Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A socially and religiously recognized union between a man and a woman that establishes certain
rights and duties between them is called a marriage. The parties to the marriage i.e. the man and
the woman are called husband and wife respectively. A marriage is often referred as a contract
between the husband and wife to live together. In our nation, Marriage is a religious
establishment which is essential for the development of our general public.
Marriage has been awarded a legal status under various personal laws i.e. Hindu Marriage Act,
1955, Parsi Marriage and Divorce Act, 1936, Indian Christian Marriage Act, 1872 and Special
Marriage Act, 1954. Although, a marriage is considered as a sacred relationship but the
complexities of the concept and development in the society gave birth to the concept of Nullity
of Marriage.
Meaning
When the court declares that a marriage between two people is not valid, the marriage is said to
be nullified. The court has power to declare a marriage void or voidable under Section 11 and
12 respectively, of Hindu Marriage Act, 1955. A void marriage is the one which is considered
as no marriage in the eyes of the court whereas voidable marriage is the one which can be
declared invalid on petition by either party to such marriage.
1. a) Bigamy [Section 5(i)]: If any of the parties to a marriage has another spouse
living at the time of marriage, it shall be considered null and void.
2. b) Prohibited degree [Section 5(iv)]: A marriage between prohibited degree
relations is void unless the customs and usages allow it.
3. c) Sapindas [Section 5(v)]: A marriage between parties who are sapindas is
void unless allowed by usages and customs.
*Sapinda relationship with reference to any person extends as far as the third
generation in the line of ascent through the mother, and the fifth through the
father, the line being traced upwards in each case from the person concerned, who
is to be counted as the first generation. Two persons are said to be sapindas of each
other if one is a lineal ascendant of the other within the limits of sapinda
relationship with reference to each of them[1].
These marriages can be held voidable by the decree of nullity by the court under Section of
Hindu Marriage Act, 1955. The parties to such marriage have to decide whether they want to
continue with such marriage or want annulment of the same.
The grounds on which a party can file a petition for nullity of marriage under
this section are:
*The grounds are under Section 5 (ii) of Hindu Marriage Act, 1955.
1) The petition shall be filed within one year of practice of force and fraud and discovery of the
same.
2) The petitioner, at the time of marriage, did not have knowledge of fact alleged in the petition.
3) The petition shall be filed within one year from the time when parties got the knowledge of
fact alleged.
4) The parties had not been sexually involved with each other since the fact alleged has been
discovered.
Though the children born out of a void or voidable marriage has been awarded the status of
legitimacy but they have been given no birth right in the Hindu Joint Family Property and cannot
claim any right in the coparcenary entities of the father. But they can inherit the property of their
father under Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956[3].
Case Laws
Yamunabai Anantrao Adhav v. Anantarao Shivram Adhav[4]: In this case, it has been held
that a marriage which is in contravention of section 11 of Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 shall be
treated as null and void from the time of its inception.
Bassappa v. Sidhagangamma[5]: It has been held by Karntaka High Court that a wife whose
marriage has been declared null and void because it was in contravention to Section 5 (i), (iv) or
(v) is not entitled to claim maintenance as she does not have a status of wife under Section 18 of
Hindu Adoption and Maintenance Act, 1956.
Lila v. Laxman[6]: It was held by Allahabad High court that a void marriage does not need a
decree of nullity as it is no marriage in the eyes of law. A decree passed for void marriage is a
mere declaration of nullity of marriage. The court only makes the fact clear that there was no
marriage between the parties.
C.S. Rangabhattar v. C. Choodamani[7]: The Andhra Pradesh High Court held that where a
husband cohabits with the wife even when he is aware of the wife’s pregnancy at the time of
marriage, he cannot file petition for decree of nullity of marriage.
Smt. Sariabai v. Komalsingh[8]: It was held that petition after eight years of marriage is barred
by statute of limitation and cannot be entertained.
Moina Khosla v. Amardeep Khosla[9]: In this case, the husband was not capable of interacting
much with females and failed to have sexual intercourse with wife. It was held that the wife was
entitled to a decree of nullity of marriage.
Gayatri Bai v. Pradeep Kumar Chourasia[10]: In this case, the High Court defined Impotency
as practical impossibility to perform sexual intercourse completely and complete sexual
penetration is an important ingredient for ordinary intercourse but the satisfaction obtained by
the parties is irrelevant.
Dr. Shrikant Adya v. Smt. Anuradha[11]: The Karnataka High Court held that if a husband is
not able to lead a sexual life and has sexual weakness, it would amount to mental cruelty and the
wife can file petition for nullity of marriage.
Conclusion
Prior to enactment of Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 the parties to a marriage had non remedy or
recourse to get out of a marriage which is a burden of them. For the purposes of social reforms
and due to the dynamic nature of society, the Act was enacted and the concept of Nullity of
Marriage was engrossed while keeping in mind the religious sentiments. Now, Section 11 and 12
of the Act is a remedy for parties who are in a void or voidable marriage. Moreover, with the
enactment of Amendment Act, 1976, the children born out of a voidable or void marriage are
also awarded a title of legitimacy. Overall, the concepts discussed above leads to development of
society.