TEMPLATE VIDEO CRITIQUE

Title of movie The Proposal (2009)

Synopsis of movie This romantic comedy revolves around an unlikely relationship between
Andrew (a personal assistant) and his bossy superior, Margaret. Facing
deportation, Margaret plans a scheme to marry Andrew who agrees to do so
only if she promotes him...

Critical Incident 1

Synopsis of Incident 1
Description of Critical Incident
Analysis of incident
Application of theory
Effect
Recommendation(s)
The scene chosen depicts a situation in which Margaret (played
by Sandra Bullock) was summoned by her bosses who break the
news of her deportation
Work Ethic
When the boss says, “Isn’t he your secretary?”, Margaret responds
with, “It wouldn’t be the first time one of us fell for our secretaries,
would it Edmund?”.
Margaret reveals very poor work ethic and unprofessional behaviour in
the workplace
Based on communication theories, it is inappropriate to make personal
attack during a formal discussion
Margaret’s comment will cause embarrassment for Edmund; thus,
affecting her relationship with him. Her comment also reflects lack of
respect for her superior.
Discussion should always focus on the issue at hand and reflect
professionalism