You are on page 1of 16

Anal Bioanal Chem (2011) 399:2961–2976

DOI 10.1007/s00216-010-4357-5

ORIGINAL PAPER

Characterization and identification of acrylic binding


media: influence of UV light on the ageing process
Valentina Pintus & Manfred Schreiner

Received: 3 August 2010 / Revised: 12 October 2010 / Accepted: 18 October 2010 / Published online: 3 November 2010
# Springer-Verlag 2010

Abstract This study characterizes and identifies two were more pronounced when the acrylic binding media
different acrylic binding media such as Plextol® D498 were mixed with pigments. The double-shot technique of
and Primal® AC33, which are widely used in modern and Py-GC/MS additionally allowed the detection of the phenolic
contemporary art. In order to investigate their fast photo- antioxidant in unaged Plextol® D498, but no oxidation
oxidative deterioration when exposed to ultraviolet (UV) products could be identified by Py-GC/MS in all samples.
light, ageing studies on these materials were carried out.
For this purpose, pure synthetic materials but also mixed Keywords Py-GC/MS . FTIR-ATR . Double-shot
with different inorganic pigments were identified and technique . Acrylic polymer . Paint materials . UV ageing
characterized before and after UV exposure by means of
pyrolysis-gas chromatography/mass spectrometry (Py-GC/
MS). Particular attention was paid to the comparison of two Introduction
different analytical methods: (1) single-shot method based
on a pyrolysis for the analysis of polymers and (2) double- Acrylic materials have been used widely in the artistic field
shot method, which allows a unique combination of thermal as well as in conservation and restoration since the late
desorption for the analysis of volatile compounds and 1950s [1]. Based on ester of acrylic and methacrylic acids,
pyrolysis of the polymers themselves. These analyses acrylics are distinguished as acrylic solutions and as acrylic
have been complemented by Fourier transform infrared emulsions (waterborne dispersions), which are generally
spectroscopy-attenuated total reflectance (FTIR-ATR) more used by different artists than acrylic solutions because
studies. The comparison of the results obtained from of their insolubility in water when they are dry, for their
unaged samples and UV-aged clearly showed material easy application in many layers, and for safety and
alterations as well as the formation of new products, which environmental reasons.
were recorded by FTIR-ATR. Generally, these changes The first acrylic emulsion paint was PRIMAL AC33,
introduced by Rohm and Haas in 1953 [2]. Generally called
Published in the special issue Analytical Chemistry for Cultural “latex” (dispersion of acrylic polymers in water), acrylic
Heritage with Guest Editors Rocco Mazzeo, Silvia Prati, and Aldo emulsions are characterized by four basic components:
Roda. water, monomer, initiator, and surfactant. The latter is
V. Pintus : M. Schreiner composed of a hydrophilic portion, oriented into the
Institute of Chemical Technologies and Analytics, aqueous phase, and a hydrophobic portion, oriented into a
Analytical Chemistry Division, Vienna University of Technology,
monomer droplet. The addition of a surface active agent
Getreidemarkt 9/161,
1060 Vienna, Austria (surfactant) is essential for the lowering of the interfacial
tension between the monomer and water. They are
V. Pintus (*) : M. Schreiner generally present in low concentration and they can be
Institute of Science and Technology in Art, Academy of Fine Arts,
anionic (e.g., sodium lauryl sulfate or dodecylbenzene
Schillerplatz 3,
1010 Vienna, Austria sulfonate), cationic (usually based on quaternary ammonium
e-mail: v.pintus@akbild.ac.at compounds), and nonionic (e.g., alkyl phenol ethoxylates).
2962 V. Pintus, M. Schreiner

Nonionic surfactants based on polyethoxylates are widely monomeric units in a polymer or about the molecular
used and more stable than natural colloid stabilizers because weight distribution and end groups [15].
their aqueous solutions are not subject to biodegradation by Due to their good pictorial properties, acrylic emulsion
microorganisms [3]. A specific study focused on the materials have been widely used as binding media for
characterization of poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG) compounds paints and even for artworks exposed to outdoor conditions.
in artists' acrylic emulsion paints from different paint This means that different weathering parameters such as
manufacturers have been carried out by Hoogland and Boon UV light, temperature, and humidity have to be considered
[4]. The analysis included data from matrix-assisted laser in order to develop a good protocol for ageing studies. In
desorption/ionization mass spectrometry (MALDI-MS) and outdoor environments, UV light plays an important role
nano-electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (nano- especially its wavelengths that normally cannot pass
ESI_MS(MS)). These techniques facilitated the analysis of through commercial window glass. Usually, that UV range
the molar mass distribution and end-groups of the PEGs, is not considered for indoor work of art, e.g., in a museum.
which were found in the water extracts of pigmented and The UV light is divided into different wavelength
unpigmented acrylic emulsion paint film, paint samples from regions such as UV-A (400 to 315 nm, near UV), which
a palette, and several small painting samples [4]. is usually considered harmless to acryls, UV-B (315 to
Through the time, the chemical and physical properties 280 nm, middle UV), which may cause discoloration,
of the acrylic emulsions have been improved using several cracks, and other damages on acrylic materials, and finally
chemically different additives. Depending on their type, UV-C (280 to 100 nm, far UV), which can cause chain
additives are able to modify color, to give resistance to heat scissions and/or cross-linking of the chemical structure of
degradation, to improve the performance, and also to the polymers; however, UV-C is completely absorbed by
increase resistance to light degradation [5]. The pigments the atmosphere.
can influence the chemical stability of the acrylics. They Over the past 20 years, the effects of photooxidation
themselves can also be considered as additives. Organic reactions due to UV light have been studied in detail [1, 20,
pigments tend to decrease the durability in comparison to 21]. For this purpose, different sources of UV light were
the inorganic. Titanium dioxide represents the most studied applied such as fluorescent [1, 20, 22] or mercury high-
pigment [6, 7]. Spathis et al. [6] studied the photo- pressure lamps [21]. Scalarone et al. [22] demonstrated that
degradation of a series of Paraloid B72 films containing different two types of artists' acrylic emulsion paints have a
titanium dioxide (TiO2) pigments. For this purpose, two high stability to photooxidation using fluorescent lamps and
crystallographic different kinds of TiO2, anatase and UV filters to remove the radiation below 400 nm. However,
anatase/rutile mixtures, were used in different concentra- no oxidation products were detected by Py-GC/MS and
tion. The results obtained by Fourier transform infrared infrared spectroscopy. Additionally, color measurements
spectroscopy (FTIR), gel permeation chromatography, and indicated a high resistance to yellowing, and a decreased
solubility measurements demonstrated that the presence of solubility of all p(nBA/MMA) copolymer paint samples in
anatase pigment significantly improved the photostability comparison with p(EA/MMA) copolymer paint samples
of Paraloid films. In contrast, it has also been reported that was determined.
anatase can form radicals and may degrade the polymers Chiantore et al. [23] used a Xenon light source filtered
due to its high reactivity to ultraviolet (UV) radiation [8]. for λ<295 nm for acrylic polymers characterized by long
More studies concerning the influence of inorganic pig- ester groups such as n-butyl groups and detected a fast and
ments on acrylic emulsions seem desirable. extensive cross-linking in combination with some fragmen-
Several studies on the identification and characterization tation, due to the favored oxidation on the tertiary carbon of
of pigmented and unpigmented acrylic emulsions have been the butyl group. When the alkyl side groups are short, the
carried out [3, 9–17]. One of the most detailed analytical chain scissions prevail over the cross-linking reactions [24].
studies on synthetic paints is presented by Learner [18]. In addition, some attentions have been paid to the
Py-GC/MS analytical technique allowed the identification competition between the chain scission reactions and the
of each synthetic polymer class showing a characteristic cross-linking reactions during the photooxidative degrada-
pyrogram. The main limitation of the technique was the tion. This is mainly due to the glass temperature Tg of
inability to carry out quantitative analysis on any of the the polymer. Polymer chains above their Tgs (surface
copolymers or mixtures of media, due to the quite common glass temperature transition) would preferentially undergo
fragmentation reactions on pyrolysis. Another analytical cross-linking [25].
method suitable for the identification of the compound class In contrast to these studies, the influence of UV-B light
is FTIR [19]. This technique is useful to fingerprint many on the stability/degradation of materials in artworks
synthetic polymer systems, but it does not give information presented under outdoor conditions has been investigated
about small differences of the chemical structures of the rarely. Furthermore, just a few systematic investigations on
UV ageing studies on acrylic binding media 2963

the formation of volatile compounds, which can be formed (ATR) to the mock-ups in a nondestructive manner, which
during photooxidative reactions and/or any changes by means that no sample material had to be gained from the
means of Py-GC/MS, especially in the double-shot mode, specimen.
have been described in the literature so far [5].
This technique has been considered as a useful and
powerful technique for the identification and characteriza- Experimental
tion of volatile compounds, polymeric materials, and
additives [5]. One of the big advantages of the double- Sample preparation
shot technique is that no additional sample is needed. With
one specimen, two analytical analyses can be carried out: Approximately 60 mg of pure acrylic binding media such
thermal desorption for the analysis of volatile compounds as Primal® AC33 and Plextol® D498 were cast on glass
and pyrolysis for the polymer itself. plates, which produced a dried film thickness in a range of
The aim of this work is the identification and 10–20 μm. Additionally, different mock-ups of pure
characterization of acrylic emulsions used as binding Primal® AC33 and Plextol® D498 mixed with inorganic
media in contemporary work of arts and to understand pigments such as titanium white (rutile and anatase),
their chemical reactions during UV exposure. Therefore, cadmium red, cadmium yellow, hydrated chrome oxide,
pure acrylic compounds as well as mixtures with ultramarine blue dark, raw umber Cyprus, and ivory black
inorganic pigments were tested in order to study any kind (Table 1) in a mixing ratio of about 3:1 were prepared on
of interactions between the color materials and the binding glass plates. The film thickness of these dried paint mixed
medium. The Py-GC/MS investigations were comple- samples was approximately in a range of 30–40 μm. In
mented by applying FTIR-attenuated total reflectance total, 12 identical specimens for each pure acrylic binding

Table 1 List of investigated mock-ups and their chemical and technical properties

Mock-ups Color Pigment classical Chemical composition Color index: Constitution number
name generic name of pigment

Primal® AC33+titanium white White Titanium white rutile p(EA/MMA)+TiO2 PW6 69


(rutile)
Primal® AC33+titanium White Titanium white anatasium p(EA/MMA)+TiO2 PW6 54
white (anatasium)
Primal® AC33+cadmium Red Cadmium red p(EA/MMA)+CdS, xCdSe PR 108 21120
red No. 1, light
Primal® AC33+cadmium Yellow Cadmium yellow p(EA/MMA)+CdS PY 37 21060
yellow No. 9 dark
Primal® AC33+hydrated Green Viridian p(EA/MMA)+Cr2O3 PG 18 44250
chrome oxide
Primal® AC33+ultramarine Blue Ultramarine blue p(EA/MMA)+ PB 29 45010
blue dark Na8Al6Si6O24.Sx
Primal® AC33+raw umber Brown Raw umber Cyprus p(EA/MMA)+ PBr 8 40610
Cyprus Fe2O3.H2O, MnO2
Primal® AC33+ivory black Black Bone (ivory) black p(EA/MMA)+C, PBk 9 47150
Ca3(PO4)2, CaCO3
Plextol® D498+titanium White Titanium white rutile p(nBA/MMA)+TiO2 PW6 69
white (rutile)
Plextol® D498+titanium White Titanium white anatasium p(nBA/MMA)+TiO2 PW6 54
white (anatasium)
Plextol® D498+cadmium Red Cadmium red p(nBA/MMA)+CdS, xCdSe PR 108 21120
red No. 1, light
Plextol® D498+cadmium Yellow Cadmium yellow p(nBA/MMA)+CdS PY 37 21060
yellow No. 9 dark
Plextol® D498+hydrated Green Viridian p(nBA/MMA)+Cr2O3 PG 18 44250
chrome oxide
Plextol® D498+ultramarine Blue Ultramarine blue p(nBA/MMA)+ PB 29 45010
blue dark Na8Al6Si6O24.Sx
Plextol® D498+raw umber Brown Raw umber Cyprus p(nBA/MMA)+Fe2O3. PBr 8 40610
Cyprus H2O, MnO2
Plextol® D498+ivory black Black Bone (ivory) black p(nBA/MMA)+C, PBk 9 47150
Ca3(PO4)2, CaCO3
2964 V. Pintus, M. Schreiner

medium and three for each pigment mixed with an acrylic autosampler into the furnace of the pyrolyzer and heated
emulsion were made, in order to obtain sufficient samples under the desired temperature conditions (e.g., from 50 °C
for the tests in the UV chamber. After drying for 24 h at to 300 °C in approximately 16 min) as it is shown in Fig. 1.
room temperature, all glass plates were arranged in the UV When the thermal desorption program is finished, the
chamber, except standard samples for the unaged compo- sample cup containing the remaining fraction is pulled up
sition. All acrylic emulsions binding media and inorganic from the heated zone, while the volatile organic compounds
pigments are products of KREMER (Kremer Pigmente produced from the thermal desorption are analyzed by the
Gmbh & Co. KG, Germany) except the white pigments, GC/MS. Meanwhile, the furnace is cooled down to
which are part of the material collection of the ISTA approximately 60 °C (autocooling) and then heated to the
(Institute for Science and Technology in Art) at the pyrolysis temperature conditions (e.g., 600 °C). As soon as
Academy of Fine Arts in Vienna. the GC/MS finishes to chromatographically separate and
detect the volatile compounds, the sample cup is dropped
UV exposure down for a second time into the pyrolyzer furnace in order
to perform flash pyrolysis, and the sample material is
UV exposure of the samples was carried out in a UV analyzed by the GC/MS.
chamber UVACUBE SOL 2/400F produced by Dr. For this investigation, Py-GC/MS analyses were per-
Hönle GmbH UV-Technology, Germany. The radiation formed with a PY AOC-20i (Frontier Lab, Japan) combined
source of UV light was supplied by a 910-W/m2 Xenon with a GCMS-QP2010 Plus (Shimadzu, Japan) equipped
arc solar simulator with an incorporated H2 filter, which with a capillary column SLB-5ms SUPELCO, USA
provides radiation with wavelengths between 295 and (30 m×0.25 mm×0.25 μm) using bonded and highly
800 nm. The chamber temperature was 48.8 °C; the cross-linked 5% diphenyl/95% methyl siloxane.
relative humidity (RH) varied between 30% and 35%, The GC column temperature conditions were as follows:
depending on the RH in the ambient atmosphere. initial temperature 40 °C, hold for 5 min, and afterwards
Unfortunately, no control of the RH is possible in the increased by 10 °C/min to 292 °C. The helium gas flow
UV exposure chamber used. Samples were aged for 31 was set at 1 mL/min, and mass spectra were recorded under
and 83 days, respectively. electron impact ionization at 70 eV. For the single-shot
analyses, the pyrolysis temperature was set at 600 °C and
Pyrolysis gas chromatography/mass spectrometry held for 1 min; the temperature of the pyrolysis interface
(PY-GC/MS) and the injector was set at 250 °C.
The double-shot parameters were as follows: for the
For the identification and characterization of the samples thermal desorption, the temperature was set at 50 °C, held
before and after UV exposure, analyses with pyrolysis gas for 2 min, and increased by 20 °C/min to 300 °C and held
chromatography/mass spectrometry (Py-GC/MS) were car- there for 2 min. After cooling (autocooling to approximate-
ried out. Particular attention was paid to the comparison of ly 60 °C), the pyrolysis was carried out at 600 °C and held
two different analytical methods: (1) single-shot method for 1 min.
based on pyrolysis for the analysis of polymers and (2) Between 80 and 300 μg of the samples were scraped
double-shot method, which allows the combination of from the mock-ups with a scalpel and put in a sample cup
thermal desorption for the analysis of volatile compounds (ECO-CUP Frontier Lab, Japan) in order to provide the
and pyrolysis of the polymers themselves. In order to analysis through the pyrolyzer. NIST 05 and NIST 05s
perform the thermal desorption of the volatile compounds, Library of Mass Spectra were used for identifying the
the sample is dropped down in a small cup by the compounds.

Fig. 1 Schematic heating curve Pyrolyzer furnace temp.


of the double-shot technique Sample temp.
for Py-GC/MS 600˚C
Autocooling

300˚C

50˚C
Thermal Desorption GC Analysis Flash Pyrolysis Time
UV ageing studies on acrylic binding media 2965

Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy-attenuated total also by artists. Nowadays, it is out of production by
reflectance (FTIR-ATR) Kremer, but other companies, which provide also materials
for art and restoration, produce similar products as
FTIR-ATR analyses were performed with an Alpha FT-IR Rhoplex® AC 33 (Rohm and Haas, Germany) and Acrylic
Platinum ATR instrument (Bruker Optics, Germany) 33 EMULSIONE ACRILICA (Bresciani, Italy), which are
equipped with a deuterated triglicine sulfate detector widely used.
(DTGS) and with a diamond crystal. Spectra were acquired It is well known that under pyrolysis condition, p(EA/
in a spectral range between 4,000 and 370 cm−1 performing MMA) binding media decompose to the respective mono-
64 scans at 4 cm−1 resolution. The resulting spectra were mers as well as to dimers and trimers in lower amounts [9,
collected and evaluated with the spectrum software OPUS® 11, 18]. As described by Learner [18], due to the presence
of Bruker Optics. of tertiary hydrogen atoms on the polymer chain, acrylates
are prone to the abstraction of the hydrogen with a
subsequent production of free radicals along the polymer
Results and discussion chain. This permits the production of various oligomers.
The identification of Primal® AC33 as p(EA/MMA) is
Unaged samples challenging due to the same molecular weight of both
monomers. For instance, the assignment of the EA-EA-
Pure acrylic binding media: Py-GC/MS results MMA trimers reported in the literature is based on the
expected retention time, due to their similar mass spectra
The pure acrylic binding medium Primal® AC33 was [11].
identified and characterized as a co-emulsion of poly(ethyl In Fig. 2 (pyrogram a), the most intense peak is related
acrylate/methyl methacrylate), p(EA/MMA). This product to ethyl acrylate (EA) at RT 4.1 min with a molecular ion at
is usually used as adhesive, consolidant [26], as well as m/z=55 from the loss of an ethoxy side group. At similar
binding medium in the field of conservation-restoration but retention times (RT 4.4 min), the methyl-methacrylate

Fig. 2 Overall pyrograms of f)


Primal® AC 33 p(EA/MMA). a
Unaged sample analyzed in IV
single-shot mode (SS) and (b)
I
unaged sample analyzed in II III
double-shot mode: thermal e)
desorption and (c) pyrolysis. d
Aged sample (83 days) analyzed
in single-shot mode and (e) aged
d)
sample analyzed in double-shot
mode: thermal desorption and
(f) pyrolysis. Peaks labeled 1
and 2 correspond to phtalic acid,
Relative intensity

di-(1-hexen-5-yl)ester, and
phtalic acid, monobutyl ester,
respectively. Peaks labeled I
(octyl ether m/z=57, 70, 112,
and 129), II (octyl ether
m/z=57,70, 112, and 127), III
(di-n-octyl phthalate m/z=57, c)
71, 113, 149, 207, and 279), 2
1
and IV (squalene m/z=55, 69,
b)
MMA
EA

95, and 121) probably from


air or contaminations
trimers
sesquimer-dimer
EMA

a)
0 10 20 30 40
Retention time (min)
2966 V. Pintus, M. Schreiner

(MMA) monomer was detected with the characteristic m/z= a peak of EA trimer (m/z=79, 106, 134, 181, 208, and 255)
69. A less intense peak of EMA with m/z=69 was recorded at RT 32.7 min (Fig. 2, pyrogram a). The identification of
at RT 6.6 min. In a previous study [27], this peak suggested these compounds is in accord with several other case
that two analyzed acrylic emulsions such as Plextol® B500 studies [3, 18], and it was possible to detect them in the
and Primal® AC33 could be terpolymers of p(EA-MMA- single-shot mode.
EMA). As discussed by Learner [14], the EMA presence The double-shot mode, more precisely with the thermal
cannot be ascribed to this terpolymer species because they desorption shown in Fig. 2 (pyrogram b), allowed the
are produced on pyrolysis of the pEA homopolymers. The identification of two chemical fragments such as phtalic
two peaks of EA and MMA indicate a co-emulsion of EA/ acid, di–(1–hexen–5–yl)ester (m/z=65, 93, and 149) at RT
MMA polymer. In addition, four peaks corresponding to 28.2 min (indicated with the peak labeled 1) and phtalic
EA-MMA sesquimer (one and a half monomer unit acid, monobutyl ester (m/z=56, 93, 149, and 160) at RT
molecule) at RT 20.5 min (m/z=55, 101, 128, and 157), 34.8 min (indicated with the peak labeled 2), which may
EA-MMA dimer at RT 21.3 min (m/z=67, 95, 140, and indicate the presence of a phthalate–ester-based plasticizer,
168), EA sesquimer at RT 21.4 min (m/z=55, 87, 143, and which are additives mainly incorporated into polymers by
162), and EA dimer at RT 22.6 min (m/z=53, 98, 126, 154, blending and commonly used in thermoplastic polymers in
and 200) were identified (Fig. 2, pyrogram a). EA dimer order to increase their flexibility, workability, or extensibility
corresponds to the largest peak in this group, while the EA- [28]. However, their detection is ambiguous, as any peak
MMA sesquimer and dimer are the less intense one. It was related to the phthalate plasticizer was detected in the
also possible to observe two peaks of EA-EA-MMA trimer single-shot mode at higher temperature. Due to their very
(m/z=55, 93, 139, 166, 200, 255, 269 and m/z=55, 93, 121, low concentration and high volatility, they may also derive
167, 200, 255, 269) at RT 31.3 min and at RT 33.0 min and from air pollutants or contamination in the laboratory.

Fig. 3 Recognition of an octyl d)


m/z 135
phenyl polyethoxy ethanol
surfactant in Primal® AC33,
p(EA/MMA) acrylic emulsion:
a total ion chromatogram
(×10,000,000) of the unaged
sample analyzed in single-shot
mode and (b) single ion mass
profile at m/z 135, a marker ion
fragment of octyl phenol. c Total
ion chromatogram
(×10,000,000) of the sample
analyzed in single-shot mode
after 83 days of UV ageing and
(d) single ion mass profile at
TIC
m/z 135, a marker ion c)
Relative intensity

fragment of octyl phenol

m/z 135 b)

TIC
a)

0 10 20 30 40
Retention time (min)
UV ageing studies on acrylic binding media 2967

Additionally, it was possible to detect some marker MMA), MMA and nBA have a different molecular weight,
peaks of a nonionic surfactant such as octyl phenyl and their oligomers can be easily distinguished by
polyethoxy ethanol, which is commonly present in the identification of their mass spectra. The pyrogram of
recent paint formulations. Generally, they are in small Plextol® D498 in Fig. 4 (pyrogram a) depicted the most
concentrations, and its marker peaks might be partially or intense peak of nBA (m/z=55, 73, 85, and 128) at RT
totally overlaid by other components. Due to the fact that 10.6 min, where the intense fragment peak at m/z=55 is
the presence of pyrolysis fragments of the nonionic similar to EA. The production of n-butene and protonated
surfactant was not evident from the total ion chromatogram, acrylic acid is indicated by the additional masses at
by plotting the corresponding single ion mass profiles at m/z=56 and 73, respectively. MMA peak (m/z=69 and
m/z=135, the octyl phenol (m/z=135, 206) was detected 100) was also detected at RT 4.4 min. Another peak at RT
(Fig. 3, pyrogram b). This is a marker compound of 3.5 min was identified as n-butanol (m/z=56). Addition-
alkyraryl polythoxylates for the nonionic surfactant octyl ally, a peak corresponding to nBMA (m/z=56, 69, and 87)
phenyl polyethoxy ethanol [3]. was detected at RT 13.3 min. As it was observed for
In contrast to these results, Plextol® D498 was Primal® AC33 at higher retention times, several peaks
characterized as a co-emulsion of poly(butyl acrylate/ were recorded (Fig. 4, pyrogram a). The first group of four
methyl methacrylate), p(nBA/MMA). Nowadays, most of peaks corresponds to the sesquimers and dimers. Under
the artists' acrylic emulsion paints are based on p(nBA/ electron impact ionization (EI) even if the molecular ions
MMA) copolymers [29], which show superior hydropho- are not detected, the sesquimers and dimers can be
bicity in comparison with p(EA/MMA). Unlike p(EA/ recognized by characteristic fragment ions obtained by

Fig. 4 Overall pyrograms of


Plextol® D498 p(nBA/MMA).
a Unaged sample analyzed in
single-shot mode (SS) and (b) f)
unaged sample analyzed in
double-shot mode: thermal 1 3 5 e)
desorption and (c) pyrolysis. d
nBA

Aged sample (83 days) analyzed


in single-shot mode and (e) aged
sample analyzed in double-shot
mode: thermal desorption and
(f) pyrolysis. Peaks: (1) phthalic d)
anhydride (m/z=76, 104, and
148), (3) diethyl phthalate
(m/z=65, 93, 149, and 177), (5)
phthalic acid, butyl undecyl
ester (m/z=57, 104, 121, and
Relative intensity

149), and (2) phenol,3,5-


bis(1,1-dimethylethyl)
(m/z=57, 91, 135, 163, 191,
and 220), (4) phenol,2-(1,1-
dimethylethyl)-4-(1,1,3,
3-tetramethylbutyl) (m/z=57, c)
91, 147, 175, 191, and 262)

1 3 4 b)
2 5
MMA

sesquimer-dimer

trimers
n-butanol

nBMA

a)

0 10 20 30 40
Retention time (min)
2968 V. Pintus, M. Schreiner

scission of a methoxy or butoxy group to give [M-31]+ Furthermore, with the double-shot technique in the
and [M-73]+ cations. Two peaks were related to nBA thermal desorption mode, peaks were registered related to
sesquimer (m/z=57, 87, 115, 142, 171, and 189) and to the phthalic anhydride (m/z=76, 104, and 148) at RT
nBA dimer (m/z=57, 98, 127, and 183) at RT 29.5 min 22.4 min, to the diethyl phthalate (m/z=65, 93, 149, and
and at RT 30.4 min, respectively. The other two peaks at 177) at RT 28.2 min, and to phthalic acid, butyl undecyl
RT 24.9 min and at RT 25.5 min were identified as nBA- ester (m/z=57, 104, 121, and 149) at RT 34.9 min, which
MMA sesquimer (m/z=55, 73, 115, 143, and 185) and are commonly known to be related to a phthalate-based
nBA-MMA dimer (m/z=57, 67, 95, 112, 126, and 141). plasticizer. They are indicated in Fig. 4 (pyrogram b) with
The later group of four peaks corresponds to the trimers. the peak numbers 1, 3, and 5, respectively. As for Primal®
The most intense peak is the pure nBA trimer (m/z=57, AC33, they possibly derive from sample contamination or
109, 134, 181, 208, 236, 282, and 311) at RT 40.9 min. from air pollutants, since no peaks related to the phthalic
The other three peaks eluted at RT 37.0, 37.4, and plasticizer are recorded in the pyrolysis. In Fig. 4 (pyrogram
38.9 min are the nBA-nBA-MMA trimers (m/z=57, 93, b), other two peaks labeled as numbers 2 and 4 were
139, 195, 250, 283, 325; m/z=57, 93, 120, 167, 195, 250, detected possibly related to an antioxidant: phenol,3,5-bis
283, 325; and m/z=57, 93, 121, 167, 195, 228, 283, 296; (1,1-dimethylethyl) (m/z=57, 91, 135, 163, 191, and 220) at
Fig. 4, pyrogram a). RT 26.6 min and phenol, 2-(1,1-dimethylethyl)-4-(1,1,3,3-
Unlike Primal® AC33, the detection of the sesquimers, tetramethylbutyl) (m/z=57, 91, 147, 175, 191, and 262).
dimers, and trimers is shown already during the thermal Similar to Primal® AC33, the octyl phenol was detected
desorption in the double-shot mode (Fig. 4, pyrogram b). (Fig. 5, pyrogram b) by plotting the corresponding single
Due to the presence of the oligomers in the thermal ion mass profiles at m/z=135. Due to its low intensity in the
desorpted pyrogram, the unzipping effect of the polymer pyrogram of the single-shot mode, it is only visible by
seems to be less in comparison to the pyrolyzed pyrogram, plotting the corresponding single ion mass profile in the
whereas at this higher temperature, the complete decompo- thermal desorption pyrogram, acquired with the double-shot
sition of the polymer occurred with the production of mode. In this case, the presence of m/z=135 marker ion
monomers. fragment was clearly acquired (Fig. 5, pyrogram b).
Fig. 5 Recognition of an octyl d)
phenyl polyethoxy ethanol m/z 135
surfactant in Plextol® D498,
p(nBA/MMA) acrylic emulsion.
a Total ion chromatogram
(×1,000,000) of the unaged
sample analyzed in double-shot
mode, thermal desorption, and
(b) single ion mass profile at c)
m/z 135, a marker ion fragment
of octyl phenol. c Total ion TIC
chromatogram (×1,000,000)
of the sample analyzed in
double-shot mode after m/z 135 b)
Relative intensity

83 days of UV ageing,
thermal desorption, and
(d) single ion mass profile
at m/z 135, a marker ion
fragment of octyl phenol

a)

TIC

0 10 20 30 40
Retention time (min)
UV ageing studies on acrylic binding media 2969

Pure acrylic binding media: FTIR-ATR results C–H bending (1,300–1,500 cm−1): Plextol® D498 has
the most intense peak at 1,449 cm−1 and a smaller one
The FTIR-ATR results of the two acrylic emulsion binding at 1,386 cm−1 close to other two small peaks at 1,360
media are shown in Table 2 and summarized in the and 1,343 cm−1. Primal® AC33 has a double peak at
following regions: 1,466 and 1,451 cm−1 and a less intense one at
1,381 cm−1. Additionally, other two peaks were
C–H stretching (2,800–3,100 cm−1): Primal® AC33 detected at 1,360 and 1,343 cm−1, similar but with a
showed the main C–H stretching frequencies at higher intensity than for Plextol® D498.
2,888 cm−1 complemented by two smaller peaks at C–O stretching C–C skeletal vibrations (900–1,250 cm−1):
2,949 and 2,741 cm−1. In contrast, the spectrum of In this frequency region, a double peak at 1,159 and
Plextol® D498 had two peaks at 2,955 and 2,929 cm−1 1,143 cm−1 was observed in the Plextol® D498 spectrum
and a smaller one at 2,874 cm−1. with another less intense peak at 1,236 cm−1. Primal®
C=O stretching (1,700–1,750 cm−1): In both spectra AC33 showed the most intense one at 1,109 cm−1 and
for Primal® AC33 and Plextol® D498, the carbonyl other two intense peaks at 1,149 and 1,240 cm−1.
stretching absorption occurs at a similar wavelength, at
1,723 and at 1,726 cm−1, respectively. Additionally, polyethoxylated surfactant with the char-
acteristic absorption bands at 2,890, 1,455, 1,343, 1,296,
1,110, 945, and 842 cm−1 [22] was detected in the
Primal® AC33 and Plextol® D498 acrylic emulsions. Due
Table 2 ATR infrared absorptions of the investigated acrylic binding to the main absorption of the acrylic emulsion binding
media media, in the case of Primal® AC 33, the most visible
Bond type Primal® AC33 Plextol® D498
peaks corresponded to 2,890, 1,343, 1,110, and 963 cm−1.
p(EA/MMA) (cm−1) p(nBA/MMA) (cm−1) Unlike Primal® AC33, Plextol® D498 showed only two
peaks at 1,343 and 1,110 cm−1 characteristic for the
C–H rock 759 754 surfactant.
– 808
843 842 Acrylic binding media mixed with inorganic pigments:
C–C stretching – 944 Py-GC/MS and FTIR-ATR results
964 963
– 990 Mainly due to the presence of the inorganic compounds in
C–O stretching 1,021 1,022 the matrix, the Py-GC/MS results obtained from both
1,061 1,063 acrylic binding media mixed with inorganic pigments did
1,109 1,115 not show any differences in comparison with the pure
1,149 1,143 acrylic binding media described in “Pure acrylic binding
– 1,159 media: Py-GC/MS results” section. Also, the FTIR-ATR
1,240 1,236 spectra are the results of the spectra of the pure pigments
1,279 – and of the binding media themselves and will not be
C–H bending 1,343 1,343 discussed in detail here. Nevertheless, some of the pigments
1,360 1,361 used for preparing the mock-ups masked in some infrared
1,381 1,386 regions the detection of the binding media with their strong
– 1,436 shoulder infrared absorption. For instance, blue ultramarine, which is
1,451 1,449 a pigment composed of silicon, aluminum, sodium, sulfur,
1,466 – and oxygen, shows overlapping stretching bands for Si–O–
1,513 – Si and Si–O–Al between 1,150 and 950 cm−1. These bands
C=O stretching 1,723 1,726 interfered with the C–O/C–C skeletal vibrations (900–
C–H stretching – 2,852 shoulder 1,250 cm−1) regions of the acrylic binding media. More-
2,860 – over, these regions are masked by the ivory black pigment,
– 2,874 which is composed of amorphous carbon with calcium
2,888 – phosphate Ca3(PO4)2 and calcium carbonate CaCO3, with
– 2,931
an intense peak at 1,020 cm−1 of the phosphate groups. The
2,949 –
umber Cyprus pigment based on iron oxide Fe2O3 with
2,955
water manganese oxide MnO 2 has a band around
1,000 cm−1 of the iron oxides.
2970 V. Pintus, M. Schreiner

Aged samples m/z=57, 71, 113, 149, 207, and 279, labeled III) and at
RT 46.8 min (squalene m/z=55, 69, 95, and 121, labeled
Pure acrylic binding media: Py-GC/MS results IV) are probably from the ambient atmosphere or other
contaminations.
The comparison between the results obtained from unaged Concerning Plextol® D498, the main difference between
and aged samples reveals that the effects of the photoox- the UV-aged and unaged sample is the total decrease of the
idative reactions could be determined only after 83 days of phenolic antioxidant peak (Fig. 6a, pyrogram c), which was
UV exposure. The main difference between UV-aged and detected in the unaged sample by the double-shot mode.
unaged Primal® AC33 sample is the gradual reduction in These additives are generally considered having poor
area of the main peaks, which is shown in Fig. 2 (pyro- photostability [30, 31]. Another product, which was
grams d and e). The most intense peak of EA in comparison difficult to be detected in the aged pure and pigment-
with the MMA peak decreased gradually after UV mixed Plextol® D498 acrylic binding medium, was the
exposure, whereas the MMA peak became the most intense butyl group (Fig. 6b, pyrograms a and d), which is more
one. In addition, the dimers, sesquimers, and trimers peaks sensitive to photooxidation reactions compared to the
diminished almost totally, which is mainly due to the acrylic binding media with a lower structural unit, e.g.,
photodeterioration of the ethyl groups. Additionally, methyl or ethyl group [23]. When the ester side group is
another indication for a photooxidation process was shown short, chain scissions occur to a higher extent than cross-
by the surfactant: plotting the corresponding single ion linking reactions.
mass profile at m/z=135 of octyl phenol detected in the Furthermore, similar to Primal® AC33, it is possible to
unaged sample in the pyrolysis pyrogram acquired with the see in Fig. 4 (pyrograms d and f) a strong reduction of the
single-shot mode, no traces were found in the pyrogram of areas of the dimers, sesquimers, and trimers peaks, which
the aged material (Fig. 3, pyrogram d). The only difference, might be due to the photooxidation of the butyl group.
which could be noticed to the results obtained in the These peaks were already detected in the thermal desorp-
double-shot mode, was the detection of the dimers, trimers, tion pyrogram (Fig. 4, pyrogram e), but their areas are
and sesquimers peaks in the thermal desorption pyrogram, reduced in comparison with the unaged sample. Another
which were not detected in the unaged material. The difference between the unaged and aged samples related is
photoageing processes have evidently changed the thermal shown by the peak of nBA in Fig. 4 (pyrograms a, c, d, and
stability of the sample with a consequent production of f). In pyrograms a and c, the peak of nBA is the most
oligomers already during the thermal desorption and intensive and especially more intense than the peak of
almost no longer detectable in the pyrolysis. New peaks MMA. After 83 days of UV exposure, it became consid-
clearly visible in the thermal desorption (Fig. 2, pyrogram erably less intense.
e) at RT 37.1 min (octyl ether m/z=57, 70, 112, and 129, Similar to Primal® AC33 by plotting the corresponding
labeled I), at RT 40.0 min (octyl ether m/z=57, 70, 112, and single ion mass profile at m/z=135 of the previous detected
127, labeled II), as at RT 43.3 min (di-n-octyl phthalate octyl phenol in the thermal desorption pyrogram, acquired
(x10,000) (x10,000)
1.0 1.0
56
57

a) 0.5
191 b) 0.5

91 163 87
135 220 0.0
0.0
50 150 200 50 100

f) f)
Relative intensity

e) e)

d) d)
c) c)

b) b)
a) a)
26.50 26.75 27.00 27.25 27.50 27.75 6.5 7.0 7.5 8.0 8.5
Retention time (min) Retention time (min)

Fig. 6 a, b Detail of the pyrograms of Plextol® D498 p(nBA/MMA). (e) Aged sample analyzed in double-shot mode: thermal desorption
a Unaged sample analyzed in single-shot mode (SS) and (b) aged and (f) pyrolysis. a Shows the mass spectra of the phenolic antioxidant
sample (83 days) analyzed in single-shot mode and (c) unaged sample which can not be detected in the aged sample. b Shows the mass
analyzed in double-short mode: thermal desorption and d pyrolysis. spectra of the butyl ester which is not detected in the aged sample
UV ageing studies on acrylic binding media 2971

Fig. 7 FTIR-ATR spectra of 1725 1139

2.0
Plextol® D498 p(nBA/MMA)
mixed with cadmium red
before (a), after 31 days of UV
ageing (b), and 83 days of
UV ageing (c)

1.5
Absorbance Units
1233

1.0
983
1447 753
1385 841

0.5 2955 c)

2874 b)

a)
0.0

3500 3000 2500 2000 1500 1000 500


Wavenumber cm-1

with the double-shot mode, no traces were found anymore principle absorptions, which might be due to the loss of
(Fig. 5, pyrogram d). volatile compounds. Especially the gradual reduction of the
Besides these differences, in both Primal® AC33 as well absorption of the carbonyl group at 1,726 cm−1 can be
as Plextol® D498, no formation of new peaks related to related to the loss of the butyl group of the Plextol® D498
new volatile compounds or new products, which could be and of the ethyl group related to the Primal® AC33.
formed during the photooxidative process, could be Additionally, the broadening of the carbonyl band indicates
detected. a progressive absorption (1) at 1,773 cm−1 corresponding
probably to the formation of a γ-lactone structure, which
Pure acrylic binding media: FTIR-ATR results absorbs at 1,780 cm−1 [21, 24, 32], or to the formation of
open chain anhydrides, which absorb at 1,800 cm−1 [33].
The comparison of the spectra obtained from unaged and (2) Additionally, the frequency region between 1,600 and
aged Plextol® D498 as well as Primal® AC33 shows 1,710 cm−1 is of interest, which may be related to the
differences mainly based on the progressive decrease of all formation of unsaturated molecules with a C=C bond at

Fig. 8 FTIR-ATR spectra of 1723 1108


Primal® AC33 p(EA/MMA)
2.0

mixed with cadmium red


1153
before (a), after 31 days of
UV ageing (b), and 83 days
of UV ageing (c)
1.5
Absorbance Units

1019
1.0

1234
963
1342 850
2887 1381
1445 756
0.5

2950
2980
c)

b) a)
0.0

3500 3000 2500 2000 1500 1000 500


Wavenumber cm-1
2972 V. Pintus, M. Schreiner

Fig. 9 FTIR-ATR spectra of

2.0
Primal® AC33 p(EA/MMA)
mixed with rutile titanium white
before (a), after 31 days of 1109
UV ageing (b), and 83 days
of UV ageing (c)

1.5
1722

Absorbance Units
1148

1.0
2886 1240 1061
1341 1022
842
1381 963
2949 1444
2980

C
B
A
0.0

3500 3000 2500 2000 1500 1000 500


Wavenumber cm-1

1,652 cm−1, due to polymer chain scissions [21]. It might (e.g., Fig. 7). Similar results have been reported in the
be also a result from the formation of ketones absorbing at literature [22, 35].
1,710 cm−1 as a consequence of the reaction of oxygen
molecules with radicals and followed by ß-scission [34]. Acrylic binding media mixed with inorganic pigments:
A gradual reduction of the absorption of the character- Py-GC/MS results
istic peaks of PEG type surfactant was observed by both
acrylic emulsions after UV exposure. Especially after The acrylic binding media mixed with inorganic pigments did
83 days of UV ageing, the sharp peaks at 2,890, 1,343, not show significant changes after the UV exposure, apart
1,110, and 963 cm−1 totally decreased according to the Py- from a more pronounced decrease of all principal peaks and
GC/MS results, which also did not show any traces of the formation of new small peaks with a characterization mass
surfactant found in unaged samples. These differences are m/z=59, 83, 99, 141, and 169 which were detected by the
clearly visible also when they are mixed with pigments thermal desorption. Unfortunately, it was not possible to

Fig. 10 FTIR-ATR spectra of


2.0

Plextol® D498 p(nBA/MMA)


mixed with blue ultramarine
before (a), after 31 days of 962
UV ageing (b), and 83 days
of UV ageing (c)
1.5

1727
Absorbance Units

1112
1144
1.0

651
688
582
1236
0.5

2955 1450
1385
2874
B C
A
0.0

3500 3000 2500 2000 1500 1000 500

Wavenumber cm-1
UV ageing studies on acrylic binding media 2973

Fig. 11 FTIR-ATR spectra of 1725

2.0
Plextol® D498 p(nBA/MMA)
mixed with umber Cyprus
before (a), after 31 days of
UV ageing (b), and 83 days
1142
of UV ageing (c) 1160

1.5
Absorbance Units
1.0
b)
c)
1449
0.5 1385
2955 841 a)
1063
2874
754
0.0

3500 3000 2500 2000 1500 1000 500


-1
Wavenumber cm

identify those peaks, which could be primarily registered for pigment mixed with Plextol® D498 as well as with Primal®
the samples with Plextol® D498 mixed with blue ultrama- AC33 before and after UV exposure showed some changes in
rine. It might be due to the presence of the blue pigment in the IR absorption similar to alterations recorded from the aged
the acrylic binding media, which influences its stability. pure acrylic binding media:

Acrylic binding media mixed with inorganic pigments: (a) A gradual broadening in the region between 3,600 and
FTIR-ATR results 3,000 cm−1, which might be due to the formation of
associated hydroxyl groups, belonging to alcoholic
Acrylic emulsions mixed with inorganic or organic pigments and/or hydroperoxidic structures [21].
can behave differently during UV exposure. Pigments might (b) In general, the absorption of the carbonyl peak at
affect the stability of the polymers as well as the properties of 1,722 cm−1 decreased gradually after 31 and 83 days
the paint formulation and catalyzing photochemical reactions. of UV ageing. However, in the case of cadmium red
In our study, the comparison of the results obtained for each mixed with Plextol® D498 (Fig. 7), that change could
Fig. 12 FTIR-ATR spectra of 1722 1152 1111
2.0

Primal® AC33 p(EA/MMA)


mixed with cadmium yellow
before (a), after 31 days of UV
ageing (b), and 83 days of UV
ageing (c) 1018
1.5
Absorbance Units

1233
963
849
1.0

1379
1444 1343
755
2950
2980 2888

c)
0.5

b) a)
0.0

3500 3000 2500 2000 1500 1000 500

Wavenumber cm-1
2974 V. Pintus, M. Schreiner

Fig. 13 FTIR-ATR spectra of 1110

2.0
Primal® AC33 p(EA/MMA)
mixed with anatase titanium
white before (a), after 31 days of
UV ageing (b), and 83 days of
UV ageing (c)

1.5
1723 1149
b)

Absorbance Units
c)

1.0
1239 a)
1021
1342 843
1381 964
2889
0.5
1445
2950 752
2984
0.0

3500 3000 2500 2000 1500 1000 500


-1
Wavenumber cm

not be observed. This is probably due to the compen- (Fig. 10), the broadening in these regions is related to
sation of the loss of ester groups with some new the increase of γ-lactones [21, 24, 32, 33], and it is well
oxidation products such as aldehyde groups absorbing pronounced in comparison to the broadening of the
in the same region and formed by reaction of the region of the ketones groups or open chain anhydrides.
secondary macroradical with oxygen [24]. In contrast to
these results, Primal® AC33 mixed with cadmium red Completely different results were obtained for Plextol®
(Fig. 8), as well as with the rutile titanium white D498 mixed with the umber Cyprus (Fig. 11). A higher
(Fig. 9), showed a higher absorption in this range. absorption in the region between 1,710 and 1,600 cm−1 could
(c) Significant for the photooxidative processes of the be observed in comparison to the γ-lactone region (1,830–
samples is the progressive broadening of the carbonyl 1,700 cm−1). Similar results were obtained for the mixture of
band in the frequency regions between 1,830 and cadmium yellow with Primal® AC33 (Fig. 12).
1,730 cm−1 and between 1,710 and 1,600 cm−1. In the Additionally, acrylic media mixed with pigments showed a
case of Plextol® D498 mixed with blue ultramarine total decrease in absorption of the bands of the nonionic

Fig. 14 FTIR-ATR spectra of 1724 1139


2.0

Plextol® D498 p(nBA/MMA)


mixed with cadmium yellow
before (a), after 31 days of UV
ageing (b), and 83 days of UV
ageing (c)
1.5

1064
Absorbance Units

1233

985
1.0

1447 841
1385 755
c)

2954
0.5

2874 b)

a)
0.0

3500 3000 2500 2000 1500 1000 500


Wavenumber cm-1
UV ageing studies on acrylic binding media 2975

polyethoxylated surfactants after 83 days of UV ageing. nounced in acrylic binding media mixed with pigments,
Especially when Primal® AC33 was mixed with cadmium which obviously increase the reactivity of the acrylic
yellow (Fig. 12), cadmium red (Fig. 8), as well as rutile binding media. The specific FTIR-ATR results indicate that
(Fig. 9) and anatase (Fig. 13), the absorption of the C–H each particular pigment induces characteristic reactions
stretching band at 2,888 cm−1 decreased while other two with the binding media under UV exposure.
peaks at 2,950 and 2,980 cm−1 corresponding to the C–H The present study shows that the double-shot technique
stretching were formed. Additionally, the C–H bending peak of Py-GC/MS enabled the detection of an additive in
at 1,343 cm−1, the C–C stretching peak at 963 cm−1, and the unaged Plextol® D498, otherwise unnoticed by single-shot
C–O peak at 1,109 cm−1 disappeared after 83 days of UV technique, but—possibly because of too high thermal
ageing. Further changes of the absorption spectrum related to desorption temperature applied—it failed for the identifica-
the photooxidative processes are shown by Plextol® D498 tion of volatile compounds, which were recorded in aged
mixed with blue ultramarine (Fig. 10): two peaks at 1,144 samples by FTIR-ATR.
and 1,111 cm−1 corresponding to the C–O stretching and
another peak at 846 cm−1 related to the C–H rock Acknowledgements This work has been funded by Regione
Sardegna (Italy), “Programma Master and Back anno 2009” Alta
progressively decreased. This effect related to the bands at
Formazione and the Austrian Science Fund, Project no. L699-N17.
1,111 and 846 cm−1 can be connected to the loss of ester
group, in agreement with the reduction of C=O absorption
and to the fast oxidative chain scission of the polyethoxy-
lated surfactants when exposed to UV light [22, 35]. References
In contrast to all other pigments, all principal absorptions
gradually increased in the case of cadmium yellow mixed 1. Learner T, Chiantore O, Scalarone D (2002) Ageing studies on
with the Plextol® D498 (Fig. 14) and especially in acrylic emulsion paints, Preprints ICOM Committee for Conserva-
tion 13th Triennial Meeting. James & James (Science Publishers),
combination with Primal® AC33 (Fig. 12) corresponding
Rio de Janeiro, pp 911–919
to increases absorption of the ester side groups. 2. Lodge R (1988) A history of synthetic painting media with special
reference to commercial materials. In: Rosenberg S (ed) Preprints
of Papers Presented at Sixteenth Annual Meeting, New Orleans,
June 1–5 1988. American Institute for Conservation, Washington,
Conclusions
DC, pp 118–127
3. Scalarone D, Chiantore O (2004) J Sep Sci 27:263–274
Before UV exposure, the Py-GC/MS analyses of the 4. Hoogland FG, Boon JJ (2009) Int J Mass Spectr 284:72–80
investigated polymers identified two different types of 5. Herrera M, Matuschek G, Kettrup A (2003) J Anal Appl Pyrol
70:35–42
acrylic emulsions: poly(ethyl acrylate/methyl methacrylate)
6. Spathis P, Karagiannidou E, Magoula AE (2002) Stud Conserv
copolymer, p(EA/MMA) in Primal® AC33, and poly(n- 48:57–64
butyl acrylate/methyl methacrylate) copolymer, p(nBA/ 7. Day RE (1990) Polym Degrad Stab 29:73–92
MMA) in Plextol® D498. The presence of a polyethoxy- 8. Zorll U (2001) Waterbased acrylates for decorative coatings.
Vincent Verlag, Hannover
lated surfactant was detected in both acrylic emulsions by
9. Sonoda N, Rioux JP (1990) Stud Conserv 35:189–204
FTIR-ATR and by plotting the single ion chromatogram of 10. Sonoda N, Rioux JP, Duval AR (1993) Stud Conserv 38:99–127
the marker ion fragment of octyl phenol. Additionally, octyl 11. Chiantore O, Scalarone D, Learner T (2003) Int J Polym Anal
phenol has been determined in Plextol® D498 by the Charact 8:67–82
12. Jones FN, Mao W, Ziemer PD, Xiao F, Hayes J, Golden M (2004)
double-shot technique in the thermal desorption mode. A
Prog Org Coat 52:9–20
phenolic antioxidant in pure Plextol® D498 matrix could 13. Learner T (2000) Conservator 24:96–103
be detected by the double-shot technique. The identifica- 14. Learner T (2004) Analysis of modern paints. The Getty
tion of this additive is significant due to its importance for Conservation Institute, Los Angeles
15. Boon JJ, Learner T (2002) J Anal Appl Pyrol 64:327–344
the stability of acrylic materials during photooxidative
16. Stringari C, Pratt E (1991) The identification and characterization
processes. of acrylic emulsion paint media. In: Grattan D (ed) Saving the
After UV exposure, FTIR-ATR recorded newly formed twentieth century. Canadian Conservation Institute, Ottawa, pp
products including unspecific aldehyde, lactones, and acidic 411–440
17. Learner T (1995) The analysis of synthetic resins found in
oxidation products. Unfortunately, these products could not
twentieth-century paint media, Pre-prints, resins: ancient and
be identified by Py-GC/MS. A clearly visible difference modern. Scottish Society for Conservation and Restoration,
after UV exposure is the complete disappearance of the Edinburgh, pp 76–84
phenolic antioxidant in Plextol® D498 obtained by double- 18. Learner T (2001) Stud Conserv 46:225–241
19. Learner T (1998) The use of a diamond cell for the FTIR character-
shot, thermal desorption mode, which suggests that this
isation of paints and varnishes available to twentieth-century artists.
material showed minor UV stability compared with In: Pretzel B (ed) Postprints: infrared and Raman user's group
Primal® AC33. All alteration processes are more pro- conference. Victoria and Albert Museum, London, pp 7–20
2976 V. Pintus, M. Schreiner

20. Whitmore PM, Colaluca VG (1995) Stud Conserv 40:51–64 Thomson G (eds) Adhesives and consolidants, preprints of the
21. Melo MJ, Bracci S, Camaiti M, Chiantore O, Piacenti F (1999) contributions to the Paris Congress, 2–8 September 1984.
Polym Degrad Stab 66:23–30 International Institute for Conservation of Artistic and Historic
22. Scalarone D, Chiantore O, Learner T (2005) Ageing studies of Works, London, pp 36–43
acrylic emulsion paints. Part II. Comparing formulations with poly 28. Wang FC-Y (2000) J Chromatogr A 883:199–210
(EA-co-MMA) and poly(nBA-co-MMA) binders, Preprints ICOM 29. Hellgren AC, Weissenborn P, Holmberg K (1999) Prog Org Coat
Committee for Conservation 14th Triennial Meeting. James & 35:79–87
James/Earthscan, The Hague, pp 350–358 30. Pospíšil J (1993) Polym Degrad Stab 39:103–115
23. Chiantore O, Lazzari M (2001) Polymer 42:17–27 31. Pospíšil J (1988) Polym Degrad Stab 20:181–202
24. Chiantore O, Trossarelli L, Lazzari M (2000) Polymer 41:1657– 32. Allen NS, Parker MJ, Regan CJ, McIntyre RB, Dunk WAE (1995)
1668 Polym Degrad Stab 47:117–127
25. Feller RL, Curran M (1981) In: Pappas SF, Winslow FH (eds) 33. Bellamy LJ (1975) The infrared spectra of complex molecules.
Photodegradation and photostabilization of coatings, ACS Sympo- Chapman and Hall, London
sium Series 151. American Chemical Society, Washington, DC, p 183 34. Lien-Vien D, Colthup NB, Fateley WG, Grasselli JG (1991) The
26. Down JL, MacDonald MA, Tetreault J, Williams RS (1996) Stud handbook of infrared and raman characteristic frequencies of
Conserv 41:19–44 organic molecules. Academic, New York
27. Howells R, Burnstock A, Hedley J, Hackney S (1984) Polymer 35. Whitmore P, Colaluca V, Farrell E (1996) Stud Conserv 41:250–
dispersions artificially aged. In: Brommelle NS, Pye EM, Smith P, 255

You might also like