Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Decentralised Procedure
DE/H/5020/001-007/DC
Crusia
10,000 IU (100 mg /1ml)
Crusia
15,000 IU (150 mg /1ml)
Crusia
12,000 IU (120 mg /0,8 ml)
Crusia
8,000 IU (80 mg /0,8 ml)
Crusia
6,000 IU (60 mg /0,6 ml)
Crusia
4,000 IU (40 mg /0,4 ml)
Crusia
2,000 IU (20 mg /0,2 ml)
DE/H/5021/001-007/DC
Active Substance:
Enoxaparin
Publication:
25.05.2018
TABLE OF CONTENTS
I. RECOMMENDATION .............................................................................................................. 6
II. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ..................................................................................................... 6
II.1 Problem statement................................................................................................................... 6
II.2 About the product ................................................................................................................... 6
II.3 General comments on the submitted dossier ........................................................................ 7
II.4 General comments on compliance with GMP, GLP, GCP and agreed ethical principles. 7
III. SCIENTIFIC OVERVIEW AND DISCUSSION ................................................................. 7
III.1 Quality aspects ......................................................................................................................... 7
III.2 Non-clinical aspects ............................................................................................................... 10
III.3 Clinical aspects ...................................................................................................................... 13
IV. BENEFIT RISK ASSESSMENT ......................................................................................... 25
Enoxaparin Sodium
Name of the drug substance (INN
name):
B01AB05
Pharmaco-therapeutic group
(ATC Code):
Solution for injection in pre-filled syringe
Pharmaceutical form(s) and
strength(s):
DE/H/5020-5021/001-007/DC
Reference Number(s) for the
Decentralised Procedure
DE
Reference Member State:
AT, BE, BG, CZ, DK, EE, EL, ES, FI, FR, HR, HU, IE, IT,
Member States concerned:
LU, LV, NL, NO, PL, PT, RO, SE, SI, SK and UK
Legal basis of application: Similar biological Art 10.4 Dir 2001/83/EC
Applicant (name and address) LABORATORIOS FARMACÉUTICOS ROVI, S.A.
JULIÁN CAMARILLO, 35 - MADRID
Postcode: 28037
Country: SPAIN
is approved provided that the applicant commits to perform a number of post authorisation follow- up
measures and obligations to be reported back to the Member States within predefined timeframes.
I. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
I.1 Problem statement
This is an application for two dose strengths (100 mg/mL and 150 mg/mL solution for injection) of an
enoxaparin-containing medicinal product claimed to be “biosimilar” to the European reference product
Clexane.
Enoxaparin is a low molecular weight heparin with a mean molecular weight of approximately 4,500
daltons (3,500-5,500). The drug substance is the sodium salt. Enoxaparin sodium belongs to
Antithrombotic Agents pharmacological class with ATC code: B01AB05 enoxaparin.
It is obtained by alkaline depolymerization of heparin benzyl ester derived from porcine intestinal
mucosa.
Enoxaparin binds to antithrombin III leading to inhibition of coagulation factors IIa and Xa.
The mechanism of action of enoxaparin is antithrombin-dependent. It acts mainly by accelerating the
rate of the neutralization of certain activated coagulation factors by antithrombin, but other
mechanisms may also be involved. Enoxaparin potentiates preferentially the inhibition of coagulation
factors Xa and IIa and only slightly affects other hemostatic mechanisms such as clotting time. The
antithrombotic effect of enoxaparin is well correlated to the inhibition of Factor Xa.
Laboratorios Farmacéuticos Rovi is applying for a marketing authorisation for Enoxaparin sodium 100
mg/mL and 150 mg/mL solution for injection.
The active substance enoxaparin sodium is not considered as a new active substance.
The application is submitted under the legal base of Similar Biological Medicinal Product referring to
Article 10.4 of Directive 2001/83/EC.
The chosen EU reference medicinal product for this application and used in the quality comparability
exercise is Clexane in all marketed strengths in solution for injection in pre-filled syringe produced in
France and sourced from the Spanish market.
For the German market reference is made to Clexane 100 mg / Injektionslösung.
The proposed biosimilar Enoxaparin Sodium solution for injection has been evaluated in a Single-
Dose, Randomized, Double-Blind, Two-Way Crossover pivotal Bioequivalence Study of Enoxaparin
(100 mg/mL) 100-mg Subcutaneous Injection Manufactured by ROVI, Spain, and Clexane (100
mg/mL) 100-mg Subcutaneous Injection manufactured by Sanofi-aventis France, Paris, France, in 46
Healthy Volunteers (Study# ROV-RO20-2015-01).
I.4 General comments on compliance with GMP, GLP, GCP and agreed ethical
principles.
GMP inspections in any of the manufacturing sites of Enoxaparin sodium drug substance and drug
product are not needed as valid GMP certificates have been submitted. Universidad Complutense is
confirmed as a registered subcontractor of Laboratorios Farmacéuticos Rovi, Granada.
GLP: All submitted non-clinical studies were performed according to GLP principles with the
exception of the in-vivo pilot PK/PD study in rabbits (study S41751) and the in-vitro characterisation
of the enoxaparin-PF4 complex.
GCP: The applicant stated that the bioequivalence study was conducted in accordance with GCP and
audited SOPs of the unit and internal quality assurance staff ensured compliance with GCP. The
analytical staff (PRA Health Sciences, Zuidlaren, The Netherlands) did not have access to the
randomization code before the pharmacokinetic analysis was performed. The study was also
conducted in accordance with GLP regulations. It was a single-dose, randomized, double-blind, 2-
period, 2-sequence crossover study.
Written approval from the investigator’s institutional review board (IRB) for ethical review of the
original study protocol was provided.
Drug substance
Enoxaparin sodium is the sodium salt of a low molecular-mass heparin obtained by alkaline
depolymerisation of the benzyl ester derivative of heparin manufactured from porcine intestinal
The conversion of heparin sodium to enoxaparin sodium is divided in four major steps comprising
formation of heparin benzethonium salt, formation of heparin benzyl ester, depolymerisation and
purification of the product to give enoxaparin sodium.
Control of Materials
Materials used in the manufacturing process are properly controlled
Characterisation
The provided characterisation data include physico-chemical properties of Rovi’s enoxaparin such as
molecular weight distribution, UV- and IR spectrum, sodium content, molecular ratio of sulfate to
carboxylate ions and NMR fingerprints.
Specification
The proposed DS specification combines tests required in the Ph. Eur. monographs “Enoxaparin” and
“Low molecular mass heparins” and tests, which are performed in accordance to in-house procedures.
The proposed DS specification complies largely with the requirements of the Ph. Eur. monographs.
The provided DS specification includes tests for appearance and solubility as well as identification by
13
C NMR, presence of 1,6-anhydro structure and sodium, anti FXa/ anti FIIa ratio and mass % of
chains of different ranges. Tests on solution appearance, pH, specific absorbance, content of benzyl
alcohol, sodium, nitrogen and heavy metals as well as on molar ratio of sulfate ions/ carboxylate ions,
loss on drying and bacterial endotoxins are also included. In addition, assay by determination of anti-
FXa and anti FIIa activity, Test on residual solvents and on microbial contamination are implemented
into the proposed DS specification.
Analytical methods are acceptable and sufficient detail has been provided.
Analytical data for exemplary commercial batches have been provided to demonstrate compliance
with the DS specification.
Drug Product
Enoxaparin sodium drug product is formulated with water for injection only, without addition of any
excipients. The composition is identical with the reference product Clexane. The critical quality
attributes of Enoxaparin sodium Rovi drug product were evaluated to meet the relevant general
requirements of Ph. Eur. and the acceptance criteria described in the monograph ‘Enoxaparin sodium
for injection’ of the British Pharmacopoeia (BP).
For commercial drug product production, lyophilised Enoxaparin sodium is solved in water. After
sterile filtration, the bulk product solution is filled into the sterilized syringes and stoppered. The
specified ranges of the operational parameters implemented for the commercial production process are
supported by appropriate process development data. Process validation was adequately performed and
confirms that the commercial process is capable to consistently produce Enoxaparin Rovi drug
product.
The DP specification proposed is based on the BP monograph Enoxaparin Sodium Injection. The list
of test parameters to be controlled at release and during stability studies is considered adequate. As
regards justification of suitability of the drug product specification acceptance criteria derived from
the pharmacopoeias reference is made to the drug substance specification.
The final product is labelled by amount as well as by anti-factor Xa activity. The activity labelled is
verified at DP release for each batch. Batch analysis has been performed on a sufficient number of
batches of commercial size produced by utilizing different DS batches. A list of all DP batches
produced so far (including those introduced in the new biosimilarity studies) with details on their
production (date, scale, DS batch used for manufacture) and their purpose of use has been presented.
DP release data of the pilot scale batches and the newly produced batches for the new comparative
studies have been provided.
Packaging materials are described. For primary packaging materials, coming into contact with finished
product solution, compliance with the respective Ph. Eur. requirements is confirmed.
Potential extractables and leachables of the primary packaging material were thoroughly investigated
and found to be acceptable.
ICH conforming stability studies as well as adequate stress studies have been performed. The number
of batches included in the studies is sufficient and cover all strengths. The updated DP stability data
presented supports the claimed shelf life of 36 months. No significant quality changes could be
observed at the recommended storage temperature. The storage instructions indicated in the SPC are
justified and are in compliance with the relevant Guideline.
Adventitious Agents
Porcine mucosa is the starting material for manufacture of enoxaparin and can potentially contain
contaminating ruminant material.
Biosimilarity
Similarity of quality profiles between the test product and the reference product Clexane authorized in
the EEA can now be derived more reliably based on a significantly larger database with respect to
Conclusion on Quality
Pharmacology
The idea of biosimilarity is that due to the complexity of the active substance full prediction of the
biological effects may not be possible with pharmaceutical methods only. Hence, characterisation of
the primary action of the active substance in the organism is sought. The most important primary
action of enoxaparin is inhibition of the circulating activated coagulation factors (serine proteases)
FXa and FIIa.
The assay used by the Applicant for determining inhibition of these factors is appropriate, and several
enoxaparin doses have been tested, allowing construction of a reliable concentration-response
relationship curve. The shape of this curve provides much more information than only one value such
as EC50 or maximal inhibition. It is difficult to describe the whole concentration-response relationship
with statistical methods. Therefore, the non-clinical biosimilarity exercise mainly relies on visual
inspection of the results after suitable graphical representation. This revealed that Enoxaparin Rovi
and Clexane can be considered similar.
The Applicant also submitted a new bioequivalence study in rabbits to support the biosimilarity of
Enoxaparin Rovi and the reference product Clexane.
A dose of 517 aFXa IU/kg SC of test and reference product was injected in 12 male rabbits each in a
cross-over design; i.e. all 24 animals received each treatment, test and reference, with a wash-out
period of 7 days in-between. Blood was drawn at different time points up to 24 hours. Product
concentration in plasma was calculated by evaluating the capacity of Factor Xa and FIIa inhibition.
Moreover, APTT (Activated Partial Thromboplastin Time) were determined from the plasma
obtained. Pharmacokinetic parameters were calculated for the anti-Factor Xa and anti-Factor IIa
activities using WinNonlin® Professional Version 6.3 software (Pharsight Corporation).
The plasma anti FXa- and anti-FIIa-activity over time is shown graphically below.
but the magnitude of the response is rather low and obviously close to the limit of quantification. In-
vitro measurements are preferred for demonstrating biosimilarity because of higher accuracy (less
fluctuation) of the data. Thus, these in-vivo findings are considered supportive.
Pharmacokinetics
PK analysis is not required for a biosimilar application. Furthermore, enoxaparin levels in plasma are
normally not measured directly but PD measurements are used to estimate and compare enoxaparin
plasma levels. An in-vivo PD study was performed in rabbits.
Toxicology
No general toxicity studies are required for biosimilar products unless there is specific concern, what
is not the case here. Hence, the Applicant has not performed toxicology studies what is endorsed.
Immunogenicity
A special aspect of biosimilar products is their immunogenicity which should not be larger than with
the comparator. In case of heparins, the most important consequence of immunogenicity is
development of HIT (heparin-induced thrombocytopenia). The molecular basis of this condition is the
formation of antibodies against a complex of the heparin with endogenous PF4 (platelet factor 4). The
antibodies, together with the heparin-PF4 complex, are able to activate and thereby consume
thrombocytes.
Hence, the Applicant characterised the enoxaparin-PF4 complex with several independent analytical
methods in direct comparison of Enoxaparin Rovi and the reference product Clexane.
No relevant differences between Enoxaparin Rovi and Clexane became obvious in all these
approaches.
Since Enoxaparin Rovi is intended for biosimilar substitution, this will not lead to an increased
exposure to the environment. An environmental risk assessment is therefore not deemed necessary.
Pharmacokinetics
Conventional PK studies cannot be performed for Low molecular weight heparins (LMWHs) due to
the heterogeneity in their physico-chemical characteristics.
Therefore, a medicinal product containing LMWH as active ingredient and claiming to be biosimilar
to a reference product needs to prove bioequivalence to the reference product on the basis of its PD
properties, according to the guideline on non-clinical and clinical development of similar biological
medicinal products containing LMWHs (EMEA / CHMP / BMWP / 118264 / 2007 Rev. 1, 17 January
2013), under the Directive 2001/83/EC Art 10(4).
Pharmacodynamics
Pivotal study (ROV-RO20-2015-01)
Population(s) studied
A total of 33 male and 13 female subjects between 18 and 44 years of age and with a BMI
between 19.0 and 31.1 kg/m2 participated in the study.
AUEC0-T A 8.05
A/B 103.8 99.8 - 108.0 9.1
(h*IU/mL) B 7.75
AUEC0-inf A 8.91
A/B 104.2 100.0 - 108.6 8.8
(h*IU/mL) B 8.55
AUEC0-T A 1.08
A/B 103.5 90.9 - 117.9 30.5
(h*IU/mL) B 1.04
A 7.46
RAUEC* A/B 100.3 87.9 - 114.5 31.1
B 7.44
CI=confidence interval; CV=coefficient of variation; LS=least squares
Treatment A: Enoxaparin (100 mg/mL) 100-mg SC injection, manufactured by Rovi (Spain)
Treatment B: Clexane® (100 mg/mL) 100-mg SC injection, manufactured by Sanofi (EU)
* RAUEC is the ratio of AUEC0-T of anti-FXa activity to anti-FIIa activity
Note: A linear mixed effects model was applied to the natural log-transformed PD parameters with sequence,
period and treatment as fixed effects and subject nested within sequence as a random effect
Blood samples for determination of anti-Xa, anti-IIa and baseline-adjusted tissue factor pathway
inhibitor (TFPI) activity were collected before dosing and up to 36 hours after dosing. The treatment
periods were separated by a washout period of 7 days, which is considered adequate.
Plasma samples were analysed for factors anti-Xa and anti-IIa using chromogenic methodologies
developed at the Harlan Laboratories S.A. facility in Barcelona, Spain. Plasma samples were analysed
for TFPI at the Harlan Laboratories S.A. facility in Barcelona, Spain using a commercially available
kit. The analytical methods are acceptable, properly validated (pre-study and within study) and the
handling of samples was adequate.
The PD parameters AUEC0-inf, AUEC0-T, and peak effect for anti-Xa, anti-IIa, and baseline-adjusted
tissue factor pathway inhibitor (TFPI) activity (anti-Xamax, anti-IIamax, and TFPImax) from the test
treatment were compared with those from the reference treatment. The pharmacodynamic variables are
in agreement with the CHMP scientific advice and considered adequate.
The geometric mean ratio and 90% CI (and 95% CI in post hoc analysis in response to the CHMP
scientific advice) were calculated. Bioequivalence was concluded if the 95% CI of the ratio of the
geometric least squares (LS) means between the test treatment and the reference treatment for AUEC0-
inf, AUEC0-T, and anti-Xamax of anti-Xa activity were completely within the standard 80% to 125% BE
interval and AUEC0-T and anti-IIamax of anti-IIa activity were completely within the standard 80% to
125% BE interval. The statistical methods are acceptable and described adequately.
AUEC0-T A 41 13.852
A/B 103.3 99.9– 106.7
(h•aXaU/mL) B 40 13.415
Anti-Xamax A 41 1.173
(aXaU/mL) A/B 101.1 96.1 – 106.4
B 40 1.160
Abbreviations: CI, confidence interval; LS, least squares.
Note: A linear mixed effects model was applied to the natural log-transformed pharmacodynamic
parameters with sequence, period, and treatment as fixed effects and subject nested within sequence as
a random effect.
a
Treatment A = Enoxaparin (100 mg/mL) 100-mg subcutaneous injection manufactured by Rovi,
Spain.
Treatment B = Lovenox (100 mg/mL) 100-mg subcutaneous injection manufactured by Sanofi-
Aventis, USA.
For anti-Xa, 40 or 41 subjects were included in the PD analyses. Two subjects were excluded from
the analyses (for all 3 PD parameters: AUEC0-inf, AUEC0-T, and anti-Xamax) for both enoxaparin
manufactured by Rovi and Lovenox because the anti-Xa baseline value was higher than the lower
limit of quantification (LLOQ) for anti-Xa. Another subject was excluded from AUEC0-inf for
enoxaparin manufactured by Rovi because the extrapolated AUEC was greater than 20%.
For anti-IIa, 38 or 39 subjects were included in the PD analyses. AUEC0-inf was not included in the
analysis because of the small sample size. Two subjects were excluded from the analyses for both
enoxaparin manufactured by Rovi and Lovenox because of unexpectedly low plasma levels of anti-IIa
(most of the plasma anti-IIa levels were below the LLOQ). Another subject was excluded from the PD
parameters (AUEC0-T and anti-IIamax) for Lovenox and one subject for both enoxaparin manufactured
by Rovi and Lovenox because the baseline values were equal to or higher than the LLOQ.
Two subjects were excluded from analyses due to baseline value > LLOQ.
All 42 subjects were included in the PD analysis for TFPI. AUEC0-inf was not estimated for 13 subjects
who received enoxaparin manufactured by Rovi and 12 subjects who received Lovenox because no
clear terminal elimination phase could be identified for these profiles.
Pharmacodynamic conclusion
In study ROV-RO20-2015-01 bioequivalence between Enoxaparin Rovi and the EU reference product
Clexane manufactured by Sanofi has been shown appropriately. The study design is considered
acceptable.
The results from study ROV-RO20-2015-01 support bioequivalence. The large differences in the
absolute values observed are considered to be derived from the inter-subject variability.
It is agreed that separate clinical investigations using both concentrations (100 mg/ml or a 150 mg/ml)
are not necessary, as the only difference is the amount of API and no clinical impact is expected in
case the same dose is applied.
No additional data are required for approval of the intravenous administration route since
subcutaneous PD data are more sensitive to demonstrate PD equivalence. If PD biosimilarity is
concluded via the subcutaneous route, which is subject to a more complex pharmacokinetics than the
direct intravenous administration, a relevant difference via direct administration is not expected.
Clinical efficacy
The Guideline on non-clinical and clinical development of similar biological medicinal products
containing low-molecular-weight-heparins (EMEA/CHMP/BMWP/118264/2007 + Draft Rev. 1)
foresees a clinical trial comparing efficacy and safety of the biosimilar candidate and the reference
product unless convincing evidence for similar efficacy and safety of the biosimilar and the reference
product can be convincingly deduced from the comparison of their physicochemical characteristics,
biological activity/potency, using sensitive, orthogonal and state-of-the-art analytical methods, and
from comparison of their PD profiles.
The applicant did not perform an efficacy/safety study. However, based on the analytical, functional
and preclinical data provided, it is concluded that an efficacy/safety trial can be waived. A clinical
Clinical safety
There were no unexpected safety findings in the 98 healthy adult subjects participating in the single-
dose crossover biopharmaceutic studies. No serious AEs were reported.
Enoxaparin has a well-established safety and tolerability profile, as described in published literature.
The data do not indicate a higher frequency or more severe AEs with enoxaparin Rovi compared to the
EU or US reference product from Sanofi.
The Applicant did not submit safety data from a clinical trial in patients. However, based on the
analytical, functional and preclinical data provided, it is concluded that an efficacy/safety trial can be
waived. A clinical efficacy/safety trial is not considered to be the appropriate measure to generate the
missing information.
The Applicant/Proposed Future MAH has submitted a signed Summary of the Applicant's/Proposed
Future MAH's Pharmacovigilance System. Provided that the Pharmacovigilance System Master File
fully complies with the new legal requirements as set out in the Commission Implementing Regulation
and as detailed in the GVP module, the RMS considers the Summary acceptable.
The applicant has submitted this Risk Management Plan in accordance with the requirements of
Directive 2001/83/EC as amended, describing the pharmacovigilance activities and interventions
designed to identify, characterise, prevent or minimise risks relating to Enoxaparin solution for
injection.
Safety specification
Important identified risks • Bleeding
• Immune-mediated thrombocytopenia
• Allergic reactions including anaphylactoid and anaphylactic
reactions
• Liver injury
• Hyperkalaemia
Important potential risks • Valve thrombosis in patients with prosthetic heart valves
• Osteoporosis
Missing information • Use during pregnancy and lactation
• Use in paediatric patients
• Use in patients with hepatic impairment
• Use in in obese patients (BMI>30 kg/m2)
• Porcine DNA in crude heparin
If the dates for submission of a PSUR and the update of a RMP coincide, they can be submitted at the
same time, but via different procedures.
• PSURs shall be submitted in accordance with the requirements set out in the list of Union
reference dates (EURD list) provided for under Article 107c(7) of Directive 2001/83/EC and
published on the European medicines web-portal. Marketing authorisation holders shall
continuously check the European medicines web-portal for the DLP and frequency of
submission of the next PSUR.
• For medicinal products authorized under the legal basis of Article 10(1) or Article 10a of
Directive 2001/83/EC, no routine PSURs need to be submitted, unless otherwise specified in
the EURD list.
Legal status
Medicinal product subject to medicinal prescription
Biosimilarity was confirmed at non-clinical level by carefully studying the interaction of Enoxaparin
Rovi and its comparator Clexane with the primary pharmacological targets, FXa and FIIa.
Furthermore, immunogenicity was adequately addressed by extensively characterising the enoxaparin-
PF4 complex, being the most important antigen, for the Rovi product vs. Clexane. Sufficient
sensitivity of the assays used was demonstrated.
At a clinical level, biosimilarity was established at the PD level as desired by measuring anti-Xa, anti-
IIa and tissue factor pathway inhibitor (TFPI) activity in direct comparison of Enoxaparin Rovi and
the reference product Clexane; conventional PK studies are not possible due to the heterogeneous
nature of enoxaparin. The applicant has conducted a single-dose, randomized, double-blind, two-way
crossover study of Enoxaparin Rovi (100 mg/ml) and Clexane from EU (100 mg/ml) as100-mg
subcutaneous injection in healthy volunteers (Study ROV-RO20-2015-01). The study design is
considered acceptable. The safety evaluation did not reveal any unexpected findings. It is not
necessary to investigate both concentrations (100 mg/ml or a 150 mg/ml) as the only difference is the
amount of API and no clinical impact is expected in case the same dose is applied. The data provided
with SC administration also support IV dosing since subcutaneous PD data are considered more
sensitive.
The application is approved. For intermediate amendments see current product information.