Remman Enterprises Inc., petitioner vs. CA & Crispin E.

Lat
G.R. 125018 April 6, 2000 330 SCRA 145

FACTS:
 Remman and Lat are adjoining landowners in Brgy. Bugtong na Pulo, Lipa City.
 Lat owns 1.8 hectares of agricultural land, planted mostly with fruit trees. While
Remman occupied 15 hectares of land devoted for his piggery business.
 Remman’s land is ½ meters higher in elevation than that of Lat.
 July 1984- Lat noticed that Remman’s waste disposal lagoon was overflowing
and flooding ¼ of his land. Lat made several representations with Remman but
fell on deaf ears.
 May 15, 1985- Almost 1 hectare of Lat’s plantation was already flooded with
water containing pig manure and as a result, trees growing on the flooded portion
started to wither and die.
 Lat then filed a complaint for damages with preliminary mandatory injunction
alleging that the acidity of the soil in his plantation increased beacause of the
overflow of water heavy with pig manure from Remman’s farm.
 RTC conducted ocular inspection evaluating evidences of both parties. It found
out that:
o Waste water lagoon is overflowing flooding 1 hectares of Lat’s plantation
o Water was ankle-deep causing the death of
 1 jackfruit tree
 15 coconut trees
 122 coffee trees and
 Unspecified number of mango trees, bananas and vegetables
 RTC ordered Remman to indemnify Lat P186,975 for lost profits for 3 crop years
and P30,000 attorney’s fee.
 CA affirmed in toto.

ISSUE: WON appellant Remman is liable for damage.

HELD:
YES. Remman is liable for damage for negligence on his part in maintaining the level of
waste water in its lagoon which flooded Lat’s plantation with acidic, malodorous and
polluted water containing pig manure.
ART 637 of Civil Code:
 Lower estates are obliged to receive the waters which naturally and
without the intervention of man descend from the higher estates, as well
as the stones or earth which they carry with them.
The owner of the lower estate cannot construct works which will impede
this easement; neither can the owner of the higher estate make works
which will increase the burden.
Similar provision is found in the Water Code of the Philippines (P.D. No.1067), which
provides:
Art. 50. Lower estates are obliged to receive the water which naturally and
without the intervention of man flow from the higher estates, as well as the
stone or earth which they carry with them.
The owner of the lower estate cannot construct works which will impede
this natural flow, unless he provides an alternative method of drainage;
neither can the owner of the higher estate make works which will increase
this natural flow.
As worded, the two (2) aforecited provisions impose a natural easement upon the lower
estate to receive the waters which naturally and without the intervention of man
descend from higher states. However, where the waters which flow from a higher state
are those which are artificially collected in manmade lagoons, any damage occasioned
thereby entitles the owner of the lower or servient estate to compensation.