Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract—This paper presents a novel fully electric vehicle , : primary shaft, secondary shaft
layout, consisting of two drivetrains, each of them including a : reference
two-speed transmission, for improving vehicle acceleration and
gradeability performance. The adoption of two-speed
: selected gear ratio (first, second or neutral)
transmissions allows eight different gear state combinations, : torque-fill enabled
increasing the possibility of selecting a high-efficiency state for : wheel
each operating condition. A torque-fill controller is developed for & : windage and friction
the compensation of the torque gap during gearshift through the
variation of the torque on the other axle. Finally, a simulation- II. INTRODUCTION
based analysis of the acceleration, gradeability and gearshift
performance of this vehicle layout is discussed, in comparison With the rising prices of non-renewable energy sources and
with alternative fully electric vehicle configurations. increased pressure for high-efficiency vehicles, hybrid electric
vehicles (HEVs) and fully electric vehicles (FEVs) are
Keywords—Two-speed transmission; four-wheel-drive fully emerging as feasible solutions for mobility. Electric motors
electric vehicle; seamless gearshift; torque-fill. (EMs) usually have an operating region with high maximum
I. LIST OF SYMBOLS torque availability at low speeds. At higher speeds their
operation is limited to a constant power region, sometimes
: longitudinal acceleration followed by a region with decreasing power as a function of
: transmission gear ratio speed [1-4]. Due to their flexibility in terms of layout and
: mass moment of inertia packaging, and reduced amount of required auxiliary systems
: torsional stiffness in comparison with internal combustion engines (ICEs),
: Laplace operator electric motors are suitable for installation in different
: torque powertrain configurations [5-6].
: time Hybrid electric powertrains are designed as a combination
: gearbox actuator position of an ICE and one or more EMs. The EMs can be directly
: non-dimensional factor for the computation of the reference integrated into the transmission system without major
motor speed during gearshift modifications, or coupled to the ICE through power split
: torsional damping coefficient devices, e.g., planetary gear sets [7-9]. Similarly to HEVs,
: efficiency FEVs can be developed according to a significant variety of
, , : angular position, speed, acceleration layouts. The most common solution is a central electric motor
: time constant or pure time delay with a single-speed transmission and a differential, in order to
reduce manufacturing costs and weight. Although existing
The following lines report the subscripts used in the paper. FEVs usually adopt single-speed transmissions, this
configuration constrains their performance, especially in case
: gearbox actuator
of electric motors characterized by a limited speed range. In
: delay fact, the single gear ratio has to be selected as a trade-off
: desired between gradeability, requiring a high value of the gear ratio,
: differential and top speed, requiring a low value of the gear ratio. In a two-
: electric motor speed electric drivetrain, the first gear ratio is selected for
: energy management system providing the required longitudinal acceleration and
gradeability performance, while the second gear ratio can be
: equivalent
designed to provide the specified top speed. Moreover, as the
, , , : front, right, left, rear efficiency of an electric drivetrain is a function of torque and
, 1, 2, : gearbox, gear 1, gear 2, disengaged gear speed, a two-speed transmission system allows increased
: half-shaft flexibility in the selection of the operating region of the electric
, , : initial, final, inertia phase drivetrain, thus bringing potential energy efficiency benefits.
E-mail of the corresponding author: a.sorniotti@surrey.ac.uk
The research leading to these results has received funding from the
European Union's Seventh Framework Programme FP7/2007-2013 (PLUS-
MOBY) under grant agreement n° 605502.
engaged gear on one primary shaft (on the front or rear , , (1)
, , , ,
transmission) and no engaged gear on the other primary shaft;
or ii) two engaged gears, one per each primary shaft. Since , , , , , ,
plays and internal torsion deformations of the transmission
system (consisting of gearbox and differential) are second- The internal dynamics of the mechanical differential are
approximation effects, they are neglected in the following neglected in this paper for simplicity. , is calculated
modelling and gearshift control analysis. In order to evaluate starting from the motor torque demand, through a transfer
vehicle performance and gearshift quality, both transmissions function. The efficiency in the formula, including the losses in
have been coupled with a simulation model of the vehicle the first gear and differential, can be reversed depending on the
longitudinal dynamics (Fig. 3). If a gear is engaged, the first- direction of the power flow through the coupling. Transmission
order dynamics of the drivetrain have been modeled efficiency is expressed through a look-up table (supplied by the
considering the system as an equivalent inertia, from the transmission system manufacturer), as a function of the input
electric motor to the differential. This inertia is connected to torque, speed and operating temperature. The equivalent
the wheel inertia through half-shafts, modeled as torsion moment of inertia of the drivetrain considers the contributions
springs and dampers. Tires are simulated through the Pacejka of the half-shafts, differential, motor, primary and secondary
magic formula model with relaxation length [18]. shafts, and first and second gears. In first gear it is:
Front electric motor Front dog clutch
,
0.5 , , ,
Front primary shaft
~ PM
Vehicle , , , , (2)
direction
Front secondary shaft , , , , , ,
, , , , , ,
C. Disengaged gear
Rear secondary shaft
In this condition the primary and secondary shafts are
~ PM
decoupled. The system is characterized by two degrees of
Rear primary shaft
freedom: i) the first one for the rotating parts of the electric
motor and the transmission system components rigidly
Rear electric motor Rear dog clutch
connected to the primary shaft; and ii) the second one for the
Fig. 3. Layout of the two-speed 4WD vehicle model. transmission parts rotating together with the differential. In
formulas:
The transmissions can work in three conditions, each of
, & ,
them governed by different equations: A. Engaged first gear: in ,
this condition the primary and secondary shafts rotate , ,
according to the first gear ratio; B. Engaged second gear: the
dog clutch is engaged such that the kinematic ratio between the , , , , , , ,
(4)
primary and secondary shafts is the second gear ratio; and C.
Disengaged gear: in this condition the drivetrain is 1
characterized by two degrees of freedom, as the electric motor , , , , , ,
,
dynamics are decoupled from the transmission output shaft where
dynamics.
,
0.5 , , ,
The equations are reported for the front axle only, as the (5)
rear drivetrain model is identical to the front one. , , , , , , ,
A. Engaged first gear The efficiency of the PM electric motor drive, including the
The torque balance of the drivetrain in first gear, including windage and friction losses and the inverter efficiency, is
the electric motor, is given by: expressed through a look-up table (supplied by the electric
motor and inverter manufacturer), function of the motor torque, where , ,
is the torque demand for the front electric
speed and operating temperature. motor that would be output by the EMS if the front drivetrain
The axial position of the dog clutch located between the was already in second gear, , is the torque demand for
first and second gear is controlled though an electro-hydraulic the rear electric motor provided by the EMS in first gear, and
actuator. The actuator position is modelled through a pure time is the front electric motor torque demand actually
,
delay, , and a first order transfer function with time constant ,
1 1 1.5
Ref. position Front
1
Front torque demand [-]
position (APP) equal to 30%. Fig. 5 shows the time histories 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5
of: i) the reference and actual front dog clutch positions; ii) the Time [s]
reference and actual front EM speeds; and iii) the front and rear Fig. 5. Upshift from 1st to 2nd gear. Dynamics of the dog clutch and electric
EM torques (reference and actual values) during the maneuver. motor (torque and speed) with reference and actual values.
35
VI. RESULTS
The non-linear forward facing vehicle model is 30
1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4
implemented in the Matlab/Simulink environment for Time [s]
evaluating: i) the acceleration and gradeability performance of
the two-speed 4WD layout; and ii) its gearshift dynamics. The
Vehicle acceleration [m/s 2]