Professional Documents
Culture Documents
7 . I S S U E D E CDEIM
G BE ES RT 2 0 0 2
TECHNO
A GUIDE TO CURRENT TECHNICAL
DIGEST
DEVELOPMENTS
and Operating Pumping Systems (Page 2) / How System Design Affects Life
Cycle Costs (Page 6) / The LCC Comparator and Its Potential (Page 10) /
Tertiary
• Initial investment costs Tertiary Industry sector
Industry
sector 40%
• Installation costs 24%
42% 27%
• Operating costs
• Maintenance costs
• Energy costs Households
Households 29%
• Downtime costs 30%
• Decommissioning /
disposal costs
Industry Tertiary
Customer value
System ary
por
quantitative assessment of productiv- ing Tem ration
sult ope
ity improvements. Any evaluation of Con les
vice Sa
atio
n Ser
the economic benefits of a particular om
e Aut
dul
Mo
technical solution compared with al- Module ing
sult
ternative systems requires reliable data e Con les
rvic Sa
atio
n Se
on the individual cost elements. As far Aut
om
ice
as energy costs are concerned, these Serv
p
Product Pum
might be relatively easy to obtain. The
costs of operation, maintenance, repair KSB competence
and downtimes, as well as the intervals
at which these will be incurred (MTBF, Fig. 3: Competence translates into customer value
MTBR, etc.) are far more difficult to
assess. Modern IT systems used by the
plant owner / operator can be valuable systems. There are many reasons why issue among pump and valve suppliers
tools for generating reliable, statisti- installed systems are not optimized. For and buyers are (Fig. 3):
cally sound data. These tools may be example, system requirements or main-
used to map cost profiles of individual tenance and operating conditions may • Optimum system design
items of equipment in a system, such as have changed over time. Upgrading • Optimum pumps for the
pumps, and evaluate the life cycle cost installed systems with new technology application
of potential improvements. To mention may increase their efficiency. Separate • Technical support by the pump
but one example, the KSB LCC Compa- budgeting for individual areas of a manufacturer
rator uses average values compiled for company often is a major obstacle to • Speed-controlled pumps
various industries for the assessment of implementing suitable LCC measures. • Pumps / valves with additional
cost benefits offered by speed control If maintenance and purchasing budgets, functions (pump as a “system
systems and monitoring. for example, are managed by different monitor”, local intelligence, ...)
units without any coordination whatso- • Modules (pump + control system
ever, the company will not arrive at an + valves+++)
IDENTIFYING COST DRIVERS optimum overall cost solution. If those • Active system integration
in charge of maintenance have a say in • Service activities, incl. teleservice
selecting the quality of the products to etc.
If you can determine the cost incurred be purchased, this will have a decidedly • Financing services
for a particular component in a system, positive effect on future servicing and
you can frequently identify major poten- maintenance costs. There are, of course,
tial for savings. Since pumping systems also cases where the end user “does not COST-EFFICIENT OPERATION OF
may have a life span of up to 20 years, have the money to save money” and as
SPEED-CONTROLLED SYSTEMS
designers and buyers need to consider such is unable to invest in energy-sav-
the overall cost over the equipment’s ing and low-mainte-
lifetime from the start. But it may also nance equipment A detailed analysis of the plant require-
make economic sense for example. Here, ments is one prerequisite. Selecting the
to review existing financing models right pumps, valves, control system,
may be the solution. piping and fittings is another. In pump-
Specific starting points ing systems, the piping diameter plays a
for making life cycle significant role, for instance. Installation
costing an established and operating costs as well as the size of
the components to be purchased are
directly correlated with the pipe size. So
what the end user needs is competent,
LCC-focused advice by the pump and /
or valve supplier.
Using speed control systems will help Energy expenses and longer mainte- remote monitoring (for example, by us-
run pumping systems at or close to BEP. nance or repair intervals frequently ing SMS) in overall service management
Resulting benefits are: offer the greatest scope for minimizing concepts are other options. Last but not
LCC. But where critical or sensitive least, a whole range of financing models
• Energy savings systems are concerned, the need to keep for rehabilitation, retrofit and upgrade
• Longer maintenance intervals production processes going may have projects may be worth exploring.
thanks to reduced loads on the top priority because the cost of lost pro-
pump duction would be unacceptably high. In
• Fewer repairs and lower risk of these cases, additional investments in CONCLUSION
failure monitoring equipment may amortize
• Reduction in downtime costs very quickly.
End users increasingly consider the sav-
Depending on the plant’s overall con- ings potential offered by LCC analysis
figuration, speed control may also help MODULES, SYSTEMS AND SERVICES and base their purchasing decision on
reduce the number of different pump relevant criteria. In the following areas
sizes required. One pump size might, in particular, KSB stands a good chance
for example, be used for different re- The savings achieved with respect to of gaining a competitive edge by empha-
quirements or planned plant extensions. individual components, such as pumps sizing LCC aspects:
Integration of the control system in the and drives, can be aggregated by incor-
pump / motor set (e.g. Hya-Drive) may porating these components in modules • Technical consulting competence
greatly simplify installation and opera- and systems and by optimizing their • Speed control and automation
tion. There are, of course, physical lim- interaction (integral speed control, inte- • Maintenance and other services
its to the cost benefits to be achieved by grated local intelligence, valves, piping, • Modules and systems
speed control, for example in systems monitoring and safety elements).
with low piping losses or high static The following articles highlight some
components. Major LCC reduction potential may of the approaches taken. If you are
also be found in activities offered interested in additional information or
within the scope of maintenance con- practical examples, you can have a look
CONDITION MONITORING tracts or services packages. If these are at the so-called LCC Folder in the KSB
performed by professional service pro- Marketing Database.
INCREASES AVAILABILITY
viders at a lower (variable) cost, plant
owners / operators may cut down on
Additional functions like pump moni- fixed costs. Integrating teleservice or
toring and diagnosis also improve
system availability. They facilitate
low-cost, predictive maintenance and
thus reduce operating costs. Obviously,
evaluation of the signals and data ob-
tained directly from the pump is not in-
tended to compensate for shortcomings
in pump design, but needs to be seen in
the wider context of comprehensive sys-
tem monitoring. Correlating actual data
with the supplier’s know-how regarding
the typical response of pumps and sys-
tems to off-design conditions provides
valuable information, which can be
applied to reduce the above-mentioned
cost elements. KSB’s Pump Expert, for
example, can serve as a “system sen-
sor”. It features standardized hardware
equipped with the interfaces usual to
process control systems. At the heart of
the monitoring unit is a software replete
with expert knowledge.
Proper system design is a prerequisite for low life cycle costs. Pumps and
matched. If these conditions are not met, How System Design Affects
any measures taken to reduce cost can only Life Cycle Costs
have limited effect. The system require-
∑{
E0 QP (t) · HP (t)
diameters selected for the system piping
are of major importance. In pumping
Ce = n·
i–p n
·ρ·g·
ηP · ηM
dt }
systems, therefore, the piping diameter j=1 1+ t0
plays a significant role. The material
100
and installation costs are immediately
Fig. 1: Main energy cost factors
dependent on those diameters and,
hence, on the weight of the individual given load profile determines how the
parts and components. Such attendant pump control works and what the best PIPE
costs as thermal insulation for the com- controlled-operation curve is.
”EFFICIENCY“
ponents cannot be ignored, either. The
chosen diameter directly defines the
velocity of flow for the system’s design ENERGY-COST This unusual approach (Fig. 2) assesses
capacity. Any increase in the size of a the efficiency of a pipe or piping system
PARAMETERS
pipe reduces the velocity of flow and, in its handling of fluids. Dynamic fric-
accordingly, the dynamic pressure drop tion losses are responsible for the head
across the various wetted components. The energy cost formula Ce (Fig. 1) of loss HL. The head loss, in turn, is the
As the pressure loss decreases, so does the pumping system shows the relevant difference between the initial head H1 at
the required system head. A pump with parameters. Taking a closer look at the the beginning of the pipe and the residu-
a lower output rating can be selected. pump’s energy input parameters (Fig. al head H2 at the end of the pipe:
The optimal size of pipe, however, can 1), one notices that: since: HL = H1 - H2
only be found, if the behaviour of all HL = H1 - H2 HL
then: η=1–
system components is duly considered. The discharge head of the pump, HP(t), H1
The system’s pumping performance per which factors proportionally into the The maximum efficiency is reached
se is assessed by first calculating the sys- power input, is a function both of when the dynamic head loss HL has
tem curve for the given dynamic pres- the dynamic head losses of the piping been minimized.
sure losses and static head. Designing and of the consumer requirements.
the system for optimal economy over The smaller the pipe diameter and the The above example (Fig. 3) describes
its entire service life requires additional greater the rate of volume flow that the situation in a cooling water supply
data, e.g., on the distribution of ope- has to pass through it, the greater the system for injection moulding machines
rating cycles at different volume flow percentage of the pump’s power that is in a hypothetical factory. After injec-
rates. This “load profile” is decisive for, expended on flow and friction losses. tion, the mould has to be cooled down
among other things, the selection of the to a specific temperature, and that calls
pump. for a certain amount of cooling water
for each machine. In the given situation,
In many cases, parallel operation of se- a flow pressure of P = 2.0 bar assures
veral pumps is a good choice (Z≥2). The proper cooling. The spent (= warm)
HL = 34 m
The following diagram (Fig. 5) illustra-
tes the situation for a DN 50 pipe. The
pump characteristic curve intersects the
system curve at 54 m. Due to the high
velocity of flow (v~2.3 m/sec), the flow
losses add up to some 34 m (~1340”) of
Fig. 4: Losses for a DN 50 pipe, calculated using KSB Offert
water. Hence, only 37 % of the pump’s
discharge head reaches the consumer as
effective head, while 63 % is devoured Movichrom 15/5 DN 50
by impediments to flow!
Pump/system diagram
90
Since the “effective head” available 80 HL
to the consumer is known to amount ηPipe = 1 –
70 H1
to H2 = 20 m, it is easy to calculate 34
60 ηPIpe = 1 – = 0.37
the hydraulic “conveying efficiency” 54
m of water
DN 80
IN FULL-LOAD OPERATION
50
HL = 4 m
40
A glance at the situation depicted in 30
Fig. 7 shows a plainly altered situation. 20
Increasing the nominal diameter of that PM = 1.76 kW
10 Pump power output
pipe to 80 mm decreases the dynamic
0
losses decidedly. 0 5 10 15 20 25 30
m3/h
The flow resistances drop to about 4 m
Fig. 7: Situation for a DN 80 pipe
of water, the theoretical “conveying ef-
ficiency” of the DN 80 pipe increases to
ηpipe = 0.83, and the pump input power Movichrom 15/5 DN 50, throttled
is a mere 1.76 kW.
Plant 1: (DN 50) PLant 2: (DN 80)
Similar comparative approaches can be is that the system can be expected to mer control valves gain added authority,
taken to closed systems, although the have better hydraulics, with a flat pres- which improves the control action.
fact must be considered that they rare- sure loss profile. Thanks to the lower
ly involve velocities of flow exceeding differential pressures prevailing in the
v = 1 m/sec (with the exception of dis- piping, hydraulic balancing is accordin-
trict heating systems), so the savings gly easy, and the pressure losses in the
are likely to be less spectacular. One balancing valves needn’t be nearly as
positive side effect of a low-loss design high, either. Consequently, the consu-
The two alternatives dealt with above Movichrom 15/5 DN 50, throttled
were calculated on the assumption that
the pump’s entire output is needed by Pump/system diagram
90
the injection moulding machines.
80 HL
ηpipe = 1 –
70 H1
67
DN 50 60 ηpipe = 1 – = 0.07
72
m of water
PM = 2.9 kW
IN PART-LOAD OPERATION 50
(THROTTLED) 40
30
The water pressure downstream of the Fig. 9: Situation for a throttled DN 50 pipe
central throttle valve is accordingly
lower, and the volume flow through
each cooler is reduced by one half. Movichrom 15/5 DN 50, variable speed
In the above case, the desired delivery High energy costs are not an inescapable
rate is achieved - without need of a evil. Often, they are a consequence of
throttle - by continuously variable speed misguided thriftiness. Anyone who, in
adjustment of the pump. Since there is planning and designing a system, con-
no throttle valve to impede the flow, the centrates solely on the initial investment
operating point is now situated at a flow costs of the components, will be amazed
The new LCC-Comp software is a valuable tool that helps sales staff generate
quantitative information on the costs incurred for a pump over its entire life span.
LCC-Comp is based upon empirically established data from various KSB divisions,
AN EFFECTIVE TOOL
with the recognized guide to LCC anal- head H at the operating point, static
ysis developed by Europump and the head and density of the fluid pumped, as TOTAL COST MUCH HIGHER THAN
Hydraulic Institute. At the end of the well as specification of the load profile. INITIAL INVESTMENT COST!
calculation process all results appear in Data on wear-induced losses, varying
the form of graphs and tables. Standard efficiencies for individual pump types LCC-Comp helps the process of deci-
solutions are automatically contrasted and impeller geometries, as well as indi- sion-making by offering cost-saving
with those incorporating frequency vidual load profiles are also included. solutions. The user recognizes at once
control or monitoring. The most eco- CO: that, after some years, investment costs
nomical solution depends on the con- only account for a small proportion
OPERATION COSTS
ditions of each individual installation. of the total cost, and that investment
Additionally, components facilitating All expenses incurred per year during in higher quality products and precise
cost savings are identified. The aim is operation for monitoring and general pump selection does pay for itself. Yet
not merely the determination of the life performance supervision count under the benefits the customer can expect
cycle costs of the pump, but rather the operating costs. from LCC-Comp go much further, as
recognition and implementation of po- the LCC methodology is not just ap-
tential cost savings through considera- CM: plied to pumps alone but rather used
tion of frequency control or monitoring within the scope of a holistic approach
MAINTENANCE AND
systems. Competent technical assistance to facilitate comparable, quantified
regarding the use of seal-less pumps
REPAIR COSTS analyses of entire pump systems.
and the selection of suitable impeller
geometries is also supported by the pro- These expenses comprise on the one
gram. A cost comparison function helps hand the average annual cost for re- CONTROL BY THROTTLING
select the optimum solution from KSB’s placement parts and maintenance, on
diverse portfolio of products. the other all unplanned repair expenses
including the hourly rates for servicing Fixed-speed centrifugal pumps possess
The following inputs are required in staff. hydraulic characteristic curves plot-
order to individually calculate the ting the head H as a function of the
various cost elements CS: flow rate Q. By throttling valves on
the pump’s discharge side, the flow rate
DOWNTIME COSTS
CIC: can be adjusted. This means the flow
This cost element takes into account the resistance rises and the flow volume
INITIAL INVESTMENT COSTS
expenses incurred for production down- changes, dependent as it is upon Q and
As well as the purchase price, the ac- time resulting from pump failure. H. With increasing flow resistance, the
quisition of a pump involves other costs system curve becomes steeper and the
such as those incurred for planning, CENV: intersection between pump and system
tendering, ordering, documentation, curve shifts towards lower pump flow
ENVIRONMENTAL COSTS
testing, freight and purchase order ad- rates. Flow control by throttling always
ministration. Here an average annual value is indicat- results in lower efficiency. Energy is
ed, which covers the expenses incurred wasted, since the surplus head generated
CIN: for the disposal of contaminants, as by the pump is not used by the system
well as for contamination by the fluid but eliminated in the throttle valve. This
INSTALLATION AND
pumped and by auxiliary systems. type of control is only acceptable when
COMMISSIONING COSTS operation under off-design conditions
Default values for all costs for the CD: is limited to short periods or when
connection of the piping and electrical the pump does not run very far off its
DECOMMISSIONING /
equipment, the installation of auxiliary design point. Systems with high static
systems and the alignment of the pump
DISPOSAL COSTS head portions, such as for example
are available in the system. Additional high-level tanks, also tolerate this kind
expenses must be specified by the user. This encompasses the total cost of dis- of control.
mantling pump and auxiliary systems
CE: and the restoration of the local environ-
ment.
ENERGY COSTS
In order to calculate energy costs, the
program simply requires the input of
energy costs per kW/h, flow rate Q and
SPEED CONTROL
COST COMPARISONS
PUMP MONITORING
Low lift pumping stations are mainly used in drainage systems for flood control or ground-
water-lowering as well as in agricultural irrigation setups. They supply the water required for
industrial, water treatment and power plants or are used for municipal applications. The rising
primarily on its life cycle costs. Conventional low lift pumping stations are
usually equipped with tubular casing pumps or submersible motor pumps. Patrik Wagner
Tubular
Casing Pump
14 / 7. ISSUE DECEMBER 2002
PUMPS SYSTEMS
AND
TECHNIK
TECHNO DKOM
I G EPAKT
ST
Fig. 2:
Conventional
design with
tubular casing
pump and
siphon
Fig. 3: Conven-
tional design
with a sub-
mersible pump
in discharge
tube.
7 . 6I S. SAUUES G
DAE CB EE MJ B
UENRI 2 0 0 2 / 15
PUMPS SYSTEMS
TECHNO DKOM
I G EPAKT
ST
AND
teleservice, financing and BOT models, are gaining increasing importance. Stefan Reutter
Failure rate
Breakdown
too late 3
Premature failure, e.g. by:
Premature Period of use Wear and tear - errors of assembly
failures - errors during commissoning
- maintenance errors
- faulty repairs
too soon just right
1 2
first irregularities
Breakdown
too late 3
1 2
o
ith ut PLANT MANAGEMENT MODEL
w
OTHER SERVICES (E.G. SUMP CLEANING) Optimization
of plant
g
m
n
n i i management
o
t o r ALL-INCLUSIVE SERVICE
FUNCTIONAL CHECK
Consultancy
MONITORING service
REPORT Rehabilitation
Predictive concepts
MAINTENANCE SERVICE
with
EMERGENCY SERVICE (24 H)
Financing
schemes
OTHER SERVICES (E.G. SUMP CLEANING)
m
g
n
o
how to record which data, interpret- particular trend, indicating, say, worn service engineer concerned is supplied
ing the data and compiling them in an or damaged parts, persists, the cause(s) with the relevant product details and
easily understood format. The informa- can be analysed by KSB’s pump ex- informed about the suspected failure.
tion compiled can then be placed at the perts, who will then recommend and This allows him to collect the necessary
disposal of the customer himself, the carry out the proper remedial action. replacement parts and tools. Teleservice
service provider or both. It is an essen- Which services in connection with the with an early failure detection system is
tial tool for avoiding operation mistakes teleservice concept should be integrated recommended in those cases where the
and planning the service intervals better. in a service contract is for the customer efficiency of a plant has to be improved,
This in turn substantially increases the and the pump manufacturer to jointly if a plant has a history of defects or if
reliability and availability of the plant decide (Fig. 2). the plant requires a high level of safety.
and at the same time brings down the An all-in service concept should be
costs of repair. To gain the most from included whenever the objective is to
teleservice, telemonitoring must be PRACTICAL APPLICATION secure the availability of a plant in the
followed up by the necessary services. medium or long term. In other words,
OF THE CONCEPT
After concluding a so-called dynamic the amount of service can be tailored to
inspection contract, the plant operator precisely match the needs of the pump
no longer needs to keep his own per- The data of a pump unit are evaluated user according to customer’s specifica-
sonnel ready to deal with a problem. and transmitted. In response to a fault tion or as demanded by the application.
Only when the system detects the first message, the staff of either the service
signs of a technical problem are these provider or the plant operator is alerted
signalled and is it time to take action. depending on the contract particulars.
The necessary service can be provided The message is transmitted by SMS, e-
by an external service company. If a mail or telephone. At the same time, the
On-site Reconditoring of
dismantling wear parts
and re-assembly
Consultancy
service and Engineering
planning of new
installations
Supply ®
management TPM History file
Material Condition
requirements monitoring
planning and Teleservice
management
Operator Flexible
training staffing
6 . A7U. SIGS A
SUBE D E C
ZEMBER 2001
2 / 19
TECHNO DIGEST
and Operating Pumping Systems (Page 2) / How System Design Affects Life
Cycle Costs (Page 6) / The LCC Comparator and Its Potential (Page 10) /
+49 (9241) 71 15 31
Tel.: +49 (9241) 71 19 12
A
TECHNO
GUIDE TO CURRENT TECHNICAL
DIGEST DEVELOPMENTS
TECHNO
A GUIDE TO CURRENT TECHNICAL
DIGEST DEVELOPMENTS
0012.0207 © KSB Aktiengesellschaft • No part of this publication may be reproduced without express permission by the editors.
A GUIDE TO CURRENT TECHNICAL DEVELOPMENTS A GUIDE TO CURRENT TECHNICAL DEVELOPMENTS
0012.0204 20 Technique Compact N° 4
Multimagno Reduces Life Cycle Costs (Page 1) / Va l v e s – Latest Pneumatic E l e c t r i c M o t o r s a n d D r i v e s – Practical Aspects of Inverterfed
Drives (Page 6) / F l u i d D y n a m i c s – Effects of Impeller Geometry on
Actuator Developments (Page 4) / Electric Motors and Drives
Operating Reliability and life Cycle Costs of Waste Water Pumps (Page 10)
– Speed Control Saves Energy
Department:
TECHNO
A GUIDE TO CURRENT TECHNICAL
DIGEST DEVELOPMENTS
TECHNO
A GUIDE TO CURRENT TECHNICAL
DIGEST DEVELOPMENTS
N Building:
Address*:
S
f o r D i a p h r a g m Va l v e s ( P a g e 1 6 )
/ Automation
/ Va l v e s
– The Pump as
Date:
Signature:
*Please complete the address field in full!