Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Artigo Direito e Moral PDF
Artigo Direito e Moral PDF
)))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))
"#*,.'/
& @.-3-,A- A.8B8;C+ <038 /039+..-. 8 .-3@-0A+ /+ *0.-0A+ - /8 =+.8;D B2398,/+ A.8E8.D @+.
>-0+ /- 8,F;03- 9+,9-0A28; - /+2A.0,F.08 G 9+> /-3A8H2- I3 A-+.083 8@.-3-,A8/83 @+. J-B-.A
J8.A - "+,8;/ *K+.L0, GD +3 83@-9A+3 - 83 98.89A-.M3A0983 H2- +3 8@.+N0>8> - +3
/03A8,908>D 9+,A.8@+,/+O+3 - .-<-;8,/+D 8+ P0,8;D 8 0>@+.AQ,908 /- 8>B+3 @8.8 8
9+,P+.>8ER+ /8 90S,908 T2.M/098 C+/0-.,8U
!5*)"!3)/
#C- @.-3-,A K+.L 80>3 A+ 8.12- 8B+2A (8K 8,/ =+.8;D 0, +./-. A+ /-39.0B-D BX 9+,9-@A28;
8,/ /+9A.0,80.- 8,8;X303 G K0AC ->@C8303 +, AC- AC-+.0-3 @.-3-,A-/ BX J-B-.A J8.A 8,/
"+,8;/ *K+.L0, OD AC- 83@-9A3 8,/ @8.A092;8.3 AC8A 8@@.+89C 8,/ /0<-.1- AC->D @2AA0,1
AC-> 0, +@@+30A0+, 8,/ .-8<-8;0,1D 0, AC- -,/D AC- 301,0P098,9- +P B+AC A+ P.8>- >+/-.,
T2.0/09 390-,9-U
$'#"&*YZ[&
6
a89C8.-; -> *0.-0A+ - b3@-908;03A8 -> *0.-0A+ c.+9-3328; d0<0; @-;8 Y,0<-.30/8/- :-/-.8; /- YB-.;Q,/08
_Y:Y`U (09-,908/+ -> (-A.83 @-;8 Y,0<-.30/8/- :-/-.8; /- YB-.;Q,/08 _Y:Y`U c.+P-33+. /8 :892;/8/- /-
d0S,9083 J2>8,83 - e+90803 O :2,/8ER+ d8.>-;0A8,8 =F.0+ c8;>f.0+ _:Yd!=c` - !33-33+. g2.M/09+ ,+
#.0B2,8; /- g23A0E8 /- =0,83 %-.803 _#g=%`U
3
%.8/28,/+ -> *0.-0A+ @-;8 Y,0<-.30/8/- :-/-.8; /- YB-.;Q,/08 - B+;303A8 /- 0,0908ER+ 90-,AMP098
c$a$dh:!cb=$%D 3+B +.0-,A8ER+ /+ c.+P-33+. *+2A+. d8.;+3 g+3f d+./-0.+U
6 '&Z[& *b =&"!(
? '&Z[& *b *$"b$#&
8
g!d4YbeD c82;0,+U d2.3+ /- $,A.+/2ER+ 8+ b3A2/+ /+ *0.-0A+U pq b/0ER+ 8A28;058/8 - @.-P8908/8 @+.
!183305 :0;C+U "0+ /- g8,-0.+V b/0A+.8 :+.-,3-D ?rrsD @U6sU
2
'!*b"D c82;+U $,A.+/2ER+ 8+ -3A2/+ /+ /0.-0A+U $,V $,3A.2>-,A+3 /- 9+,A.+;- 3+908;U 6?t -/U "0+ /- g8,-0.+V
b/0A+.8 :+.-,3-D 6sspD @U n6U
p
*03@+,M<-; -> u CAA@VhhKKKU390-;+UB.h@/PhA.8,3h<mv,3@-hrwU@/Px
!"#$%&'( #" )*+",-. /012. &034. -0 151673416 8
4Yb$"&iD *U "UW =!=b*bD 7U :U !U
& *0.-0A+ fD @+. 9+,3-120,A-D 2> P8A+ +2 P-,j>-,+ 3+908;W ,R+ -N03A-
3-,R+ ,8 3+90-/8/- - ,R+ @+/- 3-. 9+,9-B0/+ P+.8 /-;8Uv
& 9.0Af.0+ L8,A08,+ /- /0.-0A+ 0>@;098 2> 9.0Af.0+ @-;+ H28; A+/83 83 ;-03
@+30A0<83 3R+ T2;18/83 8 .-3@-0A+ /- 328 ;-10A0>0/8/-U eR+ .890+,803 +2
0,A-0.8>-,A- ;-1MA0>83 8@-,83 8H2-;83 @.-39.0Ek-3 T2.M/0983 H2- 18.8,A->D
9+,P+.>- ;-03 -3A.0A8>-,A- 2,0<-.3803D 8 9+>@8A0B0;0/8/- /8 ;0B-./8/- /-
2> 9+> 8 ;0B-./8/- /- A+/+3 +3 +2A.+3U{
9
"b!(bD =012-;U (0Ek-3 c.-;0>0,8.-3 /- /0.-0A+U $,V *0.-0A+ - =+.8;U ??t -/U eR+ c82;+V e8.80<8D 6sspD @U
pnU
:
g!d4YbeD c82;0,+U d2.3+ /- $,A.+/2ER+ 8+ b3A2/+ /+ *0.-0A+U pq b/0ER+ 8A28;058/8 - @.-P8908/8 @+.
!183305 :0;C+U "0+ /- g8,-0.+V b/0A+.8 :+.-,3-D ?rrsD @U ?rU
;
J|::bD &U $>>8,2-; z8,AU #.8/2ER+ /- dC.03A08, 70LA+. J8>> - 78;f.0+ "+/C-,U eR+ c82;+V =8.A0,3
:+,A-3D ?rrpU
2 !"#$%&'( #" )*+",-. /012. &034. -0 151673416
! .-;8ER+ -,A.- +3 0,3A0A2A+3 /+ /0.-0A+ - /8 >+.8;
& T205 9+>@8.-9-D -,AR+D @8.8 A-,A8. .-3A8B-;-9-. 8 0128;/8/-D @+. >-0+ /8
@-,8;0/8/-D .-A0.8,/+ /+ 0,P.8A+. + }18,C+}D /-@+03 /- 8@2.8/8 8 }@-./8}
/8 <MA0>8D - @.+92.8,/+ 2> >-0+OA-.>+ -,A.- 8 @-./8 - + 18,C+ O H2- f +
0128;D + T23A+ _UUU` !3 @-33+83 H28,/+ B2398> + T205 _+2 + >-/08/+.D ->
/-A-.>0,8/+3 983+3`D B2398> 8 T23A0E8D @8.8 3+;2ER+ /83 /03@2A83D -03 H2-
-;83 H2-.-> }H2- + T205 3-T8 9+>+ 3- P+33- 8 T23A0E8 <0<8}D @8.A0,/+ /+
@.-332@+3A+ /- H2- -;- f 2>8 @-33+8 }-Ho0/03A8,A-}D H2- ;C-3 /8.F + T23A+D
+ >-0+OA-.>+D .-3A8B-;-9-,/+ 8 0128;/8/-Us
s
~A098 8 '09j>89+D (0<.+ 7D 66m?8
!"#$%&'( #" )*+",-. /012. &034. -0 151673416 6
4Yb$"&iD *U "UW =!=b*bD 7U :U !U
& A->8 -> /-B8A- -N01-D 9+>+ 9+.+;F.0+ ;l109+D H2- 3- @.+9-/8D A8>Bf>D
+ ;-<8,A8>-,A+ /8 /039233R+ /8 ]#-+.08 /+ =M,0>+ ~A09+^U
"-P-.0/8 A-+.08 P+0 /-3-,<+;<0/8D 3+B.-A2/+D @-;+ T2.03A8 8;->R+ %-+.1
g-;;0,-LD H2- 323A-,A8 328 A-3- -> -3@-908; ,8 9+,9-@ER+ 3+908; /8 fA098D 3-,/+ + /0.-0A+D
@+.A8,A+D /-P0,0/+ /- 89+./+ 9+> 328 P2,ER+ /- 9+,3-.<8ER+U
c8.8 + 8;2/0/+ 82A+.D 98B-.F 8+ *0.-0A+ 8 9+,3-.<8ER+ /8 9+>2,0/8/- @+.
0,A-.>f/0+ /+ 92>@.0>-,A+ /83 ,+.>83 T2.M/0983 @.-<08>-,A- -3A8B-;-90/83U "-P-.0/+
.-3@-0A+ I3 ,+.>83 b3A8A803 @+330B0;0A8.FD 8330>D 8 @-.>8,S,908h9+,3-.<8ER+ /-
/-A-.>0,8/8 30A28ER+ C03Al.098 TF 9+,3+;0/8/8 -> 2>8 3+90-/8/-U
e+B.- + A->8D =8.08 a.+9C8/+D @.+P-33+.8 /8 Y,0<-.30/8/- :-/-.8; /-
=0,83 %-.803D 0,P+.>8 H2-V
14
a&aa$&D '+.B-.A+U #-+.08 /8 '+.>8 g2.M/098U a82.2D ecV b*$c"&D ?rrpD @U 6psO6v?U
& A->8 -> /-B8A- -N01- 8,F;03-D >-3>+ H2- 3290,A8D /83 A-+.083
8@.-3-,A8/83 @+. J-B-.A J8.A - "+,8;/ *K+.L0,D 3+B.-A2/+ ,8 B2398 0,9-338,A- /+
H2-3A0+,8>-,A+ 89-.98 /+ H2- f *0.-0A+U
J8.A f P8<+.F<-; I 3-@8.8ER+ /+3 0,3A0A2A+3 /+ *0.-0A+ - /8 =+.8;D /-
P+.>8 8 89-0A8. 8 @.-3-,E8 /- @.0,9M@0+3 0,<+98/+3 @-;+ g205 ,8 +9830R+ /8 328 /-903R+ H2-D
@+. 328 <-5D /-9+..8> /- 2>8 >+.8; 9+,<-,90+,8;D -,H28,A+ *K+.L0,D -> 9+,A.8@+30ER+
9+> 8 .-P-.0/8 0/-08D -,A-,/- H2- + *0.-0A+ /-<- 3-. 0,A-.@.-A8/+ /- P+.>8 9+,3A.2A0<8D
-,A.-;8E8,/+ 83 .-P-.0/83 @.+@+30Ek-3U
J8.A /-P-,/- 8 3-@8.8ER+ -,A.- *0.-0A+ - =+.8;D 8;-18,/+D 0,9;230<-D H2-
,+.>83 >+.8;>-,A- 0,89-0AF<-03 @+/-> 3-. *0.-0A+ - H2- ,+.>83 T2.M/0983 ,R+ /-<-> 3-.
-,A-,/0/83 9+>+ +./-,3 32@.->83U
66
*03@+,M<-; ->V uCAA@VhhKKKU/0.-0A+U2P>1UB.h.-<03A8h0,/-NU@C@h.-<03A8h8.A09;-h<0-K:0;-hwrhvvx
!"#$%&'( #" )*+",-. /012. &034. -0 151673416 :
4Yb$"&iD *U "UW =!=b*bD 7U :U !U
H2-D @+. 3-2 A2.,+D ,R+ 3- -,9+,A.-> @.-<03A+3 @+. 0,3A0A20Ek-3 3+90803 @.-<08>-,A- 89-0A83
9+>+ @.+/2A+.83 /+ *0.-0A+U
!;f> /033+D A8>Bf> -> 9+,P.+,A+ 9+> 8 A-+.08 /-3-,<+;<0/8 @+. J8.AD
*K+.L0, /-P-,/- H2- + *0.-0A+ /-<- 3-. -,A-,/0/+ -> >-0+ I T2,ER+ /- @.0,9M@0+3 - .-1.83
@.fO-3A8B-;-90/83D /- P+.>8 H2- 8>B+3 3+B.-338;A-> + >-3>+ 98>0,C+ 8 3-. 3-120/+ ->
/0.-ER+ I3 +B.018Ek-3 T2.M/0983 3+908;>-,A- P0.>8/83U
'-3A- 983+D +3 @.0,9M@0+3 .-<-;8>O3- -33-,90803D 2>8 <-5 H2- @-.>0A->
89;8.8. 8 .-8; T23A0P098A0<8 /+ *0.-0A+D @+03 ,R+ /0.-90+,8>O3- I @-.3@-9A0<8 /- ,-,C2>8
0,3A0A20ER+U
!..0>8/+ ,8 @-.3@-9A0<8 @.0,90@0+;l1098 32@.8>-,90+,8/8D *K+.L0,
8<8;08D 80,/8D ,+ Q>B0A+ /8 8@;098ER+ /+ *0.-0A+D H2- + T2;18/+. /-<-.F 9+,30/-.8. 8
0,A-1.0/8/- >+.8;D @+;MA098 - <8;+.-3 3+90803 /0P-.-,A-3 /- 98/8 >-0+D @8.8 H2- @+338
8;98,E8. 8 .-8; -P-A0<0/8/- /+ *0.-0A+U *-3A8 P-0A8D + P0;l3+P+ .-<-;8 H2- + g205D 8+ T2;18.
/-A-.>0,8/+ 983+ H2- -3A-T8 3+B 328 8,F;03-D 8+ 9+,A.F.0+ /- J8.AD @+/-.F .-<-;8. 3283
@.-P-.S,9083 /- P+.>8 >0A018/8D 0,<08B0;058,/+D 8330>D 8 3-@8.8ER+ @+30A0<03A8 /+3 0,3A0A2A+3
/+ *0.-0A+ - /8 =+.8;U
*08,A- /8 8;2/0/8 9+,9-@ER+ 8@.-3-,A8/8 @+. *K+.L0,D + *0.-0A+
9+,303A-D @+.A8,A+D -> 2> P-,j>-,+ 3+908; 9+>@;-N+ - .-P-.0/8 98.89A-.M3A098D -> 9+,T2,A+
9+> 8 328 P2,ER+ - 9+,3-H2S,9083D @8338 8 -N010. 2>8 /-;0>0A8ER+ -3@-908; /- 328
-3A.2A2.8D 8 H2- *K+.L0, <80 8A.0B20. 8+ 98.FA-. 8.12>-,A8A0<+ /+ *0.-0A+ H2-D @+. 328 <-5D
3- 8A.-;8D /0.-A8>-,A-D 8+ T2;18/+.U 6?
b338 9+>@.--,3R+ ;-<8 *K+.L0, 8 3- +@+. 8+ @+30A0<03>+D -3@-908;>-,A-
8H2-;- @.-9+,058/+ @+. J8.AD @+03D @8.8 -3A-D 9+,P+.>- -N@+3A+ 8;C2.-3D 8 ;-0 @+3320 98.FA-.
>-.8>-,A- /-39.0A0<+D 3-> H28;H2-. <8;+.8ER+ >+.8; +2 fA098U 6m
'-3A- @+,A+D ,+A8O3- 8;98,9- 0>-,32.F<-; /8 A-+.08 /- *K+.L0, H2-D @+.
328 <-5D 3- .-<-;8D ,+3 /083 8A2803D -> /0<-.383 /-903k-3 @.+P-.0/83 @-;+3 A.0B2,803
B.830;-0.+3D ,8 >-/0/8 -> H2- /-P-,/- 8 ,-9-330/8/- /- 3- 9+,9.-A058. 2>8 0,A-.@.-A8ER+
6?
*K+.L0,D "+,8;/U & 0>@f.0+ /+ /0.-0A+U eR+ c82;+V =8.A0,3 :+,A-3D ?rrmD @U 6wU
18
J!"#D J-.B-.A (U!U & 9+,9-0A+ /- /0.-0A+U pU -/U (03B+8V :2,/8ER+ d8;+23A- %2;B-,L08,D ?rrwD @U m?6U
6n
O g‰'$&"D *0.;-X /8 d2,C8U )" d+,A.+;- /- d+,3A0A290+,8;0/8/- #-+.08 - c.FA098U a8C08U g23@+/0<>D ?r66D
@U 6prO6p6U
!"#$%&'( #" )*+",-. /012. &034. -0 151673416 18
4Yb$"&iD *U "UW =!=b*bD 7U :U !U
>-/0/8 -> H2- 3-.<02 9+>+ @+,A+ /- @8.A0/8 @8.8 + /-3-,<+;<0>-,A+ /8 A-+.08 /- "+,8;/
*K+.L0, H2-D @+. 3-2 A2.,+D 3- 9+,3+;0/8D @+. 328 @.-903R+ PFA098D -> /0<-.383 /-903k-3
-N8.8/83 ,+3 #.0B2,803 -3@8;C8/+3 @-;+ >2,/+U
d&'e$*b"!ZŠbe :$'!$e
*08,A- /+ H2- P+0 8@.-3-,A8/+D A->O3- H2- 8 90S,908 T2.M/098 ,R+ /-<- 3-.
A0/8D 8@-,83D 9+>+ 2> 9+,T2,A+ /- ;-03h,+.>83 .-10>-,A8/83 +2 3+908;>-,A- -3A8B-;-90/83U
"-P-.0/8 90S,908 .-;890+,8O3- 9+> 8 @.l@.08 9+,/2A8 C2>8,8 -D 9+>+ A8;D
-,9+,A.8O3- 8A.-;8/8D /0.-A8 - 0,/0.-A8>-,A-D 8+ *0.-0A+ _9+,T2,A+ /- ,+.>83 ;-103;8A0<83
-3A8B-;-90/83 @-;+ b3A8/+` - I =+.8; _9+,T2,A+ /- .-1.83 3+90803 - 92;A2.803 @.fO
/-A-.>0,8/83` ,8 B2398 0,98,3F<-; /- 8@;098ER+ -P-A0<8 /- _8` ]T23A0E8^U
"-338;A-O3-D @+.f>D H2- T23A0E8 ,R+ /-<- 3-. A0/8 9+>+ 2> @89A+
.-8;058/+ C03A+.098>-,A- -,A.- +3 C+>-,3D >83D @+. >803 2Al@09+ H2- @8.-E8D /- 89+./+
9+> 83 0/-083 /-P-,/0/83 @+. c;8AR+ -> 328 +B.8 ]! "-@\B;098^D 9+>+ 8 8@;098ER+ /-
<8;+.-3 0,A.M,3-9+3 /- 98/8 90/8/R+U
e-,/+ 8330>D 9+,P+.>- 8@.-3-,A8/+ @+. "+,8;/ *K+.L0,D CF H2- 3-
<-.0P098. H2- *0.-0A+ - =+.8;D 3-T8 ,8 9+,3+;0/8ER+ +2 ,8 8@;098ER+D -,9+,A.8>O3-
0,A0>8>-,A- ;018/+3 - @82A8>O3- ,8 -39+..-0A8 -P-A0<8ER+ /8 @.l@.08 90S,908 T2.M/098D
,-9-330A8,/+D 8@-,83D /8 /-<0/8 @+,/-.8ER+ /- <8;+.-3D 8 P0> /- -<0A8. 8 9+,3+;0/8ER+ /-
-NA.->03>+3 9+,9-0A2803 ,8 -3A8B0;058ER+ /8 @.-3A8ER+ T2.03/090+,8;U
"b:b"‹'d$!e
a&aa$&D '+.B-.A+U )A@B;= C= (@B?= DEBFC;<=D #.8/U :-.,8,/+ c8<8, a8@A03A8 - !.08,0
a2-,+ e2/8AA0U a82.2D ecV b*$c"&D ?r66U
a"&dJ!*&D =8.08U $,V ' C;BA;:@ <@?@ ?FK;?@ L:;<@ A <@?@ !"#$!%! L:;<@M
*03@+,M<-; ->V CAA@VhhKKKU/0.-0A+U2P>1UB.h.-<03A8h0,/-NU@C@h.-<03A8h8.A09;-h<0-K:0;-hwrhvv
/- =F.90+ c21;0-30D b/3+, a0,0D d8.;+3 bU "+/.012-3D eR+ c82;+V •9+,-D 6sspU
*€&"z$'D "+,8;/U ' ;?GLB;@ C@ C;BA;:@U eR+ c82;+V =8.A0,3 :+,A-3D ?rrmU
J!"#D J-.B-.A (U!U ' <@K<A;:@ CA C;BA;:@U pU -/U (03B+8V :2,/8ER+ d8;+23A- %2;B-,L08,D
?rrwU
J|::bD &U +??=KEAO 6=K:U #.8/2ER+ /- dC.03A08, 70LA+. J8>> - 78;f.0+ "+/C-,U eR+
c82;+V =8.A0,3 :+,A-3D ?rrpU
'!*b"D c82;+M +K:B@CEQR@ =@ AH:EC@ C@ C;BA;:@U $,V $,3A.2>-,A+3 /- 9+,A.+;- 3+908;U 6?t
-/U "0+ /- g8,-0.+V b/0A+.8 :+.-,3-D 6sspU
' -#5!)# #()"# 4#"5#") $M! 4!") # "'(!$- -8'"6+(U )"V e-8.8
:0;+3lP098U'UnD7-.R+D?r66D@UnpOvnU#Q,08 e9C,-0/-. /8 :+,3-98
"b!(bD =012-;U $;QUAH 0BAO;?;K=BAH CA C;BA;:@U $,V *0.-0A+ - =+.8;U ??t -/U eR+ c82;+V
e8.80<8D 6sspU