH
NB?L? CM HI L?;MIH @IL NB?M? NQI MN;
NCMNC=M NI N;E? NB? M;G? P;FO? 3? DOMN HINC=? NB;N NB? NQI MN;NCMNC=M ?PIFP? CH
NB? M;G? >CL?=NCIH
%H NB? FIQ?L J;H?F I@ "CAOL?
Q? >CMJF;S NB? >C_?L?H=? <?NQ??H L?;FCT?>
P;LC;H=? ;H> L?;FCT?> <CJIQ?L P;LC;NCIH M CH>C=;N?> <S ;LH>IL_*C?FM?H ;H>
/B?JB;L> ;
CH MG;FF M;GJF?M
NB? ?MNCG;N? I@ NB? DOGJ G;S SC?F> NI
; H?A;NCP? ?MNCG;N? /CH=? NB? >C_?L?H=? I@ NB?M? NQI MN;NCMNC=M MBIOF> NB?I
L?NC=;FFS =;JNOL? NB? MOG I@ MKO;L?> DOGJM
NB? H?A;NCPCNS I@ NB? G?;MOL? CM
=IOHN?L@;=NO;F 3? G;S CGJLIP? NBCM =IGJON;NCIH <S M?NNCHA ; FIQ?L <IOH>
;N T?LI
%H N?LGM I@ CHN?LJL?N;NCIH
;M NB? FIQ?L J;H?F I@ NB? WAOL? CH>C=;N?M
NB?L?
;L? M?P?L;F INB?L >;SM QCNB DOGJ G?;MOL?M ;M F;LA? ;M @IL NB? ACP?H >;S $?H=?
NB? JLI=?MM @IL NB;N >;S MBIOF> <? =IHMC>?L?> NI <? A?H?L;N?> <S ; JLI=?MM
)I>?FCHA 2IF;NCFCNS
16
14
12
10
4
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
PIFOG? =IOF> L?JL?M?HN NB? >;CFS CH@ILG;NCIH =IHN?HN %N Q;M ;FL?;>S MBIQH
<S F;LE NB;N ?P?H NBIOAB NB?M? NQI G?;MOL?M ;JJ?;L =ILL?F;N?>
NBCM
L?F;NCIH CM HIN ; AII> IH? 3? G;S P?LC@S NBCM L?MOFN B?L? <S =IHN?GJF;NCHA
CH "CAOL? NB? M=;NN?LJFIN <?NQ??H >;CFS PIFOG?M IH NB? BILCTIHN;F ;RCM
G?;MOL?> <S NB? HOG<?L I@ MB;L?M NL;>?>
;H> NB? L?;FCT?> P;LC;H=? ;FIHA
NB? P?LNC=;F ;RCM
"IL MNI=E L?NOLHM ;H> ?R=B;HA? L;N?M
H>?LM?H ?N ;F ;H> H>?LM?H ?N
;F JLIPC>? ?GJCLC=;F ?PC>?H=? NB;N L?NOLHM M=;F?> <S L?;FCT?> MN;H>;L>
>?PC;NCIHM ;L? ;JJLIRCG;N?FS #;OMMC;H
.?;FCT?> PIF;NCFCNS
1
Quantiles of Input Sample
-1
-2
-3
-4 -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 4
Standard Normal Quantiles
3? HINC=? NB;N NB? F;LA?MN >;CFS L?;FCT?> P;LC;H=?M ;L? ;MMI=C;N?> QCNB BCAB
PIFOG? <ON HIN NB? F;LA?MN IH?M 0BOM
?P?H NBIOAB NB?L? =?LN;CHFS ?RCMNM ;
L?F;NCIH <?NQ??H PIFOG? ;H> >;CFS L?;FCT?> P;LC;H=?M
NBCM L?F;NCIH CM @;L @LIG
<?CHA MCGJF?
/I @;L
IOL @I=OM B;M <??H IH OHCP;LC;N? >;N; 3? NOLH HIQ NI NB? <?
B;PCIL I@ ;MM?N JLC=?M QCNBCH ; GOFNCP;LC;N? M?NNCHA %H NB? @IFFIQCHA M?=NCIH
&1.8;B
20
18
16
14
Daily realized variance
12
10
0
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5
Daily v olume x 10
6
QB?L? HN CM ; (
P?=NIL I@ >LC@N N?LGM ;H> TN CM ; NQI>CG?HMCIH;F G;LNCH
A;F? 0B? O CM ; (
G;NLCR
;H> CO L?JL?M?HNM ; NQI>CG?HMCIH;F LIQHC;H
GINCIH "LIG NB?L? IH
Q? G;S QLCN?
O
O '
F?;LFS
JF;SM NB? LIF? I@ ; =IP;LC;H=? %N G;S <? MBIQH NB;N NB? L?;FCT?>
=IP;LC;H=? =IHP?LA?M NI ;H CHN?AL;N?> =IP;LC;H=?
. N
W ( W N O K\'
%HN?L?MNCHAFS
C@ Q? B;P? MO=B ?MNCG;N?M I@ ; =IP;LC;H=? G;NLCR
CN <?=IG?M
JIMMC<F? NI ;FMI >CM=OMM JILN@IFCI ;FFI=;NCIHM @LIG ; BCAB@L?KO?H=S JICHN I@
PC?Q M JL?PCIOMFS
CN CM JIMMC<F? NI MJ?=C;FCT? L?;FCT?> =IP;LC;H=? NI ;H CHN?LP;F
I@ NCG? 3? =IHMC>?L ; ACP?H >;S P NB;N CM >?=IGJIM?> CHNI 9 NCG? CHN?LP;FM
0BCM ?RJL?MMCIH CM
NBOM
;H ?MNCG;N? I@ NB? CHN?AL;N?> =IP;LC;H=? ;H> QCFF <?
=;FF?> L?;FCT?> =IP;LC;H=? %H NB? FCGCN ;M 9 =IHP?LA?M NI CHWHCNS
L?;FCT?>
=IP;LC;H=? QCFF =IHP?LA? NI NB? CH=L?G?HN I@ CHN?AL;N?> =IP;LC;H=?
1MCHA NB? L?;FCT?> =IP;LC;H=? ;M Q?FF ;M L?;FCT?> P;LC;H=?M
CN CM JIMMC<F? NI
=IGJON? ; G?;MOL? I@ L?;FCT?> =ILL?F;NCIH >?WH?> ;M
W
( W
D-
9 '
2
W 2
D- W D-
(2)$
/I= #fH
$IOLFS L?NOLHM
4
(2)$
/I= #fH
.?NOLHM IP?L BIOLM
4
(2)$
/I= #fH
;CFS L?NOLHM
4
(2)$
/I= #fH
0.5
0.45
0.4
0.35
0.3
0.25
0.2
0.15
0.1
0.05
0
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500
20
.69F ?2.96G21 0<??29.A6<;@ 0<:=BA21 D6A5 :6;BA2 ?2AB?;@
QCNB >;N; M;GJF?> ;N NB? GCHON? @L?KO?H=S ;H> NB? BIOLFS @L?KO?H=S A;CH
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500
20
.69F ?2.96G21 0<??29.A6<;@ 0<:=BA21 .A :6;BA2 .;1 5<B? 3?2>B2;0F
/I @;L
Q? B;P? CH>C=;N?> BIQ NI >?=IGJIM? ; JLC=? JLI=?MM CHNI ; =IHNCHO
IOM J;LN ;H> ; >CM=L?N? J;LN 0B? @IFFIQCHA ?F?G?HNM
>L;QH @LIG ;LH>IL_
*C?FM?H ;H> /B?JB;L> ;
G;S <? OM?@OF NI @ILG;FFS N?MN @IL NB? ?RCMN?H=?
I@ DOGJM /?? ;FMI *
/
M <?@IL?
>?HIN? <S L 1)\)L ( NB? YNB GIG?HN I@ \' 3B?H ; @ILGOF;
=IHN;CHM \( \
( ;H> \
Q? ;MMOG? NB;N NB? ;MMI=C;N?> >CMNLC<ONCIHM ;L? ;FF
HILG;F (
;H> CH>?J?H>?HN %@ W <?FIHAM NI NB? =F;MM I@ !"!$
NB?H
;M =IHP?LA?M NIQ;L>
@IL ;HS Y +
+N
LL
'W(N L L M KZ
9 (
(
L
L L
L
L
L L
L 'B )\) )\ ) /V] )\) )\ ) ( )\ ) )\ ) ( WN
) ?M % N
) + N &
)WE W E ))W E W E )
M
KZ
E
QB?L?
B \ /V] \ ( )\) )\ )
'
/V] \ ( )\) )\ )
0BCM =IP;LC;H=? G;NLCR G;S <? =IGJON?> IH=? ;H> @IL ;FF HOG?LC=;FFS <?=;OM?
HIH? I@ NB? N?LGM >?J?H>M IH NB? ;=NO;F >;N; *
/ I<N;CH
'
'
$?H=?
;M G?HNCIH?>
NBCM MN;NCMNC= =;H <? OM?> NI N?MN @IL NB? JL?M?H=? I@
DOGJM 0I L?H>?L NBCM @ILGOF; IJ?L;NCIH;F
CN CM H?=?MM;LS NI ?P;FO;N? NB?
.?;FCT?> PIF;NCFCNS
N
, . N
JFCG WE WE
WE WE
M KZ(
E
/I @;L
Q? B;P? >CM=OMM?> MIG? L?=?HN NB?IL?NC=;F >?P?FIJG?HNM 3? HIQ
JL?M?HN MIG? I@ NB? ?GJCLC=;F L?MOFNM NB;N B;P? <??H @IOH> CH NB? FCN?L;NOL?
"CLMN
Q? G;S G?HNCIH ; FCN?L;NOL? NB;N >?;FM QCNB =IGJ;LCHA PIF;NCFCNS @IL?
=;MNM NI ;=NO;F PIF;NCFCNS L?;FCT;NCIHM +H? MO=B =IHNLC<ONCIH CM NB? IH? <S
H>?LM?H ?N ;F %N @I=OM?M
FCE? GO=B I@ NBCM FCN?L;NOL?
IH ?R=B;HA?
L;N? >;N; 0B?M? =IHNLC<ONCIHM MBIQ NB;N L?;FCT?> PIF;NCFCNS CM <?MN @IL?=;MN
<S OMCHA ; P?=NIL ;ONIL?AL?MMCIH CHPIFPCHA GOFNCP;LC;N? L?;FCT?> PIF;NCFCNS ;H>
QB?L? MIG? FIHA G?GILS CM ;FFIQ?> @IL <S OMCHA ; @L;=NCIH;F >C_?L?H=?
L;NB?L
NB;H <S ; GI>?F <?FIHACHA NI NB? #.$ @;GCFS M Q? B;P? M??H CH NB? ;<IP?
MN;NCMNC=;F ;H;FSMCM I@ "L?H=B MNI=E G;LE?N >;N;
NB? M;GJFCHA @L?KO?H=S JF;SM
;H CGJILN;HN LIF? /;GJFCHA >;N; ;N ; GCHON? @L?KO?H=S QCFF HIN SC?F> NI NB?
M;G? J;NN?LH I@ ;ONI=ILL?F;NCIH NB;H C@ BIOLFS >;N; CM OM?> 0B? L?;MIH @IL
NBCM CM NB;N ;N ;H CH=L?;MCHA @L?KO?H=S
MI=;FF?> :60?<@A?B0AB?2 ;<6@2 =IG?M
CHNI JF;S 0BCM HICM? G;S <? ?RJF;CH?> <S NB? <C>;ME MJL?;>
<S NB? @;=N
NB;N ; ACP?H ;MM?N JLC=? G;S <? =IGCHA @LIG >C_?L?HN G;LE?NM
IL >O? NI NB?
@;=N NB;N JLC=?M ;L? NL;>?> ;N >CM=L?N? P;FO?M 0B? =IHNLC<ONCIH <S H>?LM?H
IFF?LMF?P
;H> )?>>;BC MBIQM NB;N
CH NB? JL?M?H=? I@ GC=LIMNLO=NOL?
HICM?
NB? L?;FCT?> PIF;NCFCNS @IL?=;MN CM ?P?H <?NN?L NB;H ILCACH;FFS NBIOABN
M DOMN G?HNCIH?>
NB? LIF? I@ GC=LIMNLO=NOL? HICM? G;S B;GJ?L NB? ?M
NCG;NCIH I@ L?;FCT?> PIF;NCFCNS IL I@ L?;FCT?> =IP;LC;H=?M 0B? KO?MNCIH NB?H
CM I@ =IOLM? QB;N NCG? @L?KO?H=S Q? MBIOF> OM? M M??H ;N NB? <?ACHHCHA I@
NBCM M?=NCIH
NB? >;N; MBIOF> <? M;GJF?> ;N ; BCAB ?HIOAB @L?KO?H=S NI ;FFIQ
@IL ; >CM?HN;HAFCHA I@ DOGJM +H NB? INB?L B;H>
; WH?L ;H> WH?L M;GJFCHA
W0N WN #N (
KWN N K[ N KCN (
QB?L? #N =;H <? 661 IL >?J?H>?HN 0B?S MBIQ NB;N ; AII> ?MNCG;N?
H;G?>
0QI /=;F?M .?;FCT?> 2IF;NCFCNS 0/.2
CM <;M?> IH NQI =IGJIH?HNM "CLMN
QB?L?
-
,
1
WFD- WD-
N"
E WD-
N"
E (
E
;H> QB?L? [F ( @IL R
( ( 7 ;L? MN;LNCHA GIG?HNM >OLCHA NB? WLMN >;CFS
CHN?LP;F ( ( 9 ;H> 9
;L? NB? HOG<?L I@ CHN?LP;FM N;E?H @IL NB? MFIQ ;H> NB?
@;MN NCG?M=;F? 0B? MOAA?MNCIH NI OM? ?MNCG;N?M <;M?> IH >C_?L?HN NCG?M=;F?M
G;S ;FMI <? @IOH> CH ;H>C ;H> .OMM?F
<?NN?L G?;MOL?G?HN I@ PIF;NCFCNS CM FCE?FS NI <? OM?@OF @IL IJNCIH JLC=
CHA >?=IGJIMCNCIH I@ JLC=?M CHNI =IHNCHOIOM ;H> >CM=L?N? =IGJIH?HNM G;S
CGJLIP? B?>ACHA H ;H;FSMCM I@ PIF;NCFCNS G;S ;FMI MB?> FCABN IH NB? <?B;P
CIL I@ CHP?MNILM +H? J;J?L CH NBCM >CL?=NCIH CM NB? IH? <S H>?LM?H
IFF?L
MF?P
;H> C?<IF> 0B? ;ONBILM =IHMC>?L L?;FCT?> PIF;NCFCNC?M G?;MOL?>
IP?L NCG?M=;F?M ;H> MBIQ
CH ; P?=NIL ;ONIL?AL?MMCIH @L;G?QILE
NB;N L?;FCT?>
PIF;NCFCNS =IHN;CHM =IGJF?G?HN;LS CH@ILG;NCIH ;N ?;=B I@ NB?M? NCG?M=;F?M
0BCM MOAA?MNM NB;N NB?L? ;L? B?N?LIA?H?IOM CHP?MNILM QBIM? NCG? BILCTIHM ;L?
HIN NB? M;G? /O=B ;H I<M?LP;NCIH MOAA?MNM NB;N ; <?NN?L OH>?LMN;H>CHA I@
CHP?MNIL <?B;PCIL @LIG ;H ?=IHIGC= JICHN I@ PC?Q G;S <? OM?@OF
8-.5270 201.; 86.7=<
%H NBCM =B;JN?L
Q? CHP?MNCA;N? NQI CGJILN;HN CMMO?M @IL NB? GI>?FCHA I@ ;MM?N
L?NOLHM 0B? WLMN CMMO? CM NB? GI>?FCHA I@ NB? ?HNCL? >?HMCNS I@ L?NOLHM
MI NB;N
CN CH=ILJIL;N?M MIG? I@ NB? @?;NOL?M >?M=LC<?> CH B;JN?L
CH J;LNC=OF;L NB?
;MSGG?NLS ;H> NB? @;NN;CF?>H?MM I@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH %H M?P?L;F JLI<F?GM CH
WH;H=?
CN CM =LO=C;F NI L?=IAHCT? NB;N NB? =IH>CNCIH;F >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ L?NOLHM CM
HIHHILG;F ;H> NI =ILL?=NFS GI>?F CN JL?=CM? EHIQF?>A? I@ NB? =IH>CNCIH;F
>CMNLC<ONCIH CM L?KOCL?>
@IL CHMN;H=?
@IL ;MM?N ;FFI=;NCIH
2;. 2;FO?;N.CME
=IGJON;NCIH
IL NB? P;FO;NCIH I@ =IHNCHA?HN =F;CGM
0B? M?=IH> CMMO? CM NB? GI>?FCHA I@ NB? NCG?P;LC;<CFCNS I@ BCAB?L GIG?HNM
QBC=B =;H <? PC?Q?> ;M MOGG;LC?M I@ NB? >?HMCNS 0BCM CM ; E?S CMMO? @IL
JLI<F?GM NB;N CHPIFP? >;N; M;GJF?> ;N ; L;NB?L BCAB @L?KO?H=S M;S >;CFS IL
Q??EFS >;N; IL P?LS HIHHILG;F ;MM?N L?NOLHM "IL CHMN;H=?
NB? GI>?FCHA I@
=IH>CNCIH;F BCAB?L GIG?HNM QCFF <? =LO=C;F CH NB? =IGJON;NCIH I@ =IH>CNCIH;F
2;.
QBC=B CM ; MBILNN?LG G?;MOL? NSJC=;FFS =;F=OF;N?> @IL ; IL >;S
BILCTIH
CH QBC=B =;M? NB? GI>?FCHA I@ BCAB?L GIG?HNM G;S MO<MN;HNC;FFS
CGJLIP? NB? ;==OL;=S I@ 2;. (?N OM =IHMC>?L HIQ NB? =;M? I@ ;MM?N ;FFI=;NCIH
!R;=NFS ;M NB? GI>?F I@ );LEIPCNT <OCF>M IH NB? WLMN NQI GIG?HNM
G?;H ;H>
P;LC;H=?
GIL? ;>P;H=?> GI>?FM <OCF> IH GIG?HNM <?SIH> NB? WLMN NQI N
WLMN AF;H=?
NB? ?RCMN?H=? I@ NCG?P;LSCHA BCAB?L GIG?HNM G;S <? ?RJ?=N?> NI
MNLIHAFS ;_?=N NB? ;FFI=;NCIH I@ Q?;FNB 5?N
;MM?N ;FFI=;NCIH CM I@N?H =IHMC>?L?>
;N ; L;NB?L FIQ @L?KO?H=S QCNB ; GIHNBFS IL ?P?H ; KO;LN?LFS BILCTIH N
MO=B CHN?LP;FM
BCAB?L GIG?HNM ;L? F?MM FCE?FS NI <? NCG?P;LSCHA "IL ;MM?N
;FFI=;NCIH JOLJIM?
Q? G;S =IH=FO>? NB;N NB? GI>?FCHA I@ NB? BCAB?L GIG?HNM
CM =LO=C;F @IL ;MM?N =F;MM?M QCNB P?LS HIHHILG;F L?NOLHM
MO=B ;M B?>A? @OH>M
IL ?G?LACHA G;LE?N CH>C=?M GIL? =IGJF?N? >?M=LCJNCIH I@ NB?M? CMMO?M CM
JLIPC>?> CH B;JN?LM ;H>
3? NB?L?@IL? =IHMC>?L HIQ NB? ?RJFC=CN GI>?FCHA I@ NB? BCAB?L GIG?HNM
I@ ;MM?N L?NOLHM ;H> NB?CL =IH>CNCIH;F >CMNLC<ONCIHM /CH=? NB? M?GCH;F QILE I@
!HAF?
NCG?P;LSCHA PIF;NCFCNS B;M <??H MBIQH NI JLI>O=? @;N N;CFM CH NB?
OH=IH>CNCIH;F >CMNLC<ONCIH ON NCG?P;LSCHA PIF;NCFCNS ;FIH? CM HIN ?HIOAB NI
?RJF;CH ;FF NB? N;CF @;NH?MM PIF;NCFCNS WFN?L?> L?MC>O;FM MNCFF B;P? N;CFM @;NN?L NB;H
)I>?FCHA $CAB?L )IG?HNM
_N N
#N (
N
1 _N )N ( N
(
#N N
aN (
4 5
N
1 _N N
)N ( N
(
aN N aN )
'
* N
B;M T?LI G?;H ;H>
OHCN P;LC;H=? !KO;NCIH >?N?LGCH?M NB? >SH;GC=M I@ PIF;NCFCNS 0BCM G;S
<? ;HS MJ?=CW=;NCIH CH=FO>CHA NB? #.$ GI>?FM 2?=NIL =IHN;CHM ;FF NB?
J;L;G?N?LM ;MMI=C;N?> QCNB NB? =IH>CNCIH;F G?;H ;H> NB? =IH>CNCIH;F P;LC;H=?
?KO;NCIHM "CH;FFS
?KO;NCIH MJ?=CW?M NB;N NB? MN;H>;L>CT?> CHHIP;NCIH
0B? A?H?L;F JLI<F?G
0B? C>?; <?BCH> NB? WLMN CMMO? CM NB;N NB? GI>?FCHA I@ NB? =IH>CNCIH;F PIF;NCFCNS
L?H>?LM NB? OH=IH>CNCIH;F >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ NB? ?LLIL N?LG #N HIHHILG;F
?P?H C@
NB? =IH>CNCIH;F >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ NB? CHHIP;NCIH aN CM MNCFF ;MMOG?> NI <? HILG;F
0BCM L?MOFN
BCABFCABN?> <S !HAF? ;H> #IHTcF?T.CP?L;
=;H <? I@ AL?;N
CGJILN;H=? @IL M?LC?M NB;N ;L? =B;L;=N?LCT?> <S ; MFCABN >?J;LNOL? @LIG HIL
G;FCNS %H MO=B ; =;M?
?MNCG;NCHA ; #.$ GI>?F QCNB ; HILG;F =IH>CNCIH;F
>CMNLC<ONCIH G;S <? ?HIOAB NI =;JNOL? NB? @;NN;CF?>H?MM I@ NB? OH=IH>CNCIH;F
>CMNLC<ONCIH 0I ?RJF;CH QBS NBCM CM NB? =;M?
Q? H??> NI >CMNCHAOCMB <?NQ??H
NB? =IH>CNCIH;F ;H> NB? OH=IH>CNCIH;F BCAB?L GIG?HNM
1 #N 1 #N
O '
1 N
)I>?FCHA $CAB?L )IG?HNM
MI NB;N
1
N
ZO Z>
'
1 N
?=;OM? I@ &?HM?HZM CH?KO;FCNS
IH? B;M 1
N 1 N ;M N +
;H>
NBOM )ZO ) )Z> ) 0B?L?@IL?
NB? OH=IH>CNCIH;F ME?QH?MM B;M NB? M;G? MCAH ;M
NB? =IH>CNCIH;F IH?
<ON CN CM JIMMC<F? NI =;JNOL? ; BCAB OH=IH>CNCIH;F ME?QH?MM
OMCHA ; =IH>CNCIH;F >CMNLC<ONCIH QCNB ; MG;FF?L ME?QH?MM *INC=? NB;N CH =;M?M
QB?L? NB? =IH>CNCIH;F >CMNLC<ONCIH CM MSGG?NLC=
CHNLI>O=CHA #.$ ?_?=NM
QIOF> HIN L?MOFN CH ;H ;MSGG?NLC=
>CMNLC<ONCIH
MMOGCHA NB;N 1 #N )
NB? OH=IH>CNCIH;F EOLNIMCM CM ACP?H <S
1 #N 1 1 #N )N 1 > N
O (
1 N
1 N
1 N
MI NB;N
1 N
O > '
1 N
+H=? ;A;CH
&?HM?HZM CH?KO;FCNS CGJFC?M 1 N 1 N @IL N +
;H>
B?H=? O > 0B?L?@IL?
?P?H CH NB? =;M? QB?L? CHHIP;NCIHM aN ;L? ;MMOG?> NI
<? HILG;F
; #.$ GI>?F SC?F>M ;H OH=IH>CNCIH;F >CMNLC<ONCIH QCNB @;NN?L
N;CFM NB;H NB? HILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH
O (
25
20
15
Kurtosis
10
0
0 0.02 0.04 0.06 0.08 0.1 0.12 0.14 0.16 0.18
α
+@N?H
; #.$ GI>?F QCNB ; HILG;F =IH>CNCIH;F >CMNLC<ONCIH CM HIN MO^=C?HN
NI =;JNOL? NB? @;N N;CFM @IOH> CH NB? OH=IH>CNCIH;F >CMNLC<ONCIH 0BCM CGJFC?M
NB;N NB? MN;H>;L>CT?> CHHIP;NCIH aN CM HIN HILG;F ;H> NB;N Q? H??> ; GIL?
A?H?L;F MJ?=CW=;NCIH @IL NB? =IH>CNCIH;F >CMNLC<ONCIH
0B? WLMN ;NN?GJN NI =;JNOL? NB? ?R=?MM EOLNIMCM I@ #.$ MN;H>;L>CT?>
L?MC>O;FM CM <S IFF?LMF?P
QBI OM?M ;M =IH>CNCIH;F >CMNLC<ONCIH N aN )
[ aN )
8
N (
)I>?FCHA $CAB?L )IG?HNM
QB?L? '
CM NB? A;GG; @OH=NCIH ;H> NB? >?AL??I@@L??>IG J;L;G?N?L
0B? EOLNIMCM I@ NB? =IH>CNCIH;F >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ aN CM
> (
JLIPC>?> NB;N + 0B? >?AL??I@@L??>IG ;>DOMNG?HN =IHNLC<ON?M NI ?R=?MM
EOLNIMCM
<?=;OM? CN CM <S =IHMNLO=NCIH F;LA?L NB;H IH?
?R=?JN QB?H
;C
.OMM?FF
;H> 0C;I JLIPC>? NB? ?R;=N L?JL?M?HN;NCIH I@ OH=IH>C
NCIH;F EOLNIMCM @IL #.$ ;H> MNI=B;MNC= PIF;NCFCNS GI>?FM
QB?H CHHIP;NCIHM
;L? =IH>CNCIH;FFS HIHHILG;F 0B?S MBIQ NB;N NB? OH=IH>CNCIH;F EOLNIMCM @IL
<INB GI>?FM CM >?N?LGCH?> DICHNFS <S NB? =IH>CNCIH;F >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ aN ;H>
NB? PIF;NCFCNS =FOMN?LCHA I@ #N
#>*<2 *A26>6 24.52188- <=26*=287
QB?L?
GN
&)# N
&)# N aN
&)#
&)# N
aN (
;H> aN _N N
* N
/I NB? G;RCGCT;NCIH JLI<F?G IHFS >?J?H>M IH
NB? WLMN ;H> M?=IH> GIG?HNM IHM?KO?HNFS
C@ NB?S ;L? =ILL?=NFS MJ?=CW?>
-
. - (
- 1 (
,,
. 1 (
@ N ,
,
QCNB ,GN
*,
NB? M=IL? P?=NIL I@ GN
%H WHCN? M;GJF?
NB? ;MSGJNINC= =IP;LC;H=? G;NLCR CM ?MNCG;N?> <S
4 - .
4 - (
4 4
QB?L?
4 , G
, 1- ,
N
-4 (
@ N ,,
QB?L?
GN !
&)# N
&)# N aN
)
(
_N N
N
aN
(
MI NB;N
_N N
N
GN ( (
&)# N
&)# N ) '
N
$?H=?
; =LO=C;F CMMO? QB?H ; HIHHILG;F FCE?FCBII> CM OM?> @IL NB? -)(! CM
QB?NB?L ;>?KO;NCIH N?MNM =IHWLG NB;N NB? ;MMOG?> >CMNLC<ONCIH =ILL?=NFS WNM
NB? >;N;
;H> EOLNIMCM
)
QCNB + '
0BCM L?F;NCIH MBIQM NB;N
@IL ; ACP?H F?P?F I@ EOLNIMCM
IHFS ; WHCN? L;HA? I@
ME?QH?MM G;S <? ;NN;CH?> 0B? =OLP? CH "CAOL? >?FCGCNM NB? ME?QH?MM
EOLNIMCM <IOH>;LS =ILL?MJIH>CHA NI NB? >IG;CH "IL ;FF J;CLM I@ ME?Q
H?MM ;H> EOLNIMCM <?NQ??H NB? OJJ?L ;H> FIQ?L =OLP?M
; >?HMCNS ?RCMNM
HS JLIJIM?> ?RN?HMCIH NI NB? HILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH QCNB WHCN? NBCL> ;H>
@IOLNB GIG?HNM QCFF B;P? ; >IG;CH I@ >?WHCNCIH CHMC>? NB? =OLP?M
;H> NB?
?R;=N =IP?L;A? QCFF >?J?H> IH NB? ACP?H >CMNLC<ONCIH ;H>
GIL? JL?=CM?FS
IH
NB? Q;S ;MSGG?NLS ;H> @;N N;CFM ;L? CHNLI>O=?> CH NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH 3? QCFF
CFFOMNL;N? NBCM @OLNB?L CH NB? H?RN M?=NCIH OMCHA M?P?L;F ;FN?LH;NCP? >CMNLC<ONCIHM
JLIJIM?> CH NB? FCN?L;NOL?
2<=;2+>=287< @2=1 1201.; 686.7=<
0B?L? ;L? M?P?L;F Q;SM I@ >?;FCHA QCNB ;MSGG?NLS IL @;N N;CFM CH ; >CMNLC<
ONCIH "CLMN
MIG? >CMNLC<ONCIHM ;FFIQ ;MSGG?NLS IL @;N N;CFM "IL CHMN;H=?
10
2
Auth orized d om a in
Skewness
0
for the exi ste nce of a di stri butio n
-2
-4
-6
-8
-10
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 10 0
Kurtosis
20
2;2?.9 @82D;2@@8B?A<@6@ /<B;1.?F
CMNLC<ONCIHM QCNB BCAB?L GIG?HNM
%.629*;*6.=;2, *99;8*,1
QB?L?
GN !
&)# N
&)# N aN
)
(
QCNB !
(
NB? P?=NIL I@ OHEHIQH J;L;G?N?LM
0I G;RCGCT? NB? FIAFCE?FCBII> @OH=NCIH
NB? @IFFIQCHA JLI=?>OL? CM
OM?>
C H CHCNC;F ?MNCG;N? I@ NB? M?N I@ J;L;G?N?LM CM ACP?H <S 0 %N G;S <?
I<N;CH?> <S -)( ?MNCG;NCIH I@ ;H>
)I>?FCHA $CAB?L )IG?HNM
QB?L?
GN
&)# N
&)# N
'
0B? FIAFCE?FCBII> @OH=NCIH CM G;RCGCT?>
QCNB N B?F> WR?>
CN?L;NCHA MN?JM
CC]CP OHNCF =IHP?LA?H=?
P FNBIOAB NB? ?MNCG;N?> >?HMCNS CM ;MMOG?> NI <? EHIQH QB?H NB? FIA
FCE?FCBII> CM ?MNCG;N?>
NB? M=IL? P?=NIL ,GN
*,
NB;N =;H <? OM?> @IL NB?
?MNCG;NCIH CM =IGJON?> OMCHA NB? >?LCP;NCP?M I@ N aN
QCNB L?MJ?=N NI
0B? M=IL? CM NB?L?@IL? ACP?H <S
,GN
, N
,#N
, N #N ,N aN
'
,
N ,
,
,
N ,
N
aN
!HAF? ;H> #IHTcF?T.CP?L; OM? NB? >CM=L?N? G;RCGOG J?H;FCT?>
FCE?FCBII> ?MNCG;NCIH N?=BHCKO? >?P?FIJ?> <S 0;JC; ;H> 0BIGJMIH NI
?MNCG;N? NB? HIHJ;L;G?NLC= >?HMCNS 0BCM N?=BHCKO? QILEM ;M @IFFIQM 0B?
>?HMCNS CM ;JJLIRCG;N?> OMCHA NB? BCMNIAL;G I@ aN QCNB EHINM U ( ( UH
QB?L? W WH ;H>
J" J"
WF a UF
C@ a UF UF
(
N a
K
* U UH
(
C@ a
;H> CM NB? J?H;FNS N?LG NI ?HMOL? MGIINBH?MM I@ NB? ?MNCG;N? I@ NB? B?CABNM
W ( ( WH
0B? M?GCJ;L;G?NLC= G?NBI> ;PIC>M MIG? JLI<F?GM I@ >CMNLC<ONCIH GCM
MJ?=CW=;NCIH
<?=;OM? OMCHA ; HIHHILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH G;S F?;> NI CH=IHMCMN?HN
J;L;G?N?L ?MNCG;N?M C@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH CM CH=ILL?=N N NB? M;G? NCG?
NB?
M?GCJ;L;G?NLC= ?MNCG;NIL G;S <? GIL? ?^=C?HN C?
QCNB MG;FF?L MN;H>;L>
?LLIL NB;H ; @OFFS HIHJ;L;G?NLC= G?NBI>
CMNLC<ONCIHM QCNB BCAB?L GIG?HNM
p
2
p
1
p
m- 1
a n n n b z
1 2 m- 1
%.;2.< .A9*7<287 *+8>= =1. 78;6*5 -2<=;2+>=287
#;FF;HN
$MC?B
;H> 0;O=B?H
;H> (?? ;H> 0M? #;FF;HN
$MC?B
;H> 0;O=B?H ;>IJN ; P?LS A?H?L;F MJ?=CW=;NCIH I@ NB? M?LC?M ?RJ;HMCIH
,LIPC>?> NB;N F;LA? >;N; M?NM ;L? ;P;CF;<F?
NBCM M?GCHIHJ;L;G?NLC= ;JJLI;=B
G;S L?P?;F ; FIN I@ CH@ILG;NCIH ;<ION NB? NLO? >CMNLC<ONCIH $IQ?P?L
MO=B
; J;L;G?N?LCT;NCIH CM HIN J;LMCGIHCIOM
;H> =IHM?KO?HNFS ?MNCG;NCIH G;S <?
P?LS =IGJON;NCIH;FFS ?RJ?HMCP? %H ;>>CNCIH
>O? NI NB? HOG<?L I@ J;L;G?N?LM
NI <? ?MNCG;N?>
NB? =B;L;=N?LCMNC=M I@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH ;L? PCLNO;FFS CGJIMMC<F?
NI MNO>S
MJ?=C;F =;M? I@ ; M?LC?M ?RJ;HMCIH CM NB? MI=;FF?> #L;GB;LFC?L ?RJ;H
MCIH #;FF;HN ;H> 0;O=B?H ;H> (?? ;H> 0M? OM? #L;GB;LFC?L
?RJ;HMCIHM NI >?M=LC<? >?PC;NCIHM @LIG HILG;FCNS I@ CHHIP;NCIHM CH ; #.$
@L;G?QILE #L;GB;LFC?L ?RJ;HMCIHM ;FFIQ @IL ;>>CNCIH;F X?RC<CFCNS IP?L ;
HILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH <?=;OM? NB?S H;NOL;FFS CHNLI>O=? NB? ME?QH?MM ;H> EOL
NIMCM I@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH ;M OHEHIQH J;L;G?N?LM $IQ?P?L
<?CHA JIFSHIGC;F
;JJLIRCG;NCIHM
NB?S B;P? NB? >L;Q<;=E I@ SC?F>CHA H?A;NCP? P;FO?M @IL =?LN;CH
J;L;G?N?LM )IL?IP?L
NB?L? >I?M HIN M??G NI <? ;H ?;MS ;H> ;H;FSNC= =B;L;=
N?LCT;NCIH I@ NBIM? J;L;G?N?LM @IL QBC=B NB? >?HMCNS QCFF N;E? JIMCNCP? P;FO?M
;LNIH ;H> ?HHCM ?MN;<FCMB =IH>CNCIHM IH NB? J;L;G?N?LM AO;L;HN??
)I>?FCHA $CAB?L )IG?HNM
2<=;2+>=287
I
,
WI a )
JD 4LD a
(
D
QB?L? 4LD a
>?HIN?M NB? $?LGCN? JIFSHIGC;F I@ IL>?L P %N CM >?WH?> <S
4LD a
D !!T T
0QI L?JL?M?HN;NCIHM B;P? <??H NSJC=;FFS ;>IJN?> CH NB? FCN?L;NOL?
NB?
#L;GB;LFC?L NSJ? ?RJ;HMCIH
W a )
4L
a
4L a
(
;H> NB? !>A?QILNB ?RJ;HMCIH
W
a )
4L
a
4L a
4L
a
(
QCNB (
0B? !>A?QILNB ?RJ;HMCIH CHPIFP?M ;H ;>>CNCIH;F $?LGCN? JIFSHI
GC;F QBCF? E??JCHA NB? HOG<?L I@ J;L;G?N?LM =IHMN;HN 0B?L?@IL?
NB? L;HA?
@IL ;H> IP?L QBC=B JIMCNCPCNS I@ NB? ;JJLIRCG;NCIH CM AO;L;HN??> CM
MG;FF?L NB;H @IL NB? #L;GB;LFC?L IH? "IL NBCM L?;MIH
Q? @I=OM IH NB? WLMN
;JJLIRCG;NCIH
%N =;H <? MBIQH NB;N NB? NQI J;L;G?N?LM ;H> =ICH=C>? QCNB NB?
ME?QH?MM ;H> ?R=?MM EOLNIMCM I@ N a )
L?MJ?=NCP?FS %H>??>
MCH=? NB? ;J
JLIRCG;NCHA >?HMCNS CM ;MMOG?> NI B;P? T?LI G?;H ;H> OHCN P;LC;H=?
Q? B;P?
&IBHMIH
'INT
;H> ;F;ELCMBH;H
/NL;CABN@ILQ;L> =IGJON;NCIHM SC?F> NB? @IFFIQCHA ?RJL?MMCIHM @IL NB? WLMN MCR $?L
GCN? JIFSHIGC;FM )< O
)< O O
)< O O
)< O O O
)<
O O
O
)< O O
O
O ;H> )< O O
O
O
CMNLC<ONCIHM QCNB BCAB?L GIG?HNM
0.2 0.3
0.2
0.1
0.1
0 0
-10 -5 0 5 10 -10 -5 0 5 10
0.6 0.6
0.4 0.4
0.2 0.2
0 0
-0.2 -0.2
-10 -5 0 5 10 -10 -5 0 5 10
20
$13 <3 A52 ?.:5.?962? 16@A?6/BA6<; 3<? C.?6<B@ C.9B2@ <3 @82D;2@@ .;1
8B?A<@6@ D6A5<BA =<@6A6C6AF 0<;@A?.6;A
. .
aN a )
Ka ( a N a )
Ka
(
. .
a
N a )
Ka ( ;H> a N a )
Ka
N a )
=;H <? H?A;NCP? @IL MIG?
a "IL INB?L J;CLM
NB? =13 N a )
G;S <? GOFNCGI>;F 0B?M? JLI<F?GM ;L?
CFFOMNL;N?> CH "CAOL? %H ;>>CNCIH
;M QCFF <? MBIQH <?FIQ
NB? >IG;CH I@
>?WHCNCIH @IL QBC=B NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH CM Q?FF >?WH?> NOLHM ION NI <? L;NB?L
MG;FF
86*27 8/ -.D72=287
&IH>?;O ;H> .I=ECHA?L JLIPC>? MIG? ;H;FSNC=;F L?MOFNM @IL =IGJONCHA
NB? ME?QH?MMEOLNIMCM <IOH>;LS ?HMOLCHA NB;N NB? #L;GB;LFC?L ;JJLIRCG;
NCIH CM ; >?HMCNS
/IG? JLIJ?LNC?M ;L? OM?@OF NI C>?HNC@S NB? L?ACIH CH NB? (
JF;H? @IL
QBC=B N a )
CM JIMCNCP? "IL N a )
NI <? JIMCNCP?
NB? JIFSHIGC;F W a )
;M ; @OH=NCIH I@ a
MO=B NB;N
W a )
L?G;CHM T?LI @IL MG;FF P;LC;NCIHM I@ a
<?=;OM? NBCM M?N QCFF >?WH? NB?
L?KO?MN?> <IOH>;LS 0BCM M?N CM >?N?LGCH?> <S NB? >?LCP;NCP? I@ QCNB
L?MJ?=N NI a
4L a
4L
a
'
0B? M?N I@ (
NB;N MIFP?M ;H> MCGOFN;H?IOMFS
;FMI =;FF?> NB?
2;C29<=2 I@ W a )
( SC?F>M ; J;L;G?NLC= L?JL?M?HN;NCIH I@ NB? <IOH>;LS QB?L?
W a )
CM T?LI @IL ; ACP?H a +H=? NBCM <IOH>;LS CM >?N?LGCH?>
CN L?G;CHM NI
WH> NB;N MO<L?ACIH >?FCGCN?> <S W a )
@IL ;FF a
/IFPCHA NB? MSMN?G ACP?H <S ;H> SC?F>M NB? ?RJL?MMCIH @IL NB?
ME?QH?MM ;H> NB? ?R=?MM EOLNIMCM ;M @OH=NCIHM I@ a
4L
a
a
(
K a
4L a
a
(
K a
QCNB K a
4L
a
4L a
4L a
/NL;CABN@ILQ;L> =IGJON;NCIHM
;FFIQ OM NI L?QLCN? NB? >?HIGCH;NIL I@ <INB ?RJL?MMCIHM ;M K a
a
a
a /CH=? CNM GCHCGOG CM ;NN;CH?> @IL a QB?L? K
Q? =IH=FO>?
NB;N K a
CM ;FQ;SM JIMCNCP?
0B? MCAH I@ a
=B;HA?M QCNB 4L a
a
%N CM JIMCNCP? @IL a
#
%N CM H?A;NCP? @IL a
/CGCF;LFS
NB?
+ MCAH
I@ Z+ a
=B;HA?M QCNB 4L
a
a
a %N CM JIMCNCP? @IL a #
;H> H?A;NCP? ?FM?QB?L?
0B?M? JLIJ?LNC?M ;L? MOGG;LCT?> CH "CAOL? 0B? ;ONBILCT?> >IG;CH
1.5
0.5
Skewness
-0.5
-1
-1.5
3 3.5 4 4.5 5 5.5 6 6.5 7
Kurtosis
%4.@.- %=>-.7= -2<=;2+>=287
0B? OM? I@ NB? /NO>?HN [ >CMNLC<ONCIH NI =;JNOL? NB? @;N N;CFM I@ WH;H=C;F L?
NOLHM AI?M <;=E NI IFF?LMF?P ;H> IFF?LMF?P ;H> 3IIF>LC>A?
%N CM
BIQ?P?L
; MSGG?NLC= >CMNLC<ONCIH
MI NB;N CN =;HHIN =;JNOL? ;MSGG?
NLS A?H?L;FCT;NCIH NB;N WFFM NBCM A;J B;M <??H JLIJIM?> <S $;HM?H
QCNB NB? MI=;FF?> ME?Q?> /NO>?HN [ >CMNLC<ONCIH $? ;=BC?P?M NBCM <S CHNLI
>O=CHA ; A?H?L;FCT;NCIH I@ NB? /NO>?HN [ >CMNLC<ONCIH QB?L? ;MSGG?NLC?M G;S
I==OL
QBCF? G;CHN;CHCHA NB? ;MMOGJNCIH I@ ; T?LI G?;H ;H> OHCN P;LC;H=? $?
;FMI CFFOMNL;N?M BIQ J;L;G?N?LM
;H> MO<M?KO?HNFS BCAB?L GIG?HNM
=;H <? L?H
>?L?> NCG? P;LSCHA "OLNB?L ?RN?HMCIHM I@ NBCM >CMNLC<ONCIH ;L? <S 0B?I>IMMCIO
;H> &IH>?;O ;H> .I=ECHA?L ;
< >?WHCN? ;>P;HN;A? I@
)I>?FCHA $CAB?L )IG?HNM
2<=;2+>=287
N a)(
I 8
(
QB?L?
Ia H
*
C@ a ) H*I(
Ia H
*
C@ a H*I'
0B? =IHMN;HN N?LGM H ;H> I ;L? >?WH?> ;M
H J (
I
H (
;H> ;L? CHNLI>O=?> NI I<N;CH ; P;LC;<F? F QCNB T?LI G?;H ;H> OHCN P;LC;H=?
QB?L? Q? >?HIN?
J 8 '
$?L?
>?HIN?M NB? >?AL??I@@L??>IG J;L;G?N?L ;H> NB? ;MSGG?NLS J;L;
G?N?L
MI NB;N NB? P?=NIL I@ MB;J? J;L;G?N?LM CM (
0B? >?HMCNS CM
>?WH?> @IL ) ) ;H>
) )
"OLNB?LGIL?
CN ?H=IGJ;MM?M ; F;LA?
M?N I@ =IHP?HNCIH;F >?HMCNC?M "IL CHMN;H=?
C@ ( $;HM?HZM >CMNLC<ONCIH CM
L?>O=?> NI NB? NL;>CNCIH;F /NO>?HN [ >CMNLC<ONCIH
QCNBION ;MSGG?NLS %@
CH
;>>CNCIH
( NB? /NO>?HN [ >CMNLC<ONCIH =IFF;JM?M NI NB? HILG;F >?HMCNS
"CAOL? CFFOMNL;N?M NB? =13 M NB;N =;H <? I<N;CH?> QCNB NB? ME?Q?> /NO
>?HN [ >CMNLC<ONCIH 1JJ?L FIQ?L WAOL?M L?JL?M?HN ME?Q?> [ >CMNLC<ONCIHM QCNB
F;LA? H?A;NCP? JIMCNCP? ;MSGG?NLS (?@NMC>? LCABNMC>? WAOL?M =ILL?MJIH>
NI >CMNLC<ONCIHM QCNB #;OMMC;H @;N N;CFM
M ;FL?;>S G?HNCIH?>
NB? G?;H I@ ;H ;MSGG?NLC= >CMNLC<ONCIH CM HIN NB? ;=NO;F
FI=;NCIH J;L;G?N?L
; JLI<F?G >CM=OMM?> <S *?Q?S ;H> /N?CA?LQ;F>
M >?M=LC<?> CH /?=NCIH
"?LHcH>?T ;H> /N??F ;FMI JLIJIM?> ; G?NBI>
NI G;E? ;HS MSGG?NLC= >?HMCNS ;MSGG?NLC= <S MIG? =B;HA? I@ P;LC;<F? 0B? FCHE
<?NQ??H NB?CL J;L;G?N?L OMCHA NB? HIN;NCIH I@ /?=NCIH ;H> NB? J;L;G?N?L
I@ $;HM?H CM MCGJFS ACP?H <S
0.4 0.4
0.3 0.3
0.2 0.2
0.1 0.1
0 0
-6 -4 -2 0 2 4 6 -6 -4 -2 0 2 4 6
0.5 0.5
0.4 0.4
0.3 0.3
0.2 0.2
0.1 0.1
0 0
-6 -4 -2 0 2 4 6 -6 -4 -2 0 2 4 6
20 $13 <3 A52 @82D21 'AB12;A I 16@A?6/BA6<; 3<? C.?6<B@ C.9B2@ <3 .;1
)II>
#L;S<CFF
;H> I?M
0B?L?@IL?
ACP?H NB? L?MNLC=NCIH +
NB?
ME?Q?> /NO>?HN [ >CMNLC<ONCIH CM Q?FF >?WH?> ;H> CNM M?=IH> GIG?HN ?RCMNM
0B? BCAB?L GIG?HNM =;H <? =IGJON?> ;M @IFFIQM (?N T 0 L <? NB? YNB GIG?HN
I@ NB? MN;H>;L> MSGG?NLC= /NO>?HN [ >CMNLC<ONCIH
.
L L (
L
T
0L _ [ _)
K_ 8 '
0B?H
NB? YNB GIG?HN I@ NB? CHHIP;NCIH F IF H I@ NB? ME?Q?> /NO>?HN
[ >CMNLC<ONCIH =;H <? =IGJON?> ;M
4 5
L L L L
9L 1 F
T
0 L
(
MI NB;N Q? B;P?
@LIG &IH>?;O ;H> .I=ECHA?L ;
0BCM ?RJL?MMCIH CM I<N;CH?> OMCHA NB? @IFFIQCHA L?MOFN I@ #L;>MBN?SH ;H> .STBCE
J
E
C
M E FM
;M
E F
C
& :
%H J;LNC=OF;L
Q? B;P? B
B
&
B
&
:
&
;H> B
)I>?FCHA $CAB?L )IG?HNM
9 J H(
9
I H (
9
J
C@ + (
9
C@ + '
3? I<M?LP? NB;N
QB?H ( F >I?M HIN B;P? T?LI G?;H ;H> OHCN P;LC;H=?
;HSGIL? 0BCM CM <?=;OM? NB? NL;HM@ILG;NCIH >IH? NI CHNLI>O=? ;MSGG?NLS
L?;FFI=;N?M JLI<;<CFCNS G;MM @LIG IH? MC>? I@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH NI NB? INB?L
)IG?HNM I@ NB? MN;H>;L>CT?> CHHIP;NCIHM
F F H
*I
;L? NB?H >?WH?>
L
;M L 1 F
QCNB
1 F (
B F
(
;H> ACP?H NB;N F B;M T?LI G?;H ;H> OHCN P;LC;H=?
9
H9 H
? F
(
I
9 H9
H 9 H
7 F '
I
"IL MIG? ;JJFC=;NCIHM
CN CM P?LS OM?@OF NI B;P? NB? 013 ;M Q?FF ;M CNM CHP?LM?
"IL CHMN;H=?
;M QCFF <? MBIQH CH B;JN?L
2;. =IGJON;NCIH L?KOCL?M NB?
?RJL?MMCIH I@ NB? CHP?LM? 013 I@ NB? ME?Q?> [ >CMNLC<ONCIH
<?=;OM? NB? 2;. CM
<;M?> IH NB? KO;HNCF? I@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH %N CM MBIQH CH &IH>?;O ;H> .I=ECHA?L
; NB;N NB? 013 CM >?WH?> <S
! 9
#
@ =T<
) C@ a ) H*I(
3 a
9
"
@ =T<
) C@ a H*I(
QB?L? @ _)
CM NB? 013 I@ NB? MN;H>;L> [ >CMNLC<ONCIH QCNB >?AL??M I@ @L??>IG
. R
^
@ _)
+
K^'
%N CM MNL;CABN@ILQ;L> NI MBIQ NB;N NB? CHP?LM? I@ NB? 013 I@ 3 CM QLCNN?H ;M
! 9
#
@ S ) H C@ ` ) (
=
3 `
9
"
@ S ) H C@ ` '
=
M CM Q?FFEHIQH
NB? CHP?LM? I@ NB? 013 ;FFIQM NB? MCGOF;NCIH I@ JM?O>I
L;H>IG P;LC;N?M %N MO^=?M NI A?H?L;N? ` A (
;H> NI =IGJON? a
3 `
' 0B?H
a QCFF <? >CMNLC<ON?> ;M 3'
CMNLC<ONCIHM QCNB BCAB?L GIG?HNM
86*27 8/ -.D72=287
0B? >?HMCNS ;H> NB? P;LCIOM GIG?HNM >I HIN ?RCMN @IL ;FF J;L;G?N?LM M
;FL?;>S G?HNCIH?>
NB? >?HMCNS CM >?WH?> IHFS @IL + ;H>
) )
"OLNB?LGIL?
=;L?@OF M=LONCHS I@ NB? ;FA?<L; SC?F>CHA MBIQM NB;N
ME?QH?MM ?RCMNM C@ + (;MN
EOLNIMCM CH CM Q?FF >?WH?> C@ + '
3? >?WH? ;M NB? >IG;CH (
(
(
#CP?H NB?M? L?MNLC=
NCIHM IH NB? OH>?LFSCHA J;L;G?N?LM
CN CM =F?;L NB;N NB? L;HA? I@ ME?QH?MM ;H>
EOLNIMCM QCFF ;FMI <? L?MNLC=N?> NI ; =?LN;CH >IG;CH %H "CAOL?
Q? NL;=?
P;LCIOM =OLP?M L?F;NCHA ME?QH?MM NI P;LSCHA <?NQ??H
;H>
@IL M?F?=N?>
P;FO?M I@ /CGCF;LFS
CH "CAOL?
Q? NL;=? P;LCIOM =OLP?M L?F;NCHA EOLNIMCM
NI P;LSCHA <?NQ??H '
;H> @IL M?F?=N?> P;FO?M I@
"I=OMCHA IH "CAOL?
Q? HINC=? NB;N
;M >?=L?;M?M
ME?QH?MM =;H ;NN;CH
P?LS F;LA? P;FO?M +H NB? INB?L B;H>
;M MBIQH <S "CAOL?
QB?H Q? CH=L?;M?
M;S ;LIOH>
NB? N;CFM I@ NB? >?HMCNS <?=IG? NBCHH?L
?P?H @IL ?RNL?G?
P;FO?M I@ NB? J;L;G?N?L 0BCM JC=NOL? CFFOMNL;N?M NB? @;=N NB;N
@IL ; ACP?H
F?P?F I@ EOLNIMCM
IHFS ; WHCN? L;HA? I@ ME?QH?MM ?RCMNM 0BCM @?;NOL? L;CM?M NB?
KO?MNCIH I@ ?RCMN?H=? I@ ; >?HMCNS @IL ACP?H GIG?HNM
"CAOL? >CMJF;SM NB? ME?QH?MMEOLNIMCM <IOH>;LS ?HMOLCHA NB? ?RCMN?H=?
I@ ; >?HMCNS 0B? =OLP? =ILL?MJIH>M NI NB? NB?IL?NC=;F >IG;CH I@ G;RCG;F
MCT? ACP?H <S CH?KO;FCNS 0B? =OLP? !" =ILL?MJIH>M NI NB? >IG;CH I@
ME?QH?MM ;H> EOLNIMCM
QBC=B CM ;NN;CH;<F? QCNB ; ME?Q?> /NO>?HN [ >CMNLC<O
NCIH
;MMOGCHA + 3? HINC=? NB;N NB? EOLNIMCM CM <IOH>?> @LIG <?FIQ <S
4
ν=4
ν=5
3
ν=8
1
Skewness
-1
-2
-3
-4
-1 -0.5 0 0.5 1
λ
100
λ=0.0
90 λ=0.5
λ=1.0
80
70
60
Kurtosis
50
40
30
20
10
0
4 4.5 5 5.5 6 6.5 7 7.5 8
ν
CH>C=;NCHA NB;N NB? ME?Q?> /NO>?HN [ >CMNLC<ONCIH >I?M HIN ;FFIQ N;CFM NI <?
NBCHH?L NB;H NBIM? I@ NB? HILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH
0B? >IG;CH >?HIN?> =ILL?MJIH>CHA NI !" CH "CAOL? CM MJ;HH?>
<S ME?QH?MM ;H> EOLNIMCM C@ <INB GIG?HNM ?RCMN 3? HINC=? NB;N NB? L?F;NCIH
<?NQ??H ;H> CM HIN IH?NIIH? %H J;LNC=OF;L
NBIM? JICHNM NB;N ;L? FI=;N?>
CH <ON QB?L? ) B;P? HI =IOHN?LJ;LN CH 0B? FIAC= CM NB;N NB?L? ;L?
JICHNM CH QB?L? ME?QH?MM IL EOLNIMCM =?;M? NI ?RCMN
QB?L?;M CH ME?QH?MM
;H> EOLNIMCM ;L? WHCN? <S =IHMNLO=NCIH %N CM IHFS QB?H Q? L?>O=? NB? >IG;CH
NI (
(
NB;N NB? L?F;NCIH CM <CD?=NCP?
5=.;7*=2?. <9.,2D,*=287<
@N?L NB? CHCNC;F >?M=LCJNCIH I@ NB? ME?Q?> /NO>?HN [ >CMNLC<ONCIH <S $;HM?H
M?P?L;F ;FN?LH;NCP? MJ?=CW=;NCIHM @IL ;H ;MSGG?NLC= /NO>?HN [ >CMNLC
<ONCIHM B;P? <??H JLIJIM?> /IG? I@ NB?M? MJ?=CW=;NCIHM =;H <? PC?Q?> ;M
J;LNC=OF;L =;M?M I@ NB? A?H?L;F ;JJLI;=B?M JL?M?HN?> CH NB? H?RN M?=NCIH NI
A?H?L;N? ME?QH?MM @LIG ; MSGG?NLC= >CMNLC<ONCIH
"?LHcH>?T ;H> /N??F B;P? MJ?=C;FCT?> NB?CL A?H?L;F ;JJLI;=B NI
A?H?L;N? ;MSGG?NLC= >CMNLC<ONCIHM <;M?> IH BC>>?H NLOH=;NCIH NI NB? =;M?
I@ NB? /NO>?HN [ >CMNLC<ONCIH
a
N a )(
[ a)
a
[ )
a
'
CMNLC<ONCIHM QCNB BCAB?L GIG?HNM
6
Maxim um boundary A
Skew ed Student t
4
D
2
Skewness
-2
F
-4
C
-6
0 5 10 15 20 25 30
Kurtos is
%N =;H <? ?;MCFS M??H NB;N NBCM >CMNLC<ONCIH CM >CL?=NFS L?F;N?> NI NB? IH? JLI
JIM?> <S $;HM?H NBLIOAB ; G?L? =B;HA? I@ HIN;NCIH I@ NB? ;MSGG?NLS
J;L;G?N?L (;G<?LN ;H> (;OL?HN B;P? ;FMI ?RN?H>?> NBCM ;JJLI;=B NI
NB? =;M? I@ NB? ME?Q?> MN;<F? >CMNLC<ONCIH ;H>
GIL? A?H?L;FFS
NI NB? =;M?
I@ NB? ME?Q?> FI=;NCIHM=;F? >CMNLC<ONCIHM *INC=? NB;N NB? A?H?L;F ;JJLI;=B
I@ A?H?L;NCHA ;MSGG?NLC= >CMNLC<ONCIH QCFF <? OM?> CH /?=NCIH NI >?WH?
GOFNCP;LC;N? ME?Q?> >CMNLC<ONCIHM
TT;FCHC ;H> ;JCN;HCI B;P? JLIJIM?> ;HINB?L ;JJLI;=B NI A?H?L;N?
MIG? ;MSGG?NLS CH GOFNCP;LC;N? >CMNLC<ONCIHM %H NB? =;M? I@ NB? OHCP;LC;N?
/NO>?HN [ >CMNLC<ONCIH
NB?S JLIJIM? NB? OM? I@
:
N a)(
[ a)
@ a )
(
a
QB?L? @ a)
CM NB? 013 I@ NB? /NO>?HN [ >CMNLC<ONCIH QCNB >?AL??M I@ @L??>IG
3B?H
N a
L?>O=?M NI NB? MN;H>;L> /NO>?HN [ >CMNLC<ONCIH 3B?H
Q? I<N;CH ; /NO>?HN [ >CMNLC<ONCIH NLOH=;N?> @LIG ;<IP? <?FIQ ;N
T?LI ,;L;G?N?L JF;SM NB?L?@IL? NB? LIF? I@ MB;J? J;L;G?N?L
&IH?M ;H> ";>>S B;P? =IHMNLO=N?> NB? @IFFIQCHA >CMNLC<ONCIH
)I>?FCHA $CAB?L )IG?HNM
a
N a)
(
+
8
.
(
a
a
8 (
a
QB?L? .
(
>?HIN?M NB? <?N; @OH=NCIH "IL
NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH L?>O=?M
NI NB? MN;H>;L> /NO>?HN [ >CMNLC<ONCIH 3B?H H ) L?MJ
+
N CM
H?A;NCP?FS L?MJ JIMCNCP?FS ME?Q?>
HINB?L ;FN?LH;NCP? MJ?=CW=;NCIH B;M <??H JLIJIM?> <S $;LP?S ;H> /C>
>CKO? 0B?CL MI=;FF?> HIH=?HNL;F /NO>?HN [ >CMNLC<ONCIH ;FFIQM IH? NI
GI>?F ME?QH?MM <ON >I?M HIN ;FFIQ @IL ;H CH>?J?H>?HN P;LC;NCIH I@ ME?QH?MM
;H> EOLNIMCM 0B? HIH=?HNL;F /NO>?HN [ >CMNLC<ONCIH CM >?WH?> <S NQI J;L;G?
N?LM NB? >?AL??I@@L??>IG J;L;G?N?L ;H> NB? HIH=?HNL;FCNS J;L;G?N?L
0BCM >CMNLC<ONCIH CM M=;F?> NI B;P? ; OHCN P;LC;H=?
QBCF? NB? HIH=?HNL;FCNS
J;L;G?N?L =IHNLIFM NB? MB;J? I@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH 0B? HIH=?HNL;F /NO>?HN [
>CMNLC<ONCIH CM >?WH?> ;M
"/*
,
D
P
a
N a )(
+
'
a
D
P a
/CH=? IH? I@ NB? J;L;G?N?LM CM H??>?> NI =IHNLIF NB? =?HNL;FCNS I@ NB? >CMNLC
<ONCIH
CN CM =F?;L NB;N NBCM >?HMCNS CM GIL? L?MNLC=NCP? ;M @;L ;M ME?QH?MM ;H>
EOLNIMCM ;L? =IH=?LH?>
.7.;*=270 *<B66.=;2, -2<=;2+>=287<
2--.7 =;>7,*=287
NLOH=;N?> @LIG ;<IP? <?FIQ ;N T?LI 0B? J;L;G?N?L JF;SM NB?L?@IL? NB?
LIF? I@ MB;J? ME?QH?MM J;L;G?N?L
>C^=OFNS QCNB NBCM ;JJLI;=B CM NB;N GIG?HNM ;L? B;L> NI =IGJON? @IL
A?H?L;F >CMNLC<ONCIHM M %H NB? =;M? I@ NB? /NO>?HN [ >CMNLC<ONCIH
Q? I<N;CH
0B?H
;M MBIQH <S TT;FCHC ;H> ;JCN;HCI
NB? WLMN GIG?HNM
;L?
1 F +
(
B F +
(
0
? F +
(
0 F
7 +
(
8
QB?L? *
'
/N;H>;L>CT?> ME?QH?MM ;H> EOLNIMCM ;L? >?WH?> CH NB? OMO;F Q;S <S NB?
?RJL?MMCIHM ? F ?0 F *
;H> 7 F 7 0 F * *IN? NB;N Q? B;P?
1 F ? F QB?H )IL?IP?L 1 F ) 1 F ) ;H> ? F )
? F ) ' 0BCM MBIQM NB;N NB? J;L;G?N?L >CL?=NFS =IHNLIFM NB? ;MSGG?NLS
I@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH
0B? ?RJL?MMCIHM ;<IP? =F?;LFS CH>C=;N? NB;N F >I?M HIN B;P? T?LI G?;H
;H> OHCN P;LC;H=? ;HSGIL? 0B? L?;MIH CM NB;N NB? NL;HM@ILG;NCIH >IH? NI
CHNLI>O=? ;MSGG?NLS L?;FFI=;N?M MIG? JLI<;<CFCNS G;MM @LIG IH? MC>? I@ NB?
>CMNLC<ONCIH NI NB? INB?L )IL? JL?=CM?FS
HIHMN;H>;L>CT?> CHHIP;NCIHM F B;P?
G?;H H ;H> P;LC;H=? I %@ Q? HIQ >?WH? NB? MN;H>;L>CT?> CHHIP;NCIH F
F H
*I
Q? I<N;CH 1 F
B F
? F ? F ;H> 7 F
7 F 0B? H?Q CHHIP;NCIH F B;M NB? M;G? ME?QH?MM ;H> EOLNIMCM ;M F'
O J M
J M
QB?L?
J CM NB? L?;FCT;NCIH I@ ; ?LHIOCFFC JLI=?MM QCNB JLI<;<CFCNS I@ MO==?MM
;H> M CM NB? L?;FCT;NCIH I@ ; JLI=?MM QCNB >CMNLC<ONCIH =
)I>?FCHA $CAB?L )IG?HNM
MDBIT
N a )
M a
a
M a
a
M
a
(
+ F
'
+ F )
$?H=?
J;L;G?N?L JLIPC>?M ;H CHN?L?MNCHA CH>C=;NIL I@ NB? ;MSGG?NLS CH NB?
>CMNLC<ONCIH 0B? >CMNLC<ONCIH N a )
*
CM NB? MSGG?NLC= I@ N a )
QCNB L?
MJ?=N NI NB? GI>?
QCNB N a )
N a )
*
0B?L?@IL?
CHP?LNCHA JLI>O=?M
NB? GCLLIL CG;A? ;LIOH> T?LI
)IG?HNM I@ NB? ;MSGG?NLC= >CMNLC<ONCIH N a )
;L? ?;MCFS >?>O=?> @LIG
NBIM? I@ NB? MSGG?NLC= IH? M a
%@ NB? YNB GIG?HN I@ ; LP QCNB >CMNLC<ONCIH
M '
?RCMNM
NB?H NB? ;MMI=C;N?> L;H>IG P;LC;<F? F QCNB >CMNLC<ONCIH N '
;FMI
B;M ; WHCN? YNB GIG?HN
>?WH?> ;M
(
L (
9L T
0L (
QB?L? .
L
T
0 L 1 F )F + \L M \
K\
T
0
T0
T 0 T
0 T 0 T 0
(
0 T
0
7 F 9 9 9
9 9 9 '
B F
? F ? F
;H> 7 F 7 F
CMNLC<ONCIHM QCNB BCAB?L GIG?HNM
".*;<87 ( -2<=;2+>=287
,L?G;L;NH? ;H> ?L; ;H> LdHHdM ;H> *IL>G;H B;P? JLIJIM?>
NB? ,?;LMIH NSJ? %2 >CMNLC<ONCIH NI GI>?F NB? >SH;GC= I@ ;MM?N L?NOLHM 0B?
G;CH CHN?L?MN I@ NBCM >CMNLC<ONCIH CM NB;N NB? NBL?? J;L;G?N?LM =;H <? CHN?L
JL?N?> ;M NB? P;LC;H=?
ME?QH?MM
;H> EOLNIMCM I@ NB? JLI=?MM
MI NB;N CN CM
JIMMC<F? NI >CL?=NFS GI>?F NB?M? GIG?HNM C@ L?KOCL?>
2<=;2+>=287
K &)# N a )
a
(
Ka I I a I a
QB?L?
I
I
;H> I ;L? J;L;G?N?LM NI <? ?MNCG;N?> %HMC>? NBCM ALIOJ
;M
MOGCHA MIG? MJ?=CW= P;FO?M I@ NB? J;L;G?N?LM
Q? I<N;CH NB? HILG;F
A;GG;
/NO>?HN [
IL ,;L?NI >CMNLC<ONCIHM %H NB? A?H?L;F =;M? QB?L? I ;H> I (
;H> QB?L? NB? LIINM I@ I I a I a ;L? CG;ACH;LS
M;S I PH ;H> I PH
QB?L?
T
* I
(
I
* HI
(
;H> .
JH !),L "
"/* "
K"
CM NB? CHN?AL;NCIH =IHMN;HN NB;N ?HMOL?M NB;N NB? >?HMCNS CHN?AL;N?M NI IH? 3?
;FMI >?WH? Y T
0B? P?=NIL I@ MB;J? J;L;G?N?LM CM NBOM H( Y(
0BCM >CMNLC<ONCIH CM EHIQH ;M NB? ,?;LMIH %2 >CMNLC<ONCIH %N CM I@ J;LNC=OF;L
CHN?L?MN <?=;OM? CN ;FFIQM @IL <INB ;MSGG?NLS ;H> @;N N;CFM %N B;M <??H FCNNF?
OM?> CH ?GJCLC=;F MNO>C?M
BIQ?P?L
G;CHFS <?=;OM? CNM ?MNCG;NCIH L;CM?M MIG?
N?=BHC=;F JLI<F?GM
86*27 8/ -.D72=287
3? HIN? NB;N F >I?M HIN B;P? T?LI G?;H ;H> OHCN P;LC;H=?
<?=;OM? Q? B;P?
NB? @IFFIQCHA GIG?HNM M?? '?H>;FF ;H> /NO;LN
,L?G;L;NH? ;H> ?L;
)I>?FCHA $CAB?L )IG?HNM
H
1 F Y +
(
Y
H
B F Y Y +
(
Y
Y
0 H
Y
? F
Y +
(
Y Y
Y
0 H Y Y
Y Y
7 F Y +
(
Y Y
Y
Y
<=26*=287 2<<>.
(?N OM =IHMC>?L HIQ NB? CMMO? I@ ?MNCG;NCHA NBCM GI>?F CH ; NCG?M?LC?M =IHN?RN
%N MBIOF> <? HIN?> NB;N
MCH=? NB? CHHIP;NCIH FN >I?M HIN B;P? T?LI G?;H
NB?
=IH>CNCIH;F G?;H I@ NB? L?NOLH JLI=?MM DN N
N
FN CM ACP?H <S
H
1 DN )N N
N
'
Y
"IL MSGG?NLC= OHCGI>;F >CMNLC<ONCIHM
G?;H
G?>C;H
;H> GI>? =ICH=C>?
;H>
NB?L?@IL? =ILL?=N MJ?=CW=;NCIH I@ NB? =IH>CNCIH;F G?;H CM MO^=C?HN NI ?HMOL?
=IHMCMN?HN ?MNCG;N?M I@ NB? =IH>CNCIH;F G?;H J;L;G?N?LM "IL ;MSGG?NLC= >CM
NLC<ONCIHM
NB? G?;H ;H> P;LC;H=? G;S HIN <? CNM H;NOL;F FI=;NCIH ;H> M=;F?
CMNLC<ONCIHM QCNB BCAB?L GIG?HNM
6
Maxim um boundary A
Pears on IV
4
2
Skewness
-2
-4
C
-6
0 5 10 15 20 25 30
Kurtos is
%H NBCM =;M?
Q? B;P?
H
1 FN
' 0
Y
IHM?KO?HNFS
NB? =IH>CNCIH;F G?;H I@ NB? L?NOLH JLI=?MM DN <?=IG?M
H
1 DN )N N
N
0 '
Y
3CNB NBCM MJ?=CW=;NCIH
;M MBIQH <S *?Q?S ;H> /N?CA?LQ;F>
NB? =IH
MCMN?H=S I@ NB? -)( ?MNCG;NIL CM ?HMOL?> "CH;FFS
NB? FIAFCE?FCBII> ;N NCG?
[ NI <? G;RCGCT?> CM ACP?H <S
_N N
N
0
GN !
&)# N
&)# N ) (
N
QCNB !
(
(
0 NB? P?=NIL I@ OHEHIQH J;L;G?N?LM
)I>?FCHA $CAB?L )IG?HNM
7=;89B -2<=;2+>=287
)?NBI>M <;M?> IH NB? ?HNLIJS JLCH=CJF? I@ /B;HHIH
;H> JIJOF;LCT?>
<S &;SH?M
B;P? G;>? NB?CL Q;S CHNI ?=IHIG?NLC=M
?A
#IF;H
&O>A?
;H> )CFF?L N ; JL;=NC=;F F?P?F
?HNLIJS<;M?> ;JJFC=;NCIHM MNCFF
;JJ?;L NI <? M=;L=? <ON @IL ; @?Q ?R=?JNCIHM MO=B ;M 6?FFH?L ;H> $CABW?F>
/NONT?L
O=B?H ;H> '?FFS
IL +LGIH?CN ;H> 3BCN?
0B? >C^=OFNC?M QCNB NB? HOG?LC=;F CGJF?G?HN;NCIH I@ NBCM N?=BHCKO?
G;S B;P? BCH>?L?> CNM QC>?MJL?;> OM? 5?N
.I=ECHA?L ;H> &IH>?;O
<;M?> IH AGIH
FB;MMC>
;H> (?PCH? ;
<
B;P? MBIQH NB;N CN
CM JIMMC<F? NI >?P?FIJ ; P?LS L;JC> G?NBI> NI I<N;CH ?HNLIJS >?HMCNC?M ;H>
NB;N ?HNLIJS >?HMCNC?M G;S ;FMI <? OM?> CH L;NB?L =IGJF?R ?GJCLC=;F FCE?FCBII>
?MNCG;NCIHM %N CM QILNB ?GJB;MCTCHA NB;N NBCM ;JJLI;=B ;FFIQM IH? NI ?MNCG;N?
>CMNLC<ONCIHM QCNB NB? F;LA?MN >IG;CH I@ >?WHCNCIH JIMMC<F? =IGJ;NC<F? QCNB
NB? <IOH> @IOH> CH "CAOL?
2<=;2+>=287
3? ;MMOG? NB;N NB? ?=IHIG?NLC=C;H CM M??ECHA ; JLI<;<CFCNS W a
>?WH?> IP?L
MIG? L?;F =IHP?R >IG;CH
QBCF? >CMJIMCHA IHFS I@ CH@ILG;NCIH IH NB? T
WLMN GIG?HNM I@ NB? JLI<;<CFCNS
QLCNN?H ;M D QB?L? P
( ( T 0B? =IH
MNLO=NCIH I@ ; JLI<;<CFCNS >?HMCNS >?WH?> IH CHWHCN?FS G;HS JICHNM QCNB NB?
EHIQF?>A? I@ IHFS ; @?Q GIG?HNM CM BIJ?F?MM QCNBION ;H ;>>CNCIH;F =LCN?LCIH
WLMN JIMMC<CFCNS NI I<N;CH ; >?HMCNS
G;N=BCHA NB? ACP?H GIG?HNM
CM NI OM? .1
5<0 MN?J @OH=NCIHM /O=B ;H ;JJLI;=B CM CGJF?G?HN?> <S 3B??F?L ;H> #IL>IH
HINB?L =LCN?LCIH CM ACP?H <S NB? G;RCGCT;NCIH I@ ;H ?HNLIJS OH>?L
NB? GIG?HN ;H> >?HMCNS L?MNLC=NCIHM 1H>?L NBCM =LCN?LCIH
IH? MIFP?M
.
W +# ' / W a
&)# W a
Ka(
J T
.
MN W a
Ka
(
.T
a D W a
Ka D ( P
( ( T'
T
Ka W a
Ka
H
,
.
D a D W a
Ka D (
D
#CP?H NB;N ; FIA@OH=NCIH CM CHPIFP?> CH
EO
O
CMNLC<ONCIHM QCNB BCAB?L GIG?HNM
NB?H Q? I<N;CH NB? OHC@ILG >CMNLC<ONCIH IP?L M Q? ;>> NB? WLMN ;H> M?=IH>
GIG?HNM
#IF;H
&O>A?
;H> )CFF?L L?=;FF NB;N Q? I<N;CH NB? ?RJIH?H
NC;F ;H> NB? HILG;F >?HMCNS 0B? EHIQF?>A? I@ NB? NBCL> IL BCAB?L GIG?HN
>I?M HIN SC?F> ; >?HMCNS CH =FIM?> @ILG +HFS HOG?LC=;F MIFONCIHM G;S JLIPC>?
>?HMCNC?M 3? @I=OM HIQ IH BIQ >?HMCNC?M G;S <? I<N;CH?> CH ; HOG?LC=;FFS
?^=C?HN G;HH?L C@ NBCL> ;H> BCAB?L GIG?HNM ;L? ACP?H /IG? L?MOFNM =;H <?
@IOH> CH 6?FFH?L ;H> $CABW?F> ;H> +LGIH?CN ;H> 3BCN?
QBCF?
.I=ECHA?L ;H> &IH>?;O >?M=LC<? ; GIL? ?^=C?HN ?MNCG;NCIH N?=BHCKO?
<=26*=287
MI NB;N H
,
D
W a
"/* D a *< ( ( H
'
D
IH? =IOF> ?P;FO;N? ;H>
NBOM
NB? GIG?HN L?MNLC=NCIHM 0BCM L?MOFN MOAA?MNM ;M ; WLMN ?MNCG;NCIH N?=B
HCKO? HIHFCH?;L F?;MN MKO;L?M ;JJFC?> NI /O=B ;H ?MNCG;NCIH SC?F>M
GOFNCJF? MIFONCIHM ;H> CM L;NB?L MFIQ M @IOH> <S AGIH
FB;MMC>
;H>
(?PCH? ;
<
; @;MN?L ;H> HOG?LC=;FFS MN;<F? JLI=?>OL? CM ;P;CF;<F?
0BCM JLI=?>OL? OM?M NB? JBSMC=;F JLIJ?LNC?M I@ NB? ?HNLIJS >?WHCNCIH %H IL>?L
NI OM? NBCM+ JLI=?>OL?
CN CM =IHP?HC?HN NI CHNLI>O=? MIG? @OLNB?L L?MOFNM
/CH=? W a
Ka
GOFNCJFC=;NCIH I@ NB? LCABNB;H> MC>? I@ <S NBCM
CHN?AL;F ;H> NB? ALIOJCHA OH>?L IH? MCHAF? CHN?AL;F SC?F>M
0B? N?=BHCKO? >?P?FIJ?> <S +LGIH?CN ;H> 3BCN? @IFFIQM NBCM ;JJLI;=B
0B?S MBIQ BIQ MO=B ;H ;FAILCNBG G;S <? CGJF?G?HN?> GIL? ?^=C?HNFS ;M CH
6?FFH?L ;H> $CABW?F>
S?N
NB?S L?JILN ?MNCG;NCIHM F;MNCHA M?P?L;F M?=IH>M
QB?L?;M NB? IH?M I@ .I=ECHA?L ;H> &IH>?;O N;E? ; @L;=NCIH I@ ; M?=IH>
)I>?FCHA $CAB?L )IG?HNM
.
a D D
W a
Ka ( P
( ( T'
)H
"OLNB?LGIL?
)H QLCNCHA W a
"/* D D a D D
QB?L?
D D D CH>C=;N?M NB;N NB? HOG<?L I@ =IGJON;NCIHM L?KOCL?> NI ?P;FO;N?
MO<D?=N NI G;S <? L?>O=?> FMI
NB? J;MM;A? @LIG
NI CM ;
NLCPC;F FCH?;L NL;HM@ILG;NCIH A;CH
W a
GOMN M;NCM@S
;H> NBCM SC?F>M
; >?WHCNCIH @IL
. H
,
D
= ( ( H
"/*
"/* D a D
Ka(
D
N NBCM JICHN
Q? B;P? I<N;CH?> NQI ?KOCP;F?HN >?WHCNCIHM @IL NB? >?HMCNS
;H>
NB?L?@IL?
NB? T?LIM I@ NB? AL;>C?HN I@ = SC?F> NB? WLMNIL>?L =IH>CNCIHM
0BCM =IGJON;NCIH P;FC>;N?M NB? =F;CG NB;N = >?WH?M ; JIN?HNC;F *?RN
Q?
I<N;CH NB;N .
, =
3DE a D D
a E E
W a
Ka(
,D ,E
MBIQCHA NB;N NB? $?MMC;H G;NLCR CM ; P;LC;H=?=IP;LC;H=? G;NLCR M ; =IHM?
KO?H=?
NB? $?MMC;H G;NLCR CM MSGG?NLC= ;H> JIMCNCP? >?WHCN? H CHP?LM? I@
NB? $?MMC;H QCFF ?RCMN C@ NB? G;NLCR CM I@ @OFF L;HE 0BCM F;MN =IH>CNCIH CGJFC?M
NB;N
;M FIHA ;M W a
CM ; >?HMCNS
NB? GCHCGCT;NCIH I@ = B;M ; OHCKO? MIFONCIH
3? QLCN? NB? AL;>C?HN I@ = ;M N ;H> CNM $?MMC;H G;NLCR ;M 3
N NBCM MN;A?
Q? B;P? I<N;CH?> NB? WLMN E?S L?MOFN
H;G?FS NB;N NB? GCH
CGCT;NCIH I@ NB? JIN?HNC;F @OH=NCIH = QCFF SC?F> ; MIFONCIH 0BCM MIFONCIH
CH
NOLH
QCFF >?WH? ;H ?HNLIJS >CMNLC<ONCIH 3? CHMCMN IH NB? @;=N NB;N NB? E?S
MN?J NI I<N;CH ; MIFONCIH L?MC>?M CH ; GCHCGCT;NCIH L;NB?L NB;H CH ; M?;L=B
@IL ; T?LI I@ ; G;J %N NOLHM ION NB;N
HOG?LC=;FFS
NB? GCHCGCT;NCIH CM Q?FF
>?WH?>
QB?L?;M NB? M?;L=B @IL ; T?LI G;S ?P?H SC?F> GOFNCJF? MIFONCIHM 0B?
JLI<F?G CM HOG?LC=;FFS MN;<F? C@ = CM I@ @OFF L;HE ;H> C@ NB? MIFONCIH CM WHCN?
%@ 3 CM ;H IJ?H MO<M?N I@
; G;J = @LIG 3 CHNI CM =;FF?> ; C20A<? H291
"IL CHMN;H=?
C@ ' CM ; M=;F;L @OH=NCIH @LIG 3 CHNI
NB?H = AL;> ' >?WH?M
; P?=NIL W?F> %@ @IL ; ACP?H P?=NIL W?F> = NB?L? ?RCMNM ; M=;F;L @OH=NCIH ' MO=B
NB;N = AL;> '
NB?H ' CM ; =<A2;A6.9 3B;0A6<; ;H> NB? P?=NIL W?F> = CM M;C> NI
>?LCP? @LIG ; JIN?HNC;F
CMNLC<ONCIHM QCNB BCAB?L GIG?HNM
M AGIH
FB;MMC>
;H> (?PCH? ; JICHN ION
CN CM HIN AO;L;HN??>
NB;N NB? GCHCGCT;NCIH I@ NB? JIN?HNC;F @OH=NCIH QCFF I==OL ;N WHCN? >CMN;H=?
%N CM JIMMC<F? NI AO;L;HN?? WHCN?H?MM I@ NB? MIFONCIH
<ON NI >I MI CN CM WLMN
H?=?MM;LS NI >?WH? BIQ NI =IGJON? NB? CHN?AL;FM CHPIFP?> 3? NOLH NI NBCM CMMO?
HIQ
;H> Q? MBIQ BIQ NB? ?RCMN?H=? I@ ; WHCN? MIFONCIH =;H <? AO;L;HN??>
0B? >CM=L?NCT;NCIH I@ NB? JIN?HNC;F ;H> NB? =IHMNL;CHNM ;H>
=;H <? I<N;CH?> <S ; #;OMM(?A?H>L? ;JJLIRCG;NCIH M??
@IL CHMN;H=?
;PCM
;H> ,IFIHMES
NB;N SC?F>M
I
H
, ,
D
=
"/* D _E D
^E (
E D
I
,
^E WE
(
E
I
,
^E aED WE D ( P
( ( T(
E
WE ( Q
( ( U(
QB?L? ^ ^ ( ( ^I
MN?JM *IQ
C@ ; MIFONCIH ?RCMNM
NB?H CN CM EHIQH NB;N = QCFF <? GCHCGCT?> @IL
MIG? WHCN? MIFONCIH 0B? JLI<F?G NBOM =IHMCMNM CH HOG?LC=;FFS GCHCGCTCHA
=
M JICHN?> ION <S "F?N=B?L
G;HS ;FAILCNBGM ;L? ;P;CF;<F? %@
NB? JLI<F?G CM EHIQH NI B;P? ; MCHAF? GCHCGOG
*?QNIHZM G?NBI> QILEM Q?FF
3? G;S MN;LN QCNB ;H CHCNC;F P;FO? ( (
NB? P?=NIL QCNB T T?LIM
N MN?J R
Q? OJ>;N? NB? P?=NIL ;M
F F F (
QB?L? F CM MIFONCIH NI 3F F N F 0BCM F;NN?L =IH>CNCIH AO;L;HN??M
NB;N NB? RNB ;JJLIRCG;NCIH CH ; M?=IH>IL>?L 0;SFIL ?RJ;HMCIH I@ =
NB;N CM
= F F
= F
F N F F 3F F
F?;>M NI ; I.A MJIN
I@ =
QBC=B CM ;H ?RNL?GOG
86*27 8/ -.D72=287
3? @I=OM HIQ
QCNBION FIMM I@ A?H?L;FCNS
IH NB? MNO>S I@ NB? >?HMCNC?M I@ ;
MN;H>;L>CT?> P;LC;<F? F NB;N M;NCM@S
Z( ;H> %H
)I>?FCHA $CAB?L )IG?HNM
0.9
s=0.1,κ =2
0.8 s=0.4,κ =2
s=0.7,κ =2
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
-6 -4 -2 0 2 4 6
NBCM =;M?
NB? J;L;G?N?LM Z ;H> L?JL?M?HN ME?QH?MM ;H> EOLNIMCM
L?MJ?=NCP?FS
MIFONCIH NI NB? GCHCGCT;NCIH I@ NB? JIN?HNC;F MO<D?=N NI =IHMNL;CHNM
] CM AO;L;HN??> IHFS C@ J;L;G?N?LM Z ;H> ;L? CH NB? >IG;CH I@
>?WHCNCIH 3? G;S >?N?LGCH? HOG?LC=;FFS NB? >IG;CH I@ >?WHCNCIH @IL NB?
?HNLIJS >CMNLC<ONCIH 0BCM G;S <? >IH?
@IL CHMN;H=?
OMCHA ; ALC>M?;L=B IP?L
; F;LA? ME?QH?MMEOLNIMCM >IG;CH QB?L? ; MIFONCIH NI NB? MCGJF?R ;FAILCNBG
GCABN ?RCMN ICHA MI
Q? P?LC@S HOG?LC=;FFS NB;N NB? <IOH>;LS @IL NB? ?HNLIJS
>CMNLC<ONCIH CH @;=N =ILL?MJIH>M NI NB? G;RCGOG <IOH>;LS
)
*?RN
Q? =IHMC>?L BIQ NB? ?HNLIJS >?HMCNS <?B;P?M ;M ME?QH?MM
Z
;H>
EOLNIMCM
P;LS H CHMJ?=NCIH I@ "CAOL?M ;H> L?P?;FM ; LC=B J;NN?LH
I@ JIMMC<F? >?HMCNC?M "IL >?HMCNC?M QCNB MG;FF EOLNIMCM
NB? JLI<;<CFCNS G;MM
CM MKO??T?> NIQ;L>M NB? =?HN?L %HNLI>O=NCIH I@ ME?QH?MM NB?H F?;>M NI GOFNC
GI>;F >?HMCNC?M "IL >?HMCNC?M QCNB F;LA? EOLNIMCM ;H> ME?QH?MM
ACP?H NB?
;MMOG?> WHCN?H?MM I@ NB? <IOH>;LS
; MG;FF BOGJ CH NB? N;CF I@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH
QCFF ;==IGGI>;N? NB? ME?QH?MM 3? I<N;CH NB;N ?HNLIJS >?HMCNC?M G;S <? I@
OM? QB?H NB? N;CFM I@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIHM ;L? GO=B NBCHH?L NB;H NB? N;CFM I@ NB?
HILG;F >?HMCNS %HP?LM?FS
G;S <?=IG? P?LS F;LA? ;FFIQCHA @IL @;N N;CFM
/J?=CW=;NCIH N?MNM ;H> CH@?L?H=?
1
s=2,κ=6
0.9 s=2,κ=8
s=2,κ=10
0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
-6 -4 -2 0 2 4 6
20
;A?<=F 16@A?6/BA6<;@ 3<? C.?6<B@ 92C29@ <3 8B?A<@6@
Y
)4
NB? PNB L?MNLC=NCIH CM >?WH?> ;M YD
4 N TD aN (
0B? ?GJCLC=;F =IOH
GIG?HN 3? HIN? T E T E a ( T E a4 (
0B? =IP;LC;H=? G;NLCR G;S <? ?MNCG;N?> OMCHA NB? >?LCP;NCP?M I@ NB?
FIAFCE?FCBII> @OH=NCIH
9
9 9
0 0
0
0
9 (
@
NE
NE NB? @( 6
G;NLCR =IHN;CHCHA NB? ?GJCLC=;F GIG?HN =IH>C
QCNB 9 T
NCIHM
T a ( T
* a (
9 T T* '
T
a4 ( T * a4 (
QB?L? NB? [( Q
NB ?F?G?HN KNE CM NB? >?LCP;NCP? I@ NB? FIAFCE?FCBII> ;N >;N? [
QCNB L?MJ?=N NI NB? QNB J;L;G?N?L E
,GN
KNE KNE '
,E
0B? IHFS L?G;CHCHA CMMO? HIQ CM NI >?N?LGCH? NB? ;JJLIJLC;N? @ILG I@ NB?
MN;H>;L>CT?> L?MC>O;F NB;N MBIOF> <? M?F?=N?> ;M NB? <;MCM @IL NB? N?MN 1H>?L
NB? =ILL?=N GI>?F MJ?=CW=;NCIH
MN;H>;L>CT?> L?MC>O;FM MBIOF> <? 661 QCNB NB?
JIMNOF;N?> >CMNLC<ONCIH ;M =IH>CNCIH;F >CMNLC<ONCIH /CH=? Q? =IHMC>?L MN;H
>;L>CT?> L?MC>O;FM
NB?S MBIOF> B;P? T?LI G?;H ;H> OHCN P;LC;H=?
L?MOFNCHA CH
NB? @IFFIQCHA ILNBIAIH;FCNS =IH>CNCIHM @IL NB? WLMN ;H> NB? M?=IH> GIG?HNM
1 aN (
1 aN
'
1 aN aNE Q
( ( (
1 aN
aNE
(
1 aN
aNE (
1 aN
aNE
'
0B?M? GIG?HN =IH>CNCIHM NL;HMF;N? CHNI NB? L?MNLC=NCIHM NB;N NB? WLMN @IOL
JIQ?LM I@ NB? M?LC?M MBIOF> HIN <? M?LC;FFS =ILL?F;N?>
-.:>*,B =.<=< +*<.- 87 -.7<2=B /8;.,*<=<
A52; B;12? A52 B@B.9 0<;16A6<; <3 . ;<;G2?< .0</6.; D6A5 0<;A6;B<B@ =.?
4
A6.9 12?6C.A6C2@ A52 @2>B2;02 <3 =?</./696AF 6;A24?.9 A?.;@3<?:@ <3 'aN (N D6A5
4
?2@=20A A< 'NN aN
(N 6@ 661 A (
A5.A 6@
4
'\N (N 661 A (
'
%H INB?L QIL>M
C@ NB? JIMNOF;N?> >CMNLC<ONCIH NN aN
CM =ILL?=N
NB?H CNM
JLI<;<CFCNS CHN?AL;F NL;HM@ILG \N CM 661 A (
C?<IF>
#OHNB?L
;H> 0;S
JLIJIM? ; NQIMN?J N?MN "CLMN
Q? N?MN NB? HOFF BSJINB?MCM NB;N \N
CM M?LC;FFS OH=ILL?F;N?> %N =;H <? >IH? OMCHA ; MN;H>;L> () N?MN "IL NBCM
JOLJIM?
C?<IF>
#OHNB?L
;H> 0;S MOAA?MN ?R;GCHCHA NB? ;ONI=ILL?F;NCIHM I@
D D
\N \
IH 7 F;AM I@ NB? P;LC;<F?
@IL P
( (
<S L?AL?MMCHA \N \
0B? () N?MN MN;NCMNC= CM >?WH?> ;M @ 7
>
QB?L? > CM NB? =I?^=C?HN I@
>?N?LGCH;NCIH
;H> CM >CMNLC<ON?>
OH>?L NB? HOFF I@ HI M?LC;F =ILL?F;NCIH
;M ;
QCNB 7 >?AL??M I@ @L??>IG
/?=IH>
Q? N?MN NB? HOFF BSJINB?MCM NB;N \N CM >CMNLC<ON?> ;M ; OHC@ILG
A (
"IL NBCM JOLJIM?
C?<IF>
#OHNB?L
;H> 0;S >CPC>? NB? ?GJCLC=;F
;H> NB?IL?NC=;F >CMNLC<ONCIH CHNI : =?FFM ;H> N?MN QB?NB?L NB? NQI >CMNLC<
ONCIHM MCAHCW=;HNFS >C_?L IH ?;=B =?FF /O=B ;H ;JJLI;=B ;FFIQM ; AL;JBC=;F
L?JL?M?HN;NCIH NB;N =;H <? OM?> NI C>?HNC@S ;L?;M QB?L? NB? NB?IL?NC=;F >CMNLC
<ONCIH @;CFM NI WN NB? >;N; 0B? N?MN MN;NCMNC=
,.
2I @ *:
03@ :
(
I
@ *:
ANN W
;N NCG? [ ;M
C@ aN 8NN W
( ANN W
(
4P[N
C@ aN
* 8NN W
( ANN W
(
6?LI =ILL?F;NCIH CM ?KOCP;F?HN NI CH>?J?H>?H=? IHFS OH>?L HILG;FCNS 0B? =ILL?F
IAL;G CM
NB?L?@IL?
IHFS MOAA?MNCP? I@ JIMMC<F? CH>?J?H>?H=?
/J?=CW=;NCIH N?MNM ;H> CH@?L?H=?
QB?L? 8NN W
;H> ANN W
>?HIN?
L?MJ?=NCP?FS
@IL NB? FIQ?L ;H> OJJ?L
FCGCNM I@ NB? CHN?LP;F
%H ;H OH=IH>CNCIH;F M?NOJ
; H;NOL;F AII>H?MMI@WN )
N?MN @IL ; ACP?H CHN?LP;F
4
@IL?=;MN =IHMCMNM CH =IGJ;LCHA NB? HIGCH;F =IP?L;A? N 4P[N *@ QCNB NB?
NLO? =IP?L;A? W 0BCM CM NB? N?MN JLIJIM?> <S C?<IF>
#OHNB?L
;H> 0;S
%H ; =IH>CNCIH;F M?NOJ
BLCMNI_?LM?H MBIQM NB;N N?MNCHA
8>OI> &)# (
8
)4P[N ( [
( ( @
QB?L?
I
8 W)4P[N ( [
( ( @
W
WI (
I
8
)4P[N ( [
( ( @
I (
QCNB U * U U
CM NB? )(! I@ NB? NLO? =IP?L;A? JLI<;<CFCNS F?;LFS
QB?L? UDE CM NB? HOG<?L I@ I<M?LP;NCIHM QCNB P;FO? P @IFFIQ?> <S P;FO? Q
0B? JLI<;<CFCNS DE CM ?MNCG;N?> <S DE UDE * UD UD
1H>?L NB? HOFF I@
CH>?J?H>?H=?
NB? NL;HMCNCIH JLI<;<CFCNS G;NLCR L?>O=?M NI
(
4P[N
M DN
#N (
55><=;*=287
&*+5.
$.?.:2A2? 2@A6:.A2@ <3 A52 &E =?<02@@ 3<? 1.69F ?2AB?;@
/, 4 "0/! *CEE?C
() N?MN
2 0
)I>?FCHA $CAB?L )IG?HNM
0B? N;<F? ;FMI JLIPC>?M L?MOFNM I@ NB? ;>?KO;=S N?MN JLIJIM?> <S
C?<IF>
#OHNB?L
;H> 0;S %H NBCM =;M?
NB? JLIJIM?> GI>?F CM L?D?=N?>
@IL NQI L?;MIHM "CLMN
NB? G;LACH \N CM HIN 661 0BCM MOAA?MNM NB;N NB? . W
]
#.$
(
CM HIN ;<F? NI =;JNOL? ;FF NB? NCG? >?J?H>?H=S I@ L?NOLHM /?=
IH>
NB? G;LACH CM HIN OHC@ILGFS >CMNLC<ON?> 0BCM CH>C=;N?M NB;N NB? HILG;F
>CMNLC<ONCIH CM HIN ;<F? NI =;JNOL? NB? @?;NOL?M I@ NB? ?GJCLC=;F >CMNLC<ONCIH
NB;N =ILL?MJIH>M NI NB? ?GJCLC=;F >CMNLC<ONCIH 0B? WAOL? MOAA?MNM NB;N NB?
L?D?=NCIH I@ NB? HILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH @IL /, >;CFS L?NOLHM =IG?M @LIG NB?
?RNL?G?M L;MB?M ;L? GO=B GIL? @L?KO?HN ;H> <IIGM ;L? F?MM @L?KO?HN CH NB?
?GJCLC=;F >CMNLC<ONCIH NB;H CH NB? ;MMOG?> HILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH
*IQ
Q? ;MMOG? NB;N CHHIP;NCIHM ;L? HIN HILG;FFS <ON [ >CMNLC<ON?>
aN
[ 0BOM Q? ;FMI ?MNCG;N? NB? >?AL??I@@L??>IG J;L;G?N?L 0;<F? L?JILNM
NB? =ILL?MJIH>CHA J;L;G?N?L ?MNCG;N?M 0B? >?AL?? I@ @L??>IG FC?M QCNBCH NB?
L;HA? (
MOAA?MNCHA NB;N NB? N;CFM I@ NB? ?GJCLC=;F >CMNLC<ONCIH ;L? @;NN?L
NB;H NBIM? CGJFC?> <S NB? HILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH 5?N
NB? @;NN;CF?>H?MM I@ NB?
?GJCLC=;F >CMNLC<ONCIH CM HIN ;M ?RNL?G? ;M NB? IH? Q? QIOF> B;P? B;> QCNB
; MN;<F? >CMNLC<ONCIH %H>??>
<?=;OM? IOL ?MNCG;N?M I@ ;L? =F?;LFS F;LA?L
NB;H
Q? =;H ;>GCN NB;N
;N F?;MN
NB? WLMN @IOL GIG?HNM I@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH
>I ?RCMN 0B? ;>?KO;=S N?MN L?P?;FM NB;N NB? [ >CMNLC<ONCIH =;JNOL?M GIMN
@?;NOL?M I@ NB? ?GJCLC=;F >CMNLC<ONCIH @IL NB? /, ;H> NB? 4 CH>C=?M
;M
CFFOMNL;N?> CH "CAOL? $IQ?P?L
NBCM >CMNLC<ONCIH MNCFF @;CFM NI ;>?KO;N?FS
L?JL?M?HN NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ NB? "0/! ;H> *CEE?C CH>C=?M
<?=;OM? CN CGJFC?M
NII G;HS JIMCNCP? ?RNL?G?M NI <? =IHMCMN?HN QCNB NB? ?GJCLC=;F >CMNLC<ONCIH
"CH;FFS
Q? ;MMOG? NB;N CHHIP;NCIHM ;L? >CMNLC<ON?> ;M ; ME?Q?> [ >CMNLC<
ONCIH aN N (
3?
NB?L?@IL?
?MNCG;N? NB? >?AL??I@@L??>IG J;L;G?N?L
;H> NB? ;MSGG?NLS J;L;G?N?L 0;<F? L?JILNM NB? ?MNCG;NCIH I@ NB?
#.$
(
GI>?F QCNB ME?Q?> [ CHHIP;NCIH FF ;MSGG?NLS J;L;G?N?LM ;L?
H?A;NCP?
;FNBIOAB CN CM <;L?FS MCAHCW=;HN @IL NB? /, "IL INB?L CH>C=?M
,;L;G?N?L ?MNCG;N?M MFCABNFS >C_?L @LIG NBIM? L?JILN?> CH B;JN?L @IL NB? M;G?
M?LC?M
<?=;OM? Q? HIQ N;E? NB? M?LC;F =ILL?F;NCIH CH L?NOLH CHNI ;==IOHN
H CHN?L?MNCHA JLIJ?LNS I@ NB? I >CMNLC<ONCIH QCNB >?AL??M I@ @L??>IG CM NB;N ;FF
GIG?HNM I@ IL>?L ;<IP? >I HIN ?RCMN
%FFOMNL;NCIH
&*+5.
$.?.:2A2? 2@A6:.A2@ <3 A52 &
=?<02@@ B;12? ;<?:.96AF
/, 4 "0/! *CEE?C
- !$
0CG? CH>?J?H>?H=S
J& J
J& J
J& J
J& J
1HC@ILG
160
150
140
130
120
110
100
90
80
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50
1.69F ?2AB?;@
)I>?FCHA $CAB?L )IG?HNM
J& J
1HC@ILG
160
150
140
130
120
110
100
90
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50
1.69F ?2AB?;@
%FFOMNL;NCIH
-%%&'
0CG? CH>?J?H>?H=S
J& J
J& J
J& J
J& J
1HC@ILG
150
140
130
120
110
100
90
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50
1.69F ?2AB?;@
)I>?FCHA $CAB?L )IG?HNM
0I =IH=FO>?
Q? I<M?LP? NB;N NB? #.$ GI>?F CM OH;<F? NI =;JNOL?
;FF NB? M?LC;F =ILL?F;NCIH CH M?=IH> ;H> BCAB?L GIG?HNM 0QI ;FN?LH;NCP? ;J
JLI;=B?M G;S CGJLIP? NBCM >CM;JJICHNCHA L?MOFN C ?MNCG;N? ;H ;MSGG?NLC=
#.$ GI>?F MO=B ;M NB? #&. IL 0.$ GI>?FM
QBC=B QIOF> JLI<;<FS
B?FJ =;JNOL? ;N F?;MN NB? M?LC;F =ILL?F;NCIH CH NB? M?=IH> GIG?HN CC GI>?F
NB? >SH;GC= I@ NB? NBCL> ;H> @IOLNB GIG?HNM
;M CHCNC;FFS JLIJIM?> CH $;HM?H
;H> ?RN?H>?> CH &IH>?;O ;H> .I=ECHA?L ; /?? /?=NCIH
_N N
N
aN (
N
1 _N )N ( N
(
4 5
N
1 _N N
)N ( N
(
aN N aN ) N
(
N ( N
(
N aN ( aN (
'
)I>?FCHA =IH>CNCIH;F BCAB?L GIG?HNM
;H> &IH>?;O ;H> .I=ECHA?L ; B;P? ;FF GI>?F?> ME?QH?MM ;H> >CMNLC<
ONCIH J;L;G?N?LM ;M ?RN?H>?> #.$ GI>?FM 0BCM MILN I@ ?RN?HMCIH CM HIN
;M MNL;CABN@ILQ;L> ;M CN G;S M??G "CLMN CN L?KOCL?M
;N ?;=B >;N? ;H> ?;=B
MN?J I@ NB? IJNCGCT;NCIH
NI MIFP? NB? HIHFCH?;L JLI<F?G NB;N FCHEM J;L;G?
N?LM ;H> GIG?HNM 0B? M?=IH> JLI<F?G
;M G?HNCIH?> <?@IL?
CM NB;N ; FIN I@
=IHMNL;CHNM B;P? NI <? CGJIM?> IH NB? NCG?P;LSCHA BCAB?L GIG?HNM NI G;E?
MOL? NB;N NB? =IH>CNCIH;F >CMNLC<ONCIH CM Q?FF >?WH?> 0B? =IGJF?R <IOH>;LS
=IH>CNCIHM ;H> =IGJF?R HIHFCH?;L L?F;NCIHMBCJM <?NQ??H J;L;G?N?LM G;E? NB?
?MNCG;NCIH P?LS NLC=ES
=IGJON;NCIH;FFS CHN?HMCP?
;H> NCG? =IHMOGCHA
HJ aNJ \N (
@IL EOLNIMCM aN I I aN IJ aNJ \N '
8-.5270 1201.; 686.7=< -2;.,=5B
/?P?L;F MNO>C?M B;P? >CL?=NFS =IHMC>?L?> NB? GI>?FCHA I@ BCAB?L GIG?HNM $;L
P?S ;H> /C>>CKO? @I=OM IH NB? GI>?FCHA I@ NB? >SH;GC=M I@ ME?QH?MM
CH ; HIH=?HNL;F /NO>?HN [ >CMNLC<ONCIH .I=ECHA?L ;H> &IH>?;O GI>?F
0BCM L?MOFN BIF>M C@ GIG?HNM OJ NI NB? ?CABNB IH? ?RCMN "IL WH;H=C;F >;N;
NBCM
;MMOGJNCIH G;S <? QLIHA
)I>?FCHA $CAB?L )IG?HNM
QBC=B CM ;>IJN?> <S $;LP?S ;H> /C>>CKO? ;M Q?FF ;M <S LIIEM
OLE?
NB? IHFS =IHMNL;CHNM IH NB? >SH;GC=M I@ ME?QH?MM ;H> EOLNIMCM ;L? NI ?HMOL?
MN;NCIH;LCNS I@ NB? JLI=?MM
HIN JIMCNCPCNS I@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH %N NOLHM ION NB;N
NB? =IHMNL;CHNM
JL?M?HN?> CH /?=NCIH
NI ?HMOL? NB;N NB? >?HMCNS CM >?WH?>
=;HHIN <? ?;MCFS CGJIM?> CH NBCM =IHN?RN M MBIQH CH NB? =IHN?RN I@ NB?
ME?Q?> /NO>?HN [ >CMNLC<ONCIH /?=NCIH
NB? =IHMNL;CHNM IH J;L;G?N?LM
;H> NI ?HMOL? NB;N NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH CM >?WHCN? ;L? ?;MS NI ?MN;<FCMB %H
=IHNL;MN
NB? =IHMNL;CHNM IH Z ;H> ;L? HIN ;H;FSNC=;FFS EHIQH MCGCF;L
L?MOFN BIF>M @IL NB? #L;GB;LFC?L M?LC?M ?RJ;HMCIH
%H ; MFCABNFS >C_?L?HN =IHN?RN
&IH>?;O ;H> .I=ECHA?L ; B;P? MBIQH
NB;N ;H ;ONIL?AL?MMCP? MNLO=NOL? MO=B ;M JL?M?HN?> ;<IP? MO_?LM @LIG ; M?P?L?
)I>?FCHA =IH>CNCIH;F BCAB?L GIG?HNM
'
M
ZN H H aN (
N I I )aN ) '
0B?M? >SH;GC=M ;L? ?MNCG;N?> QBCF? HOG?LC=;FFS CGJIMCHA NB;N ME?QH?MM ;H>
EOLNIMCM <? CHMC>? NB? >IG;CH I@ >?WHCNCIH >?M=LC<?> CH M?=NCIH
&& 8 9 O& 9 O&
&
)I>?F ) & 8 9 O& 9
O&
& &
& &
& &
& 8 9
O& 9 O& : &
)I>?F )
& 8 9 O& 9
O& : &
&& 8 9 O& 9 O& : &
&
)I>?F ) & 8 9 O& 9
&
O& : &
& &
& &
& &
& 8 9 O&
&
&
& 8 9 O&
)I>?F )
&
& (& &
&
&
& & ' &
&
& 8 9 O& : & &
&
&
& 8 9 O&
: &
&
)I>?F )
(&
&
&
& &
&
& & ' &
&
I H
);HS I@ NB? >L;Q<;=EM I@
GI>?F ) >CM;JJ?;L $IQ?P?L
IH? =IHM?KO?H=? CM NB;N NB? CGJ;=N I@ ?RNL?G?
L?;FCT;NCIHM A?NM >;GJ?H?> <?=;OM? NB? FIACMNC= G;J N?H>M NI X;NN?H NB? L?
MJIHM? I@ P;LC;<F?M FI=;N?> CH CNM N;CFM
)I>?F ) MJ?=CW?M J;L;G?N?LM N ;H> N ;M ;H ;ONIL?AL?MMCP? MNLO=NOL? M
>CM=OMM?> ;<IP?
MO=B ; MJ?=CW=;NCIH MO_?LM @LIG ; M?P?L? >L;Q<;=E
<?=;OM?
N NBCM MN;A?
J G;S <? MN;NCMNC=;FFS MCAHCW=;HN 0BCM G;S F?;> NI NB? =IH=FO
MCIH NB;N NB?L? CM J?LMCMN?H=? CH NB? 0N /O=B ; =IH=FOMCIH QIOF> <? ?LLIH?IOM
BIQ?P?L %H>??>
C@ ;=NO;F I<M?LP;NCIHM `N >I HIN G;NN?L
NB?H
MN;LNCHA @LIG
MIG? CHCNC;F P;FO? 0
NB? M?LC?M I@ 0N QCFF KOC=EFS =IHP?LA? NI CNM MN;NCIH;LS
F?P?F ACP?H <S
0 H *
J
'
%H INB?L QIL>M
NB? GI>?F QB?L? Q? QIOF> B;P? ?MNCG;N?> 0N 0 QCNB
I J
=IOF> HIN <? >CMNCHAOCMB?> @LIG NB? IH? I<N;CH?> ?;LFC?L 0BCM
CGJFC?M NB;N NB?L? ?RCMNM ;H ?HNCL? =F;MM I@ J;L;G?N?LM H ( J
;FF M;NCM@SCHA
H
@IL QBC=B NB? GI>?FZM =B;L;=N?LCMNC=M ;L? CH>CMNCHAOCMB;<F?
J
0
0B? ;FAILCNBG =IHP?LA?M NI IH? MIFONCIH ;N L;H>IG 0I ;PIC> NBCM NSJ? I@
MJOLCIOM WH>CHA
CN CM L?=IGG?H>?> NI ?MNCG;N? ) <?@IL? ) ;H> NI P?L
C@S NB;N J;MN I<M?LP;NCIHM ;_?=N 0N IL 0 N %H HI Q;S MBIOF> Q? NLOMN CH ;H
?MNCG;NCIH QB?L? J IL J CM MN;NCMNC=;FFS MCAHCW=;HN
S?N
NB? J;L;G?N?LM IH
NB? F;AA?> CHHIP;NCIHM ;L? HIN MN;NCMNC=;FFS MCAHCW=;HN @OLNB?L >C;AHIMNC= NI
>?N?=N NBCM <?B;PCIL =IHMCMNM CH =B;HACHA NB? P;FO? I@ 0 IL I@ NB? CHCNC;F P;FO?
I@ NB? J;L;G?N?LM CH NB? HOG?LC=;F ?MNCG;NCIH %@ NB? ;FAILCNBG =IHP?LA?M NI
MCAHCW=;HNFS >C_?L?HN P;FO?M
NB?H Q? MBIOF> <? =;L?@OF ;<ION NB? ?MNCG;N?>
J;L;G?N?LM
%H MJ?=CW=;NCIH )
NB? NBCL> ;H> @IOLNB HIH=?HNL;F GIG?HNM
ZN ;H> N
A?N MJ?=CW?> OMCHA ;=NO;F I<M?LP;NCIHM "IL NB? GI>?F NI <? Q?FF >?WH?>
CN
GOMN <? NB;N ZN ;H> N <?FIHA NI NB? >IG;CH 0BCM CGJFC?M ; JIN?HNC;FFS
BCABFS HIHFCH?;L G;J 3 NB;N G;JM MIG? OHL?MNLC=N?> Z0N ;H> 0 N CHNI "OL
NB?LGIL?
CH IL>?L NI I<N;CH N ;H> N @LIG ZN ;H> N
CN CM H?=?MM;LS NI CHP?LN
; BCABFS HIHFCH?;L G;J NB;N Q? =;FF 2 CH NB? N;<F? !P?H NBIOAB MO=B ;H
CHP?LMCIH =IOF> <? >IH? CH NB?ILS
CN QCFF F?;> NI ; MFIQ ;FAILCNBG ;H> ;FMI NI
; L;NB?L OHMN;<F? ?MNCG;NCIH <?=;OM? NB? ;H;FSNC= =IGJON;NCIH I@ AL;>C?HNM
G;S HIN <? @?;MC<F? 3CNB MO=B ; MJ?=CW=;NCIH
CN CM CGJFC=CNFS ;MMOG?> NB;N
ME?QH?MM ;H> EOLNIMCM ;L? WHCN? ;N ?;=B JICHN I@ NCG? 0BCM I<M?LP;NCIH CM ;N
I>>M QCNB L?MOFNM @LIG ?RNL?G? P;FO? NB?ILS
)I>?F ) JL?M?HNM NB? M;G? >C^=OFNC?M ;M ) QCNB NB? ;>>?> =IGJFC=;NCIH
;FL?;>S >CM=OMM?> @IL GI>?F )
CH NB;N IH? G;S WH> MJOLCIOM >?J?H>?H=? I@
ME?QH?MM >O? NI ; F;=E I@ MCAHCW=;HN I IL I ?MNCG;N?M
8-.5270 8;;.5*=287
%H NBCM =B;JN?L
Q? NOLH NI NB? GI>?FCHA I@ NB? GOFNCP;LC;N? >CMNLC<ONCIH I@
;MM?N L?NOLHM 0B? GIMN CGJILN;HN =B;L;=N?LCMNC= I@ NB? GOFNCP;LC;N? >CMNLC<O
NCIH L?FC?M IH NB? >?J?H>?H=S J;L;G?N?L
C?
NB? J;L;G?N?L NB;N G?;MOL?M NB?
MNL?HANB I@ NB? FCHE <?NQ??H NQI M?LC?M "IL ; HOG<?L I@ MN;H>;L> >CMNLC<ONCIHM
H;G?FS
NBIM? <?FIHACHA NI NB? ?FFCJNC=;F @;GCFS
QBC=B CH=FO>?M NB? HILG;F
;H> NB? /NO>?HN [ >CMNLC<ONCIHM
NB? >?J?H>?H=S CM MCGJFS G?;MOL?> <S NB?
,?;LMIHZM =ILL?F;NCIH =I?^=C?HN 3? I@N?H L?@?L NI =ILL?F;NCIH QB?H G?;HCHA
>?J?H>?H=S %H JL;=NC=?
BIQ?P?L
;MM?N L?NOLHM >I HIN <?FIHA NI NBCM ?FFCJ
NC=;F @;GCFS ;H> NB? >?J?H>?H=S GOMN <? GI>?F?> QCNB MJ?=CW= N?=BHCKO?M
0B? GI>?FCHA I@ NB? >?J?H>?H=S J;L;G?N?L <?NQ??H ;MM?N L?NOLHM B;M P?LS
CGJILN;HN =IHM?KO?H=?M CH ; HOG<?L I@ WH;H=C;F ;JJFC=;NCIHM
H ;<OH>;HN FCN?L;NOL? B;M ;>>L?MM?> NB? CMMO? I@ BIQ =ILL?F;NCIH <?
NQ??H MNI=E G;LE?N L?NOLHM P;LC?M QB?H G;LE?NM <?=IG? ;ACN;N?> 0B? NCG?
P;LC;<CFCNS I@ =ILL?F;NCIH <?NQ??H L?NOLHM CM =LO=C;F @LIG ;H ;MM?N G;H;A?G?HN
JICHN I@ PC?Q MM?N ;FFI=;NCIH CM I@N?H <;M?> IH NB? OM? I@ ; =ILL?F;NCIH G;NLCR
=IGJON?> IP?L ; ACP?H M;GJF? J?LCI> %@ =ILL?F;NCIH CH=L?;M?M >OLCHA NOL<O
F?HN J?LCI>M
NB? <?H?WNM I@ >CP?LMCW=;NCIH QIOF> >CM;JJ?;L QB?H NB?S ;L? NB?
GIMN H??>?>
C?
>OLCHA =L;MB?M %GJFC=;NCIHM @IL LCME G;H;A?G?HN ;L? ;FMI
I<PCIOM <?=;OM? NB? NCG?P;LC;<CFCNS I@ NB? >?J?H>?H=S J;L;G?N?L =IGJFC=;N?M
2;FO? ;N .CME 2;. =IGJON;NCIH MCAHCW=;HNFS
M >?M=LC<?> CH B;JN?L
NB? WLMN N?MNM I@ =IHMN;H=S I@ NB? >?J?H>?H=S
J;L;G?N?L Q?L? <;M?> IH N?MNCHA NB? ?KO;FCNS I@ FCH?;L =ILL?F;NCIH =I?^=C?HNM
=IGJON?> <?@IL? ;H> ;@N?L ; =L;MB 0BCM ;JJLI;=B B;M <??H @IOH> NI <? GCM
F?;>CHA
BIQ?P?L
<?=;OM? =IH>CNCIHCHA NB? ?MNCG;NCIH I@ NB? =ILL?F;NCIH =I
?^=C?HN IH NB? M;GJF? J?LCI> CH>O=?M ;H ?MNCG;NIL <C;M /O<M?KO?HNFS
GIMN
N?MNM I@ NB? =IHMN;HN =ILL?F;NCIH BSJINB?MCM B;P? <??H <;M?> IH NB? @IFFIQCHA
;JJLI;=B "CLMN
?MNCG;N? NB? DICHN >SH;GC=M I@ MNI=EG;LE?N L?NOLHM ;H> NB?H
>?M=LC<? BIQ =IH>CNCIH;F =ILL?F;NCIHM P;LS IP?L NCG? 0B?L? ;L? M?P?L;F Q;SM
NI GI>?F NB? DICHN >SH;GC=M I@ ; HOG<?L I@ M?LC?M 0B? GIMN QC>?FS OM?>
)I>?FCHA ILL?F;NCIH
;JJLI;=B CM NB? GOFNCP;LC;N? #.$ GI>?F 0B? =?HNL;F C>?; I@ NB? WLMN
A?H?L;NCIH I@ MO=B GI>?FM Q;M NB;N =IP;LC;H=?M B;> NI <? GI>?F?> OMCHA NB?
M;G? NSJ? I@ MJ?=CW=;NCIH I@ P;LC;H=?M CH NB? OHCP;LC;N? #.$ GI>?F 'L;@N
;H> !HAF?
;H> IFF?LMF?P
BIO
;H> 'LIH?L
0B?M? GI>?FM
BIQ
?P?L
L;CM? ; JLI<F?G I@ >CG?HMCIH;FCNS <?=;OM? NB? HOG<?L I@ J;L;G?N?LM NI
<? ?MNCG;N?> CH=L?;M?M >L;G;NC=;FFS QCNB NB? HOG<?L I@ M?LC?M @N?LQ;L>M
H ;FN?LH;NCP? ;JJLI;=B CM NB? GOFNCP;LC;N? );LEIPMQCN=BCHA GI>?F "IL CH
MN;H=?
.;G=B;H> ;H> /OMG?F ;H> HA ;H> ?E;?LN N?MN QCNBCH
NBCM @L;G?QILE NB? BSJINB?MCM I@ ; =IHMN;HN CHN?LH;NCIH;F =IH>CNCIH;F =ILL?F;NCIH
<?NQ??H MNI=E G;LE?NM /IG? J;J?LM ;FMI =IHMC>?L BIQ =ILL?F;NCIH P;LC?M QB?H
MNI=EG;LE?N CH>C=?M ;L? MCGOFN;H?IOMFS ;_?=N?> <S P?LS F;LA? JIMCNCP? IL H?A
;NCP? XO=NO;NCIHM !HAF? ;H> );HA;H?FFC @I=OM IH NB? GI>?FCHA I@ F;LA?
L?;FCT;NCIHM OMCHA KO;HNCF? L?AL?MMCIHM (IHACH ;H> /IFHCE
OMCHA ?RNL?G?
P;FO? NB?ILS
WH> NB;N >?J?H>?H=S CH=L?;M?M GIL? >OLCHA >IQHMC>? GIP?G?HNM
NB;H >OLCHA OJMC>? GIP?G?HNM ,IIH
.I=ECHA?L
;H> 0;QH JLIPC>? ;H ;F
N?LH;NCP? MN;NCMNC=;F @L;G?QILE NI N?MN =IH>CNCIH;F >?J?H>?H=S <?NQ??H ?RNL?G?
L?NOLHM
%H ;>>CNCIH
CN CM QILNB ?GJB;MCTCHA NB;N NB? GI>?FCHA I@ >?J?H>?H=S CH NB?
=IHN?RN I@ ?RNL?G? ?P?HNM QCFF <? >?N;CF?> CH B;JN?L
)OFNCP;LC;N? #.$ GI>?FM
QBC=B ;L? A?H?L;FFS >C^=OFN NI ?MNCG;N? <ON ;FFIQ ; GIL? ?^=C?HN =IGJON;NCIH
I@ GIG?HNM 0B?H
CH /?=NCIH
Q? JL?M?HN NB? ;JJLI;=B <;M?> IH =IJOF;
_N N
#N (
#N N
aN (
QB?L? N
>?HIN?M NB? U(
P?=NIL I@ =IH>CNCIH;F G?;HM
N
>?HIN?M NB?
U( U
=IH>CNCIH;F =IP;LC;H=? G;NLCR I@ NB? ?LLIL N?LG #N ( ;H> CM NB? P?=NIL I@
OHEHIQH J;L;G?N?LM 0B? MN;H>;L>CT?> CHHIP;NCIH P?=NIL aN CM 661 QCNB G?;H
1 aN ;H> =IP;LC;H=? G;NLCR B aN 5I N
>?HIN?M NB? BIF?MES
>?=IGJIMCNCIH I@ N
' %H NBCM =B;JN?L
Q? ;MMOG? NB;N aN CM >L;QH @LIG NB?
GOFNCP;LC;N? HILG;F ( 5I
>CMNLC<ONCIH
/?P?L;F J;L;G?N?LCT;NCIHM B;P? <??H JLIJIM?> @IL N 0B? G;CH CMMO? NI
<? ;>>L?MM?> CM NB? >CG?HMCIH;FCNS I@ NB? J;L;G?N?L P?=NIL QB?H NB? HOG
<?L I@ P;LC;<F?M U CH=L?;M?M +<PCIOMFS
CN CM >?MCL;<F? NB;N GIMN MN;NCMNC=;F
@?;NOL?M BCABFCABN?> CH NB? OHCP;LC;N? =IHN?RN <? CH=ILJIL;N?> CH NB? GOFNC
P;LC;N? @L;G?QILE
CH J;LNC=OF;L CH N?LGM I@ ;MSGG?NLS ;H> N;CF <?B;PCIL
/IG? ;>>CNCIH;F MJ?=CW= CMMO?M L?F;N?> NI NB? GOFNCP;LC;N? @L;G?QILE B;P? NI
<? ;>>L?MM?> "CLMN
Q? B;P? NI >?;F QCNB NB? =IH>CNCIHM AO;L;HN??CHA NB;N NB?
=IP;LC;H=? G;NLCR CM JIMCNCP? >?WHCN? ;N ?;=B >;N? [ M?=IH> CMMO? CM QB?NB?L
=IH>CNCIH;F =ILL?F;NCIHM B;P? NI <? GI>?F?> CHMN?;> I@ =IH>CNCIH;F =IP;LC;H=?
GI>?F CM >?WH?> ;M
J
, K
,
P?=B N
P?=B
-D P?=B #ND #
ND .E P?=B NE
(
D E
QB?L? CM ;H U( U
JIMCNCP? >?WHCN? ;H> MSGG?NLC= G;NLCR
-D ;H> .E ;L?
U U
*( U U
*
G;NLC=?M P?=B
CM NB? IJ?L;NIL NB;N MN;=EM NB?
FIQ?L NLC;HAOF;L ?F?G?HNM I@ ;H U( U
G;NLCR ;M ;H U U
*(
P?=NIL
0B? HOG<?L I@ J;L;G?N?LM CM U U
*
W X
U U
* FNBIOAB
NBCM MJ?=CW=;NCIH CM P?LS X?RC<F?
NB? F;LA? HOG<?L I@ J;L;G?N?LM JLIJILNCIH;F
NI U L?H>?LM NBCM GI>?F P?LS >C^=OFN NI B;H>F? %H ;>>CNCIH
=IH>CNCIHM
NB;N ?HMOL? NB;N NB? =IH>CNCIH;F =IP;LC;H=? G;NLC=?M ;L? JIMCNCP? >?WHCN? ;L?
>C^=OFN NI P?LC@S ;H> CGJIM?
A*695. %H NB? =;M? W X
;H> U
NBCM GI>?F L?>O=?M NI
N " H H H
# N
% N & % " & % H H H
& % #N # N &
N " H
H
H
# N
I I I
N
% I I I
& % N & (
I
I
I
N
QCNB OHEHIQH J;L;G?N?LM
QB?L? CM ;H U( U
JIMCNCP? >?WHCN? ;H> MSGG?NLC= G;NLCR
-D ;H> .E ;L?
U( U
MSGG?NLC= G;NLC=?M ;H>
>?HIN?M NB? $;>;G;L> JLI>O=N 0BCM GI>?F
0B? $;>;G;L> JLI>O=N >?WH?M NB? ?F?G?HNQCM? JLI>O=N I@ NQI G;NLC=?M /I Q?
B;P? # $ # $
)OFNCP;LC;N? #.$ GI>?FM
MI NB;N CN CM JLIJILNCIH;F
NI U IHFS
A*695. %H NB? =;M? W X
;H> U
NBCM GI>?F L?>O=?M NI
" "
N
" "
H H # N #N # N
68-.5
QB?L? 0 CM ;H U( U
JIMCNCP? >?WHCN? ;H> MSGG?NLC= G;NLCR
;H> -0D ;H> . 0E ;L?
U( U
G;NLC=?M 0BCM MJ?=CW=;NCIH CHPIFP?M U U
* W X
U OHEHIQH
J;L;G?N?LM 0B? G;CH ;>P;HN;A? I@ NBCM MJ?=CW=;NCIH CM NB;N NB? =IH>CNCIH;F
=IP;LC;H=? G;NLCR CM JIMCNCP? >?WHCN? ;M FIHA ;M 0 ;FMI CM
A*695. %H NB? =;M? W X
;H> U
NBCM GI>?F L?>O=?M NI
0 "
" 0
N
"
0 "
0
0 H
H 0 # N #N # N 0 H
H 0
H
0 H
0 #N # N # N H
0 H
0
0I 0I N N 0I 0I
0 0 0 (
I I N
N I 0I
)4
QB?L? ?
4 #N #
N
N CM NB? M;GJF? =IP;LC;H=? G;NLCR I@ L?MC>O;FM
.*5270 @2=1 5*;0.-26.7<287*5 <B<=.6<
+H? A?H?L;F JLI<F?G QCNB GOFNCP;LC;N? #.$ GI>?FM CM NB? JLI<F?G I@ >C
G?HMCIH;FCNS 0B? MJ?=CW=;NCIHM >?M=LC<?> ;<IP? QIOF> <? P?LS >C^=OFN NI
CGJF?G?HN @IL F;LA?>CG?HMCIH;F JILN@IFCIM <?=;OM? I@ NB? F;LA? HOG<?L I@ J;
L;G?N?LM NI <? ?MNCG;N?> 0B? ";=NIL #.$ ;JJLI;=B ;H> CNM ?RN?HMCIHM
L?>O=?M NB? HOG<?L I@ P;LC;<F?M NB? @;=NILM NB;N B;P? NI <? GI>?F?> QCNB
; GOFNCP;LC;N? #.$ >SH;GC=M 0B? "F?RC<F? #.$ GI>?F CM <;M?> IH ;
>?=?HNL;FCT?> ?MNCG;NCIH I@ NB? =IP;LC;H=? G;NLCR
)OFNCP;LC;N? #.$ GI>?FM
0B? ";=NIL #.$ IL "#.$ B;M <??H JLIJIM?> <S !HAF?
*A
;H>
.INBM=BCF> NI @OLNB?L L?>O=? NB? HOG<?L I@ J;L;G?N?LM NI <? ?MNC
G;N?> !HAF?
*A
;H> .INBM=BCF> B;P? JLIJIM?> ;H ?RN?HMCIH I@ NB?
"#.$ GI>?F NB;N ;FFIQM >CMNCHAOCMBCHA <?NQ??H NB? >SH;GC= ;H> MN;NC=
MNLO=NOL? I@ ;MM?N L?NOLHM +NB?L QILE <;M?> IH "#.$ GI>?FM CM <S 'CHA
/?HN;H;
;H> 3;>BQ;HC IL /?HN;H; ;H> "CIL?HNCHC
0B? C>?; I@ NBCM J;L;G?N?LCT;NCIH CM NB;N NB? DICHN >SH;GC=M I@ NB? U(
P?=NIL I@ L?NOLHM _N =;H <? =ILL?=NFS >?M=LC<?> OMCHA ; MG;FF HOG<?L I@ @;=NILM
7 7 ) U 0BCM GI>?F B;M <??H OM?> <S IFF?LMF?P ;H> !HAF? NI GI>?F
=IGGIH J?LMCMN?H=? CH MNI=E G;LE?N PIF;NCFCNC?M 0B? >?M=LCJNCIH I@ _N CM ACP?H
<S NB? 7(
P?=NIL I@ @;=NILM MN ;H> NB? U( 7
G;NLCR . I@ NCG?CHP;LC;HN
@;=NIL FI;>CHAM
_N .MN #N '
MMOG? NB;N NB? ?LLIL N?LG #N B;M =IHMN;HN U( U
=IH>CNCIH;F =IP;LC;H=? G;
NLCR
NB;N NB? 7 @;=NILM MN B;P? =IH>CNCIH;F =IP;LC;H=? G;NLCR N ;H> NB;N
#N ;H> MN ;L? OH=ILL?F;N?> 0B?H
NB? =IH>CNCIH;F =IP;LC;H=? G;NLCR I@ _N CM
?KO;F NI
BN _N N .N .
'
%@ Q? ;MMOG? HIQ NB;N NB? =IH>CNCIH;F =IP;LC;H=? G;NLCR I@ @;=NILM N CM >C;A
IH;F QCNB ?F?G?HNM FN IL C@ I_>C;AIH;F ?F?G?HNM ;L? =IHMN;HN ;H> =IG<CH?>
CHNI
NB?H NB? GI>?F =;H <? MCGJFCW?> ;M
+
,
N F
F FN (
F
BN YFN
F N F ! F FN (
QCNB ! F
F F 0B?L?@IL?
NB? JILN@IFCI YFN B;M ?R;=NFS NB? M;G? NCG?
P;LC;NCIH ;M NB? RNB @;=NIL
MI NB;N CN =;H <? =;FF?> @;=NILL?JL?M?HNCHA JILN
@IFCI 0BCM JLIJ?LNS CH>C=;N?M NB;N NB? CH@ILG;NCIH CH NB? @;=NILL?JL?M?HNCHA
JILN@IFCIM CM MO^=C?HN @IL JL?>C=NCHA NB? P;LC;H=?M ;H> =IP;LC;H=?M I@ CH>CPC>
O;F ;MM?N L?NOLHM %@ Q? ;MMOG? NB;N NB? >SH;GC=M I@ ?;=B =IGJIH?HN FN CM
%H NB? =;M? QB?L? & ;H> =& ;L? =ILL?F;N?> QCNB =IHMN;HN =ILL?F;NCIH G;NLCR
Q?
;FMI I<N;CH
QCNB NB? =IHMN;HN G;NLCR L?ALIOJCHA N?LGM I@ NB? =IP;LC;H=?
G;NLCR I@ & ;H> NB? =IH>CNCIH;F =IP;LC;H=? G;NLCR I@ & ;H> =&
)I>?FCHA ILL?F;NCIH
"CH;FFS
C@ 7 ) U
Q? =;H ;FQ;SM =IHMNLO=N U 7 JILN@IFCIM I@ ;MM?NM
C?
FCH?;L =IG<CH;NCIHM I@ _N
QBC=B B;P? =IHMN;HN P;LC;H=?
!;=18087*5 68-.5<
0B? +LNBIAIH;F #.$ GI>?F IL +#.$ B;M <??H JLIJIM?> <S F?R;H
>?L ;H> BC<OG<; ;H> F?R;H>?L %N ;MMOG?M NB;N NB? I<M?LP?>
>;N; =;H <? I<N;CH?> <S ; FCH?;L NL;HM@ILG;NCIH I@ ; M?N I@ OH=ILL?F;N?> =IG
JIH?HNM ;H> NB? G;NLCR I@ NB? FCH?;L NL;HM@ILG;NCIH CM ;H ILNBIAIH;F G;NLCR
0B? U( U
=IP;LC;H=? G;NLCR N CM A?H?L;N?> <S T OHCP;LC;N? #.$ GI>
?FM
QB?L? T
U CM >?N?LGCH?> OMCHA JLCH=CJ;F =IGJIH?HN ;H;FSMCM 0B? G;CH
CHN?L?MN I@ NBCM ;JJLI;=B CM NB;N CN ;PIC>M ?MNCG;NCHA I_>C;AIH;F =IGJIH?HNM
I@ NB? GOFNCP;LC;N? #.$ J;L;G?N?L G;NLC=?M
<?=;OM? NB? GI>?F CM ?MNC
G;N?> HIN QCNB ILCACH;F >;N; <ON QCNB CNM JLCH=CJ;F =IGJIH?HNM NB;N ;L? <S
=IHMNLO=NCIH OH=IH>CNCIH;FFS OH=ILL?F;N?>
0B? WLMN MN?J CM NI =IGJON? NB? M;GJF? U( U
=ILL?F;NCIH I@ NB?
G;NLCR >
U HILG;FCT?> CHHIP;NCIHM \N 0 #N ( QB?L? 0 >C;A ( ( I QCNB
\N B+ MN (
B+ <+ + <+ >C;A ( ( + (
QB?L? + CM NB? 7( 7
>C;AIH;F G;NLCR I@ ?CA?HP;FO?M I@ > L;HE?> @LIG NB?
F;LA?MN NI NB? MG;FF?MN
+
<+ NB? ;MMI=C;N?> U( 7
ILNBIAIH;F
G;NLCR I@ ?CA?HP?=NILM
;H> B+ <+ + 0B? OH=IH>CNCIH;F =IP;LC;H=? I@ MN
CM NB? C>?HNCNS G;NLCR I@ IL>?L 7
<S =IHMNLO=NCIH 0B? =IH>CNCIH;F =IP;LC;H=?
G;NLCR I@ MN CM ;MMOG?> NI <? ; >C;AIH;F G;NLCR >?HIN?> =N QB?L? ?;=B
>C;AIH;F ?F?G?HN CM MJ?=CW?> ;M ; OHCP;LC;N? #.$ GI>?F 0B? P?=NIL I@
1N MN (
BN MN =N >C;A A N ( ( A N (
J K
J K
, , , ,
A N
DC DC
DC MDNC DC A NC '
C C C C
"CH;FFS
NB? =IH>CNCIH;F =IP;LC;H=? G;NLCR I@ #N CM MCGJFS ACP?H <S
)OFNCP;LC;N? #.$ GI>?FM
QB?L?
>N BN \N BH =N BH
'
0B? J;L;G?N?LM NI <? ?MNCG;N?> ;L? NB? @IFFIQCHA 0B? CH>CPC>O;F P;LC;H=?M D
I@ #N CH=FO>?> CH 0
NB? M;GJF? =ILL?F;NCIH G;NLCR I@ \N NB? >?=IGJIMCNCIH
I@ QBC=B JLIPC>?M OM QCNB BH
;H> NB? J;L;G?N?LM
DC ;H> DC
@IL P
( ( 7 I@ NB? OHCP;LC;N? #.$ GI>?FM 3? HINC=? NB;N NB? CH>CPC>O;F
P;LC;H=?M D =;H <? ?MNCG;N?> <S NB? M;GJF? ;H;FIAO? I@ 0' %H ;>>CNCIH
IH=?
NB? HOG<?L I@ @;=NILM 7 CM =BIM?H
B+ =;H <? =IGJON?> >CL?=NFS @LIG NB?
M;GJF? =IOHN?LJ;LN I@ > IHM?KO?HNFS
NB? ?MNCG;NCIH <OL>?H L?>O=?M CNM?F@
NI NB? ?MNCG;NCIH I@ NB? CH>CPC>O;F #.$ GI>?FM @IL NB? 7 @;=NILM
0B? +#.$ GI>?F CGJFC=CNFS ;MMOG?M NB;N NB? I<M?LP?> >;N; =;H <?
FCH?;LFS NL;HM@ILG?> CHNI ; M?N I@ OH=ILL?F;N?> =IGJIH?HNM <S G?;HM I@ ;H
ILNBIAIH;F G;NLCR 0B?M? OHI<M?LP?> =IGJIH?HNM =;H <? CHN?LJL?N?> ;M ; M?N
I@ OH=ILL?F;N?> @;=NILM NB;N >LCP? NB? G;LE?N
MCGCF;L NI NB;N CH NB? "#.$
GI>?F 0B? ILNBIAIH;FCNS ;MMOGJNCIH ;JJ?;LM NI <? L;NB?L L?MNLC=NCP?
BIQ
?P?L 2;H >?L 3?C>? B;M JLIJIM?> NB? #?H?L;FCT?> +LNBIAIH;F #.$
GI>?F IL #+#.$
CH QBC=B CHHIP;NCIHM ;L? FCHE?> <S ;HS JIMMC<F? CH
P?LNC<F? G;NLCR "IL NBCM JOLJIM?
B? ;LAO?M NB;N
QB?H B CM NB? G;J NB;N
FCHEM NB? OH=ILL?F;N?> =IGJIH?HNM MN QCNB NB? I<M?LP?> JLI=?MM \N
NB?H NB?L?
?RCMNM ;H ILNBIAIH;F G;NLCR A MO=B NB;N B < A
QCNB )A )
0B?
+#.$ GI>?F CGJFC=CNFS ;MMOG?M A 5+
0B? G;NLCR* A =;H <? L?JL?M?HN?> ;M ; JLI>O=N I@ 7 7
* LIN;NCIH
G;NLC=?M A DE 3DE DE
QCNB
DE
QB?L? 3DE DE
J?L@ILGM
; LIN;NCIH CH NB? JF;H MJ;HH?> <S LD ;H> LE IP?L ;H ;HAF? DE @IL P( Q
( ( U( ;H> LD CM NB? PNB =IFOGH I@ NB? U( U
C>?HNCNS G;NLCR 0B? =IH>CNCIH;F
=IP;LC;H=? G;NLCR I@ #N B;M NB? M;G? ?RJL?MMCIH ;M <?@IL?
QB?L?
>N BN \N B =N B
(
QCNB B < A' 0B? #+#.$ GI>?F CM MN;NCIH;LS
JLIPC>?> NB? CH
>?J?H>?HN #.$ JLI=?MM?M ;L? MN;NCIH;LS %H NB? =;M? QB?L? 7 U
NB?
+#.$ GI>?F =;H <? PC?Q?> ;M ; #+#.$ @IL NB? J;LNC=OF;L =BIC=?
A 5I *IN? ;FMI NB;N NB? #+#.$ GI>?F CM ; MJ?=C;F =;M? I@ NB? !''
GI>?F
MI NB;N CNM JLIJ?LNC?M =;H <? >?LCP?> @LIG NBIM? I@ NB? !'' GI>?F
M @IL NB? +#.$ GI>?F
;H ?MNCG;N? I@ NB? J;L;G?N?LM CH 0 ;H> B =;H
<? I<N;CH?> @LIG NB? M;GJF? ;H;FIAO?M I@ 0 ;H> > 0B?L?@IL?
NB? L?G;CHCHA
J;L;G?N?LM NI <? ?MNCG;N?> ;L? NB? J;L;G?N?LM
DC ;H> DC
@IL P
( ( 7
I@ NB? OHCP;LC;N? #.$ GI>?FM ;H> NB? 7 7
* LIN;NCIH ;HAF?M DE
.?F;N?> ;JJLI;=B?M B;P? <??H @IFFIQ?> <S 2LIHNIM
?FF;JILN;M
;H> ,IFCNCM
;H> <S (;HH? ;H> /;CEEIH?H
)I>?FCHA ILL?F;NCIH
HINB?L ;JJLI;=B =;H <? N;E?H CH IL>?L NI L?>O=? NB? =IGJON;NCIH;F <OL>?H
I@ F;LA?M=;F? GOFNCP;LC;N? #.$ GI>?FM )IMN GI>?FM >?M=LC<?> CH /?=NCIH
;L? >?MCAH?> NI L?>O=? NB? HOG<?L I@ J;L;G?N?LM NI <? ?MNCG;N?> "CLMN
A?H?L;NCIH GI>?FM CGJIM? MIG? ;>>CNCIH;F MNLO=NOL? IH NB? A?H?L;F MJ?=CW=;
NCIH "#.$ GI>?FM MOGG;LCT? NB? CH@ILG;NCIH CH ;MM?N L?NOLHM NBLIOAB
@;=NILM S =IHNL;MN
NB? X?RC<F? #.$ GI>?F JLIJIM?> <S (?>ICN
/;HN;
F;L;
;H> 3IF@ >I?M HIN NLS NI L?>O=? NB? HOG<?L I@ J;L;G?N?LM <ON
CHMN?;> >?=?HNL;FCT? NB? ?MNCG;NCIH JLI<F?G
MMOG? NB;N Q? B;P? NI ?MNCG;N? ; >C;AIH;F P?= GI>?F I@ NB? @ILG
QB?L? NB? =IH>CNCIH;F =IP;LC;H=? DEN <?NQ??H ;MM?NM P ;H> Q >?J?H>M IH CNM
IQH F;A ;H> IH NB? =LIMMJLI>O=N <?NQ??H F;AA?> CHHIP;NCIHM #DN ;H> #EN
%H NBCM =;M?
@IL ?;=B =IP;LC;H=?
Q? B;P? J;L;G?N?LM NI ?MNCG;N?
MI NB;N
@IL U ;MM?NM
Q? QIOF> B;P? U U
* J;L;G?N?LM 0B? C>?; I@ NB? X?RC<F?
#.$ GI>?F =IHMCMNM CH ?MNCG;NCHA NB? J;L;G?N?LM " DE (
DE ( DE @IL ?;=B
P( Q
M?J;L;N?FS 0BOM
NB? JLI<F?G L?>O=?M NI ?MNCG;NCHA IH?>CG?HMCIH;F
QB?H P Q IL NQI>CG?HMCIH;F QB?H P Q GI>?FM 0B? >C^=OFNS NB?H CM NI
=IG<CH? NB? P;LCIOM ?MNCG;N?M CHNI G;NLC=?M '
" DE (
- '
DE ( ;H> .
' DE ( /CH=? NB? ?MNCG;N?> J;L;G?N?LM =IG? @LIG CH>?J?H>?HN ?MNCG;NCIHM
NB? =IP;LC;H=? G;NLCR N CM HIN AO;L;HN??> NI <? JIMCNCP? M?GC>?WHCN? 0BOM
QCNB " DD +
DD
DD ( ;H>
DD DD )
+_>C;AIH;F ?F?G?HNM DEN
;L? ?MNCG;N?> OMCHA NB? <CP;LC;N? #.$ GI>?F @IL ;MM?NM P ;H> Q
#DEN DEN aDEN
QB?L?
#DN aDN DDN DEN
#DEN ( aDEN ( DEN (
#EN aEN DEN
EEN
;H>
DEN " DE
DE #DN #EN DE DEN '
0B? P?=NIL aDEN CM ;MMOG?> NI <? HILG;F ( 5
0B?L?@IL?
CH NB? <CP;LC;N?
GI>?F
IHFS NB? J;L;G?N?LM J?LN;CHCHA NI NB? =IP;LC;H=? DEN ;L? ?MNCG;N?>
;H> NB? =IH>CNCIH;F P;LC;H=?M DDN ;H> EEN ;L? WR?> NI NB?CL WLMNMN;A? P;FO?M
DDN ;H>
EEN %H IL>?L NI ?HMOL? NB;N DEN CM JIMCNCP? >?WHCN?
Q? CGJIM? NB?
8 8
@IFFIQCHA <IOH>M >OLCHA NB? ?MNCG;NCIH )" DE )
" DD "
EE
DE
DD
EE
9
;H>
DE DD EE
0B?H
(?>ICN
/;HN;F;L;
;H> 3IF@ MBIQ BIQ NI L?H>?L NB? <C
P;LC;N? ?MNCG;N?M =IGJ;NC<F? CH NB? M?HM? NB;N G;NLCR N CM JIMCNCP? >?WHCN?
1MCHA NB? G;NLCR HIN;NCIH @IL NB? >C;AIH;F P?= GI>?F
N -
#N #
N .
N (
;H> >?HINCHA NB? ?F?G?HNQCM? >CPCMCIH
NB?S MBIQ NB;N NB? =IH>CNCIH;F
=IP;LC;H=? G;NLCR N CM JIMCNCP? M?GC>?WHCN? C@ NB? NBL?? G;NLC=?M 0
5I .
-
;H> . ;L? JIMCNCP? M?GC>?WHCN?
;H>
DD DD )
P
( ( U *IQ
C@ Q? >?WH? 0 5I .
Q? H??> NI NL;HM@ILG
NB? ?MNCG;N?> J;L;G?N?L G;NLC=?M -
.
0
'%(
0 0
%
0 CM JIMCNCP? M?GC>?WHCN? ;H> K0DD KDD ( P
( ( U(
MN 0
'%(
-0 -
"
0
'%(
. .
#
)0 0 ) )
P( Q
( ( U 0B?L?@IL?
CN CM MO^=C?HN NI CGJIM? NB;N
DE DD
DE
DD )
P
( ( U NI ?HMOL? JIMCNCP? M?GC>?WHCN?H?MM I@ NB? =IH>CNCIH;F
=IP;LC;H=? G;NLCR
>L;Q<;=E I@ NBCM ;JJLI;=B CM NB;N NB?L? CM HI MNL;CABN@ILQ;L> Q;S NI
=IGJON? NB? MN;H>;L> ?LLILM I@ NB? J;L;G?N?L ?MNCG;N?M 0B? L?;MIH CM NB;N
NB? H?Q G;NLC=?M -
0 .
0 ;H> 00 ;L? P?LS HIHFCH?;L NL;HM@ILG;NCIHM I@ NB? CHCNC;F
G;NLC=?M -
.
;H> 0 @IL QBC=B MN;H>;L> ?LLILM ;L? ;P;CF;<F? (?>ICN
/;HN;
F;L;
;H> 3IF@ MOAA?MN NB? OM? I@ NB? <IINMNL;J JLI=?>OL? NI I<N;CH
MN;H>;L> ?LLILM %N MBIOF> <? HINC=?> NB;N @IL F;LA?M=;F? GOFNCP;LC;N? #.$
GI>?FM
NB? H??> @IL MO=B MN;H>;L> ?LLILM CM HIN =F?;L
)I>?FCHA ILL?F;NCIH
=N
= \N \N =N (
QB?L? = CM NB? OH=IH>CNCIH;F =IP;LC;H=? G;NLCR I@ \N '#DN * DN (
D I ;H>
>C;A =N
CM NB? U( U
G;NLCR QCNB NB? >C;AIH;F I@ =N IH NB? >C;AIH;F ;H>
T?LIM G;S <? ?MNCG;N?> <S NB? M;GJF? ;H;FIAO?
)4 I_>C;AIH;F
0B? G;NLCR =
4 \
N N N\
' ,;L;G?N?LM ;H> ;L? ;MMOG?> NI M;NCM@S
(
;H>
+H=? NB?M? L?MNLC=NCIHM ;L? CGJIM?>
NB? =IH>CNCIH;F =ILL?F;NCIH
G;NLCR >N CM AO;L;HN??> NI <? JIMCNCP? >?WHCN? >OLCHA NB? ?MNCG;NCIH
>L;Q<;=E I@ NBCM ;JJLI;=B CM NB;N IHFS NQI ;>>CNCIH;F J;L;G?N?LM ;H>
>LCP? NB? >SH;GC=M I@ ;FF NB? =ILL?F;NCIHM ;JJC?FFI
!HAF?
;H> /B?JJ;L>
B;P? L?=?HNFS MOAA?MN?> ;H ?RN?HMCIH I@ NBCM GI>?F CH QBC=B ?;=B ?F?
G?HN I@ NB? =ILL?F;NCIH G;NLCR B;M ;H ;ONIHIGIOM ;H> ;MSGG?NLC= >SH;GC=M
>N >C;A =N
=N >C;A =N
(
=N = - =- . =. 3 : 3 -
\N \
N -
.
=N . 3
UN U
N 3(
)I>?FCHA ILL?F;NCIH
QB?L? -
. ;H> 3 ;L? U( U
>C;AIH;F J;L;G?N?L G;NLC=?M ;H> UN
O*
\N
CM NB? U(
P?=NIL NB;N =IHN;CHM NB? HILG;FCT?> L?MC>O;F C@ CN CM H?A;NCP? ;H>
INB?LQCM? = 1\N \
N ;H> : 1UN U
N ;L? ?MNCG;N?> <S NB?CL M;GJF?
)4
)4
;H;FIAO?M 4 N \ N \
N ;H> 4 N U
N
NU
0B? =IH>CNCIH;F =IP;LC;H=?
G;NLCR N 0N >N 0N CM AO;L;HN??> NI
<? JIMCNCP? >?WHCN? C@ = - =- . =. 3 : 3 CM JIMCNCP? >?WHCN? 0B?
GI>?F + I@ !HAF? + CM I<N;CH?> ;M ; MJ?=C;F =;M? C@ 3 ;H> C@ -
;H> . B;P? ;H> IH NB? >C;AIH;F
L?MJ?=NCP?FS
0B? C>?; I@ 0M? ;H> 0MOC CM NI MJ?=C@S NB? >SH;GC= I@ NB? =IH>CNCIH;F
=ILL?F;NCIH G;NLCR >N ;M ;H .) JLI=?MM
>N
> >N N (
QB?L? > DE CM ; NCG?CHP;LC;HN U( U
G;NLCR I@ =ILL?F;NCIHM ;M CH
0B? E?S C>?; I@ 0M? ;H> 0MOC CM NI GI>?F NB? U( U
G;NLCR N ! DEN
OMCHA ; M?N I@ J;MN HILG;FCT?> I<M?LP;NCIHM
)H
C \DNC \ENC
! DEN : ) @IL
P ) Q
U(
)H H
\
C DNC \
C ENC
)
H
C@ Q? >?WH? .N NB? U( U
>C;AIH;F G;NLCR QCNB C \DNC ;M PNB >C
;AIH;F ?F?G?HN
Q? =;H L?QLCN? N ;M
N .N 1N 1N
.N ! DEN '
M FIHA ;M T U
NB? G;NLCR N QCFF <? CH A?H?L;F JIMCNCP? >?WHCN?
I@ =IOLM?
C@ NB? \DN ;L? HIN FCH?;LFS >?J?H>?HN 0I ?HMOL? JIMCNCP? >?WHCN?H?MM I@ NB?
G;NLCR >N
NB? J;L;G?N?LM ;H> B;P? NI M;NCM@S
(
;H>
*IN? NB;N NB? =IHMN;HN =IH>CNCIH;F =ILL?F;NCIH GI>?F CM H?MN?>
CH NBCM GI>?F
<?=;OM? CN =ILL?MJIH>M NI NB? =;M? QB?L? 0CG?
P;LC;<CFCNS CH NB? =IH>CNCIH;F =ILL?F;NCIH G;NLCR CM NB?L?@IL? I<N;CH?> ;N NB?
=IMN I@ IHFS NQI ;>>CNCIH;F J;L;G?N?LM
3BCF? NB? GI>?F JLIJIM?> <S 0M? ;H> 0MOC <OCF>M IH ;H .)
JLI=?MM @IL NB? >SH;GC=M I@ NB? =ILL?F;NCIH G;NLCR
NB? GI>?F I@ !HAF?
CM <;M?> IH ; #.$NSJ? MJ?=CW=;NCIH @IL NB? >SH;GC=M I@ NB? =IP;LC;H=?
G;NLCR H ;>P;HN;A? I@ NB? F;NN?L ;JJLI;=B CM NB;N NB? >SH;GC= I@ =N CM
<;M?> IH ; MCHAF? F;A I@ NB? \DN N?LGM ;M CH NB? MN;H>;L> #.$
(
GI>?F
QB?L?;M L?KOCL?M ;H ;L<CNL;LS HOG<?L T I@ I<M?LP;NCIHM NI =IG
JON? M;GJF? =ILL?F;NCIHM
)OFNCP;LC;N? #.$ GI>?FM
A?H?L;FCT;NCIH I@ GIMN I@ NB? JL?PCIOM GI>?FM B;M <??H >?P?FIJ?> <S 'LIH?L
;H> *A 0B? MI=;FF?> A?H?L;F >SH;GC= =IP;LC;H=? # GI>?F H?MNM
G;HS I@ NB? ?RCMNCHA GI>?FM QBCF? CH=FO>CHA ;MSGG?NLC= ?_?=NM 0B? GI>?F CM
>?WH?> ;M @IFFIQM
N 0N >0N
N (
8
0N 'KDEN ( QCNB KDDN DDN
P ;H> KDEN
P Q(
N 'DEN ( (
DEN " DE H
D #N #
N HD ID N I
D P( Q(
> DE QCNB DD
P(
&DE QCNB &DD
P ;H> &DE &ED
P( Q(
QB?L? HD
ID
P
( ( U
;L? U(
J;L;G?N?L P?=NILM
DE
&DE
;H> " DE ;L?
M=;F;LM QCNB '" DE ( ;H> > JIMCNCP? >?WHCN? ;H> MSGG?NLC= G;NLC=?M
0B? # GI>?F B;M NQI =IGJIH?HNM NB? WLMN N?LG 0N >0N CM FCE? NB?
=IHMN;HN =ILL?F;NCIH GI>?F <ON QCNB NB? P;LC;H=? @OH=NCIHM ACP?H <S NB;N I@
NB? !'' GI>?F 0B? M?=IH> N?LG
N B;M T?LI >C;AIH;F ?F?G?HNM <ON
B;M I_>C;AIH;F ?F?G?HNM ACP?H <S NB? !''NSJ? =IP;LC;H=? @OH=NCIHM *IN?
NB;N NB? ?F?G?HNM I@ N =;H <? QLCNN?H ;M
0BOM
NB? # GI>?F CM ; BS<LC> I@ NB? =IHMN;HN =IH>CNCIH;F =ILL?F;NCIH GI>?F
;H> NB? !'' GI>?F
";898<2=287 ?<;2? .;1 "4 <;@612? A52 3<99<D6;4 @2A <3 0<;
16A6<;@
DE P Q'
HD
D LD .;1 ID D LD P D52?2 LD 6@ A52 PA5 0<9B:; <3 .; U( U
612;A6AF
:.A?6E .;1
D .;1 D P
( ( U .?2 @0.9.?@
&DE P Q'
&DE
P Q'
I I
-
"
.;1 . "
D52?2 - 'HD (D . 'ID (D " .;1
.?2 U(
C20A<?@ .;1
.;1 .?2 @0.9.?@
(52 :<129 ?21B02@ A< @2C2?.9 :B9A6C.?6.A2 & :<129@ B;12? 163
32?2;A 0<:/6;.A6<;@ <3 A52@2 0<;16A6<;@ '=206H0.99F A52 :<129 /20<:2@
. ?2@A?60A21 C205 :<129 D6A5 A52 ?2@A?60A6<;@ DE DD EE .;1
DE
DD
EE
B;12? 0<;16A6<;@ 6 .;1 66 A52 0<;@A.;A 0<;16A6<;.9 0<??29.A6<; :<129 B;12?
0<;16A6<;@ 66 .1 666 A52 :<129 B;12? 0<;16A6<;@ 6 .;1 6C .;1
A52 & :<129 B;12? 0<;16A6<;@ 6 6C .;1 C
)I>?FCHA ILL?F;NCIH
'LIH?L ;H> *A ;FMI >?P?FIJ ;H ?RN?HMCIH NI NB? # NB;N ;FFIQM @IL
;MSGG?NLS 0B? ;MSGG?NLC= >SH;GC= =IP;LC;H=? GI>?F B;M NB? M;G?
MNLO=NOL? ;M NB? # GI>?F
?R=?JN NB;N NB? ?KO;NCIH @IL DEN CH=ILJIL;N?M
NB? F?P?L;A? ?_?=N CH NB? !'' GI>?F
CH ; Q;S =FIM? NI NB? #&. GI>?F
DEN " DE H
D #N #
N HD ID N I
D ND
N
N ND P( Q(
<=26*=287 2<<>.<
*A26>6 524.52188-
3? MOJJIM? HIQ NB;N Q? B;P? ; M;GJF? I@ MCT? @ I@ NB? U(
P?=NIL I@ I<M?LP;
4
NCIHM QLCNN?H ;M _4 '_N (N QCNB =IH>CNCIH;F G?;H ;H> =IH>CNCIH;F P;LC;H=?
ACP?H <S ;H> 1HEHIQH J;L;G?N?LM ;L? L?ALIOJ?> CH 1H>?L NB?
;MMOGJNCIH I@ =IH>CNCIH;F GOFNCP;LC;N? HILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH
NB? FIAFCE?FCBII>
@OH=NCIH @IL _4 CM
,4
84 )_4
GN
(
N
QCNB
U
GN
&)#
&)# )N
) _N N
N
_N N
(
QB?L? NB? N?LG &)# )N
) =IG?M @LIG NB? &;=I<C;H I@ NB? NL;HM@ILG;NCIH
@LIG NB? CHHIP;NCIH JLI=?MM NI NB? I<M?LP?> P;LC;<F?M
0B?H
NB? )( ?MNCG;NIL - ,
NB;N G;RCGCT?M
CM ;MSGJNINC=;FFS HIL
G;F QCNB ;MSGJNINC= >CMNLC<ONCIH
+
@ - , ( -
(
NB;N NB? FIAFCE?FCBII> =;H <? QLCNN?H ;M NB? MOG I@ ; PIF;NCFCNS J;LN ;H> ;
=ILL?F;NCIH J;LN /CH=? N 0N >N 0N
Q? B;P?
<?=;OM? 0N CM >C;AIH;F
;H>
_N N
N _N N
_N N
0N >N 0N _N N
\
N >N \N _N N
0N _N N
\
N \N (
QB?L? \N 0N #N CM ; P?=NIL I@ HILG;FCT?> CHHIP;NCIHM 0B? F;MN NQI N?LGM
I@ NB? M?=IH> ?KO;FCNS ;L? =F?;LFS ?KO;F
<ON NBCM ?RJL?MMCIH ;FFIQM IH? NI <L?;E
>IQH NB? FIAFCE?FCBII> CH NB? NQI @IFFIQCHA N?LGM
G 6 ( $ )_4
G6 6 )_4
G$ 6 ( $ )_4
(
QCNB
, 4U 5
4
G6 6 )_4
&)#
&)# )0N ) _N N
0N _N N
N
I
4
, @
, _DN DN
&)#
&)# DN (
D
N DN
4
,
G$ 6 ( $ )_4
&)# )>N ) \
N >N \N \
N \N '
N
;H> NB?H
4
,
$ +# ' / G$ 6 ( $ )_4
N >N \
&)# )>N ) \
N \
N \ N (
N
QB?L? \
DN YDN
DN *
DN '
)I>?FCHA ILL?F;NCIH
!HAF? ;H> /B?JJ;L> MBIQ NB;N NB? NQIMN?J ?MNCG;NIL 4 3
6 ( $
QB?L?
! ;
!
!
- ! ;
! ;
(
!
!
!
!
4 4
, ,G
6 6
, ,G
$
. B + (+ '
@ N ,6 @ N ,$
O? NI NB? MNLO=NOL? I@ -
NB? ;MSGJNINC= P;LC;H=?M I@ NB? #.$ J;L;G?
N?LM 6 @IL ?;=B M?LC?M ;L? NB? MN;H>;L> LI<OMN =IP;LC;H=? G;NLCR ?MNCG;NILM
"IL NB? M?=IH>MN;A? J;L;G?N?LM
BIQ?P?L
NB? ;MSGJNINC= P;LC;H=? CHPIFP?M
;FF J;L;G?N?LM
/CH=? NB? NQI M?NM I@ J;L;G?N?LM ;L? ?MNCG;N?> OMCHA FCGCN?> CH@ILG;NCIH
%9.,2D,*=287 =.<=<
O? NI CNM =IGJON;NCIH;F <OL>?H
CN CM CGJILN;HN NI N?MN QB?NB?L ; GOFNC
P;LC;N? #.$ GI>?F CM ;<F? NI WN NB? >;N; =ILL?=NFS WLMN JL?FCGCH;LS
N?MN QIOF> <? NI ?P;FO;N? NB? ;<CFCNS I@ OHCP;LC;N? #.$ GI>?FM NI =IL
L?=NFS >?M=LC<? NB? >;N; @IL ?;=B M?LC?M $IQ?P?L
MO=B ;H ;JJLI;=B =;HHIN <?
L?=IGG?H>?>
<?=;OM? CN >I?M HIN N;E? CHNI ;==IOHN NB? JIMMC<F? =ILL?F;NCIH
<?NQ??H NB? M?LC?M
QBC=B CM ;=NO;FFS NB? G;CH =B;L;=N?LCMNC= I@ GOFNCP;LC;N?
GI>?FM 0B?L?@IL?
GOFNCP;LC;N? N?MNM ;L? H??>?>
3? >I HIN @I=OM CH NBCM M?=NCIH IH NB? >?N?=NCIH I@ HIHHILG;FCNS CH ; GOF
NCP;LC;N? #.$ =IHN?RN 0B? CMMO? I@ >?;FCHA QCNB HIHHILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIHM
CM ;>>L?MM?> CH NB? H?RN M?=NCIH >?PIN?> NI NB? GI>?FCHA I@ GOFNCP;LC;N? GI>
?FM QCNB HIHHILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIHM 3? NBOM =IHMC>?L N?MNM I@ #.$ ?_?=NM
$.<2->*5+*<.- <=*=2<=2,<
H;NOL;F >C;AHIMNC= N?MN @IL NB? GOFNCP;LC;N? #.$ GI>?F
JLIJIM?> <S
0M?
CM <;M?> IH NB? L?AL?MMCIH I@ =LIMMJLI>O=NM I@ NB? MN;H>;L>CT?>
L?MC>O;FM aDN aEN IH IQH F;AM ;M @IFFIQM
)OFNCP;LC;N? #.$ GI>?FM
J
,
aDN aEN
DEN
FDE aDNF aENF
DENF DEN (
F
@IL P( Q
( ( U
Q + P' 0B? =BIC=? I@ ?RJF;H;NILS P;LC;<F?M CH NB?M? L?AL?M
MCIHM G;S NB?IL?NC=;FFS >C_?L @LIG IH? ?R?L=CM? NI NB? INB?L
>?J?H>CHA IH
NB? NSJ? I@ >?J?H>?H=S Q? Q;HN NI N?MN %@ Q? >?HIN? KDEN aDN aEN
aDNJ aENJ
NB? N?MN MN;NCMNC= CM
DE
DE 8
>. W
@
8
DE
DE (
DE
QCNB
4
,
8DE JFCG KDEN K
DEN (
4 @ N
4 5
DE 1 aDN aEN DEN 8DE =DE 3=
DE (
4
, , aDN aEN DEN
=DE JFCG KDEN (
4 @ N ,
"8;=6*7=.*> <=*=2<=2,<
0B? (DOHAIR JILNG;HN?;O N?MN @IL M?LC;F =ILL?F;NCIH B;M <??H ?RN?H>?> NI ;
GOFNCP;LC;N? =IHN?RN <S ;CFFC? ;H> IFF?LMF?P M?? ;FMI $IMECHA
%N CM QLCNN?H ;M
,J
4 W
@ NL /D / /D / (
D
@ P
)4
QB?L? /D 4 ND _N _
_ND _
CM NB? M;GJF? ;ONI=IP;LC;H=? G;NLCR
I@ IL>?L P I@ _N 1H>?L NB? HOFF
BSJINB?MCM
I@ =IHMN;HN =ILL?F;NCIH
NB? MN;NCMNC=M
4 W
CM >CMNLC<ON?> ;M ; U W
0BCM N?MN MN;NCMNC= G;S <? OM?> NI N?MN NB? JL?M?H=? I@ .$ ?_?=NM CH
NB? MKO;L?> L?NOLHM %HNBCM =;M?
Q? >?WH? NB? U U
* P?=NIL I@ =LIMM
JLI>O=NM ;M `N ]LJO _N _
0B?H
NB? N?MN MN;NCMNC= 4 W
CM
_N _
)I>?FCHA ILL?F;NCIH
)4
?MNCG;N?> QCNB /D 4 ND `N `
`ND `
;M ; M;GJF? ;ONI=IP;LC;H=?
G;NLCR @IL NB? =IP;LC;H=?M 1H>?L NB? HOFF BSJINB?MCM I@ HI .$
?_?=N
NB?
N?MN MN;NCMNC= 4 W
CM ;MSGJNINC=;FFS >CMNLC<ON?> ;M ; U W
?L; ;H> 'CG MOAA?MN?> ;H %H@ILG;NCIH );NLCR %) N?MN @IL NB?
=IHMN;HN=ILL?F;NCIH BSJINB?MCM CH ; <CP;LC;N? #.$ GI>?F 0B? <;MC= C>?;
CM NI >?LCP? ; M=IL? N?MN I@ NB? BSJINB?MCM NB;N NB? P;LC;H=?M I@ NB? J;L;G?
N?LM I@ CHN?L?MN ;L?
MI NB;N CN >I?M HIN L?KOCL? NB? ?RJFC=CN MJ?=CW=;NCIH I@
;H ;FN?LH;NCP? BSJINB?MCM >?WHCN? ;>P;HN;A? I@ NBCM ;JJLI;=B CM NBOM NB;N
NB? N?MN MN;NCMNC= >I?M HIN >?J?H> IH ; J;LNC=OF;L MJ?=CW=;NCIH I@ =ILL?F;NCIH
P;LC;NCIHM
1H>?L NB? HOFF BSJINB?MCM I@ =IHMN;HN =ILL?F;NCIH
NB? =IH>CNCIH;F =IP;LC
;H=? G;NLCR N =;H <? QLCNN?H ;M N 0N >0N QCNB
N
0N ( ;H> > '
N
C?
)) )
"IL CHMN;H=?
CH NB? GI>?F <S 0M? ;H> 0MOC
NB? HOFF I@ =IHMN;HN =ILL?F;NCIH
MCGJFS =ILL?MJIH>M NI
)OFNCP;LC;N? #.$ GI>?FM
,GN
]N ] N
(
,
, GN
]N ] N ]N ] N
(
,
8
QB?L? ]N \N \ N ( \ N \N
*
' 0BCM CGJFC?M NB;N NB? M=IL? CM
,GN
, GN
ZN
, ,
]N ] N ]N ] N ]N ] N
'
4
,
C@ P Q(
]DN ]EN
@ N C@ P
Q'
0B?L?@IL?
Q? I<N;CH NB? CH>C=;NIL K CH NB? %) N?MN @IL NB? =IHMN;H=S I@
QB?H CM NB? )(! I@ ( ;M
N
,4 4
,
K
ZN
'
]N ] N
N
@ N
?L; ;H> 'CG ;FMI MBIQ NB;N NB? ;MSGJNINC= P;LC;H=? I@ K
CM
4+ 5
B @ K
(
)I>?FCHA ILL?F;NCIH
QBC=B =;H <? =IHMCMN?HNFS ?MNCG;N?> <S MO<MNCNONCHA NB? )(! CH JF;=? I@
0B?L?@IL? NB? N?MN MN;NCMNC= CM
)
4
@ K
N ]
N ]
N
59 / 4+ 5 '
B @ K
@
%N CM ;MSGJNINC=;FFS >CMNLC<ON?> ;M ;
OH>?L NB? HOFF I@ =IHMN;HN =ILL?F;
NCIH
0M? JLIJIM?> ; N?MN @IL NB? =IHMN;HN=ILL?F;NCIH BSJINB?MCM <;M?> IH
NB? () ;JJLI;=B 0B? C>?; CM NI ?RN?H> NB? =IHMN;HN=ILL?F;NCIH GI>?F NI
IH? NB;N CH=FO>?M NCG?P;LSCHA =ILL?F;NCIHM 3B?H =?LN;CH J;L;G?N?LM CH NB?
?RN?H>?> GI>?F ;L? CGJIM?> NI <? T?LI
NB? =IHMN;HN=ILL?F;NCIH GI>?F CM
I<N;CH?> 0B? ?RN?HMCIH JLIJIM?> <S 0M? CM MCGJFS
Z (
, N
,
;H> NB? U( U
CH@ILG;NCIH G;NLCR
, G
B 1 '
,,
H ;FN?LH;NCP? MJ?=CW=;NCIH CM NI ;FFIQ =ILL?F;NCIH NI >?J?H> IH NB? JLI>O=NM I@
NB? F;AA?> MN;H>;L>CT?> L?MC>O;FM
%H NBCM =;M?
BIQ?P?L
<?=;OM? O& >?J?H>M IH INB?L J;L;G?N?LM I@ NB? GI>?F
NBLIOAB &
;H ;H;FSNC= >?LCP;NCIH I@ NB? () MN;NCMNC= CM CHNL;=N;<F?
)OFNCP;LC;N? #.$ GI>?FM
0B?H
NB? () MN;NCMNC= @IL NB? HOFF I@ =IHMN;HN =ILL?F;NCIH CM Z
B Z
QB?L?
NB? B;NM >?HIN? ?P;FO;NCIH ;N OH>?L NB? HOFF BSJINB?MCM 0M? MOAA?MNM NI
L?JF;=? B <S NB? MOG I@ =LIMMJLI>O=NM I@ NB? WLMN >?LCP;NCP?M I@ GN
MI NB;N
89 / Z
?
? Z(
QB?L? ? CM NB? @( U
G;NLCR NB? LIQM I@ QBC=B ;L? NB? J;LNC;F >?LCP;NCP?M I@
,GN
*,
' 1H>?L NB? L?AOF;LCNS =IH>CNCIHM
89 / CM ;MSGJNINC=;FFS >CMNLC<
ON?> ;M ; U U
*
'
)IHN?;LFI MCGOF;NCIHM B;P? <??H J?L@ILG?> <S 0M? NI =IGJ;L?
NB? NQI N?MN MN;NCMNC=M 59 / ;H> 89 / FNBIOAB <INB N?MN MN;NCMNC=M ;JJ?;L
NI <? =ILL?=NFS MCT?> OH>?L NB? HOFF
NB? () N?MN CM @IOH> NI B;P? <?NN?L JIQ?L
;A;CHMN MIG? ;FN?LH;NCP?M ;H> NI <? GIL? LI<OMN NI HIHHILG;FCNS %N MBIOF>
<? HINC=?>
BIQ?P?L
NB;N NB? ;FN?LH;NCP?M =IHMC>?L?> <S 0M? ;L? =FIM?
NI NB? MJ?=CW=;NCIH B? JLIJIM?M NI GI>?F NCG?P;LC;<CFCNS CH =ILL?F;NCIHM %N CM
OH=F?;L QBC=B MN;NCMNC= QIOF> J?L@ILG <?MN @IL ;FN?LH;NCP?M NB;N ;L? >C_?L?HN
@LIG NBIM? ?HPCM;A?> <S 0M?
55><=;*=287
;H> ?E;?LN ;H> $;LP?S G?;MOL?> NB? CHN?L>?J?H>?H=? I@ L?NOLHM ;H>
PIF;NCFCNC?M ;=LIMM MNI=E G;LE?NM )IL? MJ?=CW=;FFS
(IHACH ;H> /IFHCE
N?MN?> NB? BSJINB?MCM I@ ; =IHMN;HN =IH>CNCIH;F =ILL?F;NCIH <?NQ??H ; F;LA?
HOG<?L I@ MNI=E G;LE?NM 0B?S @IOH> NB;N =ILL?F;NCIH A?H?L;FFS CH=L?;M?M CH
J?LCI>M I@ BCAB PIF;NCFCNS I@ NB? 1/ G;LE?N .?=?HN =IHNLC<ONCIHM <S 'LIH?L
;H> *A
;M Q?FF ;M !HAF? ;H> /B?JJ;L> >?P?FIJ #.$ GI>?FM
=;J;<F? I@ ?MNCG;NCHA ;H> N?MNCHA BSJINB?M?M I@ NCG?P;LSCHA =IP;LC;H=? G;
NLC=?M HA ;H> B?H >I=OG?HN NB;N >?J?H>?H=S <?NQ??H 1/ MNI=EM
;H> NB? ;AAL?A;N? 1/ G;LE?N CH=L?;M?M GIL? >OLCHA >IQHMC>? GIP?G?HNM
NB;H >OLCHA OJMC>? GIP?G?HNM
0I CFFOMNL;N? MIG? JLIJ?LNC?M I@ NB? GOFNCP;LC;N? #.$ GI>?FM >?M=LC<?>
;<IP?
Q? ?MNCG;N? M?P?L;F MJ?=CW=;NCIHM @IL NQI J;CLM I@ NCG? M?LC?M NB? /,
;H> 4 >;CFS L?NOLHM
;H> NB? /, ;H> "0/! L?NOLHM
IP?L NB? J?LCI>
@LIG NI 3? <?ACH QCNB WLMNA?H?L;NCIH GI>?FM 3? ?MNCG;N? M?P?L;F
P?LMCIHM I@ NB? <CP;LC;N? !'' GI>?F
NB? @OFF
>C;AIH;F
;H> M=;F;L P?LMCIHM
,;L;G?N?L ?MNCG;N?M ;H> FIAFCE?FCBII>M I@ NB?M? GI>?FM ;L? L?JILN?> CH 0;<F?
,;L;G?N?L ?MNCG;N?M CH>C=;N? NB;N
CH NB? @OFF !'' GI>?F
=LIMM?_?=NM
;H> ;L? CH A?H?L;F L;NB?L MG;FF ;H> CHMCAHCW=;HN 0BCM
JLIPC>?M ; L;NCIH;F? @IL NB? >C;AIH;F !'' GI>?F *IQ ;FF J;L;G?N?LM ;L?
MCAHCW=;HN M ;FL?;>S BCABFCABN?> @IL NB? OHCP;LC;N? #.$ GI>?FM
NB? MOG
I@ J;L;G?N?LM B?L?
;H>
>O? NI NB? MNLO=NOL? I@ NB? GI>?F
CM =FIM? NI S?N MG;FF?L NB;H IH? %H ;>>CNCIH
Q? HINC=? NB;N
;H>
IH
)I>?FCHA ILL?F;NCIH
IH? B;H> ;H> ;H> IH NB? INB?L B;H> ;L? L;NB?L =FIM?
MOAA?MNCHA ;
@OLNB?L L?>O=NCIH I@ NB? HOG<?L I@ J;L;G?N?LM
;MMOGCHA
;H>
0B? MI=;FF?> M=;F;L !'' GI>?F ;MMOG?M NB;N NB? P;LC;H=?M
;H> =IP;LC;H=?M B;P? NB? M;G? MNLO=NOL? ;H> NB? M;G? J;L;G?N?LM
;H>
*IQ
Q? =IGJ;L? NB? >SH;GC=M I@ =ILL?F;NCIHM ACP?H <S WLMNA?H?L;NCIH
GI>?FM QCNB NBIM? I<N;CH?> QCNB GI>?FM MJ?=CW=;FFS >?MCAH?> NI =;JNOL? NCG?
P;LSCHA =ILL?F;NCIH
H;G?FS NB? !HAF?ZM GI>?F ;H> NB? 0M? ;H>
0MOCZM 02 GI>?F 0;<F? L?JILNM J;L;G?N?L ?MNCG;N?M =ILL?MJIH>
CHA NI NB?
;H> 02 GI>?FM "CLMN
NB?S ;L? ?MNCG;N?> OMCHA NB?
NQIMN?J ;JJLI;=B JLIJIM?> CH /?=NCIH 0B?L?@IL?
NB? J;L;G?N?L ?MNC
G;N?M @IL NB? /, ;L? I<PCIOMFS NB? M;G? QB;N?P?L NB? M?=IH> L?NOLH I@
NB? J;CL /?=IH>
NB? J;L;G?N?LM
;H> CH NBCM N;<F? =;H <? CHN?LJL?N?> ;M
NB? MKO;L? I@ NB? J;L;G?N?LM CH NB? JL?PCIOM N;<F? 0B? >SH;GC=M I@ P;LC;H=?M
;L? P?LS =FIM? NI NBIM? I<N;CH?> QCNB !'' GI>?FM 0B? >C_?L?H=? L?FC?M CH
NB? ?MNCG;NCIH I@ NB? =IP;LC;H=?M
=ILL?F;NCIHM %H NB? !'' GI>?FM
=IP;LC
;H=?M ;L? L;NB?L MGIINB?>
QB?L?;M =ILL?F;NCIHM ;L? P?LS ?LL;NC= M?? "CAOL?M
;H> 3CNB NB? GI>?F
NB? =ILL?F;NCIH J;L;G?N?L CM =IHMN;HN <S
>?WHCNCIH %H =IHNL;MN
NB? ;H> 02 GI>?FM JLIPC>? P?LS MCGCF;L ;H>
MGIINB?> >SH;GC=M @IL NB? =ILL?F;NCIH J;L;G?N?L
"CAOL?M ;H> >CMJF;S NB? =IH>CNCIH;F =ILL?F;NCIH <?NQ??H NB? /,
;H> NB? 4
;H> <?NQ??H NB? /, ;H> NB? "0/!
L?MJ?=NCP?FS
;M CG
JFC?> <S NB? @OFF !'' GI>?F M CN ;JJ?;LM =F?;LFS
NB?M? =IH>CNCIH;F =ILL?
F;NCIHM ;L? P?LS ?LL;NC= "CAOL?M ;H> >CMJF;S NB? =IH>CNCIH;F =ILL?F;NCIH
I<N;CH?> QCNB NB?
;H> 02 GI>?FM "CLMN
Q? HINC=? NB;N NB?
=IH>CNCIH;F =ILL?F;NCIHM ;L? HIQ GO=B MGIINB?L NB;H NBIM? I<N;CH?> QCNB
!'' GI>?FM /?=IH>
Q? I<M?LP? NB;N NB? =ILL?F;NCIHM CGJFC?> <S NB?
;H> 02 GI>?FM ;L? <;L?FS >CMNCHAOCMB;<F? @LIG ?;=B INB?L 0B?L?@IL?
CH
G;HS ?GJCLC=;F ;JJFC=;NCIHM
NB? >CL?=N GI>?FCHA I@ NB? =IH>CNCIH;F =ILL?F;
NCIH NBLIOAB ; IL ; 02 GI>?F CM FCE?FS NI JLIPC>? ; L;NB?L M?HMC<F?
?MNCG;N? I@ NB? ?PIFONCIH CH NB? =ILL?F;NCIH J;L;G?N?L
0B? GOFNCP;LC;N? #.$ ;JJLI;=B >?M=LC<?> MI @;L ;MMOG?M NB;N NB? DICHN
>CMNLC<ONCIH I@ CHHIP;NCIHM CM HILG;F +<PCIOMFS
CN CM HIN FCE?FS NI <? NB? =;M?
CH JL;=NC=?
<?=;OM? NB? OHCP;LC;N? >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ L?NOLHM B;M A?H?L;FFS <??H
@IOH> NI <? HIHHILG;F 3? NB?L?@IL? NOLH HIQ NI NB? GI>?FCHA I@ NB? DICHN
>CMNLC<ONCIH )IL? JL?=CM?FS
Q? ;L? CHN?L?MN?> CH C>?HNC@SCHA MIG? GOFNCP;LC;N?
>CMNLC<ONCIHM NB;N G;S B?FJ =;JNOLCHA NB? ;MSGG?NLS ;H> @;NN;CF?>H?MM I@ NB?
L?NOLH >CMNLC<ONCIH
)OFNCP;LC;N? #.$ GI>?FM
&*+5. $.?.:2A2? 2@A6:.A2@ <3 C.?6<B@ @=206H0.A6<;@ <3 A52 :<129
/,] 4 /,]"0/!
!MNCG;N? /N> ?LLIL !MNCG;N? /N> ?LLIL
"OFF !'' GI>?F
8
8
8
8
9
9
9
9
FIAFCE
C;AIH;F !'' GI>?F
8
8
9
9
FIAFCE
/=;F;L !'' GI>?F
8
9
FIAFCE
)I>?FCHA ILL?F;NCIH
&*+5.
$.?.:2A2? 2@A6:.A2@ <3 A52 .;1 (* :<129@
/,] 4 /,]"0/!
!MNCG;N? /N> ?LLIL !MNCG;N? /N> ?LLIL
GI>?F
8
9
8
9
FIAFCE
GI>?F
8
9
8
9
FIAFCE
02 GI>?F
8
9
8
9
FIAFCE
)OFNCP;LC;N? #.$ GI>?FM
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
-0.2
-0.4
1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005
20 '$
1
CC C
DC C
0.8 TVC
0.6
0.4
0.2
-0.2
-0.4
1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005
20
'$
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
-0.2
-0.4
1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005
20 '$
1
CC C
DC C
0.8 TVC
0.6
0.4
0.2
-0.2
-0.4
1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005
20 '$
8-.5270 =1. 6>5=2?*;2*=. -2<=;2+>=287
3? HIQ ;MMOG? NB;N NB? >SH;GC= I@ NB? NCG?M?LC?M _N _N ( ( _IN
CM NB?
661 L;H>IG P?=NIL I@ >CG?HMCIH U(
QCNB ; T?LI G?;H ;H> C>?HNCNS P;LC;H=?
G;NLCR 0B?L? ;L? M?P?L;F JIMMC<CFCNC?M NI I<N;CH N ' 0B? WLMN ;H> JLI<;
<FS GIMN =IGGIH IH? CM NB? BIF?MES >?=IGJIMCNCIH
QB?L? N CM ; FIQ?L
NLC;HAOF;L G;NLCR HINB?L JIMMC<CFCNS CM <;M?> IH NB? ?CA?HP?=NIL >?=IGJI
MCNCIH
N N 0N N
QB?L? N CM NB? G;NLCR I@ ?CA?HP?=NILM
MN;H>;L>CT?> NI
OHCN F?HANB
;H> 0N CM NB? >C;AIH;F G;NLCR I@ ?CA?HP;FO?M S =IHMNLO=NCIH
Q? B;P? N N 5N ' 0B?H
N N 0N ( QB?L? 0N CM NB? G;NLCR QBIM?
>C;AIH;F ?F?G?HNM ;L? NB? MKO;L? LIINM I@ NB? ?CA?HP;FO?M 2?=NIL CH=FO>?M
;FF J;L;G?N?LM I@ NB? =IH>CNCIH;F G?;H ;H> P;LC;H=? ?KO;NCIHM M MJ?=CW?>
CH
NB? =IH>CNCIH;F >CMNLC<ONCIH CM N
QCNB MB;J? J;L;G?N?LM
M CH NB? OHCP;LC;N? =;M?
NB? =BIC=? I@ NB? =IH>CNCIH;F >CMNLC<ONCIH N '
CM
=LO=C;F !HAF? ;H> #IHTcF?T.CP?L; ;H> *?Q?S ;H> /N?CA?LQ;F>
B;P? MBIQH NB;N NB? @IFFIQCHA L?MOFNM BIF> C 1H>?L NB? ;MMOGJNCIH I@ ;
=ILL?=N MJ?=CW=;NCIH I@ NB? =IH>CNCIH;F G?;H ;H> P;LC;H=? G;NLCR
NB? )(
?MNCG;NCIH
;MMOGCHA aN NI <? 661 QCNB ; #;OMMC;H >CMNLC<ONCIH
JLIPC>?M =IH
MCMN?HN ?MNCG;NILM
?P?H QB?H NB? #;OMMC;H ;MMOGJNCIH >I?M HIN BIF> CC 0B?
)( ?MNCG;NIL L?FSCHA IH ; #;OMMC;H >CMNLC<ONCIH CM CH?^=C?HN
BIQ?P?L
QCNB
NB? >?AL?? I@ CH?^=C?H=S CH=L?;MCHA QCNB NB? >?AL?? I@ >?J;LNOL? @LIG HIL
G;FCNS CCC 0B? )( ?MNCG;NCIH
;MMOGCHA aN NI <? 661 QCNB ; HIH#;OMMC;H
>CMNLC<ONCIH
JLIPC>?M GIL? ?^=C?HN ?MNCG;NILM NB;H NB? #;OMMC;H )(
QB?H
NB? ;MMOGJNCIH G;>? IH NB? CHHIP;NCIH JLI=?MM BIF>M CP 3B?H NB? ;MMOGJ
NCIH G;>? IH NB? CHHIP;NCIH JLI=?MM >I?M HIN BIF>
NB? )( ?MNCG;NCIH L?FSCHA
IH ; HIH#;OMMC;H >CMNLC<ONCIH JLIPC>?M CH=IHMCMN?HN ?MNCG;NILM
HINB?L >C^=OFNS CH NB? GOFNCP;LC;N? =;M? =IG?M @LIG NB? Q;S >?J?H>?H=S
<?NQ??H P;LC;<F?M CM CHNLI>O=?> %H NB? #;OMMC;H @L;G?QILE
>?J?H>?H=S CM
CHNLI>O=?> NBLIOAB NB? =IP;LC;H=? G;NLCR 0B? GOFNCP;LC;N? #;OMMC;H >CMNLC
<ONCIH QCNB T?LI G?;H ;H> C>?HNCNS =IP;LC;H=? G;NLCR CM >?WH?> ;M
N aN
"/* a a N '
I N
)I>?FCHA ILL?F;NCIH
0.2
0.15
g(z)
0.1
0.05
0
4
2 4
0 2
0
-2
-2
z -4 -4
2 z
1
0B?L?@IL?
NB? #;OMMC;H >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ NB? I<M?LP;NCIHM _N QCNB =IH>CNCIH;F
G?;H N ;H> =IP;LC;H=? G;NLCR N CM ACP?H <S
M _N
"/* _N N
N _N N
'
I
)N )
1
2
0
z
-1
-2
-3
-3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3
z
1
20 <;A<B? <3 A52 =13 <3 A52 /6C.?6.A2 .B@@6.; 16@A?6/BA6<; D6A5
%=*7-*;- 6>5=2?*;2*=. -2<=;2+>=287<
I
)>)
I
20 $13 <3 A52 'AB12;A I 16@A?6/BA6<; D6A5 12=2;12;A 0<:=<;2;A@ .;1
1
2
0
z
-1
-2
-3
-3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3
z
1
20 <;A<B? <3 A52 =13 <3 A52 'AB12;A I 16@A?6/BA6<; D6A5 12=2;12;A 0<:=<;2;A@
.;1
)I>?FCHA ILL?F;NCIH
20 $13 <3 A52 'AB12;A I 16@A?6/BA6<; D6A5 6;12=2;12;A 0<:=<;2;A@ .;1
1
2
0
x
-1
-2
-3
-3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3
x
1
20 <;A<B? <3 A52 =13 <3 A52 'AB12;A I 16@A?6/BA6<; D6A5 6;12=2;12;A 0<:
=<;2;A@ .;1
)I>?FCHA NB? GOFNCP;LC;N? >CMNLC<ONCIH
5529=2,*5 -2<=;2+>=287<
>CMJ?LMCIH G;NLCR
C@ NB? >?HMCNS CM
I
N a )(
)) M a
a
(
\
MO=B NB;N
.
U*
\I M I \
K\ (
I
QCNB FD ;H UD (
P?=NIL QCNB U U U
NB?H FD CM ;FMI ?FFCJNC=;FFS
>CMNLC<ON?> QCNB FD 1SI D D M I '
%HMN;H=?M I@ ?FFCJNC=;F >CMNLC<ONCIH ;L? NB? GOFNCP;LC;N? #;OMMC;H >CMNLC<O
NCIH
@IL QBC=B
LO
M I \
I
(
MI NB;N
N a )(
)) "/* a
a
'
I
/CGCF;LFS
NB? GOFNCP;LC;N? /NO>?HN [ >CMNLC<ONCIH CM >?WH?> <S
\ I
M I \
+ (
)I>?FCHA ILL?F;NCIH
MI NB;N
I
%
a
a
N a )(
))
'
I
*INC=? NB;N NBCM MJ?=CW=;NCIH MFCABNFS >C_?LM @LIG M ?RJF;CH?> ;<IP?
%4.@.- .5529=2,*5 -2<=;2+>=287
0B? GOFNCP;LC;N? ME?Q?> #;OMMC;H >CMNLC<ONCIH B;M <??H WLMN MNO>C?> <S T
T;FCHC ;H> ;FF; 2;FF?
TT;FCHC ;H> ;JCN;HCI
;H> ?RN?H>?> NI
NB? /NO>?HN [ >CMNLC<ONCIH <S TT;FCHC ;H> ;JCN;HCI L;H=I ;H> ?S
B;P? CHNLI>O=?> ; A?H?L;F =F;MM I@ GOFNCP;LC;N? ME?Q?FFCJNC=;F >CMNLC<
ONCIHM
0BCM ;JJLI;=B <OCF>M IH NB? OHCP;LC;N? ME?Q?> #;OMMC;H >CMNLC<ONCIH
>?
WH?> <S TT;FCHC L;H>IG P;LC;<F? F B;M ; MI=;FF?> @82D21 .B@@6.;
16@A?6/BA6<; C@ CNM =13 CM >?WH?> <S
N a
& a
a
(
QB?L? & a
CM NB? MN;H>;L> #;OMMC;H =13
;H>
a
CM NB? =ILL?MJIH>CHA 013
/IG? CHNOCNCIH @IL NBCM MJ?=CW=;NCIH CM JLIPC>?> <?FIQ 3B?H
N a
CM NB?
MN;H>;L> HILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH 3B?H
Q? I<N;CH ; #;OMMC;H
>CMNLC<ONCIH NLOH=;N?> @LIG ;<IP? <?FIQ ;N T?LI 0B? J;L;G?N?L JF;SM NB?
LIF? I@ MB;J? J;L;G?N?L
;H> CM ; U(
P?=NIL
3B?H NB? L;H>IG P?=NIL F CM HIN ;MMOG?> NI B;P? T?LI G?;HM ;H> OHCN
P;LC;H=?M
Q? =;H >?WH? NB? ME?Q?> #;OMMC;H >CMNLC<ONCIH ;M @IFFIQM (?N
)I>?FCHA NB? GOFNCP;LC;N? >CMNLC<ONCIH
3? NB?H QLCN? F ! I ( (
( L?@?LLCHA NI
;H> ;M NB? FI=;NCIH
>CMJ?LMCIH
;H> MB;J? IL ME?QH?MM J;L;G?N?LM
L?MJ?=NCP?FS
/O=B ; >CMNLC<ONCIH =;H <? >?LCP?> CH M?P?L;F Q;SM
>?M=LC<?> <S TT;FCHC
;H> ;JCN;HCI WLMN Q;S I@ A?H?L;NCHA ; ME?Q?> #;OMMC;H >CMNLC<
ONCIH CM 0<;16A6<;6;4 /OJJIM? NB;N A CM ; M=;F;L L;H>IG P;LC;<F? ;H> A CM
;H U>CG?HMCIH;F P;LC;<F?
MO=B NB;N NB? DICHN >CMNLC<ONCIH CM ; GOFNCP;LC;N?
#;OMMC;H >CMNLC<ONCIH
A
I (
QCNB (
A >
QB?L? CM >?WH?> ;M
>
'
>
FN?LH;NCP?FS
NB? L;H>IG P;LC;<F? >?WH?> <S
A C@ A + (
F
A C@ A ) (
CM ;FMI >CMNLC<ON?> ;M ; ME?Q?> #;OMMC;H P;LC;N?
0B? ME?Q?> #;OMMC;H >CMNLC<ONCIH =;H ;FMI <? I<N;CH?> <S A?.;@3<?:.A6<;
/OJJIM? NB;N
A
I (
QCNB (
A
>CMNLC<ONCIHM
<;M?> IH NB? ;JJLI;=B >?P?FIJ?> <S TT;FCHC ;H> ;FF; 2;FF?
;H> TT;FCHC ;H> ;JCN;HCI 0B? MN;H>;L> GOFNCP;LC;N? ?FFCJNC=;F
>CMNLC<ONCIH CM >?WH?> CH /?=NCIH
/OJJIM? NB;N A CM ; M=;F;L L;H>IG P;LC;<F? ;H> A CM ; U>CG?HMCIH;F
P;LC;<F?
MO=B NB;N NB? DICHN >CMNLC<ONCIH CM ; GOFNCP;LC;N? ?FFCJNC=;F >CMNLC<ONCIH
A
A 1SI ( M I (
A
QCNB
;H> (
QB?L? CM ; @OFFL;HE =IP;LC;H=? G;NLCR 0B?H
M=;F?
=B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH &
;H> ME?QH?MM J;L;G?N?L 0B? =13 I@ E CM
>?HIN?>
N9 `
NA % `
3A'-
`
(
QB?L? NA % '
CM NB? =13 I@ 1SI ( M I QCNB A?H?L;NIL @OH=NCIH M I '
;H> 3A'. '
CM NB? 013 I@ ; OHCP;LC;N? ?FFCJNC=;F >CMNLC<ONCIH 1S (
MKT
QCNB MKT ;M NB? A?H?L;NIL @OH=NCIH %H ;>>CNCIH
CM >?WH?> ;M
(
;H>
M I \ X `
MKS \
(
M I X `
QCNB X `
`
`
MJ?=C;F =;M? CM NB? ME?Q?> /NO>?HN [ >CMNLC<ONCIH 0B? =13 I@ E =;H <?
QLCNN?H ;M
U
N9 `
[I `(
@ 0 `
U (
X `
QB?L?
[I `(
N
I
X `
))
CM NB? >?HMCNS @OH=NCIH I@ ; U>CG?HMCIH;F /NO>?HN [ P;LC;N? QCNB >?AL??M
I@ @L??>IG ;H> @ _ U
>?HIN?M NB? OHCP;LC;N? /NO>?HN [ >CMNLC<ONCIH
@OH=NCIH QCNB U >?AL??M I@ @L??>IG
)I>?FCHA NB? GOFNCP;LC;N? >CMNLC<ONCIH
%4.@.- %=>-.7= -2<=;2+>=287
I
-
N a )
O `
(
D D
QB?L? ` ` ( ( `I
QCNB
aD D C@ aD ) (
`D
aD * D C@ aD '
/O=B ; MJ?=CW=;NCIH B;M M?P?L;F CHN?L?MNCHA JLIJ?LNC?M "CLMN
NB? G;LACH;F
>?HMCNC?M B;P? NB? M;G? J;NN?LHM ;M NB? IH?M >?WH?> CH NB? OHCP;LC;N? =;M?
<S "?LHcH>?T ;H> /N??F M?? /?=NCIH /?=IH>
D CM ; G?;MOL? I@
NB? ;MSGG?NLS I@ NB? G;LACH;F >?HMCNS I@ FD 0BCL>
NB? YNB GIG?HN I@ FD
CM ACP?H <S
(
L
D (
L L
1 FD
) D 1 FD
)FD + '
D
"CH;FFS
NB? =IGJIH?HNM I@ F ;L? OH=ILL?F;N?>
<?=;OM? NBIM? I@ E ;L? OH
=ILL?F;N?> <S ;MMOGJNCIH IHM?KO?HNFS
C@ H CM NB? P?=NIL I@ G?;HM ;H> I
NB? P?=NIL I@ MN;H>;L> >?PC;NCIHM I@ F
NB?H F =;H <? MN;H>;L>CT?> <S NB?
NL;HM@ILG;NCIH F F H
I
QB?L? >?HIN?M NB? ?F?G?HNQCM? >CPCMCIH
0BCM A?H?L;F @ILGOF;NCIH B;M <??H MJ?=C;FCT?> <S ;OQ?HM ;H> (;OL?HN
;H> &IH>?;O ;H> .I=ECHA?L NI NB? =;M? I@ NB? GOFNCP;LC;N?
ME?Q?> /NO>?HN [ >CMNLC<ONCIH 0BCM >CMNLC<ONCIH CM NB?L?@IL? ; GOFNCP;LC;N?
?RN?HMCIH I@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH JLIJIM?> <S $;HM?H
"?LHcH>?T ;H> /N??F
;H> &IH>?;O ;H> .I=ECHA?L ;
;H> CM JL?M?HN?> CH /?=NCIH
QB?L? ` ` ( ( `I
CM >?WH?> CH QCNB aD ID aD HD
;H>
I
J I (
+
HD + D (
D
ID D
H D '
D
-I
ID JD `D
N a) ( ( I ( ( ( I
(
D D
D
"IL ?;M? I@ ?RJIMCNCIH
Q? ;MMOG? NB;N & 6 ;H> Q? CHN?HNCIH;FFS IGCN
NB? >?J?H>?H=? I@ NB? =IP;LC;H=? G;NLCR ;H> B?H=? I@ NB? M QCNB L?MJ?=N NI
NCG?
)I>?FCHA NB? GOFNCP;LC;N? >CMNLC<ONCIH
0B? P( Q
=IGJIH?HN I@ NB? =IP;LC;H=? G;NLCR I@ L?NOLHM CM ACP?H <S
I
,
1 DD DE " DL " EL '
L
0B? P( Q( R
=IGJIH?HN I@ NB? NBCL> =?HNL;F GIG?HNM I@ L?NOLHM CM
I
,
1 DD DE DF " DL " EL " FL
L '
L
"CH;FFS
NB? P( Q( R( S
=IGJIH?HN I@ NB? @IOLNB =?HNL;F GIG?HNM I@ L?NOLHM CM
I
, I ,
, I
1 DD DE DF DG " DL " EL " FL " GL
L ! LM
L M (
L L M
M
L
QB?L? ! LM " DL " EL " FM " GM " DL " EM " FL " GM " DL " EM " FL " GM '
H;FSNC=;F ?RJL?MMCIHM I@ GIG?HNM ;L? KOCN? =OG<?LMIG? NI >?LCP?
S?N
NB?CL HOG?LC=;F =IGJON;NCIH CM P?LS @;MN
<?=;OM? IHFS G;NLCR G;HCJOF;NCIHM
;L? L?KOCL?> "IL ;H UP;LC;<F? MSMN?G
NB? >CG?HMCIH I@ NB? =IP;LC;H=? G;NLCR
CM U( U
<ON IHFS U U
* ?F?G?HNM B;P? NI <? =IGJON?> /CGCF;LFS
NB? =I
ME?QH?MM G;NLCR B;M >CG?HMCIH U( U( U
<ON IHFS U U
U
* ?F?G?HNM
B;P? NI <? =IGJON?> "CH;FFS
NB? =IEOLNIMCM G;NLCR B;M >CG?HMCIH U( U( U( U
<ON IHFS U U
U
U
* ?F?G?HNM B;P? NI <? =IGJON?>
M CN =F?;LFS ;JJ?;LM @LIG NB?M? ?RJL?MMCIHM
=IME?QH?MM <?NQ??H ?R=?MM
L?NOLHM >?J?H>M IH CH>CPC>O;F ME?QH?MM I@ CHHIP;NCIHM ;H> =ILL?F;NCIHM <?
NQ??H L?NOLHM NBLIOAB NB? " DE M IEOLNIMCM <?NQ??H ?R=?MM L?NOLHM >?J?H>M
IH CH>CPC>O;F EOLNIMCM ;H> PIF;NCFCNC?M I@ CHHIP;NCIHM ;H> =ILL?F;NCIHM <?NQ??H
L?NOLHM /O=B ; NCG?P;LC;<CFCNS CM FCE?FS NI B;P? NQI MIOL=?M +H IH? B;H>
1
2
0
z
-1
-2
-3
-3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3
z
1
20 <;A<B? =9<A <3 A52 /6C.?6.A2 @82D21 'AB12;A I 16@A?6/BA6<; D6A5 12=2;12;A
0<:=<;2;A@ .;1
869*;2<87
"CAOL?M NI MBIQ NB? =13 ;H> NB? =IHNIOL JFIN I@ NB? NQI NSJ?M I@
<CP;LC;N? ME?Q?> /NO>?HN [ >CMNLC<ONCIHM ;H> 0B? NQI P;LC;<F?M
B;P? ; T?LI G?;H ;H> OHCN P;LC;H=? 0B? >?AL??I@@L??>IG J;L;G?N?L CM
?KO;F NI CH ;FF =;M?M 0B? ;MSGG?NLS J;L;G?N?LM ;L? ?KO;F NI
'
MI NB;N NB? WLMN =IGJIH?HN CM MSGG?NLC= <ON NB? M?=IH> IH? CM G;LE?>FS
;MSGG?NLC= %H "CAOL?
NB? =ILL?F;NCIH =I?^=C?HN CM ;MMOG?> NI <?
<=26*=287
0B? ?MNCG;NCIH I@ NB? GOFNCP;LC;N? GI>?F QCNB HIH#;OMMC;H GOFNCP;LC;N? >CM
NLC<ONCIH
ACP?H <S ]
L;CM?M MIG? ;>>CNCIH;F >C^=OFNC?M ;M =IG
J;L?> QCNB NB? #;OMMC;H =;M? 1HEHIQH J;L;G?N?LM ;L? HIQ @IL NB? >S
H;GC=M I@ NB? =IH>CNCIH;F G?;H ;H> =IH>CNCIH;F =IP;LC;H=? G;NLCR ;H>
QB?L?
)I>?FCHA NB? GOFNCP;LC;N? >CMNLC<ONCIH
1
2
0
z
-1
-2
-3
-3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3
z
1
20
<;A<B? =9<A <3 A52 /6C.?6.A2 @82D21 'AB12;A I 16@A?6/BA6<; D6A5 12=2;12;A
0<:=<;2;A@ .;1
1
2
0
x
-1
-2
-3
-3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3
x
1
20 <;A<B? =9<A <3 A52 /6C.?6.A2 @82D21 'AB12;A I 16@A?6/BA6<; D6A5 6;12=2;
12;A 0<:=<;2;A@ .;1
)I>?FCHA ILL?F;NCIH
GN
&)# )N
) N N
_N N
) '
%H A?H?L;F
NB? G;RCGCT;NCIH I@ NB? FIAFCE?FCBII> B;M NI <? J?L@ILG?> CH IH?
MN?J
<?=;OM? NB? NQI M?NM I@ J;L;G?N?LM ;H> CHN?L;=N
HINC=?;<F? ?R=?JNCIH CM NB? =F;MM I@ ?FFCJNC=;F >CMNLC<ONCIHM %H NBCM =;M?
N
_N N
aN
QCNB aN
N
_N N
0B?L?@IL?
; NQI
MN?J ?MNCG;NCIH =;H <? J?L@ILG?>
CH QBC=B NB? NQI M?NM I@ J;L;G?N?LM ;L?
?MNCG;N?> M?J;L;N?FS 0B? J;L;G?N?LM ;L? ?MNCG;N?> OMCHA -)(
;MMOGCHA
HILG;FCNS I@ NB? CHHIP;NCIH JLI=?MM 0B?L?@IL?
CN CM I<N;CH?> <S G;RCGCTCHA
4
,
84 )_4
GN
(
N
QB?L?
U
GN
&)#
&)# )N
) _N N
N
_N N
'
0BCM JLI=?>OL? SC?F>M ; =IHMCMN?HN ?MNCG;NIL I@ ?P?H C@ NB? NLO? >CMNLC<
ONCIH CM HIN HILG;F 0BCM =IHMCMN?H=S L?MOFN B;M <??H JLIP?H <S IFF?LMF?P
;H> 3IIF>LC>A? ;H> &?;HNB?;O +H=? NB? J;L;G?N?L P?=NIL
B;M <??H ?MNCG;N?>
NB? MN;H>;L>CT?> L?MC>O;FM ;L? I<N;CH?> ;M aN
N
_N
N
0B?H
J;L;G?N?LM ;L? ?MNCG;N?> <S G;RCGCTCHA NB?
FIAFCE?FCBII> @OH=NCIH
;MMOGCHA HIQ NB;N CHHIP;NCIHM ;L? >L;QH @LIG NB?
GOFNCP;LC;N? >CMNLC<ONCIH N aN )
,4
0 4 ( )_
8 GN ( (
4
N
QB?L?
, 4
GN ( &)# N aN
) '
&)# N
N
/O=B ;H ;JJLI;=B =;H <? ;>IJN?> @IL NB? ?MNCG;NCIH I@ #.$ GI>?FM QCNB
#;OMMC;H IL /NO>?HN [ CHHIP;NCIHM $IQ?P?L
CN QIOF> HIN ;JJFS @IL NB? ME?Q?>
/NO>?HN [ >CMNLC<ONCIH
<?=;OM? CN >I?M HIN <?FIHA NI NB? ?FFCJNC=;F @;GCFS %H
MO=B =;M?
; DICHN ?MNCG;NCIH CM L?KOCL?> /?? /?=NCIH @IL @OLNB?L >?N;CFM
IH NB? ?MNCG;NCIH I@ NB? =IP;LC;H=? G;NLCR I@ '
$;@H?L ;H> .IG<IONM B;P? L?=?HNFS JLIJIM?> ;H ?RN?HMCIH I@ NB?
M?GCJ;L;G?NLC= ?MNCG;NCIH N?=BHCKO? I@ !HAF? ;H> #IHTcF?T.CP?L; NI
*INC=? NB;N
CH NB? =;M? I@ NB? /NO>?HN I >CMNLC<ONCIH
J;L;G?N?LM
;H> =;H
<? ?MNCG;N?> M?J;L;N?FS $IQ?P?L
C@ Q? ?MNCG;N? ; GI>?F
CN CM HIN JIMMC<F?
NI ?MNCG;N? NB? J;L;G?N?LM J?LN;CHCHA NI NB? P;LC;H=?M ;H> NI NB? =ILL?F;NCIHM
M?J;L;N?FS ;HSGIL? 0B? L?;MIH CM NB;N NB? FIAFCE?FCBII> =;HHIN <? <LIE?H >IQH
CHNI P;LC;H=?M ;H> =ILL?F;NCIHM =IGJIH?HNM
)I>?FCHA NB? GOFNCP;LC;N? >CMNLC<ONCIH
NBCM ;JJLI;=B CM <;M?> IH NB? @IFFIQCHA MN?JM 0B? WLMN MN?J =IHMCMNM CH ?MNC
G;NCHA NB? GI>?F <S -)(
JLIPC>CHA ;H ?MNCG;N? I@ NB? J;L;G?N?LM
M;S 0
0B?H
NB? WNN?> L?MC>O;FM #N ;H> NB? WNN?> P;LC;H=?M N 0
;L? OM?> NI =IG
0
JON? NB? MN;H>;L>CT?> L?MC>O;FM aN
#N * 0
N
CM ?MNCG;N?> OMCHA ;
HIHJ;L;G?NLC= G?NBI> 0B? ?MNCG;N?> >?HMCNS CM >?HIN?> N "CH;FFS
NB? J;L;
G?N?LM I@ NB? #.$ GI>?F ;L? ?MNCG;N?> <S G;RCGCTCHA NB? FIAFCE?FCBII>
@OH=NCIH
QCNB N B?F> ;M WR?>
-.:>*,B =.<=<
%H /?=NCIH
Q? >?M=LC<?> MIG? N?MNM ;CG?> ;N ;MM?MMCHA NB? ;<CFCNS I@ ;
ACP?H OHCP;LC;N? >CMNLC<ONCIH NI =;JNOL? NB? MNSFCT?> @;=NM I@ NB? ?GJCLC=;F >CM
NLC<ONCIH )IMN I@ NB?M? N?MNM B;P? <??H ?RN?H>?> NI NB? GOFNCP;LC;N? =IHN?RN
"IL CHMN;H=?
C?<IF>
$;BH
;H> 0;S JLIJIM?> ;H ?RN?HMCIH I@ NB?
N?MN CHNLI>O=?> <S C?<IF>
#OHN?L
;H> 0;S 0B? <;MC= C>?; =IHMCMNM
CH QLCNCHA NB? DICHN >CMNLC<ONCIH NN aN ( ( aIN
;M NB? JLI>O=N I@ =IH>CNCIH;F
>CMNLC<ONCIHM
;M CH
NN aN ( ( aIN
NN aIN )aIN ( ( aN
NN a N )aN
NN aN
'
0B?H
;N ?;=B J?LCI>
CN CM JIMMC<F? NI NL;HM@ILG ?;=B =IGJIH?HN I@ NB? P?=NIL
aN ( ( aIN
<S+CNM =ILL?MJIH>CHA =IH>CNCIH;F >CMNLC<ONCIH 3? NB?H I<N;CH
T *
U M?LC?M I@ \DN NN `DN )`DN ( ( `N
>`DN NB;N MBIOF> <? @IOH> NI <?
661 A (
NN aN ( a N
NN a N )aN
NN aN
(
IL
NN aN ( a N
NN aN )a N
NN a N
'
0B? WLMN >?=IGJIMCNCIH QIOF> JLIPC>? OM QCNB JLI<;<CFCNS CHN?AL;F NL;HM@ILGM
\N ;H> \ N ;H> NB? M?=IH> QIOF> JLIPC>? \ N ;H> \ N
QB?L? Q? >?HIN?
@IL CHMN;H=? . T*
\ N NN ` N )`N
K` N '
"CH;FFS
Q? B;P?
NI N?MN
C@ \
\
\ ;H> \ ;L? ?;=B 661 A (
;H> C@
\ ( \ ;H> \ ( \ ;L? ;FMI 661 A (
IHM?KO?HNFS
@IL F;LA? HOG<?LM
I@ P;LC;<F?M
CGJF?G?HNCHA NB? ;>?KO;=S N?MN G;S <? KOCN? =OG<?LMIG?
)I>?FCHA ILL?F;NCIH
55><=;*=287
89>5* />7,=287<
&*+5. $.?.:2A2? 2@A6:.A2@ <3 A52 :<129 B;12? C.?6<B@ 16@A?6/BA6<;@
/,] 4 /,]"0/!
!MNCG;N? /N> ?LL !MNCG;N? /N> ?LL
QCNB /NO>?HN I CHHIP;NCIHM
FIAFCE
]
]
QCNB ME?Q?> /NO>?HN I CHHIP;NCIHM
FIAFCE
]
]
3
( ;H> 4 (
B;P? ;M L;HA? NB? CHN?LP;F (
%H MIG?
=;M?M
; GOFNCP;LC;N? >CMNLC<ONCIH ?RCMNM
MI NB;N NB? @OH=NCIH 4 (
B;M ;H
?RJFC=CN ?RJL?MMCIH +H? MO=B =;M? CM NB? GOFNCP;LC;N? HILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH %H
G;HS =;M?M
BIQ?P?L
; >?M=LCJNCIH I@ NB? G;LACHM 2
;H> 3
CM L?F;NCP?FS
?;MS NI I<N;CH
QB?L?;M ;H ?RJFC=CN ?RJL?MMCIH I@ NB? DICHN >CMNLC<ONCIH 4 (
G;S <? >C^=OFN NI I<N;CH 0BCM CM QB?L? =IJOF;M ;L? OM?@OF <?=;OM? NB?S FCHE
G;LACHM CHNI ; GOFNCP;LC;N? >CMNLC<ONCIH @OH=NCIH
.D72=287
/6C.?6.A2 0<=B9. 6@ . 3B;0A6<; / (
(
(
D6A5
A52 A5?22 3<99<D6;4 =?<=2?A62@
)I>?FCHA ILL?F;NCIH
/ \( ]
6@ 6;0?2.@6;4 6; \ .;1 ]
/ ( ]
/ \(
/
( ]
] / \(
\
/ \ ( ]
/ \ ( ]
/ \ ( ]
/ \ ( ]
\ ( \ ( ] ( ] 6; (
@B05 A5.A \
\ .;1 ]
] '
,LIJ?LNS MN;N?M NB;N
QB?H IH? G;LACH;F >CMNLC<ONCIH CM =IHMN;HN
NB?
DICHN JLI<;<CFCNS QCFF CH=L?;M? JLIPC>?> NB;N NB? INB?L G;LACH;F >CMNLC<ONCIH
CH=L?;M?M ,LIJ?LNS MN;N?M NB;N C@ IH? G;LACH B;M T?LI JLI<;<CFCNS NI I==OL
NB?H CN GOMN <? NB? M;G? @IL NB? DICHN I==OLL?H=? FMI
C@ IH NB? =IHNL;LS
NB?H / 2 _
( 3 `
SC?F>M ;
>?M=LCJNCIH I@ NB? DICHN >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ D ;H> E $;PCHA I<N;CH?> NBCM CHNOCNCP?
>?WHCNCIH
Q? HIQ JLIJIM? NB? @IFFIQCHA CGJILN;HN NB?IL?G
JLIP?H CH /EF;L
;H> /=BQ?CT?L ;H> /EF;L
4 _( `
/ 2 _
( 3 `
0B? >?HMCNS I@ ; =IJOF; CM L?F;N?> NI CNM 013 NBLIOAB NB? @IFFIQCHA L?F;NCIH
, / \( ]
J \( ]
'
,\,]
/CGCF;LFS
NB? >?HMCNS O I@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH 4 CM >?WH?> <S NB? L?F;NCIHMBCJ
O _( `
J 2 _
( 3 `
M _
N `
'
.*<>;.< 8/ ,87,8;-*7,.
4 5 4 5
0
D( E + D D
E E0
+ + D D
E0 E0
) '
) (
0 E0
;H> D
( E
;L? NBL?? CH>?J?H>?HN =IJC?M /CH=? D
QB?L? D( E
D( 0 ;H>
E ;L? CH>?J?H>?HN
/J?;LG;HZM LBI =;H <? PC?Q?> ;M NB? >CMN;H=? <?NQ??H NB?
>CMNLC<ONCIH I@ D ;H> E ;H> CH>?J?H>?H=? /J?;LG;HZM LBI Q;M WLMN JLIJIM?>
CH <S NB? JMS=BIFIACMN /J?;LG;H /CGCF;L NI '?H>;FFZM N;O
CN CM L?F;N?>
NI NB? JLI<;<CFCNC?M I@ =IH=IL>;H=? ;H> >CM=IL>;H=? 0B? >CMNCH=NCIH CM NB;N
IH? J;CL D( E
B;M >CMNLC<ONCIH 4 _( `
>L;QH @LIG 2 _
;H> E @LIG 3 `
' 0B? CMMO? NB?H CM NI M?? C@ D( E
;H>
0 E
;L? =IH=IL>;HN
D(
;H> G;S NBOM <? PC?Q?> ;M ,?;LMIHZM =ILL?F;NCIH I@ NB? G;LACH;F >CMNLC<ONCIHM
2 D
;H> 3 E
*?FM?H MBIQM NB;N '?H>;FFZM N;O ;H> /J?;LG;HZM LBI M;NCM@S =IH
>CNCIHM L?KOCL?> NI <? =IH=IL>;H=? G?;MOL?M %@ 89 >?HIN? '?H>;FFZM N;O IL
)I>?FCHA ILL?F;NCIH
879*;*6.=;2, ,89>5*<
$dL>F?
/=INN
0BCM G?NBI> B;M <??H OM?> <S ?B?OP?FM
;H> "?LG;HC;H ;H> /=;CFF?N NI >?>O=? ; HIHJ;L;G?NLC= ?MNCG;N?
I@ NB? ;MMI=C;N?> OHL?MNLC=N?> =IJOF; 0B? ;>P;HN;A? I@ NBCM ;JJLI;=B CM NB;N
CN >I?M HIN L?KOCL? ;HS ;>>CNCIH;F ;MMOGJNCIH IH NB? HIHFCH?;L >?J?H>?H=?
$IQ?P?L
CN MO_?LM @LIG NB? >L;Q<;=EM I@ ;HS HIHJ;L;G?NLC= ;JJLI;=B %H
J;LNC=OF;L
NB? CHN?LJL?N;NCIH I@ NB? J;NN?LHM I@ HIHFCH?;L >?J?H>?H=? CM I@N?H
=IGJFC=;N?>
;H> CN CM FCE?FS NI JLIPC>? CH;==OL;N? ;H> ?LL;NC= L?MOFNM
?P?H CH
NB? <CP;LC;N? =;M? 0BCM ;JJLI;=B B;M <??H L?=?HNFS CGJLIP?> <S NB? QILE I@
#;AFC;L>CHC ;H> #IOLCfLIOR
QBI JLIJIM? ;H CHN?LG?>C;N? ;JJLI;=B
CH QBC=B NB? DICHN >?HMCNS CM =IHMNL;CH?> ;H> >?J?H>M IH ; MG;FF HOG<?L I@
IH?>CG?HMCIH;F @OH=NCIH;F J;L;G?N?LM
SC?F>CHA ?^=C?HN HIHJ;L;G?NLC= ?M
NCG;NILM @IL NB? IH?>CG?HMCIH;F @OH=NCIH;F J;L;G?N?LM
QBC=B =B;L;=N?LCT?
HIHFCH?;L >?J?H>?H=?
0B? HIHJ;L;G?NLC= =IJOF; B;M <??H JLIJIM?> <S ?B?OP?FM
%N CM >?WH?> ;M
4
[ [
,
/4 (
QCNB
[ ( [
@(
@ @ @ N 'R* R* S* S* (
/;GJF? P?LMCIHM I@ '?H>;FFZM N;O ;H> /J?;LG;HZM LBI ;L? ACP?H <S
4 4 N ,N
W X
@ , , , [ [
J4 ( J4 (
@
N N J K @ @ @ @
[ X W [
J4 ( J4 ( (
@ @ @ @
;H>
4 4
, , [ [ [ [
%3 /4 ( '
@
N N @ @ @ @
3? JLIPC>? CH NBCM M?=NCIH ; @?Q ?R;GJF?M I@ =IJOF; @OH=NCIHM NB;N B;P? <??H
MNO>C?> ;H> ?MNCG;N?> CH NB? ?GJCLC=;F WH;H=? FCN?L;NOL? /O=B =IJOF;M =;H
<? @IOH>
@IL CHMN;H=?
CH .C<IOF?N
.IH=;FFC
;H> IOSf
&IH>?;O ;H>
.I=ECHA?L <
;H> ,;NNIH 0B? =IJOF; @OH=NCIHM >?M=LC<?> CH NBCM
M?=NCIH =IP?L MIG? I@ NB? GIMN OM?> >CMNLC<ONCIH CH NB? FCN?L;NOL? "IL ; GIL?
A?H?L;F >?M=LCJNCIH I@ =IJOF; @OH=NCIHM
M?? &I? ;H> *?FM?H
3? >I HIN =IHMC>?L CH NBCM L?PC?Q BIQ G;LACHM ;L? >?WH?> 0B?S G;S <?
J;L;G?NLC= ;M Q?FF ;M HIHJ;L;G?NLC=
0;<F? L?JILNM
@IL NB? =IJOF; @OH=NCIHM =IHMC>?L?> <?FIQ
NB? L;HA?
I@ JIMMC<F? P;FO?M NB;N =;H <? L?;=B?> <S NB? =IH=IL>;H=? G?;MOL?M >?
HIN?M NB? '?H>;FFZM N;O IL NB? /J?;LG;HZM LBI 0BCM N;<F? CH>C=;N?M NB;N MIG?
=IJOF; @OH=NCIHM G;S <? ;<F? NI L?JLI>O=? IHFS JIMCNCP? IL IHFS H?A;NCP? >?
J?H>?H=? "IL CHMN;H=?
NB? F;SNIH
#OG<?F IL );LMB;FF+FECH =IJOF; IHFS
B;P? JIMCNCP? >?J?H>?H=?
5529=2,*5 ,89>5*<
/NO>?HN I =IJOF;
;H> C !
"L;HE =IJOF;
F;SNIH =IJOF;
#OG<?F =IJOF;
NB?H D B;M
;H ?FFCJNC=;F >CMNLC<ONCIH QCNB J;L;G?N?LM
;H> %H ;>>CNCIH
C@ D B;M
; >?HMCNS
CN CM I@ NB? @ILG )) N D
D
@IL MIG? HIH
H?A;NCP? @OH=NCIH N I@ IH? M=;F;L P;LC;<F? 0B?L?@IL?
NB? =IHNIOLM I@ ?KO;F
>?HMCNS @ILG ?FFCJMIC>M CH I
.B@@6.; 0<=B9.
0B? #;OMMC;H =IJOF; CM >?WH?> <S NB? @IFFIQCHA 013
/ \( ]
\
(
]
QB?L?
CM NB? <CP;LC;N? MN;H>;L>CT?> #;OMMC;H 013 QCNB ,?;LMIHZM =ILL?F;NCIH
;H>
>?HIN?M NB? CHP?LM? I@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH @OH=NCIH I@ NB?
OHCP;LC;N? MN;H>;L> HILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH
0B? >?HMCNS I@ NB? #;OMMC;H =IJOF; CM ACP?H <S
J \( ]
"/* ! > 5 ! (
)>)
QB?L? !
\
(
]
;H> > CM NB? (
=ILL?F;NCIH G;NLCR <?NQ??H
\ ;H> ] QCNB ;M =ILL?F;NCIH J;L;G?N?L
'?H>;FFZM N;O ;H> /J?;LG;HZM LBI ;L? ACP?H L?MJ?=NCP?FS <S
/
+!,%(
(
%3 /
+!,%( *
'
"CAOL? >CMJF;SM NB? #;OMMC;H =IJOF; J \( ]
@IL '' "CAOL?
JL?M?HNM NB? >?HMCNS O I@ NB? NQI>CG?HMCIH;F >CMNLC<ONCIH >?WH?> ;M O _( `
J 2 _
( 3 `
M _
N `
' %H NB? WLMN =;M?
NB? NQI P;LC;<F?M ;L? MOJ
JIM?> NI <? >CMNLC<ON?> ;M (
0.9
0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
0 0.5 1
u
3 3
2 2
1 1
N(0,1)
N(0,1)
0 0
-1 -1
-2 -2
-3 -3
-2 0 2 -2 0 2
N(0,1) Student t(3)
20
<;A<B? =9<A <3 A52 12;@6AF <3 A52 .B@@6.; 0<=B9.
)I>?FCHA ILL?F;NCIH
'AB12;A [ 0<=B9.
I 8
K!(
U
U
QB?L? ! [
I \
( [I ]
[I CM NB? <CP;LC;N? /NO>?HN [ 013 QCNB U >?AL??M
I@ @L??>IG ;H> =ILL?F;NCIH ( ;H> [I >?HIN?M NB? CHP?LM? I@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH
@OH=NCIH I@ NB? OHCP;LC;N? /NO>?HN [ >CMNLC<ONCIH QCNB U >?AL??M I@ @L??>IG
0B? >?HMCNS I@ NB? /NO>?HN [ =IJOF; CM ACP?H <S
I %
I
I !
> !
JI \( ]
8 I * % '
)>)
D
I ! D
;,126.-.*7 ,89>5*<
/ \( ]
& & \
& ]
0B? @OH=NCIH & CM =;FF?> ; A?H?L;NIL I@ NB? =IJOF; MMOGCHA NB;N & CM
NQC=? =IHNCHOIOMFS >C_?L?HNC;<F?
NB? =IJOF; >?HMCNS CM
IJOF; @OH=NCIHM
3 3
2 2
1 1
N(0,1)
N(0,1)
0 0
-1 -1
-2 -2
-3 -3
-2 0 2 -2 0 2
N(0,1) Student t(3)
20 <;A<B? =9<A <3 A52 12;@6AF <3 A52 'AB12;A I 0<=B9.
&
& \
& ]
J \( ]
'
&
&
\
&
&
]
%H NBCM =;M?
'?H>;FFZM N;O CM ACP?H <S
.
& [
/
[
K['
&
?.;8 0<=B9.
3B?H & [
&)# L
&)# L
N
@IL
Q? I<N;CH NB? "L;HE
@;GCFS I@ =IJOF;M 0B? "L;HE =IJOF; CM >?WH?> <S
O
L
L
P
/
\( ]
&)#
(
L
;H>
L
L
OP
J
\( ]
'
L
L
O
L
P
0B? =IJOF; CM >?WH?> @IL '?H>;FFZM N;O CM ACP?H <S
)I>?FCHA ILL?F;NCIH
3 3
2 2
1 1
N(0,1)
N(0,1)
0 0
-1 -1
-2 -2
-3 -3
-2 0 2 -2 0 2
N(0,1) Student t(3)
20 <;A<B? =9<A <3 A52 12;@6AF <3 A52 ?.;8 0<=B9.
0
/
(
;H> /J?;LG;HZM LBI CM
0
0
%3 /
(
QB?L? +R
F N"
R" @+* K[ C@ _ (
0F _
FR F N"
F R" R @*
K[ C@ _ )
9.FA<; 0<=B9.
3B?H & [
[
*
@IL
* '(
Q? I<N;CH NB? F;SNIH @;GCFS
I@ =IJOF;M 0B? F;SNIH =IJOF; CM >?WH?> <S
/
\( ]
' / \
]
( '
"IL +
NB? =IJOF; MCGJFCW?M NI
IJOF; @OH=NCIHM
3 3
2 2
1 1
N(0,1)
N(0,1)
0 0
-1 -1
-2 -2
-3 -3
-2 0 2 -2 0 2
N(0,1) Student t(3)
20 <;A<B? =9<A <3 A52 12;@6AF <3 A52 9.FA<; 0<=B9.
/
\( ]
\
]
'
NB?H
A(
B
CM >CMNLC<ON?> ;==IL>CHA NI NB? LIN;N?> =IJOF; /
2 \( ]
"IL
NB? F;SNIH =IJOF;
Q? B;P?
/
2 \( ]
\ ] /
\(
]
(
QCNB >?HMCNS
J2
\( ]
J
\(
]
'
B:/29 0<=B9.
3B?H & [
&)# [
@IL
;H>
/
\( ]
&)# \ &)# ]
J
\( ]
4 5
\] &)# \
&)# ]
4 5
&)# \
&)# ]
'
"5*,4.== ,89>5*
0B? ,F;=E?NN =IJOF;
JLIJIM?> <S ,F;=E?NN
CM >?WH?> <S
/
\( ]
9
\ ]
\ ]
\]
(
;H>
\ \] ]
J
\( ]
'
\ ]
\]
'
3 3
2 2
1 1
N(0,1)
N(0,1)
0 0
-1 -1
-2 -2
-3 -3
-2 0 2 -2 0 2
N(0,1) Student t(3)
20 <;A<B? =9<A <3 A52 12;@6AF <3 A52 B:/29 0<=B9.
3 3
2 2
1 1
N(0,1)
N(0,1)
0 0
-1 -1
-2 -2
-3 -3
-2 0 2 -2 0 2
N(0,1) Student t(3)
20
<;A<B? =9<A <3 A52 12;@6AF <3 A52 $9.082AA 0<=B9.
)I>?FCHA ILL?F;NCIH
*;<1*55!5427 ,89>5*
QCNB \ 2 _
;H> ] 3 `
QB?L? 2 _
+ D + _ ;H> 3
`
+ E + ` >?HIN? NB? G;LACH;F MOLPCP;F @OH=NCIHM 0B? >IG;CH I@ >?WHCNCIH
I@ NB? J;L;G?N?LM
;H> CM
(
0B? >?HMCNS I@ NB? =IJOF; CM >?WH?> <S
, / \( ]
\ C@ \ + ] (
J \( ]
,\,] ] C@ \ ) ] (
FF P;FO?M CH NB? CHN?LP;F (
=;H <? I<N;CH?> @IL <INB NB? '?H>;FFZM N;O ;H>
NB? /J?;LG;HZM LBI
"CAOL? L?JL?M?HNM NB? >?HMCNS I@ NB? );LMB;FF+FECH =IJOF; @IL
'
'
;H>
MI NB;N
' ;H> '' 0B?M? P;FO?M
=ILL?MJIH> NI ; '?H>;FFZM N;O ?KO;F NI '
<=26*=287
&I? ;H> 4O
0B? =IJOF; J;L;G?N?LM =;H ;FMI <? M?GCJ;L;G?NLC=;FFS
?MNCG;N?>
OMCHA NB? G;LACH;F ?GJCLC=;F >CMNLC<ONCIH NI =IGJON? NB? =IJOF;
#?H?MN
#BIO>C
;H> .CP?MN
+NB?L ;FN?LH;NCP? ?MNCG;NCIH JLI=?>OL?M G;S <? =IHMC>?L?> ;M Q?FF "IL
CHMN;H=?
;M CN B;M <??H MBIQH CH /?=NCIH
NB? J;L;G?N?LM I@ NB? =IJOF;
@OH=NCIH ;L? CH A?H?L;F L?F;N?> NI IH? I@ NB? =IH=IL>;H=? G?;MOL?M '?H>;FFZM
IJOF; @OH=NCIHM
2 2
1.5 1.5
1 1
0.5 0.5
N(0,1)
N(0,1)
0 0
-0.5 -0.5
-1 -1
-1.5 -1.5
-2 -2
-2 -1 0 1 2 -2 -1 0 1 2
N(0,1) Student t(3)
20
<;A<B? =9<A <3 A52 12;@6AF <3 A52 !.?@5.99#986; 0<=B9.
.<=26*=8;
3? ;MMOG? HIQ NB;N NB? OHEHIQH J;L;G?N?LM ;MMI=C;N?> QCNB NB? G;LACH;F
>?HMCNC?M M ;H> N ;L? >?HIN?> R ;H> S
L?MJ?=NCP?FS
;H> NB;N NB? OHEHIQH
J;L;G?N?LM ;MMI=C;N?> QCNB NB? =IJOF; @OH=NCIH J ;L? >?HIN?> 3? >?HIN?
NB? 7(
P?=NIL R ( S (
0B? G;RCGOG FCE?FCBII> ?MNCG;N? )(!
I@ ; GI>?F CM I<N;CH?> <S G;RCGCTCHA NB? =IH>CNCIH;F FIAFCE?FCBII> @OH=NCIH
QBC=B CM >?WH?> ;M
4
,
84 )_N ( ` N &)# J
2 _N ( R
( 3 `N ( S
M _N ( R
N `N ( S
N
4
,
&)# J
2 _N ( R
( 3 `N ( S
N
4
,
&)# M _N ( R
&)# N `N ( S
'
N
)I>?FCHA ILL?F;NCIH
M JL?PCIOMFS
NB? )( ?MNCG;NIL - , CM ;MSGJNINC=;FFS HILG;F QCNB ;MSGJ
NINC= >CMNLC<ONCIH +
@ - , ( -
(
%H JL;=NC=;F ;JJFC=;NCIHM
NB? )( ?MNCG;NCIH G;S <? >C^=OFN "CLMN
NB? >CG?H
MCIH I@ NB? JLI<F?G =;H <? F;LA?
<?=;OM? CN L?KOCL?M IH? NI ?MNCG;N? DICHNFS
NB? J;L;G?N?LM I@ NB? G;LACHM ;H> I@ NB? =IJOF; @OH=NCIH /?=IH>
NB? >?J?H
>?H=S J;L;G?N?L I@ NB? =IJOF; @OH=NCIH G;S <? ; =IHPIFON?> ?RJL?MMCIH I@
NB? G;LACH J;L;G?N?LM 0B?L?@IL?
;H ;H;FSNC=;F ?RJL?MMCIH I@ NB? AL;>C?HN I@
NB? FCE?FCBII> GCABN HIN ?RCMN +HFS HOG?LC=;F AL;>C?HNM G;S <? =IGJON;<F?
Q? B;P?
4
,
0R +# ' / &)#M _N ( R
(
, ,
N
4
,
0S +# ' / &)#N `N ( S
'
- -
N
0B?H
CH ; M?=IH> MN?J
NB? J;L;G?N?LM I@ NB? =IJOF; @OH=NCIH =;H <?
?MNCG;N?> =IH>CNCIH;FFS IH NB? G;LACH J;L;G?N?LM
4
, 4 5
0 +# ' / &)# J
2 _N ( 0R ( 3 `N ( 0S '
N
QBCF? NB? ?MNCG;NILM I@ NB? >?J?H>?H=? J;L;G?N?LM ;L? I<N;CH?> <S MIFPCHA
4
,
+# ' / &)# J
2 _N ( R ( 3 `N ( S '
N
M ;<IP?
?MNCG;NILM R
S
;H> ;L? MBIQH NI <? =IHMCMN?HN ;H> ;MSGJ
NINC=;FFS HILG;F
%.629*;*6.=;2,
#?H?MN
#BIO>C
;H> .CP?MN B;P? JLIJIM?> ;H ?MNCG;NCIH JLI=?>OL?
NB;N ;PIC>M MJ?=C@SCHA NB? G;LACH;F >CMNLC<ONCIH %HMN?;> I@ OMCHA ; J;L;G?NLC=
G;LACH;F >CMNLC<ONCIH
NB?S MOAA?MN NB? OM? I@ NB? G;LACH;F ?GJCLC=;F >CMNLC<
ONCIH @OH=NCIH 0B? ?GJCLC=;F >CMNLC<ONCIH @OH=NCIH I@ D CM
4
,
4
24 _
\
R* R
(
@ N
#?H?MN
#BIO>C
;H> .CP?MN MBIQ NB;N NB? ?MNCG;NIL CM ;MSGJ
NINC=;FFS HILG;F
QCNB ; F;LA?L ;MSGJNINC= P;LC;H=? NB;H NB? )( ?MNCG;NIL
I<N;CH?> ;MMOGCHA NB;N NB? G;LACHM ;L? EHIQH
-.:>*,B =.<=<
+H? L?;MIH @IL NB? MO==?MM I@ NB? =IJOF; @OH=NCIHM CM NB;N NB?S ;L? ;<F? NI
GI>?F ;FGIMN ;HS ECH> I@ L?F;NCIHMBCJ <?NQ??H NCG? M?LC?M ON IH? >L;Q<;=E
CM NB;N NB? =F;MM I@ =IJOF; @OH=NCIHM CM HIQ P?LS F;LA?
MI NB;N CN CM I@N?H >C^=OFN
NI M?F?=N NB? [LCABN\ IH?
C?
NB? =IJOF; @OH=NCIH NB;N <?MN WNM NB? >;N; ;N
B;H> 0B?L? CM NB?L?@IL? ; H??> @IL ;>?KO;=S N?MNM
/?P?L;F J;J?LM B;P? L?=?HNFS JLIJIM?> AII>H?MMI@WN N?MNM @IL =IJOF; GI>
?FM #?H?MN ;H> .CP?MN JLIJIM? ; N?MN @IL NB? L=BCG?>?;H @;GCFS )IL?
L?=?HN J;J?LM ;L? <S L?SG;H
C;M
;H> !G<L?=BNM
"?LG;HC;H
;H> );F;P?LAH? ;H> /ILH?NN? M ;LAO?> <S "?LG;HC;H ;H> /=;CFF?N
NB?L? ;L? MIG? >C^=OFNC?M CH >?MCAHCHA ; MN;NCMNC=;F N?MN @IL NB? ;>?
KO;=S I@ =IJOF; @OH=NCIHM NI NB? >;N; 0B? L?;MIH CM NB;N NB? CHCNC;F P;LC;<F?M
B;P? NI <? NL;HM@ILG?> CH NB?CL JLI<;<CFCNS CHN?AL;F NL;HM@ILGM NBLIOAB NB?
G;LACH;F >CMNLC<ONCIH @OH=NCIHM /CH=? NB? G;LACHM ;L? OHEHIQH
NB?S B;P? NI
<? NL?;N?> ;M HOCM;H=? J;L;G?N?LM
H;NOL;F Q;S CM NI ;>;JN NB? N?MN JLIJIM?> CH NB? GOFNCP;LC;N? >CMNLC<O
NCIH =IHN?RN <S C?<IF>
$;BH
;H> 0;S @IL =IJOF; @OH=NCIHM /O=B ;H
;>;JN;NCIH B;M <??H JLIJIM?> <S L?SG;HH
C;M
;H> !G<L?=BNM M
CH /?=NCIH
Q? L?@?L NI NB? .IM?H<F;NN NL;HM@ILG ;H> >?WH? NB?
JLI<;<CFCNS CHN?AL;F NL;HM@ILG CH N?LGM I@ =IH>CNCIH;F >CMNLC<ONCIHM IHMC>?L U
L;H>IG P;LC;<F?M DD QBIM? DICHN >CMNLC<ONCIH CM ACP?H <S 28 _ ( ( _I
;H>
G;LACH;F >CMNLC<ONCIHM <S 28 _D
+DD
_D 3? >?WH? NB? JLI<;<CFCNS
CHN?AL;F NL;HM@ILG AD @ DD
QB?L?
@ D
+D
_ 28 _
(
@ D
+D
_ )D _ 28 8 _ )_
(
@ DI
+DI
_I )D _ ( ( DI _I
28% 8 8% _I )_ ( ( _I
(
0B?L?@IL?
NB? P;LC;<F?M AD @IL P
( ( U ;L? 661 A (
CH>CPC>O;FFS ;H>
DICHNFS
/OJJIM? HIQ NB;N NB? =IJOF; / CM MO=B NB;N / 28 _
( ( 28% _I
28 _ ( ( _I
%@ Q? >?HIN? /D \ ( ( \D
/ \ ( ( \D (
( (
NB?
DICHN G;LACH;F >CMNLC<ONCIH @IL NB? WLMN P P;LC;<F?M A ( ( AD
, D /D \ ( ( \D
, D /D \ ( ( \D
/D \D )\ ( ( \D
* '
,\ ,\D ,\ ,\D
/CH=? Q? B;P?
/D 28 _D
)28 _
( ( 28 _D
28 8 8
_D )_ ( ( _D
(
IJOF; @OH=NCIHM
Q? >?>O=? NB;N
AD /D 28 _D
)28 _
( ( 28 _D
P ( ( U(
QCNB A / 28 _
QB?L? E CM NB? QNB ?F?G?HN I@ NB? OHCNMKO;L? ALC> 0I ?;=B J;L;G?N?L KE
CH NB? =;M? I@ NB? NCG?P;LSCHA =IH>CNCIH;F =ILL?F;NCIH GI>?F I@ 0M? ;H> 0MOC
N
N ! N (
) ) )H
H H
QB?L? ! N C \NC ]NC * C \NC C ]NC L?JL?M?HNM NB?
=ILL?F;NCIH <?NQ??H NB? G;LACHM IP?L NB? L?=?HN J?LCI> 3? CGJIM? NB;N
(
;H>
0B? HOFF BSJINB?MCM =;H <? N?MN?>
OMCHA ; MN;H>;L> 3;F> MN;NCMNC=
HINB?L ;FN?LH;NCP? ;JJLI;=B G;S <? NB;N J;L;G?N?LM I@ NB? /NO>?HN [
=IJOF;
QCNB >?AL??I@@L??>IG J;L;G?N?L U ;H> =ILL?F;NCIH ( ;L? >LCP?H <S
; );LEIPMQCN=BCHA GI>?F I@ NB? NSJ?
N ?N
?N
(
UN U?N U
?N
(
J K
J
K
8 8
8 8
8 8 8 8
8 8 8 8
J K J
K
J
20
QCNB
W + ?N )?N (
X + ?N
)?N
'
*IN? NB;N
CH NBCM GI>?F
Q? >I HIN H?=?MM;LCFS ;MMOG? NB;N OHCP;LC;N? =B;L
;=N?LCMNC=M I@ L?NOLHM ;FMI MBC@N -O;MC );RCGOG(CE?FCBII> ?MNCG;NCIH I@ NBCM
GI>?F =;H <? ?;MCFS I<N;CH?> OMCHA NB? ;JJLI;=B >?P?FIJ?> <S $;GCFNIH
;H> #L;S "IL NB? >?AL??I@@L??>IG J;L;G?N?L
Q? G;S CH
P?MNCA;N? M?P?L;F BSJINB?M?M "IL CHMN;H=?
Q? G;S N?MN QB?NB?L CN CM L?ACG?
CH>?J?H>?HN U U IL QB?NB?L CN CM CHWHCN?
MI NB;N NB? #;OMMC;H =IJOF;
QIOF> JL?P;CF @IL ; ACP?H L?ACG?
55><=;*=287
3? HIQ =IHMC>?L NB? ?MNCG;NCIH I@ =IJOF; @OH=NCIHM @IL IOL NQI J;CLM I@ >;CFS
L?NOLHM /, ;H> 4 IH IH? B;H> ;H> /, ;H> "0/! IH NB? INB?L
B;H> IP?L NB? J?LCI> @LIG &;HO;LS NI OAOMN 0I =IGJ;L? NB?
)I>?FCHA ILL?F;NCIH
0.9 0.9
0.8 0.8
0.7 0.7
0.6 0.6
0.5 0.5
v
v
0.4 0.4
0.3 0.3
0.2 0.2
0.1 0.1
0 0
0 0.5 1 0 0.5 1
u u
20
'0.AA2?=9<A <3 :.?46;@
;M Q?FF ;M =IH=IL>;H=? G?;MOL?M
'?H>;FFZM N;O
/J?;LG;HZM LBI
;H> NB? FIQ?LN;CF ;H> OJJ?LN;CF >?J?H>?H=?
G?;MOL?M 3? WLMN HINC=? NB;N NB? ?MNCG;N?M I@ NB? >?J?H>?H=? J;L;G?N?LM
IJOF; @OH=NCIHM
;L? L;NB?L MCGCF;L QB;N?P?L NB? G;LACH;F >CMNLC<ONCIH ;H> NB? =IJOF; @OH=
NCIH 0B? J;L;G?N?LM ;H> %3 ;L? NSJC=;FFS ;LIOH> ;H> @IL NB? J;CL
/,] 4 ;H> ;LIOH> ;H> @IL NB? J;CL /,]"0/! 3? HINC=?
NB;N >?J?H>?H=? CM @IOH> NI <? GIL? JLIHIOH=?> @IL NB? MSGG?NLC= =IJOF;M
NB;H @IL NB? ;MSGG?NLC= IH?M 3? HINC=? NB;N NB? /NO>?HN [ =IJOF; QBC=B
B;M <INB FIQ?LN;CF ;H> OJJ?LN;CF >?J?H>?H=? CM =B;L;=N?LCT?> <S KOCN? F;LA?
>?AL??I@@L??>IG J;L;G?N?LM
MI NB;N HI N;CF >?J?H>?H=? CM I<N;CH?> "IL NBCM
>;N?
NBCM WH>CHA =;H <? =IHWLG?> OMCHA ; N?MN <;M?> IH NB? ?RNL?G? P;FO?
NB?ILS
;M CFFOMNL;N?> CH NB? H?RN =B;JN?L "CH;FFS
Q? G;S =IGJ;L? NB? FIA
FCE?FCBII>M I<N;CH?> QCNB NB? P;LCIOM =IJOF; @OH=NCIHM 3? I<M?LP? NB;N NB?
=IJOF; NB;N JLIPC>?M NB? <?MN WN I@ NB? >;N; ;N B;H> CM NB? /NO>?HN [ =IJOF;
M,
FIAFCE ,;L;G?N?L '?H>;FFZM /J?;LG;HZM
?MNCG;N? N;O LBI
/,] 4 #;OMMC;H G;LACHM
#;OMMC;H
/NO>?HN I
"L;HE
,F;=E?NN
F;SNIH
.IN;N?> F;SNIH
#OG<?F
.IN;N?> #OG<?F
/,] 4 /NO>?HN I G;LACHM
#;OMMC;H
/NO>?HN I
"L;HE
,F;=E?NN
F;SNIH
.IN;N?> F;SNIH
#OG<?F
.IN;N?> #OG<?F
/CH=? NB? ?MNCG;NCIH CM J?L@ILG?> OMCHA NB? NQIMN?J ;JJLI;=B
NB? L?JILN?> =IJ
OF; =IGJIH?HN I@ NB? FIAFCE?FCBII> =;H <? =IGJ;L?> @IL NB? P;LCIOM =IJOF; @OH=
NCIHM $IQ?P?L
CN CM HIN MOLJLCMCHA NB;N NB?L? CM HI MSMN?G;NC= J;NN?LH QB?H Q?
=IGJ;L? NB? #;OMMC;H G;LACHM QCNB NB? /NO>?HN I G;LACHM %HMJ?=NCIH I@ NB? NI
N;F FIAFCE?FCBII> CH=FO>CHA NB? G;LACHM =F?;LFS CH>C=;N?M NB;N NB? GI>?F QCNB
/NO>?HN I G;LACHM J?L@ILGM <?NN?L NB;H NB? GI>?F QCNB #;OMMC;H G;LACHM
)I>?FCHA ILL?F;NCIH
M('
FIAFCE ,;L;G?N?L '?H>;FFZM /J?;LG;HZM
?MNCG;N? N;O LBI
/,]"0/! #;OMMC;H G;LACHM
#;OMMC;H
/NO>?HN I
"L;HE
,F;=E?NN
F;SNIH
.IN;N?> F;SNIH
#OG<?F
.IN;N?> #OG<?F
/,]"0/! /NO>?HN I G;LACHM
#;OMMC;H
/NO>?HN I
"L;HE
,F;=E?NN
F;SNIH
.IN;N?> F;SNIH
#OG<?F
.IN;N?> #OG<?F
A=;.6. (*5>. &1.8;B
%H B;JN?LM NI
Q? =IHMC>?L?> NB? GI>?FCHA I@ NB? ?HNCL? OHCP;LC;N? IL
GOFNCP;LC;N? >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ L?NOLHM 3B?H CN CM JIMMC<F? ;M Q?FF ;M ?_?=NCP?
'FkJJ?F<?LA
;H> )CEIM=B %N MBIOF> <? HINC=?>
@LIG NB? IHM?N
NB;N
G;HS L?MOFNM B;P? <??H I<N;CH?> @IL OHCP;LC;N? >CMNLC<ONCIHM
QB?L?;M IHFS
L?F;NCP?FS @?Q L?MOFNM ;L? ;P;CF;<F? @IL GOFNCP;LC;N? >;N; 0B? L?;MIH @IL NBCM CM
NB;N CH ; OHCP;LC;N? M?NNCHA
;H ;H;FIAIOM L?MOFN NI NB? =?HNL;F FCGCN NB?IL?G
BIF>M *I MO=B L?MOFN ;JJ?;LM NI ?RCMN CH ; GOFNCP;LC;N? M?NNCHA
%H !20 NB? @I=OM I@ CHN?L?MN CM NB? MI=;FF?> A.69 6;12E NB;N =B;L;=N?LCT?M
NB? MB;J? I@ NB? N;CFM I@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH 0B?L? ;L? ?MM?HNC;FFS NQI J;L;G?NLC=
;JJLI;=B?M NI I<N;CH ; G?;MOL? I@ NBCM CH>?R 0B? 2EA?2:. .==?<.05 MNO>C?M
NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH @IFFIQ?> <S NB? G;RCGOG IL GCHCGOG I@ L?NOLHM IP?L ACP?H
NCG? BILCTIHM 0BCM >CMNLC<ONCIH CM MBIQH NI <? H?MN?> CH NB? 42;2?.96G21 2E
A?2:2 C.9B2 A?P >CMNLC<ONCIH
QBC=B =;H <? ?MNCG;N?> ;H> QBC=B JLIPC>?M ;H
?MNCG;N? I@ NB? N;CF CH>?R 0B? A.69 <? =2.8<C2?A5?2@5<91 .==?<.05 =IHMC>?LM
NB? ?R=??>;H=?M IP?L ; BCAB NBL?MBIF> ;H> NB?L?@IL? >CL?=NFS @I=OM?M IH NB?
N;CFM I@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH 0B? >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ NB? ?R=?MM?M IP?L ; BCAB NBL?MBIF>
CM MBIQH NI <? ;JJLIRCG;N?FS >CMNLC<ON?> ;==IL>CHA NI ; 42;2?.96G21 $.?2A<
!RNL?G? 2;FO? 0B?ILS
16@A?6/BA6<; AJ>
QBC=B =;H <? ?MNCG;N?> NI JLIPC>? ;H ?MNCG;N? I@ NB? N;CF
CH>?R INB ;JJLI;=B?M B;P? >L;Q<;=EM
BIQ?P?L %H J;LNC=OF;L
NB? NQI ;J
JLI;=B?M L?KOCL? >C_?L?HN ;MMOGJNCIHM ;<ION >?J?H>?H=S I@ L?NOLHM 0B? N;CF
;JJLI;=B H?=?MMCN;N?M NB;N L?NOLHM ;L? 661
QB?L?;M NB? ?RNL?G; ;JJLI;=B IHFS
CGJIM?M NB? 661 H?MM I@ MO<M;GJF?M IP?L QBC=B ?RNL?G; ;L? =IGJON?> 0B?L?
@IL?
NB? F;NN?L ;JJLI;=B B;M NB? ;>P;HN;A? NB;N MO<M;GJF?M ;L? FCE?FS NI <?
661
C@ Q? N;E? ; MO^=C?HNFS FIHA NCG? BILCTIH +H NB? INB?L MC>?
NB? ?MNCG;N?
I@ NB? A?P >CMNLC<ONCIH JL?MOG?M NB;N NBCM CM NB? ;=NO;F >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ L?
NOLHM
QBC=B CM A?H?L;FFS ;H IP?LFS MNLIHA ;MMOGJNCIH 3B?H NB? ;MMOGJNCIHM
OH>?LFSCHA NB?M? ;JJLI;=B?M ;L? =IHMC>?L?> ;M NII MNLIHA
CN CM JIMMC<F? NI ?MNC
G;N? NB? N;CF CH>?R OMCHA M?GCJ;L;G?NLC= G?NBI>M "IL ;JJFC=;NCIHM NB;N ;L?
L?F?P;HN NI WH;H=?
NB? MI=;FF?> $CFF ?MNCG;N? QCFF <? MO=B ; M?GCJ;L;G?NLC=
?MNCG;N? I@ NB? N;CF CH>?R HINB?L >C^=OFNS NB;N Q? @;=? QCNB WH;H=C;F >;N;
CM B?N?LIME?>;MNC=CNS
QBC=B CM EHIQH NI ;_?=N NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ ?RNL?G; IL
N;CFM /IG? MIFONCIHM B;P? <??H JLIJIM?> NI >?;F QCNB NBCM CMMO?
2<=;2+>=287 8/ .A=;.6.<
3? QCFF <? =IH=?LH?> CH NBCM M?=NCIH QCNB NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ NB? G;RCGOG
IL NB? GCHCGOG L?NOLH I@ ; MNI=E ?@IL? JL?M?HNCHA NB? G;CH L?MOFNM
Q?
H??> MIG? HIN;NCIHM (?N D ( ( D4 <? ; M?KO?H=? I@ L;H>IG P;LC;<F?M =IL
L?MJIH>CHA NI L?NOLHM 3? HINC=? NB;N
+ 94
_ +' / D ( ( D4
_ +D
_( ( D4
_
4
-
+ DN
_ 28 _
4 '
N
B:/29 `
"/* "/* `
3<? ` (
3<? `
(
?P052A
`
+ '
"/* `
3<? ` + (
28 6@ A52; @.61 A< /29<;4 A< A52 1<:.6; <3 .AA?.0A6<; <3 4 (52 A5?22 16@A?6
/BA6<;@ .?2 0.9921 @A.;1.?1 2EA?2:2 C.9B2 16@A?6/BA6<;@
%H "CAOL?
Q? L?JL?M?HN NBIM? P;LCIOM >CMNLC<ONCIHM %N CM QILNB ?GJB;
MCTCHA NB;N NB? >CMNLC<ONCIHM =;HHIN <? XCJJ?> MSGG?NLC=;FFS ;LIOH> ; P?LNC=;F
;RCM 0BCM CGJFC?M CHNOCNCP?FS NB;N NI A?N ; >CMNLC<ONCIH MO=B ;M NB? 3?C<OFFZM
NB? MOJJILN I@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH OH>?LFSCHA NB? L;H>IG P;LC;<F?M GOMN <? WHCN?
3? ;FMI I<M?LP? NB;N NB? #OG<?F >CMNLC<ONCIH A?H?L;N?M NBCH N;CFM
QB?L?;M
@N?L ;FF
; MOG I@ ??; L;H>IG P;LC;<F?M ;FMI >?A?H?L;N?M ;M NB? M;GJF? MCT? CH
=L?;M?M QB?L?;M ; M=;F?> P?LMCIH =IHP?LA?M
NB;HEM NI NB? =?HNL;F FCGCN NB?IL?G
1
Wei bull
Gumbell
0.9 Fréchet
0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
-10 -8 -6 -4 -2 0 2 4 6 8 10
NB? "Lf=B?N >CMNLC<ONCIH A?H?L;N?M @;N N;CFM !GJCLC=;F ?PC>?H=? MOAA?MNM NB;N
L?NOLHM ;L? @;NN;CF?> 0BCM CH>C=;N?M NB;N NB? "Lf=B?N >CMNLC<ONCIH CM FCE?FS NI
>?M=LC<? NB? <?B;PCIL I@ ?RNL?G?M I@ MNI=E G;LE?N L?NOLHM <?NN?L NB;H NB?
INB?L NQI >CMNLC<ONCIHM @IL ; @ILG;F ?GJCLC=;F N?MN M?? (IHACH
(IL?N;H
;H> ,BCFFCJM
;M Q?FF ;M &IH>?;O ;H> .I=ECHA?L
=
@IL ?G?LACHA
G;LE?NM
/IG?NCG?M CN CM OM?@OF NI H?MN NB? NBL?? >CMNLC<ONCIHM 0BCM CM ;=BC?P?> <S NB?
42;2?.96G21 2EA?2:2 C.9B2 >CMNLC<ONCIH A?P CHNLI>O=?> <S &?HECHMIH
%N CM >?WH?> ;M
"/*
`
C@ ;H>
` + (
4 `
"/* "/* `
C@ '
3? NB?H HINC=? NB;N NB? MN;H>;L> ?RNL?G? P;FO? >CMNLC<ONCIHM =;H <? L?=IP?L?>
QCNB
.?NOLHM =;HHIN <? <?SIH>
QBC=B =ILL?MJIH>M NI <;HELOJN=S "IL NBCM
L?;MIH
NB? F?@N N;CF I@ NB? L?NOLH MOJJILN CM <IOH>?> $IQ?P?L
;M FIHA ;M IH
;P?L;A? L?NOLHM ;L? @;L ;Q;S @LIG NBCM <IOH>;LS
@;N N;CFM ;L? ; JIMMC<CFCNS @IL ;
ACP?H M;GJF?
1HCP;LC;N? N;CF ?MNCG;NCIH
;H> 3? ;FMI >?WH? NB? A?P >CMNLC<ONCIH @IL HIHMN;H>;L>CT?> ?RNL?G?M
;M
Q? IGCN CH>?R @ IH ;H> ! NI FCABN?H HIN;NCIHM QB?H NB?L? CM HI ;G<CAOCNS
!
$
# "/*
H
C@ ;H>
H
+ (
4 T
$
" "/* "/* H
C@
;*912,*5 *7*5B<2<
4
MMOG? NB;N ; M;GJF? I@ @ I<M?LP;NCIHM '_N (N CM ;P;CF;<F? 3? =IHMNLO=N
: BCMNILC?M MIG?NCG?M =;FF?> /9<08@
NB;N CM HIHIP?LF;JJCHA MO<M;GJF?M
I@ F?HANB :
QCNB %@ *: & QB?L? %'& >?HIN?M NB? CHN?A?L J;LN 0B?L?@IL?
0.8
ξ=1.4
ξ=0.7
0.7
ξ=0
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
-4 -2 0 2 4 6 8 10 12
20
$13 <3 C.?6<B@ ?P052A 16@A?6/BA6<;@
_ ( ( _. )_. ( ( _ . ) )_ . ( ( _ . '
"IL CHMN;H=?
NB? F?HANB : G;S <? =BIM?H NI =IP?L ;JJLIRCG;N?FS GIHNBFS
IL KO;LN?LFS >;N; *IQ Q? =IHMC>?L NB? G;RCGOG IP?L ?;=B : BCMNILS 0B?
G;RCGOG I@ NB? PNB MO<M;GJF? CM >?WH?> ;M
TD ' / _D. ( ( _D. ( P
( ( '
0BCM JLIPC>?M OM QCNB ; H?Q M;GJF? I@ G;RCG; 'TD (D '
"CAOL? >CMJF;SM NB? NCG? M?LC?M I@ NB? /, >;CFS L?NOLH ;H> NB? NCG?
M?LC?M I@ GCHCG; ;H> G;RCG; IP?L MO<M;GJF?M I@ : >;SM 1MCHA NBCM
M;GJF? I@ ?RNL?G;
NB? BCMNIAL;G CM ; MCGJF? Q;S NI PCMO;FCT? NB? NSJ? I@ N;CF
<?B;PCIL "CAOL? >CMJF;SM MO=B BCMNIAL;G @IL GCHCG; ;H> G;RCG; L?NOLHM
0B? =IGJ;LCMIH I@ NBCM WAOL? QCNB NB? >CMNLC<ONCIHM >CMJF;S?> CH "CAOL?
;FFIQM ;H ?>O=;N?> 4B2@@ I@ NB? NSJ? I@ ?RNL?G? P;FO? >CMNLC<ONCIH Q? ;L?
>?;FCHA QCNB #OG<?F ;M Q?FF ;M !G<L?=BNM
'FkJJ?F<?LA
;H> )CEIM=B
CHMCMN IH NB? CGJILN;H=? I@ MO=B ; AL;JBC=;F ;H;FSMCM
MIG?QB;N GIL? KO;HNCN;NCP? ;JJLI;=B CM NB? KO;HNCF? JFIN IL --JFIN
3? >?WH? NB? CHP?LM? @OH=NCIH I@ ; =IHNCHOIOM 013 2 ;M
2 W
AJ ( @IL ) W )
'
1HCP;LC;N? N;CF ?MNCG;NCIH
6 6
4 4
2 2
0 0
-2 -2
-4 -4
-6 -6
-8 -8
-10 -10
1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005
Minima Maxima
20 18
18 16
16
14
14
12
12
10
10
8
8
6
6
4
4
2 2
0 0
-10 -5 0 0 5 10
0BCM @OH=NCIH CM ;FMI =;FF?> NB? KO;HNCF? @OH=NCIH I@ NB? 2 %N =;H <? CHN?LJL?N?>
;M NB? P;FO? I@ D MO=B NB;N W J?L=?HN I@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH CM <?FIQ NBCM P;FO?
3? EHIQ NB;N C@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH @OH=NCIH I@ D CM CH NB? >IG;CH I@ ;NNL;=
NCIH I@ 4
@IL ACP?H
;H> !
NB?H NB? G;RCG; TD ( P
( (
(
!
MI NB;N NB? KO;HNCF? I@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH CM
P P
4 &)# &)# '
"CH;FFS
C@ NB? >;N; CM NLOFS
A?H?L;N?>
<S ; #OG<?F >CMNLC<ONCIH
NB? JFIN I@
D
TD ;A;CHMN &)# &)# MBIOF> <? LIOABFS FCH?;L
0I =B?=E @IL FCH?;LCNS
CN =;H <? OM?@OF NI NL;=? NB? +(/ L?AL?MMCIH FCH? I@
NB? WN I@ NB? NB?IL?NC=;F IH NB? ?GJCLC=;F KO;HNCF?M %@ Q? N;E? NB? #OG<?F
>CMNLC<ONCIH ;M L?@?L?H=? >CMNLC<ONCIH
Q? B;P? NB? @IFFIQCHA =IH=FOMCIHM %@ NB?
KO;HNCF? JFIN CM =IH=;P?
NB?H NB? FCGCN >CMNLC<ONCIH CM "Lf=B?N %@ NB? KO;HNCF?
JFIN CM =IHP?R
NB? FCGCN >CMNLC<ONCIH CM 3?C<OFF
"CAOL? JL?M?HNM NB? KO;HNCF? JFIN @IL NQI JIF;L =;M?M +H NB? F?@N MC>?
N NBCM MN;A?
NB? HILG;FCT;NCIH =IHMN;HNM ;L? OHEHIQH /CH=? Q? ;L? IHFS CHN?L
?MN?> CH =B?=ECHA FCH?;LCNS I@ NB? L?F;NCIHMBCJ
Q? =;H MN;H>;L>CT? B CH NB? OMO;F
Q;S ;M B B
1HCP;LC;N? N;CF ?MNCG;NCIH
5 5
4 4
Theoretical quantile
Theoretical quantile
3 3
2 2
1 1
0 0
-1 -1
-2 -2
0.85 0.9 0.95 1 0 5 10 15
Empirical quantile Empirical quantile
5 5
4 4
Theoretical quantile
Theoretical quantile
3 3
2 2
1 1
0 0
-1 -1
-2 -2
0 5 10 15 20 0 5 10 15
Empirical quantile Empirical quantile
1.69F ?2AB?;@
!RNL?G? 2;FO? 0B?ILS
! 2@A6:.A6<;
0B? )( ?MNCG;NCIH B;M <??H >?M=LC<?> @IL CHMN;H=? <S 0C;AI >? +FCP?CL;
/GCNB IL (IHACH (?N ( ( !
<? NB? P?=NIL I@ OHEHIQH J;L;G?N?LM ;H> >?HIN? 4
4 0B?H
NB?
FCE?FCBII> I@ NB? A?P >CMNLC<ONCIH CM MCGJFS ACP?H <S NB? ?RJL?MMCIH
-
8 )TD ( P
( (
O
TD
' $ (
TD
(
D
QB?L? O
T
CM NB? =13 I@ NB? A?P >CMNLC<ONCIH
N;ECHA NBL?? P;FO?M >?J?H>CHA
IH NB? MCNO;NCIH ;H>
H
+ ( NB? MCNO;NCIH ( ;H> NI ;FF INB?L
MCNO;NCIHM
;M CH>C=;N?> <S
!
$
$ H H
$
#
"/*
(
O
T
$
H
$
$
$ "/* L (
"
'
QB?L? GD
>?HIN?M NB? FIAFCE?FCBII> I@ ; MCHAF? I<M?LP;NCIH %H NB? =;M?
@IL CHMN;H=?
Q? B;P?
TD $
GD
&)# !
L (
!
QBCF? @IL Q? B;P?
TD TD
GD
&)# !
&)#
(
! !
&24?2@@6<;/.@21 2@A6:.A6<;
0B? G?NBI> OH>?LFSCHA NB? --JFIN JL?M?HN?> ;<IP? =;H <? JOMB?> ; <CN
@OLNB?L NI SC?F> ?MNCG;N?M I@ A?P J;L;G?N?LM
;H> ! M?? #OG<?F
0BCM ?MNCG;NCIH JLI=?>OL? CM <;M?> IH NB? JLIJ?LNS
P
1 4 TD
( @IL P
( ( '
0BCM JLIJ?LNS B;M <??H CGJFC=CNFS OM?> @IL NB? =IHMNLO=NCIH I@ NB? --JFIN
0BCM ?RJL?MMCIH MOAA?MNM NB;N NI ?MNCG;N? NB? J;L;G?N?LM
( ;H> ! IH?
=IOF> GCHCGCT? NB? >CMN;H=? <?NQ??H NB? IL>?L?> MN;NCMNC=M 4 TD
;H>
NB?CL NB?IL?NC=;F =IOHN?LJ;LN P*
'
/CH=? NB? ?RJL?MMCIH I@ NB? A?P >CMNLC<ONCIH >?J?H>M IH NB? P;FO? I@
Q?
=IHMC>?L NB? =;M?M ;H> CH NOLH 3B?H ( NB? A?P >CMNLC<ONCIH
CM ACP?H <S
T T
4 T
"/*
C@
+
! !
0BOM
C@ Q? N;E? FIAM NQC=? ;H> CHNLI>O=? ; QBCN? HICM? #D ( Q? I<N;CH
P
TD
&)# &)# &)#
#D P
( ( '
!
!RNL?G? 2;FO? 0B?ILS
0BCM ?KO;NCIH =;H HIQ <? WNN?> NI NB? MILN?> M;GJF? I@ G;RCG; QCNB ; MN;H
>;L> HIHFCH?;L IJNCGCT;NCIH JLI=?>OL? 0B?H
NB? L?AL?MMCIH<;M?> ?MNCG;NCIH
CM I<N;CH?> <S MIFPCHA NB? JLI<F?G
,
P
TD
'%( &)# &)# &)#
'
D
!
3B?H ( NB? A?P >CMNLC<ONCIH L?>O=?M NI
T
4 T
"/* "/*
!
%@ IH=? ;A;CH Q? N;E? FIAM NQC=? ;H> CHNLI>O=? ; L;H>IG HICM? #N ( Q? I<N;CH
P TD
&)# &)# #D P
( ( '
!
0BCM G?NBI>IFIAS B;M <??H ;JJFC?> <S (IHACH NI MBIQ NB;N ;MM?N L?NOLH
N;CFM ;L? @IFFIQCHA ; "Lf=B?N >CMNLC<ONCIH
55><=;*=287
3? CFFOMNL;N? MIG? I@ NB? L?MOFNM JL?M?HN?> ;<IP? QCNB NB? >;CFS L?NOLHM I@ NB?
/,
4
"0/!
;H> *CEE?C IP?L NB? J?LCI> @LIG NI "IL ?;=B
M?LC?M
Q? =IGJON? GCHCG; ;H> G;RCG; IP?L MO<M;GJF?M I@ ;JJLIRCG;N?FS ;
NB? ?MNCG;N?M I<N;CH?> @IL NB? G;LE?NM ;L? CH A?H?L;F L;NB?L =FIM? HIN;<F?
>C_?L?H=? FC?M CH NB? N;CF CH>?R I@ NB? *CEE?C NB;N CM MCAHCW=;HNFS MG;FF?L NB;H
NB? CH>?R I<N;CH?> @IL INB?L G;LE?NM %H =IHNL;MN
CNM >CMJ?LMCIH J;L;G?N?L !
CM F;LA?L 0BCM MOAA?MNM NB;N NB?L? ;L? F?MM P?LS F;LA? ?RNL?G;
<ON NB;N NB?
L;HA? I@ ?RNL?G?M CM QC>?L 0BCL>
NB? >C_?L?H=?M <?NQ??H NB? J;L;G?N?LM I@
NB? F?@N N;CF ;H> NB? LCABN N;CF ;L? L;NB?L MG;FF 0B?L? CM HI MSMN?G;NC= J;NN?LH
%@ Q? =IGJ;L? NBCM L?MOFN QCNB "CAOL?
NBCM L?MOFN M??GM L?;MIH;<F? 0BCM
NSJ? I@ <?B;PCIL B;M ;FMI <??H @IOH> <S &IH>?;O ;H> .I=ECHA?L =
&*25 -2<=;2+>=287
0B? ;JJLI;=B <;M?> IH NB? GI>?FCHA I@ NB? N;CFM I@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH ;FMI
=;FF?> J?;EIP?LNBL?MBIF> ;JJLI;=B Q;M CHNLI>O=?> <S ;FE?G; ;H> >? $;;H
,C=E;H>M
;PCMIH
;H> $IMECHA ;H> 3;FFCM /??
;FMI .IINTfH ;H> 0;DPC>C ;H> )=*?CF
1HCP;LC;N? N;CF ?MNCG;NCIH
4
"0/!
*CEE?C
2O `
+DN \
`)DN + \ (
` ) _' \
28 \
6@ 0.9921 A52 2E02@@ 16@A?6/BA6<; 3B;0A6<; 213 <3 A52 ?.;1<: C.?6./92@ DN <C2?
A52 A5?2@5<91 \ (52 3B;0A6<;
L \
DN \)DN + \
!RNL?G? 2;FO? 0B?ILS
0B? ?R=?MM >CMNLC<ONCIH @OH=NCIH G?;MOL?M NB? JLI<;<CFCNS NB;N NB? ?R=?MM
L?;FCT;NCIH L?F;NCP? NI NB? NBL?MBIF> DN \ CM <?FIQ ; =?LN;CH P;FO? `
ACP?H
NB;N NB? L?;FCT;NCIH CM ;<IP? NB? NBL?MBIF> \ 0B? G?;H?R=?MM @OH=NCIH ;P?L
;A?M NBIM? L?;FCT;NCIHM NB;N ?R=??> \ ;H> =IHMC>?LM NB? >CMN;H=? <?NQ??H NB?
G?;H ;H> \' "IL CHMN;H=?
Q? B;P? NB? @IFFIQCHA G?;H?R=?MM @OH=NCIHM @IL
MIG? MN;H>;L> >CMNLC<ONCIHM 28
,;L?NI R \
*
( @IL
+
3?C<OFF \
*J
!RJIH?HNC;F
*
H CGJILN;HN L?MOFN
?MN;<FCMB?> <S ;FE?G; ;H> >? $;;H ;H> ,C=E;H>M
L?F;N?M NB? FCGCN >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ NB? M=;F?> ?R=?MM?M IP?L NBL?MBIF> NI
NB? N;CF CH>?R
&1.8;.6 3 28 6@ 6; A52 1<:.6; <3 .AA?.0A6<; <3 A52 2EA?2:2 C.9B2 16@
A?6/BA6<; 4 A52 2E02@@ 16@A?6/BA6<; 3B;0A6<; 2O `
0.; /2 .==?<E6:.A21 3<?
\ 9.?42 /F
2O `
3 `
( \ (
D52?2 !
#
` ( 63 (
3 `
"
"/* S ( 63 (
F?;LFS
NB? N;CF CH>?R @LIG NB? A?P CM NB? M;G? ;M @IL NB? AJ> H
CFFOMNL;NCIH I@ NBCM >?HMCNS =;H <? @IOH> CH "CAOL? @IL ; M?N I@ J;L;G?N?LM
NB;N NSJC=;FFS ;LCM?M CH WH;H=? \ ;H> !
H CH=L?;M? I@ ( @IL ;
=IHMN;HN F?P?F I@ NB? M=;F? @;=NIL !( CH=L?;M?M NB? N;CF QBCF? MN??J?HCHA NB?
MFIJ? ;N NB? GIL? =?HNL;F J;LN I@ NB? >?HMCNS 0BIM? L?MOFNM CH>C=;N? NB;N C@ Q?
=BIIM? ; BCAB ?HIOAB NBL?MBIF>
NB?H NB? WN I@ ; AJ> NI NB? N;CF L?;FCT;NCIHM
QCFF ;FMI SC?F> ;H ?MNCG;N? I@ NB? N;CF CH>?R %@ Q? ;L? HIN CHN?L?MN?> CH NB?
1HCP;LC;N? N;CF ?MNCG;NCIH
Q? G;S HIN <? ;<F? NI A?N NB? LCABN N;CF MB;J? 0B? ?MNCG;NCIHM I@ NB? A?P
>CMNLC<ONCIH CH NB? JL?PCIOM M?=NCIH MOAA?MN NB;N NB? ?GJCLC=;F N;CFM JLI<;<FS
FIIE FCE? NB? =OLP? I<N;CH?> QCNB '
M ;H CFFOMNL;NCIH
Q? JFIN CH "CAOL? NB? BCMNIAL;G I@ NB? MG;FF?MN
L?NOLHM FIQ?L IL F?@N N;CF ;H> NB? F;LA?MN L?NOLHM OJJ?L IL LCABN N;CF
0B? BCMNIAL;G =;H <? =IGJ;L?> QCNB NB? >CMNLC<ONCIHM >CMJF;S?> CH "CAOL?
NI A?N ;H CHMCABN I@ NB? L;HA? @IL ' "CAOL? >CMJF;SM NB? G?;H ?R=?MM
@OH=NCIH @IL NB? I<M?LP;NCIHM CH NB? NQI N;CFM Q? IGCN NB? GIMN ?RNL?G?
L?;FCT;NCIHM NI A?N ; HC=? WAOL? 0BCM WAOL? MOAA?MNM NB;N NB? N;CFM I@ NB?
>CMNLC<ONCIH G;S <? >L;QH @LIG ; ,;L?NI >CMNLC<ONCIH
0.9
ξ = 1.5
ξ = 0.25
0.8 ξ = -0.5
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
20 $13 <3 A52 4=1 3<? C.?6<B@ C.9B2@ <3
!RNL?G? 2;FO? 0B?ILS
200 200
150 150
100 100
50 50
0 0
-10 -5 0 0 5 10
20 6@A<4?.: <3 A52 9<D2? .;1 B==2? A.69@ <3 '$
1.69F ?2AB?;@
1.1 1.1
1.05 1.05
1 1
0.95 0.95
0.9 0.9
0.85 0.85
0.8 0.8
0.75 0.75
0.7 0.7
0.65 0.65
1 1.5 2 2.5 3 1 1.5 2 2.5 3
u u
20 !2.; 2E02@@ 3B;0A6<; 3<? A52 9<D2? .;1 B==2? A.69@ <3 '$
1.69F ?2AB?;@
1HCP;LC;N? N;CF ?MNCG;NCIH
%H /?=NCIH
NB? ?MNCG;NCIH I@ NB? N;CF CH>?R Q;M <;M?> IH ; M;GJF? I@
?RNL?G?M
;MMOGCHA NB;N NB? ?R;=N >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ L?NOLHM Q;M NB? A?P >CMNLC
<ONCIH 4 *IQ
Q? JLIPC>? ;H ;FN?LH;NCP? ;JJLI;=B NI ?MNCG;NCHA NB? N;CF
CH>?R
IHFS ;MMOGCHA NB;N NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ D ( ( D4
CM CH NB? >IG;CH
I@ ;NNL;=NCIH I@ 4 %N MBIOF> <? HINC=?> BIQ?P?L NB;N NB? ?MNCG;NCIH JLI
=?>OL?M >?M=LC<?> CH NBCM M?=NCIH L?FS IH NB? ;MMOGJNCIH NB;N D ( ( D4
0B? G;CH >C^=OFNS CH NB? OM? I@ NB? N;CF ;JJLI;=B CM NB? =BIC=? I@ NB? NBL?MBIF>
\ 0BCM NBL?MBIF> B;M NI <? BCAB ?HIOAB ;M NI ?HMOL? NB;N NB? FCGCN >CMNLC<ONCIH
I@ NB? ?R=?MM >CMNLC<ONCIH @OH=NCIH CM ;=NO;FFS ; AJ> 0BCM MOAA?MNM NB? OM? I@ ;
L;NB?L F;LA? NBL?MBIF> $IQ?P?L
;M \ <?=IG?M F;LA?L
NB?L? ;L? @?Q?L ;H> @?Q?L
I<M?LP;NCIHM CH=FO>?> CH NB? AJ> ?MNCG;NCIH 0BCM G;E?M NB? ?MNCG;NCIH I@
;H> ! OHMN;<F?
QCNB F;LA? MN;H>;L> ?LLILM +H NB? INB?L B;H>
;M \ >?=L?;M?M
NB? =B;H=? I@ ;H I<M?LP;NCIH NB;N >I?M HIN <?FIHA NI NB? N;CF >CMNLC<ONCIH
<?CHA CH=FO>?> CH NB? AJ> ?MNCG;NCIH CH=L?;M?M 0B?L?@IL?
\ MBIOF> ;FMI <?
M?F?=N?> CH MO=B ; Q;S NB;N NB? HOG<?L I@ I<M?LP;NCIHM ;<IP? NB? NBL?MBIF>
<? MO^=C?HN NI ?HMOL? ;H ;==OL;N? ?MNCG;NCIH I@ NB? OHEHIQH J;L;G?N?LM
+<PCIOMFS
NB? JLIJ?LNC?M I@ NB? ?MNCG;NILM CH WHCN? M;GJF? >?J?H> IH NB?
HOG<?L I@ I<M?LP;NCIHM OM?> CH NB? ?MNCG;NCIH I@ NB? J;L;G?N?LM I@ CHN?L?MN
! \
L \
1 D \)D + \ (
MI NB;N CN CM ; FCH?;L @OH=NCIH CH \'
H ?MNCG;N? I@ NB? G?@ L \
( >?HIN?> L \
QB?L? [
( ( @ ( (
!RNL?G? 2;FO? 0B?ILS
4
;H> QB?L? '_N4 (N CM NB? M;GJF? I@ IL>?L?> I<M?LP;NCIHM 0B? L?F;NCIH
MOAA?MNM NB;N NB? NBL?MBIF> \ MBIOF> <? =BIM?H MO=B NB;N NB? JFIN I@ L _N4
! 2@A6:.A6<;
?N;CFM IH NB? )( ?MNCG;NCIH =;H <? @IOH> CH /GCNB 0B? P?=NIL I@
OHEHIQH J;L;G?N?LM CM ( !
(?N '_4 ( ( _44 ( <? NB?
P?=NIL I@ L?NOLHM MILN?> <S CH=L?;MCHA IL>?L
MO=B NB;N _4
_44 3?
NB?H
)4 M?F?=N NB? L?;FCT;NCIHM _N NB;N ;L? ;<IP? NB? NBL?MBIF> \ 3? >?WH? :O
N
R* O _N
NB? HOG<?L I@ ?R=??>;H=?M "IL ?;M? I@ ?RJIMCNCIH
Q? >?WH?
NB? :O (
P?=NIL I@ ?R=??>;H=?M ;M '] ( ( ].+ ( '_4 .+ 4 ( ( _44 (
0B?H
NB? FCE?FCBII> I@ NB? AJ> >CMNLC<ONCIH CM ACP?H <S NB? ?RJL?MMCIH
.+
-
8.+ )]D ( P
( ( :O
NO ]D
' P O ( ]D
(
D
QB?L? NO ]
CM NB? =13 I@ NB? AJ> >CMNLC<ONCIH
ACP?H <S
!
# !
] \
(
NO ]
" ! "/* PO '
%HN?L?MNCHAFS
/GCNB B;M >?LCP?> NB? ;MSGJNINC= >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ - ,
JLIPC>?> +
* ;H> OH>?L NB? ;MMOGJNCIH I@ 661 I<M?LP;NCIHM' 3? B;P?
1HCP;LC;N? N;CF ?MNCG;NCIH
+
@ - , ( '
0B? ;>P;HN;A? I@ NBCM ;JJLI;=B ;M =IGJ;L?> QCNB NB? ?RNL?G? IH? CM NB;N
Q? =;H OM? ;FF L?;FCT;NCIHM ?R=??>CHA \ ;H> HIN IHFS NB? G;RCG; IP?L T
BCMNILC?M IHM?KO?HNFS
NBCM G?NBI> CM FCE?FS NI SC?F> GIL? ?^=C?HN ?MNCG;N?M
0B? M?F?=NCIH I@ NB? NBL?MBIF> \ CM
OH@ILNOH;N?FS
; >L;Q<;=E I@ NBCM ;JJLI;=B'
55><=;*=287
Q? L?JILN NB? ?MNCG;NCIH I@ NB? J;L;G?N?LM I@ NB? FIQ?L N;CF QCNB ;H> QCNBION
NB? I<M?LP;NCIH I@ NB? +=NI<?L =L;MB +H=? ;A;CH
Q? I<N;CH NB;N NBCM
I<M?LP;NCIH IHFS ;_?=NM NB? ?MNCG;NCIH I@ NB? F?@N N;CF I@ NB? /, >CMNLC<ONCIH
&*+5.
$.?.:2A2? 2@A6:.A2@ <3 A52 4=1 16@A?6/BA6<;
(IQ?L N;CF
(IQ?L N;CF 1JJ?L N;CF
HI =L;MB
/,
4
"0/!
*CEE?C
MOAA?MNM
IH=? ;A;CH
NB;N NB?L? ;L? F?MM P?LS F;LA? ?RNL?G; <ON NB;N NB?CL
L;HA? CM QC>?L "IL NB? /, ;H> NB? "0/!
NB? N;CF CH>C=?M IH NB? LCABN
N;CF ;L? @IOH> NI <? MG;FF?L NB;H NBIM? IH NB? F?@N N;CF %@ Q? =IGJ;L? QCNB
"CAOL?
NBCM L?MOFN M??GM L?;MIH;<F?
L?X?=NCHA NB? F;LA? ;MSGG?NLS CH NB?
>CMNLC<ONCIH
"CAOL? >CMJF;SM NB? ;>DOMNG?HN I@ NB? 013 I@ NB? ?MNCG;N?> AJ> NI NB?
;=NO;F 013 I@ NB? N;CFM I@ NB? /, L?NOLHM 0B? WN ;JJ?;LM <LI;>FS =ILL?=N
0.9 0.9
0.8 0.8
0.7 0.7
0.6 0.6
0.5 0.5
0.4 0.4
0.3 0.3
0.2 0.2
0.1 0.1
Empirical Empirical
Theoretical Theoretical
0 0
0 2 4 6 8 0 2 4 6 8
20 <:=.?6@<; <3 A52 2:=6?60.9 .;1 A52<?2A60.9 013 <3 A52 4=1
--2=287*5 ;.<>5=<
0B? @;=N NB;N L?NOLHM ;L? F?JNIEOLNC= B;M F?;> NI NB?CL GI>?FCHA QCNB @;NN;CF?>
>CMNLC<ONCIHM /IG? I@ NB?M? >CMNLC<ONCIHM
MO=B ;M );H>?F<LINZM MN;<F?
F;Q
>I HIN ;FFIQ @IL ; WHCN? P;LC;H=? #CP?H NB? ?GJCLC=;F <?B;PCIL I@ NB?
N;CFM I@ L?NOLH >CMNLC<ONCIH
NB? CMMO? I@ NB? 2E6@A2;02 <3 :<:2;A@ =;H ;A;CH
<? ;>>L?MM?> QCNBCH NB? N;CF ;JJLI;=B !G<L?=BNM
'FkJJ?F<?LA
;H> )CEIM=B
J L?=;FF NB;N
C@ D CM >CMNLC<ON?> QCNB ; N;CF CH>?R
NB?H @IL ;FF
CHN?A?LM Y MO=B NB;N Y )
*
NB? YNB GIG?HN ?RCMNM QCNB
! L Y
1D L Y'
L
$608.;1@ 2@A6:.A<?
0BCM ?MNCG;NIL Q;M CHNLI>O=?> <S ,C=E;H>M OMCHA MIG? L?MOFNM IH
FCGCN >CMNLC<ONCIHM MMOG? NB;N '_ ( ( _4 ( B;M ; >CMNLC<ONCIH @OH=NCIH NB;N
<?FIHAM NI NB? >IG;CH I@ ;NNL;=NCIH I@ 4 ;H> >?WH? IL>?L?> L?;FCT;NCIHM
'_4 ( ( _44 ( QCNB _4
_44 0B?H
NB? ,C=E;H>M ?MNCG;
NIL CM >?WH?> <S
0
_4 K4 _4 K4
K4 &)# ( @IL
X
@ *(
&)#
_4 K4 _4 K4
(
QB?L?
*
&)#
0BCM JFIN G;S B?FJ M?F?=NCHA NB? ;JJLIJLC;N? P;FO? I@ NB? N;CF MCT? X( ;FNBIOAB
NB?L? CM HI IJNCG;F M?F?=NCIH =LCN?LCIH 3? QCFF NOLH NI NB;N CMMO? F;N?L IH H
;>P;HN;A? I@ NBCM ?MNCG;NIL CM NB;N CN CM >?WH?> @IL ;FF 0B?L?@IL?
CN =;H
<? OM?> NI >CM=LCGCH;N? <?NQ??H NB? NBL?? ?RNL?G? P;FO? >CMNLC<ONCIHM
699 2@A6:.A<?
0BCM G?NBI>
>?M=LC<?> CH $CFF
JL?MOG?M NB;N '_ ( ( _4 ( B;M ; >CM
NLC<ONCIH @OH=NCIH NB;N <?FIHAM NI NB? >IG;CH I@ ;NNL;=NCIH I@ NB? "Lf=B?N
?RNL?G? P;FO? >CMNLC<ONCIH + 3? =IHMC>?L ;A;CH _E4 NB? QNB F;LA?MN
P;FO? CMMO?> @LIG NB? L;Q M;GJF? >;N; $CFFZM G?NBI> ?MNCG;N?M OM
CHA
K
(
, _4 E4
K4 &)# ( @IL
X ) @'
X E _4 K4
(
3B?H NB? DM ;L? 661
CN B;M <??H MBIQH NB;N K4 CM MNLIHAFS =IHMCMN?HN ;H>
;MSGJNINC=;FFS HILG;F QCNB >CMNLC<ONCIH
+ (
X K4 ( '
(
"IL Q?;EFS >?J?H>?HN P;LC;<F?M
K4 L?G;CHM Q?;EFS =IHMCMN?HN "IL ?GJCLC
(
=;F JOLJIM?M
NB? P;LC;H=? =;H <? ?MNCG;N?> OMCHA K4 %N B;M <??H MBIQH
NB;N C@ NB? DN ;L? A?H?L;N?> <S ; "Lf=B?N >CMNLC<ONCIH NB?H NB? $CFF ?MNCG;
NIL QCFF SC?F> ; GIL? ?^=C?HN N;CF CH>?R NB;H NB? ,C=E;H>M ?MNCG;NIL M @IL
NB? ,C=E;H>M ?MNCG;NIL
Q? =;H >L;Q ; $CFF JFIN
NB;N G;S B?FJ NI WH> ;H
;JJLIJLC;N? N;CF MCT? X
, K
D
D
4 &)#
_4 E4
'
K4 X E _4 K4
*INC=? NB;N 4 CM DOMN NB? $CFF ?MNCG;NIL >?WH?> ;<IP? 1H>?L 661H?MM
NBCM
K4
?MNCG;NIL CM ;FMI MBIQH NI <? MNLIHAFS =IHMCMN?HN ;H> ;MSGJNINC=;FFS HILG;F
+ %&(
X K4 ( 0
QCNB
( C@ (
0
( C@ ) '
<:=.?6@<;
%H "CAOL?M NI
Q? JL?M?HN NB? ?MNCG;N? I@ NB? >C_?L?HN M?GC
J;L;G?NLC= ?MNCG;NILM I@ NB? N;CF CH>?R
@IL X L;HACHA @LIG NI M
CN ;JJ?;LM =F?;LFS @LIG NB?M? WAOL?M
NB?L? CM ; F;LA? ;GIOHN I@ B?N?LIA?H?CNS
;GIHA NB? ?MNCG;NCIHM 0B? ,C=E;H>M ?MNCG;NIL MOAA?MNM ; MG;FF
CHMCAHCW=;HN
P;FO? @IL NB? N;CF CH>?R 0B? $CFF ?MNCG;NIL JLIPC>?M ; N;CF CH>?R CH NB? L;HA?
' ' <ON >I?M HIN JLIPC>? ;HS CH>C=;NCIH IH ; JIMMC<F? P;FO? @IL NB? N;CF
MCT? X "CH;FFS
NB? !>$ ?MNCG;NIL ;JJ?;LM ;M NB? GIMN MN;<F? ?MNCG;NIL
QCNB
;H ;P?L;A? P;FO? @IL NB? N;CF CH>?R ;LIOH> @IL NB? FIQ?L N;CF ;H> @IL
NB? OJJ?L N;CF 0B?M? P;FO?M ;L? MFCABNFS MG;FF?L NB;H NBIM? I<N;CH?> QCNB NB?
?RNL?G; ;JJLI;=B
MSGJNINC= L?MOFNM @IL NB? M?GCJ;L;G?NLC= ?MNCG;NILM >?M=LC<?> ;<IP? CH>C
=;N? NB;N =IHMCMN?H=S ;H> ;MSGJNINC= HILG;FCNS ;L? L?;=B?> QB?H NB? N;CF MCT?
X CH=L?;M?M QCNB M;GJF? MCT?
<ON ;N ; MFIQ?L L;N? +@ =IOLM?
CN >I?M HIN JLI
PC>? ; =LCN?LCIH @IL M?F?=NCIH I@ NB? ;JJLIJLC;N? N;CF MCT? +H IH? B;H>
C@ Q?
=BIIM? ; NBL?MBIF> NII GO=B CH NB? N;CF
NB? ?MNCG;N? CM OH<C;M?> <?=;OM? NB?
;MSGJNINC= NB?ILS ;JJFC?M
<ON Q? I<N;CH P?LS CH;==OL;N? ?MNCG;N?M
<?=;OM?
DOMN NII @?Q I<M?LP;NCIHM ;L? OM?> CH NB? ?MNCG;NCIH +H NB? INB?L B;H>
C@ Q?
OM? GIL? I<M?LP;NCIHM
NB? P;LC;H=? I@ NB? ?MNCG;NIL CM L?>O=?>
<ON NB? <C;M
CH=L?;M?M
<?=;OM? N;CF I<M?LP;NCIHM ;L? NB?H =IHN;GCH;N?> <S I<M?LP;NCIHM
@LIG NB? =?HNL;F J;LN
!RNL?G? 2;FO? 0B?ILS
0.6 0.6
0.4 0.4
0.2 0.2
0 0
-0.2 -0.2
-0.4 -0.4
-0.6 -0.6
Pickands estimator Pickands estimator
90% confid. interval 90% confid. interval
-0.8 -0.8
0 200 400 600 0 200 400 600
q q
20 @A6:.A2@ <3 A52 $608.;1@ A.69 6;12E 3<? C.?6<B@ C.9B2@ <3 J
0.4 0.4
0.35 0.35
0.3 0.3
0.25 0.25
20
@A6:.A2@ <3 A52 699 A.69 6;12E 3<? C.?6<B@ C.9B2@ <3 J
1HCP;LC;N? N;CF ?MNCG;NCIH
0.4 0.4
0.3 0.3
0.2 0.2
0.1 0.1
0 0
-0.1 -0.1
20 @A6:.A2@ <3 A52 2082?@ 6;:.59 .;1 12 ..; A.69 6;12E 3<? C.?6<B@
C.9B2@ <3 J
IHM?KO?HNFS
NB?L? CM ; <C;MP;LC;H=? NL;>?I_ CH NB? M?F?=NCIH I@ X' M ;
=IHM?KO?H=?
NB?L? MBIOF> ?RCMN ;H [IJNCG;F\ N;CF MCT? 0B? WLMN ;NN?GJNM NI
>?N?LGCH? ;H IJNCG;F X AI <;=E NI $;FF ;H> 3?FMB ;H> $;FF
$;FF JLIJIM?> ; MO<M;GJF? <IINMNL;J JLI=?>OL? <;M?> IH NB? GCH
CGCT;NCIH I@ NB? G?;H MKO;L?> ?LLIL I@ NB? N;CF ?MNCG;N? 0BCM ;JJLI;=B
B;M <??H NB?L?;@N?L CGJLIP?> <S ;Hg?FMMIH ;H> >? 2LC?M FN?LH;NCP?
<IINMNL;J ;JJLI;=B?M B;P? <??H >?P?FIJ?> <S ;Hg?FMMIH ?N ;F
L??M
;H> ';O@G;H
;H> ?CLF;HN
2SH=EC?L
;H> 0?OA?FM (OR
=IGJ;L?M NB? >C_?L?HN N?=BHCKO?M ;H> =IH=FO>?M NB;N NB? P;LCIOM G?NBI>M @IL
M?F?=NCHA ;H IJNCG;F X JLIPC>? KOCN? MCGCF;L ION=IG?M CH N?LGM I@ NB? L?MOFN
CHA ( ?P?H NBIOAB NB? NBL?MBIF>M JLIJIM?> <S ?;=B G?NBI> G;S HIN <? NB?
M;G? $?L?;@N?L
Q? >?N;CF MIG? I@ NB?M? ;JJLI;=B?M NI ACP? ;H CHMCABN I@ NB?
Q;S L?M;GJF? <IINMNL;J G?NBI>M QILE
0B? <;MC= C>?; I@ <IINMNL;J JLI=?>OL? @IL M?F?=NCHA NB? IJNCG;F X CM NB?
@IFFIQCHA NB? IJNCG;F X CM NB? HOG<?L I@ IL>?L?> I<M?LP;NCIHM CH=FO>?> CH
NB? =IGJON;NCIH I@ NB? M;S $CFF ?MNCG;NIL NB;N GCHCGCT?M NB? G?;H MKO;L?>
(
?LLIL I@ 0B? IJNCG;F X CM NB?L?@IL? I<N;CH?> <S MIFPCHA
K4
4 ( 5
X +# '%( ! K4
'
K
NB? >?MCL?> NL;>?I_ <?NQ??H <C;M ;H> P;LC;H=? 0B? ;H;FSNC=;F ?RJL?MMCIH @IL
!RNL?G? 2;FO? 0B?ILS
QB?L?
* ;H> H
I ;H> ;L? ;>>CNCIH;F J;L;G?N?LM NB;N ;L? OHEHIQH
CH JL;=NC=? /CH=? NB?M? J;L;G?N?LM ;L? OHEHIQH
$;FF L?MILNM NI NB?
<IINMNL;J N?=BHCKO? NI GCHCGCT? NB? )/! 0B? C>?; =IHMCMNM CH ?MNCG;NCHA
NB? ?GJCLC=;F )/! <S =IGJ;LCHA MO<M;GJF? ?MNCG;N?M I@ NB? N;CF CH>?R QCNB
(
;H CHCNC;F P;FO? =IGJON?> IP?L NB? @OFF M;GJF? (?N 0 K 4 >?HIN? ;H CHCNC;F
?MNCG;N? I@ NB? N;CF CH>?R <;M?> IH ; L?;MIH;<FS =BIM?H X ;H> @ @ <?
NB? MO<M;GJF? MCT? 0B?H NB? IJNCG;F NBL?MBIF> X IP?L ; MO<M;GJF? I@ MCT?
@ CM ACP?H <S
( (
X +# '%( 1 0 '
K 4 K 4
K
%H JL;=NC=?
Q? =IHMNLO=N 7 L;H>IGFS M?F?=N?> MO<M;GJF?M I@ MCT? @ (?N
R
( ( 7 <? NB? CH>?R I@ NB? RNB MO<M;GJF? 3? =IGJON? NB? $CFF ?MNCG;N?
(F ( R
( ( 7 IP?L ;FF MCGOF;N?> MO<M;GJF?M H ;JJLIRCG;NCIH I@
K 4
CM NB?H ACP?H <S
, (F
+
(
K 4 0 K 4 '
7
F
"CH;FFS
NB? @OFF M;GJF? NBL?MBIF> X CM =IGJON?> ;H> NB? IJNCG;F $CFF N;CF
( (
CH>?R CM ?MNCG;N?> ;M #/ K 4 ' %N MBIOF> <? HINC=?> NB;N CH NBCM ;JJLI;=B
MIG? =BIC=?M B;P? NI <? G;>? <S NB? OM?L NB? CHCNC;F N;CF MCT? X OM?> NI
(
?MNCG;N? 0 K 4
NB? P;FO? I@ @ ;H> NB? HOG<?L I@ MCGOF;NCIHM 7 ;Hg?FMMIH
;H> >? 2LC?M =BIM? X @ *
@ @ *
;H> 7
;Hg?FMMIH ?N ;F >?M=LC<? ; MFCABNFS >C_?L?HN ;JJLI;=B @IL =IG
JONCHA NB? IJNCG;F N;CF MCT? X 0B?S I<M?LP? NB;N IH? I@ NB? >L;Q<;=EM I@
GCHCGCTCHA NB? )/! ACP?H <S CM NB;N CN L?KOCL?M ;H CHCNC;F ?MNCG;N? I@
0B?L?@IL?
NB?S >?P?FIJ ;H ;FN?LH;NCP? ?MNCG;NIL
<;M?> IH NB? GCHCGCT;NCIH
I@ NB? @IFFIQCHA )/!
(
X +# '%( 1 4
(
K 4 K 4
K
QB?L? 4
K 4 CM NB? M?=IH>IL>?L FIA;LCNBGC= GIG?HN >?WH?> CH 0I
;PIC> NB? ;>>CNCIH;F ?MNCG;NCIH I@ NB? J;L;G?N?L
NB?S MOAA?MN NB? OM? I@
NQI MO==?MMCP? <IINMNL;J ?R?L=CM?M %H NB? WLMN ?R?L=CM?
IH? >L;QM MO<M;GJF?M
I@ MCT? @ @ ;H> =IGJON?M NB? IJNCG;F N;CF MCT? X <S GCHCGCTCHA NB?
)/! ACP?H <S 0B?H IH? L?J?;NM NB? M;G? JLI=?>OL? @IL ;H ?P?H MG;FF?L
L?M;GJF? MCT? @ @ *@ ;H> I<N;CHM ; M?=IH> IJNCG;F N;CF MCT? X "CH;FFS
IH? =IGJON?M NB? IJNCG;F N;CF MCT? @IL NB? ;=NO;F M;GJF?
'
X
&)# X
X (
X &)# @
&)# X
( (
;H> I<N;CHM NB? IJNCG;F $CFF N;CF CH>?R ;M <?@IL? #/ K 4 '
WH? 94 ' / D ( ( D4
;H> 9 0 4 ' / D0( ( D
0 4
0B?H
;M MBIQH
<S (?;><?NN?L
(CH>AL?H
;H> .IINTfH
NB? MN;H>;L>CT?> ?RNL?G?M I@
NB? NQI M?LC?M B;P? NB? M;G? FCGCN >CMNLC<ONCIH 4 ACP?H CH 0B?IL?G OH
>?L NB? NQI @IFFIQCHA =IH>CNCIHM C NB? M?LC?M D B;M IHFS Q?;E FIHAL;HA?
>?J?H>?H=?
;H> CC NB?L? CM HI N?H>?H=S @IL ?RNL?G?M NI =FOMN?L
"IL WH;H=C;F M?LC?M
NB? @ILG?L =IH>CNCIH CM L;NB?L GCF>
<ON NB? F;NN?L CM
HIN FCE?FS NI ;JJFS "IL CHMN;H=?
#.$ JLI=?MM?M ;L? Q?;EFS >?J?H>?HN
<ON
B;P? =FOMN?LCHA I@ ?RNL?G?M 3B?H IH? I@ NB? NQI =IH>CNCIHM CM HIN M;NCMW?>
$kMF?L
;H> (?;><?NN?L
!G<L?=BNM
'FkJJ?F<?LA
;H> )CEIM=B
0
&)#
7O *
'
: &)#
:O * U
;MMOG? NB;N L?NOLHM ;L? CH>??> >L;QH @LIG NB? #.$ GI>?F #N N aN
NB? @;NN;CF?>H?MM I@ L?NOLHM =IG?M @LIG NB? @;NN;CF?>H?MM I@ CHHIP;NCIHM
<ON
;FMI @LIG PIF;NCFCNS =FOMN?LCHA %N CM NB?L?@IL? I@ AL?;N CGJILN;H=? NI G?;MOL?
NB? ?RN?HN NI QBC=B NB? >?J?H>?H=? MNLO=NOL? CM FCE?FS NI ;_?=N NB? <?B;PCIL
I@ ?RNL?G?M 0BCM G?;MOL? =;H <? I<N;CH?> <S NB? ?RNL?G;F CH>?R
0B? WLMN ;NN?GJN NI =IGJON? NB? ?RNL?G;F CH>?R I@ ;H .$ JLI=?MM
AI?M <;=E NI >? $;;H ?N ;F MMOG? NB? MN;H>;L> .$
JLI=?MM
#N "
# N aN QCNB )
)
;H> aN ;H 661 (
P;LC;<F?
*INC=?
NB;N CN =;H <? L?QLCNN?H CH ; MFCABNFS >C_?L?HN @ILG ;M # N
aN # N "aN
+
!RNL?G? 2;FO? 0B?ILS
&*+5. *.9B2 <3 A52 2EA?2:.9 6;12E .;1 A52 A.69 6;12E 3<? C.?6<B@ C.9B2 <3
1J NI HIQ
IHFS P?LS @?Q JL;=NC=;F L?=IGG?H>;NCIHM @IL >?;FCHA QCNB MNLIHAFS
>?J?H>?HN >;N; B;P? <??H JLIPC>?> $IFM ;H> >? 2LC?M MOAA?MN ; [NBCH
HCHA\ JLI=?>OL?
QBC=B =IHMCMNM CH L?GIPCHA ?;=B L?;FCT;NCIH ;>D;=?HN NI ;H
?RNL?G? ?P?HN 0BCM ;JJLI;=B ;JJ?;LM NI <? ;JJLIJLC;N? @IL M?LC?M QCNB ; FIQ
>?J?H>?H=?
<ON JLI<;<FS HIN @IL M?LC?M QCNB ; F;LA? ;GIOHN I@ >?J?H>?H=?
&*+5. !<;A2 .?9< 2E=2?6:2;A 3<? 0<:=BA6;4 A52 A.69 6;12E @A6:.A2@ .?2
/.@21 <;
?2=960.A6<;@
2 2
/N> ?LLIL
/N> ?LLIL
.$
0LO?
)IHNBFS
-O;LN?LFS
/?GC;HHO;FFS
.$
0LO?
)IHNBFS
-O;LN?LFS
/?GC;HHO;FFS
_N N #N (
# N N aN (
N &_N (
N "
# N N (
QCNB " +
+ ;H> + NI ?HMOL? ; JIMCNCP? PIF;NCFCNS JLI=?MM /O^=C?HN
=IH>CNCIHM @IL #N NI <? MNLC=NFS MN;NCIH;LS ;L?
)
3? ;MMOG? )&) )
'
0B? CHHIP;NCIH JLI=?MM
aN
CM ;MMOG?> NI <? 661 QCNB T?LI G?;H
OHCN P;LC;H=?
N NBCM MN;A?
Q? B;P? L?=;FF?> P;LCIOM NB?IL?NC=;F L?MOFNM I@ BIQ ?RNL?G?
L?NOLHM IL ?R=?MM?M IP?L ; NBL?MBIF> G;S <? OM?> NI =B;L;=N?LCT? NB? <?B;PCIL
I@ NB? N;CFM I@ ; >CMNLC<ONCIH +H=? J;L;G?N?LM B;P? <??H I<N;CH?>
CN CM JIMMC<F?
NI ;>>L?MM M?P?L;F OM?@OF CMMO?M
MO=B ;M NB? ?MNCG;NCIH I@ BCAB KO;HNCF?M 0BCM
KO?MNCIH CM =?HNL;F NI 2;. ;H;FSMCM
"IL CHMN;H=?
Q? G;S <? CHN?L?MN?> CH NB? NSJ? I@ ?RNL?G? L?;FCT;NCIH Q?
=;H ?RJ?=N IP?L ; BILCTIH I@ IL S?;LM %@ MIG? >;CFS >;N; CM M;GJF?> IP?L
NL;>CHA >;SM
NB?H
OH>?L NB? ;MMOGJNCIH NB;N NB?L? ;L? NL;>CHA >;SM
CH ; S?;L
Q? ;L? FIIECHA @IL NB? F;LA?MN ;GIHA
IL
L?;FCT;NCIHM
0B? CMMO? I@ =IGJONCHA 2;. @LIG WH;H=C;F >;N; QCFF <? >?N;CF?> CH B;JN?L
%H NB? JL?M?HN M?=NCIH
Q? JLIPC>? MIG? L?MOFNM IH NB? ?MNCG;NCIH I@ BCAB
KO;HNCF?M <;M?> IH NB? P;LCIOM ;JJLI;=B?M >?M=LC<?> ?;LFC?L CH NBCM =B;JN?L
1HCP;LC;N? N;CF ?MNCG;NCIH
*INC=? NB;N CHMN?;> I@ OMCHA NB? GCHCG; IL NB? F?@N N;CF I@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH I@
L?NOLHM ;M CN CM MOAA?MN?> CH 2;. =IGJON;NCIH
Q? =IHMC>?L G;RCG; ;H> NB?
LCABN N;CF NI L?G;CH =IHMCMN?HNFS QCNB NB? JL?PCIOM ;H;FSMCM MCGJF? Q;S NI
PC?Q NB? @IFFIQCHA CM NI =IHMC>?L NB? ;<MIFON? P;FO? I@ GCHCG; IL NB? ;<MIFON?
P;FO? I@ NB? F?@N N;CF I@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH
0B? ?RNL?G; ;JJLI;=B NI =IGJON? BCAB KO;HNCF?M B;M <??H CHCNC;FFS JLIJIM?>
<S )=*?CF ;H> (IHACH (?N 'TD (D <? ; P?=NIL I@ ?RNL?G?M I@
4
NB? CHCNC;F NCG? M?LC?M '_N (N =IGJON?> IP?L MO<M;GJF?M I@ MCT? : MMOG?
4
NB;N '_N (N B;M NB? A?P 4 ;M ?R;=N >CMNLC<ONCIH ;H> NB? G;RCG; 'TD (D
W + TD + T
0 J
4 T
0 J
TJ
"/*
(
!
!
T
0 J 4
W
&)#
W
'
0B? =ILL?MJIH>CHA ?MNCG;N?> KO;HNCF? >?HIN?> <S T J CM I<N;CH?> <S L?
JF;=CHA ( ;H> ! <S NB?CL ?MNCG;N?M (
( ;H> ! %H NB? =;M?
NB?
?MNCG;N?> KO;HNCF? CM
T
J 4 &)# &)#
W
'
W
!
*INC=? NB;N
MCH=? NB? DICHN >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ ( CM ;P;CF;<F?
C@ NB? ?MNCG;
( !
NCIH CM J?L@ILG?> <S )(
Q? =;H >?>O=? ; =IHW>?H=? CHN?LP;F @IL NB? ?MNCG;N?
T
J ( OMCHA NB? >?FN; G?NBI>
0B? KO;HNCF? T 0 J CH @;=N =ILL?MJIH>M NI NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ G;RCG;
0B?L?@IL?
T 0 J CH>C=;N?M NB? P;FO? NB;N =;H <? ?R=??>?> <S NB? G;RCGOG
*INC=? NB;N Q? OM? ; MFCANBFS >C_?L?HN HIN;NCIH @IL NB? KO;HNCF? $?H=? NB? NCF>?
& " NI ;PIC> =IH@OMCIH
IH B
!RNL?G? 2;FO? 0B?ILS
.
<ON CHMN?;> CNM
W
KO;HNCF?
>?HIN?> _0J 0B?L?@IL?
C@ Q? ;L?
;=NO;FFS CHN?L?MN?> CH =IHNLIFFCHA NB? JLI<;<CFCNS W NB;N NB? L?NOLH ?R=??>M ;
ACP?H KO;HNCF?
Q? L?>?WH? T 0 J T0 J ;H> A?N
!
.
0 J 4
T
W
: &)#
W
'
%HN?L?MNCHAFS
NB? ?RNL?G; ;JJLI;=B ;FFIQM =ILL?=NCHA NB? KO;HNCF? ?MNCG;NCIH
@IL JLI=?MM?M QCNB MNLIHA >?J?H>?H=? M Q? B;P? M??H CH /?=NCIH
CH
4
MO=B =;M?
NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ ?RNL?G?M I@ '_N (N CM 4 T
QCNB >?HIN
CHA NB? ?RNL?G;F CH>?R 0B?H
NI <? =IHMCMN?HN QCNB ; JLI<;<CFCNS I@
W
!
T
0 J : &)#
W
'
0BCM L?MOFN CM =IHMCMN?HN QCNB NB? JL?PCIOM =F;CG NB;N NB? ?RNL?G?M IP?L MO<
M;GJF?M I@ F?HANB : @LIG MNLIHAFS >?J?H>?HN >;N; B;P? NB? M;G? <?B;PCIL
;M NB? ?RNL?G?M IP?L MO<M;GJF?M I@ F?HANB : @LIG NB? =ILL?MJIH>CHA 661 IL
Q?;EFS >?J?H>?HN M?LC?M
0B? N;CF ;JJLI;=B B;M <??H ;>IJN?> @IL =IGJONCHA BCAB KO;HNCF?M <S )=*?CF
;H> )=*?CF ;H> "L?S *IQ
Q? @I=OM >CL?=NFS IH NB? N;CFM I@
NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH ;H> NB?L?@IL? =IHMC>?L NB? ?MNCG;NCIH I@ ; BCAB KO;HNCF? _J
MO=B NB;N 2 _J
+D
_J
W' 0I MIFP? NBCM CMMO?
.IINTfH ;H>
"IL CHMN;H=?
;MMOG? Q? =IGJON? NB? KO;HNCF? I@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ G;RCG;
%@ G;RCG; ;L? G?;MOL?> IP?L >;S MO<M;GJF?M
NBCM KO;HNCF? CH @;=N =ILL?MJIH>M
NI NB? KO;HNCF? I@ NB? L?NOLH >CMNLC<ONCIH
"IL CHMN;H=?
NB? ;MF? IGGCNN?? IH ;HECHA /OJ?LPCMCIH CGJIM?M ;
JLI<;<CFCNS E ?KO;F NI
;MMOGCHA NB;N L?NOLHM ;L? 661 IL Q?;EFS >?J?H>?HN
1HCP;LC;N? N;CF ?MNCG;NCIH
0;DPC>C IL )=*?CF MOAA?MN NB? @IFFIQCHA ;JJLI;=B 0B?S WLMN
HINC=? NB;N @IL _ + \ Q? B;P?
2 _
+D
_ +D
\
+D
\
+D + \
+D
\
+D
\
2O _ \
2 \
2 \
2O _ \
'
$?H=?
CN CM JIMMC<F? NI ?MNCG;N? NB? JLI<;<CFCNS I@ <?CHA <?FIQ ; =?LN;CH NBL?MB
IF>
2 _
( ;M
2 _
24 \
24 \
3O _
(
QB?L? 24 \
CM NB? ?GJCLC=;F >CMNLC<ONCIH @OH=NCIH H;NOL;F ?MNCG;N? I@
24 \
CM ACP?H <S
4
, @ :O
24 \
R* O (
@ N @
0B?L?@IL?
NB? KO;HNCF? _J + \ =;H <? ?MNCG;N?> OMCHA NB? @IFFIQCHA L?F;NCIH
@ :O :O
2 _J
3 _J
W(
@ @ O
MI NB;N
@
_
J \ 3
W (
O :O
IL !
$
#\ 4
.+ W
C@ (
_
J
$
"\ !
&)# 4
.+ W C@ '
NB? JLI=?>OL? >?M=LC<?> ;<IP? =;H <? >CL?=NFS ;JJFC?> IH aN CHMN?;> I@ _N
*INC=? NB;N NBCM ?RJL?MMCIH =;H <? =IGJON?>
<?=;OM? <S =IHMNLO=NCIH E /' 2
!RNL?G? 2;FO? 0B?ILS
X '
_
JK _4 K4 '
W
@
>5=2?*;2*=. -.9.7-.7,.
)O=B ?_ILN B;M <??H G;>? NI ?RN?H> OHCP;LC;N? ?RNL?G? P;FO? NB?ILS NI ;
GOFNCP;LC;N? =IHN?RN /O=B ;H ?RN?HMCIH
BIQ?P?L
CM @;L @LIG <?CHA MNL;CABN
@ILQ;L> 0B? L?;MIH CM NB;N NB?L? ?RCMNM HI GOFNCP;LC;N? ?KOCP;F?HN NI NB?
"CMB?L0CJJ?N NB?IL?G /N;N?> >C_?L?HNFS
NB?L? >I?M HIN ;JJ?;L NI ?RCMN ;
FCGCN >CMNLC<ONCIH @IL M=;F?> G;RCG; "LIG NB? JICHN I@ PC?Q I@ ?R=??>;H=?M
IP?L BCAB NBL?MBIF>M
NB?L? CM HI GOFNCP;LC;N? >CMNLC<ONCIH MO=B ;M NB? AJ> NB;N
QIOF> H;NOL;FFS WN NB? N;CFM
H ;>>CNCIH;F >C^=OFNS =IG?M @LIG NB? HINCIH I@ >?J?H>?H=S 0SJC=;FFS
Q?
G;S G?;MOL? >?J?H>?H=S <?NQ??H M?LC?M QCNB NB? Q?FF?MN;<FCMB?> =ILL?F;NCIH
G?;MOL?
>?P?FIJ?> <S ,?;LMIH ;M
)
_N _
`N `
D( E 8) ) (
`N `
_N _
NB? P;LC;<F?M _ ;H> ` >?HINCHA M;GJF? ;P?L;A?M %N NOLHM ION NB;N NBCM G?;MOL?
I@ >?J?H>?H=S IHFS ;JJFC?M NI I<M?LP;NCIHM NB;N ;L? HIN NII @;L ION CH NB?
N;CFM M ;FL?;>S M??H CH B;JN?L
NBCM B;M F?> L?M?;L=B?LM NI CHNLI>O=? INB?L
G?;MOL?M I@ >?J?H>?H=S !;LFS L?M?;L=B Q;M ;FMI <;M?> IH NB? ;MMOGJNCIH
NB;N NB? DICHN N;CF >CMNLC<ONCIH QIOF> <? ACP?H <S MIG? J;L;G?NLC= @OH=NCIH;F
)OFNCP;LC;N? >?J?H>?H=?
>?J?H>?H=S
I@N?H =;JNOL?> <S ; =IJOF; @OH=NCIH M?N I@ =IJOF; @OH=NCIHM B;M
;FL?;>S <??H >CM=OMM?> CH B;JN?L ;M ; G?;HM NI DICH G;LACH;F >CMNLC<ONCIHM
$?L?
NB? =IJOF; CM JF;SCHA NB? LIF? I@ ; J;L;G?NLC= L?JL?M?HN;NCIH I@ MIG?
>?J?H>?H=? 0B? OM? I@ =IJOF; NI >?M=LC<? ; >?J?H>?H=S CH NB? N;CFM G;S
F?;> NI ?LLIH?IOM =IH=FOMCIHM OHF?MM NB? ;>?KO;=S I@ ; ACP?H =IJOF; B;M <??H
;M=?LN;CH?>
0I A;CH NB? CHNOCNCIH I@ QBS NBCM G;S B;JJ?H
=IHMC>?L WNNCHA ; MN;<F? >CM
NLC<ONCIH NI ; M;GJF? I@ >;N; A?H?L;N?> <S MIG? @;NN;CF?> >CMNLC<ONCIH
QB?L?
NB? @;NN;CF?> >CMNLC<ONCIH CM ;MMOG?> NI B;P? ; M?=IH> ;H> G;S<? ?P?H ; NBCL>
GIG?HN S WNNCHA ; MN;<F? >CMNLC<ONCIH
Q? GCABN I<N;CH MIG? J;L;G?N?LM
$?_?LH;H
;H> 0;QH
NB?L?@IL?
JLIJIM? ; N?MN NI =B?=E NB? NSJ? I@
>?J?H>?H=S NB;N ?RCMNM CH NB? >;N; ,IIH
.I=ECHA?L
;H> 0;QH ;JJFS
NBCM G?NBI>IFIAS NI WH;H=C;F >;N; +HFS IH=? ; =?LN;CH NSJ? I@ >?J?H>?H=S
B;M <??H C>?HNCW?>
CN CM L?;MIH;<F? NI GI>?F NB? DICHN <?B;PCIL QCNB ; =?LN;CH
=IJOF;
0I ACP? ; X;PIL I@ NB? C>?;M <?BCH> NB?M? =IH=?JNM I@ >?J?H>?H=S
"CAOL?
L?JL?M?HNM ; M=;NN?LJFIN I@ L?NOLHM CHPIFPCHA NB? ;H> NB? 4
;H>
"CAOL? NL;=?M ; M=;NN?LJFIN @IL ;H> /, L?NOLHM
IP?L NB? J?LCI>
@LIG NI 0B? NQI WAOL?M ;FMI L?JL?M?HN KO;>L;HNM [;FIHA NB? >C;AI
H;F\ NI CH>C=;N? BIQ NB? N;CFM <?=IG? NBCHH?L ;H> NBCHH?L ;M Q? GIP? CHNI NB?
N;CFM M "CAOL? L?P?;FM
NB?L? ;L? KOCN? ; @?Q I<M?LP;NCIHM ;M Q? GIP? ION
CHNI NB? F?@N N;CF I@ NB? DICHN >CMNLC<ONCIH M Q? EHIQ
CH>?R L?NOLHM ;L? =ILL?
F;N?>
B?L? QCNB ; =I?^=C?HN I@ ' 3? G;S
NB?L?@IL?
=IH=FO>? NB;N NB? J;CL
4 CM HIN IHFS >?J?H>?HN
<ON ;FMI ;MSGJNINC=;FFS >?J?H>?HN "CAOL?
CH>C=;N?M NB;N
;M Q? GIP? ION CHNI NB? N;CFM
NB?L? ;L? @?Q?L ;H> @?Q?L
I<M?LP;NCIHM
MI NB;N NB? J;CL /, G;S <? PC?Q?> ;M ;MSGJNINC=;FFS
CH>?J?H>?HN $IQ?P?L
C@ Q? =IGJON? NB? =ILL?F;NCIH
Q? WH> ; =I?^=C?HN I@
' ;H>
NBOM
NB;N NB? >;N; CM >?J?H>?HN 0B? CHNOCNCIH =IHP?S?> <S NB?M?
JC=NOL?M CM NB;N CN QCFF <? H?=?MM;LS NI CHNLI>O=? NQI G?;MOL?M I@ >?J?H>?H=S
IH? @IL NB? N;CFM ;H> IH? @IL NB? GIL? =?HNL;F J;LN I@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH %@ NB?
N?MN @IL NB? GIL? =?HNL;F J;LN =IH=FO>?M NB;N NB? >;N; G;S ;FMI <? ;MSGJNIN
C=;FFS >?J?H>?HN
NB?H CN QCFF <? OM?@OF NI =IHMNLO=N ; G?;MOL? I@ >?J?H>?H=S
MJ?=CW=;FFS @IL NB? N;CFM
/CH=? NB? 1/ G;LE?N IJ?HM >OLCHA NB? ;@N?LHIIH I@ NB? !OLIJ?;H G;LE?NM
Q?
=IGJON? =ILL?F;NCIHM OMCHA ; F;A I@ NB? !OLIJ?;H G;LE?N L?NOLH GIL? JL?=CM?
;>DOMNG?HN NI NBCM JLI<F?G =IOF> <? G;>? ;FIHA NB? QILE I@ );LN?HM ;H> ,IIH
!RNL?G? 2;FO? 0B?ILS
20 '0.AA2?=9<A <3 @A.;1.?16G21 1.69F ?2AB?;@ <3 A52 .;1 A52 ,
20 '0.AA2?=9<A <3 @A.;1.?16G21 1.69F ?2AB?;@ <3 A52 .;1 A52 '$
)OFNCP;LC;N? >?J?H>?H=?
1*;*,=.;2C270 =*25 -.9.7-.7,B
<B69=8=2, -.9.7-.7,.
&%' + B + \ ) A + \ (
O
+ B + \ ( A + \
\
+ B + \ ) A + \
+A + \
+B + \ +A + \ +B
\( A
\
+A
\
\ +B
\( A
\
\
&)# +B
\( A
\
'
&)# \
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
χ(u)
-0.2
-0.4
ρ = 0 .9
-0.6
ρ = 0 .6
ρ = 0 .3
-0.8 ρ = 0
ρ = -0.3
ρ = -0.6
-1
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1
u
20 25.C6<? <3 J 3<? . .B@@6.; 0<=B9. .@ A52 0<??29.A6<; C.?62@ 3?<:
A<
&)# + A + \
\
(
&)# + A + \( B + ]
;H>
&%' \
(
O
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
chi-bar(u)
-0.2
-0.4
ρ = 0.9
-0.6
ρ = 0.6
ρ = 0.3
-0.8 ρ = 0
ρ = -0.3
ρ = -0.6
-1
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1
u
20 25.C6<? <3 J 3<? . .B@@6.; 0<=B9. D6A5 0<??29.A6<; ?.;46;4 3?<:
A<
QBC=B ;C>M CH CHN?LJL?NCHA NB? P;FO? I@ "IL INB?L ?R;GJF?M M?? $?_?LH;H
"CAOL? NL;=?M NB? @OH=NCIH \
@IL NB? #;OMMC;H =IJOF; 3? HI
NC=? NB;N ;M \ CH=L?;M?M
NB? J;NN?LH I@ >CMJ?LM?M *IH?NB?F?MM
?P?H @IL BCAB
P;FO?M I@ \
MO=B ;M ' ;H> >;N; A?H?L;N?> <S BCABFS =ILL?F;N?> >;N;
'
NB? G?;MOL? N;E?M ; P;FO? I@ F?MM NB;H ' ;H> CM NB?L?@IL? L?F;NCP?FS >CMN;HN
@LIG
F?P?F QB?L? IH? GCABN =IH=FO>? @IL ;MSGJNINC=;FFS >?J?H>?HN >;N;
%N CM IHFS @IL ?RNL?G?FS BCAB F?P?FM I@ \ NB;N =IG?M =FIM? NI CNM NB?IL?NC=;F
P;FO? I@ ' 0BCM CFFOMNL;N?M NB;N NB? H?Q G?;MOL? CM FCE?FS NI JLIPC>? ; <?NN?L
N?MN @IL ;MSGJNINC= >?J?H>?H=S NB;H '
3? G;S =IH=FO>? <S I<M?LPCHA NB;N NB? J;CL I@ >?J?H>?H=? G?;MOL?M (
NIA?NB?L JLIPC>? ;FF NB? H?=?MM;LS CH@ILG;NCIH NI =B;L;=N?LCT? NB? @ILG ;H>
>?AL?? I@ ?RNL?G;F >?J?H>?H=? "IL ;MSGJNINC=;FFS >?J?H>?HN P;LC;<F?M
Q?
B;P?
QCNB NB? >?AL?? I@ >?J?H>?H=? ACP?H <S + "IL ;MSGJNINC=;FFS
CH>?J?H>?HN P;LC;<F?M
Q? B;P? QCNB NB? >?AL?? I@ >?J?H>?H=? ACP?H
<S +H? E?S CHMCABN I@ NBCM M?=NCIH CM NB;N CN CM CGJILN;HN NI N?MN WLMN C@
<?@IL? >L;QCHA =IH=FOMCIHM ;<ION ;MSGJNINC= >?J?H>?H=? <;M?> IH ?M
NCG;N?M I@ 0B?L? L?G;CHM NB? KO?MNCIH I@ BIQ NI ?MNCG;N? NB?M? >?J?H>?H=S
G?;MOL?M 3? NOLH NI NBCM CMMO? CH NB? H?RN M?=NCIH
)OFNCP;LC;N? >?J?H>?H=?
<=26*=287 *7- <=*=2<=2,*5 27/.;.7,. 87 *7-
&)# 29 E
QB?L? 28 ;H> 29 ;L? NB? L?MJ?=NCP? G;LACH;F >CMNLC<ONCIH @OH=NCIHM @IL D ;H>
E %H JL;=NC=?
NB? P;FO?M I@ 28 ;H> 29 NB;N ;L? OM?> CH NB? NL;HM@ILG;NCIH
;L? I<N;CH?> OMCHA NB? ?GJCLC=;F >CMNLC<ONCIH @OH=NCIHM I@ NB? M?J;L;N?
P;LC;<F?M %H ; WH;H=? M?NNCHA
NB? "Lf=B?N NL;HM@ILG;NCIH ;JJ?;LM GIMN OM?@OF
QB?L? CN Q;M ?MN;<FCMB?> NB;N OH>?L Q?;E =IH>CNCIHM NB? JLI<;
<CFCNS I@ DICHN ?RNL?G? ?P?HNM CM ACP?H <S
+ ? + Z( @ + Z Z
Z ( ;M Z (
&)# Z
%N @IFFIQM NB;N
&)# Z
M
'
&)# Z
&)# Z
0BCM L?MOFN CGG?>C;N?FS MBIQM NB;N NB? N;CF CH>?R @IL DICHN ?RNL?G? L?;FCT;NCIHM
QCFF ;FFIQ OM NI =IHMNLO=N ;H ?MNCG;N? I@ %N MO^=?M NI N;E? F '%( ?( @
(
;H> NI L?;FCT? NB;N + F + Z + '%( ?( @
+ Z ' F?;LFS
C@ ; M;GJF?
'a ( ( a4 ( CM ;P;CF;<F?
NBCM CH>?R G;S <? ?MNCG;N?> OMCHA NB? $CFF ?MNCG;NIL
@LIG 0BCM SC?F>M
,I) a
&)#
E4
(
UM E Z
B
*UM (
"IL NBCM NSJ? I@ NL;HM@ILG
Q? G;S MBIQ NB;N " 1 ! H " 2 ! H CM JLIJIL
NCIH;F NI H @IL F;LA? H S M?NNCHA 3 ' 6 ;H> 4 ' 7 Q? L?=IP?L
NB? HIN;NCIHM OM?> CH NB? JL?PCIOM M?=NCIH 0B? JLI<;<CFCNS "1 ! H @IL F;LA? H
+ @ + Z( ? + Z Z
Z
Z
'
+ ? + Z Z
B '
U
"OLNB?LGIL?
Q? =;H ;MM?MM QB?NB?L NB? P;LC;<F?M B;P? ; DICHN N;CF QBC=B >?=;SM
QCNB NB? M;G? @ILG ;M @IL ?R;=N CH>?J?H>?H=? <S N?MNCHA C@ CM MCAHCW=;HNFS
>C_?L?HN @LIG
8-.5270 -.9.7-.7,B
(
"/*
*[
QB?L?
CM NB? <CP;LC;N? HILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH QCNB G?;H P?=NIL (
;H>
=IP;LC;H=? G;NLCR =IHN;CHCHA ;FIHA NB? >C;AIH;F
;H> IH NB? I_ >C;AIH;F
M ;FL?;>S G?HNCIH?> CH NB? JL?PCIOM M?=NCIH
@IL NBCM GI>?F (
(
'
3? =IOF>
NB?L?@IL?
CH JL;=NC=;F ;JJFC=;NCIHM ?MNCG;N? <S OMCHA 0 '
"IL ;MSGJNINC=;FFS >?J?H>?HN >;N;
C@ ?RJFC=CN GI>?FCHA >?J?H>?H=S I@ NB?
G;LACHM CM L?KOCL?>
Q? G;S OM? NB? =;N;FIAO? I@ =IJOF;
;FL?;>S >CM=OMM?> CH
B;JN?L JIJOF;L =IJOF; CM NB? FIACMNC= IH?
+?
Z( @
[ "/* Z [ (
)OFNCP;LC;N? >?J?H>?H=?
&*+5.
<D2? .;1 B==2? 12=2;12;02 :2.@B?2@ 3<? C.?6<B@ 0<=B9. "<A602 A5.A
A52 =.?.:2A2? 6@ . 3B;0A6<; D52?2.@ .99 <A52? =.?.:2A2?@ .?2 @0.9.?@
(IQ?L N;CF 1JJ?L N;CF
*;G? ,;L;G?N?L
>?J?H>?H=? >?J?H>?H=?
#;OMMC;H *IH? *IH?
/NO>?HN I C I I
L=BCG?>?;H % %%
% %
%
"L;HE
*IH? *IH?
F;SNIH
*IH?
#OG<?F
*IH?
,F;=E?NN
);LMB;FF+FECH ! *IH?
QCNB )
;H> QB?L? >?=L?;MCHA
CH=L?;M?M >?J?H>?H=? "IL NBCM GI>?F
(
(
' /CH=?
@IL NBCM =IJOF;
( NB? =;M? I@ ;MSGJNINC=
CH>?J?H>?H=? CM ;ONIG;NC=;FFS JL?=FO>?>
+NB?L =IJOF; G;S <? =BIM?H NI >?M=LC<? ; ACP?H >?J?H>?H=? MNLO=NOL? %H
0;<F?
Q? ACP? NB? P;FO?M I@ NB? OJJ?L ;H> FIQ?L N;CF >?J?H>?H=? @IL NB?
P;LCIOM =IJOF; CHNLI>O=?> CH B;JN?L
M?? ;FMI $?_?LH;H
8 "IL NB? /NO
>?HN [ =IJOF;
Q? >?WH? [I < YE + `)D ;H>
U
7 255><=;*=287
,IIH
.I=ECHA?L
;H> 0;QH =IHMC>?L NB? /, 1/
NB? "0/!
1'
NB? 4 #!.
NB? ".
;H> NB? *CEE?C &,
CH>C=?M
=IP?LCHA NB? J?LCI> @LIG ?=?G<?L NI *IP?G<?L
/JFCNNCHA NB? >;N; CHNI NBL?? MO<M;GJF?M
NB?S I<N;CH
@IL NB? OHWFN?L?> F?@N
N;CF I@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH ;H> <CP;LC;N?#.$ OMCHA NB? GI>?F I@ 'LI
H?L ;H> *A
M?? /?=NCIH WFN?L?> >;N;
NB? @IFFIQCHA J;L;G?N?LM
L?JL?M?HN?> CH 0;<F?
%HMJ?=NCIH I@ NB?M? ?MNCG;N?M MBIQM NB;N ,?;LMIHZM =ILL?F;NCIH =I?^=C?HN
CM CH A?H?L;F GO=B MG;FF?L NB;H 0BCM I<M?LP;NCIH L?CH@IL=?M IOL =IHD?=NOL?
NB;N ,?;LMIHZM =ILL?F;NCIH >I?M HIN G?;MOL? NB? N;CF <?B;PCIL Q?FF FMI CHN?L
?MNCHAFS
GIMN I@ NB? 0 ;L? MN;NCMNC=;FFS MG;FF?L NB;H IH?
CGJFSCHA NB;N NB?L? CM
FCNNF? ?PC>?H=? @IL ;MSGJNINC= >?J?H>?H=? ;GIHA NB?M? M?LC?M ;H> NBCM CH J;L
NC=OF;L @IL NB? ?;LFC?L J;LN I@ NB? M;GJF? %H NB? F;N?L J;LN I@ NB? M;GJF?
NB?
>?J?H>?H=S G?;MOL? CH=L?;M?M 3? CHN?LJL?N NBCM WH>CHA ;M ; MCAH NB;N G;LE?N
CHN?AL;NCIH CH=L?;M?> IP?L NCG? %H NBCM N;<F?
Q? IHFS @I=OM IH NB? F?@N N;CF
"IL NB? LCABN N;CF
NB?L? ?RCMNM ?P?H F?MM ?PC>?H=? @IL ;MSGJNINC= >?J?H>?H=S
IGJ;LCMIH <?NQ??H NB? ILCACH;F OHWFN?L?> >;N; ;H> #.$WFN?L?> >;N;
MBIQM NB;N WFN?LCHA L?GIP?M MIG? >?J?H>?H=S <ON HIN ;FF %>?;FFS
Q? QIOF>
FCE? NI EHIQ
@LIG ; NB?IL?NC=;F JICHN I@ PC?Q
QB;N NB? CGJFC=;NCIHM I@ GOFNC
P;LC;N? #.$ GI>?F IH NB? N;CFM ;L? 0BOM
OM?@OF L?M?;L=B QIOF> CH>C=;N?
!RNL?G? 2;FO? 0B?ILS
&*+5. !2.@B?2 3<? A52 923A A.69 <3 =.6?@ <3 ?2AB?;@ );H9A2?21 1.A. 0<??2
@=<;1@ A< ?.D ?2AB?;@ D52?2.@ H9A2?21 1.A. 6;C<9C2@ A52 ?2@61B.9@ <3 A52
& (52 =.?.:.A2? @A.;1@ 3<? $2.?@<;J@ 0<??29.A6<; "B:/2?@ D6A5 . .?2
;<A @64;6H0.;A9F 16O2?2;A 3?<:
1HWFN?L?> >;N; WFN?L?> >;N;
/O<J?LCI>
NI
I<M
1/1'
1/&,
1'#!.
#!.".
/O<J?LCI>
NI
I<M
1/1'
1/&,
1'#!.
#!.".
/O<J?LCI>
NI
I<M
1/1'
1/&,
1'#!.
#!.".
;N NBCM MN;A?
;M ; M=L??HCHA NIIF
OM?@OF CH NB? KO?MN @IL JILN@IFCIM QCNB AII>
?RNL?G;F <?B;PCIL
HINB?L ?R?L=CM?
JLIJIM?> <S ,IIH
.I=ECHA?L
;H> 0;QH CM NB?
G?;MOL?G?HN I@ ; GCMMJ?=CW=;NCIH I@ NB? N;CF >?J?H>?H=S 0B?S =IHMC>?L NB?
F?@N N;CF I@ L?NOLHM
<S GOFNCJFSCHA MNI=E L?NOLHM <S
MI NB;N MNI=E G;LE?N
=L;MB?M MBIQ OJ ;M F;LA? JIMCNCP? HOG<?LM "IL ; JILN@IFCI QCNB Q?CABN
QB?L?
(
<
D
E(
Q? QCFF =IHMC>?L NB? ?RJ?=N?> MBILN@;FF
>?WH?> ;M 1?
1 < )< + J
QB?L?
J
CM MIG? F;LA? HOG<?L >?N?LGCH?> <S NB? JLI<;<CFCNS + < )< + J
(
;H> QB?L? CM NB? JLI<;<CFCNS ;FFI=;N?> NI N;CF ?P?HNM M QCFF <? MBIQH CH
NB? H?RN =B;JN?L
>?;FCHA QCNB LCME G;H;A?G?HN
NB? ?RJ?=N?> MBILN@;FF CM ;
G?;MOL? I@ LCME NB;N B;M AII> JLIJ?LNC?M @LIG ;H ?=IHIGC= JICHN I@ PC?Q
#CP?H NB;N NB? JILN@IFCI L?NOLHM ;L? <?SIH> ; =?LN;CH NBL?MBIF> NB;N QCFF <?
L?;=B?> IH I@ NB? NCG?
NBCM G?;MOL? =;JNOL?M NB? ;P?L;A? FIMM?M %H NB?
@IFFIQCHA
NB? =;FC<L;NCIH CM >IH? IH >;CFS >;N; 0B? ?RJ?=N?> MBILN@;FF NB?H
L?JL?M?HNM NB? ;P?L;A? FIMM
ACP?H NB;N ; =L;MB I@ ; ACP?H =;N?AILS NIIE JF;=?
0B? >CL?=N =IGJON;NCIH I@ NB? ?RJ?=N?> MBILN@;FF CM HIN JIMMC<F? "IL NBCM
L?;MIH
MCGOF;NCIH<;M?> G?NBI>M =;H <? OM?> >?M=LCJNCIH I@ BIQ NBCM MCG
OF;NCIH =;H <? >IH?
Q? L?@?L NI ,IIH
.I=ECHA?L
;H> 0;QH "CAOL?
L?JL?M?HNM NB? ?RJ?=N?> MBILN@;FF @IL '
CH NB? OJJ?L J;H?FM ;H> @IL
'
CH NB? FIQ?L IH?M 0B? F?@N WAOL?M =ILL?MJIH> NI ; JILN@IFCI QCNB
; @L;=NCIH
I@ Q?;FNB ;FFI=;N?> NI NB? /, ;H>
;FFI=;N?> NI NB?
*CEE?C 0B? LCABN WAOL?M =ILL?MJIH> NI ; JILN@IFCI CHPIFPCHA NB? 4 ;H>
NB? 3? G?;MOL? >?J?H>?H=S OMCHA ; FIACMNC= GI>?F
; #;OMMC;H GI>?F
=;FC<L;N?> QCNB
;H> ; #;OMMC;H GI>?F =;FC<L;N?> PC; ,?;LMIHZM =ILL?F;NCIH
>;=1.; 27?.<=20*=287<
Expected shortfall
Expected shortfall
5 5
4 4
3 3
2 2
0 0.5 1 0 0.5 1
α α
SP500-Nikkei:θ = 0.001 DAX-C AC: θ = 0.001
12 12
Expected shortfall
Expected shortfall
10 10
8 8
6 6
4 4
2 2
0 0.5 1 0 0.5 1
α α
20 &2=?2@2;A.A6<; <3 A52 2E=20A21 @5<?A3.99 (52 =.?.:2A2? 6;160.A2@ A52
D2645A .99<0.A21 A< A52 <;2 <? A52 <A52? 0<B;A?F B?C2@ D6A5 0<??2@=<;1 A< A52
/6C.?6.A2 .B@@6.; 0<=B9. 0.96/A?.A21 D6A5
.@ 12=2;12;0F :2.@B?2 B?C2@ D6A5 <
0<??2@=<;1 A< A52 /6C.?6.A2 9<46@A60 .@A A52 0<??2@=<;1 A< . /6C.?6.A2 .B@@6.;
D6A5 $2.?@<;J@ .@ 12=2;12;0F :2.@B?2
<;M?>
@IL CHMN;H=?
IH NB? OM? I@ OHCP;LC;N? IL GOFNCP;LC;N? #.$ GI>?FM
(*5>. *= $2<4
%@ Q? >?HIN? CN
N
CN
N
CN
N
NB? 2;. I@ ; JILN@IFCI CM
>?WH?> <S NB? L?F;NCIH
+ CN
N
B H>
N )N (
0BCM ?RJL?MMCIH CH>C=;N?M NB;N NB? 2;. I@ NB? JILN@IFCI ;N NCG? [ @IL NB? H?RN
J?LCI> CM GCHOM NB? KO;HNCF? I@ NB? =IH>CNCIH;F 013 I@ NB? JILN@IFCI L?NOLH
!PC>?HNFS
C@ Q? ;MMOG? NB;N L?NOLHM ;L? 661
NB? 2;. CM =IHMN;HN IP?L NCG? ;H>
CM MCGJFS ACP?H <S NB? CHP?LM? I@ NB? OH=IH>CNCIH;F 013 B H>
2J
(
QB?L? 2J _
+ YJN
_ CM NB? ;MMOG?> NI <? =IHNCHOIOM 013 I@ NB? JILN
@IFCI L?NOLH IGJONCHA NB? 2;. NB?L?@IL? [L?>O=?M\ NI ?MNCG;NCHA ; KO;HNCF?
I@ NB? =IH>CNCIH;F >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ NB? JILN@IFCI L?NOLH *INC=? NB;N NBCM 013 CM
P?LS FCE?FS NI <? NCG? P;LSCHA +H? L?;MIH CM NB;N NB? PIF;NCFCNS I@ L?NOLHM
P;LC?M IP?L NCG?
M?? ;FMI B;JN?L
0B? >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ NB? JILN@IFCI L?NOLH =;H ;FMI <? >?M=LC<?> ;M >?J?H>CHA
IH NB? DICHN >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ ;MM?N L?NOLHM 0BCM <LCHAM ;<ION NQI @;MBCIHM NI
=IHMC>?L NB? 2;. ;H> !/ WLMN IH?
NB;N Q? QCFF =;FF JILN@IFCI ;JJLI;=B QCFF
=IHMC>?L NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ ;H ;AAL?A;N? L?NOLH 0B? M?=IH> IH? QCFF =IHMC>?L
NB? CH>OCPC>O;F ;MM?NM CH ;H ;JJLI;=B NB;N Q? =;FF NB? ;MM?N ;JJLI;=B %H
@;=N
NB? OM? I@ NB? ;MM?NF?P?F ;JJLI;=B CM QILNBS NI <? =IHMC>?L?>
<?=;OM?
CN G;S <? OM?> @IL GIL? CH>?JNB ;H;FSMCM 0BCM JICHN B;M <??H IONFCH?> <S
#IOLCfLIOR
(;OL?HN
;H> /=;CFF?N "IL CHMN;H=?
CN ;FFIQM =IGJONCHA
NB? M?HMCNCPCNS I@ NB? JILN@IFCI 2;. NI =B;HA?M CH NB? Q?CABNM I@ NB? JILN@IFCI
1FNCG;N?FS
CN =;H <? OM?> NI >CL?=NFS IJNCGCT? NB? Q?CABNM I@ NB? JILN@IFCI
OH>?L 2;. =IHMNL;CHNM M?? @IL CHMN;H=?
$OCMG;H
'I?>CDE
;H> ,IQH;FF
IL 'LIEBG;F
,;FGKOCMN
;H> 1LS;M?P
0BCM CMMO? CM ;FMI ;>>L?MM?> CH
/?=NCIH *INC=? NB;N ; L?>O=NCIH I@ NB? >CG?HMCIH;FCNS =;H <? ;NN;CH?> <S
.CAILIOMFS
NB? 2;. CM >?WH?> ;M
<?=;OM? NB? 013 G;S <? =IHMN;HN IP?L MIG? CHN?LP;F 3? OM? MCGJF?L HIN;NCIHM
@IL ?;M? I@ ?RJIMCNCIH
.CME );H;A?G?HN ;H> 2;.
>?WHCHA MIG? @;=NILM MOJJIM?> NI =;JNOL? NB? G;CH MIOL=?M I@ LCME ;_?=NCHA
NB? JILN@IFCI L?NOLH
0I ?MNCG;N? NB? 2;. I@ ; F;LA? JILN@IFCI IP?L NCG?
Q? =;H ;>IJN M?P?L;F
;JJLI;=B?M 0B? WLMN ;JJLI;=B CM <;M?> IH NB? =IGJON;NCIH I@ NB? 2;. I@ NB?
JILN@IFCI H I<PCIOM ;>P;HN;A? I@ MO=B ;H ;JJLI;=B CM NB;N CN ;PIC>M GI>?F
CHA NB? DICHN >SH;GC=M I@ ;MM?N L?NOLHM >L;Q<;=E CM NB;N CN QCFF JLI<;<FS
GCMM MIG? CGJILN;HN FCHEM <?NQ??H ;MM?N L?NOLHM MO=B ;M NB? NCG?P;LSCHA =IL
L?F;NCIH 0B? M?=IH> M?N I@ ;JJLI;=B?M CM <;M?> IH NB? GI>?FCHA I@ NB? DICHN
>CMNLC<ONCIH I@ ;MM?N L?NOLHM
%H A?H?L;F
NB? 2;. CM =IGJON?> IP?L ; NCG? BILCTIH R >;S
@IL CH
MN;H=? %H MO=B ; =;M?
Q? B;P?
;MMOGCHA NB? JIMCNCIH CM B?F> =IHMN;HN IP?L
NB? BILCTIH
NB? @IFFIQCHA >?WHCNCIH @IL NB? GOFNCJ?LCI> 2;.
CNF
N
B H>
NNF
+
+ YJN R
B H>
NNF (
CN
N
CN
N
QB?L? YN R CM NB? =OGOF;NCP? L?NOLH <?NQ??H [ ;H> [ R ;H> Q? >?WH?> NB?
2;. @IL CHP?MN?> ;M B H>
NNF B H>
NNF *CN
N
0I I<N;CH NB? GOFNC
J?LCI> 2;.
Q? NB?L?@IL? H??> ;H ?MNCG;N? I@ NB? =IH>CNCIH;F >CMNLC<ONCIH I@
NB? GOFNCJ?LCI> JILN@IFCI L?NOLH YJN R
LNTH?L ?N ;F
JLIJIM?> ; M?N I@ =IH>CNCIHM NB;N ; =IB?L?HN G?;
MOL? I@ LCME MBIOF> M;NCM@S
/SMN?G
NB;N 2;. ;M Q?FF ;M P;LC;H=? GCML?A;L>M NB? LCME I@ ?RNL?G?
FIMM M B;M <??H BCABFCABN?> <S ;M;E ;H> /B;JCLI
<?=;OM? 2;.
>CML?A;L>M LCME I@ ?RNL?G? FIMM?M <?BCH> NB? =IHW>?H=? F?P?F
CN G;S CH>O=?
F;LA? FIMM?M IHM?KO?HNFS
NBCM G?;MOL? G;S CH>O=? ; F;LA?L LCME ?RJIMOL?
NB;H NB? P;LC;H=? CH =;M? I@ >IQH G;LE?NM
A9.,=.- %18;=/*55
FN?LH;NCP?FS
Q? B;P?
1?
N CN
N
CN
N
1?
N 1
B H>
N
CN
N
CN
N
CN
N
'LIEBG;F
,;FGKOCMN
;H> 1LS;M?P
.I=E;@?FF;L ;H> 1LS;M?P
"?LG;HC;H ;H> /=;CFF?N >CM=OMM BIQ NB? 2;. ;H> NB? !/ I@ ; JILN@IFCI
P;LS QB?H NB? Q?CABNM I@ NB? JILN@IFCI ;L? MFCABNFS ;FN?L?> /?? /?=NCIH @IL
;>>CNCIH;F >?N;CFM IH NB? ;MM?N ;FFI=;NCIH OH>?L ?RJ?=N?> MBILN@;FF =IHMNL;CHNM
.CAILIOMFS
NB? !/ CM >?WH?> ;M M?? =?L<C ;H> 0;M=B?
8-.5< /8; 98;=/8528 ;.=>;7<
0I MOGG;LCT?
=IGJONCHA NB? 2;. IL !/ I@ ; JILN@IFCI L?KOCL?M NB? @IFFIQCHA
?F?G?HNM
NB? JLI<;<CFCNS (
NB? BILCTIH I@ NB? CHP?MNG?HN R(
NB? P;FO? CN
N
I@ NB? JILN@IFCI ;N >;N? [(
NB? 013 I@ NB? JILN@IFCI L?NOLH
0B? WLMN NBL?? ?F?G?HNM ;L? ACP?H CH JL;=NC=?
;H> NB? G;CH N;ME =IHMCMNM
CH ?MNCG;NCHA NB? 013 I@ NB? JILN@IFCI L?NOLH
M ;LAO?> <?@IL?
NB?L? CM ; BOA? FCN?L;NOL? IH BIQ NI =IGJON? NB? 2;.
I@ ; JILN@IFCI +H? L?;MIH CM JLI<;<FS NB;N 2;. CHPIFP?M M?P?L;F >CG?HMCIHM
NB;N =;H <? >?;FN QCNB OMCHA =IGJF?N?FS >C_?L?HN ;JJLI;=B?M
WLMN CMMO? CM NB? .44?24.A6<; 92C29 "IL ; G?L? G?;MOL? I@ NB? 2;.
MCGOFN;H?IOMFS GI>?FCHA NB? DICHN >SH;GC= I@ ;FF ;MM?N L?NOLHM G;S MCGJFS <?
CGJIMMC<F? %H MO=B =;M?M
CN CM JL?@?L;<F? NI QILE QCNB ; L?>O=?> HOG<?L I@
<;M? ;MM?NM IL LCME @;=NILM NB;N ;L? NBIOABN NI >LCP? LCMEM >>CHA LCME @;=NILM
0B? JILN@IFCIF?P?F ;JJLI;=B CM HIN ;JJLIJLC;N? @IL G?;MOLCHA NB? ?_?=N IH NB?
2;. I@ ; =B;HA? CH NB? JILN@IFCI Q?CABNM
$CMNILC=;F MCGOF;NCIH
2<=8;2,*5 <26>5*=287
$CMNILC=;F MCGOF;NCIH CM JLI<;<FS NB? MCGJF?MN ;H> GIMN QC>?FS OM?> ;JJLI;=B
@IL =IGJONCHA 2;. ;H> !/ %N CM @OH>;G?HN;FFS HIHJ;L;G?NLC=
CH NB? M?HM?
NB;N CN >I?M HIN L?KOCL? ;HS ;MMOGJNCIH ;<ION NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ L?NOLHM
0B? G?NBI> QILEM ;M @IFFIQM MMOG? NB;N ; M;GJF? I@ @ J;MN L?;FCT;NCIHM
'Y ( ( Y4 ( CM ;P;CF;<F? 3? >?WH? ; QCH>IQ MCT?
:
NB;N CM OM?> NI =IHMNLO=N
MO<M;GJF?M I@ MCT? : 0B?H
@ :
IP?LF;JJCHA MO<M;GJF?M 'Y ( ( Y. (
'Y4 . ( ( Y4 ( ;L? ;P;CF;<F? !;=B I@ NB?M? MO<M;GJF?M CM OM?> NI ;J
JLIRCG;N? NB? 013 I@ NB? M?LC?M 0I >I NBCM
N;E? IH? I@ NB?M? MO<M;GJF?M
@IL CH
MN;H=? NB? [NB IH?
'YN. ( ( YN (
;H> MILN NBCM MO<M;GJF? CH CH=L?;MCHA IL
>?L ?WH? NB? MILN?> >;N; ;M '0 YN. N ( ( Y0NN ( QB?L? Y0N. N
Y0NN
*IQ
NB? 2;. QCNB JLI<;<CFCNS CM >?WH?> ;M NB? KO;HNCF? I@ NB? MO<M;G
JF? 0BCM CM NB?L?@IL? NB? :
NB IL>?L MN;NCMNC= Y0
.N C@ : CM ;H CHN?A?L %@ :
CM HIN ;H CHN?A?L
NB? KO;HNCF? CM >?WH?> OMCHA ; FCH?;L CHN?LJIF;NCIH <?NQ??H
Y0
. N ;H> Y0
. N 0I MCGJFC@S
;MMOG? NB;N : CM ;H CHN?A?L ;H> NB;N Y0
.N
CM NB? KO;HNCF? I@ NB? MO<M;GJF? 0B?H
NB? 2;. ;N >;N? [ @IL >;N? [
CM
B H>
N 0
Y
.N '
"CH;FFS
NB? !/ CM >?WH?> ;M NB? ;P?L;A? I@ NB? L?;FCT;NCIHM NB;N ;L? <?FIQ NBCM
F?P?F
.
,
1?
N Y0DN '
%: & D
0B? G?NBI> B;M NQI G;CH ;>P;HN;A?M "CLMN
CN CM P?LS ?;MS NI CGJF?G?HN
/?=IH>
CN ;FFIQM @IL HIHHILG;F L?NOLHM %H>??>
CN >I?M ;==IOHN @IL @;N N;CFM
/CH=? CN OM?M NB? ;=NO;F L?;FCT;NCIHM I@ L?NOLHM
CN CM ;<F? NI =;JNOL? GIMN I@
NB? ?GJCLC=;F @?;NOL?M I@ NBCM M?LC?M
$IQ?P?L
NBCM ;JJLI;=B ;FMI L;CM?M M?P?L;F >C^=OFNC?M "CLMN
;FNBIOAB NB?
BCMNILC=;F MCGOF;NCIH ;JJLI;=B CM M;C> NI <? HIHJ;L;G?NLC=
CN CM <;M?> IH
; MNLIHA OH>?LFSCHA ;MMOGJNCIH NB? L?NOLH JLI=?MM CM MOJJIM?> NI <? 661
!GJCLC=;F ?PC>?H=? =F?;LFS MOAA?MNM NB;N NBCM CM HIN NB? =;M? "IL NBCM L?;MIH
NB? =BIC=? I@ NB? QCH>IQ MCT? : CM =LO=C;F CH JL;=NC=? (IHA?L M;GJF?M CH=L?;M?
NB? ;==OL;=S I@ 2;. ?MNCG;N?M
<ON ;N NB? M;G? NCG? CH=L?;M? NB? JLI<;<CFCNS I@
OMCHA CLL?F?P;HN >;N;
CH J;LNC=OF;L C@ NB?L? ;L? MIG? =B;HA?M CH NB? OH>?LFSCHA
G;R
"0/! GCH
G;R
*CEE?C GCH
G;R
NB?S =ILL?MJIH> NI NB? NB ;H> NB? NB IL>?L MN;NCMNC=M I@ ?;=B MO<M;GJF?
+H? ?RJF;H;NCIH @IL NBCM J;NN?LH CM NB;N ;FF L?;FCT;NCIHM CH NB? MO<M;GJF? B;P?
NB? M;G? Q?CABN 0I J;LNC;FFS =IJ? QCNB NBCM JLI<F?G
Q? G;S
@IL CHMN;H=?
%.629*;*6.=;2, *99;8*,1.<
0B? JLI<F?G QCNB NB? BCMNILC=;F MCGOF;NCIH ;JJLI;=B MN?GM @LIG NB? @;=N NB;N
L?NOLHM ;L? HIN 661 ;H> @LIG NB? >CM=L?N?H?MM I@ NB? N;CFM I@ NB? ?GJCLC=;F
>CMNLC<ONCIH 0B? NQI M?GCJ;L;G?NLC= ;JJLI;=B?M JL?M?HN?> HIQ JON MIG?
MNLO=NOL? IH NB? N;CFM I@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH <S OMCHA J;L;G?NLC= GI>?FM <ON
QCNBION ?MNCG;NCHA NB? =IGJF?N? >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ L?NOLHM 0I MIG? ?RN?HN
NB?S
;L? ;FMI ;<F? NI =IJ? QCNB NB? N?GJIL;F >?J?H>?H=? I@ L?NOLHM 0B? WLMN IH? CM
<;M?> IH NB? !20 JL?M?HN?> CH >?N;CF CH /?=NCIH 0B? M?=IH> ;JJLI;=B CM
/?GCJ;L;G?NLC= ;JJLI;=B?M
3.5
1% VaR
5% VaR
3
2.5
1.5
0.5
1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005
20 *.& <3 =<?A3<96< 0<:=BA21 D6A5 A52 56@A<?60.9 @6:B9.A6<; .==?<.05
5
1% ES
4.5 5% ES
3.5
2.5
1.5
0.5
1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005
20
' <3 =<?A3<96< 0<:=BA21 D6A5 A52 56@A<?60.9 @6:B9.A6<; .==?<.05
.CME );H;A?G?HN ;H> 2;.
0B? !20 CM >?MCAH?> NI GI>?F NB? MJ?=CW= <?B;PCIL I@ P?LS F;LA? JIMCNCP? IL
H?A;NCP? L?NOLHM %N JLIPC>?M ; J;L;G?NLC= L?JL?M?HN;NCIH I@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH
I@ NB? ?RNL?G?M IL I@ NB? N;CFM 0BCM L?JL?M?HN;NCIH CM ;<F? NI ACP? MGIINB?>
?MNCG;N?M I@ NB? 2;. ;H> CM >?MCAH?> NI JLI>O=? P?LS BCAB KO;HNCF?M
JIMMC<FS
MG;FF?L NB;H NB? GCHCGOG I@ NB? M;GJF? >CMNLC<ONCIH /O=B ;H ;JJLI;=B B;M
<??H ;>IJN?> @IL 2;. ?P;FO;NCIH <S M?P?L;F ;ONBILM )=*?CF ?MNCG;N?M
; AJ> NI ?P;FO;N? NB? N;CF CH>?R ;HC?FMMIH ;H> >? 2LC?M OM?M ; M?GC
J;L;G?NLC= ?MNCG;N? I@ NB? N;CF CH>?R )=*?CF ;H> "L?S CHNLI>O=? ;
#.$]!20 GI>?F NB;N CH=ILJIL;N?M NB? N?GJIL;F ?PIFONCIH I@ PIF;NCFCNS
(IHACH ;>IJNM ; GOFNCP;LC;N? ;JJLI;=B NI =;JNOL? NB? DICHN ?RNL?G?
<?B;PCIL I@ LCME @;=NILM
%H /?=NCIH
Q? >?M=LC<?> BIQ NB? KO;HNCF? I@ ; OHCP;LC;N? >CMNLC<ONCIH
=;H <? =IGJON?> OMCHA NB? P;LCIOM ;JJLI;=B?M >?P?FIJ?> CH NB? =IHN?RN I@ NB?
!20 NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ ?RNL?G?M
NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ NB? N;CFM IL NB? M?GC
J;L;G?NLC= ?MNCG;NCIH I@ NB? N;CF CH>?R 3? <LC?XS L?=;FF NB? ?MNCG;NCIH I@
BCAB KO;HNCF?M CH NB? =;M? I@ NB? N;CF ;JJLI;=B
'7,87-2=287*5 (&
0B? G;CH C>?; I@ NB? N;CF ;JJLI;=B NI !20 CM NB;N NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ NB? FIQ?L
N;CF C?
NB? L?NOLHM NB;N ;L? <?FIQ ; ACP?H NBL?MBIF> \ =;H <? ;JJLIRCG;N?>
QB?L? NB? N;CF CH>?R =B;L;=N?LCT?M NB? MB;J? I@ NB? N;CFM I@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH
;H> ! CM ; M=;FCHA J;L;G?N?L
MMOG? NB;N NB? ?MNCG;NCIH I@ NB? AJ> CM J?L@ILG?> IH NB? ;<MIFON? P;FO?
I@ NB? FIQ?L N;CF I<M?LP;NCIHM
;M >?N;CF?> CH /?=NCIH +H=? NB? J;L;G?
N?LM I@ NBCM AJ> ;L? ?MNCG;N?>
Q? =;H >?>O=? NB? KO;HNCF? I@ NB? ;=NO;F
>CMNLC<ONCIH ;M
!
$
# \ 4
.+
( C@ (
X
$
"\ ! &)# 4 (
.+ C@ (
1?
N 1 Y) Y B H>
N
B H>
N 1 Y B H>
N ) Y B H>
N '
.?=;FF NB;N
C@ Y \)Y + \ 3
NB? G?;H ?R=?MM @OH=NCIH ;<IP? F?P?F \ CM
>?WH?> ;M
! \
L \
1 Y \) Y \ ( ! \ + '
0B?L?@IL?
NB? ?RJ?=N?> MBILN@;FF CM ?KO;F NI NB? MOG I@ NB? 2;. ;H> NB? G?;H
?R=?MM @OH=CIH ;<IP? NB? 2;. *IQ
MCH=? B H>
N + \
Q? G;S QLCN?
! B H>
N \
!
1?
N B H>
N '
0BCM ;JJLI;=B CM =;FF?> OH=IH>CNCIH;F !20
<?=;OM? CN CM <;M?> IH NB? ;M
MOGJNCIH NB;N L?NOLHM ;L? 661 %N NB?L?@IL? JLI>O=?M ;H OH=IH>CNCIH;F 2;.
C?
J?LN;CHCHA NI NB? OH=IH>CNCIH;F >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ L?NOLHM 0BCM CGJFC?M NB;N
NB? KO;HNCF? X
QCFF HIN P;LS IP?L NCG?
?P?H C@ NB?L? CM ; MO>>?H =B;HA? CH
G;LE?N =IH>CNCIHM .?=?HNFS
)=*?CF ;H> "L?S B;P? JLIJIM?> ; GI>?F
NB;N JLIPC>?M =IH>CNCIH;F G?;MOL?M I@ NB? 2;. <;M?> IH !20 0BCM ;JJLI;=B
CM >?M=LC<?> <?FIQ
HINB?L >L;Q<;=E I@ NB? N;CF ;JJLI;=B CM NB;N Q? B;P? NI M?F?=N ; NBL?MBIF>
\ <?FIQ QBC=B Q? =IHMC>?L NB;N L?NOLHM <?FIHA NI NB? N;CF FNBIOAB MIG? NIIFM
B;P? <??H JLIJIM?> NI M?F?=N NBCM NBL?MBIF> MO=B ;M <IINMNL;J N?=BHCKO?M
3.9
3.85
1%
VaR
3.8
3.75
0 0.02 0.04 0.06 0.08 0.1
u
0B? #.$]!20 GI>?F JLIJIM?> <S )=*?CF ;H> "L?S =IHMCMNM CH
GI>?FCHA NB? =IH>CNCIH;F PIF;NCFCNS ;H> NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ NB? N;CFM M?J;L;N?FS
%H @;=N
IHFS NB? F?@N N;CF CM H??>?>
<?=;OM? NB? LCABN N;CF CM HIN L?F?P;HN @IL
2;. =IGJON;NCIH
"IL NBCM JOLJIM?
)=*?CF ;H> "L?S JLI=??> ;M @IFFIQM %H NB? WLMN
MN?J
NB?S WFN?L NB? >?J?H>?H=? CH NB? L?NOLH M?LC?M <S =IGJONCHA NB? L?MC>O;FM
I@ ; #.$ GI>?F
QBC=B MBIOF> <? 661 C@ NB? #.$ GI>?F =ILL?=NFS
WNM NB? >;N; %H NB? M?=IH> MN?J
NB?S GI>?F NB? ?RNL?G? <?B;PCIL I@ NB?
L?MC>O;F OMCHA NB? N;CF ;JJLI;=B >?P?FIJ?> CH /?=NCIH "CH;FFS
CH IL>?L
NI JLI>O=? ; 2;. ?MNCG;N? @IL NB? ILCACH;F L?NOLH
NB?S NL;=? <;=E NB? MN?JM <S
WLMN JLI>O=CHA NB? KO;HNCF? ?MNCG;N? @IL NB? #.$WFN?L?> L?MC>O;FM ;H>
=IHP?LN NB? KO;HNCF? ?MNCG;N? NI NB? ILCACH;F L?NOLH OMCHA NB? =IH>CNCIH;F
PIF;NCFCNS @IL?=;MN @IL NB? L?KOCL?> BILCTIH
"IL ; ACP?H L?NOLH M?LC?M 'Y ( ( Y4 (
NB? GI>?F ;>IJN?> NI WFN?L ION NB?
WLMN ;H> M?=IH>IL>?L >SH;GC=M CM I@ NB? @ILG
YN N #N (
# N N aN (
N &YN (
N "
# N N (
/?GCJ;L;G?NLC= ;JJLI;=B?M
QCNB " +
( ( ;H>
)
NI ?HMOL? ; JIMCNCP? PIF;NCFCNS ;H>
; =IP;LC;H=? MN;NCIH;LS JLI=?MM 0I ;PIC> MJ?=C@SCHA ;H ;L<CNL;LS >CMNLC<ONCIH
@IL NB? CHHIP;NCIH JLI=?MM aN
NB?S L?MILN NI NB? -O;MC );RCGOG (CE?FCBII>
-)( ?MNCG;NCIH
QBC=B =IHMCMNM CH G;RCGCTCHA NB? HILG;F FIAFCE?FCBII> I@
NB? GI>?F ?P?H NBIOAB NB? NLO? A?H?L;NCHA JLI=?MM I@ aN CM HIN #;OMMC;H 0BCM
N?=BHCKO? B;M <??H MBIQH NI JLIPC>? =IHMCMN?HN ?MNCG;N?M I@ NB? GI>?F J;L;
G?N?LM
JLIPC>?> NB? =IH>CNCIH;F G?;H ;H> P;LC;H=? ?KO;NCIHM ;L? =ILL?=NFS
MJ?=CW?> #IOLCfLIOR
)IH@ILN
;H> 0LIAHIH
0B? MN;H>;L>CT?> L?MC>
O;F aN CM NB?H ?MNCG;N?> <S aN YN N
*
N ( QB?L? N ;L? NB? WNN?>
N ;H>
G?;H ;H> P;LC;H=?
L?MJ?=NCP?FS 3? ;FMI OM? NBCM GI>?F NI JLI>O=? @IL?=;MNM
I@ NB? ?RJ?=N?> L?NOLH N
& YN ;H> P;LC;H=? N
"
# N
N '
0B? H?RN MN?J CHPIFP?M ?MNCG;NCHA NB? AJ> NI ;FF ?R=??>;H=?M
C?
;FF L?
;FCT;NCIHM aN NB;N ;L? <?FIQ ; ACP?H BCAB NBL?MBIF> \)>IJNCHA ; MCGCF;L
4
;JJLI;=B NI NB? IH? CH /?=NCIH
Q? >?WH? :O N
T* O aN
NB?
HOG<?L I@ ?R=??>;H=?M ;H> ' a4 ( ( a44 ( NB? P?=NIL I@ MN;H>;L>CT?> L?MC>
O;FM MILN?> <S CH=L?;MCHA IL>?L
MO=B NB;N a4
a44 "CH;FFS
Q? >?WH?
NB? :O (
P?=NIL I@ ?R=??>;H=?M ;M ' a4 ( ( a.+ 4 ( 0B?H
Q? ?MNCG;N? NB?
.+
J;L;G?N?LM ( !
I@ NB? AJ> NI NB? ?R=??>;H=?M ' aD4 (D
+H=? NB? J;L;G?N?LM ;H> ! ;L? ?MNCG;N?>
NB? KO;HNCF? CM I<N;CH?> <S
CHP?LNCHA NB? 013 I@ ?R=??>;H=?M
!
$
# \ 4
.+
( C@ (
X
$
"\ ! &)# 4 (
.+ C@ '
B H>
N N
X
N
(
B H>
N \
!
1?
N '
%N CM QILNB ?GJB;MCTCHA NB;N NB? #.$]!20 ;JJLI;=B CH=ILJIL;N?M NB?
NQI CHAL?>C?HNM L?KOCL?> @IL ;H ;==OL;N? ?P;FO;NCIH I@ NB? =IH>CNCIH;F 2;.
C?
; GI>?F @IL NB? >SH;GC=M I@ NB? WLMN ;H> M?=IH> GIG?HNM
;H> ;H ;JJLI
JLC;N? GI>?F @IL NB? =IH>CNCIH;F >CMNLC<ONCIH H I<PCIOM CGJLIP?G?HN I@ NBCM
;JJLI;=B ;M =IGJ;L?> NI NB? OH=IH>CNCIH;F !20 CM NB;N CN CH=ILJIL;N?M CH NB?
2;. =B;HA?M CH ?RJ?=N?> L?NOLH ;H> CH PIF;NCFCNS "IL CHMN;H=?
C@ Q? ;MMOG? ;
=B;HA? CH PIF;NCFCNS IP?L NB? L?=?HN J?LCI>
NB? #.$]!20 CM ;<F? NI CH=IL
JIL;N? NBCM H?Q @?;NOL? CH CNM 2;. ?P;FO;NCIH
QB?L?;M NB? OH=IH>CNCIH;F !20
L?G;CHM MNO=E ;N NB? ;P?L;A? F?P?F I@ PIF;NCFCNS IP?L NB? ?MNCG;NCIH M;GJF?
)=*?CF ;H> "L?S ;FMI JLIPC>? ; <;=EN?MNCHA ?RJ?LCG?HN
CH QBC=B
NB?S =IGJ;L? NB? J?L@ILG;H=?M I@ P;LCIOM G?NBI>M NI =ILL?=NFS L?JLI>O=?
*INC=? NB;N Q? @I=OM CH NBCM M?=NCIH IH NB? FIQ?L N;CF
QB?L?;M ;FF >?P?FIJG?HNM
CH B;JN?L Q?L? <;M?> IH NB? OJJ?L N;CF
.CME );H;A?G?HN ;H> 2;.
NB? KO;HNCF?M I@ M?P?L;F ;MM?N L?NOLHM 0B?S MBIQ NB;N NB? #.$]!20 J?L
@ILGM GO=B <?NN?L NB;H NB? OH=IH>CNCIH;F !20
MOAA?MNCHA NB;N NB? ;<CFCNS
NI =;JNOL? =B;HA?M CH PIF;NCFCNS CM =LO=C;F @IL 2;. =IGJON;NCIH
>5=2?*;2*=. (&
0B? 2;. =IGJON;NCIH >?M=LC<?> ;<IP? CM OM?@OF @IL ; MCHAF? ;MM?N IL @IL =;M?M
QB?L? NB?L? CM IHFS IH? LCME @;=NIL 0B? =;M?M @IL GOFNC;MM?N ;H> GOFNCLCME
@;=NIL ;L? ; FIN GIL? =IGJF?R
<?=;OM? NB?S L?MILN NI GOFNCP;LC;N? !20 3?
B;P? MBIQH CH /?=NCIH BIQ NI =B;L;=N?LCT? ;H> G?;MOL? ?RNL?G;F >?J?H
>?H=? 0B? G?;MOL?M CHNLI>O=?> ;L? <;M?> IH NB? ?P;FO;NCIH I@ NB? JLIJ?LNC?M
I@ NB? DICHN >CMNLC<ONCIH ;N ?KO;F JLI<;<CFCNS G;LACH;F KO;HNCF?M 0I OM? NB?M?
G?;MOL?M NI =B;L;=N?LCT? ?RNL?G?M I@ ; JILN@IFCI
C?
I@ ; FCH?;L =IG<CH;NCIH
I@ ;MM?NM
NB? @OFF DICHN >CMNLC<ONCIH H??>M NI <? ?MNCG;N?> CH NB? N;CF L?ACIH "IL
NB? =;M? QB?L? L?NOLHM ;L? ;MSGJNINC=;FFS >?J?H>?HN IL ?R;=NFS CH>?J?H>?HN
#>*7=25. ;.0;.<<287 =.,172:>.
#>*7=25. ;.0;.<<287
4
0B? NB KO;HNCF? X
I@ ; NCG? M?LC?M '`N (N =;H <? >?WH?> ;M NB? MIFONCIH I@
NB? @IFFIQCHA GCHCGCT;NCIH JLI<F?G
A?H?L;F JL?M?HN;NCIH =;H <? @IOH> CH 'I?HE?L ;H> $;FFI=E
Q?FFEHIQH MJ?=C;F =;M? CM NB? G?>C;H F
CH QBC=B NB? G?>C;H CM
>?WH?> ;M
/?GCJ;L;G?NLC= ;JJLI;=B?M
, ,
'%( )`N X)
)`N X) ( ) )
(
K
NNS* K NNS* K
IL
?KOCP;F?HNFS
4
,
'%( ^
`N X
(
K
N
QB?L?
aN ( C@ aN (
^
aN
aN ( C@ aN ) '
4
0B? ?MNCG;N?> X CM NB? OH=IH>CNCIH;F KO;HNCF? I@ '`N (N ' *IQ
CH ; L?AL?M
MCIH =IHN?RN
`N _
N \N
QB?L? _N CM ; R(
P?=NIL I@ L?AL?MMILM ;H> \N
CM NB? ?LLIL N?LG QCNB 013 2
NB? NB L?AL?MMCIH KO;HNCF? I@ \N `N _
N
=IH>CNCIH;F IH _N CM I<N;CH?> ;M NB? MIFONCIH I@ NB? GCHCGCT;NCIH JLI<F?G
, ,
'%( )`N _
N )
)`N _
N ) ( ) )
'
"
NNS* R* NNS* R*
0B? JOLJIM? I@ NBCM L?AL?MMCIH CM NI WH> NB? P?=NIL I@ J;L;G?N?LM NB;N QCFF
?HMOL? NB;N NB? KO;HNCF? I@ \N QCFF <? ;M =FIM? NI ;M JIMMC<F? Q?FFEHIQH
KO;HNCF? L?AL?MMCIH CM NB? IH? ;MMI=C;N?> QCNB
* %H NBCM =;M?
CM
IJNCGCT?> CH IL>?L NI I<N;CH ; G?>C;H ?KO;F NI
0B? ?MNCG;NCIH N?=BHCKO? ;H> NB? ;MSGJNINC= JLIJ?LNC?M I@ NB? ?MNCG;NIL I@
;L? >?P?FIJ?> CH 'I?HE?L ;H> ;MM?NN 0BCM =F;MM I@ ?</B@A 2@A6:.A<?@
CH=FO>?M MIG? NB;N B;P? MCGCF;L ?^=C?H=S NI NB? F?;MNMKO;L? ?MNCG;NIL OH>?L
HILG;FCNS I@ NB? ?LLIL N?LG <ON NB;N IONJ?L@ILG NBCM ?MNCG;NIL OH>?L HIH
HILG;F ?LLILM
'I?HE?L ;H> ;MM?NN ;FMI JLIPC>? MIG? OM?@OF ;MSGJNINC= L?MOFNM
IH L?AL?MMCIH KO;HNCF?M %H J;LNC=OF;L
NB? MIFONCIH
I@ NB? IJNCGCT;NCIH
4
JLI<F?G @IL KO;HNCF? CM MBIQH NI <? =IHMCMN?HN ;H> ;MSGJNINC=;FFS HIL
G;F 0BCM L?MOFN CM ?RN?H>?> <S !HAF? ;H> );HA;H?FFC NI NB? =;M? I@
HIHFCH?;L L?AL?MMCIHM
(2*$
!HAF? ;H> );HA;H?FFC JLIJIM?> ; GI>?F <;M?> IH KO;HNCF? L?AL?MMCIHM
=;FF?> 2C;. 0B? C>?; CM NI >CL?=NFS GI>?F NB? ?PIFONCIH I@ NB? KO;HNCF? X
CHMN?;> I@ =IHMC>?LCHA NB? ?HNCL? >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ L?NOLHM 0B? A?H?L;F MJ?=CW
=;NCIH NB?S JLIJIM? B;M NB? @ILG
L
,
X
N X
N E N _NE
(
E
N&
&
.CME );H;A?G?HN ;H> 2;.
X
N X
N
L*
L* '
0B? J;L;G?N?LM I@ NB? KO;HNCF? L?AL?MMCIHM ;L? NB?H ?MNCG;N?> OMCHA HIH
FCH?;L N?=BHCKO?M NI MIFP? NB? IJNCGCT;NCIH JLI<F?G
, ,
'%( )`N X
N
)
)`N X
N
)
"
NNS* K* NNS* K*
"*;*6.=;2, *99;8*,1.<
3BCF? NB? BCMNILC=;F MCGOF;NCIH ;H> NB? OH=IH>CNCIH;F !20 ;JJLI;=B?M ;L? <S
H;NOL? OH;<F? NI =;JNOL? =B;HA?M CH NB? <?B;PCIL I@ L?NOLHM
NB? #.$]
!20 N?=BHCKO? ;H> 2C;. CH=ILJIL;N?M MIG? MNSFCT?> @;=NM I@ L?NOLHM =IH
=?LHCHA NB? WLMN ;H> M?=IH>IL>?L >SH;GC=M 3? HIQ NOLH NI J;L;G?NLC=
GI>?FM I@ 2;. NB;N BIF> OH>?L ; =IGJF?N? M?N I@ ;MMOGJNCIHM =IH=?LHCHA NB?
>SH;GC=M ;H> NB? =IH>CNCIH;F >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ L?NOLHM
3? L?=;FF B?L? NB;N NB? G;CH ?GJCLC=;F @?;NOL?M @IL ;MM?N L?NOLHM ;L? NB?
@IFFIQCHA
N N
YN
( @IL [ ( ( @(
QCNB ) )
' 0BCM GI>?F G;S <? PC?Q?> ;M ; MJ?=C;F =;M? I@ NB?
%HN?AL;N?> #.$ GI>?F %H NB? WLMN P?LMCIHM I@ .CME)?NLC=M
NB? >?=;S
@;=NIL Q;M =BIM?H NI <? ?KO;F NI 0B? L?=OLMCIH =;H <? CHCNC;FCT?>
IL <S NB? MKO;L? I@ NB? WLMN I<M?LP;NCIH
<S NB? M;GJF? P;LC;H=?
Y
0B? CHHIP;NCIH aN CM MOJJIM?> NI <? >CMNLC<ON?> ;M ;H 661 (
1H>?L
NB?M? P;LCIOM ;MMOGJNCIHM
NB? =IH>CNCIH;F >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ YN ;N >;N?
[ CM ( N %@ Q? ;L? CHN?L?MN?> CH NB? IH?MN?J;B?;> 2;.
Q? H??> NB?
=IH>CNCIH;F
>CMNLC<ONCIH
I@ YN IH>CNCIH;FFS IH NB? CH@ILG;NCIH ;N NCG? [
CN
CM ( N
QB?L? N
N
YN "IL NB? (
>CMNLC<ONCIH
Q? >?HIN? X
NB? KO;HNCF? @IL ; JLI<;<CFCNS I@ FIMM ?KO;F NI "IL
CHMN;H=?
@IL
Q? B;P? X
' *IQ
NB? >;CFS 2;. CM ACP?H <S
B H>
N X
N
'
%H ;>>CNCIH
Q? B;P? NB? @IFFIQCHA ?RJL?MMCIH @IL NB? !/
N
N
N
T
1?
N N
QB?L?
. K
T
1?
N a + "/* a Ka & X
X
QB?L? & a
>?HIN?M NB? =13 I@ NB? (
>CMNLC<ONCIH "CH;FFS
Q? I<N;CH
& X
1?
N N
'
>5=29.;28- (*$
N
N
N
N
YN ( @IL
(
0BCM ?RJL?MMCIH CM EHIQH ;M NB? MKO;L?LIINI@NCG? LOF? 0BCM LOF? B;M <??H
L?=IGG?H>?> <S NB? ;MF? IGGCNN??ZM G?H>G?HN NI NB? ;JCN;F ==IL>
NI %H=ILJIL;N? );LE?N .CMEM CH IL>?L NI =IGJON? NB? >;S 2;. @LIG
>;CFS ?MNCG;N?M
>5=295. 98<2=287
<IP?
Q? =IGJON?> NB? 2;. I@ ; MCHAF? ;MM?N
; =;M? NB;N CM HIN P?LS CH
N?L?MNCHA CH JL;=NC=;F ;JJFC=;NCIHM *INC=? NB;N Q? G;S ;FN?LH;NCP?FS PC?Q YN
;M NB? L?NOLH I@ NB? JILN@IFCI
HIN ;M NB? L?NOLH I@ ;H ;MM?N %H MO=B ; =;M?
QB?L? N
CM NB? IH?MN?J;B?;> @IL?=;MN I@ NB? =IP;LC;H=? G;NLCR I@ ;MM?N
L?NOLHM %N CM =IGJON?> ;MMOGCHA NB;N ;FF P;LC;H=?M ;H> =IP;LC;H=?M ;L? >LCP?H
<S NB? M;G? GI>?F
DN DN
YDN
( @IL P
( ( U(
DEN DEN
YDN YEN ( @IL P( Q
( ( U(
%@ Q? OM? DEN
DN
EN
DEN
QB?L? DEN
>?HIN?M NB? IH?
J?LCI> @IL?=;MN I@ NB? =ILL?F;NCIH <?NQ??H ;MM?NM P ;H> Q
Q? I<N;CH ;@N?L
MCGJFCW=;NCIH M??
@IL CHMN;H=?
(IHACH
I
, I
, I
,
E
B H>
N
D B H>
N
D
D
DEN
D
E B H>
N B H>
N '
D D ED
0B? MKO;L?> 2;. I@ NB? JILN@IFCI CM MCGJFS NB? KO;>L;NC= @ILG I@ NB? 2;.
I@ L?NOLHM
Q?CABN?> <S NB? =ILL?F;NCIH G;NLCR <?NQ??H L?NOLHM IGJONCHA
NB? 2;. CH NBCM Q;S >I?M HIN ?P?H L?KOCL? NB? EHIQF?>A? I@ NB? JILN@IFCI
Q?CABNM
.CME );H;A?G?HN ;H> 2;.
MO=B ;M NB? F;=E I@ G?;HL?P?LMCIH CH NB? P;LC;H=? JLI=?MM 0BCM CMMO? B;M <??H
CHP?MNCA;N?> <S C?<IF> ?N ;F 0B?S MBIQ NB;N NB? MKO;L?LIINI@NCG?
LOF? JLI>O=?M IP?L?MNCG;N?M I@ NB? P;LC;<CFCNS I@ FIHABILCTIH PIF;NCFCNS
F;MN
F?MM MNLCHA?HN
;MMOGJNCIH CM NB? ;<M?H=? I@ >SH;GC=M @IL NB? ?R
J?=N?> L?NOLH 0BCM CM JLI<;<FS NII MNLIHA ;H ;MMOGJNCIH
<ON CH JL;=NC=?
NB?
?_?=N I@ ;FN?LCHA NB? =IH>CNCIH;F G?;H ?KO;NCIH IH NB? 2;. G?;MOL?M CM <;L?FS
HINC=?;<F? 0B? L?;MIH CM NB;N @IL GIMN ;MM?N L?NOLHM
NB? 2;. =IGJON;NCIH CM
F;LA?FS >IGCH;N?> <S PIF;NCFCNS
L;NB?L NB;H ?RJ?=N?> L?NOLH
=IHMC>?L;NCIHM
&1. 98;=/85285.?.5 *99;8*,1
N
& YN (
N
"
# N N
IH>CNCIH;FFS
IH NB? CH@ILG;NCIH
;N NCG? [
NB? =IH>CNCIH;F >CMNLC<ONCIH I@
YN CM N
( N
0B? >;CFS 2;. CM ACP?H <S
B H>
N N
X
N
;H> NB? !/ CM
B H>
N N
1?
N & N
N
N
& X
N
N
'
87-2=287*5 -2<=;2+>=287
FNBIOAB NB? GI>?F ;<IP? CM ;<F? NI =;JNOL? NB? >SH;GC= CH ?RJ?=N?> L?NOLHM
;M Q?FF ;M CH PIF;NCFCNS
NB? =IH>CNCIH;F >CMNLC<ONCIH CM MNCFF ;MMOG?> NI <?
HILG;F !GJCLC=;F ?PC>?H=? MOAA?MNM NB;N >CMNLC<ONCIHM ;FFIQCHA @;N N;CFM ;H>
;MSGG?NLS MBIOF> <? OM?> @IL GI>?FCHA NB? CHHIP;NCIHM %H B;JN?L
Q?
>?M=LC<?> M?P?L;F ;FN?LH;NCP? >CMNLC<ONCIHM NB;N G;S <? OM?> CH MO=B ; =IHN?RN
"IL CHMN;H=?
NB? /NO>?HN [ >CMNLC<ONCIH G;S <? P?LS ?;MCFS OM?> CH JF;=? I@
NB? HILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH
<?=;OM? JLI=?>OL?M NI =IGJON? NB? CHP?LM? I@ CNM =>@
;L? ;P;CF;<F? CH GIMN ?=IHIG?NLC= MI@NQ;L? 0B? ME?Q?> /NO>?HN [ >CMNLC<ONCIH
;FMI ;JJ?;LM ;M ;H I<PCIOM ;FN?LH;NCP?
"IL CHMN;H=?
;MMOG? HIQ NB;N NB? CHHIP;NCIH JLI=?MM CM >L;QH @LIG ;
MN;H>;L>CT?> /NO>?HN [ >CMNLC<ONCIH QCNB >?AL??M I@ @L??>IG %N CM QILNB ?G
JB;MCTCHA NB;N CH NB? =IHN?RN I@ ; #.$ GI>?F
NB? CHHIP;NCIH JLI=?MM aN CM
MOJJIM?> NI B;P? T?LI G?;H ;H> OHCN P;LC;H=? IHM?KO?HNFS
NB? ;JJLIJLC;N?
>CMNLC<ONCIH CM HIN NB? OMO;F
<ON NB? MN;H>;L>CT?> [
>?WH?> ;M
a
[ aN )
J
N (
8
QCNB CH JF;=? I@ ;H> J *
/CH=? NBCM
CM NB? OMO;F [ NB;N CM ;P;CF;<F? CH GIMN MI@NQ;L?
NB? KO;HNCF?M B;P? NI <?
;JJLIJLC;N?FS =ILL?=N?> "CH;FFS
NB? 2;. @IL YN CM ACP?H <S
B H>
N N
X0
N
(
/CH=? NB? 2;. =IGJON;NCIH IHFS CHPIFP?M NB? N;CFM I@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH
NB? KO;HNCF?M
I@ NB? ME?Q?> /NO>?HN I >CMNLC<ONCIH =;H <? =IGJON?> OMCHA NB? JLI=?>OL? <OCFN
@IL NB? MN;H>;L> /NO>?HN I
JLIPC>?> NB? ;MSGG?NLC= =IGJIH?HN CM JLIJ?LFS N;E?H
CHNI ;==IOHN
)IL? JL?=CM?FS
C@ O# CM NB? FKO;HNCF? I@ NB? OMO;F I >CMNLC<ONCIH QCNB >?AL??M
I@ @L??>IG CH A?H?L;F ACP?H <S ?=IHIG?NLC= MI@NQ;L?
NB?H NB? KO;HNCF? O&# I@
.CME );H;A?G?HN ;H> 2;.
QB?L? X0
[
CM NB? KO;HNCF? @IL ; JLI<;<CFCNS I@ FIMM ?KO;F NI @LIG
NB? MN;H>;L>CT?> [ >CMNLC<ONCIH "IL NB? !/
Q? B;P? NI ?P;FO;N? NB? M;G?
?RJL?MMCIH ;M @IL NB? HILG;F =;M?
T
1?
N 1?
N N
N
(
QB?L?
. K
T
a
1?
N aJ
Ka
[ 0
X
J X0
(
1?
N
N
N
'
>5=29.;28- (*$
IGJONCHA NB? 2;. IP?L R J?LCI>M L?KOCL?M NB? =OGOF;NCP? ?RJ?=N?> L?NOLH
;H> PIF;NCFCNS @IL?=;MNM IP?L RJ?LCI>M 1MCHA
;<OMCP?FS
NB? >?WHCNCIH I@ NB?
GOFNCJ?LCI> FIAL?NOLH
NB? RJ?LCI> ?RJ?=N?> L?NOLH CM
&F
N R N NF R
( @IL R +
'
& N
)IL?IP?L
NB? RMN?J ;B?;> PIF;NCFCNS @IL?=;MN I@ ; #.$
(
CM ACP?H <S
F
N R
H I
N
( @IL R +
'
O# "IL
CHMN;H=?
@IL
NB? KO;HNCF? I@ NB? OMO;F I >CMNLC<ONCIH CM O#
0B? ;MM?NF?P?F ?MNCG;NCIH I@ NB? ;AAL?A;N? 2;. B;M <??H ;>PI=;N?> ;M ;FFIQ
CHA @IL ; <?NN?L =IHNLIF IH NB? 2;. ?MNCG;NCIH M ;FL?;>S ;LAO?>
CN ;FFIQM
G?;MOLCHA NB? ?_?=N IH NB? ;AAL?A;N? 2;. I@ ; =B;HA? CH JILN@IFCI Q?CABNM
NB? JILN@IFCIF?P?F ;JJLI;=B QIOF> L?KOCL? ; =IGJF?N? L??MNCG;NCIH I@ NB?
GI>?F $IQ?P?L
NBCM ;>P;HN;A? =IG?M ;N ; =IMN /CH=? Q? ;L? CHN?L?MN?> CH
NB? GI>?FCHA I@ NB? DICHN >SH;GC= I@ ;MM?N L?NOLHM
Q? B;P? NI NOLH NI ; GOF
NCP;LC;N? #.$NSJ? GI>?F M Q? B;P? M??H CH /?=NCIH
NBCM ;JJLI;=B
L;CM?M ; >CG?HMCIH;FCNS JLI<F?G
?P?H @IL ; GI>?L;N? HOG<?L I@ ;MM?NM !P?H
NBIOAB Q? ?GJB;MCT?> NB? CGJILN;H=? I@ HIH#;OMMC;H >CMNLC<ONCIHM @IL L?
NOLHM
NB? GOFNCP;LC;N? GI>?FCHA CH ; HIH#;OMMC;H M?NNCHA MNCFF L?JL?M?HNM
; =B;FF?HA? "IL NBCM L?;MIH
;N NB? ;MM?NF?P?F ;JJLI;=B
CN CM =OMNIG;LS NI
;MMOG? ; GOFNCP;LC;N? #;OMMC;H >CMNLC<ONCIH
+H=? NB? GOFNCP;LC;N? #.$ GI>?F CM ?MNCG;N?>
=IGJONCHA NB? ;AAL?
A;N? 2;. CM ?;MS
MCH=? NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ NB? JILN@IFCI L?NOLH CM
YJN JN ( JN (
QCNB JN
N N ;H> JN
N N
N 3? >?>O=? NB? ;AAL?A;N? 2;. ;M
B H>
N JN
X
JN
(
QB?L? X
CM NB? KO;HNCF? @IL ; JLI<;<CFCNS I@ FIMM ?KO;F NI ( @LIG NB?
OHCP;LC;N? HILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH (
0B? !/ CM ACP?H <S ?RJL?MMCIH
87-2=287*5 -2<=;2+>=287
;M aN aN
NB?L?@IL? DOMNC@SCHA NB? JL?FCGCH;LS ?MNCG;NCIH I@ NB? =IP;LC;H=?
G;NLCR >SH;GC=
"IL INB?L >CMNLC<ONCIHM CH=FO>CHA NB? ME?Q?> [ >CMNLC<ONCIH
NB? ?MNCG;
NCIH I@ NB? @OFF GI>?F B;M NI <? J?L@ILG?> CH IH? MN?J !P?H @IL GI>?L;N?
M=;F? JILN@IFCIM
MO=B ;H ?MNCG;NCIH QIOF> <? MCGJFS OHG;H;A?;<F?
H ;>>CNCIH;F CMMO? B;M NI <? ;>>L?MM?> CH NB? =IHN?RN I@ HIH#;OMMC;H
>CMNLC<ONCIHM +H=? NB? GOFNCP;LC;N? #.$ GI>?F CM ?MNCG;N?>
Q? H??> NI
=IGJON? NB? KO;HNCF? I@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ NB? JILN@IFCI 0B? >C^=OFNS CM NB;N
CH A?H?L;F
NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ NB? ;AAL?A;N? L?NOLH =;HHIN <? >?>O=?> @LIG
NB? GOFNCP;LC;N? >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ ;MM?N L?NOLHM 0B? ?R=?JNCIH CM IH=? ;A;CH NB?
?FFCJNC=;F >CMNLC<ONCIH @;GCFS %H NBCM =;M?
NB? ;AAL?A;N? 2;. CM =IGJON?> CH
?R;=NFS NB? M;G? Q;S ;M @IL NB? #;OMMC;H =;M? MMOG? @IL CHMN;H=? NB;N ;MM?N
L?NOLHM ;L? >CMNLC<ON?> ;M ; GOFNCP;LC;N? /NO>?HN [ >CMNLC<ONCIH ;M >?WH?>
CH CH /?=NCIH QCNB >?AL??M I@ @L??>IG 0B? ;AAL?A;N? 2;. CM
NB?L?@IL? ACP?H <S
B H>
N JN
X0
JN
(
QB?L? X0
[
CM NB? KO;HNCF? @IL ; JLI<;<CFCNS I@ FIMM ?KO;F NI @LIG NB?
OHCP;LC;N? /NO>?HN [ >CMNLC<ONCIH QCNB >?AL??M I@ @L??>IG 0B? !/ CM ACP?H
<S
%H NB? HIH?FFCJNC=;F =;M?M
HI ;H;FSNC=;F MIFONCIH @IL NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH I@
NB? JILN@IFCI L?NOLH CM ;P;CF;<F? 0B?L?@IL?
Q? B;P? NI NOLH NI ;FN?LH;NCP?
N?=BHCKO?M
MO=B ;M HOG?LC=;F CHN?AL;NCIH IL )IHN? ;LFI MCGOF;NCIH
"CLMN
HOG?LC=;F CHN?AL;NCIH QIOF> HIN <? JIMMC<F? CH GIMN ;JJFC=;NCIHM I@
CHN?L?MN CH 2;. =IGJON;NCIH 0B? L?;MIH CM NB;N
?P?H @IL GI>?L;N?M=;F? JILN
@IFCIM
NB? =IGJON;NCIH <OL>?H CM ?R=?MMCP? 0B? >C^=OFNS CM ;==?HNO;N?> <S
NB? @;=N NB;N NB? J;LN NI <? CHN?AL;N?> FC?M CH NB? FIQ?L N;CF I@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH
IHM?KO?HNFS
)IHN? ;LFI MCGOF;NCIH M??GM NI <? NB? IHFS JLIGCMCHA Q;S
I@ ?P;FO;NCHA NB? ;AAL?A;N? 2;. QB?H ;MM?N L?NOLHM ;L? GI>?F?> NBLIOAB ;
GOFNCP;LC;N? >CMNLC<ONCIH QBIM? CHP?LM? 013 CM HIN EHIQH ;H;FSNC=;FFS #CIN ;H>
(;OL?HN ;>IJN?> MO=B ; MCGOF;NCIH<;M?> ;JJLI;=B @IL NB? ?MNCG;NCIH
I@ NB? 2;. I@ ; JILN@IFCI QCNB ;MM?N L?NOLHM >CMNLC<ON?> ;M ; GOFNCP;LC;N?
ME?Q?> [ >CMNLC<ONCIH 0I CFFOMNL;N? BIQ NBCM ;JJLI;=B QILEM
Q? ;MMOG? NB;N
NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ NB? CHHIP;NCIH JLI=?MM CM 2 a)
QB?L? CM NB? P?=NIL I@
MB;J? J;L;G?N?LM 0B? A?H?L;F JLI=?>OL? CM NB? @IFFIQCHA @IL =IGJONCHA NB?
;AAL?A;N? 2;. <?NQ??H >;N?M [ ;H> [
N MCGOF;NCIH Q
MCGOF;N? ; M;GJF? I@ CHHIP;NCIHM a E aE ( ( aIE
/IG? GOFNCP;LC;N? #.$ GI>?FM ;L? Q?FF >?MCAH?> @IL F;LA?M=;F? JILN@I
FCIM /IG? I@ NB?G B;P? <??H >?M=LC<?> CH /?=NCIH 0B?S CH=FO>? ";=NIL
#.$ GI>?FM ;H> NB?CL A?H?L;FCT;NCIHM
MO=B ;M +LNBIAIH;F #.$ GI>
?FM ;H> NB? "F?RC<F? #.$ GI>?F 0B? @ILG?L ;JJLI;=B L?FC?M IH L?>O=CHA
NB? >CG?HMCIH;FCNS I@ NB? JLI<F?G <S M?F?=NCHA ; L?;MIH;<FS MG;FF HOG<?L
I@ @;=NILM NI QBC=B NB? GOFNCP;LC;N? #.$ GI>?F A?NM ;>DOMN?> 0B? F;N
N?L ;JJLI;=B >?=?HNL;FCT?M NB? ?MNCG;NCIH N;ME
<S ?MNCG;NCHA NB? >SH;GC=
=IP;LC;H=? G;NLCR OMCHA OHCP;LC;N? ;H> <CP;LC;N? #.$ GI>?FM IHFS
%N MBIOF> <? ?GJB;MCT?> NB;N NB?M? GI>?FM B;P? <??H >?MCAH?> CH ;
#;OMMC;H =IHN?RN "IL NB? "F?RC<F? #.$ GI>?F
CN CM HIN =F?;L BIQ CN G;S
<? ?RN?H>?> NI ; HIH#;OMMC;H >CMNLC<ONCIH (?>ICN
/;HN;F;L;
;H> 3IF@
MOAA?MN ; NLC=E NI =CL=OGP?HN NBCM >C^=OFNS +H=? NB? F;LA?>CG?HMCIH;F
=IP;LC;H=? G;NLCR N CM ?MNCG;N?> ;M >?M=LC<?> CH /?=NCIH
CN CM OM?> NI
?MNCG;N? NB? =IH>CNCIH;F >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ NB? JILN@IFCI L?NOLH 0B?S WLMN ?MNC
G;N? NB? P;LC;H=? I@ NB? JILN@IFCI L?NOLH ;M N
N 0B?H
NB?S ;>DOMN
JN
N
; MN;H>;L>CT?> /NO>?HN [ >CMNLC<ONCIH NI NB? MN;H>;L>CT?> CHHIP;NCIHM ?P;F
O;N?> ;M aN
N YN
*
JN
QB?L?
CM NB? M;GJF? G?;H I@ NB? P?=NIL I@
;MM?N L?NOLHM 0B?S ;L? NB?H ;<F? NI =IGJON? NB? KO;HNCF? I@ NB? JILN@IFCI
L?NOLH
89>5* />7,=287<
%N CM =F?;L @LIG NB? >CM=OMMCIH ;<IP? NB;N NB? G;CH FCGCN;NCIH I@ NB? OM? I@
NB? ;MM?NF?P?F ;JJLI;=B @IL =IGJONCHA 2;. CM NB? >C^=OFNS NI >?;F QCNB ;
GOFNCP;LC;N? HIH?FFCJNC=;F >CMNLC<ONCIH
CH J;LNC=OF;L @IL NB? ?MNCG;NCIH I@ NB?
=IGJF?N? GI>?F 0BCM ;JJLI;=B B;M L?=?HNFS <?H?WN?> @LIG NB? >?P?FIJG?HN I@
NB? =IJOF; ;JJLI;=B M?? /?=NCIH +H? >?WHCN? ;>P;HN;A? I@ NBCM ;JJLI;=B
=IGJ;LCMIH I@ GOFNCP;LC;N? #.$ GI>?FM >?MCAH?> @IL F;LA?M=;F? JILN@IFCIM
B;M <??H J?L@ILG?> <S (?>ICN
/;HN;F;L;
;H> 3IF@ 0B?S =IGJ;L? .CME
)?NLC=M
NB? >C;AIH;F !'' GI>?F
NB? GI>?F
;H> NB? "F?RC<F? #.$
GI>?FM CH N?LGM I@ NB?CL ;<CFCNS NI ?MNCG;N? NB? KO;HNCF? I@ MIG? ?GJCLC=;F JILN@I
FCIM =ILL?=NFS 0B?S >I HIN WH> MCAHCW=;HN >C_?L?H=?M <?NQ??H NB? P;LCIOM GI>?FM
.CME );H;A?G?HN ;H> 2;.
>?HIN?> [
QB?L? D >?HIN?M NB? ;MSGG?NLS J;L;G?N?L
0B? G;LACH I@ ?;=B OHCP;LC;N? >CMNLC<ONCIH CM ACP?H <S \DN [ aDN
'
0B?H
NB? =IJOF; NB;N FCHEM NB? P;LCIOM G;LACHM CM
4 aN ( ( aIN
/ 2 aN
( ( 2I aIN
'
MMOGCHA
@IL CHMN;H=?
; /NO>?HN [ =IJOF; QCNB >?AL??M I@ @L??>IG QIOF>
SC?F>
4 aN ( ( aIN
@2 [
aN
( ( [
% % aIN
(
. O* . O%*
%
I
`
> `
8
K`(
I )>)
87527.*; 68-.5<
+NB?L L?=?HN L?M?;L=B @I=OM?M IH ?MNCG;NCHA NB? 2;. I@ JILN@IFCIM =IHN;CHCHA
IJNCIHM IL INB?L JIMCNCIHM QCNB HIHFCH?;L JLC=? <?B;PCIL 2;. G?NBI>M ?G
JFISCHA ; FCH?;L ;JJLIRCG;NCIH NI NB? L?F;NCIH <?NQ??H CHMNLOG?HN P;FO?M ;H>
NB? OH>?LFSCHA LCME @;=NILM ;L? OHFCE?FS NI <? LI<OMN QB?H ;JJFC?> NI HIHFCH?;L
JILN@IFCIM LCNN?H&IH?M ;H> /=B;?@?L JLIJIM?> ; 2;. @L;G?QILE NB;N
CM <;M?> IH ; M?=IH> IL>?L [>?FN;A;GG;\ ;JJLIRCG;NCIH ;H> L?=IAHCT?M NB?
CGJ;=N NB;N NBCM QCFF B;P?
HIN IHFS IH P;LC;H=?
<ON IH NB? @ILG I@ NB? >CM
NLC<ONCIH
(?N OM HIQ >?M=LC<? NBCM ;JJLI;=B M M??H CH /?=NCIH
,I
NB? =B;HA? CH NB?
3? ;MMOG? NB;N NB? ;MM?NM >?J?H> IH ; M?N I@ 7 LCME @;=NILM "IL CHMN;H=?
CH
; MNLO=NOL?> JLI>O=N MO=B ;M ;H CHMOL?> JILN@IFCI
=IHN;CHCHA NB? OH>?LFSCHA
;MM?N ;H> ; JON IJNCIH
NB? LCME @;=NIL QIOF> <? NB? OH>?LFSCHA ;MM?N 0B?
WLMNIL>?L ;JJLIRCG;NCIH I@ NB? P;FO? I@ NB? JILN@IFCI CM ACP?H <S
I
, ,I +
,
,WD M( [
,WD M( [
CN
DN [
DN MFN
D
,[ D
,MF
F
+
,
,C
F MFN
MN (
,M
F
QB?L?
>?HIN?M NB? =B;HA? CH JILN@IFCI P;FO? >O? NI NCG?
;H> F CM NB? ;A
AL?A;N? ?_?=N IH NB? JILN@IFCI P;FO? I@ @;=NIL R 0B? F;MN ?KO;NCIH CHNLI>O=?M
HIN;NCIHM NI <? OM?> <?FIQ %H MIG? =;M?M
NBCM ;JJLI;=B G;S <? PC?Q?> ;M
; P;FC> ;JJLIRCG;NCIH @IL ?P;FO;NCHA NB? JILN@IFCI P;FO? $IQ?P?L
CH A?H
?L;F
;M ?R?GJFCW?> <S LCNN?H&IH?M ;H> /=B;?@?L
CN G;S SC?F> F;LA?
;JJLIRCG;NCIH ?LLILM
&1. G-.5=*0*66*H 6.=18-
,C
, C
CN MN MN
MN '
,M ,M ,M
(IJ?T
;H> !HAF? ;H> );HA;H?FFC
LCNN?H&IH?M ;H> /=B;?@?L JLIJIM? ;H ;FN?LH;NCP? ;JJLI;=B <;M?> IH NB?
;JJLIRCG;NCIH I@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ ; MOG I@ CH>?J?H>?HN HIH=?HNL;F P;LC
;<F?M
IGJ;LCMIH I@ 2;. GI>?FM
H;NOL;F Q;S NI ?P;FO;N? 2;. GI>?FM CM NB? K56AL A2@A >?P?FIJ?> <S BLCMNI@
@?LM?H ;FL?;>S >?M=LC<?> CH /?=NCIH 0B? N?MN CM >?MCAH?> NI ?P;F
O;N? C@ ; ACP?H GI>?F CM ;<F? NI JLIPC>? CHN?LP;F @IL?=;MN NB;N B;P? NB? M;G?
=IP?L;A? ;M CH NB? >;N; $?L?
NB? =?HNL;F I<D?=N CH NB? ;JJLI;=B CM NB? 4P[N
P;LC;<F?
>?WH?> CH NB? =;M? I@ 2;. ?P;FO;NCIH ;M
C@ YJN ) B H>
N (
4P[N
C@ YJN + B H>
N '
"IL NB? <;HE NB;N CGJF?G?HNM NB? 2;. GI>?F ;H> NB;N B;M NI M?N ;MC>?
=;JCN;F L?M?LP?M
N CM HIN ;JJLIJLC;N? <?=;OM? FCKOC> ;MM?NM >I HIN JLIPC>?
AII> L?NOLHM /I IH? =IMN @OH=NCIH NB;N QCFF N;E? CHNI ;==IOHN NB? IJJILNOHCNS
=IMN I@ GIH?S CM
)YJN B H>
N ) ( C@ YJN ) B H>
N (
/N
)YJN B H>
N ) P( C@ YJN B H>
N (
869*;2<87 8/ 6.=18-<
%H NBCM M?=NCIH
Q? JL?M?HN MIG? AOC>?FCH?M IH MIG? ?GJCLC=;F MNO>C?M NB;N
;JJ?;L?> CH NB? FCN?L;NOL?
2;H >?H #IIL<?LAB ;H> 2F;;L =IGJ;L? M?P?L;F ;JJLI;=B?M @IL =IG
JONCHA 2;.
CH=FO>CHA BCMNILC=;F MCGOF;NCIH
OH=IH>CNCIH;F !20
;H> P;LCIOM
#.$ GI>?FM QCNB HILG;F .CME)?NLC=M ;H> [ CHHIP;NCIHM 1MCHA >;N;
.CME );H;A?G?HN ;H> 2;.
!'' ;H> "F?RC<F? #.$ GI>?FM J?L@ILG <LI;>FS ?KO;FFS Q?FF CH N?LGM
I@ OH=IH>CNCIH;F =IP?L;A?
PIF;NCFCNS
;H> PC=? P?LM; @IL NB? =;M? QB?L? NB? CHCNC;F PIF;NCFCNS CM FIQ?L NB;H
NB? OH=IH>CNCIH;F IH? 0B? L;N? I@ =IHP?LA?H=? >?J?H>M IH NB? >?AL?? I@
PIF;NCFCNS J?LMCMN?H=? %H NB? =;M? QB?L? CHCNC;F PIF;NCFCNS + CM BCAB?L NB;H OH=IH
>CNCIH;F PIF;NCFCNS
NB? M=;FCHA @;=NIL QCFF <? F?MM NB;H
%H NB? =;M? QB?L?
CHCNC;F PIF;NCFCNS
+ CM FIQ?L NB;H OH=IH>CNCIH;F PIF;NCFCNS
NB? M=;FCHA @;=NIL QCFF <?
GIL? NB;H
%H JL;=NC=?
>O? NI PIF;NCFCNS ;MSGG?NLS ;H> INB?L JL?>C=NCP?
P;LC;<F?M NB;N GCABN <? CH=FO>?> CH NB? PIF;NCFCNS GI>?F
CN CM ;FQ;SM <?NN?L NI
=;F=OF;N? N (
N ( (
N M?J;L;N?FS 0B? >;S 2;. CM NB?H JLI>O=?>
,
OMCHA NB? >;S PIF;NCFCNS ?MNCG;N? =IGJON?> @LIG NB? MOG ND
D
/?=IH>
WH;H=C;F ;MM?N L?NOLHM ;L? HIN HILG;FFS >CMNLC<ON?> ;HC?FMMIH
;H> >? 2LC?M MBIQ NB;N NB? M=;FCHA J;L;G?N?L @IL KO;HNCF? >?LCP?>
OMCHA NB? !20 G?NBI> CH=L?;M?M ;N NB? ;JJLIRCG;N? L;N? I@ @
QBC=B CM
NSJC=;FFS F?MM NB;H NB? MKO;L?LIINI@NCG? ;>DOMNG?HN "IL ; NSJC=;F P;FO? I@
'
( Q? B;P? @
'
QBC=B CM F?MM NB;H
'
)=*?CF ;H>
"L?S IH NB? INB?L B;H> >CMJON? NBCM WH>CHA ;H> =F;CG NB? ?RJIH?HN NI
<? AL?;N?L NB;H ' 0B? M=;FCHA @;=NIL I@
JLI>O=?> @;L NII G;HS 2;.
PCIF;NCIHM CH NB? <;=EN?MN I@ WP? WH;H=C;F M?LC?M
?R=?JN @IL L?NOLHM IH AIF>
%H PC?Q I@ NB? =IHXC=NCHA ?GJCLC=;F WH>CHAM
IH? JIMMC<F? MIFONCIH CM NI <OCF>
GI>?FM OMCHA >;S L?NOLHM >;N; 0BCM ;A;CH BCABFCABNM NB? >C^=OFNS >O? NI
NB? CH=IHMCMN?H=S CH NB? LOF? ;JJFSCHA NI 2;. @IL =;F=OF;NCHA LCME =;JCN;F ;H>
NB? IH? ;JJFSCHA NI 2;. @IL <;=EN?MNCHA
55><=;*=287
CHA NI NB? PIF;NCFCNS ?PIFONCIH ;L? HIN MCAHCW=;HNFS ;_?=N?> <S NB? =B;HA? I@
=IH>CNCIH;F >CMNLC<ONCIH 3? ;FMI I<M?LP? NB;N NB? >?AL??I@@L??>IG J;L;G?
N?L CM NII MG;FF NI <? =IHMCMN?HN QCNB NB? HILG;FCNS ;MMOGJNCIH "CH;FFS
Q? JL?M?HN NB? NBL?? N?MNM >?P?FIJ?> <S BLCMNI_?LM?H M?? /?=NCIH
0B?S ;FFIQ C>?HNC@SCHA QB?L? NB? JIMMC<F? L?D?=NCIH I@ NB? GI>?F =IG?M
@LIG JP;FO?M ;L? CH J;L?HNB?M?M
N NB? =IHW>?H=? F?P?F
NQI G?NBI>M J?L@ILG P?LS Q?FF NB? #.$]
!20 G?NBI> ;H> NB? #.$ GI>?F QCNB ME?Q?> [ CHHIP;NCIHM %H <INB =;M?M
NB? ;=NO;F HOG<?L I@ ?R=??>;H=?M CM P?LS =FIM? NI NB? ?RJ?=N?> HOG<?L 0B?
OH=IH>CNCIH;F =IP?L;A? CM HIN L?D?=N?> @IL NB? NQI G?NBI>M
;H> NB? =IH>C
NCIH;F =IP?L;A? CM HIN L?D?=N?> @IL NB? #.$]!20 G?NBI> IHFS N NB?
=IHW>?H=? F?P?F
NB? IHFS G?NBI> ;<F? NI M;NCM@S NB? OH=IH>CNCIH;F =IP?L;A?
N?MN CM NB? #.$ GI>?F QCNB ME?Q?> [ CHHIP;NCIHM 0B? CH>?J?H>?H=? I@
4P[M CM L?D?=N?> @IL ;FF G?NBI>M
0I MOG OJ
CN ;JJ?;LM NB;N NB? =IH>CNCIH;F !20 G?NBI> J?L@ILGM P?LS
Q?FF @IL P?LS MG;FF =IHW>?H=? F?P?FM %H =IHNL;MN
@IL F;LA?L =IHW>?H=? F?P?FM
&*+5.
$.?.:2A2? 2@A6:.A2@ <3 &
:<129@
*ILG;F /NO>?HN I /E?Q?> I
>CMNLC<ONCIH >CMNLC<ONCIH >CMNLC<ONCIH
.?G?G<?L NB;N NB? /NO>?HN I >CMNLC<ONCIH =IHP?LA?M NI ; HILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH
QB?H
.CME)?NLC=M
#.$]!20
#.$I
#.$ME?Q?> I
=IH@ F?P?F !RJ
$CMN MCGOF;NCIH
.CME)?NLC=M
#.$]!20
#.$I
#.$ME?Q?> I
"8;=/8528 558,*=287
<S CN
N YN
CN
QB?L?
N
N ( (
IN
CM NB? P?=NIL I@ NB? @L;=
NCIHM I@ Q?;FNB ;FFI=;N?> NI NB? ;MM?NM
QCNB NB? =IHMNL;CHN NB;N NB? JILN@IFCI
Q?CABNM
;N NCG? [( MOG NI IH?
C?
N L
( QB?L? L CM ;H U(
P?=NIL I@
IH?M 0B?L?@IL?
NB? ALIMM L?NOLH IH NB? JILN@IFCI CM ACP?H <S
YJN
N
N YN '
3? ;MMOG? NB;N NB? CHP?MNIL B;M ; ONCFCNS @OH=NCIH A NB;N >?J?H>M IH
NB? F?P?F I@ @ONOL? Q?;FNB CN "ILG;FFS
NB? IJNCG;F JILN@IFCI Q?CABNM ;L?
I<N;CH?> <S G;RCGCTCHA NB? M=;F?> ?RJ?=N?> ONCFCNS
N +# ' / 1 A
N YN
MN
N L
'
0B? U WLMNIL>?L =IH>CNCIHM "+M I@ NB? IJNCGCT;NCIH JLI<F?G ;L?
,1 A CN
4 5
1 A CN
YN (
,
N
0I MCGJFC@S NB? ?RJIMCNCIH
Q? ;MMOG? NB;N NB?L? CM HI LCME@L?? ;MM?N ;H> HI
NL;HM;=NCIH =IMN
,ILN@IFCI ;FFI=;NCIH OH>?L HIHHILG;FCNS
QB?L? A E >?HIN?M NB? QNB >?LCP;NCP? I@ NB? ONCFCNS @OH=NCIH /CH=? JILN@IFCI
Q?CABNM ;L? =IHMNL;CH?> NI MOG NI IH?
NB? "+M I@ NB? CHP?MNILZM JLI<F?G
L?>O=? NI NB? U
=IHMNL;CHNM
YN YIN
' (
1 A CN
% & (
YIN YIN
IL
;FN?LH;NCP?FS
4 5
1 A CN
N (
QB?L? M YN
>?HIN?M NB? DICHN =13 I@ NB? P?=NIL I@ L?NOLHM ;N NCG? [
%H MIG? =;M?M
NBCM GOFNCJF? CHN?AL;NCIH JLI<F?G L?>O=?M NI NB? G?L? G?;H
P;LC;H=? JLI<F?G IHMC>?L @IL CHMN;H=? NB? =;M? QB?L? NB? ONCFCNS @OH=NCIH
CM =BIM?H NI <? NB? ?RJIH?HNC;F ONCFCNS ;H> QB?L? L?NOLHM ;L? ;MMOG?> NI <?
HILG;F 0B? ?RJIH?HNC;F ONCFCNS @OH=NCIH IL .
@IL IHMN;HN <MIFON?
.CME P?LMCIH CM >?WH?> <S
A CN
"/* CN
(
1 "/* CN
1 "/*
N YN
"/* JN JN
QB?L? JN
N N CM NB? ?RJ?=N?> ALIMM L?NOLH I@ NB? JILN@IFCI
;H>
JN
N N
N CM NB? P;LC;H=? I@ NB? JILN@IFCI L?NOLH 0BOM
G;RCGCTCHA
1 A CN
CM ?KOCP;F?HN NI G;RCGCTCHA NB? ?RJL?MMCIH JN JN
0I<CH ILCACH;FFS MOAA?MN?> NB;N ;HS >CMNLC<ONCIH >?WH?> <S NQI
J;L;G?N?LM QIOF> JLIPC>? ; JL?@?L?H=? IP?L G?;H ;H> P;LC;H=?
<ON =IOHN?L
?R;GJF?M B;P? <??H JLIPC>?> MO=B ;M NB? FIAHILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH 0BCM L?
MOFN B;M <??H A?H?L;FCT?> <S +Q?H ;H> .;<CHIPCN=B ;H> B;G<?LF;CH
QBI MBIQ?> NB;N QB?H L?NOLHM ;L? >L;QH @LIG ;H ?FFCJNC=;F >CMNLC<O
NCIH
NB? G?;HP;LC;H=? ;JJLIRCG;NCIH I@ NB? ?RJ?=N?> ONCFCNS CM ?R;=N @IL ;FF
ONCFCNS @OH=NCIHM +H NB? INB?L MC>?
MIG? ONCFCNS @OH=NCIHM CGJFS NB? G?;H
P;LC;H=? =LCN?LCIH @IL ;L<CNL;LS L?NOLH >CMNLC<ONCIHM 0BCM CM NB? =;M? I@ NB?
KO;>L;NC= ONCFCNS @OH=NCIH A C
H H C H C 0B? L?;MIH CM MCGJFS
NB;N NB? ?RJ?=N?> ONCFCNS @OH=NCIH 1 A C
IHFS CHPIFP?M NB? G?;H ;H> NB?
P;LC;H=? I@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH %N MBIOF> <? HINC=?> BIQ?P?L NB;N NB? KO;>L;NC=
ONCFCNS @OH=NCIH B;M MIG? OH;JJ?;FCHA JLIJ?LNC?M %H J;LNC=OF;L
CN CGJFC?M CH
=L?;MCHA ;<MIFON? LCME ;P?LMCIH ;H> M;NC;NCIH M?? (B;<CN;HN
$IQ?P?L
>6.;2,*5 27=.0;*=287
B;JN?L
)OFNC>CG?HMCIH;F KO;>L;NOL? CM GIL? >?G;H>CHA
<?=;OM? Q? B;P? NI ?P;F
O;N? NB? U>CG?HMCIH;F CHN?AL;F
. = -
, -
,
O \
M \
K\ ^D ^DI% O \D ( ( \ID% '
< D D%
H ?R=?JNCIH CM NB? =;M? QB?L? NB? =13 M =;H <? @;=NIL?> CHNI NB? JLI>O=N I@ U
IH?>CG?HMCIH;F =13
;@N?L ;H ;^H? NL;HM@ILG;NCIH I@ P;LC;<F?M GOFNCP;LC;N?
JLI>O=N LOF? =;H NB?H <? @ILG?> <S =IG<CHCHA ; M?N I@ IH?>CG?HMCIH;F #;OMM
,ILN@IFCI ;FFI=;NCIH OH>?L HIHHILG;FCNS
*-
LOF?M JLI>O=N LOF? B;M : E 6E JICHNM
QB?L? 6E CM NB? HOG<?L I@
JICHNM OM?> ;FIHA NB? QNB ;RCM "IL BCAB>CG?HMCIH;F JLI<F?GM
/NLIO>
;>PI=;N?M ; NIIFECN I@ HIHJLI>O=N LOF?M NB;N G;S <? ;JJFC?> NI ; QC>? =F;MM
I@ JLI<F?GM %H J;LNC=OF;L
NB? MJB?LC=;F (I<;NNI LOF? @IL CHN?AL;NCIH ;A;CHMN
NB? GOFNCP;LC;N? HILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH IHFS L?KOCL?M : -
JICHNM
QBCF?
CHN?AL;NCHA ?R;=NFS ;FF JIFSHIGC;FM I@ >?AL?? WP? IL F?MM
%H ; OHCP;LC;N? =IHN?RN
;F>OTTC ;H> (SH=B ;H> ;GJ<?FF ;H> 2C
=?CL; HIN? NB;N ;M @?Q ;M WP? KO;>L;NOL? JICHNM MO^=? M JON @ILQ;L>
<S HA ;H> ?E;?LN
OMCHA KO;>L;NOL? SC?F>M P?LS ;==OL;N? ;JJLIR
CG;NCIHM @IL 661 HILG;FFS >CMNLC<ON?> L?NOLHM 0B?S OM? ; );LEIPMQCN=BCHA
GI>?F
CH QBC=B L?NOLHM ;L? #;OMMC;H QCNBCH ?;=B L?ACG? "IL MIG? Q?FFEHIQH
DICHN >CMNLC<ONCIHM MO=B ;M NB? HILG;F IL /NO>?HN [ >CMNLC<ONCIHM
KO;>L;NOL?
JICHNM ;H> Q?CABNM ;L? >CL?=NFS ;P;CF;<F? M??
@IL CHMN;H=?
&O>>
%H
INB?L =;M?M
NB? CHN?AL;NCIH CM GO=B GIL? CHPIFP?> hN/;B;FC; ;H> L;H>N
7 *99;8A26*=. <85>=287 +*<.- 87 686.7=<
;
&IH>?;O ;H> .I=ECHA?L ; MNO>S
CH ;H OH=IH>CNCIH;F
@L;G?QILE
NB? =IMN I@ ;>IJNCHA ; G?;HP;LC;H=? =LCN?LCIH
QBCF? NB? L?NOLH
M?LC?M ;L? ;=NO;FFS HIHHILG;F &IH>?;O ;H> .I=ECHA?L ?RN?H> NBCM
;H;FSMCM NI ; =IH>CNCIH;F @L;G?QILE %H <INB =;M?M
NB? ;MM?N ;FFI=;NCIH OH>?L
HIHHILG;FCNS CM <;M?> IH ; 0;SFILZM ;JJLIRCG;NCIH I@ NB? ONCFCNS @OH=NCIH OJ
NI NB? @IOLNB IL>?L
A
C C
#(
A C C C C
QB?L? C 1 C ;H> # CM NB? 0;SFILZM L?G;CH>?L 0B?H NB? ?RJ?=N?> ONCFCNS
CM MCGJFS ;JJLIRCG;N?> <S
1 A C
A C A C
C
A
C Z C
A C
R C
(
QB?L? C
Z
C
;H> R C
MN;H> @IL 1 C C E @IL Q
( (
L?MJ?=NCP?FS
%H NB? =;M? I@ NB? . ONCFCNS @OH=NCIH
NB? ;JJLIRCG;NCIH @IL NB?
?RJ?=N?> ONCFCNS CM ACP?H <S
1 A C
"/* C
C Z C R C (
IL
CH N?LGM I@ GIG?HNM I@ NB? JILN@IFCI L?NOLH
"IL MIG? L?NOLH >CMNLC<ONCIHM MO=B ;M NB? #;OMMC;H IH? IL @IL MIG? ONCFCNS
@OH=NCIHM MO=B ;M JIFSHIGC;F ONCFCNS
NB? 0;SFIL M?LC?M ?RJ;HMCIH CM ?R;=N
C?
ME?QH?MM
;H> EOLNIMCM I@ NB? JILN@IFCI L?NOLH ;H> NB? >?LCP;NCP?M NB?L?I@ Q?L?
EHIQH 3? QCFF MBIQ NB;N NB?M? ?RJL?MMCIHM =;H <? =IGJON?> L?F;NCP?FS ?;MCFS
3? G;S ;FMI =IHMC>?L NB? JIQ?L ONCFCNS @OH=NCIH IL ..
@IL IHMN;HN
.?F;NCP? .CME P?LMCIH
>?WH?> ;M
7
A C
( C@ +
(
&)# C
( C@
(
QB?L? G?;MOL?M NB? CHP?MNILZM =IHMN;HN L?F;NCP? LCME ;P?LMCIH IHNL;LS NI
NB? . ONCFCNS
NB? .. >I?M HIN =IHP?LA? NIQ;L>M ;H ;MSGJNIN? @IL
CH=L?;MCHA Q?;FNB IHM?KO?HNFS
G;LACH;F ONCFCNS I@ Q?;FNB CM JIMCNCP? ?P?H
@IL F;LA? F?P?FM I@ Q?;FNB
%H NB? =;M? I@ NB? .. ONCFCNS @OH=NCIH
OMCHA ?RJL?MMCIH
Q? I<N;CH
NB? @IFFIQCHA ;JJLIRCG;NCIH @IL NB? ?RJ?=N?> ONCFCNS
C
1 A C
C C
C Z C
C R C
(
IL
CH N?LGM I@ NB? JILN@IFCI L?NOLH
J
1 A C
J ZJ RJ '
J
J J
0B? "+M @IL NB? .. @OH=NCIH =;H <? L?QLCNN?H
;@N?L MCGJFCW=;NCIH
! & !M&
!F&
&
!
! !
&
&
YA
'
J ZJ
RJ
&
&
&
0B? CHWHCN? 0;SFIL M?LC?M ?RJ;HMCIH =IHP?LA?M NI NB? ?RJ?=N?> ONCFCNS @OH=NCIH @IL
F?P?FM I@ Q?;FNB L;HACHA <?NQ??H ;H> 5 (ICMNF
,ILN@IFCI FFI=;NCIH
A C
+ ( C(
A C
) ( C'
0B? WLMN =IH>CNCIH G?;HM NB;N ;A?HNM B;P? ; JIMCNCP? G;LACH;F ONCFCNS @IL
Q?;FNB
C?
HIHM;NC?NS QCNB L?MJ?=N NI Q?;FNB 0B? M?=IH> =IH>CNCIH CM NB;N
G;LACH;F ONCFCNS >?=L?;M?M QCNB Q?;FNB
CGJFSCHA LCME ;P?LMCIH
0I CHP?MNCA;N? JL?@?L?H=?M QCNB L?MJ?=N NI BCAB?L GIG?HNM
NB? @IFFIQCHA
>?WHCNCIH CM OM?@OF
&1.8;.6
%,8== *7- 8;?*=1 ;C2@A<?@ D6A5 =<@6A6C2 :.?
46;.9 BA696AF <3 D2.9A5 3<? .99 D2.9A5 92C29@ 0<;16A6<; 0<;@6@A2;A ?6@8
.C2?@6<; .A .99 D2.9A5 92C29@ 0<;16A6<;
.;1 @A?60A 0<;@6@A2;0F <3 :<
:2;A =?232?2;02 D699 5.C2 =<@6A6C2 =?232?2;02 3<? =<@6A6C2 @82D;2@@ 6 2
A
C
+ ( C'
"IL CHMN;H=?
$F;QCNM=BE; JLIPC>?M ?R;GJF?M CH QBC=B
?P?H C@ NB? CHWHCN?
?RJ;HMCIH =IHP?LA?M
;>>CHA GIL? N?LGM G;S QILM?H NB? ;JJLIRCG;NCIH ;N ;
ACP?H NLOH=;NCIH F?P?F %H =IHNL;MN
(B;<CN;HN >?M=LC<?M ;H ?R;GJF? CH
QBC=B IGCNN?> N?LGM ;L? I@ CGJILN;H=?
,ILN@IFCI ;FFI=;NCIH OH>?L HIHHILG;FCNS
0B?M? L?MOFNM ;L? =IHMCMN?HN QCNB NB? =IH=FOMCIHM ;LLCP?> ;N <S L>CNNC
;H> 'L;OM ;H> (CNT?H<?LA?L
)IL? A?H?L;FFS
;MMOGJNCIHM I@ JIMCNCP? G;LACH;F ONCFCNS
=IHMCMN?HN LCME
;P?LMCIH NIA?NB?L QCNB MNLC=N =IHMCMN?H=S I@ GIG?HN JL?@?L?H=? CGJFS
A I C
+ ( C C@ U CM I>> ;H>
A I C
) ( C C@ U CM ?P?H
M CH>C=;N?> ;<IP?
CH IL>?L NI CGJF?G?HN NB? "+ IL
CN CM H?=?MM;LS
NI =IGJON? NB? ?RJL?MMCIH I@ J ( J ( ;H> MI @ILNB %H NBCM M?=NCIH
Q? OM?
L?MOFNM JON @ILQ;L> <S NB;S>? ;H> "FiL?M QBI >?WH? GIG?HNM ;M
N?HMILM
0B? WLMN MN?J CM NI =IGJON? L?NOLH =IGIG?HNM %H B;JN?L
Q? ;FL?;>S
>?M=LC<?> MIG? ?F?G?HNM I@ NB? =IME?QH?MM ;H> =IEOLNIMCM G;NLC=?M @IL MIG?
>CMNLC<ONCIH @OH=NCIHM 3? >I HIN =IHMC>?L B?L? ;HS J;LNC=OF;L >CMNLC<ONCIH
@OH=NCIH .;NB?L
Q? ;MMOG? NB;N Q? B;P? =IGJON?> ;FF GIG?HNM ;H> =I
GIG?HNM OM?@OF NI NB? ;MM?N;FFI=;NCIH JLI<F?G
,ILN@IFCI FFI=;NCIH
<ON IHFS U U
* ?F?G?HNM B;P? NI <? =IGJON?> /CGCF;LFS
NB? =IME?QH?MM
G;NLCR B;M >CG?HMCIH U( U( U
<ON IHFS U U
U
* ?F?G?HNM B;P? NI
<? =IGJON?> "CH;FFS
NB? =IEOLNIMCM G;NLCR B;M >CG?HMCIH U( U( U( U
<ON
IHFS U U
U
U
* ?F?G?HNM B;P? NI <? =IGJON?> 3? >?WH?
=IME?QH?MM ;H> =IEOLNIMCM <?NQ??H ;MM?N L?NOLHM ;M
ZDEF 1 YD D
YE E YF F
(
;H>
RDEFG 1 YD D
YE E YF F
YG G
'
3? HIQ QCMB NI ;>IJN NB? @IFFIQCHA HIN;NCIHM @IL =IME?QH?MM ;H> =I
EOLNIMCM G;NLC=?M M MOAA?MN?> <S NB;S>? ;H>
"FiL?M
Q? NL;HM@ILG
NB? =IME?QH?MM U( U( U
G;NLCR CHNI ; U( U G;NLCR
MCGJFS <S MFC=CHA ?;=B
U( U
F;S?L ;H> J;MNCHA NB?G
CH NB? M;G? IL>?L
MC>?Q;SM "IL CHMN;H=?
CH
NB? =;M? I@ U ;MM?NM
NB? L?MOFNCHA (
=IME?QH?MM G;NLCR CM
Z Z Z
Z Z Z
Z
Z
Z
9
Z Z Z
Z Z Z
Z
Z
Z
Z
Z
Z
Z
Z
Z
Z
ZEF Z EF Z
EF EF
(
NB? (
=IEOLNIMCM G;NLCR CM
9 RFG R FG R
FG R
FG R
FG R
FG FG
'
3? ;L? HIQ ;<F? NI >?WH? JILN@IFCI GIG?HNM CH ; P?LS NL;=N;<F? Q;S "IL
; ACP?H JILN@IFCI Q?CABN P?=NIL
OH=IH>CNCIH;F ?RJ?=N?> L?NOLH
P;LC;H=?
ME?QH?MM
;H> EOLNIMCM I@ NB? JILN@IFCI ;L?
L?MJ?=NCP?FS
J
(
J
9
(
Z
J
9
(
RJ
9
(
, J
9
(
,
,Z
J
9
(
,
,RJ
9
'
,
YA
9
9
9
(
QB?L?
( ;H>
;L? HIHFCH?;L @OH=NCIHM I@
0B?M? U ?KO;NCIHM =;H
<? ?;MCFS MIFP?> HOG?LC=;FFS
OMCHA ; MN;H>;L> IJNCGCT;NCIH J;=E;A? /O=B ;
MJ?=CW=;NCIH B;M <??H ?RJFIL?> <S &IH>?;O ;H> .I=ECHA?L ;
0B?
>C^=OFNS CH MIFPCHA NBCM JLI<F?G CM HIN I@ NB? M;G? IL>?L ;M =IGJ;L?> QCNB
JLI<F?GM CHPIFPCHA HOG?LC=;F CHN?AL;NCIH ;M CH hN/;B;FC; ;H> L;H>N
IL HA ;H> ?E;?LN $?L?
; P?LS ;==OL;N? MIFONCIH CM I<N;CH?> CH ;
P?LS @?Q M?=IH>M
?P?H CH NB? =;M? I@ ; F;LA? HOG<?L I@ ;MM?NM
%N CM ;FMI QILNB HINCHA NB;N Q? B;P? >?M=LC<?> BIQ NI MIFP? NB? ;MM?N
;FFI=;NCIH JLI<F?G QB?H NB? @IOL WLMN GIG?HNM ;L? NI <? CH=ILJIL;N?> N
NB? M;G? NCG?
Q? G;S =IHMC>?L ;M MJ?=C;F =;M?M NB? MCNO;NCIHM QB?L? IHFS G?;H
;H> P;LC;H=? IL G?;H
P;LC;H=?
;H> ME?QH?MM ;L? ;MMOG?> NI <? CGJILN;HN
"8;=/8528 *558,*=287 >7-.; -8@7<2-. ;2<4
0I ;FFI=;N? Q?;FNB OH>?L HIHHILG;F L?NOLHM
;HINB?L J;NB =;H <? N;E?H %H
MN?;> I@ @I=OMCHA IH NB? QBIF? >CMNLC<ONCIH
QBC=B L?KOCL?M ?MNCG;NCHA ; F;LA?
HOG<?L I@ GIG?HNM
Q? =;H @I=OM IH NB? J;LN NB;N Q? ;L? CHN?L?MN?> CH %H
;MM?N ;FFI=;NCIH
Q? ;L? =IH=?LH?> QCNB NB? JIMMC<CFCNS I@ ; F;LA? >?=L?;M? CH
,ILN@IFCI FFI=;NCIH
;MM?N JLC=?M /O=B =IH=?LH A;P? LCM? NI NB? HINCIH I@ 1<D;@612 ?6@8 /?P?L;F
?R;GJF?M I@ >IQHMC>? LCME =;H <? JL?M?HN?>
MO=B ;M >IQHMC>? P;LC;H=? IL !/
0B?H @IL ;H CHP?MNIL QBI CM =IH=?LH?> ;<ION >IQHMC>? LCME
NB? IJNCGCT;
NCIH =;H HI FIHA?L <? <;M?> IH NB? OMO;F G?;HP;LC;H=? =LCN?LCIH 3? NBOM
B;P? NI >?MCAH ; JILN@IFCI ;FFI=;NCIH GI>?F NB;N =IG?M OJ QCNB OHC>CL?=NCIH;F
F?@NQ;L> =IH=?LH
!MM?HNC;FFS
NQI NSJ?M I@ MIFONCIH B;P? <??H ;>PI=;N?> 0B? WLMN IH? MNCFF
=IHMC>?LM NB? G?;HP;LC;H=? =LCN?LCIH <ON ;MMOG?M ;H ;>>CNCIH;F =IHMNL;CHN
MOJJIM?> NI ;==IOHN @IL >IQHMC>? LCME
QB?L?;M NB? M?=IH> ;JJLI;=B L?FC?M IH
; >CL?=N GCHCGCT;NCIH I@ NB? F;NN?L
.D72=287
.
>
1 ' / YJ (
Y
K2L _
( (
QB?L? 2L _
CM NB? 013 I@ NB? JILN@IFCI L?NOLH YJ %HN?L?MNCHAFS
NBCM =F;MM I@
GIG?HNM =IP?LM MIG? Q?FFEHIQH LCME G?;MOL?M 3B?H
Q? I<M?LP? NB;N
.
>
K2L _
( MI NB;N
C@ Q? >?HIN? <S X
NB? 2;. @IL JLI<;<CFCNS
X( Q? B;P? NB;N > X
X %H NBCM =;M?
L?JL?M?HNM NB? XNB J?L=?HNCF?
%@
>
=;H <? CHN?LJL?N?> ;M NB? ?RJ?=N?> MBILN@;FF
MCH=? 1?
1 YJ )Y4J
' FMI
QB?H
5
Q? I<N;CH NB? MI=;FF?> >IQHMC>? P;LC;H=?
0B
1 YJ
)YJ
*IQ
NQI NSJ?M I@ IJNCGCT;NCIH JLIAL;GM ;L? ;<F? NI N;E? >IQHMC>? LCME
CHNI ;==IOHN
8@7<2-. ;2<4 *< *7 *--2=287*5 ,87<=;*27=
<ON QCNB ;H ;>>CNCIH;F =IHMNL;CHN MO=B NB;N NB? >IQHMC>? LCME I@ NB? JILN@IFCI
MBIOF> HIN ?R=??> ; ACP?H F?P?F "IL CHMN;H=?
F?R;H>?L ;H> ;JNCMN;
@I=OM IH NB? @IFFIQCHA IJNCGCT;NCIH JLIAL;G
' / YJ J (
MN 1?
8(
,ILN@IFCI ;FFI=;NCIH OH>?L >IQHMC>? LCME
QB?L? >?HIN?M NB? LCME ;P?LMCIH J;L;G?N?L ;H> 8 ; <IOH> IH NB? !/ 0B?S
;>IJN ; J;L;G?NLC= ;JJLI;=B NI MIFP? NBCM JLIAL;G
;MMOGCHA ; MJ?=CW= >CMNLC
<ONCIH @IL ;MM?N L?NOLHM %H J;LNC=OF;L
NB?S MBIQ NB;N @IL ; GOFNCP;LC;N? HIL
G;F IL
/NO>?HN
[ >CMNLC<ONCIH
NB? ?KO;FCNS 1?
8 CM ACP?H <S ; FCH? CH NB?
JF;H? J ( J ' IHM?KO?HNFS
NB? ?^=C?HN @LIHNC?L CM FCE?FS NI <? L?MNLC=N?> <S
NBCM ;>>CNCIH;F =IHMNL;CHN
>?J?H>CHA IH NB? JLI<;<CFCNS IL =IHW>?H=? F?P?F
;H> NB? <IOH> 8 %H @;=N
NB? ?_?=N I@ MO=B ; =IHMNL;CHN CM ;G<CAOIOM ;M
=IGJ;L?> QCNB NB? <;M?FCH? OH=IHMNL;CH?> G?;HP;LC;H=? =LCN?LCIH
<?=;OM?
NB? MN;H>;L> >?PC;NCIH I@ NB? JILN@IFCI G;S ;=NO;FFS CH=L?;M? OH>?L MIG? !/
=IHMNL;CHNM 0BCM G;S <? NB? =;M? CH J;LNC=OF;L QB?H NB? CHP?MNIL CM BCABFS
LCME;P?LM? ;H> NB? M?F?=N?> <IOH> 8 CM NII MG;FF
8@7<2-. ;2<4 *< *7 89=262C*=287 ,;2=.;287
' / YJ >
'
6.<2
1?
N 1 CN ^N
)CN ^N
B H>
_M0 _
K_
6.<2
B H>
_ B H>
M0 _
K_(
0B? <LC?@ >?M=LCJNCIH I@ NB?CL ;JJLI;=B Q? JL?M?HN B?L? CM MFCABNFS >C_?L?HN @LIG
NB?CLM %H J;LNC=OF;L
NB?S ;FFIQ M?P?L;F ;>>CNCIH;F =IHMNL;CHNM CH NB?CL IJNCGCT;NCIH
JLIAL;G NB;N Q? >CML?A;L> NI MCGJFC@S NB? ?RJIMCNCIH
,ILN@IFCI FFI=;NCIH
,*
2
N B H>
1? E _E B H>
(
6 E
*
QB?L? E
Q
( ( 6
CM NB? JLI<;<CFCNS I@ M=?H;LCI Q ;H> '_E (E CM ; M?N
I@ MCGOF;N?> JLC=?M >L;QH @LIG NB? ?GJCLC=;F >CMNLC<ONCIH 0B?H
NB?S >?WH?
NB? IJNCGCT;NCIH JLI<F?G ;M
I
,
' /
D 1N WDN (
'6 <2 ( D
* I
, ,
MN B H>
E _E B H>
D WDN (
6 E D
I
, I
,
D WDN
D WDN NL;HM;=NCIH =IMNM
D D
1?
N 8
N
N
(
QB?L? X0
[
CM NB? KO;HNCF? @IL ; JLI<;<CFCNS I@ FIMM ?KO;F NI @LIG
NB? MN;H>;L>CT?> [ >CMNLC<ONCIH
;H> N
;H> N
;L? NB? ?RJ?=N?> L?NOLH
;H> PIF;NCFCNS @IL >;N? [
0B?H
NB? IJNCG;F JILN@IFCI OH>?L !/ I<D?=NCP?
CM I<N;CH?> <S MIFPCHA NB? @IFFIQCHA G;RCGCT;NCIH JLI<F?G
I
,
' /
D 1N YDN (
D
MN 1?
N
8
*INC=? NB;N NBCM ;JJLI;=B L?KOCL?M L?=IGJONCHA ;N ?;=B MN?J Q I@ NB? IJNC
GCT;NCIH ;FAILCNBG NB? JILN@IFCI L?NOLH ;M ; @OH=NCIH I@ NB? H?Q Q?CABN P?=NIL
E
N 0BCM =;H <? >IH? OMCHA NB? ;JJLI;=B >?P?FIJ?> CH /?=NCIH
"*;= (
%H NBCM J;LN
Q? CFFOMNL;N? NB? N?=BHCKO?M @IL JLC=CHA IJNCIHM ;H> ?RNL;=NCHA CH
@ILG;NCIH @LIG NL;>?> IJNCIH JLC=?M 3? ;FMI >?M=LC<? P;LCIOM Q;SM CH QBC=B
NBCM CH@ILG;NCIH B;M <??H OM?> CH ; HOG<?L I@ ;JJFC=;NCIHM 3B?H >?;FCHA
QCNB IJNCIHM
Q? CH?PCN;<FS ?H=IOHN?L NB? F;=E/=BIF?M)?LNIH IJNCIH JLC=
CHA @ILGOF;
QBC=B B;M L?PIFONCIHCT?> NB? Q;S CH QBC=B IJNCIHM ;L? JLC=?>
CH GI>?LH NCG? %H B;JN?L
Q? >?M=LC<? CH >?N;CF NB? M?GCH;F QILE I@
F;=E ;H> /=BIF?M ;H> )?LNIH /)
NB?L?;@N?L IH JLC=CHA
!OLIJ?;H MNSF? IJNCIHM /) ;MMOG?M NB;N MNI=E JLC=? @IFFIQM ; A?IG?NLC=
LIQHC;H GINCIH
QBC=B CGJFC?M NB;N NB? N?LGCH;F MNI=E JLC=? B;M ; FIAHIL
G;F >CMNLC<ONCIH 0BLIOAB B?>ACHA ;LAOG?HNM
/) MBIQM NB;N NB? N?LGCH;F
MNI=E JLC=? >CMNLC<ONCIH H??>?> @IL JLC=CHA IJNCIH =;H <? MN;N?> QCNBION L?@?L
?H=? NI NB? JL?@?L?H=? J;L;G?N?L ;H> NI NB? ALIQNB L;N? I@ NB? MNI=E 0BCM CM
HIQ EHIQH ;M NB? LCMEH?ONL;F ;JJLI;=B NI IJNCIH JLC=CHA 0B? N?LGCH;F MNI=E
JLC=? >CMNLC<ONCIH
@IL NB? JOLJIM? I@ JLC=CHA IJNCIHM
CM HIQ EHIQH ;M NB?
MN;N?JLC=? >?HMCNS IL NB? LCMEH?ONL;F >?HMCNS CH =IHNL;MN NI NB? ;=NO;F MNI=E
JLC=? >CMNLC<ONCIH
QBC=B CM MIG?NCG?M L?@?LL?> NI ;M NB? JBSMC=;F
I<D?=NCP?
IL BCMNILC=;F >CMNLC<ONCIH
%H NB? /) GI>?F
NB? I<D?=NCP? ;H> NB? LCMEH?ONL;F >?HMCNC?M ;L? <INB
FIAHILG;F 0B? LCMEH?ONL;F >?HMCNS CHPIFP?M IHFS IH? J;L;G?N?L NB;N L?KOCL?M
?MNCG;NCIH
H;G?FS NB? MI=;FF?> CGJFC?> PIF;NCFCNS ' %H B;JN?L
Q? >?
M=LC<? BIQ G;S <? ?RNL;=N?> @LIG IJNCIH JLC=? >;N; 0B?L? ?RCMNM BOA?
?GJCLC=;F ?PC>?H=? IH PIF;NCFCNS MGCF? ;H> MOL@;=? NB;N MOAA?MNM NB;N CM H?C
NB?L =IHMN;HN ;=LIMM ?R?L=CM? JLC=?M HIL ;=LIMM IJNCIH G;NOLCNC?M 0BCM ?PC>?H=?
CGJFC?M NB;N NB? MB;J? I@ NB? /) ;MMOGJNCIH I@ ; FIAHILG;F MNI=E JLC=? >CM
NLC<ONCIH >I?M HIN BIF> CH JL;=NC=? 0B? /) ;HIG;FS B;M F?> NI PIFOGCHIOM
L?M?;L=B 0BCM ECH> I@ QILE NSJC=;FFS <SJ;MM?M NB? I<D?=NCP? >CMNLC<ONCIH ;H>
JLC=CHA
B?>ACHA G?=B;HCMG ;H> =IOF> <? >?M=LC<?> ;M ;H ?GJCLC=;F >;N; GCH
CHA JLI=?MM @IL WH>CHA NB? LCMEH?ONL;F >CMNLC<ONCIH NB;N <?MN WNM NB? IJNCIH
JLC=?M 0BCM NSJ? I@ [HIHMNLO=NOL;F\ QILE CM >?M=LC<?> CH NBCM =B;JN?L ;M Q?FF
3? JLIPC>? CFFOMNL;NCIHM NB;N MIG? I@ NB? HIHMNLO=NOL;F ;JJLI;=B?M G;S QILE
L;NB?L Q?FF CH =;JNOLCHA NB? ;=NO;F LCMEH?ONL;F >?HMCNS
"OH>;G?HN;FM I@ +JNCIH ,LC=CHA
%H B;JN?L
Q? NOLH NI GIL? MNLO=NOL;F ;JJLI;=B?M I@ IJNCIH JLC=CHA
=F?;L FCGCN;NCIH I@ NB? /) GI>?F CM NB? ;MMOGJNCIH NB;N PIF;NCFCNS CM =IHMN;HN
;=LIMM ?R?L=CM? JLC=?M ;H> G;NOLCNC?M !RN?HMCIH NI ; NCG?P;LSCHA PIF;NCFCNS CM
NB? H?RN MN?J IH NB? L?M?;L=B ;A?H>; )I>?FM QCNB MNI=B;MNC= PIF;NCFCNS B;P?
<??H JLIJIM?> <S $OFF ;H> 3BCN?
;H> $?MNIH 0B?H
GI>?FM QCNB DOGJM B;P? <??H >?P?FIJ?> <S )?LNIH ;H> ;FF ;H> 0ILIOM
"OLNB?L A?H?L;FCT;NCIH B;M <??H JLIJIM?> QCNB NB? >?P?FIJG?HN I@ NB?
MI=;FF?> (fPS JLI=?MM?M /O=B ; JLI=?MM ;FFIQM @IL ;H CHWHCN? ;GIOHN I@ DOGJM
I@ P?LS MG;FF MCT? IP?L WHCN? NCG? CHN?LP;FM ;H>
NBOM
L?JL?M?HNM ;H CHN?L?MNCHA
;FN?LH;NCP? NI NB? OMO;F JLI=?MM?M
8=*=287<
0BCM =B;JN?L AI?M NBLIOAB NB? >?N;CF?> JLII@M I@ NB? IJNCIH JLC=CHA GI>?F
>?P?FIJ?> <S F;=E ;H> /=BIF?M ;H> )?LNIH 0B? /) GI>?F
B;M ;FL?;>S <??H >?M=LC<?> CH G;HS N?RN<IIEM 0B? L?;MIH @IL AICHA IP?L CN
B?L? CM NQI @IF> "CLMN
Q? Q;HN NI JL?M?HN NB? GI>?F NI ;FFIQ @IL ; XOC> ;H>
CH
N?LGM I@ HIN;NCIH
=IB?L?HN JL?M?HN;NCIH I@ NB? MO<D?=N FMI
G;HS N?RN<IIEM
>?LCP? NB? MI=;FF?> @OH>;G?HN;F J;LNC;F >C_?L?HNC;F ?KO;NCIHM <ON >I HIN MIFP?
NBCM ?KO;NCIH 0BCM ?KO;NCIH G;S
BIQ?P?L
<? MIFP?> QCNBION ?R;AA?L;N?>
?_ILN <S MNO>?HNM ;H> L?M?;L=B?LM QBI ;L? HIN G;NB?G;NC=C;HM /O=B ; L?;>?L
MBIOF> A?N @;GCFC;L QCNB NB? =IHN?HN I@ B;JN?L <?@IL? L?;>CHA NBCM IH?
0B? M?=IH> JOLJIM? I@ NBCM =B;JN?L CM NI OM? NB? /) GI>?F
; Q?FFEHIQH
?R;GJF?
CH IL>?L NI CHNLI>O=? MIG? CGJILN;HN G;NB?G;NC=;F =IH=?JNM =LO=C;F
@IL F;N?L OH>?LMN;H>CHA GIL? ;>P;H=?> NIJC=M
MO=B ;M MNI=B;MNC= PIF;NCFCNS
;H> (fPS IJNCIH JLC=CHA GI>?FM INB GI>?FM ;L? CGJILN;HN >?P?FIJG?HNM CH
;>>L?MMCHA NB? HIH#;OMMC;H @?;NOL? I@ NB? OH>?LFSCHA ;MM?N >CMNLC<ONCIH
0B?L? ;L? M?P?L;F Q;SM I@ JLIPCHA NB? /) GI>?F $?L?
Q? @I=OM IH
NB? HI;L<CNL;A? ;JJLI;=B ;H> NB? G;LNCHA;F? G?;MOL? ;JJLI;=B
;M NB?S ;L?
OM?@OF CH OH>?LMN;H>CHA NB? GIL? ;>P;H=?> IJNCIH JLC=CHA GI>?FM +NB?L ;J
JLI;=B?M MO=B ;M NB? <CHIGC;F ;H> NB? JLC=CHA E?LH?F ;JJLI;=B ;L? J?>;AIAC=;F
;H> OM?@OF @IL OH>?LMN;H>CHA NB? @OH>;G?HN;FM I@ IJNCIH JLC=CHA M NB?S ;L?
HIN >CL?=NFS L?F;N?> NI NB? F;N?L =B;JN?LM
Q? QIOF> L?@?L NB? L?;>?LM NI INB?L
N?RN<IIEM IH IJNCIH JLC=CHA @IL NB?M? G?NBI>M
+JNCIHM ;L? WH;H=C;F =IHNL;=NM NB;N >?J?H> IH =?LN;CH ?P?HNM +JNCIHM
CHPIFP? ; <OS?L ;H> ; M?FF?L
C?
NQI 0<B;A2?=.?A@ NL;>?L QBI <OSM ;H
IJNCIH CM M;C> NI B;P? ; 9<;4 =<@6A6<; MSGG?NLC=;FFS
C@ B? M?FFM ;H IJNCIH B? CM
M;C> NI B;P? ; @5<?A =<@6A6<; +JNCIHM ;L? >C_?L?HN <?=;OM? I@ NB? LCABNM NB;N
NB?S =IH@?L NI NB?CL IQH?L (?N OM MN;LN QCNB MIG? A?H?L;F >?WHCNCIHM
NB?H
Q? QCFF =IGG?HN IH NB?M? >?WHCNCIHM
.D72=287 (52 =B?05.@2 <3 . B?<=2.; 0.99 <=A6<; 46C2@ 6A@ <D;2? A52
?645A A< =B?05.@2 .A . 46C2; 1.A2 /BA ;<A /23<?2 . 46C2; .@@2A 3<? . =?2
12A2?:6;21 =?602 (52 =B?05.@2 <3 . B?<=2.; =BA <=A6<; 46C2@ 6A@ <D;2? A52
*IN;NCIHM
?645A A< @299 .A . 46C2; 1.A2 /BA ;<A /23<?2 . 46C2; .@@2A 3<? . =?212A2?:6;21
=?602 (52 1.A2 D52; A52 <=A6<; 0.; /2 2E2?06@21 6@ 0.9921 2E2?06@2 1.A. (52
=?212A2?:6;21 =?602 6@ 0.9921 2E2?06@2 =?602
2;LCIOM QIL>M CH NBCM >?WHCNCIH ;L? QILNB ?GJB;MCTCHA "IL CHMN;H=?
NB?
IQH?L I@ NB? IJNCIH B;M ;FF NB? CHCNC;NCP?M /B? QCFF I<PCIOMFS ?R?L=CM? NB?
IJNCIH C@ CN CM CH B?L CHN?L?MN /SGG?NLC=;FFS
NB? M?FF?L I@ NB? IJNCIH >I?M HIN
B;P? NB? JIMMC<CFCNS I@ L?@OMCHA NB? ?R?L=CM? I@ ;H IJNCIH B?<=2.; <=A6<;
;M
MN;N?> CH NB? >?WHCNCIH
;FFIQM IHFS ?R?L=CM? I@ NB? IJNCIH ;N ; ACP?H GIG?HN CH
NCG? 0B? MI=;FF?> :2?60.; <=A6<; ;FFIQM ?R?L=CM? ;N ;HS NCG? <?NQ??H NB?
JOL=B;M? I@ NB? IJNCIH ;H> ; ACP?H >;N? 0BCM >;N? QCFF <? =;FF?> 2E=6?.A6<;
1.A2 +JNCIHM MO=B ;M 2?:B16.; <=A6<;@ ;H> :61A9.;A60 <=A6<;@ =;H <?
?R?L=CM?> ;N M?P?L;F GIG?HNM <?NQ??H JOL=B;M? I@ NB? IJNCIH ;H> ; ACP?H
?RJCL;NCIH >;N? 0B? ;MM?N NB;N G;S <? JOL=B;M?> IL MIF> ;N ?R?L=CM? CM =;FF?>
B;12?9F6;4 .@@2A "IL NB? IJNCIH P;FO;NCIH GI>?FM =IHMC>?L?> CH NBCM <IIE
CN
CM ;MMOG?> NB;N NB? OH>?LFSCHA ;MM?N G;S ;FQ;SM A?N NL;>?>
C?
JOL=B;M?>
IL MBILN MIF>
QCNBION NL;HM;=NCIH =IMNM
CH ; G;LE?N =;FF?> NB? @=<A :.?82A
>>CNCIH;F N?LGM ;L? MIG?NCG?M OM?> "IL CHMN;H=?
NB? ?R?L=CM? JLC=? CM ;FMI
=;FF?> @A?682 =?602 0B? NCG? <?@IL? ;H IJNCIH ?RJCL?M CM =;FF?> A2;<?
0I OH>?LMN;H> QB?H ;H IJNCIH A?NM ?R?L=CM?> IL HIN
F?N OM CHNLI>O=? MIG?
HIN;NCIHM (?N ?N >?HIN? NB? JLC=? I@ NB? OH>?LFSCHA ;MM?N ;N NCG? [
NL;>?>
CH NB? MJIN G;LE?N' 3? >?HIN? <S @ NB? ?RJCL;NCIH >;N? I@ NB? IJNCIH
;H>
@ [ NB? N?HIL I@ NB? =IHNL;=N FMI
F?N 7 >?HIN? NB? MNLCE? JLC=? IHMC>?L
HIQ ; !OLIJ?;H =;FF IJNCIH %@ NB? JLC=? I@ NB? OH>?LFSCHA ;MM?N ;N ?RJCL;NCIH
?4 ( CM MG;FF?L NB;H 7( CN G?;HM NB;N NB? IQH?L I@ NB? IJNCIH =;H JOL=B;M?
NB? OH>?LFSCHA ;MM?N CH NB? MJIN G;LE?N @IL F?MM NB;H NB? MNLCE? JLC=?
7 %H
MO=B ; =;M?
CN QIOF> HIN <? IJNCG;F @IL B?L NI ?R?L=CM? NB? IJNCIH +H NB?
INB?L B;H>
C@ NB? JLC=? I@ NB? OH>?LFSCHA ;MM?N CM BCAB?L NB;H 7
CN CM L;NCIH;F
NI ?R?L=CM? NB? IJNCIH 0B? IJNCIH IQH?L IHFS H??>M NI J;S 7 @IL MIG?NBCHA
QILNB GIL? *INC=? NB;N CH G;HS G;LE?NM
NB? IJNCIH IQH?L >I?M HIN ;=NO;FFS
H??> NI J;S 7 /B? QCFF L?=?CP? ; =IGJ?HM;NCIH J;SG?HN I@ ?4 7 =;FF?>
=;MBM?NNF?G?HN %@ NB? IJNCIH IQH?L QCMB?M NI ;=NO;FFS ;=KOCL? NB? OH>?LFSCHA
;MM?N
MB? =;H JOL=B;M? CN CH NB? MJIN G;LE?N $?L ;=NO;F =IMN ;N @ QCFF NB?H
<? ?4 ?4 7
7'
0I MOGG;LCT? %@ ?4
7( NB? IJNCIH IQH?L >I?M HIN ?R?L=CM?
NBOM ;N @
NB? P;FO? I@ NB? IJNCIH CM %@ ?4 + 7( NB? IJNCIH CM QILNB ?4 7 0B? P;FO?
I@ NB? IJNCIH ;N NCG? @ CM =;FF?> NB? =.F<O 0B? G;NB?G;NC=;F @ILGOF; @IL ;
!OLIJ?;H =;FF CM ' / ?4 7(
3? G;S HIQ NOLH NI NB? !OLIJ?;H JON IJNCIH A;CH
>?HIN? <S 7 NB?
MNLCE? JLC=? I@ NB? IJNCIH
;H> <S ?4 NB? P;FO? I@ NB? OH>?LFSCHA ;N NCG? @'
0B? IQH?L I@ NB? JON IJNCIH QCFF HIN ?R?L=CM? NB? IJNCIH C@ ?4 CM F;LA?L NB;H 7'
%H>??>
C@ NB? IQH?L >C> ?R?L=CM?
MB? QIOF> L?=?CP? IHFS 7 @IL NB? OH>?LFSCHA
QB?L?;M MB? =IOF> A?N ?4 @IL ; M;F? CH NB? MJIN G;LE?N /SGG?NLC=;FFS
C@ ?4
CM MG;FF?L NB;H 7
NB? IQH?L I@ NB? IJNCIH MBIOF> ?R?L=CM?
<?=;OM? MB? =;H
3? ;FMI WH> NB? HIN;NCIH 1 , @IL %1 ,
"OH>;G?HN;FM I@ +JNCIH ,LC=CHA
NB?H M?FF NB? OH>?LFSCHA ;MM?N @IL 7( QBC=B CM GIL? NB;H MB? QIOF> A?N CH NB?
MJIN G;LE?N %H =;M? NB? IQH?L I@ NB? IJNCIH >I?M HIN IQH NB? OH>?LFSCHA
;MM?N
MB? G;S B;P? NI JOL=B;M? CN WLMN 0BCM CM NB? =;M? @IL G;LE?NM QB?L?
;=NO;F >?FCP?LS CM ?RJ?=N?> %H G;HS G;LE?NM
MB? QIOF> A?N ; =IGJ?HM;NCIH
J;SG?HN CH =;MB
A;CH
Q? G;S MOGG;LCT? %@ ?4 ) 7
NB? IJNCIH CM QILNB 7 ?4 %@
?4 7
NB?H NB? IJNCIH QCFF ?RJCL? P;FO?F?MM 0B?L?@IL?
NB? =.F<O I@ NB?
!OLIJ?;H JON IJNCIH CM ACP?H <S NB? @ILGOF; ' / ( 7 ?4
'
%H "CAOL?
Q? L?JL?M?HN NB? J;SI_ >C;AL;GM I@ NB? JON ;H> =;FF IJ
NCIHM (IIECHA ;N NB?M? WAOL?M Q? OH>?LMN;H> QBS NB? M?FF?L I@ NB? IJNCIH
L?KOCL?M ; =IGJ?HM;NCIH J;SG?HN ;N NB? D?6A6;4 <3 A52 <=A6<;
C?
QB?H NB?
M?FF?L ;H> <OS?L ?MN;<FCMB ; =IHNL;=N %H>??>
CH NB? <?MN =;M? @IL NB? M?FF?L
NB? IJNCIH <OS?L F?NM NB? IJNCIH ?RJCL? %H NB? QILM? =;M?
NB? M?FF?L B;M NI
G;E? ; =IGJ?HM;NCIH J;SG?HN
,;SI_ ,;SI_
, ,
1 1
,ON IJNCIH ;FF IJNCIH
0B? JLII@ I@ NBCM ?KO;FCNS @IFFIQM <S =IHN?GJF;NCHA NB? J;SI_M =ILL?MJIH>CHA
NI NB? P;LCIOM MSG<IFM 0B? JIMCNCIH / < =ILL?MJIH>M NI ; JOL=B;M? I@ ;
=;FF ;H> ; M;F? I@ ; JON 0B? J;SI_ CM ' / ?4 7(
' / ( 7 ?4
0BCM
?KO;FM ?4 7' %@ Q? =IHN?GJF;N? NB? LCABNB;H> MC>? I@ NB? ?KO;FCNS
Q? M??
NB;N ?N =ILL?MJIH>M NI NB? JOL=B;M? JLC=? I@ NB? OH>?LFSCHA ;MM?N ,OL=B;M?
I@ NB? OH>?LFSCHA QCFF SC?F> ; P;FO? I@ ?4 ;N @ NB;N CM ; L;H>IG P;LC;<F?
&1. 78*;+2=;*0. *99;8*,1 =8 89=287 9;2,270
182,. 8/ * <=8,4 9;2,. 9;8,.<<
;H> OAOMN
M G?HNCIH?> <?@IL?
NB? WLMN MN?J CH NB? HI;L<CNL;A?
;JJLI;=B NI IJNCIH JLC=CHA CM NI M?F?=N ;H ;JJLIJLC;N? MNI=E JLC=? >SH;GC= CH
NB? @ILG I@ ; MNI=B;MNC= >C_?L?HNC;F ?KO;NCIH IL / !
M?? /?=NCIH NB;N
SC?F>M NL;D?=NILC?M MCGCF;L NI NB? IH? L?JL?M?HN?> CH "CAOL? 3? ;MMOG?
"OH>;G?HN;FM I@ +JNCIH ,LC=CHA
1600
1400
1200
1000
800
600
400
200
0
1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005
20
C<9BA6<; <3 A52 '$
@IL NB? GIG?HN NB;N NB? MNI=E JLC=? ?N <?B;P?M ;==IL>CHA NI NB? @IFFIQCHA
>C_OMCIH JLI=?MM
K?N K[ KCN (
QB?L? K?N >?HIN?M NB? CHMN;HN;H?IOM JLC=? =B;HA?
CM NB? ?RJ?=N?> L?NOLH
?4 ?N @ [
C4 CN
(
MI NB;N
?4 ?N @ [
( @ [
'
0BCM ?RJL?MMCIH G?;HM NB;N MNI=E JLC=? =;H <?=IG? H?A;NCP? ;H> NB;N NB?
PIF;NCFCNS CM =IHMN;HN >CML?A;L>CHA NB? F?P?F I@ NB? MNI=E JLC=? INB @?;NOL?M
;L? =IOHN?L@;=NO;F IGJ;HC?M B;P? FCGCN?> FC;<CFCNS
MI NB;N MB;L?BIF>?LM =;H
FIM? ;N GIMN NB? P;FO? I@ NB? MB;L? IHMN;HN PIF;NCFCNS G?;HM NB;N =B?;J?L
MNI=E P;LC?M GIL? L?F;NCP?FS NI ?RJ?HMCP? MNI=E 0I ?F;<IL;N? NB? M?=IH> JICHN
80
70
60
50
N
40
S
30
20
10
0
0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000
Steps
@IL NB? FIQ?L MNI=E JLC=? B;M L?F;NCP?FS GIL? P;LC;NCIHM "CAOL?
QB?L?;M
NB? IH? QCNB NB? BCAB?L MNI=E JLC=? CM ;FGIMN X;N "CAOL?
0B?M? I<M?LP;NCIHM MOAA?MN NB;N NB? MNI=E JLC=? >SH;GC= CH CM HIN
;JJLIJLC;N? +H? ;FN?LH;NCP? CM NI >?WH? &)# ?N
;M ;H ;LCNBG?NC= LIQHC;H
GINCIH
K &)# ?N
HK[ KCN '
0B?H
NB? >SH;GC=M I@ ?N CM ACP?H <S %NIZM F?GG; 3? I<N;CH
M?NNCHA
H
NB;N NB? MNI=E JLC=? ?N @IFFIQM ; 42<:2A?60 ?<D;6.; :<A6<; QCNB
MNI=B;MNC= >C_?L?HNC;F ?KO;NCIH
&1. />7-*6.7=*5 9*;=2*5 -2K.;.7=2*5 .:>*=287
2500
2000
1500
N
S
1000
500
0
0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000
Steps
BN M M3 ?N (
KBN YBN K[ Y M M3 ?N
K['
!KO;NCHA ;H>
Q? A?N
?N M33 Y?N M3 MN YM'
0BCM CM NB? F;=E/=BIF?M)?LNIH 3B;1.:2;A.9 =.?A6.9 16O2?2;A6.9 2>B.A6<;
", ! %N AIP?LHM NB? JLC=CHA I@ ;FF >?LCP;NCP?M QLCNN?H IH ?N NB;N B;M ; JLC=
CHA >SH;GC= ACP?H <S 0B? ?RJFC=CN MIFONCIH I@ NBCM @OH>;G?HN;F , !
>?J?H>M IH NB? <IOH>;LS =IH>CNCIHM L?F;N?> NI NB? N?LGM I@ NB? >?LCP;NCP? =IH
NL;=N "IL CHMN;H=?
=IHMC>?L ; !OLIJ?;H =;FF IJNCIH QCNB MNLCE? JLC=? 7 ;H>
NCG? NI G;NOLCNS @ 0B? N?LGCH;F J;SI_ I@ NBCM IJNCIH CM ' / ?4 7(
;M
>?M=LC<?> CH "CAOL? 0B? N?LGCH;F J;SI_ >?WH?M NB? <IOH>;LS =IH>CNCIH
@IL MIFPCHA NB? ", ! (?N / ?N ( [
<? NB? JLC=? I@ NB? =;FF IJNCIH 3? =;H
NB?H QLCN? NB? ", ! @IL NB? !OLIJ?;H =;FF IJNCIH ;M
, / ,/ ,/
?N Y?N Y/'
,? ,? ,[
QCNB N?LGCH;F =IH>CNCIH / ?4 ( @
' / ?4 7(
'
%85?270 =1. />7-*6.7=*5 "
0B?L? ;L? G;HS @;MN ;H> ;==OL;N? HOG?LC=;F G?NBI>M @IL MIFPCHA , !M 0I
?RJF;CH NB?G ;FF CM <?SIH> NB? M=IJ? I@ NBCM <IIE $?L?
Q? >?GIHMNL;N? NB?
OM? I@ NB? "?SHG;H';= @ILGOF; NI MIFP? >?N;CF?> ?RJIMCNCIH I@ NBCM
NIJC= CM JLIPC>?> CH /?=NCIHM NI 0I QILE QCNB NB? "?SHG;H';=
@ILGOF;
Q? WLMN H??> NI I<N;CH NB? NL;HMCNCIH JLI<;<CFCNS I@ ?N ACP?H NB? MNI=E
JLC=? >SH;GC= CH 0B? / ! CH CM NB;N I@ ; A?IG?NLC= LIQHC;H
GINCIH
QBC=B <S %NIZM F?GG; M?? /?=NCIH ACP?M
K &)# ?N
K[ KCN '
Q? B;P?
.
,
+ ?4 ) _ + "/* &)# ?4
K &)# ?4
. R
&)# ?4
+ "/* K?4 '
?4
QB?L?
&)# ?N
'
"LIG
Q? =;H =IGJON? J;LNC;F >C_?L?HNC;FM ,W*,?4 ( , W*,?4 ( ;H>
,W*,[( ;H> JLIP? NB;N NB? NL;HMCNCIH JLI<;<CFCNS I@ ; A?IG?NLC= LIQHC;H
GINCIH M;NCMW?M NB? , !
, W ,W ,W
?
? '
,? ,? ,[
"IL ; GIL? ?F?A;HN >?LCP;NCIH
M?? /?=NCIHM ] *?RN Q? >?WH? M ?N ( [
CM M;NCMW?> #CP?H NB;N ;FF NB? J;LNC;F >?LCP;NCP?M ;L? MGIINB ;H> NB? MKO;L?
P;LC;NCIH CM <IOH>?>
NBCM L?MOFN G?;HM NB;N CM ; OHCKO? MIFONCIH @IL
OH>?L NB? <IOH>;LS =IH>CNCIH
&%' M ?N ( [
O ?4
(
N 4
/3 )IL?IP?L
NB? , ! ?KO;FM NI Y/ CHMN?;> I@ T?LI 0B? G?;H >LC@N >C_?L?H=?
=;H <? >?;FN QCNB <S M?F?=NCHA ; MFCABNFS >C_?L?HN / !
Q? A?N
,/ ,M ,M
YLL M ?N ( [
LL Y/ ?N ( [
LL
,[
,[ ,[
,M L ,/
L Y/ ?N ( [
'
,[ ,[
/CGCF;LFS
QLCNCHA M ?N ( [
LL / ?N ( [
Q? A?N
,M , M
LL /3 ( ;H> LL /33 '
,?N ,?N
%@ Q? MO<MNCNON? ;FF NB? J;LNC;F >?LCP;NCP?M CHNI NB? ($/ I@
Q? I<N;CH
L
L ? /33 Y?/3 /N Y/ (
IL
? /33 Y?/3 /N Y/'
%N @IFFIQM NB;N / ?N ( [
LL 1 O ?4
) ?N ( [ CM ; MIFONCIH @IL NB? ", !
OH>?L NB? <IOH>;LS =IH>CNCIH 0I WHCMB
CN CM H?=?MM;LS NI =IGJON? NB?
=IH>CNCIH;F ?RJ?=N;NCIH 3? I<N;CH
/ ?N ( [
LL 1 ' / ?4 7(
) ?N ( [
.
L
&)# ?4
L ?4 7
+ + "/* + K?4 (
+ ?4
QB?L?
&)# ?N
Y '
&1. 5*,4%,185.<.;=87 /8;6>5*
%H NBCM M?=NCIH
Q? >?LCP? NB? /) @ILGOF; @LIG NB? !OLIJ?;H =;FF ?RJL?MMCIH
ACP?H CH CH NB? JL?PCIOM M?=NCIH "CLMN
Q? M?J;L;N? NB? CHN?AL;F CH
/ ?N ( [
CH CHNI 5 5 ( QB?L?
"OH>;G?HN;FM I@ +JNCIH ,LC=CHA
.
?4
&)# ?4
5 LL + + "/* + K?4 (
+ ?4
;H>
.
L
&)# ?4
5 7L + + "/* + K?4 '
+ ?4
5 L + + "/* K`
+
.
L L `
L + + "/* K`
+
LL L
K
(
QB?L?
L
"/* &)# ?N
Y ?N LL (
;H>
&)# ?N *7
Y
K + '
0B? M?=IH> =IGJIH?HN CM ?;MC?L NI MIFP? 3CNB NB? M;G? =B;HA? CH P;LC;<F?
Q? A?N
.
L
`
5 7L + + "/* + K`
+
7LL
K
(
QB?L?
&)# ?N *7
Y
K + '
$?H=?
@IL NB? !OLIJ?;H =;FF IJNCIH
Q? B;P?
/ ?N ( [
?N
K
7LL
K
QCNB
&)# ?N *7
Y
K + (
&)# ?N *7
Y
K + (
; @ILGOF; NB;N Q;M L?Q;L>?> <S NB? *I<?F JLCT? CH !=IHIGC=M
);LNCHA;F? G?;MOL? ;H> /) @ILGOF;
%H B;JN?L
Q? JLIPC>? >?N;CFM IH G;LNCHA;F? ;H> NB? N?=BHCKO?M NI =B;HA?
JLI<;<CFCNS G?;MOL? 0B? $IFS #L;CF CH NBCM =B;HACHA G?;MOL? ;JJLI;=B NI
IJNCIH JLC=CHA CM NI =IHP?LN NB? ;MM?N JLC=? >SH;GC= ;H>
B?H=?
NB? >?LCP;NCP?
JLC=? >SH;GC= CHNI NB? MI=;FF?> :.?A6;4.92 :2.@B?2 +H=? NBCM CM ;=BC?P?>
NI>;SZM IJNCIH JLC=? =;H <? =;F=OF;N?> ;M NB? ?RJ?=N?> IJNCIH J;SI_ OH>?L NB?
LCMEH?ONL;F G?;MOL? ;H> >CM=IOHN?> ;N NB? LCME@L?? L;N? 3? JL?M?HN IHFS NB?
<;MC= QILECHAM B?L? 0B? @OH>;G?HN;F NB?IL?GM IH ;MM?N JLC=CHA Q?L? ACP?H CH
NQI J;J?LM <S $;LLCMIH ;H> ,FCME; %H $;LLCMIH ;H> ,FCME;
CN CM MBIQH
NB;N C@ ; G;LE?N B;M ; G;LNCHA;F? G?;MOL?
NB?L? CM HI ;L<CNL;A? IJJILNOHCNS
%H $;LLCMIH ;H> ,FCME;
CN CM ;FMI MBIQH NB;N NB? G;LNCHA;F? G?;MOL?
CM OHCKO? C@ ;H> IHFS C@ ?P?LS =F;CG =;H <? B?>A?>
NB;N CM
?R=FOMCP?FS C@ NB?
G;LE?N CM =IGJF?N? .?=?HN =IHNLC<ONCIHM IH NBCM MO<D?=N CH=FO>? ?F<;?H ;H>
/=B;=B?LG;S?L
MMOG? NB;N NB? LCMES ;M Q?FF ;M LCMEF?MM ;MM?NM B;P? NB? @IFFIQCHA JLC=CHA
>SH;GC=M
@N?L CHN?AL;NCIH
Q? I<N;CH
?N ? "/* [ [ CN (
.N . LLN '
N ;H> N
=B;HA? NBLIOAB NCG? ;H> NB?S ;L? I@N?H L?@?LL?> NI ;M NL;>CHA
MNL;N?AC?M 3? G;S HIQ QLCN? NB? JILN@IFCI P;FO? ;N NCG? [ ;M
C?
NB? JILN@IFCI P;FO? =B;HA?M ;L? ?HNCL?FS >O? NI GIP?G?HNM CH ?N ;H> .N
"OH>;G?HN;FM I@ +JNCIH ,LC=CHA
1*70. 8/ 7>6.;*2;.
K?N Y
?N K[ ?N KCN '
K?N Y
?N K[ ?N KCN (
Y
(
IL
Y
*'
%H NBCM M?NNCHA
NB? L?M=;F?> ;H> NL;HM@ILG?> JLI=?MM K?N ?N KCN
;H>
?N CM ; G;LNCHA;F? OH>?L NB? H?Q LIQHC;H GINCIH
C?
11 ?M ?N ?N ( @IL Z + [
%N CM =F?;L NB;N NB? L?M=;F?> ;H> NL;HM@ILG?> JLI=?MM KBN CM ;FMI ; G;LNCHA;F?
OH>?L NB? H?Q LIQHC;H GINCIH KCN
);LNCHA;F? G?;MOL? ;H> /) @ILGOF;
?85>=287 8/ >7-.;
"LIG
Q? HIN? NB;N
?N ? "/* [ [ CN (
OH>?L NB? ILCACH;F < JLI<;<CFCNS G?;MOL? .?JF;=CHA CN <S CN [ SC?F>M
Y
?N ? "/* [ CN [
? "/* Y [ CN (
OH>?L NB? H?Q = JLI<;<CFCNS G?;MOL?
;H> CH N?LGM I@ / !
K?N Y?N K[ ?N KCN '
0B? =B;HA? I@ JLI<;<CFCNS B;M =B;HA?> NB? >LC@N I@ NB? A?IG?NLC= LIQHC;H
GINCIH ;H> B?H=? NB? / !
.4 N
;H> QCNB =IHMN;HN CHN?L?MN L;N?
BN LL 11 O ?4
) CN '
S MO<MNCNONCHA NB? >C_OMCIH J;L;G?N?LM @LIG CHNI
Q? A?N
.
L O ?4
&)# ?4
BN L + + "/* + K?4 (
?4
QB?L? &)# ?4
Y '
%H NB? =;M? I@ ; !OLIJ?;H =;FF IJNCIH
NB? J;SI_ @OH=NCIH CM
O ?4
' / ?4 7(
(
;H> NB? P;FO? I@ NB? !OLIJ?;H =;FF IJNCIH =;H <? =IGJON?> ;M
.
L ?4 7
&)# ?4
/ ?N ( [
L + + "/* + K?4 (
+ ?N
QCNB >?WH?> ;M ;<IP? >?N;CF?> MIFONCIH I@ B;M ;FL?;>S <??H JLI
PC>?> CH NB? JL?PCIOM M?=NCIH
"OH>;G?HN;FM I@ +JNCIH ,LC=CHA
IL
KBN N ?N KCN '
0BCM L?MOFN G?;HM NB;N Q? =;H L?;=B BN<S ;_?=NCHA NB? LCABN Q?CABNM NI
NB? LIQHC;H GINCIH "IL WH;H=?
ACP?H NB;N BN L?JL?M?HNM NB? P;FO? I@
NB? >?LCP;NCP? ;MM?N ;@N?L ; =B;HA? I@ HOG?L;CL?
NBCM G?;HM NB;N NB?L? ?RCMNM
N
NB? Q?CABN NI ;_?=N NI NB? LCMES ;MM?N
MI NB;N NB? P;FO? I@ NB? >OJFC=;NCIH
MNL;N?AS ?KO;FM NB? P;FO? I@ NB? >?LCP;NCP? ;MM?N 1H@ILNOH;N?FS
NB? G;LNCHA;F?
L?JL?M?HN;NCIH NB?IL?G CM HIN ; =IHMNLO=NCP? JLII@ ;H> >I?M HIN ACP? OM N
>CL?=NFS "IL =;M?M QB?L? BN CM EHIQH
MO=B ;M CH
Q? G;S I<N;CH N
?RJFC=CNFS
0I M?? NBCM
Q? L?=IAHCT? NB;N NB? CH@ILG;NCIH A?H?L;N?> <S ?N ;H> ?N CM
?KOCP;F?HN 3? =IHMC>?L NB?L?@IL? NB? >SH;GC=M I@ KBN ?N ( [
S ;JJFSCHA
%NIZM F?GG;
Q? I<N;CH OH>?L =
, BN ,BN ,BN ,BN
KBN ?N Y? N K[ ? N KCN '
,?N ,?N ,[ ,?N
,BN
KBN ?N KCN '
,?N
!KO;NCHA ;H>
Q? A?N
,BN ,B
N ?N ?N ?N N (
,?N ,?N
QBC=B G?;HM
,BN
N '
,?N
0B;N CM
NB? NL;>CHA MNL;N?AS CHPIFP?M CHP?MNCHA ,BN *,?N ;GIOHN I@ NB? LCMES
;MM?N ;N NCG? [
0B? ;GIOHN NI <? CHP?MN?> CH NB? LCME@L?? ;MM?N
N
@IFFIQM @LIG NB?
M?F@WH;H=CHA ;MJ?=N I@ NB? NL;>CHA MNL;N?AS %H>??>
C@ NB? >?LCP;NCP? ;MM?N CM
CHCNC;FFS QILNB B ? (
B ? (
? (
IL
B ? (
? '
%H JL;=NC=?
=IHNCHOIOM NL;>CHA CM HIN JIMMC<F?
B?H=? F?N [D <? NCG?M QB?L? NB?
JILN@IFCI A?NM L?<;F;H=?> 3? B;P?
N .N N ?N N .N N ?N (
IL
?N
N
N N N
'
.N
3? ;FMI HINC=? NB;N =ILL?MJIH>M ?R;=NFS NI NB? ", ! I@
0B? G;LNCHA;F? ;JJLI;=B NI IJNCIH JLC=CHA NB?L?@IL? SC?F>M ;FF NB? M;G? L?MOFNM
;M CH NB? JL?PCIOM M?=NCIH 0B? MN?JM ;L?
BIQ?P?L
HIN CH NB? M;G? IL>?L ;M
<?@IL? 3? WLMN I<N;CH NB? IJNCIH JLC=? @LIG QBC=B Q? >?LCP? NB? @OH>;G?HN;F
, ! ;H> NB? B?>ACHA L;NCIH N ' FMI
CH NBCM G?NBI>
NB? NL;>CHA MNL;N?AS
SC?F>CHA NB? J;SI_ JF;SM ;H CGJILN;HN LIF?
M ; =IHM?KO?H=?
Q? HINC=? NB;N NB? ?RJ?=N?> @ONOL? P;FO? I@ NB? ;MM?N
>CM
=IOHN?> ;N NB? LCME@L?? L;N? ?KO;FM NB? =OLL?HN P;FO? I@ ?N ' 0BCM NSJ? I@
>CM=IOHNCHA CM =B;L;=N?LCMNC= @IL LCMEH?ONL;F CHP?MNILM "IL NBCM L?;MIH
NB?
JLI<;<CFCNS G?;MOL? = CM =;FF?> ; LCMEH?ONL;F JLI<;<CFCNS FMI CM CG
JILN;HN ;H> QCFF <? L?@?LL?> NI CH NB? @IFFIQCHA ;M NB? G;LNCHA;F? =IH>CNCIH
+@N?H
;M Q? QCFF M?? CH NB? H?RN B;JN?L
Q? CGJIM? NBCM =IH>CNCIH NI >?LCP?
; LCMEH?ONL;F JLI<;<CFCNS
HINB?L CHN?L?MNCHA CMMO? B;M NI >I QCNB NB? J;MM;A? @LIG < NI =' M
MBIQH CH B;JN?L
NB?L? ?RCMNM ; @OH=NCIH
M;S 9( MI NB;N
K= ?4
9 ?4
'
K< ?4
0B?L?@IL?
=;H ;FMI <? QLCNN?H @ILG;FFS ;M
. .
L L
BN L O ?4
K= ?4
L O ?4
9 ?4
K< ?4
'
"OH>;G?HN;FM I@ +JNCIH ,LC=CHA
=LCNC=;FFS L?FC?M IH NB? ;MMOGJNCIH NB;N ;MM?N JLC=? @IFFIQM ; FIAHILG;F >C_O
MCIH JLI=?MM >CL?=N =IHM?KO?H=? CM NB;N PIF;NCFCNS >?>O=?> @LIG NB? /)
@ILGOF; MBIOF> <? =IHMN;HN ;=LIMM ?R?L=CM? JLC=?M ;H> ;=LIMM G;NOLCNC?M %H
/?=NCIH
Q? CFFOMNL;N? NB;N NB? FIAHILG;F ;MMOGJNCIH >I?M HIN BIF> CH
JL;=NC=? %GJFC?> PIF;NCFCNC?M I@ IJNCIHM I@ >C_?L?HN MNLCE? JLC=?M ;L? HIN NB?
M;G?
;H> CH ;>>CNCIH NB? PIF;NCFCNS MGCF?M ;L? >C_?L?HN @LIG IH? G;NOLCNS NI
;HINB?L 0B?M? NQI @?;NOL?M =IHNL;>C=N NB? FIAHILG;F >C_OMCIH ;MMOGJNCIH
;H> MOAA?MN NB;N IJNCIH JLC=CHA GI>?FM GIL? A?H?L;F NB;H NB? /) GI>?F
;L? L?KOCL?> 3? NB?H ?RJF;CH CH /?=NCIH NB;N MN;N? JLC=?M G;S <? CH
@?LL?> @LIG IJNCIH JLC=?M %H ; =IHNCHOIOM M?NNCHA
JLC=?M I@ @ONOL? MN;N?M QCFF
<? ACP?H <S ; MN;N? JLC=? >?HMCNS 0BCM MN;N? JLC=? >?HMCNS CM I@N?H L?@?LL?> NI
CH NB? FCN?L;NOL? ;M ; ?6@8;2BA?.9 12;@6A62 .*
0B? FCN?L;NOL? IH ?MNCG;NCHA .* M CM ?RN?HMCP? 0B? GI>?FM >?M=LC<?> CH
NB? FCN?L;NOL? =IOF> <? <LI;>FS >CPC>?> CHNI NQI G;CH =;N?AILC?M
MNLO=NOL;F
P?LMOM HIHMNLO=NOL;F ;JJLI;=B?M 3? KO;FC@S ; GI>?F ;M [MNLO=NOL;F\ C@ CN
JLIJIM?M ; @OFF >?M=LCJNCIH @IL NB? MNI=E JLC=? >SH;GC=M ;H> CH MIG? =;M?M @IL
NB? PIF;NCFCNS JLI=?MM ;M Q?FF %H =IHNL;MN
; GI>?F CM M;C> [HIHMNLO=NOL;F\ C@
CN SC?F>M ; >?M=LCJNCIH I@ NB? .* QCNBION =IGJF?N?FS >?M=LC<CHA NB? >SH;GC=
I@ JLC=? 0B? HIHMNLO=NOL;F ;JJLI;=B?M =;H NB?GM?FP?M <? >CPC>?> CHNI NBL??
NSJ?M I@ GI>?FM
H;G?FS J;L;G?NLC=
M?GCHIHJ;L;G?NLC=
IL HIHJ;L;G?NLC=
GI>?FM 0B? L?MN I@ NB? =B;JN?L >?M=LC<?M MIG? HIHMNLO=NOL;F GI>?FM >?P?F
IJ?> NI ?RNL;=N MN;N? JLC=?M @LIG IJNCIH >;N; $.?.:2A?60 :<129@ JLIJIM? ;
>CL?=N ?RJL?MMCIH @IL NB? .*
QCNBION L?@?LLCHA NI ;HS JLC=? >SH;GC= 0B?S
CH=FO>? ; GCRNOL? I@ >CMNLC<ONCIHM ;H> ; QC>? =IFF?=NCIH I@ >CMNLC<ONCIHM ;F
FIQCHA @IL BCAB?L GIG?HNM '2:6 ;H> ;<;=.?.:2A?60 :<129@ JLIJIM? MIG?
;JJLIRCG;NCIH I@ NB? NLO? .* "IL CHMN;H=?
&;LLIQ ;H> .O>> MBIQ
BIQ NB? .* =;H <? I<N;CH?> ;M ;H !>A?QILNB ?RJ;HMCIH ;LIOH> ; FIA
HILG;F >?HMCNS FMI
);>;H ;H> )CFH? OM? ; $?LGCN? JIFSHIGC;F
;JJLIRCG;NCIH "<;=.?.:2A?60 :<129@ >I HIN NLS NI ACP? ;H ?RJFC=CN @ILG
*IHMNLO=NOL;F +JNCIH ,LC=CHA
<?=;OM? NB? NQI =OLL?H=C?M NSJC=;FFS SC?F> ; LCME@L?? CHN?L?MN L;N?
/N LL ?N
K
LL 7
K
(
+ +
QB?L? K &)# ?N *7
Y Y
*
;H> K K ( ;H>
?N >?HIN?M NB? ?R=B;HA? L;N?
Y NB? >IG?MNC= L;N?
;H> Y NB? @IL?CAH ?R=B;HA?
L;N? HINB?L >C_?L?H=? QCNB NB? @L;G?QILE I@ B;JN?L CM NB;N +0 IJ
NCIHMZ KOIN;NCIH CM HIN >IH? CH N?LGM I@ JLC=?M @IL ; M?N I@ ?R?L=CM? JLC=?M
<ON CH N?LGM I@ PIF;NCFCNC?M @IL IJNCIHM I@ P;LCIOM 129A.@ 0B?L? CM ; IH? NI IH?
L?F;NCIH <?NQ??H >?FN;M ;H> NB? MNLCE? JLC=? 0B? >?FN; I@ ;H IJNCIH CM >?WH?>
;M NB? >?LCP;NCP? I@ NB? JLC=? QCNB L?MJ?=N NI NB? OH>?LFSCHA P;FO? $?H=?
@IL
L
; =;FF IJNCIH
Q? B;P? !$ !3* L
*
K
' /CH=? CM ; MNLC=NFS >?=L?;MCHA
@OH=NCIH I@ 7
@IL ?;=B NB?L? =ILL?MJIH>M ; OHCKO? MNLCE? JLC=? NB;N =;H <?
?RNL;=N?> HOG?LC=;FFS
"CAOL?M ;H> NL;=? NB? PIF;NCFCNS MGCF? ;H> NB? N?LG MNLO=NOL? I@
PIF;NCFCNC?M @IL NQI >;N?M
);S
;H> &OH?
;M @OH=NCIHM I@ NB?
>?FN; ;H> G;NOLCNS 0B? WLMN >;N? CM =BIM?H ;N L;H>IG
QB?L?;M NB? M?=IH>
>;N? =ILL?MJIH>M NI NB? WLMN NL;>CHA >;S ;@N?L ,L?MC>?HN BCL;= =;FF?> @IL MH;J
?F?=NCIHM %@ FIAHILG;FCNS B?F>
Q? MBIOF> I<M?LP? ; MNL;CABN FCH? CH>?J?H>?HN
I@ G;NOLCNS "IL ; ACP?H G;NOLCNS
NB? >?PC;NCIH @LIG NB? MNL;CABN FCH? CM =;FF?>
NB? C<9.A696AF @:692 0B? MBC@N ;=LIMM G;NOLCNC?M CM NB? A2?: @A?B0AB?2 <3 C<9.A69
6A62@ $?L?
IJNCIHM QCNB FIQ BCAB MNLCE? JLC=?M ;L? BCABFS P;FO?>
G?;HCHA
CL?=N ?MNCG;NCIH I@ NB? LCMEH?ONL;F >?HMCNS
NB;N NB? G;LE?N ?RJ?=N?> ;H CH=L?;M? CH NB? ?R=B;HA? L;N? ; "." >?JL?=C;
NCIH 3? HINC=? @IL );S
NB? HILG;F >;S
NB;N ;M NB? ?RJCL;NCIH I@
NB? IJNCIHM CM GIL? L?GIN? CH NCG?
PIF;NCFCNS CM BCAB?L "IL NB? >;S ;@N?L NB?
;HHIOH=?G?HN
NB? PIF;NCFCNS MGCF? NL;HMF;N?M CHNI ; MN??J?L I<D?=N
=;FF?> ;
@:6?8 FMI NB? N?LG MNLO=NOL? I@ PIF;NCFCNC?M CM CHP?LN?>
NB? MBILN?MN G;NOLCNS
B;PCHA NB? BCAB?MN PIF;NCFCNS
0B? M?=IH> CFFOMNL;NCIH CM <;M?> IH IJNCIHM 3? =IHMC>?L ?H>I@
NB?GIHNB IJNCIHM @IL *IP?G<?L
"IL NBCM >;S
NB?L? Q?L? KOIN?>
MNLCE?M 0B? CGJFC?> PIF;NCFCNS MGCF? B;M NB? J;NN?LH JL?M?HN?> CH "CAOL?
M CN ;JJ?;LM =F?;LFS
NB? MGCF? CM HIN X;N <ON CHMN?;> CM >?=L?;MCHA +H=?
;A;CH
CN MOAA?MNM MNLIHA L?D?=NCIH I@ NB? FIAHILG;F ;MMOGJNCIH
0.05
1 m onth
3 m onths
0.045 6 m onths
1 year
0.04
0.035
Volatility
0.03
0.025
0.02
0.015
0 20 40 60 80 100
Call option delta
2;.,= .<=26*=287 8/ =1. ;2<47.>=;*5 -.7<2=B
A9;.<<287 /8; =1. $
3? L?=;FF NB;N NB? JLC=? I@ ; =;FF IJNCIH CM ACP?H <S NB? ?RJL?MMCIH
/ ?N ( [
LL 1 ' / ?4 7(
)?N ( [
.
L
L ' / ?4 7(
X ?4 )?N ( [
K?4 '
*IHMNLO=NOL;F +JNCIH ,LC=CHA
0.05
1 m onth
3 m onths
0.045 6 m onths
1 year
0.04
0.035
Volatility
0.03
0.025
0.02
0.015
0 20 40 60 80 100
Call option delta
20
*<9.A696AF @:692 3<? =?69
0.32
0.3
0.28
0.26
Volatility
0.24
0.22
0.2
0.18
0.16
5000 5500 6000 6500 7000
Strike price
CL?=N ?MNCG;NCIH I@ NB? LCMEH?ONL;F >?HMCNS
0B? WLMN ;NN?GJN NI >?LCP? NB? .* OMCHA NBCM ?RJL?MMCIH CM <S L??>?H
;H> (CNT?H<?LA?L 0B?S L?;FCT?> NB;N >C_?L?HNC;NCHA NBCM ?KO;NCIH QCNB
L?MJ?=N NI NB? ?R?L=CM? JLC=? 7 SC?F>M NB? >CM=IOHN?> 013
.
,/ L
L X ?4
K?4 (
,7 +
NB?H NB? .* G;S <? P?LS CGJL?=CM?FS ?MNCG;N?> 0BCM ?PC>?H=? MOAA?MNM NB;N
Q? MBIOF> ?RNL;=N NB? .* OMCHA ;FN?LH;NCP? G?NBI>M NB;N JON GIL? MNLO=NOL?
IH NB? IJNCIH JLC=?M ?@IL? NOLHCHA NI NB? >CM=OMMCIH I@ P;LCIOM MO=B G?NBI>M
<=26*=270 =1. 9*;*6.=.;< 8/ =1. $
MMOG? NB;N Q? B;P? NI ?MNCG;N? ; ACP?H GI>?F QCNB J;L;G?N?L M?N ' 0B?
MCGJF?MN GI>?F Q? G;S NBCHE I@ CM /) CH QBC=B NB? PIF;NCFCNS J;L;G?N?L
%N MBIOF> <? G?HNCIH?> NB;N F CM NB? OH>CM=IOHN?> .* IH QBC=B Q? @I=OM CH
NBCM =B;JN?L
QB?L?;M <$ F L?JL?M?HNM ;H LLIQ ?<L?O MN;N? JLC=?
QBC=B CM
L?@?LL?> NI ;M NB? LCMEH?ONL;F >?HMCNS .* IL MN;N? JLC=? >?HMCNS /,
"ILG;FFS
C@ % CM ;H IJNCIH JLC=?
NB?H NB? L;H>IG J?LNOL<;NCIH CM I<N;CH?> ;M
% QB?L?
/
% ;H> QB?L? % CM NB? ;P?L;A? =;FF JLC=? IP?L ;FF
IJNCIHM
*IHMNLO=NOL;F +JNCIH ,LC=CHA
0.1
RND with clean option prices
RND with perturbated option prices
0.08
0.06
0.04
0.02
-0.02
-0.04
-0.06
-0.08
70 80 90 100 110 120 130
I<M?LP?> =;FF ;H> JON IJNCIH JLC=?M ;L? >?HIN?> /N D ( P
( ( :> ;H> <N D (
P
( ( :J 0B?IL?NC=;F =;FF ;H> JON IJNCIH JLC=?M
CGJFC?> <S NB? ;MMOG?>
GI>?F
;L? >?HIN?> /N 7( (
;H> <N 7( (
L?MJ?=NCP?FS
@IL MNLCE? JLC=? 7
;H> BILCTIH 0B?H
NB? J;L;G?N?L P?=NIL CM NSJC=;FFS ?MNCG;N?> <S
HIHFCH?;L F?;MN MKO;L?M
<S GCHCGCTCHA @IL ?;=B >;S ;H> ?;=B G;NOLCNS
&
.
.
,
,
'%( " >D /N D /N 7D ( (
(
D D
QB?L? " >D ;H> " JD ;L? Q?CABNM ;MMI=C;N?> QCNB IJNCIH P ;H> CM NB? >IG;CH I@
0B?M? Q?CABNM =IOF>
@IL CHMN;H=?
<? ACP?H <S ; G?;MOL? I@ FCKOC>CNS I@ ;
ACP?H IJNCIH !R;GJF?M I@ G?;MOL?M I@ FCKOC>CNS =IOF> <? NB? HOG<?L I@ NL;>?M
@IL ; ACP?H >;S IL NB? QC>NB I@ NB? <C>;ME MJL?;>
%HMN?;> I@ OMCHA =;FF ;H> JON IJNCIH JLC=? @ILGOF;?
Q? G;S WLMN NL;HM@ILG JON
IJNCIH JLC=?M CHNI =;FF IJNCIH JLC=?M OMCHA NB? JON=;FF J;LCNS 3B?H ; JON ;H> ;
=;FF IJNCIH ?RCMN @IL NB? M;G? MNLCE?
Q? A?H?L;FFS OM? NB? IONI@NB?GIH?S IJNCIH
;H> .;G;GOLNC? ;FMI >?LCP? ; L?F;NCIHMBCJ NB;N FCHEM NB? J;L;G?N?LM
@IL >C_?L?HN G;NOLCNC?M QCNBCH NB?CL $?LGCN? JIFSHIGC;F ;JJLI;=B
"*;*6.=;2, 6.=18-<
2A=>;. 8/ 58078;6*5 -2<=;2+>=287<
;BL;
)?FC=E ;H> 0BIG;M
;H> /j>?LFCH> ;H> /P?HMMIH
;L? ;GIHA NB? WLMN IH?M NI >?M=LC<? NB? .* ;M ; GCRNOL? I@ >CMNLC<ONCIHM
%N MBIOF> <? HINC=?> NB;N NB? >?M=LCJNCIH I@ ; >?HMCNS ;M ; GCRNOL? I@ INB?L
>?HMCNC?M B;M <??H ; P?LS =IHP?HC?HN Q;S NI CGJLIP? NB? WN CH G;HS MN;NCMNC=;F
JLI<F?GM /O=B ;H ;JJLI;=B ;FFIQM =;JNOLCHA P?LS X?RC<F? >CMNLC<ONCIHM
S?N ;N
NB? JLC=? I@ MIG? N?=BHC=;F >C^=OFNC?M @IL NB? ?MNCG;NCIH "IL IJNCIH JLC=CHA
NB? GIMN Q?FFEHIQH >CMNLC<ONCIH MNO>C?> CH NB? FCN?L;NOL? CM NB? GCRNOL? I@
FIAHILG;F >?HMCNC?M 0B? L?;MIH CM NB;N CN ;JJ?;LM ;M ; NLCPC;F ?RN?HMCIH I@
NB? /) GI>?F NB;N CHPIFP?M NB? MCHAF? FIAHILG;F >?HMCNS
&1. 68-.5
3? L?GCH> NB;N NB? FIAHILG;F =13 QCNB G?;H ;H> PIF;NCFCNS Z CM >?WH?> <S
0B? N?=BHCKO? JLIJIM?> <S ONF?L ;H> ;PC?M NI =IHMNLO=N .* M QCNB
=IHMN;HN BILCTIH =;H <? OM?> @IL ;HS GI>?F
*IHMNLO=NOL;F +JNCIH ,LC=CHA
&)# ?4
S ?4 ( (
+ "/* '
?4 Z Z
+
QB?L? Q? >?WH? NB? PIF;NCFCNS IP?L NB? BILCTIH I@ NB? IJNCIH ;M ZD D ( NI
MCGJFC@S HIN;NCIH 0B? F;MN ?KO;FCNS CM I<N;CH?> <S MCGJFS CHP?LNCHA NB? MOG
;H> CHN?AL;F IJ?L;NILM 0B?L? ;L? P;LCIOM Q;SM NI ?P;FO;N? NB? CHN?AL;F "IL
CHMN;H=?
Q? B;P?
.
?4 7
S ?4 ( Z
K?4 1 ?4 )?4 + 7 7
+ ?4 )?4 + 7
+
"/* Z
&)# 7
Z
Z
&)# 7
7
'
Z
0BCM L?MOFN <OCF>M IH &IBHMIH
'INT
;H> ;F;ELCMBH;H
J QBI CH>C=;N?
NB;N C@ 1 @IFFIQM ; FIAHILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH QCNB G?;H ;H> P;LC;H=?
NB?H
3
&1 1 ! , %!
3
QB?L? 3 ,
,;L;G?NLC= G?NBI>M
"CH;FFS
NB? IJNCIH JLC=? CM ACP?H <S
-
,
&)# 7
D Z D
/ ,. 7
LL
D "/* D Z D
D
ZD
&)# 7
D
7
ZD
,-
&)# 7
D Z D
LL
D "/* D Z D
D
ZD
,-
&)# 7
D
LL 7
D
(
D
ZD
M ;H ;FN?LH;NCP?
Q? =;H >CL?=NFS OM? NB? /) @ILGOF; ;H> M?N
CH ; MCGCF;L
MJCLCN NI QB;N JL?=?>?M
-
,
,.
/ 7(
D ?N
KD
7LL
K D
(
D
?N / ,. (
'
<=26*=287 2<<>.<
X ?4 (
( ( ( Z ( Z
S ?4 ( Z
S ?4 ( Z
'
+<PCIOMFS
NB? M;G? >?HMCNS CM I<N;CH?> C@ Q? CHP?LN NB? NQI FIAHILG;F >CM
NLC<ONCIHM
C?
X ?4 (
( ( ( Z ( Z
' F?;LFS
NB? IL>?L I@ NB? J;L;G?N?LM
JF;SM ; =LCNC=;F LIF? B?L? "IL ;H IJNCGCT;NCIH JLIAL;G
NBCM G?;HM
BIQ?P?L
NB;N M?P?L;F J;L;G?N?L P?=NILM ;L? ;MMI=C;N?> QCNB ; M;G? >?HMCNS 0BCM CH
NOLH =IOF> SC?F> HOG?LC=;FFS OHMN;<F? JLIAL;GM QB?L? NB? IJNCGCT?L =S=F?M CH
;H CHWHCN? FIIJ
HINB?L >C^=OFNS CM N?MNCHA NB? HOG<?L I@ >CMNLC<ONCIHM NB;N ;L? CHPIFP?>
CH NB? .* +H? G;S <? N?GJN?> NI OM? ; FCE?FCBII>L;NCI NSJ? N?MN NI =B?=E
C@ NB? PNB >?HMCNS MBIOF> <? CH=FO>?> CH NB? GCRNOL? <S N?MNCHA C@
D $IQ
?P?L
C@
D ( NB? J;L;G?N?LM D ;H> ZD ;MMI=C;N?> QCNB NB? PNB >?HMCNS ;L?
OHC>?HNCW?> /N;N?> >C_?L?HNFS
D ;H> ZD =IOF> N;E? ;HS P;FO?
<?=;OM? NB?S
QIOF> HIN JF;S ; LIF? CH NB? >?HMCNS X /IG?NCG?M
MO=B J;L;G?N?LM ;L? =;FF?>
;B6@.;02 J;L;G?N?LM %H MO=B ; MCNO;NCIH
NB? OMO;F MN;NCMNC=;F NB?ILS <L?;EM
>IQH ;H> MJ?=CW= N?MNM H??> NI <? >?P?FIJ?> 0BCM NSJ? I@ JLI<F?G ;JJ?;LM
;FMI CH MQCN=BCHA L?AL?MMCIHM 0B?L? CM HI I<PCIOM MIFONCIH NI CN LCNC=;F P;FO?M
G;S <? I<N;CH?> <S MCGOF;NCIHM %H JL;=NC=?
IH? G;S ;>> >CMNLC<ONCIHM OJ NI
NB? JICHN QB?L? ;>>CHA NB?G SC?F>M NI HI @OLNB?L CGJLIP?G?HN
0B?L? ?RCMN P;LCIOM MIFONCIHM NI B?FJ NB? IJNCGCT?L =IHP?LA? CH N?LGM I@
)/! 3? QCFF >CM=OMM NB? MCNO;NCIH CH QBC=B Q? ?MNCG;N? ; GCRNOL? I@ NQI
IL NBL?? >?HMCNC?M %N M??GM NI JLIPC>? ; AII> WN CH GIMN =;M?M %H NB? ?P?HN
I@ NQI >?HMCNC?M
9
Q? MN;LN QCNB ; ALC> @IL
' /CH=? CN CM EHIQH NB;N
IH? G;S MO<>CPC>? NB? CHN?LP;F (
CHNI ?KO;FFS MJ;=?> JICHNM
QB?L?
D P
@IL P ( ( : %H JL;=NC=?
'
I@N?H SC?F>M P?LS AII>
L?MOFNM "OLNB?LGIL?
NI ;PIC> NB? JLI<F?G I@ MSGG?NLS G?HNCIH?> ;<IP?
CN CM
JIMMC<F? NI CGJIM? NB;N NB? >?HMCNC?M L?G;CH CH ; ACP?H IL>?L +H? JIMMC<CFCNS
NB;N ;JJ?;LM NI ACP? M;NCM@;=NILS L?MOFNM CM NI CGJIM? NB;N Z + Z 0B? WLMN
>?HMCNS QCFF NB?H B;P? ; F;LA?L MN;H>;L> >?PC;NCIH NB;H NB? M?=IH> IH?
/CGCF;L ?RN?HMCIHM G;S <? ACP?H @IL NB? =;M? QB?L? 9 0B?
J;
L;G?N?LM G;S <? N;E?H IP?L ; MCGJF?R
;M CH>C=;N?> CH "CAOL? %H NBCM
WAOL?
N;E?M P;LCIOM P;FO?M
L;HACHA <?NQ??H ;H>
"IL ?;=B F?P?F I@
(
,;L;G?NLC= G?NBI>M
0.8
0.6
3
α
0.4
0.2
0
0
0.2 1
0.4 0.8
0.6 0.6
0.4
0.8
0.2
1 0
α
α 2
1
20
?61 3<? .;1 F62916;4 A52 D2645A@ 3<? A52 :6EAB?2 <3 A5?22
12;@6A62@
D D
-
,
&
^ %?N LL
E "/* E E (
E
QB?L? " >D ;H> " JD ;L? Q?CABNM ;MMI=C;N?> QCNB =?LN;CH IJNCIHM 0B? J;L;G?N?L ^
=ILL?MJIH>M NI ; J?H;FNS J;L;G?N?L IH NB? G;LNCHA;F? =IHMNL;CHN 0B? F;LA?L
NB? P;FO? I@ ^
NB? GIL? CGJILN;HN NB? LIF? JF;S?> <S NB? G;LNCHA;F? L?MNLC=
NCIH "IL JL;=NC=;F JOLJIM?M
CH ; WLMN LOH ^ G;S <? M?N ?KO;F NI ;H> CH ;
M?=IH> LOH ?KO;F NI /IG? IJNCGCT?LM ;FFIQ @IL ;H ?RJFC=CN CGJF?G?HN;NCIH
I@ NB? G;LNCHA;F? =IH>CNCIH ;M ;H ?KO;FCNS =IHMNL;CHN
*IHMNLO=NOL;F +JNCIH ,LC=CHA
2A=>;.< 8/ 1B9.;0.86.=;2, />7,=287<
<;>CL ;H> .I=ECHA?L I<M?LP? NB;N IJNCIH JLC=?M CHPIFP? ;H ?RJ?=N;NCIH
QB?L?;M NB? .* CHPIFP?M M?=IH>IL>?L >?LCP;NCP?M 0B?S L?=IAHCT? NB;N C@ NB?
>?HMCNS =IOF> <? L?JL?M?HN?> ;M ; JIFSHIGC;F
NB?H CHN?AL;NCIH NB?L?I@ QIOF>
?;MCFS SC?F> NB? 013 "OLNB?LGIL?
NLOH=;N?> ?RJ?=N;NCIHM =IOF> ;FMI <? ?;MCFS
=IGJON?> +H? =IHP?HC?HN Q;S NI L?JL?M?HN >?HMCNC?M CM <S OMCHA NB? MI=;FF?>
A?H?L;FCT?> BSJ?LA?IG?NLC= @OH=NCIHM
, *J
( (
J
F
E ZE
J 2K Z *F
K (
( ( K F F
E Q
E
QB?L?
H Q
H
E H
H
H Q
(
H
QB?L? (
CM NB? CH=IGJF?N?A;GG; @OH=NCIH
Z
CM NB? MN;H>;L> HILG;F
013
;H> MCAH Z
CM NB? MCAH @OH=NCIH
"IL >IO<F? CHN?AL;FM I@ >?HMCNC?M
; GCRNOL? NB;N ?RN?H>M NB? =;M?M M??H
;<IP? CM ACP?H <S
= =
/ Z
J J Z
M H H Z T
2 H H
I Z T
H
2 H H
I Z T
(
QB?L? H
( H
* # '(
I ( I 0B? CH>C=;NIL @OH=NCIH CM L?KOCL?> NI
L?JL?M?HN ; =IGJIH?HN I@ NB? >?HMCNS QCNB <IOH>?> MOJJILN %N CM ;FMI ?HIOAB
@IL E??JCHA NB? @OH=NCIH L?;FP;FO?> @IL A?H?L;F P;FO?M I@ I ;H> I
*IN ;FF NB? J;L;G?N?LM CH /
;L? @L?? NI P;LS OHL?F;N?>FS
<?=;OM? MIG?
L?MNLC=NCIHM ;L? H??>?> @IL NB? @OH=NCIH NI <? NB? CHN?AL;F I@ ; WKM A;CH
NB?
J;L;G?N?LM GOMN <? HOG?LC=;FFS ?MNCG;N?> 0B? .* CM P?LS ?;MCFS I<N;CH?>
<S >?LCP;NCIH I@ ; JIFSHIGC;F
/?GCJ;L;G?NLC= G?NBI>M
.CME H?ONL;FCNS =;H <? CGJIM?> ;M MOAA?MN?> <S #?L<?L ;H> /BCO <S
CGJIMCHA NB? @IFFIQCHA G;LNCHA;F? =IH>CNCIH
I. W < ( X <
?N LL '
. W( X
2 Z H( I( W( X
2 a Z H( I
W( X
(
QB?L? a Z H( I
Z*I
< *
Z*I
< ' 0B? 013 I@ NB? <?N; >CMNLC<ONCIH CM
CGJF?G?HN?> CH GI>?LH G;NLCR F;HAO;A?M %H NB? ?MNCG;NCIH I@ NB? .* @LIG
;=NO;F IJNCIH JLC=?M
CN CM CGJILN;HN NI CGJIM? NB? G;LNCHA;F? L?MNLC=NCIH
%.629*;*6.=;2, 6.=18-<
-0.@8;=1 .A9*7<287<
%H NBCM M?=NCIH
Q? IONFCH? NB? G?NBI> >?P?FIJ?> <S &;LLIQ ;H> .O>>
@IL QBC=B ; HOG?LC=;F ;JJFC=;NCIH =;H <? @IOH> CH ILL;>I ;H> /O 0B?
*IHMNLO=NOL;F +JNCIH ,LC=CHA
C>?; I@ &;LLIQ ;H> .O>> CM NI =;JNOL? >?PC;NCIHM @LIG FIAHILG;FCNS
<S ;H !>A?QILNB ?RJ;HMCIH I@ NB? .* X ?4 )
;LIOH> NB? FIAHILG;F >?H
MCNS 0B? =IHMNLO=NCIH I@ ;H !>A?QILNB ?RJ;HMCIH CM =IH=?JNO;FFS MCGCF;L
NI =IGJONCHA ; 0;SFIL ?RJ;HMCIH <ON ;JJFC?M NI @OH=NCIHM CH A?H?L;F ;H> NI
>?HMCNC?M CH J;LNC=OF;L %H ; =IHP?HNCIH;F 0;SFIL ?RJ;HMCIH
NB? @OH=NCIH CM
;JJLIRCG;N?> <S ; MCGJF? JIFSHIGC;F ;LIOH> ; ACP?H JICHN $?L?
NB? ;=
NO;F OHEHIQH .* CM ;JJLIRCG;N?> <S ;H ?RJ;HMCIH ;LIOH> ; FIAHILG;F
>CMNLC<ONCIH =F?;L ;>P;HN;A? I@ NB? ?RJ;HMCIH ;JJLI;=B CM NB;N NB? ;J
JLIRCG;NCIH
<S CHPIFPCHA J;L;G?N?LM NB;N =;H <? P;LC?>
;FFIQM A?H?L;NCHA
GIL? A?H?L;F @OH=NCIHM +NB?L MNO>C?M OMCHA NB? !>A?QILNB ?RJ;HMCIHM ;L?
"F;GIOLCM ;H> #C;GIOLC>CM
;H> ?<?L ;H> L;H>N
%H NB? H?RN M?=NCIH
Q? QCFF JL?M?HN ;H ;FN?LH;NCP? M?GCJ;L;G?NLC= ;J
JLI;=B JLIJIM?> <S );>;H ;H> )CFH? <;M?> IH NB? $?LGCN? ;JJLIRC
G;NCIH I@ NB? #;OMMC;H >?HMCNS FNBIOAB NB? NQI L?MOFNCHA .* M ;L? =IH=?J
NO;FFS >C_?L?HN
<?=;OM? NB?S ;L? <;M?> IH >C_?L?HN ;JJLIRCG;NCIH G?NBI>M
1E V \I
'
E
Q
0BOM
C@ NB? =B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH 1 '
CM EHIQH
<S N;ECHA ;H ?RJ;HMCIH
I@ CNM FIA;LCNBG ;LIOH> \
CN CM JIMMC<F? NI I<N;CH NB? =OGOF;HNM 3?
B;P? NB? @IFFIQCHA L?F;NCIHMBCJM <?NQ??H =OGOF;HNM ;H> GIG?HNM OJ NI NB?
@IOLNB IL>?L 1 1?4 ( 1 B ?4 ( 1
1 ?4 1?4
( 1
1 ?4 1?4
B ?4 0B? EHIQF?>A? I@ NB? WLMN @IOL =OGOF;HNM CM
NB?L?@IL?
?KOCP;F?HN NI EHIQCHA NB? G?;H
P;LC;H=?
ME?QH?MM
;H> EOLNIMCM
&;LLIQ ;H> .O>> MBIQ NB;N ;H !>A?QILNB ?RJ;HMCIH I@ NB? @IOLNB IL>?L
@IL NB? NLO? JLI<;<CFCNS >CMNLC<ONCIH = ;LIOH> NB? FIAHILG;F 013 8 =;H <?
QLCNN?H
;@N?L CGJIMCHA NB;N NB? WLMN GIG?HN I@ NB? ;JJLIRCG;NCHA >?HMCNS
;H> NB? NLO? >?HMCNS ;L? ?KO;F
1 , ;H> <S >?HINCHA >?HMCNC?M QCNB
MG;FF F?NN?LM
1 , K S Z
1
,
K
S Z
X Z
S Z
KZ KZ
1 ,
1 ,
K S Z
Z
(
KZ
!>A?QILNB ?RJ;HMCIHM ;L? @L?KO?HNFS OM?> CH MN;NCMNC=;F NB?ILS NI I<N;CH >CMNLC<
ONCIHM NB;N >?PC;N? @LIG NB? HILG;F IH? L?F;N?> ;JJLI;=B B;M <??H @IFFIQ?>
CH B;JN?L NI >?M=LC<? NB? HIHHILG;F =IH>CNCIH;F >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ L?NOLHM
/?GCJ;L;G?NLC= G?NBI>M
QB?L? Z
=;JNOL?M N?LGM H?AF?=N?> CH NB? ?RJ;HMCIH 0B? P;LCIOM N?LGM CH NB?
?RJ;HMCIH =ILL?MJIH> NI ;>DOMNG?HNM I@ NB? P;LC;H=?
ME?QH?MM
;H> EOLNIMCM
M ;LAO?> <?@IL?
NB? CHN?LJL?N;NCIH I@ NBCM ?RJL?MMCIH CM MCGCF;L NI ; 0;SFIL
?RJ;HMCIH
&;LLIQ ;H> .O>> @OLNB?L MBIQ NB;N
OH>?L NBCM ;JJLIRCG;N?> >?HMCNS
NB?
JLC=? I@ ; !OLIJ?;H =;FF IJNCIH QCNB MNLCE? 7 =;H <? ;JJLIRCG;N?> ;M
.
/ =
LL ?4 7
X ?4
K?4
+
.
LL ?4 7
S ?4
K?4
+
.
1 , K S ?4
LL ?4 7
K?4
+ K?4
.
1
,
K
S ?4
LL ?4 7
K?4
+ K?4
.
L 1 ,
1 ,
K S ?4
L ?4 7
K?4 '
+ K?4
3? HINC=? NB;N NB? WLMN N?LG CM MCGJFS NB? F;=E/=BIF?M @ILGOF; %H ;>>CNCIH
/ =
/ 8
LL S 7
LL4
K?4
1 ,
1 ,
K S 7
, ?N LL (
, , $ (
,
, $
$ $
(
, , $
$
$ $
$
(
QB?L? $ L
;H> QB?L? NB? WLMN L?F;NCIH @IFFIQM @LIG LCMEH?ONL;F
P;FO;NCIH
&;LLIQ ;H> .O>> MOAA?MN C>?HNC@SCHA NB? M?=IH> GIG?HN <S CGJIMCHA
, 1 0BCM ;LAOG?HN CM ;FMI DOMNCW?> IH HOG?LC=;F ALIOH>M <S ILL;>I
;H> /O QBI HINC=? NB;N QCNBION NBCM =IH>CNCIH NB?L? ?RCMNM ; JLI<F?G
I@ GOFNC=IFCH?;LCNS <?NQ??H NB? M?=IH> ;H> NB? @IOLNB GIG?HN .;NB?L NB;H
*IHMNLO=NOL;F +JNCIH ,LC=CHA
1
$ $
(
1
1
1
$
$ $
$ '
1
F?;LFS
NB?M? ?RJL?MMCIHM ;FMI BIF> @IL NB? FIAHILG;F >?HMCNS 0B? ME?QH?MM
;H> EOLNIMCM I@ NB? FIAHILG;F >?HMCNS =;H NB?L?@IL? <? >?LCP?> ?;MCFS @LIG
NB? =OGOF;HNM ;<IP?
3CNB NB? ;MMOGJNCIH I@ ?KO;FCNS I@ NB? M?=IH> =OGOF;HNM @IL NB? ;JJLIRC
G;NCHA ;H> NB? NLO? >CMNLC<ONCIH
CN @IFFIQM NB;N
L
, KS 7
/ =
/ 8
L 1 ,
K?4
, K S 7
LL 1 ,
'
K?4
1MCHA NBCM ?RJL?MMCIH
CN CM ?;MS NI ?MNCG;N? QCNB HIHFCH?;L F?;MN MKO;L?M NB?
CGJFC?> PIF;NCFCNS
ME?QH?MM
1
;H> EOLNIMCM
1
0B? ?RJL?MMCIH I@ NB? .* =;H <? I<N;CH?> ;@N?L NQC=? >C_?L?HNC;NCHA
QCNB L?MJ?=N NI 7 ;H> NB?H ?P;FO;NCIH IP?L ?4
, K
S ?4
, K S ?4
X ?4
S ?4
1 ,
1 ,
(
K?4 K?4
QB?L? NB? J;LNC;F >?LCP;NCP?M =;H <? =IGJON?> CN?L;NCP?FS OMCHA
KS ?4
&)# ?4
T S ?4
(
K?4 ?4
K S ?4
&)# ?4
T
KS ?4
S ?4
(
K?4 ?4 K?4 ?4
K
S ?4
&)# ?4
T
K S ?4
KS ?4
K?4 ?4 K ?4 ?4 K?4
S ?4
(
?4
K S ?4
&)# ?4
T
K
S ?4
K S ?4
K?4
?4 K ?4 ?4 K?4
KS ?4
S ?4
(
?4 K?4 ?4
;H> QB?L? T &)# ?N
Y *
0BIM? =IGJON;NCIHM CH>C=;N? NB;N NB?
.* CH NB? !>A?QILNB =;M? QCFF <? ; JIFSHIGC;F QBIM? =I?^=C?HNM >CL?=NFS
/?GCJ;L;G?NLC= G?NBI>M
=IGG;H> NB? ME?QH?MM ;H> EOLNIMCM I@ NB? .* 3? ;FMI HINC=? NB;N NB? .*
CHPIFP?M L;NB?L =IGJFC=;N?> N?LGM QCNB >?LCP;NCP?M I@ NB? FIAHILG;F >?HMCNS
0B? ?RJL?MMCIH I@ NB?M? >?LCP;NCP?M =;H <? I<N;CH?> OMCHA MNL;CABN@ILQ;L>
=IGJON;NCIHM
.;62=. 985B7862*5<
H ;FN?LH;NCP?
S?N MCGCF;L
M?GCJ;L;G?NLC= ;JJLI;=B L?FC?M IH ;H ;JJLIRCG;
NCIH I@ NB? #;OMMC;H >?HMCNS <;M?> IH $?LGCN? JIFSHIGC;FM 0B? NB?IL?NC=;F
@IOH>;NCIH I@ NBCM G?NBI> CM ?F;<IL;N?> CH );>;H ;H> )CFH? ;H> ;J
JFC?> CH <E?H
);>;H
;H> .;G;GOLNC? ;H> ION;HN
&IH>?;O
;H>
.I=ECHA?L
0B? GI>?F >?M=LC<?> <S );>;H ;H> )CFH? QILEM ;M @IFFIQM "CLMN
@IL
HOG?LC=;F L?;MIHM
NB?S =IHMC>?L NB? G;J @LIG NB? ;=NO;F JLC=?M CHNI NB? MJ;=?
A?H?L;N?> <S MN;H>;L>CT?> FIAL?NOLH
+ a
>?HINCHA IH=? ;A;CH NB? PIF;NCFCNS IP?L
NB? BILCTIH I@ NB? IJNCIH ;M Z
&)# ?4 *?N
Z *
?4 ?N "/* Z Za a '
Z
0B? MN;H>;L>CT?> FIAL?NOLH a B;M T?LI G?;H ;H> OHCN P;LC;H=?
%@ Q? @I=OM IH ; =;FF IJNCIH
NB? J;SI_ I@ MO=B ;H IJNCIH
;M ; @OH=NCIH I@
a( CM
J a( ?N ( 7( ( Z(
' / ?N "/* Z Za 7( N a
(
MI NB;N NB? JLC=? I@ ; =;FF IJNCIH G;S <? QLCNN?H ;M
.
/ ?N ( 7( ( Z( ( Y
LL J a( ?N ( 7( ( Z(
XT a
Ka
.
LL N a
XT a
Ka(
*IQ
Q? ;MMOG? NB;N ;HS J;SI_ N a
G;S <? ?RJL?MM?> ;M ; @OH=NCIH I@
<;MCM ?F?G?HNM %N NOLHM ION NB;N ; <;MCM @IL NB? #;OMMC;H MJ;=? CM ACP?H <S
$?LGCN? JIFSHIGC;FM %H INB?L QIL>M
NB?L? ?RCMN L?;F HOG<?LM HF MO=B NB;N
;HS J;SI_ =;H <? QLCNN?H ;M
,
N a
HF OF a
(
F
+
QCNB HF T N a
OF a
a
Ka( QB?L? a
CM NB? #;OMMC;H >CMNLC<ONCIH ;H>
OF a
>?HIN?M $?LGCN? JIFSHIGC;FM HILG;FCT?> NI OHCN P;LC;H=?
>?WH?> ;M
O a
(
O a
a(
O a
+ a
(
O
a
+ a a (
O a
+ a a '
0B? =I?^=C?HNM HF =;H <? CHN?LJL?N?> ;M NB? =IP;LC;H=? <?NQ??H NB? IJNCIH
J;SI_ ;H> NB? RNB $?LGCN? JIFSHIGC;F LCME IHM?KO?HNFS
NB? JLC=? I@ NB?
=;FF IJNCIH <?=IG?M
, .
L
/ ?N ( 7( ( Z( ( Y
L HF OF a
XT a
Ka'
F T
"CH;FFS
);>;H ;H> )CFH? ;MMOG? NB;N NB? .* XT a
=;H <? L?JL?
M?HN?> ;M NB? JLI>O=N I@ ; =B;HA? I@ G?;MOL? >?HMCNS ;H> ; L?@?L?H=? G?;MOL?
>?HMCNS
XT a
a
a
'
$?L?
NB? L?@?L?H=? G?;MOL? >?HMCNS a
CM MCGJFS NB? #;OMMC;H IH? ;H> NB?
LCMEH?ONL;F =B;HA? I@ G?;MOL? >?HMCNS a
CM ;JJLIRCG;N?> <S ; $?LGCN?
JIFSHIGC;F ?RJ;HMCIH
,
a
LL G OG a
'
G
G
I
I
a
+ a a
+ a a
(
QB?L? NB? ID LL D ( P (
;L? NB? @ONOL? P;FO? I@ NB? PNB JLC=? I@ LCME
=I?^=C?HN NI <? ?MNCG;N?> 0B? J;L;G?N?LM I
;H> I =ILL?MJIH> NI NB?
ME?QH?MM ;H> EOLNIMCM C@ NB? L?@?L?H=? G?;MOL? >?HMCNS I@ a CM =BIM?H NI <? NB?
HILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH %N CM CGJILN;HN NI ?GJB;MCT? NB;N OHFCE? NB? !>A?QILNB
=;M?
MCH=? ; @OLNB?L =B;HA? I@ P;LC;<F? @LIG a NI ?4 B;M NI <? G;>?
I
;H>
I QCFF HIN =ILL?MJIH> NI NB? ME?QH?MM ;H> EOLNIMCM I@ NB? OH>?LFSCHA JLC=?
JLI=?MM ?4 <ON NI NB? ME?QH?MM ;H> EOLNIMCM I@ FIAL?NOLHM a "CH;FFS
NB?
ME?QH?MM ;H> EOLNIMCM I@ NB? ?RJ;HMCIH ;L? ACP?H <S
+
?R a I
(
+
7\ a I '
0B? ?MNCG;NCIH I@ NB? J;L;G?N?LM
I
;H> I =;H <? ?;MCFS J?L@ILG?>
OMCHA ; HIHFCH?;L ?MNCG;NCIH ;M CH>C=;N?> CH
0B? A?H?L;F ?RJL?MMCIH @IL NB? JLC=? I@ ; =;FF IJNCIH CM ACP?H <S
,
, .
,
/ ?N ( 7( ( Z( ( Y
HF G OG a
OF a
a
Ka HF F (
F G T F
QB?L? NB? M?=IH> ?KO;FCNS BIF>M <?=;OM? $?LGCN? JIFSHIGC;FM @ILG ;H ILNBI
HILG;F MSMN?G 3B?H NB? CHWHCN? MOG CM NLOH=;N?> OJ NI NB? @IOLNB IL>?L
Q?
I<N;CH
/ ?N ( 7( ( Z( ( Y
LL H
H
H '
0B?L?@IL?
CN L?G;CHM NI <? MBIQH BIQ NI I<N;CH NB? HF =I?^=C?HNM <E?H
);>;H
;H> .;G;GOLNC? CHNLI>O=? NB? =;FF IJNCIH A?H?L;NCHA @OH=NCIH
.
3 \( ?N ( 7( ( Z(
+ J a( ?N ( 7( ( Z(
"/* a \
Ka(
*IHMNLO=NOL;F +JNCIH ,LC=CHA
QB?L? \ CM ; >OGGS P;LC;<F? 0B? =I?^=C?HNM HF =;H NB?H <? I<N;CH?> @LIG
NB? A?H?L;NCHA @OH=NCIH ;M
, F 3 \( ?N ( 7( ( Z( ( Y
HF ?N ( 7( ( Z(
F + '
,\ O R
3 \( ?N ( 7( ( Z(
?N "/* Z\
K \
7
K \
QB?L? K \
&)# ?N *7
*Z *Z Z*
\( ;H> K \
K \
Z' "LIG
NB?L? IH
CN CM JIMMC<F? NI =IGJON? NB? =I?^=C?HNM HF ' 0I >I MI
Q? CHNLI>O=?
NB? HIN;NCIH KE KE
( NB;N CM Q? ?P;FO;N? NB? KE
;N T?LI 3? I<N;CH ;@N?L
N?>CIOM =IGJON;NCIHM
;H> CHNLI>O=CHA NB? HIN;NCIHM ( ( ;H> ( @IL NB?
WLMN
M?=IH>
;H> NBCL> >?LCP;NCP?M I@ ; MN;H>;L> HILG;F >?HMCNS QCNB L?MJ?=N
NI CNM ;LAOG?HN
H ?N L
K
7
K
(
H Z?N L
K
?N L K
7 K
(
H + Z ?N L
K
Z?N L K
?N L
K
7
K
(
H
+ Z ?N L
K
Z ?N L K
Z?N L
K
?N L
K
7
K
(
H + Z ?N L
K
Z
?N L K
Z ?N L
K
5
Z?N L
K
?N L
K
7
K
'
879*;*6.=;2, 6.=18-<
%9527. 6.=18-<
'
WLMN C>?;
QBC=B CM ;=NO;FFS OM?> <S /BCGEI
CM NI OM? ; KO;>L;NC= JIFS
HIGC;F @IL 7
"ILG;FFS
B? MOJJIM?M NB;N
D H H 7D H 7D ( @IL P ( ( :(
7
H H 7 H 7 H
7
(
7D
H H
7D (
7
7D
7D
'
7D 7D 7D 7D
%HN?AL;NCHA NBCM ?RJL?MMCIH NQC=? QCNB L?MJ?=N NI 7 ACP?M
7 7D
7 7D
7
7D
7D
J J 7'
7D 7D
7D 7D
7 7D
7 7D
7
7D
7D
7D 7D
7D 7D
D
7D
7D 7D
7 7D
7D 7D
D
7D
7D 7D
7 7D
'
7D 7D
S >C_?L?HNC;NCHA NBCM ?RJL?MMCIH ;H> N;ECHA CHNI ;==IOHN NB? @;=N NB;N NB?
>?LCP;NCP? MBIOF> <? =IHNCHOIOM ;N NB? HI>?M
Q? I<N;CH WH;FFS NB? MSMN?G I@
?KO;NCIHM @IL P ( ( :
7D 7D 7D 7D 7D 7D
7D
7D
7D
D D D D
'
7D 7D 7D 7D
%H INB?L QIL>M
Q? B;P? ; MSMN?G I@ : ?KO;NCIHM CH NB? : OH
EHIQH
7D
' 0I MIFP? NBCM MSMN?G
;>>CNCIH;F ;MMOGJNCIHM H??> NI <? G;>?
+H? I@ NB?G =IH=?LHM NB? <IOH>;LC?M "IL CHMN;H=?
Q? G;S ;MMOG? NB;N
NB?L? CM HI =IHP?RCNS ;N NB? <IOH>;LC?M 0BCM CM ?KOCP;F?HN NI ;MMOGCHA NB;N
7
7.
%N CM QILNB HINCHA NB;N ?;=B I@ NB? J;L;G?N?LM NB;N
Q? NLS NI =IGJON? CM IHFS FCHE?> NI CNM H?;L?MN H?CAB<ILM %H ; G;NLCR L?JL?
M?HN;NCIH
Q? QIOF> I<N;CH ; MI=;FF?> NLC>C;AIH;F MSMN?G
QBC=B =;H <? P?LS
?^=C?HNFS MIFP?> OMCHA NB? ;FAILCNBG >?M=LC<?> CH ,L?MM
0?OEIFMES
2?NN?LFCHA
/ /$ [( ?( 7( @
?
K 7
LL 7
K 7
'
IHM?KO?HNFS
NB? .* N;E?M NB? ?RJL?MMCIH
, / [( ?( 7
( @
X /$ 7
LL
,7
L ? K K 7
K
K K 7
K
K 7
L
7 K
K 7
K
K K 7
'
QB?L? NB? @OH=NCIH
" CM NB? CH>C=;NIL @OH=NCIH N;ECHA NB? P;FO? C@ - CM
NLO? 0B? WLMN ;H> M?=IH>IL>?L >?LCP;NCP?M I@ K ;H> K ;L? ACP?H <S
+
7
?
+
K 7
&)# L
+
7
(
7
7L 7 7
+
K
7
K
7
7
(
+
7
7
7
?
7
K
7
+
&)#
7
7LL 7 7
+ +
7
7
7
+
7
(
7 7
+
K
7
K
7
7
(
7
H H 7
+ + ;H> ++ (
7
H + + ;H> ++ '
+H? I@ NB? >C^=OFNC?M QB?H Q? WN ; =O<C= MJFCH? NI ;=NO;F >;N; CM NB;N
NB? CHN?LJIF;N?> =OLP? N?H>M NI IM=CFF;N? MNLIHAFS FCMM ;H> ,;HCACLNTIAFIO
MOAA?MN NI OM? @:<<A521 @=96;2@ 0B?M? ;ONBILM NB?L?@IL? L?=IGG?H>
NB? @IFFIQCHA JLI=?>OL? M ; WLMN MN?J
NB?S JLIJIM? NI M??E ; MJFCH? M;NCM@SCHA
,. .
'%( E 7E
^E
7
G;N=B NB? CGJFC?> PIF;NCFCNS ;N ?;=B MNLCE? 0B? WLMN N?LG NB?L?@IL? G?;MOL?M
NB? AII>H?MM I@ WN %@ Q? J?L@ILG?> ; FCH?;L CHN?LJIF;NCIH 7
H H 7
NB? M?=IH> N?LG QIOF> <? ?KO;F NI T?LI "IL ; BCABFS IM=CFF;NCHA @OH=NCIH
Q?
?RJ?=N F;LA? F?P?FM I@ NB? =OLP;NOL?
C?
I@ NB? M?=IH> GIG?HN
;H> NB?L?@IL?
; L;NB?L F;LA? CHN?AL;F 0B? M?=IH> N?LG I@ NB? ?RJL?MMCIH NB?L?@IL? G?;MOL?M
NB? MGIINBH?MM I@ NB? MJFCH? 0B? MIFONCIH QCFF <? ; NL;>?I_ <?NQ??H AII>H?MM
I@ WN ;H> MGIINBH?MM 0B? J;L;G?N?L CM ; J?H;FNS @IL NB? LIOABH?MM I@ NB?
@OH=NCIH
3?CH<?LA MOAA?MNM NI ;FFIQ NB? MGIINBCHA J;L;G?N?L NI P;LS IP?L
NCG?
MI NB;N NB? ;GIOHN I@ MGIINBH?MM G;S P;LS >?J?H>CHA IH NB? >;N; 0B?
;JJLI;=B CM <;M?> IH NB? G?NBI> I@ A?H?L;FCT?> =LIMMP;FC>;NCIH
;M >?M=LC<?>
CH 3;B<; 0B? C>?; =IHMCMNM
@IL ; ACP?H P;FO? I@
CH MIFPCHA NB?
E
MJFCH? JLI<F?G <S IGCNNCHA ?;=B I<M?LP;NCIH Q CH NOLH (?N 7E
>?HIN? NB? ?MNCG;N?> MGCF? GCHCGCTCHA @IL ; ACP?H QCNB I<M?LP;NCIH
Q IGCNN?> 0B?H
NB? IJNCG;F CM NB? P;FO? NB;N GCHCGCT?M NB? ?LLIL
.
,
E
^E E 7E
'
E
*IHMNLO=NOL;F +JNCIH ,LC=CHA
0BCM ;JJLI;=B L?>O=?M NB? ?_?=N IH NB? ?MNCG;N?> PIF;NCFCNS MGCF? I@ JIMMC<F?
IONFC?LM CH NB? >;N;
%H .* ;JJFC=;NCIHM
CN CM ;FMI H?=?MM;LS NI ?RNL;JIF;N? NB? MJFCH? <?
SIH> NB? L;HA? I@ ;P;CF;<F? MNLCE?M 3CNBION ;HS =IHNLIF
NB? ?RNL;JIF;NCIH
=IOF> F?;> NI H?A;NCP? P;FO?M I@ NB? CGJFC?> PIF;NCFCNS FCMM ;H> ,;HCACLNTIAFIO
NB?L?@IL?
MOAA?MN NI ?RNL;JIF;N? MGIINBFS CH ; BILCTIHN;F G;HH?L 0I
>I NBCM
NB?S CHNLI>O=? NQI JM?O>I>;N; JICHNM MJ;=?> NBL?? MNLCE? CHN?LP;FM
;<IP? ;H> <?FIQ NB? L;HA? I@ MNLCE? JLC=?M ;H> M?NNCHA NB? CGJFC?> PIF;NCFCNC?M
?KO;F NI NB? IH?M I@ NB? ?RNL?G?MNLCE? IJNCIHM
M ; M?=IH> MN?J
NB? MJFCH? CM ?P;FO;N?> ;N ; BOA? HOG<?L I@ JICHNM
M;S
0B?M? JICHNM CH MNLCE?PIF;NCFCNS MJ;=? A?N =IHP?LN?> CHNI JLC=?
MNLCE? P;FO?M +H=? NB?M? JICHNM ;L? I<N;CH?>
NB? =;FF JLC=?M ;L? HOG?LC=;FFS
>C_?L?HNC;N?> NQC=? NI SC?F> NB? ?MNCG;N?> =13
OG;M
"F?GCHA
;H> 3B;F?S CHP?MNCA;N? M?P?L;F MJ?=CW=;NCIHM I@
MO=B >?N?LGCHCMNC= PIF;NCFCNS @OH=NCIHM %H ; JLC=CHA =IHN?RN
NB?S I<N;CH NB;N
NB?M? GI>?FM >I HIN J?L@ILG MCAHCW=;HNFS <?NN?L NB;H ;> BI= JLI=?>OL?M NB;N
MGIINB F;=E/=BIF?M CGJFC?> PIF;NCFCNC?M ;=LIMM ?R?L=CM? JLC=?M ;H> BILCTIHM
&;..+*<.- 6.=18-<
NL??<;M?> G?NBI> NI ?RNL;=N .* M ION I@ WH;H=C;F IJNCIHM B;M <??H JL?
M?HN?> <S .O<CHMN?CH 0BCM G?NBI> CM @OLNB?L ?RN?H>?> CH &;=EQ?LNB
;H> .O<CHMN?CH ;H> &;=EQ?LNB &;=EQ?LNB ACP?M ; HO
G?LC=;F CFFOMNL;NCIH I@ NB? G?NBI> 0B? C>?; I@ NB?M? G?NBI>M CM <;M?> IH NB?
@IFFIQCHA MN?JM "CLMN
Q? N;E? ?RCMNCHA IJNCIHM H?;L?MN NI NB? GIH?S NB?H
MO<D?=N NI
! )H
# E <E )
( <E ( Q ( ( T(
H
?N LL E ?E <E (
" )H
/ D LL E <E ?E 7D
( P
( ( :'
0B? WLMN =IHMNL;CHN JLIPC>?M =IH>CNCIHM MI NB;N NB? P;FO?M <E >?WH? JLI<;<CF
CNC?M 0B? M?=IH> =IH>CNCIH =ILL?MJIH>M NI NB? G;LNCHA;F? =IH>CNCIH "CH;FFS
,H
<E <E
'%( (
0!
E
<E
H
,
'%( <E <E (
0!
E
IL
H
, <E
'%( <E &)# '
0!
E
<E
QB?L? ;M <?@IL? X
L?JL?M?HNM NB? .* 0B? ?HNLIJS =;H <? PC?Q?> ;M ;
G?NLC=
QBIM? G;RCGCT;NCIH QCFF ACP? NB? .* QCNB NB? :.E6:B: JIMMC<F?
CH@ILG;NCIH =IHN?HN
0B? =IHMNL;CHNM =;H <? QLCNN?H ;M
.
X _
K_
(
.
JD _
X _
K_ /D *LL ( P
( ( :(
.
_X _
K_ ?N '
!KO;NCIH CHMOL?M NB;N X CM ; >?HMCNS !KO;NCIH L?F;N?M NB? .*
NI NB? PNB =;FF IJNCIH 0B? F;MN ?KO;NCIH CM NB? G;LNCHA;F? L?MNLC=NCIH
);RCGCT;NCIH I@ NB? ?HNLIJS MO<D?=N NI NB? =IHMNL;CHNM ]
CM >IH? <S G;RCGCT;NCIH I@ ; $;GCFNIHC;H QB?L? NB? GOFNCJFC?LM QCFF
<? QLCNN?H ;M D O=B?H ;H> '?FFS MBIQ NB;N NB? .* CM ?KO;F NI
)
.
"/* D D JD _
X _
+ ) '
.
"/* D D JD _
K_
F?;LFS
NB? GOFNCJFC?LM GOMN <? ?MNCG;N?> HOG?LC=;FFS 0BCM G;S <? ?F?A;HNFS
;=BC?P?> @IFFIQCHA AGIH
FB;MMC>
;H> (?PCH? ;
< /?? ;FMI
B;JN?L @IL GIL? ?RJF;H;NCIHM IH BIQ NI J?L@ILG NBCM ?MNCG;NCIH
.;7.5 ;.0;.<<287
(
$
D
FD ?DN ( 7D ( D ( YDN
;H> / FD
CM ; NQC=?=IHNCHOIOMFS >C_?L?HNC;<F? @OH=
NCIH I@ FD 0B? MN;NCMNC=;F JLI=?>OL? ;>IJN?> <S hN/;B;FC; ;H> (I CM
HIHJ;L;G?NLC= E?LH?F L?AL?MMCIH %N =IHMCMNM CH ?MNCG;NCHA NB? =IH>CNCIH;F ?R
J?=N;NCIH I@ /
=IH>CNCIH?> IH F QCNBION J;L;G?N?LCTCHA NB? @OH=NCIH /
0B? MNL?HANB I@ NBCM ;JJLI;=B FC?M CH NB? @;=N NB;N CN CH=ILJIL;N?M NB? CH@ILG;
NCIH =IHN;CH?> CH NB? =B;L;=N?LCMNC=M FD QCNBION MJ?=C@SCHA ;HS @OH=NCIH;F @ILG
!HNLIJS CM ;H CHNOCNCP?FS ;JJ?;FCHA G?NBI> <?=;OM? CNM G;RCGCT;NCIH SC?F>M NB?
OHC@ILG >?HMCNS C@ NB? IHFS NBCHA NB;N Q? EHIQ CM NB;N NB? MOJJILN CM WHCN? %@
NB? G?;H CM EHIQH
NB? G?NBI> SC?F>M NB? ?RJIH?HNC;F ;H> C@
@OLNB?LGIL?
NB?
P;LC;H=? CM EHIQH
CN ACP?M NB? HILG;F >?HMCNS
IGJ;LCMIH I@ P;LCIOM G?NBI>M
N
X ?4
LL '
,7
+3
; GCRNOL? I@ FIAHILG;FM JLIPC>?M L;NB?L AII> L?MOFNM <ON NB;N NBCM MBIOF>
BIQ?P?L
<? =IGJF?G?HN?> <S NB? ?MNCG;NCIH I@ ; GI>?F NB;N ;FFIQM @IL DOGJM
OLCHA ; NLIO<F?> J?LCI>
NB? DOGJ GI>?F J?L@ILGM <?NN?L
*IHMNLO=NOL;F +JNCIH ,LC=CHA
ION;HN
&IH>?;O
;H> .I=ECHA?L OM? CHN?L?MN L;N?M %H NB;N J;
J?L
NB?S =IGJ;L? NB? GCRNOL? I@ FIAHILG;FM
NB? #L;GB;LFC?L ?RJ;HMCIH
;H> NB? ?HNLIJS<;M?> G?NBI> 0B?S =IGJ;L? NB? P;LCIOM G?NBI>M IH NB?CL
MJ??>
LI<OMNH?MM I@ ?MNCG;NCIH
;H> ?;M? I@ CGJF?G?HN;NCIH A;CH NB?S WH>
NB;N ;FF G?NBI>M JLIPC>? MCGCF;L >?HMCNC?M NB;N ;L? ;FF L;NB?L >CMN;HN @LIG NB?
<?H=BG;LE NB;N QIOF> BIF> OH>?L NB? ;MMOGJNCIH I@ FIAHILG;FCNS "IL CHN?L
?MN L;N?M
NB? G?NBI> <;M?> IH #L;GB;LFC?L ?RJ;HMCIH ;JJ?;LM NI JLIPC>?
L;NB?L MN;<F? L?MOFNM
FCMM ;H> ,;HCALCTIAFIO =IGJ;L? NB? LI<OMNH?MM I@ NQI GI>?FM
NB? GCRNOL? I@ NQI FIAHILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIHM ;H> ; MGIINB?> CGJFC?> PIF;NCFCNS
MGCF? GI>?F
CH NB? MJCLCN I@ /BCGEI 0B?S CHP?MNCA;N? NB? =IHM?KO?H=?M
I@ >C_?L?HN JIN?HNC;F MIOL=?M I@ ?LLIL CH NB? IJNCIH JLC=?M ] MO=B ;M HIH
MSH=BLIHC=CNS
F;=E I@ FCKOC>CNS IL JLC=? >CM=L?N?H?MM ] IH NB? ?MNCG;NCIH I@ NB?
.* 0B?S WH> NB;N NB? ?MNCG;NCIHM I@ NB? .* M ;L? P?LS OHMN;<F? CH NB?
N;CFM ;H> NB;N AL?;N =;L? MBIOF> <? N;E?H C@ IH? =IGJON?M BCAB?L GIG?HNM
QCNB MIG? H?A;NCP? JLI<;<CFCNC?M 0BCM ECH> I@ P?LS >CM;JJICHNCHA L?MOFNM B;M
<??H NB? <;MCM @IL NB? >?P?FIJG?HN I@ HIHJ;L;G?NLC= ;JJLI;=B?M >?M=LC<?>
;<IP?0B? .* M <;M?> IH NB? A?H?L;FCT?> <?N; >CMNLC<ONCIH
NB? GCRNOL? I@
FIAHILG;FM ;H> IH !>A?QILNB ?RJ;HMCIH ;L? GIL? CH FCH? 0B?S ;L? <INB
=IHMCMN?HN QCNB ; H?A;NCP? ME?QH?MM ;H> QCNB N;CFM NB;N ;L? @;NN?L NB;H NB?
JF;CH P;HCFF; FIAHILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH
0I @OLNB?L =IGJ;L? NB? >C_?L?HN GI>?FM
Q? =B?=E NB? MN;NCMNC=;F JLIJ?L
NC?M I@ NB? P;LCIOM .* M
>CMJF;S?> CH 0;<F? "CLMN
Q? =B?=E BIQ NB?
=IHMNL;CHNM CGJIM?> <S FIA]HILG;FCNS IH NB? NBCL> ;H> @IOLNB GIG?HNM =;H
<C;M NB? P;LC;H=? ?MNCG;N?M /?=IH>
CN CM N?GJNCHA NI =IGJ;L? NB? ?MNCG;N?M
I@ NB? ME?QH?MM ;H> NB? EOLNIMCM I<N;CH?> OH>?L NB? >C_?L?HN .* M
IGJ;LCMIH I@ P;LCIOM G?NBI>M
-3
x 10
2.5
Black-Scholes
Breeden-Litzenberger
2
1.5
0.5
-0.5
4000 5000 6000 7000 8000 9000
20 @A6:.A6<; <3 A52 &" B@6;4 A52 ?2212; .;1 6AG2;/2?42? .==?<.05
-3
x 10
1.4
Black-Scholes
Generalized beta
1.2
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
4000 5000 6000 7000 8000 9000
20 @A6:.A6<; <3 A52 &" B@6;4 A52 2;2?.96G21 2A. 16@A?6/BA6<;
*IHMNLO=NOL;F +JNCIH ,LC=CHA
-3
x 10
1.4
Black-Scholes
Mixture of lognorm als
1.2
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
4000 5000 6000 7000 8000 9000
20 @A6:.A6<; <3 A52 &" B@6;4 A52 !6EAB?2<3 <4;<?:.9 .==?<.05
-3
x 10
1.4
Black-Scholes
Edgew orth Expans ion
1.2
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
4000 5000 6000 7000 8000 9000
20 @A6:.A6<; <3 A52 &" B@6;4 A52 142D<?A5 E=.;@6<; .==?<.05
IGJ;LCMIH I@ P;LCIOM G?NBI>M
&*+5. !<:2;A@ <3 A52 &"@ </A.6;21 D6A5 C.?6<B@ 2@A6:.A6<; :2A5<1@
/N> >?P /E?QH?MM 'OLNIMCM )/! .!
F;=E ;H> /=BIF?M
#?H?L;FCT?> <?N; >CMN
)CRNOL? I@ FIAHILG;F >CMN
!>A?QILNB !RJ;HMCIH
&;=EQ?LNB
NB;N [NB?L? CM ; >;HA?L CH L?;>CHA NII GO=B CH@ILG;NCIH CH
NB? AL;JBM I@ LCMEH?ONL;F >CMNLC<ONCIHM\
/ C ?(
/ ?
>
(
D <
> (
<
QB?L? > CM NB? LCMES ;MM?N L?NOLH
;H> D CM NB? OH=?LN;CH J;SI_ I@ ;MM?N QBIM?
=OLL?HN JLC=? CM < 0B? CHP?MNILZM >?=CMCIH CM NI >?N?LGCH? NB? IJNCGOG F?P?F
I@ ? MI NB;N NB? NIN;F ONCFCNS NI <? >?LCP?> @LIG =OLL?HN ;H> ?RJ?=N?> N?LGCH;F
=IHMOGJNCIHM ;L? G;RCGCT?>
.?F;NCIHMBCJ QCNB L?;F JLI<;<CFCNS
' / A /
1A /
'
3
A
C ?
1
>
A
?
>
(
A
?
>
1
>
(
A C ?
A
/
1 D
< '
A /
*A
/
< LL D M D
KD LL
D ! D
M D
KD'
1A
/
*A
/
0B? KO;HNCNS ! D
CM EHIQH ;M NB? 6;A2?A2:=<?.9 :.?46;.9 ?.A2 <3 @B/@A6AB
A6<;
NB? @A<05.@A60 16@0<B;A 3.0A<? IL NB? =?606;4 82?;29 *IQ
Q? CHNLI>O=?
X D
! D
M D
(
+
;H> HIN? NB;N X D
+ ;H> X D
KD
' $?H=?
X D
G;S <? CHN?LJL?N?>
;M ; JLI<;<CFCNS G?;MOL? )IL? JL?=CM?FS
X D
CM NB?
. .* ;H> M D
CM NB? I<
D?=NCP? >CMNLC<ONCIH /CH=? Q? G;S QLCN? < LL D X D
KD( Q? >CM=IOHN
;H ?RJ?=N?> J;SI_ QCNB NB? LCME@L?? L;N? ;H> NBOM X D
B;M NB? CHN?LJL?N;
NCIH I@ ; .* %N @IFFIQM NB;N C@ Q? B;P? NQI I@ NB? NBL?? ?F?G?HNM
NB? NBCL>
?F?G?HN G;S <? >?>O=?> @LIG NB? INB?L NQI 0BCM IJ?HM NB? >IIL @IL GO=B
L?M?;L=B
*IQ
C@ Q? L?QLCN? ;M
X D
A
/ D
M D
(
&)# X D
&)#
&)# A
/ D
&)# M D
(
/ D
M
D
'
X D
A / D
M D
0B?M? =IGJON;NCIHM MBIQ NB;N NB? G;AHCNO>? I@ ;<MIFON? ;H> L?F;NCP? LCME
;P?LMCIHM
>?WH?> L?MJ?=NCP?FS ;M
A
/ D
- (
A
/ D
/ D
> D
(
A / D
692;2,*5 D7-270<
@?Q J;J?LM B;P? ?RNL;=N?> NB? JLC=CHA E?LH?F <S G;N=BCHA NB? L?;F ;H> NB?
LCMEH?ONL;F >?HMCNC?M GIHA NB?M? J;J?LM
Q? G;S G?HNCIH hN/;B;FC; ;H>
(I
&;=EQ?LNB
;H> .IM?H<?LA ;H> !HAF? 0B?CL =IGGIH
I<D?=NCP? CM NI CHP?MNCA;N? NB? ?GJCLC=;F JLIJ?LNC?M I@ NB? JLC=CHA E?LH?F ;H>
IL
NB? LCME;P?LMCIH @OH=NCIH
0B? NQI ?;LFC?L J;J?LM
hN/;B;FC; ;H> (I ;H> &;=EQ?LNB
%H IJNCIH JLC=CHA
NB? WLMN MCAH NB;N ;MM?N L?NOLHM G;S HIN B;P? ; HILG;F
>CMNLC<ONCIH MOL@;=?> ;M F;=E/=BIF?M CGJFC?> PIF;NCFCNS MGCF? >CM=OMM?> CH NB?
JL?PCIOM =B;JN?L 0B? PIF;NCFCNS MGCF? CM =F?;L ?PC>?H=? NB;N IJNCIHM ;L? JLC=?>
;M C@ NB? N;CFM I@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH ;L? GO=B @;NN?L NB;H NBIM? I@ NB? HILG;F
>CMNLC<ONCIH 0B?L? B;P? <??H G;HS ?RN?HMCIHM NI NB? F;=E/=BIF?M GI>?F
NI N;=EF? NB? MGCF? JLI<F?G GIHA NB?M? ?_ILNM
NB? GIMN QC>?FS MNO>C?> CM
MNI=B;MNC= PIF;NCFCNS IJNCIH JLC=CHA L?X?=NCHA ; QC>? L?=IAHCNCIH NB;N PIF;NCFCNS
CM =B;HACHA NBLIOAB NCG? ;H> G;S ;NNL;=N ; LCME JL?GCOG 0B? H?A;NCP? L?
F;NCIHMBCJ <?NQ??H NB? JLC=? ;H> PIF;NCFCNS JLI=?MM?M B;M ;FMI <??H @L?KO?HNFS
OM?> ;M ;H ?RJF;H;NCIH @IL PIF;NCFCNS ME?Q 0B? =F;MMC=;F MNI=B;MNC= PIF;NCF
CNS IJNCIH JLC=CHA GI>?F CM $?MNIHZM
QB?L? =B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH
;
MJ?=C;F =;M? I@ NB? "IOLC?L NL;HM@ILG
Q;M OM?> @IL NB? WLMN NCG? CH NB? IJ
NCIH JLC=CHA FCN?L;NOL? NI JLI>O=? ; M?GC=FIM?> @ILG MIFONCIH ?P?FIJG?HN CH
IJNCIH JLC=CHA NB?ILS >C> HIN MNIJ B?L? (;N?L
;N?M
CH=FO>?M HIL
G;F >CMNLC<ON?> DOGJM CH ; GI>?F QCNB MNI=B;MNC= PIF;NCFCNS 'IO OM?M
>IO<F??RJIH?HNC;F DOGJM <ON >I?M HIN J?LGCN MNI=B;MNC= PIF;NCFCNS O^?
,;H
;H> /CHAF?NIH JLI>O=?M NB? GIMN A?H?L;F ;^H? >C_OMCIH GI>?F
QB?L? DOGJM ;L? J?LGCNN?> ;N <INB G?;H ;H> PIF;NCFCNS F?P?FM
%=8,1*<=2, ?85*=252=B 68-.5
QC>?FS OM?> MNI=B;MNC= PIF;NCFCNS GI>?F CM >O? NI $?MNIH %N CM <;M?>
IH NB? @IFFIQCHA MNI=E JLC=? ;H> P;LC;H=? >SH;GC=M
+
K?N ?N K[ ?N ]N KFN (
+
K]N ]N
K[ ]N KF N (
2
κ=2, σ=1
1
0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000
1.5
1
0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000
10
κ=2, σ=3
5
0
0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000
20
'6:B9.A21 @>B.?2 ?<<A =?<02@@ D6A5 I
K .;1
(52
<A52? =.?.:2A2?@ .?2 6;160.A21 6; A52 =.;29@
PIF;NCFCNS 0B? P;LC;H=? ]N CH @IFFIQM ; MKO;L? LIIN JLI=?MM ;FMI EHIQH ;M
NB? "?FF?L JLI=?MM IL NB? IR%HA?LMIFF.IMM JLI=?MM M Q? QCFF MBIQ <?FIQ
&1. <:>*;. ;88= 9;8,.<<
QB?L? #N (
' 3? M?F?=N
*( ] ( ;H>
;H> JLI>O=?>
"CAOL? @IL P;LCIOM P;FO?M I@ ;H> 0B? WLMN NL;D?=NILS Q;M I<N;CH?>
QCNB ;H>
' 0B? M?=IH> NL;D?=NILS =ILL?MJIH>M NI ;H>
' 3? HINC=? NB;N <INB NL;D?=NILC?M IM=CFF;N? ;LIOH> NB? FIHALOH G?;H
%N M??GM NB;N CN CM "?FF?L QBI WLMN CHP?MNCA;N?> NBCM JLI=?MM
CH ; MNO>S
I@ J;L;<IFC= M?=IH>IL>?L J;LNC;F >C_?L?HNC;F ?KO;NCIHM "?FF?L OM?M (;JF;=? NL;HM
@ILG N?=BHCKO?M
P?LS GO=B L?F;N?> NI =B;L;N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH N?=BHCKO?M
NI >?LCP?
NB? =IH>CNCIH;F ;H> OH=IH>CNCIH;F >?HMCNC?M IR
%HA?LMIFF
;H> .IMM CH
NLI>O=?> NBCM JLI=?MM NI WH;H=? ;M ; GI>?F @IL CHN?L?MN L;N?M
/NI=B;MNC= PIF;NCFCNS GI>?F
;N ' 3? ;FMI HINC=? NB;N NB? M?=IH> NL;D?=NILS =LIMM?M NB? =?HNL;F P;FO?
GIL? @L?KO?HNFS NB;H NB? WLMN NL;D?=NILS 0B? NBCL> NL;D?=NILS CM I<N;CH?>
QCNB ;H> ' %H NBCM =;M?
NB? ;GIOHN I@ =LIMMCHAM I@ NB? G?;H F?P?F
;L? ;<ION NB? M;G? ;M CH NB? WLMN NL;D?=NILS
<ON NB? P;LC;<CFCNS I@ NB? NBCL>
NL;D?=NILS CM GIL? JLIHIOH=?> 3? =IH=FO>? @LIG NB?M? MCGOF;NCIHM NB;N NB?
MKO;L? LIIN JLI=?MM ]N CM ; =IHNCHOIOM NCG? WLMNIL>?L ;ONIL?AL?MMCP? JLI=?MM
QB?L? ]N CM =IHMN;HNFS JOFF?> NIQ;L> ; G?;H F?P?F
;N ; MJ??> =IHNLIFF?> <S
;H> B;M CNM P;LC;<CFCNS =IHNLIFF?> <S
%85?270 =1. " +*<.- 87 ,1*;*,=.;2<=2, />7,=287
, W ,W ,W
]N ]N
'
,]N ,]N ,[
P* N \
"/* - ( \
. ( \
]N (
CGJFSCHA NB;N ;M
- ( \
( ;H> . ( \
P\' 0B?H @LIG
Q?
B;P?
3? G;E? ; MFCABN ;<OM? I@ HIN;NCIH OMCHA NB? MSG<IF K& ;M ; L;H>IG P;LC;<F? IL
; L?;FCT;NCIH
/NLO=NOL;F +JNCIH ,LC=CHA
,P* N
.P* N
,]N
, P* N
. P* N (
,]N
,P* N ,- ,.
P* N ]N P* N '
,[ ,[ ,[
/O<MNCNON? NB?M? CHNI 0B?H HINC=CHA NB;N P* N
NBCM N?LG G;S <?
MCGJFCW?> !P?HNO;FFS
Q? I<N;CH NB? , !
,- ,.
]N . ]N
. ]N '
,[ ,[
!KO;NCIH GOMN <? NLO? @IL ;FF ]N /I <S WLMN M?NNCHA ]N ;H> NB?H
]N
( Q? M?? NB;N NB? @IFFIQCHA ?KO;NCIHM GOMN <? NLO?
,-
.(
,[
,.
. .(
,[
;A;CH QCNB <IOH>;LS =IH>CNCIHM -
;H> .
P\'
!KO;NCIHM ;H> ;L? =;FF?> NB? &60.AA6 2>B.A6<;@
;H> ;L? NB?
E?S @?;NOL? I@ JLI<F?GM CHPIFPCHA , ! %HMJ?=NCIH I@ MBIQM NB;N CN CM ;
M?=IH>IL>?L IL>CH;LS >C_?L?HNC;F ?KO;NCIH
+ !
NB;N G;S <? MIFP?> >CL?=NFS
+H=? ; MIFONCIH NI CM I<N;CH?>
; MIFONCIH NI G;S <? @IOH>
/IFPCHA NB? J;CL I@ .C=;NNC ?KO;NCIHM ;H> G;HO;FFS =IOF> <? HIH
NLCPC;F
;H> NB? OM? I@ ; MSG<IFC= MIFP?L CM BCABFS L?=IGG?H>?> /O<MNCNONCHA
NB? MIFONCIHM @IL - ;H> . CHNI SC?F>M
P\
\L
P* N \
"/* P ]N
J
P\*J
QB?L?
J '
L
"CH;FFS
<S CHPIECHA NB? "IOLC?L CHP?LMCIH NB?IL?G
>?M=LC<?> CH B;JN?L
2.5
κ=2,σ=1
κ=20,σ=1
κ=2,σ=2
2
1.5
0.5
0
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4
20
<;16A6<;.9 =?</./696AF .A .
1.F 5<?6G<; 3<? D6A5 =.?.:2A2?@ 0<?
?2@=<;16;4 A< A52 @6:B9.A21 A?.720A<?62@ <3 64B?2 (52 0B??2;A C.9B2 & 6@
A.82; .@ A52 @A2.1F @A.A2 92C29
J]N L
J]N ( X
'
%HMJ?=NCIH I@ NB? NL;HMCNCIH JLI<;<CFCNS CH L?P?;FM NB;N NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH
@OH=NCIH CM ; HIH=?HNL;F
?P;FO;N?> ;N J]N
QCNB X >?AL??M I@ @L??
>IG ;H> ;MSGG?NLS J;L;G?N?L
*?RN
<S >C_?L?HNC;NCHA NB? =B;L;=N?LCMNC=
@OH=NCIH ;H> ?P;FO;NCHA CN ;N \ SC?F>M
1]4 )]N ]N L
L (
]N
B ]4 )]N L L
L '
IR
%HA?LMIFF
;H> .IMM HIN? NB;N ;M
NB? ?RJ?=N?> P;FO?
=IHP?LA?M NI ;H> NB? P;LC;H=? NI 0BCM L?MOFN =IHWLGM NB;N =IHNLIFM NB?
MJ??> <S QBC=B ]N L?NOLHM NI CNM G?;H P;FO? M
NB? =IH>CNCIH;F G?;H
CM ?KO;F NI NB? =OLL?HN P;FO? ]N
NB? P;LC;H=? =IHP?LA?M NI ]N '
"CAOL? JL?M?HNM NB? >?HMCNS @OH=NCIH @IL @ [
FF NB? INB?L
J;L;G?N?LM ;L? NB? M;G? ;M NBIM? OM?> @IL NB? MCGOF;NCIHM I@ NB? NL;D?=NILC?M
CH "CAOL? IHN?GJF;NCHA
CN CM ?;MS NI M?? NB;N @IL +
;H> @
( NB? =B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH <?=IG?M
P\
P* N \
'
/NLO=NOL;F +JNCIH ,LC=CHA
Q? I<N;CH NB?
OH=IH>CNCIH;F >?HMCNS
^ QP
MP ]4
] L (
4
QB?L?
^
;H> '
3? L?=IAHCT? NB;N MP ]4
CM NB? >?HMCNS I@ ; A;GG; >CMNLC<ONCIH QCNB G?;H
;H> P;LC;H=? *'
%H NBCM M?=NCIH
Q? B;P? MNO>C?> NB? JLIJ?LNS I@ ; G?;H L?P?LNCHA MKO;L?
LIIN JLI=?MM NB;N @L?KO?HNFS ;JJ?;LM CH NB? MNI=B;MNC= PIF;NCFCNS FCN?L;NOL? 3?
;L? HIQ L?;>S NI N;=EF? NB? @OFF $?MNIH GI>?F ;M ACP?H <S ;H>
$CM GI>?F CHPIFP?M NQI LIQHC;H GINCIHM
B?H=?
; GOFNCP;LC;N? ?RN?HMCIH I@
%NIZM F?GG; CM L?KOCL?> 0BCM F?GG; CM ?RJF;CH?> CH B;JN?L
7.@ 9*;=2*5 -2K.;.7=2*5 .:>*=287
K?N 3 K[ 3 KFN (
K N K[ KF N '
(?N / ?N ( ]N ( [
>?HIN? NB? JLC=? I@ ; =;FF IJNCIH 3? I<N;CH @LIG NB? <CP;LC;N?
%NIZM F?GG; NB;N NB? >SH;GC=M / G;S <? QLCNN?H ;M
, / , /
, /
K/ 3 3
,?N ,?N ,]N ,]N
,/ ,/ ,/ ,/ ,/
3 K[ 3 KFN KF N '
,?N ,]N ,[ ,?N ,]N
)IL? >?N;CFM IH NB? HIH=?HNL;F =BCMKO;L? ;H> NB? A;GG; >?HMCNS G;S <? @IOH>
CH &IBHMIH
'INT
;H> ;F;ELCMBH;H
/NI=B;MNC= PIF;NCFCNS GI>?F
%HN?L?MNCHAFS
NB? NQI MC>?M I@ NB? ?KO;FCNS MCAH ;L? NB? M;G? CH NB?CL ?RJL?MMCIH
>C_?LCHA IHFS CH NB? IJNCIH NI QBC=B NB?S ;JJFS #CP?H NB;N NB? M;G? ?KO;NCIH
GOMN BIF> @IL ;HS NSJ? I@ =;FF IJNCIH I@ ;HS G;NOLCNS ;H> MNLCE? JLC=?
Q? HINC=?
NB;N ?;=B MC>? I@ NB? ?KO;FCNS GOMN <? CH>?J?H>?HN @LIG NB? NSJ? I@ IJNCIH
NB;N IH? =IHMC>?LM 0BCM MOAA?MNM NB;N ?;=B MC>? QCFF <? ?KO;F NI MIG? @OH=NCIH
M;S ?N ( ]N ( [
NB;N >?J?H>M IH ?N ;H> ]N 0BCM @OH=NCIH G;S <? CHN?LJL?N?>
;M ; PIF;NCFCNS LCME JL?GCOG .?JF;=CHA NB? J;L;G?N?LM <S NB?CL ;=NO;F OHCNM
, / , /
, /
?N ]N ?N ]N ]N
,?N ,?N ,]N ,]N
,/ ,/ ,/
]N
?N ( ]N ( [
Y? '
,] ,? ,[
%HNLI>O=CHA _ &)# ?N
;H> =IHMC>?LCHA ; =;FF
/ LR ( [
( Q? HINC=? NB;N !$
!R
!$ !3 !$ !$ !$
!3 !R !3 ? ;H> !R ? !3 %N @IFFIQM NB;N Q? G;S L?QLCN? NB? J;LNC;F
>C_?L?HNC;F ?KO;NCIH ;M
, / , /
, /
]N ]N ]N
,_ ,_,]N ,]N
,/ ,/ ,/
]N
_N ( ]N ( [
Y '
, ,_ ,[
0B? <IOH>;LS =IH>CNCIHM NB;N GOMN <? M;NCMW?>
CH NB? =;M? I@ ; !OLIJ?;H
=;FF IJNCIH QCNB MNLCE? JLC=? 7 ;L?
/ ?4 ( ]N ( Y( 7( @( [
' / ?4 7(
(
/ ( ]N ( Y( 7( @( [
(
,/
( ]N ( Y( 7( @( [
'
,?N
IH>CNCIH >?N?LGCH?M QB;N NB? J;SI_ ;N @ MBIOF> <? IH>CNCIH
G?;HM NB;N C@ NB? P;FO? I@ NB? OH>?LFSCHA <?=IG?M QILNBF?MM
NB?H
NB? IJNCIH P;FO? <?=IG?M HCF %@ NB? OH>?LFSCHA CM ;H ?KOCNS
Q? =IOF> CHN?L
JL?N NBCM ;M G?;HCHA NB;N C@ NB? =IGJ;HS <?=IG?M <;HELOJN
;H> =?;M?M NI
?RCMN
NB?H ;H IJNCIH QLCNN?H IH CN ;FMI <?=IG?M QILNBF?MM IH>CNCIH
MN;N?M NB;N ;H IJNCIH NB;N CM P?LS GO=B CH NB? GIH?S
ACP?H NB;N CN QCFF <?
?R?L=CM?>
QCFF B;P? ; P;FO? NB;N =B;HA?M ?R;=NFS <S NB? M;G? ;GIOHN ;M NB?
OH>?LFSCHA
%H IL>?L NI AI @OLNB?L
; BSJINB?MCM =IH=?LHCHA NB? MB;J? I@ NB? LCME JL?
GCOG _N ( ]N ( [
H??>M NI <? @ILGOF;N?> ?J?H>CHA IH NB? ;MMOGJNCIHM G;>?
Q? QCFF A?N NB? IJNCIH JLC=CHA @ILGOF;? CH NB? =IHN?RN I@ $OFF ;H> 3BCN?
!9=287 9;2,270 @2=1 <=8,1*<=2, ?85*=252=B
/?P?L;F GI>?FM B;P? <??H JLIJIM?> NI JLC=? IJNCIHM CH NB? =IHN?RN I@ MNI=B;MNC=
PIF;NCFCNS 3? G;S G?HNCIH $OFF ;H> 3BCN?
3CAACHM
>55 *7- )12=.
$OFF ;H> 3BCN? ;H> G;HS INB?LM G;>? ; =LO=C;F ;MMOGJNCIH NB;N
PIF;NCFCNS LCME CM OH=ILL?F;N?> QCNB ;AAL?A;N? =IHMOGJNCIH
;H> B?H=? B;M T?LI
MSMN?G;NC= LCME 0B?S NB?H ;LAO? NB;N LCME NB;N CM HIN MSMN?G;NC= QCFF HIN
<? JLC=?>
C?
<S CHPIECHA ;H ?KOCFC<LCOG GI>?F MO=B ;M ;JCN;F
MM?N ,LC=CHA )I>?F ,) "LIG NBCM CN @IFFIQM NB;N ' 3CNB NBCM
=LO=C;F ;MMOGJNCIH
NB?S NB?H ;LAO?> NB;N IJNCIHM =;H <? JLC=?> OH>?L NB?
LCMEH?ONL;F P;FO;NCIH JLCH=CJF? ?P?H C@ PIF;NCFCNS CM MNI=B;MNC= %H @;=N
NB?M?
;MMOGJNCIHM ;L? ?KOCP;F?HN NI >?=IOJFCHA NB? PIF;NCFCNS ?KO;NCIH @LIG NB?
G?;H ?KO;NCIH
3? NB?H B;P? NI MIFP? NB? @IFFIQCHA JLI<F?G
.
/ ?N ( ]N ( [
LL ' / ?4 7(
W ?4 )?N ( ]N
K?4 '
3
/ ?N ( ]N ( [
/ #3 ?N ( [( @( ]
+4
QCNB ] N ]O K\' 0BCM @ILGOF; =;HHIN <? OM?> B?L? MCH=? PIF;NCFCNS CM
MNI=B;MNC= 0B? C>?; I@ $OFF ;H> 3BCN? CM NI =IH>CNCIH NB? ;P?L;A?
@ONOL? PIF;NCFCNS ;N NB? =OLL?HN F?P?F OMCHA NB? B;JG;H'IFGIAILIP C>?HNCNS
P;FC> @IL );LEIP JLI=?MM?M
.
W _)`
W _)a
W a)`
Ka'
T
0B? ?RJL?MMCIH CH CH CM CH @;=N NB? F;=E/=BIF?M JLC=? QCNB NB?
;P?L;A? P;LC;H=? ] @LIG [ NI @ @IL IH? J;LNC=OF;L M;GJF? J;NB I@ ]N 0BOM
0B? JLI<F?G QCNB CM NB? >C^=OFNS CH >?LCPCHA ;FF JIMMC<F? M;GJF? J;NBM
I@ ]N ;H> NI A?N NB? =13 W ])]N
!P?H QCNBION @OLNB?L =IGJON;NCIH
Q? =;H
M?? NB;N NB? JLI<F?G <?=IG?M GIL? =IGJF?R QB?H
QBC=B G?;HM NB;N
QB?H Q? NBCHE I@ NB? ?PIFONCIH I@ ]N Q? GOMN ;FMI E??J NL;=E I@ QB?L? ?N B;M
?PIFP?> %H $OFF ;H> 3BCN?
CN CM ;MMOG?> NB;N ' 0B? =IGJON;NCIH
I@ CM NB?H <;M?> IH ; 0;SFIL M?LC?M ?RJ;HMCIH ;LIOH> NB? F;=E/=BIF?M
JLC=?
F?;LFS
NB?M? =IGJON;NCIHM ;L? ; OM?@OF MN?J NIQ;L>M I<N;CHCHA ; A?H?L;F
MIFONCIH CH QBC=B NB? LIQHC;H GINCIHM ;L? =ILL?F;N?> ;H> CH QBC=B ;A?HNM
JLC=? PIF;NCFCNS LCME 0BCM F?;>M OM NI $?MNIHZM GI>?F JL?M?HN?> CH NB? @IFFIQCHA
M?=NCIH
.<=87
$?MNIH MIFP?> NB? J;LNC;F >C_?L?HNC;F CH CNM @OFF A?H?L;FCNS $CM MIFONCIH
CM <;M?> IH M?P?L;F CHHIP;NCHA CHMCABNM 0I <?ACH
WLMN F?N >?HIN? NB? J;L;
G?N?L P?=NIL
NB?H NB? JLC=? I@ ; !OLIJ?;H =;FF IJNCIH QCNB N?LGCH;F J;SI_
@OH=NCIH ' / ?4 7(
CM
.
L
/ ?N ( ]N ( 7( @( [(
L ' / ?4 7(
W ?4 ) ?N ( ]N
K?4
/ ?N ( ]N ( 7( @( [(
?N + K_4
+ LS W `4 ) _N ( ]N
K`4
S
.
LL 7 W _4 ) _N ( ]N
K_4 (
+
QCNB NB? WLMN CHN?AL;H> CH <?CHA JIMCNCP? ;H> CHN?AL;NCHA OJ NI IH?
0B? WLMN CHN?AL;H> NB?L?@IL? >?WH?M ; H?Q JLI<;<CFCNS G?;MOL? NB;N Q? >?HIN?
<S X <?FIQ
.
/ ?N ( ]N ( 7( @( [(
?N X _4 ) _N ( ]N
K_4
+
.
LL 7 W _4 ) _N ( ]N
K_4
+
?N < D4 + &)# 7
) _N ( ]N
2 _
" K\(
P\
.
"/* P\_
\
+ D + _
2 _
" K\'
P\
$?H=?
Q? =;H QLCN? < ;H> < CH ;M
.
"/* P\ &)# 7
ER* P* N \
QCNB Q
(
0B? =B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH ER* P* N @IL Q
;H>
CM ;MMI=C;N?> QCNB
NB? NL;HMCNCIH JLI<;<CFCNC?M X ;H> W( L?MJ?=NCP?FS %@ NB? =B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH
;MMI=C;N?> QCNB NB? NQI NL;HMCNCIH JLI<;<CFCNC?M Q?L? EHIQH
NB? JLC=? I@ NB?
>?LCP;NCP? ;MM?N =IOF> <? HOG?LC=;FFS =IGJON?> CH M?GC=FIM?> @ILG 3? NOLH
NI NBCM CMMO? HIQ
/?? B;JN?L @IL ; >?N;CF?> >CM=OMMCIH I@ NB? CHP?LM? "IOLC?L NL;HM@ILG
/NLO=NOL;F +JNCIH ,LC=CHA
1*;*,=.;2<=2, />7,=287 8/ =1. %( 68-.5
NB?L?@IL?
H??> WLMN NI >?LCP? NB? J;LNC;F >C_?L?HNC;F ?KO;NCIH =ILL?MJIH>CHA
NI X
0I >I MI
Q? CHD?=N NB? A?H?L;F MIFONCIH / ?N < _N ( ]N
LL 7< _N ( ]N
@LIG CHNI NB? J;LNC;F >C_?L?HNC;F ;H> NB?H L?ALIOJ N?LGM CH
< ;H> < ( L?MJ?=NCP?FS "OLNB?LGIL?
$?MNIH G;E?M NB? CGJILN;HN
;MMOGJNCIH NB;N NB? PIF;NCFCNS LCME JL?GCOG CM ; FCH?;L @OH=NCIH I@ ]N MO=B
NB;N ?N ( ]N ( [
]N 3CNB NBCM ;MMOGJNCIH CH JF;=?
MO<MNCNON? ;FF NB? J;LNC;F
>?LCP;NCP?M CHNI ;H> CHNLI>O=? NB? HIN;NCIHM H
I
I ( \
*
\
* NI JLI>O=? NQI J;LNC;F >C_?L?HNC;F ?KO;NCIHM
I@ NB? @ILG
,<E
, <E , <E
Y \E ]N
]N
]N
,_ ,_ ,_,]N
,<E
, <E ,<E
H ]N IE
]N (
,]N ,]N ,[
;A;CH CH>?R?> <S Q
( =ILL?MJIH>CHA NI NB? NQI 013 M < ;H> <
"LIG B?L? IH
NB? OMO;F "?SHG;H';= N?=BHCKO? ;JJFC?M .?=;FF IOL I<D?=
NCP? CM NI I<N;CH NB? =B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH ER* P* N \
NB;N M;NCMNC?M
#CP?H NB;N NB? =I?^=C?HNM CHPIFP?> CH NB? J;LNC;F >C_?L?HNC;F ?KO;NCIH
;L? FCH?;L
CN CM JIMMC<F? NI AO?MM ; MIFONCIH I@ NB? @ILG
ER* P* N \
"/* -E ( \
.E ( \
]N /E ( \
_N (
QB?L? -E ( .E ( ;H> /E ;L? @OH=NCIHM I@ ;H> \' /CH=? Q? Q;HN ER* P* N \
NI
<? ; =B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH
NB? <IOH>;LS =IH>CNCIH CM
ER* P* N \
"/* P\_4
'
N 4
$?H=?
-E ( \
( .E ( \
;H> /E ( \
P\ #CP?H NB;N ER* P* N \
(
( ]N ( _N
(
( ;H> ]N ( _N
(
NBL?? + !M "IL /E
,/E *,[
;H> <S OMCHA NB? <IOH>;LS =IH>CNCIH NBCM ACP?M NB? MIFONCIH /E ( \
P\
MSMN?G I@ NQI + !M
IL .C=;NNC ?KO;NCIHM
L?G;CHM
,.E
\ P\.E .E IE .E P\ (
,[
,-E
H.E YP\'
,[
$?MNIH CM NB? WLMN NI JLIPC>? ; MIFONCIH NI NB?M? .C=;NNC ?KO;NCIHM $?
M?NM _N &)# ?N
;H> I<N;CHM @IL Q
(
/ ?N ( ]N ( 7( @( [(
?N < 7LL < (
.
"/* P\ &)# 7
ER* P* N \
>;=1.; 27<201=<
QB?L? Q? B;P? NI MCGOF;N? NL;D?=NILC?M ?CNB?L OH>?L NB? LCMEH?ONL;F JLI<;<CFCNS
IL OH>?L NB? I<D?=NCP? JLI<;<CFCNS %H NBCM =;M?
Q? QCFF H??> NB? MSMN?G I@
MNI=B;MNC= >C_?L?HNC;F ?KO;NCIHM ;H> NB? ;MMI=C;N?> , ! 0BCM =;H <? >IH? <S
;H;FIAS %H>??>
@IL
/NLO=NOL;F +JNCIH ,LC=CHA
, W , W
, W ,W ,W ,W
3 3 3 '
,?N ,?N , N , N ,?N ,]N ,[
QB?L? F0N CM ; LIQHC;H GINCIH ;H> QB?L? KF N ;H> KF0N ;L? OH=ILL?F;N?>
NB?H Q? A?N
+ 4 8 5
K_N Y N K[ N KF N
KF0N (
+
K N N
N K[ N KF N '
4 5
/CH=? /VYY KF0N ( KF N ( KF0N ;H> KF N =;H <? MCGOF;N?> M?J;L;N?FS ;H>
NB?H FCHE?> PC; NI SC?F> ; =ILL?F;N?> JLI=?MM
%@ Q? CHNLI>O=? NB? HIN;NCIHM ;H> *
1MCHA NB? MSMN?G QCNB ?CNB?L IL
CN CM JIMMC<F? NI
MCGOF;N? LCMEH?ONL;F NL;D?=NILC?M OMCHA ; WLMN IL M?=IH>IL>?L >CM=L?NCT;NCIH
M=B?G? 0B? >C_?L?H=? <?NQ??H ;H> CM NB? L?JF;=?G?HN I@
<S Y 0B? >C_?L?H=? <?NQ??H ;H> CM NB? L?JF;=?G?HN I@ (
;H> <S NB? LCMEH?ONL;F ?KOCP;F?HN ;H> 0B;N CM NB? LCMEH?ONL;F J;L;
G?N?LM ;H> B;P? ;<MIL<?>
NB? PIF;NCFCNS LCME JL?GCOG INB
;H> ;L? LCMEH?ONL;F MNI=B;MNC= >C_?L?HNC;F ?KO;NCIHM / !M F?;LFS
NI JLI>O=? MNI=E JLC=? NL;D?=NILC?M OH>?L NB? I<D?=NCP? G?;MOL? IL ;=NO;F
G?;MOL? @LIG NB? LCMEH?ONL;F G?;MOL?
CN MO^=?M NI L?JF;=? Y <S ON
NI
JLI>O=? NL;D?=NILC?M OH>?L NB? LCMEH?ONL;F G?;MOL?
Q? QCFF H??> ;H ?MNCG;N?
@IL
QBC=B CM B;L>?L ;H> GIL? =IHNLIP?LMC;F NI ?MNCG;N?
+JNCIH JLC=CHA QCNB MNI=B;MNC= PIF;NCFCNS
R* P* N \ ( \
1 "/* P\ _4 P\ ]4
'
- ( \ ( \
(
. ( \ ( \
P\ (
/ ( \ ( \
P\ '
3? CGG?>C;N?FS A?N / ( \ ( \
P\
;H> NB? .C=;NNC ?KO;NCIHM ;L? L?>O=?>
NI
,-
P\ .(
,[
,.
P\ \ P\ . . . '
,[
1MCHA ; JLIAL;G NB;N ;FFIQM @IL MSG<IFC= =IGJON;NCIHM
CN CM JIMMC<F? NI ?P;F
O;N? NBCM MSMN?G I@ ?KO;NCIHM QCNBION NII GO=B ?_ILN
/??
@IL CHMN;H=?
/CHAF?NIH
&C;HA ;H> 'HCABN
;H> B;=EI ;H>
2C=?CL;
/NLO=NOL;F +JNCIH ,LC=CHA
8-.5< @2=1 3>69<
%H NBCM M?=NCIH
Q? CH>C=;N? BIQ NI JLC=? ;H IJNCIH OH>?L NB? BSJINB?MCM NB;N
NB? OH>?LFSCHA ;MM?N =IHN;CHM ; DOGJ =IGJIH?HN 2;LCIOM =IHNLC<ONCIHM =IH
MC>?L?> MO=B GI>?FM 0B? M?GCH;F QILE CH NBCM W?F> CM <S )?LNIH QBI
=IHMC>?L?> ; A?IG?NLC= LIQHC;H GINCIH QCNB #;OMMC;H DOGJM ;M OH>?LFSCHA
JLI=?MM ;FF ;H> 0ILIOM CHNLI>O=?> NB? MCHAF? DOGJ JLI=?MM 0BCM M?N
NCHA CM P?LS MCGJF? ;H> NB? L?MOFNCHA IJNCIH JLC=CHA @ILGOF; CM DOMN ; GCRNOL?
/O=B ; GI>?F G;S <? OM?> @IL ;H IJNCIH QCNB ; MBILN L?G;CHCHA FC@? HINB?L
=IHNLC<ONCIH CM <S ;N?M
QBI ;FFIQM @IL MNI=B;MNC= PIF;NCFCNS ;M
Q?FF ;M HILG;FFS >CMNLC<ON?> DOGJM "IL ;H ?P?H GIL? L?=?HN =IHNLC<ONCIH
Q?
G;S G?HNCIH O^?
,;H
;H> /CHAF?NIH ;H> ,;H QBIM? MNI=B;M
NC= PIF;NCFCNS GI>?F ;FFIQM @IL DOGJM CH NB? G?;H ;M Q?FF ;M CH NB? P;LC;H=?
'IO >?PC;N?M MFCABNFS @LIG NBCM MNL;H>
<?=;OM? B? MBONM NB? MNI=B;MNC=
PIF;NCFCNS J;LN >IQH ;H> A?H?L;FCT?M NB? DOGJ =IGJIH?HN <S CHNLI>O=CHA NB?
;MSGG?NLC= >IO<F? ?RJIH?HNC;F
)O=B I@ NB? >?N;CFM ;H> @OH>;G?HN;FM I@ DOGJ JLI=?MM?M ;L? JLIPC>?> CH
B;JN?L /CH=? IJNCIHM >?J?H> IH NB? OH>?LFSCHA ;MM?N
CH IL>?L NI JLC=?
IJNCIHM QCNB ; DOGJ =IGJIH?HN
CN CM H?=?MM;LS NI ?RJL?MM NB? >SH;GC=M I@ ;
@OH=NCIH I@ NB? OH>?LFSCHA ;MM?N %H INB?L QIL>M
Q? L?KOCL? ;H ?RN?HMCIH I@
%NIZM F?GG; NI DOGJ >C_OMCIHM
;H CMMO? NI QBC=B Q? QCFF NOLH HIQ
%=8,1*<=2, 9;8,.<< @2=1 3>69<
3? =IHMC>?L FN
; LIQHC;H GINCIH ;H> :N
; JOL? ,ICMMIH JLI=?MM
CH>?J?H
>?HN I@ FN ' (?N 6N <? NB? L;H>IG P;LC;<F? =ILL?MJIH>CHA NI ; DOGJ L?;FCT;NCIH
C?
; G;LE?L 0B? %NI JLI=?MM NB;N Q? =IHMC>?L CM DN QB?L?
. N . N . N
DN D HM KZ IM KFM JM 6M
K:M '
QB?L? :N G?;MOL?M NB? HOG<?L I@ DOGJM NB;N NIIE JF;=? <?@IL? NCG? [ ;H>
QB?L? NB? E ( @IL Q
( ( :N ( ;L? NB? NCG?M QB?H ; DOGJ N;E?M JF;=? /IG?
=;L? H??>M NI <? N;E?H =IH=?LHCHA NB? NCGCHA %H>??>
C@ ; DOGJ N;E?M JF;=?
?R;=NFS ;N NCG?
NB?H NB? KO?MNCIH CM C@ NB? =I?^=C?HN J ;>DOMN?> <?@IL?
NCG? IL >OLCHA ' 0BCM G?;HM NB;N NB? M;G? >C^=OFNS ;M QCNB NB? >?WHCNCIH
I@ ;H %NI CHN?AL;F I==OLM ;A;CH "LIG ; WH;H=? JICHN I@ PC?Q
C@ NB? DN CM
)I>?FM QCNB DOGJM
J &%' JM '
M M
%N CM ;FMI JIMMC<F? NI QLCN? NB? DOGJ >C_OMCIH ;M ; MNI=B;MNC= >C_?L?HNC;F
?KO;NCIH
KDN HN K[ IN KFN JN 6N
K:N '
%@ DN CM ; DOGJ>C_OMCIH JLI=?MM QB?L? NB? >C_OMCIH J;LN CM ; A?IG?NLC= LIQH
C;H GINCIH
Q? I<N;CH
NI EN M DN ( [
' $?H=?
%NIZM F?GG; CM ACP?H <S
KEN I MRR HN MR MN K[ IN MR KFN
N
M DN JN 6N
( [
M DN ( [
K:N '
M ;H CFFOMNL;NCIH
@IL NB? A?IG?NLC= LIQHC;H GINCIH CH
;H> OMCHA
NB? MCGJF? @OH=NCIH EN &)# ?N
Q? I<N;CH
KEN K[ KFN &)# 6N
K:N '
0B? WLMN J;LN I@ @IFFIQM @LIG %NIZM F?GG; @IL ; A?IG?NLC= LIQHC;H
GINCIH 0B? DOGJ J;LN CM ACP?H <S NB? N?LG
&)# ?N
&)# 6N
'
Q? I<
N;CH NB;N NB? CHMN;HN;H?IOM G?;H CH CM 1KEN K['
/NLO=NOL;F +JNCIH ,LC=CHA
%H NBCM =;M?
NB? DOGJ =IHNLC<ON?M NI NB? G?;H 3CNB NBCM MI=;FF?> B;0<:
=2;@.A21 =?<02@@
Q? ;L? HIN ;<F? NI >CMNCHAOCMB <?NQ??H NB? ?_?=N I@ ;H>
' M Q? QCFF M?? CH B;JN?L
CN CM JIMMC<F? NI =BIIM? ; MJ?=CW=;NCIH I@
NB? GI>?F QB?L? NB? DOGJ =IHNLC<ONCIH =;H=?FM ION 3CNB MO=B ; 0<:=2;@.A21
=?<02@@
Q? B;P? HI C>?HNCW=;NCIH JLI<F?G
#CP?H NBCM A?H?L;F DOGJ >C_OMCIH JLI=?MM
Q? =;H HIQ NOLH NI IJNCIH JLC=
CHA "CLMN
Q? QCFF =IHMC>?L NB? 'IO GI>?F NB;N B;M ; LIQHC;H GINCIH
J;LN ;H> MIG? ?RJIH?HNC;F DOGJM 0B?H
Q? NOLH NI NB? ;N?M GI>?F
QCNB MNI=B;MNC= PIF;NCFCNS ;H> #;OMMC;H DOGJM %H NB? @IFFIQCHA MO<M?=NCIHM
Q? QCFF @IFFIQ NB? MN?JM @LIG NB? JL?PCIOM MO<M?=NCIH QB?H Q? >?LCP?> NB? $?
MNIH GI>?F
C?
Q? WLMN >?LCP? NB? @OH>;G?HN;F , !
=L?;N? NB? LCMEH?ONL;F
JILN@IFCI
NB?H WH> NB? LCABN =B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH ;H> IJNCIH JLC=CHA @ILGO
F;?
2K><287 @2=1 -8>+5. .A987.7=2*5 3>69<
Q? B;P?
I
L , ,
+
( ( ( W( ( H(
+ I <IF
F
I F
+
5F H ( + (
I
L , ,
+
+ I =IF
F
I F
+
5F H ( + (
H
+ (
@
QB?L?
CM NB? 013 I@ NB? MN;H>;L> HILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH 0B? J;L;G?N?L I
L
I *U L?JL?M?HNM NB? JLI<;<CFCNS I@ ; ,ICMMIH L;H>IG P;LC;<F? N;ECHA
NB? P;FO? U QB?H CNM CHMN;HN;H?IOM DOGJ CHN?HMCNS CM ;H> DOGJM N;E? JF;=?
IP?L NB? NCG? CHN?LP;F [ NI @
QCNB @ ['
"IL
R
U
( Q? B;P?
,
U R
U
I DF
ID
<IF WD X ID (
PR P
DF
,
U R
U
I ID
DF
=IF WID X D '
PR P
DF
0B? F;MN P;FO?M ;L? <II WI ;H> =II X I ' 0B? ?RJL?MMCIH CM >?WH?>
NI <? IH?
0B? M?KO?H=? I@ @OH=NCIHM 5F CM >?WH?> ;M @IFFIQM %@ + ;H>
I
ID
L> ,
4OD J
D
I +
"/*
J
(
;H> @IL ) ;H>
)
Q? B;P? @IL ;FF U
5I J ( (
I
ID
L> ,
4OD J
D
I +
"/*
J
(
/NLO=NOL;F +JNCIH ,LC=CHA
;H> QB?L? 4O
CM >?WH?> ;M
+
4O _
LR & _
(
+
4O _
_
(
4OI _
4OI _
_4OI _
( U
'
U
$?L?
& L?JL?M?HNM NB? =13 I@ ; (
0B? NBL?? ?KO;NCIHM ]
MBIQ NB;N NB? 4O @OH=NCIH =;H <? =IGJON?> CN?L;NCP?FS 0B?M? @ILGOF;? FIIE
QILM? NB;H NB?S ;=NO;FFS ;L? 0B? CHWHCN? MOG CH =;H <? NLOH=;N?>
;H> 'IO MBIQM NB;N NB? ;JJLIRCG;NCIH QILEM Q?FF QCNB IHFS ; @?Q
N?LGM
<?=;OM? I QCFF KOC=EFS =IHP?LA? NIQ;L>M T?LI @IL WH;H=?ILC?HN?> ;J
JFC=;NCIHM 0B? 4O @OH=NCIH =;H ;FMI <? ?P;FO;N?> OMCHA NB? 2 =IHXO?HN
BSJ?LA?IG?NLC= @OH=NCIH
+ ,
4OI _
I L
2 U
( ( _
2 U
( ( _
+ _ '
U
U
86+27270 <=8,1*<=2, ?85*=252=B @2=1 3>69<
0B? N?LG 6 CM NB? ?RJ?=N?> CHMN;HN;H?IOM DOGJ MCT? M NB? JLC=? JLI=?MM CM
>?WH?>
NB? JLI=?MM CM =IGJ?HM;N?>
C?
NB? DOGJ =IHNLC<ONCIH CH NB? >LC@N
QCFF <? T?LI )IL?IP?L
F?;LFS
6N CM NB? MNI=B;MNC= DOGJ
?RJL?MM?> ;M ; J?L=?HN;A?
QB?H?P?L ; DOGJ
N;E?M JF;=? 0B? F;MN ?KO;NCIH
>?WH?M
6N ;M ; FIAHILG;F DOGJ
F?;LFS
Q? B;P?
1
6N "/* &)#
6
6(
;H> NBOM
16 6'
"OLNB?LGIL?
M Q;M =F;CG?>
CH NB? WLMN ?KO;NCIH
NB? DOGJ =IGJIH?HN B;M <??H
=IGJ?HM;N?> <S NB? CHNLI>O=NCIH I@ 6K[ CH NB? G?;H %H INB?L QIL>M
NB?
?RJ?=N?> DOGJ =IHNLC<ONCIH CM T?LI J?L NCG? OHCN
0B? WLMN MN?J NI MIFP? NBCM JLI<F?G CM NI ;MMI=C;N? QCNB ]
NB? J;LNC;F >C_?L?HNC;F ?KO;NCIH 0B? OMO;F MN?JM ;L? NB?H NB? M;G? ;M CH
$?MNIH 0B? KO?MNCIH NB;N IJ?HM CM QB;N CM NB? CHWHCN?MCG;F A?H?L;NIL @IL ;
DOGJ >C_OMCIH 0I ;HMQ?L NBCM KO?MNCIH
F?N OM MN;LN QCNB NB? OHCP;LC;N? DOGJ
>C_OMCIH ACP?H <S
K?N HN K[ IN KFN JN 6N K:N '
(?N O ?4
<? MIG? CHN?AL;<F? @OH=NCIH ;H> >?WH?
.
! ?N ( [
1 O ?4
)?N ( [ O Z4
W Z4 ( @ )?N ( [
KZ4 (
M
NB? F;NN?L CHN?AL;F CHPIFPCHA NB? NL;HMCNCIH JLI<;<CFCNS #CP?H NB;N NB? JLI<F?G
CM );LEIPC;H
NB? B;JG;H'IFGIAILIP ?KO;NCIH MNCFF BIF>M ;H> OMCHA NB?
;LAOG?HN I@ CN?L;N?> ?RJ?=N;NCIHM ;M Q? >C> @IL $?MNIHZM GI>?F
CN CM JIMMC<F?
NI MBIQ NB;N ! CM ; G;LNCHA;F? %N @IFFIQM NB;N CNM >LC@N GOMN <? T?LI
IL CH
INB?L N?LGM NB;N NB? ?RJ?=N?> CHMN;HN;H?IOM P;LC;NCIH GOMN <? T?LI 3? G;S
OM? NB? %NI @ILGOF; @IL >C_OMCIHM CHPIFPCHA DOGJJLI=?MM?M NI I<N;CH
.
, W ,W ,W ,W
1K! O Z4
IN HN K[ IN KFN
M ,Z ,Z ,[ ,Z
5
W ZN JN 6N ( [
W ZN ( [
K:N KZ4 (
0BCM ?RN?HMCIH I@ %NIZM F?GG; NI JLI=?MM?M QCNB >CM=L?N? DOGJM CM CGG?>C;N?
/NLO=NOL;F +JNCIH ,LC=CHA
.
, W ,W ,W
O Z4
IN HN K[
M ,Z ,Z ,[
5
1 W ZN JN 6N ( [
W ZN ( [
QCNB
&)#
6
&)#
6
( '
0B? J;L;G?N?LM ( ( ;H> 6 ;L? LCME H?ONL;F %H NB? =;M? I@ ; !OLIJ?;H
=;FF IJNCIH QCNB G;NOLCNS >;N? @
MNLCE? JLC=? 7 ;H> J;L;G?N?L P?=NIL
NB?
JLC=CHA @ILGOF; CM
/ ?N ( @( [( 7(
?N < ?4 + &)# 7
QB?L? < ;H> < ;L? MOLPCP;F @OH=NCIHM 0B? >C_?L?HNC;F ?KO;NCIHM ;MMI=C;N?>
QCNB < @IFFIQM
;M CH $?MNIH
@LIG NB? =IHMNLO=NCIH I@ ; HIH;L<CNL;A? JILN@I
FCI 0B? J;LNC;F >C_?L?HNC;F ?KO;NCIH ;MMI=C;N?> QCNB < @IFFIQM <S L?=IAHCTCHA
NB;N / GOMN @IFFIQ NB? M;G? J;LNC;F >C_?L?HNC;F ?KO;NCIH ;M < '
=B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH NB;N QCFF MIFP? NB? , ! CH =;H <? AO?MM?>
CH NB? OMO;F Q;S ACP?H NB? FCH?;LCNS I@ NB? JLI<F?G
0B? ;JJ?H>CR CH ;EMBC
;I
;H> B?H ;FMI JLIPC>?M >?N;CFM IH NB? P;LCIOM
, !M ;H> AOC>?H=? IH BIQ NI MIFP? NB?G
)I>?FM QCNB DOGJM
& \ ?N ( N ( [
"/* - \(
. \(
N P\?N '
;N?M >?LCP?M
/ ?N ( @( [( 7(
?N < 7 LL < (
QCNB
@IL Q
(
.
&ER* P* N \
"/* P\ &)# 7
<E " K\(
P\
QB?L?
&ER* P* N \
1"/* P\D4
"/* -E ( \
.E ( \
N P\?N
6
!
DO
6
"/* E P\ \
(
;H>
.E ( \
Y 6
P\ P P\ E E
P
L !
&)#
6 P\ E E
'
6 E
E P\ \
-E \
(
P P\ E E
L !
*
L !
;
E P P\ E
P E P\ \ (
\
*( \
*( P ( ;H> '
0BCM @ILGOF; CM ;A;CH L?F;NCP?FS MNL;CABN@ILQ;L> NI CGJF?G?HN M <?@IL?
MIG?
=;L? CM H??>?> CH NB? =IGJON;NCIH I@ NB? CHP?LM? "IOLC?L NL;HM@ILG <?=;OM?
NB? CHN?AL;H> CM ;H IM=CFF;NCHA @OH=NCIH
;N?M ;FMI MBIQM NB;N NB? LCMEH?ONL;F =IOHN?LJ;LNM NI ?KO;NCIHM ]
;L?
8
K?N *?N Y 6
K[ BN KFN
6N K:N (
8
KBN
BN K[ P BN KF N
(
/V] KFN ( KF N K[(
+ K:
K[(
1 6 6 '
FF MN;LL?> P;LC;<F?M L?JL?M?HN LCMEH?ONL;F P?LMCIHM I@ NB? ;=NO;F P;LC;<F?M
0BCM MSMN?G I@ ?KO;NCIHM G;S <? >CM=L?NCT?> QCNB ; WH? WLMN IL M?=IH>IL>?L
M=B?G? ;M NB? <;MCM @IL MCGOF;NCIHM 0B? GI>?F I@ ;EMBC
;I
;H> B?H
CM MCGCF;L NI ;N?MZM
<ON QCNB NB? ?RN?HMCIH NI CH=FO>? ; MKO;L? LIIN
JLI=?MM @IL CHN?L?MN L;N? ;M Q?FF
/NLO=NOL;F +JNCIH ,LC=CHA
>69B *J7. 68-.5<
O^?
,;H
;H> /CHAF?NIH
B?L?;@N?L ,/ ?RN?H> NB? $?MNIH ;H> ;N?M
GI>?FM <S ;FFIQCHA DOGJM CH NB? PIF;NCFCNS JLI=?MM?M ,/ ;FMI JLIJIM? ; P?LS
A?H?L;F M?NNCHA QB?L?<S NB? DOGJ MCT? G;S >?J?H> IH MIG? I@ NB? P;LC;<F?M
I@ NB? GI>?F "ILG;FFS
NB? ,/ GI>?F CM ?RJL?MM?> CH ; GOFNCP;LC;N? @ILG
KDN DN
K[ DN
KCN KFN (
LC@N _
7 7 _(
&OGJ CHN?HMCNS _
S S _(
CM=IOHN @;=NIL > _
_(
NB?H ,/ ;MMOG? NB;N DE
4DE 4DE _( QCNB 4DE ;H> 4DE ;H U( U
G;NLCR M ; =IHM?KO?H=?
NB? MJ?=CW=;NCIH CM ; FCH?;L IH? @IL ;FF NB? J;L;G?N?LM ,/ =B;L;=N?LCT? NB?
DOGJM PC; NB?CL GIG?HN A?H?L;NCHA @OH=NCIH 0I >I MI
NB?S >?WH? J ; P?=NIL I@
+ =IGJF?R HOG<?LM ;H> CHNLI>O=? NB? GIG?HN A?H?L;NCHA @OH=NCIH ;M J
U
%
"/* J a
K a
' #CP?H NB? P?LS A?H?L;F GOFNCP;LC;N? ;^H? H;NOL? I@ NB?
JLI<F?G
,/ JLIJIM? ; >CM=IOHN?> P?LMCIH I@ NB? =B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH ;M
; MIFONCIH NI NB? , ! ;MMI=C;N?> QCNB NB? JLI<F?G
.
4
& \( DN ( )DN
1 "/* > DM
KZ "/* P\DN )DN
"/* - ( \
. ( \
DN (
QB?L? -
;H> .
;L? MIFONCIHM NI NB? @IFFIQCHA .C=;NNC ?KO;NCIHM
,.
( \
7
. ( \
. ( \
4 . ( U
S . ( \
(
,
,-
( \
7
. ( \
. ( \
4 . ( U
S . ( \
(
,
QCNB <IOH>;LS =IH>CNCIHM
. ( \
P\( ;H> - ( \
'
)I>?FM QCNB ?P?H QCF>?L DOGJM (fPS IJNCIH JLC=CHA
M ,/ G?HNCIH
CH =?LN;CH MCNO;NCIHM
>?J?H>CHA IH NB? MNLO=NOL? I@ NB?
GI>?F
MIFONCIHM G;S <? @IOH> ;H;FSNC=;FFS %H MIG? INB?L =CL=OGMN;H=?M
CN
G;S <? H?=?MM;LS NI MIFP? NB? ?KO;NCIHM HOG?LC=;FFS
,/ MBIQ BIQ NI I<N;CH @IL MJ?=CW= M?NNCHAM LCMEH?ONL;F >SH;GC=M ;H>
NB?S >?LCP?
OMCHA =B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH NSJ? N?=BHCKO?M ?RJL?MMCIHM @IL ;
F;LA? M?N I@ WH;H=C;F CHMNLOG?HNM MO=B ;M <IH> >?LCP;NCP?M
KO;HNIM
@IL?CAH
<IH> IJNCIHM
=BIIM?L IJNCIHM
;M Q?FF ;M MC;H IJNCIHM
8-.5< @2=1 .?.7 @25-.; 3>69< L?B 89=287 9;2,270
)IL? L?=?HNFS
;H ;FGIMN =IGJF?N?FS >C_?L?HN ;JJLI;=B CM ;>IJN?> @IL >?;FCHA
QCNB NCG?P;LSCHA PIF;NCFCNS ;H> @;NN;CF?> >CMNLC<ONCIHM .;NB?L NB;H ;MMOGCHA
NB;N NB? P;LC;H=? =B;HA?M NBLIOAB NCG? ;M
@IL ?R;GJF?
; MKO;L? LIIN JLI=?MM
NB? H?Q ;JJLI;=B ;MMOG?M MNI=B;MNC= NCG? =B;HA?M M GIL? ;=NCPCNC?M N;E?
JF;=? CH NB? G;LE?NM
NCG? =B;HA?M @;MN?L ;H> A?H?L;N?M AL?;N?L PIF;NCFCNS %H
; =?LN;CH Q;S
NB?M? GI>?FM ;L? HIN >CMMCGCF;L NI NB? )CRNOL? I@ CMNLC<ONCIHM
$SJINB?MCM I@ F;LE >?M=LC<?> CH B;JN?L %H>??>
NB? ) $ CM ;
MJ?=C;F =;M? I@ NB? GI>?FM >CM=OMM?> <?FIQ QB?H NB?L? CM HI =IH>CNCIH;F NCG?
=B;HA?
0B? NCG? =B;HA?> JLI=?MM CM OM?> CH GI>?FCHA NB? OH>?LFSCHA ;MM?N JLC=?
;H> @IL JLC=CHA IJNCIHM 0B? OM? I@ NCG? =B;HA?> (fPS JLI=?MM?M NI JLC=?
IJNCIHM CM HIQ EHIQH ;M (fPS IJNCIH JLC=CHA 0B? (fPS IJNCIH JLC=CHA GI>?F
L?FC?M B?;PCFS IH =B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIHM ;M Q?FF ;M NB? L?JL?M?HN;NCIH I@ (fPS
JLI=?MM?M 0B?M? NQI NIJC=M ;L? >CM=OMM?> CH B;JN?LM ;H> .?;>?LM ;L?
?H=IOL;A?> NI L?@?L NI NB?M? =B;JN?LM <?@IL? JLI=??>CHA NI (fPS IJNCIH JLC=CHA
<?FIQ
(?N OM >?HIN? NB? FIA I@ ;MM?N JLC=?M ;M ZN &)# ?N
3CNBION FIMM I@
A?H?L;FCNS
;MMOG? NB;N NB? JLI=?MM ZN MN;LNM ;N NCG? [
@LIG 0B?
MN;N?G?HN NB;N NCG? =B;HA?M CH ; MNI=B;MNC= G;HH?L G?;HM NB;N NB?L? ?RCMNM
;H CH=L?;MCHA JLI=?MM
QLCNN?H @N ( MI NB;N
ZN [ D4* (
8* \
"/* [ ! \
NB? =B;L;=N?LCMNC=
@OH=NCIH I@ NB? CH=L?;MCHA JLI=?MM
4* \
( ;H> NB? =B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH I@
NB? ILCACH;F JLI=?MM
8* \
8* \
1LDO8*
11LDO8* )@N 1L4* O
1LDDO4* 4* P! \
M* \
LDNO 4* P! \
'
&*+5.
*.?6<B@ 0.;161.A2 PCF =?<02@@2@ 12@0?6/21 /F A526? 05.?.0A2?6@A60
3B;0A6<; (52 0<??2@=<;1@ A< A52 4.::. 3B;0A6<; " :2.;@ "<?:.9 ;
C2?@2 .B@@6.; :2.;@ 2;2?.96G21 F=2?/<960 .;1 !- :2.;@ .?? 2
:.; !.1.; .;1 -<?
*;G? B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH ,;L;G?N?LM
#;OMMC;H %!?J J
2;LC;H=? #;GG;
?J '
" "
*%# %! ?J
'
#$ < ' '
#)5 <ME %" 7" . ?J& . & %" %' (
%' 7' ( ?J+ (+ . 7" 7'
866875B ><.- L?B 9;8,.<<.<
M MBIQH CH B;JN?L
NB?L? ;L? G;HS Q;SM NI L?JL?M?HN (fPS JLI=?MM?M
%H 0;<F?
Q? JLIPC>? ; M?F?=NCIH I@ =IGGIHFS OM?> (fPS JLI=?MM?M
NB?CL
=B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIHM
;H> NB? J;L;G?N?LM CHPIFP?> #)5 B;M <??H >?P?F
IJ?> <S ;LL
#?G;H
);>;H
;H> 5IL
*IN? NB;N NB? (fPS JLI=?MM?M CH=FO>? <INB =IHNCHOIOM ;H> >CM=IHNCHOIOM
JLI=?MM?M 0B? #;OMMC;H GI>?F CH 0;<F? CM NB? MCGJF?MN ?R;GJF? I@ ;
(fPS JLI=?MM
N;E?H @IL ; OHCN NCG? CH=L?G?HN
=ILL?MJIH>CHA NI NB? F;=E
/=BIF?M GI>?F 0B? =IGJIOH> ,ICMMIH JLI=?MM >?M=LC<?> H?RN QCFF <? >CM=OMM?>
?RN?HMCP?FS CH B;JN?L %N >?J?H>M IH NB? DOGJCHN?HMCNS J;L;G?N?L ;H>
IH NB? =B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH I@ NB? G;LE?L JLI=?MM 0B? =IGJIOH> ,ICMMIH
JLI=?MM CM =B;L;=N?LCT?> <S J?LCI>M I@ HI ;=NCPCNS
;FN?LH;N?> <S DOGJM QBIM?
MCT? CM >C=N;N?> <S NB? =B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH 8*
0BOM
NB? =IGJIOH>
,ICMMIH JLI=?MM ;FIH? =;HHIN =;JNOL? NB? JLIJ?LNC?M I@ WH;H=C;F L?NOLHM ON
NLC?M CH NB? ;LLCP;F I@ AII> H?QM JIMCNCP? CH=L?G?HNM ;H> <;> H?QM H?A;NCP?
CH=L?G?HNM
0B? *ILG;F %HP?LM? #;OMMC;H *%# JLI=?MM I@ ;LH>IL_*C?FM?H
;H> CNM A?H?L;FCT;NCIH <S !<?LF?CH
'?FF?L
;H> ,L;OM? ;L? >?MCAH?>
NI A;CH ; <?NN?L OH>?LMN;H>CHA I@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ L?NOLHM A?H?L;N?> <S ;
MNI=B;MNC= PIF;NCFCNS GI>?F
0B? #)5 GI>?F
CHNLI>O=?> <S ;LL ?N ;F
;FFIQM =;JNOLCHA NB?
;MSGG?NLS I@ NB? F?@N ;H> LCABN N;CFM I@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH %N =;H ;FMI <? PC?Q?>
;M ; A?H?L;FCT;NCIH I@ NB? 2;LC;H=? #;GG; JLI=?MM
0B?M? P;LCIOM =B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIHM =;H <? OM?> ;M =;H>C>;N? >CMNLC<O
NCIHM I@ ;MM?N L?NOLHM M G?HNCIH?> ?;LFC?L
NI CHNLI>O=? N?GJIL;F >?J?H>?H=S
;H> NI ?RJF;CH PIF;NCFCNS =FOMN?LCHA
Q? H??> ;H CH=L?;MCHA JLI=?MM @IL NB? NCG?
=B;HA? 3? NOLH NI NBCM CMMO? CH NB? H?RN MO<M?=NCIH
182,. 8/ =1. =26.,1*70270 9;8,.<<
;H> . N
@N `M KZ(
M
NB?H NB? =B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH G;S <? ?RJL?MM?> ;M
4* \
1LDO4* - [( \
"/* . [( \
`
(
QB?L?
"/* [*
- [( \
(
!),$ [*
* ,%($ [*
P\
. [( \
(
!)-$ [*
8
P\'
!9=287 9;2,270
MMOG? NB;N NB? >SH;GC= I@ NB? ;MM?N JLC=? B;M <??H ?MN;<FCMB?> <S NB? =BIC=?
I@ ; (fPS JLI=?MM ;H> I@ ; NCG?=B;HACHA JLI=?MM 3B;N Q? H??> HIQ CM
; LCMEH?ONL;F JLI=?MM NB;N Q? =;H OM? NI JLC=? >?LCP;NCP? ;MM?NM 0BCM CM ;
=IGJFC=;N?> CMMO?
<?=;OM? ;MM?N JLC=?M ;L? HIQ >LCP?H <S ; (fPS JLI=?MM
3CNB NB? ?R=?JNCIH I@ NB? LIQHC;H GINCIH
NB? (fPS JLI=?MM @;GCFS =IHN;CHM
JLI=?MM?M QCNB DOGJM I@ ;FF MILNM 0BCM G?;HM NB;N
CH A?H?L;F
NB?L? G;S HIN
<? ; OHCKO? G;LNCHA;F? G?;MOL? +H? JIMMC<F? Q;S NI JLI=??> CM NI @IFFIQ
);>;H ;H> )CFH? ;H> NI J?L@ILG ; MI=;FF?> 0<;C2E6AF 0<??20A6<; 3?
G;S PC?Q NBCM ;M ; =B;HA? I@ >LC@N MI NB;N NB? L?MOFNCHA JLI=?MM CM ; >CM=IOHN?>
G;LNCHA;F? 0B? NLC=E CM NI L?JF;=?
?N ? "/* [ D4*
QCNB
?N ? "/* [ T[ D4*
MO=B NB;N
LLN 1?N ? '
0B? N?LG CH T L?JL?M?HNM ; =IHP?RCNS =ILL?=NCIH /O<MNCNONCHA CHNI
;H> OMCHA ?RJL?MMCIH
Q? A?N
LLN
LHN LLN 4* P! P
T[ Y
[ &)# 4* P! P
'
'
M ; H?RN MN?J
Q? H??> NB? LCMEH?ONL;F =B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH 0BCM @IFFIQM
?;MCFS %@ M* \
CM NB? =B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH I@ ZN
NB?H
4* P! \
M* \
1LDOM* "/* P\ Z Y[
DO
0BCM ;JJLI;=B CM ;FMI OM?> CH NB? ;=NO;LC?M FCN?L;NOL? QB?L? CN CM =;FF?> NB? !MM=B?L
NL;HM@ILG /?? ;FMI #?L<?L ;H> /BCO
"IL =?LN;CH (fPS JLI=?MM?M
NBCM =B;HA? I@ >LC@N CM HIN ?HIOAB NI I<N;CH LCME
H?ONL;FCNS ;H> ; =B;HA? I@ NCG? H??>M ;FMI NI <? G;>?
/NLO=NOL;F +JNCIH ,LC=CHA
";2,270 89=287< @2=1 ;2<47.>=;*5 ,1*;*,=.;2<=2, />7,=287
CH NB? ?H>
ACP? ; L?F;NCP?FS MCGJF? ?RJL?MMCIH (?N OM NB?L?@IL? =IHMC>?L NB?
"IOLC?L NL;HM@ILG I@ /4 R
1H@ILNOH;N?FS
/4 R
N?H>M NI ? ;M R '
M ; =IHM?KO?H=?
/4 R
( HIN =IHP?LACHA NI T?LI
CM HIN MKO;L? CHN?AL;<F? ;H>
CNM "IOLC?L NL;HM@ILG =;HHIN <? =IGJON?> 0I IP?L=IG? NBCM >C^=OFNS
;LL
;H> );>;H CHNLI>O=? ; 1.:=2;6;4 3.0A<? LF NB;N =IHP?LA?M NI T?LI
;M R ' IHMC>?LCHA
J4 R
LF /4 R
/4 R
LF J4 R
(
Q? I<N;CH ; MKO;L? CHN?AL;<F? @OH=NCIH NB;N L?N;CHM ;FF NB? CH@ILG;NCIH =IH
N;CH?> CH /4 R
IHMC>?L HIQ NB? "IOLC?L NL;HM@ILG
.
! ]
"/* P]R
J4 R
KR'
NB? OJJ?L ;H> FIQ?L <IOH> I@ NB? CHN?AL;F >?J?H> IH NB? >?HMCNS X I@ NB? JLC=?
;N NCG? @ +@N?H CN CM JIMMC<F? NI A?N ;H C>?; I@ ; L?;MIH;<F? L;HA? IP?L QBC=B
NI CHN?AL;N? <S =IHMC>?LCHA NB? ;P;CF;<F? MNLCE? JLC=?M 3? G;S ?RJ?=N NB;N NB?
>CMNLC<ONCIH I@ @ONOL? IJNCIH JLC=? NI LIOABFS G;N=B NB? L;HA? I@ MNLCE?M
692;2,*5 ;.<>5=<
0B?L? ;L? ;MJ?=NM I@ ?GJCLC=;F WH>CHAM NB;N ;L? I@ L?F?P;H=? CH >?=C>CHA C@ ;
GI>?F CM OM?@OF IL HIN 0B? WLMN ;MJ?=N =IH=?LHM NB? GI>?F J?L@ILG;H=? OM?>
@IL GI>?FCHA L?NOLHM 0B? M?=IH> =IH=?LHM NB? WN NI IJNCIH JLC=?M .?A;L>CHA
NB? WLMN KO?MNCIH
NB? NCG?=B;HA?> JLI=?MM =IP?LM ; F;LA? =F;MM I@ >CMNLC<ONCIHM
QCNB HOG?LIOM NCG?=B;HACHA JLI=?MM?M ;LL ?N ;F MBIQ NB;N (fPS
JLI=?MM?M QCNB CHWHCN? ;=NCPCNS JLIPC>? ; <?NN?L WN NI ;MM?N L?NOLHM NB;H NB?
=IHNCHOIOM LIQHC;H GINCIH 0BCM L?MOFN CM CGJILN;HN ;M GIMN WH;H=C;F GI>?FM
;L? <;M?> IH LIQHC;H GINCIH IL IH ; =IG<CH;NCIH I@ LIQHC;H GINCIH ;H>
DOGJM I@ WHCN? MCT?
N NB? NCG? I@ QLCNCHA
NB?L? CM HIN GO=B QILE IH N?MNCHA NB? J?L@IL
G;H=?M I@ NCG?=B;HA?> (fPS JLI=?MM?M NI JLC=? IJNCIHM ;LL ?N ;F
=IHMC>?L P;LCIOM NCG?=B;HA?> (fPS JLI=?MM?M ;H> NQI ;JJLI;=B?M NI I<N;CH
LCMEH?ONL;F JLC=?M +@ NB? NQI ;JJLI;=B?M N?MN?>
NB? IH? >?M=LC<?> ?;LFC?L CH
NBCM M?=NCIH
C?
NB? =IHP?RCNS =ILL?=NCIH G?NBI>
;JJ?;LM NI SC?F> ; <?NN?L
WN NI IJNCIH JLC=?M %H N?LGM I@ J?L=?HN;A? JLC=CHA ?LLILM
NB? #)5 GI>?F
JLI>O=?M ; P?LS AII> WN
=IGJ;L;<F? NI NB;N I@ NB? *ILG;F %HP?LM? #;OMMC;H
/NLO=NOL;F +JNCIH ,LC=CHA
%H ;>>CNCIH
C@ ;FF DD B;P? NB? M;G? >CMNLC<ONCIH QCNB G?;H ;H> P;LC;H=?
NB?H NB? =?HNL;F FCGCN NB?IL?G CH>C=;N?M NB;N
).
. D DD
+ (
(
* :
QB?L? (
>?HIN?M NB? MN;H>;L> HILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH QCNB T?LI G?;H ;H>
OHCN P;LC;H=?
;H> YZ G?;HM =IHP?LA?H=? CH >CMNLC<ONCIH 0I OH>?LMN;H> NB?
=IH=?JN )I@ =IHP?LA?H=? CH >CMNLC<ONCIH
Q? MBIOF> CG;ACH? MCGOF;NCHA L?;FCT;
.
NCIHM I@ D DD @IL F;LA? : G;HS NCG?M
;H> M=;FCHA NBCM MOG ;M CH>C=;N?> CH
@ILGOF; 0B?H
<S =IHMNLO=NCHA NB? BCMNIAL;G I@ NB?M? MCGOF;N?> L;NCIM
Q? QIOF> I<M?LP? NB;N CN CM CH>CMNCHAOCMB;<F? @LIG NB? IH? I<N;CH?> @IL >L;QM
@LIG NB? (
>CMNLC<ONCIH
0I OH>?LMN;H> QB?L? NBCM @ILGOF; CHNOCNCP?FS =IG?M @LIG
CG;ACH? NB;N NB?
DD ;L? HILG;F 0B?H ACP?H NB;N ; MOG). I@ HILG;F L;H>IG P;LC;<F?M CM HILG;F
"LIG NB?L? IH
L?M=;FCHA NB? MOG I@ NB? DD SC?F>M
. ).
,
DD
. D
DD : ( :
+ (
'
D
* :
$*7-86 @*54<
"LIG NB? =?HNL;F FCGCN NB?IL?G
Q? CH@?L NB;N
C@ ;FF DD B;P? T?LI G?;H
NB?H
) .
. DD
,
+ + DD (
'
* : : D
;H> ? <? NB? ;AAL?A;N? P;FO? I@ DD 3B;N =IOF> <? NB? P;FO? I@ ? ;N NCG? @
ACP?H NB;N NB?L? =IOF> JIN?HNC;FFS <? ;H CHWHCN? HOG<?L I@ MN?JM <?NQ??H ;H>
@ F?;LFS
NBCM L?KOCL?M MIG? M=;FCHA
MCH=?
C@ ?;=B MN?J B;> OHCN F?HANB
NB?H
;H CHWHCN? HOG<?L I@ MN?JM QIOF> ;AAL?A;N? NI ; F?HANB NB;N CM ;FMI CHWHCN?
+OL N;ME B?L? CM NI M=;F? ?;=B MN?J CH MO=B ; G;HH?L NB;N NB? JLI<F?G >I?M
HIN ?RJFI>? 0I >I NBCM
F?N OM >CPC>? ( @ CHNI : CHN?LP;FM
?;=B I@ F?HANB
%H INB?L QIL>M
Q? B;P? : @ QBC=B CGJFC?M NB;N @ *: *?RN
>?WH?
; [L?M=;F?>\ L;H>IG Q;FE
: : F
@ @ ,
AF ?F DD '
: : D
8 +
F?;LFS
AF CM ; L;H>IG P;LC;<F? 0B? M=;FCHA @;=NIL @ *: IL CM
=BIM?H @IFFIQCHA NB? [MKO;L?LIINI@NCG?\ LOF?
;H> Q? MB;FF M?? NB? <?H?WN
LIQHC;H )INCIH ;H> /NI=B;MNC= ;F=OFOM
0
N
-2
S
-4
-6
-8
0 20 40 60 80 100 120
Number of steps
I@ MO=B ; M=;FCHA @;=NIL MIIH 3B;N Q? Q;HN NI >I HIQ CM CH=L?;M? NB? MN?JM
: QBCF? ;>DOMNCHA R MI NB;N R L?G;CHM LIOABFS ;N NB? M;G? JF;=? 3? EHIQ
4 4
NB;N @IL ;FF [ ( @
NB?L? ?RCMNM ; R MO=B NB;N R . [ ) R
. ;M MBIQH
<?FIQ
4 4
R. [ R
.
/I ;M : CH=L?;M?M
Q? ;FMI B;P? NI CH=L?;M? R'
0B? H?RN MN?J CH NB? =IHMNLO=NCIH I@ NB? LIQHC;H GINCIH CM NI HIN? NB;N
AF CM >?WH?> @IL >CM=L?N? JICHNM R ( ( :' 0I =L?;N? ; =IHNCHOIOM NL;D?=
NILS
Q? =IHMNLO=N AN. ;M ; FCH?;L CHN?LJIF;NCIH <?NQ??H AF ;H> AF ;M
MBIQH AL;JBC=;FFS <?FIQ
AF
AN.
4
R. [ 4
R
.
N
AF
IHMNLO=NCIH I@ NB? LIQHC;H GINCIH
0B? ?RJL?MMCIH I@ AN. CM NLCPC;F NI QLCN? 0I >I MI >I?M HIN ;>> CHMCABNM @IL
QB;N @IFFIQM 3? NB?L?@IL? F?;P? NB? =IGJON;NCIH ;M ;H ?R?L=CM?
*IQ
Q? ;L? L?;>S NI MNO>S MIG? I@ NB? JLIJ?LNC?M I@ NBCM [L?M=;F?>\ L;H
>IG Q;FE AF
4 4
;H> . R =IG?M ;L<CNL;LCFS =FIM? NI [( ; @;=N Q? QLCN? ;M . R [ %N L?MOFNM NB;N
NB? NL;D?=NILS
;N NB? >CMN;H=? [( <?B;P?M ;M ; ( [
L;H>IG P;LC;<F? 0BCM
G?;HM NB;N
AN. CM =IHWH?> QCNBCH ; L?ACIH >?M=LC<?> <S NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH
( [
< "IL [ + Z
BIQ >I?M AN. AM. <?B;P? ;M :
3? WLMN M?F?=N R ;H> S MO=B NB;N R
[
R
( ;H> S
Z
S
4 4
M <?@IL?
;M :
[ R .
Z S. ;H>
:@ ,
F
AN. AM. AF AG DD '
:
DG
0BCM G?;HM NB;N CH=L?G?HNM I@ NB? NL;D?=NILS NB;N Q? B;P? DOMN =IHMNLO=N?>
<?B;P? FCE? ; HILG;F L;H>IG P;LC;<F? QCNB P;LC;H=? ?KO;F NI [ Z
NB? NCG?
CH=L?;M? IP?L QBC=B NB? CH=L?G?HNM ;L? G?;MOL?> )IL?IP?L
NB? JLIJ?LNS I@
NB? CH=L?G?HNM >I?M HIN >?J?H> IH [
NB? NCG? IP?L QBC=B Q? =IHMC>?L NB?
CH=L?G?HNM 3? M;S NB;N NB? CH=L?G?HNM ;L? MN;NCIH;LS
= "IL [ ) [ ) [
) [
QB;N CM NB? L?F;NCIHMBCJ <?NQ??H AN. AN. ;H>
AN.
AN.
M <?@IL?
Q? =BIIM? MIG? SD MI NB;N @IL :
SD [D %@ : CM
MO^=C?HNFS F;LA?
NB?H DD @IL P S
( ( S ;H> DE @IL Q S
( ( S
9 , G
4
;L? CH>?J?H>?HN 0B? =IHM?KO?H=? CM NB;N AN. AN. . DD
9 DG
. , G
4
;H> AN
AN. . DD ;L? CH>?J?H>?HN 0BCM @IFFIQM @LIG NB?
DG
@;=N NB;N ?;=B CH=L?G?HN CM ; HILG;F L;H>IG P;LC;<F? ;H>
LIQHC;H )INCIH ;H> /NI=B;MNC= ;F=OFOM
/V] AN. AN. ( AN.
AN. '
$?H=?
@IL ; L?M=;F?> L;H>IG Q;FE
AN. ( >?WH?> IH ( @
Q? =;H =IH=FO>?
NB;N
C CN MN;LNM
QCNBION FIMM I@ A?H?L;FCNS
;N
CC CN CM >CMNLC<ON?> ;N [ ;M ;H ( [
CCC CN B;M CH>?J?H>?HN ;H> MN;NCIH;LS CH=L?G?HNM ;H>
CP CN CM =IHNCHOIOM
0B? FCGCN JLI=?MM
C?
;M :
M;NCM@SCHA C
CC
CCC
;H> CP CM =;FF?>
; LIQHC;H GINCIH IL ; 3C?H?L JLI=?MM QLCNN?H ;M CN JLI=?MM NB;N IHFS
M;NCMW?M C ;H> CCC CM =;FF?> ; (fPS JLI=?MM
QBC=B G;S CH=FO>? DOGJM (fPS
JLI=?MM?M JF;S ;H CGJILN;HN LIF? CH GIL? ;>P;H=?> QILE IH >?LCP;NCP? JLC=CHA
;H> NB? JLIJ?LNC?M I@ (fPS JLI=?MM?M ;L? >CM=OMM?> CH >?N;CF CH B;JN?L
0B? WLMN ?KO;FCNS @IFFIQM @LIG NB? @;=N DD @IL P
( ( R ;L? EHIQH ;N NCG?
R 0B? M?=IH> ?KO;FCNS @IFFIQM @LIG NB? @;=N NB;N DD @IL P
( ( R =IHN;CHM
HI CH@ILG;NCIH =IH=?LHCHA @ONOL? P;FO?M I@ DD @IL P R
( ( S'
*IN? NB;N C@ NB? @ONOL? I@ ; JLI=?MM IHFS >?J?H>M IH NB? J;MN NBLIOAB
CNM =OLL?HN P;FO? NB?H MO=B ; JLI=?MM CM =;FF?> ; !.?8<C6.; =?<02@@ $?H=?
4 4
;H> NB;N [ # R
. 0BCM G?;HM NB;N # . 0B? KO;>L;NC= P;LC;NCIH
: :
@ @ @ @
CN CN
?F ?F DF #(
: : : :
<?=;OM? 1 DF
*IN? NB;N QBCF? NB? CH=L?G?HN I@ ; LIQHC;H GINCIH
G;S <? JIMCNCP? IL H?A;NCP? QB?H ;MMI=C;N?> QCNB ; ACP?H JLI<;<CFCNS
NB?
KO;>L;NC= P;LC;NCIH CM ?KO;F NI NB? MCT? I@ ?;=B MN?J
%=8,1*<=2, 27=.0;*=287
(?N NB? LIQHC;H GINCIH CN L?JL?M?HN NB? JLC=? I@ ;H ;MM?N ;H>
N NB? HOG
<?L I@ OHCNM
IL JILN@IFCI Q?CABN
CHP?MN?> IH NB;N ;MM?N %H JL;=NC=?
N CM B?F>
=IHMN;HN IP?L CHP?MNG?HN J?LCI>M @N?L ; NCG? CHN?LP;F #
NB? Q?;FNB =B;HA?
CM
N CN CN
;H> CH
+4
N?AL;F MO=B ;M
N KCN 1H@ILNOH;N?FS
=F;MMC=;F CHN?AL;NCIH >I?M HIN QILE
CH =IHNCHOIOM NCG? CHPIFPCHA LIQHC;H GINCIH %H>??>
NB? =F;MMC= =;F=OFOM
MOAA?MNM NB;N
. 4 . 4
CN KCN K CN C4 C '
3? QCFF MBIQ NB;N NBCM L?MOFN IHFS BIF>M C@ NB? CHN?AL;NCIH CM >?WH?> CH ; P?LS
J?=OFC;L Q;S 0I M?? NBCM
>?WH? [ ) [ ) [ ) ) [. @ ;H>
+4
D [D ( [D
NB?H NB? CHN?AL;F CN KCN =;H <? ;JJLIRCG;N?> <S NB? MOG
.
,
5. C CN CN
D
. .
C4 C
, ,
CN CN C CN
D D
.
,
CN C
C CN '
D
"IL =IGJIH?HN I A;CH C CN ( @LIG NB? JLIJ?LNS I@ KO;>L;NC=
P;LC;NCIH
;JJLI;=B?M D [D
;H> Q? A?N
.
, .
,
C CN D [D
'
D D
)
.
"IL =IGJIH?HN J 3? B;P? &%' CN C
C CN 0I
. D
M?? NBCM
F?N OM ;MMOG? NB;N [D ( D ( ;H>9[D ;L? ?;=B M?J;L;N?> <S ?R;=NFS
9 IH?
4 4
DD %H NB;N =;M?
Q? B;P? CN C . DD ;H> C CN . DD
%N @IFFIQM NB;N
.
, .
@ ,
&%' CN C
C CN &%' DD DD
. . :
D D
@ 1DD DD '
%H
NB? M?=IH> ?KO;FCNS CM DOMNCW?> <S CHPIECHA NB? F;Q I@ F;LA? HOG<?LM
0B? NBCL> ;H> F;MN ?KO;FCNS =IG?M @LIG NB? CH>?J?H>?H=? <?NQ??H DD N NBCM
JICHN
Q? B;P?
.
C4 C @ ,
5. D [D
'
D
=;F=OFOM CH
;H> NB? CHN?AL;F CM =;FF?> ; 'A?.A.;<C6A05 6;A24?.9 $IQ?P?L
C@
NB? MN;H>;L> =;F=OFOM @ILGOF; HI FIHA?L BIF>M ;H> Q? B;P? ;H A<
6;A24?.9
. 4 , .
CN KCN &%' CN CN CN (
.
D
QB?L? ' /D . )[D [D ) ' !;=B NSJ? I@ CHN?AL;NCIH B;M CNM ;>P;HN;A?M
;H> >CM;>P;HN;A?M %H WH;H=?
Q? NSJC=;FFS @ILG JILN@IFCI ;N NB? <?ACHHCHA
I@ NB? NCG? J?LCI> ;H> Q;CN @IL NB? JLC=?M NI ?PIFP? H;NOL;F =BIC=? I@
CHN?AL;NCIH QCFF NB?L?@IL? <? ;H %NI CHN?AL;NCIH $?H=?
Q? ;FQ;SM CHN?LJL?N NB?
+4 ,.
MNI=B;MNC= CHN?AL;F
N KCN ;M NB? FCGCN &%'.
N CN CN (
D
QB?L? NB? [D M M;NCM@S [ ) [ ) [ ) ) [. @ 3? B;P? DOMN M??H NB;N
MN;H>;L> =;F=OFOM QCFF ACP? OM ; QLIHA ;HMQ?L @IL NBCM NSJ? I@ CHN?AL;NCIH
;H>
CH>??> ;HS CHN?AL;NCIH QCNB
* 0B?L?@IL?
Q? H??> MNI=B;MNC= >C_?L?HNC;F
?KO;NCIHM ;H> NIIFM MO=B ;M NB? %NI F?GG; NI >?;F QCNB MNI=B;MNC= =;F=OFOM
CHPIFPCHA LIQHC;H GINCIH 0B?M? ;L? NB? NIJC=M QBC=B Q? NOLH NI CH NB? H?RN
NQI M?=NCIHM
QB?L? [LYTZ( Z
G?;HM NB;N CM ; @OH=NCIH I@ [LYTZ ;H> Z @ LYTZ =IOF>
<? DN IL ?P?HNM INB?L NB;H DN %@ [LYTZ ;FMI CH=FO>? ?P?HNM NB;N ;L? HIN DN
F?;LFS
1DN D [( ;H> B DN [' #CP?H NB;N CN CM HILG;F
CN
@IFFIQM NB;N DN [( [
'
+H=? NB? G?;HCHA I@ NB? P;LCIOM CHN?AL;FM >?WHCHA DN B;M <??H OH>?LMNII>
=8F< 5.66*
QB?L? _
KM _
M
_
K_(
M _
M _
M _
M
_
;
(
QB?L? ;
CM ; L?G;CH>?L MO=B NB;N
;
&%' '
%H INB?L QIL>M
NB? L?MN CH NB? ;JJLIRCG;NCIH =IHN;CHM N?LGM NB;N ;L? MG;FF?L
NB;H '
3? ;L? AICHA NI ;JJFS NBCM C>?; NI MIG? @OH=NCIH M( QB?L? M >?J?H>M IH
;H %NI JLI=?MM
DN ( ;H> NCG?
[ 3? ;MMOG? NB;N M CM MGIINB CH NB? M?HM? NB;N
;FF NB? L?KOCL?> >?LCP;NCP?M ?RCMN *?RN
Q? CHNLI>O=? NB? %NI JLI=?MM
. N . N
DN D M KZ M KCM '
DN DN N N CN CN
'
,M ,M
M DN ( [
M DN ( [
DN DN
,D ,[
, M , M , M
D N D N
D N D N
'
,D ,D,[ ,[
*IQ
NB? C>?; CM NI E??J NBIM? N?LGM NB;N ;L? I@ NB? M;G? IL>?L I@ G;AHCNO>?
;M ;H> CN CN
;H> >LIJ ;FF NB? INB?L N?LGM NB;N ;L? MG;FF?L !R;=NFS
;M Q? >I CH ; L?AOF;L >C_?L?HNC;NCIH
Q? A?N
DN DN N N CN CN
(
DN DN
N N CN CN
N N CN CN
N (
DN DN
N N CN CN
'
*IQ MO<MNCNON? NB? HIHT?LI N?LGM CHNI NB? 0;SFIL ?RJ;HMCIH CH
;H>
CN CN
@LIG NB? JLIJ?LNS I@ KO;>L;NC= P;LC;NCIH CH
NI A?N
,M ,M
, M
M DN ( [
M DN ( [
N N CN CN
'
,D ,[ ,D N
0;ECHA NB? FCGCN ;M ACP?M OM NB? @ILGOF; I@ %NIZM F?GG;
, M ,M ,M ,M
KM K[ N KCN '
,D N ,D N ,[ ,D
,M ,M , M
( "/* DN
?N ( "/* DN
?N '
,[ ,DN ,DN
%NIZM F?GG; ACP?M K?N ?N ?N K[?N KCN ' %@ Q? >?WH? 3
Q? B;P?
K?N 3 ?N K[ ?N KCN (
;H> ?N CM M;C> NI @IFFIQ ; 42<:2A?60 ?<D;6.; :<A6<; 3? =;H ?;MCFS M?? NB;N
?N B;M MIG? HC=? JLIJ?LNC?M
AII> @IL >?M=LC<CHA NB? <?B;PCIL I@ MNI=E JLC=?M
"CLMN
MCH=? <S =IHMNLO=NCIH ?N "/* DN
Q? M?? NB;N L?NOLHM >?WH?> CH NBCM Q;S B;P? ; =IHMN;HN P;LC;H=? $?H=?
CH>?
J?H>?HNFS @LIG NB? F?P?F
PIF;NCFCNS QCFF <? =IHMN;HN 0BCM CM ; >?MCL;<F? @?;NOL?
K?N 3 ?N K[ ?N KCN (
B;M @L?KO?HNFS <??H OM?> ;M ; JLC=? JLI=?MM I@ NB? OH>?LFSCHA ;MM?NM 0;ECHA
;A;CH %NIZM F?GG;
Q? I<N;CH
K &)# ?N
3 K[ KCN '
%HN?AL;NCHA
Q? A?N
&)# ?4
&)# ?
3 @ C4 C
'
#CP?H NB;N C4 C CM ( @
( CN @IFFIQM NB;N
&)# ?4
&)# ?
3 @( @ '
0BOM
NB? JLC=? B;M ; FIAHILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH ;H> L?NOLHM ;L? HILG;F L;H>IG
P;LC;<F?M %H JL;=NC=?
BIQ?P?L
GIMN WH;H=C;F ;MM?N L?NOLHM ;L? HIN HILG;F
L;H>IG P;LC;<F?M $?H=?
NB? ;NN?GJN CH NBCM <IIE NI =IP?L NB? HIH#;OMMC;H
@?;NOL?M ;H> NB? ;MMI=C;N?> GI>?FCHA ;MJ?=NM
KDN K[ KCN (
KD N K[ KC N (
` M DN ( D N ( [
'
;@N?L >C_?L?HNC;NCIH
,M ,M ,M
, M
K` KDN KD N K[ KDN
,D ,D ,[ ,D
, M
, M , M
KD N
K[
KDN KD N
,D ,[ ,D ,D
, M , M
KDN K[ KD N K['
,D ,[ ,D ,[
M CH NB? =;M? I@ ; MCHAF? MIOL=? I@ OH=?LN;CHNS
Q? B;P? KDN
K[
KD N
K[ ;H> KDN KD N KCN KC N ' "OLNB?LGIL?
+ OMCHA NB?
+
M;G? B?OLCMNC= ;LAOG?HNM ;M <?@IL?
Q? A?N KCN KC N K[#N K[# N
K[ #N # N $?H=?
NB? JLI>O=N KCN KC N <?B;P?M
IH ;P?L;A?
;M K[ .?
ALIOJCHA ;FF NB? N?LGM
Q? I<N;CH NB? @IFFIQCHA <CP;LC;N? ?RN?HMCIH I@ %NIZM
F?GG;
, M , M
, M
K`
,D ,D ,D ,D
,M ,M ,M
K[
,D ,D ,[
,M ,M
KCN KC N '
,D ,D
IOL I<D?=NCP? CM
0I MBIQ NB;N ; , ! CM ;MMI=C;N?> NI NB? LIQHC;H GINCIH 0I >I MI
Q? QCFF OM? ;LAOG?HNM I@ =;F=OFOM ;H> CHNLI>O=? NB? HINCIH I@ NL;HMCNCIH
JLI<;<CFCNS
0I >?LCP? NB? , ! ;MMI=C;N?> QCNB NB? NL;HMCNCIH JLI<;<CFCNS I@ ; A?H
?L;F >C_OMCIH JLI=?MM 3? QCFF J?L@ILG NBCM >?LCP;NCIH <S OMCHA G;LNCHA;F?
JLIJ?LNC?M
0I JLIPC>? NB? MIFONCIH NI =?LN;CH , !M OH>?L <IOH>;LS =IH>CNCIHM 3?
QCFF L?@?L NI NBCM MIFONCIH N?=BHCKO? ;M NB? "?SHG;H';= NB?IL?G
NL;HMCNCIH JLI<;<CFCNS M;SM QB?L? ; JLI=?MM QCFF <? ;N MIG? JICHN CH NB?
@ONOL? ACP?H CNM JL?M?HN JIMCNCIH 3B;N ;<ION ; LIQHC;H GINCIH 3B?L? =;H
LIQHC;H )INCIH ;H> /NI=B;MNC= ;F=OFOM
NB? LIQHC;H GINCIH >C_OM?M ;A;CH ;H> CN G;S N;E? ;FF MILNM I@ P;FO?M $IQ =;H
Q? >?M=LC<? NB? JLI<;<CFCNS I@ C4
;N NCG? @
=IH>CNCIH;F IH CN <?CHA FI=;N?>
;N _ ;N NCG? [ /CH=? C4 _
( @ [
Q? B;P? C4 _( @ [
0B?L?@IL?
NB? FI=;NCIH I@ C4 CM =IHWH?> <S _( @ [
%H INB?L QIL>M
NB?
LIQHC;H GINCIH ;N NCG? @ =;HHIN MCGJFS <? DOMN ;HSQB?L?
*IQ
Q? ;ME ; @OLNB?L KO?MNCIH
[QB;N CM NB? JLI<;<CFCNS I@ B;PCHA C4 .
QB?L? . 'a IG ) a ) IO ( ;M CH "CAOL? \ 0I =IGJON? NBCM JLI<;<CF
CNS
Q? H??> NI CHN?AL;N? IP?L NB? =13 I@ C4 ' "IL NBCM JOLJIM?
Q? H??> ;H
?RJL?MMCIH @IL NB? >?HMCNS I@ C4 ACP?H NB;N NB? LIQHC;H GINCIH CM FI=;N?>
;N _ ;N NCG? [ 0BCM CM ?;MS CH NBCM =IHN?RN
<?=;OM? Q? B;P? M??H NB;N C4 CM
#;OMMC;H 0BOM Q? B;P?
C4 _
W C4 ( @ )_( [
+ + "/* (
+ C4 . ) CN _( [ + IG ) C4 ) IO ) CN _( [
IG _ C4 _ IO _
+ + ) + ) + CN _( [
. +,
+ "/* \ K\
# ,
IO _ IG _
+
+ (
QB?L?
CM NB? 013 I@ ; MN;H>;L> HILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH M NB?M? =IGJON;NCIHM
CH>C=;N?
CN CM MCGJF? NI G?;MOL? NB? JLI<;<CFCNS I@ WH>CHA NB? LIQHC;H GINCIH
CH ; ACP?H CHN?LP;F ;N MIG? @ONOL? >;N?
K_ _( [
K[ _( [
KCN
CM
, W ,W ,W
_( [
_( [
'
,_ ,_ ,[
'IFGIAILIP <;=EQ;L> ;H> @ILQ;L> ?KO;NCIHM
30
20
10
W =x
t
B
0
-10
-20
-30
0 100 200 300 400 500 600
20
$.A5 <3 . ?<D;6.; :<A6<;
30
20
10
W =x
t
B
0
-10
-20
-30
0 100 200 300 400 500 600
+ "/*
(
,_
,W
` _
` _
+ "/*
'
,[
$?H=?
NB? <;=EQ;L> ?KO;NCIH CM
,W
, W
'
,[ ,_
!J !J
/CH=? !J !J
!N !4
!J
!R !J
!S ;H> !R !S
Q? I<N;CH ?;MCFS NB? @IFFIQCHA
@ILQ;L> ?KO;NCIH
,W
, W
'
,@ ,`
/I @;L
Q? >?LCP?> CH ; J;LNC=OF;L =;M? H ;FN?LH;NCP?
GIL? A?H?L;F
QB?L? O
CM ; MGIINB CHN?AL;<F? @OH=NCIH *?RN
Q? N;E? NB? ?RJ?=N;NCIH I@
M `( [
QCNB L?MJ?=N NI DM @IL Z ) [ L?G;LE IH HIN;NCIH P;FO?M I@ L;H>IG
P;LC;<F?M ;N NCG? @ ;L? >?HIN?> <S a( P;FO?M ;N NCG? [ ;L? >?HIN?> <S `( ;H>
NBIM? ;N NCG? Z ;M _ 3? I<N;CH
.
M _( Z
O a
W a( @ )_( Z
Ka
.T .
O a
W a( @ )`( [
W `( [)_( Z
K`
T S
. .
O a
W a( @ )`( [
Ka W `( [)_( Z
K`
S T
1 1O D4
)DN `( [)DM _( Z
1 M `( [
)DM _( Z '
0B? WLMN ?KO;FCNS CH NBCM M?KO?H=? CM DOMN NB? >?WHCNCIH 0B? M?=IH> FCH? MN;N?M
NB;N ;M IH? AI?M @LIG DM _ NI D4 a( IH? GOMN NL;HMCN NBLIOAB ;FF JIMMC<F?
D4 `' 0B? Q;S Q? B;P? >?=IGJIM?> NB? JLI<F?G ;MMOG?M CGJFC=CNFS NB;N
NB? JLI=?MM CM ; );LEIPC;H JLI=?MM 0B? NBCL> ?KO;NCIH L?ALIOJM NB? >C_?L
?HN N?LGM MFCABNFS >C_?L?HNFS 0B? H?RN ?KO;NCIH CHNLI>O=?M NB? ?RJ?=N;NCIHM
IJ?L;NIL NI MBIQ NB;N B?L? Q? B;P? CGJFC=CNFS >?LCP?> ; =IH>CNCIH IH =IH>C
NCIH;F ?RJ?=N;NCIHM %H NB? F;MN ?KO;NCIH
Q? L?JF;=? NB? CHH?L ?RJ?=N;NCIH <S
CNM P;FO? 0BCM M?KO?H=? I@ ?KO;NCIHM
MN;LNCHA @LIG NB? ?H> ;H> JLI=??>CHA
OJQ;L>M
MBIQM NB;N
1 M `( [
)DM _( Z M _( Z
'
0BOM
NB? <?MN AO?MM @IL NB? @ONOL? P;FO? I@ M D4 ( @ =IH>CNCIH;F IH ;FF ;P;CF
;<F? CH@ILG;NCIH ;N NCG? Z CM M _( Z
0BCM L?MOFN G?;HM NB;N M DN ( [
CM ;
G;LNCHA;F? %N GOMN
NB?L?@IL?
<? NB;N CNM >LC@N CM HCF "LIG %NIZM F?GG;
Q?
G;S QLCN?
, M ,M ,M ,M
KM K[ KDN '
,_ ,_ ,[ ,_
#CP?H NB;N M _( [
B;M T?LI >LC@N
CN GOMN <? NB;N
, M ,M ,M
'
,_ ,_ ,[
+
1MCHA NB? >?WHCNCIH I@ M
M _( [
T O a
W a( @ )_( [
Ka
Q? A?N
. . .
,M ,W , M , W ,M ,W
O a
Ka( O a
Ka( O a
Ka(
,_ T ,_ ,_ T ,_ ,[ T ,[
;H> Q? =IH=FO>? NB;N
.
, W ,W ,W
O a
Ka '
T ,_ ,_ ,[
LIQHC;H )INCIH ;H> /NI=B;MNC= ;F=OFOM
400
350
300
250 ← probability m as s of 1
200
150
100
50 ← infinitely thin
0
-2 -1.5 -1 -0.5 0 0.5 1 1.5 2
!KO;NCIH GOMN BIF> @IL ;FF P;FO?M I@ O IHMC>?L ;M ; J;LNC=OF;L =BIC=?
I@ O @OH=NCIH NB? CL;= @OH=NCIH >?HIN?> <S < _
0B? CL;= @OH=NCIH B;M <??H
CHNLI>O=?> <S NBCM JBSMC=CMN NI =B;L;=N?LCT? NB? JLI<;<CFCNS @OH=NCIH ;==IL>CHA
NI QBC=B MIG? J;LNC=F? =B;HA?M CHMN;HN;H?IOMFS MN;N? "CAOL? ACP?M ;
AL;JBC=;F L?JL?M?HN;NCIH I@ MO=B ; @OH=NCIH 0B? @OH=NCIH CM ;=NO;FFS ; >?HMCNS
%N B;M CHWHCN? B?CABN
HI QC>NB
;H> ; JLI<;<CFCNS G;MM ?KO;F NI
3CNB NB? =BIC=? I@ O a
S a
@OH=NCIH Q? I<N;CH NB;N NB? CHN?AL;F
SC?F>M
, W `( @ )_( [
,W `( @ )_( [
,W `( @ )_( [
_( [
_( [
'
,_ ,_ ,[
"IL NB? LIQHC;H GINCIH
NLCPC;FFS ;H>
0BCM MBIQM NB;N QCNB
; MIG?QB;N GIL? ;>P;H=?> ;JJLI;=B
Q? L?=IP?L NB? , ! I@ NB? LIQHC;H
GINCIH
.B76*7*, /8;6>5*
N NBCM MN;A?
Q? B;P? MBIQH NB;N ; >C_OMCIH QLCNN?H
KDN DN ( [
K[ DN ( [
KCN
CM ;MMI=C;N?> QCNB ; NL;HMCNCIH JLI<;<CFCNS W `( @ )_( [
( NB;N I<?SM NB? , !
ACP?H <S "LIG NB?L? IH
CN CM N?GJNCHA NI M??E MIFONCIHM NI J;LNC;F
"?SHG;H';= @ILGOF;
, M ,M ,M
YM(
,_ ,_ ,[
OH>?L ; <IOH>;LS =IH>CNCIH
M a( @
O a
'
M _( [
LL N _( [
(
.
N _( [
O a
W a( @ )_( [
Ka'
T
, N ,N ,N
'
,_ ,_ ,[
N NBCM MN;A?
Q? B;P? MFCABNFS MCGJFCW?> NB? JLI<F?G CH NB;N NB? LCABNB;H>
MC>? I@ NB? >C_?L?HNC;F ?KO;NCIH CM T?LI 1MCHA ;H;FIAIOM ;LAOG?HNM ;M CH NB?
JL?PCIOM M?=NCIH
Q? HINC=? NB;N ;FMI NB? NL;HMCNCIH JLI<;<CFCNS W GOMN M;NCM@S
NBCM NL;HMCNCIH JLI<;<CFCNS .?NL;=CHA ;FF NB? MN?JM @LIG NB? JL?PCIOM M?=NCIH
NB? MNI=B;MNC= JLI=?MM DN QCNB / ! ACP?H <S CM =IGJ;NC<F? QCNB NBCM
, ! %N L?G;CHM NI <? MBIQH NB;N ?KO;NCIHM ] ;L? ; MIFONCIH
=IGJ;NC<F? QCNB NB? <IOH>;LS =IH>CNCIH 0BCM CM ;=BC?P?> <S HINC=CHA
NB;N W CM ; NL;HMCNCIH JLI<;<CFCNS M [ =IHP?LA?M NI @
NB? JLI<;<CFCNS I@
GIP?G?HN QCFF >?=L?;M? >L;G;NC=;FFS =NO;FFS
CH NB? FCGCN NBCM JLI<;<CFCNS
G?FNM >IQH NI ; CL;= G?;MOL? 3? B;P?
&%' W a( @ )_( [
R a
'
N 4
%N @IFFIQM NB;N
.
L
&%' L O a
W a( @ )_( [
Ka O _
'
N 4 T
LIQHC;H )INCIH ;H> /NI=B;MNC= ;F=OFOM
$?H=?@ILNB
CH NB? FCGCN
;M [ =IHP?LA?M NI @
NB? MIFONCIH M =IHP?LA?M NI NB?
<IOH>;LS =IH>CNCIH 0BCM MBIQM NB;N M P?LCW?M NB? , ! ;H> CM =IGJ;NC<F?
QCNB NB? <IOH>;LS %HMJ?=NCIH I@ ?KO;NCIHM ] MBIQM NB;N NB?
MIFONCIH NI NB? JLI<F?G >?WH?> <S ;H> CM HINBCHA ?FM? <ON ;
>CM=IOHN?> =IH>CNCIH;F ?RJ?=N;NCIH M _( [
LL 1O D4
)DN _( [( QB?L?
NB? NL;HMCNCIH JLI<;<CFCNS CM >?N?LGCH?> <S KDN DN K[ DN KCN ( NB;N CM
&)# _4 *_N
W _4 ( @ )_N ( [
+ + "/* + '
_4
%H JL;=NC=;F ;JJFC=;NCIHM
;M NB? L?;>?L G;S M?? CH NB? G;CH J;LN I@ NB?
<IIE
KOCN? MIG? AO?MMCHA G;S <? L?KOCL?> NI AI @LIG NB? , !
NI NB? / !
%H NBCM =B;JN?L
Q? JLIPC>? MIG? N?=BHC=;F >?N;CFM IH NB? @OH>;G?HN;FM L?
A;L>CHA G;LNCHA;F? ;H> NB? =B;HACHA G?;MOL? ;JJLI;=B NI IJNCIH JLC=CHA
0BCM ;JJLI;=B CM P?LS JIJOF;L ;GIHA MIG? G;NB?G;NC=C;HM <?=;OM? @IL G;L
NCHA;F?M
G;HS L?MOFNM B;P? ;FL?;>S <??H ?MN;<FCMB?> 3? J?L@ILG ; =B;HA? I@
G?;MOL? NI =IHP?LN NB? JLC=? JLI=?MM CHNI ; G;LNCHA;F? ;M?> IH NBCM ?R;G
JF?
Q? ?RJF;CH NB? =IH=?JNM .;>IH*CEI>SG >?LCP;NCP?
#CLM;HIPZM NB?IL?G
*;=270*5.<
1 9M ) N 9N ( @IL Z + [(
1 CM ) CN CN ( @IL Z + ['
0B? M?=IH> ?KO;FCNS ;<IP? L?FC?M IH NB? @;=N NB;N NB? ?RJ?=N;NCIH I@ NB? @ONOL?
?PIFONCIH I@ NB? 3C?H?L JLI=?MM <;M?> IH =OLL?HN CH@ILG;NCIH CM HCF "OLNB?L
GIL?
C@ OO CM MIG? Q?FF<?B;P?> @OH=NCIH
NB?H
. M . N . N
1 OO KCO OO KCO OO KCO '
%N CM ?;MS NI JLIP? NBCM L?MOFN <S CHPIECHA NB? >?WHCNCIH I@ ; MNI=B;MNC= CHN?AL;F
. M ,
OO KCO &%' ON CN CN
(
.
1*70270 9;8+*+252=B 8/ * 78;6*5 -2<=;2+>=287
*IQ Q? CHNLI>O=? NB? =IH=?JN =;FF?> 05.;42 <3 A6:2 0BCM CM >IH? <S =B;HACHA
NB? >LC@N I@ NB? 3C?H?L
JLI=?MM
IHMC>?L NB? GIG?HN A?H?L;NCHA @OH=NCIH I@
; HILG;F P;LC;N? : (
. .
R R R
_
10 L L W _
K_ L + "/* K_(
@IL 0B? MSG<IF 1 QCNB ; MO<M=LCJN < G?;HM NB? ?RJ?=N;NCIH CM N;E?H
OH>?L NB? ILCACH;F < G?;MOL?
B?L? ; : (
"LIG
Q? B;P?
.
R
10 L + "/* _ _ _ K_
. 5
4
+ "/* _ K_
.
L + "/* _ K_
"/* '
.;>IH*CEI>SG >?LCP;NCP?
9 _
(
W _
2;<*78?F< =1.8;.6
3? =;H ;FMI ;JJFS NB? =B;HACHA JLI<;<CFCNS JLI=?>OL?M NI MNI=B;MNC= JLI=?MM?M
3? =IHMC>?L NB? ;LCNBG?NC= LIQHC;H GINCIH
0B?H
Q? B;P?
. .
_
11 DN _X _
K_ _+ + "/* K_'
[ [
);LNCHA;F? L?JL?M?HN;NCIH NB?IL?G
CN CN [(
QB?L? CM ; =IHMN;HN *IQ CN B;M ; >LC@N I@ [ OH>?L NB? JLI<;<CFCNS <
/?NNCHA ;M ;<IP? IH? =;H OH>I NB? >LC@N 1H>?L ; H?Q JLI<;<CFCNS
CH>O=?> <S
CN QCFF <?=IG? : ( [
; H?Q MN;H>;L> LIQHC;H GINCIH
0B? .;>IH*CEI>SG >?LCP;NCP? CM
;>;JNCHA
9N "/* CN [ '
0B? L?F;NCIH K= 9N K< >?WH?M ; JLI<;<CFCNS G?;MOL? = QBC=B CM ?KOCP;F?HN
NI < 0;ECHA %NIZM F?GG;
Q? ;FMI I<N;CH NB;N 9N CM ; G;LNCHA;F? MCH=? CNM
>LC@N CM HCF
%H NB? G;CH J;LN I@ NB? <IIE
Q? OM? NBCM N?=BHCKO? NI =B;HA? NB? >LC@N I@
; LIQHC;H GINCIH S?N L?N;CHCHA NB? JLIJ?LNS NB;N OH>?L ; H?Q JLI<;<CFCNS
0B? @ILG;F JLII@ I@ NBCM NB?IL?G =;H <? @IOH> CH G;HS JLI<;<CFCNS N?RN
<IIEM 0B? CHNOCNCIH <?BCH> CN CM NB;N 9N CM ; G;LNCHA;F?
;H> B?H=?
CN GOMN
B;P? ; >LC@N NB;N CM ?KO;F NI T?LI FMI
ACP?H NB;N CN A?H?L;N?M NB? CH@ILG;
NCIH >LCPCHA NB? G;LNCHA;F?
CN GOMN <? NB;N 9N CM ; @OH=NCIH I@ CN ' MMOG?
NB?L?@IL? NB;N 9N M CN ( N?LGM
' 1MCHA %NIZM F?GG; ;H> NB? @;=N NB;N NB?
>LC@N I@ NB? L?MOFNCHA >SH;GC=M GOMN <? HCF
IH? I<N;CHM NB;N
K9N M7 CN
N?LGM
KCN '
NB? NB?IL?G B;M HINBCHA NI M;S CH N?LGM I@ NB? ?RJL?MMCIH N;E?H <S N %N
DOMN M;SM NB;N NB? @OH=NCIH N GOMN ?RCMN ;H> NB;N CN QCFF <? Q?FF <?B;P?> %H
NB? =;M? NB;N NB? ?RJL?MMCIH I@ NB? G;LNCHA;F? 9N CM EHIQH
NB?H CN <?=IG?M
JIMMC<F? NI CH@?L N '
/?? @IL CHMN;H=? ';L;NT;M ;H> /BL?P?
1*;*,=.;2<=2, >7,=287< *7- 8>;2.;
&;*7</8;6<
%H NBCM =B;JN?L
Q? CHNLI>O=? NB? =B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH ;H> MIG? I@ CNM JLIJ
?LNC?M /?=NCIH 3? ;FMI CFFOMNL;N? B?L? P;LCIOM L?MOFNM I@ "IOLC?L ;H;FS
MCM
QBC=B CM L?F;N?> NI NB? CHP?LMCIH ;H> CHN?AL;NCIH I@ =B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH
/?=NCIH 0B? CHN?HNCIH B?L? CM HIN NI JLIPC>? ;H ?RB;OMNCP? NL?;NG?HN
I@ NB?M? NIJC=M <ON NI JLIPC>? MO^=C?HN <;MC= =IH=?JNM @IL MNO>SCHA IJNCIH
JLC=CHA "IL GIL? ;>P;H=?> L?@?L?H=?M
M?? 1MB;EIP IL '?H>;FF ;H>
/NO;LN @IL =B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIHM ;H> LCAB;G @IL @;MN "IOLC?L
NL;HM@ILG
1*;*,=.;2<=2, />7,=287<
QB?L? 28 _
CM NB? =OGOF;NCP? >CMNLC<ONCIH @OH=NCIH 013
M8 _
CM ; JLI<;
<CFCNS >CMNLC<ONCIH @OH=NCIH =13
;H> \ CM ; L?;F HOG<?L 0B? F;MN ?RJL?MMCIH
CM P;FC> IHFS QB?H M8 _
?RCMNM
QB?L?;M CM P;FC> L?A;L>F?MM I@
QB?NB?L ; =13 ?RCMNM IL HIN "IL CHMN;H=?
C@ D CM ; >CM=L?N? L;H>IG P;LC;<F?
*<2, 9;89.;=2.<
C 8
( MCH=? "/*
CC )8 \
)
( @IL ;FF L?;F \( MCH=?
. .
DOR
)8 \
) L M8 _
K_
DOR L M8 _
K_
'
CCC 8 \
8 \
( MCH=?
. .
8 \
LDOR M8 _
K_ LDOR M8 _
K_ 8 \
'
CP 8 \
CM =IHNCHOIOM @IL ;FF L?;F \ 0BCM @IFFIQM >CL?=NFS @LIG NB? @;=N NB;N
NB? ?RJIH?HNC;F @OH=NCIH CM ; =IHNCHOIOM @OH=NCIH
P <8= \
LDO= 8 H\
' 0BCM OM?@OF L?MOFN @IFFIQM CGG?>C;N?FS @LIG
<8= \
1 LDO<8= '
86.7=< *7- =1. ,1*;*,=.;2<=2, />7,=287
3? OM? NB? BILCTIHN;F <;L ;NIJ I@ I NI >?HIN? NB? =IGJF?R =IHDOA;N? I@ I
"IL O 8 ?9
NB? =IGJF?R =IHDOA;N? I@ O CM O
QB?L? O 8 ?9
B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIHM
.
K8 \
P _M8 _
K_ P1 D (
K\ O
.
K 8 \
_ M8 _
K_ 1 D (
K\ O
.
KI 8 \
PI _I M8 _
K_ PI 1 D I '
K\I O
$?H=?
NB? =B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH =IOF> <? OM?> NI =IGJON? NB? GIG?HNM I@
; L;H>IG P;LC;<F? JLIPC>?> NB;N NB? GIG?HN ?RCMNM
87?85>=287 =1.8;.6
0B? =B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH CM ;FMI OM?@OF CH NB? =IHMNLO=NCIH ;H> NB? MNO>S I@
NB? >?HMCNS I@ ; MOG I@ L;H>IG P;LC;<F?M %@ D ;H> D ;L? NQI CH>?J?H>?HN
L;H>IG P;LC;<F?M ;H> D D D
NB?H 8 \
8 \
8 \
0B?
JLII@ @IFFIQM CGG?>C;N?FS @LIG NB? JLIJ?LNC?M I@ NB? ?RJ?=N;NCIHM IJ?L;NIL
@IL
QBC=B CN CM EHIQH NB;N NB? ?RJ?=N;NCIH I@ NQI CH>?J?H>?HN L;H>IG P;LC;<F?M
?KO;FM NB? JLI>O=N I@ NB? ?RJ?=N;NCIHM
4 5
8 \
1 LDO8 8 1 LDO8 LDO8 8 \
8 \
'
CM ;FMI ;
=B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH +<PCIOMFS
NBCM NB?IL?G ?RN?H>M NI NB? MOG I@ ?P?H
GIL? CH>?J?H>?HN L;H>IG P;LC;<F?M ;M Q? QCFF M?? CH NB? @IFFIQCHA JLIJIMCNCIH
";898<2=287
2A D ( ( DI /2 . @2A <3 U 6;12=2;12;A ?.;1<: C.?6
./92@ .;1 92A J ( ( JI /2 U ?2.9 ;B:/2? 0<;@A.;A@ 3 .99 A52 ?.;1<: C.?6./92@
5.C2 A52 @.:2 12;@6AF D6A5 05.?.0A2?6@A60 3B;0A6<; 8 \
A52; A52 3<99<D6;4
?29.A6<; 5<91@
> 8 >% 8% [
8 J \
8 JI \
'
$?<<3 3? B;P?
> 8 >% 8% \
1 "/* P J D ''' JI DI
\
1 "/* PJ \D
"/* PJI \DI
1 "/* PJ \D
1 "/* PJI \DI
8 J \
8 JI \
'
0B? WLMN ?KO;FCNS @IFFIQM @LIG NB? >?WHCNCIH I@ NB? =B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH
0B? NBCL> ?KO;FCNS @IFFIQM @LIG NB? ;MMOGJNCIH I@ CH>?J?H>?H=? ;GIHA NB?
L;H>IG P;LC;<F?M "OLNB?LGIL?
C@ J J JI
NB?H
I
8 8% \
8 \
'
B;L;=N?LCMNC= "OH=NCIHM ;H> "IOLC?L 0L;HM@ILGM
'72:>.7.<<
0QI 013 M 2 _
;H> 2 _
;L? C>?HNC=;F C@ ;H> IHFS C@ NB?CL =B;L;=N?LCMNC=
@OH=NCIHM \
;H> \
;L? C>?HNC=;F
C?
\
;H> \
;L? ?KO;F @IL
;FF P;FO?M I@ \ %H INB?L QIL>M
NB? =B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH =B;L;=N?LCT?M =IG
JF?N?FS NB? OH>?LFSCHA =13 ;H> 013 I@ D 0BCM JLIJ?LNS CM J;LNC=OF;LFS OM?@OF
QB?H QILECHA IH NB? CHP?LM? "IOLC?L NL;HM@ILG F;N?L %H MIG? =;M?M
NBCM JLIJ
?LNS CM MO^=C?HN @IL [AO?MMCHA\ NB? MIFONCIH
;M MBIQH CH NB? ?R;GJF? <?FIQ
/OJJIM? NB;N D ( ( DI
CM ; M?N I@ HILG;F L;H>IG P;LC;<F?M
?;=B QCNB
G?;H D ;H> P;LC;H=? D
@IL P
( ( U FMI F?N J ( ( JI <? ; M?N I@ L?;F
=IHMN;HNM
NB?H Q? B;P?
> 8 >% 8% \
"/* J P\ J \ "/* I JI P\ I JI \
"/* J ''' I JI
P\ J ''' I JI \ '
3? L?=IAHCT? NB;N NBCM CM NB? =B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH I@ ; H?Q HILG;F L;H>IG
P;LC;<F? QCNB G?;H J I JI ;H> P;LC;H=? J I J I ' 0BCM L?MOFN
CM >O? NI NB? Q?FFEHIQH JLIJ?LNS NB;N ; FCH?;L =IG<CH;NCIH I@ CH>?J?H>?HN
HILG;F L;H>IG P;LC;<F?M SC?F>M ; H?Q HILG;F L;H>IG P;LC;<F?
7?.;<287 =1.8;.6
%N CM I@N?H CGJIMMC<F? NI DOMN [AO?MM\ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH @OH=NCIH @LIG NB? =B;L
;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH %H MO=B =;M?M
CN CM H?=?MM;LS NI B;P? ;H ?RJFC=CN @ILGOF; @IL
CHP?LNCHA NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH @LIG NB? =B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH 0B? CHP?LMCIH NB?
IL?G CM DOMN MO=B ; @ILGOF; );HS GI>?LH IJNCIH JLC=CHA GI>?FM
MO=B ;M NB?
MNI=B;MNC= PIF;NCFCNS IJNCIH JLC=CHA GI>?F
OM? NB? CHP?LMCIH I@ =B;L;=N?LCMNC=
@OH=NCIH NI JLIPC>? M?GC=FIM?> @ILG IJNCIH JLC=CHA @ILGOF;?
";898<2=287
;C2?@6<; A52<?2: 3 8 [
6@ A52 05.?.0A2?6@A60 3B;0
A6<; <3 A52 013 28 _
A52;
.
' LDNR 8 [
28 _
K['
[
12A.6921 =?<<3 3<? A52 6;C2?@6<; A52<?2: :.F /2 3<B;1 6; ?.:P? <?
2;1.99 .;1 'AB.?A 05.=A2?
.66*
2A .;1 [ /2 ?2.9 ;B:/2?@ A52;
.
,%( [
K[ ZNU
(
[
D52?2 ZNU
6@ A52 @64; 3B;0A6<; A.86;4 A52 C.9B2@
( .;1
?2@=20A6C29F
3<? ) ( .;1 +
B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIHM
CN @IFFIQM NB;N
. . R .
ZNU _ \
M8 \
K\ M8 \
K\
M8 \
K\
R
28 _
'
*IQ
@IL a H IP
a a IP ;H> ' a
D a a
Q? A?N
4 DNR 5
' LDNR 8 [
L 8 [
LDNR 8 [
'
P
0B?H @LIG JLIJ?LNS CCC I@ " CH /?=NCIH
Q? A?N
DNR
' LDNR 8 [
L 8 [
LDNR 8 [
'
P
%@ Q? MO<MNCNON? NBCM L?MOFN CHNI NB? .$/ I@
Q? A?N
. DNR
L 8 [
LDNR 8 [
K[
P[
. DNR . .
L LDNR DNO
LDNO M8 \
K\ L M8 \
K\ K[
P[ P[
. . DNRO DNRO
L L
M8 \
K\ K['
P[
/CH=? NB? =IGJF?R HOG<?L a H IP =;H ;FMI <? QLCNN?H ;M )a) !), P ,%(
Q? B;P?
@LIG NB? L?MOFNM <S !OF?L IH =IGJF?R ?RJI
H?HNC;F
LD
!), P ,%( (
;H>
,%( LD
LD
*P'
/O<MNCNONCHA NBCM L?MOFN CHNI ACP?M
. .
,%( [ _ \
K[ M8 \
K\
[
. .
,%( [ _ \
K[ M8 \
K\(
[
28 _
K[
P[
. DNR
L
28
8 [
K[
P[
.;1 .
M8 _
LDNR 8 [
K[
28 _
K[ K[
P[ P[
. DNR
L 8 [
*?RN
Q? B;P?
.
8 [
28
K[(
P[
.
8 [
28
K['
P[
/O<MNCNON? NBCM @IL CH ACP?M
MI NB;N
O \
LDOR 8 \
LDOR 8 \
'
%N L?MOFNM NB;N
O \
O \
" LDOR 8 \
(
;H> NB;N ?P?HNO;FFS
.
M8 _
" LDOR 8 \
K\'
0BCM @ILGOF; SC?F>M CH JL;=NC=? AII> L?MOFNM 0B?L? ;L? ;FMI CHN?AL;FM NB;N
;L? HIN >?WH?> ;N /CH=? B?L? NBCM <IOH> ;JJ?;LM ?RJFC=CNFS
CN CM ?;MC?L NI
=IHNLIF NB? CHN?AL;H> ;LIOH> ; H?CAB<ILBII> I@
8>;2.; =;*7</8;6 *7- ,1*;*,=.;2<=2, />7,=287
0B? @ILGOF;? NB;N Q? B;P? I<N;CH?> MI @;L ;L? P?LS OM?@OF CH NB;N NB?S MBIQ
NB;N @IL ; >?HMCNS CN CM JIMMC<F? NI I<N;CH NB? ;MMI=C;N?> =B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH
NB?H
; MCGJF? =IGJON;NCIH M??H ;M ;H ?R;GJF? ;N NB? <?ACHHCHA I@ NBCM =B;J
N?L
MBIQM NB;N
8 \
"/* P\ \ '
*IQ
;JJFSCHA ACP?M OM NB? CHN?AL;F
.
LDOR LDO O K\'
Q? ?RJF;CH BIQ NB? ""0 LIONCH? =;H <? ?R?=ON?> @LIG JLIAL;GM 0SJC=;FFS
NB?M? JLIAL;GM >CMJIM? I@ NQI @OH=NCIHM H;G?> ;H> NB;N CGJF?G?HN
NB? NL;HM@ILG ;H> CHP?LM? NL;HM@ILG OMCHA NB? IIF?S0OE?S ;FAILCNBG "IL
; ACP?H P?=NIL I@ HOG<?LM _I ( QB?L? U
( ( :( NB?M? @OH=NCIHM =IGJON?
.
,
DF _I LD FI. ( @IL R
( ( :(
I
.
,
_I DF LD FI. ( @IL U
( ( :(
:
F
QB?L? : CM NSJC=;FFS ; JIQ?L I@ 0B? CMMO? CM BIQ IOL CHN?AL;FM =;H <?
<LIOABN CHNI NBCM >CM=L?N? @ILG 0I L?F;N? =B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH QCNB =IHNCH
OIOM "IOLC?L NL;HM@ILG
Q? ;JJFS NI ; =B;HA? I@ P;LC;<F? \* ^
;H> K\ K^ %N @IFFIQM NB;N
.
M8 _
LD QR 8 ^
K^(
.
8 ^
LD Q M8 _
K_'
NB?M? @ILGOF; ;L? OM?@OF 3? QCFF JL?M?HNFS MBIQ BIQ NB? WLMN CHN?AL;F G;S <?
>CM=L?NCT?> CHNI ;H ?RJL?MMCIH MO=B ;M 3? B;P?
CH NB? A?H?L;F =;M?
QB?L? \I O U
*INC=? NB;N Q? QCFF ?RJF;CH F;N?L BIQ O CM =BIM?H %H
NB? MCAH G?;HM [;JJLIRCG;N?FS ?KO;F NI\ *IQ
F?N _, ( _5 <? NB?
MOJJILN I@ _ ;H> >?WH?
_5 _,
R (
:
MI NB;N NB? @IFFIQCHA ACP?M ; >CM=L?NCT;NCIH I@ NB? _ L;HA?
_F _, R R
( @IL R
( ( :'
0B? WLMN N?LG CHPIFPCHA _, G;S <? =IGJON?> IH=? ;H> @IL ;FF ;H> >I?M HIN
JLIPC>? >C^=OFNC?M 0I =;MN NBCM @ILGOF; CHNI NB? ?RJL?MMCIH I@ NB? ""0
M?N
O R '
:
:
O ( @IL F;LA? :(
: _5 _, _5 _,
ACPCHA NB? ?RJL?MMCIH @IL O 3? HINC=? NB;N NB? OM? I@ NB? ""0 CGJIM?M
MNLIHA =IH>CNCIHM IH NB? ALC> IP?L QBC=B NB? \I ;L? >?WH?> %@ NB? L;HA? IP?L
QBC=B NB? _ ;L? >?WH?> CM F;LA?
NB?H O QCFF <? MG;FF ;H> PC=? P?LM;
M ;H ?R;GJF?
=IHMC>?L NB? =;M? I@ NB? HILG;F >?HMCNS @IL QBC=B NB?
=B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH =;H <? QLCNN?H ;M
+ I
8 \I
LD+ I '
M ; HOG?LC=;F ?R?L=CM?
Q? OM? ; HILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH (
JFIN I@ NB?
L?;F J;LN I@ NB? " QIOF> L?P?;F CNM IM=CFF;NILS =B;L;=N?L %H "CAOL?
NB?
>;MB?> =OLP? >CMJF;SM NB? =13 I<N;CH?> ;@N?L LOHHCHA NB? =IGG;H> CH
)0( 3? HINC=? NB;N NB? MB;J? I@ NB? [=13 \ CM =ILL?=N
<ON NB? F?P?F
?RJ?LC?H=?> ; P?LNC=;F MBC@N 0BCM JB?HIG?HIH CM EHIQH ;M 16@0?2A6G.A6<; /6.@
"IL NB? =;M? ;N B;H>
; KOC=E WR QIOF> <? NI =IGJON? IP?L ; WH? ALC>
@IL ; QC>? L;HA? I@ \ ;N ; ACP?H JICHN _
;H> NI OM? NB? L?MOFN NI =ILL?=N @IL
NB? <C;M 0B? MBILN >;MB FCH? CH "CAOL? MBIQM NB? >?HMCNS ;@N?L NBCM <C;M
=ILL?=NCIH
B;L;=N?LCMNC= "OH=NCIHM ;H> "IOLC?L 0L;HM@ILGM
1
Density out of FFT
Corrected density
0.9
0.8
0.7
0.6
f(x)
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
x
20
$13 ?2@B9A 3?<: 16@0?2A2 ( 6;C2?@6<; <3 <3 . ;<?:.9 C.?6.A2
>69 ";8,.<<.<
H 6;160.A<? =?<02@@
5N
CM ; JLI=?MM NB;N N;E?M NB? P;FO? I@ QB?H ; J;LNC=OF;L
?P?HN I==OLM ;H> INB?LQCM? 0B? GIG?HNM CH NCG? QB?H NB? ?P?HN I==OLM
;L? L;H>IG NCG?M D /CH=? ;N NCG? [
Q? EHIQ QB?NB?L IL HIN NB? ?P?HN B;M
N;E?H JF;=? C?
5N
IL
NB?M? L;H>IG NCG?M D ;L? @A<==6;4 A6:2@ 0B?
@IFFIQCHA JC=NOL? >CMJF;SM CH NB? OJJ?L J;LN
,;LN
; JIMMC<F? L?;FCT;NCIH I@
;H CH>C=;NIL JLI=?MM %H NB? FIQ?L J;LN
,;LN
;H ?KOCP;F?HN L?JL?M?HN;NCIH
CM ACP?H
=<6;A =?<02@@
MIG?NCG?M =;FF?> ; 0<B;A6;4 =?<02@@
:N CH>C=;N?M BIQ
G;HS NCG?M NB? ?P?HN B;M I==OLL?> ;N ;H> <?@IL? NCG? [ :N CM ;H CHN?A?L
P;FO?> MNI=B;MNC= JLI=?MM QCNB
,
:N
N '
D
=IOHN?L ?R;GJF? I@ ; L;H>IG NCG? NB;N CM HIN ; MNIJJCHA NCG? CM 2&
%& 5& @IL LIQHC;H GINCIH 5& N NCG? I
Q? >I HIN EHIQ C@ 2& I
+HFS ;N NCG? 2
FIIECHA <;=EQ;L>M
=;H IH? F?;LH 2& $?H=?
2& CM HIN ; MNIJJCHA
NCG?
&OGJ ,LI=?MM?M
5N
-
NCG?
.
. NCG?
.
)IL?IP?L
:N CM =b>FbA =IHNCHO? b >LICN?
FCGCN? b A;O=B?
QBC=B FCN?L;FFS
G?;HM LCABN =IHNCHOIOM QCNB F?@N FCGCN %N CM J?LB;JM ?;MC?L NI ;JJL?=C;N? QB;N
=b>FbA G?;HM <S FIIECHA ;N NB? AL;JBC=;F JL?M?HN;NCIH I@ :N <?FIQ
:N
NCG?
.
%H G;HS MCNO;NCIHM
NB? CHN?L?MN CM HIN IHFS IH NB? ?P?HN I==OLLCHA <ON ;FMI IH
NB? G;AHCNO>? I@ NB? L?;FCT;NCIH "IL ?R;GJF?
QB?H NB? MNI=E L?NOLH ?R=??>M ;
NBL?MBIF>
Q? QIOF> Q;HN NI EHIQ NB? ?R;=N ;GIOHN NB? NBL?MBIF> CM ?R=??>?>
<S 0BCM NSJ? I@ JB?HIG?HIH =;H <? GI>?F?> QCNB QB;N CM =;FF?> ; :.?821
=<6;A =?<02@@ G;LE?> JICHN JLI=?MM CM ;H CH>C=;NIL JLI=?MM 5N =IOJF?> QCNB ;
M?KO?H=? I@ L?;FCT;NCIH E
QB?L? D >?HIN? NB? NCG?M QB?H NB? ?P?HN I==OLM
0B? L?;FCT;NCIHM E ;L? =;FF?> G;LEM
QBC=B ?RJF;CHM QBS NB? JICHN JLI=?MM
CM MIG?NCG?M =;FF?> ; :.?821 =<6;A =?<02@@ "CAOL? JL?M?HNM ; JIMMC<F?
L?;FCT;NCIH I@ E ;MMOGCHA NB;N NB?L? ;L? NBL?? DOGJM J?L OHCN NCG? IH ;P?L;A?
>CMNLC<ON?> ;M ; ,ICMMIH JLI=?MM ;H> ; DOGJ CHN?HMCNS E
(
'
%@ Q? OM? DN NI >?HIN? ; G;LE?> JICHN JLI=?MM
NB?H
.*
,
DN E (
D
;H> "CAOL? CM ; JC=NOL? I@ DN ( QB?L? NB? DOGJ ?P?HNM E ;L? NB? M;G? ;M
CH "CAOL? 3? HINC=? MIG? I@ NB? JIMCNCP? DOGJM MO=B ;M NB? IH? ;N NCG?
' N ;<ION NCG?
( NB?L? CM ; J;LNC=OF;LFS H?A;NCP? DOGJ
0B? ,ICMMIH JLI=?MM
-1
-2
-3
-4
-5
0 2 4 6 8 10
&1. "82<<87 9;8,.<<
%H NBCM M?=NCIH
Q? JLIPC>? ; GIL? @ILG;F >?M=LCJNCIH I@ NB? ,ICMMIH JLI=?MM
87<=;>,=287 8/ =1. "82<<87 -2<=;2+>=287
QB?L? V [
>?HIN?M ?F?G?HNM NB;N ;L? MG;FF?L
NB;H [
CC 0B? JLI<;<CFCNS I@ B;PCHA NQI ?P?HNM CH ;H CHWHCN?FS MG;FF NCG? CHN?LP;F
CM H?AFCAC<F? "ILG;FFS
NBCM =;H <? QLCNN?H ;M +NQI ?P?HNM I==OLLCHA
<?NQ??H [ ;H> [ [ V [
'
CCC 0B? HOG<?LM I@ I==OLL?H=? CH HIHIP?LF;JJCHA NCG? CHN?LP;FM ;L? CH>?J?H
>?HN
3CNB NB?M? ;MMOGJNCIHM
Q? =;H QLCN?
H?AF?=NCHA NB? V [
(
&OGJ ,LI=?MM?M
-5
-10
-15
-20
-25
-30
-35
-40
0 2 4 6 8 10
20
'6:B9.A6<; <3 . :.?821 =<6;A =?<02@@
+ :NN :N
[(
+ :NN :N
[(
+ :N N :N
[
+: N : '
3B;N ;<ION NB? JLI<;<CFCNS I@ B;PCHA IHFS IH? DOGJ 0B?L? ;L? U =BIC=?M I@
IHFS DOGJ ;GIHA U CHN?LP;FM
0B? F;MN =IHP?LA?H=? @IFFIQM @IL U 3B;N ;<ION NB? JLI<;<CFCNS I@ B;PCHA
R DOGJM CH ( @ 3? B;P?
U
+ :IN : R [
F
[
IF
R
U 4I
F
[
I
R U R
4 F
I
I
U U R
@
F @
(
R U U U
4 F U
I
";89.;=2.< 8/ =1. "82<<87 -2<=;2+>=287
Q? A?N
F
+: R L '
R
"LIG
Q? =;H >?LCP? NB? ?RJ?=N?> HOG<?L I@ DOGJM ;H> NB? =B;L;=N?L
CMNC= @OH=NCIH I@ NB? DOGJ ;M ; JOL? ,ICMMIH JLI=?MM ON
NI >I MI Q? QCFF
H??> NB? @IFFIQCHA F?GG;
.66*
, HF
HL< R '
R
F
<R
$?<<3 ?WH? M _
L "LIG 0;SFILZM M?LC?M ?RJ;HMCIH
Q? A?N
, HF _F
<R H _ H
_
M _
L
H_ (
R
F
, HF _F
H _ H
_
M
_
HL<R H R '
R
F
&OGJ ,LI=?MM?M
%@ Q? MO<MNCNON? _
CHNI M _
;H> M
_
Q? A?N
,
,
HF HF
L< ( ;H> HL< R '
R R
F F
*IQ
Q? =;H =IGJON? NB? ?RJ?=N?> HOG<?L I@ DOGJM ;M @IFFIQM
,
,
, F
F
1: R +: R RL L R (
R R
F F F
;H>
OMCHA (?GG;
Q? A?N
/CGCF;LFS
Q? =;H >?LCP? NB? =B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH I@ NB? JOL? DOGJ JLI=?MM
,
, LDOFF
, TF
F
* \
1LDO. LDOF L L L (
R R R
F F F
86.7=< 8/ 9>;. "82<<87 9;8,.<<
M MBIQH CH B;JN?L
NB? RNB GIG?HN
C@ CN ?RCMNM
=;H <? =IGJON?> ;M NB?
RNB >?LCP;NCP? I@ NB? =B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH * \
;H> ?P;FO;N?> ;N \
"LIG
Q? B;P?
* \
PLDO * \
(
* \
LDO L DO
* \
(
DO
* \
PL P L
DO
* \
LDO L DO
PLDO * \
'
%N @IFFIQM NB;N
1: (
1 : ( ;H> NBOM B : (
1 : '
$?H=?
NB? NBCL> GIG?HN ;<ION NB? G?;H CM
1 : 1:
1:
1 : 1 : 1:
'
0B? ,ICMMIH JLI=?MM
3? =;H ;FMI MBIQ NB;N NB? @IOLNB GIG?HN ;<ION NB? G?;H CM
1 : 1:
Z ?R : + (
7\ : '
0B? ?RJL?MMCIH I@ NB?M? GIG?HNM CM OM?@OF CH NB? =IHN?RN I@ G?NBI> I@ GIG?HN
?MNCG;NCIH CHPIFPCHA NB? ,ICMMIH JLI=?MM /O=B ; MCNO;NCIH ;LCM?M CH NB? =IHN?RN
I@ N?MNM I@ NB? )CRNOL? I@ CMNLC<ONCIH $SJINB?MCM
8698>7- "82<<87 9;8,.<<
).*
0B? =IGJIOH> ,ICMMIH JLI=?MM CM >?WH?> ;M DN D E ( QB?L? :N CM ;
JOL? ,ICMMIH JLI=?MM ;H> QB?L? E L?JL?M?HN NB? ;=NO;F DOGJM ;N NCG? D (
NB? GIG?HNM QB?H ; DOGJ N;E?M JF;=? 0B? =B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH I@ NB?
=IGJIOH> ,ICMMIH JLI=?MM JF;SM ; =LO=C;F LIF? CH NB? =IHMNLO=NCIH I@ NB? (fPS
JLI=?MM (?N
.*
,
8* \
1LDO8* 1 "/* P\ E "
F
.*
,
1 1 "/* P\ E " :N 1 9 \
.*
F
,
9 \
[
N , 9 \
[
ON N ON
F F
L L L
R R
F F
"/* [ 9 \
'
0B? M?=IH> FCH? =IH>CNCIHM IH NB? HOG<?L I@ DOGJM 0B? NBCL> FCH? @IFFIQM @LIG
NB? CH>?J?H>?H=? I@ NB? P;LCIOM E ;H> @LIG NB? >?WHCNCIH I@ ;H ?RJ?=N;NCIH
3? L?=IAHCT? CH NBCM @ILGOF; ; N?LG MCGCF;L NI _F *R' 0BCM N?LG QCFF =IHP?LA?
NI LR ' 3? GOFNCJFS <S MO=B ; N?LG ;H> ;FMI >CPC>?
0B?M? =IGJON;NCIHM MBIQ NB;N
CH GIMN =;M?M
?P?H NBIOAB NB? =B;L;=N?L
CMNC= @OH=NCIH CM ?;MS NI >?N?LGCH?
NB? >?HMCNS I@ ; =IGJIOH> ,ICMMIH JLI=?MM
G;S HIN ?RCMN CH ?RJFC=CN @ILG $IQ?P?L
ACP?H NB? =B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH
+ E #
_):N R +:N R
F G
F
, , F
[
N
+ E #
_ L '
R
F G
0B? WLMN ?KO;FCNS CHNLI>O=?M NB? M?N ;FF I@ JIMMC<F? P;FO?M NB;N :N =;H N;E?
%H NB? M?=IH> FCH?
Q? OM? NB? ;MMOGJNCIH I@ CH>?J?H>?H=S I@ NB? DOGJM ;H>
NB? JLIJ?LNC?M I@ =IH>CNCIH;F JLI<;<CFCNC?M
%H N?LGM I@ >?HMCNS
Q? I<N;CH
C@ NB? G;LE?LM ;L? (
( NB;N
, F
_ R
[
N
M8* _
+ "/* L '
R R R
F
M8 _
LR
R _
(
28 _
LR
R _
( ;H>
.
8 \
1LDO8 LDOR LR K_ (
P\
QB?L? M8 _
28 _
;H> 8 \
;L?
L?MJ?=NCP?FS
NB? >?HMCNS
>CMNLC<ONCIH
0B;N CM
EHIQCHA NB;N D + _ >I?M HIN B?FJ CH JL?>C=NCHA C@ D _ _ ,ON
NBCM CHNI NB? =IHN?RN I@ Q;CNCHA NCG?
CN G?;HM NB;N NB? JLI<;<CFCNS I@ ; <OM
0B? ?RJIH?HNC;F >CMNLC<ONCIH
Pdf
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
0 5 10 15
Cdf
1
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
0 5 10 15
;LLCPCHA <?NQ??H ;H> CM NB? M;G? QB?NB?L Q? B;P? ;FL?;>S Q;CN?>
GCHON?M IL BIOLM "ILG;FFS
Q? B;P?
+ D + _ ( D _ _
+ D _ _)D + _
+D + _
+ R R O
R
L K\
LR
LRR
LR
LR
R
L 28 _
'
0BCM MBIQM NB;N NB? ?RJIH?HNC;F P;LC;<F? B;M NB? JLIJ?LNS I@ [HI G?GILS\
86.7=< 8/ =1. .A987.7=2*5 ?*;2*+5.
8 \
(
P\
;H>
CH A?H?L;F
I UPI
8 \
I
'
P\
"IL \ ( Q? B;P?
I
8
UPI I
;H> NB?L?@IL?
1D I UI '
0BOM
1D (
1D ( ;H> B D (
1D
(
1D '
0B? JLI<;<CFCNS
[
(
K[
2 [
Q? I<N;CH NB;N
;M K[ (
M [
[
'
2 [
0B? ?RJL?MMCIH
2 [
CH NB? >?HIGCH;NIL
CM =;FF?> NB? @B?C6C<? 3B;0A6<;
2 [
"IL NB? ?RJIH?HNC;F >CMNLC<ONCIH
NB? B;T;L> @OH=NCIH CM =IHMN;HN QCNB
[
' *?RN
Q? HIN? NB;N
K2 [
K
2 [
M [
K['
$?H=?
MCH=?
K2 [
K &)# 2 [
[
(
K[ 2 [
K[
Q? >?>O=?
OL;NCIH <?NQ??H ,ICMMIH DOGJM
. N
&)# 2 [
&)# 2
Z
KZ(
;H>
. N
2 [
"/* Z
KZ
<?=;OM? 2
;H> &)# 2
0B? ;MMI=C;N?> =13 CM
. N
K2 [
M [
[
"/* Z
KZ '
K[
"CH;FFS
Q? I<N;CH M [
LN ( <?=;OM? [
CM ; =IHMN;HN ;H>
3? =IH=FO>? @LIG NBCM NB;N C@ Q? M??E ; >CMNLC<ONCIH NB;N B;M ; =IHMN;HN B;T;L>
@OH=NCIH
Q? ;ONIG;NC=;FFS I<N;CH NB? ?RJIH?HNC;F IH?
-1
-2
-3
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
9N :N -N (
9N0 0 :N ['
-* \
"/* [ LDO
"/* [P\
"/* [ LDO P\
'
FMI
Q? I<N;CH CGG?>C;N?FS @IL NB? =IGJ?HM;N?> =IGJIOH> ,ICMMIH JLI=?MM
-* \
"/* [ 9 \
P\1E "
'
0BCM ?RJL?MMCIH I@ NB? =IGJIOH> ,ICMMIH JLI=?MM QCFF JF;S ;H CGJILN;HN LIF?
CH NB? H?RN =B;JN?L
L?B ";8,.<<.<
DN DN#- DN$0 (
DN#- [ CN (
).*
DN$0 F E " [1E " '
%H NBCM >?WHCNCIH
;FF NBL?? MIOL=?M I@ L;H>IGH?MM
NB? LIQHC;H GINCIH
CN (
NB? JOL? DOGJ JLI=?MM
:N ( ;H> NB? DOGJ MCT?M E " ;L? CH>?J?H>?HN 0B? J;L;
G?N?LM ( ( ;H>
;L? L?;F HOG<?LM
QCNB ;H> 0B? =B;L;=N?LCMNC=
@OH=NCIH I@ DN#- CM
(fPS ,LI=?MM?M
#- \
"/* [ P\ \ '
,LIPC>?> NB;N NB? LIQHC;H GINCIH ;H> NB? =IGJ?HM;N?> ,ICMMIH JLI=?MM ;L?
CH>?J?H>?HN
=IG<CHCHA NB?CL =B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIHM SC?F>M NB? MI=;FF?> 12
6;2AA6 05.?.0A2?6@A60 3B;0A6<; IL ?RJL?MMCIH
.
' \
"/* [ P\ \ LDOT
P\a
K2 a
'
T
3? QCFF =;FF NB? N?LG ?H=FIM?> <S NB? =OLFS <L;=E?NM NB? ?RJIH?HN
/I @;L Q? =IG<CH?> ; LIQHC;H GINCIH QCNB ; =IGJIOH> DOGJ JLI=?MM 3?
=;H ;ME QB;N B;JJ?HM C@ Q? MOJ?LJIM? ;>>CNCIH;F =IGJIH?HNM IH=?LHCHA NB?
=IHNCHOIOM LIQHC;H GINCIH J;LN
NB? ;HMQ?L CM ?;MS /CH=? ; LIQHC;H GINCIH
CM #;OMMC;H
NB? MOG I@ LIQHC;H GINCIHM QCFF L?MOFN CH ;HINB?L LIQHC;H
GINCIH /O=B ; L?MOFN >I?M HIN BIF> @IL NB? DOGJ J;LN 0I OH>?LMN;H> NB?
CMMO? ;N B;H>
F?N OM @I=OM IHFS IH NB? DOGJ J;LN 3? A?N
<S GCRCHA NQI
DOGJM
?;=B QCNB CHN?HMCNS D ;H> G;LE?LM >CMNLC<ON?> ;M 2D
;H ?RJIH?HN I@
NB? @ILG
.
5 LDOT
P\a
K2 a
T
.
LDOT
P\a
K2 a
T
.
LDOT
P\a
Ka
(
T
L
P\a
P \a
P\a V a
a
V a
'
0B? N?LG V a
G?;HM N?LGM + MG;FF?L NB;H a %HMJ?=NCIH I@ L?P?;FM NB;N
5 CM CHN?AL;<F? ;M FIHA ;M a Ka
?RCMNM 3B?H NBCM =IH>CNCIH CM M;NCMW?>
;H> a
;M a
NB? JLI=?MM CM M;C> NI <? IH? I@ 6;H;6A2 .0A6C6AF
%HNOCNCP?FS
CN G?;HM NB;N CN CM JIMMC<F? NI B;P? G;HS DOGJM MI FIHA ;M NB?M?
DOGJM <?=IG? MG;FF?L ;H> MG;FF?L +@N?H NBCM ;MMOGJNCIH I@ ?RCMN?H=? ;H>
CC ;L? L?ALIOJ?> <S CGJIMCHA NB? @IFFIQCHA ;MMOGJNCIH
+
CCC T '%(
( a
Ka
)
%H NB? =IHMNLO=NCIH
Q? B;P? OM?> =IGJ?HM;N?> ,ICMMIH JLI=?MM?M 3?
G;S ;ME C@ CN CM H?=?MM;LS NI CGJIM? =IGJ?HM;NCIH 0I CHP?MNCA;N? NBCM CMMO?
+<PCIOMFS
NBCM CHN?AL;F CM Q?FF >?WH?> ;M H =IHP?LA?M NI
;M FIHA ;M
) +H
NB? INB?L B;H>
C@ NB? DOGJM B;P? HIN <??H =IGJ?HM;N?>
NB?H <?=IG?M
%H NBCM =;M?
MCGCF;L =IGJON;NCIHM ;M JL?PCIOMFS CH>C=;N? NB;N NB? CHN?AL;H> CM
WHCN? IHFS C@
)
F?;LFS
;M a QCFF =IHP?LA? NI T?LI
a QCFF <?=IG? F;LA?L
NB? F;LA?L NB? JIQ?L 0BCM CGJFC?M NB;N NB? =IGJ?HM;N?> ,ICMMIH JLI=?MM ;FFIQM
@IL ; F;LA?L DOGJ CHN?HMCNS NB;H NB? OH=IGJ?HM;N?> ,ICMMIH JLI=?MM 0BCM
L?MOFN CM ;FMI CHNOCNCP? %H>??>
C@ Q? =IHN?GJF;N? "CAOL? L?JL?M?HNCHA
; =IGJ?HM;N?> ,ICMMIH JLI=?MM
Q? HINC=? NB;N NB? JLI=?MM N?H>M NI L?P?LN
NIQ;L>M T?LI %H INB?L QIL>M
@IL MO=B ; JLI=?MM
NB? =IHM?KO?H=? I@ DOGJM
L?G;CHM =IHNLIFF?> #CP?H NB;N =IGJ?HM;N?> JLI=?MM ;FFIQM @IL GIL? ;=NCPCNS
CH N?LGM I@ MG;FF DOGJM
NB?S CH=ILJIL;N? ; F;LA?L =F;MM I@ JLI=?MM?M "IL NBCM
L?;MIH
Q? ;FQ;SM QILE QCNB =IGJ?HM;N?> =IGJIOH> ,ICMMIH JLI=?MM?M
0I =IGJF?N? IOL CHP?MNCA;NCIH I@ NB? CHN?AL;F
Q? ;FMI H??> NI ?R;GCH? CNM
<?B;PCIL @IL F;LA? DOGJM 3? QCFF @I=OM IH NB? OJJ?L N;CF 0B? MNO>S I@ NB?
FIQ?L N;CF QIOF> JLI=??> CH ;H;FIAIOM G;HH?L 0B? CHN?AL;F QCFF
<S >?WHCNCIH
<? WHCN? C@
. =
&%' LDOT
P\a
Ka
) @IL MIG? H +
= <
+=
NB?H NB? CHN?AL;F < a Ka
=?;M?M NI ?RCMN
@IL F;LA? I #CP?H NB? CGJILN;H=?
I@ >CMNLC<ONCIHM MO=B ;M NB? ;O=BS ;H> NB? ,;L?NI >CMNLC<ONCIHM
CN G;E?M
M?HM? NI GI>C@S NB? >?WHCNCIH I@ NB? ?RJIH?HN CH MO=B ; Q;S ;M NI AO;L;HN??
NB;N NB? CHN?AL;F QCFF ;FMI L?G;CH WHCN? @IL F;LA? DOGJM (fPSZM ?R=?FF?HN C>?;
NI MIFP? NBCM JLI<F?G CM NI GI>C@S NB? =IGJ?HM;NIL <S L?MNLC=NCHA
NB? [;P?L;A?
DOGJ MCT?\ $? CHNLI>O=?> ; @OH=NCIH J a
*
a NI >;GJ?H ION NB?
N;CFM S M?NNCHA
. .
a
aJ a
Ka
Ka
) (
< <
a
;M FIHA ;M CCC CM M;NCMW?>
NB? CHN?AL;F CM HIQ Q?FF >?WH?>
F?;LFS
G;HS INB?L =BIC=?M I@ >;GJ?HCHA @OH=NCIH ;L? JIMMC<F? /IG?NCG?M
Q? ?H=IOHN?L NB? @OH=NCIH J a
5T a
N;ECHA NB? P;FO? @IL )a) )
;H> INB?LQCM? 0BCM QIOF> SC?F> ;H ;FN?LH;NCP? ?RJL?MMCIH @IL NB? =F;MM I@
JLI=?MM?M OH>?L CHP?MNCA;NCIH M MIIH ;M Q? NIO=B NB;N J;LN I@ NB? CHN?AL;F
=ILL?MJIH>CHA NI NB? =IGJ?HM;NIL
NB? G?;H I@ NB? (fPS JLI=?MM =B;HA?M
$?H=?
C@ Q? CHNLI>O=? IL =B;HA? NB? >;GJ?HCHA @OH=NCIH
NI I<N;CH ; MCGCF;L
(fPS JLI=?MM
CN CM H?=?MM;LS NI GI>C@S NB? G?;H
,LIJ?LNC?M I@ (fPS JLI=?MM?M
"CH;FFS
=IG<CHCHA ;FF NB? N?LGM
Q? I<N;CH NB? (fPS'BCHN=BCH? @ILGOF;
I@ NB? =B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH @IL (fPS JLI=?MM ;M
.
DOT
\
"/* [ P\ \ L
P\aJ a
Ka
'
T
3? L?GCH> NB;N NB? =IH>CNCIHM OH>?L QBC=B NBCM @ILGOF; CM P;FC> ;L?
CM JIMCNCP?
.
'%(
( a
Ka
) (
T
J a
*
a '
0B? N?LG <?NQ??H NB? =OLFS <L;=E?NM CH CM NB? (fPS ?RJIH?HN %HMJ?=NCIH
I@ NBCM @ILGOF; ;FMI CH>C=;N?M NB;N ; (fPS JLI=?MM CM @OFFS >?M=LC<?> <S NB? NBL??
J;L;G?N?LM ( (
";89.;=2.< 8/ L?B 9;8,.<<.<
IHMC>?L ; NCG? CHN?LP;F ( @ ;H> 'DN (4N ; (fPS JLI=?MM MN;LNCHA ;N D
0B? =B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH I@ NB? (fPS JLI=?MM I@ D4 QCFF <? I@ NB? @ILG
4 \
"/* @ ! \
QB?L? ! \
CM NB? (fPS ?RJIH?HN ;H> NB? CH>?R @ ?GJB;MCT?M NB? CH=L?G?HN
IP?L QBC=B Q? =IHMC>?L NB? JLI=?MM IHMC>?L HIQ ; J;LNCNCIH [ ) [ )
) [I @ I@ ( @ %N CM ;FQ;SM NLO? NB;N
@ [I [I
[I [I
[ [
'
$?H=?
I
-
4 \
N! N! \
(
E
CM >CMNLC<ON?> ;M ; (fPS
JLI=?MM "IL NB? J;LNC=OF;L =;M?
QB?L? [E [E @ *U @IL ;FF Q
;FF NB?
=B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIHM OH>?L NB? JLI>O=N MCAH QCFF <? ?KO;F ;H>
4 5I
4 \
4 I \
'
%H INB?L QIL>M
NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ D4 CM NB? >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ NB? MOG I@ U
CH>?J?H>?HN L;H>IG P;LC;<F?M
?;=B >CMNLC<ON?> QCNB NB? M;G? >CMNLC<ONCIH
%@ NBCM JLIJ?LNS I@ MOGG;<CFCNS BIF>M
NB?H NB? JLI=?MM CM M;C> NI <? 6;H;6A29F
16C6@6/92 +<PCIOMFS
MCH=? NB? =IHMNLO=NCIH ?PIFP?> ;LIOH> NB? (fPS JLI=?MM
0BCM MBIQM NB;N MN;<F? >CMNLC<ONCIHM ;L? CHWHCN?FS >CPCMC<F? 0B? =F;MM I@ (fPS
JLI=?MM?M NB?L?@IL? =IHN;CHM NB? =F;MM I@ MN;<F? >CMNLC<ONCIHM F?;LFS
=IHMC>
?LCHA NB? ?R;GJF? I@ NB? JOL? ,ICMMIH JLI=?MM
QBC=B CM ; (fPS JLI=?MM
Q?
OH>?LMN;H> NB;N NB?L? ;L? (fPS JLI=?MM?M NB;N ;L? HIN MN;<F? >CMNLC<ONCIHM
FMI
QB?L?;M @IL MN;<F? >CMNLC<ONCIHM QCNB NB? ?R=?JNCIH I@ NB? #;OMMC;H
NB?
M?=IH> GIG?HN >I?M HIN ?RCMN "IL ; (fPS JLI=?MM
NB? M?=IH> GIG?HN ;H>
BCAB?L G;S ?RCMN
3B;N NB? =IHMNLO=NCIH I@ NB? (fPS JLI=?MM N?FFM OM CM NB;N
<?MC>?M NB?
=IHNCHOIOM LIQHC;H GINCIH =IGJIH?HN
NB?L? ;L? DOGJM I@ WHCN? G?;MOL?
NB;N I==OL I==;MCIH;FFS ;H> NB?L? ;L? DOGJM I@ P?LS MG;FF MCT? NB;N ;L? CHW
HCN?FS ;=NCP? %HN?L?MNCHAFS
NB? FCN?L;NOL? >?;FCHA QCNB L?;FCT?> PIF;NCFCNS IHFS
>CMNCHAOCMB?M NB? =IHNCHOIOM J;LN @LIG NB? DOGJM I@ WHCN? MCT? 0BCM FCN?L;NOL?
>I?M HIN >?;F QCNB NB? DOGJM I@ CHWHCN? ;=NCPCNS
J?LB;JM ;H ;L?; @IL @ONOL?
L?M?;L=B
$./.;.7,.<
<;>CL '
.I=ECHA?L ) ?HMCNS ?G<?>>CHA @OH=NCIHM !=IHIG?NLC=
0B?ILS ]
<E?H ,
);>;H
.;G;GOLNC? / !MNCG;NCIH I@ LCMEH?ONL;F ;H>
MN;NCMNC=;F >?HMCNC?M <S $?LGCN? JIFSHIGC;F ;JJLIRCG;NCIH 3CNB ;H ;JJFC=;
NCIH NI ?OLI>IFF;L @ONOL?M IJNCIHM "?>?L;F .?M?LP? ;HE I@ NF;HN;
3ILECHA
,;J?L
<L;GIQCNT )
/N?AOH % $;H><IIE I@ G;NB?G;NC=;F @OH=NCIHM QCNB
@ILGOF;M
AL;JBM
;H> G;NB?G;NC=;F N;<F?M IP?L ,O<FC=;NCIHM
*?Q 5ILE
=?L<C
0;M=B? !RJ?=N?> MBILN@;FF H;NOL;F =IB?L?HN ;FN?LH;NCP?
NI P;FO?;NLCME !=IHIGC= *IN?M <S ;H=; )IHN? >?C ,;M=BC >C /C?H; ]
AGIH *
FB;MMC> 5
(?PCH? . ; H ;FAILCNBG @IL WH>CHA NB? >CM
NLC<ONCIH I@ G;RCG;F ?HNLIJS &IOLH;F I@ IGJON;NCIH;F ,BSMC=M ]
AGIH *
FB;MMC> 5
(?PCH? . < 0B? G;RCGOG ?HNLIJS @ILG;F
CMG %H (?PCH? .
0LC<OM ) ?>M 0B? G;RCGOG ?HNLIJS @ILG;FCMG )%0
,L?MM
;G<LC>A?
);MM;=BOM?NNM
]
BH $
IO>IOEB &
.C=B;L>MIH )
3BCN?F;Q ." +JNCG;F LCME
G;H;A?G?HN OMCHA IJNCIHM &IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=? ]
hN/;B;FC; 5 CM?HN;HAFCHA >C_OMCIH @LIG DOGJM &IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=C;F
!=IHIGC=M ]
hN/;B;FC; 5
L;H>N )3 2;LC;<F? M?F?=NCIH @IL JILN@IFCI =BIC=?
&IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=? ]
hN/;B;FC; 5
(I 3 *IHJ;L;G?NLC= ?MNCG;NCIH I@ MN;N?JLC=? >?H
MCNC?M CGJFC=CN CH WH;H=C;F ;MM?N JLC=?M &IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=? ]
hN/;B;FC; 5
(I 3 *IHJ;L;G?NLC= LCME G;H;A?G?HN ;H> CGJFC?>
LCME ;P?LMCIH &IOLH;F I@ !=IHIG?NLC=M ]
hN/;B;FC; 5
)SEF;H> ,
6B;HA
( ; $IQ I@N?H NI M;GJF? ;
=IHNCHOIOMNCG? JLI=?MM CH NB? JL?M?H=? I@ G;LE?N GC=LIMNLO=NOL? HICM? .?
PC?Q I@ "CH;H=C;F /NO>C?M ]
hN/;B;FC; 5
)SEF;H> ,
6B;HA
( < 1FNL;BCAB @L?KO?H=S PIF;NCFCNS
?MNCG;NCIH QCNB >?J?H>?HN GC=LIMNLO=NOL? HICM? *!. 3ILECHA ,;J?L
.?@?L?H=?M
GI>?FCHA
;H> @IL?=;MNCHA ;MM?N L?NOLH PIF;NCFCNS ,%!. 3ILECHA ,;J?L L=BCP?
,?HH %HMNCNON? @IL !=IHIGC= .?M?;L=B
?J;LNG?HN I@ !=IHIGC=M
1HC
P?LMCNS I@ ,?HHMSFP;HC;
H>?LM?H 0#
IFF?LMF?P 0
C?<IF> "4
(;<SM , )I>?FCHA ;H>
@IL?=;MNCHA L?;FCT?> PIF;NCFCNS !=IHIG?NLC=; ]
H>?LM?H 0#
IFF?LMF?P 0
C?<IF> "4
!<?HM $ 0B? >CMNLC<ONCIH
I@ L?;FCT?> MNI=E L?NOLH PIF;NCFCNS &IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=C;F !=IHIGC=M ]
H>?LM?H 0#
IFF?LMF?P 0
)?>>;BC * ILL?=NCHA NB? ?LLILM 2IF;NCF
CNS @IL?=;MN ?P;FO;NCIH OMCHA BCAB@L?KO?H=S >;N; ;H> L?;FCT?> PIF;NCFCNC?M
!=IHIG?NLC=; ]
HA
?E;?LN # %HN?LH;NCIH;F ;MM?N ;FFI=;NCIH QCNB NCG?P;LSCHA
=ILL?F;NCIHM .?PC?Q I@ "CH;H=C;F /NO>C?M ]
HA
B?H & MSGG?NLC= =ILL?F;NCIHM I@ ?KOCNS JILN@IFCIM &IOLH;F
I@ "CH;H=C;F !=IHIGC=M ]
L>CNNC " .CME ;H> NB? L?KOCL?> L?NOLH IH ?KOCNS &IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=?
]
L>CNNC " HINB?L FIIE ;N GONO;F @OH> J?L@ILG;H=? &IOLH;F I@ "C
H;H=C;F ;H> -O;HNCN;NCP? H;FSMCM ]
LHIF> ( /NI=B;MNC= >C_?L?HNC;F ?KO;NCIHM NB?ILS ;H> ;JJFC=;NCIHM
3CF?S
*?Q 5ILE
LHIF>
.& ?;P?L .& /E?Q?> GOFNCP;LC;N? GI>?FM L?F;N?> NI
BC>>?H NLOH=;NCIH ;H>
IL M?F?=NCP? L?JILNCHA 0?MN ]
LNTH?L ,
?F<;?H "
!<?L &)
$?;NB 0BCHECHA =IB?L?HNFS .CME
]
LNTH?L ,
?F<;?H "
!<?L &)
$?;NB IB?L?HN G?;MOL?M I@
LCME );NB?G;NC=;F "CH;H=? ]
NB;S>? #)
"FiL?M &L .# "CH>CHA ; G;RCGOG ME?QH?MM JILN@IFCI
] A?H?L;F MIFONCIH NI NBL??GIG?HNM JILN@IFCI =BIC=? &IOLH;F I@ !=IHIGC=
SH;GC=M ;H> IHNLIF ]
TT;FCHC =F;MM I@ >CMNLC<ONCIH QBC=B CH=FO>?M NB? HILG;F IH?M /=;H
>CH;PC;H &IOLH;F I@ /N;NCMNC=M ]
.?@?L?H=?M
TT;FCHC
;JCN;HCI /N;NCMNC=;F ;JJFC=;NCIHM I@ NB? GOFNCP;LC
;N? ME?Q HILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH &IOLH;F I@ NB? .IS;F /N;NCMNC=;F MMI=C;NCIH
]
TT;FCHC
;JCN;HCI CMNLC<ONCIHM A?H?L;N?> <S J?LNOL<;NCIH I@
MSGG?NLS QCNB ?GJB;MCM IH ; GOFNCP;LC;N? ME?QN >CMNLC<ONCIH &IOLH;F I@ NB?
.IS;F /N;NCMNC=;F /I=C?NS ]
TT;FCHC
;F; 2;FF? 0B? GOFNCP;LC;N? ME?Q HILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH
CIG?NLCE; ]
;BL; ,LI<;<CFCNS >CMNLC<ONCIHM I@ @ONOL? ;MM?N JLC=?M CGJFC?> <S IJ
NCIH JLC=?M
;HE I@ !HAF;H> -O;LN?LFS OFF?NCH OAOMN
]
;C &
*A /* 0?MNCHA ME?QH?MM
EOLNIMCM
;H> HILG;FCNS @IL NCG? M?
LC?M &IOLH;F I@ OMCH?MM ;H> !=IHIGC= /N;NCMNC=M ]
;C 4
.OMM?FF &.
0C;I # 'OLNIMCM I@ #.$ ;H> MNI=B;M
NC= PIF;NCFCNS GI>?FM QCNB HIHHILG;F CHHIP;NCIHM &IOLH;F I@ !=IHIG?NLC=M
]
;CFFC? .0
IFF?LMF?P 0 GOFNCP;LC;N? A?H?L;FCT?> .$ ;JJLI;=B
NI GI>?FCHA LCME JL?GC; CH @ILQ;L> @IL?CAH ?R=B;HA? L;N? G;LE?NM &IOLH;F I@
%HN?LH;NCIH;F )IH?S ;H> "CH;H=?
]
;EMBC #
;I
B?H 6 !GJCLC=;F J?L@ILG;H=? I@ ;FN?LH;NCP? IJNCIH
JLC=CHA GI>?FM &IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=? ]
;EMBC #
);>;H /J;HHCHA ;H> >?LCP;NCP?M?=OLCNS P;FO;NCIH &IOL
H;F I@ "CH;H=C;F !=IHIGC=M ]
;F>OTTC ,
(SH=B 0L;HM;=NCIH =IMNM ;H> JL?>C=N;<CFCNS MIG? ONCFCNS
=IMN =;F=OF;NCIHM &IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=C;F !=IHIGC=M ]
;FE?G;
? $;;H ( .?MC>O;F FC@? ;N AL?;N ;A? HH;FM I@ ,LI<;<CF
CNS ]
;FF
0ILIOM 3* MCGJFCW?> DOGJ JLI=?MM @IL =IGGIH MNI=E
L?NOLHM &IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=C;F ;H> -O;HNCN;NCP? H;FSMCM ]
;H>C "
.OMM?FF & /?J;L;NCHA G;LE?N GC=LIMNLO=NOL? HICM? @LIG
PIF;NCFCNS
1HCP?LMCNS I@ BC=;AI
3ILECHA ,;J?L
;HM;F .
$MC?B
2CMQ;H;NB;H / H?Q ;JJLI;=B NI CHN?LH;NCIH;F
;L<CNL;A? JLC=CHA &IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=? ]
;LH>IL_*C?FM?H +! ,LI=?MM?M I@ HILG;F CHP?LM? A;OMMC;H NSJ? "C
H;H=? ;H> /NI=B;MNC=M ]
;LH>IL_*C?FM?H +!
/B?JB;L> * *IHA;OMMC;H +LHMN?CH1BF?H<?=E
<;M?> GI>?FM ;H> MIG? I@ NB?CL OM?M CH WH;H=C;F ?=IHIGC=M &IOLH;F I@ NB?
.IS;F /N;NCMNC=;F /I=C?NS ]
;LH>IL_*C?FM?H +!
/B?JB;L> * ; ,IQ?L ;H> <CJIQ?L P;LC;NCIH QCNB
MNI=B;MNC= PIF;NCFCNS ;H> DOGJM &IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=C;F !=IHIG?NLC=M ]
;LH>IL_*C?FM?H +!
/B?JB;L> * < !=IHIG?NLC= ;H;FSMCM I@ L?;FCM?>
=IP;LC;NCIH $CAB @L?KO?H=S <;M?> =IP;LC;H=?
L?AL?MMCIH
;H> =ILL?F;NCIH CH W
H;H=C;F ?=IHIGC=M !=IHIG?NLC=; ]
;LIH?>?MC # L<CNL;A? ?KOCFC<LCOG QCNB ME?Q?> ;MM?N L?NOLHM &IOL
H;F I@ "CH;H=C;F ;H> -O;HNCN;NCP? H;FSMCM ]
.?@?L?H=?M
;LIH?>?MC #
3B;F?S .! !^=C?HN ;H;FSNC= ;JJLIRCG;NCIH I@
G?LC=;H IJNCIH P;FO?M &IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=? ]
;LNIH !
?HHCM '!. 0B? =IH>CNCIHM OH>?L QBC=B #L;GB;LFC?L
;H> !>A?QILNB =OLP?M ;L? JIMCNCP? >?WHCN? ;H> OHCGI>;F CIG?NLCE; ]
;M;E /
/B;JCLI 2;FO?;NLCME <;M?> LCME G;H;A?G?HN IJNCG;F
JIFC=C?M ;H> ;MM?N JLC=?M .?PC?Q I@ "CH;H=C;F /NO>C?M ]
;MF? IGGCNN?? IH ;HECHA /OJ?LPCMCIH G?H>G?HN NI NB? =;JCN;F
;==IL> NI CH=ILJIL;N? G;LE?N LCMEM
;HE @IL %HN?LH;NCIH;F /?NNF?G?HN
;M?F
IGGCNN?? IH ;HECHA /OJ?LPCMCIH
;N?M / 0B? =L;MB I@ Z Q;M CN ?RJ?=N?> 0B? ?PC>?H=? @LIG IJNCIHM
G;LE?NM &IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=? ]
;N?M / &OGJM ;H> MNI=B;MNC= PIF;NCFCNS ?R=B;HA? L;N? JLI=?MM?M CG
JFC=CN CH ?ONM=B? );LE IJNCIHM .?PC?Q I@ "CH;H=C;F /NO>C?M ]
;N?M / ,IMNZ =L;MB @?;LM CH /, @ONOL?M IJNCIHM &IOLH;F I@
!=IHIG?NLC=M ]
;OQ?HM (
(;OL?HN / H?Q =F;MM I@ GOFNCP;LC;N? ME?Q >?HMCNC?M
QCNB
;JJFC=;NCIH NI #.$ GI>?F &IOLH;F I@ OMCH?MM ;H> !=IHIGC= /N;NCMNC=M
]
;OQ?HM (
(;OL?HN /
.IG<IONM & )OFNCP;LC;N? #.$ GI>?FM
MOLP?S &IOLH;F I@ JJFC?> !=IHIG?NLC=M
;Q; 2
(CH>?H<?LA ! ;JCN;F G;LE?N ?KOCFC<LCOG CH ; G?;HFIQ?L
J;LNC;F GIG?HN @L;G?QILE &IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=C;F !=IHIGC=M ]
?<?L
L;H>N )3 0B? ?_?=N I@ G;=LI?=IHIGC= H?QM IH <?FC?@M
;H> JL?@?L?H=?M !PC>?H=? @LIG NB? IJNCIHM G;LE?N *!. 3ILECHA ,;J?L
?CLF;HN &
2SH=EC?L ,
0?OA?FM &( 0;CF CH>?R ?MNCG;NCIH
,;L?NI
KO;HNCF? JFINM
;H> L?AL?MMCIH >C;AHIMNC=M &IOLH;F I@ NB? G?LC=;H /N;NCMNC=;F
MMI=C;NCIH ]
?E;?LN #
$;LP?S ( 0CG?P;LSCHA QILF> G;LE?N CHN?AL;NCIH &IOL
H;F I@ "CH;H=? ]
?L; '
$CAACHM )( .$ GI>?FM JLIJ?LNC?M
?MNCG;NCIH ;H> N?MN
CHA &IOLH;F I@ !=IHIGC= /OLP?SM ]
?L; '
&;LKO? ) !^=C?HN N?MNM @IL HILG;FCNS
B?N?LIME?>;MNC=NS
C;CM
#FIMN?H (.
/J;NN / 0B? GC=LIMNLO=NOL? I@ MNI=E G;LE?NM
!,. CM=OMMCIH ,;J?L
C;CM
$CFFCIH ,
/J;NN H ?GJCLC=;F ;H;FSMCM I@ NB? FCGCN IL>?L
<IIE ;H> IL>?L XIQ CH NB? ,;LCM <IOLM? &IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=? ]
CFFCHAMF?S , IHP?LA?H=? I@ JLI<;<CFCNS G?;MOL?M 3CF?S
*?Q 5ILE
%/ IGGCNN?? IH NB? #FI<;F "CH;H=C;F /SMN?G /NL?MM N?MNCHA <S F;LA?
WH;H=C;F CHMNCNONCIHM =OLL?HN JL;=NC=? ;H> ;AAL?A;NCIH CMMO?M #"/ ,O<FC=;
NCIH
F;=E " /NO>C?M CH MNI=E JLC=? PIF;NCFCNS =B;HA?M ,LI=??>CHAM I@ NB?
)??NCHA I@ NB? OMCH?MM ;H> !=IHIGC= /N;NCMNC=M /?=NCIH
G?LC=;H /N;
NCMNC=;F MMI=C;NCIH ]
F;=E "
/=BIF?M ) 0B? JLC=CHA I@ IJNCIHM ;H> =ILJIL;N? FC;<CFCNC?M
&IOLH;F I@ ,IFCNC=;F !=IHIGS ]
F;NN<?LA .
#IH?>?M * =IGJ;LCMIH I@ MN;<F? ;H> /NO>?HN >CMNLC<
ONCIHM ;M MN;NCMNC=;F GI>?FM @IL MNI=E JLC=?M &IOLH;F I@ OMCH?MM ]
FCMM ..
,;HCACLNTIAFIO * 0?MNCHA NB? MN;<CFCNS I@ CGJFC?> JLI<;<CFCNS
>?HMCNS @OH=NCIHM &IOLH;F I@ ;HECHA ;H> "CH;H=? ]
IFF?LMF?P 0 #?H?L;FCT?> ;ONIL?AL?MMCP? =IH>CNCIH;F B?N?LIME?>;MNC=CNS
&IOLH;F I@ !=IHIG?NLC=M ]
IFF?LMF?P 0 =IH>CNCIH;F B?N?LIME?>;MNC= NCG? M?LC?M GI>?F @IL MJ?=
OF;NCP? JLC=?M ;H> L;N?M I@ L?NOLH .?PC?Q I@ !=IHIGC=M ;H> /N;NCMNC=M ]
IFF?LMF?P 0 +H NB? =ILL?F;NCIH MNLO=NOL? @IL NB? A?H?L;FCT?> ;ONIL?
AL?MMCP? =IH>CNCIH;F B?N?LIME?>;MNC= JLI=?MM &IOLH;F I@ 0CG? /?LC?M H;FSMCM
]
IFF?LMF?P 0 )I>?FCHA NB? =IB?L?H=? CH MBILNLOH HIGCH;F ?R=B;HA?
L;N?M GOFNCP;LC;N? A?H?L;FCT?> .$ ;JJLI;=B .?PC?Q I@ !=IHIGC=M ;H>
/N;NCMNC=M ]
IFF?LMF?P 0
BIO .
'LIH?L ' .$ GI>?FCHA CH WH;H=? ; L?PC?Q
I@ NB? NB?ILS ;H> ?GJCLC=;F ?PC>?H=? &IOLH;F I@ !=IHIG?NLC=M ]
IFF?LMF?P 0
!HAF? ." IGGIH J?LMCMN?H=? CH =IH>CNCIH;F P;LC;H=?
!=IHIG?NLC=; ]
IFF?LMF?P 0
!HAF? ."
*?FMIH .$ GI>?FM
CH !HAF? ."
*?Q 5ILE
LfG;O> , ,ICHN JLI=?MM?M ;H> KO?O?M G;LNCHA;F? >SH;GC=M
/JLCHA?L2?LF;A
*?Q 5ILE
L?HH;H )& 0B? JLC=CHA I@ =IHNCHA?HN =F;CGM CH >?M=L?N? NCG? GI>?FM
&IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=? ]
L?SG;H 3
C;M
!G<L?=BNM , ?J?H>?H=? MNLO=NOL?M @IL GOFNC
P;LC;N? BCAB @L?KO?H=S >;N; CH WH;H=? -O;HNCN;NCP? "CH;H=? ]
LCAB;G !+ 0B? @;MN "IOLC?L NL;HM@ILG ;H> CNM ;JJFC=;NCIHM ,L?HNC=?
$;FF
!HAF?QII> FC_M
*?Q &?LM?S
LCNN?H&IH?M )
/=B;?_?L /) *IHFCH?;L P;FO?;NLCME !OLIJ?;H "C
H;H=? .?PC?Q ]
LI=E?NN ,(
#;LP?H &. L??R;GCH;NCIH I@ NB? L?F;NCIHMBCJ <?NQ??H
JL?@?L?H=?M ;H> GIG?HN IL>?LCHAM <S L;NCIH;F LCME ;P?LM? CHP?MNILM #?H?P; ,;
J?LM IH .CME ;H> %HMOL;H=? 0B?ILS ]
LI=E?NN ,
';B;H? 5 .CME
L?NOLH
ME?QH?MM ;H> JL?@?L?H=? );H;A?
G?HN /=C?H=? ]
LIIEM
OLE? /,
,?LM;H> # ONIL?AL?MMCP? =IH>CNCIH;F EOLNI
MCM
%/) ?HNL? CM=OMMCIH ,;J?L CH "CH;H=? ] &IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=C;F
!=IHIG?NLC=M ]
O=B?H ,
'?FFS ) 0B? G;RCGOG ?HNLIJS >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ ;H ;MM?N
CH@?LL?> @LIG IJNCIH JLC=?M &IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=C;F ;H> -O;HNCN;NCP? H;FSMCM
]
ONF?L
;PC?M $ MM?MMCHA G;LE?N PC?QM IH GIH?N;LS JIFC=S 0B?
OM? I@ CGJFC?> LCME H?ONL;F JLI<;<CFCNS >CMNLC<ONCIHM ;HE I@ !HAF;H> )IH?
N;LS %HMNLOG?HNM ;H> );LE?NM CPCMCIH
3ILECHA ,;J?L
;GJ<?FF &
I=BL;H? & S @IL=? I@ B;<CN =IHMOGJNCIH <;M?> ?R
JF;H;NCIH I@ ;AAL?A;N? MNI=E G;LE?N <?B;PCIL &IOLH;F I@ ,IFCNC=;F !=IHIGS
.?@?L?H=?M
]
;GJ<?FF &5
$?HNM=B?F ( *I H?QM CM AII> H?QM H ;MSGG?NLC=
GI>?F I@ =B;HACHA PIF;NCFCNS &IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=C;F !=IHIGC=M ]
;GJ<?FF &5
(I 3
);='CHF;S 0B? ?=IHIG?NLC=M I@ WH;H=C;F
G;LE?NM ,LCH=?NIH 1HCP?LMCNS ,L?MM
,LCH=?NIH
*?Q &?LM?S
;GJ<?FF &5
2C=?CL; () IHMOGJNCIH ;H> JILN@IFCI >?=CMCIHM QB?H
?RJ?=N?> L?NOLHM ;L? NCG? P;LSCHA -O;LN?LFS &IOLH;F I@ !=IHIGC=M ]
;JJC?FFI (
!HAF? ."
/B?JJ;L> ' MSGG?NLC= >SH;GC=M CH NB? =IL
L?F;NCIHM I@ AFI<;F ?KOCNS ;H> <IH> L?NOLHM !OLIJ?;H ?HNL;F ;HE 3ILECHA
,;J?L
;LL ,
#?G;H $
);>;H
5IL ) 0B? WH? MNLO=NOL? I@ ;MM?N L?
NOLHM H ?GJCLC=;F CHP?MNCA;NCIH &IOLH;F I@ OMCH?MM ]
;LL ,
#?G;H $
);>;H
5IL ) /NI=B;MNC= PIF;NCFCNS @IL (fPS
JLI=?MM?M );NB?G;NC=;F "CH;H=? ]
;LL ,
);>;H +JNCIH JLC=CHA ;H> NB? @;MN "IOLC?L NL;HM@ILG &IOL
H;F I@ IGJON;NCIH;F "CH;H=? ]
;LL ,
3O ( 0CG?=B;HA?> (fPS JLI=?MM?M ;H> IJNCIH JLC=CHA &IOL
H;F I@ "CH;H=C;F !=IHIGC=M ]
B;=EI #
2C=?CL; () /J?=NL;F #)) ?MNCG;NCIH I@ =IHNCHOIOMNCG?
JLI=?MM?M &IOLH;F I@ !=IHIG?NLC=M ]
B;G<?LF;CH # =B;L;=N?LCT;NCIH I@ NB? >CMNLC<ONCIHM NB;N CGJFS
G?;HP;LC;H=? ONCFCNS @OH=NCIHM &IOLH;F I@ !=IHIGC= 0B?ILS ]
B;H '
"IHA 3) 0L;>? MCT?
IL>?L CG<;F;H=?
;H> NB? PIF;NCFCNS
PIFOG? L?F;NCIH &IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=C;F !=IHIGC=M ]
B;H ('
(;EIHCMBIE & %HMNCNONCIH;F NL;>?M ;H> CHNL;>;S MNI=E
JLC=? <?B;PCIL &IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=C;F !=IHIGC=M ]
B;H ('
(;EIHCMBIE & 0B? <;B;PCIL I@ MNI=E JLC=?M ;LIOH> CHMNC
NONCIH;F NL;>?M &IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=? ]
B;H 3$
);B?O &) IH>CNCIH;F DOGJ >SH;GC=M CH MNI=E G;LE?N
L?NOLHM &IOLH;F I@ OMCH?MM ;H> !=IHIGC= /N;NCMNC=M ]
B;O>BOLS )
3?C & 1JJ?L <IOH>M @IL ;G?LC=;H @ONOL?M IJNCIHM
HIN? &IOLH;F I@ "ONOL?M );LE?NM ]
B?LHITBOEIP 2
1G;HNM?P ( IH>CNCIH;F P;FO?;NLCME MJ?=NM I@
GI>?FCHA ;H> ?MNCG;NCIH !GJCLC=;F !=IHIGC=M ]
BLCMNC? 0B? MNI=B;MNC= <?B;PCIL I@ =IGGIH MNI=E P;LC;H=?M 2;FO?
F?P?L;A?
;H> CHN?L?MN L;N? ?_?=NM &IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=C;F !=IHIGC=M ]
BLCMNI_?LM?H , !P;FO;NCHA CHN?LP;F @IL?=;MNM %HN?LH;NCIH;F !=IHIGC=
.?PC?Q ]
BLCMNI_?LM?H ,
$;BH &
%HIO? 0?MNCHA ;H> =IGJ;LCHA P;FO?;N
LCME G?;MOL?M &IOLH;F I@ !GJCLC=;F "CH;H=? ]
BOHB;=BCH>; ,
;H>;J;HC '
$;GC> /
,L;E;MB & ,ILN@IFCI M?
F?=NCIH ;H> ME?QH?MM !PC>?H=? @LIG CHN?LH;NCIH;F MNI=E G;LE?NM &IOLH;F I@
;HECHA ;H> "CH;H=? ]
.?@?L?H=?M
F;LE ,' MO<IL>CH;N?> MNI=B;MNC= JLI=?MM GI>?F QCNB WHCN? P;LC;H=?
@IL MJ?=OF;NCP? JLC=?M !=IHIG?NLC=; ]
F?G?HNM ), H ?P;FO;NCIH I@ NB? MOLP?S I@ JLI@?MMCIH;F @IL?=;MN?LM
JLI<;<CFCNS >CMNLC<ONCIHM I@ ?RJ?=N?> CHX;NCIH ;H> IONJON ALIQNB 3;LQC=E
1HCP?LMCNS CM=OMMCIH ,;J?L
IF?M /#
$?_?LH;H &
0;QH & ?J?H>?H=? G?;MOL?M @IL ?RNL?G?
P;FO? ;H;FSM?M !RNL?G?M ]
IF?M /#
0;QH & )I>?FFCHA ?RNL?G? GOFNCP;LC;N? ?P?HNM &IOLH;F
I@ NB? .IS;F /N;NCMNC=;F /I=C?NS ]
IF?M /#
0;QH & /N;NCMNC=;F G?NBI>M @IL GOFNCP;LC;N? ?RNL?G?M
H ;JJFC=;NCIH NI MNLO=NOL;F >?MCAH JJFC?> /N;NCMNC=M ]
IHN . !GJCLC=;F JLIJ?LNC?M I@ ;MM?N L?NOLHM MNSFCT?> @;=NM ;H> MN;NCM
NC=;F CMMO?M -O;HNCN;NCP? "CH;H=? ]
IHN .
0;HEIP , "CH;H=C;F GI>?FFCHA QCNB DOGJ JLI=?MM?M B;JG;H
;H> $;FF
.
ILL;>I &
/O 0 /, CH>?R IJNCIH N?MNM I@ &;LLIQ ;H> .O>>ZM
;JJLIRCG;N? IJNCIH P;FO;NCIH @ILGOF; &IOLH;F I@ "ONOL?M );LE?NM ]
ION;HN /
&IH>?;O !
.I=ECHA?L ) .?;>CHA ,%+. @ONOL?M IJNCIHM
MGCF?M 0B? MH;J ?F?=NCIH &IOLH;F I@ ;HECHA ;H> "CH;H=? ]
IR &
%HA?LMIFF &%
.IMM / NB?ILS I@ NB? N?LG MNLO=NOL? I@
CHN?L?MN L;N?M !=IHIG?NLC=; ]
IR &
.IMM /
.O<CHMN?CH ) +JNCIH JLC=CHA MCGJFCW?> ;JJLI;=B
&IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=C;F !=IHIGC=M ]
IR &
.O<CHMN?CH ) +JNCIHM G;LE?NM ,L?HNC=?$;FF
!HAF?QII>
FC_M
*?Q &?LM?S
L;GfL $ );NB?G;NC=;F G?NBI>M I@ MN;NCMNC=M ,LCH=?NIH 1HCP?LMCNS
,L?MM
,LCH=?NIH
*?Q &?LM?S
ZAIMNCHI . 0L;HM@ILG;NCIH NI HILG;FCNS I@ NB? HOFF >CMNLC<ONCIH
I@ > CIG?NLCE; ]
;H; .
&?;H<F;H=,CKOf ) "CH;H=C;F G;LE?NM CH =IHNCHOIOM NCG?
/JLCHA?L2?LF;A
?LFCH
;HC?FMMIH &
>? $;;H (
,?HA (
>? 2LC?M # 1MCHA ; <IINMNL;J
G?NBI> NI =BIIM? NB? M;GJF? @L;=NCIH CH N;CF CH>?R ?MNCG;NCIH &IOLH;F I@ )OF
NCP;LC;N? H;FSMCM ]
;HC?FMMIH &
>? 2LC?M # 0;CF CH>?R ;H> KO;HNCF? ?MNCG;NCIH QCNB
P?LS BCAB @L?KO?H=S >;N; &IOLH;F I@ !GJCLC=;F "CH;H=? ]
;L;A;BC*IO<;LS #. +H N;CF ?MNCG;NCIH H CGJLIP?> G?NBI>
);NB?G;NC=;F #?IFIAS ]
;LIFF?M /
#IOLCfLIOR
&;MC;E & IGJIOH> ;ONIL?AL?MMCP? GI>?FM
.!/0 ;H> 5ILE 1HCP?LMCNS
3ILECHA J;J?L
;M /.
/OH>;L;G .' 0;GCHA NB? ME?Q $CAB?LIL>?L GIG?HNM CH
GI>?FCHA ;MM?N JLC=? JLI=?MM?M CH WH;H=? *!. 3ILECHA ,;J?L
;PCM ,&
,IFIHMES % *OG?LC=;F CHN?LJIF;NCIH
>C_?L?HNC;NCIH ;H> CH
N?AL;NCIH %H <L;GIQCNT )
/N?AOH % ?>M $;H><IIE I@ G;NB?G;NC=;F
.?@?L?H=?M
IL>L?=BN
]
;PCMIH
/GCNB .( )I>?FM @IL ?R=??>;H=?M IP?L BCAB NBL?MBIF>M
&IOLH;F I@ NB? .IS;F /N;NCMNC=;F /I=C?NS ]
? $;;H ( !RNL?G?M CH BCAB?L >CG?HMCIHM ,LI=??>CHAM I@ NB? NB
/?MMCIH I@ NB? %HN?LH;NCIH;F /N;NCMNC=M %HMNCNON?
J;J?L
? $;;H (
.?MHC=E /% (CGCN NB?ILS @IL GOFNCP;LC;N? M;GJF? ?RNL?G?M
6?CNM=BLC@N @OL 3;BLM=B?CHFC=BE?CNMNB?ILC? OH> 2?LQ;H>N? #?<C?N? ]
? $;;H (
.?MHC=E /%
.IINTfH $
>? 2LC?M # !RNL?G;F <?B;P
CIL I@ MIFONCIHM NI ; MNI=B;MNC= >C_?L?H=? ?KO;NCIH QCNB ;JJFC=;NCIHM NI .$
JLI=?MM?M /NI=B;MNC= ,LI=?MM?M ;H> 0B?CL JJFC=;NCIHM ]
? $;;H (
>? .IH>? & /?; ;H> QCH> )OFNCP;LC;N? ?RNL?G?M ;N QILE
!RNL?G?M ]
?B?OP?FM , (; @IH=NCIH >? >fJ?H>;H=? ?GJCLCKO? ?N M?M JLIJLCfNfM
] 1H N?MN HIH J;L;GfNLCKO? >ZCH>fJ?H>;H=? =;>fGC? .IS;F? >? ?FACKO? ]
OFF?NCH >? F; F;MM? >?M /=C?H=?M ? /fLC? ]
?B?OP?FM , HIHJ;L;G?NLC= N?MN @IL CH>?J?H>?H=? ,O<FC=;NCIH >?
FZ%HMNCNON /N;NCMNCKO? 1HCP?LMCN;CL? >? ,;LCM ]
?EE?LM ()
!CHG;BF &$&
>? $;;H ( GIG?HN ?MNCG;NIL @IL
NB? CH>?R I@ ;H ?RNL?G?P;FO? >CMNLC<ONCIH HH;FM I@ /N;NCMNC=M ]
?EE?LM ()
>? $;;H ( +H NB? ?MNCG;NCIH I@ NB? ?RNL?G? P;FO?
CH>?R ;H> F;LA? KO;HNCF? ?MNCG;NCIH HH;FM I@ /N;NCMNC=M ]
?F<;?H "
/=B;=B?LG;S?L 3 A?H?L;F P?LMCIH I@ NB? @OH>;G?HN;F
NB?IL?G I@ ;MM?N JLC=CHA
);NB?G;NCM=B? HH;F?H ]
?FF;=B?LC?
)?S?L , ,LI<;<CFCNC?M ;H> JIN?HNC;F 0B?ILS I@
G;LNCHA;F?M *ILNB$IFF;H>
GMN?L>;G
?G;L=BC )
"IO=;OFN 0 !KOCNS NL;>CHA MSMN?GM CH !OLIJ? HH;F?M
>Z!=IHIGC? ?N >? /N;NCMNCKO? ]
?GIM
/?HN;H; ! 0?MNCHA @IL #.$ ?_?=NM ; IH?MC>?> ;JJLI;=B
&IOLH;F I@ !=IHIG?NLC=M ]
C?<IF> "4 !GJCLC=;F GI>?FFCHA I@ ?R=B;HA? L;N?M /JLCHA?L2?LF;A
*?Q 5ILE
C?<IF> "4
#OHNB?L 0
0;S / !P;FO;NCHA >?HMCNS @IL?=;MNM
QCNB ;JJFC=;NCIHM NI WH;H=C;F LCME G;H;A?G?HN %HN?LH;NCIH;F !=IHIGC= .?
PC?Q ]
C?<IF> "4
$;BH &5
0;S / )OFNCP;LC;N? >?HMCNS @IL?=;MN ?P;FO
;NCIH ;H> =;FC<L;NCIH CH WH;H=C;F LCME G;H;A?G?HN $CAB @L?KO?H=S L?NOLHM IH
@IL?CAH ?R=B;HA? .?PC?Q I@ !=IHIGC=M ;H> /N;NCMNC=M ]
C?<IF> "4
$C=EG;H
%HIO?
/=BO?LG;HH 0 IHP?LNCHA >;S
PIF;NCFCNS NI B>;S PIF;NCFCNS /=;FCHA <S LIINB CM QILM? NB;H SIO NBCHE 3B;L
NIH "CH;H=C;F %HMNCNONCIHM ?HN?L
3ILECHA J;J?L ]
.?@?L?H=?M
C?<IF> "4
/=BO?LG;HH 0
/NLIOAB;CL & ,CN@;FFM ;H> IJJILNOHC
NC?M CH NB? OM? I@ ?RNL?G? P;FO? NB?ILS CH LCME G;H;A?G?HN 3B;LNIH /=BIIF
1HCP?LMCNS I@ ,?HHMSFP;HC;
3ILECHA J;J?L
CNNG;L ." *IHFCH?;L JLC=CHA E?LH?FM
EOLNIMCM JL?@?L?H=?
;H> ?PC
>?H=? @LIG NB? =LIMM M?=NCIH I@ ?KOCNS L?NOLHM
&IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=? ]
IHME?L ) H CHP;LC;H=? JLCH=CJF? @IL =?LN;CH JLI<;<CFCNS FCGCN NB?
IL?GM
)?GICLM I@ NB? G?LC=;H );NB?G;NC=;F /I=C?NS
IILHCE &
$;HM?H $ H IGHC<OM N?MN @IL OHCP;LC;N? ;H> GOFNCP;LC
;N? HILG;FCNS
*O^?F> IFF?A?
+R@IL>
3ILECHA J;J?L
L??M $
';O@G;H ! /?F?=NCHA NB? IJNCG;F M;GJF? @L;=NCIH CH OHC
P;LC;N? ?RNL?G? P;FO? ?MNCG;NCIH /NI=B;MNC= ,LI=?MM?M ;H> 0B?CL JJFC=;NCIHM
]
LIMN "
'F;MM?H & !^=C?HN ?MNCG;NCIH CH M?GCJ;L;G?NLC=
#.$ GI>?FM &IOLH;F I@ !=IHIG?NLC=M ]
LIMN "
*CDG;H 0! 0?GJIL;F ;AAL?A;NCIH I@ #.$ JLI=?MM?M
!=IHIG?NLC=; ]
LIMN "
3?LE?L &) FIMCHA NB? #.$ A;J IHNCHOIOM NCG?
#.$ GI>?FCHA &IOLH;F I@ !=IHIG?NLC=M ]
O<CF . $IQ KOC=EFS MBIOF> SIO FCKOC>;N? SIOL P?MN?> MNI=E 1HCP?L
MCNS I@ IHH?=NC=ON
3ILECHA ,;J?L
O^? /?=OLCNS G;LE?NM /NI=B;MNC= GI>?FM =;>?GC= ,L?MM
IMNIH
O^?
,;H & H IP?LPC?Q I@ P;FO? ;N LCME &IOLH;F I@ ?LCP;NCP?M
]
O^?
,;H &
/CHAF?NIH '& 0L;HM@ILG ;H;FSMCM ;H> ;MM?N JLC=CHA
@IL ;^H? DOGJ>C_OMCIHM !=IHIG?NLC=; ]
O^?
/CHAF?NIH '& /CGOF;N?> GIG?HNM ?MNCG;NCIH I@ );LEIP
GI>?FM I@ ;MM?N JLC=?M !=IHIG?NLC=; ]
OG;M
"F?GCHA &
3B;F?S .! %GJFC?> PIF;NCFCNS @OH=NCIHM ?G
JCLC=;F N?MNM &IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=? ]
O)IO=B?F 3$ +H NB? ;MSGJNINC= HILG;FCNS I@ NB? G;RCGOG
FCE?FCBII> ?MNCG;N? QB?H M;GJFCHA @LIG ; MN;<F? >CMNLC<ONCIH HH;FM I@ /N;
NCMNC=M ]
OLB;G #
#;FF;HN . *OG?LC=;F N?=BHCKO?M @IL G;RCGOG FCE?FCBII>
?MNCG;NCIH I@ =IHNCHOIOMNCG? >C_OMCIH JLI=?MM?M &IOLH;F I@ OMCH?MM ;H> !=I
HIGC= /N;NCMNC=M ]
!;MF?S
'C?@?L *)
+Z$;L; ) +H? >;S CH NB? FC@? I@ ; P?LS =IGGIH
MNI=E .?PC?Q I@ "CH;H=C;F /NO>C?M ]
!<?LF?CH !
'?FF?L 1
,L;OM? ' *?Q CHMCABNM CHNI MGCF?
GCMJLC=CHA
;H> P;FO? ;N LCME &IOLH;F I@ OMCH?MM ]
!G<L?=BNM ,
'FkJJ?F<?LA
)CEIM=B 0 )I>?FFCHA ?RNL?G;F ?P?HNM
@IL CHMOL;H=? ;H> WH;H=? /JLCHA?L2?LF;A
?LFCH
!G<L?=BNM ,
(CH>MEIA "
)=*?CF )I>?FFCHA >?J?H>?H=? QCNB =IJ
OF;M ;H> ;JJFC=;NCIHM NI LCME G;H;A?G?HN %H .;=B?P /0 ?> $;H><IIE I@
B?;PS N;CF?> >CMNLC<ONCIHM CH WH;H=? !FM?PC?L
*ILNB$IFF;H>
GMN?L>;G
.?@?L?H=?M
MBILN@;FF @IL JILN@IFCIM OH>?L H?NNCHA ;AL??G?HNM &IOLH;F I@ ;HECHA ;H> "C
H;H=? ]
"?LHcH>?T
/N??F )"& +H ;S?MC;H GI>?FFCHA I@ @;N N;CFM ;H> ME?Q
H?MM &IOLH;F I@ NB? G?LC=;H /N;NCMNC=;F MMI=C;NCIH ]
"?LL?CL; &0/
/N??F )"& =IHMNLO=NCP? L?JL?M?HN;NCIH I@ OHC
P;LC;N? ME?Q?> >CMNLC<ONCIHM !=IHIG?NLC=M
!=IHIGC=M 3ILECHA J;J?L
L=BCP? ;N 31/0(
"CMB?L . "L?KO?H=S >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ NB? P;FO?M I@ NB? =ILL?F;NCIH =I?@
W=C?HN CH M;GJF?M @LIG ;H CH>?WHCN?FS F;LA? JIJOF;NCIH CIG?NLCE; ]
"CMB?L .
0CJJ?NN ($ (CGCNCHA @ILGM I@ NB? @L?KO?H=S >CMNLC<O
NCIHM I@ NB? F;LA?MN IL MG;FF?MN G?G<?L I@ ; M;GJF? ,LI=??>CHAM I@ NB? ;G
<LC>A? ,BCFIMIJBC=;F /I=C?NS ]
"F;GIOLCM
#C;GIOLC>CM !MNCG;NCHA CGJFC?> , "M @LIG G?LC
=;H IJNCIHM IH @ONOL?M H?Q M?GCJ;L;G?NLC= ;JJLI;=B &IOLH;F I@ "ONOL?M
);LE?NM ]
"F?N=B?L . H IP?LPC?Q I@ OH=IHMNL;CH?> IJNCGCT;NCIH %H /J?>C=;NI
! ?> FAILCNBGM @IL =IHNCHOIOM IJNCGCT;NCIH 0B? MN;N? I@ NB? ;LN 'FOQ?L
=;>?GC= ,O<FCMB?LM
]
"IL<?M '
.CAI<IH . *I =IHN;ACIH
IHFS CHN?L>?J?H>?H=? G?;MOLCHA
MNI=EG;LE?N =IGIP?G?HNM &IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=? ]
"IMN?L "
2CMQ;H;NB;H / ;H MJ?=OF;NCP? NL;>CHA ?RJF;CH NB?
PIFOG?PIF;NCFCNS L?F;NCIH &IOLH;F I@ OMCH?MM ;H> !=IHIGC= /N;NCMNC=M ]
"L;H=K ;H> 6;EIC;H &) !MNCG;NCHA Q?;E #.$ L?JL?M?HN;NCIHM
#;LG;H )
'IBFB;A?H / "IL?CAH =OLL?H=S IJNCIH P;FO?M &IOLH;F I@
%HN?LH;NCIH;F )IH?S ;H> "CH;H=? ]
#?G;H $
);>;H
5IL ) 0CG? =B;HA?M @IL (fPS JLI=?MM?M );NB
?G;NC=;F "CH;H=? ]
#?G;H $
);>;H
5IL ) /NI=B;MNC= PIF;NCFCNS
DOGJM ;H> BC>>?H
NCG? =B;HA?M "CH;H=? ;H> /NI=B;MNC=M ]
#?H?MN
#BIO>C '
.CP?MN (, M?GCJ;L;G?NLC= ?MNCG;NCIH JLI
=?>OL? I@ >?J?H>?H=? J;L;G?N?LM CH GOFNCP;LC;N? @;GCFC?M I@ >CMNLC<ONCIHM CI
G?NLCE; ]
#?H?MN
.CP?MN (, /N;NCMNC=;F CH@?L?H=? JLI=?>OL?M @IL <CP;LC;N?
;L=BCG?>?;H =IJOF;M &IOLH;F I@ NB? G?LC=;H /N;NCMNC=;F MMI=C;NCIH ]
#BSM?FM !
$;LP?S
.?H;OFN ! /NI=B;MNC= PIF;NCFCNS %H );>>;F;
#/
.;I . ?>M $;H><IIE I@ MN;NCMNC=M
2IFOG?
/N;NCMNC=;F G?NBI>M
CH WH;H=? *ILNB$IFF;H>
GMN?L>;G
]
#CFF ,!
)OLL;S 3
/;OH>?LM ) 1M?LZM AOC>? @IL /*+,0
"ILNL;H J;=E;A? @IL F;LA?M=;F? HIHFCH?;L JLIAL;GGCHA
3ILECHA ,;J?L
?
J;LNG?HN I@ );NB?G;NC=M
1/
;FC@ILHC;
#CFF ,!
)OLL;S 3
/;OH>?LM ) /*+,0 H /-, FAILCNBG I@
F;LA?M=;F? =IHMNL;CH?> IJNCGCT;NCIH
.?JILN *
?J;LNG?HN I@ );NB?
G;NC=M
1/
;FC@ILHC;
#CIN ,
(;OL?HN / 2;FO?;NLCME @IL FIHA ;H> MBILN NL;>CHA JIMCNCIHM
&IOLH;F I@ JJFC?> !=IHIG?NLC=M ]
#F;MM?LG;H ,
$?C>?F<?LA?L ,
/B;B;<O>>CH , ,ILN@IFCI P;FO?;NLCME
QCNB B?;PSN;CF?> LCME @;=NILM );NB?G;NC=;F "CH;H=? ]
#FIMN?H (.
&;A;HH;NB;H .
.OHEF? ! +H NB? L?F;NCIH <?NQ??H
NB? ?RJ?=N?> P;FO? ;H> NB? PIF;NCFCNS I@ NB? HIGCH;F ?R=?MM L?NOLH IH MNI=EM
&IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=? ]
#H?>?HEI 2 /OL F; >CMNLC<ONCIH FCGCN? >O N?LG? G;RCGOG >ZOH?
MfLC? ;Ff;NICL? HH;FM I@ );NB?G;NC=M ]
#H?>?HEI 2
'IFGIAILIP * (CGCN >CMNLC<ONCIHM @IL MOGM I@ CH>?
J?H>?HN L;H>IG P;LC;<F?M >>CMIH3?MF?S
;G<LC>A?
);MM;=BOM?NNM
#I?NNF?L .
,;LFIOL
.;D;H 1 !KOCFC<LCOG CH ; >SH;GC= FCGCN IL>?L
G;LE?N &IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=?
#IF;H
&O>A? ##
)CFF?L );RCGOG ?HNLIJS ?=IHIG?NLC=M .I
<OMN ?MNCG;NCIH QCNB FCGCN?> >;N;
3CF?S
*?Q 5ILE
#IOLCfLIOR
&;MC;E & ; "CH;H=C;F ?=IHIG?NLC=M ,LI<F?GM
GI>?FM
#IOLCfLIOR
)IH@ILN -O;FCN;NCP? NBL?MBIF> .$ GI>?FM &IOL
H;F I@ !=IHIG?NLC=M ]
#IOLCfLIOR
)IH@ILN
.?H;OFN ! /CGOF;NCIH <;M?> ?=IHIG?NLC=
G?NBI>M
IL? (?=NOL?M
+R@IL> 1HCP?LMCNS ,L?MM
#IOLCfLIOR
)IH@ILN
0LIAHIH ,M?O>I G;RCGOG FCE?FCBII>
G?NBI>M 0B?ILS !=IHIG?NLC=; ]
#IS;F
/;HN;F;L; , %>CIMSH=L;NC= LCME G;NN?LM &IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=?
]
#L;>MBN?SH %/
.STBCE % ) 0;<F? I@ CHN?AL;FM
M?LC?M
;H> JLI>O=NM
=;>?GC= ,L?MM
/;H C?AI
NB ?>CNCIH
#L;S /" H ;H;FSMCM I@ =IH>CNCIH;F L?ACG?MQCN=BCHA GI>?FM
"OKO;
/=BIIF I@ OMCH?MM
OE? 1HCP?LMCNS
3ILECHA ,;J?L
#OC>IFCH )
0CGG?LG;HH +JNCG;F JILN@IFCI =BIC=? OH>?L L?ACG?
MQCN=BCHA
ME?Q ;H> EOLNIMCM JL?@?L?H=?M 1HCP?LMCNS I@ ;FC@ILHC; /;H C?AI
3ILECHA ,;J?L
#OG<?F !& /N;NCMNC=M I@ ?RNL?G?M IFOG<C; 1HCP?LMCNS ,L?MM
*?Q
5ILE
$;@H?L
.IG<IONM & /?GCJ;L;G?NLC= GOFNCP;LC;N? #.$ GI>?FM
+.! ,
$;FF , 1MCHA NB? <IINMNL;J NI ?MNCG;N? G?;H MKO;L? ?LLIL ;H> M?
F?=N MGIINBCHA J;L;G?N?L CH HIHJ;L;G?NLC= JLI<F?G &IOLH;F I@ )OFNCP;LC;N?
H;FSMCM ]
$;FF ,
3?FMB $ >;JNCP? ?MNCG;N?M I@ J;L;G?N?LM I@ L?AOF;L P;LC;
NCIH HH;FM I@ /N;NCMNC=M ]
$;G;I 5
);MOFCM .3
*A 2' ILL?F;NCIHM CH JLC=? =B;HA?M
;H> PIF;NCFCNS ;=LIMM CHN?LH;NCIH;F MNI=E G;LE?NM .?PC?Q I@ "CH;H=C;F /NO>
C?M ]
$;G<OLA?L $ a<?L ?CH? !LQ?CN?LOHA >?M /NC?FND?MM=B?H )IG?HNJLI<
F?GM );NB?G;NCM=B? 6?CNM=BLC@N ]
$;GCFNIH & 0CG? M?LC?M ;H;FSMCM ,LCH=?NIH 1HCP?LMCNS ,L?MM
,LCH=?
NIH
*?Q &?LM?S
$;GCFNIH & H?Q ;JJLI;=B NI NB? ?=IHIGC= ;H;FSMCM I@ HIHMN;NCIH
;LS NCG? M?LC?M ;H> NB? <OMCH?MM =S=F? !=IHIG?NLC=; ]
$;HM?H ! ONIL?AL?MMCP? =IH>CNCIH;F >?HMCNS ?MNCG;NCIH %HN?LH;
NCIH;F !=IHIGC= .?PC?Q ]
$;HM?H ( (;LA? M;GJF? JLIJ?LNC?M I@ A?H?L;FCT?> G?NBI> I@ GIG?HNM
?MNCG;NIL !=IHIG?NLC=; ]
$dL>F? 3 JJFC?> HIHJ;L;G?NLC= L?AL?MMCIH
!=IHIG?NLC= /I=C?NS
)IHIAL;JBM
;G<LC>A? 1HCP?LMCNS ,L?MM
;G<LC>A?
$;LLCM ( LIMMM?=OLCNS N?MNM I@ NB? GCRNOL? I@ >CMNLC<ONCIHM BSJINB?MCM
&IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=C;F ;H> -O;HNCN;NCP? H;FSMCM ]
$;LLCM ( 0L;HM;=NCIHM >;N; N?MNM I@ NB? GCRNOL? I@ >CMNLC<ONCIHM BS
JINB?MCM &IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=C;F ;H> -O;HNCN;NCP? H;FSMCM ]
.?@?L?H=?M
$;LLCMIH &)
'L?JM );LNCHA;F?M ;H> ;L<CNL;A? CH GOFNCJ?LCI> M?
=OLCNS G;LE?NM &IOLH;F I@ !=IHIGC= 0B?ILS ]
$;LLCMIH &)
,FCME; /. );LNCHA;F?M ;H> MNI=B;MNC= CHN?AL;FM CH NB?
NB?ILS I@ =IHNCHOIOM NL;>CHA /NI=B;MNC= ,LI=?MM?M ;H> 0B?CL JJFC=;NCIHM
]
$;LLCMIH &)
,FCME; /. MNI=B;MNC= =;F=OFOM GI>?F I@ =IHNCHO
IOM NL;>CHA IGJF?N? G;LE?NM /NI=B;MNC= ,LI=?MM?M ;H> 0B?CL JJFC=;NCIHM
]
$;LNG;HH ,
/NL;?NG;HM /
>? 2LC?M # MM?N G;LE?N FCHE;A?M CH
=LCMCM J?LCI>M .?PC?Q I@ !=IHIGC=M ;H> /N;NCMNC=M ]
$;LP?S
.OCT !
/B?JB;L> * )OFNCP;LC;N? MNI=B;MNC= P;LC;H=?
GI>?FM .?PC?Q I@ !=IHIGC= /NO>C?M ]
$;LP?S . ,L?>C=N;<F? LCME ;H> L?NOLHM CH ?G?LACHA G;LE?NM .?PC?Q
I@ "CH;H=C;F /NO>C?M ]
$;LP?S .
(C?=BNS &
(C?=BNS )3
)kFF?L , ,ILN@IFCI M?F?=NCIH
QCNB BCAB?L GIG?HNM OE? 1HCP?LMCNS OLB;G
3ILECHA ,;J?L
$;LP?S .
/C>>CKO? ONIL?AL?MMCP? =IH>CNCIH;F ME?QH?MM &IOLH;F
I@ "CH;H=C;F ;H> -O;HNCN;NCP? H;FSMCM ]
$;LP?S .
/C>>CKO? IH>CNCIH;F ME?QH?MM CH ;MM?N JLC=CHA N?MNM
&IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=? ]
$?_?LH;H &! >CL?=NILS I@ =I?^=C?HNM I@ N;CF >?J?H>?H=? !RNL?G?M
]
$?HNM=B?F ( FF CH NB? @;GCFS H?MNCHA MSGG?NLC= ;H> ;MSGG?NLC=
#.$ GI>?FM &IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=C;F !=IHIGC=M ]
$?MNIH / =FIM?>@ILG MIFONCIH @IL IJNCIHM QCNB MNI=B;MNC= PIF;NCFCNS
QCNB ;JJFC=;NCIHM NI <IH> ;H> =OLL?H=S IJNCIHM .?PC?Q I@ "CH;H=C;F /NO>C?M
]
$CFF ) MCGJF? A?H?L;F ;JJLI;=B NI CH@?L?H=? ;<ION NB? N;CF I@ ;
>CMNLC<ONCIH HH;FM I@ /N;NCMNC=M ]
$CAACHM )(
?L; ' =F;MM I@ HIHFCH?;L .$ GI>?FM %HN?LH;
NCIH;F !=IHIGC= .?PC?Q ]
$F;QCNM=BE; 3 0B? ?GJCLC=;F H;NOL? I@ 0;SFIL M?LC?M ;JJLIRCG;NCIHM
NI ?RJ?=N?> ONCFCNS G?LC=;H !=IHIGC= .?PC?Q ]
$IFM )
>? 2LC?M # 0B? FCGCNCHA >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ ?RNL?G;F ?R
=B;HA? L;N? L?NOLHM &IOLH;F I@ JJFC?> !=IHIG?NLC=M ]
$IFNB;OM?H .3
(?@NQC=B .3
);S?LM 0B? ?_?=N I@ F;LA? <FI=E
NL;HM;=NCIHM IH M?=OLCNS JLC=?M =LIMMM?=NCIH;F ;H;FSMCM &IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=C;F
!=IHIGC=M ]
$IFNB;OM?H .3
(?@NQC=B .3
);S?LM (;LA?<FI=E NL;HM;=NCIHM
!HAF?QII> FC_M
*?Q &?LM?S
H> ?>CNCIH
$OFF &
3BCN? 0B? JLC=CHA I@ IJNCIHM IH ;MM?NM QCNB MNI=B;MNC= PIF;NCF
CNC?M &IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=? ]
$OFF &
3BCN? H ;H;FSMCM I@ NB? <C;M CH IJNCIH JLC=CHA =;OM?> <S ;
MNI=B;MNC= PIF;NCFCNS >P;H=?M CH "ONOL?M ;H> +JNCIHM .?M?;L=B ]
$Q;HA /
/;N=B?FF /! )I>?FFCHA ?G?LACHA G;LE?N LCME JL?GC; OMCHA
BCAB?L GIG?HNM &IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=? ;H> !=IHIGC=M ]
%HA?LMIFF &! 0B?ILS I@ WH;H=C;F >?=CMCIH G;ECHA .IQG;H ;H> (CNNF?
W?F> ,O<FCMB?LM
0INIQ;
*?Q &?LM?S
&;=EQ?LNB & #?H?L;FCT?> <CHIGC;F NL??M &IOLH;F I@ ?LCP;NCP?M ]
&;=EQ?LNB & +JNCIH CGJFC?> LCMEH?ONL;F >CMNLC<ONCIHM ;H> CGJFC?>
<CHIGC;F NL??M FCN?L;NOL? L?PC?Q &IOLH;F I@ ?LCP;NCP?M ]
&;=EQ?LNB & .?=IP?LCHA LCME ;P?LMCIH @LIG IJNCIH JLC=?M ;H> L?;FCT?>
L?NOLHM .?PC?Q I@ "CH;H=C;F /NO>C?M ]
&;=EQ?LNB &
.O<CHMN?CH ) .?=IP?LCHA JLI<;<CFCNS >CMNLC<ONCIHM
@LIG IJNCIH JLC=?M &IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=? ]
&;=I> &
/BCLS;?P * (CGCN NB?IL?GM @IL MNI=B;MNC= JLI=?MM?M
/JLCHA?L2?LF;A
?LFCH
&;=KOC?L !
,IFMIH *#
.IMMC ,! ;S?MC;H ;H;FSMCM I@ MNI=B;MNC=
PIF;NCFCNS GI>?FM &IOLH;F I@ OMCH?MM ;H> !=IHIGC= /N;NCMNC=M ]
&;HM?H 3
>? 2LC?M # +H NB? @L?KO?H=S I@ F;LA? MNI=E L?NOLHM
JONNCHA <IIGM ;H> <OMNM CHNI J?LMJ?=NCP? .?PC?Q I@ !=IHIGC=M ;H> /N;NCMNC=M
]
&;LKO? )
?L; ' !^=C?HN N?MNM @IL HILG;FCNS
BIGIM=?>;MNC=CNS
;H> M?LC;F CH>?J?H>?H=? I@ L?AL?MMCIH L?MC>O;FM !=IHIGC= (?NN?LM ]
&;LLIQ .
.O>> JJLIRCG;N? P;FO;NCIH @IL ;L<CNL;LS MNI=B;MNC=
JLI=?MM?M &IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=C;F !=IHIGC=M ]
&;SH?M !0 %H@ILG;NCIH NB?ILS ;H> MN;NCMNC=;F G?=B;HC=M ,BSMC=;F .?
PC?Q ]
.?@?L?H=?M
&ILCIH , 2;FO? ;N LCME 0B? H?Q <?H=BG;LE @IL =IHNLIFFCHA G;LE?N LCME
%LQCH ,LI@?MMCIH;F ,O<FCMBCHA
BC=;AI
%FFCHICM
&O>> '( *OG?LC=;F G?NBI>M CH ?=IHIGC=M )%0 ,L?MM
;G<LC>A?
);MM;=BOM?NNM
&OL=T?HEI !
);CFF?N 0B? ,) 0B?IL?NC=;F @IOH>;NCIHM ;H> ;H
;MM?N JLC=CHA GI>?F =IGJ;LCMIH CH ; OHCW?> @L;G?QILE %H OHCM
0CGG?L
G;HH
)II>S & ?>M ?P?FIJG?HNM CH @IL?=;MN =IG<CH;NCIH ;H> JILN@IFCI
=BIC=? 3CF?S
*?Q 5ILE
&OL=T?HEI !
);CFF?N 0B? ,) %H <?NQ??H ;MM?N JLC=CHA ;H>
;MM?N ;FFI=;NCIH %H >=I=E
&OL=T?HEI !
);CFF?N ?>M )OFNCGIG?HN
=;JCN;F ;MM?N JLC=CHA GI>?FM ;H> L?F;N?> NIJC=M /JLCHA?L "ILNB=IGCHA
';JF;HCM ! /N;<CFCNS ;H> @IL?=;MNCHA I@ NB? =IGIP?G?HN G?;MOL?M
I@ CHN?LH;NCIH;F MNI=E G;LE?N L?NOLH &IOLH;F I@ %HN?LH;NCIH;F )IH?S ;H> "C
H;H=? ]
';L;NT;M %
/BL?P? /! LIQHC;H GINCIH ;H> MNI=B;MNC= =;F=OFOM
/JLCHA?L2?LF;A
*?Q 5ILE
';LJI_ &) 0B? L?F;NCIH <?NQ??H JLC=? =B;HA?M ;H> NL;>CHA PIFOG?
MOLP?S &IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=C;F ;H> -O;HNCN;NCP? H;FSMCM ]
'?;LHM ,
!MNCG;NCHA NB? >?HMCNS N;CF CH>?R @IL WH;H=C;F NCG? M?LC?M
.?PC?Q I@ !=IHIGC=M ;H> /N;NCMNC=M ]
'?H>;FF )
/NO;LN 0B? ;>P;H=?> NB?ILS I@ MN;NCMNC=M
2IF );=GCF
F;H
*?Q 5ILE
'CG /
/B?JB;L> *
BC< / /NI=B;MNC= PIF;NCFCNS FCE?FCBII> CH@?L?H=?
;H> =IGJ;LCMIH QCNB .$ GI>?FM .?PC?Q I@ !=IHIGC= /NO>C?M ]
'CG<;FF )/ /N;H>;L> LCME ;P?LMCIH !=IHIG?NLC=; ]
'CHA )
/?HN;H; !
3;>BQ;HC / 2IF;NCFCNS ;H> FCHEM <?NQ??H H;NCIH;F
MNI=E G;LE?NM !=IHIG?NLC=; ]
'HCABN &
/;N=B?FF / .?NOLH >CMNLC<ONCIHM CH WH;H=? ONN?LQILNB
$?CH?G;HH
+R@IL>
'I=B ,
'I=B 03 !PIFONCIH CH >SH;GC= FCHE;A?M ;=LIMM H;NCIH;F
MNI=E CH>?R?M &IOLH;F I@ %HN?LH;NCIH;F )IH?S ;H> "CH;H=? ]
'I?>CDE '#
'IIF &) 0;CF ?MNCG;N?M I@ !;MN !OLIJ?;H ?R=B;HA?
L;N?M &IOLH;F I@ OMCH?MM ;H> !=IHIGC= /N;NCMNC=M ]
'I?>CDE '#
/=B;@A;HM ))
>? 2LC?M # 0B? N;CF CH>?R I@ ?R
=B;HA? L;N? L?NOLHM &IOLH;F I@ %HN?LH;NCIH;F !=IHIGC=M ]
'I?HE?L .
;MM?NN #3 .?AL?MMCIH KO;HNCF?M !=IHIG?NLC=; ]
'I?HE?L .
$;FFI=E '" -O;HNCF? L?AL?MMCIH &IOLH;F I@ !=IHIGC= ,?L
MJ?=NCP?M ]
'IFGIAILIP * #LOH><?ALC_? >?L 3;BLM=B?CHFC=BE?CNML?=BHOHA
/JLCHA?L
?LFCH !HAFCMB NL;HMF;NCIH "IOH>;NCIHM I@ NB? NB?ILS I@ JLI<
;<CFCNS B?FM?;
*?Q 5ILE
'IO /# DOGJ>C_OMCIH GI>?F @IL IJNCIH JLC=CHA );H;A?G?HN /=C
?H=? ]
.?@?L?H=?M
,;LCM
(B;<CN;HN "/ +H NB? ;<OM? I@ 0;SFIL M?LC?M ;JJLIRCG;NCIHM @IL JILN
@IFCI M?F?=NCIH
JILN@IFCI J?L@ILG;H=? ;H> LCME G;H;A?G?HN 1HCP?LMCNS I@ (;O
M;HH?
3ILECHA ,;J?L
(C 3'
(CHA /
)=F??L ) MOLP?S I@ L?=?HN NB?IL?NC=;F L?MOFNM @IL
NCG? M?LC?M GI>?FM QCNB #.$ ?LLILM &IOLH;F I@ !=IHIGC= /OLP?S ]
(C?M?H@?F> . SH;GC= <CP;LC;N? GCRNOL? GI>?FM )I>?FCHA NB? <?B;P
CIL I@ JLC=?M ;H> NL;>CHA PIFOG? &IOLH;F I@ OMCH?MM ;H> !=IHIGC= /N;NCMNC=M
]
(C?M?H@?F> . A?H?L;FCT?> <CP;LC;N? GCRNOL? GI>?F @IL MNI=E JLC=?
PIF;NCFCNS ;H> NL;>CHA PIFOG? &IOLH;F I@ !=IHIG?NLC=M ]
(CO
4
/B;=EF?NIH )
0;SFIL /&
4O 4 FIM?>@ILG NL;HM@ILG;
NCIHM @LIG LCMEH?ONL;F NI L?;FQILF> >CMNLC<ONCIHM ?JN I@ ==IOHNCHA ;H>
"CH;H=? 3ILECHA ,;J?L
(;H=;MN?L 1HCP?LMCNS
(DOHA #)
IR #!, +H ; G?;MOL? I@ F;=E I@ WN CH NCG? M?LC?M GI>
?FM CIG?NLCE; ]
(I 3
);='CHF;S
6B;HA & !=IHIG?NLC= GI>?FM I@ FCGCNIL>?L
?R?=ONCIHM &IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=C;F !=IHIGC=M ]
(I 3
3;HA & 0L;>CHA PIFOG? ?WHCNCIHM
>;N; ;H;FSMCM
;H> CG
JFC=;NCIHM I@ JILN@IFCI NB?ILS .?PC?Q I@ "CH;H=C;F /NO>C?M ]
(ICMNF + 0B? ?LLIH?IOM ;JJLIRCG;NCIH I@ ?RJ?=N?> ONCFCNS <S G?;HM
I@ ; 0;SFILZM M?LC?M ?RJ;HMCIH ;H;FSNC= ;H> =IGJON;NCIH;F L?MOFNM G?LC=;H
!=IHIGC= .?PC?Q ]
(IHACH ") 0B? ;MSGJNINC= >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ ?RNL?G? MNI=E G;LE?N L?
NOLHM &IOLH;F I@ OMCH?MM ]
(IHACH ") "LIG 2;. NI MNL?MM N?MNCHA 0B? ?RNL?G? P;FO? ;JJLI;=B
&IOLH;F I@ ;HECHA ;H> "CH;H=? ]
(IHACH ")
/IFHCE %M NB? =ILL?F;NCIH CH CHN?LH;NCIH;F ?KOCNS L?NOLHM
=IHMN;HN ] &IOLH;F I@ %HN?LH;NCIH;F )IH?S ;H> "CH;H=? ]
(IHACH ")
/IFHCE !RNL?G? =ILL?F;NCIH I@ CHN?LH;NCIH;F ?KOCNS G;L
E?NM &IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=? ]
(IJ?T & )?NBI>M @IL ?P;FO;NCHA P;FO?;NLCME ?MNCG;N?M !=IHIGC= ,IF
C=S .?PC?Q
"?>?L;F .?M?LP? ;HE I@ *?Q 5ILE +=NI<?L]
(IL?N;H )
!HAFCMB 3 !P;FO;NCHA [=ILL?F;NCIH <L?;E>IQHM\ >OLCHA
J?LCI>M I@ G;LE?N PIF;NCFCNS I;L> I@ #IP?LHILM I@ NB? "?>?L;F .?M?LP? /SMN?G
3ILECHA ,;J?L
(IL?N;H )
,BCFFCJM , 0?MNCHA NB? =IP;LC;H=? MN;NCIH;LCNS I@ B?;PS
N;CF?> NCG? M?LC?M &IOLH;F I@ !GJCLC=;F "CH;H=? ]
(OGM>;CH? . IHMCMN?H=S ;H> ;MSGJNINC= HILG;FCNS I@ NB? KO;MC
G;RCGOG FCE?FCBII> ?MNCG;NIL CH %#.$
;H> =IP;LC;H=? MN;NCIH;LS
.?@?L?H=?M
#.$
GI>?FM !=IHIG?NLC=; ]
(OR 0 0B? FCGCNCHA ?RNL?G;F <?B;PCIL I@ MJ?=OF;NCP? L?NOLHM ;H ;H;FS
MCM I@ CHNL;>;CFS >;N; @LIG NB? "L;HE@OLN MNI=E ?R=B;HA? JJFC?> "CH;H=C;F
!=IHIGC=M ]
);>;H
;LL ,
B;HA ! 0B? P;LC;H=? A;GG; JLI=?MM ;H> IJ
NCIH JLC=CHA !OLIJ?;H "CH;H=? .?PC?Q ]
);>;H
)CFH? " +JNCIH JLC=CHA QCNB 2# G;LNCHA;F? =IGJIH?HNM
);NB?G;NC=;F "CH;H=? ]
);>;H
)CFH? " IHNCHA?HN =F;CGM P;FO?> ;H> B?>A?> <S JLC=CHA
;H> CHP?MNCHA CH ; <;MCM );NB?G;NC=;F "CH;H=? ]
);>;H
/?H?N; ! 0B? 2# GI>?F @IL MB;L? G;LE?N L?NOLHM &IOLH;F
I@ OMCH?MM ]
);B?O &)
)=OL>S 0$ *?QM ;LLCP;F
DOGJ >SH;GC=M
;H> PIF;NCF
CNS =IGJIH?HNM @IL CH>CPC>O;F MNI=E L?NOLHM &IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=? ]
);F?P?LAH? 5
/ILH?NN? 0?MNCHA NB? A;OMMC;H =IJOF; BSJINB?MCM @IL
WH;H=C;F ;MM?NM >?J?H>?H=?M -O;HNCN;NCP? "CH;H=? ]
);FT ) 1MCHA IJNCIH JLC=?M NI ?MNCG;N? L?;FCAHG?HN JLI<;<CFCNC?M CH
NB? !OLIJ?;H GIH?N;LS MSMN?G &IOLH;F I@ %HN?LH;NCIH;F )IH?S ;H> "CH;H=?
]
);FT ) !MNCG;NCHA NB? JLI<;<CFCNS >CMNLC<ONCIH I@ NB? @ONOL? ?R
=B;HA? L;N? @LIG IJNCIH JLC=?M &IOLH;F I@ ?LCP;NCP?M ]
);H>?F<LIN 0B? P;LC;NCIH I@ =?LN;CH MJ?=OF;NCP? JLC=?M &IOLH;F I@
OMCH?MM ]
);LEIQCNT $) ,ILN@IFCI M?F?=NCIH &IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=? ]
);LN?HM )
,IIH / .?NOLHM MSH=BLIHCT;NCIH ;H> >;CFS =ILL?F;NCIH >S
H;GC=M <?NQ??H CHN?LH;NCIH;F MNI=E G;LE?NM &IOLH;F I@ ;HECHA ;H> "CH;H=?
]
)=*?CF & !MNCG;NCHA NB? N;CFM I@ FIMM M?P?LCNS >CMNLC<ONCIHM OMCHA ?R
NL?G? P;FO? NB?ILS /0%* OFF?NCH ]
)=*?CF & ;F=OF;NCHA KO;HNCF? LCME G?;MOL?M @IL WH;H=C;F
NCG? M?LC?M OMCHA ?RNL?G? P;FO? NB?ILS !0$ !IFF?=NCIH BNNJ
?
=IFF?=NCIH?NB<C<?NBT=B
=AC<CH
MBIQJFNSJ?<?LC=BNHL
)=*?CF &
"L?S . !MNCG;NCIH I@ N;CFL?F;N?> LCME G?;MOL?M @IL B?N
?LIM=?>;MNC= WH;H=C;F NCG? M?LC?M ;H ?RNL?G? P;FO? ;JJLI;=B &IOLH;F I@ !G
JCLC=;F "CH;H=? ]
)?;> (.
,;J;HC=IF;IO * );RCGOG ?HNLIJS CH NB? JLI<F?G I@ GI
G?HNM &IOLH;F I@ );NB?G;NC=;F ,BSMC=M ]
)?>>;BC *
.?H;OFN ! 0?GJIL;F ;AAL?A;NCIH I@ PIF;NCFCNS GI>?FM
&IOLH;F I@ !=IHIG?NLC=M ]
)?FC=E 3.
0BIG;M , .?=IP?LCHA ;H ;MM?NZM CGJFC?> , " @LIG
IJNCIHM JLC=?M H ;JJFC=;NCIH NI =LO>? ICF >OLCHA NB? #OF@ =LCMCM &IOLH;F I@
"CH;H=C;F ;H> -O;HNCN;NCP? H;FSMCM ]
)?FCHI
0OLH<OFF / ,LC=CHA @IL?CAH =OLL?H=S IJNCIHM QCNB MNI=B;MNC=
PIF;NCFCNS &IOLH;F I@ !=IHIG?NLC=M ]
.?@?L?H=?M
);MM;=BOM?NNM
,LINN?L , /NI=B;MNC= CHN?AL;NCIH ;H> >C_?L?HNC;F ?KO;NCIHM /JLCHA?L
2?LF;A
?LFCH
.;G=B;H> (
/OMG?F . 2IF;NCFCNS ;H> =LIMM =ILL?F;NCIH ;=LIMM G;DIL
MNI=E G;LE?NM &IOLH;F I@ !GJCLC=;F "CH;H=? ]
.;NH?L ) ,ILN@IFCI >CP?LMCW=;NCIH ;H> NB? CHN?LN?GJIL;F MN;<CFCNS I@
CHN?LH;NCIH;F CH>C=?M #FI<;F "CH;H=? &IOLH;F ]
.C<IOF?N #
.IH=;FFC 0
IOSf ! IJOF;M @IL WH;H=? L?;>CHA AOC>?
;H> MIG? ;JJFC=;NCIHM Lf>CN (SIHH;CM
3ILECHA ,;J?L
.C=B;L>MIH )
/GCNB 0 N?MN @IL GOFNCP;LC;N? HILG;FCNS CH MNI=E L?
NOLHM &IOLH;F I@ OMCH?MM ]
.C=B;L>MIH )
/GCNB 0 >CL?=N N?MN I@ NB? GCRNOL? I@ >CMNLC<ONCIHM
BSJINB?MCM )?;MOLCHA NB? >;CFS XIQ I@ CH@ILG;NCIH &IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=C;F ;H>
-O;HNCN;NCP? H;FSMCM ]
.I=E;@?FF;L .0
1LS;M?P / +JNCGCT;NCIH I@ =IH>CNCIH;F P;FO?;NLCME
&IOLH;F I@ .CME ]
.I=E;@?FF;L .0
1LS;M?P / IH>CNCIH;F P;FO?;NLCME @IL A?H?L;F FIMM
.?@?L?H=?M
/?HN;H; !
"CIL?HNCHC # %>?HNCW=;NCIH
?MNCG;NCIH ;H> N?MNCHA I@ =IH
>CNCIH;FFS B?N?LIME?>;MNC= @;=NIL GI>?FM &IOLH;F I@ !=IHIG?NLC=M ]
/B;HHIH ! 0B? G;NB?G;NC=;F NB?ILS I@ =IGGOHC=;NCIH ?FF /SMN?G
0?=BHC=;F &IOLH;F ] ;H> ]
/B?JB;L> * /N;NCMNC=;F ;MJ?=NM I@ .$ ;H> MNI=B;MNC= PIF;NCFCNS %H
IR .
$CHEF?S 2
;LH>IL_*C?FM?H +! ?>M 0CG? M?LC?M GI>?FM CH
?=IHIG?NLC=M
WH;H=? ;H> INB?L W?F>M B;JG;H $;FF
(IH>IH
]
/BCB &$
(IOCM 0 %H@?L?H=?M IH NB? ;MMI=C;NCIH J;L;G?N?L CH =IJOF;
GI>?FM @IL <CP;LC;N? MOLPCP;F >;N; CIG?NLC=M ]
/BCGEI IOH>M I@ JLI<;<CFCNS .%/' ]
/BL?P? /! /NI=B;MNC= =;F=OFOM @IL WH;H=? %% =IHNCHOIOMNCG? GI>?FM
/JLCHA?L2?LF;A
*?Q 5ILE
/CFP?LG;H 3 ?HMCNS ?MNCG;NCIH @IL MN;NCMNC=M ;H> >;N; ;H;FSMCM
)IHIAL;JBM IH /N;NCMNC=M ;H> JJFC?> ,LI<;<CFCNS
B;JG;H ;H> $;FF
*?Q 5ILE
/CG;;H 5 ,ILN@IFCI M?F?=NCIH ;H> ;MM?N JLC=CHA ] 0BL??J;L;G?N?L
@L;G?QILE );H;A?G?HN /=C?H=? ]
/CGEIQCNT )
??>F?M 3( CP?LMCW=;NCIH CH ; NBL??GIG?HN QILF>
&IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=C;F ;H> -O;HNCN;NCP? H;FSMCM ]
/CHAF?NIH '& !MNCG;NCIH I@ ;^H? ;MM?N JLC=CHA GI>?FM OMCHA NB? ?G
JCLC=;F =B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH &IOLH;F I@ !=IHIG?NLC=M ]
/CHAF?NIH &
3CHA?H>?L & /E?QH?MM J?LMCMN?H=? CH =IGGIH MNI=E
L?NOLHM &IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=C;F ;H> -O;HNCN;NCP? H;FSMCM ]
/EF;L "IH=NCIHM >? LfJ;LNCNCIH b C >CG?HMCIHM ?N F?OLM G;LA?M ,O<
FC=;NCIHM >? FZ%HMNCNON /N;NCMNCKO? >? FZ1HCP?LMCNf >? ,;LCM ]
/GCNB .( );RCGOG FCE?FCBII> ?MNCG;NCIH CH ; =F;MM I@ HIHL?AOF;L
=;M?M CIG?NLCE; ]
/GCNB .( !MNCG;NCHA N;CFM I@ JLI<;<CFCNS >CMNLC<ONCIHM HH;FM I@ /N;
NCMNC=M ]
/j>?LFCH> ,
/P?HMMIH (!+ *?Q N?=BHCKO?M NI ?RNL;=N G;LE?N ?RJ?=
N;NCIHM @LIG WH;H=C;F CHMNLOG?HNM &IOLH;F I@ )IH?N;LS !=IHIGC=M ]
/N`
;LC=`
;
,C=N?N + 0B? N;F?M NB? N;CFM I@ #.$
JLI=?MM?M N?FF
?JN /N;NCMNC=M
1HCP?LMCNS I@ ,?HHMSFP;HC;
3ILECHA ,;J?L
/N?CH !
/N?CH & /NI=E JLC=? >CMNLC<ONCIHM QCNB MNI=B;MNC= PIF;NCFCNS H
;H;FSNC= ;JJLI;=B .?PC?Q I@ "CH;H=C;F /NO>C?M ]
/NC?FND?M 0& .?=B?L=B?M MOL F?M @L;=NCIHM =IHNCHO?M HH;F?M >? F; ";=
OFNf >?M /=C?H=?M >? 0IOFIOM? ]
/NLIO> $ JJLIRCG;N? =;F=OF;NCIH I@ GOFNCJF? CHN?AL;FM ,L?HNC=?
$;FF
!HAF?QII> FC_M
*?Q &?LM?S
/NONT?L ) MCGJF? HIHJ;L;G?NLC= ;JJLI;=B NI >?LCP;NCP? M?=OLCNS P;F
O;NCIH &IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=? ]
/OMG?F .
!HAF? ." $IOLFS PIF;NCFCNS MJCFFIP?LM <?NQ??H CHN?LH;NCIH;F
?KOCNS G;LE?NM &IOLH;F I@ %HN?LH;NCIH;F )IH?S ;H> "CH;H=? ]
.?@?L?H=?M
0;JC; .
0BIGMIH &. *IHJ;L;G?NLC= JLI<;<CFCNS >?HMCNS ?MNCG;
NCIH &IBHM $IJECHM 1HCP?LMCNS ,L?MM
;FNCGIL?
0;O=B?H #
$OMM?S . -O;>L;NOL?<;M?> G?NBI>M @IL I<N;CHCHA ;J
JLIRCG;N? MIFONCIHM NI HIHFCH?;L ;MM?N JLC=CHA GI>?FM !=IHIG?NLC=; ]
0;O=B?H #
,CNNM ) 0B? JLC=? P;LC;<CFCNSPIFOG? L?F;NCIHMBCJ IH MJ?=
OF;NCP? G;LE?NM !=IHIG?NLC=; ]
0;SFIL /& "CH;H=C;F L?NOLHM GI>?FF?> <S NB? JLI>O=N I@ NQI MNI=B;MNC=
JLI=?MM?M
; MNO>S I@ >;CFS MOA;L JLC=?M
] %H H>?LMIH +! ?>
0CG? M?LC?M ;H;FSMCM 0B?ILS ;H> JL;=NC=? *ILNB$IFF;H>
GMN?L>;G
]
0;SFIL /& )I>?FFCHA WH;H=C;F NCG? M?LC?M 3CF?S
*?Q 5ILE
0B?I>IMMCIO , "CH;H=C;F >;N; ;H> NB? ME?Q?> A?H?L;FCT?> N >CMNLC<O
NCIH );H;A?G?HN /=C?H=? ]
0C;AI >? +FCP?CL; & /N;NCMNC=;F ?RNL?G?M ] MOLP?S ?HN?L I@ JJFC?>
);NB?G;NC=M
(CM<IH
0CGG?LG;HH )IG?HNM I@ );LEIP MQCN=BCHA GI>?FM &IOLH;F I@
!=IHIG?NLC=M ]
0I<CH & (CKOC>CNS JL?@?L?H=? ;M <?B;PCIL NIQ;L>M LCME .?PC?Q I@ !=I
HIGC= /NO>C?M ]
0M;S ./ H;FSMCM I@ WH;H=C;F NCG? M?LC?M
&IBH 3CF?S
*?Q 5ILE
0M? 5' N?MN @IL =IHMN;HN =ILL?F;NCIHM CH ; GOFNCP;LC;N? #.$
GI>?F &IOLH;F I@ !=IHIG?NLC=M ]
0M? 5' .?MC>O;F<;M?> >C;AHIMNC=M @IL =IH>CNCIH;F B?N?LIM=?>;MNC=CNS
GI>?FM !=IHIG?NLC=M &IOLH;F ]
0M? 5'
0MOC ' GOFNCP;LC;N? A?H?L;FCT?> ;ONIL?AL?MMCP? =IH
>CNCIH;F B?N?LIM=?>;MNC=CNS GI>?F QCNB NCG?P;LSCHA =ILL?F;NCIHM &IOLH;F I@
OMCH?MM ;H> !=IHIGC=M /N;NCMNC=M ]
1MB;EIP *# /?F?=N?> NIJC=M CH =B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIHM )I>?LH ,LI<
;<CFCNS ;H> /N;NCMNC=M
2/, 2
1NL?=BN
0B? *?NB?LF;H>M
2;H >?H #IIL<?LAB .3&
2F;;L ,&# 2;FO?;NLCME ;H;FSMCM I@ MNI=E
L?NOLHM $CMNILC=;F MCGOF;NCIH
P;LC;H=? N?=BHCKO?M IL N;CF CH>?R ?MNCG;NCIH
3+ .?M?;L=B )?GIL;H>;
*?NB?LF;H>M ?HNL;F ;HE
.?M?;L=B ?J;LN
G?HN
2;H >?L 3?C>? . #+#.$ GOFNCP;LC;N? A?H?L;FCT?> ILNBIAIH;F
#.$ GI>?F &IOLH;F I@ JJFC?> !=IHIG?NLC=M ]
2F;;L ,
,;FG " 0B? G?MM;A? CH Q??EFS ?R=B;HA? L;N?M CH NB? !O
LIJ?;H GIH?N;LS MSMN?G )?;H L?P?LMCIH
=IH>CNCIH;F B?N?LIME?>;MNC=CNS ;H>
DOGJM &IOLH;F I@ OMCH?MM ;H> !=IHIGC= /N;NCMNC=M ]
2LIHNIM %
?FF;JILN;M ,
,IFCNCM * @OFF@;=NIL GOFNCP;LC;N?
#.$ GI>?F !=IHIG?NLC=M &IOLH;F ]
3;AAIH?L " /JFCH? G?NBI>M @IL ?RNL;=NCHA CHN?L?MN L;N? =OLP?M @LIG
=IOJIH <IH> JLC=?M "?>?L;F .?M?LP? ;HE I@ NF;HN;
3ILECHA ,;J?L
3;B<; # /JFCH? GI>?FM @IL I<M?LP;NCIH;F >;N; /%) ,BCF;>?FJBC;
.?@?L?H=?M
3;FFCM '" BCMKO;L?> N?MNM I@ CHN?LP;F ;H> >?HMCNS @IL?=;MNM
;H> NB?
;HE I@ !HAF;H>ZM @;H =B;LNM %HN?LH;NCIH;F &IOLH;F I@ "IL?=;MNCHA ]
3?CH<?LA / %HN?LJL?NCHA NB? PIF;NCFCNS MGCF? H ?R;GCH;NCIH I@ NB?
CH@ILG;NCIH =IHN?HN I@ IJNCIH JLC=?M I;L> I@ #IP?LHILM I@ NB? "?>?L;F .?
M?LP? /SMN?G
%HN?LH;NCIH;F "CH;H=? CM=OMMCIH ,;J?L
3?CMM MSGJNINC= NB?ILS @IL .$ GI>?FM !MNCG;NCIH ;H> N?MN
CHA !=IHIG?NLC= 0B?ILS ]
3B??F?L &
#IL>IH .# .CAILIOM <IOH>M @IL NB?LGI>SH;GC= JLIJ
?LNC?M I@ B;LGIHC= MIFC>M &IOLH;F I@ B?GC=;F ,BSMC=M ]
3BCN? $ );RCGOG FCE?FCBII> ?MNCG;NCIH I@ GCMMJ?=CW?> GI>?FM
!=IHIG?NLC=; ]
3C>>?L 2 0B? (;JF;=? NL;HM@ILG ,LCH=?NIH 1HCP?LMCNS ,L?MM
,LCH=?NIH
3CAACHM & +JNCIH P;FO?M OH>?L MNI=B;MNC= PIF;NCFCNS 0B?ILS ;H> ?G
JCLC=;F ?MNCG;N?M &IOLH;F I@ "CH;H=C;F !=IHIGC=M ]
3CFFC;GM ,LI<;<CFCNS QCNB G;LNCHA;F?M ;G<LC>A? 1HCP?LMCNS ,L?MM
6;EIh;H &) 0BL?MBIF> B?N?LIME?>;MNC=CNS GI>?FM &IOLH;F I@ !=I
HIGC= SH;GC=M ;H> IHNLIF ]
6?FFH?L
$CABW?F> . ;F=OF;NCIH I@ G;RCGOG ?HNLIJS >CMNLC<ONCIHM
;H> ;JJLIRCG;NCIH I@ G;LACH;F JIMN?LCIL >CMNLC<ONCIHM &IOLH;F I@ !=IHIG?N
LC=M ]
6CPIN !
3;HA & )I>?FCHA WH;H=C;F NCG? M?LC?M QCNB /,FOM /JLCHA?L
2?LF;A
*?Q 5ILE
7-.A
ILL?F;NCIH !MNCG;NCIH
IH>CNCIH;F =ILL?F;NCIH
!MNCG;NCIH
IHMN;HN =ILL?F;NCIH
IJOF;
IHMN;HN =ILL?F;NCIH N?MN
!HNLIJS >CMNLC<ONCIH
SH;GC= =ILL?F;NCIH
#.$ GI>?F
&?HHLC=B N?MN
#?H?L;FCT?> ?RNL?G? P;FO? >CMNLC<O
'?H>;FFZM N;O
NCIH
(CH?;L
#?H?L;FCT?> ,;L?NI >CMNLC<ONCIH
)?;MOL? I@ =IH=IL>;H=?
#))
)CRNOL? I@ >CMNLC<ONCIHM BSJINB?MCM
);RCGOG (CE?FCBII>
,?;LMIHZM LBI
)OFNCP;LC;N? #.$ GI>?F
/J?;LG;HZM LBI
-O;MC );RCGOG (CE?FCBII>
/NSFCT?> @;=NM
0CG?P;LC;<CFCNS
.?AL?MMCIH<;M?> ?MNCG;NCIH
0CG?P;LSCHA =ILL?F;NCIH
/?GCJ;L;G?NLC= );RCGOG (CE?FC
TNL;HM@ILG;NCIH
BII>
LIMM=ILL?F;NCIH
/NI=B;MNC= PIF;NCFCNS
OGOF;HNM
0;CF CH>?R
OGOF;NCP? >CMNLC<ONCIH @OH=NCIH
0QIMN?J
!P?HN NCG?
?;F?L
!R=?MM >CMNLC<ONCIH @OH=NCIH
?HMCNS @IL?=;MN
!RCMN?H=? I@ GIG?HNM
?J?H>?H=? !RJ?=N?> MBILN@;FF
!RNL?G?
?WHCNCIH
,?L@?=N >?J?H>?H=?
!RNL?G? P;FO? NB?ILS
,?L@?=N CH>?J?H>?H=?
$CMNILC=;F MCGOF;NCIH
?JNB G;LE?N
,ILN@IFCIF?P?F ;JJLI;=B
C_OMCIH JLI=?MM
.CME)?NLC=M
CL;= G?;MOL?
/E?Q?> I >CMNLC<ONCIH
CL?=NCHA JLI=?MM
!RJIH?HNC;F >CMNLC<ONCIH
CM=L?NCT;NCIH <C;M
!RNL?G; ;JJLI;=B
CMNLC<ONCIH
#?H?L;FCT?> ?RNL?G? P;FO? >CMNLC<O
IG;CH I@ ;NNL;=NCIH
NCIH
IQHMC>? LCME
/B;J? CH>?R
OL;NCIH 0;CF CH>?R
?NQ??H DOGJM
!RNL?G;F CH>?R
?NQ??H NL;>?M
!RNL?G? P;FO? NB?ILS
SH;GC= =IH>CNCIH;F =ILL?F;NCIH !RJ?=N?> MBILN@;FF
!MNCG;NCIH
!RNL?G; ;JJLI;=B
)I>?F
%C> >;N;
)OFNCP;LC;N?
!#.$ GI>?F
0;CF ;JJLI;=B
!FFCJNC=;F >CMNLC<ONCIH 1HCP;LC;N?
!MNCG;NCIH
2;.
)OFNCP;LC;N?
3?;EFS >?J?H>?HN >;N;
!G?LACHA G;LE?NM
!HNLIJS >CMNLC<ONCIH
";=NIL #.$ GI>?F
IG;CH I@ >?WHCNCIH
";MN "IOLC?L NL;HM@ILG
%H>?R
";N N;CFM
);RCGOG (CE?FCBII>
"CH;H=C;F G;LE?NM
,;L;G?N?L ?MNCG;N?M
"CMB?L0CJJ?N NB?IL?G .?AL?MMCIH<;M?> ?MNCG;NCIH
%C> >;N;
#?H?L;FCT?> ,;L?NI >CMNLC<ONCIH
)OFNCP;LC;N?
?WHCNCIH
3?;EFS >?J?H>?HN >;N;
#L;JBC=;F C>?HNCW=;NCIH
"F?RC<F? #.$ GI>?F $CAB NBL?MBIF> M?F?=NCIH
)I>?F
);RCGOG (CE?FCBII>
2;.
,;L;G?N?L ?MNCG;N?M
"Lf=B?N >CMNLC<ONCIH
2;.
#&. GI>?F
#.$ GI>?F
#))
MSGG?NLC= GI>?F
#L;GB;LFC?L ?RJ;HMCIH
IRIR NL;HM@ILG
#OG<?F >CMNLC<ONCIH
LIMMM?=NCIH;F ;AAL?A;NCIH
?WHCNCIH
$;T;L> @OH=NCIH
!#.$ GI>?F
$?N?LIA?H?CNS I@ <?FC?@M
!MNCG;NCIH
$CAB @L?KO?H=S >;N;
!RJIH?HNC;F #.$ GI>?F
$CAB KO;HNCF?M
!RNL?G; <?B;PCIL
!MNCG;NCIH
"IL?=;MNCHA
!RNL?G; ;JJLI;=B
#&. GI>?F
#?H?L;FCT?> ,;L?NI >CMNLC<ONCIH
$CAB?L GIG?HNM
/?GCJ;L;G?NLC= ;JJLI;=B
%HN?AL;N?> #.$ GI>?F
0;CF ;JJLI;=B
&OGJM
$CAB?L GIG?HNM
'OLNIMCM
IEOLNIMCM
)OFNCP;LC;N? GI>?F
IME?QH?MM
*?QM CGJ;=N =OLP?
CMNLC<ONCIHM
*IHJ;L;G?NLC= GI>?F
!>A?QILNB ?RJ;HMCIH
/?GCJ;L;G?NLC=
!RCMN?H=?
/?GCMNLIHA #.$
#.$ GI>?F
/E?QH?MM
$?LGCN? JIFSHIGC;FM
/N;NCIH;LCNS =IH>CNCIHM
)I>?FFCHA
/NLIHA #.$
)OFNCP;LC;N?
/NLO=NOL? I@ GI>?F
,ILN@IFCI ;FFI=;NCIH
0;CF CH>?R
,ILN@IFCI L?NOLH
0?GJIL;F ;AAL?A;NCIH
/E?Q?> I >CMNLC<ONCIH
0?MN @IL ;MSGG?NLS
0?MN
0?MN @IL #.$ ?_?=NM
0CG? P;LC;<CFCNS
0#.$ GI>?F
2;.
%H=L?;MCHA JLI=?MM
3?;E #.$
%H@ILG;NCIH ;LLCP;F
#;OMMC;H >CMNLC<ONCIH %HN?AL;F
)OFNCP;LC;N?
%HN?AL;N?> #.$ GI>?F
#?H?L;F ?LLIL >CMNLC<ONCIH
%HN?AL;N?> KO;LNC=CNS
#?H?L;FCT?> <?N; >CMNLC<ONCIH
%HN?LKO;LNCF? L;HA?
#?H?L;FCT?> ?RNL?G? P;FO? >CMNLC<ONCIH
%HN?LP;F @IL?=;MN
>?KO;=S N?MN
?WHCNCIH
2;.
%H>?R
%NI JLI=?MM
#?H?L;FCT?> ?RNL?G? P;FO? >CMNLC<O
%NIZM F?GG;
NCIH
)OFNCP;LC;N?
#?H?L;FCT?> ,;L?NI >CMNLC<ONCIH
)OFNCP;LC;N? #.$ GI>?F
&OGJM
)?;H
B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH
)?;H ;<MIFON? >?PC;NCIH
#.$ GI>?F
)?;H ?R=?MM @OH=NCIH
$CAB?L GIG?HNM
)?;H ?R=?MM JFIN
+JNCIH JLC=CHA
)?;H Q;CNCHA NCG?
)?;MOL?M I@ >CMJ?LMCIH
'?LH?F L?AL?MMCIH
)?;MOL?M I@ FI=;NCIH
'IFGIAILIP <;=EQ;L> ?KO;NCIH
)?>C;H
)C=LIMNLO=NOL? HICM?
'OLNIMCM
)CRNOL? I@ >CMNLC<ONCIH BSJINB?MCM
.$ GI>?F
!>A?QILNB ?RJ;HMCIH
#))
!R=?MM EOLNIMCM
)IG?HNM I@ >?HMCNC?M
#.$ GI>?F
] 0?MNCHA
$?LGCN? JIFSHIGC;FM
)CRNOL? P;LC;<F?
&OGJ GI>?F
)IG?HNM
)CRNOL? I@ >CMNLC<ONCIHM BSJINB?MCM
)OFNCJ?LCI> 2;.
,ILN@IFCIF?P?F ;JJLI;=B
)I>?FCHA
.CME)?NLC=M
/NI=B;MNC= PIF;NCFCNS
)OFNCP;LC;N? >CMNLC<ONCIH
IJOF; @OH=NCIH
(fPS JLI=?MM
!FFCJNC=;F >CMNLC<ONCIH
IHMNLO=NCIH
#;OMMC;H >CMNLC<ONCIH
)I>?F
/E?Q?> ?FFCJNC=;F >CMNLC<ONCIH
+JNCIH JLC=CHA
,LIJ?LNC?M
/E?Q?> #;OMMC;H >CMNLC<ONCIH
(;Q I@ F;LA? HOG<?LM
/E?Q?> I >CMNLC<ONCIH
(?P?L;A? ?_?=N
/NO>?HN I >CMNLC<ONCIH
(DOHAIR N?MN
2;.
(IAHILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH
)OFNCP;LC;N? #.$ GI>?F
!'' GI>?F
);LACH;F >CMNLC<ONCIH @OH=NCIH
IH>CNCIH;F =ILL?F;NCIH
);LE?N G;E?L
C;AIH;F GI>?F
);LE?N GC=LIMNLO=NOL?
!MNCG;NCIH
+L>?L>LCP?H G;LE?N
";=NIL #.$ GI>?F
-OIN?>LCP?H G;LE?N
"F?RC<F? GI>?F
);LNCHA;F? #+#.$ GI>?F
(I=;F G;LNCHA;F?
+#.$ GI>?F
)?;MOL?
/?GCJ;L;G?NLC= ?MNCG;NCIH
/?GCG;LNCHA;F?
/J?=CW=;NCIH N?MN
/2/)
2;.
);RCGOG (CE?FCBII> 2?=NILC;F GI>?F
IJOF;
!^=C?H=S
*?QM CGJ;=N =OLP?
#.$ GI>?F
*IHHILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH
%H>?R
MSGG?NLC= >CMNLC<ONCIH
2IF;NCFCNS MGCF?
!>A?QILNB ?RJ;HMCIHM
+L>?L
!HNLIJS >CMNLC<ONCIH
+L>?L XIQ
#?H?L;FCT?> <?N;
!MNCG;NCHA J;L;G?N?LM
#L;GB;LFC?L ?RJ;HMCIH
)I>?FCHA KOIN?M
$?LGCN? JIFSHIGC;FM
/CGOF;NCIH
$CAB?L GIG?HNM
+L>?L>LCP?H G;LE?N
$SJ?LA?IG?NLC= @OH=NCIH
+LNBIAIH;F #.$ GI>?F
)CRNOL? I@ FIAHILG;FM
,?;LMIH %2 >CMNLC<ONCIH
,;L?NI >CMNLC<ONCIH
/?GCJ;L;G?NLC=
,;LNC;F >C_?L?HNC;F ?KO;NCIH
/E?Q?> I >CMNLC<ONCIH
/N;<F?
,;SI_
*IHHILG;F GOFNCP;LC;N? GI>?F ,?;LMIH %2 >CMNLC<ONCIH
>?KO;=S N?MN
IG;CH I@ >?WHCNCIH
!MNCG;NCIH
$CAB?L GIG?HNM
*IHHILG;FCNS
,ICMMIH JLI=?MM
CMNLC<ONCIHM
IGJ?HM;N?>
#?H?L;F JLI<F?G
IGJIOH>
,ILN@IFCI ;FFI=;NCIH
IHMNLO=NCIH
0CG?P;LSCHA BCAB?L GIG?HNM
$CAB?L GIG?HNM
*ILG;F >CMNLC<ONCIH
);LE?>
$CAB?L GIG?HNM
+L>?L ;LLCP;F
0?MN
,LIJ?LNC?M
*ILG;FCNS
,OL?
AAL?A;N? L?NOLHM
,ILN@IFCI ;FFI=;NCIH
&;LKO??L; N?MN
IQHMC>? LCME
'IFGIAILIP/GCLHIP N?MN
!RJ?=N?> MBILN@;FF
(CFFC?@ILM N?MN
!RJ?=N?> ONCFCNS
0?MNM @IL HILG;FCNS
$CAB?L GIG?HNM
*OG?LC=;F CHN?AL;NCIH
)?;HP;LC;H=? =LCN?LCIH
+JNCIH
+JNCG;F JILN@IFCI
G?LC=;H
1H>?L HIHHILG;FCNS
NNB?GIH?S
2;.
IOH>;LS =IH>CNCIH
,ILN@IFCI FCKOC>;NCIH
!OLIJ?;H
,IQ?L P;LC;NCIH
%HNB?GIH?S
,LC=CHA E?LH?F
&OGJ JLI=?MM
,LI<;<CFCNS >CMNLC<ONCIH @OH=NCIH
(fPS JLI=?MM
,LI<;<CFCNS CHN?AL;F NL;HM@ILG
)IH?SH?MM
+ONI@NB?GIH?S
,;LNC;F >C_?L?HNC;F ?KO;NCIH
-O;>L;NC= P;LC;NCIH
,;SI_
-O;HNCF? JFIN
,ON=;FF J;LCNS
-O;HNCF? L?AL?MMCIH
/NI=B;MNC= 2IF;NCFCNS
-O;MC );RCGOG (CE?FCBII>
/NLCE? JLC=?
0?LG MNLO=NOL? I@ PIF;NCFCNC?M
-OIN?
1H>?LFSCHA ;MM?N
-OIN?>LCP?H G;LE?N
%H>?R
.;H>IG Q;FE
$?LGCN? JIFSHIGC;FM
.?;FCT?> =IP;LC;H=?
&OGJ GI>?F
.?;FCT?> KO;LNC=CNS
)CRNOL? I@ >CMNLC<ONCIHM BSJINB?MCM
.?;FCT?> P;LC;H=?
.?;FCT?> PIF;NCFCNS
)I>?FFCHA
.?NOLH >?WHCNCIHM
/NI=B;MNC= PIF;NCFCNS
.CME ;P?LMCIH
/I@NQ;L?
.CME G?;MOL? /J?=CW=;NCIH N?MN
IB?L?HN G?;MOL?
)OFNCP;LC;N? GI>?F
IQHMC>? LCME
,ILNG;HN?;O N?MN
!RJ?=N?> MBILN@;FF
.?MC>O;F<;M?> N?MN
2;.
1HCP;LC;N? GI>?F
.CMEH?ONL;F >?HMCNS
/JFCH? G?NBI>
!>A?QILNB ?RJ;HMCIHM
/N;<F? >CMNLC<ONCIH
]
!MNCG;NCIH
;O=BS >CMNLC<ONCIH
#?H?L;FCT?> <?N;
/N;H>;L> >?PC;NCIH
$?LGCN? JIFSHIGC;FM
/NI=B;MNC= >C_?L?HNC;F ?KO;NCIH
'?LH?F L?AL?MMCIH
);RCGOG ?HNLIJS JLCH=CJF?
/NI=B;MNC= >CM=IOHN @;=NIL
)CRNOL? I@ BSJ?LA?IG?NLC= @OH=NCIHM
/NI=B;MNC= PIF;NCFCNS
!MNCG;NCIH
)CRNOL? I@ FIAHILG;FM
'OLNIMCM
*IHJ;L;G?NLC= GI>?F
+JNCIH JLC=CHA
,;L;G?NLC= GI>?F
-O;>L;NC= P;LC;NCIH
/?GCJ;L;G?NLC= GI>?F
/E?QH?MM
/JFCH? G?NBI>M
/NO>?HN I >CMNLC<ONCIH
0L??<;M?> G?NBI>M
$CAB?L GIG?HNM
.CME)?NLC=M
)OFNCP;LC;N?
)OFNCJ?LCI> 2;.
/NSFCT?> @;=NM I@ ;MM?N L?NOLHM
)OFNCJF? JIMCNCIH
/O<IL>CH;N?> JLI=?MM
/?GCG;LNCHA;F?
0;CF CH>?R
/?LC;F =ILL?F;NCIH
.$ GI>?F
(DOHAIR N?MN
?=E?LM
!CHG;BF
;H> >? $;;H
)CRNOL? I@ >CMNLC<ONCIHM BSJINB?MCM
?MNCG;NIL
!MNCG;NCIH
/E?Q?> ?FFCJNC=;F >CMNLC<ONCIH !RNL?G; ;JJLI;=B
#;OMMC;H
@IL #.$ L?MC>O;FM
)OFNCP;LC;N?
#.$ GI>?F
/E?Q?> I >CMNLC<ONCIH
$CAB NBL?MBIF> M?F?=NCIH
FN?LH;NCP? MJ?=CW=;NCIHM
$CFF ?MNCG;NIL
IG;CH I@ >?WHCNCIH
);RCGOG (CE?FCBII>
!RJ?=N?> MBILN@;FF
)OFNCP;LC;N?
$CAB?L GIG?HNM
,C=E;H>M ?MNCG;NIL
)OFNCP;LC;N?
/?GCJ;L;G?NLC= ?MNCG;NCIH
2;.
3?;EFS >?J?H>?HN >;N;
/E?QH?MM
0;SFIL M?LC?M ?RJ;HMCIH
!>A?QILNB ?RJ;HMCIH
0?LG MNLO=NOL? I@ PIF;NCFCNC?M
#.$ GI>?F
] 0?MN
%H>?R
>?KO;=S N?MN
2;FO? ;N .CME
.$ ?_?=NM
MM?NF?P?F ;JJLI;=B
MSGG?NLC= #.$ ?_?=NM
2C;.
ONIL?AL?MMCP? BCAB?L GIG?HNM
IJOF;
IHMN;HN =ILL?F;NCIH N?MN
?WHCNCIH
#.$ ?_?=NM
?FN;IHFS G?NBI>
%H@ILG;NCIH G;NLCR N?MN
!RNL?G? P;FO? NB?ILS
&;LKO??L; N?MN
$CMNILC=;F MCGOF;NCIH
'IFGIAILIP/GCLHIP N?MN
%HN?LP;F @IL?=;MN
() N?MN
)OFNCJ?LCI>
/J?=CW=;NCIH N?MN
)OFNCJF? JIMCNCIH
0#.$ GI>?F
)OFNCP;LC;N? >CMNLC<ONCIH
0BL?MBIF> M?F?=NCIH *IHFCH?;L ;JJLI;=B
IINMNL;J
,ILN@IFCIF?P?F ;JJLI;=B
#?H?L;FCT?> ,;L?NI >CMNLC<ONCIH
.CME)?NLC=M
/?GCJ;L;G?NLC= ;JJLI;=B
/E?Q?> I >CMNLC<ONCIH
0C=E MCT?
2;LC;H=?
0CG?
2IF;NCFCNS
0CG? >?J?H>?H=S MSGG?NLS
/?LC;F =ILL?F;NCIH
(?P?L;A? ?_?=N
2IF;NCFCNS =FOMN?LCHA
(IHA G?GILS
0CG?P;LSCHA =IH>CNCIH;F =ILL?F;NCIH
1HCN LIIN
2IF;NCFCNS =FOMN?LCHA
0CG?P;LSCHA BCAB?L GIG?HNM
#.$ GI>?F
0L;>? XIQ
)CRNOL? I@ >CMNLC<ONCIHM BSJINB?MCM
0L;>?L
0L??<;M?> G?NBI>M
0?MN @IL ;MSGG?NLS
0QIMN?J ?MNCG;NCIH 2IF;NCFCNS MGCF?
IJOF;
2IFOG?
SH;GC= =IH>CNCIH;F =ILL?F;NCIH
FN?LH;NCP? G?;MOL?M
"CFN?LCHA @IL M?;MIH;FCNS
1NCFCNS @OH=NCIH
. ONCFCNS
3?C<OFF >CMNLC<ONCIH
.. ONCFCNS
3C?H?L JLI=?MM M?? LIQHC;H GINCIH
,L?@?L?H=?M