Rubrics for Assessment of CP

Attributes A+ B+ C- F
(1.0) (0.7) (0.4) (0.1)
The The The The
explanation/literatu explanation/literatu explanation/literature explanation/literature
re review contains re review contains review contains few review contains no
Background
major points of the some points of the points of the main significant point of the
Knowledge/Literat
main idea being main idea being idea being main idea being
ure Review
investigated/focuse investigated/focuse investigated/focused/a investigated/focused/as
d/asked d/asked sked ask

Problem Problem Problem identification Problem identification

identification and identification and and formulation and formulation
formulation has formulation has contains some flaws contains major flaws
Problem been correctly done been done
Formulation appropriately

Nearly all of the Majority of the Some of the required No significant dada
required data has required data has data has been missed. has been collected.
Collection of been collected. been collected with
Critical Data few elements
missing.

Due consideration Some Less consideration has No significant

has been given to consideration has been given to the consideration has been
the constraints and been given to the constraints and given to the constraints
Consideration to
available constraints and available and available
Constraints and
alternates/routes available alternates/routes while alternates/routes while
Available
while examining alternates/routes examining the examining the problem
Alternates (if any)
the problem at while examining problem at hand. at hand.
hand. the problem at
hand.
 Correct approach Reasonably correct Approach for data Incorrect procedure
has been employed approach has been analysis contains has been employed for
for data analysis employed for data flaws that brings data analysis with no
Data Handling & with valid analysis with conclusion in question valid conclusions
Interpretation conclusions acceptable
conclusions

An appropriate A reasonable Solution/approach for Solution/approach for

solution/approach solution/approach addressing queries addressing queries
Quality of
has been put forth has been put forth contains some flaws contains major flaws
Solution/Approach
to address the to address the
queries queries

Effective and Adequate Some development of No significant

Critical insightful development of a a point of view on the development of a point
Thinking/Commen development of a point of view on issue. of view on the issue.
ts/Justification point of view on the issue.
the issue.

Problem is well- Problem is Problem presentation Approach is poorly

Presentation of presented, appropriately and flow of discussion presented
Approach imparting good presented, contain flaws
Towards Solution clarity imparting
reasonable clarity

Report is well- Report is organized Report organization Report is poorly

organized appropriately, and flow of discussion organized imparting no
imparting good imparting contain flaws that clarity with improper
Organization
clarity with correct reasonable clarity impair the clarity for flow of discussion
flow of discussion with acceptable reader
flow of discussion

2 for each first 8 attribute + 4 for last attribute

 Rubrics for Assessment of Case Study

Attributes A+ B+ C- F
(1.0) (0.7) (0.4) (0.1)
Major points of Some points of the Few points of No significant point of
information/main information/main information/main idea information/main idea
Deduction of
idea being idea being being being
Critical
investigated/focuse investigated/focuse investigated/focused/a investigated/focused/as
Information
d/asked has been d/asked has been sked has been ked has been extracted.
extracted. extracted. extracted.

Due consideration Some Less consideration has No significant

has been given to consideration has been given to the consideration has been
the constraints and been given to the constraints and given to the constraints
Consideration to
available constraints and available and available
Constraints and
alternates/routes available alternates/routes while alternates/routes while
Available
while examining alternates/routes examining the examining the problem
Alternates (if any)
the problem at while examining problem at hand. at hand.
hand. the problem at
hand.

An appropriate A reasonable Solution/approach for Solution/approach for

solution/approach solution/approach addressing queries addressing queries
Quality of
has been put forth has been put forth contains some flaws contains major flaws
Solution/Approach
to address the to address the
queries queries

Case is well- Case is Case presentation and Case is poorly

presented, appropriately flow of discussion presented, imparting
imparting good presented, contain flaws that no clarity with
Presentation of
clarity with correct imparting impair the clarity improper flow of
Case
flow of discussion reasonable clarity discussion
with acceptable
flow of discussion

2.5 for each attribute of Case Study