A Novel Syngas Production Process Design For Gas-To-Liquid (GTL) Technology
A Novel Syngas Production Process Design For Gas-To-Liquid (GTL) Technology
1 1-8, 2012
ABSTRACT
The Gas-to-Liquid (GTL) technology presents a well proven route for utilising stranded natural
gas and securing the world energy future. In this process natural gas is converted to liquid
transport fuels (naphtha and diesel) in three major stages: Methane reforming (Syngas
production), synthesis of GTL liquids from the Syngas (Fischer Tropsch process), refining of the
GTL liquids to transport fuels (Product up-grade).The Syngas production stage accounts for 60%
of the total cost of the GTL process. This is mainly due to the air separation unit (ASU) which
supplies oxygen for the reforming process. In this work a novel syngas production process is
proposed, using the oxygen ion transport membrane concept. The Oxygen ion transport
membrane is a cutting edge technology that combines air separation and high-temperature
synthesis gas generation processes into a single Oxygenmembrane reactor. This design can
reduce the capital cost of the entire process by 30%. A simulation analysis using Aspen HYSYS
proves the viability of the proposed design.
syngas production (Figure 1). This process Nickel catalyst and it produces synthesis gas
involves the cryogenic air separation unit with a H2 to CO ratio (H2/CO) typically less
(Linde Process) to obtain oxygen, and the than 2:1, on a molar bases (Wilsam, 2008).
The permeated oxygen ions immediately The conventional GTL process is capital
react with natural gas (reforming reaction) intensive; hence the plant needs to be large
with the aid of the reforming catalyst. The scaled in order to achieve economic
reaction product is syngas and is collected as operation. Synthesis gas production accounts
the main product of the reactor. As seen in for more than 60% of the total cost of the
equation 3, oxygen partial pressure ratio is plant (Kim et al., 2009). This huge capital
the driving force for oxygen transport. cost is mainly due the cryogenic air
Oxygen partial pressure is always higher on separation unit (ASU) which supplies
the bulk air side of the reactor and lower on oxygen for syngas production. The air
the permeate side due to depletion by separation unit in
reforming reaction. Figure 2 is said to be the single most
expensive unit of a GTL plant and makes up
3.0 STATEMENT OF PROBLEM 20% of the cost of a typical GTL plant
including off sites and utilities (Steynberg, 2007).
P-17
P-19 P-20 P-18 P-20
P-1 P-27
P-2 I-3
V-2
P-5
P-6
P-26
P-66 P-67 P-24
I-2
E-12 I-4
P-16
P-8
E-8
P-7
P-50 P-15
V-6 E-4
P-39
I-10
P-34 P-51 E-7
P-32 P-48
V-1
I-14 P-14
V-5
V-4
I-7 P-56
P-65
P-61
P-58 P-43 P-53 P-9 P-10 P-11 P-12
E-21
P-33
I-13
P-38 P-63 P-46 P-60 P-35 P-41
P-47
P-29
E-24
P-52 P-62
P-37
E-20
In this work, the ability of the ‘oxygen generation, making the process a net
membrane reactor’ to combine air separation electricity generator.
and methane reforming is employed, to
modify the conventional ‘HaldoeTopsoe’ 3.1 Proposed Modification of Conventional
syngas process. The objective is to greatly GTL Process
reduce the overall cost of the Gas-to-Liquid Using the Oxygen transport membrane
process, making it more economical and concept, Figure 3 is a proposed flow diagram
enhance its proliferation. To maximise the for the modification of the conventional
energy consumption of the process, the high syngas generation process; combining air
pressure, depleted-air stream is further separation and methane reforming into a
utilized in a turbine for electricity single oxygen membrane reactor with co-
power generation.
3.2 Detailed Process Description 10. The compressed air is heated to between
800oC and 900OC,the operating temperature
The two major feeds to the process are
of the oxygen membrane reactor (E-4). The
natural gas and atmospheric air, while the
heating is done by externally fired heaters
main product is syngas. The processed is
within heat exchanger-fired heater E-1. The
described based on these streams.
heated air stream P-27, is introduced to the
3.2.1 Air Stream cathode side of the oxygen
P-5
P-14
Raw Syngas
300c
I-1
P-16
CO2 rich stream Condensate P-35
Flue gas
P-42
Component splitter
E-9 E-8
E-15 CO2 Compressor
Condenser
P-17
P-19
Desulphurizer E-2 Sub-cooled Syngas
P-37
200 C
E-14
P-20
Steam vent Steam turbine
P-39 S-2 P-13
P-4
Natural Gas Feed P-6 300c
P-31
40bar Electricity
HE
P-22 P-21
P-23 I-4 E-16 Cooled Syngas
I-2
I-8 400 C
450-500 C I-5
P-12
P-7 P-24
P-32
P-8 P-19 P-18
E-1 Steam
Boiler feed water
Boiler
Fired Heater
Pre-reformer E-5
P-26 P-27
E-3
Atmospheric air 21% oxygen
30-40bar
I-7
Depleted air 3-4% oxygen
E-13
Turbine P-28
P-38 S-1
P-29
Electricity
Figure 3 : PFD of the Proposed Modification of the GTL Syngas Process using the Novel
Oxygen Membrane Reactor.
membrane reactor where some of the consumed by the anode-side reactions, the
contained oxygen is transferred to the anode partial oxygen pressure at that side will be
side to react with natural gas. The driving very low and the ratio of partial oxygen
force for oxygen permeation is the ratio of pressures very high, thereby permitting
partial oxygen pressures at the cathode and transport of oxygen.
anode side of the membrane. Since oxygen is
The oxygen permeation within the reactor hydrocarbons, to methane, carbon monoxide
produces an oxygen depleted air stream P-28 and hydrogen.
containing between 3% to 10% oxygen. This
Since the adiabatic pre-reforming is
depleted air stream is first of all heated to a
endothermic, the gas will experience a drop
temperature of about 1200oC and expanded
in temperature across the pre-former, hence
in the turbine unit E-13. The turbine drives
the resultant stream P-9 is heated to the
the compressor unit E-10 and also drives a
membrane operating temperature. The
power generator that produces part of the
methane containing stream P-10 enters the
electrical power requirement by the plant.
anode side of the oxygen membrane reactor
The expanded stream P-29 is then
at a temperature and pressure that permits
discharged through the heat exchanger-fired
the conversion of all the remaining methane
heaterE-1 where it transfers sensible heat to
to syngas (typically about 1000°C and 30-40
entering gases and the contained residual
bar pressure). The anode side of the oxygen
oxygen supports combustion of fuel to the
membrane reactor has a first section which
extent required to raise incoming cold
contains no catalyst. Process gas in the
streams to the desired temperature.
methane containing stream reacts with the
3.2.2 Natural Gas Stream permeated oxygen predominantly in a partial
oxidation reaction because of the absence of
Natural gas feed stream P-6 is heated to an
reforming catalyst. Since the reaction is
intermediate temperature of about 300°C
exothermic, the temperature of the permeate
within the heat exchanger-fired heater E-
and non-permeate side gases increase.
1, then mixed with hydrogen purge stream
Beyond this point, a catalyst is installed
P-36 and desulphurized in the
within a second section of the anode side of
desulphurization unit E-2. The resultant
reactor.
stream, having a super- reduced sulphur
content, is mixed with a stream P-23 made In the catalyst containing section of the
up of steam and recycled CO2 stream to form reactor, permeated oxygen reacts with the
a stream P-7 having the desired steam to process gases in a combined partial
carbon ratio (typically 0.6:1.5) needed to oxidation and steam reforming reaction. The
feed the pre-reformer. Stream P-7 is heated exothermic heat released by the oxidation
to between 450°C and 550°C within the heat reactions balances the endothermic heat
exchanger-fired heater E-1 and the hotter consumed by the steam reforming reactions.
stream P-8 is passed through an adiabatic The reforming reaction is promoted by the
pre-reformer E-3 which converts heavier catalyst which is either contained in the
porous support of the membrane or in a
catalyst bed adjacent to the membrane. To The syngas stream P-14 still contains some
maintain the overall and local heat balances impurities which are predominantly carbon
along the bed at a level which prevents dioxide. This carbon dioxide rich component
excessive temperature rise of the transiting is removed in an acid gas removal unit E-9,
gases, control is exercised by adjusting local which can be a liquid wash system in which
catalyst activity, gas composition, and acid gases are stripped or absorbed by an
oxidant supply. amine wash.The pure stream leaves as the
final syngas product stream P-15 for
The reactions occurring in the Oxygen
delivery to the downstream Fischer Tropsch
membrane reactor are as shown in equations
process.
(1) and (2).
4.1 Simulation Result that the modified design is viable and can
provide the same capacity as the
The simulation successfully solved at the
conventional process. The results obtained
conditions described above. This confirms
are summarised as shown in Table 1
Feed Product
Steam feed = 109, 999.998 m3/h CO2 produced = 1.803 × 107 kg/h
The integration of oxygen production and The proposed design is a net electricity
methane reforming into a single unit of producer. It integrates syngas production
oxygen membrane reactor greatly reduces with power generation into a single plant as
the size of the entire GTL plant. The reactor shown in the PFD. According to the
supplements the function of the ATR and simulation result, 43.1 MW of electricity can
ASU in the conventional design. According be produced from the proposed design.
to Paul et al. (2007) this route will reduce the This can be used to not only supply the
size of an entire GTL plant by a factor of electricity need of the syngas plant but can
about 20 and the weight in tonnage by a be exported to other parts of the entire GTL
factor of 60. This has a far reaching cost and plant.
logistics advantage especially in locations
5.4 Safety
where space is a limitation like offshore
locations. Due to the elimination of the ASU, the risk
of handling pure oxygen (which is highly
flammable) is eliminated. The oxygen
membrane reactor is designed to consume
the oxygen produced as it is being produced, 7.0 REFERENCES
eliminating the risk of explosions or fire Anderson B., The Fischer-Tropsch
outbreak due to oxygen handling. Also there Synthesis, PhD. Thesis, Department of
is no need for cryogenic oxygen tank storage Chemical Engineering, McMaster
thereby eliminating the possibility of boiling University, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada. 2004
liquid expansion vapour explosion (BLEVE)
which is possible in the conventional ATR Andrew S., “A Growing Focus on
process. Unconventional Oil.-A Major Oil
Company’s View of Prospects and
Potential”. Shell – Global Business
6.0 CONCLUSION Environment.EIA Midterm Energy Outlook
and Modelling Conference 12th April, 2005.
The proposed syngas production process will
offer great cost savings in the Gas-to-Liquid
Chen M., Dyer N., Gerdes F., Lowe M.,
process. Most of the capital and running cost
Akhave R., Rowley R., Asen I., and Eriksen
savings will be due to the elimination of the
HAn integrated ITM Syngas/Fischer-
air separation unit, compactness, and lower
Tropsch Process for GTL Conversion,
electricity consumption. The simulation
Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis,
result shows that the proposed process is
Elsevier Science, Vol.112 pp 887-874. 2007.
viable and is more economically advantaged,
than the conventional HaldorTopsoe process.
Christopher H., Synthesis Gas Processes for
These cost savings will make the GTL Synfuels Production, presented at
technology more economically viable and EUROGAS '90 Trondheim, June 2000.
commercially attracting, leading to more
energy security in the wake of crude oil Christopher M. C ‘Ceramic membrane
depletion. GTL offers a source of cleaner reactor systems for converting natural gas to
transport fuels that meet the emerging and hydrogen’, U.S. Dept. of Energy hydrogen
more stringent environmental program annual conference, May 24, 2004.
laws/regulations. It also offers a means of
Douglas, M. Chemical and Process
utilizing stranded natural gas, preventing gas
Technology Encyclopaedia, Revised Edition,
flaring, reducing CO2 emissions and at the
Wiley, New York, 2001
same time monetizing otherwise wasted
energy resources.
Dry, E. The Fischer–Tropsch process: 1950– NorbyT., and Larring YMixed Hydrogen-
2000. Catalysis Today .Vol. 71, pp 227–241, Electron Conductors for Hydrogen
2002. Permeable Membranes, Studies in Surface
Science and Catalysis, Elsevier Vol 86 pp
Dyer, N., Richards E., and Russek, LIon 185-186, 2006.
transport membrane technology for Oxygen
Separation and Power production, Studies in Paul N., Nobin B., Steven L., and Dale M.,
Surface Science and Catalysis, Elsevier, Vol “Ion Transport Membrane Technology For
12 pp 87-88, 2000. Syngas Production Separation And Syngas
Production”, Science Direct Journal , 2000.
Emmanuel, O., Tayo, F., and Wakeel, I., Accessed 25 October, 2010
“Application of the Fischer Tropsch www.sciencedirect.com.
Synthesis Gas-To-Liquids Process to the
Paul Schubert, Carles Bayens, & Larry
Economic Evaluation of Natural Gas: The
Weick, Development Progress for GTL
Case of Nigeria”. 3rd IAEE Conference, Rio
Fuels, Speciality Products., Syntroleum
De Janeiro, 2010.
Corp., Tulsa, Oil & Gas Journal - March
12, 2001.
Jager B., “Development of Fischer-Tropsch
Reactors” .American Institute of Chemical
Paul, D., Robin, E., Russek, L., and Dale, T.,
Engineering. Spring Meeting, New Orleans,
“Ion Transport Membrane Technology for
1st April 2003.
Oxygen Separation and Syngas Production”,
Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis,
Kevin H., A Case Study of Oryx GTL, Oil
Elsevier Science, London Vol 180 pp 99-
and Gas Technology Report, Qatar. 2006.
111, 2007.