Professional Documents
Culture Documents
originalarbeit
1
Sakakibara Dental Laboratory, Tokyo, Japan
2
Center of Interdisciplinary Dentistry, Department of Environment and Medical Center, Donau University at Krems,
Krems, Austria
3
Division of Orthodontics, Department of Craniofacial Growth and Development Dentistry, Kanagawa Dental Collage,
Yokosuka, Japan
&
The occlusal plane (OP) is one of the most important ele- them into consideration when reconstructing occlusion in
ments involved in occlusal reconstruction in restorative, dental practice. However, the literature on occlusion to date
prosthodontic and orthodontic treatment. The presence or has not provided sufficient information on relationships be-
absence of posterior interferences depends primarily on the tween such anatomical features.
occlusal plane configuration. In powerful grinding move- D’Amico [1] regarded the canine as a stress breaker, as
ments of the mandible like bruxism, disocclusion of the it reduces the activity of the temporal and masseter muscles
posterior teeth is important to prevent the hyperbalance of in the lateral mandibular movement, and he has formulated
masticatory muscle activity. We have investigated the rela- the occlusion concept known as canine guidance. Goldstein
tionship between the inclination of the occlusal plane in- [2] investigated the relationship between different schema of
volving the degree of the curve of Spee and the posterior occlusion and periodontal diseases and reported that the
disocclusion during forward or retrusive condylar move- canine guidance had a significantly lower rate of periodontal
ment. Results indicated that increasing the inclination of disease than those with progressive disocclusion or group
the occlusal plane provides posterior interference during function. Subsequently, many investigators have studied the
protrusive mandibular movement, while posterior disocclu- significance of posterior disocclusion, and the importance
sion is obtained during retrusive movement. Accentuation of of occlusion schema controlled by the canine is now being
the curve of Spee provides elimination of posterior contact recognized [3, 4]. Nevertheless, it appears that confusion
during retrusive condylar movements. Therefore, the occlu- exists over the recognition of canine-guided occlusion or
sal plane inclination should be properly and carefully ana- posterior occlusion. At present, there is no definite measure
lyzed and must be a part of the diagnosis and treatment to what extent the inclination of canine guidance should be
planning prior to any occlusal reconstruction. given or how disocclusion of the posterior teeth should be
determined.
Keywords: Posterior disocclusion, curve of Spee, occlusal Mchorris [5, 6], in a series of his research, pointed
plane, retrusive guidance out that occlusal guidance is important, particularly during
parafunction, and emphasized on the importance of bal-
ancing anterior guidance with the sagittal condylar path
Introduction
(Posterior guidance). Artificial alteration of the balance
Anatomical features such as the shape of the occlusal surface, between the anterior or canine guidance and the posterior
the inclination of the occlusal plane, the facial pattern, and guidance led to the induction of abnormal activity of mas-
the functional structure of the temporomandibular joint (TMJ) ticatory muscles [7] or displacement of the mandible [8],
are important determinants of occlusion, and we should take and resulted in dysfunction of the TMJ [6]. Taking these facts
together, Slavicek [9–12] advocated the occlusal concept
of sequential guidance, in which guidance of all teeth
This research is a part of Miwa Hanashima’s Master Thesis of Advance
Dentistry, Donau University, Krems, Austria. The results of this research should be harmonized with the individual’s facial pattern
were once published in the Journal of Gnathology and Occlusion, Volume and TMJ.
22, 2002 issue, in Japanese. Therefore this English translation issue is a In dental practice, when we attempt to provide a patient
secondary publication with copyright permission from Japanese Society of
with the ideal occlusal guidance that permits posterior dis-
Gnathology.
occlusion, we must consider many factors that influence
Correspondence: Sadao Sato, Research Center of Brain and Oral Science,
Kanagawa Dental College, 82 Inaoka-Cho, Yokosuka 238-8580, Japan. occlusion. Particularly, in patients with chronic joint loosen-
E-mail: satosada@ca3.so-net.ne.jp ing, complicated mandibular movements often make it diffi-
J. Stomat. Occ. Med. Occlusal plane and posterior disocclusion in joint loosening 1/2008 1
originalarbeit
2 1/2008 Occlusal plane and posterior disocclusion in joint loosening J. Stomat. Occ. Med.
originalarbeit
Fig. 4: Changes in the tooth axis of the lower first molar and the occlusal
plane after adjustment by the curve of Spee. If the mandibular dentition is
aligned along the curve of Spee, the first molar tooth axis is mesially
inclined by the angle a relative to the dentition with a flat occlusal plane,
so the slope of the occlusal plane on the first molar itself becomes
steeper by angle a
Fig. 2: Positional relationship of parameters in the protrusive movement.
Using the study model, when the mandible moved forward 5 mm at the
incisor position, the distance that the disto-buccal cusp tip of the lower
the sagittal plane was examined. When the mandible moves
first molar moved was measured. The amount of disocclusion, defined
as the vertical distance from the moved cusp tip to the occlusal plane (D) backward, both the distance that the disto-buccal cusp of the
was calculated first molar moves and the distance that the condyle moves
backward differ, as the inclination of retrusive guidance on
the first premolar changes (Fig. 3). At a fixed positional
the amount of posterior disocclusion, as calculated with the
relationship between the condyle and the lower dentition,
following equation:
when the lower first premolar moves a given distance, the
Z pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi steeper the inclination of retrusive guidance is, the more
D ¼ sin arctan OP X 2 þ Z 2 distance the molar moves downward, but the less distance
X
the condyle moves downward.
where OP is the inclination of the occlusal plane relative to Under the study model, when the condyle was moved
AOP (Fig. 2). 1 mm posterior-superiorly at 30 , and when the buccal cusp of
the lower first premolar moved 3 mm along the retrusive
guidance on the upper first premolar at 30 , the disto-buccal
Amount of posterior disocclusion in the retrusive
cusp of the lower first premolar moved 2.7 mm (X) backward,
movement
and 0.9 mm (Z) downward. From these values, the amount of
We examined the relationship of the retrusive movement of posterior disocclusion (D) was calculated with the following
the mandible to the amount of the posterior disocclusion in equation:
Z pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
D ¼ sin arctan þ OP X 2 þ Z 2
X
J. Stomat. Occ. Med. Occlusal plane and posterior disocclusion in joint loosening 1/2008 3
originalarbeit
3
movement
2 OP ( ) Vertical distance of
disocclusion (mm)
1 Retrusive guidance ( ) 25 30 40
Retral movement condyle (mm) 1.3 1.0 0.5
0
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 0 0.7 0.9 1.2
OP inclination (°) 10 1.2 1.4 1.6
Fig. 6: Relationship between the inclination of the occlusal plane and 15 1.4 1.6 1.8
the amount of disocclusion at the disto-buccal cusp of the first molar in
20 1.6 1.8 1.9
the protrusive movement. In the protrusive movement, the steeper the
occlusal plane is, the less the amount of disocclusion at the cusp of the 30 2.0 2.1 2.2
first molar is
4 1/2008 Occlusal plane and posterior disocclusion in joint loosening J. Stomat. Occ. Med.
originalarbeit
2.5 the Kanagawa Dental College, the cusp height of the upper
first molar was measured as 1.99 mm 0.27 (mean SD). If
2 we consider that disocclusion can be provided when the
Disocclusion (mm)
3
AG54°
Tab. 5: Effect of OP inclination and curve of Spee
2.5 RG40°
RG30° on the posterior disocclusion during protrusive
2
RG25° movement
1.5
1
OP Radius of Spee Disocclusion
inclination (mm) (mm)
0.5 ( ) 0 10 15 20
0
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 Flat 4.2 3.6 3.4 3.1
OP inclination (°)
100 3.9(0.3) 3.3(0.3) 3.0(0.4) 2.7(0.4)
Fig. 8: Relationship between the inclination of the occlusal plane and the 80 3.8(0.4) 3.2(0.4) 2.9(0.5) 2.6(0.5)
amount of disocclusion at the disto-buccal cusp of the first molar in the
protrusive and retrusive movements. To provide an appropriate amount 60 3.7(0.5) 3.0(0.6) 2.7(0.7) 2.4(0.7)
of disocclusion at the first molar in the retrusive movement in addition to
the protrusive movement of the mandible, an angle of inclination of the Number inside the parenthesis represents the difference in flat OP inclination
occlusal plane of 20 to 30 is needed
J. Stomat. Occ. Med. Occlusal plane and posterior disocclusion in joint loosening 1/2008 5
originalarbeit
Tab. 6: Effect of OP inclination and curve of Spee disocclusion during the protrusive movement, interference
on the posterior disocclusion during retrusive will occur during the retrusive movement; whereas if the
movement (Difference from “flat”) occlusal plane is made steeper in order to provide posterior
disocclusion during the retrusive movement, interference will
OP Radius of Spee Disocclusion (mm) occur during the protrusive movement. Thus, we face an
inclination (mm) enormous difficulty if we are to establish an occlusal scheme
( ) 0 10 15 20 to ensure posterior disocclusion in either movement.
The determinants of posterior disocclusion include the
Flat 0.6 1.1 1.3 1.6 cuspal inclination and the degree of the compensation curves
100 0.9( þ 0.3) 1.3(þ0.2) 1.5(þ0.2) 1.8(þ0.2) such as the curve of Spee and the curve of Wilson. The cuspal
inclination cannot be made flatter, because flattering it to
80 0.9(þ0.3) 1.4(þ0.3) 1.6(þ0.3) 1.8(þ0.2)
disocclude posterior teeth will make the mandible unstable,
60 1.0(þ0.4) 1.5(þ0.4) 1.6(þ0.3) 1.9(þ0.3) resulting in decreased masticatory efficiency.
In this study, the mean cusp height of the upper first
Number inside the parenthesis represents the difference in flat OP inclination
molar in Japanese is shown to be about 2 mm, and thus
posterior disocclusion accompanied by mandibular move-
ment should go beyond this distance.
The inclination of the occlusal plane is the most impor-
tant determinant to influence posterior disocclusion. The
flatter the occlusal plane is, the greater is the amount of
posterior disocclusion during the protrusive movement
(Tab. 3). Therefore, we have to seek a condition to provide
posterior disocclusion in both the protrusive and retrusive
movements. Theoretically, as shown in Fig. 8, with an occlusal
plane of 20 –30 , molar disocclusion can be produced in both
protrusive and retrusive movements.
However, such a steep occlusal plane of 20 –30 will cause
problems in mandibular stability. As seen in many Class II
cases, a steeper occlusal plane flattens the apparent cuspal
inclination, which causes backward movement at the inter-
cuspal position, resulting in the mandibular retrogression and
an unstable intercuspal position. One way to solve this prob-
lem is to modify the curve of Spee without changing the
occlusal plane itself. In particular, our study demonstrates
Fig. 9: Relationship between the radius of the curve of Spee, the amount
of disocclusion, and the direction of disocclusion. The diagram shows that accentuation of the curve of Spee by modifying the tooth
the relationship of different radii of the curve of Spee to the movement axis of the molar provides the apparent amount of disocclu-
direction. Particularly in retrusive movement, when the radius is small, sion at the maxillary and mandibular first molar became
the mandibular dentition moves downward at a greater angle than the
maxillary dentition does, and thus at the early period of movement the greater in the retrusive movement than in the protrusive
distance diverges, which facilitates disocclusion movement. Therefore, we can conclude that in occlusal re-
construction in a patient with the joint loosening, whose
mandible on the retrusive side tends to move backward, it is
Discussion
crucial to modify the curve of Spee by adjusting the tooth axis
When occlusion is regarded as a dynamic movement, the start of the posterior teeth.
of the movement is the intercuspal position where the cusps of Appropriate inclination of the occlusal plane and accen-
the maxillary and mandibular teeth are in the maximum tuation of the curve of Spee must be determined for individual
contact. At this position, the condyle and the TMJ are con- patients, as the eminence and the tooth size difference in each
sidered to be in the most stable state owing to the occlusal patient. In this study, we demonstrate that in mandibular
support. From this position, the mandible moves in a three- movement viewed in the sagittal plane, at an average sagittal
dimensional direction, i.e. protrusively, laterotrusively, and condylar inclination (SCI) of 44 , an inclination of the anterior
retrusively. In most occlusal concepts proposed so far, occlu- guidance of 54 , an inclination of retrusive guidance of 30 ,
sal guidance and posterior disocclusion are considered in and an inclination of occlusal plane of 10 , if the radius of the
the context of the protrusive or laterotrusive movement of curve of Spee is 60 mm, a molar disocclusion of 3 mm in the
the mandible, but not much attention has been paid to the protrusive movement and 1.5 mm in the retrusive movement
retrusive condylar movement on the working side. is provided. As shown in Fig. 9, this study also demonstrates
However, in patients with a skeletal Class II jaw relation- that when the radius of the curve of Spee is made smaller, the
ship or joint loosening, the condyle on the working side tends angulation of disocclusion in the retrusive movement is in-
to move backward. In such a case, posterior disocclusion can creased, facilitating disocclusion at the early period of the
be achieved by creating guidance during the protrusive man- movement. In the actual mandibular movement, the factors in
dibular movement on the inner lingual or buccal slope of the the horizontal direction are included, so to ensure appropriate
upper first premolar. However, under such a condition, if the disocclusion we will need to examine the relationship between
occlusal plane is made flat in order to provide the posterior the laterotrusive movement and the curve of Wilson.
6 1/2008 Occlusal plane and posterior disocclusion in joint loosening J. Stomat. Occ. Med.
originalarbeit
Conclusion [4] McHorris WH. Occlusion with particular emphasis on the functional
and parafunctional role of anterior teeth. Part II. J Clin Orthod
We have investigated the relationship between the inclination 1979;13:684–701.
[5] McHorris WH. The importance of anterior teeth. J Gnathol 1982;
of the occlusal plane, posterior and disocclusion during re- 1:19–36.
trusive condylar movement involving the degree of the curve [6] McHorris WH. Focus on anterior guidance. J Gnathol 1989;8(1):3–13.
of Spee. It was observed in this study that different angulations [7] Belser UC, Hannam AG. The influence of altered working-side
occlusal guidance on masticatory muscles and related jaw
of the occlusal plane and radius of the curve of Spee can affect movement. J Prosth Dent 1985;53:406–13.
the amount of posterior disocclusion in all mandibular move- [8] Toubol J-P, Michel J-F. le mouvement initial de Bennett.
ments. The study demonstrated that a steep occlusal plane can Experimentation clinique, Consequences therapeutiques. Les
Cahiers Proth 1983;42:69–87.
provide posterior interferences since the amount of posterior [9] Slavicek R. Prinzipien der okklusion. Inform Orthodont Kieferorthop
disocclusion is decreased, which is detrimental to the masti- 1982;3(4):171–212.
catory system. In addition, the compensating curve should [10] Slavicek R, Schadlbauer E, Schrangl J, Mack H. Skelettale Beziehung-
also be considered to obtain the proper disocclusion in the dentoalveolare Kompensation. Inform Orth-odont Kieferorthop
1982;3(4):215–38.
working side during retrusive movement of the mandible. [11] Slavicek R. Die Okklusionkonzepte in der Totalprothetik. Neue
Therefore, the occlusal plane inclination should be properly Functionbezogen Hilfs-mittel. Quintessence Dent Technol 1990;
and carefully analyzed and must be a part of the diagnosis and 15:491–503.
[12] Slavicek R. Die funktionellen Determ-inanten des Kauorgans. Fd.
treatment planning prior to any occlusal reconstruction. Slavicek R. Zah-narstlich-Medixiniches Schrifttum Munchen, 1984.
[13] Williamson EH, Lundquist DO. Anterior guidance: its effect on
electromyographic activity of the temporal and masseter muscles.
J Prosth Dent 1983;49:816–23.
Acknowledgements [14] Shupe R, Mohamed SE, Christensen LV, Finger IM,Weinberg R.
Effects of occlusal guidance on jaw muscle activity. J Prosth Dent
We thank Dr. Cynthia Protacio-Quismundo, DMD, FAPO, for 1984;51:811–8.
her help is preparing the manuscript. This work was per- [15] Sato S, Isaka F, Kimura S, Watanabe T, Murai S, Akimoto S. A study
formed in Research Institute of Occlusion Medicine and regarding with principles of occlusion in Japanese (in Japanese). Jpn
Research Center of Brain and Oral Science, Kanagawa Dental J Gnathol Occlusion 1996;17:89–96.
[16] Celar A, Sato S, Akimoto S, Yamamura S, Matsumoto A, Slavicek R.
College and supported by grant-in-aid for Open Research Sequential guidance with canine dominance in Japanese and
from the Japanese Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Caucasian samples. Bull Kanagawa Dent Col 1994;22:18–24.
Science and Technology. [17] Müller M. Grundlagen und Aufbau des Articulationsproblems im
natürelichen und künstlichen Gebisse, 1925.
[18] Tuazon R, Sato S. Three dimensional caracterzation of class deep bite
malocclusions with dual occlusal plane. Eur J Orthodont, &.
References [19] Kulmer S, Ruzicka B, Niederwanger A, Moschen I. Incline and length
of guiding elements in untreated naturally grown dentition. J Oral
[1] D’Amico A. The canine teeth-normal functional relation of the Rehabil 1999;26:650–60.
natural teeth of man. [20] Leja W, Hilbe M, Stainer M, Kulmer S. Non-carious cervical lesions in
[2] Goldstein GR. The Relationship of Canine-Protected Occlusion relation to occlusal pattern and guiding component inclination. (in
to a Periodontal Index. J Prosth Dent, March, 1979. Germany) Dtsch Zahnarztl Z 1999;54:412–414.
[3] McHorris WH. Occlusion with particular emphasis on the functional [21] Marion LR, Bayne SC, Shugars DA, Bader JD, Guckes AD, Scurria MS,
and parafunctional role anterior teeth. Part I. J Clin Orthod Heymann HO. Effect of occlusion type and wear on cervical lesion
1979;13:606–20. frequency. J Dent Res 1997;76:309 (Abst 2364).
J. Stomat. Occ. Med. Occlusal plane and posterior disocclusion in joint loosening 1/2008 7
INSTRUCTIONS to AUTHORS IJSOM 0/07 SPRINGERWienNewYork
You are requested to authorize us to print your paper by sending within 7 days the carefully corrected proofs to
3 complimentary copies of the relevant issue will be sent to the corresponding author.
Offprints against payment can be ordered in quantities of 50 only (maximally 150 copies).
The prices quoted are valid only for authors ordering offprints at the time of their returning the marked proofs for
their private use.
Credit card: Visa Mastercard Amex Diners Number .................................................. Expiry date ..............................
Purchase order number ......................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................................................................................................
(Name of person or institution)
...................................................................................................................................................................................................
(Address)