Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Global Climate Change As Perceived by El d89c3f79
Global Climate Change As Perceived by El d89c3f79
Abstract. This study aimed to describe how the global climate change was perceived by
teachers of elementary schools. The subjects were 111 teachers from 7 elementary schools
in Yogyakarta City and Sleman district. The data were collected using open-ended
questions (including perception about the weather, feeling evoked by global warming
words and free responses related to global warming issues). The data were analyzed
using the technique of qualitative and quantitative content analysis with Indigenous
Psychology Approach. The result showed that only one teacher reported that there was
no weather anomaly, while 110 teachers reported that they perceived weather anomaly.
Of those who perceived weather anomaly mostly referred to natural conditions (including
global climatic condition and environmental destruction) and human behavior as its
causes. Responses about feeling as evoked by global warming word were classified into
three categories, i.e. emotional, physical and irrelevant responses. Free responses about
global warming were classified into four categories respectively from the highest
frequency of responses: prevention (including statement “must be prevented”, prevention
behaviors and prevention efforts), states (including the weather states and feeling), causes
(including technological advances and human behavior generally), and others. The
research finding was discussed in the frame of environmental concern as a means of
character education in elementary school.
Keywords: elementary school teacher, indigenous psychology approach, global climate
change, weather anomaly
1998). Since then, many countries in the various different values (e.g. achievement,
world including Indonesia have given security, benevolence) with varying
their serious attention to the movement of degrees of importance. A particular value
mitigation and adaptation to global may be important to one person but may
climate change. American Psychological be unimportant to another (Schwartz,
Association (APA Task Force on the 2012). Some values are closely related to
Interface between Psychology and Global environmental concerns. The definition of
Climate Change, in press) stated that the Environmental concern is “the degree to
issue of global climate change had positive which people are aware of the problems
impacts on the collective awareness of regarding the environment and support
protecting the environment. This collective the effort to solve the problems and or
awareness was rooted from the values that indicate the willingness to contribute
directed individual behavior. Therefore, in personally to their solution” (Dunlap &
our study, we used this issue to identify Jones as cited in Alibeli & White, 2011).
not only the beliefs about climate change Previously, Fransson and Garling (1999)
itself but perhaps we could discover reviewed the definition of environmental
values that underlined it. concerns from literature. They
Some studies suggested that we could summarized that environmental concern
elicit the society’s values through the issue was defined into two concepts, (1) an
of global climate change. Research finding evaluation or attitude toward facts, self
from Newcastle Australia (Harriet, 2000) and other’s behavior that had a
showed that the global climate change consequence to the environment and (2)
issue was understood on local knowledge, the general attitude or value orientation.
values, and moral responsibility. Similarly, Fransson and Garling (1999) described
a qualitative study conducted by Fischer, value orientation previously suggested by
Peters, Vavra, Neebe, and Megyesi (2011) Stern that was associated with environ-
found respondents’ beliefs about the mental concern. The value orientation
factors that shaped behavior instead, such included (1) Environmental concern which
as people’s tendency to be self-centered represents a way of thinking called New
due to their insatiable consumption habits Environmental Paradigm (NEP). NEP was
and being money-oriented. Their study a paradigm that views humans as an
was about the belief and knowledge of integral part of the whole of natural
climate change issues and energy on the ecosystem; (2) environmental concern
respondents in 5 European countries. associated with anthropocentric altruistic
This study aimed to describe public values, that was, people care for the
perception on global climate change environmental quality because they
issues. The public in this study were believed that the damage to the
teachers of elementary schools. From environment threatens human well-being,
teachers’ perception on this issue, we so the focus of concern was on human, not
wanted to know whether their perception of nature; (3) environmental concern
reflected concerns over environmental associated with self-interest; (4) Environ-
issues and the beliefs and values that are mental concern associated with religious
associated with environmental concerns. or post-materialistic values.
Values refer to what we think is Alibeli and White (2011) examined the
important in our life. Each of us holds tripartite model of environmental concern
senior analyst (Yuniarti, 2013). In this Before collecting the data, the
approach, the process of data analysis was questionnaire was tried out on a few
conducted in several stages. The persons respondents (we selected 5 respondents
from population did the data analysis at that had characteristic resemble the
the first stages and senior analyst at the population) to make sure that the open-
next stages. The minimum number of ended questions were understandable.
three persons in stage 1 was set up to
minimize subjectivities. The identified Data collection
themes from qualitative content analysis
Respondents in this study involved 111
after then were summed into a percentage
elementary school teachers from 7
using Microsoft Excel 2010.
elementary schools in Yogyakarta City (i.e:
SDN Bhayangkara, SDN Serayu) and
Instrument
Sleman District (i.e: SDN Samirono, SDN
In order to obtain original responses from Percobaan II, SDN Karangwuni, SDN
respondents, we constructed open-ended Minomartani, SDN Malang Rejo). The
questions. Previously, we asked about the characteristic of respondents can be seen in
familiarity with the terms related to global Table 1.
climate change (i.e: pemanasan global,
prubahan iklim global, cuaca ekstrem, Table 1.
Characteristics of Respondents
penipisan lapisan ozone) to 64 respondents
who attended Indigenous Psychology Demography Description
workshop held by CICP Universitas Age Range : 25 – 60
Gadjah Mada on March 2015 as a prelimi- Mean : 46
nary survey. The result showed that global Gender Male : 27
warming was a term that was known by Female :78
all respondents and most of them related blank : 6
their experience concerning local weather We collected the data in May and June
to global climate change. Based on this 2015. The timing of the data collection was
finding, global warming term and the unfortunately simultaneous with the
weather perception were used to timing when elementary schools prepared
formulate the open-ended questions. National Examination for their students.
The open-ended questions in this Therefore, by using convenience
study were part of the complete question- sampling_i.e. non-probability sampling
naire that comprised questions about where subjects were selected because of
teachers’ conception about global warm- their convenience accessibility and
ing, self-report about pro-environmental proximity to the researcher_, we went to
behavior, worldview and myth of nature. some schools and “door to door” asked
In this study, we focused on exploring permission to school principals to collect
teachers’ beliefs about global warming (or data on teachers under their management.
global climate change), including (1) Then, in order to make sure that the
Teacher perception about weather change questionnaire was responded by respon-
and its cause (2) Response of feeling as dents themselves, we gathered them in
evoked by global warming word (3) Free one class and distributed the question-
responses about global warming. naires which they returned immediately
after.
Teachers’ perception about weather change and Feeling responses as evoked by global warming
its causes word
From 111 respondents, only one teacher From this question, we found various
reported that there was no change of responses, not only about feeling but also
weather while the other respondent physical sensations and other responses
perceived the weather changing - that is that were irrelevant to feeling. The
the recent weather difference from normal statistics of each theme could be seen in
weather patterns or in other words, the Table 3.
Table 2.
Thematic Classification about Causes of Weather Anomaly (N=111)
Table 3
Thematic Classification about Feeling Responses (N=111)
Categories Descriptive statistic (%)
Emotion Worry (27.03%); Concerned (18.2%); Disappointment (1.8%)
Physic Hot weather (22.52%); Discomfort (7.21%)
Others Irrelevant responses (20.72%)
Blank Not answer (2.70%)
The emotion themes like worry, Free responses about global warming
prihatin (concerned) and disappointment
Previous studies about public perception
indicated that teachers experienced a
of global climate change suggested that
negative affect over global warming. It
global climate change was a complex issue
reflected that they perceived global
that involved multiple facets, such as
warming as a risk since the affect was an
psychological, socio-political, cultural, and
important sign of perceived risk
economic facets. Therefore, asking teachers
(Leiserowitz, 2006, Peters, Burraston, &
to write down their free responses to these
Mertz, 2004; Slovic, Finucane, Peters, &
issues functioned to give them space to
MacGregor, 2004).
express anything that popped up in their
The other themes about feeling as minds. From this question, we expected to
evoked by the word “global warming” elicit the actual beliefs about the issue that
were physical sensation (29.73 %). These was associated with global warming in the
reminded us to be cautious about the deep teachers’ mind. Categories of teachers’
structure of the local language. responses could be seen in Table 4.
Apparently, questions about feeling by the
Table 4
word perasaan in the Indonesian language
Thematic Classification of Free Responses
had multiple meanings as shown by this
(N=111)
finding, including emotion, physical
sensation (for instance: rasanya panas/It Categories Descriptive statistics (%)
feels hot) and also irrelevant responses Prevention Statement “must be prevented”
that were found in pretty high percentage (12.61%), Prevention behavior
(20.72%). The example of irrelevant (48.66%), Prevention effort
responses that might be represent the (5.40%)
worries of the catastrophic effect of global States Feeling and weather (12.31%)
warming were: bumi semakin tua (the earth Causes Technology (3.60%) & human
is going older), kiamat semakin dekat (the behavior (6.31%)
end of the world is near),or impact of Others Others (5.4%)
gobal warming on the environment: air Blank Not answer (5.4%)
susah menyerap di tanah (water cannot be
absorbed into the earth), etc. These various As shown in Table 4, prevention was
responses to questions about feeling the response with the highest frequency
suggested to the next researcher to be (66.67%), followed by a statement about
more sensitive to indigenous languages. states, causes, others and abstain. The
theme from prevention categories that (Yamori, 2007). In the context of global
mostly appeared was prevention behavior, climate change, those choices were
responded by 48.66% of all respondents. adaptation or mitigation.
Sub-themes of prevention behaviors were This study found that almost all
reforestation (reboisasi) and maintaining respondents showed concerns of global
environmental sustainability (36.94%), warming. It might reflect the existence of
preventing pollution (6.31 %) and collective responsibility values on
management of building (5.41%). Sub- teachers. Although we could not identify
themes of prevention efforts were opinions specific values underlining their concerns
about the urgency of government’s role (be they anthropocentric, biocentric or self-
and for an environmental education. We interest, self-transcendence or self-
inferred that this result reflected the enhancement), regarding the relevance of
teachers’ belief that human had control this study to character education by means
over nature. of environmental concerns, this finding
gave us an optimistic expectation that
Discussion teachers would be involved in the
environmental education through their
This study aimed to describe teachers’ attitude and daily behaviors.
perception about global climate change.
We expected that positive attitude
Through this study, we expected to
toward the environment as teachers
discover values or beliefs that underlined
showed in this study would manifest into
their perception as the studies by Fischer,
their daily behaviors. In order to facilitate
et al. (2011) and Harriet (2000) have shown.
the congruency of their behavior to their
Compared with the study of Fischer, et al.,
attitude, school management could
and Harriet which used focus group
support them by giving facilities. Referring
discussion, we used a survey with open-
to Fuji (2006) that attitude toward frugality
ended questions to collect data and
would be an effective means to promote
conducted a qualitative content analysis
pro-environmental behaviors, school
with Indigenous Psychology Approach as
management could facilitate the realiza-
proposed by Yuniarti (2013).
tion of pro-environmental behaviors easier
The result of this study showed that to do by means of programs (for example
most of our respondents (1) referred to organizing an intra-school competition
global climatic and environmental among the classes on the green and clean
conditions as the causes of weather environment issues), tools (for example
anomaly; (2) gave negative emotions as setting aside garbage cans, maintaining
evoked by the word “global warming”; (3) chalkboard and chalks instead of using
mentioned the urgency of prevention to LCD in classrooms) and infrastructures
coping with global warming. It was clear (e.g. designing school building with big
that these findings reflected the perceived windows for good ventilation and
risks of global warming among most of illumination so as to reduce electricity
our respondents. People perceived risks usage, etc.).
when they felt that the challenges or
The research finding showed that only
harmful events would come to them
a few respondents mentioned pollution.
(Denney, 2005) and they were able to make
These findings indicated that promoting a
choices actively to approach or avoid them
green environment to prevent global
_______________________________________________________________________________
i. This research was funded by AAICP (Asian Association of Indigenous and Cultural
Psychology).
ii. We thank to Dr. Wenty M Mirza, S.Psi, M.A, director of CICP faculty of Psychology,
Universitas Gadjah Mada for giving the permission to conduct this study through
internship program in CICP; Haidar Buldan Thontowi, M.A and Banyu Wicaksono,
S.Psi for their coaching in training of qualitative and quantitative content analysis
using microsoft excel; Nurul Aisya Berylia and Orysa Noor Azizah for their
assistance in secretariat of CICP.