You are on page 1of 21

Dr Hari Prasad Dasari

Design Aspects of Cyclones Chemical Engineering Department


NITK

Introduction
Cyclones provide a relatively low-cost method of removing particulate matter fro
m exhaust gas streams.

Their removal efficiency is accordingly much better than that of settling


chambers.

However, cyclones are not as efficient as electrostatic precipitators, baghouses,


and venturi scrubbers but are often installed as pre-cleaners before these more
effective devices.

Chemical Engineering Department Dr. Hari Prasad Dasari


Dr Hari Prasad Dasari
Separation PrincipleChemical Engineering Department
NITK

Particle Collection Process

Particles enter the device with the flowing


gas (see Fig); the gas stream is forced to t
urn, but the larger particles have more mo
mentum and cannot turn with the gas.

These larger particles impact and fall down the cyclone wall and are collected
in a hopper.

The gas stream actually turns a number of times in a helical pattern,


much like the funnel of a tornado.

Chemical Engineering Department Dr. Hari Prasad Dasari


Dr Hari Prasad Dasari
Chemical Engineering Department
NITK

The range of particle sizes collected in a cyclone is dependent upon the over
all diameter and relative dimensions of the device.

Stacking cyclones in series or in parallel can provide further alternatives for i


mproving overall collection efficiency.

There are three types of cyclones.


They are usually characterized by where the gas enters and exits the cyclone b
ody (tangentially, axially, or peripherally).

(1) Top Inlet


(2) Axial Inlet
(3) Bottom Inlet

Chemical Engineering Department Dr. Hari Prasad Dasari


Dr Hari Prasad Dasari
Chemical Engineering Department
NITK

Axial Inlet

Top Inlet

Bottom Inlet
Chemical Engineering Department Dr. Hari Prasad Dasari
Dr Hari Prasad Dasari
Nomenclature for a tangential entry cyclone.Chemical Engineering Department
NITK

Dr. Hari Prasad Dasari


Dr Hari Prasad Dasari
Chemical Engineering Department
NITK

Cyclones in series

Cyclones in Parallel
Dr Hari Prasad Dasari
Cyclones in series Chemical Engineering Department
NITK

Larger particles can be collected in the first cyclone and a smaller, more efficie
nt cyclone can collect smaller particles.

Such an arrangement can reduce dust loading in the second cyclone and avoid
problems of abrasion and plugging.

If the first cyclone should plug, there still will be some collection occurring in the s
cond cyclone.

The additional pressure drop produced by the second cyclone adds to the ove
rall pressure drop of the system.

“The higher pressure drop can be a disadvantage in such a series system des
ign.”

Dr. Hari Prasad Dasari


Dr Hari Prasad Dasari
Cyclones in Parallel Chemical Engineering Department
NITK

Cyclones in parallel use a common inlet, higher volumes of gas can be treat
ed at reasonable pressure drops.

In configurations where a common hopper is used, each cyclone should


have the same pressure drop.

The axial entry type minimizes the eddy formation that is common in tangenti
al entry cyclones.

Dr. Hari Prasad Dasari


Dr Hari Prasad Dasari
Chemical Engineering Department
DESIGN AND PERFORMANCE EQUATIONS
NITK

Objects moving in circular paths tend to move away from the center of their
motion.

The object moves outward as if a force is pushing it out (Centrifugal Force).

The whirling motion of the gas in a cyclone causes particulate matter in the gas
to sense this force and move out to the walls.

An expression for this force is as follows:

Dr. Hari Prasad Dasari


Dr Hari Prasad Dasari
Chemical Engineering Department
NITK

These types of considerations (equation), in conjunction with considerations of


cyclone geometry and vortex formation, have led to the development of
numerous performance equations.

These equations attempt to characterize the behavior of cyclones.


(Some work well, and some do not (Ex: High Pressure, High Temperature)

Three important parameters can be used to characterize cyclone performance:

Dr. Hari Prasad Dasari


Dr Hari Prasad Dasari
Cut diameter (dpc) Chemical Engineering Department
NITK

The cut diameter is defined as the size (diameter) of particles collected


with 50% efficiency.

It is a convenient way of defining efficiency for a control device since it


provides information on the effectiveness for a particle size range.

A frequently used expression for cut diameter is:

Dr. Hari Prasad Dasari


Dr Hari Prasad Dasari
Chemical Engineering Department
NITK

Typical size efficiency curve

Dr. Hari Prasad Dasari


Dr Hari Prasad Dasari
Collection Efficiency (E) Chemical Engineering Department
NITK

A number of equations have been developed for determining the fractional


cyclone efficiency (Ei) for a given size particle.

Fractional Efficiency is defined as the fraction of particles of a given size


collected in the cyclone, compared to those of that size going into the cyclone.

Two methods of calculating cyclone efficiency

(1) Leith and Licht theory for calculating fractional efficiency


(2) Lapple theory for calculating fractional efficiency

Dr. Hari Prasad Dasari


Dr Hari Prasad Dasari
Chemical Engineering Department
NITK

(1) Leith and Licht theory for calculating fractional efficiency (1973):

In this expression, c is a factor that is a function only of the cyclone’s dimensions

The value of n is dependent on the cyclone


diameter and temperature of the gas strea
m.

Dr. Hari Prasad Dasari


Dr Hari Prasad Dasari
Chemical Engineering Department
NITK

(2) Lapple theory for calculating fractional efficiency (1951):

Cyclone collection efficiency (vs) particle size ratio

Dr. Hari Prasad Dasari


Dr Hari Prasad Dasari
Chemical Engineering Department
NITK

The sum of these products in the rightmost section of the box will give the
overall efficiency.

Dr. Hari Prasad Dasari


Dr Hari Prasad Dasari
Pressure drop Chemical Engineering Department
NITK

The pressure drop across a cyclone is an important parameter to the purchaser


of such equipment.

Increased pressure drop means greater costs for power to move an exhaust
gas through the control device.

With cyclones, an increase in pressure drop usually means that there will be
an improvement in collection efficiency

For these reasons, there have been many attempts to predict pressure drops
from design variables.

The idea is that having such an equation, one could work back and optimize
the design of new cyclones.

Dr. Hari Prasad Dasari


Dr Hari Prasad Dasari
Chemical Engineering Department
NITK

An expression occasionally used is:

where q = volumetric flow rate.


kc = dimensionless factor (vanes)
= 0.5 (without vanes)
= 1 (vanes that do not expand the entering gas or touch the outlet wall
= 2 (vanes that expand and touch the wall)

This equation, when compared to experimental data, was found to have


a poor correlation coefficient.
Dr. Hari Prasad Dasari
Dr Hari Prasad Dasari
Chemical Engineering Department
NITK

The most popular of the empirical pressure drop equations has the form:

where Kc = proportionality factor

Low-efficiency cyclones 2–4 in H2O (5–10cm H2O)


Medium-efficiency cyclones 4–6 in H2O (10–15cm H2O)
High-efficiency cyclones 8–10 in H2O (20–25cm H2O
)

Dr. Hari Prasad Dasari


Dr Hari Prasad Dasari
Chemical Engineering Department
Changes in the performance characteristics
NITK

Dr. Hari Prasad Dasari


Effect of operation variables on cyclone Drand
Hari Prasad Dasari
Chemical Engineering Department
performance: NITK

Dr. Hari Prasad Dasari

You might also like