You are on page 1of 10

Available online at www.sciencedirect.

com

Placenta 29 (2008) 539e548

Effect of Variable Long-Term Maternal Feed Allowance on the


Development of the Ovine Placenta and Fetus
S.P. Quigley a,b, D.O. Kleemann a, S.K. Walker a, P.A. Speck b, S.R. Rudiger b, G.S. Nattrass b,
M.J. DeBlasio c, J.A. Owens c,*
a
South Australian Research and Development Institute, Turretfield Research Centre, Rosedale, SA 5350, Australia
b
South Australian Research and Development Institute, Livestock Systems Alliance, Roseworthy Campus,
University of Adelaide, Roseworthy, SA 5371, Australia
c
Research Centre for Early Origins of Adult Disease, School of Paediatrics and Reproductive Health,
University of Adelaide, Adelaide, SA 5005, Australia
Accepted 27 February 2008

Abstract

Maternal feed allowance during pregnancy can affect the development of the ovine placenta and fetus. The impact of variations in feed
allowance prior to as well as throughout pregnancy has received less attention. Ewes were offered 0.6 (R), 1.2 (C) or 1.8 (AL) maintenance
requirements from 89 days before conception until day 133 of pregnancy. Ewes were euthanased on days 50, 92 and 133 of pregnancy. Ewe
live weight and body condition score, maternal and fetal metabolic and hormonal profiles, fetal body dimensions and organ weights, and the
number, weight and morphology of placentomes were measured. Maternal live weight and condition score were lower in R compared to AL
ewes at all stages of pregnancy (P < 0.05). Plasma glucose and albumin concentrations of R ewes were significantly reduced (P < 0.05) at
mid and late gestation, respectively. Placental components were generally unresponsive to long term variations in maternal feed allowance. How-
ever, placental weight was significantly (P < 0.05) correlated with fetal weight at days 50 (r ¼ 0.59) and 133 (r ¼ 0.69) of gestation. By late
gestation growth-retarded singleton fetuses from R ewes were 19% lighter (P < 0.05), with reduced abdominal (9%) and thoracic (10%) girths
(P<0.05) but of similar crown-rump length compared with fetuses from AL ewes. These differences were associated with significantly reduced
IGF-I concentrations in fetal plasma (P < 0.05). In conclusion, maternal, placental and fetal adaptations to long established planes of variable
maternal feed allowance were able to maintain fetal growth during early and mid-pregnancy while fetal growth restriction, associated with re-
duced fetal IGF-I levels, became apparent in late pregnancy.
Ó 2008 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Keywords: Sheep; Nutrition; Fetal development

1. Introduction nutrition [2,3], maternal nutrient partitioning (e.g. adolescent


ewe model) [4,5] and litter size (e.g. prolific ewe model) [6]
Perturbations of the pre-natal environment can affect the on ovine fetal development are widely reported. Severe restric-
development of the fetus and placenta, subsequently impacting tions of substrate supply may result in maternal, placental and
on post-natal viability and productivity. These latter aspects fetal adaptations to the altered pre-natal environment, which
have implications for the fields of agriculture and medicine. allows survival of offspring, often at the expense of normal
The effects of intrauterine growth retardation (IUGR) via fetal development. There is increasing evidence from epidemi-
artificial methods (e.g. carunclectomy) [1], maternal under- ological and experimental studies that the programming of
fetal development may be particularly sensitive to maternal
nutrient status during the peri-conception period. Changes in
* Corresponding author. Tel.: þ61 8 8524 9665; fax: þ61 8 8524 9088. maternal live weight [7] and differences in ewe body condition
E-mail address: julie.owens@adelaide.edu.au (J.A. Owens). score [8] prior to mating have been related to altered

0143-4004/$ - see front matter Ó 2008 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.placenta.2008.02.014
540 S.P. Quigley et al. / Placenta 29 (2008) 539e548

utero-placental weights at days 53e56 and 65 of gestation, ram. Pregnancy and litter size was determined by ultrasonography (Echo Cam-
respectively, in sheep. However, no studies appear to have in- era SSD-500, 3.5 MHz probe; Aloka Co Ltd, Tokyo, Japan) on day 44 of ges-
tation. Non-pregnant ewes were subsequently removed from the experiment
vestigated if these differences persist throughout pregnancy. while pregnant ewes within treatments were stratified on litter size and ranked
Perturbed fetal development may be apparent as altered on live weight and randomly allocated to three sample cohorts based on ges-
fetal/birth weight, length, girth and disproportionate tissue tational age (days 50, 92 and 133 of gestation).
growth. There is a tendency for substrates to be directed to
maintain essential tissues and organs, such as the brain, at 2.2. Euthanasia and fetal dissection
the expense of less vital ones. As a result, size at birth, muscle
development and growth [9,10], wool follicle formation [11], Ewes were penned as a group on the mornings of euthanasia, left undis-
adiposity [6,12] and gastrointestinal tract development [13] turbed for 30 min and then bled via jugular venipuncture. They were subse-
quently slaughtered by captive-bolt pistol and exsanguination. The
may be altered in growth restricted fetuses and newborns. reproductive tracts were immediately recovered by hysterotomy, blood col-
Such perturbations in development may affect neonatal sur- lected from the umbilical arteries and the fetuses euthanased with a sodium
vival or influence post-natal productivity of livestock. pentobarbitone overdose. Blood samples were collected into Lithium Heparin
Adaptations of the fetus to restricted nutrient supply not tubes and plasma samples were stored at 20  C until analysis.
only alter post-natal performance but are also considered Fetal weight, crown rump length, abdominal girth, thoracic girth, skull
width, skull length, litter size and sex were recorded. The liver, kidneys, heart,
likely precursors to adulthood disease in humans. These fetal brain and lungs were removed and weighed. The longissimus dorsi, semitendi-
adaptations are often associated with fetal hypoglycaemia, hy- nosus and supraspinatus muscles were removed from the left side of late ges-
poxaemia and modifications to the insulin-like growth factor tation fetuses and weighed. Absolute and relative weights were determined for
(IGF) and hypothalmo-pituitary-adrenal axes. A number of ep- all tissues removed from the fetuses.
idemiology studies have implicated these fetal adaptations to
placental insufficiency with diseases later in life [14]. 2.3. Placental measurements
The following experiment examined the hypothesis that
long-term pre- and post-conception feed allowance of the The total number of placentomes, weight of individual placentomes, and
the number and weight of placentomes per fetus (in the case of multiple litters)
ewe induces adaptations in feto-placental and maternal charac- were recorded. Placental weight was defined as the aggregate weight of indi-
teristics and affects the development of the ovine fetus. Some vidual placentomes. The morphology of individual placentomes was character-
of the mechanisms responsible for these adaptations were ised according to their level of eversion [18] at day 92 and 133. Placentomes
investigated. were classified as type A (inverted), B, C or D (increasing levels of eversion,
respectively). The number of each placentome type was divided by the total
number of placentomes per ewe and the proportion of each type of placentome
2. Materials and methods determined per ewe.

The experimental protocol was reviewed and approved by the Primary In-
dustries and Resources South Australia, Animal Ethics Committee in accor- 2.4. Maternal and fetal metabolic and hormone profiles
dance with the Australian Code of Practice for the Care and Use of Animals
for Scientific Purposes [15]. Maternal and fetal plasma glucose (GLUC HK, Roche Diagnostic Sys-
tems, Germany), albumin (Albumin Plus BCG, Roche Diagnostic Systems)
and urea (UREA/BUN, Roche Diagnostic Systems) and maternal plasma
2.1. Animals, feeding, mating and experimental design
non-esterified fatty acids (NEFA C, Wako Pure Chemicals, Japan), cholesterol
(CHOD-PAP, Roche Diagnostic Systems) and triglyceride (TRIG, Roche Di-
Multiparous South Australian Merino ewes (n ¼ 119), greater than 3 years
agnostic Systems) concentrations were measured as indicators of nutritive sta-
of age at the commencement of the study, were ranked by live weight
tus on the COBAS MIRA automated analysis system (Roche Diagnostic
(64.5  0.8 kg, mean  SEM) and randomly allocated to three feed allowance
Systems). The intra-assay coefficients of variation of the glucose, albumin,
treatment groups. The treatments were control (C, n ¼ 30), restricted (R,
urea, NEFA, cholesterol and triglycerides assays were 1.8, 7.3, 6.2, 3.1, 2.9
50%C, n ¼ 60) and ad libitum (AL, 150%C, n ¼ 60), in which ewes were
and 4.2%, respectively.
fed at 120%, 60% and 180% of metabolisable energy (ME) requirements, re-
Plasma concentrations of fetal IGF-I and IGF-II were determined on
spectively. The maintenance ME requirements of a 64 kg non-pregnant ewe
a sub-population of fetuses (n ¼ 9 or 10 for R and AL fetuses at day 92
were calculated from AFRC [16]. C ewes were offered 120% of maintenance
and 133 of gestation). IGF-I and IGF-II were separated from binding proteins
ME requirements in an attempt to maintain body conditions score throughout
by size exclusion HPLC of plasma at pH 2.5 [19]. IGF-I and IGF-II concen-
pregnancy. AL ewes were fed such that there was greater than 10% feed re-
trations were then determined in neutralised chromatography fractions using
fusals each day, which was calculated to be an average daily intake of
a commercially available ELISA kit, according to the manufacturer’s instruc-
180% of ME requirements. Ewes were fed a pelleted diet (90.7% dry matter
tions (Diagnostic System Laboratories, Inc., Texas, USA). The intra-assay co-
(DM), 9.5 MJ ME kg1 DM and 120 g kg1 crude protein), consisting of ce-
efficients of variation of the IGF-I and IGF_II assays were 3.2 and 8.8%,
real and lucerne hays, barley, oats, lupins, oat bran, almond shells, limestone
respectively.
and molasses (Johnsons Stockfeeds, Kapunda, SA, Australia). All of the die-
tary components were decreased or increased in equal proportions in the R and
AL treatments, respectively. The ewes were fed daily in their treatment groups 2.5. Statistical analysis
from 89 days prior to mating until the day of slaughter on either day 50 (early),
92 (mid) or 133 (late) of pregnancy. Ewe live weight and condition score [17] Analysis of variance procedures (GLM procedure in SAS) [20] were used
were monitored at weekly intervals. After 75 days of treatment feeding, ewes to interpret the significance of main effects and their first order interactions on
were treated with controlled intra-vaginal drug release devices (EAZI- all variables. Data that were not normally distributed or exhibited unequal var-
BREEDÔ CIDRÒ Sheep and Goat Device, Pharmica and Upjohn, Australia) iances were log transformed before analysis. Proportional placentome mor-
for twelve days. Vasectomized rams, fitted with harnesses and crayons, were phology data were arcsin transformed before analysis to ensure stabilisation
put with the ewes at CIDR removal. Crayon-marked ewes were inseminated of variance. Relationship coefficients (r) and associated probabilities (P) be-
48 h later via laparoscopy (day 0) with fresh semen collected from a single tween maternal, placental and fetal parameters were established using Pearson
S.P. Quigley et al. / Placenta 29 (2008) 539e548 541

product-moment correlations (CORR procedure in SAS) [21]. All correlations 3.2. Maternal metabolic profile
were determined within each gestational stage, within litter size groupings and
within feed allowance treatments.
Maternal plasma glucose concentration was lowest at day
133 of gestation (P < 0.05), while plasma urea and NEFA
3. Results concentrations were both greatest at this time (P < 0.05). Ma-
ternal plasma glucose concentration was reduced in R ewes
3.1. Maternal live weight and condition score compared with AL ewes at each stage of gestation, although
this was only significant for twin bearing ewes at day 92
Live weights and condition scores of R and AL ewes dif- (P < 0.05, 4.6  0.6 and 6.6  0.5 mmol L1, R and AL, re-
fered significantly from 50 days prior to insemination, at in- spectively) and singleton bearing ewes at day 133 of gestation
semination and on allocated days of slaughter (P < 0.05, (P < 0.05, 3.2  0.2 and 3.9  0.2 mmol L1, R and AL, re-
Table 1). Ewe live weight increased significantly between spectively). Similarly, maternal plasma albumin was signifi-
days 92 and 133 of pregnancy (P < 0.05) in all treatment cantly reduced in singleton bearing R ewes compared with
groups, even though feed allowances remained fixed at initial singleton bearing AL ewes (P < 0.05) at each stage of gesta-
treatment levels and condition scores of treatment groups con- tion. Litter size had no effect on maternal plasma glucose, al-
tinued to diverge. Nevertheless, AL ewes were 30e40% bumin, urea, cholesterol and triglyceride concentration,
heavier than their R counterparts at late gestation. Ewe live however NEFA concentration was elevated in R twin bearing
weight at mating correlated positively with ewe condition ewes compared with R singleton bearing ewes at day 92
score at mating (P < 0.01, r ¼ 0.78) and ewe live weight (P < 0.01, 1.8  0.2 and 0.7  0.2 meq L1, respectively)
(P < 0.01, r ¼ 0.86) and condition score (P < 0.01, r ¼ 0.73) and day 133 of gestation (P < 0.01, 2.1  0.6 and
on day of slaughter. 0.5  0.2 meq L1, respectively).

3.3. Placental characteristics


Table 1
Number, live weight and body condition score of ewes offered different feed Total placentome weight was significantly different at each
allowances prior to and throughout pregnancy
stage of gestation and greatest at day 92 (P < 0.05, data not
Stage of experiment Litter size Maternal feed allowance shown). The number of placentomes was similar at each stage
Restricted Control Ad libitum of pregnancy. Fetal to placentome weight ratio increased ap-
Number of ewes (n) proximately 10-fold with each successive stage of develop-
Days 89 and 50 59 30 60 ment examined (P < 0.01, data not shown). Maternal feed
Day 0 (insemination) 47 27 55 allowance had no effect on the total number of placentomes,
Day 44 (scanning) 23 18 40
total placentome weight, mean placentome weight or the fetal
Day 50 1 6 6 4
2 2 0 10 to placentome weight ratio in singleton or twin bearing ewes,
Day 92 1 4 4 7 at each stage of gestation (Table 2). The total placentome
2 4 2 6 weights from twin bearing pregnancies were heavier than sin-
Day 133 1 4 6 7 gleton bearing pregnancies at days 50, 92 and 133 of gestation
2 3 0 6
(P < 0.05, data not shown). There was no significant relation-
Ewe live weight (kg) ship between total placentome weight and ewe live weight at
Day 89 64.4  0.7 64.6  1.0 64.5  0.7 mating and slaughter at each stage of gestation. There was
Day 50 57.5  0.9a 63.0  1.3b 65.4  0.9b
Day 0 55.4  1.1a 65.5  1.5b 69.8  1.1c
a greater proportion of type A placentomes per ewe at day
Day 50 1 54.6  3.2a 64.4  3.2b 68.1  4.0b 50 of gestation than at days 92 and 133 (P < 0.01). At both
2 59.0  4.8a e 76.3  2.1b days 92 and 133 of gestation, maternal feed allowance had
Day 92 1 51.8  4.1a 70.2  4.1b 77.4  3.1b no effect on placentome morphology in singleton bearing
2 63.2  3.6a 78.4  5.1b 83.1  2.9b ewes. However, twin bearing R ewes had a greater proportion
Day 133 1 58.5  4.5a 77.3  3.7b 81.81  3.4b
2 65.8  4.4a e 91.2  3.1b
of everted placentomes than AL ewes at day 92 (type B, C and
D) and day 133 (type C and D) of gestation (P < 0.05). Type
Ewe body condition score
B, C and D placentomes were heavier than type A placen-
Day 89 3.3  0.1 3.2  0.1 3.3  0.1
Day 50 3.0  0.1a 3.1  0.1b 3.2  0.1b tomes from singleton and twin bearing ewes at both days 92
Day 0 2.9  0.1a 3.2  0.1b 3.5  0.1c and 133 of gestation (P < 0.05). While type D placentomes
Day 50 1 3.0  0.1a 3.3  0.1a 3.8  0.2b from twin bearing ewes were heavier than type D placentomes
2 3.0  0.2a e 3.8  0.1b from singleton bearing ewes at both days 92 and 133 of gesta-
Day 92 1 2.5  0.2a 3.5  0.2b 3.7  0.2c
tion (P < 0.05).
2 3.0  0.2a 3.5  0.2ab 3.8  0.1b
Day 133 1 2.4  0.2a 3.1  0.1b 3.8  0.1c
2 2.3  0.1a e 3.9  0.1b 3.4. Fetal body dimensions
Values are least-square means  standard error of the mean. Different alpha-
betical superscripts across the rows, indicate significant differences between Weight of singleton fetuses from AL feed allowance ewes
treatments (P < 0.05). was only significantly greater than those from R ewes at day
542 S.P. Quigley et al. / Placenta 29 (2008) 539e548

Table 2
Placental characteristics of singleton and twin bearing ewes offered different feed allowances prior to and throughout pregnancy
Parameter Litter size Maternal feed allowance
Restricted Control Ad libitum
Day 50 of pregnancy
Total placentome number 1 87.5  7.1 82.7  7.1 80.3  8.7
2 93.5  7.2 e 85.7  3.3
Total placentome weight (g) 1 124.6  12.3* 138.4  12.3 125.7  15.1**
2 293.7  54.6 e 235.0  24.4
Fetal:Placentome weight 1 0.1  0.02 0.1  0.02 0.1  0.02
2 0.1  0.03 e 0.2  0.02
Day 92 of pregnancy
Total placentome number 1 73.3  4.3 76.3  4.3 73.0  3.0**
2 98.5  6.4 98.5  9.0 89.5  5.2
Total placentome weight (g) 1 824.0  164.8 863.5  164.8 668.9  124.6**
2 1180.0  94.7 1029.6  133.9 998.8  77.3
Fetal:Placentome weight 1 0.9  0.1 1.0  0.1 1.1  0.1**
2 1.2  0.1 1.4  0.2 1.5  0.1
Day 133 of pregnancy
Total placentome number 1 72.5  9.3 76.3  7.6 69.6  7.0*
2 91.3  7.8 e 90.7  5.5
Total placentome weight (g) 1 411.8  58.4** 557.0  47.7 482.2  44.2
2 810.8  122.1 e 639.1  86.3
Fetal:Placentome weight 1 9.1  0.8 7.9  0.6 9.7  0.6
2 8.4  3.2 e 13.3  2.2
Values are least-square means  standard error of the mean. No significant differences between treatments, within each litter size, were present. Within columns,
differences between litter sizes, within a treatment, are indicated by *(P < 0.05) and **(P < 0.01).

133 (P < 0.05, Table 3). There was no significant difference in ewes at both days 92 (P < 0.05, 0.3  0.02 and 0.4  0.02,
fetal crown rump length between fetuses collected from AL R and AL respectively) and 133 (P < 0.05, 0.5  0.03 and
and R ewes at any stage of gestation. By day 133 of gestation 0.6  0.02, R and AL respectively) of gestation. Fetal liver
R singleton fetuses were significantly thinner (P < 0.05), with and brain weights, as a proportion of fetal weight, correlated
smaller abdominal (319.3  11.3 and 349.9  8.6 mm) and positively (P < 0.01, r ¼ 0.70) and negatively (P < 0.01,
thoracic (331.7  10.5 and 367.4  7.7 mm) girths than AL r ¼  0.57) with placental weight at day 133 of gestation,
fetuses. Fetal weight was correlated positively with total pla- respectively (Fig. 1), indicative of asymmetric growth
centome weight at days 50 and 133 of gestation, but not at retardation.
day 92 (Fig. 1).
3.6. Fetal muscle weights
3.5. Fetal organ development
Singleton fetuses had significantly (P < 0.01) heavier
The restriction of maternal feed allowance reduced the ab- longissimus (40.9  1.4 and 33.4  1.7 g) and supraspinatus
solute (P < 0.05) and relative (P < 0.05) weight of the lungs (10.7  0.5 and 8.5  0.6 g) muscles than twin fetuses. In
of singleton fetuses at day 50 of gestation (data not shown). R singleton fetuses the weights of the longissimus, semitendi-
Restriction of maternal feed allowance increased the absolute nosus and supraspinatus muscles were reduced by 19%,
(46.3  1.7 and 41.6  1.4 g) and relative (70.7  2.0 and 23.5% and 21.3% respectively compared with AL singleton
58.3  1.6 g kg1 fetal weight) liver weights of R compared fetuses. In R twin fetuses, the weights of the longissimus,
with AL twin fetuses at day 92 (P < 0.05); maternal feed al- semitendinosus and supraspinatus muscles were reduced by
lowance had no affect on organ development of singleton fe- 17.4%, 23.4% and 12.4% respectively, compared with AL
tuses at day 92. At day 133, absolute liver weights of R twin fetuses although this was only significant (P < 0.05)
singleton fetuses were reduced in response to restricted mater- for the longissimus muscle. The relative weight of the semite-
nal feed allowance (P < 0.05, Table 4), although relative liver ndinosus, longissimus and supraspinatus muscles (g kg1 fe-
weights were similar between R and AL singleton fetuses. The tal body weight) were unaffected by maternal feed allowance
livers of R twin fetuses were proportionately larger than AL or litter size.
twin fetuses (P < 0.05) at day 133. While absolute brain
weights of day 133 singleton fetuses were unaffected by ma- 3.7. Fetal metabolic profile
ternal feed allowance, R fetuses had proportionately larger
brains than AL singleton fetuses (P < 0.05). The brain to liver Fetal plasma glucose concentration decreased (P < 0.05)
weight ratio was reduced in twin fetuses from feed restricted and fetal plasma albumin concentration increased (P < 0.05)
S.P. Quigley et al. / Placenta 29 (2008) 539e548 543

Table 3
Body dimensions of fetuses collected at days 50, 92 and 133 of pregnancy from ewes offered variable feed allowances prior to and throughout gestation
Parameter Litter size Maternal feed allowance
Restricted Control Ad libitum
Day 50 of pregnancy
Fetal weight (g) 1 16.0  0.7 17.3  0.7 18.0  1.0
2 18.7  1.0 e 18.1  0.5
Fetal crown rump length (mm) 1 97.2  2.9 101.9  2.9 104.5  3.6
2 103.3  3.0 e 105.5  1.3
Fetal abdominal girth (mm) 1 56.7  2.1 56.0  2.1 58.5  2.6
2 61.0  2.3 e 58.7  1.0
Fetal thoracic girth (mm) 1 54.3  1.2 55.8  1.2 55.3  1.4
2 57.5  1.6 e 58.9  0.7
Skull width (mm) 1 14.7  0.4 15.7  0.4 15.9  0.5
2 15.3  0.6 e 15.2  0.3
Skull length (mm) 1 24.5  0.3a 25.2  0.3b 26.4  0.3b
2 25.3  0.6 e 25.5  0.3
Day 92 of pregnancy
Fetal weight (g) 1 680.9  26.5 695.8  26.5 685.3  20.0
2 660.6  21.8 688.8  30.8 712.7  17.8
Fetal crown rump length (mm) 1 332.0  14.4 334.8  14.4 336.9  10.9
2 345.0  11.6 317.3  16.3 320.3  9.4
Fetal abdominal girth (mm) 1 202.0  6.0 188.5  6.0 198.7  4.6
2 194.9  5.0ab 182.3  7.1a 201.7  4.1b
Fetal thoracic girth (mm) 1 187.8  3.2 194.3  3.2 191.9  2.4
2 187.8  2.0a 185.8  2.8a 196.0  1.6b
Skull width (mm) 1 43.8  0.7 44.0  0.8 45.2  0.5
2 44.3  0.5 43.4  0.8 44.9  0.4
Skull length (mm) 1 78.4  1.1a 81.5  1.3ab 81.5  0.8b
2 80.71  .0 78.6  1.5 82.0  0.8
Day 133 of pregnancy
Fetal weight (g) 1 3573  287a 4333  234ab 4524  217b**
2 3386  126 e 3676  89
Fetal crown rump length (mm) 1 513  13a 553  1.0b 536  10ab
2 515  9 e 525  6
Fetal abdominal girth (mm) 1 319  11a 343  9ab 350  9b**
2 309  7 e 315  5
Fetal thoracic girth (mm) 1 326  11a 346  9ab 366  9b**
2 331  4 e 334  3
Skull width (mm) 1 62  1 63  1 64  1*
2 59  1 e 61  1
Skull length (mm) 1 118  2 123  2 122  2
2 116  2 e 119  1
Values are least-square means  standard error of the mean. Different alphabetical superscripts across the rows, indicate significant differences between treatments
(P < 0.05). Within columns, significant difference between litter sizes, within a treatment, is indicated by *(P < 0.05) and **(P < 0.01).

as gestation progressed. Fetal plasma glucose (P < 0.05) was was not significantly different between day 92 and day 133 of
greater in twin fetuses from AL ewes than twin fetuses from gestation. Singleton fetuses from R and AL ewes had similar
R ewes at day 92 of gestation (Table 5). However, maternal plasma IGF-I concentrations at both days 92 and 133 of ges-
feed allowance had no effect on albumin or urea concentra- tation. Twin fetuses from AL ewes had higher plasma IGF-I
tions within each stage of gestation. Litter size had no effect concentrations than twin fetuses from R ewes at both days
on plasma glucose and albumin concentrations; however 92 (P < 0.05) and 133 (P < 0.05) of gestation. Fetal plasma
plasma urea concentration was significantly higher in single- IGF-II concentration was unaffected by maternal feed allow-
ton fetuses compared with twin fetuses from R ewes at day ance and litter size. There were no significant relationships be-
92 of gestation. Fetal plasma glucose correlated positively tween fetal plasma IGF-I and IGF-II and fetal weight,
with fetal weight (P < 0.05, r ¼ 0.34) and placentome weight placental weight, liver weight and plasma glucose at day 92
(P < 0.05, r ¼ 0.36) at day 133 of gestation. of gestation. However, by late gestation fetal weight, placental
weight and fetal plasma glucose concentration were all corre-
3.8. Fetal plasma IGF-I and IGF-II lated positively (P < 0.05) with fetal plasma IGF-I concentra-
tion (Fig. 2). No significant relationships existed between fetal
Fetal plasma IGF-I concentration increased between day 92 plasma IGF-II and fetal or placental parameters at day 133 of
and 133 of gestation (P < 0.01, Table 5). IGF-II concentration gestation.
544 S.P. Quigley et al. / Placenta 29 (2008) 539e548

Fig. 1. Relationship between placental and fetal weights at day 50 (a), 92 (c) and 133 (e) of gestation and between placental weight and relative fetal liver weight
(b), relative fetal brain weight (d) and fetal liver:brain weight (f) at day 133 of gestation. Singleton (filled symbols) and twin (unfilled symbols) fetuses were col-
lected from ewes offered restricted (7), control (,) and ad libitum (B) feed allowances prior to and throughout gestation. Positive relationships existed between
placental and fetal weight at day 50 (r ¼ 0.44; P < 0.01) and day 133 (r ¼ 0.69; P < 0.001) and relative fetal liver weight at day 133 (r ¼ 0.70; P < 0.001). Neg-
ative relationships existed between placental weight and relative fetal brain weight (r ¼  0.57; P < 0.001) and fetal liver:brain weight (r ¼  0.79; P < 0.001) at
day 133.

4. Discussion of fetal growth. Restricting maternal feed allowance decreased


live weight and condition score of ewes which, together with
The present study is unique in the timing of onset and lowered maternal plasma glucose and albumin concentrations,
duration of the maternal feed restriction imposed. It is the only suggests energy and protein deficiencies and the mobilization
study in which fetal, placental and maternal characteristics of fat reserves.
were quantified at three stages of gestation in ewes that were In the present study, placental weight and the number of
already significantly divergent in live weight and body condi- placentomes were generally unresponsive to variations in
tion score from approximately 50 days prior to conception as long-term maternal feed allowance imposed 89 days prior to
well as throughout gestation. insemination, in both singleton and twin pregnancies, at all
Differential maternal feed allowance coupled with variable stages of pregnancy. The classical studies of Everitt [22] dem-
litter size, resulted in compensatory adaptations of the mother, onstrated that feed intake during pregnancy had a profound in-
placenta and fetus, which enabled fetal survival at the expense fluence on placental weights in sheep. However, recent
S.P. Quigley et al. / Placenta 29 (2008) 539e548 545

Table 4
Organ weights of fetuses collected at day 133 of pregnancy from ewes offered variable feed allowances prior to and throughout gestation
Tissue Litter size Maternal feed allowance
Absolute weight (g) Relative weight (g kg1 fetal weight)
Restricted Control Ad libitum Restricted Control Ad libitum
a b b a b
Liver 1 100.7  11.6 143.4  9.5 131.8  8.8 * 27.9  1.7 33.3  1.4 28.8  1.3a*
2 95.3  4.9 e 90.0  3.5 28.2  0.8a e 24.4  0.6b
Heart 1 28.4  3.5 33.7  2.9 34.6  2.7* 8.0  0.5 7.8  0.4 7.6  0.4
2 28.8  1.7 e 28.7  1.2 8.5  0.4 e 7.8  0.3
Lungs 1 127.2  12.3a 161.1  10.1ab 164.4  9.3b* 36.2  3.4 37.3  2.8 36.9  2.6
2 135.5  7.7 e 131.2  5.5 40.2  2.2 e 35.8  1.6
Kidney 1 18.0  2.1 23.3  1.7 21.8  1.6* 5.1  0.4 5.4  0.4 4.8  0.3
2 18.5  0.7 e 17.4  0.5 5.5  0.3a e 4.8  0.2b
Brain 1 53.4  2.3 56.0  1.9 55.0  1.7 15.1  0.9a 13.0  0.7ab 12.3  0.7b*
2 50.3  1.6 e 53.2  1.1 14.9  0.5 e 14.5  0.3
Brain:Liver 1 0.6  0.05a 0.4  0.04b 0.4  0.04ab* e e e
2 0.5  0.03a e 0.6  0.02b e e e
Values are least-square means  standard error of the mean. Different alphabetical superscripts across the rows, indicate significant differences between treatments
(P < 0.05). Within columns, significant difference between litter sizes, within a treatment, are indicated by *(P < 0.05).

evidence suggests that the mechanisms by which maternal nu- between control and nutrient restricted (70% of ME require-
trient status regulates placental development and function are ments from 22 days post-conception) ewes at days 45 and 90
more complex than the simple supply of nutrients. For exam- of gestation but there was a tendency towards decreased pla-
ple, the timing, duration and severity of the intervention, the cental weights at day 135 of gestation in nutrient restricted
age of the ewe and the long-term management system imposed ewes [23]. In contrast, ewes that were nutrient restricted
may all influence how the placenta responds to nutrient supply (50% of ME requirements) between days 28 and 77 of gesta-
in sheep. No differences in placental weights were reported tion had increased placental weights at day 144 of gestation
[24]. An acute restriction, between days 85 and 90 of gesta-
tion, reduced placental weights at day 90 of gestation but
Table 5
Metabolites and insulin-like growth factors in the circulation of fetuses not at day 133 [25]. With respect to peri-conception nutrient
collected at days 92 and 133 of pregnancy from ewes offered variable feed status, lean ewes, 12 weeks prior to conception and maintained
allowances prior to and throughout gestation as such until slaughter, had similar placentome weights to fat
Parameter Litter size Maternal feed allowance and moderate body condition score ewes at day 65 of gestation
Restricted Control Ad libitum [8], while offering ewes 70% of ME requirements from
45 days prior to conception until day 53e56 of gestation
Day 92 of pregnancy
Glucose (mmol L1) 1 1.3  0.4 1.7  0.4 1.4  0.3 also had no influence on placental weight at that time [7]. Nu-
2 0.7  0.2a 0.8  0.3a 1.7  0.2b trient supply to ewes at different ages also has variable affects
Albumin (g L1) 1 19.0  0.9 18.0  1.0 20.2  0.6 on placental development, with over-nutrition of adolescent
2 20.1  1.7 20.5  2.4 21.5  1.4 [26] and adult [27] ewes resulting in decreased and unchanged
Urea (mmol L1) 1 5.4  0.3ab** 6.2  0.3b 5.3  0.2a
2 4.9  0.2 6.3  0.2 5.1  0.1
placental weights compared to control fed ewes of a similar
IGF-I (ng ml1) 1 13.2  0.7 e 12.8  0.7 age. Interestingly, under-nutrition of adolescent ewes resulted
2 11.9  0.6a e 14.1  0.5b in smaller fetuses at day 130 of gestation despite no differ-
IGF-II (ng ml1) 1 172.8  17.0 e 163.3  17.0 ences in placental mass at day 90 and 130 of gestation [28].
2 168.8  13.0 e 147.0  12.0 Variable placental development was also reported when ewes
Day 133 of pregnancy adapted to a harsh production system, with inadequate nutri-
Glucose (mmol L1) 1 0.6  0.2 0.6  0.2 0.6  0.2 tion, or a more sedentary lifestyle, with adequate nutrition,
2 0.4  0.1 0.5  0.1
e
were fed either 50% or 100% of ME requirements from
Albumin (g L1) 1 28.1  2.3 30.1  1.9 33.1  1.9
2 29.1  1.4 e 30.3  1.0 days 22 to 78 of gestation [29], suggesting that long-term en-
Urea (mmol L1) 1 5.5  0.8 5.5  0.6 7.1  0.6 vironmental or intergenerational influences may also deter-
2 5.8  0.7 e 6.7  0.5 mine the response of the placenta to variable nutrient supply.
IGF-I (ng ml1) 1 16.2  2.7 e 20.3  2.4 In the present study, fetal weight was correlated with pla-
2 11.5  0.6a e 18.0  0.8b cental weight in early and late gestation, consistent with other
IGF-II (ng ml1) 1 198.0  19.6 e 192.7  17.5
2 181.7  28.9 e 198.1  35.4 studies [7,30]. The lack of any relationship between placental
weight and fetal weight at day 92 of gestation may be attrib-
Values are least-square means  standard error of the mean. Different alpha-
betical superscripts across the rows, indicate significant differences between uted to the compensatory overgrowth of placentomes at mid
treatments (P < 0.05). Within columns, significant difference between litter gestation. It has been demonstrated that nutrient restriction in-
sizes, within a treatment, is indicated by **(P < 0.01). duces a conversion of type A to type C or D placentome
546 S.P. Quigley et al. / Placenta 29 (2008) 539e548

Fig. 2. Relationship between fetal plasma IGF1 and fetal (a) and placental (b) weights and glucose concentration (c) at day 133 of gestation. Singleton (filled
symbols) and twin (unfilled symbols) fetuses were collected from ewes offered restricted (7) or ad libitum (B) feed allowances prior to and throughout gestation.
There was a positive relationship between fetal plasma IGF1 concentration and fetal weight (r ¼ 0.74; P < 0.001), placental weight (r ¼ 0.48; P < 0.05) and fetal
plasma glucose concentration (r ¼ 0.59; P < 0.01).

morphology in sheep [23,29,31]. It has been suggested that counterparts. Further, a brain sparing effect was evident in
this conversion is associated with an increase in size and vas- these growth retarded fetuses, where growth of the brain
cularisation of placentomes [32], thereby increasing their ca- was maintained at the expense of less vital organs, such as
pacity for nutrient exchange between the maternal and fetal muscle, liver and lungs. This phenomenon has been com-
compartments. It is possible that the progression of placen- monly observed in the fetus subject to nutrient deprivation
tome morphology in the present study disrupted the relation- in many previous studies and reflects physiological adapta-
ship between placental and fetal weights at day 92 of tions that divert scarce resources to the brain at the expense
gestation. Altered placentome morphology was not sufficient of other tissues [1]. The decreased muscle mass resulting
to compensate for the low nutrient availability in R ewes at from maternal under-nutrition and increasing litter size evi-
day 133 of gestation in the present study however. dent in late gestation fetuses in the present study is of signif-
Fetal growth restriction was evident by day 133 of gestation icance to animal production. Reductions in muscle mass in the
in ewes that were offered a restricted feed allowance. The rel- range of 12e28%, across a range of muscles, may have a sig-
ative absence of retarded fetal growth in response to restricted nificant impact on post-natal muscle growth and yield of live-
maternal feed allowance at early and mid gestation suggests stock [10]. While normal lung development is essential for the
that the adaptive mechanisms of the ewe and the placenta survival of the neonate, aberrant skeletal muscle, liver and
were able to satisfactorily compensate at these early stages lung development during gestation have been implicated in
of gestation, when the conceptus has much lower nutrient re- the development of adult onset diseases, including type 2 di-
quirements for growth compared to near-term. However, in abetes and obstructive airway disease. Interestingly, lung
late gestation, when fetal growth accelerates rapidly relative weight of day 50 fetuses was reduced by restriction of mater-
to placental size maternal and placental adaptations may nal feeding but this was not reflected in twins. A possible ex-
have been unable to maintain adequate nutrient supply. This planation is that maternal feed restriction may increase
resulted in late gestation fetuses which were lighter and thin- placental tissue as an adaptive response, particularly in twins
ner, had disproportionate tissue growth and decreased plasma [7] and through this mechanism reduce the effects of nutrient
glucose and IGF-I concentrations, compared with normal restriction on organ growth.
S.P. Quigley et al. / Placenta 29 (2008) 539e548 547

Restricted nutrient supply to the mother may have indi- References


rectly reduced the supply of substrates available for growth
of the fetus and altered the production and circulating concen- [1] Owens JA, Owens PC, Robinson JS. Experimental fetal growth retarda-
trations of IGF-I in the fetus. It was apparent by late gestation tion: metabolic and endocrine aspects. Research in perinatal medicine
(VIII). Advances in fetal physiology: reviews in honour of G.C. Liggins
that fetal plasma IGF-I was positively associated with fetal 1989:263e86.
weight, placental weight and fetal glucose concentration. Fur- [2] Everitt GC. Factors affecting foetal growth and development of Merino
ther, circulating IGF-I concentrations were lower in fetuses sheep with particular reference to maternal nutrition. Faculty of Agricul-
whose mothers received restricted nutriment, consistent with tural Science 1965:335.
circulating IGF-I regulating fetal growth in the last third of [3] Mellor DJ, Murray L. Effects of long term undernutrition of the ewe on
the growth rates of individual fetuses during late pregnancy. Res Vet Sci
pregnancy [33]. In support, circulating IGF-I is decreased 1982;32:177e80.
with maternal under-nutrition [34,35], carunclectomy [36] [4] Wallace JM, Bourke DA, Aitken RP, Palmer RM, Da Silva P,
and hypoxaemia [37] in the fetal sheep. Further, IGF-I knockout Cruikshank MA. Relationship between nutritionally-mediated placental
mice have impaired growth [38], while maternal under-nutri- growth restriction and fetal growth, body composition and endocrine
tion [39] and carunclectomy [40] decrease the expression of status during late gestation in adolescent sheep. Placenta 2000;21:100e8.
[5] Wallace JM, Bourke DA, Da Silva P, Aitken RP. Nutrient partitioning
IGF-I mRNA expression in the liver and skeletal muscle of fetal during adolescent pregnancy. Reproduction 2001;122:347e57.
sheep, respectively. It is, therefore, possible that restricted nutri- [6] Greenwood PL, Hunt AS, Hermanson JW, Bell AW. Effects of birth
ent supply to the developing fetus reduced the expression of weight and postnatal nutrition on neonatal sheep: I. Body growth and
IGF-I in tissues. In support, it has been demonstrated that pro- composition and some aspects of energetic efficiency. J Anim Sci
vision of external glucose, in the presence of under-nutrition, 1998;76:2354e67.
[7] MacLaughlin SM, Walker SK, Roberts CT, Kleemann DO, McMillen IC.
elevated fetal IGF-I levels [41] while IGF-I infusion increased Periconceptional nutrition and the relationship between maternal body
protein synthesis in fetal skeletal muscle when amino acid and weight changes in the periconceptional period and feto-placental growth
glucose concentrations were maintained at constant levels [42]. in the sheep. J Physiol 2005;565:111e24.
Therefore, it is possible that low plasma IGF-I concentrations in [8] Osgerby JC, Gadd TC, Wathes DC. Effect of maternal body condition on
the present study may have limited protein accretion in specific placental and fetal growth and the insulin-like growth factor axis in Dor-
set ewes. Reproduction 2003;125:717e31.
tissues and in the fetuses as a whole. [9] Greenwood PL, Slepetis RM, Hermanson JW, Bell AW. Intrauterine
Despite evidence that IGF-II is also involved in fetal devel- growth retardation is associated with reduced cell cycle activity, but
opment, the present study revealed no such associations. This not myofibre number, in ovine fetal muscle. Reprod Fert Dev
finding is in contrast to other studies which have reported pos- 1999;11:281e91.
itive [36] and negative [43] associations between fetal weight [10] Greenwood PL, Hunt AS, Hermanson JW, Bell AW. Effects of birth
weight and postnatal nutrition on neonatal sheep: II. Skeletal muscle
and IGF-II in fetal sheep. However, these associations growth and development. J Anim Sci 2000;78:50e61.
emerged in late gestation after the pre-partum cortisol surge, [11] Schinkel PG, Short BF. The influence of nutritional level during pre-natal
which inhibits IGF-II production by fetal tissues [44] and and early post-natal life on adult fleece and body characters. Aust J Agric
may be greater in the fetuses of feed allowance restricted ewes. Res 1961;12:176e202.
In conclusion, the impact of long established planes of vari- [12] Budge H, Edwards LJ, McMillen IC, Bryce A, Warnes K, Pearce S, et al.
Nutritional manipulation of fetal adipose tissue deposition and uncou-
able maternal nutrition in the sheep on feto-placental-maternal pling protein 1 messenger RNA abundance in the sheep: differential ef-
growth and physiological responses was investigated in this fects of timing and duration. Biol Reprod 2004;71:359e65.
study. Restricted maternal feed allowance in this model re- [13] Trahair JF, De Barro TM, Robinson JS, Owens JA. Restriction of nutri-
sulted in asymmetric IUGR by late gestation, compared to me- tion in utero selectively inhibits gastro intestinal growth in fetal sheep.
dium or ad libitum maternal feed allowance. In addition, fetal J Nutr 1997;127:637e41.
[14] Baker DJP. Mothers, babies and health in later life. Edinburgh: Churchill
growth appeared to be regulated by placental weight, indepen- Livingstone; 1998. p. 217.
dent of maternal nutritional status, during early and late gesta- [15] NHMRC. Australian code of practice for the care and use of animals for
tion. Restricted fetal growth during late gestation was scientific purposes. Canberra, Australia: Australian Government; 2004.
characterised by reduced circulating IGF-I concentrations. p. 84.
Overall, substantial reductions in maternal nutrient availability [16] AFRC. Energy and protein requirements of ruminants. Wallingford, UK:
CAB International; 1993. p. 176.
resulted in fetal growth-restriction that only became evident [17] Russell A, Doney J, Gunn R. Subjective assessment of body fat in live
late in gestation. sheep. J Agric Sci (Camb) 1969;72:451e4.
[18] Vatnick I, Schoknecht PA, Darrigrand R, Bell AW. Growth and metabo-
lism of the placenta after unilateral fetectomy in twin pregnant ewes.
Acknowledgements
J Dev Physiol 1991;15:351e6.
[19] Owens P, Johnson R, Campbell R, Ballard F. Growth hormone increases
The assistance of Karen Kind, Kathy Gatford and Melissa insulin-like growth factor-I (IGF-I) and decreases IGF-II in plasma of
Bradbury (Research Centre for Research Centre for Early Or- growing pigs. J Endocrinol 1990;124:269e75.
igins of Adult Disease, University of Adelaide) and the Turret- [20] Spector PC, Goodnight JH, Sall JP, Sarle WS. The GLM procedure. SAS
Procedures Guide 1985:443.
field Farm staff in fetal and placental collections is gratefully
[21] DeLong DM, Yuan YC. The CORR procedure. In: SAS procedures
acknowledged. Simon Humphrys (Primegro LTD) conducted guide. Cary, NC: SAS Inst. Inc.; 1988. p. 125.
the IGF assays on fetal plasma samples. This work was sup- [22] Everitt GC. Maternal undernutrition and retarded fetal development in
ported by SARDI Livestock Systems. Merino sheep. Nature 1964;201:1341e2.
548 S.P. Quigley et al. / Placenta 29 (2008) 539e548

[23] Osgerby JC, Wathes DC, Howard D, Gadd TC. The effect of maternal [34] Bauer MA, Breier BH, Harding JE, Veldhuis JD, Gluckman PD. The fetal
nutrition on placental growth trajectory and the uterine insulin-growth somatotrophic axis during long term maternal undernutrition in sheep:
factor axis in the pregnant ewe. J Endocrinol 2004;182:89e103. evidence for nutritional regulation in utero. Endocrinology 1995;136:
[24] Heasman L, Brameld J, Mostyn A, Budge H, Dawson J, Buttery P, et al. 1250e7.
Maternal nutrient restriction during early to mid gestation alters the rela- [35] Osgerby JC, Wathes DC, Howard D, Gadd TS. The effect of maternal un-
tionship between insulin-like growth factor I and bodyweight at term in dernutrition on ovine fetal growth. J Endocrinol 2002;173:131e41.
fetal sheep. Reprod Fert Dev 2000;12:345e50. [36] Owens JA, Kind KL, Carbone F, Robinson JS, Owens PC. Circulating in-
[25] McMullen S, Osgerby JC, Milne JS, Wallace JM, Wathes DC. The effects sulin-like growth factors-I and -II and substrates in fetal sheep following
of acute nutrient restriction in the mid-gestational ewe on maternal and restriction of placental growth. J Endocrinol 1994;140:5e13.
fetal nutrient status, the expression of placental growth factors and fetal [37] Iwamoto HS, Murray MA, Chernausek SD. Effects of acute hypoxemia
growth. Placenta 2005;26:25e33. on insulin-like growth factors and their binding proteins in fetal sheep.
[26] Wallace JM, Aitken RP, Cheyne MA. Nutrient partitioning and fetal Am J Physiol 1992;263:E1151e6.
growth in rapidly growing adolescent ewes. J Reprod Fertil 1996;107: [38] Liu JP, Baker J, Perkins AS, Robertson EJ, Efstratiadis A. Mice carrying
183e90. null mutations of the genes encoding insulin-like growth factor 1 (IGF-I)
[27] Wallace JM, Milne JS, Aitken RP. The effect of overnourishing single- and type I IGF receptor (IGFIr). Cell 1993;75:59e72.
ton-bearing adult ewes on nutrient partitioning to the gravid uterus. [39] Brameld JM, Mostyn A, Dandrea J, Stephenson TJ, Dawson JM,
Br J Nutr 2005;94:533e9. Buttery PJ, et al. Maternal nutrition effects the expression of insulin-
[28] Luther J, Milne J, Aitken R, Matsuzaki M, Reynolds L, Redmer D, like growth factors in fetal sheep liver and skeletal muscle. J Endocrinol
et al. Placental growth, angiogenic gene expression and vascular de- 2000;167:429e37.
velopment in undernourished adolescent sheep. Biol Reprod 2007;77: [40] Kind KL, Owens JA, Robinson JS, Quinn KJ, Grant PA, Walton PE, et al.
351e7. Effect of restriction of placental growth on expression of IGFs in fetal
[29] Vonnahme KA, Hess BW, Nijland MJ, Nathanielsz PW, Ford SP. sheep: relationship to fetal growth, circulating IGFs and binding proteins.
Placentomal compensation may compensate for maternal nutrient restric- J Endocrinol 1995;146:23e4.
tion in ewes adapted to harsh range conditions. J Anim Sci 2006;84: [41] Oliver MH, Harding JE, Breier BH, Evans PC, Gluckman PD. Glucose
3451e9. but not a mixed amino acid infusion regulates plasma insulin-like growth
[30] Greenwood PL, Slepetis RM, Bell AW. Influences on fetal and placental factor-I concentrations in fetal sheep. Pediatr Res 1993;34:62e5.
weights during mid to late gestation in prolific ewes well nourished [42] Shen W, Wisniowski P, Ahmed L, Boyle DW, Denne SC, Liechty EA.
throughout pregnancy. Reprod Fert Dev 2000;12:149e56. Protein anabolic effects of insulin and IGF-I in the ovine fetus. Am J
[31] Heasman L, Clarke L, Firth K, Stephenson T, Symonds ME. Influence of Physiol 2003;284:E748e56.
restricted maternal nutrition in early to mid gestation on placental and fe- [43] Jones CT, Gu W, Harding JE, Price DA, Parer JT. Studies on the growth
tal development at term in sheep. Pediatr Res 1998;44:546e51. of fetal sheep. Effects of surgical reduction in placental size, or experi-
[32] Ford SP, Nijland MJ, Miller MM, Hess BW, Nathanielsz PW. Maternal mental manipulation of uterine blood flow on plasma sulphation promot-
undernutrition advanced placentomal type, in association with increased ing activity and on the concentration of insulin-like growth factors I and
placentomal size and cotyledonary blood flow. J Soc Gynecol Invest II. J Dev Physiol 1988;10:179e89.
2006;13(Suppl.):212A. [44] Li J, Saunders JC, Gilmour RS, Silver M, Fowden AL. Insulin-like
[33] Lok F, Owens JA, Mundy L, Robinson JS, Owens PC. Insulin-like growth factor-II messenger ribonucleic acid expression in fetal tissues
growth factor-I promotes growth selectively in fetal sheep in late gesta- of the sheep during late-gestation: effects of cortisol. Endocrinology
tion. Am J Physiol 1996;270:R1148e55. 1993;132:2083e9.

You might also like