You are on page 1of 8

MODULE I * No such thing as attempted treason; mere

attempt consummates the crime.


Article 114

ELEMENTS OF TREASON: NOT TREASONOUS


1. That the offender is either a FILIPINO 1. Acceptance of public office and
CITIZEN or a RESIDENT ALIEN discharge of official duties under the
(permanent or temporary allegiance to the enemy does not constitute per se the
Government of the Philippines) felony of treason (exception: when it is
2. .That there is a WAR in which the policy determining)
Philippines is involved 2. Serving in a puppet government
3. That the offender either – (ministerial functions) and in order to
 LEVIES WAR against the government serve the populace is NOT treasonous.
- there must be an actual assembling of But it is treason if: a) there is discretion
men involved; b) inflicts harm on Filipinos; c) it
- not necessary that there be any is disadvantageous to them.
formal declaration of state or war 3. If the purpose is to merely to change
- the war must be directed against the officials.
government
- levying of war must be in collaboration AGGRAVATING circumstances in treason
with a foreign enemy ( If the levying of war 1. CRUELTY by subjecting guerilla
is merely a civil uprising, without any suspects to barbarous forms of torture
intention of helping an external enemy, the before putting them to death; and
crime is not treason. The offenders may be 2. IGNOMINY, by stripping the wife or her
held liable for rebellion.) clothes and then abusing her in the
 ADHERES to the ENEMIES, giving presence of her husband, a guerilla
them AID and COMFORT suspect. (People v. Adlawan)
- adherence and giving aid or comfort
must concur together. *Defense of suspended allegiance and
- the act committed need actually change of sovereignty is not accepted
strengthen the enemy because what is suspended is the exercise
- the aid or comfort given to the of the rights of sovereignty. (Laurel v. Misa)
enemies must be after the declarartion of
war. The enemies must be the subject of a Article 115
foreign power. (It does not embrace rebels
in insurrection against their own country CONSPIRACY to commit treason
because they are still citizens and not ELEMENTS:
enemies.) 1. In time of war
* When killings and other common crimes 2. 2 or more persons come to an
are charged as overt acts of treason, they agreement to commit treason
cannot be regarded as separate crimes or 3. They decide to commit it
as complexed with treason.
The raping mentioned in the information
PROPOSAL to commit treason
therein alleged is not a specific offense but
mere element of the crime of treason. 1. In time of war
(People v. Adlawan) 2. A person who has decided to commit
* Filipino citizens can commit treason treason proposes its execution to some
outside the Philippines. But that of an alien other person/s.
must be committed in the Philippines. * Mere proposal even without acceptance is
* Ways of proving treason: punishable too. If the other accepts, it is
- 2 witnesses testifying to SAME OVERT already conspiracy.
ACT
- CONFESSION of the accused in open Article 116
court
MISPRISION of treason
1. That the offender must be OWING citizens to reprisals on their persons or
ALLEGIANCE to the government, and not property
a foreigner * Intention is immaterial
2. That he HAS KNOWLEDGE of any
conspiracy (to commit treason) against Article 134
the government
3. That he CONCEALS or DOES NOT REBELLION OR INSURRECTION
DISCLOSE and make known the same as ELEMENTS:
soon as possible to the governor or fiscal 1. That there be
of the province or the mayor or fiscal of A. PUBLIC UPRISING, and
the city in which he resides B. TAKING ARMS against the
* Refers to knowledge of any conspiracy Government
against the Government of the Philippines, 2. That the PURPOSE of the uprising or
not knowledge of treason actually commited movement is either
by another. A. to REMOVE from the allegiance to
* Offender under this article is punished as said government or its laws (1) the
an accessory to treason territory of the Philippines or any part
thereof, or (2) any body of land, naval
or other armed forces
Article 117. Espionage B. to DEPRIVE the chief executive or
1. By those without authority (Prision congress, wholly or partially, of any of
Mayor) their POWERS or prerogatives
ELEMENTS: * It is not necessary, to consummate
1. That the offender ENTERS a warship, rebellion, that the rebels succeed in
fort, or naval or military establishment or overthrowing the Government.
reservation * Rebellion v. Insurrection - Rebellion is
2. That he has NO AUTHORITY therefor; used where the object of the movement is
3. That his purpose is to OBTAIN completely to overthrow and supersede the
INFORMATION, plans, photographs or existing government. Insurrection refers to a
other data of a confidential nature relative to movement which seeks merely to effect
the defense of the Philippines some change of minor importance to
2. By reason of public office (Reclusion prevent the exercise of government
Temporal) authority with respect to particular matters.
Elements: * Rebellion v Subversion - Subversion, like
1. That the offender is a PUBLIC OFFICER treason, is a crime against national security.
2. That he has in his POSSESSION the Rebellion is a crime against public order.
articles, data or information referred to in
par 1 of art 117, BY REASON OF THE *Under R.A. No. 9372 (Human Security Act
PUBLIC OFFICE he holds of 2007), a person who commits an act
3. That he DISCLOSES their contents to a punishable as rebellion or insurrection,
representative of a FOREIGN NATION thereby showing and creating a condition of
widespread or extraordinary fear and panic
Article 118 among the populace, in order to coerce the
government to give in to an unlawful
INCITING TO WAR OR GIVING MOTIVES demand shall be guilty of the crime of
FOR REPRISALS terrorism.
ELEMENTS: Article 134-A
1. That the offender performs UNLAWFUL COUP D E’TAT
or UNAUTHORIZED acts
2. That such acts PROVOKE or give ELEMENTS:
occasion for a war involving or liable to
involve the Philippines or EXPOSE Filipino
1. The offender is a person/s belonging to * It is not a defense in rebellion that the
the MILITARY or POLICE or holding any accused never took oath of allegiance to, or
PUBLIC OFFICE or employment that they never recognized the Government.

2. Committed by means of SWIFT ATTACK * There is no complex crime of rebellion


accompanied by THREAT, VIOLENCE, with murder and other common crimes.
INTIMIDATION, THREAT, STRATEGY,
STEALTH * Rebellion, and not murder, where killings
are politically motivated.
3. Directed AGAINST duly constituted
AUTHORITIES or REPUBLIC of the Article 136
PHILIPPINES, or any MILITARY CAMP or
other facilities needed for the exercise and Conspiracy and Proposal to commit coup
continued POSSESSION of power d’etat (Prision Mayor in its minimum)

4. Purpose is to SEIZE or DIMINISH state Conspiracy and Proposal to commit


power rebellion or insurrection (Prision
Correccional)
* *Under R.A. No. 9372 (Human Security
Act of 2007), a person who commits an act Article 137
punishable as coup d’etat under RPC,
thereby showing a creating a condition of Disloyalty of Public Officers and
widespread and extrordinary fear and panic Employees
among the populace, in order to coerce the
government to give in to an unlawful ELEMENTS:
demand shall be guilty of the crime of
terrorism. 1. The offender must be a public
officer/employee
2. Acts of disloyalty punished:
Article 135
A. FAILING to resist a rebellion by all the
The following are liable for rebellion, means in their power;
insurrection and coup d’etat: B. CONTINUING TO DISCHARGE the
duties of their offices under control of the
A. The leaders - rebels;
C. ACCEPTING APPOINTMENT to office
1) Any person who promotes, maintains or under them.
heads a rebellion or insurrection; or
Article 138. Inciting to Rebellion or
2) Any person who leads, directs, or
Insurrecction
command others to undertake copu d’etat

B. The participants ELEMENTS:

1. Any person who participates or executes 1. That the offender DOES NOT TAKE
the commands of others in rebellion, or ARMS or is NOT IN OPEN HOSTILITY
insurrection; against the government

2. Any person in the government service 2. That heINCITES OTHERS to the


who participates or executes directions or execution of any of the acts of rebellion
commands of others in undertaking a coup
d’etat; 3. That the inciting is done by MEANS of
3. Any person not in the government speeches, proclamations, writings,
service who participates, suports, finances, emblems, banners or other representations
abets, or aids in undertaking a coup d’etat. tending to the same end
Inciting rebellion v. Proposal to commit Government; in sedition, it is sufficient that
rebellion the public aprising is tumultuous.

* In proposal, the person who proposes has * While in sedition, the purpose of the
decided to commit rebellion; in inciting to offenders may be political and social; in
rebellion, it is not required that the offender rebellion, it is always political.
has decided to commit rebellion.
The purpose of the raid and the act of the
* In proposal, the person who proposes the raiders in rising publicly and taking up arms
execution of the crime uses secret means; was not exactly against the Government.
in inciting to rebellion, the act of inciting is Rather, the object was to attain by means of
done publicly. force, intimidation, etc., one object - to inflict
an act of hate or revenge upon the person
Article 139. Sedition or property of a public official, namely,
Punzalan, who was then mayor of Tiaong.
ELEMENTS:
Sedition v. Treason
1. That the offenders RISE PUBLICLY and
TUMULTUOUSLY * Treason is the violation by a subject of his
2. That they employ fFORCE, INTIMIDTION allegiance to his sovereign or to the
ot other means OUTSIDE of LEGAL supreme auhtority of the State. Sedition is
METHODS; the raising of commotions or disturbances
3. That the offender employ those means to in the State.
attain any of the following objects
Article 140
a. to prevent the promulgation or execution
of any law or the holding of any popular Persons liable for sedition:
election
1. The leader of the sedition (Prision
b. to prevent the national government, or Mayor), and
any provincial or municipal government, or 2. Other persons participating in the
any public thereof from freely exercising its sedition (Prsion Correccional).
or his functions, or prevent the execution of
any administrative order Article 141. Conspiracy to commit sedition
(Prision correccional in its medium period).
c. to inflict any act or hate or revenge upon
the person or property of any public officer * There is no proposal to commit sedition.
or employee
Article 142.
d. to commit for any political or social end,
any act of hate or revenge against private Inciting to Sedition (Prision Correccional
persons or any social class in its maximum period)

e. to despoil, for any political or social end, ELEMENTS:


any person, municipality or province, or the
national government of all its property or 1. That the offender DOES NOT TAKE
any part thereof. A DIRECT PART in the crime of
sedition
Sedition v. Rebellion 2. That he INCITES OTHERS to the
ACCOMPLISHMENT of any of the
* In both rebellion and sedition, there must acts which constitute sedition
be public uprising. While in rebellion there 3. That the inciting is done by means
must be taking up of arms against the of speeches, proclamations, writing,
emblems, cartoons, banners, or constitutional commissions or committees
other representations tending to the or divisions thereof, or of any provincial
same end board or city or municipal council or board
2. That the offender DOES any of the
* Different acts of inciting to sedition: following acts

1. Inciting others to the accomplishment of a) he DISTURBS any of such


any of the acts which constitute sedition by meetings
means of speeches, proclamations, writings b) he behaves while in the presence
etc. of any such bodies in such a
2. Uttering seditious words or speeches manner as TO INTERRUPT its
which tend to disturb the public peace proceedings or TO IMPAIR the
3. Writing, publishing, or circulating respect due it
scurrilous libels against the government or
any of the duly constituted authorities Article 145
thereof, which tend to disturb the public
peace Violation of Parliamentary Immunity

*It is not necessary, in order to be seditious, Acts punishable:


that the words used should in fact result in a
rising of the people against the constituted 1. By using FORCE, INTIMIDATION,
authorities. The law is not aimed at merely THREATS or FRAUD to PREVENT any
at actual disturbance, as its purpose is aslo member of National Assembly from –
to punish utterances which may endanger
public order. (People v. Nabong) a. attending the meeting of the assembly or
any of its committees, constitutional
Article 143 commissions or committees or divisions
thereof, or from
Acts tending to Prevent the Meeting of b. expressing his opinions or
Congress and Similar Bodies (Prision c. casting his vote
Correccional)
2. By ARRESTING or SEARCHING any
ELEMENTS: member thereof while Congress is in a
regular or special SESSION, EXCEPT in
1. That THERE BE A PROJECTED or case such member has committed a crime
ACTUAL MEETING of Congress or any of punishable under the code by a penalty
its committees or subcommittees, higher than prision mayor.
constitutional commissions or committees
or division thereof, or of any provincial Article 146
board or city or municipal council or board
2. That the offender who may be any Illegal Assemblies
person PREVENTS such MEETING by
FORCE or FRAUD 1. Any MEETING attended by ARMED
persons for the perpose of ommitting any of
Article 144 the CRIMES PUNISHABLE under the
Code.
Disturbance of Proceedings (Arresto
Mayor) *Persons merely present at such meeeting
shall suffer the penalty of arresto mayor,
ELEMENTS: unless they are armed, in which case the
penalty shall be prision correccional.
1. That THERE BE A MEETING of
Congress or any of its committees,
2. Any MEETING, in which the audience, * It’s not necessary that the offended party
whether armed or not, is INCITED to the in the first form of direct assault be a person
commission of the crime of treason, in authority. If the aim of the offender is to
rebellion or insurrection, sedition, or assault attain an object of sedition, the offended
upon a person in authority or his agents. party may be a private individual or person
belonging to social class.
* A gathering or group, whether in a fixed
place or moving, is included in the word 2. Without public uprising, by ATTACKING,
“meeting.” by EMPLOYING FORCE, or by
SERIOUSLY INTIMIDATING or
Article 147 SERIOUSLY RESISTING any person in
authority or any of his agents, while
Illegal Associations engaged in the performance of official
duties, or on the occassion of such
ELEMENTS: performance.

1. Associations TOTALLY or PARTIALLY Person in authority - any person directly


organized vested with jurisdiction (the power or
authority to govern or execute laws),
a. for the purpose of committing any of the whether as an inidividual or as a member of
crimes punishable under RPC some court or governmental corporation,
board, or commission.
b. for some purpose contrary to public
morals An agent of a person in authority - is one
who, by direct provisions of law or by
election or by appointment by competent
Persons liable:
authority, is charged with the maintenance
of public order and the protection and
1. Founders, directors and presidents of the security of life and property.
association;
2. Mere members of the association.
* When the person in authority or their
agents descended to matters which are
Illegal Association v. Illegal Assembly private in nature, an attack made by one
against the other is not direct assault.
* In illegal assembly, it is necessary that
there is an actual meeting or assembly; in * When a person in authority or his agent is
illegal association, it is not necessary that the one who provokes and attacks another
there be an actual meeting. person, the latter is entitled to defend
himself and cannot be held liable for assault
* In illegal assembly, it is the meeting and or resistance nor for physical injuries,
attendance at such meeting that are because he acts in legitimate defense.
punished; in illegal associations, it is the act
of forming or organizing and membership in * An assault upon a person in authority may
the association that are punished. be committed by another person in authority
as Article 148 makes it an aggravating
Article 148 circumstance when the offender is a “public
officer or employee.” However, there can be
Direct Assault no assault upon or disobedience to one
authority by another when they both
1. Without public uprising, by employing contend in the exercise of their duties.
FORCE or INTIMIDATION for the
attainment of any of the purposes * The knowledge of the accused that the
enumerated in defining the crimes of victim is a person in authority or his agent is
rebellion and sedition. essential.
* Defendants must have the intention to 1. Refusing WITHOUT LEGAL
defy the authorities. EXCUSE to obey summons
2. REFUSING TO BE SWORN or
* Direct assault is qualified - placed under affirmation
3. REFUSING to ANSWER any
1. When the assault is committed with LEGAL INQUIRY to produce books,
weapon (firearms, sharp/cutting records etc.
instruments, stones, clubs, and any object 4. RESTRAINING another from
with which some physical injury may be attending AS WITNESS in such
inflicted) body
2. When the offender is a public officer or 5. INDUCING DISOBEDIENCE to a
employee - A teacher may be guilty of direct summons or refusal to be sworn
assault committed on another teacher
(Gelig v. People) * Any of the acts punished by Article 150
3. When the offender lays hands upon a may also constitute contempt of the
person in authority. Congress.

* Complex crime of direct assault with Article 151


homicide or murder, or with serious or less
serious physical injuries. But, the crime of Resistance and Disobedience to a
slight physical injuries is absorbed in direct Person in Authority or the Agents of
assault. such Person

Article 149 Elements of resistance and serious


disobedience (par. 1):
INDIRECT ASSAULT (Prision
Correccional in its minimum and 1. That a person in authority or his agent is
medium periods) angaged IN THE PERFORMANCE of
official duty or gives a lawful order to the
ELEMENTS:  offender

1. That a person in authority or his agent is 2. That the offender RESIST or


the VICTIM of any of the forms of DIRECT SERIOUSLY disobeys such person in
ASSAULT defined in ART. 148. authority or his agent.

2. That a person comes to the AID of such 3. That the act of the offender is not
authority or his agent. INCLUDED in the provisions of Art. 148,
149 and 150.
3. That the offender makes use of FORCE
or INTIMIDATION upon such person * The disobedience contemplated consists
coming to the aid of the authority or his in the failure or refusal to obey a direct
agent. order from the authority or his agent.

* Indirect assault can be committed only Elements of simple disobedience (par.


when a direct assault is also committed. 2):

Article 150 1. That an AGENT of a person in authority


is engaged IN THE PERFORMANCE of
Disobedience to summons issued by official duty or gives LAWFUL ORDER to
Congress (Arresto Mayor) the offender

Acts punishable: 2. That the offender DISOBEYS such agent


3. That such disobedience is NOT of a
SERIOUS in nature.

* The use of force in resistance is not


serious, compared to that of direct assault,
because there is no manisfest intention to
defy the law and the officers enforcing it.

* When the attack or employment of force is


not deliberate, the crime is only resistance
or disobedience.

Article 152

Persons in Authority and Agents of


Persons in Authority.

* Persons in authority - municipal mayor,


division superintendent, teacher-nurse,
president of sanitary division, provincial
fiscal, justice of peace, municipal councilor,
barrio captain and brgy. Chairman,
professors or private colleges and
universties (according to jurisprudence)

* To be an agent of a person in authority,


one must be charged with (1) the
maintenance of public order,a nd (2) the
protection and security of life and property

You might also like