Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2008 Pandey Et Al MT MGR
2008 Pandey Et Al MT MGR
DOI 10.1007/s11001-008-9057-6
Abstract The effects of the ocean coast on magnetotelluric industrial onshore–offshore MT experiments presently
(MT) data have been studied and results are described in being carried out to explore its hydrocarbon potential, our
this article. MT soundings from various sites along coastal results have an important bearing on designing and acqui-
plains of Kachchh were acquired where volcanic rocks sition of future MT surveys in this region.
overlie Mesozoic sediments having potential resource
prospects. The region of our study lies in the proximity of Keywords Magnetotelluric Deccan traps Coast effect
Gulf of Kachchh and Arabian Sea. This article describes the
effects the presence of a conductive body on the acquired
MT data. With the help of synthetic MT modelling and Introduction
induction arrows we demonstrate the influence of shallow
conductive body on the MT data. The modelling results Kachchh, is the westernmost extension of the Deccan traps
when compared to the field observations show that much of of India, bounded by Arabian Sea and Gulf of Kachchh.
the high frequencies are unaffected by the coast, however The shallow (*50 m) coastal waters separate Kachchh
low frequencies of the data do seem to be distorted by mainland from the Saurashtra peninsula, in the south.
onshore–offshore resistivity contrasts. The least affect on Kachchh evolved as marginal pericontinental basin of
high frequencies can be attributed to very shallow water western India and has major structures trending from
depth as well as to the fact that the onshore–offshore NW-SE to E-W directions (Fig. 1). The dominant tectonic
resistivity contrasts are not large enough to influence the features include NW-SE to E-W trending faults namely:
high frequency data badly. The results presented here report Kachchh Mainland Fault (KMF), Katrol Hill Fault (KHF)
for the first time the effect of the coast on the analysis on etc (Fig. 1). Broadly the regional stratigraphy of Kachchh
MT data from Kachchh. Due to several academic as well as can be divided into four major parts. Massive lava flows at
the Cretaceous-Tertiary boundary divide the Mesozoic and
Quaternary sediments. The Mesozoic rocks, which range
D. Pandey from Middle Jurassic to Lower Cretaceous occur conspi-
Bullard Laboratories, University of Cambridge, Madingley
cuously in various major uplifts (Biswas 1987) residing
Road, Cambridge CB3 0EZ, UK
above Precambrian basement. The basement rocks are
D. Pandey (&) M. Sinha exposed in the northern parts near KMF and generally dip
SOES, National Oceanography Centre, Southampton SO14 3ZH, southward towards the coast. The ‘‘Median High’’ is a
UK
pronounced structural feature that divides the depositional
e-mail: dyp@noc.soton.ac.uk
pattern within the Kachchh basin (Biswas 1982). The
L. MacGregor coastal regions are covered with Recent sediments
Offshore Hydrocarbon Mapping Plc., Aberdeen AB23 8GD, UK (*0.5 km) underlain by basaltic rocks. Seismic imaging of
Mesozoic sediments (lower seismic velocity rocks) in
S. Singh
Laboratoire de Géosciences Marines, IPG Paris 4 Place Jussieu, Kachchh having prominent hydrocarbon potential has been
75252 Paris Cedex 05, France a challenging task due to variable basaltic cover (higher
123
Mar Geophys Res
H
(solid triangles). The solid circle Major/minor faults N
corresponds to the drill well. L
I G
VI
A
The induction log from this well Suthari well N
GO
MT stations D
was incorporated in this study.
H
DI
23.5 F A U
Geographical north (pointing L T
F
upwards on this map) was
N
A
chosen as the X-axis for the MT
U
L
I A
data acquisition. The gray
T
KATROL HILL FAULT
Latitude (deg)
dashed thin/thick lines Jakhau
E D
correspond to minor/major NAIRA RIVER FAULT
faults in the region, respectively
Line1_003
M
Line1_002
Line1_001
23.0
Mandvi Mundra
Line2_001 Line2_003
Line2_002 Line2_004
India Ara
bian chh
Sea ach
t
lif
K
of
Up
lf
Gu
ar
iaw
th
Ka
22.5
68.5 69.0 69.5 70.0 70.5
Longitude (deg)
seismic velocity rocks) above. On the other hand, good The MT method utlizes naturally occurring electro-
resistivity contrasts can be expected between the Mesozoic magnetic energy to determine electrical resistivity
strata comprising of sandstones/shales and the overlying variations within the sub-surface. The broad spectrum
basaltic extrusives. The parametric wells drilled in the available for MT studies offers one to choose desired fre-
region confirm such observations (Fig. 3). Therefore quency ranges depending upon the depths of interests.
employing MT method, which utilizes sub-surface resis- Using MT to investigate deeper parts of the crust would
tivity distributions, for resource exploration in this case mean acquiring long period MT data. However, since
may offer an alternative solution to sub-basalt imaging southern part of Kachchh lies very close to the Arabian sea
problem. as well as Gulf of Kachchh, it is vital to evaluate the effect
Apart from exploratory focus, Kachchh, has a history of of the coastal conductive body on the MT data. In this
repeated tectonism in the past. One of the most devastating article we examine the coast effect on the MT data from
earthquake in India (Bhuj Earthquake, January 26, 2001; southern Kachchh and aim to provide a benchmark for
Mw = 7.7) and its aftershocks were concentrated in the future MT data acquisition in this region.
zone of intersection of the regional thrust faults (Mainland
Fault—Fig. 1) and associated minor faults. This significant
activity invited global attention from geoscientists to study Data acquisition
an intra-plate earthquake (Bodin and Horton 2004; Bilham
et al. 2003; Mandal and Johnston 2006; Mandal 2006). Magnetotelluric soundings were carried out in Kachchh as
Ever since, several geophysical studies (standalone as well shown in Fig. 1 (solid triangles) along Line 1 and Line 2.
as integrated experiments) have been initiated (Mishra There are three stations along Line 1 (orthogonal to the coast
et al. 2005; Gupta et al. 2001). Based on seismological line) and four along Line 2 (parallel to the coast line). The
studies (Bodin and Horton 2004; Mandal and Johnston X-axis during this acquisition was chosen in the geographic
2006) the focal depth *22 km of the main event and its North-South (N-S) direction whereas the East-West (E-W)
aftershocks extending through the entire lower crust, direction was defined as the Y-axis. A five component MT
indicate its nucleation within the lower crust. However recording system was used to record three magnetic field
causes of such stress concentration in this zone are still components Hx, Hy and Hz along the X, Y and Z axes and two
elusive and underline the need to study its tectonic electric field components Ex and Ey along X and Y, respec-
framework using multiple geophysical approach. Thus, tively. Data were recorded in single station mode over a wide
there exists a growing tectonic as well as prospective period range (0.001–1000 s). Induction log from a borehole
research interest in Kachchh (particularly southern part) for along Line 1 was also available and is shown in Fig. 3. The
detailed geophysical investigations. resistivity-depth profile from the induction log clearly
123
Mar Geophys Res
demarcates four major stratigraphic sub-divisions. Near- MT impedance. The Groom–Bailey’s method assumes
surface conductive sediments are underlain by high resis- two-dimensionality for the undistorted impedance. Distor-
tivity basaltic rocks. It is further evident that thick tion may be expressed by a simple real tensor operated to
sedimentary sequences prior to the basaltic eruptions reside the impedance in general. This method models observed
above the basement rocks. Later, the borehole location was impedance tensor (Zobs) in terms of distortion parameters
treated as an individual site for computing synthetic MT twist (T), shear (S) angles and regional 2D impedance
response for modelling purpose. The borehole data were tensor (Z2D) as follows,
smoothed over an interval of 3 m before computing its Zobs ¼ RðhÞTSZ2D RT ðhÞ ð1Þ
synthetic MT response. The following section describes the
basic MT data processing which was carried out to obtain the where R(h) is a rotation matrix with angle h, as geoelectric
apparent resistivity and phase curves for each site. strike direction. This factorization allows separation of
determinable distortions in terms of twist and shear angles
from the observed impedance tensor. The limiting values of
Elementary data processing twist and shear angles is ±45°. The distortion parameters
twist (T), shear (S), the geoelectric strike and the regional
The time-series data were processed using built-in software impedance tensor (Z2D) are estimated using statistical
package (PROCMT) along with the field instrument. The approach by fitting the observed impedance tensor with the
elementary data processing included computation of MT decomposition model. In order to obtain consistent estimates
impedance curves from the observed spectra. Further, the of the geoelectric strike direction in this study, GB decom-
Groom–Bailey (GB) decomposition (Groom and Bailey position with unconstrained twist and shear parameters was
1989) for possible distortions (Fig. 2) and subsequent used. During the decomposition process impedances were
rotation of the impedance curves were performed. The GB rotated to minimize the diagonal components. A fairly stable
decomposition was used to determine the geoelectric strike twist and shear values at most frequencies were obtained
direction as well as to estimate distortion effects from the (Fig. 2). Despite using twist and shear values to constrain the
Fig. 2 MT response curves for Apparent Resistivity (GB) Line1_003 Phase (GB) Line1_003
site Line1_003 after GB
decomposition. The XY (circles) 90
0
0
2 1 0 -1 -2 -3 2 1 0 -1 -2 -3
LOG Frequency (Hz) LOG Frequency (Hz)
45
-45
-90
2 1 0 -1 -2 -3
LOG Frequency (Hz)
123
Mar Geophys Res
decomposition processes, the data however, could not reveal Electrical resistivity (ohm-m)
a consistent strike direction at most of the sites. The lack of a 1 10 100 1000
0
consistent, frequency independent strike direction and very
low twist and shear values were attributed to the possibility
200
of reasonably simple sub-surface. An in-depth description of
Groom–Bailey decomposition of the data is provided in 400
Pandey (2003).
Another important issue associated with MT method is that 600
the non-inductive galvanic disturbances (due to surficial
bodies lying smaller than high frequency skin depth) can cause 800
serious interpretational errors. These frequency independent
distortions result in parallel offset between the apparent 1000
Depth(m)
complete a viable interpretation of MT data as it would affect
1400
the estimation of ‘true’ resistivity and depth values after
inversion of the data. It can be overcome by applying shallow
1600
probing methods to estimate the near surface resistivity and
then appropriate adjustment of the short period end of curves 1800
to that value. Commonly, the near surface information from
other complementary studies (such as resistivity, TEM, 2000
borehole data) may be utilized to correct the responses against
possible static shift. In present scenario, apparent resistivity 2200
data obtained after the GB analysis for the two orthogonal
components were examined for possible static shift. Synthetic 2400
MT response using resistivity-depth variations from borehole
data (Fig. 3) were obtained and used for static shift determi- 2600
123
Mar Geophys Res
arrows in such cases are highly useful as diagnostic tool to analyse such effects (e.g. Raval et al. 1981; Menvielle
detect possible distortions in the data. The real induction et al. 1982; Santos et al. 2001). At a given location, the
arrows for all the sites in this survey are plotted for low coast effect can be primarily visualised by the induction
(0.05 Hz) and high (80 Hz) frequencies on a regional tec- arrows (Parkinson 1959). In present study, the low fre-
tonic map and are shown in Fig. 4. For plotting these quency induction arrows (Fig. 4) point towards the coast
arrows, standard Parkinson’s convention (Parkinson 1959) suggesting the influence of the conductive sea water. Fur-
are used where arrows point towards the current concen- ther, 2D finite element modelling (Wannamaker et al.
tration. At high frequencies (smaller skin depths), 1987) was carried out to obtain synthetic data and to
induction arrows do not show any preferred direction and examine possible coast effect on the observed field data.
have smaller magnitudes. The low frequency (larger skin
depths) induction arrows on the other hand indicate strong
alignment towards the coastal water suggesting the effect Synthetic MT modelling
of the sea-land boundary at all MT sites.
Since there was not much prior information available
regarding electrical resistivity-depth structure in this
Coast effect estimation region, we used previously published structural informa-
tion (using seismic, gravity as well as borehole data) in
Conventionally, the term ‘coast effect’ was used to association with the available induction log data (Mishra
describe the effect of induced currents flowing along land/ et al. 2005; Pandey 2003) to construct the resistivity-depth
ocean boundary on the real induction arrows. In case of model for the present study. A hypothetical 2D ocean-land
strong conductivity discontinuities between a land-ocean model used for the coast effect study is shown in Table 1
boundary, the amount of induced currents flowing along and Fig. 5. The ocean was modelled using constant con-
this interface would be altered. This leads to the modifi- ductivity and a gradual increase in depth away from the
cation of vertical magnetic field distribution in the region coast. The shallow continental resistivity model was con-
and hence distortion in the data. In observations on-land, structed using nearby well data (Fig. 3). In general, a
this effect is observed mainly in the vertical component, seaward dip in sub-surface layers is incorporated which is
since the anomalous currents do not remain beneath the site consistent with the local geology of the region (Biswas
but are deflected in the near surface conductive region 1982).
(Dosso and Meng 1992). Subsequently, coast effect in MT In present study, MT sites were chosen along 2D
data were observed where the onshore electric field transacts. Since there are very few MT stations in this
(orthogonal to the coast line) was enhanced because of the study, a 2D modelling was considered to be robust for
mismatch in the conductivities of the ocean and land (e.g. evaluating the coast effect. MT sites along Line 1 were
Beamish et al. 2002, Menvielle et al. 1982; Raval et al. projected onto an orthogonal straight line to construct a 2D
1981; Dosso and Meng 1992; Santos et al. 2001; Padilha model through these sites. The drill well is also considered
et al. 2002). Depending upon the conductivity contrasts as an additional site in this 2D model. The 2D resistivity-
across such an interface, the electric field component depth model was used to compute the MT response curves
perpendicular to the coast would be modified. The electric with the forward modelling algorithm described by
field discontinuity results in a significant distortion effect Wannamaker et al. (1987). The GB decomposed apparent
on the landward side of the boundary. Such distortions in resistivity and phase data acquired from different sites
magnetotelluric prospecting are caused by anomalous field along the profile were used to compare with the synthetic
variations due to the concentration of induced currents in response of the 2D model. For the 2D resistivity-depth
the ocean where the conductivity is generally higher than model shown in Table 1, the X axis was orthogonal to the
the surrounding coastal rocks. Oceanic influences on coast line (SW-NE). It is usually assumed that the con-
onshore MT data depend on the distance of the MT sites ductivity of sea-water may be considered constant when
are from the coast, and the frequencies used for sounding. compared with the large variations in geological conduc-
Steep coasts and water depths (contributing to the con- tivity (Beamish et al. 2002). The shallow sea on the left
ductance) close to the MT sites may cause severe hand side of the MT sites was introduced into this 2D
distortions in the data because of the coastal sediments and model with a gradual seaward increase in water depth with
land conductivity contrasts. q = 0.25 X-m. Standard bathymetric maps (ETOPO2)
Estimation of such effects and appropriate corrections, if provided information on the sea water depth near the coast.
required, are therefore essential before further processing. Landward, a four layered model was constructed whereas
Since first observed in Australia (Parkinson 1959), oceanward a very shallow conductive sea water layer is
numerous case studies have been made worldwide to underlain by the layered structure (Table 1). Since the
123
Mar Geophys Res
G H
have smaller magnitude with no I N
L
VI
fixed alignment. However, at A
H I
23.6
N
GO
low frequency (0.05 Hz) they D
are strongly aligned towards the F A U
DI
L T
23.4
F
sea suggesting a possible ocean
A
U
coast effect
L
KATROL HILL FAULT
A N
23.2 NAIRA RIVER FAULT
Lin
e1
D I
Latitude (deg)
Line1_003
Line1_002
Line1_001
M E
23.0 2 3 4
00 _00 _00
2_ 2 2
ne ne ine h
Li Li
Line2_001 L
hch
of Kac
22.8 Line 2 G ulf
22.6
22.4
Arabian Sea
plift
war U
22.2 Kathia
68.0 68.2 68.4 68.6 68.8 69.0 69.2 69.4 69.6 69.8 70.0 70.2 70.4
Longitude (deg)
23.8 M
A
I N G H
L
VI
A
H I
23.6
N
GO
D
F A U
DI
L T
23.4
F
A
U
L
A N
Line1_003
Line1_002
Line1_001
M E
23.0 2 3 4
00 _00 _00
2_ 2 2
ne ne ine
Line2_001 Li Li L chh
fK ach
22.8 Line 2 Gu lf o
22.6
22.4
Arabian Sea
plift
war U
22.2 Kathia
68.0 68.2 68.4 68.6 68.8 69.0 69.2 69.4 69.6 69.8 70.0 70.2 70.4
Longitude (deg)
123
Mar Geophys Res
Table 1 Parameters used in 2D ocean-coast model for synthetic MT observed field responses. This particular line was chosen
modelling mainly for two reasons: Firstly, the profile was orthogonal
No. Depth Oceanward Landward Remarks to the coast and secondly due to additional constraints on
(km) resistivity resistivity near-surface resistivity variations from borehole data were
(Xm) (Xm) available. The borehole control was very important in
1 0–0.5 0.25 0.5–2 Seawater/ providing the initial resistivity-depth variations of the sub-
sediments surface model. The Line 2 sites however, are parallel to the
2 0.5–1.2 10 10 Basalts coast (i.e. a coastal body could not be incorporated in 2D
3 1.2–2.5 5 5 Mesozoic profile) as well as further seawards. Therefore, any likely
sediments coast effect, if observed along Line 1, would be expected to
4 2.5–10 35 35 Basement contaminate Line 2 data even further. Moreover, a distinct
coast effect is already observed on the larger induction
arrows at these sites. In this situation, Line 1 was consid-
002 003
ered more suitable for the characteristic analysis.
001| well |
0 Sea water
| | Frequencies of interest have been chosen in the same
Quaternary sediments
range as those observed in the field data (200–0.001 Hz).
1000 Basalt
The nearest MT site along Line 1 to the ocean is about
2000 Mesozoic sediments 5 km from the coast. The comparison of forward responses
Ohm-M
with the amplitude and phase data from all these sites along
Depth (METERS)
3000 0.25
0.1 this profile are shown in Fig. 6. Results show that the low
4000 0.5 frequency data (\0.01 Hz) may suffer from coast-effect
Basement 1
5000 2
contamination. The two (XY and YX) apparent resistivity
3 and phase curves for the synthetic data clearly diverge from
6000
5 each other below these frequencies. Similar behaviour in
10
7000
35
the observed data can be seen at low frequencies. At high
8000
frequencies, the synthetic and observed data both seem to
be unaffected by the coast. The coast effect modelling was
9000 METERS
123
Mar Geophys Res
2 1 0 -1 -2 -3 2 1 0 -1 -2 -3
LOG Frequency (Hz) LOG Frequency (Hz)
0 0
2 1 0 -1 -2 -3 2 1 0 -1 -2 -3
LOG Frequency (Hz) LOG Frequency (Hz)
Phase Line1_001 Phase Line1_002
180 180
Modelled (black) Modelled (black)
135 PhsXY 135 PhsXY
Observed (gray) Observed (gray)
PhsYX PhsYX
90 90
PHASE ANGLE (DEG)
45 45
0 0
-45 -45
-90 -90
-135 -135
-180 -180
2 1 0 -1 -2 -3 2 1 0 -1 -2 -3
LOG Frequency (Hz) LOG Frequency (Hz)
Phase Suthari Phase Line1_003
180 180
Modelled (black) Modelled (black)
135 PhsXY 135 PhsXY
Well response (gray) Observed (gray)
PhsYX PhsYX
90 90
PHASE ANGLE (DEG)
45 45
0 0
-45 -45
-90 -90
-135 -135
-180 -180
2 1 0 -1 -2 -3 2 1 0 -1 -2 -3
LOG Frequency (Hz) LOG Frequency (Hz)
123
Mar Geophys Res
impedance curves derived from observed MT data. The Bodin P, Horton S (2004) Source parameters and tectonic implica-
modelled and observed impedance curves were found to be tions of aftershocks of the Mw 7.6 Bhuj earthquake of 26
January 2001. Bull Geol Soc Am 94:818–827
consistent. Dosso HW, Meng ZW (1992) The coast effect response in geomag-
In this study MT data (rotational variants of the response netic field measurements. Phys Earth Planet Sci Inter 70:39–56
curves) were used primarily for shallower targets (such as Groom RW, Bailey RC (1989) Decomposition of magnetotelluric
basalt layer). However, the ocean-coast effect modelling impedance tensors in the presence of local three-dimensional
galvanic distortion. J Geophys Res 94(B2):1913–1925
described here brings out an important concern for future Gupta HK, Harinarayana T, Kousalya M, Mishra DC, Mohan I,
MT data acquisitions in this area. Of late, several inter- Puranachandra Rao N, Raju PS, Rastogi BK, Reddy PR, Sarkar
disciplinary studies (including MT as a component) have D (2001) Bhuj Earthquake of 26th January, 2001. J Geol Soc
been initiated in this region. Therefore, above results allow India 57:275–278
Mandal P (2006) Sedimentary and crustal structure beneath Kachchh
one to carefully select the desired set of frequencies while and Saurashtra regions, Gujrat, India. Phys Earth Planet Inter
MT data acquisition and processing in this region. If 155:286–299
required, appropriate corrections (Santos et al. 2001) Mandal P, Johnston A (2006) Estimation of source parameters for the
should be incorporated during the interpretation of long aftershocks of 2001 Mw 7.7 Bhuj earthquake, India. Pure Appl
Geophys 163:1537–1560
period MT data in this region. Menvielle M, Rossignol JC, Tarits P (1982) The coast effect in terms
of deviated electric currents: A numerical study. Phys Earth
Acknowledgements The authors thank ONGC India for providing Planet Sci Inter 28:118–128
the data as a part of LITHOS consortium at University of Cambridge. Mishra DC, Chandrasekhar DV, Singh B (2005). Tectonics and
DP is grateful to Cambridge Commonwealth Trust, Schlumberger crustal structures related to Bhuj earthquake of January 26, 2001:
Cambridge Research and Darwin College, Cambridge for financial based on gravity and magnetic surveys constrained from seismic
support towards his research. Comments by anonymous reviewers and seismological studies. Tectonophysics 396:195–207
helped to improve the manuscript. Parkinson W (1959) Directions of rapid geomagnetic fluctuations.
Geophys J Royal Astron Soc 2:1–13
Pandey DK (2003) Analyses of seismic and magnetotelluric data from
References Kutch, India. PhD thesis, University of Cambridge
Padilha A, Vitorello I, Brito P (2002) Magnetotelluric soundings
across the Taubate basin, southeast Brazil. Earth Planets Space
Bahr K (1991) Geological noise in magnetotelluric data: a classifi- 54:617–627
cation of distortion types. Phys Earth Planet Sci Inter 60:24–38 Raval U, Weaver J, Dawson T (1981) The ocean-coast effect
Beamish D, Clark TDG, Clarke E, Thomson AWP (2002) Geomag- reexamined. Geophys J Royal Astron Soc 67:115–123
netically induced currents in the UK: geomagnetic variations and Santos FAM, Nolasco M, Almeida EP, Pous J, Mendes-Victor LA
surface electric fields. J Atmos Sol Terr Phys 64:1779–1792 (2001) Coast effects on magnetic and magnetotelluric transfer
Bilham R, Bendick R, Wallace K (2003) Flexture of the Indian plate functions and their correction: application to MT soundings
and intraplate earthquakes. Earth Planet Sci 112:315–329 carried out in SW Iberia. Earth Planet Sci Lett 186:283–295
Biswas SK (1982) Rift basins in western margin of India and their Wannamaker PE, Stodt JA, Rijo L (1987) A stable finite element
hydrocarbon prospects with special reference to Kutch basin. solution for two-dimensional magnetotelluric modelling. Geo-
Am Assoc Pet Geol Bull 66(10):1497–1513 phys J Royal Astron Soc 88:277–296
Biswas SK (1987) Regional tectonic framework, structure and evolu-
tion of the western marginal basins of India. Tectonophysics
135(4):307–327
123