Professional Documents
Culture Documents
com
ScienceDirect
Comprehensive Psychiatry 67 (2016) 46 – 53
www.elsevier.com/locate/comppsych
Abstract
Objectives: The aim of this study was to analyze the predictors of dental anxiety in 5 to 7-year-old children in a two years follow-up.
Materials and methods: This is a longitudinal study conducted with 784 children with 5 to 7 years old. A face-to-face interview was
conducted with the parents. The Dental Anxiety Question (DAQ) answers were categorized as presence or absence of dental anxiety. The
possible predictor factors analyzed were: related to the children (age, sex, parentage, childbirth, physical activity, body satisfaction,
psychological well-being, physical well-being, dentist visit); and related to the parents or guardians (excessive alcohol consumption, smoke,
family income, number of children). Forward stepwise logistic binary regression was performed for the multivariate analysis. The analysis
was controlled by gender.
Results: The prevalence of dental anxiety was 17.4%. Children in lower family income had 2.3 (95% CI: 1.3–4.0) greater chance to report
high dental anxiety in comparison to children in higher family income. Similarly, children's parents who reported lower psychological well-
being had 1.5 (95% CI: 1.0–3.0) greater chance to report high dental anxiety in comparison to children's parents with higher psychological
well-being.
Conclusions: The prevalence of dental anxiety was high, and the family income and psychological well-being were inversely associated to
dental anxiety in children.
Clinical relevance: Knowing the dental anxiety predictors could help the pediatric dentist to analyze and understand who is more susceptible
to develop dental anxiety. An adequate approach, a trust relationship could be built, improving the oral health conditions and reducing the
need of treatment in children.
© 2016 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
representing a serious challenge for dentists [7]. Eitner et al. Study of Health and Well-being in Preschool Children) was
(2006) reported that the highest level of dental anxiety is designed to assess longitudinal changes in health conditions,
related to the evasion of dental treatment, increasing dental physical activity practices, anthropometric parameters, motor
caries, as well as the DMFS (decayed (D), missing (M), or skill performance and other lifestyle factors among preschool
filled (F)) indices [8]. children and in school age. Baseline data were collected by
Possobon et al. (2007) showed a causal chain in relation graduate students in physical education properly calibrated
to dental anxiety and avoidance of dental treatment. Patient between September and November of 2010, in preschools of
with dental anxiety has a tendency to avoid dental treatment, Recife, Pernambuco state, Brazil. However, the oral health
which leads to an oral health deterioration, requiring more evaluation was only included in the first follow-up (September
complex and invasive treatments, increasing the potential of to November of 2012).
pain, coming back to dental anxiety, and causing greater The protocol was approved by the Human Research
chance to avoid the dental treatment. Therefore, the subject Ethics Committee of the University of Pernambuco (protocol
only accepts treatment when the symptoms of pain become no. 0096.0.097.000-10) and informed written consent was
unbearable [9]. obtained from the children's parents or guardians and the
In a cross-sectional study including 970, 5–12 years-old respective school principals.
children, Colares et al. (2013) found a prevalence of dental
anxiety of 14.4%. Additionally, they identified that children 2.2. Participants
who had toothache had 1.55 higher chances to have dental The target population of the study at baseline was three to
anxiety than those who did not felt toothache [1]. Nicolas et al. five-year-old preschool children who were enrolled in both
(2010) monitored 1303 five to twelve years-old French children public and private preschools in the six political administra-
and observed a lower prevalence 7.6% with dental anxiety tive regions (PAR) of Recife. A sampling procedure of
(7.6%). Additionally, those who had dental caries or children clusters in a single stage was adopted for sample selection,
who thought they had dental problems were more anxious than and the school was the sample unit. All schools in Recife
those who did not had caries or thought not have caries [10]. with preschool children were eligible to be included in the
Wogelius et al. (2005) in a cohort study, determined the study. Stratification criterion was adopted in order to ensure
prevalence of missed dental appointments among Danish that the sample represented the target population regarding
children with 6–8 years of age and also the association the distribution: type of school (public and private), size
between dental anxiety and missed dental appointments. The (small: b 50 children enrolled in early childhood education;
authors concluded that 37.7% of children missed at least one medium: 50 to 199 children enrolled; large: 200 children or
dental visit; however, children with dental anxiety had not more) and the distribution of these according to the six
higher odds to miss two or more dental visits compared with administrative regions political (RPA). In each selected
children without dental anxiety. In this study only toothache school, all regularly enrolled children were invited to
leads the children to miss two or more dental visits (OR: participate in the study [12] (subjects' inclusion criteria)
2.61; 95% CI: 1.63–4.18) [11]. with 1155 children accepting to participate in the baseline.
To reduce the consequences generated by dental anxiety After two years, the project has a follow-up rate of 76% (n =
and adopt an adequate approach it is necessary to identify the 784) (Fig. 1). For the analysis conducted in the present study,
causative factors. Besides caries and toothache as known it is possible to detect as significant risk ratio higher than 1.5,
associated factors of dental anxiety, there are others factors with 95% confidence interval, and statistical power higher
that should be investigated, as family income; parents' than 80%.
consumption of alcohol and smoking; children's physical
activity and screen time; children's body satisfaction; child's 2.3. Measures
psychological aspects; and frequency of visits to the dentist. 2.3.1. Psychological and physical well-being
Furthermore, most studies used cross-sectional designs to A standardized face-to-face interview was conducted with
analyze dental anxiety correlates which do not allow the parents. Four questions were pooled to give a proxy measure
inferring about causality. Therefore longitudinal studies are of “psychological well-being” and the “physical well-being”
needed to analyze the possible causes of dental anxiety. was obtained pooling other two questions (Table 1).
Thus, the objective of this study was to analyze the For the computation of the variables psychological and
predictors of dental anxiety in children 5–7 years by of a physical well-being, it was attributed scores from 1 (lowest
school-based longitudinal study. level) to 5 (highest level), then the weighted mean was
calculated and categorized in tertiles.
2. Materials and methods 2.3.2. Physical activity
2.1. Procedure The time spent in physical activity (games and outdoor
active activities) and screen time (tv, computer and video
A longitudinal study with preschool children aged three to games) were computed considering parents' answers in
five years started in 2010. The ELOS-Pre Project (Longitudinal regard of their child in both activities during morning,
48 F.C. Soares et al. / Comprehensive Psychiatry 67 (2016) 46–53
afternoon, and evening at the week, and weekend days. For with four possible answers: “No”, “Yes, a little bit”, “Yes,
each period of the day we recorded the time in the categories: he/she has fear”, and “Yes, he/she has a lot of fear”. The
0 min (0), 1–15 min (1), 16–30 min (2) 31–60 min (3) and children were considered with dental anxiety when their
more than 60 min (4). parents informed that they have a lot of fear. From the 784
The scores were calculated adding the responses in the monitored children, 747 had valid data on the dental anxiety
morning, afternoon and evening, with a range from 0 to 12 component. Prior to the study, we have had conducted a pilot
points. The total score (weekday + weekend day) was study in which we have tested the reliability test intraex-
calculated and the amplitude variation was 0–24 points. aminer for this questioner (Kappa = 0.94) and also, the
Children who reported active time participation in sports and reliability test interexaminer (Kappa 0.89) [16].
games outdoor less than 60 min per day were classified as
less active. More detailed description of this measurement 2.4. Strategy of analysis
was described by Oliveira et al. (2012) [13,14].
Data analyses were performed using SPSS for windows
2.3.3. Dental anxiety (version 22). For descriptive purposes crude and relative
Children's dental anxiety was obtained by the Dental frequencies are presented. Differences between categorical
Anxiety Question (DAQ) [15] in which parents were variables were assessed using chi-square test. Forward
questioned: “Your child have fear to go to the dentist?”, stepwise binary logistic regression was performed to
F.C. Soares et al. / Comprehensive Psychiatry 67 (2016) 46–53 49
Table 1
Composition of the variables: “Psychological well-being” and “physical well-being”.
Variables Questions Possible answers
Extremely
Quite a bit
Limitations for emotional or behavioral problems in the last month
Slightly
Not at all
Deeply unsatisfied
Unsatisfied
Satisfied with the capacity of having friends in the last month Not satisfied neither unsatisfied
Satisfied
Greatly satisfied
Psychological well-being Deeply unsatisfied
Unsatisfied
Satisfied with their life (child) in the last month Not satisfied neither unsatisfied
Satisfied
Greatly satisfied
All of the time
Most of the time
Seem upset or sad Some of the time
A little of the time
None of the time
Extremely
Quite a bit;
Limitations for healthy physical problems in the last month
Slightly
Physical well-being
Not at all
No
Disease
Yes
Table 2
Social and behavioral characteristics of the participants at the baseline (2010), follow-up (2012) and the drop-outs.
Variables 2010 a (n = 1185) Drop-outs b (n = 401) 2012 a (n = 784)
Table 3
Chi-square test between child information, parental or guardian data, and family data factors at the baseline with dental anxiety at the follow-up.
Dental anxiety
Variables No Yes p
n % n %
Child information
Male 316 80.8 75 19.2
Gender 0.179
Female 301 84.6 55 15.4
3 95 86.4 15 13.6
Age (years) 4 178 82.0 39 18.0 0.580
5 321 82.5 68 17.5
Nature 510 82.3 110 17.7
Parentage 0.346
Adoptive 48 77.4 14 22.6
Normal 293 79.2 77 20.8
Childbirth 0.053
Cesarean 265 84.9 47 15.1
1st tertile 182 79.8 46 20.2
Physical activity 2nd tertile 180 81.8 40 18.2 0.835
3rd tertile 165 81.7 37 18.3
1st tertile 162 79.4 42 20.6
Screen time 2nd tertile 216 83.1 44 16.9 0.537
3rd tertile 150 79.8 38 20.2
No 424 82.7 89 17.3
Body satisfaction 0.296
Yes 128 79.0 34 21.0
1st tertile 150 75.8 48 24.2
Psychological well-being 2nd tertile 255 85.0 45 15.0 0.028
3rd tertile 143 83.1 29 16.9
1st tertile 192 78.7 52 21.3
Physical well-being 2nd tertile 226 85.9 37 14.1 0.082
3rd tertile 131 79.9 33 20.1
No 223 82.3 48 17.7
Dentist visit (last year) 0.740
Yes 330 81.3 76 18.7
Parental factors
b5 103 78.6 28 21.4
Excessive alcohol consumption (doses) 0.472
≥5 119 82.1 26 17.9
No 424 82.7 89 17.3
Smoke 0.296
Yes 128 79.0 34 21.0
Family data
≤2 389 79.1 103 20.9
Family income Brazilian (minimum wages) 0.001
N2 161 89.9 18 10.1
≤2 387 84.1 73 15.9
Number of children (mom) 0.024
N2 171 77.0 51 23.0
In the initial association analyzes with dental anxiety, six out from the best of our knowledge this is one of the first studies to
of 14 variables had p b 0.25 (Table 3) and were tested in the analyze dental anxiety in this age group. In preschool age (3–
multiple logistic regression model. Among the predictive factors 5 years) is the period which the children's personality is built,
tested in the regression model, gender, number of children, and the constitution of the children's personality when the children
birth were not predictors of dental anxiety at 5–7 years. Children learn new skills and establish their behaviors [17]. Since the
in family with until two minimum wages at the baseline had 2.3 6 years of age, the children faces profound social changes,
times higher odds to have dental anxiety at 5–7 years. In relation starts at school, and suffers the social responsibility of being
to the psychological well-being, children in lower tertile of accepted by peers [18]. In consequence, high levels of anxiety
psychological well-being at baseline had 53% higher odds of have been evidenced in these children [19].
having dental anxiety at 5–7 years compared to children in the The majority of the published papers do not include a big
highest tertile of psychological well-being (Table 4). range of the possible associated factors to dental anxiety in
one single investigation. Therefore, some publications might
have not included important components for a better
4. Discussion understanding of dental anxiety in children [1,19–21].
Another differential of the present paper is the data collection
The present study analyzed comprehensively the predictors being performed in the school environment, since the
of dental anxiety in 5 to 7-years-old children. The age range at majority of the studies [3,6,7,17] performed the data
the baseline (3–5 years) is a differential in this study, because collection in the dentist office which could inflate the
F.C. Soares et al. / Comprehensive Psychiatry 67 (2016) 46–53 51
Table 4
Binary logistic regression of the predictors of dental anxiety at 6 years old.
Crude model Adjusted model I Adjusted model II
Variable
OR (IC 95%) p OR (IC 95%) p OR (IC 95%) p
Family income (minimum wages)
≤2 2.36 (1.39–4.037) 0.002 2.25 (1.26–4.03) 0.006 2.26 (1.26–4.04) 0.006
N2 1 1 1
Number of children (mom)
≤2 1 1 1
N2 1.58 (1.06–2.36) 0.025 1.47 (0.96–2.24) 0.074 1.45 (0.95–2.23) 0.081
Gender
Male – – 1.15 (0.76–1.73) 0.501
Female 1
Childbirth
Normal 1.48 (0.99–2.21) 0.053 1.29 (0.84–1.99) 0.249 1.30 (0.84–2.01) 0.233
Cesarean 1 1 1
Psychological well-being
1st tertile 1.61 (1.03–2.54) 0.037 1.52 (1.03–2.97) 0.042 1.53 (1.03–2.97) 0.041
2nd tertile 0.99 (0.58–1.69) 0.975 1.06 (0.58–1.95) 0.746 1.06 (0.58–1.96) 0.675
3rd tertile 1 1 1
Physical well-being
1st tertile 1.07 (0.66–1.75) 0.772 0.79 (0.42–1.52) 0.492 0.79 (0.41–1.51) 0.483
2nd tertile 0.65 (0.39–1.09) 0.102 0.59 (0.34–1.04) 0.070 0.59 (0.33–1.04) 0.068
3rd tertile 1 1 1
Adjusted model I — dependent variable + independent variables; adjusted model II — dependent variable + independent variables + gender.
measure of dental anxiety/phobia. Because the children and anxiety) had significantly fewer close friends, fewer
the parents outside the dentist office do not suffer the organized activities, and a nearly four times higher frequency
influence of the dentist environment (i.e. dental instruments, of personal professional support as compared to the
sounds or the characteristic smell of a dentist office). reference-group patients (no dental anxiety) [24]. The dental
Children in lower family income at baseline had two anxiety is associated to the social and emotional well-being
times higher chance to have dental anxiety at the follow-up of quality of life [29]. Children with problems in their social
compared to the family with higher income. Previous studies and emotional well-being perceptions generally feel inferior
also demonstrated that higher family income is associated comparing to their peers, are ashamed of their relatives, and
with lower prevalence of dental anxiety [1,3,5,22–24]. It is do not know how to deal with their life problems. Therefore,
practically consensual that subjects with higher social, these factors could lead to dental anxiety during the dental
financial, and environmental resources have better health treatment [30]. The impulsive temper, challenger, and
profiles [25,26]. The association between anxiety and intolerant to frustration, associated to cognitive deficits and
financial condition might be explained with the fact that inability with social interaction could contribute to inade-
lower income subjects face more problems, not having quate behavior, like dental anxiety [31]. Children with social
leisure opportunities, or education, resulting in higher levels and emotional problems are silent, sad, friendless, and with
of anxiety. Therefore, the socioeconomic level could be lower academic performance [32]. The pediatric dentist
faced as a modifier effect between the dental treatment and challenge is to identify these children an intervene aiming to
anxiety [27]. Another aspect to be considered is the fact that reduce their dental anxiety. Consequently, dentists with
Brazilian children from lower family income usually receive appropriate approach to children with dental anxiety would
dental treatment in the public health system. It is a cultural reduce children's dental anxiety, increasing the number of
flaw the unawareness of how to deal with these children, and visits to the dentist and impact in the children's oral health
this lack of knowledge leads to a failure approach, leading to and well-being.
an over valorization of quantitative results, completely The prevalence of dental anxiety in 5 to 7-years-old
disconnected to an emotional approach. In that way, children was 17.4%. This result is similar to the result
emphasizing the need of special attention to lower family presented by Colares et al. (2013), in which 14.4% of the
income children in relation to dental anxiety should be children had dental anxiety [1]. The prevalence of children
considered by the pediatric dentists [28]. with dental anxiety is high, deserving attention, because
Children with lower psychological well-being (lower children with dental anxiety visit the dentist less often,
tertile) at baseline had 53% higher chance of having dental reflecting a higher possibility of caries, and higher loss of
anxiety in the follow-up comparing to children with higher teeth affected by disease, influencing in their general health
psychological well-being level (higher tertile). As demon- and in their quality of life [10,33–35]. Olak et al. (2013)
strated by Gustafsson et al., study-group patients (dental confirmed that dental anxiety was highly associated to caries
52 F.C. Soares et al. / Comprehensive Psychiatry 67 (2016) 46–53
[19] Aminabadi NA, Pourkazemi M, Babapour J, Oskouei SG. The impact community, provider and regulatory sectors. BMC Oral Health
of maternal emotional intelligence and parenting style on child anxiety 2008;8:8, http://dx.doi.org/10.1186/1472-6831-8-8.
and behavior in the dental setting. Med Oral Patol Oral Cir Bucal [29] Luoto A, Lahti S, Tolvanen M, Locker D. Oral-health-related quality
2012;17:1089-95, http://dx.doi.org/10.4317/medoral.17839. of life among children with and without dental fear; 2009115-20,
[20] Ferreira CM, Diogo E, Filho G, Bonecker GV, Holanda EM, Deus G http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-263X.2008.00943.x.
De, et al. Dental anxiety: score, prevalence and behavior. Rev Bras Em [30] Ten Berge M, Veerkamp JS, Hoogstraten J, Prins PJ. Childhood dental
Promoção Da Saúde 2004;17:51-5. fear in The Netherlands: prevalence and normative data. Community
[21] Krikken JB, Wijk AJ Van, Cate JM, Veerkamp JSJ. Child dental anxiety, Dent Oral Epidemiol 2002;30:101-7.
parental rearing style and referral status of children. Community Dent [31] Pinheiro MIS, Haase VG, Del Prette A, Amarante CLD, Del Prette
Health 2012;29:289-92, http://dx.doi.org/10.1922/CDH. ZAP. Training parent social skills for families of children with
[22] Oliveira MMT, Colares V. The relationship between dental anxiety and behavior problems. Psicol Reflexão E Crítica 2006;19:407-14, http://
dental pain in children aged 18 to 59 months: a study in Recife, dx.doi.org/10.1590/S0102-79722006000300009.
Pernambuco state, Brazil. Cad Saude Publica 2009;25:743-50, http:// [32] Rubin KH, Coplan RJ, Bowker JC. Social withdrawal in childhood.
dx.doi.org/10.1590/S0102-311X2009000400005. Annu Rev Psychol 2009;60:141-71, http://dx.doi.org/10.1146/
[23] Colares V, Caraciolo GM, Miranda AM, Araújo GVB de, Guerra P. annurev.psych.60.110707.163642.
Fear and/or anxiety related to the avoidance of dental visits. Arq Cent [33] Pohjola V, Lahti S, Tolvanen M, Hausen H. Dental fear and oral health
Estud Curso Odontol Univ Fed Minas Gerais 2004;40:59-72. habits among adults in Finland. Acta Odontol Scand 2008;66:148-53,
[24] Gustafsson A, Arnrup K, Broberg AG, Bodin L, Berggren U. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/00016350802089459.
Psychosocial concomitants to dental fear and behaviour management [34] Pramila M, Archana KM, Chandrakala B, Ranganath S. Dental fear in
problems. Int J Paediatr Dent 2007;17:449-59, http://dx.doi.org/ children and its relation to dental caries and gingival condition — a
10.1111/j.1365-263X.2007.00883.x. cross sectional study in Bangalore City, India. Int J Clin Dent Sci
[25] McEwen BS. How socioeconomic status may “get under the skin” and 2010;1:1-5.
affect the heart. Eur Heart J 2002;23:1727-8, http://dx.doi.org/10.1053/ [35] Olak J, Saag M, Vahlberg T, Söderling E, Karjalainen S. Caries
euhj.2002.3283. prevention with xylitol lozenges in children related to maternal anxiety.
[26] Kristenson M, Eriksen HR, Sluiter JK, Starke D, Ursin H. A demonstration project. Eur Arch Paediatr Dent 2012;13:64-9.
Psychobiological mechanisms of socioeconomic differences in health. [36] Olak J, Saag M, Honkala S, Nõmmela R, Runnel R, Honkala E, et al.
Soc Sci Med 2004;58:1511-22, http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0277- Children's dental fear in relation to dental health and parental dental
9536(03)00353-8. fear. Stomatologija 2013;15:26-31.
[27] Roazzi A, Dias MGBB, Silva JO da, dos Santos LB, Roazzi MM. What [37] Nigam AG, Marwah N, Goenka P, Chaudhry A. Correlation of general
is emotion? Searching the organizational structure of children's anxiety and dental anxiety in children aged 3 to 5 years: a clinical
concept of emotion. Psicol Reflexão E Crítica 2011;24:51-61, http:// survey. J Int Oral Heal JIOH 2013;5:18-24.
dx.doi.org/10.1590/S0102-79722011000100007. [38] Stenebrand A, Wide Boman U, Hakeberg M. Dental anxiety and symptoms
[28] Barker JC, Horton SB. An ethnographic study of Latino preschool of general anxiety and depression in 15-year-olds. Int J Dent Hyg
children's oral health in rural California: intersections among family, 2013;11:99-104, http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1601-5037.2012.00551.x.