You are on page 1of 34

Ergonomics Thesis: Applying Manual Handling on Agricultural

Work and Techniques

A Research Paper
Presented to
University of Batangas
College of Engineering
Industrial Engineering Department

In Partial Fulfillment
of the Requirements
in Ergonomics

Prepared by:

Adarlo, Richard Angelo Q.


Orense, Armand Rei T.
Chen, Ansel Ray-Tien B.
Llave, Divina M.
Andal, Kent M.
Comia, Ian

IE 4-1

Submitted to:

Miss Noemi Panganiban

December 2019

Campuses: Hilltop | MH del Pilar | Pallocan East | Pallocan West | Lipa


Telephone Numbers: +63 43 723 1446 | 980 0041
Website: www.ub.edu.ph
Chapter I

THE PROBLEM AND ITS SETTING

Introduction

In March 2001, agricultural health leaders should be easily able to

recognize that the prevalence and human and economic costs of

musculoskeletal disorders (MSDs) make them one of the highest agricultural

safety and health priorities. Instead, musculoskeletal disorders in agricultural

workplaces remain largely unremarked. Currently, they are overlooked in most

surveillance and prevention programs.

Work-related musculoskeletal disorders are so common among

experienced farmers and farm workers that many perceive them as no more

than normal and inevitable consequences of farm labor. However, even when

limited to the poor sources of data currently available on the extent of these

injuries in agricultural workplaces, there is reason for new, high priority concern.

We believe that the overall incidence of these injuries in the nation's agricultural

workplaces likely exceeds 60 per 1000 workers, placing agriculture squarely

among those industries with the highest recorded rates. This estimated

incidence rate yields a total of over twenty times as many musculoskeletal

Campuses: Hilltop | MH del Pilar | Pallocan East | Pallocan West | Lipa


Telephone Numbers: +63 43 723 1446 | 980 0041
Website: www.ub.edu.ph
injuries and illnesses as estimated pesticide injuries and illnesses in US

agriculture annually (Blondell, 1997). Musculoskeletal injuries and diseas es

likely affect the production agriculture workforce more frequently during their

working years than any other safety and health problem. Disability due to

musculoskeletal injuries and diseases incurred during their working years affect

the production agriculture workforce more frequently and more severely than

any other safety and health problem during the remainder of their working years

and, for many, for the balance of their lives. Work-related musculoskeletal

disorders are largely preventable, often with relatively simple and inexpensive

modifications to work methods, tools, or tasks. In other instances, effective

prevention may require rethinking work processes or arrangements. In either

case, the payoff for improved prevention can often be measured in both

improved work health and performance and improved productivity if thinking

about prevention is juxtaposed with thinking about improving production

practices.

Farmers some of the highest risks of work-related musculoskeletal injury

and disease in the nation. However, the problem is little recognized within or

without agriculture and is not currently given high prevention and research

priority by most farm safety groups or organizations. Most of the known injuries

in the industry that can be considered are mainly caused by prolonged hours of

Campuses: Hilltop | MH del Pilar | Pallocan East | Pallocan West | Lipa


Telephone Numbers: +63 43 723 1446 | 980 0041
Website: www.ub.edu.ph
work that affects the production of good quality products of the nation,

incapacitating the nation primary source of our GDP consumption.

Why are musculoskeletal disorders not our number one prevention priority

in agricultural workplaces? This is the question we pose for agricultural health

and safety professionals. Once the true extent, incidence, severity, and cost of

work-related musculoskeletal disorders in American agriculture become more

widely recognized, we believe this problem will become our highest farm safety

priority.

Definition of the Terms

Agricultural Worker – a person who is employed in agriculture, usually a manual

worker. https://www.collinsdictionary.com/dictionary/english/agricultural-worker In

our study, it is a person who demonstrates the proper motions to fulfill his

agricultural duties

Musculoskeletal Disorders (MSDs) – Musculoskeletal Disorders or MSDs are

injuries and disorders that affect the human body’s movement or musculoskeletal

system (i.e. muscles, tendons, ligaments, nerves, discs, blood vessels, etc.).

https://ergo-plus.com/musculoskeletal-disorders-msd/ In our study, we are

Campuses: Hilltop | MH del Pilar | Pallocan East | Pallocan West | Lipa


Telephone Numbers: +63 43 723 1446 | 980 0041
Website: www.ub.edu.ph
looking mostly at disorders such as tendinitis (mainly for trigger finger), Lateral

Epicondylitis, and biciptal tendinitis.

Agricultural Workplace – An area of land, especially together with a house and

other buildings, used for growing crops or keeping animals.

https://dictionary.cambridge.org/us/dictionary/english/farm The working

environment of the agricultural worker, which in this case would be fields and

piggeries.

Materials Handling – Farming or agricultural equipment or devices used in

farming procedures.

Significance of the study

 To provide evidence of the problems and discomfort faced by everyday

farmers.
 To connect the Industrial Engineering Department to another problem that

can be solved through their expertise and research.


 To educate students on the importance of the agricultural sector and how

innovations are needed to maintain its stability.


 To provide researchers data and information from which analysis can be

conducted for conclusions to be made.

Scope and Limitation and Delimitation

Campuses: Hilltop | MH del Pilar | Pallocan East | Pallocan West | Lipa


Telephone Numbers: +63 43 723 1446 | 980 0041
Website: www.ub.edu.ph
The study aims to identify key ergonomic problems in the life of an

average agricultural worker and the musculoskeletal disorders related to his

work. The limits are to the energy spent by the farmer to conduct his duties and

has to be properly timed to work with his schedule. Also, the farmer may be

specialized in one are of agriculture and not necessarily in others. The farmers

are limited to the equipment and crop or animals they can afford to raise.

The study is aimed specifically at agricultural workers on the open field and not

related to the consumers whom they supply or the management they work for.

The focus is on these workers who cultivate and harvest the raw materials.

Statement of the problem

The study aims to determine the Musculoskeletal Disorder among

Farmers considering the behavior. Specifically, this study sought answers to the

following questions:

1. Is there a significant relation between age and accumulative trauma disorders

in modern day farmers?

2. Do female farmers experience more pain than female farmers?

3. Does repetitive movement affect the farmers pain?

Campuses: Hilltop | MH del Pilar | Pallocan East | Pallocan West | Lipa


Telephone Numbers: +63 43 723 1446 | 980 0041
Website: www.ub.edu.ph
4. Are harvesting crops more painful than removing insects from the crops or

pruning shears?

Conceptual Framework

Research was conducted using IPO research as shown below:

Campuses: Hilltop | MH del Pilar | Pallocan East | Pallocan West | Lipa


Telephone Numbers: +63 43 723 1446 | 980 0041
Website: www.ub.edu.ph
Theoretical Frame Work

Figure A: Work-related mental health disorders are similar to MSDs in that risk

is affected by a diverse range of psychosocial hazards, and assessment and

control procedures need to be holistic with a high level of participation by

workers; it is therefore useful to look at the characteristics of tools and

resources developed recently for workplace use in managing mental health risk.

Campuses: Hilltop | MH del Pilar | Pallocan East | Pallocan West | Lipa


Telephone Numbers: +63 43 723 1446 | 980 0041
Website: www.ub.edu.ph
It might seem reasonable simply to incorporate use of such tools within MSD

risk management procedures like Cumulative Trauma Disorder risk indicator.

Campuses: Hilltop | MH del Pilar | Pallocan East | Pallocan West | Lipa


Telephone Numbers: +63 43 723 1446 | 980 0041
Website: www.ub.edu.ph
CHAPTER II

REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURES AND STUDIES

Related Literatures

1. Current Information on the Scope of Musculoskeletal Disorders in

Agriculture
According to Briones (2017),

as the Philippine economy expands, its structure changes.

The output share of agriculture fell by 14 percentage points over the perio

d 1986-2015 while its employment share fell by 21 percentage points.

And while agriculture still provides employment for a sizable 29 percent of

workers, its output share is only 10 percent.

Hence, productivity of the average worker in agriculture is only about a thir

d of the average worker.


2. Ergonomic Hazards in Agriculture

Meyers (1998) in reviewing the work of the University of California

Agricultural Ergonomics Research Center for the past decade has cited

three general risk factors as both endemic and of highest priority

throughout the agricultural industry.

Campuses: Hilltop | MH del Pilar | Pallocan East | Pallocan West | Lipa


Telephone Numbers: +63 43 723 1446 | 980 0041
Website: www.ub.edu.ph
3. Successful Intervention Programs in Agricultural Workplaces

A forthcoming NIOSH publication entitled Simple Solutions (2001)

highlights many of the most successful of these intervention. Keys to

success in this work have been:1) cooperative partnership with involved

farmers and farmworkers throughout intervention development and trial;

2) applied focus on commodity or crop specific tasks and tools; 3)

intervention evaluation focused on health as well as ergonomics

outcomes; and 4) fitting interventions to accepted production methods to

encourage adoption and minimize worker displacement

4. Reference Points Found in Agriculture at Risk

Bismark’s (1999) states that work-related musculoskeletal

disorders develop slowly over months and years of repeated stresses.

The risk factors themselves are ubiquitous, found in most jobs. Left

unaddressed, musculoskeletal disorders can result in lifelong pain and

permanent disability. As understanding about them has grown,

recognition and diagnosis have literally exploded to make them the most

frequent and most costly of work-related injuries in most industries.

However, despite their growing priority among occupational health

professionals, they have largely escaped recognition, prevention and

Campuses: Hilltop | MH del Pilar | Pallocan East | Pallocan West | Lipa


Telephone Numbers: +63 43 723 1446 | 980 0041
Website: www.ub.edu.ph
control in most agricultural safety programs. While these injuries were

known in 1987, they escaped notice in Agriculture at Risk.

5. Prevention, Intervention, and Intervention Effectiveness Evaluation

According to Maranan (2011), first, and less obviously, there is

need to interact on a continuing basis with the commercial companies that

are expected to produce and market emerging interventions. This applies

especially to those that are crop or commodity specific in focus.

Second, new extension funding and programs are needed to

expand the focus of farm safety programs and existing production

programs to recognize and address the problems presented by poor

ergonomics in terms of both production inefficiencies and worker health

and safety

6. Tasks in Agriculture that Create a Greater Risk of Injury

Kahan (2008) defines: Harvesting fruits and vegetables - Reaching,

bending, and carrying heavy picking tubs all place stress on the worker’s

muscles.

Handling animal feed - Large, unwieldy bags of feed are awkward,

and the act of emptying them into feeding troughs requires a twisting

motion that can injure the worker’s back. Weeding in fields and plant

Campuses: Hilltop | MH del Pilar | Pallocan East | Pallocan West | Lipa


Telephone Numbers: +63 43 723 1446 | 980 0041
Website: www.ub.edu.ph
nurseries - This task requires workers to spend long periods of time

bending at the waste, straining the muscles of the lower back.

Composting animal manure - A single producing dairy cow can

leave farmers with 150 pounds of manure every day. This can be

composted into powerful fertilizer, but it must first be collected,

transported, and emptied into the composting area.

7. Mitigation of musculoskeletal problems

Vyas (2009), in her article entitled “Mitigation of musculoskeletal

problems and body discomfort of agricultural workers through educational

intervention”, conducted a study about WMSDs among 120 Indian farmers

(60 males and 60 females) and also developed an educational

intervention to improve conditions for workers in terms of safety. A body

map and Visual Analogue Discomfort 11-point scale (VAD) were used for

data gathering. The results showed that all of the respondents had some

degree of MSDs, especially in the neck, shoulder, upper arm, and fingers.

8. Ergonomic design

Bhattacharyya and Chakrabarti (2012), in their paper entitled

“Ergonomic basket design to reduce cumulative trauma disorders in tea

leaf plucking operation”, showed that tea leaf plucking operation is the

main task in tea plantation including some WMSDs risk factors. Their

Campuses: Hilltop | MH del Pilar | Pallocan East | Pallocan West | Lipa


Telephone Numbers: +63 43 723 1446 | 980 0041
Website: www.ub.edu.ph
study was done in India among 180 female workers who worked on tea

farms. As plucking needs some severe body effort, ergonomics

interventions will create safer conditions. In this study, some methods and

questionnaires, such as the methods of Occupational Repetitive

Assessment (OCRA), Quick Exposure Check (QEC), Heart rate

monitoring, NMQ and Rating of Perceived Exertion (RPE), were OCRA

outcomes that confirmed the existence of the risk of WMSDS. In this

study, and considering the gathered data, a new basket was designed.

Two baskets – traditional and new design – were compared during usage

in terms of certain physiological indicators, such as heart rate, energy

expenditure, and rating of perceived exertion. These indicators showed

the effectiveness of the new basket design in terms of work physiology

and ergonomics.

9. Prevalence and changes in chronic diseases

Cha et al (2009), in her study and related article entitled

“Prevalence and changes in chronic diseases among South Korean

farmers”, which was done on a case series study among the registered

data of the Korean Ministry of Health and Welfare, assessed the

prevalence of chronic diseases among women farmers and compared it to

other occupational groups. In this study 39,060 cases were assessed. All

Campuses: Hilltop | MH del Pilar | Pallocan East | Pallocan West | Lipa


Telephone Numbers: +63 43 723 1446 | 980 0041
Website: www.ub.edu.ph
of the cases were divided into three occupational groups “self-reported

farmers, manual workers, and non-manual workers” according to the

classification of Korean standards. This study showed that chronic disease

prevalence, especially disc problems and arthritis among the female

farmers, was more than for other occupational groups. Visiting doctors by

the female workers was also more frequent than for the men.

10. Musculoskeletal Disorders and Materials Handling

Bernard (1997), as our understanding of musculoskeletal disorders

has grown, so has our recognition of their widespread incidence to the

point that they are now considered the most prevalent and costly of all

work-related injuries (NAS, 2001, Bernard, 1997). Musculoskeletal

disorders have been definitively associated with repeated or continued

exposure to well-identified risk factors including: highly repetitive tasks,

awkward positions of body segments and awkward, whole body postures,

heavy loads and avoidable material handling, sustained vibration, and

other musculoskeletal disorder hazards. All commonly found in agricultural

work.

Campuses: Hilltop | MH del Pilar | Pallocan East | Pallocan West | Lipa


Telephone Numbers: +63 43 723 1446 | 980 0041
Website: www.ub.edu.ph
11. Falls From Agricultural Machinery
Elkind, 2008; Rogers et al., 2000, strengthening the assumption of the

protective role of this variable. This result may be interpreted by considering that

by developing familiarity with the machine through routine upkeep and

inspection, the operator can make more intelligent decisions to reduce the safety

hazards related to the machine. In this light, preventive interventions could be

designed to enhance this expertise, in particular for novice operators who are not

supported by the protective role played by work experience. Engaging training

methods using behavioral modeling techniques, as hands-on demonstrations and

behavioral simulations
12. Occupational Ergonomics

WHO (1985), there are some factors that create or aggravate work-related

disorders, such as work demands, social and cultural factors, work place

characteristics, and environmental factors. In this respect, as ergonomics covers

all of the mentioned farms, it has an important role in occupational health. In

addition, WMSDs as one of the main ergonomic concerns, are known to be a

common problem for the majority of female workers (NIOSH, 1995; OSHA, 2000;

Parimalam, Kamalamma, & Ganguli, 2005). Otherwise, in most working cases in

agriculture, some sort of musculoskeletal problem occurs according to the

physical demands on the body, awkward postures, prolonged standing and

kneeling, stooping, bending, and repetitive muscle activities. Assuredly, these

Campuses: Hilltop | MH del Pilar | Pallocan East | Pallocan West | Lipa


Telephone Numbers: +63 43 723 1446 | 980 0041
Website: www.ub.edu.ph
postures will result in fatigue, illness, and accidents. In addition, the inadequate

knowledge of workers about agricultural health and safety leads to the most life

threatening situations.

13. Working in Agriculture


ILO (2009), agriculture is defined as: “Agricultural and forestry activities

carried out in agricultural undertakings including crop production, forestry

activities, animal husbandry and insect raising, the primary processing of

agricultural and animal products by or on behalf of the operator of the

undertaking as well as the use and maintenance of machinery, equipment,

appliances, tools, and agricultural installations, including any process, storage,

operation or transportation in an agricultural undertaking, which are directly

related to agricultural production” (Hurst & Kirby, 2004).

14. Respiratory Health Hazards in Agriculture

World Health Organization (WHO) in 1962 as any person engaged either

permanently or temporarily, irrespective of legal status, in activities related to

agriculture (4). Agriculture was in turn defined as embracing all forms of activity

connected with growing, harvesting, and primary processing of all types of crops;

with breeding, raising, and caring for animals; and with tending gardens and

nurseries. Thus, the term comprises a spectrum of pursuits, from growing to

processing, and a wide range of commodities. This definition has been used in

Campuses: Hilltop | MH del Pilar | Pallocan East | Pallocan West | Lipa


Telephone Numbers: +63 43 723 1446 | 980 0041
Website: www.ub.edu.ph
the present review, but it is recognized that there are some settings that may in

part be considered agricultural and in part manufacturing.

15. Gender differences in work-related risk factors associated with low

back symptoms

However, most previous studies that examined the interaction between

physical and psychosocial factors for LBS have indicated the presence of

interaction (Devereux, Buckle, and Vlachonikolis 1999; Huang et al. 2003;

Fernandes et al. 2009; Lapointe et al. 2009). The findings of this study and

previous studies support the theoretical models proposing that the causes of

NSS and other musculoskeletal symptoms are multifactorial, and that these

factors may interact (Davis and Heaney 2000; Buckle and Devereux 2002; Karsh

2006). These interactions, in turn, are most likely to increase the risk of

musculoskeletal symptoms and its consequences

16. Identifying Measures to Reduce Musculoskeletal Disorder Risks in

Residential Construction

Karsh’s (2006) Theories and models that describe how MSDs are caused

rely on the interaction of a number of different factors. Some of these theories

focused on biomechanical mechanisms while others focused on psychological

mechanisms. Force, posture, repetitiveness and vibration are frequently

Campuses: Hilltop | MH del Pilar | Pallocan East | Pallocan West | Lipa


Telephone Numbers: +63 43 723 1446 | 980 0041
Website: www.ub.edu.ph
described in literature as major biomechanical factors contributing to MSDs

causation.

17. Effect of individual and work parameters on musculoskeletal health of

manual agriculture workers

Bhardwaj (2019), some theoretical models have proposed that the role of

physical and psychosocial factors in the development of MSD is complex or

involved complex relationships. Given the clear evidence on the connection

between psychosocial factors and depression, in which each of the predictors is

linked with MSD, there is an urgent need to examine this complex relationship.

18. Intervention development to reduce musculoskeletal disorders: Is the

process on target?

Ergon (2016), to assist in manual handling activities, technological

evolution has progressed from mechanized tools, to automated systems, to

collaborative interactive robots, and of late, to wearable exoskeleton devices. On

international and local levels, legislation, standards and codes of practices have

been introduced in an attempt to minimize the presence of hazards in the

workplace and reduce their levels of associated risk. However, the advancement

in technology, such as the introduction of industrial robots, collaborative robots,

Campuses: Hilltop | MH del Pilar | Pallocan East | Pallocan West | Lipa


Telephone Numbers: +63 43 723 1446 | 980 0041
Website: www.ub.edu.ph
and exoskeleton robots can occur at a rate with which the creators of these

guidance requirements cannot match.

19. Workstyle and Musculoskeletal Discomfort (MSD): Exploring the

Influence of Work Culture in Philippines

Karsh’s (2006) study has theoretical implications for MSD analysis and

prevention. Karsh's (2006) integrated model highlighted where contextual risk

factors for meat processing fit in a causation model. This study provides support

for Karsh's model, where wider cultural, social and economic influences can be

critical precursors to exposure to physical and psychosocial MSD risk factors in

the industrial workplace.

20. Agricultural environment

Vogel (2015) due to the difficulties in diagnosing the etiology of these

injuries, it is often very hard to pinpoint single or exact cause of such of injuries

within the work environment. Work related musculo-skeletal disorders are

injuries and pains as a result of damage to soft tissues such as tendinitis or

tenosynovitis or a situation of nerve compression leading to the development of

Carpal Tunnel or Cubital Tunnel injuries.

Campuses: Hilltop | MH del Pilar | Pallocan East | Pallocan West | Lipa


Telephone Numbers: +63 43 723 1446 | 980 0041
Website: www.ub.edu.ph
Chapter III

This chapter provides the description of the research method, subject of the

study, materials, the procedures and statistical treatment utilized in analyzing the

data/information that were gathered.

Research Design

The purpose of a historical research design is to collect,verify and

synthesize evidence from the past to establish facts that defend or refute a

hypothesis. This study is a quantitative type of research that compost of

numerical values in order to arrive on a certain action. Graphs and tables are

presented in this type of research ,it is equipped with statistical and comparable

data that can be synthesized that are being practiced and experienced by the

farmers from Barangay Sabang Lipa City, Batangas.

Observations, interviews and a short questionnaire were utilized in order

to conduct the study of Cumulative Trauma Disorder of the farmers. A

questionnaire was issued to assess the CTD. With the aid of these, the

identification of CTD and the factors connected to the pain each farmers

experienced became viable. Therefore the application of certain ergonomic

principles were noticeable. The data was acquired by interviews, questionnaires

Campuses: Hilltop | MH del Pilar | Pallocan East | Pallocan West | Lipa


Telephone Numbers: +63 43 723 1446 | 980 0041
Website: www.ub.edu.ph
and through physical observation, the problems faced by the farmers were

identified and solved as well as the identification of Cumulative Trauma Disorders

among local farmers.

The use of statistical tools was applied to the data collected to identify the

factors affecting the pain local farmers were experiencing.

Participants of the Study

All the farmers that corresponds to agricultural line of work is subjected to

this study. Workers regarding of their age ,work experience or work load are all

treated as one sample. Farmers that typically work 8 hour shifts were observed.

The participants are experiencing such discomfort that are significant as to

Cumulative Trauma Disorder; which is our main focus to our study.

Data Gathering Instrument

The data gathering instrument was conceptualize by reading different

concepts and studies regarding ergonomic problems and the musculoskeletal

disorders related to agricultural work.

The research instrumentt will be a questionnaire. The questionnaire is

divided into two parts: the respondent’s profile and questionnaire proper. The

profile included all the information about the respondent -- his/her academic

Campuses: Hilltop | MH del Pilar | Pallocan East | Pallocan West | Lipa


Telephone Numbers: +63 43 723 1446 | 980 0041
Website: www.ub.edu.ph
background, years of work in the field of agriculture, and type of agricultural

products. On the other hand, the questionnaire proper included the profile of the

respondent and two parts questionnaire. These subtopics were measured

through scales of 4 for Always, 3 for Often, 2 for Sometimes and 1 for Never.

Questionnaires are ways for participants to get involved and talk about

their views. In addition, the interviewees are able to discuss their perception and

interpretation in regards to a given situation. It is their expression from their point

of view.

Validation of the Research Instrument

In this study, our Ergonomics instructor validated our works. The instructor

guided the researchers along the process as well as in giving reminders to finish

the paper. The researchers gave their instructor the draft of the research and

then were given correction. After which the paper was returned, revision and

editing was made by the researchers.

Data Gathering Procedure

The researchers constructed a set of questions to be answered by the

farmers of Sabang Farm; comments and feedbacks were given orally by the

Sabang councilor while waiting for the respondents like the labor to finish with the

questionnaires. They have distributed it to opposite gender as they vary in their

jobs and tasks daily. Questionnaires were collected right after they have

Campuses: Hilltop | MH del Pilar | Pallocan East | Pallocan West | Lipa


Telephone Numbers: +63 43 723 1446 | 980 0041
Website: www.ub.edu.ph
answered the survey. All of it was kept safely. Moreover, the researcher

evaluated and tallied the answers of the respondents to have the final results.

The result gave the researchers the knowledge on how do the respondents vary

in their ideas and opinions with the topic given. Following tool were used to

identify certain details that the researcher will need in order to asses the risk

concerning their disorders. One of the main tool that the researchers used is the

CTD risk factor which are to be discussed at Chapter 4 - Results and Discussion.

Statistical Treatment of Data

The following statistical tools were used in the study.

Responses to the questionnaire by the farmers of Barangay Sabang, Lipa City

based on their current movements, pains and discomfort they experience,

causes, risk, and severity of the pains and discomfor will be statistically analyzed

with the data requirements of the study.

Farmers will be statistically analyzed with the data instruments of the study.

Descriptive statistics such as mean, and weighted mean are considered.

Mean. This is the sum of the values divided by the number of values.

Weighted Mean. This is the average of all the means of the questions within this

battery section. To have a “weighted” average put in the weights.

Campuses: Hilltop | MH del Pilar | Pallocan East | Pallocan West | Lipa


Telephone Numbers: +63 43 723 1446 | 980 0041
Website: www.ub.edu.ph
The frequencies from which the mean was based were from a three- point Likert

scale: 3- Good, 2- Bad, 1- Problematic. The verbal interpretation is based on the

following scale:

Option Scale Range Verbal

Interpretation

3 2.50- 3.00 Good

2 1.50- 2.49 Bad

1 0.50- 1.49

Problematic

Campuses: Hilltop | MH del Pilar | Pallocan East | Pallocan West | Lipa


Telephone Numbers: +63 43 723 1446 | 980 0041
Website: www.ub.edu.ph
CHAPTER IV
RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS

This chapter includes the presentation, analysis, interpretation of the data

gathered. It provides the results and discussions that will make the readers to

have a better grasp and understanding of proofreaders and their beliefs,

practices and experiences.

Figure 1:
Type of Work M F
Harvesting Crop 3 3
Removing Insects 5 2
Pruning Shears 4 3
Total 12 8

Campuses: Hilltop | MH del Pilar | Pallocan East | Pallocan West | Lipa


Telephone Numbers: +63 43 723 1446 | 980 0041
Website: www.ub.edu.ph
According to Figure 1, there is a trend toward males bearing the brunt of

hard labor, making them more susceptible to pain. This is what the data on the

table shows when comparing the male and female samples.

2.

Table 2:
Age Significance Gender Significance
X Y Relationship X Y Relationship
Age Spa S Gender Spa NS
Age Spb NS Gender Spb NS
Age Spc NS Gender Spc NS
Age Hpa NS Gender Hpa NS
Age Hpb NS Gender Hpb NS
Age Hpc S Gender Hpc NS

The data on Table 2.1 shows that there is a significant relationship between

age and pain, leading to the inference that pain is higher the more you age.

Campuses: Hilltop | MH del Pilar | Pallocan East | Pallocan West | Lipa


Telephone Numbers: +63 43 723 1446 | 980 0041
Website: www.ub.edu.ph
The data from Table 2.2 shows that there is no significant

relationship between gender and pain. They do not affect each other in obvious

ways.

Campuses: Hilltop | MH del Pilar | Pallocan East | Pallocan West | Lipa


Telephone Numbers: +63 43 723 1446 | 980 0041
Website: www.ub.edu.ph
Campuses: Hilltop | MH del Pilar | Pallocan East | Pallocan West | Lipa
Telephone Numbers: +63 43 723 1446 | 980 0041
Website: www.ub.edu.ph
Table 3:
Tally of
Tally severity Percentage
Cutting grass using
hands 10 57 46.72%
Moving crops 4 29 23.77%
Adjusting Clothes 6 36 29.51%
Total 20 122 100.00%

The data from Figure 3 shows that the most severe pains from the

neck, hands, shoulders, Lower back and foot pain are most likely to derive from

cutting grass using hands because such a repetitive movement can cause

damage or injury to the hands.

Campuses: Hilltop | MH del Pilar | Pallocan East | Pallocan West | Lipa


Telephone Numbers: +63 43 723 1446 | 980 0041
Website: www.ub.edu.ph
Figure 4:
Tally of
Type of Work Occurrence
Harvesting Crop 15
Removing Insects 17
Pruning Shears 17
Total 49

The data from Figure 4 shows that pruning shears and removing insects

may be a source of more pain than harvesting the crop. This is perhaps due to

more monotonous and meticulous searching for bugs and more effort when using

the shears to cut down excess grass. The data from figure 2.2 shows that there

is no significant relationship between gender and pain. They do not affect each

other in obvious ways.

Campuses: Hilltop | MH del Pilar | Pallocan East | Pallocan West | Lipa


Telephone Numbers: +63 43 723 1446 | 980 0041
Website: www.ub.edu.ph
Table 5
Recurring of Pain in Specific Body Parts
Body Part Mean Verbal Interpretation
Neck 2.30 Sometimes
Shoulder 2.55 Often
Hand 2.75 Often
Lower Back 2.40 Sometimes
Feet 2.50 Often
Weighted Mean 2.95 Often

As shown in the table above, all the mentioned body parts are mainly used

for manual agricultural work which causes to experience pain. Among all the

parts, the majority of the respondents reported that they experience pain mostly

in their hands as it is used in every activity especially in handling tools for

harvesting, planting, grass cutting and other farming activities. It had a mean

score of 2.75 with a verbal interpretation of Often.

The least reported to experience pain is the neck. It had a mean score of

2.30 with a verbal interpretation of Sometimes. The reason why neck experience

less pain is because it is highly flexible and allows the head to turn and flex in all

directions. It does not specifically doing manual handling work for any activity

unlike the hand.

Proper grip of farming tools and time to time resting is highly encouraged

to avoid the occurence of pain and future implications.

Campuses: Hilltop | MH del Pilar | Pallocan East | Pallocan West | Lipa


Telephone Numbers: +63 43 723 1446 | 980 0041
Website: www.ub.edu.ph
CHAPTER V
SUMMARY, CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION

This part gives a summary of the whole research conducted, presents the

findings and gives recommendations.

Summary

The research undertaken has proven to the affect of pain on agricultural

workers. After agricultural workers were interviewed and surveyed, the data was

organized and analyzed to discover certain conclusions. There is a trend toward

males bearing the brunt of hard labor, making them more susceptible to pain.

The age and pain are proportional to each other. The most severe pains from the

neck, hands, shoulders, lower back and foot pain are most likely to derive from

cutting grass using hands because such a repetitive movement can cause

damage or injury to the hands. There is no significant relationship between

gender and pain. They do not affect each other in obvious ways.

1. Is there a significant relation between age and accumulative trauma disorders

in modern day farmers?

2. Do female farmers experience more pain than female farmers?

3. Does repetitive movement affect the farmers pain?

Campuses: Hilltop | MH del Pilar | Pallocan East | Pallocan West | Lipa


Telephone Numbers: +63 43 723 1446 | 980 0041
Website: www.ub.edu.ph
4. Are harvesting crops more painful than removing insects from the crops or

pruning shears?

Conclusion

In conclusion, there is a serious problem of CTD that agricultural workers

suffer and have to endure.

Recommendations

 Consider wearing personal protective equipment for farming like boots, long

sleeves, hat, farming/gardening gloves, etc.

 Other body parts shall be considered for a wider scope of research.

 The study can be used for future researches and as a source of data

Campuses: Hilltop | MH del Pilar | Pallocan East | Pallocan West | Lipa


Telephone Numbers: +63 43 723 1446 | 980 0041
Website: www.ub.edu.ph

You might also like