Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The manuscript was accepted after revision for publication on 13 March 2009.
DOI: 10.1243/14680874JER02509
Abstract: The paper reviews the virtual design process of an automotive high-speed direct-
injection (HSDI) two-stroke diesel engine, developed at the Department of Mechanical and
Civil Engineering (DIMeC) of the University of Modena and Reggio Emilia. The new concept of
the engine is the tumble-supported and spray-controlled combustion system, which enables
the adoption of loop scavenging without valves, and the use of a very simple and compact
combustion chamber, carved in the engine head.
The concept has been applied to a three-cylinder engine, with a capacity of 1050 cm3,
supercharged by means of a Roots compressor and a variable geometry turbocharger. Some
alternative configurations have been defined. Integrated one-dimensional and multidimen-
sional computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulations have been performed in order to
optimize the main engine parameters, as well as to predict brake performance and emissions,
in comparison with a reference four-stroke automobile diesel engine.
Simulation results demonstrate the potential of the concept, which may be applied to
develop a new generation of ultra-compact and clean automotive diesel engines.
advanced configuration, the engine shows a power Sirion, 1999), this concept is widespread in the
density of 50 kW/l, a minimum specific fuel con- aeronautic field to power light aircraft [8–11].
sumption of 235 g/kW h, along with relatively low
in-cylinder peak pressures (120 bar). AVL claims
that the engine is much lighter than a four-stroke 2 THE NEW CONCEPT
unit of the same top power and with similar single-
cylinder displacement (the total weight is less than The final goal of the project carried out at the
80 kg). As far as emissions are concerned, the University of Modena and Reggio Emilia is to
behaviour of this two-stroke engine does not differ develop a new generation of cost-effective, ultra-
from a four-stroke counterpart, and additional compact, fuel efficient, and clean two-stroke diesel
advantages have been found in terms of noise and engines, suitable for different applications: small
NOx reduction. passenger cars and off-road vehicles, light aircraft,
The two-stroke high-speed diesel engine concept small boats, etc. At the moment of completing this
was also investigated in 1999 by Yamaha, who built a paper, all the relevant fluid thermodynamic pro-
1000 cm3, two-cylinder engine, with crankcase loop cesses have been extensively investigated by means
scavenging [5]. The most peculiar characteristic of of state-of-the-art computational fluid dynamics
(CFD) tools, while the first experimental campaign
this prototype is the combustion system, made up of
has been designed but has not yet been carried out.
a pre-chamber, connected to the cylinder through
The core of the project is a brand new type of
four holes. During compression, these holes impart a
combustion system. It is well known that conven-
swirling motion to the charge entering the pre-
tional DI diesel engines (both two- and four-stroke)
chamber, while, during expansion, they allow the gas
adopt a bowl in the piston, whose shape is optimized
to expand in the cylinder, with limited flow losses, in
in order to generate an optimum mean and
comparison to traditional indirect diesel engines.
turbulent flow field around TDC (top dead centre),
Even if the power density was not particularly high,
provided that a proper swirl motion is imparted to
this engine featured compact dimensions, along
the intake flow. Conversely, in the new combustion
with very low fuel consumption and engine-out
system the combustion chamber is carved within the
emissions.
engine head, while the piston crown is flat. Further-
In 2005, Daihatsu [6] announced a two-cylinder,
more, for the sake of compactness and cost,
1200 cm3 capacity automotive engine, exhibiting a scavenging is obtained without poppet valves, but
maximum power of 65 kW and a maximum torque of using piston controlled slots at the bottom of the
230 N m. Daihatsu claims that the prototype is very cylinder liner. Since this scavenging is of the loop
fuel efficient and clean, being able to comply with type, the combustion chamber and the injection
EURO V regulations. The scavenging and air meter- system are designed in order to comply with a flow
ing systems are like the ones previously mentioned field characterized by a strong tumble motion.
for the AVL prototype, with particular care devoted During compression, such a tumble vortex is
to reducing the mechanical loss of the supercharger, dissipated, generating a very high turbulence before
as well as to generating a moderate swirling motion TDC. The turbulence level remains very high around
within the chamber. The engine features a cooled TDC, also thanks to the contribution of fuel jet
exhaust gas recirculation (EGR) device and the latest momentum. At full load, soot is limited by the
common rail injection system. optimized shape of the chamber, associated with
In 2005, FEV announced the development of a high spray penetration (high injection pressure,
four-cylinder supercharged two-stroke diesel engine minimal spray ‘distortion’ by the mean flow), and
for military ground vehicles [7]. This engine, called diffusion (six or more nozzle holes). Nitrogen oxides
OPOC (opposed-piston, opposed-cylinder), features are low because of the large amount of residuals,
uniflow scavenging (intake and exhaust ports at typical of loop-scavenged engines.
opposite ends of the cylinder), asymmetric port The new combustion system yields several advan-
timing (exhaust ports open and close before intake), tages in comparison with the conventional system
and electrically assisted boosting. FEV claims a very adopted in most of the two-stroke prototypes
high power–weight ratio (325 HP, 125 kg) and low (characterized by uniflow scavenging with on-head
fuel consumption. exhaust poppet valves and a bowl in the piston).
While in the automobile field the two-stroke diesel First, on-head exhaust valves are not used, with
engine still has not found an application in industrial ensuing advantages in terms of overall compactness,
production, apart from some exceptions (Daihatsu cost, reliability, weight, and friction losses. Second,
Another very useful device that may be added is a scavenging process and the curves of the rate of
system able to vary the transmission ratio between heat release (ROHR). The discharge coefficients and
the Roots compressor and the engine. The main the scavenging parameters were obtained by run-
advantage of this system is to keep a high boost ning multidimensional CFD calculations, including
pressure at low engine speeds, enhancing low end modelling of the flow through the inlet and the
torque. Furthermore, at partial load, such a system exhaust manifolds of a single cylinder. These
provides a further calibration parameter, which may simulations were carried out using STAR-CD. The
be used to optimize fuel consumption or the curves of ROHR were provided by specific analyses,
composition of the trapped charge. focused on the combustion process alone, using a
customized version of KIVA-3V, developed in co-
operation with the University of Chalmers (Sweden).
4 THE VIRTUAL ENGINEERING PROCESS While KIVA was used to optimize the details of the
combustion chamber and of the injection strategy,
The development of a brand new combustion STAR was the main tool for the development of the
system and its application to the design of a real port and manifold geometry near the cylinder.
engine is a challenge that cannot be tackled lightly. Obviously, the exchange of data among the three
The choice made at the University of Modena and CFD tools is fundamental. Besides the already
Reggio Emilia in 2004 was to cover as much ground mentioned flow of information from the multi-
as possible through theoretical investigations, in dimensional calculations to the one-dimensional
order to start the experimental stage of the project engine model, the GT-Power outputs are employed
with detailed guidelines and to minimize the to provide initial and boundary conditions to
troubleshooting phase at the test bed. Indeed, in multidimensional calculations. Combustion ana-
summer 2007, a virtual engine model had been lyses start at exhaust port closure (EPC) from a flow
defined through an iterative process, consisting of field provided by the scavenging analysis. Finally, the
three main types of CFD simulation, as shown in in-cylinder gas composition at the end of the
Fig. 2. combustion process is entered in the scavenging
First, one-dimensional engine simulations were analyses.
carried out by means of the GT-Power software [13]. The paper reviews the results obtained at the end
These calculations are fundamental to address the of this virtual process, describing the simulations
choice of the main engine parameters, as well as to carried out on the final engine configurations, whose
provide a prediction of brake performance. Several outputs have not yet been published.
models were built, with an increasing degree of
accuracy, as soon as information provided by the
other types of simulation was available. In particular, 5 THE SCAVENGING PROCESS
engine simulations require as input data the inlet
and exhaust ports discharge coefficients and some The main goal of the scavenging system is to
parameters describing in a lumped fashion the generate a strong tumble motion at EPC, while
minimizing cross flow between the intake and
exhaust ports. Reduction of flow losses through the
ports is obviously important too, but not so critical
for brake performance, as the engine is strongly
supercharged. Finally, the presence of residuals at
the end of the gas exchange process is desired,
particularly at partial load, in order to reduce NOx
emissions. The scavenging system, whose layout is
shown in Fig. 3, is of the Schnurle type, and is
symmetric as regards a plane orthogonal to the
crankshaft axis.
The intake system is made up of two manifolds
wrapped around the cylinder and eight intake ports.
It should be observed that all the ports are oriented
towards one focal point within the cylinder, at the
opposite side of the exhaust ports. This configura-
Fig. 2 Schematic of the virtual engineering process tion, suggested also by Blair [14], is ideal to generate
Fig. 3 View of a computer aided design (CAD) model representing intake and exhaust ports and
the cylinder
a very compact front of fresh air sweeping the previously listed is the transfer port elevation, i.e. the
cylinder along a loop trajectory. The exhaust system angle of the port axis as regards the horizontal plane.
is quite conventional, with two manifolds, connected Plain horizontal ports offer good discharge coeffi-
to two ports each. cients, but they are not completely satisfactory when
The CFD simulations showed that one of the most considering turbulence and trapping efficiency. As
relevant parameters to meet the scavenging targets the elevation angle increases, the strength of the
across the cylinder, i.e. for different values of the value of 0.05 has been found for the average
ratio of scavenging pressure to exhaust pressure. discharge coefficient (defined as the ratio of the
Three different engine speeds are also considered: average port effective area to piston area). This is
2000, 3000, and 4000 r/min. It can be observed that the evidence of the excellent attitude of the
the influence of the operating conditions (PR and scavenging system to let the charge flow across
speed) on the scavenging features is quite limited. the cylinder without obstruction [1, 14].
This issue justifies entering a unique scavenging
model for all the one-dimensional engine simula-
tions.
6 COMBUSTION ANALYSES
Scavenging performance is acceptable for a DR
between 1.5 and 2.5, the range in which the engine
The geometrical features of the combustion cham-
typically operates at full load. In such a range,
ber were defined by considering the in-cylinder flow
considering the case 3000_PR1.5, the CE goes from
field patterns (the results of the previously men-
1.2 to 1.7, the RE is always higher than 65 per cent,
tioned three-dimensional CFD calculations) and,
and the amount of fresh charge trapped within the
above all, the outputs of combustion simulations.
cylinder is between 70 and 80 per cent of the total in-
The simulations were carried out using a customized
cylinder mass.
version of the KIVA-3V code. A full account on this
The quality of scavenging slightly improves as the
activity is given in another paper [20], while only the
PR increases, in particular for what concerns the RE.
main results are presented here.
This is due to the fact that higher velocities of the
First, it was found that the details of the in-
flow entering the cylinder produce a more compact
cylinder flow field at EPC are not very relevant for
front of fresh charge sweeping the cylinder, thus
combustion, as it occurs on traditional diesel
reducing the amount of air mixing with exhaust
engines. This result can be explained by considering
gases, before short-circuiting the cylinder. The
that, during compression, the in-cylinder mean
sweeping of exhaust gas is never complete within
velocities become almost null; thus, any difference
the cylinder, even in front of very high values of DR.
in terms of flow patterns is cancelled. Furthermore,
This issue is typical of loop-scavenged Schnurle-type
the turbulent kinetic energy field at TDC depends
engines, and is due to a pocket of residual gas which
more on fuel injection than on the mean flow at EPC.
remains trapped in the ‘eye’ of the tumble vortex.
The lack of a strong correlation between charge
As far as discharge characteristics are concerned,
motion details and combustion is a quite fortunate
the distribution of effective areas were calculated
outcome, since it makes it possible to consider a
from all the CFD simulations, for both intake and
conventional initial flow field for all the combustion
exhaust ports, and the following issues have been
observed. calculations, starting at EPC, without the need for a
specific scavenging analysis. This issue was exploited
1. The discharge properties of inlet ports are almost to speed up the comparison among different com-
independent of operating conditions, so that a bustion chamber configurations, in order to obtain
unique correlation between the crank angle and the design guidelines. Once a promising combustion
inlet port effective area can be easily found. chamber geometry was found, more accurate calcu-
2. The nature of the flow through the exhaust port is lations were performed, starting from an in-cylinder
very complex, being strongly transient (pressure flow field, calculated by means of previous scaven-
waves travel along the exhaust duct, accelerating ging analyses [15].
or slowing the gas) and three-dimensional (for As an example of combustion simulations, some
instance, a very large recirculation region is temperature fields are shown in Figs 5 and 6 at a few
observed just downstream of the cylinder and a consecutive crank angles, on two different planes.
uniform distribution of velocity is never reached For comparison, the correspondent fields of the
in any cross-section throughout the computa- reference four-stroke engine are also plotted. The
tional domain). As a consequence, the discharge operating condition is 3000 r/min at full load. From
data are very scattered, and it is necessary to Figs 5 and 6 it can be observed that temperatures in
discard some values in order to obtain a physi- the two-stroke engine are always lower than in the
cally consistent correlation between effective area corresponding four-stroke unit, as a result of a
and crank angle. higher content of residuals in the trapped charge.
3. The values of port effective areas are quite large, Furthermore, the combustion patterns are comple-
in comparison to standard two-stroke engines. A tely different: while in the conventional engine the
Fig. 5 Gas temperature plotted on a radial plane at 0, 30, 60 and 90u after top dead centre
(ATDC) for both the HSD2 and the four-stroke engine, at full load, 3000 r/min
higher temperature can be found in the bowl region, observed that, in the two-stroke engine, the peak of
in the two-stroke engine combustion occurs at the ROHR is always lower than that of the four-stroke
periphery of the chamber, with a much less regular engine. This result may be explained mainly by the
field, especially on the plane perpendicular to the larger amount of residuals trapped within the
cylinder axis. cylinder. Furthermore, in the two-stroke engine the
Another interesting comparison between two- and combustion process enters the completion phase
four-stroke engines can be made in terms of heat (after the end of injection, when burnt gases, air, and
release curves (Fig. 7) at different engine speeds fuel vapour are mixing throughout the chamber)
(1500, 2000, 3000, and 4000 r/min) at full load. It is earlier than the conventional engine. Assuming that
Fig. 6 Gas temperature plotted on a plane perpendicular to the cylinder axis at 0, 30, 60 and 90u
ATDC for both the HSD2 and the four-stroke engine, at full load, 3000 r/min
the beginning of this phase is when the 90 per cent is that, in the two-stroke engine, fuel jet penetration
of fuel is burnt, the lead of the two-stroke over the is higher, for a number of reasons: a greater distance
four-stroke grows as engine speed increases: at between the injector and walls, a lack of a strong
1500 r/min this advance is about 5u, but becomes charge motion interfering with sprays, and a lower
30u at 4000 r/min. The explanation for this behaviour rate of chemical reactions (because of the high
cism. However, both assumptions are conservative, performance, because of the energy lost in the
as can be easily demonstrated. blowdown process, as well as the poor trapping
According to the Woschni [1] model, the heat efficiency at low engine speeds. A very simple and
transfer rate during combustion is related to in- effective way to meet these opposite requirements is
cylinder gas velocities. While in four-stroke engines to adopt a device able to vary the height of the
gas velocities are very high near the wall because of exhaust ports. This solution has been chosen for the
the swirl vortex, in the two-stroke engine the base configuration of the two-stroke engine.
velocities are much lower, since the tumble vortex For the choice of the turbocharger and positive
has been completely destroyed during the compres- displacement compressor, the fundamental para-
sion stroke. meter is the flowrate to be delivered by each
As far as friction losses are concerned, the two- component. A rough estimation of this parameter
stroke engine has definitely fewer of them since: may be made by assuming that the two-stroke
engine will have the same brake power as the four-
(a) there is no valvetrain; stroke reference engine:
(b) at each crankshaft revolution the maximum
inertial force occurring at TDC is always m_ 4S gf ,4S
_ 2S ~
m : ð1Þ
balanced by the in-cylinder gas pressure; gtr,2S gf ,2S
(c) there are three pistons, instead of four, weight-
ing the same or even less (there is no bowl in the where m _ 2S is the mass flowrate, gtr is the trapping
piston). efficiency, and gf is the fuel conversion efficiency.
Finally, results of three-dimensional CFD simula- Obviously, the maximum flowrate deliverable by the
tions were used instead of experimental information. turbocharger components must be somewhat
In particular, the GT-Power model requires as input higher, in order to make the compressor and turbine
data the ports discharge coefficients as a function of operate at their best efficiency points, or close to
piston position and the direction of flow; the ROHR them. It should be remembered that the higher the
profiles at each operating condition, and the exhaust turbocharger efficiencies, the lower is the back-
gas purity as a function of the scavenging ratio. Even pressure at the exhaust port, and thus the better the
if the lack of experiments on the two-stroke engine scavenging.
leaves some uncertainty about the results of one- As far as the positive displacement compressor is
dimensional simulations, the author believes the concerned, the required maximum volumetric flow-
trends indicated by calculations to be accurate rate (Qmax) can be roughly assessed by equating the
enough to address engine design. airflow entering the compressor to the one entering
the engine, calculated by
m_ 2S
8 TWO-STROKE BASE ENGINE CONFIGURATION Qmax ~ ð2Þ
rIN,C
The definition of the main geometric parameters
and the components of this type of engine is a quite where rIN,C is the gas density entering the positive
long and complex process, since almost every choice displacement compressor. From equation (2), it can
is more or less dependent on the others, so that a be observed that the higher the inlet gas density, the
variation to a single parameter requires the recali- smaller can be the capacity of the positive displace-
bration of many others. ment compressor. The choice of a small compressor
A particularly critical issue, in comparison to four- strongly helps to improve fuel consumption at
stroke engines, is the timing of ports events. On the partial load, since it reduces the power adsorbed
one hand, delayed opening of the exhaust or a too-
Table 2 Two-stroke BASE engine specific features
advanced opening of intake ports may generate
backflows of exhaust gases into the intake manifolds, Dynamic compressor Garrett C101A
VG turbine Garrett GT17V
associated with strong pressure pulses. Under these PD compressor Roots–Eaton M24
conditions, the operations of the engine are not Engine–PD compressor transmission ratio 1:3.0
regular, with large cylinder-to-cylinder variations. Exhaust port opening 100–120u ATDC
Intake port opening 135u ATDC
The same problem may occur when the turbine has Geometric compression ratio 19.5:1
a relatively low permeability. On the other hand, Minimum AFR 16
Inlet plenum capacity 2100 cm3
early opening of exhaust ports reduces engine
Fig. 8 Average operating conditions for the two-stroke BASE engine at full load; (a) efficiency
map of the dynamic compressor; (b) efficiency map of the Roots compressor; (c)
efficiency and rack position of the variable geometry turbine
by this component. Therefore, it is convenient to put turbocharger can fit four-stroke HSDI diesel engines,
the positive displacement compressor after the four valves per cylinder, having almost twice the
dynamic compressor. Furthermore, the charge cool- capacity of the two-stroke unit. Some fundamental
ing between the two compression stages helps to results of the two-stroke BASE engine simulations at
increase gas density and avoid a thermal stress on full load are presented in Figs 8, 9, and 10.
the positive displacement compressor. The quality of matching between the engine and
A list of specific features of the two-stroke engine the supercharging system can be checked on the
is shown in Table 2. It is observed that the three graphs of Fig. 8. Picture (a) presents the
Figure 13 presents the results of the acceleration unit remains quicker up to 100 km/h although the
test in terms of vehicle speed and final boost superior power of the four-stroke unit makes the big
pressure (i.e. the pressure of the charge entering engine win for a split second.
the cylinders after the external compression). The
two-stroke engine dynamic response is about 6 s
quicker, not only because of the higher value of 11 TWO-STROKE VERSUS FOUR-STROKE
‘steady’ torque but also of the lower gas dynamic ENGINE AT PARTIAL LOAD
inertia, as visible from the boost pressure curves.
This lower gas dynamic inertia has been observed Another comparison between two- and four-stroke
already by the authors in a similar case [22], and it is reference engines is performed at partial load (brake
ascribed to the fact that, in positive displacement torque 60 and 30 N m, with engine speed varying
compressors, delivery pressure is not related to from 1250 to 3000 r/min). These operating condi-
engine speed, but is imposed by the global system tions correspond to the typical engine usage in a
gas dynamic resistance. In particular, at the begin- driving cycle for small passenger cars, which are
ning of the test the turbine rack closes abruptly and more likely to be interested in the two-stroke
then the exhaust system permeability falls down; as concept.
a response, the Roots delivery pressure builds up, so It is observed that the reference four-stroke engine
helping the acceleration of the turbocharger. It can needs a cooled EGR system in order to comply with
be observed that, just 1 s after the beginning of the EURO IV regulations, while the two-stroke engine
test, the total boost pressure in the two-stroke features no device of this sort. Furthermore, the
engine has reached the steady target (first plateau), turbine rack position, exhaust port timing, and Roots
while, for the same purpose, the four-stroke engine compressor transmission ratio in the two-stroke
needs about 4 s. engine are set in order to minimize fuel consump-
The dynamic performance of the two-stroke tion.
engine can be matched only by a four-stroke engine The one-dimensional CFD simulation results at
with a much larger capacity than the reference unit. partial load (60 and 30 N m of brake torque) are
In order to find an equivalence, a 1.9 L turbocharged shown in Figs 15 and 16. The four diagrams in each
HSDI four-stroke diesel engine, with four cylinders figure correspond to the brake specific fuel con-
inline, having a maximum brake power of 140 HP at sumption (b.s.f.c.), trapped residuals fraction,
4000 r/min, was compared to the two-stroke engine trapped air–fuel ratio (i.e. the ratio of fresh air
with the EVO configuration, in the same acceleration trapped within the cylinder to the injected fuel), and
test. The results of this comparison are shown in maximum in-cylinder pressure. First, it can be
Fig. 14. As shown, the car powered by the two-stroke observed that the two-stroke engine operates with
a higher AFR, particularly in the SIMPLE configura-
tion. The lower the load and engine speed, the higher
is the fraction of fresh air in the trapped charge, in
comparison to the four-stroke engine. The reason for
the larger AFR in the SIMPLE and BASE configura-
tions, in comparison to the EVO set-up, is the higher
Roots compressor speed. In fact, in the more
sophisticated two-stroke engine (2S_EVO), the com-
pressor velocity was set in order to lower the
adsorbed power, so enhancing fuel efficiency.
In terms of b.s.f.c., both two-stroke_EVO and two-
stroke_BASE engines show a slightly better fuel
efficiency than the four-stroke reference engine
(+6.6 and +4.4 per cent respectively), while 2S_SIM-
Fig. 14 Comparison between the two-stroke engine PLE is almost equivalent (+2.3 per cent). The AFR of
with the EVO configuration and a 1.9 L 2S_EVO may be strongly enhanced simply by
turbocharged HSDI four-stroke diesel engine
(top power 140 HP at 4000 r/min). Time
increasing the speed of the Roots compressor, as
history of the vehicle speed and boost pres- set in the SIMPLE and BASE configurations. Ob-
sure for the simulation of a 70–120 km/h viously, the drawback of this strategy is the worsen-
acceleration test ing of fuel consumption.
Fig. 15 Comparison between the two-stroke engine Fig. 16 Comparison between the two-stroke engine
with the BASE, EVO, and SIMPLE configura- with the BASE, EVO, and SIMPLE configura-
tions and the four-stroke reference engine at tions and the four-stroke reference engine at
partial load conditions (brake torque of partial load conditions (brake torque of
60 N m), showing one-dimensional CFD simu- 30 N m), showing one-dimensional CFD simu-
lation results lation results
In terms of the residual fraction, the two-stroke stroke engine does not need any EGR device to keep
engines have something less than the four-stroke the NOx under control.
engine. This issue is counterbalanced by more air
excess, particularly at very low loads.
Finally, it is observed that in-cylinder maximum 12 CONCLUSION
pressure is always lower in the two-stroke engine.
Therefore, the gas dynamic noise produced by the The paper reviews the virtual design process of a
two-stroke engine is also expected to be lower. new type of small-capacity, two-stroke HSDI diesel
In order to compare engine-out emissions at engine, under development at the Department of
partial load, a new set of combustion simulations Mechanical and Civil Engineering of the University
was performed on both the two-stroke engine and of Modena and Reggio Emilia (Italy). This develop-
the four-stroke reference engine. The injected fuel ment was carried out through the integrated use of
mass required to meet the torque target was CFD simulation tools, both one-dimensional and
calculated by running one-dimensional simulations, multidimensional.
considering the two-stroke BASE configuration. The new concept of the engine is the tumble-
These calculations also provided initial and bound- supported and spray-controlled combustion system,
ary conditions for the scavenging analyses, per- which enables the adoption of loop scavenging
formed with STAR-CD. Finally, the simulation of the without valves and the use of a very simple and
combustion process, starting from the previously compact combustion chamber, carved in the engine
calculated in-cylinder flow field at EPC, has been head.
performed by means of the KIVA-3V code. Because The concept was applied to a three-cylinder
of the time required to complete these simulations, engine, with a capacity of 1050 cm3, supercharged
only four operating conditions were considered: by means of a Roots compressor and a variable
1500, 2000, 2500, and 3000 r/min, with a brake geometry turbocharger. Some alternative configura-
torque of 60 N m. tions were also considered. In the most sophisticated
The combustion simulations account for the one (2S-EVO), the engine–compressor transmission
composition of the trapped charge, including a ratio can be adjusted as a function of the operating
significant amount of residuals. For the prediction conditions.
of pollutants, in particular of soot, the KIVA models The paper provides a comparison through numer-
were specifically calibrated using the experimental ical simulation between the two-stroke engine and a
values available for the four-stroke reference engine. four-stroke reference engine (1251 cm3, four-cylin-
Thus, the relative comparison between the two- der, 90 HP at 4000 r/min), at both full and partial
stroke and the four-stroke engines should not be load. It was found that the two-stroke engine can
affected by large approximations. The comparison reach a superior specific power (from 87 up to
between the two engines in terms of specific 113 HP/l versus 75 HP/l) and has higher values of
emissions (soot, NO, and CO) is presented in torque at any speed. Also, the two-stroke engine
Table 4. transient performances are excellent, in comparison
As shown in Table 4, soot and carbon monoxide to the four-stroke engine.
emissions are strongly reduced in the two-stroke At partial load, the most interesting feature of the
engine (289 and 275 per cent respectively), while two-stroke engine is that it operates with a higher
the reduction of nitrogen oxides is less significant. AFR than the four-stroke engine. Furthermore, a
However, it should be remembered that the two- high amount of residual gas is always present within
Table 4 Comparison between the two-stroke engine and the four-stroke reference engine in
terms of specific emissions at partial load (torque 60 N m)
NOx (g/kW h) CO (g/kW h) Soot (mg/kW h)
Two-stroke Four-stroke Two-stroke Four-stroke Two-stroke Four-stroke
1500 1.85 2.22 0.18 1.00 1.07 68.22
2000 1.41 1.96 0.40 1.08 28.13 56.26
2500 2.10 1.78 0.29 1.24 4.71 59.91
3000 2.02 2.10 0.23 1.15 6.18 172.42
the cylinder, without the need for an external EGR Malmaison, France, 29–30 November 1993, pp.
system. These conditions guarantee lower values of 53–62.
engine-out emissions, in particular of soot and CO 4 Knoll, R. AVL two-stroke diesel engine. SAE paper
980757, 1998.
(289 and 275 per cent as regards the four-stroke
5 Yamaha Motor official announcement data, Envir-
reference engine). Also, fuel consumption is slightly onment-friendly SD (Super Diesel) engine devel-
better, despite the conservative hypotheses made for oped. 23 March 1999.
friction losses. 6 Daihatsu Motor Company Ltd, Press Information,
The author fully acknowledges that the study The 61st International Motor Show (IAA), Frank-
presented in this paper is just the first step in the furt, 2005. Available from www.daihatsu.com, 2005.
development of a new type of engine. A massive 7 FEV Engine Technology. Available from www.fev.
com, 2005.
effort is still required to build a physical prototype
8 DeltaHawk Diesel Engines. Available from
and run experimental tests. In the next phase, it is www.deltahawkengines.com.
predicted that a number of critical issues will 9 Michael Zoche Antriebstechnik. Available from
emerge. However, this study demonstrates that the www.zoche.de.
project has the potential to tackle the future 10 Diesel Air Limited. Available from www.dair.co.uk.
challenges with good hope of success. 11 Wilksch Airmotive Limited. Available from
www.wilksch.com.
12 Hata, N. and Lio, T. Improvement of two-stroke
engine performance with the Yamaha Power Valve
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
System (YPVS). SAE paper 810922, 1981.
13 Gamma Technologies, GT-Power users manual
This study was possible because of the work of the (version 6.1), Released on 29 September 2004
University of Modena and Reggio Emilia team, made (Gamma Technologies, Westmont, Illinois).
up of many persons: Professor Giuseppe Cantore, 14 Blair, G. P. Design and simulation of two-stroke
Fabrizio Paltrinieri, Stefano Fontanesi, Carlo Alberto engines, 1996 (SAE, Warrendale, Pennsylvania).
Rinaldini, Carlo Arturo De Marco, Vincenzo Ga- 15 Fontanesi, S., Gagliardi, V., Malaguti, S., and
gliardi, and Simone Malaguti, plus a number of Mattarelli, E. Multidimensional cycle analysis of
former students: Matteo Galloni, Gabriele Ligabue, a novel 2-stroke HSDI diesel engine SAE paper
Simone Tegoni, Marco Cavazzuti, Giuseppe Martino, 2007-01-0161, 2007.
16 Balestrazzi, D., Borghi, M., Fontanesi, S., and
Paolo Settepanella, Rosario Gabrieli, Raffaele Bab-
Mattarelli, E. The influence of swirl control
bone, Stefano Bernardi, and Filippo Monzani. I wish strategies on the intake flow in four valve HSDI
to thank all of them for their fundamental contribu- diesel engines. SAE paper 2004-01-0112, 2004.
tion in terms of hard work, enthusiasm, and ideas. 17 Cantore, G., Fontanesi, S., Gagliardi, V., and
A special thanks to Professor Valeri Golovitchev for Malaguti, S. Effects of relative port orientation on
granting the use of his version of the KIVA-3V code. the in-cylinder flow patterns in a small unit
Last but not least, the author wishes to acknowl- displacement HSDI diesel engine. SAE paper
edge CD-Adapco Group, for the use of the STAR-CD 2005-32-0093, 2005 also SAE Trans. J. Engines, 2005.
code, and Gamma Technologies, Westmont, Illinois, 18 Li, Y., Xu, J., Gong, X., Liu, S., and Xu, S. Effects of
for GT-Power, both granted to the University of combination and orientation of intake ports on
swirl motion in four-valve DI diesel engines. SAE
Modena and Reggio Emilia.
paper 2000-01-1823, 2000.
19 Hermann, H. and Dürnholtz, M. Development of a
DI diesel engine with four valves for passenger cars.
REFERENCES SAE paper 950808, 1995.
20 De Marco, C. A., Mattarelli, E., Paltrinieri, F., and
1 Heywood, J. B. and Sher, E. The two-stroke cycle Rinaldini, C. A. A new combustion system for 2-
engine, 1999 (SAE, Warrendale, Pennsylvania). stroke HSDI diesel engine. SAE paper 2007-01-
2 Fleck, R. and Campbell, D. J. An experimental 1255, 2007.
investigation into the potential of small two-stroke 21 Cantore, G. and Mattarelli, E. A new concept for
diesel engines. IMechE, paper C433/061, 1991. ultra-compact automotive HSDI diesel engines.
3 Nomura, K. and Nakamura, N. Development of a SAE paper 2007-01-1253, 2007.
new two-stroke engine with poppet-valves: Toyota 22 Cantore, G., Fontanesi, S., and Mattarelli, E. A
S-2 engine. In A new generation of two-stroke new concept of supercharging applied to HSDI
engines for the future? (Ed. P. Duret). Proceedings diesel engines. SAE paper 2001-01-2485; also SAE
of the International Seminar held at IFP, Rueil- Trans. J. Engines, 2001.