Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Crete
Author(s): D. Blackman and K. Branigan
Source: The Annual of the British School at Athens, Vol. 77 (1982), pp. 1-57
Published by: British School at Athens
Stable URL: https://www.jstor.org/stable/30102778
Accessed: 26-03-2020 23:48 UTC
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide
range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and
facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at
https://about.jstor.org/terms
British School at Athens is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access
to The Annual of the British School at Athens
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
THE EXCAVATION OF AN EARLY MINOAN
(PLATES I-2)
THIS report is concerned with the excavation of an Early Minoan tholos tomb
Kyriaki in the Ayiofarango, one of the river systems which gives out on to t
west of Kaloi Limenes (FIG. I). Details of the site location (PLATE Ia) can be f
on the Ayiofarango survey,' which, together with this report and one other a
make up the complete report of work undertaken by the authors in the vicin
in the summers of 197 1 and 1972. The excavation of the tholos, which was
there were surface indications that looting was incomplete but possibly to be
in September 1972 in collaboration with Dr. C. Davaras of the Greek Arch
The excavation lasted for a period of three weeks, and was undertaken b
supervisors and ten workmen, directed by the authors.
SUMMARY
The excavations revealed a circular 'tholos' tomb of typical Early Minoan type, with a
complex of four rooms attached to its eastern side. Although the tomb and antechambers had
been almost completely looted, it was possible to establish both the sequence and the
approximate relative dating of the tomb and its antechambers. The tomb and two antechambers
appear to have been constructed in EM I, over the traces of an earlier structure, and the other
antechambers to have been added in EM II and MM IA respectively. In addition to the tomb
complex, a rough enclosure wall was found on the south side of the cemetery area and a large
rough platform of stones between it and the antechambers. Finds from the tomb included a great
deal of pottery (estimated at not less than 1,957 vessels originally), and small quantities of
obsidian, stone bowls, figurines, and other small finds.
1 D. Blackman and K. Branigan, BSA 72 (i977) 13-84. assisting the organization of the expedition. Special thanks
2 D. Blackman and K. Branigan, BSA 70 (I975) 17-36. must go to Dr. H. Catling and Professor P. Warren in this
3 We are grateful to the Greek Archaeological Service andrespect, and to Andones Zidhianakes for considerable help in
to Dr. S. Alexiou for facilitating the excavations, and to obtaining supplies in Iraklion. For the party's accommoda-
Dr. C. Davaras for his willing help and co-operation. Dr. I.tion at Kaloi Limenes we are very much indebted to Mr. J.
Sakellarakis, who discovered the looted tomb in 1965, provided Vardiniyiannis.
much useful information during discussions with him in 1972. The excavation was directed by David Blackman and Keith
For financial assistance we are very grateful to the UniversityBranigan, with the assistance of three site supervisors: Miss P.
of Bristol and the Expeditions Committee of the University. InGreenwood, Miss. P. Williams, and Mr. A. Freedman, all of the
particular, we are pleased to record the encouragement of the Department of Classics, University of Bristol. Miss R. Haigh
Vice-Chancellor, Dr. A. Merrison; of our head of Department, also assisted on the site, and was responsible for the washing and
Professor J. M. Cook; and of Professor Peel and Mr. D. Inglepreliminary sorting of the pottery excavated in October, 197 1.
Smith of the Geography Department. We are also grateful toZacharias Spyridakis, Chief Guard at Phaistos, organized the
the British Academy, the University of Oxford, and the Britishworkmen and assisted in many ways. We should also like to
School of Archaeology at Athens, for further financial assist- record the generosity of the University of Sheffield in providing
ance. The British School must also be thanked for supportinga grant to cover the expenses of a draughtsman, and our thanks
our application for a permit, for providing our staff withare due to Mr. G. Canvin for preparing the illustrations for
accommodation before and after the dig, and for generally publication.
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
2 D. BLACKMAN AND K. BRANIGAN
IERAPT
MALI
03
KNOS
GORTYN
PHAISTO
IKARY.;y
FIG.Central,showigcfAyKkTd-uv17
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
AN EARLY MINOAN THOLOS TOMB AT AYIA KYRIAKI 3
EXCAVATION RESULTS
THE TOMB CHAMBER
Before excavation, the outline of the circular chamber was clear to see, but the centr
chamber was full of large stones, rubble, and soil (level i). It was evident that this was
backfill by the tomb-robbers, or else the disturbed original tumble and fill which they h
pushed behind them as they dug round the interior of the tomb. This impression was co
by the scarcity of finds both within the fill and below it, and it is clear that the tomb chambe
been thoroughly and efficiently looted of its entire contents. In view of the uncertain origin o
fill as found by us, no attempt was made to study the shape and size of the stones within
estimate its volume. (Small finds in disturbed fill: stone bowl fragments 15, 16, 17
figurine 32; obsidian blade 29; clay 'horn' 31.)
The only undisturbed material found was in two small pockets in the floor of the to
one hardened lump of soil containing a base sherd, still adhering to the wall of the tomb
above the floor. The latter presumably indicates the minimum depth of the burial deposi
point, although in tombs such as Kamilari and Koumasa E4 it was noted that burial
tended to be mounded up at the sides of the tomb and lower in the central area. The two
of soil found where the hard floor surface had been loosened containedjust four small sh
dating of all of these items will be commented on below (p. 44).
When cleared the tomb architecture could be studied and recorded in detail. At groun
the tomb was roughly circular with a diameter varying between 4-5 m and 4'7 m; at it
surviving points, the circular shape was disguised by the varying degree of preservatio
tomb had been built by the excavation of a level platform into the hill-slope, to a maxi
depth of I.5 m on its western side. On the east side a thin deposit of the original subso
preserved beneath the lowest course of the tomb wall (PLATE Ib). The first course
consisted of smallish blocks, with dimensions in the range ofo.25 m-o-3 m long and o-2 m
deep (PLATE 2a, b, c). Above this 'foundation' course the next course of stones was very
larger, and the large blocks were often 'framed' by small lumps of stone which fi
interstices between the big blocks (PLATE 2a, b). The uppermost surviving courses inclu
notable proportion of large relatively thin stones, more slab-like in appearance than
4 K. Branigan, The Tombs of Mesara (1970) 107.
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
) 0 METRES 5
TOMB
r
'K(s)
H
(1) Z N
(2) K)
E
A M rock
11 Y
A B E
e P A
FIG. 2. The excavations at Ayia Kyriaki, showing the excavation areas. Room-numbers are given in brackets
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
AN EARLY MINOAN THOLOS TOMB AT AYIA KYRIAKI 5
From the robbers' fill of the tomb (level i), which on balance we believe to be disturbe
material originally in the tomb, rather than subsequently dumped there from elsewhere by th
robbers, came a total of III sherds. These included typical EM I (Ayios Onouphrios, Pyrgo
Salame), EMII (Vasiliki, brown-slipped), EMIII/MMI ('ashtrays', black-washed), MM
(barbotine) and MM IB ('crinkled' rim) sherds, as well as fragments of five EM III/MM I stone
bowls.
5 Blackman and Branigan, BSA 70 (1975) 17-20, fig. 2. 6 For use of the term 'Salame ware', see below, p. 29.
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
6 D. BLACKMAN AND K. BRANIGAN
ROOM 3
To the east of room 5 another small room was formed by the eastward continuation of the
north and south walls of room 5, and by a badly damaged return wall. This room, numbered 3,
measured 2'35 m x o095 m. Its walls were either totally destroyed or else reduced to their
foundation course (PLATE Id). The north wall and about half of the east wall were represented
by only a rubble foundation and three wall-stones still in position at the north-east corner. The
southern end of the east wall was better preserved with substantial foundation-stones in place,
and smaller stones and earth packed into the core of the wall. Its method of construction was
similar to that noted in the south wall, which continued without visible break or butted joint
from the south wall of room 5. It appears, therefore, that the outside walls of rooms 3 and 5 wer
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
AN EARLY MINOAN THOLOS TOMB AT AYIA KYRIAKI 7
o.75
that m
of wide, placed
room 5, beingtowards theofnorth
composed end of
a thinner, its eastlayer
trampled wall. of
The floor
pale greyofsoil.
roomAll 3the
wasdeposits
less solid than
overlying this floor appeared to have been totally disturbed by the tomb-robbers. Below the
floor, the same two deposits of soil were found as have already been described for room 5, and
these deposits formed continuous, pre-tomb strata beneath both of the rooms, and (as noted
later) to the east of them as well. The pottery found in the lowest of these two levels (level 8) has
already been briefly described above.
ROOM 2
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
8 D. BLACKMAN AND K. BRANIGAN
ROOM I
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
AN EARLY MINOAN THOLOS TOMB AT AYIA KYRIAKI 9
AREA A
To the east of area Z (room 2), area A was excavated. Beneath robbers' spoil tipped here fr
excavation of areas to the west and/or north, the modern ground surface (level I) was found t
undisturbed. As this thin layer ofgreyish-brown soil was stripped off, a group of flat slabs of ston
was found in the south-west corner of the area, close to the wall of room 2. Six large slabs
some smaller stones formed a rough 'platform' measuring 1.5 m x I13 m, which appeare
have been deliberately formed rather than to have resulted from the tumble of stones from
east wall of room 2. The four largest slabs, indeed, were all larger than any of the stones use
the walls of room 2. As the surface soil was cleared from the rest of area A, a hard, compa
layer of stony brown earth (level 3) was exposed. The 'platform' was found to rest directly on
level, which we suggest was the original Early Minoan surface at this end of the tomb com
Removing the compacted level, we found it contained seventy-nine sherds, of which seven
certainly EM I (including part of a chalice, and some Ayios Onouphrios I sherds) and five w
EMII (including three from red-washed-on-buff bowls). This surface was therefore lai
earlier than EM II, and the 'platform' was probably, but not certainly, placed in position so
after the surface was laid. Since this area is immediately outside room 2, which we have see
above was constructed no earlier than EM IIA, it is probable that room 2, the surface outsid
and the platform were all part of a single phase of work.
Below the compacted surface material, a deposit of fine, deep yellowish-brown soil (level
was found to continue down to the bedrock. In places this soil was up to 15 cm. deep, an
contained, mostly in its upper part, a good quantity of sherds. Altogether 188 sherds w
recovered from this level, all of them of EM I type. The pottery included plenty of small sher
Ayios Onouphrios I, some black and grey burnished sherds (including a prong handle),
sherds of Salame, EM I wiped, and Pyrgos ware.
At the north end of the area this level was interrupted by a pit, almost I m square. The fil
the pit (level 6) was a fine yellowish-brown soil similar to that of the level into which it was d
but not so deep in colour, and looser in texture. In this deposit a rich collection of material
found, comprising 277 sherds, six obsidian blades (68, 69, 72, 78, 79, 88) and a loom-weight
The sherds were entirely of EM I character where datable, except for a large piece fro
askos(?), and two bowls in Ayios Onouphrios ware, which all seem likely to be of EM II
Apart from many Ayios Onouphrios I sherds, there were many of Pyrgos ware including la
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
IO D. BLACKMAN AND K. BRANIGAN
AREA E
Area Z was excavated to the east of area H (room i). Beneath soil recently deposited b
tomb robbers, tumbled stones from the tomb complex were found. On removal, these we
to overlie a compacted pale brown soil (level I) which provided a surface outside room I
fifty-eight sherds found in this surfacing material in area Z, all thirteen datable piece
EM I. From the sherds found in the level of fine yellowish-brown soil (level 2) be
surfacing and overlying bedrock, there was the rim of a red painted bowl of EM II. Altho
surfacing could date to EM II, therefore, we believe it more likely that the sherds are
and that the surfacing is contemporary with the construction of room I at a later date (f
see p. 48).
AREA M
Area M was excavated to the east of rooms 3 and 5 (area K), initially to see whether fur
chambers lay to the east of these. Although traces of walls were found here they are not ide
as the remains of chambers from the tomb complex, as explained below.
There were extensive robbers' dumps downslope to the east of the tomb and its chambers
when these were removed in area M they revealed the modern ground surface (level 2). Be
the greyish-brown topsoil, a compacted surface of pale brown soil and stones (level 3) exte
eastwards from the east wall of room 3, across area M and a metre into area Y. At the nort
of area M a curving line of four large stones, laid neatly edge to edge, were found set int
surface. Sherds from the topsoil were obviously of little value for dating either the surface
alignment of stones, and only ten sherds were found in the surface make-up. Five of
appeared to be EM I. Many more sherds, however, were found in the greyish-brown soil (
5), which was sealed by the surfacing and which appears to have been deliberately introdu
here to level up the slope before the surfacing was laid. From this deposit came 192 sherds,
EM I-II date including a jug neck of Ayios Onouphrios II ware, and several sherds fro
large storage-jars in the same ware. These suggest that this surfacing, and the line of ston
into it, were put down no earlier than EM II.
When the greyish-brown make-up (level 5) was removed, remains of two further walls ca
light, running more or less parallel to each other, but on a different alignment from bot
tomb chambers and the line of four stones set in the surfacing. One wall, probably o.5 m
survived for a distance ofjust over 2 m, running into the adjacent area Y, and was partly ov
by the curving line of stones. The other wall survived to a length of only I-5 m, but clearly
under the east wall of room 3, and just emerged on the other side of it. Three isolated sto
further east might allow its length to be extended by a further 2"5 m. Neither wall surviv
more than its foundation course, and each was built of smaller stones than those used in t
construction of the facing for the walls of the tomb chambers. Their significance will be dis
below (p. 43).
There was no deposit associated with these walls, and they may well have been la
destroyed in the levelling operation before the surfacing was laid above them.
interpretation of the chronology of rooms 3 and 5 is correct, however, then these walls,
which ran beneath a wall of room 3, must be the earliest walls on the site, and must predat
construction of the tomb. The surviving foundation stones sat on the top of a deep yellow
brown soil (level 6) identical to that found in area A and described above (A, level 7). I
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
AN EARLY MINOAN THOLOS TOMB AT AYIA KYRIAKI II
AREA Y
East of area M and west of area B, area Y was excavated in order to follow the alignme
large stones found in area M. No further stones of the alignment were found here,
underlying wall described above (Area M) was traced into the western edge of the area b
extensive robber disturbance cut right through it. No other archaeological features or d
were found in area Y.
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
12 D. BLACKMAN AND K. BRANIGAN
AREAS FAND N
To the north of rooms 3 and 5 (area K) a
north of area N, an L-shaped area, lab
initial sounding here in 1971 which sugg
area. Area F proved to have very thin to
The EM I sherds found in the surfac
fragmented than most pottery on the s
(p. 50). Area N proved to be very similar
although the surface sherds here were di
area F.
AREAS O AND P
At the extreme south-east edge of the site, robbers' pits in area O suggested an area of possible
interest, and possible wall-stones were noted on the surface at one point. Excavation showe
several groups of tumbled stones, which seem likely to have fallen from the peribolos wall furthe
up the slope to the west. There were no sealed or undisturbed deposits in the area. Area P
between area O and A, proved to be entirely without archaeological deposits, a thin surface soil
overlying a sterile, compacted pale brown subsoil, which itself lay on bedrock.
THE FINDS
The finds are grouped according to the category of object into which they fal
stratified groups or contexts. Most finds were from surface levels or disturbed
found in stratified groups are listed together with other finds in that group i
section on the excavations. Within each category of finds, the individual finds
described and any necessary parallels for them are quoted, and there then follow
a brief discussion of the whole category of finds. Under each individual find, th
listed in the following order: Small find number, illustration reference, nature/f
Material, dimensions in cm. Find spot, and where known, date of find-context
necessary discussion, including typological dating.
STONE OBJECTS
A. Stone Vases
I. FIG. 3, base of a straight-sided cup or dish. Soft, greyish examples of the type (2IA), many of serpen
serpentine; d. 4'9. Area 9, surface. Warren lists forty nearly all from the Mesara.' Probably MM I.
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
AN EARLY MINOAN THOLOS TOMB AT AYIA KYRIAKI 13
11 10
16
30
15
83 26
28
xo. FIG. 3, prong handle of a small cup. Greyish-green exclusively from the Mesara tholoi, and of EM III-MM I
serpentine; 1. 4'5. Area 9, surface. This appears to belong date.10
to Warren's form 17A, I of which Warren records thirty-
28. FIG. 3, fragment, probably from a ladle. Green chlorite
nine examples, mostly from the Mesara and including
schist, with incised herringbone decoration; 1. 3'4. Area
several of this material.s Probably EM III-MM I. E, robbers' pit. The combination of material and decora-
x . FIG. 3, rim of a small bowl or cup. Greenish chlorite- tion identifies this as an EM II vase, but the form it
schist?; d. 9-0. Area K, robbers' spoil. Form uncertain belongs to is uncertain. It does not appear to belong to a
owing to incompleteness, but the material and more pyxis, however, and both the curvature and the axis of the
particularly the decoration of finely incised hatching in decoration in relation to it suggest that it is a rare example
alternating triangles is typical of EM II vases. of a ladle. Warren records just four examples of this type,
15. FIG. 3, rim from a small jar with straight, sloping sides. 23A, two of which are in this same material." This
Dark grey serpentine?; d. 6-5. Tomb, disturbed tumble. fragment may come from the side of a ladle like that from
Probably Warren form 21A, and probably MM I. Platanos, illustrated by Warren,12 and dated to EM II.
i6. FIG. 3, rim of a bowl with rim lug. Purplish steatite; d. 30. FIG. 3, rim of a bowl or cup. Pale grey-green schist?; d. 6-7.
6-8. Tomb, disturbed fill. This belongs to Warren's form Tomb, disturbed fill. Whilst the form is uncertain, the
IoA, of which there are forty-nine recorded examples, material is distinctive. Warren notes the rarity of schist for
including many of steatite.9 The type is relatively scarce Minoan vases, and dates the small group known to
in the Mesara, and dates between late EM II and MM I. EM III-MM I.13 They are all from the Mesara and are
The use ofsteatite might favour a late EM II-III date but usually bowls or cups; our example could be either.
does not preclude a date as late as MM I. 83. FIG. 3, base of a bowl. Deep-greenish serpentine; d. 2-8.
26. FIG. 3, moulded base of a small bowl. Greyish-black Area H, robbers' dump. Possibly from a bowl of Warren's
serpentine; d. 3'9. Area M, surface soil. Warren's form type 8C but this is a very tentative identification. The
32A, of which there are 40 recorded examples, almost material favours an EM III-MM I date.
The nine vase fragments from the excavations correspond fairly well to stone vase groups
the other Mesara tholoi. They range between EM II and MM I, and are all of the smal
types apparently made completely, or almost completely, for funerary use.
8 Ibid. 38. g Ibid. 27-8. 10 Ibid. 78-9. n Ibid. 48-9. 12 Ibid. 49 and P288. 13 Ibid. I37.
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
14 D. BLACKMAN AND K. BRANIGAN
B. Stone Figurines
51. FIG. 4,
32. FIG. 4, top halfofa pebble figurine. a heart-shaped
Pale grey figurine
schist;with a notched
1. 5-0, base. Grey
w. 4-3, th. 2-0. Tomb, disturbed fill. This type of pebble
sandstone; 1. 4"8, w. 5-8, th. s-o. Area H, surface soil.
figurine with a flat profile, tapering This carefully
body shaped,and
flat piece
roughly
of stone is confidently
indicated head was labelled the Pyrgos type,14
identified as a figurine. four
It has no exact parallels, but it
examples of it (made of 'slate') being appears
foundto be a variant
in theof the Ayios Onouphrios type, of
Pyrgos
cave burial deposit. Typologically whichthe type
five examples are belongs
known.15 All of theto five Ayios
EM I, and the finds in the Pyrgos cave Onouphrios
were type figurines
mainly have necks
of and heads, but they
that
period. share with this figurine the rounded shoulders and tiny
legs. In particular the only closely datable example, from
48. FIG. 4, a pebble with a prominent groove on each side. an EM II level in Tomb II at Lebena, has legs represented
Greyish brown sandstone; 1. 7-5, w. 5-8, th. 2-7. Area H, by a small notch in the base, as here.
robbers' dump. We know of no parallels to this piece, and
its identification as a figurine must be in doubt. The two 99. FIG. 4, a naturally shaped stone taking the form of a bull's
grooves which produce the impression of a pair of head. Buff sandstone; 1. 6- I, w. across horns 6-o. Area A,
steatopygous legs, however, have been man-made, and surface soil. There is no certainty that this piece was used
pebble figurines are found in wide variety and consider- as a figurine, but its resemblance to a bull's head is strong,
able numbers in the earlier part of the Aegean Early and natural concreations and shapes were used both in
Bronze Age. Crete and elsewhere as figurines.
None of the four items here listed can be certainly identified as a figurine; but 32 and 51 can be
placed within known categories of Early Minoan figurines, 48 is a deliberately shaped stone with
no obvious functional use, and 99 is distinctively shaped. It is a pity that none of these items was
found in sealed deposits within the tomb complex-a fate they share with almost all of the other
small finds.
98. Large flake or chip from a polished axe. Micro-crystalline x8. Spherical pounder. Hard purplish rock, d. 5-0, ht. 3-7-
pale green rock, indentical with 4; 1. 3.9, w. 4-5. Area Z, Area A, surface soil. Again, the base is marked by signs of
wear.
surface soil. This piece is clearly recognizable from its
shape as well as its surface working, as a piece of 103. Spherical pounder. Buffsandstone, d. 7.5,
greenstone axe. robbers' dump. Badly chipped and dama
surface.
9. FIG. 4, unfinished perforated axe or hammer. Material
identical to that of 4 and 98 above. 1. 1. oo, w. 5-o, depth: o105. Spherical pounder. Material identical to I8; d. 8-3, ht.
6.2. Unfinished shaft-hole 3 x 4. Area e, surface soil. 6.2. Area H, surface soil. Traces of wear on base.
Perforated axes or hammers were used in the Aegean All these four of the spherical pounders here can be broadly
EBA, and examples exist from the Troad, and the compared to the six found in the settlement at Myrtos, made of
mainland, as well as from Crete. A good parallel to this similar materials.19
piece was found at Ayia Triadha.'n
o102. Cylindrical pounder or pestle. Grey limestone; d. 5-0, 1.
73. FIG. 4, perforated weight? Soft grey limestone; oval, d. 8-2 7.5. Area A, surface soil.
x 9-o(?). Perforation: 2"5 narrowing to 0o5. Area ', level 90. FIG. 4, small pestle? Hard, dark green pebbles held
2: Minoan surfacing make-up, EMI-early EMII. together by a calcareous concretion; ht. 2-6, 1. 3- I. Area T,
Warren found an identical weight in the EM II settlement surface soil. This is a natural product, but the polished
at Myrtos."1 surfaces of the pebbles, and the concave wear on the
calcareous material suggest that it has been used as a
54. FIG. 4, perforated weight? unfinished. Buff sandstone;
small pestle, perhaps for preparing 'cosmetics'.
oval, d. 8.2 x 12.o(?). Perforation: 3o. Area A, surface
soil. An identical unfinished example was found in the Io4. Elongated rubber. Buff sandstone; 1. 8-2, w. 3-I. Area H,
EM II settlement at Myrtos.s8 level 5. Pre-peribolos wall level, and probably pre-tomb.
14 K. iranlgan, BSA tbbt (1971) b5. (BSA Supp. Vol. 7) (1972) 213, fig. 105-
15 Ibid. 65-7- is Ibid. 222, fig. Io6.
16 C. Zervos, L'Art de la Crlte (1956) pl. 103, 3, left. 19 Ibid. 233-
1" P. Warren, Myrtos: An Early Bronze Age Settlement in Crete
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
AN EARLY MINOAN THOLOS TOMB AT AYIA KYRIAKI 15
74
9
73
54
90
.51
101 -1001
W--48.
99
67
32
FIG. 4. Stone objects from Ayia Kyriaki (1:2)
The context is therefore EM I. Three examples were 1oo. FIG. 4, whetstone? Purplish-red sandstone, I. 4-8, section 4
found at Myrtos, and Warren suggests they were used for x 2.5. Area a, surface soil.
burnishing pottery.20
The collection of stone tools is reminiscent of the collection from Myrtos, but less so of the stone
items usually recorded from the Mesara tholoi. To some extent this reflects the early excavators'
20 Ibid. 235, fig. I02, n. 198. 21 Ibid. 236, fig. I03, n. 202.
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
16 D. BLACKMAN AND K. BRANIGAN
D. Beads
84. Disc or quoit bead. Steatite; d. 0o9. Area H, surface found, suggesting that the robbers had set out to recover
clearance. This simple type of bead was found in quantity all complete small items such as beads and sealstones, and
(over sooo) in tholos A at Platanos. Their scarcity on our perhaps all fragments of gold. Apart from this one bead,
site may be explained by the heaps of sieved earth that we no such small items were found by us.
E. Chipped Stone
The chipped stone from the excavations comprised sixty-six pieces of obsidian (thirty of which
came from stratified deposits), a small flake of flint, and a core of chert. The core ofchert and the
flake of flint might be thought indicative of working on the site, but in the absence of any other
ddbitage this view cannot be supported.
The obsidian assemblage (FIG. 5) is similar to many others of the Aegean EBA, containing
mainly parallel-sided prismatic blades, represented by proximal, medial, and distal fragments,
as described and defined by Torrence.23 All the blades were incomplete and must be presumed to
have been utilized before deposition, particularly in view of the absence of cores, flakes, or
ddbitage. The only flake of obsidian found (No. 88d) had probably been utilized. It seems clear,
therefore, that obsidian found on the cemetery site had been manufactured into blades elsewhere
and subsequently brought to the site. It may also have been used elsewhere before being
transported to the cemetery. Some of the obsidian, at least, can be shown to have belonged to
domestic occupation debris, for some of the blades were found in A7, which is an EM I pre-tomb
level. It is certainly possible that other obsidian blades, particularly those sealed beneath the
EM II surfacing, also came from pre-tomb levels originally, although this cannot be proved. The
stratified groups and their dating are as follows:
i. Blade 57, found sealed beneath the floor of the ante- 4. Blades 13(2), 14, 19, 20, 22, found in the floor make-up of
chamber, level K8. EM I, pre-tomb. room 2, level Z4. EMI-IIA.
2. Blades 76, 77, 81, 87 found in the pre-tomb deposit, A7.
EM I, pre-tomb. 5. Blades 35, 36, 52, 58, 59, 6o found in the make-up of the
surfacing outside room 3, level M5. EM I-II.
3. Blades 68, 69, 72, 78, 79, 88a-f, found in the pit, A6.
Mainly EM I material but one EMII askos, and strati- 6. Blade 49, found in the tumble of the peribolos wall, level
graphically EM I-IIA. T2. Post EM IIA, probably MM.
22 e.g., Kalathiana: S. Xanthoudides, The Vaulted Tombs ofCycladic Prehistory ('979) 67-8, fig. I. We should like to take
Mesara (1924) pl. XLVI, '35' and 1351a. this opportunity to thank Robin Torrence for discussing the
23 R. Torrence in J. Davis and J. Cherry (eds.), Papers in obsidian corpus with us.
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
AN EARLY MINOAN THOLOS TOMB AT AYIA KYRIAKI 17
0 5
cms.
88f
88c
88e
88b 88d
72 88a
78 79 68
69
13 19
- 13 14 20
35
81 22
76 77 36
87
57
58
60 49
59 7
2 8
6
12
52 39
37
33 42
47
44
45 50 64
23
40 65
29
38
43
24 34.
93
94
86 96
bb 80 85
95 55
71
70 75
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
I8 D. BLACKMAN AND K. BRANIGAN
METAL OBJECTS
97. Part of a small finger-ring. Copper or bronze. d. 2.0. Area
two examples of EBA date are known from Zygouries and
M, surface soil. This ring, of flat section, belongsSamos,
to so that this example could belong anywhere in the
period EM II-MM I.
Branigan's type 4, of which two are known from MM
Knossos. The type is not common in the Aegean EBA, but
CLAY OBJECTS
A. Weights
behind peribolos wall. The context is EM I-II. The form
63. FIG. 6, hemispherical spindle-whorl. Red clay with traces
of pale brown slip; d. 4-5, ht. 2-6. Area A, level 6: pre-
is comparable to that of some clay weights from Myrtos
tomb pit. The context is EM I. Several similar examples
which Warren identified as spindle-whorls rather than
found in the EM II settlement at Myrtos.24 loom-weights.25 This example, albeit incomplete, is larger
than any of Warren's spindle-whorl group, and may be
89. FIG. 6, truncated conical loom-weight. Coarse grey better
clay. compared with two cylindrical loom-weights from
the same
d. 4-8, ht. 5-2 (incomplete). Area H7, level 4, packing settlement.26
B. Figurines
61. FIG. 6, zoomorphic handle or projection from a vase? certainly a third example of the type represented by 61
Gritty, buff clay, traces of red paint; two small holes at and g91.
point where the 'ears' are broken off; 1. 6-2, w. 30. Area P, I. FIG. 6, two joining fragments of a 'plaque' figurine. Pale
surface soil.
buff, smooth clay, with red painted decoration in the form
of zones of chevrons on one side and hatched triangles on
9I. FIG. 6, zoomorphic handle or projection from a vase?
Gritty, buff clay, red paint around the base of the the other; 1. 5-8, w. 5-1. Area A, surface soil; Area II,
robbers' dump. There are no Minoan or Aegean paral-
'nose', and on one ear; 1. 4"4, w. 3-2. Area A, surface
soil.
lels to this item known to us. Its fabric and the decorative
motifs, however, are common amongst the pottery from
Io6. FIG. 6, fragment of a similar zoomorphic figure? Red clay; the site and there is no doubt that it is a local product,
1. 3"7, w. 2"9. Area 17, robbers' dump. This piece is not probably of early EM II date.
The two or three zoomorphic projections almost certainly come from vessels. The curvatur
shows that they were part of larger items originally, and no fragments of possible clay bodies fo
these necks and heads were noted by us. They seem more likely to be projections from jugs or
closed jars, and a general tendency to add plastic zoomorphic decoration to Minoan vases is well
known. The Koumasa tholos cemetery produced several clay jugs or jars with projecting ox
heads,27 and our examples may have come from similar vessels. Other suggestive parallel
include some of the EM I suspension vases from Lebena,28 and a small clay head and neck found
by Warren at Myrtos.29
The plaque figurine is to our knowledge a unique find in the Aegean and immediately recalls
the mid-third millennium schist 'idols' from Iberian burials.30 It must be emphasized, however
that the fabric and decoration are entirely EM I-II, and in our present state of knowledge it is
best to interpret this piece as a variant of the general Aegean family of flat figurines of EB I-II. I
should also be said that the item may have fulfilled some function other than as a figurine.
C. Various
56. FIG. 6, circular clay counter. Buff fabric, with fine pale of counter or gaming-piece; Warren found eighteen small
brown slip, lightly burnished; d. 5-0. Area T, surface soil. triangular clay counters cut from pottery vessels at
The fabric is probably EM II. It is presumably some sort Myrtos.31
24 P. Warren, Myrtos fig. 99, nos. 149-5I, 156. 28 S. Alexiou, ILN (6 Aug. 198o0) figs. 9, 14.
25 Ibid. 228-9, fig. Ioo. 29 Warren, Myrtos fig. 95, n. 5.
26 Ibid. 220-I, fig. 96, nos. 83-4. 30 H. Savory, Spain and Portugual (1968) pl. 19.
31 Warren, Myrtos 217-18, fig. 107.
s' Xanthoudides, op. cit. pl. XX, 4140, 4141 .
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
AN EARLY MINOAN THOLOS TOMB AT AYIA KYRIAKI 19
56
89 )61
63
91 106
82
FIG. 6. Clay objects from Ayia Kyriaki (I:I)
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
20 D. BLACKMAN AND K. BRANIGAN
THE POTTERY
Stratified Groups
All the principal stratified groups from the site are described even though in some cases the
material was too fragmentary to allow worthwhile illustration of the pieces. The groups are
described in the chronological order of their deposition.
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
AN EARLY MINOAN THOLOS TOMB AT AYIA KYRIAKI 21
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
22 D. BLACKMAN AND K. BRANIGAN
A31[
All
A6
A51
C12
A41
A2
v4d
B111 C151
"-B7
C13N
B9
-Bl rB81
Dl1 4D17
RI E231
E221
44
,6-
E26
'El8 E20
E21l
F281
_F27/
F31A
F341 bd
F301 F291
F32
a
36
G38[ SG371
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
AN EARLY MINOAN THOLOS TOMB AT AYIA KYRIAKI 23
illustration. A 'Pyrgos' chalice rim and the neck of a jar (C12) were in
and the Ayios Onouphrios ware included an EM I collared jar rim
the base of a jug in a red fabric with a thick red slip and vertical white
style is referred to as Lebena Ware); we believe it to be EM I by reaso
deposited shortly before the level was sealed in tomb phase 2B includ
EM II cup with a black wash on a hard brownish-red fabric, and a lar
(C15) .
E. Fill ofpit A6; not later than the beginning of phase 2B. Level A6 (FIG. 7, E18-26)
Most of the 277 sherds in this pit were small, and about half were black, grey, and reddish-
brown coarse wares. The pit was sealed by the surfacing put down in phase 2B, but it could have
been dug and filled before this event, possibly during the first phase of tomb use (2A). The fact
that no recognizable layer of soil or trample accumulated over it before the 2B surfacing was laid
does, however, suggest that it was dug shortly before the surfacing was put down. This does not
preclude the possibility that many of the sherds in the deposit came from the earlier levels
into which the pit was dug. The soil in the pit was very similar to that of the level into which
it intruded (A7); this and the large quantity of small sherds (only 18% of the sherds were
large enough to merit individual recordings) both suggest that much of the material may be
residual.
This is unlikely to be true, however, of the substantial pieces of seven vessels from the deposit,
which are illustrated. The chalice stems, E18-2o, the first two in brown burnished fabrics and
the third in black, are paralleled in the Pyrgos and Kanli Kastelli deposits, and are found a
Phaistos too in pre-palatial levels (Pyrgos, figs. 8 and Io; Kanli Kastelli pl.I A, fig. 1.5; Festos P. II,
pl. 14c). The chalice base with horizontal grooves (E2x, and another identical) in blac
burnished fabric is a type well represented in the Pyrgos deposit too, and although Myrto
produced chalice stems of similar type, the fabrics here are plainly EM I. There were eight large
sherds from the bowls of other Pyrgos chalices in the deposit. Ayios Onouphrios ware, we
represented amongst the small sherds in the deposit, included recognizable pieces from EM I
jugs and jars with vertical stripes, and fragments of collared jar necks like E22. Most of these
sherds were in a buff to pinkish fabric with small grits, often with a thin white to pinkish surface
33 Warren, Myrtos 269-71.
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
24 D. BLACKMAN AND K. BRANIGAN
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
AN EARLY MINOAN THOLOS TOMB AT AYIA KYRIAKI 25
G. Make-up of the surfacing laid down in phase 2B. Levels A3, M3, 14 (F
The phase 2B surfacing was traced across three trenches and from its
136 sherds, from which five profiles are illustrated. Most of the mate
I and 2A, but it is possible that some later material became incorp
deposit by treading in, during phases 2B-2D.
Pottery from the earlier phases on the site included 5 sherds of EM
with red painted decoration on a white or pinkish wash, and 4 sherds
including two Pyrgos chalice rims. A two-handled jar in the EM I
(G35) is a well-known EM I shape and its lattice decoration should not
EM II date. One sherd of brown burnished, and three of grey burnish
EM I or EM II, and there were 4 sherds of Ayios Onouphrios ware in
on buff slip fabric of EM II, including a spouted bowl (G36). Also of E
in an orange fabric with red slip (G37), and two carinated cups or gobl
brown wash (G38). The latest sherds, perhaps, were four of orange
metallic blackish-brown wash, one of which came from a handled cup
were found in the phase II levels at Myrtos (Myrtos fig. 64), and these
from post-surfacing phases on our site.
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
26 D. BLACKMAN AND K. BRANIGAN
K411
Vt~391 t4o4
S42j L431
kL44 k46
~L45~
L47
L481
L. Tomb clearance, disturbed but materialfrom original tomb fill? Tomb, Level I (FIG. 8, L43-8)
Although we cannot be certain, we believe that the I I I sherds recovered in the robbers' fill
the tomb came originally from the burial deposits in the tomb. They certainly include a wid
variety of fabrics covering the whole period of the cemetery's usage. EM I material included tw
red slipped and burnished sherds (Salame), one straw-wiped, three pattern burnish, one black
burnished, and five Ayios Onouphrios including a base and a body sherd from EM Ijugs. EM I
was represented by two grey-burnished, including an eared lid (possibly EM I, L43), tw
Vasiliki, and an Ayios Onouphrios cup in buff slipped ware with dark brown paint. Two red-
slipped on hard buff fabric sherds were probably EM II, and two sherds of red-to-black wash o
buff fabric pieces could be EM II-III. Two further sherds possibly of EM III were from fl
based jugs with a black wash and white painted vertical lines. There were fourteen fragments
MM I 'ashtrays', many with one or two horizontal bands in white paint on a red or black was
(L44, 45). Pieces of later MM I date may include six sherds from cups recorded as wheel-made
covered with a black wash, and sherds from at least two vessels with barbotine decoration. On
of these, L48, also had a crinkle rim, and white and red paint spots decorating the lower half, an
appears to be of MM IB date. Two cup rims are of uncertain date but both L46 painted with a
brown band on a deep bufffabric, and L47, covered with a flaky brown wash, are thought m
likely to be of MM I date.
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
AN EARLY MINOAN THOLOS TOMB AT AYIA KYRIAKI 27
Although it was not possible to establish a type fabric series and assign all sh
other of these fabrics, we were able to look in detail at eighteen different war
may have included more than one fabric; some certainly included several). Two
pottery, however, did not fall into these categories of wares and are left as 'un
sherds belonged to coarse plain wares in the main-buff (FIG. 9, 9- I1), red (FIG.
(FIG. 9, 5) and grey (FIG. 9, 4)-but also included a small number of plain buff b
(FIG. 9, 33-4). Although no detailed analysis of these 'unclassified' sherds was u
estimate that about 50 per cent of the whole pottery assemblage consisted of p
sherds, but some of these may have come from undecorated parts of Ayios On
wares. Plain red and brown wares are estimated each to account for about 5 per c
assemblage and plain grey and buff burnished wares each to account for 2-3 per
The following description and discussion is concerned mainly with the remaining
the pottery assemblage, except that the totals of different forms include vessels
well as classified wares.
The wares are each described in turn below, in approximately chronological order, a brief and
general description of the fabrics being followed by description of surface treatment and
decorative motifs. The principal forms associated with each ware are then indicated, the type
forms being shown in FIG. 14 and there numbered Ci-x4 (cups), Bx-x2 (bowls and dishes), JI-9
(jars), and Si-9 (jugs and teapots). Other forms occur very rarely and are specifically mentioned
as they arise. The main forms shown in FIG. 14 are general classifications within which there are
several minor variations. At present there is no standard type form series for Early Minoan
pottery and this series presented here may prove useful to future excavators, although it will
certainly need to be extended-particularly for pottery assemblages coming from domestic as
opposed to funerary sites.
Wiped ware. Red or brown rather soft and coarse fabric with surface marked by all-over wiping
with cloth or grass. The ware is found in Late Neolithic and EMI levels at Knossos. No
recognizable forms in our deposits, but large jars suggested by curvature of sherds.
Black gritty ware (FIG. 9, 1-3). Although a plain ware, this was quite a distinctive type fabric on
this site, dark brown or black with plenty of white and yellowish grits, with no surface treatment
or decoration. Used for cup Ci, bowl Bi, and for several lids.
Pyrgos ware (FIG. IO, 52-9). We use this term for all pattern-burnished sherds. These occur on
our site mainly in brown and black fabrics but occasionally in buff and grey fabrics. Burnishing
has been applied differentially to produce lattice decoration, alternating bands of burnished
and unburnished, vertical stripes, and (very rarely) chevrons. By far the commonest form is the
chalice Ci, but other forms include C4, B5 (without handles), Bxo, BxoA, J3 and J8.
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
28 D. BLACKMAN AND K. BRANIGAN
L2
3s
1
I4
5 8
17
6
112
9 11o
11
13 14
J15
16
17 18
19 ]20 21
22-
123K 124\ 26
(25
27 281 ,29-
30
132 133
131
135 36
34
140
L38j 39
37
FIG. 9. Unstratified pottery from Ayia Kyriaki. I -3 Black Gritty; 4-1 I Coarse Plain wares; 12-14 Cooking-pot; 15-18 Red/Brown
slipped ware; 19-32 Black burnished; 33-5 Grey burnished. 36-40 Red slipped and burnished (Salame) (1:4)
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
AN EARLY MINOAN THOLOS TOMB AT AYIA KYRIAKI 29
Dark burnished ware (FIG. 9, 19-32). This ware includes all plain
surface colour of brown to black. The fabrics are generally gritty or
Forms are remarkably varied: Ci, 2, 4, 10, ii; B3, 6, 8, 9, 1o and IoA;
these forms are distinctively EM I (e.g. Ci, B9, J3, and SI); but other
EM II shapes and suggest that some plain dark-burnished wares su
that period.
Grey burnished ware (FIG. 9, 33-5; 10, 41-5, 47). The fabric varies from rather coarse and sandy
to fine and hard, and the burnish from a smooth all-over burnishing to the striated burnish
typical of straw-burnishing. The shapes are mainly cups (CI, 3, 4) and bowls (BI, 8, 9, io), but
the ware is occasionally used for a jar (J3) and for small lids. The forms are a mixture of EM I
(CI, B9, J3) and EMII (B8), and it seems certain that the ware was used in both phases. This
is true at Knossos, and Warren has demonstrated that grey burnished ware was in use in EM IIA
at several sites.35 The bowl B9 looks somewhat out of place in an Early Minoan context and the
coarser, straw-burnished variety of grey burnished ware may well span at least the Final
Neolithic and EM I. Grey burnished ware is certainly found in neolithic levels at Phaistos and is
identified as Final Neolithic by Vagnetti and Belli.36
Salame ware (FIG. 9, 36-40). This is the term proposed by Branigan to designate red slipped
and burnished ware, which on our site occurs in a red-to-orange, rather soft fabric with few grits.
It appears in forms CI, Bi, B6, J4, J6, J8 and for spherical pyxides. Only J4 is a distinctive
EM I form, and it is likely that Salame ware covers both EM I and EMIIA periods. It is
presumably superseded in EM II by red and brown slipped ware, often made in a similar fabric
but never found with burnishing.
Lebena ware (FIG. IO, 71-4). It was proposed by Branigan in 1970 that this term be applied
to the early white-painted-on-red ware found at Lebena in the EM I levels. The fabric on our
site varies from orange to buff, medium hard and fine, with a thick, even slip. The paint is
usually thick, even white or off-white in colour. The ware is not common on the site, and
occurs in a limited range of forms-C6 (without handle), J3, J5, J7, and as both lids and
spherical pyxides.
Ayios Onouphrios I ware (FIGS. IO, 77-92; I I, 93-5; 12, 132, 135-9). The division of Ayios
Onouphrios ware into two classes was proposed by Schachermeyr in I962,37 although the
variety of fabrics, paints, and decorative motifs included under this general heading was
recognized long ago. Schachermeyr's earlier type (which he proposed to call Lebena ware) was
characterized by red painted decoration, as opposed to the brown paint of the second type. To
some extent this difference does seem to be important, but fabric and surface treatment also seem
to be important criteria to consider. From our observation of the various forms associated with
the differing Ayios Onouphrios fabrics, and also from the admittedly limited evidence of our
stratified groups, we would suggest that Ayios Onouphrios I ware be broadly defined as follows.
The fabric varies in colour from pale buff to orange-pink or reddish-buff, often with small
brown and red grits. The surface is sometimes left plain or slightly smoothed, but often has a thin
wash of white or pinkish white paint. Over this, the decoration is applied in a matt red paint,
either washy or thick and even. Occasionally the paint is a dark red, close to the browns
characteristic of Ayios Onouphrios II. Decorative motifs are predominantly vertical and
horizontal lines, the former mainly on the body and the latter on the neck and shoulders, but
chevrons, zigzags, and hatched triangles are found on the necks of collared jars, and suspension
5 Warren, Myrtos 269-71. (1978) 128.
36 L. Vagnetti and P. Belli, Studi miceni ed egeo-anatolici 19 37 F. Schachermeyr, Arch. Anzeiger 77 (i962) 105-
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
30 D. BLACKMAN AND K. BRANIGAN
41
42 143 44
45
49
A48
147
461
50 51
53' 54
52
591
58
571
55 61
r561 162
60
64 66
165
L63-
67
169 170
68
a71j
741
J61
J31 75
172
801
79
177 78
821 83 841 85
81
86 87l
88
901 911
89 92
FIG. IO. Unstratified pottery from Ayia Kyriaki. 41-5, 47 Grey burnished; 46, 48-51 Incised Grey; 52-9 Pyrgos; 60-3 Dark-wash
ware; 64- 70 Urfinis; 7 -4 White-on-red (Lebena); 75-6 'Ash-tray' ware; 77-92 Ayios Onouphrios I (1:4)
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
AN EARLY MINOAN THOLOS TOMB AT AYIA KYRIAKI 31
951
,931
94
961 98
97
99
101
100
102 104;
103
107
1051
106
1101
1081
109
113
1111
112
116
115
114
1181 119r
117i
FIG. I I. Unstratified pottery from Ayia Kyriaki. 93-5 Ayios Onouphrios I; 96- I 19 Ayios Onouphrios II (1:4)
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
32 D. BLACKMAN AND K. BRANIGAN
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
AN EARLY MINOAN THOLOS TOMB AT AYIA KYRIAKI 33
122
120
j31i
127
1231 1!241
j2r5
126
J129
128
1311
130
132 133
_1341
135
139
136
137 138
140c
141
142
,145
143
144 146
147
148 149"
1501 151
FIG. 12. Unstratified pottery from Ayia Kyriaki. 120-3 I, 133-4, 140-51 Ayios Onouphrios II; 132, 135- 9 Ayios Onouphrios I (1:4)
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
34 D. BLACKMAN AND K. BRANIGAN
1531
152
156
158
1541
157
155
1161
160
159
165 166
163
162 1644
1671
168"
169
170
174
1171
1172
175
173
182
4183 '184
"179 180 '181
FIG. 13. Unstratified pottery from Ayia Kyriaki. 152-6 Ayios Onouphrios II; 157-63 Vasiliki; 164-6 White-on-black (Gournia);
167-8 Polychrome; 169-72 Pedestal bowls; 173 Large bowl; 174 Double-vase; 175 Crucible(?); 176-90 'Ash-tray' ware (1:4)
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
AN EARLY MINOAN THOLOS TOMB AT AYIA KYRIAKI 35
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
36 D. BLACKMAN AND K. BRANIGAN
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
AN EARLY MINOAN THOLOS TOMB AT AYIA KYRIAKI 37
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
38 D. BLACKMAN AND K. BRANIGAN
Fabric/Ware % Fabric/Ware %
Red-brown unburnished 23-0 Red-wash ware 2.0
Dark, unburnished 19,7 Dark-wash ware 7.8
Vasiliki, Pseudo-Vasiliki I8-2 Vasiliki ware 3T5
Dark-on-light 12-8 Ayios Onouphrios II 63.4
Cooking-pot (two fabrics) 13-8 Cooking-pot ware 2-o0
Red-brown burnished 7"9 Red/Brown slipped ware 2-7
Grey burnished 2.6 Grey burnished and Fine Grey ware 5-6
Ivory burnished 20o Buff burnished 13To
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
AN EARLY MINOAN THOLOS TOMB AT AYIA KYRIAKI 39
4 6
2 3
5 9
1 FORMS
7 7A" 8 12 C
10"
13
11 1
14 5
10 BORMS
2 3 6 B
11
9 8
4
12
7
1 2 5
4
6
3 7 8 9
FORMS J"
1 2
3 4
9
FORMS S
8
7
FIG. 14. A chart of pottery forms found in the Ayia Kyriaki excavations. Forms C cups; forms B bowls; formsJ jars; forms S spouted
jugs (not to scale)
fabrics overlap these boundaries. It can be taken only as a very general indication of changing
preferences in the funerary use of vessel forms.
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
40 D. BLACKMAN AND K. BRANIGAN
CupCI 50 JarsJI 7
C2 30 J2 9
C3 69 J3 34
C4 59 J4 2
C5 21 J5 I
C6 12 J6 iI
C7/7A 490 J7 13
C8 39 J8 Io
C9 3 J9 32
Cio 25
CIi II Total jars 119
CI2 228
C13 3 Jugs SI 54
CI4 18 S2 28
S3 85
Total cups I,o58 S4 27
S5 Io4
Bowls BI 27 S6 2
B2 14 S7 67
B3 19 S8 I
B4 6 S9 2
B5 24 Askoi 2
B6 47
B7 15 Total jugs 372
B8 18 Others 207
B9 3
BIo/IoA 22
BiI 3
BI2 3
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
AN EARLY MINOAN THOLOS TOMB AT AYIA KYRIAKI 41
(i) Ayios Onouphrios II cups of form CIo with slightly concave shoulders, and painted
decoration above the shoulder of alternating triangles filled with cross-hatching and chequer-
board patterns. All are in a pale yellow-buff fabric with smoothed surface and decorated in a
reddish-brown paint. See e.g. FIG. 12, 12I. There were four examples of this distinctive type.
(2) Vasiliki ware cups. All were in eastern Vasiliki ware fabric, and six cups had rim
diameters of 7-o, 7-4, 7-6, 8-6, 8-8, and 8-8. This may be too great a range to signify semi-specialis
production in a single workshop.
47 Dr. Peacock and Professor Renfrew have recently begun a 49 Xanthoudides, Vaulted Tombs pl. xxvib, nos. 4o09, 4112,
programme of analyses on prehistoric Aegean pottery. 4113, 4114. A. Zoes, op. cit., especially pls. I 1-17.
48 D. Levi, Festos i * (Incunabula Graeca 60) (1976) fig. 275, 50 Cf. Levi, figs. 252, 275, and i* plates, pl. 12 b, g, h.
row 2, centre.
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
42 D. BLACKMAN AND K. BRANIGAN
There are three topics which require interpretation and discussion, and th
the following order: history and development of the site; evidence for ritual
with the Minoan tomb complex; and the social and economic implications of
history.
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
AN EARLY MINOAN THOLOS TOMB AT AYIA KYRIAKI 43
I. Pre-tomb Occupation
The only structural remains of the pre-tomb phase a
foundations found in areas M and Y, the southern one of w
room 3, which is itself identified as part of the original tom
these foundations, and levels A 7 and H5 are in turn associate
deposits, pit A6 is sealed by the trampled surface outside r
Its pottery places it almost certainly in EM I, but it could be
than to pre-tomb occupation. There are also levels K6, 7,
anterooms 3 and 5, and therefore pre-tomb in date. The na
use of the site is not certain; but on balance it appears
occupation of some kind. The scant structural remains could
or a small ossuary like those of the EM period in north
destroyed to allow of worthwhile discussion. It is perhap
different alignment to the overlying tomb chamber. The pr
tomb use of the site is the discovery of stone tools in the pr
A7 was a whetstone and in 175 a sandstone rubber (104).
whorl, whilst from surfacing laid down early in EM II cam
(73), and a whetstone (74). One is tempted to suggest also th
might also belong to this pre-tomb occupation, since it is dif
use of the tomb. Even excluding these, however, it remains t
functional tools or items of clay and stone were found eith
EM I-II mixed material which formed the make-up of the e
ritual objects from the site-stone vases, sea-shells, and figu
came from such levels. This surely suggests, though it does
tools-other than the obsidian blades-were brought to th
possible to suggest ritual usage for some of these ston
Whetstones are certainly found in several tholos assemblag
those published are fine specimens, usually with one or two
ceremonial or symbolic; our examples in contrast are plain
be used for pounding materials to make cosmetics for ri
below, p. 53), but the signs of wear on ours suggest heavier d
serve a symbolic function as grave-goods,52 but whereas this
products of specialist craftsmen it is much less so for an item
(54), which is more simply explained by assuming it was be
might recall that in our brief discussion of the stone tool as
that from the settlement of Myrtos and its marked differences
With all these considerations in mind, we suggest that befor
small domestic structure stood on the site, associated w
weaving, and no doubt with farming. It remains possible that
ritual deposit dating to the time of the tomb's construction
The date of the pre-tomb occupation is indicated by two g
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
44 D. BLACKMAN AND K. BRANIGAN
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
AN EARLY MINOAN THOLOS TOMB AT AYIA KYRIAKI 45
12
, -1
3-
-1
1
2
3-u
C
3
3
PLATFORM
N
PERIBOLOS
WALL
, metres 5
FIG. 15. The tomb complex at Ayia Kyriaki, as excavated in 1972. Features of phase I (pre-tomb) are shaded horizontally. Hatched
stones in the peribolos wall are stones stood on end
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
46 D. BLACKMAN AND K. BRANIGAN
deposits, pottery, and other artefacts--suggests that the tombs were never finished. As they stan
so close to the tomb complex of W6, their history must in some way be related, and they can most
plausibly be placed either at the beginning of the tomb complex's history, or at the end ofit. That
is, they can be either interpreted as an initial pair of tombs whose construction was abandoned
and replaced by that of the excavated complex, or else they can be seen as tombs intended to
replace the full, and possibly collapsing W6 tomb in MM I. In the survey report we inclined
slightly in favour of the late date, on the basis of the style of wall-build, which was compared
with the walls of EM III-MM I tombs such as Kamilari I and III, and E22 (Ayios Andonios) in
our survey. We are now less inclined to accept the wall-build as a useful indication of a late date
of construction. Where, as here, only the foundation course of stone survives, then it is misleading
to compare it with the wall-build of tombs which survive to a greater height. In our own tomb,
and in EioA in the survey area,55 we noted that the bottom course of stones was often of smal
squarish blocks, such as we see in the foundation course of W6A and B, and used for upper
courses too in many of the later tombs. The only remaining clue to the date of the conjoined
tombs (if we ignore the one EM I/II sherd and eight EM coarse sherds found around the tombs,
which could have arrived here from the W6 complex) is the peculiar conjoined plan itself. The
only parallel to this construction in Crete is Lebena tombs II and IIA, tomb II of which was built
in EM I and tomb IIA added in EMIIA. On balance, therefore, we would slightly favour
placing our two conjoined tholoi at the start of the site's history as a cemetery. It should be noted
that the complex of rooms outside the excavated tholos is an almost exact parallel to the four
rooms found outside Lebena II and IIA. Why the tombs were first to be built further up the
slope, and why they were abandoned at an early stage of construction and the new site adopted is
uncertain.
54 Blackman and Branigan, BSA 72 (1977) 56-8, fig. 28.55 Ibid. 39.
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
AN EARLY MINOAN THOLOS TOMB AT AYIA KYRIAKI 47
SITE W6A/B
0 METRES 5
FIG. 16. The unfinished double tholoi just west of the Ayia Kyr
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
48 D. BLACKMAN AND K. BRANIGAN
than the building of the tomb and the first two outer chambe
built later than EM IIA, since the small surviving area of depo
piece of Fine Gey ware and Ayios Onouphrios sherds probabl
EM II. From the first, the room possessed a 'bench' alongside
hard, compacted floor ran. Outside the room, a roughly le
ing over areas A, M, 7I, and Z. There is no stratigraphic evid
time with the building of room 2, but the evidence of th
recovered from the surfacing material and its make-up in all
tent. Most of the pottery was of EM I date, but there were a
each area.
Features associated with this surfacing are not closely datable, but for various reasons th
most likely to have been constructed soon after the surfacing was laid, rather than later in
C. The peribolos wall was constructed after the surfacing was laid, since towards its easte
the surfacing was cut back to allow for the curve of the wall. Running as it does towards
south-east corner of room 2, it would appear to have been constructed to delineate the ed
the cemetery area at the time when room 2 was in use, but room I was not yet built.
therefore be attributed to phase B. The platform, which fills the gap between the end of
peribolos wall and the corner of room 2, is similarly attributable to phase B, on the ground
if it were built in phase C then it would form an impediment (though not a total barrier) to
to the newly built room; this would be an unlikely, though not impossible, arrangement. F
the alignment of stones found along the northern edge of area M, set into the top of the surfacin
is attributed to phase B only on the grounds that they appear to have no function other th
delimit the cemetery or ritual area in the same way as does the peribolos wall on the far side
surfacing. They do not resemble the peribolos wall in construction, and they may well ne
have supported any superstructure (wall) at all. Nevertheless, they seem more likely to be p
the enclosure or demarcation work of phase B rather than to be associated with the constru
of room I with which they could have no possible functional connection.
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
AN EARLY MINOAN THOLOS TOMB AT AYIA KYRIAKI 49
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
50 D. BLACKMAN AND K. BRANIGAN
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
AN EARLY MINOAN THOLOS TOMB AT AYIA KYRIAKI 51
58 Ibid. 164-5.
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
52 D. BLACKMAN AND K. BRANIGAN
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
AN EARLY MINOAN THOLOS TOMB AT AYIA KYRIAKI 53
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
54 D. BLACKMAN AND K. BRANIGAN
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
AN EARLY MINOAN THOLOS TOMB AT AYIA KYRIAKI 55
There is no direct evidence from the excavations for the subsistence economy of th
group who utilized the site in the EBA, although some light may be thrown on it in t
discussion of social organization. Similarly, the limited evidence for the economics
may be more conveniently discussed in the context of social organization.
It has long been considered likely that the Mesara tholoi were the tombs of clans
extended families, and it is not intended to repeat the arguments and evidenc
survey in the Ayiofarango supported this thesis, and suggested that in this catchme
was possible to identify tentatively the territories occupied by the clans in the val
which included a peak sanctuary, a tholos cemetery, a spring, and settlement
suggested pattern of settlement is seen in FIG. 17, where it can be seen that the A
tholos, site W6, has three farmsteads ascribed to it (sites E5, E2o, and W7). In the a
skeletal remains from the tholos, and in view of the probability that the ceramic asse
the tomb is incomplete owing to looting, it may be possible to use these survey da
approximate estimate of the size of the population group using the tomb, and of t
burials originally made at this cemetery. We believe the tomb complex was in use f
period of between 8oo and 900 years, but that its use was slight and intermittent f
century or so of its existence; effectively, its period of regular use was between 700 a
If it was serving the needs of three nuclear families occupying the three EM farmste
we would expect a total number of burials each century of about 6o, each family c
five burials per generation of twenty-five years.73 The total number of burials mad
during its period of use might thus have been 420 to 480, to which must be added a
for the declining numbers in its last century of usage. A final total of between 450 a
might be envisaged, made by three nuclear families, each of five or six persons, whi
formed a clan or extended family. We might compare this estimate of the total numb
in the tomb, with that which we can make from the suggested 'burial assemblage' of
cups, ajug and either a bowl orjar, with each burial (above, p. 51). On this basis,
of the remaining unlooted pottery suggests a minimum of about 320 to 370 burials
of bowls/jars and jugs).
There is nothing in the size or construction of the tomb to imply that its constru
have needed a larger labour-force than that which three families could provide. All
71 Summarized, ibid. 128-31 . 73 J. Bintliff, ibid. 83-4-
72 Blackman and Branigan, BSA 72 (i977) 65-72.
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
56 D. BLACKMAN AND K. BRANIGAN
E 24
E 25
E 18
E 17
OW 7
OW 2
E 12
E 10 11
OW 3 E74
E9
13
E57
AYIOFARANGO E. B. A.
Tholos
E4
W6
E 4A
Tholos reported
W7
W8
E 20
Peak sanctuary
ditto probable
ditto possible
Settlement
COPPdga H Farmstead
W 11
Spring
Arable
E 22
KMS
FIG. 17. Early Minoan settlement in the Ayiofarango. The tholos of Ayia Kyriaki is Site W6
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
AN EARLY MINOAN THOLOS TOMB AT AYIA KYRIAKI 57
materials are available nearby, and the largest stones used could be
using levers.
The families which used the cemetery at Ayia Kyriaki must be presumed also to have utilized
the small, discrete areas of cultivable land on the edge of which their houses were built. The
alluvial deposit at Ayia Kyriaki itself was by far the richest of these arable areas, but all were
small and totalled a maximum potential acreage of 8o acres (32 ha). Due to the poor quality of
the land, a maximum of 4o acres (16 ha) might be sown in any one year, so that the three families
might produce over 300 bushels of grain and 600 litres ofoil. Rather less than halfof this would be
needed for domestic consumption,74 so that if the arable was utilized to its maximum potential,
in good years there would be a sizable surplus. It is, of course, very unlikely that maximum
exploitation was achieved or even sought, but it remains likely that the population unit using the
Ayia Kyriaki tholos could produce a surplus of grain and olives in most years. In addition, sheep
and goats may have contributed to the surplus, and certainly contributed to the subsistence diet.
Copper may have been acquired locally from the source I km to the south-east, and clay for
pottery manufacture could be found elsewhere in the valley. Whether the copper and clay
sources of the valley were for common use or were the property of those clans within whose
territory they fell, is unknown. The economic relationship between the clan groups in the valley
is thus uncertain. Beyond the valley, however, exchange must have taken place to procure at
least some of the pottery which we are convinced was imported from the plain of the Mesara and
beyond (above, pp. 41-2), as well as other items. From the excavations, the obsidian and at least
some of the stone vases stand out as obvious imports, and it was presumably to acquire such
goods that the agricultural surplus was used.
There is much more that could have been discussed had our excavations found an unlooted
tholos rather than a disturbed and looted one. One looks to the publication of the Lebena th
and the future discovery and excavation of further tholos tombs in the region to throw furt
light on society, economics, and ritual in the Early Bronze Age of southern Crete. We believ
however, that our work at Ayia Kyriaki has demonstrated that even looted tholoi can provi
valuable information and new insights, if they can be totally excavated with a view not just
recovering artefacts, but to establishing the nature and history of their construction and use,
their relationship to surrounding, contemporary sites.
D. BLACKMAN
K. BRANIGAN
74 J. Bintliff, BSA 72 (1977) 28.
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
B.S.A. 77PLATE 1
(d)
(b)
E20
-4A
BMOTSLHNAIYREFVCX
)dnuorgef(2m,tl5siac3R
W6
;tsaEgnikol,ImR)c(2bhrNeMyd6WTKA
W8
(c)
(a)
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
PLATE 2 B.S.A. 77
(a) (b)
(c) (d)
This content downloaded from 176.232.215.172 on Thu, 26 Mar 2020 23:48:02 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms