1797
Med. Fac. Landbouww. Rijksuniv. Gent, 56(4a), 1991
BIOLEACHING OF GREEK NON-SULPHIDE NICKEL
ORES USING MICROORGANISM ASSISTED
LEACHING PROCESS
P. Tzeferis, S. Agatzini, E.T. Nerantzis
A. Dudeney, D. Leak & K. Alibhai
National Technical University of Athens
Laboratory of Metallurgy
42 Patission street, 06 82 Athens, Greece
ABSTRACT
Nickel is of vital importance in many modern industrial processes. Nickel ore deposits are
found either as sulphides or as laterites.The dominating importance of lateritic ores for the
future supply of nickel becomes obvious when one considers that about 80% of the presently
known nickel reserves are associated with lateritic types of ores and it is strongly believed
that the nickel production will in the not too distant future be dominated by laterite ores. Nickel
from laterites is produced both pyrometallurgically and hydrometallurgically but most of the
current industrial practice is energy intensive and non-economic for low-grade ores.The aim
of the present study was to develop a low energy method using microorganisms in order to
recover nickel from low-grade Greek laterites, as Greece has extensive laterite domestic
sources.Bioleaching experiments were carried out to study the leachabiity of various laterite
ore samples by several fungal strains. All strains, prior to leaching, were adapted to nickel and
laterite environment by gradual acciimatisation. Two bioleaching tecniques were developed:
(a) leaching in the presence of microorganisms and (b) chemical leaching at high temperature
(85°C) with a solution consisted of the metabolic products obtained from the cultivation of
fungus strains at 30°C in carbohydrate media such as glucose, sucrose and molasses. It was
found that up to 55-60% of the nickel was extracted using the first technique and fungi strains
Po (Penicilium sp.) and Ag (Aspergillus sp.) in almost 50 days. Losses of soluble nickel in the
fungal biomass were found to be 3.5% and 10.8%, respectively.The cobalt recovery achieved
was around 50%. Nickel recoveries obtained by the second technique were in the range of
70-72%. Use of factory grade Greek beet molasses, after chemical pretreatment with
ferrocyanide, can contribute to a considerable reduction of overall cost since their price in
Greek industrial market is considerably lower than price of industrially produced sulphuric
acid and at least twenty times less than price of food grade sucrose.
TROD! 1ON
Nickel plays an important role in modern technology since it has numerous
applications. Nickel consumption growth rate is expected (1) to increase significantly until the
year 2000, primarily because of its increasing use in the stainless steel industry (which is the
main consumer of nickel) but also because of many new applications (e.g. in the electronic
industry, modern corrosion control, building and construction industries e.t.c.).Nickel ore
deposits are found either as sulphides or as laterites. It is foreseen(@) that, in the nearvery
future, laterites will become of dominating importance for the future supply of nickel. Greece
has extensive laterite deposits with a low nickel content. The development of an economical
method to exploit those deposits is of great importance for the Greek metallurgical industry.
Biohydrometallurgy or bacterial (fungal) metal extraction is considered a low cost
and non-waste effective technology allowing a comprehensive use of mineral resources using
microorganisms and/ or their metabolites (®). Biological leaching is applicable to all ore grades
and to waste materials from traditional ore processing, has lower energy requirements than
conventional processes (operates at ambient temperatures) and is less hazardous from
environmental aspect (4). z
The aim of this work was to investigate the possibilty of using microorganisms in
order to extract nickel and cobalt from low-grade Greek laterites. The work was performed at
the Laboratory of Metallurgy of the NTUA and part of it was carried out in the framework of
cooperation with the Centre for Biotechnology and the Mineral Resources Engineering
Department of the Imperial College, London.
2. MATERIALS AND METHODS
-Laterite ore samples
Two lateritic nickel ore samples with different chemical and mineralogical composition
were employed: (a) “Litharakia” (Euboes island, Greece) low-grade ore with 0.73% Ni and (b)
‘Kastoria” (kastoria, Northern Greece) ore with relatively high nickel content 4.239%.
jicroorganisms
‘The folowing organisms were employed: .
a) Strains of Aspergilus sp., Ay, Az & Ag (Commonwealth Mycological institute, London,
courtesy of Dr.Leak, Imperial college)
b) Strains of Penicilfum sp., Po, P14, Poa & Pg (Federal Institute of Geo-Sciences and
Natural Resources, Hanover, courtesy of Dr. Bosecker)
¢) Strain of Penicilium sp., F;, isolated from an actively laterising nickel ore deposit
(Mantoudi, Euboea island).
4) Strains of Aspergillus sp.A, and Penicilium sp., P, obtained from a Greek collection
(Technical Educational Institute, Athens)
‘All strains screened for their ability to produce organic chelating acids (mainly citric and
oxalic acids) and their tolerance to nickel concentrations and low pH conditions. Moreover,
adaptation of all fungus strains was proceeded in nickel concentrations up to 4000ppm and
laterite content up to 10% by stepwise increasing nickel and laterite content in the culture
medium.
- Media
The following types of media were employed:
a) Czapek-Dox broth or agar (GZ- CzA),
b) Modified “Shu & Johnson’ (5) sucrose based media,
c) Factory grade Greek beet molasses, obtained from “Hellenic Sugar Industry S.A.
(E.B2).
All (a), (b), and (c) types of media were used for both fungus growth and bioleaching
experiments in different carbohydrate content (3% and 15% respectively).1799
- Chemical leaching experiments.
The chemical leaching tests were carried out before microbiological leaching
experiments commenced in order to determine which organic acids (produced biologically)
were responsible for nickel solubilsation from laterite crystal lattice. This preliminary work was
considered necessary because leaching efficiency of heterotrophs mainly depends on the
production of organic metabolic compounds (organic acids, amino acids, polysaccharides) with
significant metal-binding properties which are excreted from the cells to the medium(®).
Various organic acids and combinations mainly between organic acids and sulphuric
acid were tested in the concentration range of 0.1-0.5M. The leaching test were carried out in
conical flasks containing known weights of ore and volumes: of synthetic organic: acid
solutions. :
-Bioleaching experiments.
Bioleaching tests were carried out in flasks following two different techniques:
{a) Microorganisms are cultivated in the presence of the ore. In this technique medium
and inoculum are added to the ore. Prior to leaching, ore was sterilised to avoid interference
from organisms present in the ore (indigenous). ee
(b) Leaching with metabolic products of fungal growth after separation from the
biomass (two phase procedure). Cultivation was carried out in lab. fermenters and leaching
with biologically produced acid metabolites at both natural pH (final pH of the fermentation
process) and even lower pH (acidified to 0.3 by means of sulphuric acid).
3.RES DI
1. Among various organic acids (acetic, citric, oxalic, formic, lactic, suiphosalicylic)
tested for their ability to dissolve nickel from lateritic ore samples used, most effective was
citric acid including both samples. Although citric acid requires for effective leaching longer
time (40-50 days) than equimolar sulphuric acid, in the case of ‘kastoria” garnieritic sample it
performed better than sulphuric acid (yields of 57.5% versus 52.7% of the nickel respectively)
at the same conditions (0.5M, 30°C, 10% pulp density), depended markedly on the type of
mineralisation. Oxalic acid was the least effective leaching agent as far as nickel is
concerned while leached much more iron than any other organic leaching agent used (63% of
iron from "kastoria® and 20% from ‘Litharakia” sample). One possible explanation for this could
be the following reductive process (FeO is soluble):
Fej0g + CoH04 —> 2FeO + 260p + HzO
Results of chemical leaching are shown in Table 1.The considerable variability in
nickel recoveries achievable in chemical leaching of different samples depends on the type of
mineralisation.1802
|. GE AL ION
From the above described preliminary study on the feasibility of using bioleaching to
Tecover nickel from non-sulphide nickeliferous Greek ores can be concluded that samples
tested ere generally amenable to bioleaching by both techniques used in laboratory scale.
Maximum yields obtained were up to 72% of nickel, 50-55% of cobalt and 20-25% of iron
codissolution.Yet, much remains to be done before heterotrophic leaching process will find
technical and economic application and thus become profitable business. Expensive nutrient
requirments have to be replaced by inexpensive molasses or other organic waste products
(e.g. from paper, food and beverage industries) in order to reduce the overall cost. Use of
Greek molasses, although they have a variable chemical composition and need chemical
pretreatment before bioleaching to attain higher nickel yields, can contribute towards this
direction of research.
REF! ICE
1.J.P. Schade and M.O. Pearce (1988)."The role of nickel in modern
technology’. In: Proceedings of a symposium on the extractive metalurgy of nickel and cobalt,
117th TMS Annual Meeting, Phoenix Arizona, January 25-28, 1988.
2. T.R.Scott (1976) "Recent advances in hydrometaliurgy with implications for the
developing countries” In:"Economics of mineral engineering”, seminar organised by the
United Nations in co-operation with the government of Turkey, Ankara, April 1976, pp. 56-89.
3. G.L.Karavaiko, G.Rossi, A.D. Agate, S.N.Groudev, Z.Z.Avakyan (1988) .
Bioaeot ology of Metals, (Manual), UNEP, USSR Commission for UNEF, Centre for
International Projects GKNT, Moscow, pp.321.
4. D.G. Lundgren et.al. (1986). "Chemical reactions important in Bioleaching and
Bioaccumulation” In: H.L.Ehrlich and D.S.Holmes, Editors. "Workshop on biotechnology for the
mining, metal-refining and fossil fuel processing industries". Biotechnol. Bioeng., Symposium
No.16., John Wiley & Sons, Inc. 1986,pp.7-22.
5.P.Shu and M.J.Johnson(1948). “The interdependence of medium constituents in
citric acid production by submerged fermentation”. Bacteriol, 56, pp.577-585.
6. K.Bosecker (1985). "Leaching of lateritic nickel ores with heterotrophic
microorganisms" , In: proceedings of the sixth international symposium on Biohydrometalturgy,
Vancouver, Canada, August 21-24, 1985.
KNOWL MENT
The authors are grateful to the Commission of the European Communities (CEC),
Directorate General for Science, Research and Development, DG-XIl C-5, the General
Secretariat of Research and Technology of Greece (f..E.T) and the General Mining and
Metallurgical S.A.LARCO for financial support. Thanks are also expressed to the Hellenic
Sugar Industry S.A. (E.B.Z) for molasses samples and relative information.1801
“itis noteworthy that Ni/Fe in sample “Litharakia” is 0.05. Numbers marked in the above
table indicate a decrease in the recovery owing either to biosortion of metal in fungal biomass
of precipitation of organometallic compounds or hydroxides (calcium citrate, iron citrate,
goethite) .
3, Leaching of “Litharakia” ore sample with metabolic products produced as &
result of the cultivation of strains Pz and Ag in sucrose based media at 30°C, gave
extractions of nickel up to 25% when it was carried out without any dilution with mineral acids
and up to 72% when it was carried out after acidification to a pH of 0.3 by means of sulphuric
acid. In both cases leaching temperature was 95°C. Although the pracess.as a whole is being
mote expensive because of the cost of fermentation and consumption of mineral acids, there
is also the alternative use of washed and dryed mycelium which represent @ protein-rich
valuable foodstuff.
‘A simplified process flowsheet for nickel recovery from laterites using the above two- =
phase technique follows:
‘SOLID-_ LIQUID MICROBIAL PROTEIN
‘SEPARATION
ORGANIC ACIDS-CONTAINING
NON-SULPHIDE ‘CULTURE SOLUTION
NICKELIFEROUS:
ORE
SULPHURIC ACID
TO APH OF 03
QRGANOMETALLIC
OMPLI
SOLID RESIDUE ein
‘SOLUTION
4. Chemical leaching of ‘Litharakia” ore sample using metabolic products of strains Pp
and F 4 (most effective strains for bioleaching in molasses media) in 15% molasset media
after acidification of fermented liquid to pH 0.3 with suiphuric acid, gave nickel yields of 54%
and 62%, respectively. Before fermentation procedure, the beet-molasses medium was
treated by adding 1.59 of potassium ferrocyanide- (K4iFe(CN)g]) which has been used
extensively in the treatment of molasses for the production of citric acid by mold fermentation .
Itis suggested that better resuits obtained after this pretreatment could ascribed to at least
two functions of ferrocyanide. The first is to remove deleterious trace metals from the medium
whereas the second is to act as a direct inhibitor of growth of the mycelium. Both functions
can stimulate citric acid production. Results mentioned above (up to 62%) compared to nickel
recoveries in pure sucrose media (up to 72%) and leaching with sulphuric acid (45.5%) all at
the same leaching conditions (pH:0.3, temperature: 96°C, leaching time:S hours) are much
more attractive in economic terms despite cost of necessary pretreatment of molasses.
Greek, factory grade, untreated molasse’s price in Greek industrial market is estimated 13-14
drsikg, considerably lower than the price of industrially produced sulphuric acid and at least
twenty times less than the price of food grade sucrose.1800
TABLE 1
ee
Leaching of laterite low-grade nickel ore “Litharakla”
pulp density:10%, Particle size