Professional Documents
Culture Documents
March 11 Research 1 Doc.1
March 11 Research 1 Doc.1
College of Nursing
A Research Paper
Presented to the
College of Nursing
ARELLANO UNIVERSITY
Pasay City
In Partial Fulfillment
of the Requirements for the Degree
BACHELOR OF SCIENCE IN NURSING
Perales, Janet M.
Bernal, Cris L.
Sumalpong, Jessel Ann C.
Pano, Mark Kerby C.
Group 4
Submitted to:
Alejandro R. Sandiko Jr., MD, RN, RMT
Adviser
CHAPTER 1
THE PROBLEM AND ITS BACKGROUND
Introduction
Stress is a fact of life, where ever you are and whatever you are doing. You cannot
avoid stress, but you can learn to manage it so it doesn’t manage you. Stress can be
described as a dynamic and reciprocal relationship between the person and the
environment. The need to have the safest working environment and the best quality of
healthcare delivery to patients by nurses cannot be overemphasized. It is therefore
imperative to identify factors that would promote these goals and prevent other negative
factors from impeding their achievement [ CITATION 2LT15 \l 1033 ]
to their knowledge and abilities and which challenge their ability to cope” (World Health
Organization 2017.) In Europe, 28% of workers (41 million people) suffer from work-
related stress the European Union & European Foundation for the Improvement of Living
and Working Conditions.
In the study of Eleni Moustakas in 2010, stress is a part of modern nursing which
makes chronic diseases in nursing in long term such as hypertension, asthma, etc. and
affects their quality of life and increases the risk of injuries due to work. Job stress can
also have a significant impact on the individuality of nurses and their abilities to
accomplish the task and in particular causes weakness in decision-making, loss of
concentration, apathy, loss of motivation and anxiety. And the above-mentioned factors
can directly lead to absenteeism, reduced efficacy, and eventually nurse’s burnout.
Work stress has been identified as a key factor in service delivery in every
organization and in most fields of work. Stress a term continually being redefined in the
scientific study of disease and illness, is nevertheless a well-proven and important factor
in almost all inflammatory diseases.
Apart from the work environment, the individual worker as a member of society
also has other sources of stress that may be brought to bear on his/her performance in the
workplace.Other pressures that affect the personal lives of workers.
Nursing is an incredibly stressful career. From the moment nursing students start
their education program to when they retire; they face difficult situations and stressors on
a daily basis. In fact, stress and burnout affect 10-70% of nurses. [ CITATION Reg19 \l
13321 ].
In a 2002 survey, over 60% of nurses agreed that stress was a significant issue in
their work lives, and in a 2004 survey, 55% of respondents expressed the same view
4 Arellano University 4
College of Nursing
When Jose (not his real name), a registered nurse, started to work in a public
hospital in Manila, he didn’t think that he would be on-duty for 16 straight hours. It went
on for a week and he thought of quitting his job. But for the sake of gaining experience,
he stayed.[ CITATION Ann14 \l 13321 ].
Through this paper, the researchers were urged to further study the work-related
stress coping mechanisms of staff nurses of Arellano University Jose Abad Santos that
are working in Quirino Memorial Medical Center. This is also to enhance how we can be
effective nurses in managing one and patient at a time.
The study aims to identify the coping strategies of the staff nurses working in
Quirino Memorial Medical Center Emergency Department in dealing with work-related
stress.
1. What is the demographic profile of the staff nurses in Quirino Memorial Medical
Center in terms of:
3. Age
4. Gender
5. Civil status
6. Years of service in the Emergency Department
b. How do the staff nurses of Quirino Memorial Medical Center Handle Work-
Related Stress in the following strategies?
5 Arellano University 5
College of Nursing
c. Appraisal-focused
1. What do you do when your stress-out?
2. Do you take anything to calm you down when you are stress-out?
3. How do you handle your emotions when you are stress-out?
Problem-focused
1. How do you manage your time when you have too much workload? How
do you prioritize?
2. What do you do in a situation when you cannot seem to find the right
solution to a problem?
3. In your opinion, what makes you a great problem-solver?
Emotional focused
1. Tell me about a time you faced an ethical dilemma at work. How did you
deal with it and what was the result?
2. Tell us about a time when someone criticized your work. How did you
respond and how did you learn?
3. Tell me about a time you had a conflict w/ your supervisor. How did you
resolve it?
3. What best coping strategies can you suggest/advice the upcoming fresh nursing
graduates and nursing student of Arellano University in managing and handling stress?
6 Arellano University 6
College of Nursing
Conceptual Framework
The research paradigm that guided this study is shown in the figure below,
following the Input-Process-Output approach.
INPUT PROCESS
OUTPUT
“Work-Related Stress Management Seminar”
Figure 1.1 Paradigm of a research study entitled "Coping Strategies of Staff Nurses
in Dealing with Work-Related Stress in QMMC”
The input identifies the respondents’ demographics which include; age, gender,
civil status, years of service in the emergency department. Whereas, the process includes
interview the respondents answered the provided questions. The output of this study will
help the researchers conduct a program towards coping strategies.
7 Arellano University 7
College of Nursing
Theoretical Framework
Researchers convinced and based the study on Lazarus and Folkman’s Theory
because this emphasizes coping strategies that will provide advantages to the
respondents. The research is focused on (Lazarus, 1984), Transactional theory of stress
and coping. The appraisal –focused, problem-focus and emotion-focus coping taxonomy
are the focal point of the theory.
The study will be delimited to the staff nurses of the Emergency Department of
Quirino Memorial Medical Center. This to identify respondent individual strategies on
how to handle work-related stress in their various situation.
The respondents will not be limited to a specific gender, age, sex, civil status,
graduation year and their occupational tenure ship.
This research will commence and will be completed on the 1st semester of AY
2020-2021 in the Arellano University Pasay Jose Abad Santos Campus.
Definition of Terms
To clarify and comprehend the problem and understand the research study, the
following terms are defined operationally:
Stress. This refers to the mental pressure and emotional tension of the respondents
related to workloads.
8 Arellano University 8
College of Nursing
Coping Strategies. Refers to the staff nurses of how they cope with stresses or overcome
by the suggested coping strategies or plan of action.
Work-related Stress. Refers to the staff nurses and identify the main causes of stress is
work-related.
CHAPTER II
REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE
Introduction
This chapter will discuss the relevant literature and studies related to Coping
Strategies Among Staff Nurses in Dealing with work-related stress. It includes the
foreign and local studies which lead the researches to formulate the research problem,
formulation of the guiding questions, gathering, and interpretation of data.
Understanding Stress
According to Carrie Wilkens Ph.D., is the Co-Founder and Clinical Director of the
Center for Motivation and Change NYC (2014). Stress can result in both physical and
emotional symptoms; Physical Sign of Stress can make our body hurt and make you feel
sluggish and tired. Sleep disruptions are one of the hallmark symptoms of being overly
stressed. And the most common physical sign of stress includes stiff neck and back pain,
headache, and decreased libido.
Behavioral signs of stress, the first noticeable signs are how you acting (your
behavior). These can include increased clutter in your personal or workplace, forgetting
what you’re doing or having trouble organizing yourself, and moving around very
quickly or very slowly. Mental and emotional signs of stress can show up in your
emotions or your internal world. This can look like feeling very emotional and having
your emotions change wildly with little notice, or feeling disconnected from everything
around you, those are the signs that you are dealing with stress.
Understanding and recognizing when you’re stressed and how you’re expressing
your stress are important in helping you find which skills you need to help cope with your
stress. Remember, stress is an important and inevitable part of life.
Arellano University 10
College of Nursing
Donald (2015), stated a worker’s place in the life span can be important for
understanding his or her work motivation and what he or she wants from the job. This
research challenges preconceptions about older employees, traditionally employer
strategies focus on the health of older employees but younger employees require more
support to reduce emotional exhaustion and cynicism and to use stress management
strategies successfully. Additionally, this study suggests there are differences between
younger and older employees concerning customer interaction in-service employees and
represent an important resource, particularly in light of the aging population.
Employees of different ages cope with customer stressors in different ways and as
a result experience higher or lower levels of burnout. Older workers use stress
Arellano University 11
College of Nursing
The current study illustrates the important role of age within employee-customer
interactions in the service sector. We that older employees can bring a level of emotional
maturity to service organizations, which, when compared to younger employees, could
offer a more positive customer experience. Where younger workers are involved, we
advise employers to be aware of the need to provide support to develop their emotions.
Obiora (2015), It was found that sources of stress for nurses could be
Administrative or organizational. Stressors could also be from physical sources or
psychological and emotional point of view. Interpersonal conflict and role ambiguity
among nurses is also a critical source of stress for Nurses. Several articles (1, 2, 4, 6, 7)
claimed that Administration and Organizational concerns are a major source of stress for
nurses. These concerns are usually in the form of lack of administrative support for
nurses, poor leadership qualities of nurse managers, the inadequacy of role authority
among other defective leadership roles that nurses are exposed to at their units or
departments. Almost all the articles claim that physical factors are the major and most
reported sources of stress for nurses.
The physical factors identified in the reviewed works include heavy workload and
turnover (1, 3, 5, 6) External demands (7), high job demand (9), stressful nature of the
nursing profession (10), environmental factors in the work area like temperature, noise,
lightning, ventilation (2) and threat to survival (8). These physical factors act in isolation
and in combination with other factors to cause stress for nurses. The other dimension to
Arellano University 12
College of Nursing
causes of stress for nurses is psychological and/or emotional. These are sources relating
to internal conflicts affecting the mental and emotional status of the nurses.
Mc Grath (2012), some aspects of working life have been linked to stress. Aspects
of the work itself can be stressful, namely work overload and role-based factors such as
lack of power, role ambiguity, and role conflict. Threats to career development and
achievement, including the threat of redundancy, being overvalued and unclear
promotion prospects and stressful. Stress is associated with reduced efficiency, decreased
capacity to perform, a lack of concern for the organization and colleagues. During the last
decade, there has been increasing recognition of the stress experienced by hospital
nursing staff.
Arellano University 13
College of Nursing
Although some stressful situations are specific to a particular type of hospital unit, nurses
are subject to more general stress which arises from the physical, psychological, and
social aspects of the work environment. High levels of stress result in the environment.
High levels of stress result in staff burnout and turnover and adversely patient care.
Interventions that are sources of occupational stress seem to be required to support
nurses.
Akkela and Leca (2015), explored work-related stress in Romanian NMs working
in selected hospitals in the United Arab Emirates using a hermeneutic phenomenological
approach. Nurse managers reported being stressed mainly from heavy workloads
followed by the organizational environment, dealing with staff and the country itself, in
Japan,
Miyata et al. (2015) conducted a semi-structured interview in 15 NMs to
determine their sources of stress were identified: work overload that accompanied their
position, the responsibility of managing unit-related issues and problems, and dealing
with organizational and staff expectations and demands. A similar finding was noted in
one study in the UK (Kelly etal.,2016). Stress originated mainly from workloads along
with dealing with patient complaints, managing crises, and service relocation.
result in decreased quality of care as well as increased costs, due to diversities in the way
Eds are organized and structured (staff, size, hours of operation, treatments).
Duque (2012), cited the common effects of stress. These are insomnia, headaches,
backaches, constipation, diarrhea, high blood pressure, heart disease, depression and
alcohol, tobacco or drug use. He suggested doing the following: 1) After seeing the
doctor, share your treatment plan with people close to you. Talk with friends and relatives
and explain what you are going through; 2) If your doctor prescribes medication take it
exactly the way it prescribed. Do not stop taking your medication until your doctor tells
you to stop doing so; 3) Keep all follow-up appointments with your doctor; 4) Remember
that it may take some time to start feeling better; 5) If you experience side effects from
any medication, tell your doctor; and 6) Seek professional counseling. If you are methods
of coping with stress that is not contributing to your greater emotional and physical
health, it is to find healthier ones. There are many healthy ways to manage and cope with
stress, but they all require change. You can either change the situation or change your
reaction. When deciding which option to choose, it is helpful to think of the four A’s:
avoid, alter, adapt, or accept. Since everyone has a unique response to stress, there is no
“size fits all” solution to managing it. No single methods work for everyone or in every
Arellano University 15
College of Nursing
situation, so experiment with different techniques and strategies. Focus on what makes
you feel calm and in control.
Mojoyinola (2012), the study investigated the effects of job stress on the physical
health, mental health personal and work behaviors of nurses in public hospitals I Ibadan
Metropolis, Nigeria. It aimed at addressing the issue of how stress at work can be
effectively managed, reduced, or prevented by the government and hospital boards to
enhance the health of the nurses, as well as improving their personal and work behaviors.
The study was carried out among 153 nurses working in two public hospitals in Ibadan
Metropolis, Nigeria. Export- facto research design was adopted for the study. A single
questionnaire tagged “Stress Assessment Questionnaire for Hospital Nurses (SAQFHN)
was developed and used for the study. The study established that job stress has a
significant difference in personal and work behavior or highly stressed nurses and less
stressed nurses. Based on these findings, it was recommended that the government
(Federal or State) and Hospital Management Boards should improve the welfare of the
nurses. It was also recommended that their morale should be boosted by involving them
in policy or decision-making concerning their welfare or care of their patients.
Ways to cope with stress- A. stretching; a physically it helps the body loosen
muscles, lubricate joints and increase the body oxygen supply; B. listening to sound and
son’s and getting task-organized or scheduling helps minimize stress; C. venting can help
you unload unwanted feelings; D. self-awareness, the individual develops a habit of
paying attention to one’s self-expression of thought, emotions, and behavior. According
Arellano University 16
College of Nursing
to the DOH, 'venting' can help you unload unwanted feelings.' Janeth O. Buhawe, RN
Feb.2015. While dealing with stress it is important to deal with your physician, mental
and social well being. A. Physically, one should maintain one’s health and learn to relax
if one finds oneself under stress. B. Mentally it is important to think positive thoughts,
value oneself, demonstrate good time management, plan and think ahead, and express
emotions. C. Socially one should communicate with people and seek new activities. By
following these simple strategies, one will have an easier time responding to stresses in
one’s life.
Appraisal-Focused
According to Saigal (Elizabeth Saigal, 2018), appraisal-focused therapy is
directed towards challenging your assumptions and modifying the way you think. This
may include distancing yourself from the problem or challenge, altering goals and values,
or identifying the humor in the situation to bring a positive spin.
Arellano University 17
College of Nursing
Problem-Focused
An article by Saul McLeod (McLeod, 2015) defined problem-focused as coping
that targets the causes of stress in practical ways which tackles the problem or stressful
situation that is causing stress, consequently directly reducing the stress. Problem-focused
strategies aim to remove or reduce the cause of the stressor, including Problem-solving,
Time-management, Obtaining instrumental social support.
Emotional-Focused
A coping strategy that involves trying to reduce the negative emotional responses
associated with stress such as embarrassment, fear, anxiety, depression, excitement, and
frustration. This may be the only realistic option when the source of stress is outside the
person’s control. Drug therapy can be seen as emotion-focused coping as it focuses on
the arousal caused by stress, not the problem. Other emotion-focused coping techniques
include. Distraction, Emotional disclosure, Praying for guidance and strength,
Meditation, Eating more, Drinking alcohol, Using drugs, Journaling, Cognitive
reappraisal, Suppressing (stopping/inhibition of) negative thoughts or emotions.
(Marshall, 2015)
Hypothesis
Sarah Mae Sincero Nov. 13, 2012. According to her, stress can be negative or
positive, depending on the level of our response to the stressor we encounter. Negative
stress is actually about the stress that is beyond one's control. This bad impact of severe
stress is often manifested in physical and mental signs and symptoms. However, when we
are only exposed to mild or moderate stress, we can experience the good side of stress,
which include improved activity, learning efficiency at work and eventually, a higher
level of self-esteem that could lead us to be able to withstand a higher stress level in the
future. Many psychologists also contributed to the study of coping mechanisms by
Arellano University 18
College of Nursing
CHAPTER III
Introduction
This chapter discusses the procedures and methods that were used to conduct this
study, which includes the following: setting, research design, sampling techniques,
respondents of the study research instrument, the researcher’s Data gathering phase 1 and
Setting
Research Design
evaluationof the staff nurses working within the emergency department of Quirino
Memorial Medical Hospital. The qualitative research methods used for study are
described further below and included purposive sampling, open–ended interviewing, and
Sampling Procedure
This study aims to know coping strategies among staff nurses in dealing with
work-related stress, with this purpose the researchers will use the Purposive sampling as
Ton07 \l 1033 ] “Purposive sampling is an informant selection tool that is widely used. It is
a nonrandom technique that does not need underlying theories or a set number of
informants. Simply put, the researcher decides what needs to be known and sets out to
Arellano University 20
College of Nursing
find people who can and are willing to provide the information by virtue of knowledge or
experience”.
interviewer asks questions of a participant, who then answers those questions. The
interview is considered open-ended because even though the questions can be scripted,
the interviewer usually doesn't know what the contents of the response will be. These
interviews may have some questions to gather basic factual data on participants such as
age and gender, but usually they focus more on the participant's thoughts, feelings,
Data collection and analysis processes tend to be concurrent, with new analytic
steps informing the process of additional data collection and new data informing the
data analysis processes are not entirely distinguishable from the actual data. The
theoretical lens from which the researcher approaches the phenomenon, the strategies that
the researcher uses to collect or construct data, and the understandings that the researcher
has about what might count as relevant or important data in answering the research
The respondents of this study are the staff nurses of the Quirino Memorial
Research Instrument
The researchers will utilize a self-made survey questionnaire. The coping theory
of Lazarus and Folkman (1984) will thebasis of this research tool. The said tool will be
are as follows: Dr. Alejandro R. Sandiko Jr. (Nursing Research Adviser), August I.
Manzon (Research sub-adviser), Mr. John Marc Balano (Arellano University Guidance
counselor).
The title of this studywith our selected topicwas approved and was presented by
our Consulting Nursing Research Adviser: Mr. August I. Manzon. Upon the approval, it
was then presented to Mrs. Evangeline D. Simon, Dean of the College of Nursing for the
The purpose of the study and the research instruments tothe respondents. The
researchers will reassure the respondents that their identity willbe kept confidential and
ask them to sign a written consent prior to the face to faceinterview. Each respondent will
Data Processing
Once the tools are gathered, they will be checked for the completeness of the data.
Any errors found by the validators will be immediately corrected. The researchers will
Method of Analysis
approach.
Arellano University 23
College of Nursing
Research title.
____________________________
Researcher.
Question.
2. Do you take anything to calm you down when you are stress-out?
4.How do you manage your time when you have to much work load? How do you
prioritize?
5.What do you do in a situation when you cannot seem to find the right solution to
a problem?
Arellano University 24
College of Nursing
7. Tell me about a time you faced an ethical dilemma at work. How did you deal
with it and what was the result?
8.Tell us about a time when someone criticized your work. How did you respond
and how did you learn?
9.Tell me about a time you had a conflict w/ your supervisor. How did you
resolved it?
Interview Answer will be gathered and taken through role-taking and Audio
recorders for verbal transposition.
Arellano University 25
College of Nursing
TABLE OF CONTENTS
CHAPTER PAGE
1 THE PROBLEM AND ITS BACKGROUND
Arellano University 26
College of Nursing
Introduction 1
Background of the Study 3
Statement of the Problem 4
Conceptual Framework 5
Theoretical Framework 6
Scope and Delimitation 6
Definition of Terms 7