Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The quantitative determination of nucleotides from DNA modiÐed by styrene oxide is described using a com-
bination of inductively coupled plasma high-resolution mass spectrometry (ICP-HRMS) and electrospray ioniza-
tion mass spectrometry (ESI-MS), both interfaced to reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography
(HPLC). LC/ICP-MS (resolution > 1500 to discriminate against 15N16O‘ and 14N16OH‘) was employed to
determine quantitatively the content of modiÐed nucleotides in standard solutions based on the signal of phosphor-
us ; phosphoric acid served as an internal standard. By means of the standard addition technique the sensitivity of
the LC/ESI-MS approach was subsequently determined. Since a comparison of UV, ICP and ESI-MS data sug-
gested that in ESI-MS the ionization efficiency of the adducts is identical within the error limits, quantitative
determination of all adducts is possible. For LC/ESI-MS with single ion monitoring, the detection limit for styrene
oxide adducts of nucleotides was determined to be 20 pg absolute or 14 modiÐed in 108 unmodiÐed nucleotides in a
5 lg DNA sample, which comes close to the best methods available for the detection of chemical modiÐcations in
DNA Copyright ( 1999 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
KEYWORDS : modiÐed nucleotides ; liquid chromatography/electrospray ionization mass spectrometry ; liquid
chromatography/inductively coupled mass spectrometry ; inductively coupled plasma high-resolution mass spectrometry ;
quantitative determination
Copyright ( 1999 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. J. Mass Spectrom. 34, 421È426 (1999)
QUANTITATIVE LC/MS OF NUCLEOTIDES 423
Figure 1. Structures of styrene oxide DNA adducts. The selection represents typical attachment sites : (A) b-SO -N-3 adduct to adenosine
5¾-monophosphate ; (B) a-SO -N-2 adduct to guanosine 5¾-monophosphate ; (C) b-SO -N-3 adduct to cytidine-5¾-monophosphate ; (D)
b-SO -N-3 adduct to uridine-5¾-monophosphate, a deamination modification formed during the reaction. a,b-SO refers to the attachment
site in the styrene oxide moiety.
plete oxidation on the sampler and skimmer surfaces. served as a control for the reproducibility of the mea-
Generally the signals decrease with increasing propor- surements, since they should remain the same in all
tion of methanol, which could result in variations of the measurements. The results of these experiments are
ion source sensitivity. shown in Fig. 4 ; very small signals and signals of com-
The Ðrst step here was to optimize the system based pounds with short half-lives (such as the N-7 adducts of
on the signal-to-noise ratio using an eluent containing guanosine) were omitted from the calculation.
25% methanol because this is the important range for We explain the variations in the slopes [Fig. 4(b)] by
the elution of the modiÐed nucleotides. To determine small errors made during the preparation of the stan-
the inÑuence of the methanol in the eluent correctly, in dard solutions ; since the standard addition is based on
the next experiment we added phosphoric acid 1 ppm the dilution of a solution, small errors may cause signiÐ-
phosphorous) to both solvents at a constant concentra- cant deviations. A comparison of the ICP-MS traces
tion during the analysis time. The signal trace for phos- (m/z 30.97, single ion monitoring), ESI-MS traces
phorus is shown in Fig. 2(a). These data were taken to
calculate the best-Ðtting function, which was used as
correction function for the subsequent experiment. It is
important to note that the signal-to-noise ratio remains
constant since the noise level also decreases.
The validity of this approach was tested in the next
experiment. Repetitive injections of phosphoric acid
(2 ppm P) were made and the correction function was
applied [Fig. 2(b)]. The stability is between 10 and 20%,
which is sufficient for our purposes. This experiment
was included in the analysis routine after every three
runs to compensate for variations and to establish the
long-term stability of the correction function.
To enhance the precision of the measurements
further, at the end of each run 5 ll of a 2 ppm P solu-
tion were injected and the concentrations of adducts
were calculated based on the area of that signal as inter-
nal standard. Typical chromatograms of the [M [ H]~
ions of the four nucleotides are shown in Fig. 3.
For the next step, solutions were prepared with
styrene oxide adducts of each of the three nucleotides
5@-adenosine monophosphate, 5-cytidine mono-
phosphate and 5-guanosine monophosphate separately
and the content of the adducts based on the phosphorus
was determined using ICP-MS. These solutions were
used as standard solutions later. Then a DNA sample
was reacted with styrene oxide and digested to mono-
nucleotides. Aliquots of this mixture were spiked with Figure 2. (A) Data used for the construction of the correction
function. The decrease in signal intensity is accompanied by a
standard solutions and, by means of the standard addi- decrease in baseline noise, resulting in a constant signal-to-noise
tion protocol, the sensitivity of ESI-MS for each adduct ratio. (B) Repetitive injections of phosphoric acid with application
was determined. The signals of the thymine adducts of the correction function.
Copyright ( 1999 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. J. Mass Spectrom. 34, 421È426 (1999)
424 C. SIETHOFF ET AL .
Figure 3. Separation of the four product mixtures of the reaction of styrene oxide with the nucleotides (A) 5¾-cytidine, (B) 5¾-thymidine,
(C) 5¾-adenosine and (D) 5¾-guanosine. The peaks which are quantified based on the internal standard (last peak, 2 ppm) are indicated in
each case. Sources of errors leading to variations in the sensitivity are unresolved peaks, e.g. in the adenine and guanine traces.
Figure 4. Results of the standard addition experiment for the nucleotide adenosine 5¾-monophosphate as an example. (A) ÍM É HËÉ trace
of the mono-adducts. The unresolved doublets 2/3 and 6/7 were jointly quantified, hence the content is higher than the others. (B) Results
of standard addition experiments. The intercepts with the y -axis reflect the concentration of the adducts in DNA incubated with styrene
oxide. The result of the calculation is given in (C). The numbered adducts refer to (1) b-N-1 adduct, (2,3) b-O -phosphates, (4,5) a-O -
phosphates, (6,7) a-N-6 adduct and (8) b-N-6 adduct. A comprehensive account of the structure elucidation will be given elsewhere.25
Copyright ( 1999 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. J. Mass Spectrom. 34, 421È426 (1999)
QUANTITATIVE LC/MS OF NUCLEOTIDES 425
([M [ H]~, single ion monitoring) and UV (254 nm) though, that high-resolution mass spectrometry has to
data for adduct mixture separations supports that be used to avoid interferences.
assumption, since the traces are nearly identical (Fig. 5). As mentioned already, an increasing content of meth-
This was also true for all the other nucleotides, regard- anol in the eluent (see Fig. 2) changes the signal inten-
less of the concentrations. sity during the separation, but we observed no decrease
in instrumental sensitivity. As we have shown for
ESI-MS, the sensitivity for the detection of all adducts
here is the same within the error limits obtained in the
DISCUSSION measurements. This is due to the fact that all adducts
are chemically very similar and the charge for negative
ions is located in the phosphate group, rendering the
The main obstacle for the quantitative determination of modiÐcation site less important. The comparison shown
adducts of DNA components was the impossibility of in Fig. 5 supports this assumption since the traces given
combining quantitative determinations and the eluci- for ICP-MS, ESI-MS and UV detection are identical.
dation of unknown structures. Known components can Only single signals typical for the detectors indicate the
be determined precisely (using AMS) or newly formed speciÐcity. In the UV trace a small amount of styrene
unknown adducts detected (with post-labelling), but to oxide is visible, but this signal is not observed with ESI
detect and quantify unknown adducts without synthetic and ICP-MS. On the other hand, signals show up in the
standards was not possible. With ESI-MS only, the phosphorus trace which are not visible in the ESI-MS
structures of unknown adducts could be elucidated, but signal ion [M [ H]~ trace, because those adducts obvi-
without pure synthetic standards quantitative results ously have a di†erent mass. As we have shown, loss of
are difficult to obtain. Only by employing both LC/ESI- H O with the formation of cyclic structures is a
MS and LC/ICP-MS can we elucidate the structure and 2
common reaction for styrene oxide ; the details will be
determine the concentration of an adduct in the same discussed elsewhere (C. Sietho† and M. Linscheid, to be
sample. The strength of the approach is that we do not published). A few minor signals are shown in the traces
have to rely on a synthetic (radioactive) label as in post- without structure assignment, since the small amount
labelling ; rather, the naturally common feature of all did not allow structure elucidation. Thus all adducts
nucleotides, the phosphate group, is employed. ICP-MS can be quantiÐed by means of electrospray data, which
detection is generally not a†ected by the speciation of have been calibrated based on the ICP-MS data.
an element,26 which allows one to detect any phosphate For the styrene oxide adducts determined using LC/
with the same efficiency ; thus even inorganic phosphate ESI-MS, detection limits between 0.01 and 0.03 lg ml~1
is a suitable internal standard. It seems inevitable, were obtained. With a DNA concentration of 5 mg
Figure 5. Comparisons of the HPLC separations of reaction mixtures of 5¾-monophosphates of cytosine (C), thymidine (T), adenosine (A)
and guanosine (G) using UV detection (254 nm, upper traces), phosphorus detection at m /z 30.97 with ICP-HRMS (middle traces) and
monitoring ÍM É HËÉ ions (ESI-MS ; m /z values are given on the traces). Styrene oxide is visible only in the UV trace ; adducts with
molecular masses other than the adducts appear in the phosphorus traces.
Copyright ( 1999 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. J. Mass Spectrom. 34, 421È426 (1999)
426 C. SIETHOFF ET AL .
ml~1 this represents a molar concentration of 16.2 nucleotide concentrations. The combination of this
mmol l~1, calculated with a mean molecular mass of approach with LC/ESI-MS provides a powerful means
307.7 g mol~1 for a nucleotide. Since 20 ll were used of elucidating unknown structures and of determining
for injection on to the regular HPLC column (4 mm the concentrations of analytes in the same sample, thus
i.d.), a detectable concentration of 4.6 ] 10~8 M (or 920 giving clues to the complex chemistry of xenobiotic
fmol absolute) results if the average adduct detection compounds in living systems. In this study single ion
limit is 0.02 lg ml~1. The mean molecular mass of the detection was sufficient, since only styrene oxide
adducts is 427.7 g mol~1. This means that for a concen- adducts were analysed. In the future, for the investiga-
tration of 5 mg ml~1 DNA we can detect one modiÐ- tion of more xenobiotic compounds, a wider mass range
cation in 3.5 ] 105 unmodiÐed nucleobases. On must be employed to detect adducts with di†erent
replacement of the regular HPLC column with a micro- molecular masses. As yet, the detection of styrene oxide
column of 50 mm ] 320 lm i.d., the detection capabil- adducts by means of LC/ICP-MS, monitoring phos-
ities improve dramatically. A 1 ll injection volume phorus, is less sensitive than with the electrospray
yields the same ion abundance owing to the much method. To improve the sensitivity, studies are under
higher peak concentration. This results in a detection way to replace methanol by acetonitrile and, even more
limit of seven modiÐcations in 106 unmodiÐed nucleo- promising, to include more efficient aerosol generators
bases using single ion monitoring. With on-column pre- for ICP-MS. In addition, more than one internal stan-
concentration of a 50 ll injection volume, we could dard may improve the precision of quantitative results,
demonstrate that 14 modiÐcations in 108 nucleotides if necessary. For the future it can be envisaged that
can be detected, which comes close to results obtained screening for adducts in DNA may be performed based
with the post-labelling technique. on the combination of LC/ICP-MS and LC/ESI-MS.
Not only phosphorus but also more relevant elements
such as sulphur, selenium and arsenic or heavy metals
CONCLUSION could be included in the search for adducts of biological
oligomers or polymers. The Ðrst orientating experi-
ments are very promising27 (P. Janning, B. Pongratz
The reaction of styrene oxide with DNA served as an and M. Linscheid, in preparation).
instructive example to demonstrate that the LC/ICP-
MS signal of phosphorus can be used to determine
modiÐed DNA components. It is important to realize
that it is not necessary at this stage to know the struc- Acknowledgements
tures of the adducts, since the measurement is based on
Financial support by the Bundesminister fur Forschung und Technol-
the atomic signal of phosphorus. The only assumption ogie (BMBF), Bonn, the Ministerium fur Wissenschaft und Forschung
is that the molecular masses of the adducts in a study des Landes Nordrhein-Westfalen (MWF) and the Fonds der Chemis-
are almost the same to allow the calculation of molar chen Industrie (VCI) is gratefully acknowledged.
REFERENCES
1. A. M. Jeffrey, Pharmacol . Ther . 28, 237 (1985). 15. K. Hemminki, K. Szyfter, P. Vodicka, P. Koivisto, R. Mustonen
2. F. A. Beland and M. C. Poirier, Environ . Health Perspect . 99, 5 and A. Reunanen, Prog . Clin . Biol . Res . 372, 219 (1991).
(1993). 16. K. W. Turteltaub and J. S. Vogel, Mass Spectrometry in the
3. J. A. Swenberg, F. C., Richardson, J. A. Boucheron and M. C. Biological Sciences , edited by A. L. Burlingame and S. A.
Dyroff, Environ . Health Perspect . 62, 177 (1985). Carr, pp. 477–495. Humana Press, Totowa, NJ (1996).
4. S. A. Belinsky, V. E. Walker, R. R. Maronpot, J. A. Swenberg 17. C. Siethoff, W. Schrader, R. Pesch, H. Mu nster and M. Lins-
and M. W. Anderson, Cancer Res . 47, 6058 (1987). cheid, in Proceedings of the 43rd ASMS Conference on Mass
5. M. N. Rios-Blanco, K. Plna, T. Faller, W. Kessler, K. Hakanss- Spectrometry and Allied Topics , Atlanta, GA, 1995, 249.
on, P. E. Kreuzer, A. Ranasinghe, J. G. Filser, D. Segerback 18. L. Moens and N. Jakubowski, Anal . Chem . 70, 251A (1998).
and J. A. Swenberg, Mutat . Res ., 380, 1 (1997). 19. H. Berndt, G. Schaldach and S. H. Ka gler, Fresenius’ J . Anal .
6. K. W. Turtletaub, R. J. Mauthe and K. Dingley, Mutat . Res . Chem . 355, 37 (1996).
376, 243 (1997). 20. D. Stuewer and N. Jakubowski, J . Mass Spectrom . 33, 579
7. T.-Y. Yen, N. I. Christova-Gueoguieva, N. Scheller, S. Holt, J. (1998).
A. Swenberg and M. J. Charles, J . Mass Spectrom . 31, 1271 21. G. M. Laws, S. P. Adams, W. W. Nichols and J. R. Selden,
(1996). Fundam . Appl . Toxicol . 23, 308 (1994).
8. S. Naylor, L. S. Gan, B. W. Day, R. Pastorelli and P. L. 22. P. Vodicka and K. Hemminki, IARC Sci . Publ ., 127, 109
Skipper, Chem . Res . Toxicol . 3, 11 (1990). (1993).
9. P. L. Skipper and S. R. Tannenbaum, Environ . Health Per- 23. S. Cantoreggi, R. C. Gupta and W. K. Lutz, IARC Sci . Publ .
spect . 102, 17 (1994). 124, 201 (1993).
10. V. E. Walker, J. P. MacNeela, J. A. Swenberg, M. J. Turner Jr 24. K. Pongracz, S. Kaur, A. L. Burlingame and W. J. Bodell, Car-
and T. R. Fennell, Cancer Res . 52, 4320 (1992). cinogenesis 10, 1009 (1989).
11. D. K. La, P. D. Lilly, R. J. Anderegg and J. A. Swenberg, Car- 25. C. Siethoff, PhD Thesis, University of Dortmund (1997).
cinogenesis 16, 1419 (1995). 26. L. Moens, Fresenius’ J . Anal . Chem . 359, 309 (1997).
12. D. K. La and J. A. Swenberg, Mutat . Res . 365, 1 (1996). 27. M. Linscheid, P. Janning and W. Schrader, in Mechanismen
13. P. Vodicka, L. Vodickova, K. Trejbalova, R. J. Sram and K. des Transports von Mineralstoffen und Spurenelementen ,
Hemminki, Carcinogenesis 15, 1949 (1994). edited by H. J. Haas, Wissenschaftliche Verlagsgesellschaft,
14. S. F. Liu, S. M. Rappaport, J. Rasmussen and W. J. Bodell, Stuttgart (1995), pp. 109–119.
Carcinogenesis 9, 1401 (1988).
Copyright ( 1999 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. J. Mass Spectrom. 34, 421È426 (1999)