Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/51045190
CITATIONS READS
126 607
6 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Gabriela Macedo on 04 March 2014.
Submitted 9 July 2010: Accepted 20 October 2010: First published online 13 April 2011
Abstract
Objective: To assess the available data on the prevalence of metabolic syndrome
(MS) in Latin-American countries.
Design: Systematic review. Searches were carried out in PubMed, ISIWeb, SCielo
and Redalyc, using ‘metabolic syndrome x’ and ‘prevalence’ as keywords for titles
and/or abstracts. Articles selected were cross-sectional studies in Latin-American
countries, whose main objective was to study MS and whose study population is
described below. MS must be determined using Adult Treatment Panel III criteria.
Twelve studies with these criteria were selected, one of which was multi-centric.
Setting: Latin America.
Subjects: Apparently healthy subjects aged 18–65 years (including young adult,
mature adult and elderly populations) of both genders.
Results: The general prevalence (weighted mean) of MS in Latin-American
countries was 24?9 (range: 18?8–43?3) %. MS was slightly more frequent in women
(25?3 %) than in men (23?2 %), and the age group with the highest prevalence of
MS consisted of those over 50 years of age. The most frequent components of MS
were low HDL cholesterol levels (62?9 %) and abdominal obesity (45?8 %). Similar
outcomes were obtained from the multi-centre study on Latin-American popu-
lations analysed.
Conclusions: The present review brings us closer to an understanding of
the prevalence of MS in Latin-American countries. However, it is not possible to Keywords
know the full scope of the problem, partly because data from some countries are Metabolic syndrome
not available, and because the methodological differences among the studies CVD
published up to the present limit a joint analysis of their results. Latin America
A description of metabolic syndrome The definition provided by the Adult Treatment Panel
III (ATP III) seems to be more ‘equitable’(5), given that it
In 1998, Reaven(1) defined metabolic syndrome (MS), also does not establish a hierarchal relationship among the five
known as X syndrome, as a conglomerate of coronary components: abdominal obesity (AO), glucose alterations,
risk factors. Since that time, the definition of MS has hypertension (HT), hypertriacylglycerolaemia and low
been modified by a number of experts(2–4). Although the HDL cholesterol levels. In addition, ATP III is one of the
different definitions of MS generally include the same most internationally accepted and used definitions, as well
components, they differ in the assignment of each com- as the most up-to-date as a result of its high use and
ponent’s importance for the diagnosis of MS (for instance, analysis(3,6,7). Nevertheless, it is worth mentioning that, in
number of criteria, hierarchy of components). the latter part of 2009, prominent institutions such as the
1. Abdominal obesity – waist circumference .102 cm in men 1. Abdominal obesity – waist circumference .102 cm in men
and .88 cm in women (measured at the mid-point and .88 cm in women (measured at the mid-point
between the lower-most rib and the iliac crest) between the lower-most rib and the iliac crest)
2. Elevated fasting glucose – fasting serum glucose 2. Elevated fasting glucose – fasting serum glucose
$110 mg/dl $100 mg/dl, or on drug treatment for elevated glucose
3. Hypertension – systolic blood pressure $130 mmHg and/ 3. Hypertension – systolic blood pressure of $130 mmHg
or diastolic blood pressure $85 mmHg, or the current use and/or diastolic blood pressure $85 mmHg, or the current
of anti-hypertensive medication use of anti-hypertensive medication
4. Low HDL cholesterol – serum HDL cholesterol ,40 mg/dl 4. Low HDL cholesterol – serum HDL cholesterol ,40 mg/dl
in men and ,50 mg/dl in women in men and ,50 mg/dl in women, or on drug treatment for
5. High TAG – serum TAG $150 mg/dl, in both genders reduced HDL cholesterol
5. High TAG – serum TAG $150 mg/dl, in both genders, or
on drug treatment for elevated TAG
International Diabetes Federation (IDF) and the American 21?8 % was found, which ranged from 6?7 % (in 20–29-year-
Heart Association/National Heart, Lung and Blood Institute olds) to 43?5 % (in 60–69-year-olds)(20).
standardized their criteria for defining MS(8). These updated Results from different cross-sectional studies conducted
diagnostic criteria maintained the components defined by in countries with emerging economies have reported that
the last ATP III modification made in 2005(3), and also the prevalence of MS in these countries is also high.
contributed with new guidelines for the measurement of Hence, in studies carried out on adult populations of
waist circumference by recommending specific cut-off India and Iran, the prevalence rates of MS varied from
points for each ethnic group or population (Table 1). 33?7 % to 41 %(21–23).
Although there are several studies reporting the pre-
valence of MS in Latin America, in the majority of them
Clinical importance of diagnosing metabolic
MS is a secondary objective of the study and thus they do
syndrome
not reflect the real prevalence of this syndrome among
the general population. This may be because this region
In 2007, Grundy(9) described the reasons why MS analysis
has experienced a nutritional transition, having gone
was useful from a clinical perspective. To summarize,
from being an area in which malnutrition was a main
it mentions that MS detection is important because it
concern to experiencing problems associated with over-
allows for easy identification of patients who are at risk of
eating (obesity, MS and CVD mortality). This situation has
developing atherosclerosis, type 2 diabetes mellitus
probably delayed the development of studies focusing
and/or associated comorbidities and who are subjected to
exclusively on MS and its components, as well as the
a higher risk of mortality from these causes(10–17). In addi-
analysis of other precursors to the development of these
tion, the concept of MS facilitates the understanding of
diseases.
the physiopathological relationships between its different
For these reasons, the objective of the present systematic
components and other related cardiovascular risk factors.
review is to assess the prevalence of MS in Latin America
This understanding may also be helpful for carrying out
using data already published in the scientific literature.
epidemiological and clinical studies associated with the
treatment and/or prevention of CVD, which may entail
drugs, lifestyle changes(9,11) or both simultaneously.
Materials and methods
4. Clinical diagnosis of MS determined using ATP III criteria 74 Did not meet criterion 3
13
(24–35, 100)*
F Márquez-Sandoval et al.
12
(24–35)
Mujica et al.(25) 1007 adults, Talca, Chile Probabilistic, WC: N/A 35?5 AO: N/A N/A
18–74 years old without specifying G, TAG and HDL-C: fasting High G: 26?3
66 % W, 34 % M the exact type BP: N/A HT: 37?0
MS: ATP III, 2005 High TAG: 40?1
Low HDL-C: 21?5
Pinzón et al.(26) 155 adults, Bucaramanga, Convenience WC: NHANES II 34?8 AO: 53?6 N/A
22–73 years old Colombia G, TAG and HDL-C: fasting High G: 3?9
46 % W, 54 % M BP: American Society of High TAG: 32?9
HT HT: 16?8
MS: ATP III, 2005 Low HDL-C: 96?1
Medina et al.(27) 1878 adults, Arequipa, Peru Stratified and WC: at the navel level, after 18?8 AO: 50?9 Logistic regression model
20–80 years old randomized exhaling normally High G: 10?4 adjusted for age and sex:
54 % W, 46 % M G, TAG and HDL-C: fasting HT: 47?0 Low physical activity: OR 5 1?92,
BP: Joint National High TAG: 87?3 95 % CI 1?41, 2?60
Committee Low HDL-C: 93?4 Excessive alcohol intake:
MS: ATP III, 2005 OR 5 1?59, 95 % CI 1?06, 2?40
Familial antecedent of
hypertension and type 2
diabetes: OR 5 1?63, 95 % CI
1?23, 2?16 and OR 5 1?66,
95 % CI 1?17, 2?33, respectively
F Márquez-Sandoval et al.
Tull et al.(28) 893 adults, Saint Croix, Virgin Probabilistic, WC: N/A 20?5- AO: N/A Logistic regression model:
20–70 years old Islands without specifying BP: one measurement. HT: N/A $70 years: OR 5 1?04, 95 % CI
46 % W, 54 % M the exact type G, TAG and HDL-C: fasting High G: N/A 1?02, 1?05
High TAG: N/A Hispanic: OR 5 1?82, 95 % CI
MS: ATP III, 2001 1?07, 3?07
Low HDL-C: N/A HOMA-IR score: OR 5 5?59,
95 % CI 3?69, 8?46
Metabolic syndrome in Latin America
Table 3 Continued
Overall Overall prevalence of
prevalence individual components
Author Population study City/country Sampling Measurements of MS (%) of MS (%) Associations*
(29)
Gómez et al. 202 adults, San Juan, Puerto Convenience WC: N/A 31 AO: 48?5 N/A
$20 years old Rico G, TAG and HDL-C: N/A High G: 31?2
60 % W, 40 % M BP: N/A HT: 77?2
MS: ATP III, 2001 High TAG : 31?2
Low HDL-C: 27?7
Florez et al.(30) 3108 adults, Zulia, Venezuela Stratified and WC: at the navel level 35?3 AO: 42?9 Logistic regression model:
$20 years old randomized G, TAG and HDL-C: fasting High G: 10?9 Age .45 years: OR 5 3?82, 95 %
BP: two measurements HT: 38?1 CI 3?01, 4?84
MS: ATP III, 2001 High TAG: 32?3 Sedentary: OR 5 1?39, 95 % CI
Low HDL-C: 65?3 1?01, 1?91
BMI . 25 kg/m2: OR 5 4?24, 95 %
CI 3?25, 5?54
High HOMA-IR score: OR 5 2?44,
95 % CI 1?93, 3?09
Aguilar et al.(31) 2158 adults, Mexico Probabilistic, without WC: replaced by BMI 26?6 AO: N/A N/A
20–69 years old specifying the G, TAG and HDL-C: fasting High G: N/A
exact type BP: two measurements HT: N/A
MS: ATP III, 2001 High TAG: N/A
Low HDL-C: N/A
Marquezine et al.(32) 1507 adults, Victoria, Brazil Probabilistic, without WC: at the mid-point 25?4 AO: N/A Low-income social class:
25–64 years old specifying the between the lower-most High G: N/A OR 5 1?64
exact type rib and the iliac crest HT: N/A
G, TAG and HDL-C: fasting High TAG: N/A
BP: one measurement Low HDL-C: N/A
MS: ATP III, 2001
Velásquez et al.(33) 251 adults, Virgem das N/A WC: at the mid-point 21?6 AO: 26?7 Logistic regression model:
18–88 years old Graças, Minas between the lower-most High G: 6?0 BMI .25 kg/m2: OR 5 20?84,
47 % W, 53 % M Gerais, Brazil rib and the iliac crest High TAG: 22?3 95 % CI 8?85, 49?09
G, TAG and HDL-C: fasting Age 30–42 years-: OR 5 3?38,
-
HT: 62?5
BP: three measurements 95 % CI 1?22, 9?36
Low HDL-C: 37?1
MS: ATP III, 2001 Age 43–59 years: OR 5 5?89,
95 % CI 1?82, 9?04
Age 60–88 years: OR 5 20?75,
95 % CI 4?98, 86?47
1707
1708
Table 3 Continued
MS, metabolic syndrome; W, women; M, men; WC, waist circumference; G, glucose; HDL-C, HDL cholesterol; BP, blood pressure; ATP III, Adult Treatment Panel III; N/A, information not available; NHANES II, Second
National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey; AO, abdominal obesity; high G, hyperglycaemia; HT, hypertension; high TAG, hypertriacylglycerolaemia; HOMA-IR, homeostatic model assessment–insulin resistance.
*Only statistically significant associations are shown (P , 0?05).
-Prevalence of age-adjusted MS, only data reported in this article.
-Reference group for age ,30 years.
-
Table 4 Cross-sectional multi-centre study of the prevalence of MS among Latin-American populations included in the present review
Overall prevalence of
Overall prevalence individual components of
Author Population study (n) Countries Sampling Measurements of MS (%) MS (%)* Associations
Escobedo 11 550 adults, Barquisimeto, Venezuela Stratified and WC: at the mid-point Barquisimeto: 26 AO: 76?3 N/A
et al.(35) 25–64 years old (n 1836) randomized between the lower-most Bogota: 20 High G: 31?2
50 % W, 50 % M Bogota, Colombia (n 1550) rib and the iliac crest Lima: 18 HT: 60?1
Buenos Aires, Argentina G, TAG and HDL-C: fasting Mexico City: 27 High TAG: 85?9
(n 1476) BP: two measurements Buenos Aires: 17 Low HDL-C: 85?6
F Márquez-Sandoval et al.
Lima, Peru (n 1645) MS: ATP III, 2001 Quito: 14
Mexico City, Mexico Santiago: 21
(n 1720)
Quito, Ecuador (n 1627)
Santiago, Chile (n 1648)
MS, metabolic syndrome; W, women; M, men; WC, waist circumference; G, glucose; HDL-C, HDL cholesterol; BP, blood pressure; ATP III, Adult Treatment Panel III; AO, abdominal obesity; high G, hyperglycaemia;
HT, hypertension; high TAG, hypertriacylglycerolaemia.
*Calculated prevalence of population with MS.
Metabolic syndrome in Latin America 1709
(27,29,32)
whereas the lower prevalence was found in those under studies reported the prevalence of HT by age ,
34 years of age, except for low HDL cholesterol levels. observing an increase in parallel.