Professional Documents
Culture Documents
00
Printed in GreatBritain. © 1993PergamonPressLtd.
Key Word Index--Hydroid genus Millepora; Hydrozoa; growth forms; isoenzymes; electrophoresis;
biochemical systematics.
Abstract--Throe sympatrically occurring forms of colony growth of hydroid Millepora from the shore of
South Vietnam were electrophoretically compared for the products of 21 loci coding for isoenzymes. "Plate-
like" growth form was found to be genetically isolated from "branch-like" and "comb-like" forms which
presumably represent different morphological variants of a single species.
Introduction
Hydroids of the genus Millepora are widely distributed in warm waters of the World
Ocean. They are characterized by high phenotypic plasticity which is supposed by
some authors to be of intraspecific origin (Hickson, 1898; Estalella, 1982). At the same
time, morphological differences including differences in growth form are usually used
as main taxonomic criteria in their systematics (Wood-Jones, 1907; Boschma, 1948;
Weerdt, 1981, 1984). Based on morphological differences, nine species of Millepora are
described for the Indo-Pacific (Boschma, 1948; Zou, 1978).
It is obvious now that numerous problems existing in coral systematics are caused
by some peculiarities of coral proliferation and spreading. Reproduction by fragmenta-
tion is known to be the predominant mode of proliferation and local dissemination in
many coral species, and is not excluded for Millepora (Highsmith, 1982). In such a
situation numerous colonies originating from one parent colony are genetically
identical. In some coral species, however, sexual reproduction may be predominant. In
these cases the colonies originating from sexually produced meiotic planulae are
genetically heterogenous. Species with different modes of reproduction differ in the
genetic structure of their natural populations. Until recently the immunological test of
histocompatibility was used to define the predominant mode of reproduction of the
local coral populations (Hildemann eta/., 1977; Johnston eta/., 1981; Neigel and Avise,
1983). This approach is based on the supposition that two separate colonies are
histocompatible if they are genetically identical (asexual reproduction) and are not
compatible if genetically different (sexual reproduction). However, direct genotyping of
multiple loci coding for enzymes has shown that this supposition is not absolutely
correct (Heyward and Stoddart, 1985; Willis and Ayre, 1985). Such genotype definition
became possible due to the electrophoretic method of isoenzyme analysis. Using
isoenzymes it was shown, for example, that different growth forms of the scleractinian
coral Pavona cactus are intraspecific variants determined by different genotypes (Willis
and Ayre, 1985). The other successful application of isozymes is the discovery of
ameiotic asexually produced planulae in some scleractinian corals (Stoddart, 1983;
Ayre and Resing, 1986). Isozymes were used as genic markers in detailed studies of the
spatial genetic structure of natural populations in the scleractinian coral Pocillopora
damicornis (Stoddart, 1984a, b). It was found that in spite of a planktonic larval stage in
the life cycle of the coral, separate settlements of R damicomis differ from one another
(Received 13 March 1992)
729
730 G.P. MANCHENKO ETAL.
more drastically than the settlements of other invertebrates with planktonic larvae. The
R damicornis settlements of a few hundred metres in length were found to be a
mixture of a few genetic clones. It is obvious that substantial contribution of genetic
clones in the formation of spatial population structure on the one hand and genetic
determination of intraspecific morphological variants on the other, may be the real
cause of numerous taxonomic problems as well as the coral species problem in
general (Braekel, 1977; Veron, 1981).
Sexual reproduction in Millepora is well defined (Boschma, 1956; Eguchi, 1968).
Though reproduction by fragmentation is also not fully excluded, there are some
reasons to think that sexual reproduction predominates in this hydroid (Highsmith,
1982). The problem of taxonomic status of different growth forms of Millepora is about
three and a half centuries old (Boschma, 1948). Here we describe the results of a
comparative electrophoretic study of enzymes in different growth forms of Millepora
from the shore of South Vietnam in order to clarify their systematic interrrelationships.
TABLE 1. ENZYMES STUDIED, GENIC LOCI CODING FOR ISOENZYMES AND ELECTROPHORETIC
CONDITIONS
Electrophoretic
Enzymes Loci* bufferst
*Multiple loci are numbered according to the position of corresponding isoenzymes from anode to
cathode.
l-The composition of buffer systems is given in the text.
GENETICSAND SYSTEMATICSOF MILLEPORA 731
estimates of Nei's indices were calculated using allelic frequencies at polymorphic and monomorphic loci (Nei,
1972).
FIG. 1. DIFFERENT GROWTH FORMS OF MILLEPORA. (A) "Plate-like" (M. plab/phylla); (B) "comb-like" (M. dichotoma); (C)
"branch-like" (114.intricata).
732 G.P. MANCHENKO ETAL
TABLE 2. ALLELE FREQUENCIESAND OBSERVED (Hob) AND EXPECTED (He~) HETEROZYGOSITIESOF GENE LOCI STUDIED IN
THREE GROWTH FORMS OF MILLEPORA: "PLATE-LIKE" (P), "COMB-LIKE" (C) AND "BRANCH-LIKE" (B)
Alleles
Growth
Loci form (N)* 1 2 3 4 5 6 Sst Hob H~×
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
TABLE 2--CONTINUED
Alleles
Growth
Loci form (/V) 1 2 3 4 5 6 Sat Hob H,~
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
B 0.187+0.043 0.208+0.043 52
C 0.107±0,036 0.157:1:0.045 43
P 0.113±0.039 0.165±0,040 45
B, C (pooled) 0.147±0.028 0.183±0.031 48
Calculations are based on the gene products of 21 presumptive loci in "branch-like" (B) and "comb-like"
(C) forms and 20 loci in "plate-like" (P) form.
*The locus is assumed to be polymorphic if the frequency of more common alleles does not exceed
0.95.
other at Sod-1 and Sod-2 loci. Not fixed but significant differences in allele sets and
frequencies of common alleles are observed at many of the loci compared, but are
more pronounced at the Tpep-1 locus when these two groups of growth forms are
compared. Moreover, branch-like and comb-like growth forms express an additional
TPEP locus (Tpep-2) which is absent in the plate-like form. Because the Tpep-1 locus of
the plate-like form and the Tpep-2 locus of the branch-like and comb-like forms have
one allele in common (Table 2), we assumed that the Tpep-2 locus resulted from
duplication of the Tpep-1 locus. However, an opposite situation with the loss of gene
from a pre-existing two-locus TPEP system is also not excluded. The appearance of a
new gene, or the loss of a gene in a pre-existing multilocus enzyme system may serve
as a synapomorphy in a particular lineage and thus be of considerable systematic
value (Buth, 1984).
Obtained results indicate with certainty that the plate-like growth form is genetically
isolated from the branch-like and comb-like forms. The three growth forms of
Millepora fall into two genetically distinct groups (Table 4). The branch-like and comb-
like forms are genetically very similar (•=0.95), whereas the plate-like form is
considerably different from the branch-like ( / = 0.74) and comb-like ( / = 0.77) forms. In
terms of genetic distance and similarity, two groups (one represented by plate-like and
734 G.E MANCHENKO ETAL.
Compared growth
forms* / D
References
Ayala, F. J. (1975) Genetic differentiation during the speciation process. Evol. BIol. 8, 1-78.
Ayala, F. J., Tracey, M., Hedgecock, D. and Richmond, R. (1974) Genetic differentiation during the speciation
process in Drosophila. Evolution 28, 576-592.
GENETICSAND SYSTEMATICSOF MILLEPORA 735
Ayre, D. J. and Resing, J. M. (1986) Sexual and asexual production of planulae in reef corals. Mar. Biol. 90, 187-
190.
Boschma, H. (1948) The species problem in Millepora. Zool. Verh., Leiden 1, 1-115.
Boschma, H. (1956) Millepora and Stylasterina. In Trea~'seon Invertebrate Palaeontology. Part F. Coelenterates
(Moore, R. C. ed.), pp. 90-106. University of Kansas Press, Kansas.
Braekel, W. H. (1977) Corallite variation in Poritesand the species problem in corals. In Proc. 3rdlnt. CoralReef
Syrup. (Miami), Vol. 1, pp. 457-462. Miami.
Bullini, L. (1982) Genetic, ecological and ethological aspects of the speciation process. In Mechanisms of
Specia~bn, pp. 241-264. Allan R. Liss, New York.
Buth, D. G. (1984) The application of electrophoretic data in systematic studies. A. Rev. Ecol. Syst. 15, 501-522.
Chambers, S. M. (1978) An electrophoretically-detected sibling species of Goniobasis floridensis (Megogastro-
poda: Pleuroceridae). Malacologia 17, 157-162.
Eguchi, M. (1968) The Hydrocorals and Scleractinian Corals of Sagami Bay. Collected by His Majesty the
Emperor of Japan. Maruzen, Tokyo.
Estalella, N. M. (1982) Sistematica del genero Millepora (Hydrozoa: Milleporidae) y datos sobre algunos
organismos associados. Poeyana 246, 1-27.
Harris, H. and Hopkinson, D. A. (1976) Handbook of Enzyme Electrophoresis in Human Generics. North-Holland,
Amsterdam.
Heyward, A. J. and Stoddart, J. A. (1985) Genetic structure of two species of Mondpora on a patch reef:
conflicting results from electrophoresis and histocompatibility. Mar. Biol. 85, 117-121.
Hickson, S. J. (1898) On species of genus Millepora: a preliminary communication. Proc, ZooL Soc. Lond. 246-
256.
Highsmith, R. C. (1982) Reproduction by fragmentation in corals. Mar. Ecol. Progr. Ser. 7, 207-226.
Hildemann, W. H., Raison, R. L., Cheung, G., Hull, C. J., Akaka, L. and Okamoto, J. (1977) Immunological
specificity and memory in a scleractinian coral. Nature 270, 219-223.
Johnston, I. S., Jokiel, P. L., Bigger, C. H. and Hildemann, W. H. (1981) The influence of temperature on the
kinetics of allograft reactions in a tropical sponge and a reef coral. Biol. Bull, 160, 280-291.
Manchenko, G. P. and Kulikova, V. I. (1988) Genetic divergence between closely related species of nemerteans.
Isozyme Bull. 21, 193.
Metcalf, R. A., Marlin, J. C. and Whitt, G. S. (1984) Genetics of speciations within the Polistes fuscatus species
complex. J. Hered. 75, 117-120.
Nei, M. (1972) Genetic distance between populations. Am. Nat. 106, 283-292.
Neigel, J. E. and Avise, J. C. (1983) Clonal diversity and population structure in a reef building coral, Acropora
cervicornis: self-recognition analysis and demographic interpretation. Evolution :37, 437-453.
Nevo, E., Belles, A. and Ben-Shlomo, R. (1964) The evolutionary significance of genetic diversity: ecological,
demographic and life history correlates. In Evolutlbnary Dynamics of GeneEc Diversity (Mani, G. S. ed.),
(Lecture Notes in Biomathemadcs), Vol. 53, pp. 13-213. Haifa.
Salmon, M., Ferris, S. D., Johnston, D., Hyatt, G. and Whitt, G. S. (1979) Behavioral and biochemical evidence
for species distinctiveness in the fiddler crabs, Uca speciosa and U. spinicarpa. Evolu~bn 33, 182-191.
Serov, O. L., Korochkin, L. I. and Manchenko, G. P. (1977) Electrophoretic techniques for analysis of isoenzymes.
In Genetics oflsozymes (Beljaev, D. K., ed.), pp. 18-64. Nauka, Moskow [in Russian].
Stoddart, J. A. (1983) Asexual production of planulae in the coral Pocillopora damicomis. Mar. Biol. 76, 279-284.
Stoddart, J. A. (1984a) Genetical structure within populations of the coral Pocillopora damicornis, Mar. BioL 81,
19-30.
Stoddart, J. A. (1984b) Genetic differentiation amongst populations of the coral Pocillopora darnicornis. Coral
Reefs 3, 149-156.
Thorpe, J. P., Beardmore, J. A. and Ryland, J. S. (1978a) Genetic evidence for cryptic speciation in the marine
bryozoan Alcyonidium gela~nosum. Mar. Biol. 49, 27-32.
Thorpe, J. P., Ryland, J. S. and Beardmore, J. A. (1978b) Genetic variation and biochemical systematics in the
marine bryozoan Alcyonidium myt/'l~ Mar. Biol. 49, 343-350.
Veron, J. E. N. (1981) The species concept in "Scleractinia of Eastern Australia". In Proc. 4th Int. Coral Reef
Syrup. (Queson City, Philippines), Vol. 2, pp. 183-188. Manila.
Weerdt, W. H., de (1981) Transplantion experiments within Caribbean Millepora species (Hydrozoa:
Coelenterata) including some ecological observations on growth forms. Bi]dr. Dierk. 51, 1-19.
Weerdt, W. H., de (1964) Taxonomic characters in Caribbean Millepora species (Hydrozoa: Coelenterata). Bijdr.
Dierlc 54, 243-262.
Willis, B. L. and Ayre, D. J. (1985) Asexual reproduction and genetic determination of growth form in the coral
Pavona cactus: biochemical genetic and immunogenetic evidence. Oecologia 65, 516-525.
Wood-Jones, F. (1907) On the growth form and supposed species in corals. Proe, Zool. Soc. Lond. 2, 519-556.
Zou, R.-L. (1978) Studies on the corals of Xisha Islands, Guandong Province, China. 2. The genus Millepora
with the description of a new species. In The Collec~bn of Research ReportS of Ocean Organisms in the
Oceanic Regions of Zhongsha and Xisha Islands, pp. 85--89. Academia Sinica, South China Sea Institute of
Oceanology.