You are on page 1of 13

Anatomia, Histologia, Embryologia

ORIGINAL ARTICLE

Fibre Dissection and Sectional Study of the Major Porcine


Cerebral White Matter Tracts
R. Pascalau1* and B. Szabo2,3
Addresses of authors: 1 Iuliu Hatieganu University of Medicine and Pharmacy, 8 Babes Street, 400012 Cluj-Napoca, Romania;
2
Department of Anatomy and Embryology, Iuliu Hatieganu University of Medicine and Pharmacy, 8 Babes Street, 400012 Cluj-Napoca,
Romania;
3
Department of Ophthalmology, Emergency County Hospital, 3-5 Clinicilor Street, 400006 Cluj-Napoca, Romania

*Correspondence: Summary
Tel.: 0040 734 415 295;
fax: 0040 264 597257; White matter anatomy is the basis for numerous applications in neurology,
e-mail: raluca.pascalau@yahoo.ro neurosurgery and fundamental neuroscience. Although the porcine brain is fre-
quently used as experimental model in these fields of research, the description
With 9 figures and 1 table of its white matter is not as thorough as in the human brain or other species.
Thus, the aim of this study is to describe the porcine white matter tracts in a
Received February 2016; accepted for
complex manner. Two stepwise dissection protocols adapted from human anat-
publication June 2017
omy were performed on six adult pig brain hemispheres prepared according to
doi: 10.1111/ahe.12280 the Klingler method. Other four hemispheres were sectioned along section
planes that were chosen similar to the Talairach coordinate system. As a result,
three commissural tracts, seven association tracts and one projection tract were
identified: corpus callosum, fornix, commissura rostralis, the short-association
tracts, fasciculus longitudinalis superior, fasciculus uncinatus, fasciculus longi-
tudinalis inferior, fasciculus occipitofrontalis inferior, cingulum, tractus mamil-
lothalamicus and capsula interna. They were described and illustrated from
multiple points of view, focusing on their trajectory, position, dimensions and
anatomical relations. All in all, we achieved a three-dimensional understanding
of the major tracts. The results are ready to be applied in future imagistic or
experimental studies.

neuroscience does also benefit from the knowledge of


Introduction
white matter anatomy especially due to the stimulation
The anatomy of the cerebral white matter is nowadays mapping studies that explore the functional connectivity
more and more important due to its applications in neu- of the brain (Catani et al., 2005; Fortin et al., 2012; Duf-
rology, neurosurgery and fundamental neuroscience that fau, 2015; Sarubbo et al., 2015; Zemmoura et al., 2015).
arose together with the development of the Diffusion All these applications can be further developed by
Tensor Imaging (DTI) techniques. For example, fractional experimental research on animal models. It is well known
anisotropy is an indicator for the evolution of neurologi- that the pig (Sus scrofa) is an excellent model in neuro-
cal diseases such as stroke, multiple sclerosis, Alzheimer’s science because of the resemblance of its anatomy, distri-
disease or epilepsy (Concha et al., 2005; Sbardella et al., bution of gray and white matter and embryological
2013; Gerrish et al., 2014; Sun et al., 2014; Xu et al., development with the human brain (Andersen et al.,
2014). What is more, tractographic reconstructions are 2005; Lind et al., 2007; Sauleau et al., 2009; Radlowski
used for assessment and surgical planning in traumatic et al., 2014). Moreover, its dimensions make it more
brain injury (Zappala et al., 2012; Jang and Seo, 2015), appropriate than other laboratory animals for imaging
brain tumours (Bello et al., 2010; Gras-Combe et al., studies or surgical experiments (Holm and West, 1994;
2012) and Deep Brain Stimulation (Coenen et al., 2012; Saikali et al., 2010; Conrad et al., 2014). As a result it is
Henderson, 2012; Torres et al., 2014). Fundamental an alternative to non-human primates in pre-clinical

© 2017 Blackwell Verlag GmbH


378 Anat. Histol. Embryol. 46 (2017) 378–390
R. Pascalau and B. Szabo White Matter Fibre Dissection and Sections in Pig

safety studies (Ettrup et al., 2010), Deep Brain Stimula- loops were used to remove the grey matter structures (the
tion research (Sauleau et al., 2009; Knight et al., 2013), cortex, the thalamus and some of the basal ganglia, which
brain development studies (Radlowski et al., 2014), become very friable after freezing) and to separate the
pathophysiological studies (Wang et al., 2012) and neuro- adjacent white matter tracts according to the cleavage
surgical training (Aurich et al., 2014). planes that have been created by the ice crystals during
In this context, it is worth to explore the porcine white the preparation. The surgical scalpel was used just for
matter anatomy thoroughly. However, apart from the two cuts in the entire dissection to respect as much as
internal capsule, corpus callosum and the anterior com- possible the anatomical relations of the white matter
missure, which were indirectly studied by use of imaging tracts. At each step of the dissections, digital photographs
techniques (Saikali et al., 2010; Dyrby et al., 2007; Yun from the same distance were taken and at some stages
et al., 2011; Conrad et al., 2014), the white matter tracts diluted Indian ink was spread on the specimen to
in the porcine brain are not so well documented in the enhance the visualization of the trajectory of the fibres.
scientific literature. Most of the imaging or histological The mediolateral fibre dissection protocol has six steps.
studies present the white matter of each lobe as a whole The first step consists of identifying the sulci and gyri on
(Watanabe et al., 2001; Wang et al., 2012; Radlowski the medial surface of the cerebral hemisphere and of
et al., 2014). The aim of this study is to provide a removing the cerebral cortex beginning from the depth of
description of the major white matter tracts of the por- the sulcus to the top of the gyrus. At the end of this step,
cine brain in a manner that is comparable with the stud- the short-association fibres and the cingulum can be visu-
ies on human white matter (Fernadez-Miranda et al., alized. The second step is the exposure of the white mat-
2008; Dini et al., 2013). The Klingler preparation method ter tracts that are located under the ependymal layer of
(Klingler, 1935; Ludwig and Klingler, 1956; T€ ure et al., the third ventricle, namely, the anterior pillar of the for-
2000; Martino et al., 2011) is based on the formation of nix, tractus mamillothalamicus and tractus mamil-
formaldehyde crystals that separate the fibres so that they lotegmentalis, which will be followed to their projections
can be dissected in a three-dimensional fashion which is in the nucleus thalamic anterior and lamina tecti respec-
homologue with virtual tractogaphy (Lawes et al., 2008; tively. Commissura rostralis is also dissected in this step
Agrawal et al., 2011). Combining it with standard sec- of the dissection. In the third step, the uppermost cal-
tions offers a more complex view and compatibility with losal fibres are revealed by removing the cingulum, the
pig brain atlases (Felix et al., 1999; Yun et al., 2011; Con- short-association fibres and some of the projection fibres
rad et al., 2014). that intersect corpus callosum. In the fourth step of the
dissection, the body and rostral horn of the lateral ventri-
cle are exposed by eliminating corpus callosum. The fifth
Materials and Methods step aims to reach corona radiata. It requires the removal
of the head of nucleus caudatus with the wooden spatula
Preparation of the specimens and the excision of the anterior part of the fornix by use
The study was conducted on 10 cerebral hemispheres of a horizontal cut at the level of the pulvinar thalami.
coming from adult pigs, which were purchased from a Finally, the sixth step of the dissection is the exposure of
butcher. They were preserved in 4% formaldehyde solu- the medial surface of the capsula interna which is done
tion for 6 months. by taking off the thalamus. A horizontal cut is made at
After this period, six hemispheres were prepared for the level of the hypothalamus. The spatula is inserted in
fibre dissection according to the Klingler method as fol- the depth of the cut and the thalamus is pooled upwards
lows: the blood vessels and the meningeal layers were and extracted together with corona radiata. The capsula
removed under 109–209 magnifying loops. The speci- interna fibres can be followed from the cortical surface to
mens were immersed in 9% formaldehyde solution and the cerebral peduncle.
kept 14 days at 20°C. They then thawed under running The other fibre dissection protocol begins from the lat-
water for several hours. eral surface of the brain and includes four steps. In the
The other four hemispheres were used for sections. first step, the sulci and gyri on the lateral surface are
identified and the cortex is removed so that the short-
association fibres can be seen. The second step consists
Fibre dissection
of the exposure of capsula externa and the most superfi-
Two stepwise dissection protocols (Fig. 1) previously cial long-association tracts, such as fasciculus longitudi-
adapted from human anatomy by our research group nalis superior, fasciculus longitudinalis inferior and
(Pascalau et al., 2016) were performed each on three fasciculus uncinatus, which are situated just underneath
hemispheres. Wooden spatulas and 109–209 magnifying the short-association fibres. Claustrum and capsula

© 2017 Blackwell Verlag GmbH


Anat. Histol. Embryol. 46 (2017) 378–390 379
White Matter Fibre Dissection and Sections in Pig R. Pascalau and B. Szabo

Fig. 1. Fibre dissection protocols. (see explanation in text).

extrema cannot be separated from the short-association located in the Talairach coordinate system, considering
fibres. Capsula externa can be identified as a sheet of that the PC in the midsagittal section is the origin of the
white matter located dorsally to fissura sylvia. It must be sistem, the AC-PC line is the Ox axis, the perpendicular
removed in the third step of the dissection to expose vertical line passing through the PC is the Oy axis and the
nucleus lentiformis and fasciculus occipitofrontalis infe- left–right axis with the origin in PC is Oz.
rior. The fourth step begins with the removal of nucleus The research protocol and the use of animal specimens
lentiformis which results in revealing the lateral surface of were approved by the Ethics Committee of “Iuliu Hație-
the genu of capsula interna. Its fibres are then followed to ganu” University of Medicine and Pharmacy, Cluj-
the cortical surface. Napoca.

Sections Results
To be in concordance with some MRI or histological stud- White matter tracts are groups of neuronal axons which
ies of the porcine brain (Felix et al., 1999; Watanabe et al., have parallel trajectories forming fascicles within the sub-
2001; Saikali et al., 2010; Yun et al., 2011; Conrad et al., cortical space. Their aim is to connect different functional
2014), the section planes were chosen similar to the areas of the brain and to create the brain functional net-
Talairach coordinate system (Talairach and Tournoux, work. According to the structures connected, white mat-
1988). The axial sections were parallel to the anterior ter tracts can be classified in: commissural fibres,
commissure–posterior commissure line (AC–PC line), the connecting homologue cortical areas in the two hemi-
coronal sections were parallel to a plane which is perpen- spheres; association fibres, connecting different cortical or
dicular to the AC–PC line and the sagittal sections were subcortical areas within the same hemisphere and projec-
parallel to the midsagittal plane. The section thickness was tion fibres which connect cortical with subcortical struc-
4 mm. By use of a milimetric scale, each section could be tures. As a general rule, commissural, association and

© 2017 Blackwell Verlag GmbH


380 Anat. Histol. Embryol. 46 (2017) 378–390
R. Pascalau and B. Szabo White Matter Fibre Dissection and Sections in Pig

Fig. 2. Corpus callosum and fornix. (a) Mid-


sagittal section. (b) Mediolateral fibre dissec-
tion (third step, inked). (c) Coronal section
(x = 4 mm). (d) Transversal section
(y = 8 mm). (e) Mediolateral fibre dissection
(fourth step). b, body of corpus callosum; c,
cingulum; cc, corpus callosum; ec, capsula
externa; f, fornix; g, genu of corpus callosum;
hc, hippocampus; ic, capsula interna; nc,
nucleus caudatus; nl, nucleus lentiformis; r,
rostrum of corpus callosum; s, splenium of
corpus callosum; t, thalamus.

projection tracts can be recognized by their transversal, coronal sections from x = 12 mm to x = 16 mm and
sagittal and longitudinal directions respectively. in the third step of the mediolateral fibre dissection.
The radiations of splenium and genu are best visible on
transversal sections (y = 0–8 mm). The dorsal surface of
Commissural tracts
corpus callosum has relations with cingulum and with
Corpus callosum the projection fibres that intersect it in their way to the
Being the largest white matter tract in the porcine brain, cortex. Its ventral surface is the external wall of the lat-
corpus callosum is a symmetrical dorsally convex struc- eral ventricle and it has contact with nucleus caudatus
ture situated on the midline above the lateral ventricles and fornix.
(Fig. 2). On the midsagittal section it has a “C” shape,
with 36.7 mm length and maximum width of 2.9 mm, Fornix
that can be divided rostrocaudally in rostrum, genu, Fornix is a commissural tract belonging to the limbic sys-
body and splenium. This shape also appears on sagittal tem (Fig. 2). Its body can be seen in the fourth step of
sections from z = 12 mm to z = 12 mm. Callosal radi- the mediolateral fibre dissection as a triangular mass
ations connecting homologue frontal, parietal, occipital placed in a transversal plane above the thalamus. On
and temporal cortical areas are best visualized in frontal sections (x = 8 to 8 mm) it looks like a

© 2017 Blackwell Verlag GmbH


Anat. Histol. Embryol. 46 (2017) 378–390 381
White Matter Fibre Dissection and Sections in Pig R. Pascalau and B. Szabo

transversal band with a maximum width of 3.2 mm and The anatomical relations of commissura rostralis from
on sagittal sections (z = 4 to 4) it has an arcuate shape. medial to lateral are as follows: the anterior pillar of for-
It is continued rostrally by the 11-mm-long and 1-mm- nix, head of nucleus caudatus, the anterior limb of cap-
wide anterior pillars which descend to corpora mamillar- sula interna and nucleus accumbens.
ia. They can be exposed in the second step of the medio-
lateral fibre dissection. The caudal extensions of the body
Association tracts
are crura fornicis which disperse in the white matter of
the hippocampus. Important anatomical relations of for- Short-association tracts
nix are the thalamus, which it surrounds, the trunk of Also known as arcuate fibres, the short-association tracts
commissura rostralis, which crosses the anterior pillars connect adjacent gyri (Fig. 4). They are situated the most
and corpus callosum. superficial, just underneath the cortex of the sulci. As a
result, they represent the first white matter fibres encoun-
Commissura rostralis tered in the stepwise fibre dissections. Frontal sections
Commissura rostralis is an “H”-shaped structure connect- show that these “U”-shaped fibre bundles run perpendic-
ing the two olfactive bulbs and temporal cortices (Fig. 3). ular to the length of each sulcus and they can be used to
Its trunk appears on the midsagittal section as a circle determine the Gyrification Index (GI) defined as the ratio
with 1.5 mm diameter situated at (x = 20 mm, between the total outer cortical surface and the superfi-
y = 0 mm) and on the x = 20 mm frontal section it cially exposed part of the cortex (Table 1). The length of
looks like a 38-mm-long band. The rostral radiations the short-association tracts increases with the GI. The
diverge like a fan with 38° aperture to the olfactive bulb longest are the ones of sulcus rhinalis: 25.16 mm and sul-
and they can be revealed in the second step of the medio- cus cruciatus: 17.33 mm. At this level (x = 4–16 mm) GI
lateral fibre dissection and on z = 4 mm sagittal and is also the highest. The projection fibres and the most
y = 0 mm transversal sections. On the other hand, the superficial long-association fibres such as cingulum, fasci-
posterior radiations cannot be distinguished from the culus longitudinalis superior and inferior are the most
long-association tracts that run within the temporal lobe. important anatomical relations of the arcuate fibres.

Fig. 3. Commissura rostralis. (a) Coronal section (x = 20 mm). (b) Transversal section (y = 0 mm). (c) Sagittal section (z = 4 mm). (d) Mediolat-
eral fibre dissection (second step). c, cingulum; cc, corpus callosum; ec, capsula externa; f, fornix; ic, capsula interna; na, nucleus accumbens; nc,
nucleus caudatus; nl, nucleus lentiformis; oc, chiasma opticum; rc, commissura rostralis; t, thalamus.

© 2017 Blackwell Verlag GmbH


382 Anat. Histol. Embryol. 46 (2017) 378–390
R. Pascalau and B. Szabo White Matter Fibre Dissection and Sections in Pig

Fig. 4. Short-association tracts. (a) Medial sur-


face of the brain. (b) Mediolateral fibre dis-
section (first step). (c) Lateral surface of the
brain. (d) Lateromedial fibre dissection (first
step). (e) Coronal section (x = 28 mm). (f)
Coronal section (x = 8 mm). bo, bulbus
olfactorius; c, cingulum; fs, fissura sylvia; gc,
gyrus cinguli; gco, gyrus coronalis; gem, gyrus
ectomarginalis; ges, gyrus ectosylvius; gfs,
gyrus frontalis superior; gm, gyrus marginalis;
gs, gyrus sigmoideus; gs, gyrus sylvius; sa, sul-
cus ansatus; sc, sulcus cruciatus; scg, sulcus
cynguli; sd, sulcus diagonalis; se, sulcus ecto-
sylvius caudalis; sl, sulcus lateralis; sn, sulcus
naris; sp, sulcus pre-sylvius; sr, sulcus rhinalis;
ss, sulcus splenialis; ssc, sulcus suprasylvius
caudalis; ssg, sulcus sagittalis; ssr, sulcus
suprasylvius rostralis.

Table 1. Gyrification index (GI) at different frontal planes transversal sections (y = 12–16 mm), whereas on the
coronal sections (x = 8 to 24 mm) it appears like a
X (mm) Gyrification index
round or flat structure. Before entering the parietal lobe
16 1.91 it makes a 143° genu. Fasciculus longitudinalis superior
12 1.6 is related to the short-association fibres superficially and
8 1.97 with the capsula interna–corpus callosum intersection
4 1.74
area deeply.
4 2
16 2.27
24 1.77 Capsula externa
28 1.68 Capsula externa is a 2.34-mm-wide layer of white matter
Average 1.8675 located between claustrum, laterally, and nucleus len-
Standard deviation 0.215257 tiformis, medially. It is traversed by two long-association
tracts: fasciculus uncinatus and fasciculus longitudinalis
inferior (Fig. 5). On transversal sections (y = 4 to
12 mm) it looks like a 21.2-mm-long band and on coro-
Fasciculus longitudinalis superior nal sections (x = 0–24 mm) it is “V” shaped, forming a
The long-association tract connecting the frontal and triangle with capsula interna around nucleus lentiformis.
parietal lobes is fasciculus longitudinalis superior The anatomical relations of the medial surface of capsula
(Fig. 5). It is a 62.27-mm-long and 4.4-mm-wide band- externa are capsula interna, nucleus lentiformis and fasci-
like fibre bundle, situated just underneath the short- culus occipitofrontalis inferior, in dorsoventral order. Its
association tracts of the dorsolateral region of the brain lateral surface has contact with claustrum and some arcu-
so that it can be reached in the second step of the ate fibres. Because claustrum is removed together with
lateromedial fibre dissection. This shape can be recog- the arcuate fibres of gyrus ectosylvius, gyrus sylvius and
nized on sagittal (z = 12 mm to z = 16 mm) and sulcus suprasylvius, which represent capsula extrema,

© 2017 Blackwell Verlag GmbH


Anat. Histol. Embryol. 46 (2017) 378–390 383
White Matter Fibre Dissection and Sections in Pig R. Pascalau and B. Szabo

Fig. 5. Fasciculus longitudinalis superior, capsula externa and fasciculus occipitofrontalis inferior. (a) Midsagittal section. (b) Sagittal section
(z = 12 mm). (c) Transversal section (y = 12 mm). (d) Coronal section (x = 8 mm). (e) Coronal section (x = 20 mm). (f) Transversal section
(y = 4 mm). (g) Lateromedial fibre dissection (second step). (h) Lateromedial fibre dissection (third step). c, cingulum; cc, corpus callosum; ec,
capsula externa; f, fornix; fli, fasciculus longitudinalis inferior; fls, fasciculus longitudinalis superior; foi, fasciculus occipitofrontalis inferior; fu, fasci-
culus uncinatus; hc, hippocampus; ic, capsula interna; lv, lateral ventricle; m, mesencephalon; nc, nucleus caudatus; nl, nucleus lentiformis; co,
chiasma opticum; rc, commissura rostralis; ro, radiatio optica; t, thalamus.

capsula externa is revealed at the second step of the Its trunk or its arms can be found on sagittal (z = 8–
lateromedial fibre dissection. At this stage of the dissec- 12 mm), transversal (y = 8 to 8 mm) or frontal
tion it plays the role of a landmark for the trunks of fas- (x = 16–24 mm) sections in the inferior part of capsula
ciculus uncinatus and fasciculus longitudinalis inferior. externa, lateral to fasciculus occipitofrontalis inferior and
Their radiations must be followed from here to the corti- rostral to fasciculus longitudinalis inferior.
cal surface by further removal of the short-association Fasciculus longitudinalis inferior connects the temporal
fibres. pole with the occipital lobe. It is a 41.9-mm-long and
Fasciculus uncinatus runs from the frontal pole to the 5.71-mm-wide band which passes through capsula externa
temporal pole through capsula externa, in the depth of and underneath the temporal and occipital arcuate fibres.
sulcus rhinalis. It has the shape of letter “U” and a total It appears on sagittal and transversal sections taken at the
length of 51.9 mm and maximum width of 8.57 mm. same levels as fasciculus uncinatus and on the frontal sec-
The arms of fasciculus uncinatus form an angle of 55°. tions taken more caudally (x = 16 to 8 mm). Its

© 2017 Blackwell Verlag GmbH


384 Anat. Histol. Embryol. 46 (2017) 378–390
R. Pascalau and B. Szabo White Matter Fibre Dissection and Sections in Pig

temporal radiations have contact with the temporal arm It surrounds corpus callosum and fornix and is located
of fasciculus uncinatus and its occipital radiations have just underneath the cortex of gyrus cinguli and lobus pir-
medial relation with fasciculus occipitofrontalis inferior. iformis so it can be exposed in the first step of the medi-
olateral fibre dissection. On the first sagittal section
Fasciculus occipitofrontalis inferior (z = 4 mm) it follows the external contour of corpus
If fasciculus uncinatus and fasciculus longitudinalis infe- callosum and some of its frontal, parietal and occipital
rior provide indirect fronto-occipital connections, deep to radiations are visible. They give the cingulum a triangular
them there is a direct long-association tract, fasciculus shape in the frontal sections (x = 8 to 20 mm). It has
occipitofrontalis inferior (Fig. 5). It can be reached in the maximum width of 1.8 mm and a total length of
third step of the lateromedial fibre dissection using as 90.9 mm. It has anatomical relations with the short-asso-
landmark nucleus lentiformis, which is situated just dor- ciation fibres of the medial and basal surfaces of the
sal to its trunk, from which the frontal and occipital radi- brain, with the dorsal surface of corpus callosum and
ations diverge forming a 133° angle and a total length of with crus fornicis.
5.4 mm. On transversal (y = 4 to 4 mm) and sagittal
(z = 12 mm) sections it looks like a 2.2-mm-wide and
Tractus mamillothalamicus
8.2-mm-high band, whereas on coronal sections
(x = 16 to 24 mm) it has various heights. Travelling a There is a limbic white matter tract accessible under
long distance in the brain, it has numerous anatomical the ependymal layer of the third ventricle (Fig. 7). It
relations such as commissura rostralis and capsula interna can be revealed in the second step of the mediolateral
(especially radiatio optica) medially, nucleus lentiformis fibre dissection. Tractus mamillothalamicus is a cylindri-
dorsally and fasciculus uncinatus and fasciculus longitudi- cal 1-mm-thick, 13-mm-long tract running from cor-
nalis inferior laterally. pora mamillaria to the anterior thalamic nuclei. It
makes a 27° angle with the anterior pillar of fornix, a
Cingulum 80° angle with tractus mamillotegmentalis and a 24°
Cingulum is a limbic long-association tract connecting angle with the Oy axis. It appears on the y = 4 mm
the subcallosal frontal lobe with lobus piriformis (Fig. 6). transversal and x = 16 mm frontal sections. Its

Fig. 6. Cingulum. (a) Coronal section (x = 8 mm). (b) Mediolateral fibre dissection (first step). (c) Sagittal section (z = 4 mm). (d) Mediolateral
fibre dissection (first step, dorsocaudal view). c, cingulum; cc, corpus callosum; cr, corona radiata; f, fornix; ht, hypothalamus; ic, capsula interna;
lv, lateral ventricle; rc, commissura rostralis; sc, colliculus quadrigeminus rostralis; t, thalamus; 3v, third ventricle.

© 2017 Blackwell Verlag GmbH


Anat. Histol. Embryol. 46 (2017) 378–390 385
White Matter Fibre Dissection and Sections in Pig R. Pascalau and B. Szabo

Fig 7. Tractus mamillothalamicus. (a)


Transversal section (y = 4 mm). (b) Coronal
section (x = 16 mm). (c) Mediolateral fibre
dissection (second step). cc, corpus callosum;
cm, corpus mamillare; ec, capsula externa; f,
fornix; ic, capsula interna; lv, lateral ventricle;
na, nucleus accumbens; nc, nucleus caudatus;
nl, nucleus lentiformis; co, chiasma opticum;
rc, commissura rostralis; t, thalamus; tmtg,
tractus mamillotegmentalis; tmth, tractus
mamillothalamicus.

anatomical relations are the subthalamic nuclei and the edge and root. The relations of the medial surface are
third ventricle. nucleus caudatus rostrally, thalamus and the occipital
horn of the lateral ventricle for the retrolenticular por-
tion. The lateral surface has contacts with nucleus len-
Projection tracts
tiformis, fasciculus occipitofrontalis inferior, capsula
Capsula interna externa and fasciculus longitudinalis superior. The rostral
Most of the corticonuclear, corticospinal thalamocortical edge is crossed by commissura rostralis and embraced by
(corona radiata) projection tracts and some interstriate nucleus accumbens. The caudal edge is located between
fibres are concentrated in the centre of each cerebral the arcuate fibres of the occipital lobe. In order to reach
hemisphere, in capsula interna (Fig. 8). It has the shape the dorsal edge of capsula interna, namely, the cortical
of an open fan continued by the cerebral peduncle and it surface, the projection fibres have to intersect the
represents the final target for both lateromedial and transversal fibres of corpus callosum at the level of cap-
mediolateral fibre dissection techniques. On frontal sec- sula interna–corpus callosum intersection area, which can
tions (x = 8 to 16 mm) it can be recognized as an 5.62- be felt in during the fibre dissection as a very firm white
mm-wide and 34.37-mm-long oblique band forming an matter region. Within each gyrus, the projection fibres
19° angle of with the Oy axis. It is the medial edge of a are closely related to the short-association fibres. The root
triangle formed together with capsula externa around of the fan is represented by the cerebral peduncle which
nucleus lentiformis. The transversal sections (y = 4 to comes in contact with the nuclei and fascicles of the
8 mm) show its well-known “V” shape which can be brainstem.
divided into anterior limb, genu and posterior limb
which continues with the retrolenticular portion, namely,
radiatio optica. It has a total length of 31.25 mm, maxi- Discussion
mum width of 5 mm and the limbs form a 126° angle at
The multiple approaches in which this study presents the
the level of genu so that they act as two edges of a trian-
white matter tracts of the porcine brain are aimed to pro-
gle around nucleus lentiformis whose third edge is cap-
vide a three-dimensional understanding of the porcine
sula externa. Sagittal sections (z = 4–8 mm) reveal
white matter anatomy, which is summarized in Fig. 9.
capsula interna as a white matter trapezoid surrounded
This scheme was created based on the data included in
by the basal ganglia.
the Results, such as the order in which the tracts are
If we consider capsula interna as an open fan, we
exposed in the stepwise fibre dissections and their posi-
should nominate the anatomical relations of its medial
tion on the standard sections. The Klingler method has
surface, lateral surface, rostral edge, caudal edge, dorsal
the advantage of preserving the spatial anatomy (Dini

© 2017 Blackwell Verlag GmbH


386 Anat. Histol. Embryol. 46 (2017) 378–390
R. Pascalau and B. Szabo White Matter Fibre Dissection and Sections in Pig

Fig. 8. Capsula interna. (a) Coronal section (x = 8 mm). (b) Transversal section (y = 4 mm). (c) Lateromedial fibre dissection (fourth step, inked).
(d) Sagittal section (z = 8 mm). (e) Mediolateral fibre dissection (sixth step, inked). al, anterior limb of capsula interna; c, cingulum; cc, corpus
callosum; cp, cerebral peduncle; ec, capsula externa; f, fornix; g, genu of capsula interna; ht, hypothalamus; ic, capsula interna; lv, lateral ventri-
cle; nc, nucleus caudatus; nl, nucleus lentiformis; pl, posterior limb of capsula interna; t, thalamus; 3v, third ventricle.

et al., 2013; Yaman et al., 2014; Zemmoura et al., 2015) (Watanabe et al., 2001; Saikali et al., 2010; Conrad et al.,
because it does not require force or cuts. It has also been 2012, 2014). However, white matter tracts are not indi-
proved to be reproducible with some adjustments in ani- vidually represented in these reconstructions except for
mal anatomy (Yaman et al., 2014; Pascalau et al., 2016). corpus callosum and fornix. There is also no DTI study
On the other hand, the sectional study gives a lot of on the porcine brain that reconstructs all the tracts such
details about the anatomical relations, which are extre- as in the case of the human, canine or feline brain
mely important. What is more, the association between (Leclercq et al., 2011; Jacqmot et al., 2013; Anaya Garcia
sections integrated in the coordinate system and fibre dis- et al., 2015). As far as we know, only some corpus callo-
section images of the same tract could be the basis for sum and capsula interna are used as ROI in the studies
future fibre tracking studies, provided that the Region Of reported in the literature (Dyrby et al., 2007; Wang et al.,
Interest (ROI) selection is done on sectional images and 2012; Radlowski et al., 2014).
that the anatomical knowledge plays a crucial role in this As a result, some of the white matter tracts illustrated
process (Mori and van Zijl, 2002; Catani, 2007; Leclercq in this study could not have been compared with other
et al., 2011). images of the pig brain so that they were only compared
Three-dimensional anatomy plays a very important role with fibre dissection or DTI images from other species
in the research applications of the porcine brain. This is (Jacqmot et al., 2013; Yaman et al., 2014; Anaya Garcia
why studies based on sectional imaging always try to inte- et al., 2015; Pascalau et al., 2016). Comissura rostralis,
grate the data in three-dimensional reconstructions tractus mamillothalamicus and long-association tracts like

© 2017 Blackwell Verlag GmbH


Anat. Histol. Embryol. 46 (2017) 378–390 387
White Matter Fibre Dissection and Sections in Pig R. Pascalau and B. Szabo

Nevertheless, our results and especially our stepwise


dissection methods should also be used in teaching or
training purposes because, in spite of the long learning
curve, the experience of fibre dissection correlated with
brain sectioning enriches the anatomical spatial vision
and the dissecting skills (Martino et al., 2011). The Klin-
gler method is nowadays very popular among neurosur-
geons and trainees (Martino et al., 2011; Yaman et al.,
2014; Zemmoura et al., 2015), but the access to human
brains is limited, whereas the pig brain is very accessible
(Ettrup et al., 2010). Thus, porcine brain fibre dissection
seems like a good alternative.

Conclusions
Fig. 9. Three-dimensional scheme of the major porcine white matter
tracts in lateromedial view. c, cingulum; cc, corpus callosum; cm, cor- The major porcine commissural, association and projec-
pus mamillare; cr, commissura rostralis; f, fornix; fli, fasciculus longitu-
tion tracts were described in a multiapproach fashion in
dinalis inferior; fls, fasciculus longitudinalis superior; foi, fasciculus
order to fulfil the lack of thorough descriptions of them
occipitofrontalis inferior; fu, fasciculus uncinatus; hc, hippocampus; ic,
capsula interna; nc, nucleus caudatus; nl, nucleus lentiformis; t, thala- in the literature in comparison to human anatomy, pro-
mus; tmth, tractus mamillothalamicus. vided that the porcine brain is frequently used as animal
model for neuroscience research which aims to have
applications in human biology or medicine. Two stepwise
fasciculus longitudinalis superior, fasciculus uncinatus,
fibre dissection protocols were used for the exposure of
fascicuus longitudinalis inferior and cingulum have very
the fibre bundles in their entire length and standard sec-
similar shape and position with the equine, bovine,
tions integrated in a coordinate system were performed
canine and feline ones. Fasciculus occipitofrontalis infe-
to determine their spatial localization and their dimen-
rior was more similar to the bovine and canine ones and
sions. Special attention was given to the anatomical rela-
less to the feline and equine ones. As for fasciculus occip-
tions of each tract.
itofrontalis superior, which was identified in the canine
As a result, a three-dimensional view of the major
and feline brains (Jacqmot et al., 2013; Anaya Garcia
tracts was achieved and it was schematically illustrated.
et al., 2015; Pascalau et al., 2016), it has not been
The results are comparable with the literature on pig or
encountered in the porcine brain, which resembles it to
other species and they are ready to be applied in future
the equine and bovine brains (Yaman et al., 2014; Pas-
imagistic or experimental studies.
calau et al., 2016). Capsula interna, corpus callosum and
fornix are comparable to the aforementioned species as
well as with the porcine brain images from the literature References
(Dyrby et al., 2007; Saikali et al., 2010). In a general view, Agrawal, A., J. P. Kapfhammer, A. Kress, H. Wichers, A. Deep,
the major white matter tracts have similar organization W. Feindel, V. K. Sonntag, R. F. Spetzler, and M. C. Preul,
with the human ones (Fernadez-Miranda et al., 2008) 2011: Josef Klingler’s models of white matter tracts: influ-
except for fasciculus longitudinalis superior which does ences on neuroanatomy, neurosurgery, and neuroimaging.
not have the temporal projections of its human homo- Neurosurgery. 69, 238–252.
logue as a consequence of the more pronounced caudal Anaya Garcia, M. S., J. S. Hernandez Anaya, O. Marrufo
expansion and curvature of the primate telencephalon Melendez, J. L. Velazquez Ramırez, and R. Palacios Aguiar,
compared to the porcine one (Lind et al., 2007). 2015: In vivo study of cerebral white matter in the dog
Some limitations to our study could be the use of mid- using diffusion tensor tractography. Vet. Radiol. Ultrasound.
line-sectioned hemispheres, which interfered with the 56, 188–195.
study of the commissural tracts, the thickness of the sec- Andersen, F., H. Watanabe, C. Bjarkam, E. H. Danielsen, and
tions (4 mm) affecting the precision of the tracts localiza- P. Cumming, 2005: Pig brain stereotaxic standard space:
tion and the known limitations of the Klingler method mapping of cerebral blood flow normative values and effect
(T€ure et al., 2000; Martino et al., 2011): the risk of fibre of MPTP lesioning. Brain Res. Bull. 66, 17–29.
rupture and the impossibility to separate some adjacent Aurich, L. A., S. Junior, L. F. Monteiro, F. Marques do Rego,
tracts (this was the case of the posterior radiations of A. Ottoni, G. S. Jung, and R. Ramina, 2014: Microsurgical
commissura rostralis). training model with nonliving swine head. Alternative for

© 2017 Blackwell Verlag GmbH


388 Anat. Histol. Embryol. 46 (2017) 378–390
R. Pascalau and B. Szabo White Matter Fibre Dissection and Sections in Pig

neurosurgical education. Acta Cirurgica Brasileira. 29, 405– Gerrish, A. C., A. G. Thomas, and R. A. Dineen, 2014: Brain
409. white matter tracts: functional anatomy and clinical rele-
Bello, L., A. Castellano, E. Fava, G. Casaceli, M. Riva, G. vance. Semin. Ultrasound CT MR. 35, 432–444.
Scotti, S. M. Gaini, and A. Falini, 2010: Intraoperative use Gras-Combe, G., S. Moritz-Gasser, G. Herbet, and H. Duffau,
of diffusion tensor imaging fiber tractography and subcorti- 2012: Intraoperative subcortical electrical mapping of optic
cal mapping for resection of gliomas: technical considera- radiations in awake surgery for glioma involving visual
tions. Neurosurg. Focus. 28, E6. pathways. J. Neurosurg. 117, 466–473.
Catani, M., 2007: From hodology to function. Brain. 130, Henderson, J. M., 2012: “Connectomic surgery”: diffusion ten-
602–605. sor imaging (DTI) tractography as a targeting modality for
Catani, M., D. K. Jones, and D. H. ffytche, 2005: Perisylvian surgical modulation of neural networks. Front. Integr.
language networks of the human brain. Ann. Neurol. 57, 8– Neurosci. 6, 15.
16. Holm, I. E., and M. J. West, 1994: Hippocampus of the
Coenen, V. A., J. Panksepp, T. A. Hurwitz, H. Urbach, and B. domestic pig: a stereological study of subdivisional volumes
M€adler, 2012: Human medial forebrain bundle (MFB) and and neuron numbers. Hippocampus. 4, 115–125.
anterior thalamic radiation (ATR): imaging of two major Jacqmot, O., B. Van Thielen, Y. Fierens, M. Hammond, I.
subcortical pathways and the dynamic balance of opposite Willekens, P. Van Schuerbeek, F. Verhelle, P. Goossens, F.
affects in understanding depression. J. Neuropsychiatry Clin. de Ridder, J. P. Clarys, and J. de Mey, 2013: Diffusion ten-
Neurosci. 24, 223–236. sor imaging of white matter tracts in the dog brain. Anat.
Concha, L., C. Beaulieu, and D. W. Gross, 2005: Bilateral lim- Rec. (Hoboken). 296, 340–349.
bic diffusion abnormalities in unilateral temporal lobe epi- Jang, S. H., and J. P. Seo, 2015: Damage to the optic radiation
lepsy. Ann. Neurol. 57, 188–196. in patients with mild traumatic brain injury. J. Neurooph-
Conrad, M. S., R. N. Dilger, A. Nickolls, and R. W. Johnson, thalmol. 35, 270–273.
2012: Magnetic resonance imaging of the neonatal piglet Klingler, J., 1935: Erleichterung der makroskopischen Pr€apara-
brain. Pediatr. Res. 71, 179–184. tion des Gehirns durch den Gefrierprozess. Schweiz. Arch.
Conrad, M. S., B. P. Sutton, R. N. Dilger, and R. W. Johnson, Neurol. Neurochir. Psychiatr. 36, 247–256.
2014: An in vivo three-dimensional magnetic resonance Knight, E. J., H. K. Min, S. C. Hwang, M. P. Marsh, S. Paek,
imaging-based averaged brain collection of the neonatal pig- I. Kim, J. P. Felmlee, O. A. Abulseoud, K. E. Bennet, M. A.
let (Sus scrofa). PLoS ONE. 9, e107650. Frye, and K. H. Lee, 2013: Nucleus accumbens deep brain
Dini, L. I., L. M. Vedolin, D. Bertholdo, R. D. Grando, stimulation results in insula and prefrontal activation: a
A. Mazzola, S. A. Dini, G. R. Isolan, J. C. da Costa and large animal fMRI study. PLoS ONE. 8, e56640. https://doi.
A. Campero. 2013: Reproducibility of quantitative fiber org/10.1371/journal.pone.0056640.
tracking measurements in diffusion tensor imaging of Lawes, I. N. C., T. R. Barrick, V. Murugam, N. Spierings,
frontal lobe tracts: a protocol based on the fiber dissection D. R. Evans, M. Song and C. A. Clark, 2008: Atlas-based
technique. Surg. Neurol. Int. 4, 51. segmentation of whitematter tracts of the human brain
Duffau, H., 2015: Stimulation mapping of white matter tracts using diffusion tensor tractography and comparison with
to study brain functional connectivity. Nat. Rev. Neurol. 11, classical dissection. NeuroImage. 39. 62e79.
255–265. Leclercq, D., C. Delmaire, N. Menjot de Champfleur, J. Chiras,
Dyrby, T. B., L. V. Søgaard, G. J. Parker, D. C. Alexander, N. and S. Lehericy, 2011: Diffusion tractography: methods, vali-
M. Lind, W. F. Baare, A. Hay-Schmidt, N. Eriksen, B. dation and applications in patients with neurosurgical
Pakkenberg, O. B. Paulson, and J. Jelsing, 2007: Validation lesions. Neurosurg. Clin. N. Am. 22, 253–268.
of in vitro probabilistic tractography. NeuroImage. 37, Lind, N. M., A. Moustgaard, J. Jelsing, G. Vajta, P. Cumming,
1267–1277. and A. K. Hansen, 2007: The use of pigs in neuroscience:
Ettrup, K. S., J. C. Sørensen, and C. R. Bjarkam, 2010: The modeling brain disorders. Neurosci. Biobehav. Rev. 31, 728–
anatomy of the G€ ottingen minipig hypothalamus. J. Chem. 751.
Neuroanat. 39, 151–165. Ludwig, E., and J. Klingler, 1956: Atlas Cerebri Humani: Der
Felix, B., M. E. Leger, and D. Albe-Fessard, 1999: Stereotaxic innere Bau des Gehirns dargestellt auf Grund mackroskopis-
atlas of the pig brain. Brain Res. Bull. 49, 1–138. cher Pr€aparate. Boston: Brown.
Fernadez-Miranda, J. C., A. L. Jr Rhoton, J. Alvarez-Linera, Martino, J., P. C. De Witt Hamer, F. Vergani, C. Brogna, E.
et al., 2008: Three-dimensional microsurgical and tracto- M. de Lucas, A. Vazquez-Barquero, J. A. Garcia-Porrero,
graphic anatomy of the white matter of the human brain. and H. Duffau, 2011: Cortex-sparing fiber dissection: an
Neurosurgery. 62, 989–1026. improved method for the study of white matter anatomy in
Fortin, D., C. Aubin-Lemay, A. Bore, G. Girard, J. C. Houde, the human brain. J. Anat. 219, 531–541.
K. Whittingstall, and M. Descoteaux, 2012: Tractography in Mori, S., and P. C. M. van Zijl, 2002: Fiber tracking: principles
the study of the human brain: a neurosurgical perspective. and strategies – a technical review. NMR Biomed. 15, 468–
Can. J. Neurol. Sci. 39, 747–756. 480.

© 2017 Blackwell Verlag GmbH


Anat. Histol. Embryol. 46 (2017) 378–390 389
White Matter Fibre Dissection and Sections in Pig R. Pascalau and B. Szabo

Pascalau, R., C. C. Aldea, V. A. Padurean, and B. Szabo, 2016: T€


ure, U., M. G. Yasargil, A. H. Friedman, and O. Al-Mefty,
Comparative study of the major white matter tracts anat- 2000: Fiber dissection technique: lateral aspect of the brain.
omy in equine, feline and canine brains by use of the fibre Neurosurgery. 47, 417–426.
dissection technique. Anat. Histol. Embryol. 45, 373–385. Wang, H., X. Wahg, and Q. Guo, 2012: The correlation
https://doi.org/10.1111/ahe.12208. between DTI parameters and levelsof AQP-4 in the early
Radlowski, E. C., M. S. Conrad, S. Lezmi, R. N. Dilger, B. phases of cerebral edemaafter hypoxic-ischemic/reperfusion
Sutton, R. Larsen, and R. W. Johnson, 2014: A neonatal pig- injury in piglets. Pediatr. Radiol. 42, 992–999.
let model for investigating brain and cognitive development Watanabe, H., F. Andersen, C. Z. Simonsen, S. M. Evans, A.
in small for gestational age human infants. PLoS ONE. 9, Gjedde, and P. Cumming, 2001: MR-based statistical atlas
e91951. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0091951. of the G€ottingen minipig brain. NeuroImage. 14, 1089–
Saikali, S., P. Meurice, P. Sauleau, A. Eliat, P. Bellaud, G. Ran- 1096.
duineau, M. Verin, and C. H. Malbert, 2010: A three- Xu, Y., S. Qiu, J. Wang, Z. Liu, R. Zhang, S. Li, L. Cheng, Z.
dimensional digital segmented and deformable brain atlas of Liu, W. Wang, and R. Huang, 2014: Disrupted topological
the domestic pig. J. Neurosci. Methods. 192, 102–109. properties of brain white matter networks in left temporal
Sarubbo, S., A. De Benedictis, S. Merler, E. Mandonnet, S. lobe epilepsy: a diffusion tensor imaging study. Neuro-
Balbi, E. Granieri, and H. Duffau, 2015: Towards a func- science. 279, 155–167.
tional atlas of human white matter. Hum. Brain Mapp. 36, _
Yaman, M. E., M. Izdes, S. Senturk, Y. Ozturk, and A.
3117–3136. Kazanci, 2014: Fiber dissection training model for neurosur-
Sauleau, P., E. Lapouble, D. Val-Laillet, and C. H. Malbert, gical practice: white matter fiber dissection with Klingler’s
2009: The pig model in brain imaging and neurosurgery. technique in Bovine Brain. J. Neurol. Sci. Turk. 31, 783–
Animal. 3, 1138–1151. 789.
Sbardella, E., F. Tona, N. Petsas, and P. Pantano, 2013: DTI Yun, S. P., D. H. Kim, J. M. Ryu, J. H. Park, S. S. Park, J. H.
measurements in multiple sclerosis: evaluation of brain Jeon, B. N. Seo, H. J. Kim, J. G. Park, K. O. Cho, and H. J.
damage and clinical implications. Mult. Scler. Int. 671730, Han, 2011: Magnetic resonance imaging evaluation of Yuka-
https://doi.org/10.1155/2013/671730. tan minipig brains for neurotherapy applications. Lab.
Schaller, O., and G. M. Constantinescu, 2012: Illustrated vet- Anim. Res. 27, 309–316.
erinary anatomical nomenclature. Stuttgart: Enke. Zappala, G., M. Thiebaut de Schotten, and P. J. Eslinger, 2012:
Sun, X., D. Salat, K. Upchurch, R. Deason, N. Kowall, and A. Traumatic brain injury and the frontal lobes: what can we
Budson, 2014: Destruction of white matter integrity in gain with diffusion tensor imaging? Cortex. 48, 156–165.
patients with mild cognitive impairment and Alzheimer dis- Zemmoura, I., E. Blanchard, P. I. Raynal, C. Rousselot-Denis,
ease. J. Investig. Med. 62, 927–933. C. Destrieux, and S. Velut, 2015: How Klingler’s Dissection
Talairach, J., and P. Tournoux, 1988: Co-planar Stereotaxic Permits Exploration of Brain Structural Connectivity?. An
Atlas of the Human Brain. New York: Thieme. electron microscopy study of human white matter: Brain
Torres, C. V., R. Manzanares, and R. G. Sola, 2014: Integrating Struct. Funct. 221, 2477–2486. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.corte
diffusion tensor imaging-based tractography into deep brain x.2011.06.020.
stimulation surgery: a review of the literature. Stereotact.
Funct. Neurosurg. 92, 282–290.

© 2017 Blackwell Verlag GmbH


390 Anat. Histol. Embryol. 46 (2017) 378–390

You might also like