Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ABSTRACT
can take regular food allowed to them dur- at higher risk of coronary heart disease as
ing the other months of the year. There is a part of other interventions like exercise,
no restriction on any special diet or food smoking cessation, cessation of excessive
items during the Ramadan fast. According alcohol, and weight control. Diet therapy
to Islamic law, children aged below 12, has shown modest reductions in lipid
sick patients, travelers and menstruating levels in the population, (Henkin, Shai &
or nursing women are exempted from fast- Zuk, 2000; Alfred, 2003). A survey found
ing. Ramadan fasting differs from total that as many as 50% of patients with
fasting, as re-feeding is permitted twice in elevated cholesterol levels would prefer
24 hours. over-the-counter products like garlic,
Ramadan Islamic fasting is an excel- yeast or soya products (Caron & White,
lent model of how dietary modifications 2001; Anderson, Johnstone & Cook-
may affect the lipid profile. There have Newell, 1995; Silagy & Neil, 1994).
been only few studies on the effect of The aim of this study is to evaluate
Ramadan fasting on health, especially in and to compare the effects of Ramadan
Kuwait. Akanji, Mojiminiyi & Abdella fasting on blood pressure, waist circumfer-
(2000) demonstrated beneficial changes in ence, lipid profiles and blood sugar on
serum apo A-1 and its ratio to apo B and healthy randomly-selected males and
HDL in stable hyperlipidaemic subjects females.
after Ramadan fasting in Kuwait.
Mohammad et al (2003) observed no
significant differences in acute myocardial METHODS
infarction admissions during Ramadan
months compared to one month prior to it Sixty healthy adult volunteers were
in 5 consecutive years recruited, comprising 41 males between 24
Hyperlipidaemia is one of the estab- and 56 years (mean age 37±8.6 years) and
lished major risk factors of coronary heart 19 females between 23 and 33 years (mean
disease & cerebrovascular disease. As age 27.7±3.4 years). The subjects consisted
early as in 1996, statins were hailed as of a group of healthy people from the
“miracle drugs” and their underuse duly community who responded to our adver-
noted (Roberts, 1996). According to crite- tisements of the study at mosques and
ria based on the current guidelines of the hospitals. The study was carried out in the
NCEP- ATP III, of the 36 million people month of October-November, 2003. The
who should be taking statins in the United average duration of the fast was about 12
States only 11 million are on them (Ford et hours a day. Volunteers were allowed to
al., 2003). Across the world, of 200 million eat what ever they liked from Iftar to (sun-
people who meet criteria for treatment, set to dawn)
only 25 million take treatment with statins Blood samples were collected by
due to excessive cost. The statin drugs finger-prick from the left index finger.
account for the largest prescription drug Approximately 35-60 microliters of whole
expenditure in the United States at $12.5 blood was drawn from each volunteer,
billion per year (Wilde & Landers, 2003). after about 12 hours of fasting, in the 1st
However there is an equally important, and 4th week of Ramadan, into a
yet grossly underutilised means of treat- Cholestech capillary tube. The total choles-
ment of hyperlipidaemia. terol, LDL cholesterol, HDL cholesterol,
Diet modification is the cornerstone VLDL cholesterol, serum triglycerides and
of therapy for mild to moderate hyperlipi- blood glucose were analysed by enzymat-
daemia and is also recommended along ic method using L.D.X. analyser
with pharmacological treatment in people (Cholestech Corporation, USA). The total
Effect of Ramadan fasting on various parameters 145
error estimate for lipid levels by L.D.X cantly (p<0.001). A reduction in the aver-
analyser meets the CDC guidelines and age values of total cholesterol, serum
has documented agreement with the CDC triglycerides, LDL cholesterol, VLDL cho-
reference method (Bachorik & Ross, 1995). lesterol, mean blood pressure and blood
The right arm was used to measure blood glucose was observed at the end of the fast
pressure twice, 5 minutes apart by the but the differences were not statistically
same observer and the average value cal- significant. There was a non-significant
culated. The mean arterial blood pressure increase in HDL cholesterol at the end of
was determined using the formula: mean the fast (p<0.52). In the study population
arterial blood pressure = diastolic blood in general, there was a significant reduc-
pressure + 1/3 (systolic blood pressure - tion in the Atherogenic Index - (AI)
diastolic blood pressure). The waist cir- (p<0.01) Table 3.
cumference was measured at the narrow-
est point between the highest point of Iliac
crest and the lower costal margin by the DISCUSSION
same observer (Ford, Giles & Dietz, 2002).
The Atherogenic Index was calculated by In males and females, waist circum-
the formula AI = (Total cholesterol - HDL ference, as a reflection of abdominal
cholesterol) / HDL cholesterol) (Tatsu- adiposity, was decreased significantly.
kawa et al., 2000). These results are in line with the reports of
The statistical analysis was per- Azizi (1978), Takruri (1989) and Poh et al.
formed using SPSS (11) software standard (1996), who observed a significant
version. Quantitative data were reported decrease in body weight during Ramadan
as mean ± standard deviation and com- fasting. The decrease in body weight was
pared using the paired two-tailed stu- attributed to efficient utilisation of body
dent's T test. A probability level of<0.05 fat during fasting (ElAti, Beji & Danguir,
was considered statistically significant. 1995). It has also been reported that over-
weight persons lose more weight than nor-
mal or under-weight subjects during
RESULTS Ramadan fasting, (Takruri, 1989). Obesity
has been recognised as a serious risk factor
The subjects comprised 60 healthy for mortality and morbidity of cardiovas-
volunteers, 41 males (68.3%) and 19 cular diseases in general population
females (31.7%). The mean age was 37±8.6 (Huebert et al., 1983). Kissebah &
years (males) and 27.7±3.4 years (females). Krakower (1994) and Wajchenberg (2000)
In the male group (Table 1), the waist cir- have demonstrated that cardiovascular
cumference, total cholesterol and LDL disease-related morbidity and mortality
cholesterol were significantly reduced at might be affected not only by the total
the end of fasting (p<0.0001, P<0.05, amount of fat but also by the regional dis-
p<0.01respectively). There was a non-sig- tribution of body fat. Subsequent epidemi-
nificant rise in the HDL cholesterol, serum ological reports have established that
triglycerides and VLDL cholesterol values abdominal fat accumulation increases the
at the end of the fast (p<0.52, p<0.89, incidence of cardiovascular disease and
p<0.7) respectively. Mean blood pressure death (Daniel et al., 2003). Hence the
and blood glucose levels were not affected reduction in waist circumference observed
significantly. in this study after 3 weeks of fasting may
In the female group (Table 2), the translate into a significant health benefit
waist circumference was reduced signifi- for those who fast.
146 Salhamoud AS et al.
The effect of Ramadan fasting on erides and total cholesterol, LDL choles-
lipid profile in this study was more pro- terol and VLDL cholesterol with fasting.
nounced in the male subjects compared to Hallak & Nomani (1988) found a decrease
the female. This difference in benefit could in LDL cholesterol, an increase in HDL
probably be explained by a significantly cholesterol, but no change in the total
higher pre-fasting or basal level of total cholesterol with fasting. Nagra & Rahman
cholesterol in the male group 4.91 ± 0.96 (1998) reported a significant decrease in
compared to the total cholesterol 4.17 total cholesterol and LDL cholesterol, but
± 0.72 in the female group (p < 0.005). A there were non-significant increases in
significantly higher pre-fasting LDL cho- HDL cholesterol, serum triglycerides and
lesterol value 3.40 ±0.82 was also observed VLDL cholesterol in a study conducted on
in the male group compared to the LDL 26 healthy females. The variations in the
cholesterol 2.40 ± 0.72 in the female group results from different studies could be
(p < 0.001). This is in line with a study con- explained by the fact that Ramadan fasting
ducted on 96 hyperlipidaemic subjects follows the lunar cycle rather than the
who received physician or dietitian coun- solar cycle. Hence the duration of fasting,
seling for lifestyle modification which which is limited during daylight hours,
concluded that the magnitude of the effect varies from country to country and from
of diet control on the levels of cholesterol year to year depending on whether
& LDLc are proportionate to the baseline Ramadan falls during long hot summer
cholesterol & LDLc levels (Henkin & Shai, days or short cold winter days. Also the
2003). Hence the significantly lower base- diverse social and economic differences
line lipid values in the younger female between different ethnic groups may have
population might have limited the magni- influenced dietary patterns. These factors
tude of the beneficial effect of fasting in might have significant effects on the meas-
that group. ured variables in different studies that
Studies reported in literature on the were carried out in previous years.
effect of Ramadan fasting on various Standardisation of research method-
blood components have been conflicting ology regarding the time of the year and
and inconsistent. Adlouni & Ghalim (1997) season when the data were collected and
reported a significant decrease in total correction for the ethnicity of the subject
cholesterol, serum triglycerides, LDL cho- populations may make study results more
lesterol and HDL cholesterol with fasting amenable to comparison.
that persisted even up to one month after In this study population in general,
Ramadan. Maislos et al. (1993) observed a there was a significant reduction in the
rise in HDL-cholesterol, a reduction in the Atherogenic Index. Reductions in
total cholesterol/HDL cholesterol ratio Atherogenic Index (decreased total choles-
and in the LDL chol/HDL chol ratio, and terol and increased HDL cholesterol) were
no significant difference in serum triglyc- associated with decreased morbidity and
148 Salhamoud AS et al.
Daniel D, Patrick C, Pierre D & André T Hallak MH & Nomani MZA (1988). Body-
(2003). Subdivision of the weight loss and changes in blood
Subcutaneous Adipose Tissue lipid levels in normal men on
Compartment and Lipid-Lipoprotein hypocaloric diets during Ramadan
Levels in Women. Obesity Research fasting. Am J Clin Nutr 48:1197-1210.
11:469-476.
Henkin Y, Shai I & Zuk R (2000). Dietary
Daradkheh JK (1992). Parasuicide during treatment of hyperlipidemia: Do
Ramadan in Jordan. Acta Psychiatrica dietitians do it better ? A random-
Scandinavica 86: 253-254. ized, controlled trial. Am J Med
109:549-555.
ElAti J, Beji C & Danguir J (1995). Increase
fat oxidation during Ramadan in Henkin Y & Shai I (2003). Dietary
healthy woman and adaptive mecha- Treatment of Hypercholestrolemia:
nism for body weight maintenance. Can We Predict Long-Term Success?
Am J Clin Nutr 62: 302-307. J Amer Coll Nutr 22(6): 555-561.
Ford ES, Giles WH & Dietz WH (2002). Huebert HB, Feinleib M, McNamara PM &
Prevalence of the metabolic syn- Castelli WP (1983). Obesity as an
drome among US adults: Findings independent risk factor for cardio-
From the Third National Health and vascular disease: a 26-year follow up
Nutrition Examination Survey. of participants in the Framingham
JAMA 287 (3):356-359. Heart Study. Circulation 67: 968-977.
Ford ES, Mokdad AH & Giles WH & Kissebah AH & Krakower GR (1994).
Mensah GA (2003). Serum total cho- Regional adiposity and morbidity.
lesterol concentrations and aware- Physiol Rev 74:761-811.
ness, treatment, and control of
hypercholesterolemia among US Mohammad Z, Cheriyil G, Wafa R,
adults: findings from the National Lukman T (2003). Incidence of acute
Health and Nutrition Examination myocardial infarction during the
Survey, 1999 to 2000. Circulation month of Ramadan and Eid Days.
107:2185-2189. Paper presented at the Second Gulf
Cooperation Council (GCC) Cardio-
Goldberg RB, Mellies MJ & Sacks FM vascular Conference for the Gulf
(1998). Cardiovascular events and Heart Association (GHA). Official J
their reduction in diabetic and glu- Gulf Heart Assoc Vol 4 NO 4. Abstract
cose-intolerant myocardial infarction in:http://www.hmc.org.qa/hmc/
survivors with average cholesterol heartviews/H-V-v4N4/7.htm.
levels: sub group analyses in the cho- Viewed on 14 Dec 2005.
lesterol and recurrent events (CARE)
trial. Circulation 98:2513-2519. Maislos M, Khamaysi N, Assali A, Abou-
Rabiah Y, Zvili I & Shany (1993).
Habbal R, Azzouzi L, Adnan K, Tahiri A & Marked increase in plasma high-den-
Chraibi N (1998). Variations of blood sity lipoprotein cholesterol after pro-
pressure during the month of longed fasting during Ramadan. Am
Ramadan. Arch Mal Coeur Vaiss 91(8): J Clin Nutr 57:640-642.
995-998.
150 Salhamoud AS et al.