Professional Documents
Culture Documents
and
New Deal
Review Assignment
By
Benton Anderson
Seve De Respino
Emma Harmen
Collin Klees
Great Depression and New Deal Chapter Outline
Although the 1920’s seemed to be a time of prosperity, it laid the groundwork for
the depression that followed. Officially, the Great Depression began on Black Friday in
1929 when the stock market crashed. However, the factors that actually had caused this
crash in the economy had been a long time in the making. These factors included the
maldistribution of wealth which resulted in unequal purchasing power and left the
American consumer base unable to maintain the demand and thus the growth the
economy had been experiencing. In addition, the American people had accumulated large
amounts of debt during the 1920’s and had been living in excess of their means. When the
debt caught up to the consumers the economic crisis began. Also, buying on margin was a
major factor that led to the collapse of the stock market. Paying a fraction of the actual
price and then borrowing the rest hoping that the stock will go up led to artificially
increased stock prices that eventually returned to realistic levels. This left many people
“holding the bag” that could not afford to pay off the loan they used to buy the stock.
Finally, the Dawes Plan, which supported the rest of the world’s economy by basing it on
the American economy through a series of loans, turned America’s economic problems
into a global crisis.
The effects of this economic weakness were apparent immediately. In the first
three years of the Great Depression 9,000 banks failed and unemployment rose to 25%.
The president at the time, Herbert Hoover adopted a relatively Laissez-Faire policy to the
problems of the Great Depression. He attempted to marginally increase government
spending but that did little more than create a federal deficit. Toward the end of his term
he created the Reconstruction Finance Corporation which provided loans to banks to try
to help the suffering economy. However, this was too little too late. In 1932, FDR became
president and immediately began to increase government involvement in the economy’s
recovery. Although FDR attempted to bring an end to the depression by pumping
government money into the economy, his agencies were largely ineffective and it wasn’t
until the industrial production and spending caused by WWII that the economy
recovered. His first act as president was to declare a bank holiday to attempt to rekindle
the people’s faith in the banking industry. He then passed a flurry of legislation called the
New Deal during his 100 days of taking office. This legislation marginally eased the
public’s suffering but still was unable to end it. Then, in 1935, FDR started the Second
New Deal which continued to create government involvement in the economy to
stimulate growth. The main examples of the Second New Deal are the NLRB, the WPA,
and the Social Security Act. However, the biggest setback FDR encountered was the
Supreme Court. It was constantly defeating his legislation and dismantling both New
Deals. His solution to this problem was a “court packing plan” where he would add up to
six new justices due to the “overbearing workload” the courts had. The public response
was outcry and FDR abandoned the plan. However, the court stopped invalidating his
legislation due to a change in the justice’s voting patterns. Overall, FDR’s recovery plan
failed to achieve economic recovery; however it did create the precedent of the
government providing welfare programs such as social security and other relief programs.
In addition, it created new expectations of government involvement in the lives of the
people and the direction of the economy.
In addition, there were important domestic events as well. During Herbert
Hoover’s administration, Hoover believed in Voluntarism which meant he wanted
America to make sacrifices and tighten the belt to get through the Great Depression. In
addition, veterans marched on Washington to demand their bonuses early; this group was
called the Bonus Army. After reaching Washington, Hoover sent the army to remove
them led by General Douglas MacArthur and Dwight D. Eisenhower. In addition, the
Dust Bowl had displaced many Americans sending them west to California. Once there
they were met with hostility and did not receive the help they needed. Overall, Hoover
failed both in his economic policy and his domestic policy. During FDR’s administration
the only domestic issue was a result of the Great Depression. Therefore, the major
domestic event that concerns him is his opposition. The opposition to the New Deal came
from two major directions, those who did not think that it went far enough and those who
thought it went too far. Huey Long, the Louisiana populist demagogue, called for a
redistribution of wealth and said that the New Deal did not go far enough. On the other
hand, Father Charles E. Coughlin, a Catholic priest, preached to his radio audience that
the New Deal went too far. Overall, the opposition had little effect due to Huey Long
being assassinated and Father Charles E. Coughlin losing popularity due to his anti-
Semitism. Overall, the domestic issues of the time were dominated by the Great
Depression and therefore were dependent on the political and economic issues.
Glossary Terms and Definitions
Influential Figures
Father Coughlin - once a supporter of the New Deal, later turned to radical conservatism
and anti-Semitism. Notable for being one of the famous opponents of FDR to the far right.
Dr. Francis Townsend - the initiator of the concept of Social Security, eventually passed in
1935.
John Lewis - leader of the United Mine Workers of America union, and the main force
behind the CIO.
Calvin Coolidge - One of the three Laissez-Faire presidents preceding FDR during the
1920s. Notable for not doing much at all to help stop the oncoming depression.
Herbert Hoover - The president before Roosevelt. Known for being the scapegoat of many
of the problems of the Depression. Notable for doing "too little, too late" in order to combat
the economic downturn during his administration.
"Rugged individualism" - Phrase coined by Hoover that epitomizes the strength and
moral worth of the individual through his or her work ethic. Hoover used this policy to
justify his inaction toward the impoverished during the early years of the depression.
Hoovervilles - Shantytowns built by homeless people stricken by the financial crisis
during the Great Depression. They were named after the President Hoover due to the
commonly held belief that he let the nation fall into the Depression.
Huey Long - Roosevelt's opposition from the far left who supported more widespread
distribution of wealth to the point of socialism in order to combat the problems of the
depression.
Douglas MacArthur - Army Chief of staff. Ordered by President Hoover to disperse the
Bonus Army protesters in Washington.
Franklin Delano Roosevelt - President of the U.S. after a decade-long string of three
ineffective, Laissez-Faire presidents whose lack of government involvement arguably helped
to cause the Depression. Prominently known for greatly expanding the role of government
and implementing his New Deal policies and numerous public works programs (CCC, TCA,
NRA, etc.) in hopes of restoring the U.S. economy, with mixed results.
Andrew Mellon - financial advisor and Secretary of the Treasury during the 1920s whose
policies of reducing taxes and otherwise laid the foundation for some of the depression era
economic problems.
John Maynard Keynes - the British economist who wrote the ideas on Keynesian
Economics, where the government is the source of the reform to a struggling economy.
Priming the Pump - one of the methods of Keynesian Economics where the
government infuses large amounts of money into a struggling economy in order to
stabilize the economy and increase consumer confidence.
Other
Sit Down Strike - a method of striking used prominently by the UAW where the protesting
workers sit down at their posts to prevent working until their demands are met and immediate
replacement by ownership.
Bread Lines - People affected by the Depression would receive a ration of food at these soup
kitchens.
The Grapes of Wrath - a novel by John Steinbeck, famous for chronicling the hardships of
the depression.
Essay 1
How successful were the programs of the New Deal in solving the problems of the Great
Depression? Assess with respect to TWO of the following:
-Relief
-Recovery
-Reform
By the 1930’s the U.S. started to feel the effects of their “on margin” buying, as
factors such as the misdistribution of wealth and installment buying led to the Stock
Market crash in 1929. This pushed most Americans into depression as many people lost
their jobs and homes as they entered into a life of poverty. President Hoover assured the
country to stay calm and that this would pass over. Americans, hostile of Hoover’s
approach, elected Franklin Roosevelt to the White House in 1932 in hope that his “will
do” attitude and optimism would get the country out of the Great Depression. As
Roosevelt entered office, he provided a “New Deal” to the people. This New Deal had the
concept of try anything and everything that could possibly help get the U.S. out of the
depression. Roosevelt hoped this New Deal would provide relief and recovery to the
nation. Although World War I ultimately brought the U.S. out of depression, Roosevelt’s
New Deal did show great success in providing relief and recovery to the nation during the
Great Depression.
In order to provide relief to the people, FDR had to restore Americans faith in the
government and economy. During FDR’s first hundred days, he made several actions
such as the, Bank Holiday. This closed the banks down for four days so congress could
meet and discuss banking-reform legislation. This helped stabilize the banks and it gave
Americans the assurance that things would soon get better and change was on its way.
FDR also provided relief to the nation by creating a series of public works programs. For
example, the CCC (Civilian Conservation Corps), the WPA (Works Progress
Administration), and the TVA (Tennessee Valley Authority) all provided work
opportunities for the unemployed as well as helped improve roads, bridges, and local
cities. Also, many artists, actors, and writers, who found their success in the 1920’s but
were now unemployed, received unemployment money as a form of relief. These
programs only helped some Americans however; the public saw FDR and his programs
enormously uplifting; thus providing relief.
Next FDR provided recovery to Americans and the government. Roosevelt
created the NRA (National Recovery Act). This attempted to recover from the Great
Depression by establishing and administering a system of industrial codes to control
production, prices, labor relations, and trade practices in businesses. Even though this
was declared unconstitutional by the Supreme Court during the Schechter Decision, it
provided recovery as it led to the to the creation of the (PWA) Public Works
Administration and the (NIRA). These two programs put money into the economy and
used the theory of “priming the pump” to stimulate the economy.
FDR did face many issues in achieving recovery and relief with his New Deal, such as in
the Schechter Decision. Also, some, such as Huey Long, criticized and opposed
Roosevelt’s New Deal, calling it socialistic. However, FDR’s New Deal did help gain
Americans faith in the government during the tough times of the 30’s. Although the U.S.
economy will not recover until the start of WWII, FDR’s New Deal did help make great
stepping-stones for recovery and relief at the time and for the future (Social Security
Act). Roosevelt’s New Deal did make strides to relieve and recover the American people;
but most importantly, it reassured the American people to believe in the economy, the
government, and the country.
Essay 2
How and for what reasons did United States foreign policy change between 1920 and
1941? Use the documents and you knowledge of the period 1920-1941 to construct your
response.
During the period of 1920-1941, the United States foreign policy changed
dramatically leading up to World War 2 in the mid 1940’s. Although, in the early 1920’s-
1930s’, the Americans labeled themselves as an isolationist country and didn’t want to
partake in any “entangling alliances”; in the 1940’s America emerged as a ‘rising star’
and was seen by many to be a superpower.
In the 1920’s through the mid 1930’s, America labeled itself as an isolationist nation
after being pulled into World War One, and took a strong stand against any ‘entangling
alliances.’ For instance, Congress refused to join the League of Nations proposed by
Woodrow Wilson due to the possibility of being dragged into another European war.
However, the term isolationist doesn’t fully explain the U.S. role in foreign affairs. In
1921, the U.S. took part in the Washington Naval Conference, and then signed the
Kellogg-Briand Pact in 1928 with France, Great Britain, and Japan to try and stop future
wars from breaking out. The pact stated that wars were a last resort and deadly force
should only be used in self/national defense. Similarly, the U.S was economically
involved with other countries with programs such as the Dawes Plans, which helped
Germany set itself back on its feet with U.S. investment to pay war debts. Germany then
paid its war debts to Britain and France which then paid back their loans to the United
States. Not only did America influence European affairs, it also gave heavy investments
in Latin-American countries in the 1920’s through Woodrow Wilson’s “dollar diplomacy”
strategy. A departure from Roosevelt’s policy of “carrying a big stick” Hoover used the
U.S. economy to further U.S. interests in Latin America. However, on the eve of World
War Two, the U.S. had no choice but to enter into foreign affairs when Pearl Harbor was
attacked.
Before entering World War II, the United States passed Neutrality Acts In 1935, 1936,
and 1937. These acts were an attempt to continue isolating the U.S. and maintain the
comfort of two ocean of separation. In 1939, FDR allowed the sale of munitions to
countries with democratic governments based on a “cash and carry” basis. This
stipulation in the Act started the Lend-Lease Act in 1941. This Act allowed the sale of
munitions to countries in war; however, the sales figures greatly favored the Allied
Powers like Great Britain, the Soviet Union, and France. The U.S, after the attack on
Pearl Harbor, became fully involved in the foreign conflict by entering World War 2 in
1941, and officially shed its isolationist tag in favor of joining the Allies.
In conclusion, the U.S. saw a dramatic change in its foreign policy from 1920-1941.
America tried to stay away from foreign problems to avoid involvement in another major
war. However, from 1920 until the mid 1930’s, they were involved in resolution
conferences and positioned itself for world dominancy. At the brink of, and during, World
War 2, the U.S. became increasingly involved in foreign affairs, and continued to do so
after the war. This was the first step toward becoming a superpower.
Essay 3
Analyze the responses of Franklin D. Roosevelt’s administration to the problems of the Great
Depression. How effective were these responses? How did they change the role of the federal
government?
When Franklin Delano Roosevelt took office the Great Depression was in full
effect. His predecessor, Herbert Hoover, took a laissez-faire approach to the economic
situation which was ineffective. Even after he did start to take action, such as the creation
of the RFC, it was too little, too late. Therefore, when FDR took office in 1932 he passed
a flurry of legislation called the New Deal, aimed at stimulating an economic recovery.
Although FDR’s New Deal legislation attempted to stimulate the economy and ease
suffering caused by the hard economic times, it was largely ineffective. However, the
New Deal was successful in creating a precedent of government involvement in the
economy and providing relief to those in need.
In the first one hundred days of his presidency, FDR passed legislation aimed at
getting the economy back on track, however, this legislation was ineffective and at times
ruled unconstitutional. For instance, the National Recovery Administration was created to
create codes for businesses to decrease unemployment and stimulate the economy. In
addition, it guaranteed the right of collective bargaining to workers. However, large
corporations often controlled the making of the codes and abused them to further their
own interests instead of helping the economy. Also, the legislation creating the NRA was
ruled unconstitutional in the Supreme Court case Schechter v. United States. In the case,
the Supreme Court ruled that Congress had no right to regulate business that did not cross
state lines. Therefore the codes were unconstitutional because they applied to all industry.
This made the NRA largely ineffective at creating any long term recovery in the
economy. In addition to the creation of the NRA to aid in economic recovery, FDR
created welfare programs such as the CWA and the CCC. Both programs put people to
work on temporary project funded by the government. The goal of these projects was to
decrease unemployment and stimulate the economy by giving many men a source of
income. Although the projects did employ millions of men they did not do enough to
have a major effect on the depression. Finally, the most notable of New Deal legislation
was the Social Security Act which established “insurance” to supplement those who were
too old to work and those who had recently been laid off. Its purpose was to support the
needy and to stimulate the economy by giving people money to spend. Similar to the
other public works projects it achieved neither of its two objectives on a large enough
scale to have an major effect in reviving the economy. Overall, the Great Depression was
such a huge economic catastrophe that the government could not respond on a large
enough scale to dramatically affect the recovery. Only the production demanded by the
start of World War II could create the stimulus needed to revive the economy.
These programs created to aid the economy were the first major involvement the
government had in the economy. After the government intervened during the Great
Depression the people expected a government intervention each time the economy started
to suffer. This is the same situation that occurred with the relief programs created during
this time. Once the government established its role in Social Security and other relief
programs, it became the norm. Overall, the New Deal attempted to stimulate the economy
which only recovered with the build up to WWII. From this time on the government led a
role in stimulating the economy and providing relief.
Essay 4
Compare and contrast the programs and policies designed by the reformers of the
Progressive era to those designed by reformers of the New Deal period. Confine your
answer to programs and policies that addressed the needs of those living in poverty.
1. Huey Long became a prominent rival of Roosevelt’s New Deal through his advocacy of
A. Socialism
B. The nationalization of leading industries
C. A large scale redistribution of wealth
D. Pensions for the elderly
E. A foreign war to end the depression
2. All of the following advocated radical alternatives to the New Deal during the mid-
1930’s EXCEPT
3. The most important difference between he policies toward relief for the unemployed in
the administrations of Franklin D. Roosevelt and Herbert Hoover was that Roosevelt
supported
5. All of the following were approved during the first hundred days of the administration of
Franklin D. Roosevelt EXCEPT
8. Franklin D. Roosevelt’s general strategy toward the economic crisis of the Great
Depression was to
10. All of the following were important causes of the Great Depression EXCEPT
11. Franklin D. Roosevelt’s New Deal program attempted or achieved all of the following
EXCEPT
13. In his inaugural address, Franklin D. Roosevelt said that if Congress did not pass the laws
he believed it should, he would
A. The addition of up to six new justices if present justices over the age of 70 did not retire
B. The immediate and mandatory removal of all Supreme court justices over the age of 70
C. The immediate and mandatory removal of all Supreme Court justices who voted against
New Deal legislation
D. The addition of up to 15 new justices if present justices over the age of 70 did not retire
E. The mandatory retirement of justices over the age of 70 combined with the subsequent
expansion of the court to 15 members
A. Farmers disgruntled about low prices for meat, grain and dairy products
B. Homeless persons building shantytowns near Washington, D.C
C. Japanese-Americans protesting forced relocation from the West Coast
D. World War I veterans demanding financial aid form the federal government
E. Migrant farm workers seeking employment in California
16. In personally taking over the task of setting the dollar amount the government would pay
for gold, Franklin Roosevelt’s announced purpose was to
A. 10%
B. 25%
C. 40%
D. 60%
E. 90%
18. “if your neighbor’s house was on fire, and he didn’t have a garden hose, wouldn’t it make
sense to let him use your hose to fight the fire so the fire could be put out before it spread
to your house?” This question was raised by Franklin Roosevelt to justify
19. All of the following “New Deal” agencies were created during the great Depression to
provide jobs for the unemployed EXCEPT
21. Fearing the U.S. Supreme Court would find much of his second term New Deal
legislation unconstitutional, as it had done for much of the New Deal legislation passed
during his first term, Franklin Roosevelt responded by
1. C Huey Long was a communist who advocated for a large scale redistribution of
wealth
2. C Upton Sinclair wrote the book The Jungle about the meatpacking industry in
Chicago
3. E While both presidents increased government spending Roosevelt was the only
one who created federal work relief programs such as the CCC
4. A The new deal programs set a precedent for the government to later follow.
5. E Social Security was not passed until the Second New Deal.
6. B The NRA set up codes for businesses to follow to help increase prices and
maintain employment
7. C Herbert Hoover bailed out some banks during the end of his presidency; this
used government money which increased the deficit.
8. B FDR tried anything and everything during his presidency which sometimes
resulted in contradictory policies.
9. C Easy credit policies led to artificially increased stock prices that precipitated the
crash.
10. B The FDIC was not created until the first new deal.
12. B He declared a bank holiday so he could reinstill the confidence of the people in
the banks.
13. C He wanted to show the people that he was going to do whatever he needed to
do to help them
14. A It was to “lessen the work load” of the older age justices and also turn the voting
pattern in his favor.
15. D The bonus march was a protest of veterans for the early payment of their bonus
against Herbert Hoover.
17. B One out of every four people were unemployed at the worst time of the
depression.
18. C It justifies the loaning of war equipment to Britain on the basis of if they don’t
beat them we will have to later.
19. A Farm security manipulated prices and did not provide jobs.
20. D The opposite is true. There was too much credit which led to the Stock Market
crash.
21. D His plan was the “court packing” plan where he would appoint justices.
Citation of Multiple Choice
#1-#10
Packet from Mr. Parker
#11-#21
F e l d m e t h , G r e g o r y. A P U n i t e d S t a t e s H i s t o r y . 7 t h . P i s c a t a w a y, N e w J e r s e y :
Research and Education Association, 2006. 379-781. Print.