You are on page 1of 8

See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.

net/publication/315767023

PREVALENCE OF DENTAL PHOBIA AMONG PATIENTS AT DENTAL CLINICS IN


UAE

Article  in  Gulf Medical Journal · January 2016

CITATIONS READS

0 271

6 authors, including:

Hossam Eid
Gulf Medical University
41 PUBLICATIONS   38 CITATIONS   

SEE PROFILE

Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:

Evaluation of Nanostructured Surface Dental Implants in Diabetic Animal Model View project

All content following this page was uploaded by Hossam Eid on 04 April 2017.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.


GMJ ORAL PROCEEDINGS
GULF MEDICAL JOURNAL

PREVALENCE OF DENTAL PHOBIA AMONG PATIENTS AT


DENTAL CLINICS IN UAE
Syeda Sheema1, Safa Khan1, Zaid Muayad1, Ali Thaier1, Meera Obaid1*, Hossam A. Eid2
1Level10 Dental Students, College of Dentistry, 2PhD, Associate Professor, Periodontology Department, College of Dentistry,
Gulf Medical University. Ajman, UAE
*Presenting Author

ABSTRACT
Introduction: Dental phobia is a serious psychological condition with a multi-factorial etiology.
Most cases of dental phobia can be attributed to traumatic or painful dental experiences. Patients
with this phobia tend to avoid dental visits, which endangers their oral health.
Objective: The objective of the study was to assess the prevalence and possible causes of dental
phobia in dental patients in the UAE.
Materials & Methods: A random sample of 250 dental patients aged 12–37 years received
questionnaires that covered aspects such as sociodemographic factors, dental anxiety/phobia, and
related causes.
Results: The study indicated that dental phobia was more prevalent among females (22.8%) than
males (18.3%). When the association of dental procedures with dental phobia was evaluated, of 250
patients, 26.5% and 26.3% feared filling procedures and injections, respectively, followed by
extraction (24.8%), scaling (10.5%), and root canal treatments (4.8%). Nearly 23.9% of patients were
afraid of dental instruments, while 17.2% feared dentists themselves. Dental anxiety was more
prevalent in patients above 36 years (30.3%) than those in the age groups of 12–25 years (12.7%) and
26–35 years (22.9%). Caucasians were also observed to be more phobic (30%) than ethnicities such
as Arabs (22.4%), South Asians (20.5%), Filipinos (20%), and Africans (8%). Moreover, uneducated
people experienced greater dental fear (60%) than students from primary schools (33.3%), high
schools (23.6%), secondary schools (20.7%), and universities (17%).
Conclusion: The study showed that dental phobia among some UAE patients negatively affected
their oral health as they postpone routine dental care.
Keywords: Dental phobia, oral health, dental procedures, dental experiences, UAE
Citation: Sheema S, Khan S, Muayad Z, Thaier A, Obaid M, Eid HA. Prevalence of dental phobia
among patients at dental clinics in UAE. Gulf Medical Journal. 2016;5(S1):S136–S142.

INTRODUCTION fear related to the health and status of teeth, has


The word phobia, which has its roots in the been observed in individuals with different
Greek language, refers to an intense, backgrounds, males and females. However, we
unreasonable fear from a specific activity, object could differentiate based on age. Children
or situation1–3. Dental phobia, which refers to seemed more prone to dental phobia; those
aged 6–12 years harbored greater fear of going
Correspondence: Dr. Hossam Abdelatty Eid for dental checkups and treatments1–3.
Abdelmagyd (BDS, MSc , PhD Oral Medicine People with dental phobia endanger their
& Periodontology), Associate Dean and oral health by putting off routine dental care for
Associate Professor, Periodontics, College of years or even decades2–4. Global statistics
Dentistry, Gulf Medical University, Ajman, regarding the prevalence of dental anxiety or
UAE. Email: dr.hossam@gmu.ac.ae, phobia are heterogeneous. Statistics indicate
dentaleagle2011@gmail.com that 5–15% of the world’s adult population

GMJ. 8th Annual Scientific Meeting Oral Proceedings 2016.


136 www.gulfmedicaljournal.com
SYEDA SHEEMA, ET AL GMJ. ASM 2016;5(S1):S136–S142

suffers from dental phobia (odontophobia). Dentists’ apprehension about a treatment


Dental phobia as a psychological barrier seems can increase the patients’ fear regarding the
to be prevalent in the UAE (47% males, 53% treatment. Therefore, dental practitioners
females) as well as the entire GCC region. should ease anxiety among patients8–11. The aim
Studies in Oman indicate that almost 50% of this study is to assess the prevalence and
school children have some form of dental possible causes of dental phobia among patients
phobia. In Dubai, a study of 5,000 school at dental clinics in the UAE.
students suggested that the dental anxiety rate is
48%4, 5. MATERIALS & METHODS
Odontophobia has a multifactorial etiology; A cross-sectional survey was conducted on a
most cases of dental phobia can be attributed to random sample of 250 dental patients of
traumatic or painful dental experiences1, 3, 4. various nationalities aged 12–37 years at the Al
Patients with dental phobia tend to avoid dental Qassimi Hospital, Abu Dhabi private clinics,
visits, resulting in less anxiety, which leads to GMC clinics, and Abu Dhabi hospitals. All
further avoidance; this is termed as operant subjects received adequate verbal and written
conditioning. Dental phobia could be acquired information about the purpose, procedure, and
indirectly through parental or vicarious benefit of the study. The study team obtained
pathways. Several studies have found a consent from participants before administering
significant correlation between children’s fear the questionnaire, and maintained
and maternal fear. Similarly, individuals may confidentiality and anonymity. Consent from
develop anxiety by observing painful guardians/parents was required for participants
procedures or hearing about them from others; aged 12–18 years. Subjects received structured
this is termed as vicarious learning1, 3. questionnaires, including questions on
sociodemographic factors, dental anxiety, and
There is also evidence linking
possible related causes. Subjects were informed
socioeconomic status with dental anxiety, with
that participation was voluntary. Participants
dental anxiety being more prevalent among
were selected according to the following
patients from a lower socioeconomic status3.
inclusion criteria: age of participants ≥ 12 years
Moreover, a significant inverse relationship
(with consent of parent/guardian for
exists between dental awareness and anxiety; the
participants aged 12–18 years). Patients with
lower the awareness and knowledge regarding
mental or psychological disorders and subjects
dental health, the higher the anxiety2. Sex seems
refusing to provide consent were excluded from
to be a determinant as well, with females
the study. Permission to conduct the study was
proven to experience greater dental anxiety than
obtained from the ethical research committee of
males2, 3. Studies conducted on people aged 18–
Gulf Medical University’s Centre for Advanced
65 years (average: 22.3 years) revealed that the
Biomedical Research and Innovation (CABRI).
prevalence of dental anxiety is higher among
The study – which included data collection, data
younger students and adults over the age of
entry, processing, coding, analysis, and report
452, 3. Waiting room time seems to be an
preparation – was conducted over six months.
aggravating factor for dental anxiety, allowing
CABRI will store the collected data for three
anxious patients to further process negative
years after completion of the study.
experiences. Studies show that in a stressful
environment such as the waiting room of a RESULTS
dental clinic, patients with a high level of dental The collected data were statistically analyzed
anxiety tend to recall more threatening words with descriptive statistics and inference testing
than positive words1. This is termed as using the Pearson chi-squared test (p ≤ 0.001).
cognitive bias and seems to be a common trait All calculations were arrived at using SPSS
among anxious patients3–7. version 19.0 (IBM Corp, Armonk, NY, USA).

GMJ. 8th Annual Scientific Meeting Oral Proceedings 2016.


www.gulfmedicaljournal.com 137
PREVALENCE OF DENTAL PHOBIA AMONG PATIENTS AT
DENTAL CLINICS IN UAE GMJ. ASM 2016;5(S1):S136–S142

Table 1. Association between participants’ sociodemographic characteristics and dental phobia (N = 250)
Dental phobia
Sociodemographic characteristics Yes No p value
No. % No. %
Male 21 18.3 94 81.7 0.38
Gender
Female 31 22.8 105 77.2 (NS)
12–25 years 13 12.7 89 87.3
0.01
Age 26–35 years 19 22.9 64 77.1
(p ≤ 0.001)
>36 years 20 30.3 46 69.7
South Asian 18 20.5 70 79.5
Filipino 4 20.0 16 80.0
Ethnicity Arab 22 22.4 76 77.6 --
Caucasian 6 30.0 14 70.0
African 2 8.0 23 92.0
Primary school 5 33.3 10 66.7
Secondary school 6 20.7 23 79.3
Education High school 13 23.6 42 76.4 --
University 25 17.0 122 83.0
Others (illiterate) 3 60.0 2 40.0

Figure 1. Sociodemographic factors

100% 92.00%
87.30% Phobic
90% 81.70% 83.00%
77.20% 77.10% 79.50% 80.00% 77.60% 79.30% 76.40%
80% Non Phobic
69.70% 70.00%
66.70%
70%
60.00%
60%
50%
40.00%
40% 30.30% 33.30%
30.00%
30%
18.30%
22.80% 22.90% 20.50% 20.00% 22.40% 20.70% 23.60%
17.00%
20% 12.70%
8.00%
10%
0%
High School
Female

Primary School
Male

Caucasian
>36 years old

Secondary School

Others (Illiterate)
Filipino

Arab

Africans

University
12-25 years old

26-30 years old

Indian Subcontinent

Gender Age Ethinicity Education

Of the 250 patients evaluated, 22.8% phobic than those of other ethnicities (Arabs:
females suffered from dental phobia compared 22.4%, South Asians: 20.5%, Filipinos: 20%,
with 18.3% for males. Dental anxiety was Africans: 8%). Moreover, dental anxiety was
observed to be more prevalent among patients more prevalent among uneducated people
above 36 years (30.3%) compared with younger (60%) than students in primary schools
age groups (12–25 years: 12.7%, 26–35 years: (33.3%), high schools (23.6%), secondary
22.9%). Caucasians were observed to be more schools (20.7%), and universities (17%).

GMJ. 8th Annual Scientific Meeting Oral Proceedings 2016.


138 www.gulfmedicaljournal.com
SYEDA SHEEMA, ET AL GMJ. ASM 2016;5(S1):S136–S142

Table 2. Association between dental procedures and dental phobia (N = 250)


Dental phobia
Association between dental procedures and dental
Yes No p value
phobia
No. % No. %
Dentists 5 17.2 24 82.8
What are you most Injections 31 26.3 87 73.7
scared of at the dental --
clinic? Dental instruments 16 23.9 51 76.1
Other 0 0.0 14 100
Relaxed 7 9.1 70 90.9
A little uneasy 11 13.3 72 86.7
When you are in the
Tense 18 34.0 35 66.0
dentist’s office for
Anxious 10 38.5 16 61.5 --
your turn in the chair,
how do you feel? So anxious that I sometimes
break out in a sweat and almost 6 85.7 1 14.3
feel physically sick
A traumatic experience at the
27 33.3 54 66.7
dental clinic
How did you develop A friend’s traumatic experience 0.05
11 21.6 40 78.4
this fear? at the dental clinic
Images/TV content/movies 7 17.1 34 82.9
Other 5 13.2 33 86.8
Extraction 36 24.8 109 75.2
Which dental Filling 13 26.5 36 73.5
procedure are you
most scared of? Scaling 2 10.5 17 89.5
Other 1 4.8 20 95.2
Very bad 4 6.9 54 93.1
How do you feel Bad 7 7.7 84 92.3
about having your
Okay 18 28.6 45 71.4 --
teeth scraped and
polished? Good 18 62.1 11 37.9
Very good 5 50.0 5 50.0
Very bad 0 0.0 32 100.0
How do you feel Bad 5 9.3 49 90.7
0.00
about getting an Okay 9 15.0 51 85.0
(p ≤ 0.001)
injection in the gum? Good 17 25.0 51 75.0
Very good 21 56.8 16 43.2
Very bad 2 6.7 28 93.3
Bad 3 4.5 64 95.5
How do you feel 0.00
Okay 11 19.0 47 81.0
about getting a filling? (p ≤ 0.001)
Good 17 29.3 41 70.7
Very good 19 51.4 18 48.6
Very bad 1 4.0 24 96.0
How do you feel Bad 8 16.0 42 84.0
0.00
about getting a tooth Okay 5 10.2 44 89.8
(p ≤ 0.001)
extracted? Good 11 19.3 46 80.7
Very good 27 38.6 43 61.4
Very bad 1 3.0 32 97.0
How do you feel Bad 11 15.3 61 84.7
about having sleep 0.00
Okay 11 14.9 63 85.1
induced for the (p ≤ 0.001)
treatment? Good 11 33.3 22 66.7
Very good 18 47.4 20 52.6

When the association between dental the 250 patients, 26.5% and 26.3% feared filling
procedures and dental phobia was evaluated, of procedures and injections, respectively,

GMJ. 8th Annual Scientific Meeting Oral Proceedings 2016.


www.gulfmedicaljournal.com 139
PREVALENCE OF DENTAL PHOBIA AMONG PATIENTS AT
DENTAL CLINICS IN UAE GMJ. ASM 2016;5(S1):S136–S142

followed by extraction (24.8%), scaling (10.5%), Figure 2. Distribution of dental phobia among some
and root canal treatment (4.8%). Nearly 23.9% UAE patients
patients were afraid of dental instruments, while
only 17.2% feared dentists themselves. (Pearson
chi-squared test, p ≤ 0.001) 21%
n = 51
While in the waiting room, most patients
feel anxious and physically sick (85.7%), while Phobic
others feel tense (34%) or uneasy (13.3%). A Non-phobic
traumatic dental visit was the main cause for 79%
dental phobia (33.3%) among evaluated n = 199

patients, followed by a friend’s traumatic


experience (21.6%), and images, TV content,
and movies (17.1%) (Pearson chi-squared test,
p ≤ 0.001). DISCUSSION
A high percentage (42.4%) of the evaluated The results of the present study indicate that
patients revealed that dental fear deters them dental phobia was more prevalent among
from booking appointments even if they Caucasians (30%) than those of other
needed them, while 45.7% felt a shiver in their ethnicities (Arabs: 22.4%, South Asians: 20.5%,
body when the dentist is ready to start the Filipinos: 20%, and Africans: 8%). The study
procedure (Pearson chi-squared test, p ≤ 0.001). shows that the prevalence of dental phobia was
Most (56.5%) phobic patients avoid dental higher among females (22.8%) than males
visits, and this interferes with their social (18.3%). This result is similar to that from other
activities (36%). studies, which can be attributed to a difference
When the patients were asked to rate their in pain thresholds between the genders12–14.
level of dental fear, 57.9% reported extreme Our findings indicate that a dental anesthetic
dental fear and only 6.3% experienced mild injection was the procedure inducing anxiety
fear. Many participants (55.9%) complained the most (26.3%), while a root canal treatment
about feeling nervous or edgy about upcoming had the least influence on anxiety (4.8%). These
dental visits (Pearson chi-squared test, findings are consistent with the results of
p ≤ 0.001), 58.8% often think about things that Humphris et al., who found that the dental
may go wrong before going to the dentist, and anesthetic injection was the most anxiety-
75.7% thought something bad would happen to provoking item, with a mean score of 2.45±1.23
them during the procedure. (Pearson chi- across samples15. However, they reported that
squared test, p ≤ 0.001) scaling and polishing (1.90±1.35) was the least
anxiety-provoking procedure, which is
Lastly, among the participants, 27.8% felt at
inconsistent with our findings. Interestingly, in
ease when they had a family member or a friend
our study, about 17.2% feared dentists
by their side during the procedure, followed by
themselves, which can be attributed to
listening to music (23.3%), leniency from the
iatrogenic factors. This finding may be due to
dentist (17.5%), and being explained the
some dentists exhibiting inadequate necessary
procedure (15.8%).
communication skills while interacting with
patients. This finding raises the issue of the
responsibility of the dental profession and/or
the practitioner. Basically, the aggravation of
dental anxiety in patients after a dental episode
due to lack of preventive measures could be
considered a result of the concerned

GMJ. 8th Annual Scientific Meeting Oral Proceedings 2016.


140 www.gulfmedicaljournal.com
SYEDA SHEEMA, ET AL GMJ. ASM 2016;5(S1):S136–S142

professional’s fault. Relevant education should, the number of individuals representing each
hence, be provided to dental students and ethnic group, which could have negatively
professionals16. affected the validity of the study results. This
The percentage of people with dental limits the degree to which the results can be
anxiety in this study was 21%, higher than the assumed to apply to the overall UAE
results from Western countries, such as the population. A larger heterogeneous sample
United Kingdom (11%) and Northern Ireland would have improved the generalizability of the
(19.5%), and close to findings from Turkey results. Another limitation is that criterion
(23.5%)17, 18. However, these results are lower validity could not be established using standard
than that of a 2014 study among Saudis scales due to the non-availability of translated
(48.3%)19. Our study results indicate anxiety and and validated dental anxiety questionnaires in
phobias increase with an increase in age, in line the UAE. The main weakness of this study is
with several other studies by Tunc et al. and the use of a convenience sample.
Thomson et al. 200017, 20. However, these
CONCLUSION
findings contradict other study results, which
found that the lowest anxiety scores were The results of the study indicate dental phobia
recorded for those aged 50 years or older12, 18, 20, among some UAE patients resulted in routine
21. The higher anxiety with increased age in the dental care being postponed, negatively
current study may be attributed to bad dental affecting their oral health.
experiences, along with the absence of ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
appropriate dental education, leading to
The research team wants to thank the members
permanent psychological damage. The current
of the biostatistics department as well as the
study reported that 85.7% patients feel anxious
staff members of the College of Dentistry, Gulf
and physically sick, followed by tense (34%) or
Medical University, for helping with the
uneasy (13.3%) while waiting at the dental
research. Moreover, the authors appreciate the
clinic. Many evaluated patients developed dental
help of Al Qassimi Hospital (Sharjah), ADNOC
phobia primarily due to a traumatic experience
Hospital (Abu Dhabi), Talat Medical Centre
in the dental office (33.3%), followed by a
(Abu Dhabi), and Palmyra Dental Clinic (Abu
friend’s traumatic experience (21.6%) or images,
Dhabi).
TV content, and movies (17.1%). Our results
were similar to the findings of some other REFERENCES
studies22, 23. Some studies showed no significant
1. Bodner E, Iancu I. Recalling the threat:
difference in dental anxiety scores among dental anxiety in patients waiting for dental
participants based on their frequency of dental surgery. Isr J Psychiatry Relat Sci.
visits and duration since the last dental visit24. 2013;50(1):61–6.
According to the present study, dental fear 2. Carter AE, Carter G, Boschen M,
was more prevalent among uneducated people AlShwaimi E, George R. Pathways of fear
(60%) than students from primary schools and anxiety in dentistry: A review. World J
Clin Cases. 2014;2(11):642–53.
(33.3%), high schools (23.6%), secondary
3. Oliveira MA, Bendo CB, Ferreira MC,
schools (20.7%), and universities (17%). This
Paiva SM, Vale MP, Serra-Negra JM.
result indicates that the relationship between Association between childhood dental
dental anxiety and sociodemographic factors is experiences and dental fear among dental,
unclear despite some studies showing that psychology and mathematics
dental anxiety is most frequent in lower undergraduates in Brazil. Int J Environ Res
socioeconomic status groups25, 26. Public Health. 2012;9(12):4676–87.
This study had some limitations. The 4. Bhola R, Malhotra R. Dental procedures,
oral practices, and associated anxiety: a
sample size is small, with significant variation in

GMJ. 8th Annual Scientific Meeting Oral Proceedings 2016.


www.gulfmedicaljournal.com 141
PREVALENCE OF DENTAL PHOBIA AMONG PATIENTS AT
DENTAL CLINICS IN UAE GMJ. ASM 2016;5(S1):S136–S142

study on late-teenagers. Osong Public 16. Economou GC. Dental anxiety and
Health Res Perspect. 2014;5(4):219–32. personality: investigating the relationship
5. Oliveira MA, Vale MP, Bendo CB, Paiva between dental anxiety and self-
SM, Serra-Negra JM. Dental fear survey: a consciousness. J Dent Educ. 2003;67:970–
cross-sectional study evaluating the 80.
psychometric properties of the Brazilian 17. Tunc EP, Firat D, Onur OD, Sar V.
Portuguese version. Scientific World Reliability and validity of the Modified
Journal. 2014;2014:725323. Dental Anxiety Scale (MDAS) in a Turkish
6. Hakim H, Razak IA. Dental fear among population. Community Dent Oral
medical and dental undergraduates. Epidemiol. 2005;33:357–62.
Scientific World Journal. 2014;2014:747508. 18. Settineri S, Tati F, Fanara G. Gender
7. Weiner AA. The fearful dental patient: a differences in dental anxiety: is the chair
guide to understanding and managing. position important? J Contemp Dent Pract.
Ames: Wiley-Blackwell; 2011. 2005; 6:115–22.
8. van Wijk AJ, McNeil DW, Ho CJ, 19. Bahammam MA, Hassan MH. Validity and
Buchanan H, Hoogstraten J. A short reliability of an Arabic version of the
English version of the Fear of Dental Pain modified dental anxiety scale in Saudi
questionnaire. Eur J Oral Sci. adults. Saudi Med J. 2014;35(11):1384–9.
2006;114:204–8. 20. Thomson WM, Locker D, Poulton R.
9. Armfield JM. The extent and nature of Incidence of dental anxiety in young adults
dental fear and phobia in Australia. Aust in relation to dental treatment experience.
Dent J. 2010;55:368–77. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol.
2000;28:289–94.
10. Oosterink FMD, de Jongh A, Aartman
IHA. What are people afraid of during 21. Yuan S, Freeman R, Lahti S, Lloyd-Williams
dental treatment? Anxiety-provoking F, Humphris G. Some psychometric
capacity of 67 stimuli characteristics of the properties of the Chinese version of the
dental setting. Eur J Oral Sci. 2008;116:44– Modified Dental Anxiety Scale with cross
51. validation. Health Qual Life Outcomes.
2008;6:22.
11. Gow M. Dental anxiety, fear and phobia.
Dentistry. 2011:37–40. 22. Maggirias J, Locker D. Five-year incidence
of dental anxiety in an adult population.
12. Acharya S. Factors affecting dental anxiety
Community Dent Health. 2002;19:173–9.
and beliefs in an Indian population. J Oral
Rehabil. 2008;35:259–67. 23. Woolgrove J, Cumberbatch G. Dental
anxiety and regularity of dental attendance.
13. Luyk NH, Beck FM, Weaver JM. A visual
J Dent. 1986;14:209–13.
analogue scale in the assessment of dental
anxiety. Anesth Prog. 1988;35:121–3. 24. Sohn W, Ismail Al. Regular dental visits and
dental anxiety in an adult dentate
14. Desai VD, Gaurav I, Bailoor DN. Dental
population. J Am Dent Assoc.
anxiety – an area of concern for the oral
2005;136:58–66.
physician – a study. J Indian Dent Assoc.
2011;5:177–9. 25. Armfield JM, Spencer AJ, Stewart JF.
Dental fear in Australia: who’s afraid of the
15. Humphris GM, Freeman R, Campbell J,
dentist? Aust Dent J. 2006;51:78–85.
Tuutti H, D’Souza V. Further evidence for
the reliability and validity of the Modified 26. Hittner JB, Hemmo R. Psychosocial
Dental Anxiety Scale. Int Dent J. predictors of dental anxiety. J Health
2000;50:367–70. Psychol. 2009;14:53–9.

GMJ. 8th Annual Scientific Meeting Oral Proceedings 2016.


142 www.gulfmedicaljournal.com
View publication stats

You might also like