Comparative Chart

Contract Name: Upgrading of Chorkate Santipur Road (Chandrakot Rural Municipality Access Road)
Contract ID:RIDO-GUL-RB-W-NCB-17-2076/077
RAYAMAJHI-
Rautaha/ Bandan M/S Worldwide/D.N.D Singha and ps-ramechhap-sunil samir
PE's Estimate Lohani & Brothers Pvt.Ltd. Lumbini-Prakritik JV RAJESHWARI-PTR Pacific-Karna JV
SL. Bhagwati/ KBC JV J.V. Brothers/Kashyap JV jv
Item Name & Description ADHIKARI JV
NO
Official Discounted
Quantity Unit Amount Rate Amount Rate Amount Rate Amount Rate Amount Rate Amount Rate Amount Rate Amount Rate Amount
Rate (NRs) Rate(25%)
Insurance of works, equipment, Contractor's
1 workmen and employees and Third party 1 PS 1040000 1040000 1040000 1040000 1040000 1040000 1040000 1040000 1040000 1040000 1040000 1040000 1040000 1040000 1040000 1040000 1040000 1040000 1040000
Insurance against damage to other persons and
property.
Relocation of services (electrical pole, tap stand
2 water supply pipe lines etc ) all complete as per 1 PS 578145.41 578145.41 578145.41 578145.41 578145.41 578145.41 578145.41 578145.41 578145.41 578145.41 578145.41 578145.41 578145.41 578145.41 578145.41 578145.41 578145.41 578145.41 578145.41
engineers instructions.
Occupational Safety and Health (OSH) and
3 Personnel Protective Equipments (PPE) as per 1 PS 250000 250000 250000 250000 250000 250000 250000 250000 250000 250000 250000 250000 250000 250000 250000 250000 250000 250000 250000
Occupational Safety and Health Guideline
2017.
Provide Operate and maintain quality control
laboratory including equipment ,accessories
and consumables for both field testing facilities
and off site test with manpower along with
4 1 PS 1000000 1000000 1000000 1000000 1000000 1000000 1000000 1000000 1000000 1000000 1000000 1000000 1000000 1000000 1000000 1000000 1000000 1000000 1000000
transportation facility for employer and
handover all laboratory equipments to office
after completion of project as per spec. as
instructed by Engineer
Provide and installation of project information
5 board with size of 1.8*1.2m as per 2 Nos. 20000 40000 20000 40000 39000 29250 58500 10000 20000 25000 50000 10000 20000 10000 20000 10000 20000 10000 20000
specification and instruction of Engineer.
Provide and maintain the road operable by
removing the debris and other obstruction with
6 traffic safety, control measures and temporary 1 LS 500000 500000 25000 25000 390000 292500 292500 200000 200000 100000 100000 300000 300000 50000 50000 50000 50000 200000 200000
diversions during construction period as
instructed by the Engineer.
Provision and maintenance of labour camps,
Engineers site office with required facilities
7 1 LS 600000 600000 25000 25000 390000 292500 292500 400000 400000 100000 100000 200000 200000 50000 50000 50000 50000 200000 200000
with safety and hygenic environment as
instructed by Engineer
Roadway , drain and Foundation excavation in
all type of soil and rock material including
8 28783.72 Cum 110.77 3188372.66 65 1870941.8 117 87.75 2525771.43 60 1727023.2 150 4317558 80 2302697.6 27 777160.44 60 1727023.2 100 2878372
disposal of excavated material at approved
environmentally safe tipping sites.
Roadway & Drain excavation in highly
sensitive Power House & Hydropower Dam
area of Upper Hugdi Hydropower Project in
9 all type of soil and rock material without 11812.55 Cum 595.98 7040043.55 80 945004 260 195 2303447.25 100 1181255 150 1771882.5 100 1181255 200 2362510 150 1771882.5 200 2362510
causing any damage to hydropower structures
including all type of safety measures to be
taken as directed by the Engineer.
Haulage of surplus excavateed material
(excluding the used material in structure) in
10 highly sensitive power house and Dam area to 5880.05 Cum 71.43 420011.97 150 882007.5 195 146.25 859957.3125 100 588005 100 588005 100 588005 200 1176010 150 882007.5 200 1176010
environmentally safe tipping site as directed by
the Engineer.
Providing and laying of hand pack Stone soling
with 150 to 200 mm thick stones and packing
11 1228.93 Cum 3535.74 4345176.96 2200 2703646 2600 1950 2396413.5 2000 2457860 2000 2457860 2800 3441004 3000 3686790 2000 2457860 1500 1843395
with smaller stone on prepared surface as per
specifications.
Providing and laying Stone Masonry work in
cement mortar 1:4 in structure including 110
12 4172.56 Cum 9698.23 40466446.57 6800 28373408 10400 7800 32545968 7000 29207920 6000 25035360 6500 27121640 6000 25035360 6700 27956152 6000 25035360
mm dia 6 kgf HDPE pipe Weep Holes and
Pointing etc all complete as per specifications.
Providing and laying Plum concrete ( Boulder
mixed concrete) as per drawing and
13 2032 Cum 11504.77 23377692.64 7000 14224000 13000 9750 19812000 8500 17272000 6000 12192000 7500 15240000 7000 14224000 8500 17272000 8000 16256000
specifications , 60% M 15 concrete and 40%
boulders/stones.
Supply and place concrete class M15/40
14 1170.53 Cum 12822.27 15008851.7 10000 11705300 15600 11700 13695201 9000 10534770 10000 11705300 9000 10534770 12000 14046360 9200 10768876 10000 11705300
including necessary formwork and support.
Providing , Preparing and Installing form work
15 including necessary supports and removing 20320 Sqm 336.38 6835241.6 350 7112000 130 97.5 1981200 300 6096000 500 10160000 250 5080000 300 6096000 250 5080000 100 2032000
after completion .
Providing and Laying RCC 450 mm dia NP3
16 Flush jointed hume pipe for culvert including 100 R.M. 9429.79 942979 6000 600000 7800 5850 585000 4500 450000 6000 600000 5500 550000 10000 1000000 8000 800000 4500 450000
fixing with cement mortar 1:2 as per
specifications.
Providing and Laying RCC 600mm dia NP3
17 Flush jointed pipe for culvert including fixing 60 R.M. 11912.23 714733.8 8000 480000 9100 6825 409500 9000 540000 8000 480000 7500 450000 15000 900000 12000 720000 7000 420000
with cement mortar 1:2 as per specifications.
Providing and Laying RCC 900mm dia NP3
18 Flush jointed pipe for culvert including fixing 20 R.M. 21594.33 431886.6 15000 300000 26000 19500 390000 15000 300000 11000 220000 14000 280000 20000 400000 18000 360000 11000 220000
with cement mortar 1:2 as per specifications.
 Comparative Chart
Contract Name: Upgrading of Chorkate Santipur Road (Chandrakot Rural Municipality Access Road)
Contract ID:RIDO-GUL-RB-W-NCB-17-2076/077
RAYAMAJHI-
Rautaha/ Bandan M/S Worldwide/D.N.D Singha and ps-ramechhap-sunil samir
PE's Estimate Lohani & Brothers Pvt.Ltd. Lumbini-Prakritik JV RAJESHWARI-PTR Pacific-Karna JV
SL. Bhagwati/ KBC JV J.V. Brothers/Kashyap JV jv
Item Name & Description ADHIKARI JV
NO
Official Discounted
Quantity Unit Amount Rate Amount Rate Amount Rate Amount Rate Amount Rate Amount Rate Amount Rate Amount Rate Amount
Rate (NRs) Rate(25%)
Providing mechanically woven double twisted
crates / mattress including rolling, cutting and
with lacing wire and binding wire Heavy zinc
coated Hexagonal mesh type 100 mm x 120
mm, mesh wire 3 mm, selvage wire 3.9 mm,
lacing wire 2.4 mm, assembling, placing in
19 position including stretching; forming 5932.5 Cum 3659.66 21710932.95 3500 20763750 7670 5752.5 34126706.25 4000 23730000 4500 26696250 4000 23730000 3500 20763750 3700 21950250 3800 22543500
compartments; tying the sides and diaphragms
with binding wire in each mesh; tying with
bracing wires and tie wires; and tying down the
lid with providing and filling stone/boulder in
gabion boxes/mattress etc.. Including dressing,
bedding, bonding all complete.
Providing, laying and fixing of Geo-textile
20 2733 Sqm 101.32 276907.56 80 218640 130 97.5 266467.5 90 245970 100 273300 100 273300 30 81990 100 273300 100 273300
(filter fabrics).
Providing suitable material and Back filling
21 behind abutment, wing wall and return wall 2507.44 Cum 334.65 839114.8 70 175520.8 130 97.5 244475.4 100 250744 100 250744 100 250744 20 50148.8 50 125372 200 501488
complete as per specifications.
Providing and laying of Reinforced (Grade
22 M20) cement concrete includind necessary 82.21 Cum 16431.31 1350818 13000 1068730 18200 13650 1122166.5 15000 1233150 15000 1233150 12000 986520 15000 1233150 15000 1233150 12000 986520
formwork and support in super-structure as per
drawing and Technical Specification.
Providing and laying , fitting and placing
23 HYSD bar reinforcement in sub-structure 4.23 Ton 123205.2 521158 110000 465300 130000 97500 412425 90000 380700 100000 423000 100000 423000 100000 423000 95000 401850 110000 465300
complete as per specifications.
Loosening, leveling and Compacting original
ground supporting embankment to facilitate
placement of first layer of embankment,
24 scarified to a depth of 150 mm, mixed with 75000 Sqm 15.62 1171500 20 1500000 45 33.75 2531250 20 1500000 20 1500000 25 1875000 10 750000 20 1500000 25 1875000
water at OMC and then compacted by rolling
so as to achieve dry density as per
specifications.
Supplying, laying, spreading, watering,
levelling and compaction of natural sand
25 gravel (Quarry/Riverbed) subbase grading as 13050 Cum 2565.57 33480688.5 1000 13050000 1430 1072.5 13996125 1500 19575000 1500 19575000 950 12397500 1000 13050000 1050 13702500 1650 21532500
per table 12.1 of standard specification as
instructed by the Engineer.[1201]
Providing, laying, spreading, watering, levelling
26 and compaction of crushed stone base for base 11250 Cum 3552.75 39968437.5 2400 27000000 2210 1657.5 18646875 2500 28125000 2500 28125000 2800 31500000 3000 33750000 3100 34875000 2800 31500000
course. as per specifications. (SS 1204)
Prime Coat, with MC 30 / 70 by Mechanical
Means : Providing and applying prime coat
with Hot Bitumen ( including cutter) on
27 62595 Ltr 119.03 7450682.85 90 5633550 130 97.5 6103012.5 110 6885450 100 6259500 120 7511400 100 6259500 110 6885450 110 6885450
prepared surface of granular base including
cleaning of road surface and spraying by
mechanical means as per specification.
Providing and applying tack coat with hot
Bitumen By Mechanical Means at specified
28 153010 Ltr 107.16 16396551.6 90 13770900 130 97.5 14918475 110 16831100 100 15301000 110 16831100 100 15301000 110 16831100 110 16831100
rate on the prepared non-bituminous surfaces
including cleaning as per Technical Speciation .
Providing and laying surface dressing as
wearing course in single coat using 19mm
nominal chipping size gravel of specified size
29 on a recently applied layer of bituminous binder 69550 Sqm 65.86 4580563 120 8346000 91 68.25 4746787.5 50 3477500 96 6676800 75 5216250 50 3477500 49 3407950 70 4868500
on prepared surface all complete as per
Drawing and Technical Specification and
Engineer's instructions. [Spec. cl. No: 1303]
Providing and laying surface dressing as
wearing course in single coat using 10 mm
nominal chipping size gravel of specified size
30 on a recently applied layer of bituminous binder 69550 Sqm 58.95 4099972.5 60 4173000 65 48.75 3390562.5 35 2434250 95 6607250 65 4520750 40 2782000 49 3407950 60 4173000
on prepared surface all complete as per
Drawing and Technical Specification and
Engineer's instructions. [Spec. cl. No: 1303]
Providing and mixing of Anti stripping agent as
31 765.05 Kg 394.75 302003.49 650 497282.5 780 585 447554.25 400 306020 500 382525 500 382525 700 535535 750 573787.5 700 535535
per Design/ direction of Engineer
Providing and mixing of Bitumen cutter as
32 9180.6 Ltr 110.4 1013538.24 100 918060 143 107.25 984619.35 120 1101672 100 918060 110 1009866 125 1147575 120 1101672 110 1009866
per design / direction of Engineer
Direct Seedling on side: Broadcasting grass
33 2000 Sqm 36.06 72120 25 50000 26 19.5 39000 150 300000 100 200000 10 20000 2 4000 10 20000 40 80000
seeds on slopes ; Seedling rate 25 gm per sqm.
 Comparative Chart
Contract Name: Upgrading of Chorkate Santipur Road (Chandrakot Rural Municipality Access Road)
Contract ID:RIDO-GUL-RB-W-NCB-17-2076/077
RAYAMAJHI-
Rautaha/ Bandan M/S Worldwide/D.N.D Singha and ps-ramechhap-sunil samir
PE's Estimate Lohani & Brothers Pvt.Ltd. Lumbini-Prakritik JV RAJESHWARI-PTR Pacific-Karna JV
SL. Bhagwati/ KBC JV J.V. Brothers/Kashyap JV jv
Item Name & Description ADHIKARI JV
NO
Official Discounted
Quantity Unit Amount Rate Amount Rate Amount Rate Amount Rate Amount Rate Amount Rate Amount Rate Amount Rate Amount
Rate (NRs) Rate(25%)
Sowing shrubs or tree seeds on all slopes at 25
cm intervals, including digging planting holes
34 1481.42 Sqm 51.11 75715.38 200 296284 52 39 57775.38 150 222213 100 148142 20 29628.4 2 2962.84 15 22221.3 40 59256.8
to 5 cm depth and covering with soil. Two
seeds per planting hole.
Preparation and planting of live pegs selected
species (eg asuro, namdiphul, simali) of
35 minimum length to 0.5m into soft debris. Pegs 800 RM 254.21 203368 50 40000 104 78 62400 150 120000 400 320000 25 20000 5 4000 20 16000 40 32000
spaced at 5 c to c within rows, and interoven
with vegetation.
Providing, furnishing and laying of live sods of
perennial turf forming grass on embankment
slope, verges or other locations shown on the
36 800 Sqm 357.72 286176 100 80000 104 78 62400 150 120000 100 80000 20 16000 5 4000 30 24000 40 32000
drawing or as directed by the Engineer
including preparation of ground, fetching of
sords and watering.
Planting rooted grass slips on the slopes >
60 degree including preparation of slips on site
37 a maximum of 5 cm depth with metal rod or 446 Sqm 2240.38 999209.48 100 44600 85 63.75 28432.5 150 66900 100 44600 25 11150 5 2230 20 8920 50 22300
operation iclude diggig, planting hole to
hardwood peg, depending on the nature of the
soil.
Providing and installation of 150 mm *
150 mm 1. 5 m long delineators (road
way indicators, hazard markers, object
markers), 80-100 cm high above ground
38 500 Nos. 1265.13 632565 1800 900000 1950 1462.5 731250 1500 750000 2000 1000000 3000 1500000 2000 1000000 1200 600000 3000 1500000
level, painted black and white in 20 cm
wide strips, buried or pressed into the
ground and conforming to the drawings
and Technical Specifications
Providing and erecting a W metal beam crash
barrier, comprising of 3 mm thick corrugated
sheet metal beam rail, 70 cm above
road/ground level fixed on ISMC series
Channel vertical post, 150 X 75 X 5 mm
39 Spaced 2 m center to center, 1.8 m high, 1.1 m 500 RM 6074.84 3037420 5500 2750000 9100 6825 3412500 8000 4000000 1500 750000 7000 3500000 7000 3500000 4000 2000000 7000 3500000
below ground/Road level Metal Beam Rail to
be fixed on a vertical post with a spacer of
channel section 150 X 75 X 5 mm, 330 mm
long complete as per drawing and technical
specification.
Supplying and erecting traffic sign in place
including 50mm dia. Steel tube, 2mm. thick
steel plate, cement concrete, painting, writing
40 and supporting steel angle nut and bolt etc. 30 Nos. 5877.94 176338.2 4000 120000 13000 9750 292500 5000 150000 25000 750000 3000 90000 2000 60000 2800 84000 3000 90000
completea) 60cm. Dia. Circular, 60cm.
equilateral traingle and 60cm.x 45cm.
rectangular shaped sign (single post).
Supplying and fixing in place M20/20 RCC
41 Slab for drain cover size (1.00m X 0.3m X 80 Nos. 1068.36 85468.8 2000 160000 1950 1462.5 117000 2000 160000 15000 1200000 1000 80000 1500 120000 1200 96000 3000 240000
0.125 m) as per drawings and specification
Supplying and placing R.C.C. kilometer post
including excavation, back filling, painting and
42 10 Nos. 2601.93 26019.3 4000 40000 10400 7800 78000 10000 100000 15000 150000 3500 35000 3000 30000 1300 13000 5000 50000
writing etc. all complete as per specification a)
Standard KM post placed at each kilometer.

Supplying and placing R.C.C. kilometer post

including excavation, back filling, painting and
43 writing etc. all complete as per specification 3 Nos. 5985.66 17956.98 8000 24000 13000 9750 29250 5000 15000 15000 45000 7500 22500 3000 9000 1300 3900 7000 21000
b) Bigger kilometer post (placed at each 5
km.)
44 Backhoe Loader 292 Hrs. 2818.94 823130.48 1500 438000 3250 2437.5 711750 3000 876000 2000 584000 500 146000 1500 438000 1700 496400 1500 438000
45 Unskilled Labor 126 Md 680 85680 800 100800 1040 780 98280 900 113400 700 88200 300 37800 500 63000 750 94500 600 75600
Total Price (Without VAT and PS) 243595473.7 171910724.60 185805998.12 184044902.20 189359486.50 179705405.00 174666532.08 179664074.0 184920162.80
VAT (13%) 31667411.58 22348394.2 24154779.76 23925837.29 24616733.25 23361702.65 22706649.17 23356329.62 24039621.16
Total Price (With VAT and PS) 278131030.65 197127264.21 212828923.29 210838884.90 216844365.16 205935253.06 200241326.66 205888549.03 211827929.37
Below or Above 81003766.44 65302107.36 67292145.75 61286665.49 72195777.59 77889703.99 72242481.62 66303101.27
Percentage Below or above (%) 29.12% 23.48% 24.19% 22.04% 25.96% 28.00% 25.97% 23.84%
Required Performance Security 29498419.13 22432672.54 23328189.82 20625723.7 25534824.15 28097091.03 25555840.96 22883119.81
Rank 1 7 5 8 4 2 3 6