You are on page 1of 6

R E SE A R CH A N D D E V ELO PM EN T | A LUM I N A C A S TA B L E S

A Study on the Phosphate-Bonded


High-Alumina Castable –
Effect of MgO Addition
R. Sarkar1 , U.K. Behera1
Abstract: Mono-aluminium phosphate [MAP, Al(H2PO 4)3] is a widely used chemical binder in
the refractory industries due to its higher water solubility and greater bonding strength at low
temperatures as it reacts with both basic and amphoteric oxides and has higher application
temperature. In the present work, commercial-grade MAP is used in high-alumina castables,
with different particle size distributions, as the sole binder. The effect of addition of 1 mass-%
MgO as a setting accelerator to the castable compositions is also studied. Castables are processed
as per conventional processing methods and heat treated after drying at 1000 and 1600 °C.
Dried and fired compositions were evaluated for density and strength. Also micro-structural study
of the 1600 °C sintered samples was carried out. Addition of MgO resulted in a marginal decrease
in density values which may be due to a greater amount of hydrated phase formation and their
decomposition at higher temperatures; but it significantly increased crushing strength for all the
heat treatment temperatures. Greater bonding from faster reaction at low temperature and the
formation of a liquid phase at higher temperatures are the reasons for such an enhancement.

Keywords: phosphate bonding, alumina castables, MAP, MgO addition, properties, microstructure

1. Introduction Type of bonding material used and its constituent that sets the unshaped (casta-
Refractory castables can be classified as a amount greatly affect the properties and per- ble) refractory, retains the shape, and pro-
blended mixture of different fractions of formances of the castable. The bonding vides strength even up to elevated tempera-
refractory aggregates and fines with a agent of a castable may change the chemical tures. For phosphate bonding, the phos-
bonding agent and various additives. They composition, fluidity, workability, dry-out, phate bond is intentionally developed in the
are supplied in dry condition as loose pow- firing conditions and finally the properties refractory system. There are plenty of phos-
ders and mixed with a liquid (usually water) [3]. Hence much research is available in the phate-forming compounds available com-
at the user’s industry site and then vibrated, literature to improve the quality of castables mercially and among them phosphoric acid
poured or pumped, or pneumatically shot by using different bonding agents [1–9]. (H 3PO 4) or mono-aluminium phosphate
into the application area to form the desired Binders are essential for the development of [MAP or Al(H2PO4)3] are the main bonding
shape or structure that becomes rigid strength at both ambient and elevated tem- agents that have been widely studied for
because of hydraulic or chemical settings peratures and also help to retain the shape refractory castables [10]. According to the
and then fired for densification and under green conditions as no compaction is proposed setting mechanism in the litera-
strength development [1]. Applications of involved in the shaping process during ture [1, 10–12], H3PO4 initially reacts with
castables have grown significantly in the installations of castables. Different bonding Al 2O3 (above 127 °C) or Al(OH)3 at room
last half-century and over the years casta- materials commonly used for castables are temperature forming MAP. This MAP
bles have changed from simple mixes to hydraulic (cement and hydratable alumina), decomposes on heating to form ortho alu-
very complex engineered formulations, chemical (phosphate, silicates, geopolymers, minium phosphate (OAP, AlPO 4) till
used in a variety of very demanding and etc.), colloidal (silica sol, alumina sol) and 1327 °C and which on further heating forms
critical industrial applications. Also in others [1, 6–9]. pure alumina and phosphoric pentoxide in
many of the applications castables are the In the case of chemically bonded refrac- a gaseous state. The details of the equations
most appropriate choice due to better per- tories, a chemical bond is formed between are given below. Also, MAP is considered
formance and easier installation [2]. the bonding agent material and refractory [8, 13−14] to be the most applied chemical

44 Refractories Manual 2018 www.interceram-review.info


Authors 6H3PO4 + Al2O3 = 2Al(H2PO4)3 + 3H2O amount of strength at operating tempera-
(Temperature 127–427 °C) (1) tures above 1300 °C (because of complete
DR. RITWIK SARKAR decomposition of phosphate) till the ceramic
(ritwiksarkar@rediffmail. 3H3PO4 + Al(OH)3 = Al(H2PO4)3 + 3H2O bond forms on sintering. This binder system
com), is Professor, National (Room temperature) (2) also has a poor ability to bond with existing
Institute of Technology,
fired refractories. In addition, the refractory
Rourkela, India, with more
than 20 years of experi-
Al(H2PO4)3 = AlPO4 + 3H2O + P2O5 lining has a high chance of lamination as
ence in Ceramics & Refrac- (Temperature 732–1327 °C) (3) they have a weak bonding strength.
tories. He has work experi- An important aspect of phosphate bond-
ence in private sectors 2AlPO4 = Al2O3 + P2O5 ing is that it takes a long time for setting or
like IFGL Refractories Ltd., (above 1350 °C) (4) hardening in high-alumina castables at room
ACC Ltd., H&R Johnson (I) temperature [10]. Thus, the soft/plastic char-
Ltd., and also in R & D or-
So this bonding finally results in pure alu- acter can be retained for a long time in phos-
ganization like CSIR-CGCRI
in India and IKKM, RWTH
mina with no trace of phosphorus in the phate-bonded unshaped compositions and
Aachen, Germany (DAAD fired composition. Also, phosphate shows they are widely used for plastic refractory
Fellowship). Dr. Sarkar has better bonding with metallic parts com- compositions. For castable applications, set-
received many awards in pared to other bonding systems [1]. But there ting is desired within a specific time period
his career for his academic are several disadvantages associated with and so addition of setting accelerators (i.e.,
excellence and scientific phosphates. Primarily the setting of the MgO, CaO, calcium aluminates, etc.) to the
contribution in Ceramics &
material is very slow and sluggish. In order compositions is required. These additives
Materials Science including
Young Scientist Award.
to speed up the reaction, setting agents are induce an acid–base reaction, thus a fast set-
used, like, MgO, CaO, calcium aluminates, ting reaction occurs, resulting in the forma-
etc. These additives induce an acid–base tion of phosphate-based salts (amorphous/
reaction, forming amorphous/crystalline crystalline) and the refractory is set with desir-
phosphates that enhance refractory harden- able properties [8, 10]. The phosphate bond is
ing and other properties. Also phosphate mainly important for its good adhesion and
binder in the refractory field due to its high bonding requires considerable amounts of lesser chance of cracking during heating,
solubility in water, high bonding strength mechanical moisture for workability and so allowing faster repair and reduced downtime
and reaction with basic and amphoteric raw a long heat-up schedule is required for dry- [10, 15–16]. However, a detailed study of this
materials at low temperatures, high applica- ing. The green strength is weak due to the bond material in the castable system is not
tion temperature and no residual impurity lack of strong bonding, like in cement. On widely available in the literature. Such a study
phase in the final product. firing, the bond system loses a considerable is planned in the present work with a high-alu-
mina castable system having two different
Table 1 Physico-chemical properties of the raw materials particle size distributions and in the presence
(WTA – White Tabular Alumina, WFA – White Fused Alumina) (©R. Sarkar) of a setting accelerator (MgO).

Constituent WFA grain [%] WTA grain [%] Alumina fines [%]
Al 2 O 3 98.93 99.34 99.5 2. Experimental
SiO 2 0.1 0.03 0.03 The phosphate-bonded high-alumina casta-
ble was prepared using different grain sizes
Fe 2 O 3 0.06 0.035 0.03
of white fused alumina (from a Chinese
TiO 2 Trace – Trace source), white tabular alumina (WTA)
CaO 0.1 – 0.02 (Almatis, Kolkata, India), technical alumina
fines (Almatis, India) and liquid mono-alu-
MgO – – 0.01
minium phosphate (MAP) (Mrk Chemicals,
Na 2 O + K 2 O 0.4 0.15 0.1 India). The MAP used was a colourless, vis-
Bulk density [g/cm ] 3
3.77 3.61 – cous, adhesive solution, with an Al2O3 con-
Apparent porosity [%] 1.8 3.93 – tent ~8–10 %, P2O5 content ~35–38 %, spe-
cific gravity between 1.50–1.55 and a viscos-
Specific sur face area [m 2 /g] – – 2.6
ity at room temperature between 18–25 s
Phase analysis Corundum Corundum Corundum (Ford Cup B-4 method). The details of the
physico-chemical properties of the other raw
materials are provided in Table 1. For the

67th Volume 2018 Refractories Manual 45


R E SE A R CH A N D D E V ELO PM EN T | A LUM I N A C A S TA B L E S

batches containing MgO as a setting acceler-


ator, freshly calcined MgO, prepared by cal-
cining chemical-grade magnesium hydrox-
ide (99 % pure, Loba Chemie, India), is added
at an amount of 1 mass-%. The castable com-
positions with different particle size distri-
bution were formulated using a Dinger and
Funk model with distribution coefficients, q
values, of 0.21 and 0.29 [1–7, 20] and the dis-
tribution plot of both the distribution coef-
ficients is provided in Figure 1. Details of the
batch composition are given in Table 2. A
fixed amount of 8 vol-% to mass-% of the
MAP solution was used for the study.
All the raw materials were initially dry-
mixed in a planetary mixer (model N50;
Hobart, Peterborough, UK). First, the
coarser components were mixed, then the
fine components were added (also calcined Figure 1 Particle size distribution used in this work (©R. Sarkar)
MgO for the MgO-containing batches), and
finally, the MAP solution was added. After
proper mixing and a desirable flow consist- Standard (BIS) specifications, IS 1528–1974, ent work. The highest particle size of 3 mm
ency was achieved, the whole mixture was reaffirmed on 2002. Each data represented has a CPFT of 100 % and the lowest particle
then cast in a lubricated iron mould of 50 here are an average of five individual meas- size being 0.01 mm shows 0 % CPFT. The
mm cube size. The cast specimens were urements. Micro-structural study of the composition with a q value of 0.21 has a
cured within the mould for one day, and then 1600 °C sintered samples was conducted by higher extent of fines content. There is an
they were dried in a hot air oven at 200 °C for a field-emission scanning electron micro- abrupt change in the slope of the plot in the
24 h. The dried specimens were fired at 1000 scope (Nova Nano, FEI, USA) after gold finer size range due to the high fines content
and 1600 °C at the rate of 3 K/min with a coating through a sputter coater. in the compositions (low q value). Table 2
soaking period of 2 h. All the firings were shows that the percentage of finer (< 0.2 mm)
conducted in a 1700 °C programmable elec- fraction is greater for the composition q =
tric furnace (Okay & Co., India). The dried 3. Results and Discussion 0.21. Physico-chemical properties of the
and heat-treated specimens were character- Figure 1 shows the plot of CPFT (cumulative starting raw materials (Table 1) indicate that
ized for density, strength, phase analysis and percent finer than) of different size fractions the materials are pure and contain the very
micro-structural study. Density and strength against particle size for the distribution coef- minimum of impurities.
were characterized as per Bureau of Indian ficients q = 0.21 and 0.29, used for the pres-
3.1 Density Study
Figure 2 shows the variation in bulk density
Table 2 Particle size distribution in the batch of the castable composition (©R. Sarkar)
(BD) of different compositions studied
Components Size [mm] Mass-% for q = 0.21 Mass-% for q = 0.29 against firing temperature. Density values
were found to increase with the increase in
White Fused Alumina 3–2 11.7 13.72
temperature. Also BD was found to increase
White Tabular Alumina 2–1 17.82 20.02 with the q value. Higher q value means
White Tabular Alumina 1–0.5 15.4 16.37 greater extent of coarser fractions, which has
a greater bulk density value than the finer
White Tabular Alumina 0.5–0.2 16.21 16.2
fraction. But addition of MgO was found to
White Tabular Alumina 0.2–0.05 21.49 19.63 reduce the densification of the compositions
marginally for both q values at all tempera-
Alumina Fines 0.05–0.01 17.38 14.06
tures. Addition of MgO causes faster reac-
White Tabular Alumina 0.2–0.05 21.49 19.63 tion between basic MgO and acidic phos-
Alumina Fines 0.05–0.01 17.38 14.06
phate (MAP) in the composition, resulting in
hydrated magnesium phosphate-based reac-
tion products [10, 12, 21–22].

46 Refractories Manual 2018 www.interceram-review.info


by increasing the temperature of the matrix
phase due to the exothermic reaction of
Mg-phosphate formation. Thus, the pres-
ence of MgO at low temperatures enhances
the bonding of the castables, thus enhancing
the strength. Again, at higher temperatures,
the low melting characters of Mg-based
phosphates [such as Mg3(PO4)2 which has
a melting point ~1357 °C and Mg(PO3)2
~1165 °C] produce liquid phase [10] bonding
in the compositions enhancing the strength.
But, as the amount of MgO addition was not
significant, the extent of liquid phase for-
mation was limited and did not degrade
the properties.

3.3 Micro-Structural Study


Figure 4 shows the micro-structural fea-
Figure 2 Variation in bulk density of the castables (©R. Sarkar) tures of the different compositions sintered
at 1600  °C. Figure 4 A and C show the
micro-structure of compositions without
MgO + 2Al(H2PO4)3 + 9H2O monly found in cement-containing compo- MgO and indicate that the composition
= Mg(H2PO4)2 ∙ 2H2O + 2(MgHPO4  sitions, is absent as these compositions are with q = 0.21 has lower grain sizes com-
∙ 3H2O) + 2(AlPO4 ∙2H2O) (5) not based on hydraulic bonding. Castables pared to that of q = 0.29. The granular struc-
with higher q value result in greater strength ture is found to be a non-uniformly com-
These reactions occur during the castable which may be associated with greater densi- pacted one; it is observed to be well com-
processing steps and the formed Mg(H2PO4)2 fication, associated with compaction [2–3, pacted in certain portions and not well
∙2H 2O phase is a metastable/soluble com- 25]. Addition of MgO is found to considera- compac ted i n ot her por t ions w it h
pound whereas the MgHPO4∙3H 2O (new- bly enhance the strength values of the casta- inter-granular porosities. But the addition
beryite) phase is a well stable/insoluble one. bles for all temperatures and q values. The of MgO is found to change the micro-struc-
These hydrated magnesium phosphate presence of MgO enhances phosphate bond tural features considerably. Micro-photo-
phases decompose to different anhydrous formation, both by forming Mg-based phos- graphs of both the q values show consider-
magnesium phosphates on heating, namely phates and also enhancing the Al-based ones able growth of the grains and the sharpness
Mg 2P 2O7, Mg(PO3)2 and Mg 3(PO 4)2 . The
presence of these hydrated phosphates at low
temperatures (dried condition) and their
decompositions at higher temperatures
causes a decrease in the density values for all
the different temperatures. The MgO-con-
taining compositions resulted in lower den-
sity values compared to that of batches with-
out MgO. However, the effect of temperature
is found to be similar for these batches.

3.2 Strength Study


Figure 3 shows the variation of the cold
crushing strength (CCS) values of different
castable compositions against firing temper-
ature. Strength values are found to increase
with increasing temperatures for all the
castable compositions having different q val-
ues and MgO content. Degradation of
strength at intermediate temperature, com- Figure 3 Variation in cold crushing strength of the castables (©R. Sarkar)

67th Volume 2018 Refractories Manual 47


R E SE A R CH A N D D E V ELO PM EN T | A LUM I N A C A S TA B L E S

of the grains is reduced. MgO-containing 4. Conclusions considerably due to faster bond formation at
compositions have relatively rounded MAP-bonded high-alumina castables hav- low temperature and liquid phase formation,
grains indicating the presence of a liquid ing distribution coefficients (q values) of 0.21 as observed in the micro-structural study, at
phase at 1600 °C sintering. Grains are in and 0.29 with and without MgO addition high temperatures. |
contact with each other which may help in were prepared and processed through con-
bonding and increasing strength. However, ventional castable processing techniques. A
the grains are not well compacted ones and higher q value and temperature resulted in a References
inter-granular porosity is commonly higher density but the presence of MgO mar- [1] Sarkar, R.: Refractory Technology: Fundamentals
and Applications. CRC Press, Florida, US, (2016)
observed. This liquid phase formation and ginally reduces the density values which may 252−254, ISBN 9781498754255
grain bonding has helped in increasing the be associated with a greater extent of [2] Krietz, L.: Refractory castables. C.A. Schacht (Ed.),
strength values at room temperature but hydrated phase formation and their decom- Refractories Handbook, CRC Press, Florida, US,
(2004) 259−285, ISBN 9780824756543
may adversely affect the strength values at positions at higher temperatures. But MgO [3] Ishikawa, M.: Refractory castables.
high temperatures. addition was found to enhance the strength Taikabutsu Overseas 19 (1999) [3] 7−13

Figure 4 FESEM photomicrographs of the 1600 °C sintered castables,


(A) q = 0.21 without MgO, (B) q = 0.21 with 1 % MgO, (C) q = 0.29 without MgO and (D) q = 0.29 with 1 % MgO (©R. Sarkar)

48 Refractories Manual 2018 www.interceram-review.info


Acknowledgment
[4] Zhou, N., Hu, S., Zhang, S.: Advances in modern applications. Elsevier Ltd., Oxford (2004) 43−62,
refractory castables. CN-Refractories 13 (2004) ISBN 9780080445052
[2] 3−12 The authors thankfully acknowledge the
[14] Giskow, R., Lind, J., Schmidt, E.: The variety of phos-
[5] Zhou, N.: New castables and their role in phates for refractory and technical applications support of Mr. S. Mukherjee and Mr. S.
advancements in monolithic refractories. by the example of aluminum phosphates. Cfi/Ber.
Chatterjee for supplying different grades
Interceram 55 (2006) [1] 24−26 DKG 81 (2004) E1−E5
[6] Lee, W.E., Vieira, W., Zhang, S., Ghanbari Ahari, K., [15] Gower, G.D., Gower, I.R.: Properties of magnesi- of alumina and the staff of the Department
Sarpoolaky, H., Parr, C.: Castable refractory con- um-phosphate-bonded refractory castables, of Ceramic Engineering, NIT Rourkela for
cretes. Int. Mater. Rev. 46 (2001) [3] 145−167 Refract. Appl. News 11 (2006) [5] 11−13
their support and help regarding different
[7] Nouri-Khezrabad, M., Braulio, M.A.L., Pandolfelli, V.C., [16] Finch, T., Sharp, J.H.: Chemical reactions between
Golestani-Fard, F., Rezaie, H.R.: Nano-bonded refrac- magnesia and aluminum orthophosphate to experimentation for the work.
tory castables. Ceram. Int. 39 (2013) [4] 3479−3497 form magnesia-phosphate cements. J. Mater.
[8] Parr, C., Auvray, J.M., Pelletier, J., Szepizdyn, M., Sci. 24 (1989) 4379−4386
Wohrmeyer, C., Zetterstrom, C.: A review of refracto- [17] Dinger, D.R., Funk, J.E.: Particle Packing III: Discrete
ry bond systems for monolithic castable refracto- versus continuous particle sizes, Interceram, 41 castables for petro-chemical application. Ceram.
ries. In: Proc. of the 5th Ann. Symp. on Refractories, (1992) [5] 332–334 Int. 42 (2016) 8331–8337
St. Louis, USA, (2014) 18–35 [18] Myhre, B., Hundere, A.: The use of particle size [23] Singh A.K., Sarkar, R.: Effect of binders and distribu-
[9] Li, Z., Ye, G.: Bonding and recent progress of distribution in development of refractory castables. tion coefficient on the properties of high alumina
monolithic refractories. Interceram 41 (1992) Proc. XXV Alafar Congress, Bariloche, Argentina, castables. J. Austr. Ceram. Soc. 50 (2014) [2] 93–98
[3] 169−172 (1996) 33–42 [24] Sarkar, R., Parija, A.: Effect of alumina fines on high
[10] Nishikawa, A.: Technology of monolithic [19] Sarkar, R., Das, S.K.: Effect of distribution coefficient alumina self-flow low cement castables, Refracto-
refractories. Plibrico Japan Company Ltd., on gel bonded high alumina castable. IRMA J. ries World Forum 6 (2014) [1] 73–77
Japan (1984) 101−114 43 (2010) [1] 31–36 [25] Sarkar, R., Parija, A.: Effect of alumina fines on
[11] Cassidy, J. E. : Phosphate bonding then and [20] Sarkar, R.: Particle size distribution for refractory vibratable high alumina low cement castable,
now. Ceram. Bull. 56 (1977) [7] 640−643. castables: A review. Interceram 65 (2016) [3] 82 – 86 Interceram 63 (2014) [3] 113−116
[12] Luz, A.P., Gomes, D.T., Pandolfelli V.C.: High-alumina [21] Luz, A.P., Braulio, M.A.L., Pandolfelli, V.C.: Refractory
phosphate-bonded refractory castables : Al(OH)3 castable engineering, installation techniques: Fo-
sources and their effects. Ceram. Int. 41 (2015) cusing on shotcreting. Göller Verlag, Baden-Baden,
9041–9050 Germany (2015) Chapter 5, 257–309
[13] Wagh, A.S.: Chemically bonded phosphate ceram- [22] Luz, A.P., Oliveira, G.R., Gomes, D.T., Pandolfelli, V.C.: 1 Department of Ceramic Engineering, National
ics, twenty-first century materials with diverse Mono-aluminum phosphate-bonded refractory Institute of Technology, Rourkela, Odisha, (India)

Know-how Engineering | Solutions


Enhancing performance, stability, efficiency
Refractory applications benefit from the use of a Promat insulation system to
minimise heat losses and to allow better process stability.
Promat insulation is thinner, lighter and more efficient and will help you achieve
the best possible cost and operational efficiency, while respecting the design
of your application.

Etex Building Performance GmbH, Promat Industry, P.O. Box 101564, D-40835 Ratingen
+49 (0)2102 493-0 | industry.hpi@promat.de | www.promat-industry.com
67th Volume 2018 Refractories Manual 49

You might also like