Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2.1 - Basic - UN - Verification - & - Investigation May 2011 PDF
2.1 - Basic - UN - Verification - & - Investigation May 2011 PDF
2.1 - Basic - UN - Verification - & - Investigation May 2011 PDF
st
UN Peacekeeping PDT Standards, Specialized Training Material for Military Experts on Mission 1
Edition 2011
Pg. 2 Section 2.1 Basic UN verification and investigation techniques
Background
Current UN peacekeeping missions, especially those mandated to address
multidimensional challenges in a deteriorating or fragile security environment, present
complicated and often dangerous working environments for UN Military Experts on
Mission. Where there is insufficient UN or multinational security forces to establish a
safe and secure environment, MEoM are requested to execute the traditional roles of
investigation and verification.
Aim
The aim of this section is to provide peacekeepers with an understanding of the
procedures and techniques involved in conducting verifications and investigations in
a complex United Nations peace operation environment and develop awareness of
the do’s and don’ts in the area of human rights monitoring and investigations.
Learning Outcomes
On completion of this section, participants will be able to:
• Identify the definition, aim and phases of the verification process in a
United Nations peace operation environment to allow peacekeepers to
conduct verifications.
• Define the purpose and procedures of investigations to enable
peacekeepers conduct investigations and effectively support human rights
monitoring and investigations.
Training Sequence
The material contained in this module could be delivered over one or two training
units, depending on the number of learning activities the instructor decides to
incorporate. The instructor can modify the duration to suit national training
st
UN Peacekeeping PDT Standards, Specialized Training Material for Military Experts on Mission 1
Edition 2011
Section 2.1 Basic UN verification and investigation techniques Pg. 3
Duration
The times shown below are the minimum recommended time periods. Additional
activities and discussions can be added as time permits.
Methodology
This module contains learning activities to keep adult learners engaged. The
facilitation team should use as many of the learning activities as time allows and keep
them tailored to the target audience. Participants should be fully involved in the
learning process through practical exercises, brainstorming sessions, discussion of
case studies, working in small groups on specific tasks, etc.
The instructor should inform participants of content, format and timing. Knowing what
to expect, participants can improve their ability to focus on the subject and benefit to
a greater extent from the session.
Instructors are highly recommended to distribute the handout to participants the day
before the session to give them the necessary time to prepare the session’s topics.
Structure of the presentation
• Definition of verification
• Phases of a verification/inspection
• Investigations
• Conducting investigations
• Witnesses interviews
• Evidence handling
• Information assessment
st
UN Peacekeeping PDT Standards, Specialized Training Material for Military Experts on Mission 1
Edition 2011
Pg. 4 Section 2.1 Basic UN verification and investigation techniques
Instructor Profile
This module is best presented by an instructor who has experience in verification and
investigation in UN field missions, who could share his/her experience with the group.
If there is more than one instructor, at least one should have practical experience.
The instructor should also encourage questions from the participants and aim for an
interactive discussion. All participants should be encouraged to contribute to the
group discussions, case study discussions and in any other activity.
Instructor Preparations
Required Readings
• UN DPKO/DFS Guidelines; Roles and Training Standards for UN Military
Experts on Mission, 2009
• A Peacekeeping Training manual. UN DPKO
• UN Peacekeeping Handbook for Junior Ranks
General Preparations
Equipment:
1. Computer
2. Projector and Screen
3. Flip Chart
Materials:
1. Copies of handouts…etc.
2. Power Point presentations
Mission Specific
If Section 2.1 is being presented to prepare students for a particular UN
peacekeeping mission, then gather mission specific information from the mission
website (available at the UN DPKO internet website, through ‘current operations’:
http://www.un.org/Depts/dpko/dpko/index.asp). Additional mission specific
information is available at the UN DPKO Policy and Training internet website:
http://peacekeepingresourcehub.unlb.org/PBPS/Pages/Public/Home.aspx
st
UN Peacekeeping PDT Standards, Specialized Training Material for Military Experts on Mission 1
Edition 2011
Section 2.1 Basic UN verification and investigation techniques Pg. 5
Symbols Legend
Speaking Points (The main points to cover on the topic. Ideally the
speaking points are presented in the instructor’s own words versus being
read to participants)
Mission Specific (A point where the session will benefit from mission
specific information)
Optional Learning Activity (An activity that can be used if there is time
and it is appropriate for the participant group. Guidelines for these
activities are provided at the end of the unit, section or part – as indicated
in the text)
Key summary points (Key messages that are worth repeating at the end
of the session. Alternatively, the instructor can ask participants what are
the main messages they are taking from the session. Instructors can
then fill in any points that have been missed.)
st
UN Peacekeeping PDT Standards, Specialized Training Material for Military Experts on Mission 1
Edition 2011
Pg. 6 Section 2.1 Basic UN verification and investigation techniques
Session Notes
Slide 1
SECTION 2.1 BASIC UN VERIFICATION AND INVESTIGATION
TECHNIQUES
Aim Slide 2
The aim of this section is to provide peacekeepers with an
understanding of the procedures and techniques involved in
conducting verifications and investigations in a complex United
Nations peace operation environment.
Slide 3
Learning Outcome
On completion of this section, participants will be able to:
• Identify the definition, aim and phases of the verification
process in a United Nations peace operation environment to
allow peacekeepers to conduct verifications.
• Define the purpose and procedures of investigations to allow
peacekeepers conducting investigations.
Definition of Verification
st
UN Peacekeeping PDT Standards, Specialized Training Material for Military Experts on Mission 1
Edition 2011
Section 2.1 Basic UN verification and investigation techniques Pg. 7
Slide 4
A definition
• Verification is “the process of establishing the truth,
accuracy or reality of something”
Definition of verification
• Verification is “the process of establishing the truth, accuracy or reality of
something”
Verification Slide 5
• Aim
• Authority
• Tasks
Slide 6
Types of a verification/inspection
• Formal: Scheduled verifications/inspections
• Informal: Unscheduled verifications/inspections
• Specific: Pursuant to claims of non-compliance
st
UN Peacekeeping PDT Standards, Specialized Training Material for Military Experts on Mission 1
Edition 2011
Pg. 8 Section 2.1 Basic UN verification and investigation techniques
Phases of a Verification/Inspection
Slide 7
Phases of a verification/inspection
• Phase 1 Planning, preparation and briefing
• Phase 2 Execution
• Phase 3 Post-verification debriefings and reporting
Phases of a verification/inspection
There are three phases to conduct a verification/inspection:
Phase 1 Planning, preparation and briefing
Phase 2 Execution
Phase 3 Post-verification debriefings and reporting
Slide 8
• Select and check the Verification Kit (which normally includes walkie-
talkie, binoculars, detailed maps with all known positions, compass etc)
• Carry your UN ID card!!!
• Attend the Ops Brief given by OpsO. (It covers all of the information
required, aims and objectives, routes, localities to visit, special radio
procedures and current restrictions or limitations in the area to be
inspected)
• Ensure the UN flag is mounted on your vehicle
• Pick up any assigned Liaison staff or interpreters en route
Slide 9
Phase 2 Execution
• Always enter positions through the main gate
• Count armaments according to the agreement
• Be sure that you inspect the entire area in question
• Contact your HQ on the radio as required
• Log all relevant information and figures in your report
• Before dropping the LO off, make sure all members involved in
the verification/inspection sign the report
• Never show maps or figures of opposing forces to non-UN
personnel
• Only report the facts – not speculation
• Be sure to cover the whole verification /inspection area
• Always be suspicious and curious yet polite
• In addition to your task observe road conditions terrain and
the presence of obstacles of any kind, especially minefields
• Promptly report to human rights officers allegations of human
rights violations you may gather during your verification
activities
Phase 2 Execution
Points to keep in mind are:
• Always enter positions through the main gate
• Count armaments according to the agreement (The figures should be
agreed by all observers and the LO immediately after leaving the
position)
• Be sure that you inspect the entire area in question, not just part of it.
• Contact your HQ on the radio as required to report on progress /
problems.
st
UN Peacekeeping PDT Standards, Specialized Training Material for Military Experts on Mission 1
Edition 2011
Pg. 10 Section 2.1 Basic UN verification and investigation techniques
• Log all relevant information and figures in your report, including the
time you entered the Information.
• Before dropping the LO off, make sure all members involved in the
verification/inspection sign the report
• Never show maps or figures of opposing forces to non-UN
personnel
• Only report the facts – not speculation, rumor or hearsay
• Be sure to cover the whole verification /inspection area
• Always be suspicious and curious yet polite.
• In addition to your task observe road conditions terrain and the presence
of obstacles of any kind, especially minefields
• Observe and promptly report to human rights officers allegations of
human rights violations. As a way of example, while inspecting military
facilities you may observe detainees with marks of torture requiring
urgent medical attention or women or children illegally held who may be
at risk of sexual abuse. Be prepared to take action if you assess that
the victims’ situations cannot wait for human rights officers’ intervention.
Appropriate action may include engagement with local military authorities
and facilitating access to medical care.
Slide 10
Phase 3 Debriefing and Reporting
• De-briefing is normally done orally.
• Check your vehicle, vehicle kit and personal kit
• Conduct a detailed debrief as soon as possible.
st
UN Peacekeeping PDT Standards, Specialized Training Material for Military Experts on Mission 1
Edition 2011
Section 2.1 Basic UN verification and investigation techniques Pg. 11
Investigations
Slide 11
Investigations
• The purpose of an investigation is to establish the facts
of an incident
• MEoMs may be required to be the initial investigating
authority for an incident or be part of joint investigations
with other components (e.g. human rights).
Investigations
General:
The basic purpose of an investigation is to establish the facts about what
actually has happened.
An investigation can be demanded / initiated by one or several of the
conflicting parties or by UN itself. This would normally be described in the
investigation procedures for the specific mission.
MEoMs may be required to be the initial investigating authority for an
incident. Observer teams may discover an incident or be the nearest
responding authority, and thus, be required to conduct the initial
investigation and/or secure the scene for handover to another agency.
st
UN Peacekeeping PDT Standards, Specialized Training Material for Military Experts on Mission 1
Edition 2011
Pg. 12 Section 2.1 Basic UN verification and investigation techniques
Slide
Preparations for investigations 13
• Purpose of the investigation.
• Initiating / complaining party.
• Exact problem
• What to look for?
• Determine if it is a ‘routine’ or sensitive matter.
• Any previous records on file.
• Any special interest by complaining party have
• All pre-arranged or intended meetings expected.
• To locate other witnesses
• The means of transportation available
The planning phase activities for conducting verifications are applicable during
the investigation preparations. In addition MEoM should learn at least the
following:
• The key problem = what to look for? Determine what particulars must be
established before a conclusion can be made in the specific case.
• Determine if it is a ‘routine’ matter or a sensitive matter.
• If any similar investigation had been carried out before (in the same
area). Any previous records on file.
• If there is a special interest the complaining party have, which could
influence on the investigation (a hidden agenda to obstruct the
investigation or to bind your resources in order to hide something else)
• Background information including on human rights issues.
• All pre-arranged or intended meetings expected. Where, when and with
whom?
• To locate other witnesses and make pre-arrangements with them, if
possible with due consideration for confidentiality and their safety.
• The means of transportation available for you (vehicles, aircraft) Where,
when?
st
UN Peacekeeping PDT Standards, Specialized Training Material for Military Experts on Mission 1
Edition 2011
Section 2.1 Basic UN verification and investigation techniques Pg. 13
Conducting an Investigation
Slide 14
Conducting an Investigation
• General Recommendations
• Arriving to the scene of the incident
• Behavior of the Investigation Team
• Sensitive Areas
Conducting an Investigation
• General Recommendations
Isolate and protect the scene: Assess the security of the scene
(identifying the threat from mines and UXO); Determine the need for
tactical security (are you safe?); Protect the scene from non-
authorized personnel and the public
Designate responsibilities for undertaking: The primary investigation;
Scene security; Evidence/exhibit recording; Witness identification /
interviewing
Create good order on the location, where you e.g. will meet
witnesses.
Keep witnesses apart from each other and call them for interviewing
one by one.
st
UN Peacekeeping PDT Standards, Specialized Training Material for Military Experts on Mission 1
Edition 2011
Pg. 14 Section 2.1 Basic UN verification and investigation techniques
• Sensitive Areas
Interpretation. You should have access to a reliable interpreter.
Make clear to the interpreter some basic rules before his / her first
investigation, such as:
o Interpret as exactly as possible what is said
o Do not add anything to or take anything out of the translation
o Do not make comments on what is translated
o If the investigator does not understand an answer, he/she will
formulate the new question, not the interpreter.
o The interpreter should not be involved in separate ‘private’
discussions with one of the parties.
o In some cases a witnesses only speak a certain local language
and you can find an interpreter able to translate directly between
that language and English. In other cases you will have to
translate in two steps. In both cases you may ask very simple
questions.
o Never discuss anything with one party only using a language that
is not understood by or not translated to the other party.
o Ensure confidentiality of sources and discussions with parties.
st
UN Peacekeeping PDT Standards, Specialized Training Material for Military Experts on Mission 1
Edition 2011
Section 2.1 Basic UN verification and investigation techniques Pg. 15
Witness interviews
st
UN Peacekeeping PDT Standards, Specialized Training Material for Military Experts on Mission 1
Edition 2011
Pg. 16 Section 2.1 Basic UN verification and investigation techniques
Slide 15
Witness interviews
• Parties' representatives could be present
• Confront witnesses with contradictory information
• Particular information witness can contribute
• Schedule interviews at secure sites
• Initial discussion with witness
• Following guidelines advise subject about confidentiality
of statements
• Consider outside factors/pressures for interviewed
person.
Witness interviews
The evidence
Forms of Evidence
Slide 16
Forms of Evidence
• Verbal
• Material
• Circumstantial
st
UN Peacekeeping PDT Standards, Specialized Training Material for Military Experts on Mission 1
Edition 2011
Section 2.1 Basic UN verification and investigation techniques Pg. 17
Forms of Evidence
Verbal evidence:
• Is unreliable and subjective
• Requires corroboration
Evidence Handling
Evidence Handling
st
UN Peacekeeping PDT Standards, Specialized Training Material for Military Experts on Mission 1
Edition 2011
Pg. 18 Section 2.1 Basic UN verification and investigation techniques
Information Assessment
Slide 18
Information Assessment
• Compare notes
• Assess the credibility of witnesses
• Identify any corroborating information
• Identify any contradictory information
• Exercise caution in drawing conclusions
Information Assessment
Points to consider when assessing collected information and evidence:
• Compare notes (yours and those of other interviewers)
• Assess the credibility of witnesses (if necessary, factor in interpreter bias)
• Identify any corroborating information
• Identify any contradictory information
• Exercise caution in drawing conclusions
st
UN Peacekeeping PDT Standards, Specialized Training Material for Military Experts on Mission 1
Edition 2011
Section 2.1 Basic UN verification and investigation techniques Pg. 19
Questions
1. What is the definition of verification?
2. What is the aim of verification?
3. What are the phases of a verification/inspection?
Learning Outcome
1. Verification is “the process of establishing the truth or validity of something”.
2. The aim of verification is to support the success of the mandate or agreement
through an inspection and/or assessment to establish compliance or non-
compliance with that agreement.
3. There are three phases of a verification/inspection:
• Phase 1 Planning, preparation and briefing
• Phase 2 Execution
• Phase 3 Debriefing and reporting
st
UN Peacekeeping PDT Standards, Specialized Training Material for Military Experts on Mission 1
Edition 2011
Pg. 20 Section 2.1 Basic UN verification and investigation techniques
st
UN Peacekeeping PDT Standards, Specialized Training Material for Military Experts on Mission 1
Edition 2011
Section 2.1 Basic UN verification and investigation techniques Pg. 21
st
UN Peacekeeping PDT Standards, Specialized Training Material for Military Experts on Mission 1
Edition 2011