Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2018
The plan
o Role-Play sessions
o Safe environment
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
Your needs…
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
My aims…
o Understand
o Exposure
o Confidence
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
Note….
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
You know how to communicate already!
ü You’ve seen enough
patients in your life
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
General Communication Themes
o 2-way conversation
o ‘Chuck and check’
o Open and closed questions
o Patient-centred
o “How does that sound?”
o “Am I making sense to you?”
o “Let me know if I’m going too fast”
o Acknowledge everything
o Cues (verbal and non-verbal)
o Emotion
o Fears
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
General Communication Themes
o Rapport
o Reflect eg in ICE
o Relevance eg in psychosocial
o Body language
o Open/closed
o Empathise / sympathise
appropriately
o “I understand how you feel”
o “I can see how this is difficult for you”
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
Scenario 1
Mr. Geoff Roberts
34 year old male
You have been asked to see Geoff Roberts - a patient on the ward
who is being treated with IV antibiotics for cellulitis of his leg.
Clinically his leg has been improving and is due to be discharged in
two days. His last observations have been normal and the cellulitis
area has been reducing.
There has been an emergency on the ward which has led to a 1
hour delay in his medication being given.
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
1. The Angry Patient
o Challenges
o The patient overtakes the conversation
o The patient doesn’t calm down at all
o Can’t cover practical needs such as
discussing the medication as anger
dominates
o Our own tension/nerves increase
o Doctor gets frustrated and annoyed
o Distance
o Watch for role-player gradually closing distance
o Look out for your own subconscious leaning in
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
Scenario 2
Mr John Walsh
56 year old male
You have been given a chest x-ray report for a John Walsh, who
was admitted with a 6 month history of worsening cough.
It shows a mass in the right upper lobe and suggests a strong
likelihood of lung cancer. Follow-up CT has shown likely
metastases.
You have been asked by your consultant to explain the results.
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
2. Breaking Bad News
o Challenges
o Balance between medical information
and dealing with reaction
o Often many questions have no
answers at present
o How much information to ask at this
stage
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
2. Possible Strategies
o Balance between giving the information quickly but
sensitively (buffer)
o “Best case scenario…worst case scenario”
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
Scenario 3
Mr Rajeev Singh
49 year old male
Mr Singh has been admitted with a provisional
diagnosis of temporal arteritis and has been
commenced on oral prednisolone.
He is refusing to take the prednisolone.
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
3. The Patient Who Refuses Treatment
o Challenges
o Medical need vs patient’s personal
fear
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
3. Possible Strategies
o Acknowledge their right to be involved in their own treatment early on
o Offer solutions
o “How about I look into the rules for you?”
o “Maybe there are specific rules/allowances for these medications – lets look
into it”
o “Is there anyone that you know who might have a little more knowledge
about this?”
o Remember you may not be able to convince someone – what is next best?
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
Scenario 4
Richard Weaver
65 year old male
Mr Weaver has had a myocardial infarction last week.
He has recovered well, has been started on relevant
medications and is due for discharge tomorrow.
You have been asked to carry out a diet history and
counsel him appropriately.
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
4. Health Promotion - Diet Counseling
o Challenges
o Different approaches
o Don’t want to lecture
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
4. Possible Strategies
o Carrot vs stick approach
o “There are many benefits that you may find through changing diet such as
your cholesterol being reduced”
o “If you continue with this diet unfortunately your blood pressure might
continue to rise”
o Key pointers:
o White meat instead of red meat
o Grilled instead of fried
o Olive/rapeseed oil instead of butter
o 5 fruits/vegetables a day
o Reduce salt (6g per day) and sugar
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
Scenario 5
Mr Majeed Qureshi
68 year old male
A lady has demanded to see a doctor on the
ward of her father, Mr Majeed Qureshi.
Her father was admitted 3 days ago with a hip
fracture but has suffered a stroke overnight. He
had all the appropriate preventative measures in
place.
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
5. Angry Relative
o Challenges
o Anger can dominate
the situation
o Natural when family
members are involved
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
5. Possible Strategies
o Acknowledge their anger
o “I can clearly see that you are angry”
o “You’re frustration is understandable”
o Confidentiality
o “I know it is frustrating but I do need to check that we
have permission to discuss your father’s medical records”
o Offer to investigate
o “Would you mind if I looked into the situation a little further
– I think some details need to be clarified”
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
Scenario 6
Mrs Jane Donovan
26 year old female
Jane Donavan presents with a broken wrist
which has been put in a cast. She stated to
nursing staff that she had slipped on the ice.
She has been cleared to go home.
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
6. Domestic Violence
o Challenges
o Patient often doesn’t want help
o Children involved
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
6. Possible Strategies
o Look for cues if patient not initially open
o “He’s this, I’m that”
o Offer support
o “We can help in any way you think we can”
o “Have you considered approaching the police?”
o “We can contact relevant people for you if this is easier”
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
Scenario 7
Mr Jack Hobbs
23 year old male
Jack has recently been diagnosed with
chlamidiya through a urine test after requesting a
test himself. He has had the approproate
treatment.
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
7. Sexual History Taking
o Challenges
o Doctor embarrassment
o Patient embarrassment
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
7. Possible Strategies
o Signpost right at the beginning
o “throughout the consultation I may be asking you a few personal questions”
o Embarrassment
o Acknowledge
o “I can see that you are a little embarrased”
o “We see this type of thing almost daily as doctors”
o “Your symptoms are actually very common”
o Importance of time…“There is no rush – please take your time”
o Thank them for coming…“Thank you for coming to the hospital to discuss this – I
know it can’t have been easy”
o Reassure about common nature of problem… “What you are talking about is
something that is very common – you are certainly not alone”
o Offer relevant alternatives…“If you prefer I could ask if a female doctor see you”
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
Scenario 8
Mr Wayne Pollock
2 year old male
Wayne is brought in by his parents with a
spiral fracture to his femur. He has been
stabilised and treated appropriately.
You have been asked to carry out a history as
from mum to find out what happened.
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
8. Non-Accidental Injury
o Challenges
o Easy to sound accusatory
o Parent reaction
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
8. Possible Strategies
o Non-accusatory questioning
o “Could you take me through what happened?”
o “We’re just trying to put together the story”
o “No-one is blaming anyone here”
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
9. The Blaze Patient
o Challenges
o Very frustrating scenarios
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
9. Possible strategies
o Acknowledge they don’t want to be there
o “I can see that you don’t seem to want to discuss your
diabetes today”
o “I can appreciate that there are many other things that you
would rather be doing than discussing your diabetes”
o “Is there any way that you would like us to address your
diabetes?”
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
Scenario 10
Mr Jason Fritz
15 year old male
Jason is consenting to have an incarcerated
hernia repaired.
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
10. Consent / Capacity
o Challenges
o How to judge if components are
covered
o Gillick vs Fraser competence
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
10. Possible Strategies
o At 16 presumed competent to make decisions
o Gillick competence
o Under age 16 are they able to demonstrate capacity?
o Fraser competence
o Specifically for contraception consent
o Components of capacity
o Can they understand the information?
o Can they retain the information?
o Can they weigh up the information?
o Can they communicate the decision?
o Example questions
o “Can you tell me what you understand from what we have discussed?”
o “I’ve mentioned a lot there – could you repeat what I’ve talked about so
I know I haven’t confused things?”
o “Are you able to tell me what is running through your mind?”
o “Are you able to tell me what you have decided?”
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
Scenario 11
Mrs Edith Francis
76 year old female
You have been asked to speak to the daughter
of Mre. Francis - a lady with terminal breast
cancer.
She has two weeks to live and her daughter is
concerned about her symptoms.
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
11. Palliative Care
o Challenges
o Confidentiality issues
o Limited answers to challenging
questions
o Dealing with impact on the daughter
as well as patient issues
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
11. Possible strategies
o Acknowledge 3 aspects of Palliative Care
o Physical – symptoms eg pain
o Emotional – depression, anxiety, fear
o Practical – support systems
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
Scenario 12
Mrs Jennifer Capris
43 year old female
Mrs. Capris has been admitted with problem-drinking
and has had some haematemesis overnight.
She has attended several times with this problem and
has been advised that she needs an OGD tomorrow.
She wishes to self-discharge this morning.
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
12. The Patient Who Wants !
To Leave Hospital
o Challenges
o Frustration if can’t persuade them
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
12. Possible Strategies
o Are they competent to make this decision?
o Can they understand the information?
o Can they retain the information?
o Can they weigh up the information?
o Can they communicate their decision?
o If competent and still wishes to go, what is the next best way that you can help?
o “Ok I can see that you still wish to go – could we at least put in an alternative plan as I’m still worried
about you?”
o Review the next day?
o Urgent clinic appointment
o Contact numbers
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
Scenario 13
Miss Francis Jones
33 year old female
Miss Jones is known to have a long history of
migraines and is seen regularly by the neurologists.
She had a normal CT scan 3 months ago.
She has attended A&E with another migraine and the
pain has now settled with treatment. She is fit to be
discharged but asks to see a doctor.
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
13. The Demanding Patient
o Challenges
o Easy to get into an argument
o Easy to give your answer too
early
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
13. Possible Strategies
o Regularly acknowledge the demand
o “I know you really want the scan – I promise I’ll come on to that shortly”
o “I know you are really keen on the scan – I assure you I will get to it soon”
o Offer alternatives
o “I can see you are very keen – how about I discuss this with the radiologist for their opinion?”
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
Scenario 14
Mr Jonathan Griffiths
27 year old male
Mr Griffiths has been brought to A&E by his
brother who says that he ‘is not himself these
days’.
You are asked to carry out a psychiatric
assessment.
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
14. The Psychiatric History
o Challenges
o Questions can be tricky to ask in a
sensitive way
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
14. Possible Strategies
o Buffer
o “I would like to ask you a few questions about your thoughts and how you are feeling”
o “Some may apply to you but some may seem a little strange – please bear with me”
o Suicidal risk
o “Sometimes when people feel low like this, they often feel like life is not worth it, or sometimes like ending their life – is this ever
the case?”
o Check insight
o “Are you always aware that you are feeling like this / hearing these things / having these thoughts?”
o “How do you feel about them?”
o Habits/coping mechanisms
o “Sometimes when people feel like this they can turn to things to help cope – smoking, alcohol, drugs perhaps. Can I check if
this is the case with yourself?”
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
Scenario 15
Mrs Stephanie Jones
43 year old female
You are asked to see Mrs Jones by the
nursing staff. She is currently an inpatient in
hospital and is being treated for a flare-up of
her Crohn’s disease.
She wishes to discuss something that
happened this morning.
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
15. Patient Complaint
o Challenges
o You didn’t see what happened
o The patient doesn’t want to listen to
you
o Don’t want to undermine colleague
but also want to respect the patient
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
Scenario 16
Mrs Jenny Philips
38 year old female
Mrs. Philips presents with
problems with her periods. You
are asked by your consultant to
take a relevant history.
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
16. The Embarrassed Patient
o Key end points
o Full clinical history despite
embarrassment
o Patient (or doctor) doesn’t feel too
uncomfortable
o Challenges
o May take time to develop rapport
o We get embarrassed to ask certain
questions
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
16. Possible strategies
o Eye contact
o Getting closer
o Importance of time…
o “There is no rush – please take your time”
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
Scenario 17
Mrs Kenny Adams
40 year old male
This gentleman has been admitted
with deranged liver function tests
(raised ALT and GGT).
His breath and clothes smell of
alcohol. Your consultant asks you to
discuss his alcohol habit.
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
17. Alcohol
o Key end points
o Understand how much they drink
o Make aware of recommended limits
o Challenges
o Patient may not believe they drink
too much
o Patient may become defensive
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
17. Possible strategies
o Ask openly
o “How do you feel about your alcohol intake?”
o “Are you aware of any guidance about alcohol?”
o “Are you aware of some of the effects of excess alcohol on our body?”
o Non-judgmental approach
o “Drinking alcohol is a very common activity – we are not here to judge you – just guide on
its potential effect on health”
o “Of course you make decisions about your lifestyle and habits – I think it is important that
we run through a possible harmful effects”
o Clear advice
o “Current guidance is to drink no more that 14 units of alcohol per week, men and women”
o “You should also have 2-3 alcohol free days per week”
Copyright
Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
What we have covered
Copyright Arora Medical Education Ltd Not to be used for medical advice
Conclusions
ü Acknowledge
ü Emotion
ü Body language
ü Distance